such a performance by a little known orchestra who is so young outshines many performances by well-known conductors and orchestras; they deserve to be on the world stage like Carnegie Hall or Royal Albert Hall, and i have listened to more than 36 recordings of Mahler's Third, what a gem!!!
In 1.46 Cameraman take a shot when i played on “Air” it’s not my mistake BECAUSE I hear the 32” drum it’s a little bit flat, so i try to play Ghost movement. I don’t know cameraman behind me 😂😂😂
O-M-G!!! I cannot believe what you have accomplished. You are to be the new beacon in Asia! And what blows my mind is that you reached the level of Mahler to communicate grandiose human feelings. Knowing that most of you are so young, I know that in the future you will keep on impressing us more and more!
Love the four pairs of cymbals. All of those utility percussionists have pretty much just been sitting around since the first movement, so why not give them more to do!
Mahler would have loved it. He loved percussion. What he also would have liked to have had there, are stronger trombones. It's only two on a part (2 part writing), and it's a strain for them to belt their watermelons out at a full fortissimo. I sometimes think there should 6 'bones there, so you have three on a part.
controversial. in the last moments of the 3rd Mahler wanted to differentiate it from the Pan's march, so he didn't mark everything fff, but instead playing fully. for me personally as long as the cymbals have a lasting sound im a happy man
Mahler titled his 8th Symphony ( The Symphony of a Thousand ) so it makes sense that he would have wanted as many musicians on stage including 4 Cymbal players
@@ianng9915 Youre correct and I know this- but Richard Williams referred to his 8th and then suggested why the 3rd would need 4 cymbals....while the 3rd was written in 1896 and the 8th in 1910. His dating was out of order
Thanks a lot for uploading this fragment! Full symphony: th-cam.com/video/PGyxJQgrf7c/w-d-xo.html I scoured TH-cam for Mahler 3 videos with more than two cymbals in this moment and could only find these (with three). Does anyone know of any other videos with four cymbals? th-cam.com/video/LVVoGYFu49E/w-d-xo.htmlsi=NaYNwXuhrsyY7W98&t=5868 (Philharmonia Orchestra) th-cam.com/video/lzksRzeEeDw/w-d-xo.htmlsi=GzvZk7cn51-dNxqV&t=6061 (KBS Symphony Orchestra, 2017) th-cam.com/video/wurlZpFG4k8/w-d-xo.htmlsi=7b6lWUCdGMnabuge&t=5869 (KBS Symphony Orchestra, 2024) th-cam.com/video/KAAHxzcoWMY/w-d-xo.htmlsi=DwGAu91YaJFxvzlI&t=5760 (Basque Symphony Orchestra) th-cam.com/video/2TATNdVy7a8/w-d-xo.htmlsi=ICAu4nukaoAX9Ycg&t=6720 (Utrechtsch Studenten Concert) th-cam.com/video/HWoqvbyyfHE/w-d-xo.htmlsi=FvzijTPXTLG8TwyR&t=5554 (Colorado MahlerFest Orchestra)
I played this piece again last year (cymbals part) I wanna play with 3-4 cymbals again but we have no more percussionist… So I played with 22” by hoping it’s enough for this moment like 3-4 cymbals😂 th-cam.com/users/shortsg9kOupHPtEc?si=7w9eOGj4MwEXCW3r
He has health problem, so that's why he can't stand to conducted for long piece p.s. Actually, many old conductors sitting down to conduct such as Rafael Frühbeck de Burgos
Then you have not seeing much! Are those the parameters by you judge a performance? Have you seeing James DuPriest? Leif Segerstam？Oh! You don’t know them? Then study a little more. And don't start whining if they don't use a baton!
Mahler 3. Underperformed and underrated. A magnificent symphony, and of course you get more Mahler in this than in any other!
Mahler is overrated. Shut up. This student orchestra is average and needs to go back to practice
My fave Mahler symphony
Absolutely stunning performance. 4 pairs of cymbals was FANTASTIC !!!!!!
This is EPIC! You know it will be when you have 8 timpani to play two notes, and 4 pairs of cymbals for that epic moment!
such a performance by a little known orchestra who is so young outshines many performances by well-known conductors and orchestras; they deserve to be on the world stage like Carnegie Hall or Royal Albert Hall, and i have listened to more than 36 recordings of Mahler's Third, what a gem!!!
I agree- marvelous playing
Always love the timpani parts here.
Yeah! Me too!!
I love the timpani parts too
In 1.46 Cameraman take a shot when i played on “Air” it’s not my mistake
BECAUSE I hear the 32” drum it’s a little bit flat, so i try to play Ghost movement. I don’t know cameraman behind me 😂😂😂
Never even noticed until you pointed it out! Awesome playing
@@MrTableturns thank you very much!😂
O-M-G!!! I cannot believe what you have accomplished. You are to be the new beacon in Asia! And what blows my mind is that you reached the level of Mahler to communicate grandiose human feelings. Knowing that most of you are so young, I know that in the future you will keep on impressing us more and more!
