If leadership of Taliban in Afghanistan hasn't been airdroped then why there's Sharia slavery instead of Adat and Pashtunwali? Why are there so many limitations? There are only 4 wifes per husband max and other limitations. Did you have such limitations before imposing Sharia "law" by US puppets there?
@@hanzalaomar9915 The parts saying there would be an intra-Afghan negotiated return to power in order to maintain a ceasefire. The Taliban went in, guns blazing
This is how buffoons think about freedom. Under the rules of law and majority of the people around the world knows that roaming naked is against the constitution. I believe your one the people who antagonize freedom and harass women at the same time.
@@ulrikjensen6841 Quran 9:115 And Allah would not let a people stray after He has guided them until He makes clear to them what they should avoid. Indeed, Allah is Knowing of all things.
@@tremannaik99 Quran 14:42 Do not think that Allah is unaware of what the wrongdoers do. He only delays them until a Day when their eyes will stare in horror
He is lying his age 30 years old lived all his life in Switzerland he has Swiss citizen passport he never fought 1 day in Afghanistan hes d.og of CIA UK US they sent him from Switzerland
@@andrewjonas6437 don’t believe him, this Taliban spokes Studied in New Zealand the international law, If NZ didn’t let him study he could go to Qatar where you would the offices and bases of Taliban in Qatar, they are trying to mordernize their government
The USSR backed government in Afghanistan lasted for 3 years after the Soviets left. The US backed government collapsed while the Americans were still pulling out.
Sie alle haben mit ihren high tech waffen trotzdem verloren. Und viel Zu teuer die ganzen Flüge, betankung, Bomben usw. Kein Land hat es jemals geschafft Afghanistan zu besiegen kein Land.
While DW is but centrist liberal bs, the Afghan (Afghani is a currency, or do you call British people Pounds and Japanese people Yens?) spokeperson is just a fundamentalist fascist, theocratic totalitarian or any number of other appropriate alliteration of the same sentiment, they are actively repressing free press, women, atheist, apostates, LGBT+, etc. the question, why should that behaviour be recognized as governance? a nation has a right to self determination, you decide when you are a nation, but a country is only created out of other countries recognition of a peer, which is why there are several countries which are not really countries and vice versa. They are both awful people but one holds beliefs more reprehensible than the other.
@@bkzegyptshin1 Silly people support Taliban 1. Banning boxing 2. Banning music 3. Banning drawings 4. Banning photography 5. Banning movies 6. Banning women high-heeled shoes that produce a sound 7. Banning women showing their hair 8. Banning women wearing perfume 9. Banning women going out 10. Banning women to breathe during stoning
@D nobody is doing anything for them. But all the Taliban demand is the right to self determination which is in their right and is something Us loves to say until it's not convenient for them
The Afghan people in general are very gentle, hospitable, kind and curious about the World. None of us in the West have known what it's like to live through full scale war since WW2 (and America wasn't touched at all) For a people who have known such hardship, and that's putting it lightly, they are extraordinarily sweet natured and patient.
@@Yueh-99 You really think that's what's happening? Have you not seen the news reports? Of parents crying because they have no choice? Very easy for you with your armchair politics. They have no money, no food, no welfare, no heating in sub zero temperatures. Just thank God you're not in that position.
"The leadership wasn't air dropped" he was targeting ashraf ghani when Americans dropped him near kabul and gave him message that you will be president of Afghanistan.
@@AhsanNadeem Silly people support Taliban 1. Banning boxing 2. Banning music 3. Banning drawings 4. Banning photography 5. Banning movies 6. Banning women high-heeled shoes that produce a sound 7. Banning women showing their hair 8. Banning women wearing perfume 9. Banning women going out 10. Banning women to breathe during stoning
Do you mean him literally kicking her with his feet, somewhere one her tummy or breasts? Yes, amazing respect. I bet these taliban tewwowists know nothing 'bout dat level of respect.
USSR lost because Yanks fully supported the Mujahids. Without American support, USSR will still be in Afghanistan. Likewise, Russia & China fully supported the Taliban. If not Afghanistan would be the 51st state of USA. The British fought 4 wars against Afghanistan & won 3. They lost the 1st Anglo-Afghan war where 4500 Scottish Highlanders surrendered all their firearms to the Afghans in return for safe passage out of Afghanistan. But the Afghans broke treaty & sent 20,000 troops to harry & shoot at the 4500 Scottish Highlanders. All 4500 Scotsmen died except 1, but not without dispatching 17000 Afghans to Jannah using just their bayonets. Imagine how slow the rate of Afghan fire must have been for the Scots to bayonet them between each round the Afghans fired & while the Afghans were pouring the next round & powder into their muskets for the next shot.
@@kamlahari5369 Okay yankees, China support them but who will spend 19 years in mountain starving, sleeping less and fighting much, handling all the weather conditions seeing their friends dying and not sure how long they will survive doing all this still they fought and won
They can verbally slap the west all they want, but that's not gonna convince the world to give them money. The Afghan people are starving because of one simple fact, Afghanistan never had an economy. Economic development was stifled by the Taliban. The entire country was staying afloat because of international(mainly American) aid. 80% of the Afghan government's budget was essentially donations from America.
USSR lost because Yanks fully supported the Mujahids. Without American support, USSR will still be in Afghanistan. Likewise, Russia & China fully supported the Taliban. If not Afghanistan would be the 51st state of USA. The British fought 4 wars against Afghanistan & won 3. They lost the 1st Anglo-Afghan war where 4500 Scottish Highlanders surrendered all their firearms to the Afghans in return for safe passage out of Afghanistan. But the Afghans broke treaty & sent 20,000 troops to harry & shoot at the 4500 Scottish Highlanders. All 4500 Scotsmen died except 1, but not without dispatching 17000 Afghans to Jannah using just their bayonets. Imagine how slow the rate of Afghan fire must have been for the Scots to bayonet them between each round the Afghans fired & while the Afghans were pouring the next round & powder into their muskets for the next shot.
Straightforward..no lies no buttering.. absolute truth n honest . Far better than so many currupt politicians who try to word games. This man can be trusted more than tge very US govt😂. Allahuakbar..great warriors of Islam. May Allah bless you and your family sir. Ameen❤️
World will have more peace when it is free from religion. It prevents progress and excuses people to commit acts of horror, all because their imaginary friend "Wills it."
@@spookyt8692 dear do u know what people with no religion has done to world,given enormous massacres n genocides. In whole world the true religion is Islam. When a man think that whatever he want he can do one is going him about his deeds. We know such people with severe results to mankind. Shekh usman ibn farooq explained it very well. If u prefer it good. ❤️
Legit. We may be the "developed" nations. But that doesnt mean we should do everything in our power to empower other nations, especially when we are still dealing with our own issues.
@@cherrycoyote55 as if u care about the rest of the world , when u just have interest in any country u show u help that country and u take times that from behind doors ..
Every nation cares what the international community thinks. If you don't want to murder your economy, you need to engage with the international trading and banking system, and to do that you need international recognition. Afghanistan's economic capacity has plummeted since having its foreign aid instantly severed (85% of the old government's source of revenue) and being stonewalled from international trading and banking, and it's not going to get any better until it has access to at least those last two things.
Spokesperson of government of afghanistan is absolutely intelligent, while the reporter tries to push on his agenda, he just trashes him down so calmly
@@61.pranamyajoshi23 half correct and half false. Fordt half is false because Afghan people aren't homeless they got a great Land to fight for. Last half is correct because the west are thieves they stool the Afghan people's money and refused to back it.
If leadership of Taliban in Afghanistan hasn't been airdroped then why there's Sharia slavery instead of Adat and Pashtunwali? Why are there so many limitations? There are only 4 wifes per husband max and other limitations. Did you have such limitations before imposing Sharia "law" by US puppets there?
All those problems mentioned by this presenter has been created by the Western Nations and by freezing Afghanistan's assets. Afghanistan was normal before the Taliban not because of the Afghan government but the world was having a connection with Afghanistan.
If leadership of Taliban in Afghanistan hasn't been airdroped then why there's Sharia slavery instead of Adat and Pashtunwali? Why are there so many limitations? There are only 4 wifes per husband max and other limitations. Did you have such limitations before imposing Sharia "law" by US puppets there?
Last statement is heart touching. New afgan government is providing safety to their citizens which is the biggest benefits. I am damn sure one day afganistan is one of the most capable country in every sector .
@@FrauElegante first learn atleast 500 to 800 years of Afghan history and cultural amnesia before you comment online because it doesn't cost you anything. And not just from the first TH-cam video or wiki page you see
The optimist, staid, stoic and never flustered, feels a sudden pang of everso the slightest of perhaps a tiny misgiving. You see dear reader that water… the “water” well that is in fact a cup of rodent bait containing potassium cyanide.
Let them live, I'm happy to see Afghan War is over. And now they are Independent Gov over their land. By the way, I'm a EX Military Male once deployed in Afghanistan.
An yet the taliban won't last due to lack of a unity, representation of minorities, and the fact it is central location between multiple powers. The real question is when and how the USA returns.
@@thewingedhussar4188 Mostly US won't, if Taliban and Chinese grow their relations like today. Afghanistan won't be a ground for US to Stand. It's all about China. Asia is a Chinese power zone. Even India isn't getting it's way to Indian Ocean because of China.
Im very glad to see how open minded you're. despite being a veteran deployed in enemy's land you still hope good for the people you fought against. I pray all Americans become like you. The world would become a great place.
