Javed is right. No Indian muslim understands Farsi, Arabic and can only understand bit of Sanskrit and Prakrit. But when put together, they understand Urdu.
@@mohammadharisfahim6614 Not just Hindi but Gujrati, Marathi, Bengali, Odia and all South Indian languages. Most of them branched out from Sanskrit around 5th century onwards to become spoken and written languages on their own before Farsi arrived in 16th century, it was a natural evolution.
@@mohammadharisfahim6614 languages go with region not religion.. Depends on region.. Like a bengali muslim will understand alot of sanskrit derived words so does assamiya, odia, malyali Or kannadiga.... As these languages have alot direct sanskrit words..... No one can deny urdu/hindi developed from khari boli which was a apbhransh Or natural evolution of surseni prakrit that's why hindi/urdu, punjabi, gujrati, nepali, awdhi, bundeli, marwari, haryanvi sounds similar
Old Hindi was the earliest stage in 7th century of the Delhi dialect (Khariboli) of the Hindustani language, and so the ancestor of Modern Hindi . It developed from Shauraseni Prakrit and was spoken by the peoples of the Hindi Belt, especially around Delhi, in roughly the 13th-15th centuries. It is attested in only a handful of works of literature, including some works by the poet privithi Raj raso, verses by the poet-saint Namdev, and some verses by the Sufi saint Baba Farid in the Adi Granth. The works of Kabir also may be included, as they use a Khariboli-like dialect. Old Hindi was originally written in Devanagari When Mughals came to India and loanwords from Persian being added to Old Hindi's Prakritic base, the language evolved into Hindustani, which further developed into the present day modern languages of Hindi and Urdu. So there is no history of Urdu as a language of Indian history before 1730. It is only Hindvi, Hindi, Hindustani, apbramsh bhasha. So there is 75% words in Urdu is from prakrit Hindi and Sanskrit And only 25% loan words from Arabic Farsi and turkish So we can say that Muslim speaks Hindi with more Arabic and Persian word and written in nastqlic script and called Urdu So Hindi is real and Urdu is duplicate 😂
”Bhasha ka base illiteracy hai. (The base of language is illiteracy).Aur literature kehte hain brilliant illiteracy ko. (Literature is brilliant illiteracy).” He also says that brilliant literature should not be defined by the use of words that ordinary, perhaps even illiterate, people do not use. - Firaq Gorakhpuri Javed Sahab ke bare main kuch kehna, Sooraj ko diya batane vali bat ho gayi...... great Literature work over the decades....
+Dhiren Desai Are you just saying it or you have read any of his literary works? IF so, name some. Indians are good at praising someone without even reading his/her works.
@@javedk7242 Hello Javed shahab…comment likh ke anth saal ho gaye…context thik tarah se yaad nahin… I think I may be reiterating the fact that Javed Akhtar shahab may be eluding to… I had watched Firaq shahab’s interview once…his views on real literature were very fascinating…this was just in response to that…
The existence of your Urdu is zero without Hindi and Sanskrit Urdu vocabulary content 75% of word of Hindi prakrit in Sanskrit And only 25% of Arabic Persian Turkish
@@nitishsaxena1372 Bollywood ke sub songs urdu me hain or almost 99% films urdu me hain... 100 % urdu her Pakistani ko bhi nhi ati jese indians ko 100% hindi nhi ati.
Languages were made so that we may communicate with each other. More the better. Another aspect is while speaking you are also doing sort of breathing exercise, using tongue & mouth. So in short a language which keeps you physically healthy shall survive longer. Just as religion is being used as political tool, so is language, which is sad. Although English has now become the lingua franca.
Alhamdolillah Urdu is well spoken and understood in Pakistan. It is our first language and our entire curriculum and media are truly promoting our national language
@Jayant Ranapisay people of India specially Hindu hate Urdu. They can't say a sentence in Urdu properly. Urdu is dead in India. It's only alive in Bollywood movies.
Jayant Ranapisay urdu hamari qomi zaban hai, hamesha thi or rahy gi, javaid sahab ki baat se bilkul itifaq krta hon k zaban ka koi mazhab nahin hota, zaban to ilaqon ki hoti hai na k mazhab ki laiken aap k india main aap hi ki hakumat urdu k words ko text books se nikaal kr sanskrit k words daal rahi hai or ye kaam kaafi arsay se chal raha hai... phr ye urdu aapki zaban kaisay hoi jub k aapki hakumat hi isko apni zaban tasleem nahin krti
Jayant Ranapisay or bhai jaan aap jo baat kr rahy hain k urdu originate india main hoi thi us baat se humain koi ikhtilaaf nahin hai.... aisay to daikha jae to pakistan banany waly bhi indian thy, partition se pehle to sab aik tha.... phr jub pakistan bana to humne is urdu zaban ko apni qomi zaban declare kr diya... aaj pakistan k kisi bhi idary main chale jaen aapko urdu hi milegi... baat kisi zaban per apna haq jamana nahin bal-k us se baigana salook krne ki ho rahi hai..
@@jannatkichidya Old Hindi was the earliest stage in 7th century of the Delhi dialect (Khariboli) of the Hindustani language, and so the ancestor of Modern Hindi . It developed from Shauraseni Prakrit and was spoken by the peoples of the Hindi Belt, especially around Delhi, in roughly the 13th-15th centuries. It is attested in only a handful of works of literature, including some works by the poet privithi Raj raso, verses by the poet-saint Namdev, and some verses by the Sufi saint Baba Farid in the Adi Granth. The works of Kabir also may be included, as they use a Khariboli-like dialect. Old Hindi was originally written in Devanagari When Mughals came to India and loanwords from Persian being added to Old Hindi's Prakritic base, the language evolved into Hindustani, which further developed into the present day modern languages of Hindi and Urdu. So there is no history of Urdu as a language of Indian history before 1730. It is only Hindvi, Hindi, Hindustani, apbramsh bhasha. So there is 75% words in Urdu is from prakrit Hindi and Sanskrit And only 25% loan words from Arabic Farsi and turkish So we can say that Muslim speaks Hindi with more Arabic and Persian word and written in nastqlic script and called Urdu So Hindi is real and Urdu is duplicate 😂
Javed hi urdu ki prachar ki bollywood jariye India me. Hindi film me Javed akhter Hindi film ke naam per urdu hi urdu words and dilogue. Hindi Kam urdu jyada
@@mahimir7727 Hindus are not a monolith. Never heard from anywhere that Hindus unanimously rejected Urdu. If you're talking about the Indian state then India recognises Urdu as one of its official language and it's there on our currency notes. Also if anything, Islamic scholars rejected Urdu when the first time the holy Quran was translated in Urdu. The islamic scholars said such holy texts shouldn't have been translated in such a vulgar language. It was much later that this narrative was spinned out political motives that Hindustani has to be split into Hindi (with more Sanskrit vocab) and Urdu (with more Persian and a bit of Arabic vocab).
@Clayay! Husain what period are you talking of? Read the evolution of Urdu and how Urdu was born. Read about where it got its syntax, it's verbs and it's diverse vocabulary. The name Urdu for the language came much later.
