Are Muslims in India’s Haryana facing ‘ethnic cleansing’? | The Take
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 10 ส.ค. 2023
- Near India’s capital, in Haryana state, demolitions of more than 1,200 homes and shops in a Muslim-majority area have followed clashes that killed six people. The demolitions have been halted for now, but this week, a local High Court raised the idea that the ones that took place might be an act of “ethnic cleansing” by the state. The clashes and demolitions are seen by many Muslims as the latest in a trend of violence in India during Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s nine years in power. So what space exists for Muslims in India?
In this episode:
Mohammad Ali, journalist
Episode credits:
This episode was produced by Ashish Malhotra, David Enders and our host Malika Bilal. Khaled Soltan and Zaina Badr fact-checked this episode.
Our sound designer is Alex Roldan. Our lead of audience development and engagement is Aya Elmileik. Munera AlDosari and Adam Abou-Gad are our engagement producers.
Alexandra Locke is The Take’s executive producer, and Ney Alvarez is Al Jazeera's head of audio.
What is particularly heartbreaking for victims in India is that Modi is still honoured with highest medals in the Gulf countries. This gives him added energy to carry on his extremist ideology.
Modi should be challenged by a real Sadhu.
Especially the US and Western countries' media that ignore the religious violence in India......
Unbelievable.. how this religious violence still excess..and where are the Police to stop those troublemaker.. maybe India forget that Muslim are people too and also thier citizen..where is the equality of it's citizen
Earth is not flat and stationary.
@@AgniveshArya and ur point?
Definitely so.
India has always had this problem, getting worse under RSS.
And BJP
Radical Hindutva Terrorist group RSS, Vishwa Hindu Parishad and Bajrangi Dal are responsible for these barbaric evil deeds.
And slavery of Arabs...
In this case muslim mob start stone pelting....watch proper video....ok ....
@@AgniveshAryahypocrites hindu discrimination kasta the worst ...
Not only haryana it's all over India 🇮🇳🇮🇳😢😢
Please be strong. I have no idea wtf is their problem.
If you feel unsafe then go to Afghanistan leave there in Taliban governance.
@@rayl2085Pakistan
@@HariKrishna-ix2in OK first tell 3 million Hindus working and leaving in middle east to be kicked back to their India
@@aleemshaikh1269are they citizen of those countries?
Now in Haryana!! India is now Gujrat!
And manipur too
Why Muslim living in india. Because of Mal e ganimat. So it is happening.
it's time for gulf countries to do something
Do they need Mal e ganimat.
All they care about is wealth. They forget that they didn’t work for their oil wealth but it was a blessing from Allah. For them to now just turn around and be money oriented in everything they do whether it furthers or justifies Muslim oppression.
Dude.... India is such big country
Why can they do
@@Land_of_Punt Allah blessed oil but not water. Ahmed drinks oil. White oil
@@missiles1993 what are you on about? Allah didn’t bless oil. The fact that there’s large amounts of oil found in Arabia is a blessing from GOD that’s what I meant.
❤️Thanks For The Truth ❤️
❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
Not only haryana.... It's all over India 😢....
Not only india.... It's all over world....
@@advait5452Only in BJP states. Here in Turkey it's super peaceful
@@primaryesthethicinstincts4832 here Congress state. They justifying child rape bcoz its sunnat.
@@primaryesthethicinstincts4832 In Pakistan we know how they treat minorities.
@@mayan5600 Apparently to Indians everyone is from Pakistan. It's a unhealthy obsession. 😁
The whole world could see the situation in India about India's minorities but why no actions are being taken??????
What are they waiting for??????
Who will take take action. Muslim should leave India go back to Pakistan Jinnah
@@emandas5640why?
@@robust5615 hindus think Muslim are Pakistani agent
@@emandas5640 and 30 million Hindus residing in middle east and Muslim countries should also go to India
@@aleemshaikh1269 Hindus don't have problems on Arab countries. Hindus have problems on indian Muslim who choose Pakistan in 1947. If Arab Muslim will come to india . We give full respect to them. But not indian Muslim for choosing Pakistan
Nowdays Muslim of haryana living in fear due to BJP government 😢😢😢😢
AllahuAkbar SubhanAllah MashaAllah JazakAllah AlHaeer Iltimas-e-Dua ❤
AllahumaSalyAla Mohammad SAWW WaAly Mohammad SAWW ❤
Ameen Ya RabulAlameen ❤
If they feared would thay spit on the religious procession?
Fake news playing victim card
What if someone spit on your religious procession? What would u do if u believe in god?
@@DeepakSagekarvictim card bro😂😂
Yes, it's Israeli model followed by the government because they are well known from the muslim world.
