Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra vs Pixel 8 Pro Camera Comparison: Black Test!
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 27 ก.ย. 2024
- Welcome to another Black Test, the Galaxy S24 Ultra vs the Pixel 8 Pro. Let's see how well the Pixel 8 Pro stacks up against the Galaxy S24 Ultra.
Galaxy S24 Ultra: howl.me/cltpyM...
Pixel 8 Pro: howl.me/cltpAS...
►►►SUBSCRIBE for more - bit.ly/Subscrib...
Gear
Nanlite Pavotube: geni.us/jT0nA
Sony A7III: geni.us/ykmf
Tamron 28-75: geni.us/9wsOvq
Amazon: geni.us/EKZfH
B&H Affiliate Link: goo.gl/A4jaVM
Check out more Booredatwork:
1) Google STADIA vs Project xCloud: • Google Stadia vs Proje...
2) Samsung CHG 90 49-inch ULtrawide: • Samsung CHG 90 49-inch...
3) The First iPhone X Hands-On Experience: • iPhone X - First Look!
Follow BooredatWork on social media:
Facebook - www.facebook.c...
Twitter - / booredatwork
Periscope: Booredatwork
Twitch: / booredatwork
Pinterest- / booredatwork
Here’s where you can find more of the Boored family on TH-cam!
OnBoored: / onboored
BooredFemme: / booredfemme
Booredgamer: / booredgamers
Be sure to comment below, your feedback is what we look for. Thanks for watching!
Can we just appreciate the photo quality and the colours from the Pixel? Just stunning.
Pixel cameras has always been better than Samsung. It's too bad Samsung is more focused on gimmicky things that we won't use after a week than what we really care about and that is cameras.
@@NewYorksFinest1pixel is the apple of android it doesn’t offer as many features but the ones it does are super fine tuned for every scenario
over sharpness and faulty separation is nice !
@@ashouhdylame
@@NewYorksFinest1 But Samsung has always got a better display+the S24 Ultra camera will get better with updates
Just got the pixel 8 pro and its the first time i have a high end phone. Never been into taking pictures but damn, this phone got me hooked on the photography thing lol the camera is so good
The shot of the trainer, how come his hoodie on the inside is two different colors in the two different shots, and which one is the actual color?
Came here to ask the same question. I assume that was supposed to be red since Samsung is known for struggling with reds, but confirmation would be good.
You never mentioned at around 7 minutes in that the Pixel kept missing the blur by your left arm. And at 7:40 the entire side of your face is blurred
Indeed, but I think he didn't mentioned because it's a test on dark skin tones
They didn't lie when they advertised the pixel camera portraying skin tones to be more realistic. Also like how much the colors look better on the pixel. The previous Galaxy was way to oversaturated when it came fo colors.
I preferred the Galaxy on your trainer pic at the bar because it showed how the light bulbs really looked
Yess!!! The "Black Test" needs to be a staple video!!!
I agree 💯
another day, another time any phone get trashed by pixel on photo. This time is S24U getting trashed again, right after s23U being trashed by pixel line in mkbhd blind test.
👍🏾👍🏾 Agreed 💯💯
How about videos, which records better videos?
@@TheOriginalRiddim iphone
Thanks for the review. The pixel destroys Samsung in the camera dept. I wish Samsung would stop with all the gimmicky stuff and focus on the camera. My cousin has a pixel and I have a Samsung and his photos are way better and more real than mine. C'mon Samsung it's not like you don't have the $ to fix the cameras
Not for long becus S24U will get a big camera update thus week
I love Googles image processing, but they definitely need to up the megapixels on the selfie camera.
Lower Megapixels allows it to perform better in low light, if its the same size sensor more light hits each pixel because there's less of them. Thats probably why they do it that way, much like the sony a7s series of cameras only being 12mp but being the best low light real camera.
@@JayTsPhoto oh man, thanks for that info. I never knew that. That’s probably why they kept it so low. I love the camera results, but a lot of times pics on the front facing camera comes out muddy.
@@Johnlmooring yeah that's mostly because phone manufacturers and even consumers have a terrible fascination with eliminating as much noise as possible. So when they make their noise reduction algorithms it's way too aggressive and you lose most of the detail....I've been doing photography for a long time and noise is something that makes a photo have detail/ sharpness....that's how film works, it uses silver crystals and the grain you see is those crystals and that's what's responsible for how sharp a certain film stock is.
So noise isn't always a bad thing but they apply their noise reduction and it muddies the picture up.....10mp is plenty in the right hands, I usually use a 6.1mp camera from 20 years ago and I print 8x10's with it...... anyways I'm going off topic.