For people yearning to return to the Stone, Iron, and Bronze ages--- in their attempt to impose tribal fairy tale beliefs exported out of the desert of Saudi Arabia --- yes.... perfect English!
The western reporters will never be able to make Taliban look bad as much as they try. Taliban are true to their people and country. They are intelligent honest they will lift their country to better faith in Allah (God) will help them. Truth stands out clear
"Does Afghanistan has free press" ?? Which country on planet Earth has free or unbiased press . It was more like a soft interrogation than an interview.
@@anotherguycalled6253 Taliban didn't provide peace at all. They blew up a mosque that was made for shias and shot everyone inside it while they were praying
@@RainierTy1 bruh other countries have cultures as well. They don't have to comply to or follow the western cultures. They have their own and they are allowed to follow them.
@@RainierTy1 the neo liberal cancer needs to be eradicated. It has bombed and killed more people than any so called extremist group and destroyed lives of many men in west also destroyed families. And without a nuclear family you are same like a dung beetle in this world. What lifestyle west has anyway? You think we dont know how miserable you people are? Dont even get me started.
@Chris Viking "To the wise its false" stop saying that just because you want to believe you're smart or whatever. Almost every single major scientist was religious if that's what you were trying to say and because your against islam I won't use the 80% of them that advanced science. "The one who studies science a little knows that there is no God, but when he understands it more and expands his knwoledges into it he realizes that there is a God and a creator behind all of it". -Albert einstein
@@Andrea.181 😂😂😂😂... Joke of the day. The world needs to stop interfere in Afghanistan. Afghans have never started a war, we are always been attacked and we have only defended ourselves, which is every human right to do, so stop your nonsense✌️
6:56 Smart answer. Tit for tat. Its like he's saying: "Your media holds values of insulting others in the name of freedom of speech, our media will uphold our society's values of maintaining their honour".
@@normalhuman6581 Are you a Sadhu or what? Free speech is a fallacy. There's loads of instances where it isn't allowed: defamation, lible, threats, obscenity etc etc.
@@hasansaleem9517 You are very right, there are limits to freedom of speech. Such limits do not extend to criticism of religion in general and Islam in particular. Islam is just a very bad idea as it can be seen by results achieved. I'm not trying to insult you: the world would be a much better place without religion.
@@FranFerioli A world without religion is impossible. Athiesm is in fact a religion per se as it entails the swapping of religious dogma for another (scienctific) dogma. Secular laws are enforced 'religiously'. Treason is punishable by death in the US, as is blasphemy in other parts of the world. The difference is each has blasphemed their own 'God'. As for Islam, it isn't and wasn't anything new, a mere continuation of Ibrahimic faith. It's the fastest growing religion in 'secular' West, and predicted to be the largest religion by 2070. Not a bad idea after all.
The Foreign ministry spokes person is intelligent, well mannered and provides great insight and facts in this interview. The interviewer is just pushing an agenda that we have seen from occupying forces for the past twenty years in Afghanistan.
The Taliban are not just a normal fundamentalist regime. They used literal terrorist attacks & killed thousands of their own people. That is not like the extremely unfortunate "collateral damage" that happens during all major wars. Intentionally murdering civilians to increase unrest is not tolerable. It’s monstrous. This isn’t like attacking a hostile force. It is cold blooded, well calculated mass murder to use, as the name clearly states, terror, in order to reach a desired outcome. It’s cowardly and, because it can not be described differently, evil. If they were fairly normal, somewhat idealistic freedom fighters like the Vietkong I wouldn’t be saying that. What’s the point? Journalists should always ask uncomfortable questions. And the Taliban in particular should have some very good answers. So where is the issue? He didn’t interrupt, he gave him time to answer, he obviously wasn’t going to have a friendly chat for a breakfast television program but while his tone was particular, that hardly qualifies as pushing an agenda. Leading the interview in a certain way is natural because let’s face it, this isn’t going to be about the next tax policy of a local party, its about the fate of 40 million people under an entirely new leadership. Asking about rumors is also a perfectly viable question because it gives the opportunity to defend one’s position or state differing opinions. Pushing an agenda would be to not have an interview at all.
I think you are mistaking ISIS for taliban, yes taliban use suicide bombers to attack the invading forces{which i think is wrong to do in islam} but I have never heard them using it the way you mentioned in your comment.
The journo asked how this will benefit Great Britain and the United States LOL Dude it’s not about you, it’s about people of Afghanistan and yes they have to be able to establish stable leadership and cooperate with other nations for economic growth, he just told you.
Dealing with the Taliban is a zero sum game. If the taliban can't offer anything, why shouls they be offered anything? Many people die of war and starvation in africa each day, because they have nothing to offer the rest of the world. Unfortunately you don't deal with the people, you deal with their leaders.
The first thing the Afghan people needs is durable peace and get rid of wars and corrupt leaders who were being imposed on them by foreign powers and this is what they achieved and this was the true definition of foreign occupation on Afghanistan sovereignty.Moreover It,s up to the Afghan people to run their country by any type of government by the Afghans and for the Afghans.Other countries should have no concern with this internal matters of Afghanistan.Imposing sanctions or applying any other tactics on them are unjustifiable brutal.
@@malikmumtazz6333 do you think the situation would have been different if the taliban didn't declare victory? It might have been in their own best interest not to, I would say.
If leadership of Taliban in Afghanistan hasn't been airdroped then why there's Sharia slavery instead of Adat and Pashtunwali? Why are there so many limitations? There are only 4 wifes per husband max and other limitations. Did you have such limitations before imposing Sharia "law" by US puppets there?
2:24 "How would Europe benefit from Afghanistan?" Literally cannot believe he asked that! Is that an actual question? Is this for real? You DON'T. You don't benefit. Thats how you benefit. Why would England or France expect to benefit from Afghanistan? Did they think they are still colonial masters thus can benefit? Who came up with that imperialist question? How does Afghanistan benefit from the UK? Only warcrimes? Same from the USA and Australia. When they were exposed they decided to forgive themselves.
@@jonatand2045 Humanitarian reasons? Europe doesn't do humanitarian. Europe only does trade and then labels it 'help'. Europe says here is some money but to get this there are these conditions that you need to do for us. That is called TRADE not help. Because help BY DEFINITION IS ALWAYS FREE OF ANY CONDITION! You have RARELY HELPED ANYONE. You only do trade.
Yeah, I can't believe its a question too. Like the person said, Afghan already checked the requirements. It might be still a highly unstable region now but it's time for the west to just let them be.
@@acecream8568 Whatever they do is up to them. The west needs to let go of its racist imperialist ways because more and more nations are getting sick of the west and thats NOT good for business. Look at France and how it is talked about in the African Union. Its is spat out everywhere and kicked out everwhere.
China has mining rights already. They had them under the NATO backed corrupt government. The question is who is going to invest hundreds of millions of dollars developing a mine when they can do it somewhere else.
@Monetized Monk why should he leave his native land?.. we asia are more civilized than you..you thief that it..every way you go that place soon will be full of hunger and misery..
America called Kim jong Un a terrorist, and then they negotiated, they called Iran terrorists then negotiated, they called taliban terrorists and then negotiated, which makes me think, if bin laden wouldn’t die they might have negotiated with him as well...
America does not have any laws which prohibits human rights . It's not the Americans who suffer from poverty , discrimination and basic human right violations.
Silly people support Taliban 1. Banning boxing 2. Banning music 3. Banning drawings 4. Banning photography 5. Banning movies 6. Banning women high-heeled shoes that produce a sound 7. Banning women showing their hair 8. Banning women wearing perfume 9. Banning women going out 10. Banning women to breathe during stoning
@@takiyaazrin7562 Silly people support western 1. Drugs are very healthy things 2. Murdering is allowed 3. Rape is allowed 4. Watching porn allowed 5. No god no religious things 6. You can rape 10 woman and none gona tell you something 7. Misbehaving with elders are allowed 8. You can party whole night and do **** with 10 woman are allowed Man i am confused, what this people want and what are they talking about. Islam is trying to save you, trying to cover woman from problems, trying make peace.
Sad to say but he is right, there is no difference between Afghanistan to many other countries that are part of the UN. On the other hand nobody have to give them any aid.
@harry brown If only I can familiarize myself with all of the war crimes committed by the US military against the Afghan people. Forced disappearances, arbitrary detentions , torture, and intentional targeting of civilians via air strike would be a start I guess. Oh and also the uranium mines that were being exploited by the US. And I wouldn’t use the word “aid”. I prefer to call it , “reparations” from the arsenal of democracy and freedom.
The West has a saviour complex. Leave Asia, Africa and Latin America alone. Leave us alone. We don't want your system of government. But of course, your western cognitive dissonance will not allow you to see things from my point of view. We don't need western governments to dictate the way that we rule our countries. The white saviour complex is strong in Europeans and Americans. To anyone who supports the western point of view, don't you find it atleast a little strange that as soon as America lost control of Afghanistan, everyone had something to say about how to run the country and Americans seem "concerned" all of a sudden??
