"Had Mao died in 1956, his achievements would have been immortal. Had he died in 1966, he would still have been a great man but flawed. But he died in 1976. Alas, what can one say?" -Chen Yun
@@wheresmyeyebrow1608 did you think that this video provides accurate info? im sorry but this is just the average western viewpoint on mao zedong, fueled with propaganda.
my father grew up in the immediate aftermath of the Great Leap Forward and during the Cultural Revolution and he's told me those were particularly hard and bitter times
There is always somebody with "histories" and tales in this kind of video 🤣.... Of course, all those Chinese and farmers that were happy with Mao are going to be a 100% ignored in order to create the anti China narrative 😊
If only the western powers actually left China alone, none of these socialists states would have ever had to go into the defensive to protect themselves from capitalist influence, the thing that brought ruin to their country, exploited and contributed to the whole communist revolution in China and some other countries.
@@NeostormXLMAX the loss of historical artifacts and records has no positive. It is a horrendous removal from the ability to more effectively study history.
Communism says that art work is an illusion built by the bourgeoisie to distract the working class from destroying capitalism. Yes, it’s that horrendously stupid.
that's most likely a lie, clearly this video is biased and cites no sources, it's mostly fiction for the anti-china industrial complex that exists in the west
The problem with anything Chinese history related is that the numbers tend to be alot bigger compared to the rest of the world the 100 years war between France and England had tiny death tolls compared to even 1 of China's civil wars.
These videos are genius. It starts with 1 million dead in China, then 5 million. Finally 20 million people. Now it's 80 million. Genius.Is there 80 million people in France now?😂
The numbers are pulled out of the ass of rabid anti CCP types. If you look at how they arrived at 80m is by counting falling birth rates as deaths then projecting that forward so saying 80m would exist today without mobilization or these policies. The death rate during the GLF was barely even above India's. 24 v 25 per 1000
The foot binding practice has been officially banned by the Chinese government since the established of the Republic. It was not very effective, but the ban has been gradually become more acted throughout the country.
@@wingkeungkong415 No? I think they were talking about such a new ridiculous low for revolutions, killing people based on telling a mango is a mango, far from helping anyone.
@@wingkeungkong415 Tell that to the Quiet Revolution, the Velvet Revolution, the Euromaidan, the Color Revolutions, the Jasmin Revolution, the Revolution that ended the junta in Myanmar and communist rule in Mongolia, the Revolutions that led to the independence of nations like in the Baltics. Reality is unkind to absolutes.
On the note of steel production during the GLF, I remember reading a story about how Mao visited his home village during the campaign and was saddened that a large wooden Buddha statue in the village center he loved growing up was torn down and burned to help meet his steel quota. Just an interesting note on the more human side of an otherwise brutal authoritarian.
My friend's grand parents were doctors during Mao's reign, and got the hell out of China asap. She has a huge dislike for Communism and refuses to visit main land China.
And where they were funded? BTW Pol pot and his commies were supplied and supported by NV, Mao China and soviets, they helped to bring Cambodia to comm*nism and kept friends when they were genocided their ppl and invaded only when they were attacked first. It was murica who tried to stop them, and it was NV who helped them to rise power in the first place. If NV didn't help Pol pot and his cummies they wouldn't genocided in the first place commie scum
I LOVE YOUR VIDEOS. Please keep this series going forever. I absolutely love this series and have watched previous episodes multiple times. Please more of this series and please don't stop at 10. Please make 100s for this series
@@RESTITVTOR_TOTIVS_HISPANIAE fricken pick a name. Compared to any leader that has never starved or extra-judicially murdered millions of their citizens. 23 million of those deaths weren’t even out of malice, just a consequence of bad agricultural and economic policy.
From discussions with Chinese colleagues about their education and learning about Mao, apparently they learn that it was a massive tragedy but that he had 'good intentions'
@@RESTITVTOR_TOTIVS_HISPANIAE lol interesting you could have that opinion when even people I've met who were raised in China on Chinese propaganda don't see Mao's 'good results'. Deng Xiaoping fixed Mao's massive failure if anything
Hey jabzy have you ever considered making a video on saudi arabia on it's start the finding of oil and the conflict between the communist governments and the monarchies ?
@@JabzyJoe this period of history is very interesting. My favourite part about it is how the exiled house of Saud made such a tremendous comeback despite exile to Kuwait. There’s still a spear tip in the walls of one of the buildings Ibn Saud helped to take (it was lodged in during a battle he was a part of) What I really find to be under appreciated in this period is the settlement of the nomadic Bedouins and their role in Saudi society. From the Ikhwan militias to the taken of the grand mosque in the 70s, their impact has been large.
Post WWI Arabia seems ok, until you realize behind the big 5 (Jabal Shamar, Nedj/Saudi, Asir, Yemen and the Hejaz/Hashemite) there were about 27 different tribes. That gets complicated, especially when you mix in the British!
Good video Jabzy, but one misleading point in it I noticed. At 6:28, the quote of Mao saying 'when there is not enough to eat, people starve to death. It is better to let half of the people die so that the other half can eat their fill'. This was said 5 years before Yellow River Flood it's presented alongside, and is a metaphor for industrial production rather than anything food-related. It's meant to mean that their industrial plan should focus resources on a smaller number of projects, rather than spreading their resources too thinly.
as a Vietnamese, i would like to see how some historian depict my country. VCP and VNQDD made numerous mistaken during their rule that was costly to the people. Modern Vietnam share some character of the lesser year but people trying to bring up event that happen decade ago as a reason to tear down the progress made by the people is stupid at time. Learning from previous mistake is a important factor in growing and developing a nation, learning from past mistake is important for the newer generation to strengthen our future.
Some facts may be "controversial", but in general, your understanding of Chinese history is amazing! edit: for example it seems that China is responsible for not recognizing the McMahon line (around 15:55). Actually India pass the McMahon line before the war as well. China did try it best to maintain peace on the border. It's up to you to decide whether it was good enough.
@@PossessedPotatoBird Much more people were born than were killed in China under Mao. We don't know if things would have been better without Mao, but most people in China are benefitting from his legacy. 80 million death (or whatever the death toll is) is indeed a terrible price to pay, but it has already been paid, so there are many Chinese people who are content with enjoying what has already been paid for.
