Have you been watching along with the Breakdowns? Don't forget to check out the latest Breakdown on Harry Potter and The Half Blood Prince here! th-cam.com/video/Rve8m6voOLk/w-d-xo.htmlsi=YkaRDvWg3HnsASIS
My head canon for Vold.'s victimology is that, once he became comfortable killing people, his soul wouldn't fracture unless he had some degree of emotional investment. Thus (long shot speculation) I think that the muggle tramp was the head mistress from the orphanage (after succumbing to alcoholism and losing her job & home).
I love Gina's idea of a whole season of flashbacks of tom riddle creating the horcruxes. It would be so cool if the gave us an off season episode between the "years/books" showing the back story and how Voldemort made the horcruxes. Thanks for coming out with this episode I've been patiently dying for it! Lol!
I’m not going to lie pretty disappointed 1-3 got individual break room discussions and now 4-6 have to share one this is what I listen to when feeling depressed and have been a little content starved
@@TheCrispyChipwith all due respect, if you tried making videos for all the content they are (especially right now) then you would be late with some content too
Did you guys not listen to the full video? The DAYS they spend PER MOVIE researching, reading, watching, writing, filming, editing? These movies have so much content between interviews, websites, behind the scenes, plus the actual book and movies -not to mention all of the lore from other Fantastic Beasts, Cursed Child, and wikia pages, other content creators, new news on the upcoming series, etc. And you guys want to complain that they combined the movies into one break room video, even though they’ve already broken each movie down individually? It’s holiday season, there’s a ton of other movie content recently, and also they are allowed to have their own lives. I’m thankful for ANY content they put out regarding the HP series and I’m sure as much fun as they’re having they also are tired of spending what has been months doing this for their fans who have asked for it for so many years. With that being said THANK YOU to all of the New Rockstars team who continuously pump out quality content day after day. You have no reason ever to apologize, I’ve been a fan for 8 years and nothing will stop me from supporting you guys!
@hayleehunt4938 (No joke was writing this comment up and was about to not, until i read yours and thankyou, so to add to it)... Yeah, what the hell are these guys talking about. Listen to the video. They are loving doing these breakdowns, Erik, Gina, the editors and everyone involved in the process, but they are exhausted. Yeah, I'd love to hear them talk for a long time too, but they have done enough. And thankyou to them because they've sparked my love for Harry Potter again after so many years, making me want to read the books again, but for the knowledge and not as a way to put me to sleep like they did when I was younger. They did that for me and probably many others and I'm grateful for it. So be grateful and don't get mad at them over the fact there are less videos and a possible drop in quality, they tired and it's Christmas. Let them cook and let them breathe. Love those guys
I've always thought cumberbatch would be a good Snape, and not because he can do a good rickman impression, but because he can be so sinister seeming but also turn on a dime. On the flip side I always thought it'd be fun to bring some of the kids from the films to come play the professors. Like have Radcliffe, who's now 35 which is about right for Snape when you think about it, or Watson play trelawny.
Love this breakdown series, love these chats about your processes, it has been awesome! I'm super excited for the final two, thank you to all who worked on them!
There are extended cuts for the first three films that officially exist. Surprised yall didn’t mention this. Also, I believe goblet of fire has one, but was only on tv.
Clearly they fucking know this. They watched it all for breakdowns. Are you not listening? They can't include every single everything.... breakdowns will take hours.
i dont refrigerate tomatoes as they last longer out of the fridge but i do like a cold sliced tomato on a sandwich or salad so i will put one in for a few hours before i use it so it will be cold but i use it right away
Random thought: Voldemort's birthday is listed as December 31. Interesting because it's the polar opposite of of Harry's July 31 birthday. I have complicated feelings about JK but I'm really enjoying these breakdowns and everything you guys do!
Ive seen a popular fan theory that he did get his hands on the sword and was trying to make it his last horcrux with harrys death but since it rebounded and killed his body instead, harry became the horcrux and the sword simply disappeared like when griphook died
Ok you’re killin’ me with the re-uploads. This is a reply to the original comment saying that its US health code to refrigerate them. Im a chef in CA. I have worked in places that both refrigerated tomatoes and do not refrigerate tomatoes. Tomatoes are heavy breathers, meaning they give off a gas that makes them ripen. If you keep them in a walk-in refrigerator, they will be fine as long as there is sufficient air circulation. If you have them in a small enclosed space they will rot every quickly. It all really depends on how fast you use them and if you have the proper facilities.
