Herbie Hancock - Actual Proof (Live at Montreux Jazz Festival 2010)
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 30 มิ.ย. 2014
- 2010 Montreux Sounds
Montreux Sounds: www.montreuxsounds.com
Mercury Studios: www.mercurystudios.co/distrib... (if applicable)
LIVE AT MONTREUX - MONTREUX JAZZ ARCHIVES
This performance is part of the unique Claude Nobs Foundation audio-visual collection, included since 2013 in the UNESCO Memory of the World Register. From Aretha Franklin or Miles Davis to David Bowie or Prince, more than 5’000 concerts have been recorded LIVE both in audio and video since the creation of the Montreux Jazz Festival in 1967 by Claude Nobs.
MONTREUX JAZZ FESTIVAL WHERE LEGENDS ARE BORN
The Montreux Jazz Festival takes place for two weeks every summer in Switzerland, drawing 250,000 music lovers to the shores of Lake Geneva. Since 1967, the Festival has celebrated all genres of music and generated countless legendary performances. Artists who have graced the stage of Montreux include Aretha Franklin, David Bowie, Prince, Bob Dylan, Lauryn Hill, Kendrick Lamar, Leonard Cohen, Marvin Gaye, Miles Davis, Nina Simone and many more.
Official Websites:
www.claudenobsfoundation.com
www.montreuxsounds.com
www.montreuxjazzfestival.com
#MJF
#montreuxsounds
#claudenobsfoundation
#montreuxdigitalproject
#MontreuxJazzFestival
#MontreuxJazz - เพลง
Shout out to dude on guitar for not playing a single note during Herbie’s solo. The ability to have a massive vocabulary and not say anything is the true mark of a pro.
I think it's Lionel Loueke
Amen.
That would be me the entire gig. Purely because of intimidation.... 😮
Tal is a supremely talented artist. Her playing is unassuming but very complex. She deserves her place as one of the best jazz bassists in a generation. Always impressive, always humble.
Yep she's a beast. She only hits the right note at the right time, never too much, never too little. That's quite the musical maturity for anyone, let alone someone her age. Her and her bass are one.
Tal is an excellent Bass player who plays for the band and not for herself, musicianship!
🌬🔊👍👍👍👍👍🎸👍👍👍👍🎶 👀👌
Just can't get enough of Tal. Herbie who?
Is this Lionel Loueke on guitar ?
You haters leave that girl alone! When I was a young musician (Tal's age), I had an innate feel and instinct for music-- particularly jazz. I had the love and passion for the music...but I lacked the discipline when it came to practicing. 30-35 years later, when I reflect on my early experiences as a fledgling musician, I realize I simply DIDN'T practice, nor put in the 'real work'! Recently, I decided I wanted to start playing again-- this time, just for recreation. Doing so, for me, it meant FINALLY admitting-- to myself-- that I had loved the idea of BEING a competent musician, but truthfully -- save the first 4-5 years learning my instrument, had not put forth the effort to have earned that right. I readily admit had I seen this performance 30-35 years ago, I'd have been EXCEPTIONALLY jealous (not hateful, but jealous) of a musician the same as I (certainly younger) that played better than I could. Nope! 75% of the problem was MY azz not 'puttin' in the REAL work and practice! Sure, the 'natural talent factor' can always be considered when it comes to the case of an obviously 'gifted' musician such as Tal, but even 'gifted' artists MUST 'put in the work'. This young lady has obviously put in the effort to be able to display this level of talent and musicianship. Bravo for her. I can imagine she was in Heaven jammin' with Herbie and those other older cats. Thanks for the post.
The girl is phenomenally talented. I am afraid she needs more exposure and volume in most appearances. Her accomplishments with Jeff Beck among others remains unprecedented
Totally brother
Herbie Hancock-piano, keyboards; Vinnie Colaiuta-drums; Lionel Loueke-guitar; Greg Phillinganes-keyboards; and Tal Wilkenfeld-bass who was around 26 at the time.
24.
Thank you - not familiar w guitar player.