Just in case if you only believe in the hearsay of your elders and don't apply your own critical thinking then i must make some challenging thoughts based on scientific logic and linguistics. Languages don't have religions. If anything, a language is usually revered if the religious text is written in that particular language. But the holy Quran is not written in Urdu, it is written in Arabic. Urdu is not even a Semetic language which is to say it is not even from the same language family of Arabic. It is considered by all linguistics as derivative of Hindustani which covers two form, Urdu and Hindi (I'm not saying it, this is believed by all the linguistics unanimously). The Arabic vocabulary in Urdu is so little that even Spanish has more percent of Arabic words than Urdu. Words don't make up a language anyway, the syntax and verbs do. Otherwise English would have been called a Latin language because the modern English vocab is 60% Latin but no, English is called a German language because of its syntax and verbs. Every language has borrowed vocab but that doesn't English which has been influenced by Greek, Latin, Sanskrit and more would lose its identity. The vocabulary of Urdu is dominated by Persian and Sanskrit. Even if we've to believe the assumption that languages have religions then Farsi is originally a language of Zoroastrians and not Muslims. But no, the languages do not religion but they can have a culture and Farsi has a Persian culture and Urdu has an Indian culture. Despite being heavily dominated by Persian, the syntax of Urdu is from the Indian language of Khari boli and almost all the verbs are of Sanskrit origin (www.dawn.com/news/681263/urdus-origin-its-not-a-camp-language).
Dekh Pakistani Bollywood mein Hindustani ka istemal hota hai joh jyada kar North Indian log samajhte hai. Kyun ki hindustan Pakistani ki tarah homogeneous nahi hai tabe bahut se alag alag background ke log mil jul kar rahte hai jiska result hai hindustani hai. Hindustani Urdu aur Hindi shabdo ka mishran hai joh speaker hisab se zyada Hindi leaning ho sakta hai yaha toh more Urdu leaning par woh rahte hindustani hai. Agar tujhe Urdu mein bolna ho ki what’s your name? toh tum bologe “Tumhare/Apka kya nam hai”. “tumhara/apka”, “kya”, “nam” aur “hai” shabd arabi ya Farsi se aye hai kya? Yeh sab Sanskrit se nikle hai aur aise bahut se shabd hai jo Sanskrit based hai toh har kahe bakwas na haga karo. Aur tu jo mera likha paad aur samajh raha hai kyun ki colloquial hindi aur Urdu mutually intelligible hai. Bollywood mein agar bahut sare Urdu ganne hai toh is lete kyun ki Urdu ka janma Hindustan mein hua tha aur woh hindustani culture ka ek hissa hai. Hindustan mein minority ki bhi izzat hote hai aur unhe bhi equal opportunities aur representation milte hai. Pakistan ki tarah nahi ki partition ke bad 14% Hindu aur uske 70+ salo bad 2.41%. Tum log Muslamaan ko alag desh chahiye kar ke Pakistan bana liya par aab bhi joh first language Urdu speakers joh most Northern Indian states aaye the unhe Muhajir bolte ho.
My khud batah sekta hai hindi mai god ko bhagawan aur urdu Mai khuda rab malik Hindi mai love ko Prem bolte aur urdu mai muhabbot ulfat bolte hai hindi Mai dunia ko bicho bolte hai aur urdu mai alam ye khayenat bolte jo ap log hindi bolte hena asal Mai woh urdu hai Bollywood mai 90 person Urdu mai hota hai
@@rohitbhushan7229 Old Hindi was the earliest stage in 7th century of the Delhi dialect (Khariboli) of the Hindustani language, and so the ancestor of Modern Hindi . It developed from Shauraseni Prakrit and was spoken by the peoples of the Hindi Belt, especially around Delhi, in roughly the 13th-15th centuries. It is attested in only a handful of works of literature, including some works by the poet privithi Raj raso, verses by the poet-saint Namdev, and some verses by the Sufi saint Baba Farid in the Adi Granth. The works of Kabir also may be included, as they use a Khariboli-like dialect. Old Hindi was originally written in Devanagari When Mughals came to India and loanwords from Persian being added to Old Hindi's Prakritic base, the language evolved into Hindustani, which further developed into the present day modern languages of Hindi and Urdu. So there is no history of Urdu as a language of Indian history before 1730. It is only Hindvi, Hindi, Hindustani, apbramsh bhasha. So there is 75% words in Urdu is from prakrit Hindi and Sanskrit And only 25% loan words from Arabic Farsi and turkish So we can say that Muslim speaks Hindi with more Arabic and Persian word and written in nastqlic script and called Urdu So Hindi is real and Urdu is duplicate 😂
में इनकी बात से सहमत नही हूं बिना अरबी फारसी तुर्की के उर्दू नही होगी तब हिंदी होगी ,लेकिन मैं मानता हूं की हिंदी मैं गाने लिखने चाहिए 90 में ज्यादा 80%उर्दू में है हा ये भी बात है उसे लिखने वाले उर्दुवासी थे
In pakistan Urdu with its original script is in a safer place as compared to India ۔۔۔۔۔even a 5th pass person can read and understand Urdu script easily.
Magar aap logon ka Urdu bolna aapke punjabi se mix hota hai. Matlab yeh ki pata padta hai ki koi Punjabi Urdu bol raha hai. Achha nahin lagta sunne mein. Jabki aisa Hindustan mein nahin hai.
@@bhatshahid2664 I am kashmiri and raised and got education in Rawalpindi Punjab ....but ....we don't speak urdu like native punjabis........Urdu with punjabi tone touch is usually spoken by The people of central punjab i.e Lahore Faisalabad etc......and....now their accent is getting better ..... one of my little nieces in kashmir speaks urdu and we call her that she speaks like lahori people.....who speak like throwing words ......
Please stop this hatred towards two great languages of Awadh region of India. Na Hindi kisi ke pita ki hai aur na Urdu kisi ke abba ki hai. Ye dono zabane ghulam Hindustan ki Awadh riyasat ki mukhtalif zabane thin aur hamesha rahengi, hamen inse muhabbat honi chahiye. Kisi zaban ko mazhab se jodna sahi nahi hai lekin badkismati se naye zamane me yahi ho raha hai. Aap beshaq kisi bhi zaban me guftgu kariye aapki marzi lekin dusri zaban ki mukhalfat karna ya beizzati karna tehzeeb nahi hai. Ye dono hi zabane alhada hote hue bhi ek jaisi hain. Yahan par be fizool ki nafrat mat failaiye. Mazakraat karne me koi burai nahi hai lekin gandgi failana nafrat failana gunah hai. Aap Hindu ke nukht-e-nazar se dekhenge to aapko Hindi se muhabbat hogi aur hona lazimi bhi hai lekin Urdu se nafrat nahi honi chahiye. Aur yahi baat hamare musalman bhaiyo ko bhi samajhna hoga Hindi unki bhi utni hi zaban hai jaise Urdu hai. Aaj bahot sare Hindu khaalis Hindi bolna nahi jante aur sare Muslim khaalis Urdu nahi jante, bahot se to Urdu, Farsi likh padh bhi nahi paate. Bahot se logon ko Urdu ke hurufon ka talafuzz bhi theek se nahi aata. Aise me kisi zaban par itna ghurur karna theek nahi hai. Aapas me nafrat mat rakhiye. Isse kaumi yakjehti aur badhegi. Wo kaisa manzar hoga jisme Hindu kaum Urdu, Farsi seekhen aur Muslim bhai Hindi, Sanskrit seekhen. Kisi zaban ke liye ek dusre ke mazhab ko gaali mat dijiye. Shukriya! ---- Kunwar (Prince) Devanshu Srivastava, 8th generation direct descendant of Raja Jhau Lal Srivastava of Awadh (Lucknow).
This is the main reason why we South Indians don't appreciate Bollywood. Our languages are heavily influenced by Sanskrit and hence Shudh Hindi would be so much more enjoyable to us. That's not the case with Persian/Urdu
@@asfaquehussain7146 Urdu tab se boli ja rahi hai jabse uska naam Urdu tha bhi nahi. Usse pehle usko Hindustani aur usse pehle usko Rekhta kaha karte the.
