@@AJITHTHOMAS-xp6cm are u human or rahul gandhi 🤣🐫🏃♀️ mad..in hyderabad old city, karnataka, keralac10% areas shows Discrimination. 👏 In kerala some areas sharia law going indirectly..pak, Palestine flags, seperate muslim league plays
@@readingbook2797 Concerns of RSS on population imbalance are genuine, According to Pew Research Centre 'India will have the largest Muslim population of the world in 2050'. Those literates in comments section calling on population control bill, should know the ground reality of fertility rate of Indias different communities, Hindus which constitutes 78% of the population of India have the TFR. of 1.9 which is below the replacement level of 2.1, so the Hindu population is already in decline, meanwhile the TFR. of Muslims is around 2.5, which means almost half of the Muslim families still having more than 2 children. Hope this data will give some reality check to our secular citizens of India. I know these facts are hard to digest for my secular friends but our beautiful diverse country will be the largest Muslim country in 2050.
Population control is a disastrous policy. Just read the case study on China. NO govt in the world will ever do that. This is a very shallow argument Population control . We already have 2 child policy. If u see educated middle class and up many with single child. For family with parent married after 2000s. So education and taking people from poor to middle class status is solution
@@111_N0_0ne Focus on the POPULATION in some North Indian states, be it muslim or Hindus. Taking the aggregate of all the Hindus in India paints a skewed picture as it gets compensated from the southern states. Just break it state by state. Everybody knows the growth rate in Bihar, UP and some states.
It's high time this country starts rewarding people and regions that are contributing to the nation - states with good population control, gdp, high literacy, tax-payers etc. and reduce the mollycoddling of delinquent people and regions who are only a sink for funds.
@@nv9991 Congress is not in power. There slogan was in the three state elections which got hammered. We should actually reward the states that controller population.
@nv9991 “Then what happens [...] uski utni hissedari"...” ================== The Congress Party has realised that it was unwise of it to have thought along such lines as an all-encompassing policy. UNLIKE a certain so-called 56-inch chester who refuses to be modest, the Congress has rectified its stance.
Delimitation cannot be stopped . Solution is to break northern states into smaller states so no one state has undue influence. Also Rajya Sabha’s power can be increased to have an ability to block laws which seem favouring a particular state.
The increase or decrese of MPs should be based on the performance of the states in controling the population. The more increase in population means reduction in the number of MPs
By that logic... 1) Are you suggesting, More Muslim growth, less Muslim MPS and MLAs? 2) What happens to the congress slogan of "Jiski jitni Abadi, uski utni hissedari"...
Because of the mistake someone has done on family planning they get got financial backing and now they get get more seats in parliament. Wow we are encouraging other states to increase the population. Is this good for india.
Bihar k nepal se lage 2 Jile pehla kishsngsnj Jaha muslim 65-70% ho gye h uske baad poorniya Jaha muslim 45-50% ho gye h ye bhaut dheere dheere Ek Ek karke bharat k jilo ki demography badal rahe h
@@Vhshjvbjbcch3457 kishanganj bihar Literacy rate 74% Total population around 1.5 lac people Isme 55% Hindu hai ya 40 - 45% Muslim hai isme galat kya hai
Bihar k Hindu sbse south jaate hain job k liye, since Bihar mei hain nahi utni and waha jaake settle hojaate hain, but Muslims Eventhough garibi mei reh lete hain but gav 6od k nahi jaate hain.
Abe sale aur bhi bahut sare district nepal se lagte hai up aur bihar main Jahan majority hindu hai ,kiyon hug raha hai comment section main, total 14 district up Bihar nepal border share karte hai Jahan par hindu 90% population main hai ,
@@ayushtripathi2433 Galat yeh hai dost ki jaise hi inki population 15% se jyada hoti hai yeh log dusri community to tang karne lagte hai or atank machate hai, jaise ki unhe unke festival nhi manane dena or forcefully convert karna, doosri community ki females ko harrass karna is quite common for these people. Muslim jate hai atank machate hai.
Bihar and Bengal are not controlling the population, how can they get more seats. The South has controlled the population hence deserves credit and more seats. The problem is South Parties are against uncontrolled population growth, but pappu says "Jitni Aabadi Utna Hak"😂
@@ferozsultan2804 The data you drawn is of National Family Health Survey 4 which was done in 2015. The latest is NFHS 5, that happened in 2019-20. My data is from this one.
Delimitation would be disastrous for the country. Political establishment is already one of the biggest employers in the North. Almost every other person is a politician or linked to politics in some way. It is through political influence that most people here grab land, leak papers, grab government projects, and get jobs. North should be treated like a basket case that it really is. It can be just about managed but not improved. And if you leave Northern states to their own devices, they will fall apart like Pakistan. I hope delimitation is further postponed for the greater good.
So many flaws in this logic: 1. The very basis of democracy is equal representation, which like it or not, depends on people/ population, however it is. Shameful to see a colonial/ white saviour-like ideology of 'if left alone, will fall apart'. This very ideology Britain and Europe used as justification to rule India and other African countries, that the local people can't rule over themselves properly. Did Independence turn out to be disastrous according to you as the Goras predicted like you now? Please come out of this mentality 🙏 2. North India's dire condition is not just because of corruption. Southern states have been flourishing on its resources, discriminately because of freight equalization policy. Technically, if they were left so, Southern states owe a big chunk of money to the North🙄. Further back in history, North was always the shield for the south from the ruthless invasions and plunders, which led to flourishing culture, education in the South that we are so proud of, also a major contributor to the Independence movement. So, don't you dare look down on your own countrymen and even think of denying them their constitutional rights! Just like RSS has no right to rally to deny the Muslim population the same even if they are the poorest, uneducated or vulnerable to terrorism. Same for The Tribal population.
People forget these days that there's also left extremism. And the left extremist ideology has been taken over by the kandgress, because it is left with nothing else. So this also needs to be said.