The Super younger ... was playing among those talented Beasts. ...... ha ha
@@brdnrd 23; born in December. ;)
@@fretbuzz59 23 years and 7 months to the day at the start of the festival. That's 24 in my book.
The accumulated talent here is overwhelming... 😮
At 3:37, Vinnie breaks a stick, tosses the pair, grabs a new pair, keeps the beat with his kick, jumps back in. Love it!
Herbie Hancock - Actual Proof live at Montreux
Posted on September 22, 2018 by admin
Herbie Hancock plays “Actual Proof” from the 1974 “Thrust” album, live at the 44th Montreux Jazz Festival in 2010.
Great band with Tal Wilkenfeld on bass, Gregg Phillinganes on keys, Vinnie Colaiuta on drums, Lionel Loueke on guitar and of course the great Herbie Hancock on keys.
Thanks for line up info !!!
Lionel's solo...What the fuck is that...Brilliant!!!
Who ever cut vinnie colaiuta solo in this video is a sinner
Brother is putting on the pounds
One think the world does not need is more jazzy drum solos.
@@fdfsdfsvsfgsg4888 WRONG
notice near the end even herbie is watching her and shaking his head at how good she is , love her
It is a bit unfair to compare a great upcoming bass-player with Jaco. Tal Wilkenfeld is a real big talent and she stands for her own. And she really serves the music and does not show her ego. As much as I like Jaco for going beyond the limits with an e-bass, I like Tal Wilkenfeld for being able to make a musical statement along with the greatest musicians. In ten years we will talk about bass players playing like Tal Wilkenfeld.
Agreed. Although it's nice to have her now!
Nah probably not actually. Theres just not a lot of natural chemistry there. You can tell herbie loves it, being the free natural loving man he is but they just don’t mesh as well. Still a great performance and not to take anything any from this girl but it’s really not comparable
Jaco was one of a kind and he is gone now. Tal has gotten better each time I hear her. She is so consistent. Never gets ahead of who she is playing with.
Well said.
@@larrylund2682 Yep!!!, what hier Tal delivers is just unbelievable, the worlds better compared to what I have heard from others in this piece!
Tal Wilkenfeld can tell her kids she played with all of these great musicians ( It's a long list), and these great musicians can tell their grandchildren they got to play with Tal Wilkenfeld.
Maybe she will cut a record that shows that , not for her kids , but for the benevolence of Art
Hope i am not being to hypothetical
When i pretend , at least i know i'm pretending
I keep trying to like jazz, but it just always sounds like everybody doing what they want not paying attention to the sum of all parts. Or in other words s bunch of colors that don't go with each other haphazardly mixed around a then flung at the wall. maybe I'm just not cool enough to hear it
Have you met her? I have known her since the first day she stepped foot on U.S. soil, and she is all about herself. Even at age 13 she was all ego. Nothing I would want to tell grandchildren about.
@@jamesholmberg3158 Well, there's 'jazz' and then there's 'jazz'. It's not all abstract, with odd time signatures. There's so much good stuff out there. A rich heritage. Keep on trying!
Basically all children are playing....;-)
I love how Herbie Hancock is anticipating what Tal is doing in her solo. She likes to use sequences and whenever she does Herbie jumps in matching what shes doing. Beautiful musicianship on his part.
+Kolumaic good ears :)
refreshing to read comments that don't involve Tal being "pretty".
Jazz is like football - the best teams have star players that know what each other is going to do ... magic happens, goals are scored!
@@ericmills2094, an atypical and on-the-spot comment! I'm not going any further on this "thread", because I know there's going to be something that'll push me "over the edge"! Thanks for making a relevant comment!
Herbie is the king at letting the music build and not worry to much.. Kinda why he's Herbie 😁
The great Greg Phillinganes on keys!
LEGEND !!!!
Máster!!!
Don't know him. Never heard of him.
But he must be great if he's on stage with Herbie. No doubt about it.
@@rhmayer1 Played w/Stevie Wonder, Michael Jackson, Toto, Steely Dan ...
@@stephanleo Tx!