@@asfaquehussain7146 Muslim rule? Aapka ishara agar Mughal hukumat ki taraf hai toh toh kaafi Mughals khud khasa Musalman nahi the. Akbar ne toh ek naya mazhab banane ki bhi koshish ki thi. Mughal darbaar me bobot Hindu bhi the jisme mere khud ke ancestors bhi the. Kafi sipahi bhi Hindu the. Usi tarah Rajput shashan me bhi Musalman sipahi hua karte the. Baat faarsi/persian ki kare toh yeh Islam ke aane se pehle se zinda hai. Yeh Parsio'n/Zoroastrians ki zabaan hua karti thi. Urdu ki grammar aur syntax pura Indian hai jo jaise Javed sahb ne kaha wahi ek zabaan ko banata hai. Haan, vocabulary bohot mixed hai jisme faarsi ka ek bohot ahem kirdar hai. Lekin sanskrit words bhi bohot hain jaise hath aur chand aur thode Arbi lafz hain.
Kabhi koi zabaan ya bhasha kisi se oonchi ya neechi nahi hoti. Har zabaan ka barabar se ehtraam karna chahiye kyunki har zabaan apne sath hazaro saalo ki tehzeeb ki nishani hai.
Lafz "Hind" bhi farsi hai. Farsi holnay walay hee asal main Hindi bolte hain urdu ko bhi. Q keh wo samajte hain ye Hind ki zuban hai to Hindi kehlayega. Asal naam Hindustani hai jahan se Urdu/Hindi niklain hain.
@Aqal Mand only Muslims say that I challenge you to show me atleast one paper or book which was written in urdu before 19th century. In reality Urdu was just another dialect of Hindi which was written in Khadiboli oldest Hindi scripture (Old Devanagari) is from 1st century CE
@Gym Lover 2.0 Old Hindi was the earliest stage in 7th century of the Delhi dialect (Khariboli) of the Hindustani language, and so the ancestor of Modern Hindi . It developed from Shauraseni Prakrit and was spoken by the peoples of the Hindi Belt, especially around Delhi, in roughly the 13th-15th centuries. It is attested in only a handful of works of literature, including some works by the poet privithi Raj raso, verses by the poet-saint Namdev, and some verses by the Sufi saint Baba Farid in the Adi Granth. The works of Kabir also may be included, as they use a Khariboli-like dialect. Old Hindi was originally written in Devanagari When Mughals came to India and loanwords from Persian being added to Old Hindi's Prakritic base, the language evolved into Hindustani, which further developed into the present day modern languages of Hindi and Urdu. So there is no history of Urdu as a language of Indian history before 1730. It is only Hindvi, Hindi, Hindustani, apbramsh bhasha. So there is 75% words in Urdu is from prakrit Hindi and Sanskrit And only 25% loan words from Arabic Farsi and turkish So we can say that Muslim speaks Hindi with more Arabic and Persian word and written in nastqlic script and called Urdu So Hindi is real and Urdu is duplicate 😂
@Gym Lover 2.0 The famous work "Prithviraj Raso" was written by Chand Bardai, in hindi. In 1191 An epic poem, it demonstrates the life and contributions of the 12th century king, Prithviraj Chauhan.
hindi is 50 percent sansakirit and 50 oercent urdu words sara din urdu bolte ho ho or kehte ho k hindi bol raha hon sara din jo bolo rat ko ja jr counting kro k is mai urdu words kitne hain
Old Hindi was the earliest stage in 7th century of the Delhi dialect (Khariboli) of the Hindustani language, and so the ancestor of Modern Hindi . It developed from Shauraseni Prakrit and was spoken by the peoples of the Hindi Belt, especially around Delhi, in roughly the 13th-15th centuries. It is attested in only a handful of works of literature, including some works by the poet privithi Raj raso, verses by the poet-saint Namdev, and some verses by the Sufi saint Baba Farid in the Adi Granth. The works of Kabir also may be included, as they use a Khariboli-like dialect. Old Hindi was originally written in Devanagari When Mughals came to India and loanwords from Persian being added to Old Hindi's Prakritic base, the language evolved into Hindustani, which further developed into the present day modern languages of Hindi and Urdu. So there is no history of Urdu as a language of Indian history before 1730. It is only Hindvi, Hindi, Hindustani, apbramsh bhasha. So there is 75% words in Urdu is from prakrit Hindi and Sanskrit And only 25% loan words from Arabic Farsi and turkish So we can say that Muslim speaks Hindi with more Arabic and Persian word and written in nastqlic script and called Urdu So Hindi is real and Urdu is duplicate 😂
@@jannatkichidyaeven urdu isn't much acceptable same as hindi. As akthar sahab said as long as we(indian and pakistani) understand we consider it as hindi(indian) or urdu(pakistani) , when we don't understand it we say it might be urdu(indian) or hindi(pakistani) And here hindustani(hindi+urdu) language comes. 😂
@Jayant Ranapisay they came from Afghanistan they were turk mongols but from Afghanistan And i am a pathan from Afghanistan now a proud pakistani thats what makes us related and biggest thing they were muslims and muslim ki ijaad muslims par muslims ka haq ziada he khas kar jab wahi muslims 500 saal ap par hukumat kar chuke ho
@Jayant Ranapisay india is a hindu country thats another debate they never wanted to convert them other wise if arab countries and iran could be converted it wasn't a big deal for india half of it was already muslim even if they tried 1% percent now india would have been a muslim country but i don't talk about it debate is about urdu and mughal and for ur kind of information Persian is a second language of afghanistan and half of afghanistans population even now is Persian
@Jayant Ranapisay and lol all muslims in india and pakistan panjabis sindhis rajpoots are hindu converted there any muslim who was muslim from the beginning arabs and Afghanistanis are jews converted iran had there own religion indian pakistan muslims are hindu converted so don't say they prefer dying then comverting
Javed sahab Urdu ko Urdu kahane se darte hain. Ghuma phira ke lafzon men logon ki soch ko deesha heen (clue less) kar dete hai. Hindustani kahen tow Urdu aur Hindi ka wajud kahan raha. Dukan band hone ka darr. Shayad Jeena Isee Ka Naam Hai.
@@jacksparrow9105 No Turkish got it from Arabic coz Mongols first transferred gun powder tech to Arabs but in Muslim world this word flow is extremely common.
Boycott urduwood, fooling people saying it's Hindi but 95% Bollywood songs are in urdu. Or say it's urdu film industry, don't say it's Hindi film industry.
@@saifulislam4221 You don't use our grammar pattern in your Urdu language The 75% of Urdu word is that Sanskrit and prakrit and Hindi And only 25% of Urdu word is Arabic Persian and turkish
Then why Malayali Muslims (who're good in numbers) speak Malayalam and hardly any Urdu. Why Bengali Muslims went against Urdu to create Bangladesh? Why so many Pashtuns speak in such an accented Urdu which it never intended to be? Tell you what, I'm a Hindu and my grandparents used to speak and write Urdu proudly. Ever heard of Munshi Premchand? He's considered as the father of Urdu Afsanas. If you study Urdu at a higher level then you might get to know that. Zabano'n ka mazhab nahi hota, kal kahoge palak Musalman aur tamatar Hindu.
I am a hindu.But i have great admiration for Urdu poetry.Religion has nothing to do with language.Hindi doesn't represent all Hindus.Bengali Hindus speaks Bengali like tamilian speaks Tamil.that's it
@T A Hindi جی نہیں میرے بھائی ۔ ہندی بولنے والے "ذرا"لفظ کو "جَرا" بولتے ہیں Ji nhi my brother. Hindi bolnay walay "Zara"ko "Jara" boltay hain "Zeera" Hindi bolnay may "Jeera" hojata hay...
