@@Wonderer224 someone who is born in a Muslim family, it's not a wonder that he would be Muslim. But someone who is born not in a Muslim family, the odds are not big, that he would become Muslim. I am happy when the Muslim community grow and I am happy to see more and more ppl convert. I am certainly biast. I myself reverted from Christianity to Islam and I identify strongly with the reverts. They have a different struggle. I mean it's certainly different, if your have to loose family and friends for your reversion. It's different, if you can't celebrate Eid with family, because you don't have a Muslim family. And as more I think about that, as more I appreciate the fact, that there are ppl out there who gave up so much for their belief. And some others got it gifted by birth and don't recordnise their blessing to have been born in a Muslim household. Don't worry, I am not racist. If I pointed out this two englisch Muslims, does not automatically mean that others are inferior. You do the same mistake, that usually drive me nuts by ppl. I'll explain. If you talk about something or if you point out something, that doesn't mean that that's the only thing that you think or say, or that you are obsessively just ruminate about that. You have to look and asses the situation and see what is appropriate for this situation. With my students I don't talk about my private life, but with my best friend I do. Would it be not silly for my student to think that: because my teacher doesn't talk about her private life, therefore she doesn't have a private live, or maybe she doesn't like men, or maybe she is gey? If a person did not exclude specifically something and communicated that clearly, how can you accuse him of excluding that thing? If I say, I love ice cream, that doesn't mean that I love just ice cream, and nothing else.
@@mn-lt4kq yes, beautifully said. I myself am German revert. That's clear that I would have an understanding what it means to be a revert. Sure everybody has their own story, but struggles are similar. I mean I could ask any revert specific questions, for example: How did your parents react? How do you celebrate Eid?.... And they could give me a positiv or a negative answer. But those questions don't even apply to Muslim, who are born in Muslim families. I don't know how someone could possibly think of racim, when reading my comment.
@@safyafarooq2878 Your comment is fine my brother. You were just addressing the current video. Don't worry about them, these Haram police and TH-cam Scholars always show up in the comments and show off how better they are than the others. If your Niya is pure, noone can judge you but Allah. May Allah guide us all.
Mashallah. Thanks Br. Paul for getting mister Dutton on your show. I have been reading his books for years and his works are gems. He is the top one writer on the maliki madhab and the Muwatta in the english speaking world.
How enormously you contribute to Muslims knowledge everywhere is nothing short of admiration Paul...thanks alot and also professor Dutton is a delight to listen to
Salaam Alaikum br Paul : Adequate rest and adequate hydration for you br Paul , you are precious . Praying for your well being and long life . Great work .
Alhumduillah, may Allah azzawajal bless you, a good intellectual discussion, I came to the west as kid from Pakistan, now in my 60s, I am learning this beautiful and true religion. Please keep up the good work for us to benefit and become the rightfully guided
I love you both for the sake of Allah, i cherish the time i listen to you and i hope Insha'Allah that we can meet in Jannah when our journey in life for Allah's sake becomes our guide their
This was a beautiful insight and a very knowledgeable resource that i will watch over and over again In sha Allah. Thanks again Paul for inviting top class speaker's with academic rigour
Beautiful interview brother Paul Masha'Allah. When i came to know the Muwatta of Iman Malik رحمه الله تعالى was the second most authentic book after the book of Allah and way before Sahih Al-Bukhati and Muslim, came into the scene, i was mind struck‼️ i have the Muwatta in English and will start studying it Insha'Allah, that's my intention.
Thank you very very much for a very informative discussion. I heard from my late Imam Tewfiq Shahin of Ottawa Mosque that it is recorded that our Holy Prophet never spoke for more than TEN minutes on any subject.
JZK for introducing a Capetonian Muslim scholar to the world..lived there for 7 years.. learned and benefitted tremendously from the lectures and scholarly works of the local Sheikhs and Imams...the late Sheikhul Ahmad Deedat R.A being one of them ..Alhamdulillah 💙❄️
May Allah return you to health. Your cold sounds like it is giving your nose a hard time. ❤ Learned a lot about early process of Islamic Law thank you.