@@PossessedPotatoBird The population of China in 1850 is 430 million, which means that population grew by 28% in the 100 years before Mao. In comparison, in the 25 years under Mao, population grew by 64%. Population growth in China under Mao is among the fastest in Chinese history, largely due to industrialization and modernization. On the other hand, many people actually thought such a rapid growth in population was a bad thing, ergo the post-Mao one-child policy.
@@user-uh8fu3mb9l don’t waste your time, those westerners or west worshippers will always say « China BAD ». They hate the chinese deeply and are hypocrites who only seek the downfall of the chinese.
It's all just propaganda, for example he blames the locusts on the pest campaign against the sparrows without mentioning that the sparrows themselves were an invasive species that was also a plague on the fields while they still used traditional seed casting methods. And while the pest campaign contributed to the locusts, plagues of locusts have arisen throughout history without any pests campaigns. He also makes no mention of China's long history with famine, and just darts over the year long drought and the flooding of the yellow river which drowned over a million people, washed away stockpiles of food, and drowned the fields. Both of these events were devastating. He also mentions Lysenkoism (close cropping) without mentioning that the KMT had been experimenting with a variety of agricultural methods in different regions as part of an effort to modernize China's agriculture. All the blame is placed on Mao for continuing experiments that were already under way when the revolution happened. Some of those experiments proved disastrous and others beneficial He also says Mao didn't want to know about the famine but when he realized he was being fed faulty reports he started traveling to the affected areas and sending people to study everything they could possibly learn to solve the famine and prevent the next one. And the video says 80 million died but that's a completely made up number from the black book of communism, the actual number of deaths from the famine were around 15 million, and can fluctuate up and down a few depending on what criteria is deemed appropriate. Similar famines had occurred throughout China's history but what made the great famine different was that it affected the whole mainland all at the same time. This guy's basically just an anti-communist liberal who read the Black Book of Communism and took everything in it at face value without doing any additional research or scrutinizing it, so you may as well just listen to that on audiobook. Two of the authors cited on the cover denounced it btw, and said the author who put it together was obsessed with exaggerating death tolls to get the highest numbers possible.
We love these videos - I use them to teach Chinese people - so much we do not know about China and I am loving learning. Such a complex world we live - To understand history is to hopefully create understanding
Xi is working on his own cult of personality now. This didn’t work out well last time. A buddy of mine had a professor who had been sent to a farm during the CR. His take, “ it was stupid”
“If history teaches us anything, it is simply this: every revolution carries within it the seeds of its own destruction. And empires that rise will one day fall.” - Princess Irulan (Dune, Frank Herbert)
I must disagree with this France revolution did not destroy France Just made France became the biggest power in European Chinese revolution just make China become the biggest power in Asia Maybe later the world
If you look at deaths on a per capita basis, the famines caused by the great leap forward are one of the smaller mass death events in history. Any huge disasters in China are like that, kills millions but barely felt by 98-99% of people. On the other hand, the deadliest man made catastrophe in history (per capita) would be the Great Potato Famine, which killed 1/5th the population of Ireland, displaced another 1/5th, and essentially destroyed the Gaelic language and much of Irish culture. It's probably one of the most devastating ethnic genocides in history, despite its "low" body count. The population of ireland still has not recovered.
The great leap forward resulted with over 10% of the population dying, this was rapidly recovered from because the one child policy was not implemented until 1980 and prior to it China had a birthrate similar to sub-Saharan Africa and the 90%(ish) of the survivors of the Great Leap tended to have much longer lifespans and so the population resumed growth almost immediately. Still, 10% death is something you don't normally see in a nation during peace time outside of a plague and was completely unnecessary and inhumane.
You should do an entire video dedicated to documenting various influential academic, political, and cultural figures who ignorantly (at best) kept singing of Mao, his regime, and his movements’ praises.
I find it funny that while many autocrats blame the U.S. for buying civil activists and academics to stand against their government, they usually do exactly that to the U.S.
Ignorantly? There's a reason Mao is praised to this day, China was in a terrible position before the revolution and it massively improved after it. You can't expect the revolution to magically fix every problem that dates back countless dynasties in a day
@AceFromGorillaz Mao was dead before the limited yet effective market reforms of the 80s and then in the 90s especially. So, no, they're just bubble world living scumbags.
Although Mao’s purpose in criticizing The dismissal of Hai Rui was to purge Peng Zhen, the mayor of Beijing, the play was actually written by Wu Han, then deputy mayor of Beijing and a renowned historian specializing in Ming history. He was a sycophant of Mao and at first praised by Mao for this work but ironically became the first victim of the cultural revolution.
Your history and particularly your drawings are excellent and I hadn’t seen you in my feed and I just assumed that you put something negative about China or did something else that the sensor that TH-cam frowned upon. I’m sorry you have to go through that.
Can you please make a video about the Iron Guard as well? It's one of the most weird fascist movements in my opinion. It combined the nazi ideology with christianity and had a death cult. But I only have surface level knowledge.
Huh? A death is a death. These comments saying the great leap forward was 'not that bad/impactful' are utterly bizarre and kind of disgusting. You do realize that Mao's "mismanagement" consisted of executing all political dissenters and academics, and causing, without any good reason whatsoever, the deadliest famine in history, right? You make it seem like Mao and the Chinese government at the time had no way of knowing that they were killing off tens of millions of people by mass starvation.
The truth is that: Great leap forward: 55 million kills. Cultural revolution: 20 million kills. Landlord murder under mao: 25 million. Total: 100 million.
Getting a high body count in China is a bit easy tho with the massive population. Their regional rebellions have a higher kill count than some international wars.
What is your point? Sorry but your comment seems to imply that Mao's genocide is not a big deal or that Mao was not that bad of a dictator since China has a large population, which makes no sense.
I think this era was definitely one of the darkest periods of Chinese modern history but my dad says the stability and peace they got was much preferable than the chaotic warlord era and the Japanese occupation area that his dad had to endure; and that while there were so many needless deaths, the populace grew so substantially that they had to implement the one child policy a few decades later. it’ll be very interesting to see the next period of Chinese history in this series!