worked at taco bell and whataburger and can confirm places like that do refrigerate our tomatoes. maybe because we cut them? preserve longer cause we get such a huge amount? idk but we do it
Its a fact that tomatoes will spoil faster on the counter than on the fridge. If you're using them quickly it doesnt matter. But for an extended time, it best to put them in the fridge
So I’ve heard a theory floated around that Voldy actually had the sword of Griffindor with him when he went to kill Harry, in Goddrick’s Hallow, but when all the things went down, the sword disappeared, as it has been shown to do
We refrigerate our tomatoes at the restaurant I work at I not sure if it’s right or wrong the health inspector said the temperature needs to be a a certain degree but I’m just there for the paycheck I don’t really know lol
The fact that Rolling made the process of creating a horcrux so vile that it can be known to the public, how did Voldemort accidentally make Harry one?
The only things I could think of if this cast a black actor to play Snap is the bullying. Wither it be intentionally or unintentional could be perceived as racially motivated thus cause the marauders to be perceived as racist. Or having a black man pining over a white woman
Have you been to the Harry Potter studio tour near London. They are the proper sets and are absolutely amazing. I went in winter and they had the full size Hogwarts castle in winter mode, with snow, etc.
I don't get this argument that they should recast the characters mid-series.. There isn't a big time jump like in House of the Dragon or The Crown, it would be jarring if they suddenly looked different. And whatever kid plays Draco will become filthy rich -- is it really so terrible that he would have to dye his hair for a role?
I don’t think the horcrux has to be created at the time of killing someone. Wizards kill others but few make a single horcrux (death eaters aren’t out here with horcruxes). Killing rips the soul. You kill some people then you have your tattered soul within yourself. Later you do the horcrux magic to encase a fragment within the object. By the time Vold tried killing Harry he had a fractured soul with 5 fragments outside of his body (in the book they believe this makes the soul very unstable) so the rebounding spell ripped another chunk of soul off of Vold’s already tattered one that latched onto Harry. This was seen as the exception because instead of dying, Vold’s horcruxes allowed his original damaged soul to linger in existence. The soul was just out there free from his body already and in bad shape. When he was a living wizard creating intentional horcruxes, he would have had to preform the complex magic to get the part of his soul from inside him to the object. His soul chunk wouldn’t just jump out into an object he brought with him to the murder. He could have killed 2 people, then acquired the 2 objects, then turned the objects into horcruxes
definitely don't refrigerate tomatoes. it destroys the flavor and texture. I, like Eric, did it wrong for years and was a convert and it was like tasting tomatoes for the first time they were so much better unrefrigerated.
Also a my friend and i keep going back to a hot topic debate! Can you guys please help us fugure this out? DOES THE ROOM OF REQUIREMENT MOVE? OR IS IT IN ONE LOCATION IN THE CASTLE? We have seriously spent hours debating in this. I think it moves. She thinks no its doesnt. What do you guys think?!
You know guys there is a possibility that because HP isn’t set in the US they might do things differently 🤯 And your googling results might affect that geographical fact 🤷♀️
I don’t think we can compare recasting aging up to HotD and The Crown. Those shows aged up decades. We’re aging up a summer vacation. Not remotely the same. Recasting would be a huge distraction. I hate that idea. Also, can we [Gina] PLEASE stop pronouncing Rowling’s name wrong. It’s Rowling, rhymes with bowling. Like Rolling.
Alright if the tomatoe is sliced or cut then you have to put it in the fridge. Also your rpm must be at least like $20 on the NR channel for the HP breakdowns to be that profitable. Am I close? What’s your rpm and avd too
Personally, I disagree with the notion that we should just fall in line with casting decisions. Some of these characters were not described as they were just to be changed for some racially inclusive reasons. If Snape is a tall, slender, lengthy, pale faced man with short greasy hair down to his shoulders then that's what I wanna see. There are plenty of background roles to race swap or even new ones that can be included. Nothing against giving certain new people a chance , but what about finally giving the fans what they want to see?? Like, we Black people have plenty of more stories that have yet to be touched by Hollywood.
True because why can't we have real black characters? Just taking white characters and making them black isn't true representation. I think it doesn't matter for certain people but other people have defining traits like you said with snape, he should be a greasy little weirdo.
