Ash Sarkar Debunks Anti-Migrant Myths
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 7 ก.ย. 2024
- While establishment media jumps at the chance to go on refugee safari in the Channel, Ash Sarkar debunks the myths behind anti-migrant sentiment.
Subscribe to Novara Media on TH-cam ⇛ novara.media/yo...
Support our work ⇛ novaramedia.co...
Subscribe to the TyskySour podcast ⇛ novara.media/t...
![Megan Thee Stallion - Neva Play (feat. RM) [Official Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/TpYTyAaTRts/mqdefault.jpg)
Wonder how many illegal immigrants has Ash Sarkar taken into her house?
Except 4 out of 10 of them are Albanian and Albania isn’t at war last time I checked
You don't have to be in a war zone to be desperate 😅
@@MI-vc9lp you do to be defined as a refugee though genius.
@@SilencedReflex My point still stands
@@MI-vc9lp well it doesn’t because it’s completely irrelevant, they’re not refugees so your point holds 0 weight.
@@SilencedReflex Albania is a corrupt and poor country, should everyone live in horrible conditions unless it's a literal warzone?
if they are fleeing from syria, then they have passed 12 other countries of safety.
It is a myth that just because a country isn't officially at 'war' then it is safe. The video mentioned why some people want to specifically come to the UK (although also mentioned not that many contextually when compared with the rest of the world) - language, family connection etc.
But yeah I've met asylum seekers in Greece and the treatment by Greek police forces and their state is horrific. The same can be said for many other countries in Europe - Serbia is one that particularly springs to mind but many others too like Italy, France, Hungary etc. They aren't 'safe' when you're constantly harassed by police forces, given no means to apply for work or proper or safe accommodation.
There's so much unbelievable disinformation and myths out there surrounding the lives of migrants and asylum seekers - it's hard to know where to begin with demystifying it all. The worst part is it all fits right into Tory/elite divide and rule tactics and the top end just carry on fleecing workers for all their worth.
I've spoken to them personally most admitted they come here for the women as they see them as easy
@@James-iu8zs don't talk like an idiot. France, Belgium, the Netherlands the list goes on. Those countries are safe. They're coming here to milk the system and take over in stealth Jihad
@@James-iu8zs if you have family already here, you can legally get them here. If you're taking that to justify illegal entry, you're a right biscuit mate.
@@danielseaburg9763 I hear you but there's a couple things - 1. Only can be brought over if your family have got their status and they need to often be close family, like immediate family. So some people might have looser family ties or people they know but still means they'd be far more comfortable coming here than somewhere where they know nobody - however this situation would mean they couldn't be brought over 'legally'
2. Sometimes this processing shit takes ages - I know of people in Yorkshire region who've waited over years to get a decision, I know someone now waiting over 2 years. This is the home office being shit. This person I know has their daughter still back at home - the dilemma is do you carry on waiting and hope a decision comes through (you don't know how much longer it'll take or even if you'll get a positive one - you might not) and then try bring over, or do you just say to them you're better off leaving and trying to reach here yourself to join your mother?
They're a young teenager in a country with a civil war going on - I've very sadly seen a video back in their village (which the mother showed me) of soldiers in the area forcing the kids (including their daughter) to strip naked - for what appears to be no reason other than a show of authority and fear tactic - they then shoot rubber bullets near these teenagers to instill more fear. It was the mother literally showing me this video of their daughter as someone nearby managed to get a small amount of footage of it. Imagine watching that with your own daughter in it? Her life is in literal danger - so again - wait for a decision that appears to be taking forever - or get your daughter to try come over here? She can't be brought over legally - her mother has not got status here.
She'll likely pass through some 'safe countries' if she survives a journey into Europe. But will she actually be safe. I'm sure she'd feel safer in the UK where she has some family.
This is just one of many personal stories I know of - I understand people don't like anecdotal evidence used in debates like this and say they are emotional and can't be used as proper arguments. Plus others could fire anecdotes back saying other things that disagree with your side. However, these are literal human beings we're talking about, with emotions, dreams, friends, family etc. We as a country have caused so much destruction of cultures, families, lives via the empire and pillaging of countries. We also are supposed to be a very rich country - a G8 country as it were - but really we're just ran by rich people, for rich people - a lot of the place is poor as fuck
Meanwhile said rich people as I stated earlier create divide and rule - get you to pour your energy and anger into blaming other poor people (the 'chavs', the 'scroungers'), migrants etc meanwhile the rich tories, companies and others carry on fleecing you and fleecing you and fleecing you. Person above mentions racist stuff about claiming people coming over to 'stealth jihad' and milk system - but tories (and new Labour and others) are milking the system, staying rich whilst destroying free healthcare we've had for decades - they want everything to be private - they aren't building any affordable homes or replenishing old but usable buildings - they're building unaffordable flats everywhere, new huge buildings, they're making dodgy deals with mates over the vaccine, they're selling off parts of the NHS to friends
Why we insist so much on hating other not so well off people around us whilst rich people fleece us is beyond me. If there were 'no migrants' and somehow every 'scrounger' had a job (this scenario is barely physically possible, but just hypothetically) - I can bet my bottom dollar most people in lower wage brackets would still be very poor and have shit and difficult lives - why? Because we'd still be poor, rich people would still be getting richer and barely much would change
We're targeting the wrong people. That's the bottom line of all of this. Don't believe the government, the institutions, the home office etc and start trying to look after your community around you
It's something like 90% men under 30 and only a tiny percentage of those would be considered to be legitimate refugees if they claimed asylum as they should do in the first safe country that they get to. And unfortunately for Ash, that would never be the UK.
