I'm sorry for some inaccurate in territories, I will continue to train my overlay and editing skills... In this animation, in addition to showing the internal conflicts of the empire, also included some conflicts of other countries, so I spent a long time editing... Thank you for watching!! ------------------------------------- 很抱歉有些領土上的不精確，我會繼續訓練我的疊圖與編輯能力... 這部動畫將會顯示出帝國內部與外部國家的衝突，因此我花了大量的時間進行編輯
@@centralmapping6566 Looking forward to the release of your detailed works on the Sino-Vietnamese War. I have now decided to make The Ukrainian-Russian conflict (2014-2022) Including the Crimea Conflict, Donbas War and 2022 Ukraine-Russia War
The Habsburgs are over, now the Nations have to make their own states. the so called "Austria-Hungary" was the possession of the Habsburgs, with Franz Joseph as emperor of Austria and king of Hungary, king of Bohemia, king of Croatia, Dalmatia, Lodomeria, Galicia and so on. eg. Ioan Boeriu fieldmarshal for the Habsburgs, with his Romanian troops pacified Vienna and Prague in the bolshevik coup.
I'm impressed with the amount of research that went into this video, and I learned about quite a few new breakaway states that I've never even heard of before. My only real complaints are that the borders are wonky and the rivers could use some work (My recommendation is to replace the borders with the rivers rather than showing both side by side). Keep it up and you'll become better than Tigerstar.
Tbh Tigerstar's videos are child's play compared to this. This guy has a lot more details and information in his videos. Tigerstar is more popular only because he was a pioneer in this genre on TH-cam
Great job! In mapping, you don't often find really high-quality work! It's sad to see such a small number of likes and views on the video. I hope as many people as possible will see and appreciate this work!
A really good and detailled video, especially given the messy events that took place here... The only thing that seems a bit sloppy is the southern Austrian border to Italy and the KSCS at the end of the video. Otherwise a nice video!
@@akuganteng790 Indonesia has a unifying language (Indonesian) as an official language, in contrast to Austria-Hungary and Yugoslavia which do not have a unifying language....
I never knew there was this much chaos after Austria surrendered, I thought it was just a part of Austria leaving World War 1. 我從來不知道奧地利投降後有這麼多混亂，我以為這只是奧地利離開第一次世界大戰的一部分。
War Destiny [Mapping] It’s not to bad the borders but the war slides are excellent and has nice detail, what video are you doing next after this? The war in Ukraine or
Correct. Every other nation gained territory, population, and a ready infrastructure. It happened this way. We continue to live, we don't want to take anything back by force, but we are surrounded by ourselves, it's a fact. Peace!
@@koulematon7359 :-) whose greed is it and who does it kill? Central Europe was built under Hungarian leadership. There was NEVER a serious Slovak, Slovenian, Romanian, or Croatian war of independence against Hungary, only if they received external help from great nations. The Serbs tried a little, but they realized that we also protected them from the Turks. Learn history! Peace!
@@tamaskontra775Lmao Romania literally occupied Budapest and Győr in days, and they didn't receive any support from anybody since the British and the French opposed crossing the Tisa
I don't think you need to worry about errors. Because it is a great success to describe the disintegration and disintegration war of a mixed state like Austria-Hungary on a map.
Thank you! In fact, before I made this video, I did watch your vid about Banat Rep and D-mapper vid about Czechoslovakia explanation, but I gathered info from Wikipedia and books by myself. But thank you for reminding me... I got credit for D-Mapper, I should have put you in too!
@@WarDestinyMapping From my research, I was under the impression the Green Cadres already controlled most the land you show them controlling long before the war ended, also thanks for using my video as a source :)
@@heremapping4484 You are right, green cadres occupied a lot of land in Austria-Hungary before the end of the First World War, especially in the eastern part of Bosnia, it is a pity that I do not have enough info on this part, but the detailed infoI collected is from Porega in October to 1919 Green Cadres was integrated into the Czechoslovak Legion(Trnava Region)
@@WarDestinyMapping I'm glad you did a lot of research, I actually could have helped you with sources if you dm'd me, I have a bunch of maps of Hungarian soviet Republic, and Soviet Republics in Croatia after the war. :(
Great job! It might have continued, btw. In 1921, when a referendum was held about Sopron (Ödenburg), where remaining Hungary got more votes. Also Serbian-Hungarian Baranya-Baja Republic was proclaimed in August 2021, but failed within a week.
