His vocals in the whole song are phenomenal. His phrasing and tonal changes are so beautiful to the ears, I have been listening to this version for days and may end up losing my hearing :D from how loud I'm playing it.
@@kB-hg2ci agree, vocal effects or not it sounds natural to me.The face expressions and all only add up to the authenticity of his voice.This is Michael Jackson level voice honestly and not many singers worldwide can achieve it
Yes! I've seen his channel recently. He has some great stories and tells them like a great story teller. The kinds of stories that should be told 100s and 1000s of years from now.
2:02...is just pure extasy during Steve's solo because of the baseline that drops an octave, and Simon takes his ride with those smooth gostnotes who are verry clear. Its just an eargasm in the song.
@@Pindamoes Real Singers like Bobby Kimball didn’t need auto tune to sound like that, this band doesn’t come from this day in age. This goes way back in the 70s, think again.
@@elgreco502 they are using a vocal effect. Google it. Members of the band admit it. Check on TH-cam hold the line 2008 Joseph William's and compare the voices .. unless Kimball lost it in a 12 month period I am right (which I am!)
@@mikeblockhead u are not even close.with your theory everybody used auto tuned historically which is not true.he can sing it even acapella dude.for fun
The way Simon purposely takes it down a notch in volume at 2:28 to be able to make the chorus sound huge again is such a genious move! He know EXACTLY which moments he can use for doing this without losing the flow of the song. The man is such a dynanic genious!
@@carlosedmundohurtadomagliu7215 de hecho en este mismo video si te fijas suena increible pero hay algo extraño en la voz de bobby kimball investigue y resulta que uso alguna especie de afinador digital tipo Autotune, en otros temas se noto mas, y en otros temas de esta misma gira directamente uso grabaciones originales e hizo Playback
This Toto line up was truly one of a kind! No one else can do it like Bobby Kimball! The sheer volume of pure soul that comes out with everything he sings can never be replicated! Also Greg Phillinganes and Leland Sklar were incredibly amazing filling in for Paich, Steven and Mike..with Sklar learning the whole set in just 5 days..following Mikes last minute hand injury..and Greg covering parts of both Paich and Steven..absolute legends! And that Music Man much like the big toms never fails in the hands of Lukather and Simon Philips respectively! Incredibly stellar line up! My most favorite Toto concert!
I always feel like im playing #GTA SAN ANDREAS when every time i listening to this song so awesome haha i feel old now haha im 21 right now turning 22 this month haha
Fala pessoal! Cadê os brasileiro de bom gosto? acabei de legendar essa música!! Quem curtir traduções, só acessar o canal! Obrigado pela oportunidade!!
![Toto - Rosanna, Africa, Hold The Line & Stop Loving You (live) [2024]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/pG0-_z77-Q4/mqdefault.jpg)
![Toto - Rosanna, Africa, Hold The Line & Stop Loving You (live) [2024]](/img/tr.png)
What a fuckin beast Bobby Kimball is. Goddamn.
Haha. Yes
Bobby Kimbal is a legend. Steve Lukather is a legend hands down. Most underrated guitarist since Mark knopfler.
Not among guitarists! He’s a legend
Mark Knopfler and Steve Lukather are my 2 favorite guitarists
Bobby Kimball is simply amazing
He really is...it's like he got better!
This is clearly auto tuned though..
@@KyrstenPourchelle agree. Better range
@@smashanakali Yes. That's the first thought that went through my head when he started singing
@@LucasFigueiredoBR indeed. The backing vocals and guitars even sound auto tuned as well.
The run Bobby does at 1:30 is what makes me keep coming back to this version and what sets peak Bobby Kimball above all of the other singers for Toto
It's literal autotune lol
His vocals in the whole song are phenomenal. His phrasing and tonal changes are so beautiful to the ears, I have been listening to this version for days and may end up losing my hearing :D from how loud I'm playing it.
@@kB-hg2ci agree, vocal effects or not it sounds natural to me.The face expressions and all only add up to the authenticity of his voice.This is Michael Jackson level voice honestly and not many singers worldwide can achieve it
This is the definitive version of this song in my opinion
Agreed! Exquisite!
dont care how many lead singers Toto brings aboard, none will get to Bobby Kimball, he is above the rest!!! what a voice!!!!
Wait what! That's Lee Sklar on bass. He tours with Phil Collins also. Awesome.
Saw Leland on Phil's "But Seriously" tour... Was awesome!
Have you seen his channel. He talks about all of this stuff. He's great.
Yes! I've seen his channel recently. He has some great stories and tells them like a great story teller. The kinds of stories that should be told 100s and 1000s of years from now.
He stood in for Mike in this tour, he had injured his hand! An unbelievable bass player!!