That's not true.
Putting aside that I don't know anything about these people or how asylum works, let me lay down some *facts*
There is no law that says refugees have to claim asylum in the first country they come to
they are no refugees , they are economic migrants
@@whynottyg7250 Its irrelevant. These people can do as they please, if they chose to seek asylum in the UK, then they are free to do that and follow the legal process.
You'd think these refugees would and should be picked up with rich countries with the same culture and ideology instead of countries they consider it's people infidels.
But the top ten are experiencing serious migration problems. What is you point? that the UK isn't having enough problems and should be in the top ten? Either there is a housing crisis or there isn't. If there is then solve it before you support unlimited immigration don't ignore it and just say it's not the migrants fault. Solve the accommodation problem first. The UK homeless aren't in 5 star hotels, why not?
Stop bombing their countries, then they wouldn't need to come here.
"We can't take any more! This country is crumbling!" - Who is running this crumbling country again?
A fucking substituted clown
@Daniel Parker Green Easy on the fragility there, chap; you'll do yourself a mischief.
@Danny Cross 'Sound like' to fascist semi-evolved primates like you, compared to Bojoke, Gove, Cummings & little Farage et al who have conclusively demonstrated that they are wankers beyond reasonable doubt..
@@user-zm8xv8tl2l A decade ago, after a world wide crash of capitalism. Mmmmm.
@@user-zm8xv8tl2l Which socialist government was that?
Where does she see “women and children “ in these boats?
Uhhh she literally debunked nothing haha. Holy fuck, Britain is lost.
Except, precisely how major corporations are a larger drain on the nation's resources than asylum seekers. You'd have to actually watch it though.
Asylum Applications? You can 'apply' from France, you don't have to illegaly enter to 'apply'.
Honest? Entering illegaly is honest?
Housing? Any spare rooms in your house Ash? Go on, you love them so much, put them up at your expense.
You have to be physically present in the UK to claim asylum. That is very basic knowledge.
@@whynottyg7250 Watch the video
@@whynottyg7250 If you're uprooting your entire life to flee across the world and start a new life somewhere else, it makes sense that you'd go where they speak a language you're at least familiar with, where you have family or friends to help you, or at least a community to connect with. Only a tiny, tiny fraction of the refugees come all the way here, they're the ones with good reason to do it
why not ! I make no excuses for Arabic countries not taking in refugees. It’s shameful. How can your daughter not have a right of abode in the UK? ALl British passport holders do.
@@haiybo they're probably making it up FYI. Also arab countries do take in refugees - around 85% of Syrian refugees are living in the neighbouring countries, some of which are really struggling to cope with this population increase. Which is why we have a responsibility to help, not cry over a handful of brown people showing up while we pretend to care in the abstract
The older I get the more I want people to live safely, happily and wherever they want and the less time I have for bigots.
A healthy worldview! I've noticed the same thing with my own thinking.
Thought it's a bit sad to see how when some people get older they lose their curiosity, grow intellectually lazy and start yearning for "the good old days" fantasies that never actually existed.
You folks are restoring my faith in humanity. ❤
I applaud you 👏🏿👏🏿
Fred Ginn how is it realistic to go wherever you want and call anywhere home, though?
@Aj Battle @Fred Ginn it's because you are going to die (you know your time is close) and want to some good intention to get some forgiveness.
But actually you don't care, whatever happen to UK and its future, you don't care.
This coming from someone who celebrated London becoming ethnic majority!
What's wrong with that, in your mind?
@@musicandfilms9956 Different people = different country, you can claim thats racist or whatever but its just true.
@@LiftedBuddha Well, you're right there. You are being racist. Given the multiple ways that the UK has interfered in the Global South over the last few centuries for the benefit of our own wealthy elites, it's entirely just that some of their people come and live here. What harm are they causing you, anyway? Does 'different' mean 'worse'? Tell me two ways in which migrating people from the Global South have caused your life to decline.
Because only a racist would think like that.
@@user-ie7gm7kk6o When a racist is elected to the US Presidency and other unabashed racists are heads of states in Europe, it's obvious that the label is claimed with pride by millions of people.
The title of your video is Migrants and then you talk the whole way through about Asylum seekers 🤔
Can you do another video on economic Migrants ??
like pritti patel ? isnt that what she was
Yup, not one woman and child, just a load of illegal economic migrant men of military fighting age, so within 5 seconds what she said was complete nonsense wasn't it.
Oh no not military fighting age!! Get off my lawn!
Well why don't the women pull their finger out there arse and fight in a war if they are so strong and independant
Number of asylum seekers taken is meaningless if net migration isn't taken into account.
Taking in refugees has costs for the people already living in a country.
It's definitely not obvious that people in dire straits whilst in France that would be alieviated by coming to the UK. Even if there's something specifcally bad for them about living in France there are numerous countries on France's borders. It's harder to sympathise.
no mention of the British homelessness problem of course we should look after immigrants instead of our own people cuz reasons
She looks out for her people and other BAMEs before considering the white British homelessness problem. If these were brown refugees that were homeless as she coined when bringing up brown men in rubber-dinghies, I believe her outcry would be much greater.
