TRACKLIST: 00:00:00 Intro / Annihilation 00:03:51 Imagine 00:08:42 Week and Powerless 00:12:05 The Hollow 00:15:10 Rose 00:18:55 Blue 00:24:03 Whats Going On 00:28:58 People Are People 00:32:55 The Outsider 00:37:18 Peace, Love, and Understanding 00:42:02 When the Levee Breaks 00:48:36 The Noose 00:53:57 3 Libras 01:00:28 The Package 01:08:42 Gimmie, Gimmie, Gimmie 01:12:22 Orestes 01:18:12 Passive 01:23:54 Counting Bodies Like Sheep to The Rythm of the War Drums 01:29:50 Fiddle and the Drum 01:33:15 By and Down the River
Everytime they add things to this song gets better. The part of the solo is a masterpiece. I think they should remake this song in studio, cause the have added many interesting things to this song (and I mean the live versions of this song, you can notice differences from the original) Even there's an alternative version of this and it sounds great!
Yep! Your comment popped up just as I restarted the show after listening to Orestes... 😂😂 Brilliant. I can't even listen to the prerecorded version without my insides twitching to listen to the red rocks performance.. it is incredible.
All of my hairs standing up on end. I didn’t anyone could replace Josh Freese as the drummer, but they just found a left handed version of him in Jeff. So impressed!
Yep! I was reading this comment while listening to Orestes trying to figure out if it was going to be in this song or Passive, but then I remembered how magical the end of that song is and sure enough, my eyes stated to well up, checked the time, and there is was 1:17:00. 🤘
He's a hired gun who joined as part of the touring band, not a part of the songwriting process nor did he play on any of the studio albums. He joined the band as a touring member during the thirteenth step tour and would later join the band for other tours later on. I'm not sure if he was ever referred to as an official member of the band, but I could be wrong on this.
@@aconformist1 He is an official member. Has been since 2003. The band is always on hiatus due to Maynard's other projects. Members are always working solo or with other artists during these long gaps. Iha couldn't play in the summer of 2018 due to Pumpkins reunion. But he's been on studio albums Emotive and Elephant.
This is just absolute, total, complete, pure perfection. I would give almost anything to be able to witness this in person. I am envious of every single person in that amphitheater. Seeing APC and Tool live would be a dream come true and I have to do it. Maybe one day in the not too distant future it will happen. I could then die happy.
@@danielporter6410Got to see them in 2003 when they toured for the 13th step. If you get the opportunity to see them, do it. I promise you won't regret it.
Drummer playing balls out. Holy crap is that some brilliant playing. I sure as hell wish that the editing wasn't so chopped up into one second segments during the uptempo numbers.
I will never forget listening to this for the first time. I was gonna just watch a couple performances of songs that I like and ended up watching the whole frickin thing
Maynard the best live singer vocalist I have everseen, so clean and consistent. He doesn't runs out of idea. This performance is so less egoistic , he just stayed on the dark spot without being too upfront he intentionally din this not about him, just the band, the music and the song. Actually each the members of APC are so great giving us the best times.
I've been personally responsible for probably hundreds of the views here. I come back over and over and over to this concert. When I'm grieving I crawl inside the sounds like a nest, other times I'm just cooking or doing laundry and I put it on like a phone call from an old friend.
Quickly becoming one of my fav bands. After a decade of loving Tool, only recently delved into APC/Puscifer and I adore them both. Find them a lot easier to listen to than Tool at this point, not as overwhelming... some of those elements are there but it isn't too much. Everything Maynard touches turns to gold, sings you to sleep one minute and the next he emits powerful and raw emotion, fucking love it.
Incredible Sound. The vocals and musicianship, across the board, is next level (Friedl is one of the more interesting and dynamic drummers I've come across in recent years).
I got to see them for that same tour but in Jacksonville florida. I remember just being blown away by that opening of vanishing. I was like oh my God, this is going to be a good night. Me and the person who went with me still talk about that show to this day. I'm still friends with people to this day and who I met at that show. Good times. I've gotten married and had three kids since then. Wow, time has flown.