It is made up. They do it by countering LOWERING BIRTH RATES as deaths. This many people weren't born because they started working in urban jobs or because of mobilization. They in bad faith count those as deaths. The statistics are there, the death rate during the GLF was the same level as India's at the time. In fact Mao had lowered death rates from mid 40:1000 to 10:1000 so he in reality saved millions of lives. The death rate for GLF is 25:1000 India's was 24:1000
Actually, the death of ordinary Chinese people is not a big issue. The key point is that almost all foreign-educated technical experts who returned to China and university professors who did not follow the Kuomintang to Taiwan died during the Cultural Revolution. Some committed suicide, while others were tortured to death. In many famous Chinese universities, there are memorial halls displaying the photos of those who founded the schools or made outstanding contributions to them. Although their birth dates are different, their death dates are exactly the same. Therefore, after China's reform and opening up, they could only seek technology imports from the West and Japan, as there were virtually no people with basic academic backgrounds in the entire country at that time, having been wiped out during the Cultural Revolution. As a result, the Chinese began to continuously acquire technology through various means, as there was no foundation for research and development. In fact, most Chinese people cannot reflect on the Cultural Revolution and even believe that it was necessary for making China strong. What you see and hear now are mainly the descendants of the perpetrators from that time. Those who had even the slightest dissenting opinions or knowledge and culture from the old era were all killed by these people. Opposing the Cultural Revolution is essentially equivalent to criticizing all Chinese people. Only the descendants of those who do not understand history may have some resentment towards the Cultural Revolution.
lol wtf, 80mil? my dad was born in 1956 and grew up during both the great leap foward and the cultural revolution and although he's told me alot about how even low quality noodles were only reserved for the most special occasions (meat being completely out of the question) the death count is nowhere near as high as people nowadays say it is always interesting to see americans who have never stepped foot on chinese soil in their entire lives act like theyve been through it all in youtube comment sections though
Generally speaking, estimates for total death toll in big tragedies like this become higher the more information is learned. Early estimates usually just include the number of specific individuals which documents describe as having died from the tragedy, and this is crudely extrapolated to the people who weren't well documented as well. But oftentimes, the best-documented people were the least badly hit by tragedy, so that as we learn more about the previously lesser studied populations, our estimate goes up. After that, there's an even bigger thing: Tragedies create ripple effects causing even more deaths, but its difficult to trace any SINGLE person's death to that. For example, my Great Uncle had COPD and died in a hospital, because it was during the height of the recent pandemic so all respirators were taken by COVID patients. If you just count people killed by COVID, my uncle wouldn't be listed. But it is nearly certain that the COVID pandemic indirectly caused or at least contributed to his death. In the past two decades or so, scholars have started to estimate these sorts of indirect deaths and include them in their approximate totals. Looking specifically at The Campaign to Suppress Counter-Revolutionaries, the earliest estimates coming out shortly after Mao's death placed the death toll at about 0.7 million. But as additional previously covered-up deaths were identified, new documents became available to researchers, and deaths from abysmal treatment in slave labor camps were included, that estimate today sits at somewhere between 2 and 5 million--at least 3 times and potentially as much as 7 times higher than what was initially thought. The % increase in death tolls for the Great Famine and Cultural Revolution aren't quite as drastic as those of The Campaign to Suppress Counter-Revolutionaries, but they have increased for for very similar reasons. This isn't unique to discussion of Chinese History. Estimated death tolls for events as variable in nature as The Holocaust, The Black Death, Hurricane Katrina, the US Invasion of Iraq, and British Colonization of India, have all increased over the past years and decades. There isn't a global and/or ""western"" conspiracy to inflate the number of people killed through Mao's totalitarianism and dysfunctional governance. Nor is there a conspiracy to inflate the numbers killed by any other mass-death events. It's just that scholars have more information than they did earlier, and include indirect deaths which had previously been swept under the rug.
I gonna say though. I'm glad I'm American and didn't experience the 3rd world shithole that was China. I would be homeless in the streets and still better off than the average Chinese peasant
@p00bix 'scholars' use "people that were never born" to inflate the death toll, so yes, it is a deliberate way to inflate the numbers. It's, quite frankly, the most glaring thing people always omit when talking about the Great Leap Forward. If we use the same methodology for European Colonisation of the Americas, the death toll for Native Americans would be in the billions, much like how the Indian death toll under British rule was over 1.8 billion. It's absolutely absurd. Just count the deaths as is, which I suspect is in the low millions because if it was any higher, China's population could not have possibly reached 1 billion by the 1970s. If we look at the previous wars in Chinese history that killed over 20 million people, the population always stagnated for over a century. And here, we are expected to believe 80 million people died when China's population was around 550 million. So, essentially, by 1965, China population should have dipped below 470 million. But, instead, it swelled to nearly a billion.
@@Russo-Delenda-Est Americans also heard about imaginary WMDs and killed 500 000 civilians for it. Wouldn't trust what one says or hears for the life of me.
Shop owners making a quick buck by cashing in on current trends sounds rather capitalist to me, as does exporting massive amounts of produce for profit
State capitalism. All of this was motivated and justified for the need for economic growth. Same thought process as capitalist repression, just less abstracted and more explicit.
"State capitalism" is, by definition, an oxymoron. Capitalism is when the means of production are privately owned. When the state owns the means of production, there is no private ownership; therefore, what communist apologists call state capitalism makes no sense. It's simply authoritarian collectivism, that is legitimized through the collectivist ideology of communism.
40% time in ideological education doesnt lead to good soldiering. What is more I have a feeling that today, tho the army swears loyalty to the party the soldiers actually feel loyal to China their country not the government.
Absolute power and all of that. There is a reason many early leftist thinkers were against one man rule. But naturally, such thinking was ignored in favour of great man unity, and we got the terrible executions of what should have been grand leftist revolutions leading to terrible suffering.
Why doesn't CCP disclose the figures? The 80 million comes from the statistics of the number of abnormal deaths. In my hometown, only one village survived in one county, and all of them starved to death. People ate people, corpses, and soil. Still 90% of Chinese people worship him because of government blocking information and brainwashing
It was also the era with fastest population growth and increase in life expectancy thanks to rural healthcare programs. Deng Xiaoping era saw increase infant deaths and lower life expectancy in countryside because of end of village doctors and focus on the cities
But every country saw that in the post-war years. For example Iraq saw faster life expectancy gains from 1950-79 until the Iran-Iraq war and didn't have a massive famine
I recommend people learn more about Chiang Kai-shek's regime and the White Terror in KMT-held Taiwan. At least have some balance in looking at the history at the time of the OP video. Same advice goes for today.