What to do when losing a war on multiple fronts: France: overthrow the government Germany: keep fighting until you completely collapse Italy: switch sides Hungary: INVADE CZECHOSLOVAKIA!!!!
Amazing video! Only one little correction: in the italian front, in the province of western Lake Garda, the Italian troups managed to occupy a small part of Trentino (austrian region), and they were keeping it even after the defeat of Caporetto, so during september/october 1918 that territory was under italian control.
This is such a great video! Nobody really knows that the collapse of Austria-Hungary continued after ww1. I just have one question, what is the name of the music you used at the start of the mapping part of the video? It is a great choice and I must have my hands (or ears) on it. Anyways, keep up the great work!
(Sorry, I will not be gentle. :-) ) First mistake: no one wants the previous borders back, because they are full of idiots commenting unnecessarily stupid things. 🙂 I try to explain (but why? :-) ) Central Europe was built under the Hungarian kingdom, it became part of Europe at all, and not some subjugated no man's land. Many nations live here. It's strange, but they never rebelled more seriously against the Hungarians, only if they received external help. (f.e.: 1849.) (and now comes the biggest jerk, I admit) Why are you pretending, if you could never create a normal nation-state without outside help? Rather, thank you for all the help you have received from us over the centuries, and shut up. 🙂Peace!! :DDDD
I know this is unrelated but In Romania, Gheorghe Tătărescu before he became prime minister he had some roles counted 28 military clashes between the local population and gendarmes in Bessarabia I found a few information about them including Bulgarian Communist operations in Drochia District and the Bolgrad Republic do you know any more information since other than that I only know non-Bulgarian ones operated near Izmail but nothing else.
The collapse of Austria Hungary pretty much guaranteed the events of WW2 and later needless ethnic violence in the region. Only if the empire was able to federalize like it was planning to.
First time I see a Hungarian Communist state existed shortly after the war. Gives me another reason why Hitler (being from Austria) was so worried about the spread of communism!
It's not simple. The best example of this is that it never occurred to me. We, hungarians, hates Stalin and Hitler too. Our former country is lost forever. We are not a European powerful country, in the 20th century our fate was always decided above our heads.
Austria-Hungary: *disintegrated* The countries that formed from Austria-Hungary: _-Time to start the massacre, because life was _*_"too boring"_*_ from 1914 to 1918._
the romanians and serbs were really hyped here, i mean, imagine be one of them in 1918, your whole country has fallen and there's already talks to partition it, but from a month to other you retake your independence as the occupation forces retreat by apparently no reason, and then the next year your countries army is already at the enemy capital
It is true that during the collapse of the empire it was very chaotic, with the independence of various nation-states, foreign aggression, and peasant rebellions and uprisings
Quite enlightening. In Hungary the Treaty of Trianon is spoken about with a lot of resentment by the vocal minority that still cares. We usually just see the Austria-Hungary borders, Great Hungary borders, then the current small Hungary borders, and cry injustice because we were 'dragged into' WW1. Seceding from the Austria-Hungary Empire is all but unmentioned and the conflicts afterwards are not taught much at all. Only that the Treaty of Versailles was followed by Trianon. But it seems it has actually given back Hungary a lot more territory than we were able to hold at the time.
Occupied territory does not count as foreign territory. Just because Afghanistan was occupied following the 2001 intervention, doesn't mean it was part of the USA.
