The Russian Civil War: Every Day [MAJOR ERRORS]
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 20 พ.ค. 2024
- A detailed map animation of Northern Eurasia between 1917 and 1931, focusing on the Russian Civil War, but also showing some peripheral conflicts.
Independent states are labelled by their country names (e.g, Poland, Hungary, etc.), provisional governments by their government names (e.g., Provisional Government of the Northern Region, Autonomous Chukotka Government, etc.), and holdout forces by their commanding officer (e.g., Semyonov, Nikolayev, etc.)
Chinese warlords are shown, albeit simplified considerably. They are labelled by the short form of their provincial names, so:
Feng = Fengtian
Wan = Anhui
Xin = Xinjiang
Ning Gan = Ninghai-Gansu Ma Clique
Ninghai = Ma Clique
Jin = Shanxi Clique
0:00 Intro
0:10 October Revolution
0:36 White Resurgence
1:41 Soviet Resurgence
1:52 Destruction of White Remnants
4:53 Minor Rebellions Crushed
5:19 Outro
Dates are year.month.day. Months are represented by numbers.
A video I used to help make this: • Національно-визвольна ...
Discord: / discord
Minor mistake: North Sakhalin was returned to the Soviets on 1925.5.26
better than EmperorTigerstar or Suomi!
@@user-bq6mc9eq9f yes
Wow this is the best one by far well done!
Its not minor, great video anyways
Really bad map. This map is confusing. Why does Japan and White movement have same colours? You can't tell apart which is which. 2/10 shit map Made in China
The Russian Civil War: Every mapper's worst nightmare
The citizen of the internet mappers who had to make a video on the interwar: *laughs in pain*
HRE and EIC are very worst
@don't read my profile picture the what?
@Eros Matthew Montallana the Holy Roman Empire?
@@birbseesall1529 East India Company
Russia: engaged in a total, all encompassing, multi-sided civil war.
_meanwhile in the trans-siberian railway_
"i'm starting to think this isn't prague"
Real history): - My commander, what if the Bolsheviks want to disarm us and we cannot get to the Entente forces or give us captivity to the central powers?
- We will capture half of Russia
Someone: lets you hear that Czechoslovak troops will be disarmed
(It is not true)
Many cities: We embrace the radical democracy of councils on our territory. Glory to the Communists!
Czechoslovaks: Nope
2/3 of the former tsarist officer, supporters of the Mensheviks, right wing Socialist Revolutionaries and constitutional democrats: Thank you so much
Lenin in the Smolny Palace: Fuck you
@@BonduoChannel can you elaborate more on the czevhoslovak legion? because i can't really understand this.
@@BonduoChannel What is right wing socialism?
@@Someone111ify he talks about faction of SR party that opposed the October revolution.
@@iamseamonkey6688 basically those Czech forces were fighting under Russian command since the Russians promised to free Czechoslovakia from Austria-Hungary if they cooperated and in which they did. But when the civil war began, the Czech legions were trapped in a chaotic multi-front civil war. The only way for Czech forces to successfully evacuate was through the trans-Siberian railway into Vladivostok in the far east. Which they actually succeeded with the help of Japanese forces.
Fun Fact: if you look at the top-right corner of the map, you will notice that Wrangel Island is occupied by Canada for a while: such as in 4:29. The island was part of Russia but it was uninhabited. Later on, a bunch of Canadian sailors got shipwrecked and took refuge on the island. Believing the island was unclaimed since it was uninhabitated, the sailors leader made a mistake and claimed the island without authorisation. The Soviet Union was furious and Canada immediately dropped all claims to the island. Well done Yan Xishan at the fact that you even went into the detail to write about a tiny uninhabited island that isn't part of the main civil war conflict.
It's not that tiny of an island actually
@@Firemarioflower It depends on your frame of reference. Compared to the entire Russia, and the full civil war, it is a very small detail. Then again, the entire video is full of intricacies, but I mention the Wrangel Island incident because it wasn't part of the Civil war.