@William Brown ye big brains cuz u shud prioritise other peoples families over your own (country is literal extension of family why do u think we have different countries) as usual it’s people like u who have never lived in these areasor never had a friend raped by our divirse friends and by diverse I mean over 90% Muslim men I suppose u are fine with London no longer resembling anything British I suppose u fine wiv sharia courts my stunning n brave big brained friend?
@William Brown also the archbishop IS THE VERY DEFINITION OF MORALLY BANKRUPT
@William Brown and who pays for it all? These aren't migrants coming in and working, they come in with their hands out and get free housing, welfare and other costs paid for by the tax payers.
And it's not a fucking coincidence that violent crime rates sky-rocket where they are
But hey so long as you get to virtue signal about how open minded you are none of that matters eh?
“Once you’ve got refugee status, you’ll get permission to work in the UK - in any profession and at any skill level. If you’re not ready or able to look for work and have very little or no income, you can apply for benefits instead.”
-Citizens Advice
Weird thing to lie about, Ash
you misinterpreted what she said. she said you can only apply to work if you've been waiting for a response to your initial claim for 12 months - and that application is for refugee status. once you have that, you can indeed get the benefits and work.
These people need quantifying, Economic migrant is NOT a refugee! Anyone entering through unorthodox means Life time ban.
Nearly anyone fleeing a war zone over a border would be illegal without refugee law. By your reckoning Jews who fled Nazi persecution would and should be banned.
I thought Mr Farage believed "all lives matter"? Colour me surprised...
@Fred Ginn Not even sure I'd go that far haha!
Oh, you don't want to have colour if you're dealing with farage, trust me
@Fred Ginn We'll all be on the dinghy to France if he got his way haha!
@@emilyharrison2867 It must be because of our lovely weather.
Many of them go to those safe countries, not many make it to here. How safe is France for Asylum seekers? In July 2020 the ECHR found that France was violating the rights of aslyum seekers.
Yeah, by "all lives" he meant all lives as long as said lives are straight white conservative men with no financial issues or disabilities.
Farage is an absolute mug who can go do one.
You can be left wing and against mass illegal migration. Like Bernie Sanders once said it is a koch brothers dream.
@@cartoonhead9222 Marx also believed the population should be armed but these days self labelled marxists are some of the biggest gun control freaks around. The progressive socialists are so far away politically from the people they claim to admire its hilarious.
Agreed, I'd add that Novara are a dream for the right wing. No wonder the likes of Owen Jones and Ash Sarkar get mainstream gigs. I like Ash personally, she's funny and charismatic and interesting when she's talking about lit stuff, but her politics are daft. She's a very useful idiot for the right. The identitarian faux-left got northern mining towns voting for old Etonian sociopaths. And they'll keep doing it. Have to laugh or it'd make me cry. "Divide and conque----- sorry, diversity is our strength!"
Apologies for ranting
Peace
You can't. Socialism and open borders go together. Is there a way to close the borders without guards, without detention centres and without causing immense suffering to the poorest and most desperate? No.
@@musicandfilms9956 History entirely disagrees.
@@danielseaburg9763 Thank you for that informative reply. Perhaps you would provide details of the pleasant experiences of poor people trying to move across the borders of the European Union, Japan, the USA, the UK... after which I will show you otherwise.
But they're not Asylum seekers. The Dublin convention states that they must seek asylum in the first safe country (France and other EU countries they have passed through are all safe). They are economic migrants and are queue jumping those who apply through the legal process. That's a fact. The final fact is that voters don't want loose immigration laws. Every demographic (including BAME) agrees that immigration levels are too high. It's not racist or xenophobic to point this out. I don't see much debunking...
They are not fleeing from Syria though are they ? They are fleeing from France which is not a war torn dangerous country. The very fact these young men are in France suggests they are not families we need to help. We need to focus our money and resources on the families still in Syria which have no options....surely Ash!
"The White British population has decreased by 600,000 while the minority population has increased by 1.2 million, so yes lads, WERE WINNING!" - Ash Sarkar - The replacement is real folks
What, exactly, worries you about people of colour becoming a higher proportion of the population in the UK?
@@rexmundi7811 The 'native population'? If by that, you mean 'people like you who have white skin', then it will be a long time before that happens, if current demographic trends continue. Why does that worry you at all? Don't you like other people?
@@rexmundi7811 Some assumptions there. What makes England/the UK 'your country' as in your possession? Like anywhere else, Britain has always been a nation of migrants, and its culture has always been in flux. What would you lose by a change that didn't need changing anyway? The history of Britain is not something to be particularly proud of, given the ways we exploited other countries.
If you truly believe that a country should not be "handed over to other people", then I assume you agree with me that the British Empire was a crime against those many nations we violently took over for the benefit of a few people here. The legacy of our imposition of British cultural practices is long and wide.
@@rexmundi7811 The nation state is a relatively recent invention, as is the border. People moved freely until recently. Anyway, I still don't know what your complaint is. Tell me two things you have lost in your lifetime as a result of people moving into Britain.
@Fred Ginn it's nice that all these people are realising they're in the wrong and deleting their comments though
"We're winning lads!". That's what she says about the Great Replacement. Taquiya is all we expect from this self serving opportunist
It's called ethnocide
Careful, lads - your mouth-foam is showing...
Kakergi plan in full effect.