Silly people support Taliban 1. Banning boxing 2. Banning music 3. Banning drawings 4. Banning photography 5. Banning movies 6. Banning women high-heeled shoes that produce a sound 7. Banning women showing their hair 8. Banning women wearing perfume 9. Banning women going out 10. Banning women to breathe during stoning
@@barca8341 those things quite unprohibited in Islam, but then again, those things barely exist during Prophet Muhammad's life, so there's no specific rule that tell us that music,drawing,photography,movies etc. are absolutely unprohibited. It's only hinted but not specific
so eloquent and patient ... the interviewers have a nasty habit of asking a question and then interrupting the answer ... nasty annoying interviewers need to learn viewers want to hear the person being interviewed not the blabbing rhetoric spewing media muppets
He might be corrupt media shill, but the Afghanistan people are suffering and still don't have proper working of the government, and people are paid with rice and not money.
He answers questions without thinking so perfectly only true People can answer like him He has abilities like No one Else in the Western journalism He shut the Mouth of the Interviewer so perfectly Even He asked so bad questions that Prooves me really who were wrong for real the Last Decades I Hope the Afghanistan people live for ever in Peace ☝🏽
@@jonatand2045 the only reason of this consequnse is west sanction. after their devastating lost on the ground they still try to win over geopoltically.
I think the Germans are salty because they decided to lay down and surrender to the Americans allowing them to occupy and build bases all over Germany while the poor illiterate Afghans they make fun off fought them for 20 years
@@bashsibda6289 in islam oppression is worse than slaughter the USA wanted to change the religion and genetic makeup of Afghanistan by introducing foreign imposed feminism and liberalism.Allah knows best
@@clovenshield3067 Shariah law is not based on Human Rights. Shariah condones and requires the violation of Human Rights. Any country that does not adhere to Human Rights is going to have a problem if it wants to integrate with the rest of the world in the 21st century.
Their country their law. First protect you own countries from such law and practice, no need to worry about others. Afghanistan ppls can take care their own
@@MaTara01 BMA O Tara you cook a lot of stuff in your head and burns a lot of thing.... But for sure "The God" who has created day and night as one of his signs is "Most Merciful".... Known by the name Allah who never Sleeps!!?
@@anonymouschickpea4271 His intelligence is irrelevant, it's precisely his nonchalant demeanor and the likelihood that he is educated and professional is what makes all of this more ominous. You may have a good conversation with him, but the ideology behind him and what he stands for is completely deranged and primitive. The obvious nutcase that yells obscenities and is obviously a menace - is one you can point out and expect such behavior from..but the fact that the Taliban has official spokesmen who seem docile is why we have to watch out for a wolf in sheep's clothing.
@@PrinceIndra9000ngz Fooled how? Of course their spokesperson will be an eloquent person that can speak languages well, that's what a spokesperson is supposed to do. Does the US use hillbillies who speak English by a way no one but them can understand as spokespersons? No.
Masha allah accept afgahan people sariyat law.. Taliban proud our umma life Proud islam good life . good quran sariyt law... Thanks to allah.. Allahu akber...
Actually, he sounds very much as someone who lived in the US. His sound and fluency are equivalent to using American English daily from the age of early 20s to today, imho.
20 years they tryed to create a secular Afghanistan !!!! Secular State is Part of Western Civilisation , because they lost the deep believe in the Gospel.......
@@tacocruiser4238 Both are insane, uneducated and ideological fascists. But at least you could threaten Trump much easier than those dogmatic Kamikaze.
@@MetallicReg Nothing you said makes any sense. Just vague platitudes. You probably don't even know what a "fascist" is. Neither Trump nor the Taliban are fascists.
If leadership of Taliban in Afghanistan hasn't been airdroped then why there's Sharia slavery instead of Adat and Pashtunwali? Why are there so many limitations? There are only 4 wifes per husband max and other limitations. Did you have such limitations before imposing Sharia "law" by US puppets there?
It is either these guys or the previous corrupted officials. West was in love with the corrupted officials and funded them till they left Afghanistan before them . I wonder why!
@@hc3657 Not true. America supported Afghanistan for 20 years and was tired of the forever wars. America also thought that the people of Afghanistan would fight to keep the gains made, especially by women in the country. During America's time in Afghanistan, women were journalists, politicians, doctors, judges, and more. The men of Afghanistan had the same gains and more. The government was not perfect but No government is perfect. Also, no one thought Afghanistan, with so much to lose including free elections, wouldn't fight to keep their democracy. If Joe Biden didn't care about Afghanistan people, he wouldn't have airlifted over 100 thousand to safety. He also wouldn't have allowed almost one billion dollars worth of humanitarian aid to be given to the country after leaving if he and America didn't care for the Afghanistan people. But America can't fight the battle of another country forever. While the USA was in Afghanistan, the Taliban were blocked. Sooner or later, if the Afghanistan people want freedom, they need to stand up to the Taliban for themselves. The Taliban are only a group of maybe 100 thousand. The people of Afghanistan are 40 million. What they accept for a government is really their choice.
@@onepeace1274 Seriously, you can't buy/bribe people to accept what's wrong. US tried for 20 years with their bs and Britain tried 4 times (invaded Afghanistan 4 times). Clearly Truth stands out Clear from the error. You may be militarily powerful but you were up against an ideology far superior than whatever you had to offer. 1. Men and women are NOT same and therefore invalidates your "same rights" arguments. 2. Usury is slavery/exploitation 3. Democracy is populism (which is unjust). The concept of the ignorant masses electing a ruler is nothing short of stupidity. Democracy in a weaker nation turns it into a colony. I can go on and on
@@onepeace1274 The US didn't care about Afghan people otherwise they wouldn't have supported Ghani, Karzai and their corrupt bloodsucking buddies feasting on afghan blood for decades! The Americans knew this, they could've done something about it, but they didn't, because they only cared about themselves. Also about airlifting thousands...that's just a brain drain for Afghanistan. Taking the cream of the crop, the skilled workers of Afghanistan and moving them to the US...that's just a steal
@@User-xw5mk The USA airlifted the citizens of Afghanistan not for a brain drain, but because they are terrified of the Taliban, and for proper reasons. They personally witnessed the cruelty, the beheadings, the suicide bombings and the inhumanity of the Taliban first hand. The whole world saw the Afghanistan men trying to hold on to planes to get away from the Taliban and the lines of people headed for the borders. We also saw the videos of the Taliban killing 23 former military after they surrendered with hands up. And the reports of other revenge killings. The throng of people at the airport desperately trying to to get out of the country and those still trying to get out of the country tells another story. Wish you would tell the truth. And the former government had its flaws as all governments do, but at least the people had free elections and everyone, including women had equal rights to education and jobs and even the government. The Taliban won't even allow free elections. They select only their Taliban for the highest positions in the government when there are many different ethnic groups who should have equal representation. At least when America was there, the Afghanistan people had a chance to elect the people of their choosing. Under Taliban rule, that is no longer an option for them, which is another reason many have left and are leaving freely. Again, please at least tell the truth. But it is okay if you don't tell the truth because we get the truth from all of the Afghanistan people who have left. No need for your testimony.
Is the moral code we use in the west. DW is a western media channel. And yes, I'm biased but I do belive western morality is the superior morality in today's world.
@@SC-zq6cu yeah and made by Chinese workers and developed mostly by immigrants in their countries or soviets. when your country is subjugated for centuries by western rule and your resources are drained by the colonizers, you don't quite achieve the same amount of wealth as them.
@@jassingh8232 Okay then stop using stuff that colonisers came up with. If its so easy to criticise western moral codes then it should be equally easy to abandon western inventions as well. Just because they are made by chinese workers or developed by immigrants does not change their sources. For the record western moral codes are not entirely made in west either, they are a result of thousands of years of development in a lot of other places as well, primarily the middle east. So if it is okay to ditch them just because the west advocates for them then it should be equally easy to ditch tech that the west advocates, does not matter if those were made by the chinese workers. Otherwise its just opportunistic behaviour and this kind of moral grandstanding has no place in it.
I’m praising one guy who happens to be a rep. of the taliban government because he sounds like he is American trained. Is that a bad thing.. no, why cause this is the first time in 40+ years they actually get to try to be a country.
The hubris of this reporter is offensive, almost unbearable. The reporter should ask why Afghanistan is in a humanitarian crises, and what the world can do to help.
Taiwans constitution does not recognize Taiwan itself as the defined borders of their state. It still claims mainland China which by those criteria, Taiwan isn’t a nation. However I do believe Taiwan should be independent and separate from China
@@smoochie3331 The vast majority of people and land the PRC claims is governed by them so obviously they’re the legitimate state over Taiwan. Taiwan or “Republic of China” it still officially refers to itself claims exactly the same population and territory as the PRC. How is Taiwan fit for the criteria mentioned above if they won’t release claims on those? If I were them I would amend the ROC constitution to recognize only Taiwan as their nation but they won’t even do that because of political infighting due to Taiwanese officials who are against Taiwanese independence so they can continue claiming the entire mainland of China.
Basic needs and services can’t be meet and you think holding a nation wide elections is paramount. Even if they did hold an election they new government will be faced will filler busters and roadblocks. Every country that came out of a war had an interim government until things quelled down and then they held elections. Why is the Taliban any different?
The only place US wins in a war is in their Hollywood movies 🤣🤣🤣.
*Oh my god, what have you said😀*
Lmao this is a great sentence
What a lovely line 😜😆
In its history, the US has lost all of two wars. Try again
😂😂😂😅😁😁😁
"This Taliban government wasn't air dropped" .... that explains everything.
If leadership of Taliban in Afghanistan hasn't been airdroped then why there's Sharia slavery instead of Adat and Pashtunwali? Why are there so many limitations? There are only 4 wifes per husband max and other limitations. Did you have such limitations before imposing Sharia "law" by US puppets there?