‘’ …. Take what’s mine…….. mine…mine…. Minnnneeeeee !!!!….” Epic!!!! 01:04:34 And then when they continue the song… awesome. Oh yes, Did I mention that this is recorded at red Rock?
Jeff Friedl...omg...chills multiple times...his playing is so lyrical. I saw APC live in Austin...totally otherworldly experience! One of the best live performances EVER. Two bands for me...Zep & APC.
You can say that you've recently learned that questions require question marks or else they're not questions, periods separate sentences, and commas separate thoughts or represent pauses in a sentence.
@@fyou2327Wow man you got him good. I'm sure by now you've learnt about rhetorical questions. Some things don't need an answer... maturity comes with age. You'll get there soon
This show is absolutely phenomenal. I’ve just recently got into APC seriously and I’m wondering what the eff my problem is 😂 I’ve always been a fan of Maynard and Tool. I can’t get enough of this. It makes you want to cry and mosh at the same time. Maynard is perfection.
I all love three but APC is really is my favorite. Just saw Puscifer this year. That show was an experience. I saw Tool years ago. I will see them again this fall. I have not seen A Perfect Circle and I see they are playing at Red Rocks. I would love to see them there. Great comment "cry and mosh at the same time." This band really digs deep in to emotion.
I cried several times at the beauty captured in these live moments. Many can do it in a studio with endless takes, but few sound this good in concert. Big ups to the sound engineer. I think Im gonna take another lap with thos ome immediately.
Agree with the manic editing. You’ll Have a seizure trying to watch that. Takes away from really incredible performance. Maynard , his various talented bands, bandmates and shared gifts have deeply influenced my soul.
Shit! Orestes is probably one of the greatest song of any time in this show. Is unsane. Blow away my mind, is poetry and darkness, liberty and peace. What a fucking masterpiece.
TRACKLIST:
00:00:00 Intro / Annihilation
00:03:51 Imagine
00:08:42 Week and Powerless
00:12:05 The Hollow
00:15:10 Rose
00:18:55 Blue
00:24:03 Whats Going On
00:28:58 People Are People
00:32:55 The Outsider
00:37:18 Peace, Love, and Understanding
00:42:02 When the Levee Breaks
00:48:36 The Noose
00:53:57 3 Libras
01:00:28 The Package
01:08:42 Gimmie, Gimmie, Gimmie
01:12:22 Orestes
01:18:12 Passive
01:23:54 Counting Bodies Like Sheep to The Rythm of the War Drums
01:29:50 Fiddle and the Drum
01:33:15 By and Down the River
You're the real hero. But I listen start to finish. I'm sure you do as well.
P
🤘🏻🔥🔥
Great setlist
Plz put James Iha in the description 👍
Are you also team "Okay, let's watch this phenomenal Orestes performance again" and end up watching the entire thing for the 30th time?
Everytime they add things to this song gets better. The part of the solo is a masterpiece. I think they should remake this song in studio, cause the have added many interesting things to this song (and I mean the live versions of this song, you can notice differences from the original)
Even there's an alternative version of this and it sounds great!
Yep! Your comment popped up just as I restarted the show after listening to Orestes... 😂😂 Brilliant.
I can't even listen to the prerecorded version without my insides twitching to listen to the red rocks performance.. it is incredible.
Yes!!!
damn it same here
Orestes is one of the greatest live performances of all time
Completely agree
Facts.
When I saw them a couple of years ago they didn't play Orestes. I'm still recovering from that disappointment.
All of my hairs standing up on end. I didn’t anyone could replace Josh Freese as the drummer, but they just found a left handed version of him in Jeff. So impressed!
PAL PICOOOOO TEMAZO
That Orestes performance was a spiritual experience
It's the one song on this i keep repeating. The ending when they all cut loose is just beautiful.
I listen to this song multiple times a day every day. I can't get over how good they performed this song live
The harmonies are insane. So good
Outstanding!
This is insane, how can a band be this good live??
Practice, and get to know about the gear that suits your sound and dynamics.