@@Vitrousis "a lot more territory than we were able to hold at the time". Hungary was losing especially against Romania at that point, and the Treaty of Trianon restored some territory that we've lost. They actually did as good as they could considering language and culture borders, which is a hell of a lot more consideration than say, African countries got when their borders were drawn by colonial powers
@@lakdav They did not restore any territory except some in Western Hungary (look up Sopron plebiscite) If you're referring to returning occupied territories that were either never claimed by any neighboring country/was under the occupation of a neighboring country during the wars following the dissolution of Austria-Hungary, that does not count as rewarding/giving back territory. That's like saying after the allied occupation of Germany ended, they rewarded the entirity of Germany back to Germany since they were not able to hold it, lol. I'm not going against you or anything I'm just trying to clear up a common misconception/misuse of words when you refer to leaving occupied territories as rewards. Romania never would've wanted to annex Budapest or any over the Danube river, maximum extent was maybe till the Tisa, but even those claims were neglected. So yeah, tldr is it's calling leaving the occupation zone instead of giving back territory, as they have never laid any claims or did any neighboring country claimed that for example Győr should've stayed under Romanian hands
@@Vitrousis I don't know anything about claims and such in this instance, like my original comment said, all this is pretty new to me. What I do see on this map is that it looked like a giant free-for-all battle royale between upstart opportunistic countries that popped up as the Empire broke apart to its vague demographic parts. Who's to say that none of the warring new countries would have eventually laid their claims on territories they held, had the Entente not forced those treaties before there was a 'winner' ( a winner who would have had the same demographic problems as the dissolved Empire)
The trauma of Trianon, it affected Hungary deeply for many decades... Stil does... In the collective psyche of the Magyar, lies the lost lands in the east and south..
@@georgeamesfort3408 Romanians were also invaders from the balkan as sheep herders. Hungarians lived in the carpathian basin way before Romanians ever set foot in Transylvania. As for the magyarization, romanians did it much worse after the treaties.
I cried on this video. I am from Hungary. I find emotional both the betrayal of politicians from inside, the betray from the West, the unfair fight of Romanians not keeping agreements, and on the other side the fight that Hungarians could hold for two years all alone starting with a disbanded army, and going through a socialist revolution from inside where the previous prime minister and president was assassinated. The 1000 years old borders got destroyed by about 5 sides, fighting all alone. I highly respect all those Hungarians who gave their lives and fought very well at all times throughout history. Hungarians can still feel the consequences of Trianon every day. You can feel it by looking at old building, seeing all those medieval fortresses, or when you look at a geographical map of Europe and see the 1000 years-old borders "ingraved" in the Carpathians. I hope things will be the best they can ever be.
The same for West Ukraine She was heroically fighting the outnumbering Polish horde supported by France in order "to fight Bolsheviks" but the weapons given were used against other enemy, which wasn't a threat. If the monarchy stayed, the world would be a better place
@@KalashnikovPM63 hungary really only became an ethnically diverse region after the mongol invasions killed up to half the population by some estimates combined with the slavic and romanian migrations from the south after the ottoman conquest of the balkans
![War Destiny [Mapping]](http://yt3.ggpht.com/2MpsIU8Gp44eZO-CQJnMBXCbOLzzMMhVTD8F-nfrGoFqSAJHNAKK9hoGMenCGc-r6nhLw-yvyw=s48-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj)
I'm sorry for some inaccurate in territories, I will continue to train my overlay and editing skills...
In this animation, in addition to showing the internal conflicts of the empire, also included some conflicts of other countries, so I spent a long time editing...
Thank you for watching!!
-------------------------------------
很抱歉有些領土上的不精確，我會繼續訓練我的疊圖與編輯能力...
這部動畫將會顯示出帝國內部與外部國家的衝突，因此我花了大量的時間進行編輯
I can see you working hard. Highly recommend have a break for your health care sometime.
@@Anwwoo Thank you, I always take 1-2 weeks off after finished the project.
War Destiny [Mapping] what are you doing next? I am working on the Sino-Vietnamese War rn however I hope you enjoy your break.
@@centralmapping6566 Looking forward to the release of your detailed works on the Sino-Vietnamese War.
I have now decided to make The Ukrainian-Russian conflict (2014-2022)
Including the Crimea Conflict, Donbas War and 2022 Ukraine-Russia War
Bro you are so underrated, you deserve way more subs
"The War is over! Now we can finally go to war!"