@T A Hindi Jo zeera ko jeera bolay Aur zra ko jra bolay Aisa shakhs dunya ki hr zaban nhi bol sakta hay Laykin jiski seedhi Urdu zaban hay wo dunya ki hr zaban bol skta hay Mayra khayal hay shayad mayri baat ka mtlb ab apko samajh may ajaigay shayad 🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔
Urdu is an Indian languagebut Islamist didn't want to make it Indian language so they adopted perso-arabic script so that it will appear foreign language and nobody in India could study it.Thus to create a fraud narrative that Urdu is muslim language.Govt should make devnagri as script of urdu
I strongly oppose it. Its a urdu language that used in Bollywood not hindi.hindi is dirty language.when v call from our mobile it says in actual hindi.jis vekti ko aap call kar rahe ho wo apke call ka uttar nahi deraha hai.kuch samay baad punaha prayatn karein.yak sounds do dirty.
@@wahegurumeharkari2944 Sach sun kar teri phatt gayee. U r the follower of balatkari dharam.apne mandiro mei bachiyon ka balatkar karte hain. Niyog pratha shuddi karan pratha jaanle apne dharam ko thuke ga bhi nahi tu.
If u r fine with inclusion of Persian, Arabic and Turkish words then what is your problem with today's inclusion of English words ? Don't be hypocrite, Mr. Akhtar. India is a multilingual nation and no single language can complete its linguistic identity.
![Shareปลาวาฬ ส่งท้าย SS1 พาเปียโน ขึ้น Ferrari ก่อนไปขาย แลก Nissan l [Nickynachat]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/KAknGkTNIvg/mqdefault.jpg)
Whenever Javed speaks ,gems of wisdom are strewn around.What insight into the reality of Hindustani devoid of religious bias!
Javed is right. No Indian muslim understands Farsi, Arabic and can only understand bit of Sanskrit and Prakrit. But when put together, they understand Urdu.
No Hindu also understand prakrit or Sanskrit. They understand Hindustani.
@@mohammadharisfahim6614 Not just Hindi but Gujrati, Marathi, Bengali, Odia and all South Indian languages. Most of them branched out from Sanskrit around 5th century onwards to become spoken and written languages on their own before Farsi arrived in 16th century, it was a natural evolution.
@@mohammadharisfahim6614 languages go with region not religion.. Depends on region.. Like a bengali muslim will understand alot of sanskrit derived words so does assamiya, odia, malyali Or kannadiga.... As these languages have alot direct sanskrit words..... No one can deny urdu/hindi developed from khari boli which was a apbhransh Or natural evolution of surseni prakrit that's why hindi/urdu, punjabi, gujrati, nepali, awdhi, bundeli, marwari, haryanvi sounds similar
Awesome!! A KKG642 said, he is not just 'Hindustani' treasure, he is world treasure...because his knowledge transcends languages!
Old Hindi was the earliest stage in 7th century of the Delhi dialect (Khariboli) of the Hindustani language, and so the ancestor of Modern Hindi . It developed from Shauraseni Prakrit and was spoken by the peoples of the Hindi Belt, especially around Delhi, in roughly the 13th-15th centuries. It is attested in only a handful of works of literature, including some works by the poet privithi Raj raso, verses by the poet-saint Namdev, and some verses by the Sufi saint Baba Farid in the Adi Granth. The works of Kabir also may be included, as they use a Khariboli-like dialect. Old Hindi was originally written in Devanagari
When Mughals came to India and loanwords from Persian being added to Old Hindi's Prakritic base, the language evolved into Hindustani, which further developed into the present day modern languages of Hindi and Urdu.
So there is no history of Urdu as a language of Indian history before 1730.
It is only Hindvi, Hindi, Hindustani, apbramsh bhasha.
So there is 75% words in Urdu is from prakrit Hindi and Sanskrit
And only 25% loan words from Arabic Farsi and turkish
So we can say that Muslim speaks Hindi with more Arabic and Persian word and written in nastqlic script and called Urdu
So Hindi is real and Urdu is duplicate 😂
Mr 70% urdu key word's farsi se liyey gayey hai mr mandirchap copy paste krne se phele dekh leta
”Bhasha ka base illiteracy hai. (The base of language is illiteracy).Aur literature kehte hain brilliant illiteracy ko. (Literature is brilliant illiteracy).” He also says that brilliant literature should not be defined by the use of words that ordinary, perhaps even illiterate, people do not use.
- Firaq Gorakhpuri
Javed Sahab ke bare main kuch kehna, Sooraj ko diya batane vali bat ho gayi...... great Literature work over the decades....
+Dhiren Desai
Are you just saying it or you have read any of his literary works? IF so, name some.
Indians are good at praising someone without even reading his/her works.
Aap ne jo bhi kaha Javed sahab ke baare men kyoun kaha mujhe samajh men nahi aaya. Shayad aap ko bhi.
@@2sridhark just saw your message after seven years may make it irrelevant…I think you’re talking about Firaq Goralhpuri…
@@javedk7242 Hello Javed shahab…comment likh ke anth saal ho gaye…context thik tarah se yaad nahin…
I think I may be reiterating the fact that Javed Akhtar shahab may be eluding to… I had watched Firaq shahab’s interview once…his views on real literature were very fascinating…this was just in response to that…
Really is that Hindi speakers cannot live without Urdu
Shukriya,Dost, Khush,jawab,imandar, sirf, tarikh ,are not Hindi words
I say dhanyawad or thank you. Never said sukriya ever. Stop assuming
@@wonderfullife737 you are exception
@@adishraworld7763 in villages we used to say dhanyavad 100% of time.
The existence of your Urdu is zero without Hindi and Sanskrit
Urdu vocabulary content 75% of word of Hindi prakrit in Sanskrit
And only 25% of Arabic Persian Turkish
Lol delusional without hindi verbs urdu isn't anything, without verbs there cannot be a language so come out of delusion
Love Javed saab...adore and respect him.x
Urdu is an emotion ❤️
No. Shame.
"Sare jahan main dhoom hamari zabaan ki ha."----Urdu the great!
Love u Javed saab.. Great poet
بہت خوب صورت پروگرام
हिन्दी हमारी माँ और उर्दु हमारी मौसी है। 👍
I love urdu language
Mr. Akhtar - you are just simply absolutely a treasure! Brilliant!!!
Finally proved URDU is predominate in film
+azmat khan why it has to be proved ??
Atulshah laji . Because people in India think that Hindi is being used in Bollywood.
kaisi bahas me pad Gaye Bhai...Jo bhi Hai enjoy Karo khush raho.
@@aqeebkhan3603 it's more like Hindustani jise Urdu ya Hindi dono keh sakte hain. Khalis Urdu toh ptv bolta hai.
@@nitishsaxena1372 Bollywood ke sub songs urdu me hain or almost 99% films urdu me hain...
100 % urdu her Pakistani ko bhi nhi ati jese indians ko 100% hindi nhi ati.
Languages were made so that we may communicate with each other. More the better.
Another aspect is while speaking you are also doing sort of breathing exercise, using tongue & mouth.
So in short a language which keeps you physically healthy shall survive longer.
Just as religion is being used as political tool, so is language, which is sad.
Although English has now become the lingua franca.
Good points
Mr. Akhtar is right... as long as i understand i consider it as hindi, when i don't understand it then i say it might be urdu...
I am from Pakistan. Our case is reverse. Jahan tak smajh aati hai wahan tak Urdu. Jo smajh nahi aata woh hindi
Aur ham dono ko jo samajh aati hai wahi language ka naam Hindustani hai joki abhi javed sahab bta rhe the 😂
@@science57506: Btw pakistani ka science se kya lena dena ? 🤣Irony... If wish take Javed Akhtar to Pakistan, he is burden on our society... he he he
@@ShaneBond07 India ka literature se kya lena dena?