If they made the noise reduction less aggressive the photos would be even nicer, especially the front camera ....out of any of the phone manufacturers google really has some people that actually understand photography and it shows in the cameras.
@@JayTsPhoto thanks for the lessons bro. You really taught me a lot. Do you think it’s time for US phones to start using 1 inch sensors? Is it a real benefit? I’ve been hearing rave reviews about the Vivo X100 Pro and it’s 1 inch sensor.
@@Johnlmooring It could be a benefit for video low light performance since the video side of computational photography hasn't caught up yet to the photo side. As far as photos go it could add a bit of depth from the larger sensor but in reality a 1 inch sensor is really only around 24% bigger than what's in the pixel 8/ s24 ultra. And then when you get into a bigger sensor you have to take into account crop factors so then they would have to completely rework the entire lens system to get the same field of view
The Pro 8 looks to have more accurate colors. Blacks look darker on your shirt. Your buddies shirt looked red on the Pro 8 and fuchsia on the S24.
Pixel😍😍
Thanks for this test. The Pixel 8 with real tone is great. Just need this feature to be on the S24 Ultra and it will be a beast. Thanks for this camera test. Very much needed. 👊🏾
Absolutely pixel win 🏆
I tend to prefer pixel photos over the Galaxy's. The one main reason is because the photos on the Samsung appear as if for example you went into the Google photo editor and put the shadows or black point on an image to the positive side. I just prefer the higher contrast on the pixel and the consistency with the shadows on the pixel. Samsung tends to add a bit too much brightening in its images that I have noticed over a course of multiple TH-cam videos have been watching.
I appreciate your opinion a lot. I am compelled to review right now beause I appreciate you as a person and value and respect your opinion. It's paramount! You're a fantastic TH-camr!!! I liked and subscribed both and look forward to your future videos! You just saved me a lot of money. It sounds like I agree with you, out of the box the Pixel 8 Pro wins, but my question for you is only this. If you use software on your computer to correct the image anyway for anything I release to the public, at that point that's the only reason I'm still considering the S24 Ultra at this time. If you consider which is the best unprocessd to be the Samsung then that's important to make the distinction. If it's still not the best, there is only 1 true winner and and the cheaper Pixel is definitely the only true winner here. Thanks! And look forward to your response to my question!!!!! Thank you!!
Wow! This is exactly what i suggested In the previous black test that you did. There's no way you read that and made this video that quick, in which case you had already thought of this. Awesome work and thank you!
To me it seems like the pixel is doing a bit of oversharpening and the s24 looks more natural, and I'm not a fan of the contrasty photos of the pixel, it makes skins tones looks grayish, hopefully s software update on the s24 will improve the dynamic range.
🤫Always brought Samsung Flagship.
From Notes to Ultra's & gotta agree that Samsung photos Always suffer from clarity &over saturation.
It's no surprise that both the Apple 14 & Pixel are whoopin the Sammy Ultra.
Just pre-ordered the S24 Ultra cos it still beats the competition on versatility though.😱
if u ask random ppl which 2 phones has the best camera u prob hear a lot iphone & samsung. Pixel is being the forgotten puppy next to them. might be Samsungs borderline false advertising claiming to have the best camera & camera setup, feels weird claiming to be while they cant achieve it to be. for the average user its prob one of the best tbh. Feature wise it offers way more but if those are actual useful is written in a different book. what annoys me is samsung weird white film filter across the image that appears when there is a bit of light on the scene basically resulting the image having no contrast or it all over the place. like even my 2 year old 150$ xiaomi phone didnt do it.
Man the Pixel's quality cannot be understated. Also what is up with the overexposure filter on the S24 Ultra in every shot? It's like a bright layer of light over the image.
sorry but at the timeline 1:56 what is the colour of your sweatshirt? blue or violet? it's incredible... and in timeline at minutes 4:55 your jacket is green or avana/beiges? thanks bye
Let's all welcome Samsung too artificial intelligence[A I] something pixels have been doing for years now.theres no way Samsung could capture better photos than a pixel phone.google pixel is the best for computational photography hands down.
And that video just proves everything.jus love my pixel 6 pro even More
I honestly don't know what you (and the surroundings, lighting) look like in reality. Maybe use a reference video/photo made with a proper camera?
Btw, I honestly stopped caring about the camera generations ago. It's a choice between good and better. If I really wanted to use the camera professionally, I would care, but then again, I would probably use a dedicated camera.
If I have a decent telephoto sensor, I'm good. And my S10 already did great.