![[Full] อังคารคลุมโปง Close Up EP.49 | คนใกล้ผีคนที่ 49 : หมอฉุกเฉิน “หมอบอส” (Thai Sub)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/dKPUaX7UxMQ/mqdefault.jpg)
![CAMPปลิ้น | EP.76[1/2] โจโฉเปิดป่าโหดรับโอ๊ต-ป๊อบ รอบนี้พี่เอาจริง!](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/pNg5O7Pf-a0/mqdefault.jpg)
"Had Mao died in 1956, his achievements would have been immortal. Had he died in 1966, he would still have been a great man but flawed. But he died in 1976. Alas, what can one say?"
-Chen Yun
This is like what they used to describe Hitler. Something about if he died prior to invading Poland his legacy would've been legendary.
@@EroPantherH wait seriously? Who said that?
@@tavla123 Did you not watch the video?
@@wheresmyeyebrow1608 did you think that this video provides accurate info? im sorry but this is just the average western viewpoint on mao zedong, fueled with propaganda.
@@BlueTyphoon2017 Chen Yun, one of the 8 major leaders of Chinese Communist Party alongside Deng Xiaoping in 80s,
-10,000,000 social credit
-80 million social credits.
- 10000000000000000 social credit
-1 trillion social credits (in yuan)
Hahahahaha
Damn, by that standard, a single Chinese citizen isn't worth even a single peice of social credit...oof
my father grew up in the immediate aftermath of the Great Leap Forward and during the Cultural Revolution and he's told me those were particularly hard and bitter times
Thank you for sharing. Unimaginable the ill ur family went through. My family is Irish and came to the the US during their terrible famine.
Glad to know he survived
Western propaganda ramping up 😂..... Probably because China is becoming a super power that threats the US hegemony.
There is always somebody with "histories" and tales in this kind of video 🤣.... Of course, all those Chinese and farmers that were happy with Mao are going to be a 100% ignored in order to create the anti China narrative 😊
Sure he did .sure
The sheer cultural destruction and loss of historical artifacts is unforgivable.
If only the western powers actually left China alone, none of these socialists states would have ever had to go into the defensive to protect themselves from capitalist influence, the thing that brought ruin to their country, exploited and contributed to the whole communist revolution in China and some other countries.
Some of it was good but yeah it was a disaster
However the problem is I don’t believe such a massive casualties count was possible it has undoubtedly been exaggerated by the west
@@NeostormXLMAX the loss of historical artifacts and records has no positive. It is a horrendous removal from the ability to more effectively study history.
Communism says that art work is an illusion built by the bourgeoisie to distract the working class from destroying capitalism.
Yes, it’s that horrendously stupid.
"When one man said they looked like potatoes, he was executed". Living in China during those times must have been bizarre.
Nowaday is much better than those old times but still worse than western world
it's over.
that's most likely a lie, clearly this video is biased and cites no sources, it's mostly fiction for the anti-china industrial complex that exists in the west
No it didn’t my grandparents miss the old time, today she said there are too many black people in china……I can assure u this 80 million is a fantasy
@@kaslanakiana3927 I haven't met a racist who didn't think the past was better. It comes as part of the package I suppose.
The problem with anything Chinese history related is that the numbers tend to be alot bigger compared to the rest of the world the 100 years war between France and England had tiny death tolls compared to even 1 of China's civil wars.
These videos are genius. It starts with 1 million dead in China, then 5 million. Finally 20 million people. Now it's 80 million. Genius.Is there 80 million people in France now?😂
The numbers are pulled out of the ass of rabid anti CCP types. If you look at how they arrived at 80m is by counting falling birth rates as deaths then projecting that forward so saying 80m would exist today without mobilization or these policies. The death rate during the GLF was barely even above India's. 24 v 25 per 1000
Did you consider the fact that China has always had a bigger population? Meaning more people were involved in the fighting??
Bullshit, there were 200 million people in China back then. Now there are 1.4 billion people.
Chinese history since Qin Empire. Before that, Zhuxia was decentralized and warfare was limited, governed by rules of engagement
Can't wait for next episode when Deng Xiaoping becomes the main character
Well basically he was the sad decline in between
I can't believe you spoil the video just like that smh
@@ichsagnix4127 Tianmen Massacre?
@@P4Tri0t420 nope, more like market liberalisation.
@@ichsagnix4127 cope.
The foot binding practice has been officially banned by the Chinese government since the established of the Republic. It was not very effective, but the ban has been gradually become more acted throughout the country.
i can't believe wow_mao would do this 😭😭😭😭
This is anti-intellectual video😂
thug shaker central
do you care when West killed millions of communist?
@@haochengzhai7156why, too much truth about it?
@@johner3364 YOU DIDNT HAVE TOCUUUTTT ME OFFF
This series just keep getting longer and longer. Hopefully we can reach the modern day!
and better too!
Vive le Québec!
It’s wild that simply saying that a mango looks like a potato is enough grounds to justify an execution.
all based on a religion of mangoes.
This thing happen in the France revolution too
You probably Do not know what is a revolution
@@wingkeungkong415 No? I think they were talking about such a new ridiculous low for revolutions, killing people based on telling a mango is a mango, far from helping anyone.
@@Game_Hero ' revolution is all like that
Including The France n Russia revolution
@@wingkeungkong415 Tell that to the Quiet Revolution, the Velvet Revolution, the Euromaidan, the Color Revolutions, the Jasmin Revolution, the Revolution that ended the junta in Myanmar and communist rule in Mongolia, the Revolutions that led to the independence of nations like in the Baltics. Reality is unkind to absolutes.
On the note of steel production during the GLF, I remember reading a story about how Mao visited his home village during the campaign and was saddened that a large wooden Buddha statue in the village center he loved growing up was torn down and burned to help meet his steel quota. Just an interesting note on the more human side of an otherwise brutal authoritarian.
Aaw what a sentimental human
J/k may he be donkey raped in hell for all eternity.
kinda ironic considering the cultural revolution that came thereafter.
You use “Authoritarian” as if there’s ever been a libertarian state anywhere.
@@soggmeisterlasagnagarfield That isn't implied or suggested by the comment.
@@SavageHenry777 It is
Thank you for making such fantastic content!
My friend's grand parents were doctors during Mao's reign, and got the hell out of China asap. She has a huge dislike for Communism and refuses to visit main land China.
Based.
She's smarter than most people today.
You mean communist occupied mainland Twain.
@@long-hair-dont-care88. Mark Twain
Good and stay the fuck out
@Yibay Exactly what I was thinking.