@@science57506: RoFL... damn i forgot, i replied to madrasa chap... LoL
I know urdu well
can some body tell that ,has the writing of urdu adopted Arabic stayl. I see the change
No urdu is written in nastaleeq script
@@waxeemunofficial7316 Yes u r right
Alhamdolillah Urdu is well spoken and understood in Pakistan. It is our first language and our entire curriculum and media are truly promoting our national language
@Jayant Ranapisay people of India specially Hindu hate Urdu. They can't say a sentence in Urdu properly. Urdu is dead in India. It's only alive in Bollywood movies.
At the cost of other regional languages.
Jayant Ranapisay urdu hamari qomi zaban hai, hamesha thi or rahy gi, javaid sahab ki baat se bilkul itifaq krta hon k zaban ka koi mazhab nahin hota, zaban to ilaqon ki hoti hai na k mazhab ki laiken aap k india main aap hi ki hakumat urdu k words ko text books se nikaal kr sanskrit k words daal rahi hai or ye kaam kaafi arsay se chal raha hai... phr ye urdu aapki zaban kaisay hoi jub k aapki hakumat hi isko apni zaban tasleem nahin krti
Jayant Ranapisay th-cam.com/video/3sIHw-QUXG4/w-d-xo.html watch this video
Jayant Ranapisay or bhai jaan aap jo baat kr rahy hain k urdu originate india main hoi thi us baat se humain koi ikhtilaaf nahin hai.... aisay to daikha jae to pakistan banany waly bhi indian thy, partition se pehle to sab aik tha.... phr jub pakistan bana to humne is urdu zaban ko apni qomi zaban declare kr diya... aaj pakistan k kisi bhi idary main chale jaen aapko urdu hi milegi... baat kisi zaban per apna haq jamana nahin bal-k us se baigana salook krne ki ho rahi hai..
Tow languages are hidden sweet is Urdu & Persian. Although my lang is Bangli
Come on.idiot... bengali is the sweetest
Sharif babu Hahaha bangla sobcheye bhalo
Sanskrit is best, urdu is copied from Sanskrit and Arabi Persian
@@maruthimacha9418 true!
धन्यवाद सर् , आप से बहुत कुछ सीखने को मिलता है । जितना भी सुनो कम लगता ।
ভাষা নদীর মতো সচল, সময়ের সাথে সাথে আরও অনেক উপনদী এসে মেসে,
Shaandar all true
Nice to hear you sir👌👌
both sandooq and bandooq are turkish , in arabic sandoq is called ' baqa'
fahd090078601 dandoq and bandoq are Arabic words not Turkish
Samdooq is still used frequently in Arabic while Bandooq has been used for gun in recent history now the word Rushah is used for firing or Gun.
See the below link for Arabic dictionary for word sandooq
www.almaany.com/ar/dict/ar-ar/%D8%B5%D9%86%D8%AF%D9%88%D9%82/
For Bandooq Arabic dictionary link
www.almaany.com/ar/dict/ar-ar/%D8%A8%D9%86%D8%AF%D9%88%D9%82/
In hindi thete r no words for za n fa.so typical hindi speaking people say jabardast for zabardast. jindagi gor zindagi.phaisla for faisla n all.
हिंदी और उर्दू में बस फर्क है इतना कि हम देखते हैं ख्वाब और वह देखता है सपना
Antar jitna bhi ho lekin apke bhasa main sudhata honi chahiye
What is 'language'...and what is 'our' language? Hear a master technician of language and one of India's leading intellectual speak on the subject.
i like urdu language its very nice to hear urdu words
Thanks a lot.
@@jannatkichidya Old Hindi was the earliest stage in 7th century of the Delhi dialect (Khariboli) of the Hindustani language, and so the ancestor of Modern Hindi . It developed from Shauraseni Prakrit and was spoken by the peoples of the Hindi Belt, especially around Delhi, in roughly the 13th-15th centuries. It is attested in only a handful of works of literature, including some works by the poet privithi Raj raso, verses by the poet-saint Namdev, and some verses by the Sufi saint Baba Farid in the Adi Granth. The works of Kabir also may be included, as they use a Khariboli-like dialect. Old Hindi was originally written in Devanagari
When Mughals came to India and loanwords from Persian being added to Old Hindi's Prakritic base, the language evolved into Hindustani, which further developed into the present day modern languages of Hindi and Urdu.
So there is no history of Urdu as a language of Indian history before 1730.
It is only Hindvi, Hindi, Hindustani, apbramsh bhasha.
So there is 75% words in Urdu is from prakrit Hindi and Sanskrit
And only 25% loan words from Arabic Farsi and turkish
So we can say that Muslim speaks Hindi with more Arabic and Persian word and written in nastqlic script and called Urdu
So Hindi is real and Urdu is duplicate 😂
Are sir ! Aap har jagah wahi purane examples dete hain . Main aap ka har interview dekhta hoon taki kuchh naya jaanne ko mile
WoooW sir
Javed hi urdu ki prachar ki bollywood jariye India me.
Hindi film me Javed akhter Hindi film ke naam per urdu hi urdu words and dilogue.
Hindi Kam urdu jyada
Thanks sir
Urdu is a turkish word which means army( lashkar)
Urdu tab se boli ja rahi hai jabse uska naam Urdu tha bhi nahi. Usse pehle usko Hindustani aur usse pehle usko Rekhta kaha karte the.
@@nitishsaxena1372 hhhhh hhhhh urdu is Muslim language... Hindu n issy inkar Kiya tha Mery bhai....
@@mahimir7727 Hindus are not a monolith. Never heard from anywhere that Hindus unanimously rejected Urdu. If you're talking about the Indian state then India recognises Urdu as one of its official language and it's there on our currency notes.
Also if anything, Islamic scholars rejected Urdu when the first time the holy Quran was translated in Urdu. The islamic scholars said such holy texts shouldn't have been translated in such a vulgar language. It was much later that this narrative was spinned out political motives that Hindustani has to be split into Hindi (with more Sanskrit vocab) and Urdu (with more Persian and a bit of Arabic vocab).
@Clayay! Husain what period are you talking of? Read the evolution of Urdu and how Urdu was born. Read about where it got its syntax, it's verbs and it's diverse vocabulary. The name Urdu for the language came much later.
Just in case if you only believe in the hearsay of your elders and don't apply your own critical thinking then i must make some challenging thoughts based on scientific logic and linguistics.
Languages don't have religions. If anything, a language is usually revered if the religious text is written in that particular language. But the holy Quran is not written in Urdu, it is written in Arabic. Urdu is not even a Semetic language which is to say it is not even from the same language family of Arabic. It is considered by all linguistics as derivative of Hindustani which covers two form, Urdu and Hindi (I'm not saying it, this is believed by all the linguistics unanimously). The Arabic vocabulary in Urdu is so little that even Spanish has more percent of Arabic words than Urdu. Words don't make up a language anyway, the syntax and verbs do. Otherwise English would have been called a Latin language because the modern English vocab is 60% Latin but no, English is called a German language because of its syntax and verbs. Every language has borrowed vocab but that doesn't English which has been influenced by Greek, Latin, Sanskrit and more would lose its identity. The vocabulary of Urdu is dominated by Persian and Sanskrit. Even if we've to believe the assumption that languages have religions then Farsi is originally a language of Zoroastrians and not Muslims. But no, the languages do not religion but they can have a culture and Farsi has a Persian culture and Urdu has an Indian culture. Despite being heavily dominated by Persian, the syntax of Urdu is from the Indian language of Khari boli and almost all the verbs are of Sanskrit origin (www.dawn.com/news/681263/urdus-origin-its-not-a-camp-language).