She is a genocidal nut that is grinning inanely.
you never get people risking their lives on rafts trying to get into socialist countries, its always the other way round, Cuba, Vietnam, Cambodia etc.
Your logic is poor. You need ask why that might be. Is it because socialism is exploitative and inherently inhuman? Capitalist nations and regions rely on the exploitation of low-wage labour in Vietnam, Cambodia etc. Your clothes and many other items you enjoy would be far more expensive if we took our collective foot off the necks of the poor. That's one reason people flee. There are many others, none of which blame the Global South for what we are doing to it.
@@musicandfilms9956 let me get this right, are you arguing that the reason so many people risk their lives fleeing communist countries is because capitalists are exploiting them, and they are fleeing to capitalist countries to escape capitalism?????
@@musicandfilms9956 Pol Pot in Cambodia murdered a third of his own population, he was the person that followed the communist manifesto the closest, Marx said in the communist manifesto that landowners need to be eliminated, along with the banking class (jews) and the aristocracy. In Cambodia virtually everyone was a landowner, and there fore according to Marx had to die, maybe thats one of the reasons people risk their lives to escape communist countries
@@andrewbclinton Pol Pot was a murderous authoritarian, not a socialist. His horrendous crimes were exposed in the UK by John Pilger - a socialist journalist. Your misreading of Marx appears wilful: eliminating upper classes who prey upon the rest of us does not mean killing them - the way that capitalism kills the poor by the million, yet you wrote nothing about that. It means taking political and economic steps to stop them gaining and possessing their undeserved wealth. You're welcome to defend those parasites all you like.
@@andrewbclinton Are you so unaware of the way the global system of capitalist trade works that you really don't know that corporations are engaged in a race to the bottom? Nations such as Vietnam, Cambodia, Bangladesh and many others have no power in trade deals, so they are forced to accept appallingly one-sided relationships with the USA/UK/EU. That leaves their welfare states, trade unions and other vital protections in shreds and their workers suffer dreadful conditions and pay too low to live on. We enjoy the benefits, meaning our societies are much more attractive to live in. Wouldn't you flee to here? The solution, obviously, is applying socialist principles of solidarity rather than competition and capitalism which have led to the vast and growing international and intra-national levels of inequality. Or are you saying the current system is equitable, fair and successful for us all?
Hardly debunked and acted as some counternance of the growing fears, hysteria and confusion to the migrant crossings.
At least 2 of her arguments I have proof of being false. Already shows how trust worthy is this channel...
Then provide the source or a link. It’s not much of an argument to state you have evidence, then fail to provide it.
fredalot. That’s literally the least offensive insult I’ve been called. I’m disappointed in you. 2/10.
fredalot. I certainly do. It’s pretty childish.
If its false show us ur "proof"
You mentioned women and children but the videos show none, nice emotional manipulation propaganda piece.
The Kalergi propaganda must go on regardless. She said herself she wants whites to be in the minority.
Ash I suggest you visit one of the hotels housing these men dressed exactly as you are in the video and then tell us honestly what the experience was like - maybe then you will understand what a lot of people are reporting is happening all over the country
She said smugly that they're winning, when minorities in London are growing and will soon outnumber whites. It's clear that she wants immigration and "win" over white people. So, I'd take anything she says as very biased to her political goals of winning *over* white people.
I thought all lives mattered
Conservatives being lying hypocrites? Imagine my shock.
These young men should be fighting in Syria not fleeing like cowards leaving the women and children behind
@@MrJonnyl123 Who should they fight?
@Daniel Parker Green asylum seekers aren't migrating illegally.
@Daniel Parker Green explain to me what they've done that's illegal.
Earlier today I saw my grandmother - who used to share Britain first when it was a thing - share a post complaining about asylum seekers 'getting everything for free' while elderly Britons have to pay television licensing fees. Said grandmother committed tax fraud for several years by living permanently in a holiday home which was against the terms she agreed to (and not small print, you had to sign something SPECIFICALLY to say you lived elsewhere and this was just a holiday home). After a whistle was blown, she moved into a very clean, tidy, roomy rented building with a front garden and as of today bought a flat for £40,000.
The people who are loudest about complaining about other people 'bankrupting the country and stealing through welfare' often have skeletons in the closet.
@@LiamE69 Literally the day I posted it; not sure precisely where.
Dragging your own gran in a youtube comment...
''bought a flat for 40k'' and that's how i knew you were lying.
carrying woman and children LOLOLOL
what i do not understand is why ,risk the channel ,from France
It's a good question, isn't it? And AS answers it in the video. Desperation leads to desperate behaviour, which some people can not understand.
@@misterbonzoid5623 desperation about what? France not being a safe country for asylum?
@@fibreguy42 Yes exactly. They are often housed in hideous conditions like in Calais.
@@scullocrusho so makes sense for UK govt to process asylum claims in France then
Good question. Why would anyone if they weren't put in a desperate situation? But yours is too clever a question for the commenters here.
Its not far right to say these illegal immigrants aren't welcome here in the UK. It's common sense.
I can guarantee this lady speaking here is privileged and any sort of immigration won't affect her, unlike the working class people who are sick of it all.
Population is a relevant factor for any country to consider. We are already a heavily populated country, especially England. Saying 'well there's loads of space' is absolutely infantile response because people require more than space. In fact, a modern Western person requires a colossal amount of resources.
Britain (the landmass) could never dream of being able to adequately meet its present population's resource needs right now, nevermind adding another five or ten million. That means we have to get those resources from somewhere else in the world, even if those places could use those resources themselves.
