Are heat pumps ACTUALLY worth the investment?

แชร์
ฝัง
  • เผยแพร่เมื่อ 13 ม.ค. 2025

ความคิดเห็น • 76

  • @AllenHart999
    @AllenHart999 2 หลายเดือนก่อน +2

    This is a bit misleading, I have had 3 estate agents value my house and they all said the green stuff doesn’t really add anything. I would be interested to see any data to support your claim. Could you do a video to show the Scop octopus install get on average. Also a video to show how the full life costs of a heat pump is cheaper than a gas boiler. Thanks.

  • @jdog164
    @jdog164 3 หลายเดือนก่อน +4

    Don't like the idea of going back to massive water tank taking up space; it seems like a step backwards as our combi boiler doesn't need a tank.

  • @yp77738yp77739
    @yp77738yp77739 3 หลายเดือนก่อน +3

    I don’t understand how, when the government has announced they are stopping cheap off peak electricity, that a heat pump can be viable.
    Gas costs about 5P/kWh and peak electricity is about 25p/kWh, it takes approximately the same energy to heat a unit mass of water with either energy source. It goes against the laws of physics that it can be cheaper.
    The only exception being if you have generated your own electricity for “free”using PV or wind.

    • @russcraig1216
      @russcraig1216 3 หลายเดือนก่อน

      Heatpumps can be over 300% efficient without breaking the laws of thermodynamics. They are not consuming electricity to produce heat they are using it to pump heat from the environment (ground/air/water) to your home. This doesn't break the law of thermodynamics. Your fridge for example will have a CoP of around 1.6 (160% efficient). I hope you now understand. There will be more in depth explanations a google search away.

    • @yp77738yp77739
      @yp77738yp77739 3 หลายเดือนก่อน

      @@russcraig1216 Thanks
      I looked and it’s essentially a fridge in reverse, but with the addition of a refrigerant to water heat exchanger.
      Every step in any system has inefficiencies, so I still struggle to accept that a complex system of exchange of states can be more efficiency than a single, direct transfer of energy. But I guess I must be wrong (or everyone using them has been fooled)!
      We did use one in a rental property about 10 years ago I had in Switzerland, the plant room was massive and took up the space of a normal UK kitchen. The room itself was overbearingly hot, suggesting a rather high inefficiency, so warm we used it to dry our laundry. I do remember our monthly electrical bill was 3 fold what I am paying now, but I was too busy at work to pay much attention.

    • @BarryHeaven
      @BarryHeaven 3 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

      They are only stopping off-peak for those without a smart meter. Simple answer is get a free smart meter.

    • @yp77738yp77739
      @yp77738yp77739 3 หลายเดือนก่อน

      @@BarryHeaven are you sure, I thought the entire off peak rate tariff was going? To be completely gone by 2030 I read.

    • @foxythedirtydog4494
      @foxythedirtydog4494 3 หลายเดือนก่อน

      ​@@yp77738yp77739 You seem to be very ignorant about this whole subject. I suspect you are watching dodgy youtubers who don't understand facts but enthusiastically push rumours and conspiracy theories.
      Here is how I see the points you raised.
      Heat pumps, as has been mentioned, move heat from outside water, ground or more commonly air to your heating system. You also get most of the energy you put in as well. It is not all good news as they need cooler water in the return so usually other upgrades like larger radiators are needed. Underfloor heating is ideal. Good insulation is needed to take advantage of off peak electricity. They usually have to run longer than a boiler would so not good if the hose is empty all day. Also they are noisy.
      Off peat electricity use is encouraged as it reduces peak loads which is where the grid struggles. It is likely to be used more not banned but I expect the price difference to reduce as EV takeup advances. I only use off peak electricity as I have a large battery for load shifting. A big upfront cost that will take 4 more years to break even. I could also use it to make money by selling power back for a profit at peak times.
      I don't have a heat pump yet as the payback time is too long and I despise the red tape around getting one installed. I want to install it myself and keep my gas boiler as a backup/booster. For £7500 I could install a very nice system but can only get a mediocre system fitted within the regulations. I have a 200 year old 6 bedroom house which needs a good system. I will probably end up making my own system out of used refrigeration equipment.

  • @m0aze611
    @m0aze611 หลายเดือนก่อน

    I would question the 16% - yes I know they need to promote this technology. My previous property had warm air heating and that put people off and yet it warmed the house quicker and much cheaper to run. To combat this my estate agent researched the warm air boiler and once she showed them my gas bills they became quite positive. I miss it. Some potential buyers were genuinely worried that the warm air boiler was a ASHP and that was a year ago.