The Habsburgs are over, now the Nations have to make their own states.
the so called "Austria-Hungary" was the possession of the Habsburgs, with Franz Joseph as emperor of Austria and king of Hungary, king of Bohemia, king of Croatia, Dalmatia, Lodomeria, Galicia and so on.
eg. Ioan Boeriu fieldmarshal for the Habsburgs, with his Romanian troops pacified Vienna and Prague in the bolshevik coup.
Fr Entire Central Europe agrees
🇷🇸🇷🇴💩
Based Ottomans
Chinese after WW2 be like
I like that you've even included the tiny breakaways like the Hutsul republic.
I'm impressed with the amount of research that went into this video, and I learned about quite a few new breakaway states that I've never even heard of before. My only real complaints are that the borders are wonky and the rivers could use some work (My recommendation is to replace the borders with the rivers rather than showing both side by side). Keep it up and you'll become better than Tigerstar.
Thank you so much for appreciating it!
I'll use this recommendation, if it looks too messy, and fix this problems after the current project is done.
Tbh Tigerstar's videos are child's play compared to this.
This guy has a lot more details and information in his videos.
Tigerstar is more popular only because he was a pioneer in this genre on TH-cam
@@KnownNiche1999 Agreed!
@@KnownNiche1999fr
@@KnownNiche1999 Well I would say depends on the Tigerstar Videos.
the most detailed video about this topic I've ever seen. Congratulations War Destiny for this insane animation!
Thank you for your appreciation
Great video!!! One of the most detailed videos about Austro-Hungarian dissolution I've ever seen!
Thank you for appreciating this video! But I sorry that some border(city) may not be very accurate...
Great job! In mapping, you don't often find really high-quality work! It's sad to see such a small number of likes and views on the video. I hope as many people as possible will see and appreciate this work!
I'm glad you appreciate my work so much, thank you!
здарова
Wowee! This was amazing to watch, transitions are very relaxing. Nice job War Destiny, keep it up!
Thank you for your appreciation! I will continue to improve and make better works
A really good and detailled video, especially given the messy events that took place here... The only thing that seems a bit sloppy is the southern Austrian border to Italy and the KSCS at the end of the video. Otherwise a nice video!
Thanks!!
Yap... That part is indeed my problem, the overlay is wrong
great video man, this collapse was much more complicated than most people think
Thanks buddy, Yeah, that's why it took me so long to make
finally.. after 3 months. i hope you will upload regular video in future. amazing content 👏
I will try my best, thank you
The amount of detail in this video is amazing!
Fuck, guys, he even included the offensive of the army of the Ukrainian People's Republic in August. Cool, just cool
One of the most detailed maps, in my opinion, as it shows some unknown facts like western Ukraine
Думаю що більшість поляків та українців знають про те що ця країна існувала якщо знають що існувала УНР
@@owoxl так але ось про гуцульську республіку я дізнався тільки з цього відео
@@dimonchicktotsamyu2992раджу подивитись про неї відео на каналі імені Т.Г. Шевченка, ця республіка використала хитрість на Різдво
You did a great job with this
Thank you for your appreciation!
incredible detail. Keep up the amazing work!
Great job dude 👏
Thanks
Fantastic work bro👌, it would be nice if you provide me with the main sources you used to make the masterpiece! 👍👍👍
Thank you!! No problems
Multiple languages lead to lot of conflicts
Switzerland : Am I z joke to you?
Indonesia : 🙄
@@akuganteng790 Indonesia has a unifying language (Indonesian) as an official language, in contrast to Austria-Hungary and Yugoslavia which do not have a unifying language....
@@fitriyanti7139 Yugoslavia at least had Serbo-Croatian, which was spoken by a clear majority
@@mineminecraftlp4593 Yugoslavia broke up only because of the leadership. Yugoslav wars started only because of coup and change in course.
Very well done thank you
This war is one of the most interesting and less-known conflicts in modern history
I never knew there was this much chaos after Austria surrendered, I thought it was just a part of Austria leaving World War 1.