This doesn't mean we should end immigration, but the fact is that we need to have a structured immigration policy and that will include borders.
I don’t recall an argument for no borders.
What it means is our government needs to actually step up and develop and reform the economy and country so we DO have the resources we need. Our population is ageing and requires more working-age people to support the economy and the systems we depend on.
Whether they're born here or they immigrate, we need things in place so those people can live and thrive and be productive here. Saying "we don't have enough but SOME PEOPLE ARE FOREIGN" is a distraction from the core problem, we're not investing in our future
@@cactustactics having an ageing population is not a problem at all. Even if it was, the idea that it can be solved by simply adding more people to our population and further increasing our numbers would mean we'd have to expand our population for eternity. Never getting it under control.
Resources can't be conjured from nowhere. It's time to look at ourselves scientifically, as we would any other species, and assess what population an island like Britain can support in the long term. Esoteric arguments about it being people's 'right' to travel where they want or whatever mean nothing in the face of reality. If we overcrowd Britain it'll cause us all damage through environmental degredation in the long term.
@@Google-Account-hd5dk an economy based on infinite growth is a problem, yes - but that's what we have right now? So until we make fundamental changes, we're headed for trouble - because an ageing population means more of the people who require the most support, and less of the people who actually produce in the economy and provide the source of that support.
Any arguments about "the NHS can't support all these immigrants" are a cloak for the real issue - the NHS can't support our current population going forward. It needs investment, to provide for our population, whoever they are. And because it's the way our economy works, we need more working-age people producing the wealth to fund it. That's the reality of our current situation, not a hypothetical zero-growth economy
@@cactustactics an uncontrolled population is as large a problem as infinite economic growth. We don't 'need' any extra population to provide wealth or manpower required for elderly people's care, it's that statement which is actually a cloak for people to push their ideological sentiments.
I'm not talking about the NHS. I'm talking about a very small island called Britain and an even smaller country called England. These landmasses are absolutely incapable of feeding their populations if it came down to it being necessary (without massive farming innovations). I mean France and England have basically the same population and look at the difference in size. As Western purchasing power diminishes, as non European countries gain wealth, the UK and Britain will increasingly find that we can't simply get all the food we want from poorer countries' fertile land. Food is not even the most limited resource, we could go through every previous metal that is necessary for our present lifestyle of you want.
The baby boomers size as a percentage of the population is large but it is massively overstated. All it means is that elderly care will take up a larger portion of the economy while that generation is in later life. With some minor modifications the economy can easily handle it and once that generation has passed then things will return to normal.
Love this format. Breaking down a topical issue, removing the usual media facade and explaining it in simple, digestible terms. Keep it up, Novara!
Totally agree ZOD4. Incredible how it still does not break through the dissonance amongst many commentators in the comments section, population, land mass, resources etc etc. These arguments have been refuted and yet! And yet. Who hurt these people so deeply that their disdain clouds evidence based journalism?
@@sharminullah7111 we're the 7th most populated nation on the planet, per square mile. funny how that bit was left out isn't it?...
@@danielseaburg9763 eh? That's the Maldives according to the United Nations. Sorry this reply is late, only just seeing the TH-cam email in my junk mail! Shows you how much junk mail I have yikes.
I've seen that woman at 1.13 before, how does Question Time continue to allow these blatant audience member plants??
@Fred Ginn I think you're right!
@Fred Ginn but these sort of silly video content makers need the more rare extreme view holding types for soundbites to make it appear as if that's the general view.
Long live Farage, hip hip hurray 😉
"Remember, wagies! It's not I, the business owner, who's depressing your wages, leeching off government benefits, and enjoying the fruits of what you've made, it's those refugees with no money and no power!"
@Fred Ginn I don't think many business owners are leaving comments on Novara Media videos.
A company is lucky if it makes 2% profit per year. And is considered wildly successful if it does.
Let that sink in.
You seem to think a company makes thousands of % profit every year. They do not. Go start a business and see for yourself.
Uneducated fool.
@@danielseaburg9763 that boot must taste real good huh
i literally didnt mention profit margins at any point in my comment, and even if what you said was true (it isn't) my point would still stand
You have no idea what you're talking about
*me taking notes during this video so I can use them as talking points during dinner with my racist and right wing family*
We love to see it.
Which family, Jon Snow or the Targaryen lot?
what will you tell your family when they ask why nearly all the migrants in the boats seem to be young men?
@@chichikov617 is this that misandry I've been hearing so much about
Now now Breaker of chains your family aren't that bad your father the Mad King wasn't that bad...unlike you he didn't burn down King's Landing. You did that.
Question: does she offer some of these refugees to stay at her house?
A friend of mine is an asylum seeker. Shes a fabulously talented mathematician, but is forced to live in less than 40 pounds a week. Shes not even allowed to apply for jobs and use her knowledge to provide for herself. She lives in a hostel where shes even been the victim of theft, which sickens me to my core. She wasnt even able to buy a new phone to stay in contact with friends and family back home. Believe me people no one comes to the UK to claim asylum for financial gain. Who in their right mind would come halfway across the world, spend all their savings to be forced to live in less that 40 quid a week!?
this is the thing, these are people who are absolutely driven, survivors of terrible situations who have the determination to make a dangerous journey to a whole other place, uprooting their whole lives to try and make a better one. So many of them are skilled, educated, or just prepared to do whatever they can
Having these people in our society is a huge opportunity, in terms of productivity and what they can contribute. Instead they're being left to rot because our goverment wants to discourage anyone from coming here. Even in cold economic terms it's completely wasteful and makes no sense, but what's new
Well they seem to think the UK is better than France.