Al salamu alaykum brother Paul, am here to remind you that the work you do is very beneficial to the Muslim ummah and to encourage you to continue your good work, and also to suggest a topic to be discussed on your platform that has been on my mind for quite some time, that is Islam's opinion on property rights. Specifically about intellectual property, but property rights in general. I find the discussions on this channel to be very enlightening, and property rights is an interesting topic to be discussed since it is very important to many issues in the Americas, especially when it relates to the indigenous population. Aspects that I think would be interesting to talk about would be, 1) the legitimately of ownership (what does it mean to own something) 2) difference between private property and public property,(and how that relates to the state) 3) difference between Islamic conception of property and modern western conception,( a tangent about the waqf system and it's working would be nice) 4) a discussion about land ownership, specifically when it comes to collective land ownership(do indigenous tribes still hold a right to the land of their ancestors? Even after their land was conquered? what about the private land that individuals in said tribes own, do their descendents hold rights to these lands via the right of inheritance, and how would they ideally be divided). And as I said a talk about intellectual property and how it's viewed under Islamic law would be very much appreciated.
Sir,accept my heartiest.❤❤❤You are really a great hearted person.❤Both of you are loving and fantastic.May Allah keep you fine and bless upon you all the times.I really love you most, sir.❤Have a very blessed life by the grace of Almighty Allah.Take my heartiest respect, sir.❤❤❤
ASA Paul, Thanks for the great lecture. As for regarding why some Islamic sciences like hadith, written documentation, Arabic grammar, Fqih etc.. evolved or appeared lately, the reason is, people "invent" specialized disciplines when a specific skill is lost from the layman. For example nobody needed to learn Arabic grammar because in the beginning the Muslims were Arabs, then after the conquests a lot of non Arabs accepted islam and they needed a way to understand how Arabic works, similarly the collection of Quran because new muslims didn't have the knowledge of the sahaba so a collection of the Quran was needed. Same thing with Hadith, the people of Madinah lived with the prophet, they know him and internalized his personality and mindset, his companions shaped their personality after him (PBUH) they can understand the nuance between 2 extremes and reconcile any apparent contradiction they developed this mindset. ages and generations passed and these skills were lost, that dictated new sciences to be developed to compensate for the skills and mindset lost by generations. that's why reading books about Islamic sciences without a good teacher is a bad idea, because the teacher also teach etiquette (Adab) good manners and personality and fear and love for Allahand his messenger, not just some dry rules. They like the professor said used to embody the knowledge they had on their daily actions and life, this is how great scholars developed a mindset of dealing with unprecedented situations they actually apply what they learned. And that's was a huge difference from Bani Israel scholars, who used to a collect huge knowledge without applying it, this knowledge will be used against them in the day of judgement just like any scholar who learns only without application of what he learned in his life. Sorry for the rant but to sum up, people didn't need to document hadith because they lived among the people who witnessed the prophet and all his battles and trials and internalized some part of the light he brought in. Peace be upon the Messenger and his family and companions.
Thanks for a very insighttful and educational discussion. A comment ...the shift from oral to written tradition is a manifestation of the transition from tribal society to the power society.... from watch and learn to read and learn. Watch
29:23 Funny thing we back to oral transmission again in this youtube and some podcast stuff in today's ages, and people forget that "This" is an "oral transmission" they seems didn't mind it and when come to "Islam stuff" they want the "exact" written text. lol Salam for you both, I had great time here to learn.