我從來不知道奧地利投降後有這麼多混亂，我以為這只是奧地利離開第一次世界大戰的一部分。
same bro this is a new thing to me lol
Knowing your vids, it's a quality one!
Thanks!
After watching: it was a very well done video, but the Austro-Hungarian-Yugoslavian border was partially incorrect
@@malopracing Thank you for your observation, that's right...some borders are inaccurate
Dad: why the fuck you crying so loud
Me:
Fr
Im laughing
Fr chain
@@cooldude05940 I’m doing both as an Austrian-Czech-Bulgarian
@@veteranpg3d156 bro got a wild family lineage
Very nice video. Although some borders are just a bit off but other than that this is very nice.
Thank you, that's right... some borders inaccurate
War Destiny [Mapping] It’s not to bad the borders but the war slides are excellent and has nice detail, what video are you doing next after this? The war in Ukraine or
@@centralmapping6566 Maybe my next project to make is the conflict in the Donbass in 2014, you know... the Ukraine war doesn't know when it will end
War Destiny [Mapping] mmm,
@@centralmapping6566 Because I won't release the war that's not over, or what advice do you have?
Wow, really the Hungarians lost everything in a matter of days.
:(
Greed kills.
Correct. Every other nation gained territory, population, and a ready infrastructure. It happened this way. We continue to live, we don't want to take anything back by force, but we are surrounded by ourselves, it's a fact. Peace!
@@koulematon7359 :-) whose greed is it and who does it kill? Central Europe was built under Hungarian leadership. There was NEVER a serious Slovak, Slovenian, Romanian, or Croatian war of independence against Hungary, only if they received external help from great nations. The Serbs tried a little, but they realized that we also protected them from the Turks. Learn history! Peace!
@@tamaskontra775Lmao Romania literally occupied Budapest and Győr in days, and they didn't receive any support from anybody since the British and the French opposed crossing the Tisa
0:21 The State of SHS also included Slovenia
I don't think you need to worry about errors. Because it is a great success to describe the disintegration and disintegration war of a mixed state like Austria-Hungary on a map.
Austria: Russia, help!
Russia: We're sorry the number you have dialed is no longer in service.
Good video bro
Thank you
Great work, I'm wondering if you used by Banat video as a source?
Thank you!
In fact, before I made this video, I did watch your vid about Banat Rep and D-mapper vid about Czechoslovakia explanation, but I gathered info from Wikipedia and books by myself.
But thank you for reminding me... I got credit for D-Mapper, I should have put you in too!
@@WarDestinyMapping From my research, I was under the impression the Green Cadres already controlled most the land you show them controlling long before the war ended, also thanks for using my video as a source :)
@@heremapping4484 You are right, green cadres occupied a lot of land in Austria-Hungary before the end of the First World War, especially in the eastern part of Bosnia, it is a pity that I do not have enough info on this part, but the detailed infoI collected is from Porega in October to 1919 Green Cadres was integrated into the Czechoslovak Legion(Trnava Region)
@@WarDestinyMapping I'm glad you did a lot of research, I actually could have helped you with sources if you dm'd me, I have a bunch of maps of Hungarian soviet Republic, and Soviet Republics in Croatia after the war. :(
@@heremapping4484 That's great! where would you release them
You earned a sub
Great video!
Thanks
So nice to see.
Very excellent work!!!
how did you get those resources
in the description column
Great job!
It might have continued, btw. In 1921, when a referendum was held about Sopron (Ödenburg), where remaining Hungary got more votes.
Also Serbian-Hungarian Baranya-Baja Republic was proclaimed in August 2021, but failed within a week.
Cool animation, pretty similar to that one from D-Mapper but with more details/corrections I guess
Anyway 👍
Thanks, I have reference to the vids he made in Czechoslovakia because he is an expert on that.
Glad you used Kenji Kaway awesome WWII Apocalypse OST.
What to do when losing a war on multiple fronts:
France: overthrow the government
Germany: keep fighting until you completely collapse
Italy: switch sides
Hungary: INVADE CZECHOSLOVAKIA!!!!
Hungary: REVISION!