Exactly, he seems to go for the brighter image of his face which seems odd to me. Because me being a darker skin tone I don't want the Samsung software brighting up my skin tone because that's what they think I should look like. But that's just me
@4:45 two solid images? one has pink colors the other red. one of the two is wrong color then?? which was the real color?
Real tone is fantastic, intereting to see the sammy did a decent job though.
Great video, we should build more awareness of real tone 😎
Since its only about the black test , i can let it pass through. But overall in terms of portrait shots the pixels portrait cut out is horrible when compared to that of samsungs. ANd also the blur effect of pixel is soo overdone that it kinda look un-natural, whereas samsung has a better roll off of the blurness which makes the image look more DSLR like.Just an opinion. By the way.. Cool video dude!!
Love from India
One can slightly tone down the brightness on S24U but Pixel's portrait edge detection is kinda meh.
2:54 why portrait vs normal. Its not equitable i think 👍🤔
I think the pixel does a better job at detailing textures (your jacket looks so damn good in the pictures). Ultra does a better job at light (some can be adjusted in settings to reduce the brightness on some pictures) and whole picture- backgrounds look pretty bad when focusing on the foreground with the Pixel whereas Ultra still has some decent details with the background while still focusing on the foreground. A good lightning example is the one in the bar- pixel just had a blurred light bulb where Ultra showed the element inside the light bulb floating (details on the glass/coil/light all separated).
I just need a good astrophotography session to compare the two! I need to see if I can get great Milky Way pictures and fun planets/stars/nebulas/comets!
Pixel color science is excellent
Considering Samsung is releasing an update tomorrow, will there be an updated comparison? If not, that's ridiculous
That's just a rumour theres been no statement from Samsung that there will be an update tomorrow.
@BatfinksWings there's been an official statement actually from Samsung editor on twitter. And it's not that far fetched, most of the time they release updates to fine-tune before most people receive them.
@@Alex-dj9qj Max Jambor? Editor of a Samsung magazine?! I'm waiting on my delivery of the s24u but I wouldn't hold out for a miracle fix, it took the 6months or so to improve the s23u, mine was pretty poor until August for the cam. I'm not expecting a big fix.
@BatfinksWings I mean, I remember having a S10+ and they updated the camera straight away after pre-orders and it improved the night mode (it was not amazing post-processing back then bc their night mode wasn't fully fleshed out yet compared to Huawei but there was definitely a big improvement). So I'm personally not that skeptical. I'm also happy with the camera as it is to be fair, I edit pictures anyway and I do that even after using a mirrorless/DSLR. It looks like a great camera setup and can't wait to shoot RAW w it
I’m glad I found this video. For darker skin the pixel does a lot better
4:30 aren't we gonna talk about how this pic the clothing is red-orange vs fushia on the galaxy
You did it! That was really quick. Thank you again for this. Very much appreciated.
Glad I could put this out as quickly as possible.
@@BooredAtWork ! d ! 0 t
Hey 😊
I do overall think like you, but in a way not.
I do believe that the Galaxys photos is overall to bright. Almost as the lense got some on it. I also believes that the Pixel takes a more accurate photo of your face and skin tone. I do not like the smooth surface that the Galaxy add.
I love this. I have never seen a review based on dark skin. Thank you!
You are welcome. Glad you enjoyed this
I'm so disappointed with the S24 Ultra cameras.
Okay?....and what's wrong with it?
@@FredrickKonadu it's a great phone, but Samsung could've done a lot better with the camera. The camera software right now is disappointing.
@@carver9312bro wtf bro. It just release and the software ain't even release yet. Chil out
@ventagram840 I agree with you. I'm primarily basing my judgement off of today's software. I can't see into the future, I'm going by today's standards and the S23 Ultra cameras started out at A+
@@FredrickKonaduare you blind ! What sort of question is that, can’t you see those washed photos what they look like ? S24 photos are so washed and not clean at all , they look so cheap , if you post one of them on the social media people will think you are using xiaomi phone that came out 6 years ago
5:25 It looks like S24U completely missed the focus - you look quite soft, but when you look at the big banners behind you on the left("Seton Hall" and "BigEast"), they are vert sharp and clear, as is the crowd.
Not sure why, but I think I like the Pixel better in almost every single shot...