@@cactustactics Saudi Arabia and Kuwait is calling them
So much anger, she is sexually frustrated if you ask me.
Perhaps one of her much loved illegal immigrants will accommodate her
I wouldn't so full of crap
Perhaps it's you who is really. No-one else was thinking about that.
Servo, G4S and the traffickers are all benefiting from £££££££
We should help them
BIGGEST PAIN IN THE ARSE CHIP ON SHOULDER IN MODERN HISTORY 🤦♂️🙄
How many refugees she's taken into her house? Given money too on a weekly basis? And her financial situation?
Wow it's almost like we live in a society or something
Since you mention it fluke, I suppose you are volunteering to help these people? Or was your comment more a futile attempt at a "gotcha" moment?
It's not her place as an individual to invite people into her home. And no one is expecting you to do so either. But it is the responsibility of any country, with the means to do so, to help those seeking aid.
@Fred Ginn there's a difference working for childline to uploading a video telling the whole world britain is not accepting enough immigrants. Childline is for children already lives in the UK but did she research the number of available housing, strength of the econmy, benefits and etc. The government can afford to give out? Yeah, i'm sire they have billionsss in bank accounts here and there where do you think the money comes from to help keep small businesses and citizens losing everything they've got in a situation like I don't know...pandemic?
@@user-sq1le3jd8i Yes, i agree with you. Help those in need but Britain can only do so much. Why is she comparing Britain to other countries? Every nation has different strength and weaknesses the number of housing, cost of living and etc. Every first world country obviously has billions set a side that is most likely for british citizens when the entire country goes to shit.
@Fred Ginn you're right private individuals don't have to take in refugees themselves perhaps she could do it as a lesson to be learned. And i would ask her that to her face in the right situation
Ash is a national treasure..an actual one, not a soap star or unelected peer.
Turn them back there not needed or wanted there a proper channels to go through, how many maybe terrorist's not that she cares.
Watching from 2024, need more videos like this
Ah yes the girl who said Karl Marx was her "daddy" on this week's Jeremy Vine show.
@Fred Ginn Marx spent his entire life wasting his rich friend's money writing about crap he knew nothing about. He's never worked a day in his life, has never been a "labourer", but somehow has the audacity to write about class struggle when his own struggle has been arguably more gentle than any of the people in his works. He's completely overlooked several important points namely the interest of the worker and the owner and falsely believed that worker and the owner can't mutually benefit. If you're still buying in to Marxism after history has demonstrated again and again that human cannot exist without hiearchy then you're fucked in the head.
Plus, he was a racist. If George Washington can have his statue toppled for "owning slaves", if Churchill can be denounced by the radical lefts for being "racist", then we can certainly shit all over Marx for sharing the same worldview.
...🎤."Aaaand the winner ladies and gentleman, by facts in the first round .....DA Shaaaaaaw" 👊
@@dashaw3255 Just like George Brenard Shaw and all these BLM gangsters.
What a plank you are Sarker.😂😂😂😂
I bet she hasn't saved as many migrant lives as Nigel Farage has.
Would Ash be willing to house an illegal immigrants?
@Ash Sarkar, in this presentation you seem to be guilty of something that may comintators in this field present: coupling refugees with economic migrants. It is a pitty that you do this because in doing so you have failed to give a choerent argument in favour of either group of immigrants.
There is rarely a simple and clear difference. They are all people on the move, just like you did earlier in your existence on this planet. Yet you expected the freedom to do so, and you had that freedom because of the accident of where you were born. People have been moving around the planet as long as there have been people. The UK is composed of migrants and their descendants - you are one. Moving to a new place for a better life is natural.
@@musicandfilms9956 There is usually a clear and simple legal difference, conflating the two does not help explain the difference to those who do not understand what the difference is and may be xenophobic towards all incommers. I have been an immigrant to about half a dozen countries over the years (I have been a legal long term resident in them, not just a visitor), but I have never been a refugee and have never change my domicile.
@@firstlast7052 am I an economic migrant? Because I’m a doctor and I was born and educated in America. However, I had to take exams, apply for a visa, and pay taxes before becoming a British citizen.
Because if so, you are right.
My situation is different from these “refugees”
I fought for and earned my place and I contribute to British society not leech off it.
Tell these liberal assholes not to compare them to me. That’s an insult to every legal immigrant who works hard to make a life here and be accepted.
@@musicandfilms9956 don’t compare those leeches to me. I earned my place and fought for it.
I paid taxes got a background check and visa and didn’t collect welfare and took exams for my job as a doctor.
I didn’t have family here except my girlfriend who only became my wife after I became a citizen.
I did everything on my own and on my own money
@@Shadowdoc26 Which is sad, really, as you express no understanding, empathy or compassion for people in desperate situations - often caused by the history and current actions of the Western nations to which people are forced to flee. You didn't do "everything on my own and on my own money", anyway. You relied on a vast network of mostly state-funded or state-created infrastructure: roads, phones, health care, political systems, borders... We are all interdependent and if we claim otherwise, we delude ourselves and make our societies poorer.