And why would Canada listen to the SU? it's not like they were with their hands empty and more pressing matters at the moment. Maybe they didn't even recognized their government.
@@AlexLangerak Well maybe cause a bunch of illegitimate sailors decided to claim the island. The Canadian government didn't authorise the island to be theirs. Also, it is just a piece of ice and has no real worth, do you really think Canada would fight a war over the island even if they didn't recognise the SU?
@@HelithaGM Not fight a war with the S.U., but simply ignore the claims or even giving it back to White Russia
After looking at the Chinese and Russian Civil War I say: There is no First and Second World War. There is one Eurasian War which lasts from 1912 to 1949. :o
Hope this will never happen again, unless it is in SPACE! lol
So many interrelated conflicts... and I will amend (1867)-(1991(active))-(ongoing-middle east/Russia-Ukraine) All conflicts, from the start of the break up of the Ottoman Empire to to the fall of the USSR (with any additional related ongoing conflicts) relate in a very complicated web of interaction... you can thank the advent of global diplomacy for this. (Although regionally a line can be drawn to the beginning of recorded history, in some instances, it wasn't until the 19th century that conflicts began to take on a truly global aspect.)
@@notbeiliu1539 whoa space communism!
Stop it I can only get so aroused
Yep, not to mention there were soviet republics in Germany and Hungary that got crushed. The horrors of war showed that it only makes sense to risk your life for your class and abolishment of classes, and not for monopolies and corporations ruling your country. And it never stopped in 1949, it keeps going.
@@notbeiliu1539 hate to break it to you but space is fake
The amount of detail is unparalleled. Nothing seems to escape your eyes.
@@olumluhayatbugunvarsinyari534 uh.. I have no idea what you just said but ok.
That's 'cause the creator of this video is asian
*Stalingrad*
@@thecitizenoftheinternet1077 lol
全世界无产阶级联合起来
Впервые вижу такое детальное воспроизведение военных действий. Гигантский труд!
Why does Japan and White movement have same colours? *wtf Xishan* ? Почему Япония и Белые одинаково окращены, что за хня.
@@fyurerys Белые и Антанта обозначаются одними цветами. Японцы в первой мировой воевали на стороне Антанты, потому и цвет тот же
@@rinrin1187 в период гражданской, они воевали конкретно против России. И против белых, и против красных. Чел правильно подметил, ибо Японцы должны быть выделаны отдельным цветом.
Такая себе карта. Почему отдельно была показана Якутия, хотя она не провозглашала независимость?
@@danieldeleon1270 тем не менее, лучшее что есть на ютубе.
Semyonov: Okay, Sternberg there's still the possibility for us to retreat safel-
Sternberg: *invading Mongolia*
What Could Go Wrong?
Дааа Монголия!
Yeees, Mongolia!
WHAT? HOW?
*Music starts playing*
Semyonov: Dies
Sternberg: dies trying to retake Semyonov/Transbaikal territory
He actually liberated Mongolia
This is BY FAR the most detailed mapping of the Russian Civil War I've seen on youtube. Really puts all other big mapping youtubers to shame.
2000 drawing i am rip
i bet this was brutal to make
At least someone understands.
@@yanxishan6575 can you PLEAAAASE make one on the history of Nepal
Or how Gorkha Kingdom unified Nepal
I really wanna see it
Also, I subscribed you for you hard work and dedication towards your channel
yeah quite a *brutal revolution* (not funny) to make
@@coolguy3848 Napoleon fat
What complicated war, there were so many sides. And I didn't realise there was still some fighting so much later
Micahistory 2 . Me neither. That is why we need more people on TH-cam for this
@@srezno-ivan2006 yeah. I agree
"And I didn't realise there was still some fighting so much later" Make sense out of simple "explanation" about "paranoid" Stalin, huh?