Waw what I do I think I have perfect urdu from Pakistan
Pakistan ma punjabi sindhi blochi pashto boli Jati ha
Bollywood movies are 90 % made in urdu songs pure urdu mai hoty hain in ko hindi movies kahna ghalat ha.
Dekh Pakistani Bollywood mein Hindustani ka istemal hota hai joh jyada kar North Indian log samajhte hai. Kyun ki hindustan Pakistani ki tarah homogeneous nahi hai tabe bahut se alag alag background ke log mil jul kar rahte hai jiska result hai hindustani hai. Hindustani Urdu aur Hindi shabdo ka mishran hai joh speaker hisab se zyada Hindi leaning ho sakta hai yaha toh more Urdu leaning par woh rahte hindustani hai. Agar tujhe Urdu mein bolna ho ki what’s your name? toh tum bologe “Tumhare/Apka kya nam hai”. “tumhara/apka”, “kya”, “nam” aur “hai” shabd arabi ya Farsi se aye hai kya? Yeh sab Sanskrit se nikle hai aur aise bahut se shabd hai jo Sanskrit based hai toh har kahe bakwas na haga karo. Aur tu jo mera likha paad aur samajh raha hai kyun ki colloquial hindi aur Urdu mutually intelligible hai. Bollywood mein agar bahut sare Urdu ganne hai toh is lete kyun ki Urdu ka janma Hindustan mein hua tha aur woh hindustani culture ka ek hissa hai. Hindustan mein minority ki bhi izzat hote hai aur unhe bhi equal opportunities aur representation milte hai. Pakistan ki tarah nahi ki partition ke bad 14% Hindu aur uske 70+ salo bad 2.41%. Tum log Muslamaan ko alag desh chahiye kar ke Pakistan bana liya par aab bhi joh first language Urdu speakers joh most Northern Indian states aaye the unhe Muhajir bolte ho.
بہت خوب کہا ہے
Urdu is a pure Indian language...🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳 .. Pakistan adopted it later 😏😏..
URDU is best language
Fuck Urdu.... Bengali is best
@@hillclimbracingofficial4105 Both are Indian languages ❤️
Love you Javed Akhtar
Adarniya Javed akhter mahoday kripya aap mujhe bol sakte he Urdu bhasa aur Hindi bhasha me Kya antar he.
My khud batah sekta hai hindi mai god ko bhagawan aur urdu Mai khuda rab malik Hindi mai love ko Prem bolte aur urdu mai muhabbot ulfat bolte hai hindi Mai dunia ko bicho bolte hai aur urdu mai alam ye khayenat bolte jo ap log hindi bolte hena asal Mai woh urdu hai Bollywood mai 90 person Urdu mai hota hai
दो बेटियाँ हैं
मादरे हिंदुस्तान की
उर्दू असल मे बहन है
हिंदी ज़बान की
Lucknow se start hui h
Pakistani language nhi h
Ye Hindustani language se aai h
@@ARShaikh515 Then why is it's script persian. Why not devanagri ??
@@rohitbhushan7229 Old Hindi was the earliest stage in 7th century of the Delhi dialect (Khariboli) of the Hindustani language, and so the ancestor of Modern Hindi . It developed from Shauraseni Prakrit and was spoken by the peoples of the Hindi Belt, especially around Delhi, in roughly the 13th-15th centuries. It is attested in only a handful of works of literature, including some works by the poet privithi Raj raso, verses by the poet-saint Namdev, and some verses by the Sufi saint Baba Farid in the Adi Granth. The works of Kabir also may be included, as they use a Khariboli-like dialect. Old Hindi was originally written in Devanagari
When Mughals came to India and loanwords from Persian being added to Old Hindi's Prakritic base, the language evolved into Hindustani, which further developed into the present day modern languages of Hindi and Urdu.
So there is no history of Urdu as a language of Indian history before 1730.
It is only Hindvi, Hindi, Hindustani, apbramsh bhasha.
So there is 75% words in Urdu is from prakrit Hindi and Sanskrit
And only 25% loan words from Arabic Farsi and turkish
So we can say that Muslim speaks Hindi with more Arabic and Persian word and written in nastqlic script and called Urdu
So Hindi is real and Urdu is duplicate 😂
@@ARShaikh515 mujahir people imposed urdu on Pakistan
"ज़बान" के होवे है, हम तो "भाषा" जाने है।
में इनकी बात से सहमत नही हूं बिना अरबी फारसी तुर्की के उर्दू नही होगी तब हिंदी होगी ,लेकिन मैं मानता हूं की हिंदी मैं गाने लिखने चाहिए 90 में ज्यादा 80%उर्दू में है हा ये भी बात है उसे लिखने वाले उर्दुवासी थे
In pakistan Urdu with its original script is in a safer place as compared to India ۔۔۔۔۔even a 5th pass person can read and understand Urdu script easily.
Magar aap logon ka Urdu bolna aapke punjabi se mix hota hai. Matlab yeh ki pata padta hai ki koi Punjabi Urdu bol raha hai. Achha nahin lagta sunne mein. Jabki aisa Hindustan mein nahin hai.
@@bhatshahid2664
I am kashmiri and raised and got education in Rawalpindi Punjab ....but ....we don't speak urdu like native punjabis........Urdu with punjabi tone touch is usually spoken by The people of central punjab i.e Lahore Faisalabad etc......and....now their accent is getting better .....
one of my little nieces in kashmir speaks urdu and we call her that she speaks like lahori people.....who speak like throwing words ......
8:37 "उसके बावजूद भी" common wrong phrase. उसके बावजूद is complete in itself. Adding भी is somehow wrong
Urdu is blend of all other languages including sanskrit and hindi
सस्तृत से हिंदी हिंदी से उर्दू बनी है और तुम बोल क्या रहे हो
Please stop this hatred towards two great languages of Awadh region of India.
Na Hindi kisi ke pita ki hai aur na Urdu kisi ke abba ki hai. Ye dono zabane ghulam Hindustan ki Awadh riyasat ki mukhtalif zabane thin aur hamesha rahengi, hamen inse muhabbat honi chahiye.
Kisi zaban ko mazhab se jodna sahi nahi hai lekin badkismati se naye zamane me yahi ho raha hai.
Aap beshaq kisi bhi zaban me guftgu kariye aapki marzi lekin dusri zaban ki mukhalfat karna ya beizzati karna tehzeeb nahi hai. Ye dono hi zabane alhada hote hue bhi ek jaisi hain.
Yahan par be fizool ki nafrat mat failaiye. Mazakraat karne me koi burai nahi hai lekin gandgi failana nafrat failana gunah hai. Aap Hindu ke nukht-e-nazar se dekhenge to aapko Hindi se muhabbat hogi aur hona lazimi bhi hai lekin Urdu se nafrat nahi honi chahiye. Aur yahi baat hamare musalman bhaiyo ko bhi samajhna hoga Hindi unki bhi utni hi zaban hai jaise Urdu hai.
Aaj bahot sare Hindu khaalis Hindi bolna nahi jante aur sare Muslim khaalis Urdu nahi jante, bahot se to Urdu, Farsi likh padh bhi nahi paate. Bahot se logon ko Urdu ke hurufon ka talafuzz bhi theek se nahi aata. Aise me kisi zaban par itna ghurur karna theek nahi hai.
Aapas me nafrat mat rakhiye. Isse kaumi yakjehti aur badhegi. Wo kaisa manzar hoga jisme Hindu kaum Urdu, Farsi seekhen aur Muslim bhai Hindi, Sanskrit seekhen.