Khmer Rouge had to be inspired by something from China
And where they were funded? BTW Pol pot and his commies were supplied and supported by NV, Mao China and soviets, they helped to bring Cambodia to comm*nism and kept friends when they were genocided their ppl and invaded only when they were attacked first. It was murica who tried to stop them, and it was NV who helped them to rise power in the first place. If NV didn't help Pol pot and his cummies they wouldn't genocided in the first place commie scum
The dumbest western 😂
I LOVE YOUR VIDEOS. Please keep this series going forever. I absolutely love this series and have watched previous episodes multiple times. Please more of this series and please don't stop at 10. Please make 100s for this series
Great content!
The culture revolution shows nicely why you should never abandon beauty as a way to gauge health.
Another great video as always!
New Jabzy video poggers
Amazing how unfit Mao was for actual statecraft.
Compared to whom?
@@RESTITVTOR_TOTIVS_HISPANIAE fricken pick a name. Compared to any leader that has never starved or extra-judicially murdered millions of their citizens. 23 million of those deaths weren’t even out of malice, just a consequence of bad agricultural and economic policy.
All socialists are.
@@RESTITVTOR_TOTIVS_HISPANIAE If you want a comparison with leaders of the socialist world at the time: Tito? Castro?
@@Saurophaganax1931 I genuinely think communists don't care about that stuff. They will sacrifice whatever needs to be sacrificed for the utopia
From discussions with Chinese colleagues about their education and learning about Mao, apparently they learn that it was a massive tragedy but that he had 'good intentions'
It isn't about "good intentions", it is about good results and the fact that this 80 million number is entirely a fantasy.
@@RESTITVTOR_TOTIVS_HISPANIAE lol interesting you could have that opinion when even people I've met who were raised in China on Chinese propaganda don't see Mao's 'good results'. Deng Xiaoping fixed Mao's massive failure if anything
@@RESTITVTOR_TOTIVS_HISPANIAE indeed
@@RESTITVTOR_TOTIVS_HISPANIAE A fantasy pretty much made up by the alt-right capitalist.
I hope xi xinping also show his good intentions to Chinese people.
Hey jabzy have you ever considered making a video on saudi arabia on it's start the finding of oil and the conflict between the communist governments and the monarchies ?
Thinking the next big series will be on the Middle East from after WW1
@@JabzyJoe this period of history is very interesting. My favourite part about it is how the exiled house of Saud made such a tremendous comeback despite exile to Kuwait.
There’s still a spear tip in the walls of one of the buildings Ibn Saud helped to take (it was lodged in during a battle he was a part of)
What I really find to be under appreciated in this period is the settlement of the nomadic Bedouins and their role in Saudi society. From the Ikhwan militias to the taken of the grand mosque in the 70s, their impact has been large.
@@JabzyJoe I think doing a series on the muslim world from the 1700s would be good.
@@mrttripz3236 I read about the spear from the book house of said great book about Saudi Arabia
Post WWI Arabia seems ok, until you realize behind the big 5 (Jabal Shamar, Nedj/Saudi, Asir, Yemen and the Hejaz/Hashemite) there were about 27 different tribes. That gets complicated, especially when you mix in the British!
Good video Jabzy, but one misleading point in it I noticed. At 6:28, the quote of Mao saying 'when there is not enough to eat, people starve to death. It is better to let half of the people die so that the other half can eat their fill'. This was said 5 years before Yellow River Flood it's presented alongside, and is a metaphor for industrial production rather than anything food-related. It's meant to mean that their industrial plan should focus resources on a smaller number of projects, rather than spreading their resources too thinly.
You are fighting the unfalsifiable orthodoxy that is anti-communism. Good luck with that.
A video(s) on the Vietnamese revolution would be great!
as a Vietnamese, i would like to see how some historian depict my country.
VCP and VNQDD made numerous mistaken during their rule that was costly to the people.
Modern Vietnam share some character of the lesser year but people trying to bring up event that happen decade ago as a reason to tear down the progress made by the people is stupid at time.
Learning from previous mistake is a important factor in growing and developing a nation, learning from past mistake is important for the newer generation to strengthen our future.
This is right wing billionaire funded anti-communist propaganda and that would be exposed plainly for all to see if they did one on vietnam.
@@spookyengie735 As a Chinese, I very much agree with this. (Yes, I am Chinese)
When you're executed for saying a fruit looked like a potato because you're starving.
Me when I make shit up
I'd like to see some references. Would you please give me a list of books or something about this period of history?
Jabzy upload. It's going to be a good day today 😊
Some facts may be "controversial", but in general, your understanding of Chinese history is amazing!
edit: for example it seems that China is responsible for not recognizing the McMahon line (around 15:55). Actually India pass the McMahon line before the war as well. China did try it best to maintain peace on the border. It's up to you to decide whether it was good enough.
Why use "quotation" marks?
@@otten5666 "why" do anything at all? u feel me?
@@BOZ_11 "no"
You mean disputed.
@@RobespierreThePoof yep
When will the history of China documentary be complete?
Great work!
In 1950 there were fewer than 550 million people in China, and in 1975 there were more than 900 million.
And?
@@PossessedPotatoBird Much more people were born than were killed in China under Mao. We don't know if things would have been better without Mao, but most people in China are benefitting from his legacy. 80 million death (or whatever the death toll is) is indeed a terrible price to pay, but it has already been paid, so there are many Chinese people who are content with enjoying what has already been paid for.
@@user-uh8fu3mb9l those births have nothing to do with his policies… that’s actually a lower birth rate than usual during most of Chinese history
@@PossessedPotatoBird The population of China in 1850 is 430 million, which means that population grew by 28% in the 100 years before Mao. In comparison, in the 25 years under Mao, population grew by 64%. Population growth in China under Mao is among the fastest in Chinese history, largely due to industrialization and modernization. On the other hand, many people actually thought such a rapid growth in population was a bad thing, ergo the post-Mao one-child policy.
@@user-uh8fu3mb9l don’t waste your time, those westerners or west worshippers will always say « China BAD ». They hate the chinese deeply and are hypocrites who only seek the downfall of the chinese.
Great to make videos on China, its really interesting, Keep up the content 👌 👍
It's all just propaganda, for example he blames the locusts on the pest campaign against the sparrows without mentioning that the sparrows themselves were an invasive species that was also a plague on the fields while they still used traditional seed casting methods. And while the pest campaign contributed to the locusts, plagues of locusts have arisen throughout history without any pests campaigns.