@@imaXenoXbecause the opposition Atleast became a bit powerful, to Atleast raise their voice, against hate. Inspite being ridiculed by the media, they are still sitting on the lap of the govt.
Unpopular view: Like it or not, the ideology of not wanting delimitation of both groups is the same - looking down on the public and trying to deny them their constitutional right of representation (Southern states denying the Northern states thinking they are inferior, RSS denying the muslims thinking they are dangerous; SAME MENTALITY). Are we really discussing this in the era of partcipative democracy? Who is anyone to think of denying others their representation, guaranteed by the constitution? Who is anyone to judge of consequences beforehand of giving people their basic rights? Agreed there'll be problems and they have to be identified and tackled constitutionally and rationally, NOT BY DISCRIMINATION. The history of Bharat is very long and golden, let not your ignorance sow seeds of division and hate.
Economic performance should also considered in delimitation to balance the problems Many region demand seprate statehood There should be restrictions on revenue expenditure if state is not capable of paying by itself
What is the Point if we cannot even NAME the obvious. Sad. Only words. Obvious words. To know, IS to not help care... Words of Shashank.... Respect? Does a biased Speaker in parliament Deserve respect? Does an unruly Parliamentarian Deserve respect ? Does a Divisive Stupid prime minister Deserve respect? Does a foolish Low intelligent opposition Deserve respect ? Does an immoral Unethical doctor Deserve respect ? Does an abusive Irresponsible father Deserve respect ? Does an ill prepared Uncaring teacher Deserve respect ? Does a corrupt Valueless IAS officer Deserve respect ? Should we respect The person or position? High time we Get this right If our society Needs to Improve ... Good Night. Shashank
Every human, including RSS BJP members are unique individually not confined to this world alone. Because everybody is responsible individually beyond, even after the earth, cannot escape, to be very very careful about his or her responsibility.
This is a " Utopian" philosophy. Ground reality is entirely different. It's a race for survival of the fittest. Mahatma Gandhi's philosophy is ideal but not practical unless ethical values are drilled into our education system. Where there is hate and discrimination there cannot be development and growth in the economy as potential investors shy away from investing money where there is no peaceful environment for businesses to grow and develop and eventually the economy and the country suffers...
For Population control make it a policy that no subsidy, no direct benefit, no scholarship, no subsidised ration, no free govt. Hospital facility, no reservations, no loans, no voting rights etc be given to those having more than two children 😮
Why am from south delimitation will happen anyways that's a constitutional thing.. northies and muslis didn't stop making babies and now every one's calls it a demographic dividend. While most of those highly educated contributing individuls per ratio of population is from.south.
And until they do delimitation, women's reservation bill isn't going to be in effect. And if they do, well, Prajwal Ravanna's party wins. It's a lose-lose for women's rights.
The nation, which was partitioned along religious lines, certainly has to worry about the growth of the community that asked for a separate nation because of their religious ideology. The Muslim population share in India turned half from 18% to 9% after the partition in 1947, but today, just after 75 years, they are back to their pre-partition proportion which is around 17%(thanks to their exceptionally high reproduction rate). At the same time, in Bangladesh, the Hindu population has dwindled from 24% share in 1971 to 7% today. The question is, if the same pattern is followed by the "religion of peace" again and again all around the world, are Indians bracing for another partition?
@@philemontr1437 Have you heard of operation searchlight in east Pakistan, now Bangladesh? Almost 3 million Hindus were killed because of their faith, Islamic states have poor track record in safeguarding their minorities, of course because of their mostly peaceful religion.
Yhi baat to bharat k lalchi Hindu or jaat mein bate hindu nhi smjh rahe hain wo Pagal ho chuke h lalach mein unko dikh nhi tha ye log aaj ki date m bhi 8-10 bacche paida karke bharat ki demography change kar rahe h
@@philemontr1437Who the f was responsible for migration then? Matlab thuk kar chaatoge he. Yahi to reason hai jo ye haal hai aaj tumhara. Sense gayab ho jaata hai. You normalise certain things without even realising. Wo migration hona he nahi chahiye tha, jo bhi hua tha, either 47 or at around 70s. Who created Muslim League? Who started 4 wars against India? The same people who believed in the idea of Muslim league. And if I take off another peel, then you will get hurt but the aasmaani book has told them to do so. So what else to say? Now I don't want to paint every Muslim as extremist, but Islam is. And those who say no, are living in denial.
I dont know why who decide fate of indian polity is it rss hq😂...then welcome to socalled democracy...when migrant in uk become pm ..but here muslim born citizen not have same opportunity its look like a sin 😂.
@@itsallaboutmindset8278 bahut sare h Koi bhi log jo international news dekhte h wo jante Hai Europe m kya ho raha h kaise Ek majhab ki vjh se France ki history m pehli bar gath bandhan sarkar bnegi kaise waha philistine ke flag lekar Log roads par khade rahe kaise naav mein bhar bhar k illegal ghuspaitiye waha Roz ghusne ki kosis karte h is social media ke jamane mein kisi se kuch chipa nhi h kaise Europe m Ek majhab ki population badhi h or Usi hisab se waha crime rate or dange badhe h
Delimitation at the disadvantage of south India 🇮🇳 will very much mean the death of India..because we have been thaught by every political party here that we are discriminated by the Hindi region and this perceived slavering of our people are always there just below the surface ..you take away our representation and Tax revenue the perception will become real and will boil over..and I want India as one country but mind you any attempt to subjugate and marginalise by reducing representation is something you nationalists guys don’t want to touch..
@@samuelvijayakumar1871or devolve all powers to the state..the central government can make recommendations and only army and currency and free movement be the commonality, like a sort of European Union..each state be a country and India a sort of super governing body
@@jithinpoliyedathmohanan7237 States were not formed by any agreement. States were created for administrative efficiency. They can not claim treatment like EU. If it happens then they will have to live under military rule.