Kisi zaban ke liye ek dusre ke mazhab ko gaali mat dijiye.
Shukriya!
----
Kunwar (Prince) Devanshu Srivastava,
8th generation direct descendant of Raja Jhau Lal Srivastava of Awadh (Lucknow).
کتاب کا نام کیا ہے
Urdu Aur Bollywood
Bahut Khub
This is the main reason why we South Indians don't appreciate Bollywood. Our languages are heavily influenced by Sanskrit and hence Shudh Hindi would be so much more enjoyable to us. That's not the case with Persian/Urdu
Isliye unhone nahi bola qki tab Urdu Bollywood main itna nhi hota
I am a Tamilian and am no aware that "Urad" is a Tamil word. It is not.
It is from tamil.. it is a hindi form of 'ulundhu'
Sridhar Kaushik
Urdu is "Turky" word according to google
@@asfaquehussain7146 Urdu tab se boli ja rahi hai jabse uska naam Urdu tha bhi nahi. Usse pehle usko Hindustani aur usse pehle usko Rekhta kaha karte the.
@@nitishsaxena1372
MUSLIMS Rules ane k baad Urdu ko piroya gya..with help of Persian
@@asfaquehussain7146 Muslim rule? Aapka ishara agar Mughal hukumat ki taraf hai toh toh kaafi Mughals khud khasa Musalman nahi the. Akbar ne toh ek naya mazhab banane ki bhi koshish ki thi. Mughal darbaar me bobot Hindu bhi the jisme mere khud ke ancestors bhi the. Kafi sipahi bhi Hindu the. Usi tarah Rajput shashan me bhi Musalman sipahi hua karte the.
Baat faarsi/persian ki kare toh yeh Islam ke aane se pehle se zinda hai. Yeh Parsio'n/Zoroastrians ki zabaan hua karti thi.
Urdu ki grammar aur syntax pura Indian hai jo jaise Javed sahb ne kaha wahi ek zabaan ko banata hai. Haan, vocabulary bohot mixed hai jisme faarsi ka ek bohot ahem kirdar hai. Lekin sanskrit words bhi bohot hain jaise hath aur chand aur thode Arbi lafz hain.
Ab yeh Grammer aur syntax kiya hai
Urdu is the father of hindi.
Ja oye kam kr
Lol
Kabhi koi zabaan ya bhasha kisi se oonchi ya neechi nahi hoti. Har zabaan ka barabar se ehtraam karna chahiye kyunki har zabaan apne sath hazaro saalo ki tehzeeb ki nishani hai.
jaakr kud jao building se😂😂😂😂 Sanskrit urdu se pehele aaya tha so uske hisaab se hindi urdu se pehele aaya
Sanskrit is the grand father of urdu
Right javed sahab
Urdu is very beautiful language ❤️
اردو آسان بھی ہے
Lafz "Hind" bhi farsi hai. Farsi holnay walay hee asal main Hindi bolte hain urdu ko bhi. Q keh wo samajte hain ye Hind ki zuban hai to Hindi kehlayega. Asal naam Hindustani hai jahan se Urdu/Hindi niklain hain.
Urdu is not language its just another dialect of Hindi
@Aqal Mand only Muslims say that I challenge you to show me atleast one paper or book which was written in urdu before 19th century. In reality Urdu was just another dialect of Hindi which was written in Khadiboli oldest Hindi scripture (Old Devanagari) is from 1st century CE
@@H4XOR23 Urdu is 13th century language. It is not dialect of Hindi. It is dialect of Hindustani. Urdu is not dependent on Hindi.
@Gym Lover 2.0 Old Hindi was the earliest stage in 7th century of the Delhi dialect (Khariboli) of the Hindustani language, and so the ancestor of Modern Hindi . It developed from Shauraseni Prakrit and was spoken by the peoples of the Hindi Belt, especially around Delhi, in roughly the 13th-15th centuries. It is attested in only a handful of works of literature, including some works by the poet privithi Raj raso, verses by the poet-saint Namdev, and some verses by the Sufi saint Baba Farid in the Adi Granth. The works of Kabir also may be included, as they use a Khariboli-like dialect. Old Hindi was originally written in Devanagari
When Mughals came to India and loanwords from Persian being added to Old Hindi's Prakritic base, the language evolved into Hindustani, which further developed into the present day modern languages of Hindi and Urdu.
So there is no history of Urdu as a language of Indian history before 1730.
It is only Hindvi, Hindi, Hindustani, apbramsh bhasha.
So there is 75% words in Urdu is from prakrit Hindi and Sanskrit
And only 25% loan words from Arabic Farsi and turkish
So we can say that Muslim speaks Hindi with more Arabic and Persian word and written in nastqlic script and called Urdu
So Hindi is real and Urdu is duplicate 😂
@Gym Lover 2.0 The famous work "Prithviraj Raso" was written by Chand Bardai, in hindi. In 1191 An epic poem, it demonstrates the life and contributions of the 12th century king, Prithviraj Chauhan.
hindi is 50 percent sansakirit and 50 oercent urdu words sara din urdu bolte ho ho or kehte ho k hindi bol raha hon sara din jo bolo rat ko ja jr counting kro k is mai urdu words kitne hain
"ٹ" بھی ہے "ت" بھی کے اور "ط" بھی ہے ۔
Old Hindi was the earliest stage in 7th century of the Delhi dialect (Khariboli) of the Hindustani language, and so the ancestor of Modern Hindi . It developed from Shauraseni Prakrit and was spoken by the peoples of the Hindi Belt, especially around Delhi, in roughly the 13th-15th centuries. It is attested in only a handful of works of literature, including some works by the poet privithi Raj raso, verses by the poet-saint Namdev, and some verses by the Sufi saint Baba Farid in the Adi Granth. The works of Kabir also may be included, as they use a Khariboli-like dialect. Old Hindi was originally written in Devanagari
When Mughals came to India and loanwords from Persian being added to Old Hindi's Prakritic base, the language evolved into Hindustani, which further developed into the present day modern languages of Hindi and Urdu.
So there is no history of Urdu as a language of Indian history before 1730.
It is only Hindvi, Hindi, Hindustani, apbramsh bhasha.
So there is 75% words in Urdu is from prakrit Hindi and Sanskrit
And only 25% loan words from Arabic Farsi and turkish
So we can say that Muslim speaks Hindi with more Arabic and Persian word and written in nastqlic script and called Urdu
So Hindi is real and Urdu is duplicate 😂
Interesting fact is that so called Original language is not acceptable that much in relation with Urdu language.... Lol
Another retard bhakt spewing illiterate venom
@@jannatkichidyaeven urdu isn't much acceptable same as hindi. As akthar sahab said as long as we(indian and pakistani) understand we consider it as hindi(indian) or urdu(pakistani) , when we don't understand it we say it might be urdu(indian) or hindi(pakistani)
And here hindustani(hindi+urdu) language comes. 😂
1. Arabic
2. Urdu
Dono best hai dusri language ke mukable mai .
urdu is great hindi good but urdu literacy language
IS KE forefather muslim they Yeh muslman se Kafir ho gaya Badnaseeb Insan hai yeh.... Allah hamaray iman ki hifazat kare Ameen
urdu bhi Indian language he..