He also makes no mention of China's long history with famine, and just darts over the year long drought and the flooding of the yellow river which drowned over a million people, washed away stockpiles of food, and drowned the fields. Both of these events were devastating.
He also mentions Lysenkoism (close cropping) without mentioning that the KMT had been experimenting with a variety of agricultural methods in different regions as part of an effort to modernize China's agriculture. All the blame is placed on Mao for continuing experiments that were already under way when the revolution happened. Some of those experiments proved disastrous and others beneficial
He also says Mao didn't want to know about the famine but when he realized he was being fed faulty reports he started traveling to the affected areas and sending people to study everything they could possibly learn to solve the famine and prevent the next one.
And the video says 80 million died but that's a completely made up number from the black book of communism, the actual number of deaths from the famine were around 15 million, and can fluctuate up and down a few depending on what criteria is deemed appropriate. Similar famines had occurred throughout China's history but what made the great famine different was that it affected the whole mainland all at the same time.
This guy's basically just an anti-communist liberal who read the Black Book of Communism and took everything in it at face value without doing any additional research or scrutinizing it, so you may as well just listen to that on audiobook. Two of the authors cited on the cover denounced it btw, and said the author who put it together was obsessed with exaggerating death tolls to get the highest numbers possible.
@confident femboi Okay thanks for the information
We love these videos - I use them to teach Chinese people - so much we do not know about China and I am loving learning. Such a complex world we live - To understand history is to hopefully create understanding
Good report
Xi is working on his own cult of personality now. This didn’t work out well last time.
A buddy of mine had a professor who had been sent to a farm during the CR. His take, “ it was stupid”
You know nothing
He has get rid of one million. Corrupt official
If your friend says so then it must be true
@@AceFromGorillaz I think his biggest achievement is getting rid of the corrupt official
Sources?
they dont need because they cant find
I love all of your content! Smol random idee from teeny tiny unimportant sub: Do a series like this on the History of Russia!
That would be.. quite the video
“If history teaches us anything, it is simply this: every revolution carries within it the seeds of its own destruction. And empires that rise will one day fall.” - Princess Irulan (Dune, Frank Herbert)
Fiction.
@@Zodroo_Tint Taken from a work of fiction? Yes. Lacking validity in the real world? No.
I must disagree with this
France revolution did not destroy France
Just made France became the biggest power in European
Chinese revolution just make China become the biggest power in Asia
Maybe later the world
@@wingkeungkong415 - Just give them some more time.
@@wingkeungkong415 I mean... It just took them like 5 republics
great stuff!
Melting down pots and pans is so stupid because youre just going to buy new ones which per kilogram are more expencive than structural steel.
Americans: "Better dead, than red."
Mao: " I can do both."
It would be very difficult to lead any country worse than Mao did.
Pol Pot: Really?
Every communism leader are TERRIBLE 😔😔😔
Other than Pol pot.
@@POCLEE pol pot never killed anyone accidently
Witnout him it is impossible for China to Rise again
Those are rookie numbers, around 600 trillion people died in Maoist China sources say
If you look at deaths on a per capita basis, the famines caused by the great leap forward are one of the smaller mass death events in history. Any huge disasters in China are like that, kills millions but barely felt by 98-99% of people. On the other hand, the deadliest man made catastrophe in history (per capita) would be the Great Potato Famine, which killed 1/5th the population of Ireland, displaced another 1/5th, and essentially destroyed the Gaelic language and much of Irish culture. It's probably one of the most devastating ethnic genocides in history, despite its "low" body count. The population of ireland still has not recovered.
The great leap forward resulted with over 10% of the population dying, this was rapidly recovered from because the one child policy was not implemented until 1980 and prior to it China had a birthrate similar to sub-Saharan Africa and the 90%(ish) of the survivors of the Great Leap tended to have much longer lifespans and so the population resumed growth almost immediately. Still, 10% death is something you don't normally see in a nation during peace time outside of a plague and was completely unnecessary and inhumane.
@@DiMacky24 It did not kill that many people lol. That's just straight up made up numbers.
Genocide on Serbian people in World war I, also World war II (Independent state of Croatia)
commie spoted
This video seems to cite 0 sources and just relies on ppl taking the death count at face value, ignoring the fact that its still massively debated on
This is the best explanation of the Cultural Revolution I've found on youtube. Thank you!
My favorite part about the Chinese history documentary is how every few videos the part keep increasing
Kill one, you're a murderer. Kill a million, you're a King. Kill everyone, you're a God.
❤️ I love your code 🎉🙏
@@thabangmaimela4034 And that would make Mao a wannabe God...
What are your sources?
Frank dikotter is pretty good if you want further reading
"Come on, Humans! We've wiped out entire species before. We can do it again!" - Homer Simpson.
You should do an entire video dedicated to documenting various influential academic, political, and cultural figures who ignorantly (at best) kept singing of Mao, his regime, and his movements’ praises.
I find it funny that while many autocrats blame the U.S. for buying civil activists and academics to stand against their government, they usually do exactly that to the U.S.
Honestly that could be a whole series, so many were ignorant for the sake of popularity.
Ignorantly? There's a reason Mao is praised to this day, China was in a terrible position before the revolution and it massively improved after it. You can't expect the revolution to magically fix every problem that dates back countless dynasties in a day
@AceFromGorillaz Mao was dead before the limited yet effective market reforms of the 80s and then in the 90s especially. So, no, they're just bubble world living scumbags.
19:57 script read error.
Although Mao’s purpose in criticizing The dismissal of Hai Rui was to purge Peng Zhen, the mayor of Beijing, the play was actually written by Wu Han, then deputy mayor of Beijing and a renowned historian specializing in Ming history. He was a sycophant of Mao and at first praised by Mao for this work but ironically became the first victim of the cultural revolution.
Tankies be seething
What’s the music that places in the background
The Amur river is not properly alligned with Heliongjiang province.
Your history and particularly your drawings are excellent and I hadn’t seen you in my feed and I just assumed that you put something negative about China or did something else that the sensor that TH-cam frowned upon. I’m sorry you have to go through that.
Please more videos in this series
Can you please make a video about the Iron Guard as well? It's one of the most weird fascist movements in my opinion. It combined the nazi ideology with christianity and had a death cult. But I only have surface level knowledge.
sounds interesting, never seen anyone delve into the topic neither
you mean like : th-cam.com/video/AAGSs5u98K8/w-d-xo.html
I am a prophet.