The great Greg Phillinganes playing with them too! What an awesome combination of amazing players!
I have just enough musical talent to realize that I have no idea what it would be like to be as talented as anyone on that stage.
Tal Wilkenfeld is absolutely brilliant on this recording - I love the way Herbie comps during her solo. The anticipation and musical conversation between them. The two of them together - totally ripping it up.
Typical creative as usual Hancock ! Highest quality of Funk/ Jazz music,musicians,greatest improvisation’s, ! Hurry up ! You’re welcome! Young Talents / Bass - guitar 🎸 Bravo !
3:35 That moment when Vinnie realizes he has a cracked stick and seamlessly changes it in the midst of a round of Herbie's choruses...
Darn Luc Bergeron watched this like 50 times just noticed Vinnie change sticks without even looking almost only Vinnie!
Good eye!
Killer performance and line up...damn. Herbie is so killing it and Tal and Vinny. Hell Greg in the background keys
Tal, you're inspiring. My 13 year old daughter has been playing drums since she was 4 and guitar since she was seven, and she jumped on the bass last year thanks to you! Come see us in New Zealand next time you are home!
I can't make sense of music like this, but I can appreciate it all the same.
When you get a legend to perk up and smile with your solo, like Tal did at 8:10, you know you got it.
Herbie Hancock is a great musician! This is one of the complicated jazz compositions, but Tal Wilkenfeld is like a fish in the water.
I get the impression that if this little European girl was not playing bass there would only be about 8 comments.Herbie Hancock the great jazz pianist demonstrating virtuosity and grace .
Joanie Barc she is infact Australian.
This is other worldly musicianship.
that girl amazin...looks so young...but keeps up with these guys...amazin
The amazing thing is these guys can keep up with her!
nice note
Do we think Tal needs about 15% more volume in the mix?
+Peter Stephen and one pants !!!
+Ben I don't under stand your meaning Ben . Should I? Is it important ?
new hip lingo ?
you think Tal should have different Pants ?
+Peter Stephen yes, but don't be afraid ....it's a joke !!
+Peter Stephen For sure, but it's Herbie's gig after all ;)
+Mr. Walter yea but it's BASS. is the ground floor everythings stands on...
After listening to Actual proof regularly since its release until today I can’t help feeling a bit disappointed.
That girl on the bass is absolutely amazing
Tal Wilkenfeld!! Ones of best girl bass player in the world!!👌👌👌 th-cam.com/users/TalWilkenfeld
@@ARLDAM Thank you!
Love seeing the joy on Herbie's face when he plays with youngsters like Tal here on bass.
Tai who? She's killing me!!
Tal Wilkenfeld
*****
Tal Wilkerson
from Down Under
and she's got stones in person; I met her two years ago and she knows what she knows
as you can plainly see here
How ironic, the most talked about bass players lately have been (for valid reasons) Tal and Esperanza Spaulding.
TheTimananda Yeah, you met her - but don't know her name: Wilkenfeld.
Tal, again, is a true master of the bass. Looking good, but even sounding better. Jaco remembered by a new generation!
I can not hear Tal, please remix!
This is exactly what was in my thoughts... closed my eyes and Jaco Pastorius was reborn in Tal.
Weather Report...
Tal with Herbie at Montreux, Tal traveling and performing with Jeff Beck..A phenom...
Lionel Loueke technique and sound beyond my mind!!!
This is amazing. Tal is taking it and hh plays off her. I've heard this many times over the years. Still resonates in the heart and soul.
Love Herbie Hancock, Headhunters album was on constantly in my younger days. Still stands today as a great album. Tal Wilkenfeld is a killer bassist. Her work on Jeff Becks Live At Ronnie Scotts was stellar and she kills it here. Thanks for posting this montreuxlive, now I think I'll go find a copy of Headhunters to buy.
Thrust, my favourite LP...
Lionel Loueke on guitar....I was just listening to him on iTunes tonight too!
I LOVE THIS GIRL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1
СССР СССРОВИЧ малая огонь, я тоже заценил)
Vinnie is not a girl!