Koi ye bhi btao border se Lge states Bihar UK Bengal Assam yha achanak se muslim population badhi h jiski vajah se waha k Kai jilo ki demography change ho gai h waha Hindu alapsankhyak OR muslim bahusankyak Ho gye h ye news bhi wo bataya karo aaj jo hindu aapas m SC St obc uppar cast banke lad rahe h baad mein smjh aaega Inko Kashmir se Koi sabak nhi seekha Hai logo ne
Sabse pehle to brahmano ko pandit banne se rokna padega,samaj main jab equality nahi hogi to kiya faida,St, SC, OBC ke liye jayada se jayada reservation milna chahiye
Concerns of RSS on population imbalance are genuine, According to Pew Research Centre 'India will have the largest Muslim population of the world in 2050'. Those literates in comments section calling on population control bill, should know the ground reality of fertility rate of Indias different communities, Hindus which constitutes 78% of the population of India have the TFR. of 1.9 which is below the replacement level of 2.1, so the Hindu population is already in decline, meanwhile the TFR. of Muslims is around 2.5, which means almost half of the Muslim families still having more than 2 children. Hope this data will give some reality check to our secular citizens of India. I know these facts are hard to digest for my secular friends but our beautiful diverse country will be the largest Muslim country in 2050.
So what is the issue if India has the largest Muslim population? Hindus will still be majority if that is your concern. Secondly, no community should reach below replacement rate, it's not good in long term. Instead of hating on Muslims, maybe you should raise awareness among your own community as to why this is happening.
@@sherlockholmes882 You must be a Muslim to sound this illogical, right? Everyone knows India has a higher population than normal, and everyone raises demand for population control bill, but the moment they learn its Muslims who are having irresponsible reproduction, they suddenly jump to defend such acts like you are doing right now. I know my friend, for you the Muslim community are the epitome of human civilization, their patriarchal ways to suppress women are a role model, perhaps India should consider declaring India as Shariya state for it to become a free and first world country, right?
thats because muslims of india are super poor and mostly of dalit background. if you compare the fertility rate of hindu dslits/SC/ST with muslims, its almost the same
@@sherlockholmes882 lol, tell me you are Muslim without telling me, justification for irresponsible reproduction in a country already suffering from over population in todays age is appalling and beyond stupidity...🥱
@@sherlockholmes882 i see, justification for irresponsible reproduction? Everyone was asking for a population control bill because of overpopulation till now but suddenly its all good? Hhh?
Value of muslim vote should decrease if bjp is in its senses cz muslims are doom for bjp n nda also…delimitation should be like that muslims populated area should be given lesser seats otherwise there is proper planned strategy of demographic takeover of Hindu dominated india as islamic nation
Congress slogan ---> Jiski jitni Abadi, uski utni hissedari ----> MP/MLA Hissedari as per population --> More population. More hissedari. RSS is opposting congress's demand for more MP/MLA seats in north.
Divide Uttarpradesh state into two states.We should send CM Yogi Adityanath, CM Nitish Kumar, CM of Madhya Pradesh,CM Mamata Banerjee, CM of Rajasthan,CM of Orissa to foreign countries to attract investment, develop infrastructure, industrial development, generate employment opportunity to their people ,and revenue to their respective states. They should not be dependent on other developed states revenue to be shared by the Central Government.
The Organiser could focus on educating the Hindi heartland for ensuring better quality of life. It is Education that has transformed the South and NW. Educated Muslim families have fewer children. In the next millenia too the Muslim population will only record proportional increase.. The ORGANISER should stop creating Muslim phobia.
@@nv9991 Since you seem to doubt everyone and everything, I suggest that you go and have it verified personally. I am from Kerala and I know how things were decades ago and how things are today. Even if the number of children have come down from 6 - 8, to 3 - 4, it is a great change. Nothing changes overnight. Petro-dollar is what keeps Indian economy vibrant. Please Remove coloured glasses for better vision.
Even the muslim population is less than 25 percent we have been witnessing all kinds of ant india slogan imagine what will happen when they become 30 percent recently in wb a muslim leader openly claimed this is islamic country
Forget about Religion, RSS etc for a minute, India is the largest populated country on earth. Better control the population across the board now. The resources (infrastructure, land, food, water etc) are limited so the real issue is controlling the population across the country. China had one child policy and finally able to control their population. We need to learn good from others. Have a policy and increase the literacy, automatically in 20-30 years the result will be seen.
They won't do that instead they will play religious politics to win elections. Bring development instead of hatred & dividing the society. They only rake up sensitive issues to keep the minds of people distracted from core issues like corruption, unemployment, women safety, health, infrastructure & so on.
Do you know the fertility rate of the 78% of the Indias Hindu population? It is 1.9 which is below the replacement rate of 2.1, and the population of majority is in decline, while the TFR. of the Muslim population is 2.5 which means almost half of the Muslim families are having more than 2 children and that is above the replacement level rate of 2.1, so its a clear fact that the second large majority community is reproducing higher than level which can be considered normal.
@@111_N0_0ne The population control policy should apply to all Indians without exceptions. Adding any dimension like religion, caste etc. simply changes/diverts the focus.
@@adsdynamic9219 You are sounding illogical here, you want this country to control its population, but without addressing the community which is producing irresponsibly.
north india will not tolerate any kind of injustice. 1 person, 1 vote, and constituencies as per population density. Period!! for those saying delimitation, remember India or bharat or aryavrate means north india in real, not dravid region. This is the land of Lord Ram, Lord Krishna, Lord Shiva, Budhha, Mahavir, sikh gurus and most of freedom fighters. this is the land of brave warrior, generals, soldiers and rulers who saved not just the north but the south as well. All the great leaders of Nidia were from north india. even south india is protected by north indian Bravehearts and run by north indian IPS/IAS bureaucrats.
Hindu majority good for india bcz hindu neighbour are intelligent eduated thats why village muslim are rich they have land they govt job bcz kehte jaisa sanghat hota hai waisa insan me badlao bhi aata hai
I am living in banglore i am watching those area no where muslim majority area no where hindu majority totally mixup area hindu neigbour have muslim muslim neighbour & also christian
I think we can do delimitation without reducing seats in South. More seats in North is important for better governance. Problem with large seats is that too much diversity in each seat leads to votebank politics, and governance issues take a back seat. For eg: if there are 3 castes in a seat, then majority caste always wins. So, splitting will give voice to all castes.