Thank you very much!
Superb playing. This should be the way the percussion should sound. The tempo was wonderful. Almost up there with Bernstein and Abbado.
This performance invigorates the human spirit
Love the four pairs of cymbals. All of those utility percussionists have pretty much just been sitting around since the first movement, so why not give them more to do!
😂😂😂
Probably the only conductor who wrote science fiction and horror novels in one of his lives 🚀
I do not think Mahler intended the 4 cymbal players to be involved but nevertheless it was effective
Mahler would have loved it. He loved percussion. What he also would have liked to have had there, are stronger trombones. It's only two on a part (2 part writing), and it's a strain for them to belt their watermelons out at a full fortissimo. I sometimes think there should 6 'bones there, so you have three on a part.
Mahler would probably have had forty if he could have afforded them!
controversial. in the last moments of the 3rd Mahler wanted to differentiate it from the Pan's march, so he didn't mark everything fff, but instead playing fully. for me personally as long as the cymbals have a lasting sound im a happy man
Mahler's intention was "more cymbals", same in the repetition of 1. Movement after the second horn call.
There are four trombone parts.@@barryguerrero7652
In my opinion, this symphony is considered among the greats, it's better than the 8th tho. His 4th and 7th are underrated gems.
Bravo!!
Very nice - is there (or will there be) an upload of the entire symphony?
th-cam.com/video/PGyxJQgrf7c/w-d-xo.html
thank you very much! this is video link for full performance!
Mahler titled his 8th Symphony ( The Symphony of a Thousand ) so it makes sense that he would have wanted as many musicians on stage including 4 Cymbal players
But this is only the 3rd? Mahler didnt come up with the title "Symphony of a thousand"- the promoter- Emil Guttman did!
@@hillcresthiker he has 9 symphonies plus a symphonic song cycles. His 8th is the biggest but probably not for everyone unless you’re listening live.
@@ianng9915 Youre correct and I know this- but Richard Williams referred to his 8th and then suggested why the 3rd would need 4 cymbals....while the 3rd was written in 1896 and the 8th in 1910. His dating was out of order
why did i cryyy?
excellent
Thank you!
Awesome. Keep in mind this happens after one and half hour of performing 😅.
Yeah
Thanks a lot for uploading this fragment! Full symphony: th-cam.com/video/PGyxJQgrf7c/w-d-xo.html
I scoured TH-cam for Mahler 3 videos with more than two cymbals in this moment and could only find these (with three). Does anyone know of any other videos with four cymbals?
th-cam.com/video/LVVoGYFu49E/w-d-xo.htmlsi=NaYNwXuhrsyY7W98&t=5868 (Philharmonia Orchestra)
th-cam.com/video/lzksRzeEeDw/w-d-xo.htmlsi=GzvZk7cn51-dNxqV&t=6061 (KBS Symphony Orchestra, 2017)
th-cam.com/video/wurlZpFG4k8/w-d-xo.htmlsi=7b6lWUCdGMnabuge&t=5869 (KBS Symphony Orchestra, 2024)
th-cam.com/video/KAAHxzcoWMY/w-d-xo.htmlsi=DwGAu91YaJFxvzlI&t=5760 (Basque Symphony Orchestra)
th-cam.com/video/2TATNdVy7a8/w-d-xo.htmlsi=ICAu4nukaoAX9Ycg&t=6720 (Utrechtsch Studenten Concert)
th-cam.com/video/HWoqvbyyfHE/w-d-xo.htmlsi=FvzijTPXTLG8TwyR&t=5554 (Colorado MahlerFest Orchestra)
I played this piece again last year (cymbals part) I wanna play with 3-4 cymbals again but we have no more percussionist…
So I played with 22” by hoping it’s enough for this moment like 3-4 cymbals😂
th-cam.com/users/shortsg9kOupHPtEc?si=7w9eOGj4MwEXCW3r
I should think you need lungs the size of Thailand to sustain those chords
For some reason, it kinda weirdly reminds me of Shostakovich 4th's ending.
What's up with the MASK???
Because the Covid measures
This is in no way to be offensive but I don't think I've EVER seen a conductor sitting down while conducting a performance. It threw me off haha
He has health problem, so that's why he can't stand to conducted for long piece
p.s. Actually, many old conductors sitting down to conduct such as Rafael Frühbeck de Burgos
And Beecham and Klempera in 1960s
@@williamtucker7595 yep I saw Klemperer conduct Mahler 2 at the RFH sitting down.
Ever heard of Celibidache?
Then you have not seeing much! Are those the parameters by you judge a performance? Have you seeing James DuPriest? Leif Segerstam？Oh! You don’t know them? Then study a little more. And don't start whining if they don't use a baton!
👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