Long Time No See
Yap.. I'm currently working on the Ukraine-Russian War, which will be released soon
@@WarDestinyMapping Nice
Thanks
@@WarDestinyMapping But I Would Suggest Uploading it When The War Ends
@@WarDestinyMapping Because It Would Change a Lot More
Amazing video! Only one little correction: in the italian front, in the province of western Lake Garda, the Italian troups managed to occupy a small part of Trentino (austrian region), and they were keeping it even after the defeat of Caporetto, so during september/october 1918 that territory was under italian control.
This video is so perfect!
This is such a great video! Nobody really knows that the collapse of Austria-Hungary continued after ww1. I just have one question, what is the name of the music you used at the start of the mapping part of the video? It is a great choice and I must have my hands (or ears) on it. Anyways, keep up the great work!
Thank you very much!!
And the first song name is "Moscow 19"
th-cam.com/video/GFWpDOPRfyM/w-d-xo.html
Its not really after ww1, since the allied powers was behind the little entente....
bro i really didnt know this is new thing to me
This is amazing!
Great music, nice choice
Truly a sad destiny for such an empire.
Awesome
Thanks
What is the song at the beginning ?
th-cam.com/video/GFWpDOPRfyM/w-d-xo.html
Hungary: We want to have back the borders we had before the Trianon.
the borders before the trianon: 4:14
(Sorry, I will not be gentle. :-) ) First mistake: no one wants the previous borders back, because they are full of idiots commenting unnecessarily stupid things. 🙂 I try to explain (but why? :-) ) Central Europe was built under the Hungarian kingdom, it became part of Europe at all, and not some subjugated no man's land. Many nations live here. It's strange, but they never rebelled more seriously against the Hungarians, only if they received external help. (f.e.: 1849.) (and now comes the biggest jerk, I admit) Why are you pretending, if you could never create a normal nation-state without outside help? Rather, thank you for all the help you have received from us over the centuries, and shut up. 🙂Peace!! :DDDD
Well done
I know this is unrelated but In Romania, Gheorghe Tătărescu before he became prime minister he had some roles counted 28 military clashes between the local population and gendarmes in Bessarabia I found a few information about them including Bulgarian Communist operations in Drochia District and the Bolgrad Republic do you know any more information since other than that I only know non-Bulgarian ones operated near Izmail but nothing else.
The collapse of Austria Hungary pretty much guaranteed the events of WW2 and later needless ethnic violence in the region.
Only if the empire was able to federalize like it was planning to.
Unfortunately, it's correct.
@@tamaskontra775 There was only one force in the monarchy opposed to federalization, and it was the Hungarian elite.
very nice :)
Thanks
what an amazing map and effects
Wow it is Nice.
I nice you Man from Turkey🇹🇷👍
This is the definition of chaos.
Goddamn i didnt know the romanians got all the way to gyor
make a video about holy roman empire
First time I see a Hungarian Communist state existed shortly after the war. Gives me another reason why Hitler (being from Austria) was so worried about the spread of communism!
It's not simple. The best example of this is that it never occurred to me. We, hungarians, hates Stalin and Hitler too. Our former country is lost forever. We are not a European powerful country, in the 20th century our fate was always decided above our heads.
Austria-Hungary: *disintegrated*
The countries that formed from Austria-Hungary: _-Time to start the massacre, because life was _*_"too boring"_*_ from 1914 to 1918._
Hungary tried to do a turkish war of independence
sad that they failed tho
A True european battle royale
nice job on finding those small states
i cant find anything on them if i look them up though
any idea how i can get information on them?
I actually built a database about this video, you can go to my homepage to check it out
pastebin.com/u/War_Destiny_Mapping
It contains the info and resources I have collected, you can check them (but sorry I can't translate them all into English)
@@WarDestinyMapping not a problem thanks
Everyone is talking about Hungary but they forget Bulgaria that also lost unfairly most of it's lands.
Bułgaria dont los1/3 of ther terretories
@@Mitowski no, we lost even more.
@@Mitowski Hungary lost 70% or their territories, with 3,5 million hungarians.