If the caste representaion alone is the only formula for developing so-called backward castes then how the hell caste politics based states are also still the most backward?
You are the instrument of rss generated propaganda. You talk about representation, what is the Muslim percentage of representation in Parliament, job and government sector?you creating fear among hindu community
Kishanganj is the best example of Ganga jamuni tahzeeb where the majority is Muslim but till now there has not been any violence in the name of religion 😊
@@Zaiyannn69 are u human or rahul gandhi🐫🤣lier king 2 Temple burn,Palestine flags..it's social media Era fake 1950,s congres falthu tricks nahi chaltha
@@Zaiyannn69 @Zaiyannn69 wow so lucky place in world ur area..🌎 Nehru,rajiv gandhi forgot ur area👏..otherwise like kashmir, manipur kept seperate rules.....enjoy ..pls away from gandhi family 🤝unity india
I am against farther increase of parliament seat until we achieve higher income status. It will rewards poor performing state and discourage state which are working well in woman education and population reduction. It will also significantly alter power dynamic of the union and ultimately may endanger the union.
I dont know why who decide fate of indian polity is it rss hq😂...then welcome to socalled democracy...when migrant in uk become pm ..but here muslim born citizen not have same opportunity its look like a sin 😂.
Can you blame anyone? Muslims even in UK France are doing stupid things like demanding Sharia Law. Is this fair? If anyone is smart they will become Atheist or Hindu instead of following pedo Muhammad.
Everyone has the right to share opinions. Have you heard of this democratic concept? Muslims got two full exclusive nations. Muslims played double game with Hindus.
One thing is quite clear
The South will not allow any discrimination
Delimitation or otherwise
You need to learn to write.
Abrahamics can stay away in these things
@@adithyaadi1363 why so. What does the constitution say
@@AJITHTHOMAS-xp6cm are u human or rahul gandhi 🤣🐫🏃♀️ mad..in hyderabad old city, karnataka, keralac10% areas shows Discrimination. 👏
In kerala some areas sharia law going indirectly..pak, Palestine flags, seperate muslim league plays
These guys are just like the North Indian
Unpad log
Talking nonsense
But act big
I felt basing on the population there should be population control especially in bihar and u.p
@@readingbook2797 Concerns of RSS on population imbalance are genuine,
According to Pew Research Centre 'India will have the largest Muslim population of the world in 2050'. Those literates in comments section calling on population control bill, should know the ground reality of fertility rate of Indias different communities, Hindus which constitutes 78% of the population of India have the TFR. of 1.9 which is below the replacement level of 2.1, so the Hindu population is already in decline, meanwhile the TFR. of Muslims is around 2.5, which means almost half of the Muslim families still having more than 2 children. Hope this data will give some reality check to our secular citizens of India. I know these facts are hard to digest for my secular friends but our beautiful diverse country will be the largest Muslim country in 2050.
@@111_N0_0ne Muslims still will be in minority in 2050
How it will be the largest muslim country?
Population control is a disastrous policy. Just read the case study on China. NO govt in the world will ever do that. This is a very shallow argument Population control . We already have 2 child policy. If u see educated middle class and up many with single child. For family with parent married after 2000s.
So education and taking people from poor to middle class status is solution
@@111_N0_0ne Focus on the POPULATION in some North Indian states, be it muslim or Hindus. Taking the aggregate of all the Hindus in India paints a skewed picture as it gets compensated from the southern states.
Just break it state by state. Everybody knows the growth rate in Bihar, UP and some states.
It's high time this country starts rewarding people and regions that are contributing to the nation - states with good population control, gdp, high literacy, tax-payers etc. and reduce the mollycoddling of delinquent people and regions who are only a sink for funds.
World does not revolve around you.
No delimitation please. States that have over-procreation should not be rewarded
I am against delimitation.
Then what happens to the congress slogan of "Jiski jitni Abadi, uski utni hissedari"...
@@nv9991 Congress is not in power. There slogan was in the three state elections which got hammered. We should actually reward the states that controller population.
@nv9991
“Then what happens [...] uski utni hissedari"...”
==================
The Congress Party has realised that it was unwise of it to have thought along such lines as an all-encompassing policy.
UNLIKE a certain so-called 56-inch chester who refuses to be modest, the Congress has rectified its stance.
Jitna abadi Utna hak
Caste census has the same problem. Communities who have done population control are at a disadvntage.
@@akshatshankar1335 no community has practised population control. Even brahmin, baniya and thakur have more than 5 children.
You practice caste system but have a problem with caste census.
Delimitation cannot be stopped . Solution is to break northern states into smaller states so no one state has undue influence. Also Rajya Sabha’s power can be increased to have an ability to block laws which seem favouring a particular state.
This will be like not father but mother's husband
The increase or decrese of MPs should be based on the performance of the states in controling the population. The more increase in population means reduction in the number of MPs
By that logic...
1) Are you suggesting, More Muslim growth, less Muslim MPS and MLAs?
2) What happens to the congress slogan of "Jiski jitni Abadi, uski utni hissedari"...
This logic defies the very constitution that you so passionately voted for this election
This sounds good
@@nv9991 definitely less katwas 😂
Because of the mistake someone has done on family planning they get got financial backing and now they get get more seats in parliament. Wow we are encouraging other states to increase the population. Is this good for india.
The South should not lose out period
"Democracy is punishing us for doing our job well" 💀
Bihar k nepal se lage 2 Jile pehla kishsngsnj Jaha muslim 65-70% ho gye h uske baad poorniya Jaha muslim 45-50% ho gye h ye bhaut dheere dheere Ek Ek karke bharat k jilo ki demography badal rahe h
@@Vhshjvbjbcch3457 kishanganj bihar
Literacy rate 74%
Total population around 1.5 lac people
Isme 55% Hindu hai ya 40 - 45% Muslim hai isme galat kya hai
Bihar k Hindu sbse south jaate hain job k liye, since Bihar mei hain nahi utni and waha jaake settle hojaate hain, but Muslims Eventhough garibi mei reh lete hain but gav 6od k nahi jaate hain.