Sir Urdu please do keep on adding Urdu translation subtitles in your videos. There are millions of Urdu speaking people all around the world to learn these high quality lectures from your channel. Thank you
Why do you not dedicate some of your resources to pay to well learned good muslims ( truely sincere ) to do translations . It will be a good service . Why? , Because the greedy ones who start off their own shops as so called maulavees and maulaanas cannot teach the truth to the masses and to motivate and to inspire the next generation to achieve great heights is very remote . Only those who dedicate themselves and their earnings to uplift the masses can reach higher status spiritually and materially . Br Paul is dedicated ( Abdullah a servant of God and he brings in such , as his guests , ) So you do think right that there are millions of human beings who speak Urdu and will be benefitted by these discourses)
@@786humaira1 I would love to do it but unfortunately I am a medical person. I'm not very good in languages both English and Urdu. Also I am extremely busy with my professional duties. Nowadays one doesn't need to do translations manually. There are certain means by with auto- translation can easily be incorporated when editing and making videos for TH-cam.
@@tmk5nice that you are thinking about others , inshallah one day you will achieve it , may be in your retirement or one of your children or friends will do it for you . I sometime back translated Allama Iqbal’s poem : in English and asked my son to put English subtitles on it , he loved the meaning and translation and said this is real nice you should do more . I just started and stoped at” lap pe aate hai dua . “You can check on mu you tube channel . So dear sir keep your wish alive , do not give up . All these lectures are well worth in gold , very inspiring and practical . Good luck
Wallah Paul you are the only person on TH-cam that makes me jealous because what you did for Islam ☪️ in last 2 years I couldn’t do it in last 24 years being born and raised in Muslim family. MashaAllah.❤️ 🌎
Subhanallah, what a blessed conversation, these are the likes of gatherings that the Angels attend and upon which Mercies of Allah descend, as said by the messenger of Allah peace be upon Him. We love you in the seek of Allah, may Allah protect you, guide you, and reward you the best of rewards.
MashâAllah .. very happy and proud of this podcast we really benefit world wide may Allah Swt accept your efforts. I have a question for our dear friend Dr Yassin Did Imam shafi meet imam Abu Hanifa? Thank you
There was a man sergent Gordon who accepted islam in early 18th century in India and fought against British East India company along with Muslim rulers of India .... And got martyerd,May Allah please with him and grant him jannat ul firdos...... You guys are making us proud 😢😢
I actually find it funny when Hadith rejecters try to say that the Hadith was written by Al-Bukhari as if we do not have earlier works of Hadith like the Mwatta of Imam Malik.
About hadith, there is a preserved book before the Muata'e, which is the book of Hammam ibn Munabbih (19 - 101/130 AH) which was the student of Abu hurayra the companion of the prophet peace be upon him
Woah mashallah mr Dutton is really knowledge about the history of sharia and fiqh ive learned alot i wish you host him again and discuss the differences between sharia and man mad laws
Hello professor Williams I am one of your followers and I was wondering if you could make a video about the Muslim schism or Fitna and it current Impact on us as Muslim I know it's a very difficult topic but I believe only a well educated professor such as you with might be able to undertake this truly complex quest I wish you best from the Maghreb region and thank you for bearing with and may Allah bless england and it's people
Al hamdulilah, beautiful discussion. I believe Umar II was the one who charged Imam Zuhri to commit to writing the ahadith. From the works of Imam Zuhri is the Muwatta born.
I appreciate the valuable comment of your guest prof. Yasin Dutton, why non Muslim scholars study Islam, Quran and the Prophet life’s teaching if they do not have love to the subject? Why they spend all their lives studying what they do not love or believe in! The key Aya in this issue has been noted well in Quran. [البقرة:121]: الَّذِينَ آتَيْنَاهُمُ الْكِتَابَ يَتْلُونَهُ حَقَّ تِلَاوَتِهِ أُولَٰئِكَ يُؤْمِنُونَ بِهِ وَمَن يَكْفُرْ بِهِ فَأُولَٰئِكَ هُمُ الْخَاسِرُونَ. One correct recitation of Quran, is an evidence of believing in it, others are losers. [العلق:19]: كَلَّا لَا تُطِعْهُ وَاسْجُدْ وَاقْتَرِب. In contrary, do not follow their aggression,(described in verse 6) and adhere to wisdom of identifying right and wrong, acknowledge, mankind earthy nature, bow down and elevate you spirit closer (to Allah).