No it crawled from under a Rock!
And the Americans certainly did a marvellous job. 😀
@@johnwhitehurst474 cope harder johnny
@@TheTenthJinchuuriki Good one 😂
If he's saying Yes it's actually a yes, and No when he says a no. That's that. These men don't lie.
They lied about the Doha agreement...
@@somatotrophin1535 what?
@@hanzalaomar9915 The Taliban broke the Doha agreement
@@somatotrophin1535 which part of the doha agreement?
@@hanzalaomar9915 The parts saying there would be an intra-Afghan negotiated return to power in order to maintain a ceasefire. The Taliban went in, guns blazing
Hate or love them they fought for what they believe in and won.
Allah hu Akbar.
May Allah forbid these monsters from entering Jannah
@@samuraijack1920 lol ur brainwashed.
Didn't they simply took over because the national army ran away from their post? And the appointed president fled?
@@osman7240 you r delusional
"the leadership was not air dropped"
I love that potshot lol
Yes, they came by plane from Qatar. Huge difference.
@@zadarthule they were locals, born & bred
Afghanistan need a saviour, usa is not obviously one of them
@@imperatoraurelian3410 they dont need savior
They just need their money back and economic sanctions gone
@@imperatoraurelian3410 they are still not nearly as bad as North Korea, it’s just more dangerous because there isn’t a central power.
Afghani "we don't have food to eat"
Journalist "but can women roam around naked like they can in the west?"...
And people still don’t seem to see the problem 🤦🏾♂️
Exactly
This is how buffoons think about freedom. Under the rules of law and majority of the people around the world knows that roaming naked is against the constitution. I believe your one the people who antagonize freedom and harass women at the same time.
I swear!!!
When did you hear that in this interview?
A very eloquent man speaking more sense in one interview than every American President over the last 20 years.
Lol, if you call that eloquent, your a lost soul/person. Lol
@@eddav8089 you're brainwashed
Yeah because if he didn’t the taliban would make sure he and his family would never talk again.
Lies again? I'm Batman
I see both trump and biden as fool's .
"Kindness is a mark of faith, and whoever has not kindness has not faith."
-Prophet Muhammad (a.s)
Taliban has NO faith, then.
@@ulrikjensen6841 Quran 9:115
And Allah would not let a people stray after He has guided them until He makes clear to them what they should avoid. Indeed, Allah is Knowing of all things.
S.A.W*
sure...exactly the same approach that Taliban have adopted toward their people .
@@tremannaik99 Quran 14:42
Do not think that Allah is unaware of what the wrongdoers do. He only delays them until a Day when their eyes will stare in horror
He's correct the government has to provide for their citizens not the international community
He is lying his age 30 years old lived all his life in Switzerland he has Swiss citizen passport he never fought 1 day in Afghanistan hes d.og of CIA UK US they sent him from Switzerland
@@saulamin5463 where's your proof for your claims ??
source : trust me bro? lmao
@@saulamin5463 you are a liar.
@@saulamin5463 he studied in New Zealand and ran through all the International laws to establish their own Government,
@@andrewjonas6437 don’t believe him, this Taliban spokes Studied in New Zealand the international law, If NZ didn’t let him study he could go to Qatar where you would the offices and bases of Taliban in Qatar, they are trying to mordernize their government
Finally the Russians could laugh back at US 🇺🇸 for facing a terrible defeat in Afghanistan
Didnt the russians lose too?
@@troy4298 not nearly as bad the americans they got routed
@@masterdreadeye1865 yeah but they still lost, doesnt really change my point
I'm pretty sure if we declared open war the taliban literally have no defense against anything airborne beyond maybe some radar jammers
@@JohnDoe-ligma 😂😂😂 damn what they were doing for 20 yrs ??? US has killed more civilians than Taliban ever did since thier origin
The USSR backed government in Afghanistan lasted for 3 years after the Soviets left. The US backed government collapsed while the Americans were still pulling out.
Right ✅
Because government of Afghanistan was controlled by Warlords of North allie they're so cowerd and corrupt they fleed before USA left
Sie alle haben mit ihren high tech waffen trotzdem verloren. Und viel Zu teuer die ganzen Flüge, betankung, Bomben usw.
Kein Land hat es jemals geschafft Afghanistan zu besiegen kein Land.
@@RavenLee18 :Wrong, Mongolian army conquered and had completely controlled ruled Afghanistan.
*Well, the NATO/ USA bolted out in the dead of the night!* Do I have to remind you of this?
DW got a slap on the face from this Afghani gentleman
While DW is but centrist liberal bs, the Afghan (Afghani is a currency, or do you call British people Pounds and Japanese people Yens?) spokeperson is just a fundamentalist fascist, theocratic totalitarian or any number of other appropriate alliteration of the same sentiment, they are actively repressing free press, women, atheist, apostates, LGBT+, etc. the question, why should that behaviour be recognized as governance? a nation has a right to self determination, you decide when you are a nation, but a country is only created out of other countries recognition of a peer, which is why there are several countries which are not really countries and vice versa. They are both awful people but one holds beliefs more reprehensible than the other.
Gentleman?!?!?! Please raise your standards. He is absolutely not a gentleman.
@@Andrea.181 What makes him not a gentleman?
@@Andrea.181 he control his anger, he know the interview questions is making a fool out of him, to me that is gentleman
@@laurasarkaar1365 a man raising a hand on a woman or supporting a man doing such thinks isn’t and will never be a gentleman. Simple.
I must say that the Afghan spokesperson speaks really well.
Especially without gametes and fallopian tubes! They're definitely alaqah now
Taliban spokesman *
its as if they where trained as a spokesperson or smth...
CIA trained
@@bkzegyptshin1 Silly people support Taliban
1. Banning boxing
2. Banning music
3. Banning drawings
4. Banning photography
5. Banning movies
6. Banning women high-heeled shoes that produce a sound
7. Banning women showing their hair
8. Banning women wearing perfume
9. Banning women going out
10. Banning women to breathe during stoning
i like how the first question was how will it benefit the UK, Germany or the US, as if the world was here to please them.
@D nobody is doing anything for them. But all the Taliban demand is the right to self determination which is in their right and is something Us loves to say until it's not convenient for them
could have used the word "colonizers"
@@kashifkhan-yr8wi not really since Afghanistan has never been colonized
@@ItJuM856 but uk is biggest colonizer in the history
@@ItJuM856 But doesn't that work both ways? Why should any country be obligated to work with them and on what terms?
The Afghan people in general are very gentle, hospitable, kind and curious about the World. None of us in the West have known what it's like to live through full scale war since WW2 (and America wasn't touched at all) For a people who have known such hardship, and that's putting it lightly, they are extraordinarily sweet natured and patient.
Until they don't decide to get RPG.
Or when they sell their daughters for profit and keep their sons to perpetuate male centered culture….. yeah very sweet natured and patient
@@Yueh-99 You really think that's what's happening? Have you not seen the news reports? Of parents crying because they have no choice? Very easy for you with your armchair politics. They have no money, no food, no welfare, no heating in sub zero temperatures. Just thank God you're not in that position.
I wish you could understand the reason too...
@Beth Sullivan you're correct 💯
"The leadership wasn't air dropped" he was targeting ashraf ghani when Americans dropped him near kabul and gave him message that you will be president of Afghanistan.
Give me the date when Ashraf Ghani was dropped into Afghanistan? Taliban will definitely turn against Your country Pakistan… for sure.
@@samsami2145 if you are from Afghanistan you would have already known that if you are Indian I can't help you 🤏🧠
@@AhsanNadeem
I am from Afghanistan, and have the same question.
@@AhsanNadeem Silly people support Taliban
1. Banning boxing
2. Banning music
3. Banning drawings
4. Banning photography
5. Banning movies
6. Banning women high-heeled shoes that produce a sound
7. Banning women showing their hair
8. Banning women wearing perfume
9. Banning women going out
10. Banning women to breathe during stoning
@@takiyaazrin7562 lol copy paste stay mad
The value of respect shown by french police to women protesting in Yellow West protest were amazing .
Don't you agree 🤣🤣🤣
That is something most people don't see.
Do you mean him literally kicking her with his feet, somewhere one her tummy or breasts? Yes, amazing respect. I bet these taliban tewwowists know nothing 'bout dat level of respect.
Hahah exactly
Give me detail I want too see
Afghani was straight to the point.
DW: no more questions, thank you sir!
USSR lost because Yanks fully supported the Mujahids. Without American support, USSR will still be in Afghanistan. Likewise, Russia & China fully supported the Taliban. If not Afghanistan would be the 51st state of USA. The British fought 4 wars against Afghanistan & won 3. They lost the 1st Anglo-Afghan war where 4500 Scottish Highlanders surrendered all their firearms to the Afghans in return for safe passage out of Afghanistan. But the Afghans broke treaty & sent 20,000 troops to harry & shoot at the 4500 Scottish Highlanders. All 4500 Scotsmen died except 1, but not without dispatching 17000 Afghans to Jannah using just their bayonets. Imagine how slow the rate of Afghan fire must have been for the Scots to bayonet them between each round the Afghans fired & while the Afghans were pouring the next round & powder into their muskets for the next shot.
@@kamlahari5369 it was Pakistan who helped USA in breaking down of USSR... otherwise USSR would be a super power in the world now...