@@SatanSplainer rhetorical question say hi
And post production
@@whistlyyy1609 Exactly. Overdubs are part of almost any live recording that's professionally released.
It's very rare! The only other band I know that's better live than on CD is The Cure....
If Maynard's singing from 1:16:55 - 1:17:40 doesn't make you cry, you're not a human. PERIOD
Fucking beautiful.
A thing of absolute beauty
Yep! I was reading this comment while listening to Orestes trying to figure out if it was going to be in this song or Passive, but then I remembered how magical the end of that song is and sure enough, my eyes stated to well up, checked the time, and there is was 1:17:00. 🤘
Crying right now
The perfection of Billy's and Maynard's vocals together is just.............
only beaten by layne Staley and Jerry Cantrell
I was there. It rained. What a delightful reminder. Such an amazing experience.
Were you allowed to record?
@@juancastro7084 I was there as well, No, strongly discouraged
One of the best performances of Maynard. Studio quality performance
Well it helps that Red Rocks is one of the best places to do a concert.
@@geoffreyprior8931 Maynard doesn't need any help.
@@geoffreyprior8931 well i've seen APC in europe, it was amazing and the place was really shitty compare to Red rocks
there are any other members in the band, you know?
This is one of the best live performances I've ever heard.
It doesn't hurt that Red Rocks is one of the best live music venues in the country.
It makes me so happy that James Iha got to be part of such an amazing band after the Smashing Pumpkins.
o damn. didnt notice that was James. Nice call
@@asrouse1 he’s been part of the band for some time. I think since 13th step
He's a hired gun who joined as part of the touring band, not a part of the songwriting process nor did he play on any of the studio albums. He joined the band as a touring member during the thirteenth step tour and would later join the band for other tours later on. I'm not sure if he was ever referred to as an official member of the band, but I could be wrong on this.
@@aconformist1 He is an official member. Has been since 2003. The band is always on hiatus due to Maynard's other projects. Members are always working solo or with other artists during these long gaps. Iha couldn't play in the summer of 2018 due to Pumpkins reunion. But he's been on studio albums Emotive and Elephant.
This is just absolute, total, complete, pure perfection. I would give almost anything to be able to witness this in person. I am envious of every single person in that amphitheater. Seeing APC and Tool live would be a dream come true and I have to do it. Maybe one day in the not too distant future it will happen. I could then die happy.
Tool is on tour now and apc and pucifer are touring together early next year, go see them, you won't regret any of it!
@@danielporter6410Got to see them in 2003 when they toured for the 13th step. If you get the opportunity to see them, do it. I promise you won't regret it.
@@danielporter6410
Definitely some money WELL $PENT!!
The harmonies in The Hollow from 14:20 to 14:55 are otherworldly
Peace, Love, and Understanding here is just wow, Billy Howerdel is phenomenal
I had no idea he could sing like that. 🤯 Just realized it was him all this time…
Harmony
That guitar is like an extension of Billy’s body.
Fun fact: Billy's a robot and the guitar plugs into him.
@@fyou2327 I wouldn’t doubt it. 😂
Drummer playing balls out. Holy crap is that some brilliant playing. I sure as hell wish that the editing wasn't so chopped up into one second segments during the uptempo numbers.
He had a cast on his leg when i saw them live in something like 2005 and he didn't miss a beat.
This needs to be released on vinyl.
Yes!
I will never forget listening to this for the first time. I was gonna just watch a couple performances of songs that I like and ended up watching the whole frickin thing
Haha, same here 🤘
This is absolutely unreal quality!!! A lot of bands can’t even get this on a studio album…
Maynard the best live singer vocalist I have everseen, so clean and consistent. He doesn't runs out of idea. This performance is so less egoistic , he just stayed on the dark spot without being too upfront he intentionally din this not about him, just the band, the music and the song. Actually each the members of APC are so great giving us the best times.
I had no idea this was in 2013. Thats an uplifting thought because it its the year I finally got sober.
i got serious goosebumpes when i heard Billy shouting "wake up". what a marvelous concert
Man I hope these guys tour again. I’d hate to never get to see them live. What an experience it must be.