HEHEHEHEHEHEHEHEHEHEHEHEHEH GOOOOOD JOKE LORENZ :):):):):)
she is in her 30s lol
She was barely into her twenties when this was recorded!
super bass !!!
Tal holding back Hancock for a while was FREAKING AMAZING
I wouldn't have recognized Mike Clark or Paul Jackson!! Now we need Blackbird McKnight!!
Tal is so exceptionally good and can seamlessly play with the best. I still don't understand how she can play all of Jeff Beck's material; the live show at Ronnie Scott's was amazing. I think someone placed her here to teach us a lesson.
Yea "someone's" grand design, not her talent and work. Fys
Vinnie's no slouch either
Those 2 belong together
spacejamgoliath To be fair, it could be both.
Wish she'd play with Jeff again. I wanted to catch one of those gigs live.
@@thescroot but it isn't - no fantasy guy in the sky exists.
One of my favorite songs from the “Thrust” LP. I was 15 when 1st hearing this! Bennie Maupin’s alto flute is the missing sound.
Beautiful just beautiful.Love every second of it !!!!
Herbie Hancock (piano, keyboards)
Vinnie Colaiuta (drums)
Lionel Loueke (guitar)
Tal Wilkenfeld (bass)
Greg Phillinganes (keyboards)
Kristina Train (vocals)
Herbie and amazing band. Love it
DANIEL FARIA
TW is special and she lives inside the music. The work she did with Vinnie and Jeff Beck shows just how diverse gifted and complicated she is.
Great composition.....oustanding rendition...!
Beautiful sounds. And Tal is a handful for the eyes and the ears!
Tal! maravillosa!
Go to see her in the Jeff Beck 's live show at the " Ronnie Scott " Club in London ... That girl is incredible , and so pretty ...
The mix on the bass in fine in my studio with real speakers. She is sooo cute looking and she always gets so into the music that its fun just watching her play. So talented, I love her groove type style. The Sadowsky bass has a solid low end sound.
Wow that young girl is amazing playing with those guys.
Notice the way Tal is the one who conducts and keeps time? She needed more volume so that they could hear her but used body language as well.
Yes agree !!!
Tal is so good on this clip!
She is AWESOME ! Great Performance of all
Just so fresh and in the moment and Tal adds to this what a combo mind blown just when I think it’s over it has begun beautiful float away baby
*Just a little bit of info on the Bass Player Tal Wilkenfeld. She is from Australia and moved to the United States when she was 16 to pursue her career as a Guitarist! She took up playing Bass and Voila....Playing with some of the best Musicians in the world!
This is interesting because she seems to have a east coast accent, but I can hear the aussie in her voice..also lovely and I look forward to getting her new album! She has a video of her band at a cabin in NYC with 3 songs from her new album. I first saw her with Jeff Beck on the Clapton guitar festival and I thought she was 14 or so I was blown away by her talent and now I have heard her sing.
She looks younger than she is but after 2-3 months playing the bass she was already hanging out with some greats.. Listen to her interview with Marc Marion on his podcast.. It's awesome
@@algmusicuk Or the one with Bill Burr. That one's awesome too.
Thanks for the Tal info. SHE is the young lady jamming with Jeff Beck for anyone who.has seen his RonnieScott's performance. She did damn good there...and yeah, I can't really HEAR HER here.
Go Aussie gal!
Just remember that the Bass player was 18 at the time of this video! What an amazing talent.
She was 22 born 12/2,86....
great...thanks for share....
Very nice.All excellent musicians.
8:05 Tal put a big smile on Herbie's face...priceless!
He did appear to get lost in her magic for just a bit..haaa dirty old man.
@@larrylund2682 ?
Tal and Vinnie team up a lot. I saw them both with Chick Corea and Frank Gambale and they were flawless.
Thank you for sharing Mr Hancock and Friends Sunday June 19 2022 11:26am EST USA The Master Weaver The Creator Has A Master Plan
We know all greatest musicians but Tal is so young and so loved by Jeff and many others at her age. Unbelievable!!! Wish all the best!!!