Why ar u Talking about "Syrien refugees" And women And children while u show footage of black males on the boat? U think we ar that dump that we can't Tell the difference?
why dont you try and help build up and better their society so they have a country to be proud of ,instead of this unhelpful meaning less drivel you spout ,they will never be happy here ,we will never be happy that they (and you ) are here , this is only going to end badly ,for all concerned , you have no idea at all what have stirred up ,i have never heard so many people so angry about this ( and non in support of your view ) ,on the plus side i would like to thank you for continuing to stoke the fires of the nationalist cause , you and your far left chums are doing more to promote and change peoples ideas than we could ever dream of Thank you Ash Sarkar
It is incredible that you typed out all of that without Having a single coherent thought to begin with
I want open borders. I'm a white English bloke. You couldn't be more wrong.
@@musicandfilms9956 yea and check out whats just dropped on west yorkshire police web site , 32 men charged with child exploitation between 1999 and 2012 ,victims ranged from 13 to 16 years old ,guess what nationality and religion they are yes immigration wonderful
ash i do not think you are speaking for the majority of the ethnic people of the u.k who would like less immigrants in this country
no mate we're not all xenophobic
@@cactustactics i take it your going to adopt one of these gimmegrants and house and feed them ????
no thought not ...so i suppose the rest of us taxpayers will gave to foot the bill , we got enuff of our own living on the streets , they should be 1st priority , not any tom , dick or mohhamed that arrives here illegally
@@djcuts3628 oh you think the NHS is good do you ARE YOU GONNA PUT PATIENTS IN YOUR HOUSE no i didnt thINK so looks lik u think THE TAXPAYER SHoULDD BE FUNDING BASIC SERVCES LIKE THIS IS SOME KINd of "STATE" bet U think wealthy ppl shouLD BE PAYING MRE TOO AND INVESTMent in OThER THINGS INstead of autserity!!!! u couldnt make it up
@@cactustactics i think they should be put on the 1st boat back to france , what part ILLEGAL immergrant is that hard to understand ??????
@@cactustactics they never put a penny into the pot but expect every thing for free
Illegals not migrants
Ash makes some great points . the media will do what they need to get by .corruption of government contracts should be investigated , serco needs reigning in . but those people in that boat, I would guarantee are not Syrians . we in this country could do with getting this problem rationally debated and stop sensationalising immigration for the sake of prodding peoples buttons . its needed but not without some limitations .
*sees Ash, clicks the link*
Simp
So shes saying the housing crisis isn't because there arnt enough houses, its that not enough houses are being built, I really cannot be bothered to engage with the sheer level of rubbish in this video
just watch it again, you may get it the second time around. BTW, you can pause thevideo and even go back to listen to a part you did not get the first time around.
Obviously….it all goes over your head?? Until you’re ready to entertain the thought that Nige, Boris and Nick may be wrong!!
Piers Morgan sends his regards.
the only people who thinks who really wants this is a good idea is you , owen jones and that bloke over in frances who is doing a roaring trade selling dingeys
Reason for migrants coming hear should be addressed, cause and effect are the concern's. This is about politians that in the past and present are lacking, in the effects of sanctions and wars that are imposed; force the civilians of those lands to migrate. Criminal is the act of imposing poverty either by war, sanction, drugs, or famine.
@Dr Professor Then the human race would not exist.
@@andrewfranklin302 Your reply to a sensible comment is senseless.
talking about migrants while dressed like someone on a hen do,,,classy
Are those bell ends riding along side of those people in the inflatable, in an actual boat? And asking them how they're doing?
Yeah they're acting like they're interviewing the line for Britain's Got Talent because they want to push this idea that it's not extremely dangerous and people aren't risking their lives to get here. Makes it easier for people to dehumanise them and turn off their empathy
if your argument is just that they cross illegaly, not everything that is illegal is bad.
It's also explicitly allowed in UK case law dealing with refugees, this is the offical way to do it
We have no duty to obey unjust laws.
You put em in your house ash ........................yeah thought not
yeah nobody though that Neil, because it's dumb as hell
This woman has not a clue
Yes your mama will be proud of you for sure dressing up like that acting like that.
Ha! U should see her IG!
@@nishachatwani7840 Seen enough. Pure hypocrites. Just trying to squeeze another dollar out of us somehow.
Independent media doing the job the mainstream SHOULD be doing, yet again. Fantastic.
Love this
"The literal communist" At it again. Sigh.
are you lost
Migration has been very detrimental to the culture in Rotherham over the last couple of decades.
Theyshould be quiet for the sake of Diversity.
But I bet you don't say that when you're down your local curry house or Chinese takeaway, do you?
@@Marvhead
You most definitely can’t say that in curtain circles. That is the problem that allowed the flourishing of the grooming gangs local to me.
Don’t say that it’s racist
Really like Novara Media videos. I'm not a Labour supporter, but like to listen to different opinions. The main critique I have of this video, is that it's quite one sided. I think it would be also good to address some of the problems that immigration may cause e.g. poor assimilation into British culture (in some cases). By acknowledging such problems and suggest solutions, it will strengthen your arguement.
I think you're missing the point of the video.
@@Priority76 I agree with you actually. The video does what it says on the tin. However, there are genuine issues with having immigrants from war torn countries jumping on boats to enter to UK illegally. I think these should have been adressed too, to give a better overall picture of what's going on.