Not for long becuz the S24U will get a big camera update this week
The color processing is slightly better on the Pixel. And they both seem to go back and forth with over exposing. But the biggest thing to me is that the S24's portrait mode is SIGNIFICANTLY better. The cutout is much better and there's an actual rolloff of the background blur. For the cutout just look at how the space between his arm and torso is missed on the Pixel and how in general the background blur kinda looks like a bad cutout. The color and contrast stuff on the S24 can easily be fixed either as you're taking the shot or afterwards. Can't do anything about subpar portrait processing though. So I'd still go for the Galaxy. Also yeah the Galaxy will be getting software updates that hopefully resolve some of the contrast issues in auto mode.
@@wouter.d.h. Everyone is banking on the update ahaha, aint gonna change anything
@@wouter.d.h.Ahhhh no?? The pixel 8 pro still has an awesome camera.
@@ssaini5028 It will change a lot
Samsung makes photos look bright and fun. Pixel makes photos look dark and depressing. After having pixels for years. I am disappointed as a photographer with the Pixel. All photos of people and animals look dark and depressing. If you cover each photos and compare them the Samsung photos look like the subject is having more fun.
I am going back to Samsung!
Interesting how people just assumed the Pixel was better.
🤦
Cover them and compare- which one would you rather post of yourself on social media if you were the subject?
The Samsung is making your skin tone lighter than the camera you used for the video
Coming from moden iPhone I want my daily driver to be an android now.. Conflicted what one I should get??
Pixel looks superior to me in every picture.
PIXEL IS SO MUCH BETTER I AM DISAPPOINTED IN SAMSUNG THIS YEAR
This guy works for samsung he just undercuts all the pixel photos when generally pixel photos are wayyyy better
Making me feel better about not upgrading my S22 Ultra and trading in a Pixel 5 for a free Pixel 8pro. I love both Samsung and Googles U.I.s and features and can enjoy either at my desire. Truth be told, the only thing I feel is a game changing advantage by Sammy is the 10x telephoto. It would've been nice to see some zoom shots.
Google: Let's add True Tone to make people with darker skin look good in our photos.
The photos: Everyone looks like a zombie with liver damage.
To be fair, Pixel photos outside the shade or not indoors are looking good.
S24 looks hazy in way too many shots and often way too oversharpened.
PIxel also looks oversharpened way too often.
At this point: Just shoot RAW
@@DennisSchmitzbecause when your taking pictures of kids or animals you don't have 10 minutes to get the perfect shot. Point and click is what most people use and pixels point and click is horrible
Finally...I waited for this.
Me too
Been very interested in this comparison - I think the Pixel does a way better job
As the video titles, google wins
But from the comments, to much samsung fans here..they giving many forgiveness by bring another things
Just stick to the title about
Real Tone really is amazing!
I thought the pixel kicked its butt on each and every shot.
You're delulu gan boy
samsung camera is crap,just look at the colors.on every phone is similar but on this s24u crap they are always washout or off colors.just bad. at 4:33 on samsung guy have pink hoodie compared to red.i mean come on,you cant call that good camera.for that price range this crap cant even get colors right :D
Thank you so much !
I have a pixel 8 pro and the camera for just point and shoot is horrible! Selfie and regular....blurry shots, lot of noise, super slow at night shots.
The Pixel is awesome
Do video comparison
Pixel 8 pro is unbeatable in this department
I keep thinking you're the UrAverageConsumer guy
Would it be okay if i did a review labeled "white test" how is it okay to say "black test" i think thats called hypocritical
The Pixel still darkened your skin...
No God darken his skin the pixel just displays his natural skin tone. The Samsung lightens his skin tone which makes us darker skin people look washed out a lot of times
@ikegold122 Nope, his skin in being darkened, he even says it himself.
Bro am a fan of Samsung but I think you need googles to see well and say the fact that google pixel photo are much better on this video
Nice comparison
Pixel 👍
Pixel is the only king 👑
Pixel 8 is so much better…
Let’s get Wesley Snipes for the Black Test.
Can he blush?
Black test thats the full stop
Pixel all day, it's sad that for the past 5 years pixel has consistently been better in photo quality. I got rid of my note 23 ultra because my pixel 5 took better photos.
Google pixel 8 pro killed the Samsung Galaxy s24 ultra picture quality is far better than on the Samsung Galaxy s24 ultra picture quality kindly look at your jacket pixel 8 pro clean and real to real life let's go Google pixel 8 pro this year we are the new king whoo.... Google pixel 8 pro killed also the iphone 15 pro max hahaha 🤣😂
Pixels over sharping is crazy
Galaxy for the win for me. The pixel merged your face into the background in the last image. I preferred the Galaxy images
For some reason he seem to like the washed out look of the galaxy not just in this comparison but also in the iphone one too. I dont like when samsung brightens my skin up
Yeah, no giant leap for Samsung remains behind the Pixel in photography. Which is nothing to be ashamed of. I was expecting more, but that may come with updates. Though the caveat is that the S24U still has some ancient sensors, the 3X zoom and the ultra-wide are pre-dinosaurs in camera tech terms. The primary has yet to improve, and the 5X, like the iPhone's, is version one and is easily beaten by the Chinese 5X, which has been doing it for years.