  • @Tony-Stockport
    @Tony-Stockport 4 หลายเดือนก่อน +5

    Like EVs Heat Pumps are technically fantastic but not suitable for everyone. I live in a 60 year old semi-detatched house with good insulation. To swap over to a Heat Pump system the saving would take nearly 20 years to pay off the investment. If I was in a poorly insulated house with a boiler on its last legs or a house without central heating then it would be a different story.

    • @st200ol
      @st200ol 4 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

      Does that payback period include the savings in getting rid of gas altogether? The gas standing charge isn’t an insignificant cost. Every little helps.

    • @Tony-Stockport
      @Tony-Stockport 4 หลายเดือนก่อน +2

      @@st200ol Yes. Standing charge on gas is £108 per year for me. I would love the technology of a ground source heat pump but the cost of a system change, let alone the hassle of ripping up floor boards, etc means it's not a sensible move for the vast majority of people in the UK.

    • @kippertrace5808
      @kippertrace5808 3 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

      🎶 🎵 Gas is free. Gas is free. In a debt based economy. 🎶 🎵

    • @russcraig1216
      @russcraig1216 3 หลายเดือนก่อน

      To give a counterpoint many historic buildings including here in Scotland are heat pump warmed. If they can do it in Denmark it can be done here. That doesn't mean that in your specific case it makes sense just that people shouldn't assume old means that heat pumps won't work.

    • @iancrowson2988
      @iancrowson2988 3 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

      I also live in a 60s semi. I have had a heat pump installed by Octopus in August. The install was very good. So far it heats water efficiently at no more cost than gas. I turned the heating on two days ago, so far so good. They are not for everyone because of physical space needed. As far as installation costs, with grant cheaper to install than a replacement gas boiler.
      Running costs, well that depends on your tariff and the relative cost of gas v electricity. I am expecting to save money. The heat pump is 3 to 5 times more efficient than a gas boiler. As you say not for everybody, and never will be, same for electric vehicles.

  • @Cyberbobxxxx
    @Cyberbobxxxx 2 หลายเดือนก่อน +2

    What’s the payback for all the money spent on this over complicated expense nonsense? What’s that point of removing a simple cheep to run efficient combi boiler? Would you spend £12-15 k of your own money on this?

  • @adespade119
    @adespade119 3 วันที่ผ่านมา

    What about adding passive solar heating to the input

  • @waynebeal1152
    @waynebeal1152 3 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    Hi @russcraig
    Can't remember my original post I'm assuming it's cause I said gas is 4 times cheaper? .
    I understand how heat pumps work as an installer.
    I think the point I was trying to make was neat pumps are 3 -4 times cheaper to run than a gas boiler in terms of energy but the energy cost is the same in difference per KW price Ie gas is around 4 times cheaper per KW to run so it all balances out long term .
    Thanks for the reply 👍

  • @moorparkscottages
    @moorparkscottages 4 หลายเดือนก่อน

    I was quoted £7500 for a heat pump by Octopus. it may be more efficient than our oil boiler but I can but 3 oil boilers for the same price. Look forward to the prices coming down.

    • @JohnR31415
      @JohnR31415 4 หลายเดือนก่อน

      @@moorparkscottages I was quoted an 11kW system… my heat loss is about 4kW at worst.
      MCS is weird.

    • @datoon83
      @datoon83 4 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

      @@JohnR31415 have you had a full heat loss survey done? Only then you would know your heat loss...

  • @Cyberbobxxxx
    @Cyberbobxxxx หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    Everyone raves about heat pumps and yes they heat the house and work in the winter and not that noisy. But they are very expensive, complicated and difficult to get repaired. Everyone who has one installed reels of great cop figures and how warm it is and how much better than a combi boiler ect, but the question that is never answered is what is the payback? Same as solar! When do you get free electricity? Never get the answer. Would you pay £15k for a heat pump that will in reality only save approximately £200 a year. Ps, will need massive radiators and a small room to house all the kit.

  • @JohnR31415
    @JohnR31415 4 หลายเดือนก่อน +3

    Didn’t this get posted yesterday?

    • @timoliver8940
      @timoliver8940 4 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

      Yes.
      Living in an “all electric” house with no gas boiler or wet central heating system why would I want to put ugly pipes and radiators around the interior of my house?