See them for Maynard’s 60!! this spring 👍🏻🤙🏻🔥
@@sehlordhorr8540fuck yeah im there for the san diego show
Maynard. Nothing more needs to be said. The man is just phenomenal.
The music, the voice, pure magic
This was in 2011 Me and my wife's first date
I can't think of a better first date
My wife's and my.
Maynard is particularly amazing in this concert
Man, Billy's voice and guitar in this concert is perfect
I keep coming back to this performance years later. Thankful for the audio and visual quality but damn, do I wish I was there to see it live.
Me too
I've been personally responsible for probably hundreds of the views here. I come back over and over and over to this concert. When I'm grieving I crawl inside the sounds like a nest, other times I'm just cooking or doing laundry and I put it on like a phone call from an old friend.
I was there, best show I've seen
Uma das melhores sensações que tenho é assistir esse show em meu quarto com a luz apagada, a sonoridade dessa banda é impenotisante.
2023
awesome beyond words ... I do wish they had rolled Judith into the lineup ... this would have been the ultimate venue for that masterpiece ...
Quickly becoming one of my fav bands. After a decade of loving Tool, only recently delved into APC/Puscifer and I adore them both. Find them a lot easier to listen to than Tool at this point, not as overwhelming... some of those elements are there but it isn't too much. Everything Maynard touches turns to gold, sings you to sleep one minute and the next he emits powerful and raw emotion, fucking love it.
I'll never have a problem listening to Tool.
I was here and it was one of the best concerts I've ever been to.
EVERYONES TALKING ABOUT ORESTES BUT PEOPLE ARE PEOPLE IS A LEGIT EARGASM.
The buildup and climax of The Noose sound absolutely breathtaking here
This is sick! Sound and vocals are ridiculous. The sound combination is amazing.
Incredible Sound. The vocals and musicianship, across the board, is next level (Friedl is one of the more interesting and dynamic drummers I've come across in recent years).
Billy's voice ❤
Got to see them on the Thirteenth Step Tour at the North Shore Events Centre in Auckland, New Zealand. Amazing night!
I got to see them for that same tour but in Jacksonville florida. I remember just being blown away by that opening of vanishing. I was like oh my God, this is going to be a good night. Me and the person who went with me still talk about that show to this day. I'm still friends with people to this day and who I met at that show. Good times. I've gotten married and had three kids since then. Wow, time has flown.
I've listened to your recording of that show, thank you so much for taping. I was only 11 at the time and living in Nelson
‘’ …. Take what’s mine…….. mine…mine…. Minnnneeeeee !!!!….” Epic!!!!
01:04:34
And then when they continue the song… awesome.
Oh yes,
Did I mention that this is recorded at red Rock?
So many unreal songs in here. I love Passive
Jeff Friedl...omg...chills multiple times...his playing is so lyrical. I saw APC live in Austin...totally otherworldly experience! One of the best live performances EVER. Two bands for me...Zep & APC.
Incredible. Was lucky to see them open for NIN in SF but this is near …
Aging like very fine wine, such an Incredible band, This show is perfection
Every single ounce of this show is perfect. One of the best concerts I have ever been to in my entire life. It was sublime.
First time watching this set but man im excited for orestes based of these comments hell ya
The most talented band I have ever seen
YOU BROUGHT IT BACK THANK YOU SO MUCH :)
Wow no words just a perfect circle
Godlike performance what can i say ..
You can say that you've recently learned that questions require question marks or else they're not questions, periods separate sentences, and commas separate thoughts or represent pauses in a sentence.
@@fyou2327Wow man you got him good. I'm sure by now you've learnt about rhetorical questions. Some things don't need an answer... maturity comes with age. You'll get there soon
That "People are People" was so damn good. Thanks for uploading this concert!!!! What a tour de force of talent.
The package 🔥
It's incredible. It gets LOTS of plays from me.
This show is absolutely phenomenal. I’ve just recently got into APC seriously and I’m wondering what the eff my problem is 😂 I’ve always been a fan of Maynard and Tool. I can’t get enough of this. It makes you want to cry and mosh at the same time. Maynard is perfection.