Full support to modi
Support you mom😂
Radical hindu
Extremist **
Bad Situation are going on with Muslim in india by bjp government. It should stop now immediately.
I am from Bangladesh 😢
Don't give us moral lecture on how we should fake care od our minorities. In your nation you have depleted the hindu population from 24% to 4 ot 5 % now.
Propaganda arm of Qatar government aljazeera is filled with hatred for H1ndu community. They attack h1ndu yatra and play victim with help of their UMMAH. You can keep dreaming of eliminating the h1nduz with ur hate for H1ndu propaganda
How will come ghazwa e hind this is the process for next😊
@@amirbasharNow I'm understand the Hadith what a punishment waiting for them
@@amirbashar If you radical Islamist's blabber non-sense like this, We also tell Pakistan will collapse become part of India.
The high court of Haryana have itself questioned the government are they commiting ethnic cleansing in the region, imagine what would be the condition on ground.
I live in haryana and there is nothing as al jazeera is showing so stop defaming indias image😢
@@vinodbhandari6679 defaming India is in their blood.
@@vinodbhandari6679hey fake id user.where actually you are living? In different comment you put different places.🤣🤣
@@advait5452and blindness in your blood.
Because of PM Modi I'm IND muslim 🇮🇳🇮🇳😢😢😢
Fight back bro dont let them hurt u
@@AbuShivaToyib
You cannot even face 1 million Israeli being 2 billion mootalmaan
@@AbuShivaToyib brother if we just open our mouth against injustice we will be jailed till eternity here in india muslim are only allowed to cry and suicide but not even speak about this injustice to anyone.
@@SHANTANUBISWAS-vs2iv victim card bro .... zindagi me in k saath kuch nhi hua hoga jo comment kar rha 😏😏😏 pakistan bangladesh me kya haal kar diya in logo ne minority ka khtm ho gayi ..Al Jazeera kabhi ye news dikhaya me to blindly ignore kar deta hu Al Jazeera,trt ,bbc English ka
@@ShivamsinghRajpoot-jc5pd tu ignore karna kisne bola dekhne ke liye waise bhi Pakistan Bangladesh ke hindu fake minority victim card khelte hain 😄😄😄
Sad to say, yes as and Indian I am ashamed too
niklo Pakistan
@@fabash6763why should he. Idnia is not ur fathers property
@@hossainabeer it is openly our property get lost Pakistani
@@fabash6763no baniya... Pakistan is your father... You are just getting angry like a jealous wife 😂😂😂😂
Bechara Bikari baniya.
@@sabtaingopinath9652 aata lo bachonko khilaw kaha aagye sirji
Hindus are not responsible for it, RSS and BJP is responsible. Actually almost 60% Hindus are good people.
That I agree
You are a liar, 90% of hindus are RSS BJP
Agree
Majority of Hindu Terrerist are included in violence
Moh me ram Dil me nathuram hath me jhanda Dil me danga 😂😂
99%
Not only muslim all minority targeted by indian goverment
good joke 😂😂
Actually. You are right. Some people only understand the way Israel deals.😂
I hope that Indians can live together peacefully, regardless of their religion, because what happened to India and the separation of parts from India was a nightmare and repeating it again is also a mistake.
Not possible under the ruling government BJP
Impossible under hindutva. Nazism is the new majority religion of India now.
@@adma7298😂 ) Lmao average Indian
@@adma7298you should
Radical Hindutva Terrorist group RSS, Vishwa Hindu Parishad and Bajrangi Dal are responsible for these barbaric evil deeds.
"Only through hardship, sacrifice and militant action can freedom be won. The struggle is my life. I will continue fighting for freedom until the end of my days."
Nelson Mandela
Was this supposed to be inspirational? How many of your houses have been burned down?
Muslim in India need to own guns and stand for themselves or else no one will speak for them
They do Al-Jazeera won't talk about how the Muslim mon shoot at the Hindus and even the police
@@FreePalestine1122free to go to other nations, I don't know why their population is exploding if that was the case
This is happening because they have guns....
It's already happen.....they smuggling gun this is main reason that's why violence occurred
Once a puncturewala always a puncturewala.
Hasbi Allahu Wa Nimal Wakil ❤️☝️
Haryana is a Starting of ethinc cleansing
Meanwhile Manipur in fire and ruins since 3 months....
Don't you see that as ethnic cleansing??
@@FreePalestine1122 Then why muslim living in disbeliver land? Leave
May Allah strengthen our brothers and sisters in India
Hope. But Mal e ganimat is not very easy now.