Abe sale aur bhi bahut sare district nepal se lagte hai up aur bihar main Jahan majority hindu hai ,kiyon hug raha hai comment section main, total 14 district up Bihar nepal border share karte hai Jahan par hindu 90% population main hai ,
@@ayushtripathi2433 it's 16 lac population in kishanganj and around 68 percent are Muslim check your facts
@@ayushtripathi2433 Galat yeh hai dost ki jaise hi inki population 15% se jyada hoti hai yeh log dusri community to tang karne lagte hai or atank machate hai, jaise ki unhe unke festival nhi manane dena or forcefully convert karna, doosri community ki females ko harrass karna is quite common for these people. Muslim jate hai atank machate hai.
Give equal no of seats in Rajya Sabha to every state of India irrespective of size and population 👍👍👍👍🇮🇳🇮🇳
@@vednandyal and after how many steps will people be asking for equal number of seats for every community and individual.........
Those SOBs and Boise dks will dive up into 50 states. Bihar into 100 states
@@devsan1636 we can pass a bill to freeze the no of states. After giving statehood to J&K and ladakh amend article 3
Correct.
@@devsan1636 than current "Bridge Falling into river" System of governance there.
Thanks for the indepth analysis, it's full of political wisdom.
Jai South India !
Indeed!
Some weightage to states' GDP share in the total national GDP should also be given to reach at agreeable delimitaitonto all the states and regions.
That will be never agreed to. Politicians will have a good time while citizens will suffer.
Bihar and Bengal are not controlling the population, how can they get more seats. The South has controlled the population hence deserves credit and more seats. The problem is South Parties are against uncontrolled population growth, but pappu says "Jitni Aabadi Utna Hak"😂
@@sunilpatel3728
Bihar TFR 3.6
UP TFR 3.4.
Bengal TFR 1.4
Don't spread misinformation about Bengal.
@ferozsultan2804 Wrong....
You right on Bengal
But Bihar, it is 3
And UP its close to 2.1
@@shreyansh1364 Its not my own data,this is the data which is available on Google.
@@ferozsultan2804 The data you drawn is of National Family Health Survey 4 which was done in 2015. The latest is NFHS 5, that happened in 2019-20. My data is from this one.
@@ferozsultan2804 And you are even wrong for WB it is at 1.56 acc to NFHS 5.
While NFHS 6 is currently underway.
Tell these guys that there are other states in south India and that’s a true representation
Good journalism
👌👌👌
Informative.... thanks
Delimitation would be disastrous for the country. Political establishment is already one of the biggest employers in the North. Almost every other person is a politician or linked to politics in some way. It is through political influence that most people here grab land, leak papers, grab government projects, and get jobs. North should be treated like a basket case that it really is. It can be just about managed but not improved. And if you leave Northern states to their own devices, they will fall apart like Pakistan. I hope delimitation is further postponed for the greater good.
So many flaws in this logic:
1. The very basis of democracy is equal representation, which like it or not, depends on people/ population, however it is. Shameful to see a colonial/ white saviour-like ideology of 'if left alone, will fall apart'. This very ideology Britain and Europe used as justification to rule India and other African countries, that the local people can't rule over themselves properly. Did Independence turn out to be disastrous according to you as the Goras predicted like you now? Please come out of this mentality 🙏
2. North India's dire condition is not just because of corruption. Southern states have been flourishing on its resources, discriminately because of freight equalization policy. Technically, if they were left so, Southern states owe a big chunk of money to the North🙄. Further back in history, North was always the shield for the south from the ruthless invasions and plunders, which led to flourishing culture, education in the South that we are so proud of, also a major contributor to the Independence movement. So, don't you dare look down on your own countrymen and even think of denying them their constitutional rights!
Just like RSS has no right to rally to deny the Muslim population the same even if they are the poorest, uneducated or vulnerable to terrorism. Same for The Tribal population.
Well explained
Save Democracy and the Constitution!
Save India from EXTREMISM, HATE, FEAR, AND VIOLENCE!
Jai Samvidhan!🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
Save what ? Why were you guys celebrating for on 4th June then ?😂
People forget these days that there's also left extremism. And the left extremist ideology has been taken over by the kandgress, because it is left with nothing else. So this also needs to be said.
@@imaXenoXbecause the opposition Atleast became a bit powerful, to Atleast raise their voice, against hate. Inspite being ridiculed by the media, they are still sitting on the lap of the govt.
@@himanisuri5484 People who spread hatred among castes wanna raise vioce aginst Hate Irony 🤡
As if one side is solely guilty of extremism and violence. Kashmiri militants, Khalistanis come to mind and they are anti BJP.
Indian express has a standard and the interviewer doesn't meets the standard.
9:36 the man still doesn't answer to the specific question asked.
Unpopular view: Like it or not, the ideology of not wanting delimitation of both groups is the same - looking down on the public and trying to deny them their constitutional right of representation (Southern states denying the Northern states thinking they are inferior, RSS denying the muslims thinking they are dangerous; SAME MENTALITY).
Are we really discussing this in the era of partcipative democracy? Who is anyone to think of denying others their representation, guaranteed by the constitution? Who is anyone to judge of consequences beforehand of giving people their basic rights?
Agreed there'll be problems and they have to be identified and tackled constitutionally and rationally, NOT BY DISCRIMINATION. The history of Bharat is very long and golden, let not your ignorance sow seeds of division and hate.
Economic performance should also considered in delimitation to balance the problems
Many region demand seprate statehood
There should be restrictions on revenue expenditure if state is not capable of paying by itself
What was organizer doing for 75 years ?
What is the Point if we cannot even NAME the obvious.
Sad.