I all love three but APC is really is my favorite. Just saw Puscifer this year. That show was an experience. I saw Tool years ago. I will see them again this fall. I have not seen A Perfect Circle and I see they are playing at Red Rocks. I would love to see them there. Great comment "cry and mosh at the same time." This band really digs deep in to emotion.
0:37 Peace, Love and Understanding forever in my heart 🪐
this is sick ! so much beauty and power, what a gig!
I would’ve loved one more album before the covers album.
Sea of names and thirteenth step are both incredible albums.
This needs to be released as a album! WOW!!!!
it is! haha
an* album. For fuck's sake, do you not know how vowels work?
I cried several times at the beauty captured in these live moments. Many can do it in a studio with endless takes, but few sound this good in concert. Big ups to the sound engineer. I think Im gonna take another lap with thos ome immediately.
How is no one commenting about "Rose", full magic piece
Yes dude! Rose and Orestes are the best songs they have made
By down, rule all over
@@travishall6442 The Package is fuckin' nasty too.
What does "full magic piece" mean?
Thought the same! It's beautiful
Mano eu n consigo conceber a perfeição dessa voz ao vivo I CANT CONCEIVE THAT PERFECT VOICE LIVE
it never gets old..kudos on this post
Agree with the manic editing. You’ll Have a seizure trying to watch that. Takes away from really incredible performance. Maynard , his various talented bands, bandmates and shared gifts have deeply influenced my soul.
I’m so thankful this video exists but also so mad we don’t have this for TOOL.
This....was amazing...my first time hearing this.....my ears...feel...good?
The perfection of cyclical absolution
So glad i found this!! I was there, and the meories came flooding back! Thank you for posting!!!
it's mind blowing how pitch perfect maynard's performance is here.
who ever did this edition of the show, you are a f genius
well you certainly can't say they don't pull it off live. just INCREDIBLE
So awesome! You know a band is good live when they sound just like their recordings. I've seen them live twice and they were amazing both times!
01:23:54 Oh my god, this song has such a deep drive! This must be incredible to feel that live! 😮😮
As good a concert, by elite musicians, that I have heard - top to bottom. Man, that's tight ... and great!
Best lineup, best live, best of the Perfect circle
Without a single doubt, one of the best live acts you’ll ever witness
Shit! Orestes is probably one of the greatest song of any time in this show. Is unsane. Blow away my mind, is poetry and darkness, liberty and peace. What a fucking masterpiece.
I'm obsessed with that song, it's a fucking banger! 🔥🥺
That is one hell of a rock band.
OMG, thank you SO MUCH, I've been looking for this concert everywhere....
LOVE this so much !
Bless you.
Magical.
Thanks A LOT!! The best concert i've ever watched,Truly...
This is an amazing live recording. Wish we could get a tool concert filmed this well too
Pure heaven❤
Man...so lucky to get this set list. So many Emotive songs and the best of the best of the rest....amazing
So damn good!
And the best for last. Perfect song. By and down the River has a special place in my Heart and ears
That was amazing, had never heard of this band before today and I'm an instant fan. So nice to hear something new to me and have my mind blown!
Welcome. I been hooked from day one many many years ago. this is prollybbn one of the best bands ever created
Sound engineer knocked it out of the park!
One of the best shows I've been too... Audio was amazing live.
way too cool🔥 APC＝PERFECT💯完璧で最高のLIVEです🔥
Thank you from the bottom of my heart 🌹🌹🌹💯
PERFECT WORK! THANKS!
Thanks, bro🎉
I replayed this 6x today.
If you can, enable your 5.1 surround set and let Dolby do its thing.
Perco tudinho. Pode levar tudo de mim a perfect circle, maynard. Pó levar tudo
Fixin to see them here again (my first time at Red Rocks) in April 2024 for Maynard's 60th. I heard Puscifer and Primus are gonna be there too...
A melhor banda de todas!!
Gimme, gimme!
So perfect ;(