Nope. The skin tone of characters doesn’t matter. We need to see a bitter, lonely Snape who gives off a sickly moody vibe like he never leaves his dungeon and his skin/hair is always gross from brewing potions. But simultaneously is imposing as a teacher and takes out his enormous life regrets on his non-Slytherin students. An actor’s presence, skill, and wardrobe/makeup styling can do it all. The casting call shouldn’t be segregated, have everyone show up and they’ll pick the best Snape. The only thing that irritates me about movie changes is when they fundamentally change the character traits like they did with Ginny. The red hair was on point but they made her so uncool when she was supposed to be a sporty and popular tomboyish kinda girl after book 3. Like the Weasley family could all look different because they’re adopted and I’d be here for it as long as the personalities are on point. I’d love for Fred and George to actually be twins tho bc it’s kinda their whole vibe. Also for all the secrecy when Percy starts dating Penelope, maybe they write Percy as being gay, would make more sense than him hiding a girlfriend. We have the books and we have the original movies. Let them take some creative license on the smaller details of the show while giving life to great parts of the books we didn’t get to see in the movies. The team shouldn’t limit themselves to considering cast members of a single race for certain roles, it’s honestly a weird thing to do in a fictional story
![The Triwizard Tournament! Harry Potter and The Goblet of Fire (2005) [REACTION] First Time Watching!](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/doRXvEkYH5U/mqdefault.jpg)
![Larry David [FULL EPISODE] | Conan O'Brien Needs A Friend](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/fEMzCHX2ONA/mqdefault.jpg)
Have you been watching along with the Breakdowns? Don't forget to check out the latest Breakdown on Harry Potter and The Half Blood Prince here!
th-cam.com/video/Rve8m6voOLk/w-d-xo.htmlsi=YkaRDvWg3HnsASIS
1:04:10 Heath Ledger joker is the perfect example of this. People were upset about it and he ended up like defining the role for future generations
We really appreciate all the time and effort you put into the breakdowns. Thank youu ❤
My head canon for Vold.'s victimology is that, once he became comfortable killing people, his soul wouldn't fracture unless he had some degree of emotional investment.
Thus (long shot speculation) I think that the muggle tramp was the head mistress from the orphanage (after succumbing to alcoholism and losing her job & home).
I thought Gina was saying "season 1 of severus" not severance, and I got excited thinking there was a Snape series i somehow missed
I love Gina's idea of a whole season of flashbacks of tom riddle creating the horcruxes. It would be so cool if the gave us an off season episode between the "years/books" showing the back story and how Voldemort made the horcruxes. Thanks for coming out with this episode I've been patiently dying for it! Lol!
It only took 9 minutes for Eric to mention Lost. I think that's a new record!! @BreakroomNR 8:51
I’m not going to lie pretty disappointed 1-3 got individual break room discussions and now 4-6 have to share one this is what I listen to when feeling depressed and have been a little content starved
Same:/ but it was probably views/ time with the holidays coming up
Yeah the got lazy and we're pumping out different break rooms. You can even tell the quality in even the breakdowns themselves has suffered.
@@TheCrispyChipwith all due respect, if you tried making videos for all the content they are (especially right now) then you would be late with some content too
Did you guys not listen to the full video? The DAYS they spend PER MOVIE researching, reading, watching, writing, filming, editing? These movies have so much content between interviews, websites, behind the scenes, plus the actual book and movies -not to mention all of the lore from other Fantastic Beasts, Cursed Child, and wikia pages, other content creators, new news on the upcoming series, etc. And you guys want to complain that they combined the movies into one break room video, even though they’ve already broken each movie down individually? It’s holiday season, there’s a ton of other movie content recently, and also they are allowed to have their own lives. I’m thankful for ANY content they put out regarding the HP series and I’m sure as much fun as they’re having they also are tired of spending what has been months doing this for their fans who have asked for it for so many years.
With that being said THANK YOU to all of the New Rockstars team who continuously pump out quality content day after day. You have no reason ever to apologize, I’ve been a fan for 8 years and nothing will stop me from supporting you guys!
@hayleehunt4938 (No joke was writing this comment up and was about to not, until i read yours and thankyou, so to add to it)...
Yeah, what the hell are these guys talking about. Listen to the video. They are loving doing these breakdowns, Erik, Gina, the editors and everyone involved in the process, but they are exhausted. Yeah, I'd love to hear them talk for a long time too, but they have done enough. And thankyou to them because they've sparked my love for Harry Potter again after so many years, making me want to read the books again, but for the knowledge and not as a way to put me to sleep like they did when I was younger. They did that for me and probably many others and I'm grateful for it. So be grateful and don't get mad at them over the fact there are less videos and a possible drop in quality, they tired and it's Christmas. Let them cook and let them breathe. Love those guys
I'm mad at myself for missing this live 😣
Thank you for all your hard work! These videos/breakdowns are a lot of fun
I've always thought cumberbatch would be a good Snape, and not because he can do a good rickman impression, but because he can be so sinister seeming but also turn on a dime. On the flip side I always thought it'd be fun to bring some of the kids from the films to come play the professors. Like have Radcliffe, who's now 35 which is about right for Snape when you think about it, or Watson play trelawny.