@@kamlahari5369 can you cite sources for the China and Russian help for Afghanistan?
@@kamlahari5369 Okay yankees, China support them but who will spend 19 years in mountain starving, sleeping less and fighting much, handling all the weather conditions seeing their friends dying and not sure how long they will survive doing all this still they fought and won
Afghan* not Afghani
The end line sentence was slap to the face of international human rights activists like america , Uk France etc.
exactly
@Simple Life , your spelling is like that of a beggar 😂, mr. bhakt
Lmaoo ik you didn’t say france…..
They can starve for all I care
They can verbally slap the west all they want, but that's not gonna convince the world to give them money.
The Afghan people are starving because of one simple fact, Afghanistan never had an economy. Economic development was stifled by the Taliban. The entire country was staying afloat because of international(mainly American) aid. 80% of the Afghan government's budget was essentially donations from America.
I am from pakistan but I tell you even in pakistan the media spokesman of govt. can not express themselves like this gentleman did, ma sha Allaah.
USSR lost because Yanks fully supported the Mujahids. Without American support, USSR will still be in Afghanistan. Likewise, Russia & China fully supported the Taliban. If not Afghanistan would be the 51st state of USA. The British fought 4 wars against Afghanistan & won 3. They lost the 1st Anglo-Afghan war where 4500 Scottish Highlanders surrendered all their firearms to the Afghans in return for safe passage out of Afghanistan. But the Afghans broke treaty & sent 20,000 troops to harry & shoot at the 4500 Scottish Highlanders. All 4500 Scotsmen died except 1, but not without dispatching 17000 Afghans to Jannah using just their bayonets. Imagine how slow the rate of Afghan fire must have been for the Scots to bayonet them between each round the Afghans fired & while the Afghans were pouring the next round & powder into their muskets for the next shot.
@@kamlahari5369 “all 4500 scotemen died except 1” if i by myself was killing 4499 i would not have left that 1 too.
true!
Isn't Pakistan the US's puppet?
@@kamlahari5369 and in 20 years west left. Afghanistan is that pin where the giant balloon falls and exploded LOL
What a pagan interviewer. What a marvellous spokesman❤
What's 'pagan' doing here
Brilliant he is , love the way he counters his questions
Lol, he's a talib
@@midorimashintaro2092 lol thanks for stating the obvious.
@@kalims2775 lol he's a talib
@@midorimashintaro2092😱Really?! Stop crying, kid.
@@kalims2775 make me😂
God bless this gentleman and all the people of Afghanistan
do you consider yourself evil?
Great respect for him, the way he responded the questions are amazing and genuine 👍👍
Straightforward..no lies no buttering.. absolute truth n honest . Far better than so many currupt politicians who try to word games.
This man can be trusted more than tge very US govt😂.
Allahuakbar..great warriors of Islam.
May Allah bless you and your family sir.
Ameen❤️
ameen brother. the day we are free from america, brits, and Israel is the day the world can have peace
@@noobie1437 ❤️
Mohammed Amir they are coming for you be ready
World will have more peace when it is free from religion. It prevents progress and excuses people to commit acts of horror, all because their imaginary friend "Wills it."
@@spookyt8692 dear do u know what people with no religion has done to world,given enormous massacres n genocides. In whole world the true religion is Islam.
When a man think that whatever he want he can do one is going him about his deeds. We know such people with severe results to mankind. Shekh usman ibn farooq explained it very well. If u prefer it good. ❤️
Who cares what the international community thinks. The international community has its own problems it needs to deal with.
Legit. We may be the "developed" nations. But that doesnt mean we should do everything in our power to empower other nations, especially when we are still dealing with our own issues.
@@cherrycoyote55 as if u care about the rest of the world , when u just have interest in any country u show u help that country and u take times that from behind doors ..
@@cherrycoyote55 empower nations?
Who cares ? When you want to ask ask thinks to the west, you care whoat other thinks.
Every nation cares what the international community thinks. If you don't want to murder your economy, you need to engage with the international trading and banking system, and to do that you need international recognition. Afghanistan's economic capacity has plummeted since having its foreign aid instantly severed (85% of the old government's source of revenue) and being stonewalled from international trading and banking, and it's not going to get any better until it has access to at least those last two things.
Well spoken young man Man’sha’allah
proud to be a taliban u dog?
@SassySam 🤣🤣🤣
that doesn't work this time
100% The only place US wins in a war is in their Hollywood movies 🤣🤣🤣.
I think Afghanistan is a more safer place to visit then it was during the past 2 decades of war.
They need to be tax heaven like Switzerland as they can defend quite well ,just economise that .
Im not sure that comparison makes me want to visit.
@@CHMichael I saw a video of some locals saying it’s very safe travelling through most of the country since the Taliban controls almost all of it now.
@@CHMichael They dont want white Americans to be there anyway.
It’s not
Always the same
Question about “women”, meanwhile invading, stealing, exploiting and sanctioning Afghani’s.
Women are Afghanis as well
Spokesperson of government of afghanistan is absolutely intelligent, while the reporter tries to push on his agenda, he just trashes him down so calmly
what.
You defending this terrorist liar?
Love the Taliban. May Allah help you. Ameen
Yes, because their illustrious history of terrorism goes away.
Then move to Afghanistan not some western country
move there
@@checkcommentsfirst3335 islam will come to u
This is what you say that when you just speak the truth
Why would a homeless man worry about Theives?
@@61.pranamyajoshi23 Because eventually you'll need to sleep.
@@61.pranamyajoshi23 half correct and half false. Fordt half is false because Afghan people aren't homeless they got a great Land to fight for. Last half is correct because the west are thieves they stool the Afghan people's money and refused to back it.
If leadership of Taliban in Afghanistan hasn't been airdroped then why there's Sharia slavery instead of Adat and Pashtunwali? Why are there so many limitations? There are only 4 wifes per husband max and other limitations. Did you have such limitations before imposing Sharia "law" by US puppets there?
All those problems mentioned by this presenter has been created by the Western Nations and by freezing Afghanistan's assets. Afghanistan was normal before the Taliban not because of the Afghan government but the world was having a connection with Afghanistan.
If leadership of Taliban in Afghanistan hasn't been airdroped then why there's Sharia slavery instead of Adat and Pashtunwali? Why are there so many limitations? There are only 4 wifes per husband max and other limitations. Did you have such limitations before imposing Sharia "law" by US puppets there?
Normal before Taliban. So you liked dancing boys! didn't You? you degenerate One?
Last statement is heart touching. New afgan government is providing safety to their citizens which is the biggest benefits. I am damn sure one day afganistan is one of the most capable country in every sector .
INSHALLAH and ameen
Optimisim is good for sleep
@@Zaitgeist i don't find a word to describe you. But sure i am not looking for a good word.
@@FrauElegante first learn atleast 500 to 800 years of Afghan history and cultural amnesia before you comment online because it doesn't cost you anything. And not just from the first TH-cam video or wiki page you see
He speaks better than any of the US Presidents or UK Prime Ministers put together.
Comment section is a salt mine 😂😂 love it.
Allahu Akbar 💪🏼
While the optimist and the pessimism argue over the glass of water the opportunist sneaks in and drinks it!
delicious!
Who is the opportunist in this analogy?
Probably China
@@drmodestoesq Turkey
The optimist, staid, stoic and never flustered, feels a sudden pang of everso the slightest of perhaps a tiny misgiving. You see dear reader that water… the “water” well that is in fact a cup of rodent bait containing potassium cyanide.
Let them live, I'm happy to see Afghan War is over. And now they are Independent Gov over their land. By the way, I'm a EX Military Male once deployed in Afghanistan.
@oana gabriela Yeh, I was very against my deployment. That's why, I was only deployed once back in 2018 😁
An yet the taliban won't last due to lack of a unity, representation of minorities, and the fact it is central location between multiple powers.
The real question is when and how the USA returns.
@@thewingedhussar4188 Mostly US won't, if Taliban and Chinese grow their relations like today. Afghanistan won't be a ground for US to Stand.
It's all about China. Asia is a Chinese power zone. Even India isn't getting it's way to Indian Ocean because of China.
@@user.94827 yep, wumao confirmed
Im very glad to see how open minded you're. despite being a veteran deployed in enemy's land you still hope good for the people you fought against. I pray all Americans become like you. The world would become a great place.
I just love this guy....he is so confident and knows how to respond to baseless questions 😌
Perfect English, sharp vocabulary
For people yearning to return to the Stone, Iron, and Bronze ages--- in their attempt to impose tribal fairy tale beliefs exported out of the desert of Saudi Arabia --- yes.... perfect English!
Apart from the narrow mind everything is sharp sure.
@M Saad agreed.
Not necessarily. If one can understand, that's enough.
They have denied themselves the glory of being born as human beings.
@@kiabtoomlauj6249 you are super ignorant 😂
The spokesman speaks really well
The western reporters will never be able to make Taliban look bad as much as they try. Taliban are true to their people and country. They are intelligent honest they will lift their country to better faith in Allah (God) will help them. Truth stands out clear
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
"Does Afghanistan has free press" ?? Which country on planet Earth has free or unbiased press . It was more like a soft interrogation than an interview.
💯% agreed
Rights are not given by the government. The government’s role is is to recognize and protect them.
Depends on the government.
No Its up to the government to protect rights, which Is what the Taliban has done. Provided peace.