@@Ailasher maybe it's because you don't know anything about history
@@zenitsu1909 lol Some random shittard from a internet comments section wants to teach me about the history? I hope not! Better teach you ass, shittard!
Normal civil war: fight between 2 group
Russia: za warudo
Очень детальная и красивая работа, с учетом всех сил, без примитивного деления на белых и красных. Огромное спасибо, было интересно.
если на то пошло - где интервенты французские-английские-американские
@@Pilum1000 антанта
@@user-eg1vn6id4z не особо детально тогда :>
@@Pilum1000 Такие детали были бы уже излишними. Делить антантовских интервентов по национальности здесь не имеет никакого смысла, т.к. они все преследовали общие цели в этой войне и очень близко сотрудничали (например, на Дальнем Востоке принимали участие американцы вместе с японцами, а в архангельско-мурманских краях - американцы с англичанами).
@@lxv97 это не совсем так. кое-какие цели у них различались и действовали они раздельно в целом и даже уходили по разному :>
и если детали излишни - то что за претензии к другим - деталям :>
хотя коэш это не подход уже вовсе
Прекрасная карта, на которой показаны все значительные государственные образования на территории бывшей Российской Империи, а не простое разделение на "белых" и "красных".
какие блять образования, не было никаких образований. еще скажи украина была хаахах.
Ты серьёзно сейчас?
Государственные образования - это конечно сильно сказано, но тут скорее идеологические стороны делились не просто на красных и белых, хотя те и другие в основе своей поддерживали ту или иную сторону.
@@fyurerys Ну а что на карте не видно УНР?
@@mitteleuropa8485 что за унр. там Белоруси нет и Украины т.к. и не было, какая унр. была ток УССР, БССР.
1:49 Kolchak: Wait, that's illegal!
That part is sad
*tips budenovka*
-Nothing personal, kiddo...
The bolsheviks literally ran across a distance of thousands of miles within just a few days and teleported themselves to Siberia.
Я жив так-то
Czechs: nic osobního kluka
Transsiberian Railway: Exists
Czechoslovak Legion: *It's free real estate*
The full story is just completely insane. Some Czechs and Slovaks decided to fight for the Russians to help defeat the Austrian Empire and gain independence for Czechoslovakia. Then the Revolution started and the Reds took control of the western borders. Since the Czechs and Slovaks had been fighting for the Whites, they were cut off from their way home. Even if they could get through the Reds, they then would run into Austrian and German armies that considered them traitors.
Also, the Whites were more or less falling into anarchy and so the Czechs and Slovaks said "screw you guys, I'm going home". Can't go west through the frontlines, so they took control of the Transsiberian Railway to get all their people to the Pacific, take ships to Vancouver, then cross North America to New York and again take ships to get to France. And then you're pretty much home. Easy.
Yeah, basically whites were screwed once the 70.000 men numbering army of non-existent state fought their way through Russia and escaped
And 10-11 thousands Czechs and Slovaks fought in Red Army in internationalist battalions with Germans, Austrians and Romanians.
@@Yora21 They didn't have to fight their way through the "Reds". They could do it quite freely. But the Entente forced them to oppose the "Red" to win the "white" and the Russians again began war with Germany.
@@user-yg5hl7gr7j not true. Red attacked Czechs after trying to disarm them, and then they attacked Czechs when they seized golden treasure of the state
not gonna lie, EmperorTigerstar films looks amateur compared to your one
That's the standard I try to meet when making these.
@@yanxishan6575 ur from china?
@@erwinrommel6561 From the REAL China.
Emperor refuses to update his style. Look at Olye Bye latest video about Asia. He overtook Tigerstar eons ago. Pretty much every mapmaker nowadays is better than tigerstar, he doesn't even make maps anymore all that often.
@@nqh4393 Taiwan numba one!
Seriously, I’m so impressed by your map work. I would literally pay you to create videos about world war 1 and 2, the Chinese civil war, and the Russo Japanese war, and I mean on all fronts.