He’s played on numerous bands
Just wanna reiterate that Bobby Kimball, the lead singer, was 60 during this concert.
That's fuckin ridiculous. The guy is a monster! Legend!
So amazing!
Dude is a boss!!!
Damn he sounded great.
@@sullym1867 no, the auto tune sounded great.
The vocal, the instruments, the rythm section, Jesus Christ superstar! 😮💪🎵🤘
Leland Sklar, on Bass... one of the greatest Bass Guitarists, ever. Sought after by all of the great bands- live or in the studio.
And on his TH-cam channel
He looks like he should be playing in a country music/southern rock band, but a gig is a gig
I thought it God
@@gocappy He has toured extensively with James Taylor and Phil Collins.
The best of the best, thanks, guys....
This song is immortal! Gives goosebumps all the time! ♥️
Unreal. Better than studio version. Insane.....after all those years. True masters of the craft.
Bobby it's amazing, great voice.
It’s a joke how good this song is, just perfect and they smash every live performance I’ve ever seen.
2:02...is just pure extasy during Steve's solo because of the baseline that drops an octave, and Simon takes his ride with those smooth gostnotes who are verry clear. Its just an eargasm in the song.
Bassline*, Ghost notes*
I have no idea how he plays that and I've been avidly practicing electric guitar for 17 years. His level of skill is truly incredible.
Magic happens when you get three musicians of that caliber together
This live version sounds amazing
bro he has live autotune
Lau 01 not live, but later added in post production.
@@Pindamoes If he's using autotune then why was there a wrong note on 3:32?
@@Pindamoes Real Singers like Bobby Kimball didn’t need auto tune to sound like that, this band doesn’t come from this day in age. This goes way back in the 70s, think again.
@@EastDetroitMusic-Sirens3000A people can’t fathom actually singing now lmao
How can you listen to 2019 music when this kind of band exists ?
ikr
With my ears
@@ImJustHereMan adorable that people call that modern autotuned crap "music"
Yep and Iron Maiden..!
How can you listen to 2022 music when this kind of band exists?
Bob!!!!! MAN his vocals are so underrated!!!! Man he can blow!!!!
I Guess Gandalf didn’t want to be a wizard anymore and decided to play bass
jeff R Leland Sklar.
Just thinking the bass player kinda looks like Sharuman or Albus Dumbledore
that's the legend Leland Sklar.
HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!!!!
His name is Leland Sklar, the God Of Bass. Worship Him.
What a MASTERPIECE!
Vocal highlight at 01:30.......superb :-)
he is outrageous.
It is auto tuned!
@@mikeblockhead not even close dude.hahaha
@@elgreco502 they are using a vocal effect. Google it. Members of the band admit it. Check on TH-cam hold the line 2008 Joseph William's and compare the voices .. unless Kimball lost it in a 12 month period I am right (which I am!)
@@mikeblockhead u are not even close.with your theory everybody used auto tuned historically which is not true.he can sing it even acapella dude.for fun
Absolutely fantastic performance. The best in the business!!!!
Grande Bobby Kimball en la voz
I don't know why, this lead singer is so amazing
The way Simon purposely takes it down a notch in volume at 2:28 to be able to make the chorus sound huge again is such a genious move! He know EXACTLY which moments he can use for doing this without losing the flow of the song. The man is such a dynanic genious!
Bobby cantou demais nesse dvd...falsete lindo nessa musica
This is an AMAZING performance!
Bobby. One of my all time favorite singers. And the only one for this Group!
I saw them on this tour, it was absolutely awesome, I was about 10 ft from the stage.
I would give up anything to be born in that era & be in that crowd… LARGER THAN LIFE
Mr.Robert Kimball, the one and only voice of TOTO, thx for the time with you Bobby
35 años y siguen intocables, inigualables. Las mejores bandas del mundo mundial.
Ya 40
seriously. so good I wanna cry...
What a voice! Even auto-tune would be amazed.
Wow what a powerful voice thanks for the memories bobby hope you are doing well
HOT DAMN!!! What a fantastic performance from EVERYONE!!! THIS IS TOTO!
Years later and ya still can't beat this music. Toto rocks. Period. Bobby's voice was fantastic in the day too, and not bad to look at either.
Gracias. Buenísimo. Esta versión es lo máximo. Como hubiera querido estar en ese concierto.
100%
Los suenos se hacen en realidad...algun dia esto va a pasar
@@vaidas1965 no ya no ya que el vocalista original ya no está en la banda y tampoco suena como en este video
@@MysteriousDash ,es verdad Bobby perdió el tono de antes, ahora reemplaza otro grande de Toto.