@@anotherguycalled6253
Taliban didn't provide peace at all. They blew up a mosque that was made for shias and shot everyone inside it while they were praying
apparently, rights and morality are decided by a single US judge
@@MohdHilal judges and eternal affairs uphold the law. It's nice to find a good lawyer though if in the US.
The journalist asking some very good questions
But couldn’t help but notice just how condescending and conceited he was in his approach.
He was positively gloating! This is probably the only time in his life he got to feel superior about anything.
I mean, he is talking to the friendly face of an religious extremist government that hates the west and it’s way of life 🤷🏽♂️
@@RainierTy1 So everyone has to follow western lifestyle and until then they can't be termed as civilized?😆😆 It is pure racism.
@@RainierTy1 bruh other countries have cultures as well. They don't have to comply to or follow the western cultures. They have their own and they are allowed to follow them.
@@RainierTy1 the neo liberal cancer needs to be eradicated. It has bombed and killed more people than any so called extremist group and destroyed lives of many men in west also destroyed families.
And without a nuclear family you are same like a dung beetle in this world.
What lifestyle west has anyway? You think we dont know how miserable you people are? Dont even get me started.
He spoke calmly and firmly. Excellent English. Kudos!
To bad he has yet to learn or even understand Islam or modern governing.
@@thewingedhussar4188 i'm pretty sure he understands islam very well
@Chris Viking "To the wise its false" stop saying that just because you want to believe you're smart or whatever. Almost every single major scientist was religious if that's what you were trying to say and because your against islam I won't use the 80% of them that advanced science.
"The one who studies science a little knows that there is no God, but when he understands it more and expands his knwoledges into it he realizes that there is a God and a creator behind all of it".
-Albert einstein
It's unnerving to be honest.
@@thewingedhussar4188 there no liberal party in islam jog on
We Afghans support the new government and we are proud of our Spokeman. Well answered to every questions. Well done 👏👏🇦🇫Zindabad
Yes that's why so many people were jumping on that plane
Good for you. Now leave the world alone.
@@Andrea.181 😂😂😂😂... Joke of the day. The world needs to stop interfere in Afghanistan. Afghans have never started a war, we are always been attacked and we have only defended ourselves, which is every human right to do, so stop your nonsense✌️
@@Andrea.181 please leave afghans alone !
@@Teslakeytotheuniverse369. absolutely😂😂
6:56 Smart answer. Tit for tat. Its like he's saying: "Your media holds values of insulting others in the name of freedom of speech, our media will uphold our society's values of maintaining their honour".
Free speech is good actually
Go live in caves
@@normalhuman6581 Are you a Sadhu or what? Free speech is a fallacy. There's loads of instances where it isn't allowed: defamation, lible, threats, obscenity etc etc.
@@hasansaleem9517 You are very right, there are limits to freedom of speech. Such limits do not extend to criticism of religion in general and Islam in particular. Islam is just a very bad idea as it can be seen by results achieved. I'm not trying to insult you: the world would be a much better place without religion.
@@hasansaleem9517
True... Blasphemy is not one such case
Mocking religion is good
Taliban are terrorist
@@FranFerioli A world without religion is impossible. Athiesm is in fact a religion per se as it entails the swapping of religious dogma for another (scienctific) dogma. Secular laws are enforced 'religiously'. Treason is punishable by death in the US, as is blasphemy in other parts of the world. The difference is each has blasphemed their own 'God'. As for Islam, it isn't and wasn't anything new, a mere continuation of Ibrahimic faith. It's the fastest growing religion in 'secular' West, and predicted to be the largest religion by 2070. Not a bad idea after all.
The Foreign ministry spokes person is intelligent, well mannered and provides great insight and facts in this interview. The interviewer is just pushing an agenda that we have seen from occupying forces for the past twenty years in Afghanistan.
The Taliban are not just a normal fundamentalist regime. They used literal terrorist attacks & killed thousands of their own people.
That is not like the extremely unfortunate "collateral damage" that happens during all major wars.
Intentionally murdering civilians to increase unrest is not tolerable. It’s monstrous.
This isn’t like attacking a hostile force. It is cold blooded, well calculated mass murder to use, as the name clearly states, terror, in order to reach a desired outcome.
It’s cowardly and, because it can not be described differently, evil.
If they were fairly normal, somewhat idealistic freedom fighters like the Vietkong I wouldn’t be saying that.
What’s the point?
Journalists should always ask uncomfortable questions.
And the Taliban in particular should have some very good answers.
So where is the issue? He didn’t interrupt, he gave him time to answer, he obviously wasn’t going to have a friendly chat for a breakfast television program but while his tone was particular, that hardly qualifies as pushing an agenda. Leading the interview in a certain way is natural because let’s face it, this isn’t going to be about the next tax policy of a local party, its about the fate of 40 million people under an entirely new leadership.
Asking about rumors is also a perfectly viable question because it gives the opportunity to defend one’s position or state differing opinions.
Pushing an agenda would be to not have an interview at all.
@@Arcaryon who you lying to big man 🤣
@@aligelle8649 I don’t need to lie when you can fact check every single thing I said.
I think you are mistaking ISIS for taliban, yes taliban use suicide bombers to attack the invading forces{which i think is wrong to do in islam} but I have never heard them using it the way you mentioned in your comment.
@@Arcaryon but imma get unreliable sources like cnn and bbc
The journo asked how this will benefit Great Britain and the United States LOL
Dude it’s not about you, it’s about people of Afghanistan and yes they have to be able to establish stable leadership and cooperate with other nations for economic growth, he just told you.
Dealing with the Taliban is a zero sum game. If the taliban can't offer anything, why shouls they be offered anything? Many people die of war and starvation in africa each day, because they have nothing to offer the rest of the world. Unfortunately you don't deal with the people, you deal with their leaders.
The first thing the Afghan people needs is durable peace and get rid of wars and corrupt leaders who were being imposed on them by foreign powers and this is what they achieved and this was the true definition of foreign occupation on Afghanistan sovereignty.Moreover It,s up to the Afghan people to run their country by any type of government by the Afghans and for the Afghans.Other countries should have no concern with this internal matters of Afghanistan.Imposing sanctions or applying any other tactics on them are unjustifiable brutal.
@@malikmumtazz6333 Taliban can impose sanctions or other tactics, on other countries .. why is that unjustifiable brutal?
@@malikmumtazz6333 do you think the situation would have been different if the taliban didn't declare victory? It might have been in their own best interest not to, I would say.
@My Bro yeah no. No one is going to trust the taliban to keep their word.
He is a One man army Mashallah 😍 nice Q&A
If leadership of Taliban in Afghanistan hasn't been airdroped then why there's Sharia slavery instead of Adat and Pashtunwali? Why are there so many limitations? There are only 4 wifes per husband max and other limitations. Did you have such limitations before imposing Sharia "law" by US puppets there?
The Afghan once said “we dont need someone to tell us how to be Islam. We all already Islam”.
They are absolutely right…!!! Do the Afghan people tell the USA how to run your country ?
@@lialaliala2968 they said its still better before the Taliban get incharge.
So they are already submission hahah
@@lialaliala2968 a
O
Kurds would disagree but whatever
2:24 "How would Europe benefit from Afghanistan?"
Literally cannot believe he asked that!
Is that an actual question? Is this for real?
You DON'T. You don't benefit. Thats how you benefit. Why would England or France expect to benefit from Afghanistan? Did they think they are still colonial masters thus can benefit? Who came up with that imperialist question?
How does Afghanistan benefit from the UK? Only warcrimes? Same from the USA and Australia. When they were exposed they decided to forgive themselves.
So no reason to help them then, not even for humanitarian reasons, since those resources are better used elsewhere.
@@jonatand2045 Humanitarian reasons? Europe doesn't do humanitarian. Europe only does trade and then labels it 'help'.
Europe says here is some money but to get this there are these conditions that you need to do for us.
That is called TRADE not help. Because help BY DEFINITION IS ALWAYS FREE OF ANY CONDITION! You have RARELY HELPED ANYONE. You only do trade.
@@jonatand2045 Not to mention Afghanistan has trillions in the ground. They must develop it and not be reliant on anyone else.
Yeah, I can't believe its a question too. Like the person said, Afghan already checked the requirements. It might be still a highly unstable region now but it's time for the west to just let them be.
@@acecream8568 Whatever they do is up to them. The west needs to let go of its racist imperialist ways because more and more nations are getting sick of the west and thats NOT good for business. Look at France and how it is talked about in the African Union. Its is spat out everywhere and kicked out everwhere.
Afghan government will be desperate and China will give them aid for mineral mining rights.
It's true china see them like a mine only $%
China has mining rights already. They had them under the NATO backed corrupt government. The question is who is going to invest hundreds of millions of dollars developing a mine when they can do it somewhere else.
@@indianboybro that's still better than the west sees them as terrorists and bombs them
It will turn into how Africa turned into .they will lose their nation natural resources
@@indianboybro Or it will turn into how Australia and Canada turned into and they will make billions from their natural resources.
Talichad. Talibased
I from Malaysia fully support for Taliban government. May success always my brother
@Monetized Monk why should He lmao
@Monetized Monk like us? And run back after failing 😂.
@Monetized Monk why should he leave his native land?.. we asia are more civilized than you..you thief that it..every way you go that place soon will be full of hunger and misery..