You’ve somehow managed to collect such a vast and detailed amount of research on wars that are hard to get info on. I don’t know how, but you have done it.
Seriously, please don’t give up on mapping. If you did this type of mapping for the world wars, you’d likely have the most accurate videos of them in the entire mapping community.
You’ve earned my subscription long ago, but I’d do it again just for every one of your videos. Keep up the good work!
Thank you so much!
@@yanxishan6575 i wonder what you could do if you made a join button
@@yanxishan6575 I love these maps and this creativity and research you have
Late 1919
Whites: You're about to lose the war
Reds in Yakutia: Say it no more
1923:
Reds: youre about to lose the war
Whites in yakutia: say no more
The Virgin regular civil wars VS The chad Russian Civil War
It's sad that this war isn't that well known. In school they told us that the Bolsheviks took over the government and began to make the country Communist but they never talked about the Civil War which tried to stop Communisn. This war was probably one of the most significant wars of the 20th century if not the most. It's overshadowed by the World War but in some ways caused them too.
@@brrrrrtenjoyer In my point of view was a Great Eurasian war (1914-1951)
10 million dead in the war, another 5 million farmers killed and 10 million died in the famine afterwards.
@@ivanbregar1646
> another 5 million farmers killed and 10 million died in the famine afterwards
What evidence you have?
The virgin two-sided American Civil War vs. the chad Russian free-for-all.
What I love about your videos is how much detail you put into them. I’ve never seen a Russian Civil War video that did as good a job as you did in showing all the little factions that were involved. Fantastic job as always!
A vast amount of work have been done!
It's the most accurate map of Russian Revolution I've found in TH-cam.
Thank you and Spasibo!
I see your daddy gave you a good advice.
@@isthatyoujohhwayne My dady gave me advice to how not to rip the skin
@@Akaki1999 by using someone else's mouth instead of your own hand.
Imagine the brutality that occurred every time a colour moved
Emperor Ssraeshza Wrong.
Emperor Ssraeshza the Zionist Bolsheviks opposed the Orthodox monarchy, and the atrocities they’ve committed on the Russian people will never be forgotten. They’re going to burn in hell for the Marxist cancer they’ve spread across the world.
Dycewyfe it doesn’t matter, Tsarists were as bad as Reds.
@@Dycewyfe 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
@@Dycewyfe
Lol learn the definition about zionism.
"the youtuber, not the leader of the Jin Clique" -- oh. Thanks for clarifying.
A big like.
You have truly impressed me! This is one of the best and most detailed! Most mappers skip over the rebellions that took place in the years following the defeat of the main white forces in 1924-1925! Simply amazing!
Minor mistake, Pskov was occupied by the Germans on the 24th of February. Still nothing that important, very detailed video.
Это по старому календарю.
@@AlexIsoyan yeah iirc thats why there are anachronistics naming if not checked the calendars the name is decembrist but its in red october not sure
Actually including anarchists for a change?
Thank you good sir for creating the best civil war map i ever seen
Anarcho TV exactly what I was thinking
Nestor Makhno you and your movement held out for 4 full years against the Bolsheviks, the Germans and the Whites. Now that’s what I call bravery.
@@Vox_Popul1 they weren't anarchists, but bandits.
3450D no they weren’t, Makhno even signed an alliance treaty with the Red Army twice to defeat the White Army, he was also the creator of the Free Territory of Ukraine and of the Makhnovshchina. He was an anarchist revolutionary and deserves to be remembered as such.
The Red army allied with the Ucrainan anarchists had murdered 6,000-8,000 Ukrainian Jews alone 1919. Fuck communists
Definitely one of, if not the best quality videos of the civil war out there. Detail is amazing and you've mentioned things i didn't even know about (Like the existence of the All-Russian Government, and the series of rebellions after White Movement defeat)
And oh yeah, music fits amazingly well
Great job man!
Another masterpiece, thanks so much for keeping these uploads regular!