You mentioned how Prophet Muhammad pbuh looked. Reminds me please check a book by Dr Abdul Hai of Pakistan called Uswai Rasool Akram. You gonna love it..
الله أكبر ولله الحمد والشكر والثناء و الفضل والمنة جزاكم الله خير الجزاء في الدنيا والآخرة الله أكبر والعزة لله عز وجل و لرسوله الكريم وللمؤمنين والمؤمنات الأحياء منهم والأموات الله أكبر 🕌🕋
![BABYMONSTER - 'DRIP' M/V REACTION [WAS NOT EXPECTING THIS!!!]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/t0Lpgr1jo3Y/mqdefault.jpg)
How proud I feel to see two englisch Muslims, who are so much dedicated to Islam. Mashallah. Subhanallah. Alhamdulillah. Allahuakbar.
You should be proud of all Muslims regardless race or nationality. To be english Muslim is no better than to be a Nigerian Muslim or Pakistani Muslim.
@@Wonderer224 someone who is born in a Muslim family, it's not a wonder that he would be Muslim. But someone who is born not in a Muslim family, the odds are not big, that he would become Muslim. I am happy when the Muslim community grow and I am happy to see more and more ppl convert. I am certainly biast. I myself reverted from Christianity to Islam and I identify strongly with the reverts. They have a different struggle. I mean it's certainly different, if your have to loose family and friends for your reversion. It's different, if you can't celebrate Eid with family, because you don't have a Muslim family. And as more I think about that, as more I appreciate the fact, that there are ppl out there who gave up so much for their belief. And some others got it gifted by birth and don't recordnise their blessing to have been born in a Muslim household.
Don't worry, I am not racist. If I pointed out this two englisch Muslims, does not automatically mean that others are inferior.
You do the same mistake, that usually drive me nuts by ppl.
I'll explain. If you talk about something or if you point out something, that doesn't mean that that's the only thing that you think or say, or that you are obsessively just ruminate about that.
You have to look and asses the situation and see what is appropriate for this situation. With my students I don't talk about my private life, but with my best friend I do. Would it be not silly for my student to think that:
because my teacher doesn't talk about her private life, therefore she doesn't have a private live, or maybe she doesn't like men, or maybe she is gey?
If a person did not exclude specifically something and communicated that clearly, how can you accuse him of excluding that thing? If I say, I love ice cream, that doesn't mean that I love just ice cream, and nothing else.
You mean proud of how Islam message reaches all hearts regardless their nationalities or colour.
@@mn-lt4kq yes, beautifully said. I myself am German revert. That's clear that I would have an understanding what it means to be a revert. Sure everybody has their own story, but struggles are similar.
I mean I could ask any revert specific questions, for example:
How did your parents react? How do you celebrate Eid?....
And they could give me a positiv or a negative answer.
But those questions don't even apply to Muslim, who are born in Muslim families.
I don't know how someone could possibly think of racim, when reading my comment.
@@safyafarooq2878 Your comment is fine my brother. You were just addressing the current video. Don't worry about them, these Haram police and TH-cam Scholars always show up in the comments and show off how better they are than the others. If your Niya is pure, noone can judge you but Allah. May Allah guide us all.
The Christians have their Paul. We got our own.
Alhamdulillah.
Ours is the genuine one, not fake.
@@abdalhaqq9465 Deceived and Bewitched On the Road to Jerusalem.
@@snakejuce Road to Damascus, wasn't it?
😂 oh man that's hilarious
Our Paul calls to guidance, the other....
I couldn't be more happier than to see two English muslims making such a nice discussion about islam.
I literally read your comment as "two English MUFFINS" 😅🤦♂🤦♂
Islamic law originated out the ass of Muhammad. And all Muslims love to sniff his ass.
Nothing English about them
2 luminous men I see my own eyes. What a blessing! Subhan'Allah 🇸🇦
Mashallah. Thanks Br. Paul for getting mister Dutton on your show. I have been reading his books for years and his works are gems. He is the top one writer on the maliki madhab and the Muwatta in the english speaking world.