Not that it was hard to guess that this series was going to get even longer after it was already extended twice before 😄
Never yet found a good place to end it. So just going to run up to the beginning of xi.
Honestly it's less impactful when he was only deadliest because he royally mismanaged the populous nation in the world
Huh? A death is a death. These comments saying the great leap forward was 'not that bad/impactful' are utterly bizarre and kind of disgusting. You do realize that Mao's "mismanagement" consisted of executing all political dissenters and academics, and causing, without any good reason whatsoever, the deadliest famine in history, right? You make it seem like Mao and the Chinese government at the time had no way of knowing that they were killing off tens of millions of people by mass starvation.
The truth is that:
Great leap forward: 55 million kills.
Cultural revolution: 20 million kills.
Landlord murder under mao: 25 million.
Total: 100 million.
Yes this is true, I wrote these statistics 😊
actually mao kiled 2 billion people with his bare fist
source: i saw it in a dream
The data you mentioned is too exaggerated and very ridiculous. A more accurate figure is that 25 million people died
***CITATION NEEDED***
Chinese vs India war 1962 and 1967 please make video
80 million? I thought it was 80 billion!
Chinese population doubled from 1949 to 1976, why don't you just add more 0s to your figure?
Getting a high body count in China is a bit easy tho with the massive population. Their regional rebellions have a higher kill count than some international wars.
What is your point? Sorry but your comment seems to imply that Mao's genocide is not a big deal or that Mao was not that bad of a dictator since China has a large population, which makes no sense.
The story is good but every story has ending point but there is ending point on chapter.
I think this era was definitely one of the darkest periods of Chinese modern history but my dad says the stability and peace they got was much preferable than the chaotic warlord era and the Japanese occupation area that his dad had to endure; and that while there were so many needless deaths, the populace grew so substantially that they had to implement the one child policy a few decades later. it’ll be very interesting to see the next period of Chinese history in this series!
Thank you for your input, Reimu!
Stability with more death numbers in war? You pathetic CCP bot.
Damn 80 million ! the number is so crazy its almost as if its made up....
Just like 6 million!
@@blackmesa1565 how exactly could mao have killed 80 million people when the combined death toll of ww2 was 50-60 million? Seems kinda impossible
Test your IQ😂
It is made up. They do it by countering LOWERING BIRTH RATES as deaths. This many people weren't born because they started working in urban jobs or because of mobilization. They in bad faith count those as deaths. The statistics are there, the death rate during the GLF was the same level as India's at the time. In fact Mao had lowered death rates from mid 40:1000 to 10:1000 so he in reality saved millions of lives. The death rate for GLF is 25:1000 India's was 24:1000
@@haochengzhai7156 useless, most IQ tests dont go into negative
Do you have a list of sources for this video?
US stopped helping KMT after WW2 and that's the result we got....
Because the America knew that the kmt was corrupt from top to bottom
He killed a bazillion Chinese. Personally, he drove from town to town with his Russian made T-90 tank
Commie scum on his way to deny truth and facts 🤣 🤡👹🐷
@@chingis1154 Common Mongolian L?
@@dieguito3422 nah, common adai W
Actually, the death of ordinary Chinese people is not a big issue. The key point is that almost all foreign-educated technical experts who returned to China and university professors who did not follow the Kuomintang to Taiwan died during the Cultural Revolution. Some committed suicide, while others were tortured to death. In many famous Chinese universities, there are memorial halls displaying the photos of those who founded the schools or made outstanding contributions to them. Although their birth dates are different, their death dates are exactly the same. Therefore, after China's reform and opening up, they could only seek technology imports from the West and Japan, as there were virtually no people with basic academic backgrounds in the entire country at that time, having been wiped out during the Cultural Revolution. As a result, the Chinese began to continuously acquire technology through various means, as there was no foundation for research and development. In fact, most Chinese people cannot reflect on the Cultural Revolution and even believe that it was necessary for making China strong. What you see and hear now are mainly the descendants of the perpetrators from that time. Those who had even the slightest dissenting opinions or knowledge and culture from the old era were all killed by these people. Opposing the Cultural Revolution is essentially equivalent to criticizing all Chinese people. Only the descendants of those who do not understand history may have some resentment towards the Cultural Revolution.
I wonder where do we even get these numbers
Did you watch the video?
nice title tbh, hope the clickbate makes your channel explode : ) (genuinely) been subscribed on one account or another since 2014
lol wtf, 80mil? my dad was born in 1956 and grew up during both the great leap foward and the cultural revolution and although he's told me alot about how even low quality noodles were only reserved for the most special occasions (meat being completely out of the question) the death count is nowhere near as high as people nowadays say it is
always interesting to see americans who have never stepped foot on chinese soil in their entire lives act like theyve been through it all in youtube comment sections though
Sure thing buddy
白左是这样的
Generally speaking, estimates for total death toll in big tragedies like this become higher the more information is learned. Early estimates usually just include the number of specific individuals which documents describe as having died from the tragedy, and this is crudely extrapolated to the people who weren't well documented as well. But oftentimes, the best-documented people were the least badly hit by tragedy, so that as we learn more about the previously lesser studied populations, our estimate goes up.
After that, there's an even bigger thing: Tragedies create ripple effects causing even more deaths, but its difficult to trace any SINGLE person's death to that. For example, my Great Uncle had COPD and died in a hospital, because it was during the height of the recent pandemic so all respirators were taken by COVID patients. If you just count people killed by COVID, my uncle wouldn't be listed. But it is nearly certain that the COVID pandemic indirectly caused or at least contributed to his death. In the past two decades or so, scholars have started to estimate these sorts of indirect deaths and include them in their approximate totals.
Looking specifically at The Campaign to Suppress Counter-Revolutionaries, the earliest estimates coming out shortly after Mao's death placed the death toll at about 0.7 million. But as additional previously covered-up deaths were identified, new documents became available to researchers, and deaths from abysmal treatment in slave labor camps were included, that estimate today sits at somewhere between 2 and 5 million--at least 3 times and potentially as much as 7 times higher than what was initially thought. The % increase in death tolls for the Great Famine and Cultural Revolution aren't quite as drastic as those of The Campaign to Suppress Counter-Revolutionaries, but they have increased for for very similar reasons.