Wow this is more qccurate and detailed than emperor tigerstar! I didn't know there were so many rebels after 1923.
Also didn't know we Canadians claimed a tiny Arctic island off the coast of Siberia.
More details no accurate 😂😂😂😂 idiot
First Name Last Name You put no detail in your Grammar I see?
@@kevinward550 so why does that matter if we're on the interbet 🤔🤔🤤💁👅😂😂🙃
@@firstnamelastname7079 Just because we're on the internet doesn't mean you can speak gibberish
@@kevinward550 haha gibberish is janavakvaaksnsk silly!😂😂💩💩🤙👌
1:36 Russian Soviet Federative Socialist Republic: cheat activated
Absolutely brilliant work, well done! I'm impressed by your close tracking of the shifting northern front in 1918; however, that front was a *tiny* bit more dynamic during 1919 than this video shows, with the White/Allied forces and the Bolos pushing one another up and down the Northern Dvina River during the summer, and the final surge by the Whites under Colonel Muruzi after the Allied withdrawal. But perhaps on this scale of map, those movements would hardly show up anyway.
This is amazing. The amount of work and detail put into this is simply tremendous.
Спасибо за качественный контент!)
This is one of the most detailed mapping videos I've ever seen! Great work!
A war more people should know about. My grandfather was in the Russian Imperial cavalry. He was wounded fighting the Germans and later fought the Bolsheviks. Ended up in Canada where he married another refugee from Russia. When things go wrong in Russia, they go REALLY wrong.
The sheer amount of detail is overwhelming. You did a great job.
Probably the most Detailed and Historicly Accurate Mapmof the Civil War. love how You also Included Gurrilias and the Basmashi Movement
One of the best mapping videos on the Russian Civil War. Great work, keep it up.
I can't imagine how much time and effort it takes to research and animate this... If there's somebody on TH-cam who deserves more subscribers and recognition, it's you
This really deserves a thumbs up ! Great work and a lot of small things that weren't present in 90% of the other videos about the Russian civil war were all here and in great detail non the less. I congratulate you for your effort.
Your attention to detail is incredible! I think this is one of the greatest mapping videos I've ever seen. Keep up the fantastic work!
This is incredibly detailed, I can't imagine the amount of work and time you must of put into this!
The research part of this is what impresses me most of all. But it was worth it, great work my friend, the result is amazing!
This is so amazing !
You get a like from me !
This was shown in my history class as well! Absolutely excellent detail and data!
The detail in this video is amazing. This definitely deserves a like.
This is better than most other videos on this topic. Very good!
Wow, this is amazing. Definitely the best video about this topic I ever saw. You should have 15 million subscribers by now. So much detail
That was very well-made! you deserve a like!
One thing that would help alot I think is if in these map videos you add in some overlay of the terrain, and maybe even the seasons. It's hard to understand why certain things happen without the climate.
Very good video! Better than all others about this war. You put a giant effort in it. Big respect for you
Невероятно детализированно, круто
Лайков за кропотливую работу
I wonder why this suddenly popped up in my recommended vids 😇🍿
So much details, thats an amazing work! Congrats:)
Not gonna lie, today discovered and immediately my new favorite mapping channel! This is quality content!
Thank you!
That is hell of an animation
THAT IS
IT
IT
IS PERFECT
AHHHHHHH
wow, impressive research behind that map, congratulations on the hard work
Outstanding!! Thank you so much!
I just discovered your channel and love the maps! I watch a few videos every day after work. Thank you for the hard research work and for the entertainment!
This is amazing! The best russian civil war version ever. It must have been very hard to add the others conflicts in Europe. Keep up Yan!
Есть недочеты ,однако сделано качественно! Лайк.
Major General William Sidney Graves (1865-1940) commanded the U.S. Army Expeditionary Force in Siberia in 1918-1920. After retiring, the general - an honest American soldier, for whom the interests of his country and his people stood above everything else - wrote the book "America's Siberian Adventure (1918-1920)".