Only words. Obvious words.
To know, IS to not help care...
Words of Shashank....
Respect?
Does a biased
Speaker in parliament
Deserve respect?
Does an unruly
Parliamentarian
Deserve respect ?
Does a Divisive
Stupid prime minister
Deserve respect?
Does a foolish
Low intelligent opposition
Deserve respect ?
Does an immoral
Unethical doctor
Deserve respect ?
Does an abusive
Irresponsible father
Deserve respect ?
Does an ill prepared
Uncaring teacher
Deserve respect ?
Does a corrupt
Valueless IAS officer
Deserve respect ?
Should we respect
The person or position?
High time we
Get this right
If our society
Needs to Improve ...
Good Night.
Shashank
Waqf board, 4 wife'sno diverse ,madarsa,musoim reservation is it equal law fir Christian, hindu,muslim 😢
Label everyone and everything, but don't introspect, I like these kinds of stupid people.....
Why Ok only south and North ?
what about census
Not sure
There is simple solution divide up in 3 parts easy 3 states 3 cm 3 hc and easy management
Every human, including RSS BJP members are unique individually not confined to this world alone. Because everybody is responsible individually beyond, even after the earth, cannot escape, to be very very careful about his or her responsibility.
This is a " Utopian" philosophy. Ground reality is entirely different. It's a race for survival of the fittest. Mahatma Gandhi's philosophy is ideal but not practical unless ethical values are drilled into our education system. Where there is hate and discrimination there cannot be development and growth in the economy as potential investors shy away from investing money where there is no peaceful environment for businesses to grow and develop and eventually the economy and the country suffers...
For Population control make it a policy that no subsidy, no direct benefit, no scholarship, no subsidised ration, no free govt. Hospital facility, no reservations, no loans, no voting rights etc be given to those having more than two children 😮
Then South demands for Dravidanadu
If that happens then india will divide
Why am from south delimitation will happen anyways that's a constitutional thing.. northies and muslis didn't stop making babies and now every one's calls it a demographic dividend. While most of those highly educated contributing individuls per ratio of population is from.south.
And until they do delimitation, women's reservation bill isn't going to be in effect. And if they do, well, Prajwal Ravanna's party wins. It's a lose-lose for women's rights.
@@YTry1Reservation itself is a wrong concept. Jobs should be based on the ability of the person to do the job, not on the percentage of their gender.
Because Today India isn't developed enough @@YTry1
@@YTry1 50% reservation in the armed forces as well should be there or not?
@@YTry1where the FCk did you study
Don’t you know how reservation works
This is a very sensitive issue in the South. I hope the delimitation exercise is done in a fair manner for the sake of the country.
After delimitation BJP>>>>>> Rss
That is the fear of Rss 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣🤣 🤣🤣
The nation, which was partitioned along religious lines, certainly has to worry about the growth of the community that asked for a separate nation because of their religious ideology. The Muslim population share in India turned half from 18% to 9% after the partition in 1947, but today, just after 75 years, they are back to their pre-partition proportion which is around 17%(thanks to their exceptionally high reproduction rate). At the same time, in Bangladesh, the Hindu population has dwindled from 24% share in 1971 to 7% today. The question is, if the same pattern is followed by the "religion of peace" again and again all around the world, are Indians bracing for another partition?
The Migration of Bangladeshi hindu to northeast India is the reason for the Reduction of Hindu population in Bangladesh.
@@philemontr1437 Have you heard of operation searchlight in east Pakistan, now Bangladesh? Almost 3 million Hindus were killed because of their faith, Islamic states have poor track record in safeguarding their minorities, of course because of their mostly peaceful religion.
@@philemontr1437There is systematic uprooting of Hindus from Bangladesh thanks to Jamaat e Islami, BNP.
Yhi baat to bharat k lalchi Hindu or jaat mein bate hindu nhi smjh rahe hain wo Pagal ho chuke h lalach mein unko dikh nhi tha ye log aaj ki date m bhi 8-10 bacche paida karke bharat ki demography change kar rahe h
@@philemontr1437Who the f was responsible for migration then? Matlab thuk kar chaatoge he. Yahi to reason hai jo ye haal hai aaj tumhara. Sense gayab ho jaata hai. You normalise certain things without even realising. Wo migration hona he nahi chahiye tha, jo bhi hua tha, either 47 or at around 70s. Who created Muslim League? Who started 4 wars against India? The same people who believed in the idea of Muslim league. And if I take off another peel, then you will get hurt but the aasmaani book has told them to do so. So what else to say? Now I don't want to paint every Muslim as extremist, but Islam is. And those who say no, are living in denial.
Delimitation ka law khud congress ne banaya tha aaj Wahi congress iska virodh kar rahi h wah
Delimitation rule Ambdekar aur conregss ne banaya tha. It is in the constitution.
@@nv9991 to phir bjp agar karti h to Galat nhi hoga na
I dont know why who decide fate of indian polity is it rss hq😂...then welcome to socalled democracy...when migrant in uk become pm ..but here muslim born citizen not have same opportunity its look like a sin 😂.
You're Muslim ?
Can you tell me the source of your information? Like which TH-camrs or media channels or media people do you watch? It will be interesting to know.
Rishi sunai Koi illegal mirgrent nhi tha jaise Ek majhab k log illegally Europe mein ghus rahe h bus rahe h or bhagae bhi ja rahe h okk
@@itsallaboutmindset8278 bahut sare h Koi bhi log jo international news dekhte h wo jante Hai Europe m kya ho raha h kaise Ek majhab ki vjh se France ki history m pehli bar gath bandhan sarkar bnegi kaise waha philistine ke flag lekar Log roads par khade rahe kaise naav mein bhar bhar k illegal ghuspaitiye waha Roz ghusne ki kosis karte h is social media ke jamane mein kisi se kuch chipa nhi h kaise Europe m Ek majhab ki population badhi h or Usi hisab se waha crime rate or dange badhe h
@@Vhshjvbjbcch3457 Abay tujhse to poocha he nahi hai bhai.