Why some peaple are obsessed by the past and can't imagine prosperity everywhere...
@@botektecnology6756go ask all historians 😂
This is a great discuss to watch, even for me who born as a Muslim. I keep learning about my religion.
Thank you Hajj Yasin Dutton for your work on the Muwatta and Imam Malik
May Allah Bless Both of you in this Life and in the Hereafter.
Yasin Dutton.........finally! Mashallah!!
Mashallah what an amazing guest Prof. Yasin Dutton was. Thank you brother Paul.
Paul you are spoiling us with all this great content!
May Allah swt reward you and your guest.
Yasin Dutton is great scholar! I found his books very scholarly! Thanks for arranging this dialogue!
Glad you enjoyed it!
How enormously you contribute to Muslims knowledge everywhere is nothing short of admiration Paul...thanks alot and also professor Dutton is a delight to listen to
May Allah bless you both with good health, May Allah bless your Family and Make your life easy and give you success in this world and the next.
Ameen
Salaam Alaikum br Paul :
Adequate rest and adequate hydration for you br Paul , you are precious . Praying for your well being and long life .
Great work .
Thank you brothers, May Allah grant you success in every step of your life
Great brother. Very intellectual video. Very good efforts. May Allah accept your good deeds .Jazakallah.
Alhumduillah, may Allah azzawajal bless you, a good intellectual discussion, I came to the west as kid from Pakistan, now in my 60s, I am learning this beautiful and true religion. Please keep up the good work for us to benefit and become the rightfully guided
Dear brothers Allah bless you are doing great work on this planet and we love you
I love you both for the sake of Allah, i cherish the time i listen to you and i hope Insha'Allah that we can meet in Jannah when our journey in life for Allah's sake becomes our guide their
Lovely discussion full of eloquence and intellectual reflections. May Allah bless you both and many thanks Paul for the valuable content you provide.
May Allah bless you both
This was a beautiful insight and a very knowledgeable resource that i will watch over and over again In sha Allah. Thanks again Paul for inviting top class speaker's with academic rigour
Wonderfully wise thoughts much needed for modern society to progress with moral values.
When I was like 9 years old, when ever i look at the Sky I knew there is one god who has control the sky.. Yaa ALLAH for give us.
This is the best TH-cam channel ever. Thanks for enlightening Muslim minds. جزاك الله خيرا
Ahh my varsity Arabic teacher! Lovely seeing him on the channel!
May Allah bless you both ameen
I never listened such beautiful conversation ,Allah bless you both InshAllah.
I'm extremely glad to have caught the last upload before it was removed. Very logical, empathic, well explained and backed up.
Beautiful interview brother Paul Masha'Allah. When i came to know the Muwatta of Iman Malik رحمه الله تعالى was the second most authentic book after the book of Allah and way before Sahih Al-Bukhati and Muslim, came into the scene, i was mind struck‼️ i have the Muwatta in English and will start studying it Insha'Allah, that's my intention.
We pray to Allah may accept brother Yasin's good deeds.
This is heartwarming to watch. Thank you. This is truly wonderful Brothers.
So beautiful..
MashaaAllah..😭💖
A very real discussion that I found to be very genuine And enriching. JazakAllah
May Allah Azzawajal bless you brothers, ameen
Thank you very very much for a very informative discussion. I heard from my late Imam Tewfiq Shahin of Ottawa Mosque that it is recorded that our Holy Prophet never spoke for more than TEN minutes on any subject.
JZK for introducing a Capetonian Muslim scholar to the world..lived there for 7 years.. learned and benefitted tremendously from the lectures and scholarly works of the local Sheikhs and Imams...the late Sheikhul Ahmad Deedat R.A being one of them ..Alhamdulillah 💙❄️
All praise is due to Allah Lord of all creations the most merciful and the most compassionate.
Most amazing of brother
having a beautiful discussion.
Love the intellectual conversation 👍
Times having people like You & Dr. Dutton is not "Worse" in any aspect.