@@carlosedmundohurtadomagliu7215 de hecho en este mismo video si te fijas suena increible pero hay algo extraño en la voz de bobby kimball investigue y resulta que uso alguna especie de afinador digital tipo Autotune, en otros temas se noto mas, y en otros temas de esta misma gira directamente uso grabaciones originales e hizo Playback
He sings if he will hear this last time his voice. Amazing. Best live performance of this song
RELEASED IN 1978 The 70s were the BOOOOOMB ..
That solo= my whole career of playing guitar
Toto: Let's have fun and play this song to perfection while acting like its easier than breathing.
Everyone else: struggles with the first riff.
So awesome seeing Leland Sklar up there with them! This is the song that got me into rock n’ roll at a very young age.
Amazing performance.
The singer is an absolute beast
Autotuned or not, insane vocal performance from bobby
Pure facts. Thanks for posting this.
Yea no matter the autotune I absolutely love his voice in this concert
Agree, but curious about how it would sound without it
@@noD1va Just as good th-cam.com/video/649VM3sy7ek/w-d-xo.html
How do you know it’s autotuned?
Da brividi, non smetto di ascoltarli qui, Bobby, la chitarra, tutti, 💗💗💗💗💗💗💗
*Real Music* *Real Energy*
Wishing that beautiful stuff on all the future kids and generations.
2:43 snare sound are amazing
The man who plays keyboards is a legend!
Greg Philinganes
His glissandos were perfect . I still can't do a perfect one . Dang
and on this tour he was covering the parts of two keyboards both Davids ans Steves
Always fantastic!!
Best love video ever.
I love this Song so much
Just AMAZING!!
hold the line, in our opinion .................. the best.
Music will never be this good again, oh well
La mejor versión, sin duda, tremendo
Muito fã dessa Banda ❤❤🎸🎵
Toto ⭐
This Toto line up was truly one of a kind! No one else can do it like Bobby Kimball! The sheer volume of pure soul that comes out with everything he sings can never be replicated! Also Greg Phillinganes and Leland Sklar were incredibly amazing filling in for Paich, Steven and Mike..with Sklar learning the whole set in just 5 days..following Mikes last minute hand injury..and Greg covering parts of both Paich and Steven..absolute legends! And that Music Man much like the big toms never fails in the hands of Lukather and Simon Philips respectively! Incredibly stellar line up! My most favorite Toto concert!
After watching this version, I can't watch another - Toto and Bobby Kimball at their best....
I just love this!¬!!!!!!!!!!
Não canso de ver essa performance
Bobby great version good to see you brother.
autotune
Bob is one the greatest vocalist in the last time , monster .
Que nunca muera esta canción!!!
Part of me wishes Bobby's voice didn't have that much autotune.
Another part of me is glad he does considering his recent performances.
What a great voice even out of his prime
Menudos cracks, grandes TOTO!!!!
Gta san andreas is the reason why I started listening to TOTO
or Vice City ;)
Vice City and San Andreas. Amazing selection of songs.
@@RateOfChange KDST bro and emotion
Go toto
woooo hoooo...............................TOTO !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
J adore
La legendaria Banda de Rock TOTO...!!! con Boby Kimball...la mejor voz de la banda x 100 pre
The best Rock Cocert has been ever ...existed by Far...Bobby : WoooW
That drummer is killer
Unbelievable voice
... ,this is ,po Piči- Nádhernééé.Ďakujem Toto.
there is Gandalf on the Bass, i know him from phil collins, he got a mighty power i guess
I miss the original solo, I was waiting for it
How fuckly good Simon play this song !!! So groovy !!
Crazy good!
There you go .
2021 and this song still Kicks @ss!!! 🤘😀
I always feel like im playing #GTA SAN ANDREAS when every time i listening to this song so awesome haha i feel old now haha im 21 right now turning 22 this month haha
Nobody can replace bobby kimball.♥️💪💪💪👏👏👏👏👍👍👍👍
Canta muito
larga vida a TOTO ..!
I appreciated this song way more after this 👍
Loved seeing Bobby at his peak!
Them and journey completely destroyed the Spokane arena! Damn perfect concert
Really nice to see Chris Evans in the crowd rocking to this great song!
Year 2300, still this song!
Ain't that a fact .
So amazing. Bobby kimball👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻💙
Fala pessoal! Cadê os brasileiro de bom gosto? acabei de legendar essa música!! Quem curtir traduções, só acessar o canal! Obrigado pela oportunidade!!
Leland Sklar is in every video from 80's pop bands.
Fantasticno Sale guitarman.
The glory days ❤❤❤
Bravo....Toto....
Love it 😍
Panoramix on bass ruleZZ! Go Lee!
Lo mejor de lo mejor toto
Lee Sklar is the time traveler. He played with EVERYBODY