Delimitation at the disadvantage of south India 🇮🇳 will very much mean the death of India..because we have been thaught by every political party here that we are discriminated by the Hindi region and this perceived slavering of our people are always there just below the surface ..you take away our representation and Tax revenue the perception will become real and will boil over..and I want India as one country but mind you any attempt to subjugate and marginalise by reducing representation is something you nationalists guys don’t want to touch..
Then break the country … South India will be a different country
@@samuelvijayakumar1871or devolve all powers to the state..the central government can make recommendations and only army and currency and free movement be the commonality, like a sort of European Union..each state be a country and India a sort of super governing body
@@jithinpoliyedathmohanan7237 We already have that. What's your point?
@@jithinpoliyedathmohanan7237 States were not formed by any agreement. States were created for administrative efficiency. They can not claim treatment like EU. If it happens then they will have to live under military rule.
Then what happens to the congress slogan of "Jiski jitni Abadi, uski utni hissedari"...
Organizer means?
Rss own news paper
@@kashtaraiya OK OK OK, mouth piece.
Koi ye bhi btao border se Lge states Bihar UK Bengal Assam yha achanak se muslim population badhi h jiski vajah se waha k Kai jilo ki demography change ho gai h waha Hindu alapsankhyak OR muslim bahusankyak Ho gye h ye news bhi wo bataya karo aaj jo hindu aapas m SC St obc uppar cast banke lad rahe h baad mein smjh aaega Inko Kashmir se Koi sabak nhi seekha Hai logo ne
Only upper caste to do discrimination against obc, SC St
Sabse pehle to brahmano ko pandit banne se rokna padega,samaj main jab equality nahi hogi to kiya faida,St, SC, OBC ke liye jayada se jayada reservation milna chahiye
Fir wahi bakwas bina dimag aur fact kuch bhi hag do
@@dheeraj6514 tum log bus SC St obc uppar cast karte raho Baki desh m jo hi rahe h usse Tumko kya tumhari nafrat to bus 15% uppar cast se hain
@@kashtaraiya fact 😆😆😆 or bakwas tumhe lagega bro, because you manuwadi people never ever accept reality.
Concerns of RSS on population imbalance are genuine,
According to Pew Research Centre 'India will have the largest Muslim population of the world in 2050'. Those literates in comments section calling on population control bill, should know the ground reality of fertility rate of Indias different communities, Hindus which constitutes 78% of the population of India have the TFR. of 1.9 which is below the replacement level of 2.1, so the Hindu population is already in decline, meanwhile the TFR. of Muslims is around 2.5, which means almost half of the Muslim families still having more than 2 children. Hope this data will give some reality check to our secular citizens of India. I know these facts are hard to digest for my secular friends but our beautiful diverse country will be the largest Muslim country in 2050.
So what is the issue if India has the largest Muslim population? Hindus will still be majority if that is your concern.
Secondly, no community should reach below replacement rate, it's not good in long term. Instead of hating on Muslims, maybe you should raise awareness among your own community as to why this is happening.
@@sherlockholmes882 You must be a Muslim to sound this illogical, right? Everyone knows India has a higher population than normal, and everyone raises demand for population control bill, but the moment they learn its Muslims who are having irresponsible reproduction, they suddenly jump to defend such acts like you are doing right now. I know my friend, for you the Muslim community are the epitome of human civilization, their patriarchal ways to suppress women are a role model, perhaps India should consider declaring India as Shariya state for it to become a free and first world country, right?
thats because muslims of india are super poor and mostly of dalit background.
if you compare the fertility rate of hindu dslits/SC/ST with muslims, its almost the same
@@sherlockholmes882 lol, tell me you are Muslim without telling me, justification for irresponsible reproduction in a country already suffering from over population in todays age is appalling and beyond stupidity...🥱
@@sherlockholmes882 i see, justification for irresponsible reproduction? Everyone was asking for a population control bill because of overpopulation till now but suddenly its all good? Hhh?
Value of muslim vote should decrease if bjp is in its senses cz muslims are doom for bjp n nda also…delimitation should be like that muslims populated area should be given lesser seats otherwise there is proper planned strategy of demographic takeover of Hindu dominated india as islamic nation
kudh ke logo pe vishwas nhi hai tereko 😂
Secularism hindus 😂
Congress slogan ---> Jiski jitni Abadi, uski utni hissedari ----> MP/MLA Hissedari as per population --> More population. More hissedari.
RSS is opposting congress's demand for more MP/MLA seats in north.
Delimitation will leave coastal non hindi speaking people to go for secession
Divide Uttarpradesh state into two states.We should send CM Yogi Adityanath, CM Nitish Kumar, CM of Madhya Pradesh,CM Mamata Banerjee, CM of Rajasthan,CM of Orissa to foreign countries to attract investment, develop infrastructure, industrial development, generate employment opportunity to their people ,and revenue to their respective states. They should not be dependent on other developed states revenue to be shared by the Central Government.
The Organiser could focus on educating the Hindi heartland for ensuring better quality of life. It is Education that has transformed the South and NW. Educated Muslim families have fewer children. In the next millenia too the Muslim population will only record proportional increase.. The ORGANISER should stop creating Muslim phobia.
100% educated & petrodollar rich Muslims in Kerla have fewer children than poor Hindus? Can you provide data supporting this?
@@nv9991 Since you seem to doubt everyone and everything, I suggest that you go and have it verified personally. I am from Kerala and I know how things were decades ago and how things are today. Even if the number of children have come down from 6 - 8, to 3 - 4, it is a great change. Nothing changes overnight. Petro-dollar is what keeps Indian economy vibrant. Please Remove coloured glasses for better vision.
UP must be further divided into 3 states for better administration
And merged to Pakistan for India’s good.
Even the muslim population is less than 25 percent we have been witnessing all kinds of ant india slogan imagine what will happen when they become 30 percent recently in wb a muslim leader openly claimed this is islamic country
India is not a hindu country also. You want a hindu country then go back to eurasia.