Love this breakdown series, love these chats about your processes, it has been awesome! I'm super excited for the final two, thank you to all who worked on them!
There are extended cuts for the first three films that officially exist. Surprised yall didn’t mention this.
Also, I believe goblet of fire has one, but was only on tv.
Clearly they fucking know this. They watched it all for breakdowns. Are you not listening? They can't include every single everything.... breakdowns will take hours.
The way you buy produce is the way you store produce. Tomatoes are not in the refrigerated section of the grocery store. Debate over.
TH-cam…. Not just filming a video and talking into a camera… these types of TH-camrs don’t get enough credit
i dont refrigerate tomatoes as they last longer out of the fridge but i do like a cold sliced tomato on a sandwich or salad so i will put one in for a few hours before i use it so it will be cold but i use it right away
Random thought: Voldemort's birthday is listed as December 31. Interesting because it's the polar opposite of of Harry's July 31 birthday.
I have complicated feelings about JK but I'm really enjoying these breakdowns and everything you guys do!
2hr+ reviews with no cuts, please.
Ive seen a popular fan theory that he did get his hands on the sword and was trying to make it his last horcrux with harrys death but since it rebounded and killed his body instead, harry became the horcrux and the sword simply disappeared like when griphook died
I love the Carlin Brothers 🎉
Love it! More behind the breakdown please!
Ok you’re killin’ me with the re-uploads.
This is a reply to the original comment saying that its US health code to refrigerate them.
Im a chef in CA. I have worked in places that both refrigerated tomatoes and do not refrigerate tomatoes.
Tomatoes are heavy breathers, meaning they give off a gas that makes them ripen. If you keep them in a walk-in refrigerator, they will be fine as long as there is sufficient air circulation. If you have them in a small enclosed space they will rot every quickly. It all really depends on how fast you use them and if you have the proper facilities.
I've thoroughly enjoyed this btw, like an afternoon in a good coffee shop.
The best example of they don’t look what you’d expect but became the character, Colin Ferrell in The Batman/The Penguin
I knew people will be commenting on the tomatoes. The second he said it in the breakdown i thought "oof wrong move, people won't be happy" 😂😂
I think The crown did it really well. 1:05:50
Grateful to have these Breakroom type of episodes. Now before Gina gets hired to write for the HP series, can she please get to do a series on AoS????
worked at taco bell and whataburger and can confirm places like that do refrigerate our tomatoes. maybe because we cut them? preserve longer cause we get such a huge amount? idk but we do it
Its a fact that tomatoes will spoil faster on the counter than on the fridge. If you're using them quickly it doesnt matter. But for an extended time, it best to put them in the fridge
So I’ve heard a theory floated around that Voldy actually had the sword of Griffindor with him when he went to kill Harry, in Goddrick’s Hallow, but when all the things went down, the sword disappeared, as it has been shown to do
I’m Canadian, and we refrigerate tomatoes
We refrigerate our tomatoes at the restaurant I work at I not sure if it’s right or wrong the health inspector said the temperature needs to be a a certain degree but I’m just there for the paycheck I don’t really know lol
The fact that Rolling made the process of creating a horcrux so vile that it can be known to the public, how did Voldemort accidentally make Harry one?
Gina, will you talk about why the island where Dumbledore buried is used through out the movies is there a production significance to it?
The only things I could think of if this cast a black actor to play Snap is the bullying. Wither it be intentionally or unintentional could be perceived as racially motivated thus cause the marauders to be perceived as racist. Or having a black man pining over a white woman
I would love to see a just for fun breakdown of A Very Potter Musical
would you do behind the breakdown for the daredevil/punisher rewatch? that would be fun
I’d say If snape got the liquid luck he gave it to Lilly cuz he didn’t use it that’s for sure 😂
Gina has killed it yet again 🍻 you too, Erik 😁
Have you been to the Harry Potter studio tour near London. They are the proper sets and are absolutely amazing. I went in winter and they had the full size Hogwarts castle in winter mode, with snow, etc.
I 100% won’t watch if they announce they plan to replace the actors ever few seasons
1:05:51 Felicity Jones? Your queen is Claire Foy
Felicity Jones? That was Claire Foy.