Bro can you make Indonesian independant war (1945-1949)
the romanians and serbs were really hyped here, i mean, imagine be one of them in 1918, your whole country has fallen and there's already talks to partition it, but from a month to other you retake your independence as the occupation forces retreat by apparently no reason, and then the next year your countries army is already at the enemy capital
Banat Republic was Hungarian, Serbian or Romanian?
I think its Hungarian but if we look at the language its Hungarian and German (Austrian and Swabian)
Serbian i think, this area at that period is populated by Romanian and serbs but it has a magyar minority.
Does anybody have any sources on the Kusic Soviet?
Top 5 Sad moments
You mean top 5 based moments
@@metodiusm428 Stealing land is not based
@@hookplay7229 Didn't Hungarians do exactly that when they arrived from Asia?
@@metodiusm428didnt amerimutt stole land from native americans?
@@hungolian-warrior as an african-american, I agree. Did those whites not steal from the Native people who lived there first?
Good mapping from🇹🇷❤️🇹🇼
That was chaotic!
It is true that during the collapse of the empire it was very chaotic, with the independence of various nation-states, foreign aggression, and peasant rebellions and uprisings
@@WarDestinyMapping what can I expect from the Balkans
@@spiralmapping9899 what do you mean??
@@WarDestinyMapping the Balkans region of Europe is a mess lol
Ohh, I understand
This region of Europe needed some serious Flex Tape.
all nations in A-H: get freedom/joined to Yugoslavia.
Ukraine: There's nothing we can do.
Quite enlightening. In Hungary the Treaty of Trianon is spoken about with a lot of resentment by the vocal minority that still cares. We usually just see the Austria-Hungary borders, Great Hungary borders, then the current small Hungary borders, and cry injustice because we were 'dragged into' WW1. Seceding from the Austria-Hungary Empire is all but unmentioned and the conflicts afterwards are not taught much at all. Only that the Treaty of Versailles was followed by Trianon. But it seems it has actually given back Hungary a lot more territory than we were able to hold at the time.
Occupied territory does not count as foreign territory. Just because Afghanistan was occupied following the 2001 intervention, doesn't mean it was part of the USA.
@@Vitrousis "a lot more territory than we were able to hold at the time". Hungary was losing especially against Romania at that point, and the Treaty of Trianon restored some territory that we've lost. They actually did as good as they could considering language and culture borders, which is a hell of a lot more consideration than say, African countries got when their borders were drawn by colonial powers
@@lakdav They did not restore any territory except some in Western Hungary (look up Sopron plebiscite) If you're referring to returning occupied territories that were either never claimed by any neighboring country/was under the occupation of a neighboring country during the wars following the dissolution of Austria-Hungary, that does not count as rewarding/giving back territory. That's like saying after the allied occupation of Germany ended, they rewarded the entirity of Germany back to Germany since they were not able to hold it, lol. I'm not going against you or anything I'm just trying to clear up a common misconception/misuse of words when you refer to leaving occupied territories as rewards. Romania never would've wanted to annex Budapest or any over the Danube river, maximum extent was maybe till the Tisa, but even those claims were neglected. So yeah, tldr is it's calling leaving the occupation zone instead of giving back territory, as they have never laid any claims or did any neighboring country claimed that for example Győr should've stayed under Romanian hands
@@Vitrousis I don't know anything about claims and such in this instance, like my original comment said, all this is pretty new to me. What I do see on this map is that it looked like a giant free-for-all battle royale between upstart opportunistic countries that popped up as the Empire broke apart to its vague demographic parts. Who's to say that none of the warring new countries would have eventually laid their claims on territories they held, had the Entente not forced those treaties before there was a 'winner' ( a winner who would have had the same demographic problems as the dissolved Empire)
@@lakdav So you're saying that north-western europeans are responsible for your racism
Austria-Hungary collapsed at the end of WW1.
#austriahungary
#austrohungarianempire
#ww1
Thank you, captain obvious
A Civil War In Austria-Hungary Countries?
What of the neighborhood in Tianjin China?