3:35 vinnie saw his sticks wasnt giving it, gotta say, the stick change was just flawless..
Oh yeah... Nice spot
Brilliant
Indeed!
Clearly Ms Wilkenfeld is technically gifted and artistically magnificent. It never seems like she’s showing off.That is music. As a student of the bass I’m just grateful she chose bass as her medium. It kind of clears our horizons.
I love it. Thnks Montreux Festival
Génial !
Great
tal is killing it, as usual
Mr. Hancock turned 80 just a few days ago (A BIG happy Birthday to You). And he's still one of the best... Wow
Great solo Herbie! My favourite song from headhunters.
you dont need to smoke weed to get high ,just listen Herbie Hancock first electric band albums,with Paul Jackson in bass
this is unreal. way off the chart if you will, each one of these giants are playing it wit such master touch . wowwwwww
époustouflant !!!!!!!! quelle musique !!!! et quel plaisir de jouer !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Amazing!!!
Would love to have a conversation with Herbie about how he constructed this piece of music ....the musicians are all from a different planet.......what a piece
How would that help you as far as knowing what made him think of it to begin with?
I wrote charts for Herbie of 11 tunes in 1989 including this tune. Looks like Herbie’s not looking at it 21 years later - a close up screen shot looks different. I didn’t ask him about Actual Proof but the concerts sounded great that year.
He had Wah Wah Watson (my connection to him), Darryl Jones, Ndugu, Mino, & Bill Evans- sax if i remember correctly. I did get to sit with him as he looked over a chart of Hang Up Your Hang Ups I was writing- by hand- pre computer. Herbie said to me “Did Wah Wah say it’s right?” I lied and said yes. Wah Wah had actually told me “Herbie asked if you can make it neater!” So I used a ruler and some lettering stencils & they looked good.
On Actual Proof remember it taking awhile to figure out. While I didn’t ask him about this I believe the title itself is from Buddhism.
I love this song!!! Vinnie Colaiuta does a great job with Herbie Hancock!
Yes he does indeed - a demonic sight-reader and Zappa alum...
Jest świetna :) Kocham ją
All I can say is that I dig this groove! Great band too!
love that bass girl
Tal Wilkenfeld is so beautiful, she is my Queen of Bass.
Quelle belle performance ,riche en rebond...issements .Génial et talentueux .
Thanks for great music.Herbie,keep inspiring the young generation.
that female bass player kicks ass awesome the whole group is tight
yeah that's right! cut it off just before the drumsolo!!
Outstanding
tal winkenfeld totally fearless of playing with them; duet with hancock AWESOME
With all these phenomenal players up there, I find myself watching Tal.
Masterclass - I think the man on the deck underestimated Tal and kept her low down in the mix -she easy needed a good 20% more....
Herbie is a King though :-)
masterful piece. thanks for posting it :-)
outstanding!!
Herbie, Tal Wilkenfeld, Greg Phillangenes Vinnie Calaiuta....geez Louise....what a lineup
If Tal Wilkenfeld had born 30 years before, she would be playing the bass with Frank Zappa.
But she is already played with Jeff Beck!
Tal Wilkenfeld can tell her kids she played with all of these great musicians ( It's a long list), and these great musicians can tell their grandchildren they got to play with Tal Wilkenfeld.
....and going head-to-head with Jaco Pastorious!
@@pattomuso She is just a cray talent.
Hopefully history deals her better cards.
Luv and Peace.
@Sebastian Most certainly! I mentioned Jaco specifically as I was lucky enough to see him 'live' with Weather report in '78
Tal Wilkenfeld is actually everywhere :D
YES MY FRIEND SHE IS EVERYWHERE I THINK SHES THE BEST PLAYER I NEVER SEEN
She is cool at such young age!
herbie always fantastic with this time young girl on bass guitar and vinnie on drums .nice people!!!
no one ever filled Jaco’s shoes until this girl. She has so much soul. She captivates the listener in the same way, but she has her own style...