DO NOY REFRIGERATE TOMATOES
I don't get this argument that they should recast the characters mid-series.. There isn't a big time jump like in House of the Dragon or The Crown, it would be jarring if they suddenly looked different. And whatever kid plays Draco will become filthy rich -- is it really so terrible that he would have to dye his hair for a role?
I don’t think the horcrux has to be created at the time of killing someone. Wizards kill others but few make a single horcrux (death eaters aren’t out here with horcruxes). Killing rips the soul. You kill some people then you have your tattered soul within yourself. Later you do the horcrux magic to encase a fragment within the object. By the time Vold tried killing Harry he had a fractured soul with 5 fragments outside of his body (in the book they believe this makes the soul very unstable) so the rebounding spell ripped another chunk of soul off of Vold’s already tattered one that latched onto Harry. This was seen as the exception because instead of dying, Vold’s horcruxes allowed his original damaged soul to linger in existence. The soul was just out there free from his body already and in bad shape. When he was a living wizard creating intentional horcruxes, he would have had to preform the complex magic to get the part of his soul from inside him to the object. His soul chunk wouldn’t just jump out into an object he brought with him to the murder. He could have killed 2 people, then acquired the 2 objects, then turned the objects into horcruxes
1:01:00 bad take.
definitely don't refrigerate tomatoes. it destroys the flavor and texture. I, like Eric, did it wrong for years and was a convert and it was like tasting tomatoes for the first time they were so much better unrefrigerated.
Also a my friend and i keep going back to a hot topic debate! Can you guys please help us fugure this out? DOES THE ROOM OF REQUIREMENT MOVE? OR IS IT IN ONE LOCATION IN THE CASTLE? We have seriously spent hours debating in this. I think it moves. She thinks no its doesnt. What do you guys think?!
it 100% moves
You know guys there is a possibility that because HP isn’t set in the US they might do things differently 🤯 And your googling results might affect that geographical fact 🤷♀️
What about ketchup?
I don’t think we can compare recasting aging up to HotD and The Crown. Those shows aged up decades. We’re aging up a summer vacation. Not remotely the same. Recasting would be a huge distraction. I hate that idea.
Also, can we [Gina] PLEASE stop pronouncing Rowling’s name wrong. It’s Rowling, rhymes with bowling. Like Rolling.
She doesn't know what a deleted scene is? Wtf
Omg no she misremembered the movie? That scene wasn't cut and there's others that enforce the taboo. Jeez
❤
Release the butthole cut(the 3 hour breakdowns)
Alright if the tomatoe is sliced or cut then you have to put it in the fridge. Also your rpm must be at least like $20 on the NR channel for the HP breakdowns to be that profitable. Am I close? What’s your rpm and avd too
#ReleaseTheGinaCut
That's not what happens with hepsibah though Ur misinterpreting
🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩
Personally, I disagree with the notion that we should just fall in line with casting decisions. Some of these characters were not described as they were just to be changed for some racially inclusive reasons. If Snape is a tall, slender, lengthy, pale faced man with short greasy hair down to his shoulders then that's what I wanna see. There are plenty of background roles to race swap or even new ones that can be included. Nothing against giving certain new people a chance , but what about finally giving the fans what they want to see?? Like, we Black people have plenty of more stories that have yet to be touched by Hollywood.
True because why can't we have real black characters? Just taking white characters and making them black isn't true representation. I think it doesn't matter for certain people but other people have defining traits like you said with snape, he should be a greasy little weirdo.
Nope. The skin tone of characters doesn’t matter. We need to see a bitter, lonely Snape who gives off a sickly moody vibe like he never leaves his dungeon and his skin/hair is always gross from brewing potions. But simultaneously is imposing as a teacher and takes out his enormous life regrets on his non-Slytherin students. An actor’s presence, skill, and wardrobe/makeup styling can do it all. The casting call shouldn’t be segregated, have everyone show up and they’ll pick the best Snape. The only thing that irritates me about movie changes is when they fundamentally change the character traits like they did with Ginny. The red hair was on point but they made her so uncool when she was supposed to be a sporty and popular tomboyish kinda girl after book 3. Like the Weasley family could all look different because they’re adopted and I’d be here for it as long as the personalities are on point. I’d love for Fred and George to actually be twins tho bc it’s kinda their whole vibe. Also for all the secrecy when Percy starts dating Penelope, maybe they write Percy as being gay, would make more sense than him hiding a girlfriend. We have the books and we have the original movies. Let them take some creative license on the smaller details of the show while giving life to great parts of the books we didn’t get to see in the movies. The team shouldn’t limit themselves to considering cast members of a single race for certain roles, it’s honestly a weird thing to do in a fictional story