The soldiers of Semenov and Kalmykov, under the protection of Japanese troops, roamed the country like wild animals, killing and robbing people; if Japan wanted, these murders could have stopped in a day. If questions were raised about these brutal murders, the answer was that the dead were Bolsheviks, and this explanation obviously suited the world quite well. Conditions in Eastern Siberia were terrible, and there was nothing cheaper than human life.
Terrible murders were committed there, but they were not committed by the Bolsheviks, as the world thinks. I will be far from any exaggeration if I say that for every person killed by the Bolsheviks in Eastern Siberia, there are one hundred killed by the anti-Bolsheviks.
I read his book “American adventure in Siberia”
Yeah, poor Bolsheviks, what victims who killed millions of their own people, friends, and family, wow, my heart really feels for them!
It made no sense for the Bolsheviks to kill people who should work for their economy. the main resource of the state is people - Joseph Stalin. for the whites, personal power was important, even at the cost of killing and destroying Russia, and for the Reds it was important to overthrow the imperials and build a state in which the working class would prevail.and they really built it, but unfortunately the cunning and arrogance of some people helped them destroy the Soviet system by putting sticks in its wheels, to break up the state and divide its legacy with banditry.Putin is one of them.On the day he dies, I will celebrate, I don't drink alcohol at all, but on this day I will get drunk so that I will almost be dead myself.
This is called "White Terror". I'm pleasantly surprised that people in the West have also heard about)
The brazilian channel Arte da Guerra recommended yours and that's what brought me here. Congrats on the videos!
I recently came across your channel and by God it is a hidden gem! A damn shame you don't have more subs my man! Well, you just earned yourself one more! :)
You're a real master! I wish the outcome was different... but it's done with a real talent
That's wonderful! Thank you for your work and research!
holy crap, the overloaded details...what amazed me was that you somehow managed to keep the map nice and neat even with all these little fractions everywhere.牛逼！
3:08 RIP Mad Baron
Love the music change when the Provisional Government comes into play, even moreso with Kolchak
Wow I had no idea this much went on in Russia during that time period. Great job putting this together Yan!
Nice work, taihaole! Thanks and carry on!:)
So detailed, so interesting; the way you included the names of the individual forces had me on a Wikipedia spree and me going through your videos. Glad this video was recommended to me.
Спасибо тебе за такую красивую и детальную работу ты очень постарался!
Thanks a lot! That's extremely valuable
I can’t even keep up with what’s happening for half the video, the fact you were able to animate it and get the info you needed to get it accurate is astonishing to me
Великолепно, просто нет слов! Мужик, ты великолепен! 👍🏻
Definitely the best I've seen. It's obviously not perfect with wars like this you'll always miss something, but I like it and very much appreciate the hard work and research done for this.
Oh this beautiful! Well done sir!
This is the best map video I have ever seen. GG man You deserve a couple million subs.
The White Army and the Black Baron
Are trying to restore the Czar's throne,
But from the taiga to the British seas
The Red Army is the strongest of all!
DDDZzs 223355 and they got defeated by a bunch of Poles and Finns.
@@Edgymemer You really don't get to speak. Wehrmacht lost the only war it fought lmao.
I like how you show changing borders around Russia during their Civil War. A simultaneous Russian and Chinese civil war would be interesting, although I expect that China's fighting goes on to 1948 while Russia's ends much sooner.
man, i really appreciate the effort you put into your videos, you earned a subscriber
Your mapping styles are very clear!
I hope your channel more grow up then others.
Here's subscribes~.
Best. Video. Ever.
There can't be a more accurate version than this one, good job
Yes there can. There can always be better. This one has some minor mistakes not having them would be better.
@@gunarsmiezis9321 Like?
@@duduchannel6729 Rad the other comment some have been pointed out.
@@gunarsmiezis9321 Yes.
@@yanxishan6575 hey, can you make the history of Russia 1871 (or 1900) - 2021?