May Allah return you to health. Your cold sounds like it is giving your nose a hard time. ❤ Learned a lot about early process of Islamic Law thank you.
Al salamu alaykum brother Paul, am here to remind you that the work you do is very beneficial to the Muslim ummah and to encourage you to continue your good work, and also to suggest a topic to be discussed on your platform that has been on my mind for quite some time, that is Islam's opinion on property rights. Specifically about intellectual property, but property rights in general. I find the discussions on this channel to be very enlightening, and property rights is an interesting topic to be discussed since it is very important to many issues in the Americas, especially when it relates to the indigenous population.
Aspects that I think would be interesting to talk about would be,
1) the legitimately of ownership (what does it mean to own something)
2) difference between private property and public property,(and how that relates to the state)
3) difference between Islamic conception of property and modern western conception,( a tangent about the waqf system and it's working would be nice)
4) a discussion about land ownership, specifically when it comes to collective land ownership(do indigenous tribes still hold a right to the land of their ancestors? Even after their land was conquered? what about the private land that individuals in said tribes own, do their descendents hold rights to these lands via the right of inheritance, and how would they ideally be divided).
And as I said a talk about intellectual property and how it's viewed under Islamic law would be very much appreciated.
Ma shaa Allah brothers really good topic ❤
th-cam.com/video/reh6SItaFxA/w-d-xo.html
Mashallah always happy to sit and listen to 2 wise old men speak ❤
Absolutely fantastic discussion. So glad I found this channel.
Jazakallah khier Uncle Paul for another beneficial episode. Well done, sir
The wisdom emanates from this man's demeanor & speech. Thank you for inviting him on Paul.
This is an epic discussion.
Mashallaha, we are lucky to have scholars like you both,
BarakAllahu fikum !
Sir,accept my heartiest.❤❤❤You are really a great hearted person.❤Both of you are loving and fantastic.May Allah keep you fine and bless upon you all the times.I really love you most, sir.❤Have a very blessed life by the grace of Almighty Allah.Take my heartiest respect, sir.❤❤❤
Listening the conversation in between the two eminent personalities on a very important subject is just overwhelming and inspiring.
Great discussion. Thanks Paul
مشاء الله may Allah reward you for this work simply beautiful to listen to this and learn from you. may Allah guide us to the right path
Literasi beliau ini bagus sangat, pembicara yang selalu berdasarkan referensi valid, Salam hangat dari Indonesia om Muhammad Paul.
ASA Paul, Thanks for the great lecture. As for regarding why some Islamic sciences like hadith, written documentation, Arabic grammar, Fqih etc.. evolved or appeared lately, the reason is, people "invent" specialized disciplines when a specific skill is lost from the layman. For example nobody needed to learn Arabic grammar because in the beginning the Muslims were Arabs, then after the conquests a lot of non Arabs accepted islam and they needed a way to understand how Arabic works, similarly the collection of Quran because new muslims didn't have the knowledge of the sahaba so a collection of the Quran was needed. Same thing with Hadith, the people of Madinah lived with the prophet, they know him and internalized his personality and mindset, his companions shaped their personality after him (PBUH) they can understand the nuance between 2 extremes and reconcile any apparent contradiction they developed this mindset. ages and generations passed and these skills were lost, that dictated new sciences to be developed to compensate for the skills and mindset lost by generations. that's why reading books about Islamic sciences without a good teacher is a bad idea, because the teacher also teach etiquette (Adab) good manners and personality and fear and love for Allahand his messenger, not just some dry rules. They like the professor said used to embody the knowledge they had on their daily actions and life, this is how great scholars developed a mindset of dealing with unprecedented situations they actually apply what they learned. And that's was a huge difference from Bani Israel scholars, who used to a collect huge knowledge without applying it, this knowledge will be used against them in the day of judgement just like any scholar who learns only without application of what he learned in his life. Sorry for the rant but to sum up, people didn't need to document hadith because they lived among the people who witnessed the prophet and all his battles and trials and internalized some part of the light he brought in. Peace be upon the Messenger and his family and companions.