This isn't unique to discussion of Chinese History. Estimated death tolls for events as variable in nature as The Holocaust, The Black Death, Hurricane Katrina, the US Invasion of Iraq, and British Colonization of India, have all increased over the past years and decades. There isn't a global and/or ""western"" conspiracy to inflate the number of people killed through Mao's totalitarianism and dysfunctional governance. Nor is there a conspiracy to inflate the numbers killed by any other mass-death events. It's just that scholars have more information than they did earlier, and include indirect deaths which had previously been swept under the rug.
I gonna say though. I'm glad I'm American and didn't experience the 3rd world shithole that was China. I would be homeless in the streets and still better off than the average Chinese peasant
@p00bix 'scholars' use "people that were never born" to inflate the death toll, so yes, it is a deliberate way to inflate the numbers.
It's, quite frankly, the most glaring thing people always omit when talking about the Great Leap Forward. If we use the same methodology for European Colonisation of the Americas, the death toll for Native Americans would be in the billions, much like how the Indian death toll under British rule was over 1.8 billion. It's absolutely absurd. Just count the deaths as is, which I suspect is in the low millions because if it was any higher, China's population could not have possibly reached 1 billion by the 1970s.
If we look at the previous wars in Chinese history that killed over 20 million people, the population always stagnated for over a century. And here, we are expected to believe 80 million people died when China's population was around 550 million. So, essentially, by 1965, China population should have dipped below 470 million. But, instead, it swelled to nearly a billion.
It was just a prank, bro🙄
sadly this sociopath is celebrated by the brazilian left. 😢
So there are many educated people even in Brazil! :) glad to know
7:50 21:51 24:45 25:47 26:54 28:03 33:02
Wrong, at least 800 million death.
unrealistic
Probably more than 80 mi
Yes you are right, the US definetly killed more than 80 million people.
I always heard 120 to 130ish.
@@Russo-Delenda-Est Americans also heard about imaginary WMDs and killed 500 000 civilians for it. Wouldn't trust what one says or hears for the life of me.
All Chinese people are dead. There are no more Chinese people in China. They are all Kpop stands
@@maiyn2 i like you
18:40
The German Democratic Republic was also a communist State (:
Good Video as always (:
80 million?
Literally all of chinese history: Those are rookie numbers, you got to bump those numbers up
*the glories of communism*
the answer - Mao was just a stalin´s pupil , much like pol - pot , Kim Il Sung, Castro, Tito, were ...
A famine in China, unheard of prior to mao
Shop owners making a quick buck by cashing in on current trends sounds rather capitalist to me, as does exporting massive amounts of produce for profit
State capitalism. All of this was motivated and justified for the need for economic growth. Same thought process as capitalist repression, just less abstracted and more explicit.
"State capitalism" is, by definition, an oxymoron. Capitalism is when the means of production are privately owned. When the state owns the means of production, there is no private ownership; therefore, what communist apologists call state capitalism makes no sense. It's simply authoritarian collectivism, that is legitimized through the collectivist ideology of communism.
40% time in ideological education doesnt lead to good soldiering. What is more I have a feeling that today, tho the army swears loyalty to the party the soldiers actually feel loyal to China their country not the government.
everything is ideological, especially when words such as "it's common sense" and "let's look at it objectively" come up
@@martinnemeth6909 No.
@@baltulielkungsgunarsmiezis9714 yes
Where did you get the number? Check China population curve from 1949 - 1980 please. Or you just made up the number?
images of this video is quite low
It’s crazy how he did actually for the time good and pragmatic things and then at some point completely over the top and unnecessary suffering
Absolute power and all of that. There is a reason many early leftist thinkers were against one man rule. But naturally, such thinking was ignored in favour of great man unity, and we got the terrible executions of what should have been grand leftist revolutions leading to terrible suffering.
Napoleon was like that too
@@wingkeungkong415 Yeah Napoleon was an imperialist was quite progressive as a politician
@@lukasj19999 but how many people died in the napoleonic war
@@wingkeungkong415 4-7 million
Ain’t Communism Great…..
it is
@@FerdarPleaseSubscribe
It just kills ya…
@Yibay true
@Yibay it keeps you in poverty
@@maayan748it just makes everyone equally poor.
Foot binding was already illegal in 1911
It was still practiced until Mao
De jure, yes, de facto, no.
I think it's disingenuous to use 80 million just to grab more views, the numbers are widely disputed and are still an on going debate,
He left a question mark
@themediumcheese I think you're misunderstanding how he has used the question mark, but prehaps in in the wrong
Why doesn't CCP disclose the figures? The 80 million comes from the statistics of the number of abnormal deaths. In my hometown, only one village survived in one county, and all of them starved to death. People ate people, corpses, and soil. Still 90% of Chinese people worship him because of government blocking information and brainwashing
Considering that Mao's successor purged the CCP and sacked China's National Archives, your Statement has truth to it.
“Let me explain how this is NATOs fault”
*makes extraordinary claims*
*doesn't link any sources in desc.*
An unfalsifiable orthodoxy
Common famine denier
He uses exclusively westoid sources if does any research at all
@@alphana7055 "westoid" cry me a river, commie.
@@Emel_unlegit Of course there was a famine in China, what are you talking about.
Even liu shaoqi had limits
Do you even know how large the number 80million is?😅
Mao killed 90 billion with his bear hands, it's true
It was also the era with fastest population growth and increase in life expectancy thanks to rural healthcare programs.
Deng Xiaoping era saw increase infant deaths and lower life expectancy in countryside because of end of village doctors and focus on the cities
But every country saw that in the post-war years. For example Iraq saw faster life expectancy gains from 1950-79 until the Iran-Iraq war and didn't have a massive famine
Mao: The Deadliest Dictator
Fixed the thumbnail for ya
Holy shit, glad im American
A new number was invented
Taiwan is a beautiful country that showcases the potential of the Chinese people when they're not being enslaved by their leaders.
Taiwan was a fascist dictatorship until 1992, bro.
@@yaldabaoth2 30 years ago, yes. nearly a third of a century ago. What's your point? it is now a prosperous free democracy
@@yaldabaoth2 Fascist? Lol just how little do you know
I recommend people learn more about Chiang Kai-shek's regime and the White Terror in KMT-held Taiwan. At least have some balance in looking at the history at the time of the OP video. Same advice goes for today.
It's just a rebel province who only exists because the U.S. wants them to exist. What's your point?