Allah exist in Arab not in kaafir country
Aameen yaa rabb
@@ShivamsinghRajpoot-jc5pdCommon sense it present in everyone not in Hindus
@@naumannaeem7027 follower of a child rapist shouldn't talk about common sense.
It’s so sad that we’re living a world that injustice be came normalized and perpetrators get away with in front of everyone and nobody saying anything about it 😢
Lol Islam is the epitome of injustice!
Who will pay for the Hindus killed in the hindu kush mountains?
Thanks Al Jazeera for showing true situation of India
Al Jazeera Never show true news
@@ShivamsinghRajpoot-jc5pdRadical Hindutva Terrorist group RSS, Vishwa Hindu Parishad and Bajrangi Dal are responsible for these barbaric, atrocious and evil deeds.
@@ShivamsinghRajpoot-jc5pdyes it does hater
@@sidali2590 No it doesnt.
It never talks about muslim nation crime on its minority.
When did you see them talking anything about forced conversion in Pakistan and lynching in Pakistan.
Their channel description says it.
Al jazzera is the godi media of muslim world.
@@mayan5600 Al Jazeera did cover that once it's not biased the conversions in pakistan happens rarely
RSS Bajrang dal and and many dal are responsible for this violence and criminal cases
Life of Human beings are important than anything.
Love from India to al Jazeera ❤❤❤
Riot is not new but govt is openly biased now
A state of violence INDIA
No Doubt, There is going on Jungle Raaj
In india minority muslim christan and sikh are in sorrow
Only Muslim becoz of Pakistan.
They should be we don’t want terrorists in our country.😂
@@emandas5640 what abt manipur christains Dalits don't lie dear we know hindus love for christains sikhs and Dalits
@@aleemshaikh1269 Hindus love everybody except islam against Hindus that's why Jinnah divide Hindu subcontinent's
🥴🥴only comments box....??????
Pakistan Bangladesh ka condition dekha jaha saare minority ka kya haal kar diya gya
They're saying that the cow is their mother and we respect that but why they let them on the road and not taking care like mother 😞.... Sadly they just hate minorities.....and this is BJP building new India
sir have you seen or heard the name gaushala ??? seeing comments from sikhs against hindus is like watching hate between two brothers ,, becoz sikhs have forget about their own history
No we don't..We Love our sikh Brothers & other Religions..
Go back guys...don't spread hate against Hindus
OIC especially Islamic republic of Pakistan and Bangladesh should help their muslim brethren in India. Please give asylum to the suffering people of manipur, kashmir and now Haryana. lets make the British/Jinnah's/Nehru's dream of 1947 become better and better
What about the Hindu dream?
Hahaha😂🤣😹, Pakistan and Bangladesh? Are these muslim country? These are muslim populated countries not muslim countries. 😢😢😢
Indeed
You know how many Bangladeshis migrate to India illegally and how many Hindus and Sikhs from Pakistan find asylum in India every year but not even one Indian Muslim leave India for Pakistan and Bangladesh
@@anaesthete5592 , well. build a wall or something. otherwise don't complain
Pathetic condition 😞
Dear Al Jazeera. Sometime please cover other minorities in Muslim countries
You mean Turkey, Indonesia, Malaysia, Morocco, Azerbaijan, UAE, Oman, .....
@@primaryesthethicinstincts4832Bahrain ,Qatar,Saudi ,uae,Kuwait,Hindus enjoy high standard of life in these countries
@@primaryesthethicinstincts4832you mean nepal, mauratius, bhutan, Trinidad and tobago, suriname, where muslim enjoy high standard of life in these countries.
@@primaryesthethicinstincts4832 turkey is a secular state it's not an islamic country.
Hindus in Pakistan and Banglades live in peace because they have either killed them orconverted them. So I thiNK INDIA is doing better.
@@mayan5600 Violence is only happening in BJP states. More violence is coming because of elections.
whatever happening in India is not a new thing in India. before the mughal and western invasion of the subcontinent, everyone lived in peace that included Islamic brothers and sisters because Islam reached India in the 7th century. I will tell you one thing people "American Culture in America, Indian culture in India and Arab culture in Arabia". Don't fight to change the natural way of things in a land. Hopefully OIC can punish the Quran burners asap
All over india the minority is facing the same.
Absolutely right
All over india the Hindus are facing the same.
Propaganda arm of Qatar government aljazeera is filled with hatred for H1ndu community. They attack h1ndu yatra and play victim with help of their UMMAH. You can keep dreaming of eliminating the h1nduz with ur hate for H1ndu propaganda
@@ZakirHussain-re9ewwe take pride in hunting down mullah whi doesn't respect the indic civilization
@@muralimm4466yes unless u re rich
The BJP government of India has been recognise Israel as ideal of her..therefore every tactic which Israel would have doing against Palestinians, they ( BJP) following...