Altaf Hussain urdu is Indian muslim language
Sure it is but its made by mughal so we muslims have more right on then u
@Jayant Ranapisay they came from Afghanistan they were turk mongols but from Afghanistan
And i am a pathan from Afghanistan now a proud pakistani thats what makes us related and biggest thing they were muslims and muslim ki ijaad muslims par muslims ka haq ziada he khas kar jab wahi muslims 500 saal ap par hukumat kar chuke ho
@Jayant Ranapisay india is a hindu country thats another debate they never wanted to convert them other wise if arab countries and iran could be converted it wasn't a big deal for india half of it was already muslim even if they tried 1% percent now india would have been a muslim country but i don't talk about it debate is about urdu and mughal and for ur kind of information Persian is a second language of afghanistan and half of afghanistans population even now is Persian
@Jayant Ranapisay and lol all muslims in india and pakistan panjabis sindhis rajpoots are hindu converted there any muslim who was muslim from the beginning arabs and Afghanistanis are jews converted iran had there own religion indian pakistan muslims are hindu converted so don't say they prefer dying then comverting
Javed sahab Urdu ko Urdu kahane se darte hain. Ghuma phira ke lafzon men logon ki soch ko deesha heen (clue less) kar dete hai. Hindustani kahen tow Urdu aur Hindi ka wajud kahan raha. Dukan band hone ka darr. Shayad Jeena Isee Ka Naam Hai.
Bollywood ne Sanskrit ko jahilo, pagalo murkho aur naukaro ki bhasha kyu dikhaya ????
Sanskrit bolta hi kon hay 😂😂😂
@@namaloomafraad8267 to?
sandooq and bandooq are arabic words....javed saheb claimed this words as turkish...its wrong....
yes u r more knowledgeable person than javed
@@jacksparrow9105 No Turkish got it from Arabic coz Mongols first transferred gun powder tech to Arabs but in Muslim world this word flow is extremely common.
@@UsmanSiddiq1 sandooq Arabic word hai
Boycott urduwood, fooling people saying it's Hindi but 95% Bollywood songs are in urdu. Or say it's urdu film industry, don't say it's Hindi film industry.
Hahahaha Urdu ke prati itna pyar to chale jaiye Pakistan.
Murkh ka bhi koi had hota hai..😂😂
Urdu is a pure Indian languages dude.. get some knowledge
Tu tum log urdu used maat kero bollywood woh muslim ka zuban hai samajeh mai ayah
But Urdu is an Indian language.
@@prodigiii712 bolna toh ata nhi phr bhi😂
@@saifulislam4221
You don't use our grammar pattern in your Urdu language
The 75% of Urdu word is that Sanskrit and prakrit and Hindi
And only 25% of Urdu word is Arabic Persian and turkish
Aaj bhi pakistan jin ki zaban urdu he in ko hindustani kaha jata he
Hindustani means land of Hindus
And urdu is not the language of hindus. Urdu is a language of the Sub-continent (baraysageer-برصغیر).
Hindi represent hinduz
&
Urdu represent Muslims
That's it.
no language represent religion..it represent region..
no any muslim in bangladesh speak urdu..they speak bangla
May be you should read write & speak ARABIC not Urdu.
Quran = Arabic
Vedas, Upanishads etc. = Sanskrit
Bible = Hebrew
Then why Malayali Muslims (who're good in numbers) speak Malayalam and hardly any Urdu. Why Bengali Muslims went against Urdu to create Bangladesh? Why so many Pashtuns speak in such an accented Urdu which it never intended to be? Tell you what, I'm a Hindu and my grandparents used to speak and write Urdu proudly. Ever heard of Munshi Premchand? He's considered as the father of Urdu Afsanas. If you study Urdu at a higher level then you might get to know that. Zabano'n ka mazhab nahi hota, kal kahoge palak Musalman aur tamatar Hindu.
I am a hindu.But i have great admiration for Urdu poetry.Religion has nothing to do with language.Hindi doesn't represent all Hindus.Bengali Hindus speaks Bengali like tamilian speaks Tamil.that's it
Urdufication is dangerous. Still. Praising. Mughals.
Don’t ever this guy a visa to come to Pakistan.
اردو کے بولنے والے دنیا کی ہر زبان بآسانی بول سکتے ہیں بغیر لکنت کے ۔ مثال کے طور پر "ٹ" بھی ہے "ڈ" بھی ہے اور "د" بھی ہے اردو میں ۔
sindhi nahi bol sakty 😂😂😂
acha to janab frog mendaq, tree darkht or zaban ko zara sindhi me bol kr dikhao 😂😂😂😂
@T A Hindi
جی نہیں میرے بھائی ۔ ہندی بولنے والے "ذرا"لفظ کو "جَرا" بولتے ہیں
Ji nhi my brother.
Hindi bolnay walay "Zara"ko "Jara" boltay hain "Zeera" Hindi bolnay may "Jeera" hojata hay...
@T A Hindi
Jo zeera ko jeera bolay
Aur zra ko jra bolay
Aisa shakhs dunya ki hr zaban nhi bol sakta hay
Laykin jiski seedhi Urdu zaban hay wo dunya ki hr zaban bol skta hay
Mayra khayal hay shayad mayri baat ka mtlb ab apko samajh may ajaigay shayad 🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔
No
Hindustani bhasa me Sanskrit ko gusana hi hindi hai,
Not mhatma Gandhi Lun Abu alkalam requested k Urdu hindi ka naam chnge kro Hindustani rakho
Hindustani meri ghar ki bhasha hai.
Urdu is hindustani language yahan ki hi bhasha hai yahi Paida huaa hai Urdu ..India mein..
Zuban ka qdardan,Adub k pujare
hindi zabaan ka talaffuz bekaar hai .
or tumari mentality bhi..
Sacch ma that's why I hate because it show some sort of rudenesss.we r much okk with our beloved urdu
shehroz haider बिना हिन्दी उर्दू भी बेकार है दोनों मिलाकर ही बोली जाए तो अच्छी लगती है ।
meri jaan hindi se urdo nikli hai
Talaffuz kya hota hai be?
Urdu is derived from arabic Turkish n farsi.hindi is derived from Sanskrit. All Bollywood n its songs r urdu..hindi is dead in pustak only.
Fuddu hai kya... All Bollywood songs are mixture of Hindi Urdu punjabi
Urdu is an Indian languagebut Islamist didn't want to make it Indian language so they adopted perso-arabic script so that it will appear foreign language and nobody in India could study it.Thus to create a fraud narrative that Urdu is muslim language.Govt should make devnagri as script of urdu
What about south Indian language script?
Haha Urdu in devanagari script😂
Urdu is always written with persian .
It's a foreign language for you not us .
@@DrStrange234 yes like for Bangladeshi too it's a foreign language
Glad u got pakistan
Perso Arabic script was adopted way before the rise of Islamism. Urdu poems were written in 12th century with Perso Arabic script.
Logically incorrect
Elaborate?
Gurmukhi aur shahmukhi ma likhi jati ha aray buday
I strongly oppose it. Its a urdu language that used in Bollywood not hindi.hindi is dirty language.when v call from our mobile it says in actual hindi.jis vekti ko aap call kar rahe ho wo apke call ka uttar nahi deraha hai.kuch samay baad punaha prayatn karein.yak sounds do dirty.
@@laquica3255 acha u need to accept the fact first
Why do you think its dirty? How can a language be dirty or something? Its just language 😂
Tu 5yo hai na?
I can see just the hate towards the nation you creepy follower of pedophile nobi muhummaddddddd 🍑🥕🌶️🥒🤺🤣🤣🤣💯
@@wahegurumeharkari2944
Sach sun kar teri phatt gayee.
U r the follower of balatkari dharam.apne mandiro mei bachiyon ka balatkar karte hain.
Niyog pratha shuddi karan pratha jaanle apne dharam ko thuke ga bhi nahi tu.
If u r fine with inclusion of Persian, Arabic and Turkish words then what is your problem with today's inclusion of English words ? Don't be hypocrite, Mr. Akhtar. India is a multilingual nation and no single language can complete its linguistic identity.
He never said he had a problem with that. Do you have a shortage of IQ?