I certainly would not buy the S24U for the cameras as of today; now, they do not even have the 10X, which makes it unique. They have above-average camera software (usually), which helps them compete against rivals with much better sensors.
Very expensive, and no reason to upgrade from S23U, which is the norm these days. All flagships are now closely matched, and only unique features differentiate them. The Ultra will have to rely on the S-pen for that, but with the Pixel deals, that, for me, remains the easy choice for value.
I don’t want that Samsung modem in the pixel, I’ve heard so many bad things about it and connectivity is number one for me because I use my phone to channel my home internet hotspot
So ya s24ultra wins in hardware hands down
I would’ve gone pixel if they had snapdragon and better hard drive speeds because I love pixel hardware
But ya can’t justify the hardware downgrade just for software
And the s24u beats the pixel in photography every time
I think if Google gives its image quality to other phones nobody will probably buy them
It's all subjective but the Pixel to me had a lot more wins in my eyes for your skin tone than the Galaxy to me. Samsung sometimes just seemed washed out sometimes
it is hard to believe these pictures are of S24 Ultra. I think you are not telling the truth.
After watching your pics comparison, it doesn't change my mind in a bit to buy the s24 ultra.
Why would it change your mind. You pay for whatever fits your needs. Ultimately it's your decision you have to pay for it ... #Pixelforthewin 🤓🤓
@@yaboipookiepookYa the pixel has shit modem and shit cpu, s24 all the way
@theNimboo Speak for yourself bubba ... no such problem on my end with Pixels in regards to modem or CPU's. They're regarded as the smartest smart phones for a reason and they fulfill my needs thoroughly.
Listen! This is a great video! But it's your opinion that matters! Watch different channels and you will see different results! Let's all spread love instead of negative judgement! Me personally, I would not choose a Pixel 8 Pro over an S24 Ultra! Not even if you gave me the Pixel 8 Pro for free! I love what Samsung is doing with their S24 Ultra!
Thank you. the Pixel really does a good job on real tone for people of color, but it still might not be for everyone
En otros canales también coincide el hecho que en mayoría de apartados lo hace mejor el pixel y se inclinan hacia el, no seas solo un Fanboy
@@BooredAtWork Had you tried it with other colours?
Thank God, I was going to give you mu phone for free. Now I get to keep it
What Samsung is doing is taking everything from the pixel. So you have to like the pixel lol
Samsung cameras are average at best. The cameras are not super good but not super bad either in the middle
Pixel pro , tooooppppp
Samsung rule
pixel is better
Bro galaxy didn’t stand a chance
Pixel is much better, all photos taken with galaxy are washed out
Wow the pixel is great the samsung looks washed out idk or over brightened
Don't worry Sammy fans, the King of stealing others technology ( Samsung ), has already implemented some of the things that make the Pixel Great. So Google was kind enough to work with Samsung and let them steal some of there AI tech......but Samsung sells Google that crappy Exynos processor they call Tensor. I have the Pixel, and while I love the AI, the camera and features that are extremely useful......man does this Samsung processor SUCK, also Google for 12 gigs of ram this device really does have poor ram management.
Pixel has better Photos. End of discussion.
yeah we know
I really, really don't like the oversharpening of the Pixel shots. It looks as if you took the "Clarity" slider in lightroom and swiped it all the way to the right.
Samsung S24 ultra is far better
nah but you wish it was
Loving the Pixel 8 Pro
Samsung fucked up this time lol
Its not a bad phone it just a very small jump from last years S23 Ultra
First ❤
Galaxy nails it. Had pixel and just over contrast everything and underexpose to make things look like real tone, but if you pay attention to the eyes, they are dark. When you take a photo of a person with blue eyes, they appear to be dark.
Team Samsung this time.
Camera comparison only of faces?????🫠🫠🫠🫠
pixel win
@7:36 thats a very veryyy bad portrait for a flagship
P8 pro🎉
This is so helpful. I'm deciding between s24 and Google pixel and the big thing for me is a black dark skinned person is the camera. So thanks so much for this. My current phone is an s9 so I'm way behind and excited to finally have a good cam.
which one you ended up with?
pixel is the king of photograph not even iphone can beat this device