Makes you realise the 1947 (Partion) Pakistani's are very lucky people, don't forget about the Sikh community (Khalistan) who are also targeted by the Media.
One day all Hindus knows what is Pain' 👍
Propaganda arm of Qatar government aljazeera is filled with hatred for H1ndu community. They attack h1ndu yatra and play victim with help of their UMMAH. You can keep dreaming of eliminating the h1nduz with ur hate for H1ndu propaganda
Hindus have known it, now they are ar making you know it
coming from a muslim who destroyed our libray and destroyed our history and rule over us.
It's time for muslim to see what is Pain.
Ironically the burned vehicles and the properties showed in the video were Hindu's
Total Ethnic Cleansing
Haryana is just a start we should be prepared for our defence
Are you Indian?
Haryana nuh muslim responsible mostly people are uneducated that's main reason
Thanks, 🙏 Al Jazeera
It is true that in India we are treated as second class citizens in these days.There is no justice for Muslim in India though Supreme court and others opposition leaders are trying to normalise the situation.
Pray for us.
Radical Hindutva Terrorist group RSS, Vishwa Hindu Parishad and Bajrangi Dal are responsible for these barbaric evil deeds.
😂😂you guy have Sharia law in india
@@strombreaker3446if there is shariyah law in India half of it's population will be dead😂
@@mohamedriyas7224oh for sure if India goes through Sharia punishment laws for muslim and Hindu punishment for Hindu's who breaks the rule then we will be living in bhai chara🤣 you know what I said
@@mohamedriyas7224
Wtf?
"Freedom is never voluntarily given by the oppressor; it must be demanded by the oppressed."
Martin Luther King, Jr.
Who decides who is the oppressed and who is the oppressor😂😂
Islam will never allow true muslim to adopt India as their motherland- BR Ambedkar.
So pakistani people are not muslim. Pakistan is India's land even though you call it Pakistan. Or Bangladesh??
We don't need to complain all the times to the world we need to stand together with our Indian brothers and sisters
Al Jazeera is absolutely right
condolance to my muslim brothers may Allah protect you from cruel hindues
Radical Hindutva Terrorist group RSS, Vishwa Hindu Parishad and Bajrangi Dal are responsible for these barbaric, atrocious and evil deeds.
First Do Well planned Riot then play Victim Card 🤷🏻♂️: Peaceful Muslim Community's Awesome Strategy,👌👌👍👌👍
@Say_My_Name-- Say radical Hindutva Terrorists to stop killings, persecutions and provocations.
@@Say_My_Name-- Civil war is coming for you! Because you are not leaving any stone unturned for it.
Yes modi is Allah
اللهم احفظ مسلمين الهند واحقن دمائهم وبارك فيهم واحفظهم واحفظ أعراضهم وبارك فيهم وانصرهم ...على الهندوس ...ومودي وحكومته يارب اللهم انصر مسلمين كشمير على ..الاحتلال الهندي يارب ..
Freedom for Palestine and Gaza and Kashmir und Turkestan and Africa not just Ukraine
Freedom for Kashmir
Kashmir is Pakistan 🇵🇰
India for Muslim ☪️
Free Balochistan
Free Pakistan occupied kashmir and reunite with India
Free Sindh from Filthy Pakistan
Jai Sree Ram,, Jai Hind
Pakistan is running with bowl around world for feeding their people and here the matter " rise the slogan Kashmir hamara "
Give Kurdistan and balochistan also
Pakistan me kya haal Kiya minority sab dikhta hai bhai
@@nightpanther9209please at least let them live peacefully.. instead of ur barbaric people
Good Character and Attitudes are important to Humanity for Peace Freedom Liberty and enjoying things without hurting others.
All Nouth India Muslim not safe
Stop stone pelting enough is enough..... otherwise violence Never Stop
Without any doubt
One single currency for all Islamic countries just like European union (pound).....Joint Defence cooperation of all Islamic countries just like NATO.... please stand United
Hide Manipur incident 😞😞
It’s not good, wish we can all live together peacefully without any hate towards each other. After all we are all brothers and sisters of one another, hate against any other will never gain anything, but love and respect will keep us together no matter what religion or culture background we have, I pray that soon we can end the war of hatred, Ameen 🤲😔
Shahali: Not until loose jaw 56 ends 4 good.
Real scenario of Hindu cruel community.. Everyone should stop this
criminal offence before it's too late
Chinese done on Uyghur
You'll never see this kind of behavior with non-believers.