@@zulimanismail1966 taliban aren’t civilized. We Malaysian are not going back to Stone Age policy that forces women not go to school
I hope they put you on the terrorist watch list
America called Kim jong Un a terrorist, and then they negotiated, they called Iran terrorists then negotiated, they called taliban terrorists and then negotiated, which makes me think, if bin laden wouldn’t die they might have negotiated with him as well...
America does not have any laws which prohibits human rights . It's not the Americans who suffer from poverty , discrimination and basic human right violations.
Silly people support Taliban
1. Banning boxing
2. Banning music
3. Banning drawings
4. Banning photography
5. Banning movies
6. Banning women high-heeled shoes that produce a sound
7. Banning women showing their hair
8. Banning women wearing perfume
9. Banning women going out
10. Banning women to breathe during stoning
@@takiyaazrin7562 lier
@@takiyaazrin7562 Silly people support western
1. Drugs are very healthy things
2. Murdering is allowed
3. Rape is allowed
4. Watching porn allowed
5. No god no religious things
6. You can rape 10 woman and none gona tell you something
7. Misbehaving with elders are allowed
8. You can party whole night and do **** with 10 woman are allowed
Man i am confused, what this people want and what are they talking about. Islam is trying to save you, trying to cover woman from problems, trying make peace.
@@zinformative you can say the exact same thing about Islam
Sad to say but he is right, there is no difference between Afghanistan to many other countries that are part of the UN.
On the other hand nobody have to give them any aid.
Maybe US has the responsibility to give them aid, after all they destroyed the country.
The problem here is Al Qaeda they invited the American to Afghanistan by attacking twins tower in the name of Allah
@harry brown
If only I can familiarize myself with all of the war crimes committed by the US military against the Afghan people. Forced disappearances, arbitrary detentions , torture, and intentional targeting of civilians via air strike would be a start I guess. Oh and also the uranium mines that were being exploited by the US.
And I wouldn’t use the word “aid”. I prefer to call it , “reparations” from the arsenal of democracy and freedom.
Aid comes with shariah law. MBS owes them some zakat taqquiya
You Taliban?
Allah bless you Taliban brothers ❤️❤️❤️
❤❤อามีน❤❤ให้กำลังใจ.พี่น้องตาลีบัน.ยังเต็มที.มาตลอด❤❤ไทยแลร❤❤
The West has a saviour complex. Leave Asia, Africa and Latin America alone. Leave us alone. We don't want your system of government. But of course, your western cognitive dissonance will not allow you to see things from my point of view. We don't need western governments to dictate the way that we rule our countries. The white saviour complex is strong in Europeans and Americans. To anyone who supports the western point of view, don't you find it atleast a little strange that as soon as America lost control of Afghanistan, everyone had something to say about how to run the country and Americans seem "concerned" all of a sudden??
@@anasmousa7572
And so did the taliban kill so many innocent civilians. They are worse than the US
Western media likes to see only those issues that this questioner asked about.
Silly people support Taliban
1. Banning boxing
2. Banning music
3. Banning drawings
4. Banning photography
5. Banning movies
6. Banning women high-heeled shoes that produce a sound
7. Banning women showing their hair
8. Banning women wearing perfume
9. Banning women going out
10. Banning women to breathe during stoning
@@DarthVaderoftheShire .love u brother, for ur precise reply.
@@DarthVaderoftheShire But why did they ban music,drawing,photoghraphy,movies?
@@barca8341 those things quite unprohibited in Islam, but then again, those things barely exist during Prophet Muhammad's life, so there's no specific rule that tell us that music,drawing,photography,movies etc. are absolutely unprohibited. It's only hinted but not specific
@@definitelynotcharaznable7749 I cant live without those
so eloquent and patient ... the interviewers have a nasty habit of asking a question and then interrupting the answer ... nasty annoying interviewers need to learn viewers want to hear the person being interviewed not the blabbing rhetoric spewing media muppets
Exactly
He might be corrupt media shill, but the Afghanistan people are suffering and still don't have proper working of the government, and people are paid with rice and not money.
Where this Afgan school and learn English. He has excellent English and has Russian accent, right ?
Wow... jumping right to the ad hominem, simply because the brainwashing has been so effective. So transparent are the ways of this ideology.
@@mamamarianovits9029 I did not understand can you explain your sentence?
He is such a good orator. My respects! Afghans deserve the best after all these years of war.
Every question the interviewer asked is happening in most Western countries.... no problem there.....
Lol is a fire burning under you, Abdullah? Jimmy Sparks, curious (white) name you have given yourself 🤣🤣🤣
Women are not denied education xD
Taliban aren't good people but US is just as worse
@@madanigaming6595 then go live in Afghanistan, why so many people migrate to us rather than tan
@@user-ml4ps5cq3v
Let's leave pre-established ideas aside, he speaks better than many western leaders!
yeah... that's why empty vessel sounds much.
then he doesnt need western leaders help
he has no difficulty with pleasing voters
@@MrOner07 VOTERS? LOOOL you must be joking
He is so Nice i really like this man
He answers questions without thinking so perfectly only true People can answer like him
He has abilities like No one Else in the Western journalism
He shut the Mouth of the Interviewer so perfectly Even He asked so bad questions that Prooves me really who were wrong for real the Last Decades
I Hope the Afghanistan people live for ever in Peace ☝🏽
I hope they succeed for the people of Afghanistan and they will bring peace and prosperity
They already brought hunger. Who knew jihadists weren't the best at statecraft.
@@jonatand2045 the only reason of this consequnse is west sanction. after their devastating lost on the ground they still try to win over geopoltically.
@@everythingaroundbd6063
That is the bad thing about sanctions, that goverments under them can use them as an excuse for their incompetence.
Alaqah is peaceful. That's why they hate gametes
Amen
I think the Germans are salty because they decided to lay down and surrender to the Americans allowing them to occupy and build bases all over Germany while the poor illiterate Afghans they make fun off fought them for 20 years
Germany, during ww2, actually built hospitals, schools, and housing for Afghanistan.
They wanted to create Allies with strong warrior nations
And what is the state of the ordinary people in those countries today? What strategy worked best for them? Fight and destroy or surrender and rebuild?
Germany was up against 4 out of 5 other world powers... at the same time... but still Taliban victory is very impressive.
@@bashsibda6289 in islam oppression is worse than slaughter the USA wanted to change the religion and genetic makeup of Afghanistan by introducing foreign imposed feminism and liberalism.Allah knows best
@@clovenshield3067
Shariah law is not based on Human Rights.
Shariah condones and requires the violation of Human Rights. Any country that does not adhere to Human Rights is going to have a problem if it wants to integrate with the rest of the world in the 21st century.
Their country their law. First protect you own countries from such law and practice, no need to worry about others. Afghanistan ppls can take care their own
Great Taliban 👍
Yeah ilove joe
Now he seems like a charming fella
Yeah, but if someone commits "haraam", he executes extreme harming.
@@MaTara01 BMA
O Tara you cook a lot of stuff in your head and burns a lot of thing....
But for sure "The God" who has created day and night as one of his signs is "Most Merciful"....
Known by the name Allah who never Sleeps!!?
thats their tactic
This how the media do things
He lived in new New Zealand for a while. Taliban put their people who have experience with western countries to be their media spokesmen
It's unnerving how he's well spoken
the moderator?
CIA implants everywhere over there
Why unnerving? I find him very intelligent, and he seems very caring about his people. Isn't it good he can communicate with a wider audience?
@@anonymouschickpea4271 His intelligence is irrelevant, it's precisely his nonchalant demeanor and the likelihood that he is educated and professional is what makes all of this more ominous. You may have a good conversation with him, but the ideology behind him and what he stands for is completely deranged and primitive.
The obvious nutcase that yells obscenities and is obviously a menace - is one you can point out and expect such behavior from..but the fact that the Taliban has official spokesmen who seem docile is why we have to watch out for a wolf in sheep's clothing.
@@FactStorm Who are the real wolves in sheep's clothing here though? The Taliban don't hide their beliefs.
Hey american, give back frozen Afghan asset you stole😂😂😂
I Believed Somali should be the first Country to recognize them.
Damn I never thought he would be able to speak English so fluently
Not just English they are speaking fluent five languages 👍
@@lialaliala2968 he*
Don’t be fooled. They knew to send this guy as a spokesperson for the Taliban
@@PrinceIndra9000ngz Fooled how? Of course their spokesperson will be an eloquent person that can speak languages well, that's what a spokesperson is supposed to do.
Does the US use hillbillies who speak English by a way no one but them can understand as spokespersons? No.
English is just a language and language can be learned. No big deal
Masha allah accept afgahan people sariyat law..
Taliban proud our umma life
Proud islam good life . good quran sariyt law...
Thanks to allah..
Allahu akber...
🤮🤮🤮🤮
His English is really good….
Soruces say that he is actually a New Zealand citizen and his family still resides in New Zealand...
What accent does he have?
@@bilalrasoul5522 He is a former NZ resident. He isn't a citizen. A resident just means he legally lived there... It doesnt mean he is a NZ citizen.
Actually, he sounds very much as someone who lived in the US. His sound and fluency are equivalent to using American English daily from the age of early 20s to today, imho.
@@bilalrasoul5522 As a kiwi i can hear it in his accent
God never abandon her righteous servants, this is the example.🇵🇭❤
God not real
20 years they tryed to create a secular Afghanistan !!!!
Secular State is Part of Western Civilisation , because they lost the
deep believe in the Gospel.......