@@blindedbythenoise3107 Yeah I'd say if people are having to move out of their country en masse because it's so fucked, there are some massive issues going on. I think if the thing that bothers you is the people coming here won't 'assimilate into British culture' you have to have a bit of a think about you're attitude towards this. There are a ton of videos about the negatives of people immigrating to the UK, if that's the sort of thing you want to watch. It's pretty much all bollocks though.
@@Priority76 I disagree with you. I'm not saying that we should not show compassion to these desperate people. I cant begin to imagine what they have to deal with. That said, we can't also accept that such activities do not cause some problems. Im actually in support of supporting such people, but it needs to be done in the correct way. Also, even if you disregard my opinion, remember we live in a democracy and there are people who have alot more uninformed and far right views than me. I'm not even right wing. If you disregard certain concerns in videos like this, they will turn their noses up at it, like you have done to me.
@@blindedbythenoise3107 I agree with you, to an extent. But to be honest I don't think it's even really possible anymore to change people' minds on these issues anymore. I think you have people who have compassion and will want to welcome and help these refugees and you have those who want to stick barbed wire fences in the English channel. And probably not many people in the middle. I'm not disregarding your opinion I just think assimilating into British culture is such a non issue. It's like if your friends house exploded and he needed somewhere to stay and you said no because he likes watching football and you don't.
Well said Ash, I think the quote a few years ago was 1,000,000 vacant homes in the UK to gouge the rents of those that are being let. The same people, private landlords, being the beneficiaries of housing benefit and council tax holidays for vacant properties. I'm not sure how much private landlords gross in housing benefit across the UK but I'm sure it would be far more than what 4,000 migrants would get.
Jesus christ this comment section is a pit of great replacement racist bile. While you guys are here, why not subscribe and watch more of the Novara's back catalogue so you can start the policy and history education you need to become decent members of society? I can't promise that it will lead to your wife taking you back, but at the very least it should result in less of your friends and family giving you a wide berth and glazing over when you speak to them about immigrants at social gatherings.
Imagine thinking these London urbanites can educate anyone. The owner of them gets humiliated on twitter weekly.
@@tvrtvr6984 I'm not sure who or what you are referring to, but I would suggest watching the start of tonight's Tyskie Sour show. They had an immigration expert on as a guest and discussed the current situation, the tragic death of the child who drowned today and policy ideas for how to solve the problem. Since you're already here commenting on a Novara video about immigration you might find it more productive to watch a more detailed discussion with policy proposals.
well said Ash and thank you
these comments are horrid
Just a wild assumption but i'm betting none of them are qualified Doctors or Dentists much less speak English. The real valued immigration to the UK comes through the proper legal channels not via the English channel by dinghy! All that's coming here is trouble. I value the services provided by immigration to this land by aforementioned skilled people since either the pay is too low or we are incapable of training our own?(time that was sorted) But be under no illusion folks these dingy invaders are not coming here to fix your teeth nor help us operate on cancer. Latest poll suggests that 100% of foreign NHS workers did not arrive by dingy!
alot of reactionary cringe lords in the comment sections
lol
imagine being a dumbass denying the white replacement
@@mozhem_povtorit Imaging being the dimwit thinking that is even a thing.
@@baronmeduse ...imagine not knowing white population is declining in all white nations
or thinking it's a good thing
Man I love her
Careful with the Tramadol man that shit is legit
These young men should be fighting in Syria not fleeing like cowards. We should only take the women, children, over 50s and disabled
The bloke complaining about asylum seekers taking railway jobs sounded like Barry Shitpeas.
@Ana Assburgian Compared to the alternative, right-wing 'journalists' who just gorp and point at a shit situation, reporting, thinking and inferring what they are told to by the rich and powerful, Novara is by far the least idiotic of them all.
you are free to leave the uk at any time i will even volunteer to pack your bags and take you to the airprt and buy you a one way ticket
Thank you for your input Sheri.
I bet, if you met any recent migrant, you'd change your mind. They're people just like you and your family.
Not much actually disgusts me but standing on a ship and asking migrants on dingys if they’re ok is one😞
wait til you hear about their crimes of ''enriching'' children over here......if some words disgust you....then don't look into it.
Wow. She doesn’t even try to hide the contempt she has towards the United Kingdom.
The British government isn't the United Kingdom, it's a small percentage of the wealthy.
Yoh the racists and xenophobes are all over this comment section.
Love your content - Novara is paving the way for incisive British journalism. The BBC seems like a tool of government these days.
The BBC are anti-British, anti white, marxists. Regardless of who is in power.
See the thing is most people in this country won't watch Novara as this channel is way too intelligent putting forward intelligence and well articulated arguments.
So intelligent they look at a dingy with all males in it and see women and children, thats only a skill those with very high intelligence can do.
@@tvrtvr6984 oh I guess you are amongst those with no intelligence than hay?
@@tvrtvr6984 the reporter literally says there are women on board.
@@user-zm8xv8tl2l fuck that the examining board's algorithms might down grade me
@@whynottyg7250 no I don't think I will so...
Keep on doing what your doing Ash, You are brilliant .
How does she know where they come from..why not stay in France
Turkey is in Europe!?
5% of it including Istanbul is
Very biased, strange view on reality.
"Waiting for the Tramydol to kick in"
Brilliant.
Yet they apperantly burn down barracks
Spot on as always Ash :)
1:18
Some people might not know what shadwell baisin is....