Haryana means Land of Hari.malecch has no place here.
Their tactics of religious march or procession runs similar with Northern Ireland's orange marches of past.
When the govt of India released the rapist of Bilkis bano 😓 on independence day then what we can expect
Thanks for covering .
save muslim in haryana Uttarakhand up communal gang destroying muslim houses with bulldozer in small case muslim jail in uapa dracon law govt is also communal
How long owner of those houses build it and why Horiana government only now found out ?
Bro why muslim mob pelt stone,fired 131 vehicles...why Muslim not use own commons sense
Wow so peaceful Hindus also killing innocent people. I am from South Africa we don't have these problems all Indians are brothers. All our fathers come from India we are Indian we cannot understand this. My mother is Hindu. We do not understand. This is madness
It's not bad as it is being reported. Al Jazeera is spreading propaganda.
Rival Pakistan. Did Arab allow pork
Only if you knew both sides of story
🤣 pakistani 🇵🇰 khud k desh me maara daala saare Hindu,sikh ko gyaan india pe de Rha jaha population masjid, rights sabkuch increase hua bangladesh me kya haal kiya
This type of violence Regercely circulate all over state of india 😞
Thanks ALJAZEERA
May Allah protect them inshAllah,
not only in haryan , it's all over India
Did the hindus did it without any reason?????
The world is chaotic
Thank you gulf countries for honouring Indian prime minister with the highest medals
Al Jazeera : Always Biased 👍👍 this should be your Brand Line
Videos are emerging right now of women being arrested and beaten in the area by the police.
Muslim Mughal Empire vaapas leh ao India mein another Aurangzeb ko leh ao. In Hindutva ko sabak sikao.
भीड़ का कोई धर्म नहीं होता....नफरत की हर कोशिश को मिलकर हराना होगा, चाहे वो किसी के खिलाफ़ ही क्यों ना हो। सबको ध्यान रखना होगा कि
"लगेगी आग तो आयेंगे घर कई जद में,
यहां पर हमारा मकां थोडी है।"
Your Reporting is just as good as BBC. Biased and losing credibility rapidly. 😂
m০di's bjp should be tried under international court.. C০w w০rshippers are fIying beyond their capabilities. The result will be catastrophic
Islamic countries keep rewarding Modi national honours. They are encouraging the current regime because they have economic interests.
People are starting to notice. I'm not south asian, only discovered the problem a few year ago. Genocide is a big deal and this is an age of information.
Because they know the truth, they don't lean towards fake news and false narratives
That was a joke medal dude, that was just to win a economic deal. They give it everyone who brings a deal to them. Leave them.
You know what you can do? You can migrate to Malaysia and get PR.
Help Malaysia grow, pay taxes to a just government. India is living in your taxes, cut of the criminal nation, leave it for your good.
Congress came to power in karnataka and all criminal extremists have become law abiding citizens. So its governance that makes these people against other minorities who are Portrayed as heroes especially very poor neighbourhoods
The whole world could see the situation in India about India's minorities but why no actions are being taken??????
I'm not south asian. Allot people are
Noticing how messed up things are.
Why dont middle easterns countries open their borders for their ummah?
Please help indian muslim 😢😢😢
😂
What goes around comes around. Lets not act like arabs were not castrating their slaves.
So if you wanna pray with them….
Al Jazzera you have had the same motivation to cover Ethic Tamils slaughtered in Sri Lanka with Arms supply from Pakistan & China to SL Govt…
Its all about politics and money religion shouldn't be a problem people who using religion for their own self benefits that kinda people that we should be aware
Thanks Al Jazeera. To show the Crime of RSS and BJP.
So why you don't show clips of nooh..
What about stone pelting on shobha yatra by these muslim
Please don't generalise,it is the right wing govt and it's stooge having only 30% vote share responsible for the anarchy, the rest 70% are secular and peace loving,our India is the beautiful land of Khwaja Mohinuddeen Chisti Ajmeri the sufi king, Khawaja Zindabad,Hindustan Zindabad.
Are you really a Muslim? Or Hindu trying to say that majority of Indians are good?
If majority are good, then how come this is happening? How come Modi is PM?
@@friendly4186 Is modi India or India modi, expand your range of thinking.
Not just there its everywhere in India, before it was in Maharashtra and Uttrakhand and Uttar Pradesh, bihar
God save our country.
He who trusts his own reason is a fool;
but he who walks according to wisdom will be saved.
Moodi is tearing apart India with this Hidutva approach
"Are"? The title should read as "how"
"religion unites people"
Brutality