Thanks a lot for such a beautiful comment.
💯🙏❤️🙂👍
Salaam. Thx for sharing your thoughts gentlemen. Most incitefull.
Brilliant as always Paul!
Really enjoyed listening.
Wowww I've been looking for a ("Western" viewpoint) scholarly take on Al-Muwatta recently and bamm here it is...
Get well soon Sir.
We need the scholars of the Islamic nation in order to light the way not only for Muslims but for all mankind ♥️♥️, thank you from Morocco
What a great person dr yasin is masha allah
*_May Allah grant you the best of health._*
Such an Interesting Discussion.
Thanks for a very insighttful and educational discussion.
A comment ...the shift from oral to written tradition is a manifestation of the transition from tribal society to the power society.... from watch and learn to read and learn.
Watch
Mashallah Great Discussion!!!❤
Alhamdulillah, another interesting video.. Now, an avid subscriber..Insha'Allah more interesting videos in the future..
May Allah give Brother Paul with good health, it appears that brother Paul is down with a cold....
29:23 Funny thing we back to oral transmission again in this youtube and some podcast stuff in today's ages, and people forget that "This" is an "oral transmission" they seems didn't mind it and when come to "Islam stuff" they want the "exact" written text. lol
Salam for you both, I had great time here to learn.
Excellent work
Sir Urdu please do keep on adding Urdu translation subtitles in your videos. There are millions of Urdu speaking people all around the world to learn these high quality lectures from your channel. Thank you
Why do you not dedicate some of your resources to pay to well learned good muslims ( truely sincere ) to do translations . It will be a good service . Why? ,
Because the greedy ones who start off their own shops as so called maulavees and maulaanas cannot teach the truth to the masses and to motivate and to inspire the next generation to achieve great heights is very remote .
Only those who dedicate themselves and their earnings to uplift the masses can reach higher status spiritually and materially .
Br Paul is dedicated ( Abdullah a servant of God and he brings in such , as his guests , )
So you do think right that there are millions of human beings who speak Urdu and will be benefitted by these discourses)
@@786humaira1 I would love to do it but unfortunately I am a medical person. I'm not very good in languages both English and Urdu. Also I am extremely busy with my professional duties.
Nowadays one doesn't need to do translations manually. There are certain means by with auto- translation can easily be incorporated when editing and making videos for TH-cam.
@@tmk5nice that you are thinking about others , inshallah one day you will achieve it , may be in your retirement or one of your children or friends will do it for you .
I sometime back translated Allama Iqbal’s poem : in English and asked my son to put English subtitles on it , he loved the meaning and translation and said this is real nice you should do more . I just started and stoped at” lap pe aate hai dua . “You can check on mu you tube channel .
So dear sir keep your wish alive , do not give up .
All these lectures are well worth in gold , very inspiring and practical . Good luck
Wallah Paul you are the only person on TH-cam that makes me jealous because what you did for Islam ☪️ in last 2 years I couldn’t do it in last 24 years being born and raised in Muslim family. MashaAllah.❤️ 🌎
Subhanallah, what a blessed conversation, these are the likes of gatherings that the Angels attend and upon which Mercies of Allah descend, as said by the messenger of Allah peace be upon Him.
We love you in the seek of Allah, may Allah protect you, guide you, and reward you the best of rewards.
jazaakumallaah khoyr..
I love to see reverts who love islam 🎉
Masha'Allah
Salam Alaikum from UK
MashâAllah .. very happy and proud of this podcast we really benefit world wide may Allah Swt accept your efforts.
I have a question for our dear friend
Dr Yassin
Did Imam shafi meet imam Abu Hanifa?
Thank you
Would love to hear more from the Prof 😊
I would love to see Sheikh Okasaha kameny- Al Hirz institute on blogging theology.