Forget about Religion, RSS etc for a minute, India is the largest populated country on earth. Better control the population across the board now. The resources (infrastructure, land, food, water etc) are limited so the real issue is controlling the population across the country. China had one child policy and finally able to control their population. We need to learn good from others. Have a policy and increase the literacy, automatically in 20-30 years the result will be seen.
They won't do that instead they will play religious politics to win elections.
Bring development instead of hatred & dividing the society.
They only rake up sensitive issues to keep the minds of people distracted from core issues like corruption, unemployment, women safety, health, infrastructure & so on.
Do you know the fertility rate of the 78% of the Indias Hindu population? It is 1.9 which is below the replacement rate of 2.1, and the population of majority is in decline, while the TFR. of the Muslim population is 2.5 which means almost half of the Muslim families are having more than 2 children and that is above the replacement level rate of 2.1, so its a clear fact that the second large majority community is reproducing higher than level which can be considered normal.
@@111_N0_0ne The population control policy should apply to all Indians without exceptions. Adding any dimension like religion, caste etc. simply changes/diverts the focus.
@@111_N0_0ne _ What is our problem with that, we have other better issues to focus on.
What do you want to prove with that logic ?
@@adsdynamic9219 You are sounding illogical here, you want this country to control its population, but without addressing the community which is producing irresponsibly.
north india will not tolerate any kind of injustice. 1 person, 1 vote, and constituencies as per population density. Period!!
for those saying delimitation, remember India or bharat or aryavrate means north india in real, not dravid region. This is the land of Lord Ram, Lord Krishna, Lord Shiva, Budhha, Mahavir, sikh gurus and most of freedom fighters. this is the land of brave warrior, generals, soldiers and rulers who saved not just the north but the south as well.
All the great leaders of Nidia were from north india. even south india is protected by north indian Bravehearts and run by north indian IPS/IAS bureaucrats.
Hindu majority good for india bcz hindu neighbour are intelligent eduated thats why village muslim are rich they have land they govt job bcz kehte jaisa sanghat hota hai waisa insan me badlao bhi aata hai
Congress channel?
I am living in banglore i am watching those area no where muslim majority area no where hindu majority totally mixup area hindu neigbour have muslim muslim neighbour & also christian
Frazer town, shivanjinagar.....
Thank you communist linked Indian express for the info
anti-nationalism and leftism in its full avatar.😂
cow-nationalism in the comments. 😂
@@prashanthb6521 and what are you a convert , who is happy about india getting islamised?
@@b.devendrakumar2360 he seems to be DMK supporter. What else can be expected from him?
1 child policy in Hindi hartland only solution.
How about 1 child policy for muslims?
@@sweetpotato_42 one child policy for everyone who lives in Hindi-heartland.
Hindi speaking people are pumping kids like pi*s
Waqf board ( 3rd largest land holder)
3 wifes no diverse
Madarsaa
Is it equal laws😂?
Mr intellectual 🐫🐕
Ap logo ka kaam dhanda Naa heh ....
Khali rss ke piche pade rho😂😂😂😂
The Jihadi Express for a reason.
Jitni abadi utna hak. Also delimitation is a constitutional exercise must be done to protect constitution.
I think we can do delimitation without reducing seats in South. More seats in North is important for better governance. Problem with large seats is that too much diversity in each seat leads to votebank politics, and governance issues take a back seat. For eg: if there are 3 castes in a seat, then majority caste always wins. So, splitting will give voice to all castes.
If the caste representaion alone is the only formula for developing so-called backward castes then how the hell caste politics based states are also still the most backward?
Work speaks. No need of anything other than educating the young and old. In kerala senior citizens try 10th,12th exams and pass too.
People who eat, do sex, reproduce, pay 0 taxes should not be burden on hardworking tax paying citizens.
Population control is civilized society issues not the RSS issues...
You are the instrument of rss generated propaganda. You talk about representation, what is the Muslim percentage of representation in Parliament, job and government sector?you creating fear among hindu community
France🐫
UK
Sweden
Why sharia demand increasing?
Turns into islamic..?
Any 70...80% muslim population district..any Christian, hindu live happily 😂
Kishanganj is the best example of Ganga jamuni tahzeeb where the majority is Muslim but till now there has not been any violence in the name of religion 😊
@@Zaiyannn69 are u human or rahul gandhi🐫🤣lier king
2 Temple burn,Palestine flags..it's social media Era fake 1950,s congres falthu tricks nahi chaltha
@@Zaiyannn69 @Zaiyannn69 wow so lucky place in world ur area..🌎
Nehru,rajiv gandhi forgot ur area👏..otherwise like kashmir, manipur kept seperate rules.....enjoy ..pls away from gandhi family 🤝unity india
@@Zaiyannn69 thats an exception
I am against farther increase of parliament seat until we achieve higher income status. It will rewards poor performing state and discourage state which are working well in woman education and population reduction. It will also significantly alter power dynamic of the union and ultimately may endanger the union.
Why Soros linked Indian express is concerned about what Organiser thinks?
is soros ur daddy?
Isn't yours😊@@vpstateofmind
@@vpstateofmind Seems like he's yours, that's why you're so hurt.
@@pawankumar-ev8xn I forgot your daddy was m0di 😂
@@heavenlypot lol commenting soros soros under every comment surely you guys dad is soros , isnt daddy giving you any love honey 😂
I dont know why who decide fate of indian polity is it rss hq😂...then welcome to socalled democracy...when migrant in uk become pm ..but here muslim born citizen not have same opportunity its look like a sin 😂.
Can you blame anyone? Muslims even in UK France are doing stupid things like demanding Sharia Law. Is this fair? If anyone is smart they will become Atheist or Hindu instead of following pedo Muhammad.
Everyone has the right to share opinions. Have you heard of this democratic concept? Muslims got two full exclusive nations. Muslims played double game with Hindus.
People like you who still could not sense threat even after seeing the downfall of west(reverse case if you follow abrhamic faiths)