Shariya law zindabad 🎊🔥
Afganistan will not survive 4 months without aid from infidels still they have ego as if they have 50 trillion economy
ask yoursel how they survived in the mountains for 43 years ... what is 4 years
@@meddylujjah575 They were not ruling the country.
And no hungry populace to manage
@@lostlegend9015 They can only be hungry if the west imposes sanctions on the country I think your aware about the Venezuela issue
@@fangdog29 let me also ask you how has the Iranian people survived for decades with the with the western sanctions
Always so calm when he responds to the questions of offensive and condescending western interviewers.
The questions are insulting...I guess he is more patient than I am
❤❤
@@hamzayasin8150❤❤
Congratulations you fought hard for a long time so whats for supper?
From this spokesperson's statement Talbians are not simpler as world is thinking about them ,they knew the political importance of the state as well
How about taking care of their own people and making food available, that is simpler no?
@@DK-is2fi that's not something can happen over night, US just defeated a few months ago, they going for a fresh start.
Also agricultural importance, since the grapes surely will ripen for the winepress 🍇🍷
@@haziq0007 How about they breaking fences on the durand line and warning pak army not to move ahead.
@@haziq0007 defeated? More like the US got bored and left
Khorazan...they will liberate the Palestine...summa ameen
@BlackBannerz Allahu alam...unless and until we follow ahlus sunnah wal jamaah salafi not sufi
@kohlasa6909 then that's never gonna happen
This taliban guy has more knowledge than Donald trump about international conventions.
I'll take Trump over the Taliban as my leader every time.
@@tacocruiser4238 cut from the same cloth
@@jandrews6254 In what way?
@@tacocruiser4238 Both are insane, uneducated and ideological fascists.
But at least you could threaten Trump much easier than those dogmatic Kamikaze.
@@MetallicReg Nothing you said makes any sense. Just vague platitudes. You probably don't even know what a "fascist" is. Neither Trump nor the Taliban are fascists.
Great interview. Really impressed how beautifully he handled the interview. There is so much clarity as they have a strong purpose & belief.
If leadership of Taliban in Afghanistan hasn't been airdroped then why there's Sharia slavery instead of Adat and Pashtunwali? Why are there so many limitations? There are only 4 wifes per husband max and other limitations. Did you have such limitations before imposing Sharia "law" by US puppets there?
And you finally made it 🏳️💚
20 years ..... of Lies and Collonization terror ... they won !!!
The interviewer came with his own bias
Why would any country trust the Taliban: good reasonable question , the spokesman did not answer the simple question.
bags of it!
It is either these guys or the previous corrupted officials. West was in love with the corrupted officials and funded them till they left Afghanistan before them . I wonder why!
@@hc3657 Not true. America supported Afghanistan for 20 years and was tired of the forever wars. America also thought that the people of Afghanistan would fight to keep the gains made, especially by women in the country. During America's time in Afghanistan, women were journalists, politicians, doctors, judges, and more. The men of Afghanistan had the same gains and more. The government was not perfect but No government is perfect. Also, no one thought Afghanistan, with so much to lose including free elections, wouldn't fight to keep their democracy. If Joe Biden didn't care about Afghanistan people, he wouldn't have airlifted over 100 thousand to safety. He also wouldn't have allowed almost one billion dollars worth of humanitarian aid to be given to the country after leaving if he and America didn't care for the Afghanistan people. But America can't fight the battle of another country forever. While the USA was in Afghanistan, the Taliban were blocked. Sooner or later, if the Afghanistan people want freedom, they need to stand up to the Taliban for themselves. The Taliban are only a group of maybe 100 thousand. The people of Afghanistan are 40 million. What they accept for a government is really their choice.
@@hc3657 You're describing US and NATO.
@@onepeace1274 Seriously, you can't buy/bribe people to accept what's wrong. US tried for 20 years with their bs and Britain tried 4 times (invaded Afghanistan 4 times). Clearly Truth stands out Clear from the error. You may be militarily powerful but you were up against an ideology far superior than whatever you had to offer.
1. Men and women are NOT same and therefore invalidates your "same rights" arguments.
2. Usury is slavery/exploitation
3. Democracy is populism (which is unjust). The concept of the ignorant masses electing a ruler is nothing short of stupidity. Democracy in a weaker nation turns it into a colony.
I can go on and on
@@onepeace1274 The US didn't care about Afghan people otherwise they wouldn't have supported Ghani, Karzai and their corrupt bloodsucking buddies feasting on afghan blood for decades! The Americans knew this, they could've done something about it, but they didn't, because they only cared about themselves.
Also about airlifting thousands...that's just a brain drain for Afghanistan. Taking the cream of the crop, the skilled workers of Afghanistan and moving them to the US...that's just a steal
@@User-xw5mk The USA airlifted the citizens of Afghanistan not for a brain drain, but because they are terrified of the Taliban, and for proper reasons. They personally witnessed the cruelty, the beheadings, the suicide bombings and the inhumanity of the Taliban first hand. The whole world saw the Afghanistan men trying to hold on to planes to get away from the Taliban and the lines of people headed for the borders. We also saw the videos of the Taliban killing 23 former military after they surrendered with hands up. And the reports of other revenge killings. The throng of people at the airport desperately trying to to get out of the country and those still trying to get out of the country tells another story. Wish you would tell the truth. And the former government had its flaws as all governments do, but at least the people had free elections and everyone, including women had equal rights to education and jobs and even the government. The Taliban won't even allow free elections. They select only their Taliban for the highest positions in the government when there are many different ethnic groups who should have equal representation. At least when America was there, the Afghanistan people had a chance to elect the people of their choosing. Under Taliban rule, that is no longer an option for them, which is another reason many have left and are leaving freely. Again, please at least tell the truth. But it is okay if you don't tell the truth because we get the truth from all of the Afghanistan people who have left. No need for your testimony.
is it controversial to ask when did 'western culture & rights' become the morale code to live by?
Is the moral code we use in the west. DW is a western media channel. And yes, I'm biased but I do belive western morality is the superior morality in today's world.
No, but it is controversial to criticizer the west while enjoying the knowledge, tech and facilities developed by them.
@@SC-zq6cu yeah and made by Chinese workers and developed mostly by immigrants in their countries or soviets. when your country is subjugated for centuries by western rule and your resources are drained by the colonizers, you don't quite achieve the same amount of wealth as them.
Considering the alternative is the barbarism that the Taliban claim is Islam(which it isn't) Western morals would seem superior in comparison.
@@jassingh8232
Okay then stop using stuff that colonisers came up with. If its so easy to criticise western moral codes then it should be equally easy to abandon western inventions as well. Just because they are made by chinese workers or developed by immigrants does not change their sources. For the record western moral codes are not entirely made in west either, they are a result of thousands of years of development in a lot of other places as well, primarily the middle east. So if it is okay to ditch them just because the west advocates for them then it should be equally easy to ditch tech that the west advocates, does not matter if those were made by the chinese workers. Otherwise its just opportunistic behaviour and this kind of moral grandstanding has no place in it.
A very articulate representative, no matter what your opinion on the Taliban may be.
Bro for real I was thinking the same thing😂😂
I wouldn't praise anything they're doing. 🙄
@@elana137 cool. I did though.
@@elana137
Yes you will not accept...because they have defeated your master America 🇺🇸 and your other yuck western masters..
They flew shamefully
I’m praising one guy who happens to be a rep. of the taliban government because he sounds like he is American trained. Is that a bad thing.. no, why cause this is the first time in 40+ years they actually get to try to be a country.
Call on allah for help, yall hate western laws and lifestyle oohh saudia arabia is close by they SHOULD help
excellent interview, and the answer of the last question is a tight slap to the interviewer. And seriously he asked what benefit usa gonna get 😂
The hubris of this reporter is offensive, almost unbearable. The reporter should ask why Afghanistan is in a humanitarian crises, and what the world can do to help.
So I would have loved to hear from him if Taiwan is a country and should be recognized too…because it has all those things he mentioned.
It’s Formosa and they are not as opposed to joining China than you’d believe.
Taiwan is a good country.
Taiwans constitution does not recognize Taiwan itself as the defined borders of their state. It still claims mainland China which by those criteria, Taiwan isn’t a nation. However I do believe Taiwan should be independent and separate from China
@@505Vermont with the same reason that mainland claim a territory they can’t control as one country, would you say china isn’t really a country too?
@@smoochie3331 The vast majority of people and land the PRC claims is governed by them so obviously they’re the legitimate state over Taiwan. Taiwan or “Republic of China” it still officially refers to itself claims exactly the same population and territory as the PRC. How is Taiwan fit for the criteria mentioned above if they won’t release claims on those? If I were them I would amend the ROC constitution to recognize only Taiwan as their nation but they won’t even do that because of political infighting due to Taiwanese officials who are against Taiwanese independence so they can continue claiming the entire mainland of China.
You have to give this guy props for going knowing he would be grilled like that
If it is so legitimate...Then hold an election where women get to vote.
do u have trust in ur girls logical thinking?? lol
@@siloa6273 Most girls I know can spell better than you.
duhh don't shove your democracry on everyones throat. Not everybody dances to your tune,
Basic needs and services can’t be meet and you think holding a nation wide elections is paramount. Even if they did hold an election they new government will be faced will filler busters and roadblocks. Every country that came out of a war had an interim government until things quelled down and then they held elections. Why is the Taliban any different?
@@akon360 You think the Taliban is interim?
I'm also Pathan n love my sweet brothers