The WWI in Asia and Oceania is interesting to discover : the first big fire between France and Germany wasn't in Europe but at Tahiti island.
Hungarian and Slovak Soviet Republic😊
Most unfortunate circumstance in hungarian history
@@content1006 I would not say so, it is quite interesting in history to observe how a capitalist country twice became communist with a planned economy
@@sortimadout369 the economic system is not the issue itself but the brutal and unhinged dictators leading them
@@content1006 Dictatorship is a problem of many countries, not only communist ones.
The trauma of Trianon, it affected Hungary deeply for many decades... Stil does... In the collective psyche of the Magyar, lies the lost lands in the east and south..
Lost lands that they opressed and magyarised for decades that were at last returned to their people.
Lands that were returned to European peoples, which were occupied by a Uralic tribe.
Nothing bad happened.
They got to feel what it was like to be a non hungarian in their kingdom when Romania occupied them
@@georgeamesfort3408 Romanians were also invaders from the balkan as sheep herders. Hungarians lived in the carpathian basin way before Romanians ever set foot in Transylvania. As for the magyarization, romanians did it much worse after the treaties.
@@king-mihai RETURNED? Which territory?
(Yeah and the romanian regimes did the same thing to the hungarian population).
From this: 0:51 Austrian & hungarian controlled lands
To this: 3:44 Austrian & hungarian controlled lands at their lowest
Как называется игра
Пэинт и Умелые руки
Btw that was the exact reason why some austrain guy got the idea that ethno-state is better option than multiculturalism
Diversity of nations only creates rebellion
So maybe the most suitable way is to ethnic cleansing...can be tested in Nazis and Serbs
Agree
Multiculturalism can lead to endless ethnic conflicts
Glory to the Hustul Republic 🇺🇦 ! Before this video I’ve never heard about this country that once existed
Good!(from hungary). Vesszen a Trianon!
1000th like
支持！
If they wanted Italy in ww2 with them they had to respect the pact that they signed. The pact said that Italy receive also Dalmazia.
Would have been better using the German and Hungarian names of the places.
3:33 that map is beautiful. It should’ve stayed that way
If czechoslovakia would take more from austria... i would be very happy ^w^
no
0:54
True !
You are tiresome idiots. You can play with this, but be glad that I didn't put it more harshly. Learn history! (os shut up?) :-)
First, Montenegro liberated alone and second, you forgot Christmas uprising
1:26 lookin like a hoi4 peace conference horror
The 600-year-old Habsburg dynasty fell like this
Austria & hungary singing dame da ne in the background for everytime they lost territories they once had
Hot map!
I cried on this video. I am from Hungary. I find emotional both the betrayal of politicians from inside, the betray from the West, the unfair fight of Romanians not keeping agreements, and on the other side the fight that Hungarians could hold for two years all alone starting with a disbanded army, and going through a socialist revolution from inside where the previous prime minister and president was assassinated.
The 1000 years old borders got destroyed by about 5 sides, fighting all alone. I highly respect all those Hungarians who gave their lives and fought very well at all times throughout history. Hungarians can still feel the consequences of Trianon every day. You can feel it by looking at old building, seeing all those medieval fortresses, or when you look at a geographical map of Europe and see the 1000 years-old borders "ingraved" in the Carpathians. I hope things will be the best they can ever be.
Respected to those Hungarian
To put this from a human perspective Hungary got gang banged
The same for West Ukraine
She was heroically fighting the outnumbering Polish horde supported by France in order "to fight Bolsheviks" but the weapons given were used against other enemy, which wasn't a threat.
If the monarchy stayed, the world would be a better place
Croatia was never hungary
@@KalashnikovPM63 hungary really only became an ethnically diverse region after the mongol invasions killed up to half the population by some estimates combined with the slavic and romanian migrations from the south after the ottoman conquest of the balkans
💪🏻🇵🇱
It's a normal day in the Balkans.
Central Europe
Saddest video on TH-cam.
4:27 inaccurate borders of Hungary, North Yugoslavia, and Austria
Slavs on 11th nov 1918: hippity hoppity austria hungary's access to sea is now my property