Yan Xishan , good warlord and good historical movie maker . Keep up your work !
Ya know what? This is just damn impressive! Good job!
Wow, I had known bits and pieces of the history of the RCW, but to see it laid out on a single map in its entirety really made me realize how chaotic the war really was. In the latter half of 1918, it seems like the war was really going favorably for the whites and I don't think anyone could be blamed for thinking it looked like they were going to win the whole conflict. Just goes to show that things in history don't always necessarily go how you might predict they would.
world-class work here, i bet this goes right into university classrooms
Sobering stuff. Thank you for this.
the amount of detail in this video is really impressive, I came here to look at the allied intervention in the Russian civil war and you were the only TH-camr I saw include that
You Earned Yourself A subscriber! 👍
Edit: Thanks for the heart 🤗
@DGG Ali422 Sure he did.
Hello. thanks for your video. I would only like to say that based on the memoirs of Evgeny Vishnevsky and Ivan Strod, it is clear that the Pepelyaev army never held such a large territory as you showed. His influence did not extend to the whole of Yakutia, but was limited to the cities of Ayan, Nelkan, Amga. In general, Pepelyaev controlled the cities along the Ayan tract. And Rakitin controlled the cities along the Okhotsk tract. But they certainly did not control the entire territory of Yakutia
Amazing detail. Good job.
Good job, thanks a lot. Fantastic.
I spent way too long trying to find info about those last White troops in the Far East in 1923-1924 (I'd never seen that in any other video), and I gotta say, kudos to you for putting in that level of detail. All around, great work!
Did you find something about them?
@@Mr.Ketler Very little. There was one site with a list of all the polities and breakaway states during the Russian Civil War. The Yakutia section mentioned a White Russian unit commanded by Valentin Pavlovich Nikolayev that controlled a town called Allaikha as late as 1924. The town seems to no longer exist, and I couldn't find any other info about him.
@@andrewcizas4362 Allaikha is a river in Yakutia
Дякую за таке детальне освітлення громадянської війни. Респект автору.
Шкода, що не вдалось тоді відстояти. Але гарно зробив, вподобайка!
@@davyother2699 Этот раз тоже ничего не получитса
всем было бы лучше, если бы Украина выстояла и желательно замочила советский союз
@@alexeyprofi3951, всем - это кому? Самой Украине, которая приобрела всю свою промышленность и превратилась в высокоурбанизированную страну с высоким уровнем развития образования, науки и медицины на момент обретения независимости, и выходцами из которой была как бы не треть от всего ЦК (в том числе, трое из семи глав СССР)?
Может, прочим советским республикам, часть из которых (особенно Средняя Азия и значительная часть Кавказа) почти всеми современными благами культуры, развитой инфраструктуры и т.д. пользуются благодаря вбухиванию в них денег профицитными советскими Россией и Украиной?
А может человечеству в целом было бы лучше без улучшения условий жизни и труда в странах Запада вследствие страха перед социальной революцией по типу российской, без научной (и в частности, космической) гонки, конкуренция в которой продвинула человечество в развитии на десятилетия вперёд?
Или было бы лучше, потому что без жестокой, но сверхбыстрой подготовки единого СССР к ВМВ, вся Восточная Европа в 41-42 годах легла бы под нацистов, а большую часть славянского населения изгнали бы за Урал или уничтожили?
Кому "всем" было бы лучше без объединения СССР в 1920-х, и что бы приобрёл конкретно ты в случае поражения красных в Гражданке?
@@danonimusgombelinius7254 сталин сам заключал сделки с гитлером, война это его вина. большевики проводили дисгеническую политику убийства всех людей, которые чего-то добились ака кулаки, устроили гражданку, репрессировали кучу людей, устроили голодомор и все остальное что угодно лучше этого
this deserves a sub. amazing job
I'm reading Robert Service's Lenin biography and I have watched this video again, it has really helped me to understand Russian Civil War fronts on map.