Maa Shaa Allah both brothers
اللَّهُمَّ صَلِّ عَلَى مُحَمَّدٍ وَعَلَى آلِ مُحَمَّدٍ كَمَا صَلَّيْتَ عَلَى إِبْرَاهِيمَ وَعَلَى آلِ إِبْرَاهِيمَ، إِنَّكَ حَمِيدٌ مَجِيدٌ، اللَّهُمَّ بَارِكَ عَلَى مُحَمَّدٍ وَعَلَى آلِ مُحَمَّدٍ كَمَا بَارَكْتَ عَلَى إِبْرَاهِيمَ وَعَلَى آلِ إِبْرَاهِيمَ، إِنَّكَ حَمِيدٌ مَجِيدٌ
Wonderful chat .. gave me things to ponder upon n improve myself MashaAllah
39:40 went straight deep into my heart ♥️
There was a man sergent Gordon who accepted islam in early 18th century in India and fought against British East India company along with Muslim rulers of India .... And got martyerd,May Allah please with him and grant him jannat ul firdos...... You guys are making us proud 😢😢
Thanks
Many thanks!
I actually find it funny when Hadith rejecters try to say that the Hadith was written by Al-Bukhari as if we do not have earlier works of Hadith like the Mwatta of Imam Malik.
About hadith, there is a preserved book before the Muata'e, which is the book of Hammam ibn Munabbih (19 - 101/130 AH) which was the student of Abu hurayra the companion of the prophet peace be upon him
Woah mashallah mr Dutton is really knowledge about the history of sharia and fiqh ive learned alot i wish you host him again and discuss the differences between sharia and man mad laws
th-cam.com/video/reh6SItaFxA/w-d-xo.html
Hello professor Williams I am one of your followers and I was wondering if you could make a video about the Muslim schism or Fitna and it current Impact on us as Muslim I know it's a very difficult topic but I believe only a well educated professor such as you with might be able to undertake this truly complex quest I wish you best from the Maghreb region and thank you for bearing with and may Allah bless england and it's people
Masha Allah ❤
im a muslim too..from malaysia👍
Messanger of Allah subhane we te'ala Muhammed salAllahu alejhi we selem , sahabas r,a, & tabins & tabi_tabins and that's it.
That is autenthic 💯
So BEAUTIFUL 🎉😊
Masha Allah. Proud of you guys, learnt alot
Al hamdulilah, beautiful discussion. I believe Umar II was the one who charged Imam Zuhri to commit to writing the ahadith. From the works of Imam Zuhri is the Muwatta born.
I appreciate the valuable comment of your guest prof. Yasin Dutton, why non Muslim scholars study Islam, Quran and the Prophet life’s teaching if they do not have love to the subject? Why they spend all their lives studying what they do not love or believe in!
The key Aya in this issue has been noted well in Quran.
[البقرة:121]:
الَّذِينَ آتَيْنَاهُمُ الْكِتَابَ يَتْلُونَهُ حَقَّ تِلَاوَتِهِ أُولَٰئِكَ يُؤْمِنُونَ بِهِ وَمَن يَكْفُرْ بِهِ فَأُولَٰئِكَ هُمُ الْخَاسِرُونَ.
One correct recitation of Quran, is an evidence of believing in it, others are losers.
[العلق:19]:
كَلَّا لَا تُطِعْهُ وَاسْجُدْ وَاقْتَرِب.
In contrary, do not follow their aggression,(described in verse 6) and adhere to wisdom of identifying right and wrong, acknowledge, mankind earthy nature, bow down and elevate you spirit closer (to Allah).
You mentioned how Prophet Muhammad pbuh looked. Reminds me please check a book by Dr Abdul Hai of Pakistan called Uswai Rasool Akram. You gonna love it..
الله أكبر
ولله الحمد والشكر والثناء و الفضل والمنة
جزاكم الله خير الجزاء في الدنيا والآخرة
الله أكبر والعزة لله عز وجل و لرسوله الكريم وللمؤمنين والمؤمنات الأحياء منهم والأموات
الله أكبر 🕌🕋
You two look very english indeed :D