    • @martinwray7001
      @martinwray7001 4 หลายเดือนก่อน

      ​@@timoliver8940is yours the 'air to air' heat pump option?
      Pity there is no grant for that, I'd love to bin the rads.

  • @mobi1etone
    @mobi1etone หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    People that believe the COP figures and savings from these companies probably believe the mileage range quoted from EV manufacturers. Even IF a heat pump system saved me 33% of my electricity bill, it would take 25 years to pay back for the initial instillation of the system.

  • @FlopFlips
    @FlopFlips 4 หลายเดือนก่อน

    At 3:51, does the average annual saving of £220 include savings from disconnecting from the gas network (no longer paying standing charge), or is this due to the higher efficiency of heat pumps compared to gas boilers?

    • @Biggest-dh1vr
      @Biggest-dh1vr 4 หลายเดือนก่อน +2

      At least part is due to the efficiency, as the standing charge for gas is just over £100 per year

    • @terryT-r5o
      @terryT-r5o 3 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

      But beware, there are no tools for the end user to measure the efficiency, and even now I’m getting at best a cop of 2. Which means , because elec is about 4 times more expensive than gas my costs are at least twice as high as with gas.

    • @Biggest-dh1vr
      @Biggest-dh1vr 3 หลายเดือนก่อน

      @@terryT-r5o Have you had a second opinion in on the heat pump, or an explanation of the poor performance?
      Time of use tariffs can save substantial amounts of money (though probably not making up for the poor performance). Are you on one?

  • @russcraig1216
    @russcraig1216 3 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    Yet another tariff that isn't available to all those (often rural) customers whose SMETS2 meter is stuck in dumb mode due to lack of signal. The industry really needs to sort dumb mode smart meters in both Northern and Southern networks. Parliament should be forcing the regulator to act.

    • @PinkDuckUK
      @PinkDuckUK 3 หลายเดือนก่อน

      Replacement 4G comms hubs are to be trialled in England from Dec 2024 with wider rollout Q3 2025.

    • @russcraig1216
      @russcraig1216 3 หลายเดือนก่อน

      @@PinkDuckUK Is that for the South network or will it cover the Arqiva/North network? Quite why we couldn't have a UK-wide standard approach I don't know!

    • @PinkDuckUK
      @PinkDuckUK 3 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

      @@russcraig1216 Will happen for Southern cellular network first. Scottish Government opted for Arqiva approach, though that could change given different network characteristics of 4G perhaps.

    • @russcraig1216
      @russcraig1216 3 หลายเดือนก่อน

      @@PinkDuckUK thank you. Whilst my 4G indoor reception isn't brilliant it is probably good enough if they go that way. 5G ironically is better indoors here!

  • @tempest957
    @tempest957 หลายเดือนก่อน

    In the Uk the best thing about a heat pump is NOT having one! We have a swimming pool and our heat pump is perfect to heat it. Turn it on in May Turn it off in September, perfect! This skilled builder fitter is 100% currect in everything he is saying! Or take your heat pump and move to Florida, then your ok!

  • @melhiore
    @melhiore 4 หลายเดือนก่อน +2

    I swear I saw this yesterday...

    • @ThePrawlin
      @ThePrawlin 4 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

      Indeed. But this version has the correct spelling of asbestos. Instead of yesterday’s somewhat embarrassing asPestos!

  • @InquisitiveMind23
    @InquisitiveMind23 4 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Hi, Are you serving Scotland? You guys don't offer solar or heat pumps to Scotland. Sad.

    • @russcraig1216
      @russcraig1216 3 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

      According to their website they do

  • @tedbearfudge
    @tedbearfudge หลายเดือนก่อน

    If heatpumps are so great why have the houses of parliment, buck house and government building not changed over to them?

  • @tedbearfudge
    @tedbearfudge 3 หลายเดือนก่อน +3

    In a word Bollocks, 1.7 to 3% increase in the value of your house max. the cost outweighs any benefits. Stick with gas for as long as you can. Only my opinion, best to do your own reasearch. annual service £150 to £300. new filters every 3 months costing £20.

    • @richardlewis5316
      @richardlewis5316 หลายเดือนก่อน

      A gas boiler is able to vary its working temperature so costs very little to run at 48degrees so no saving when using a heat pump.

  • @stevoone342
    @stevoone342 หลายเดือนก่อน

    I think some of the octapus pr saying £500 for a heat pump isn’t really true for most. My quote for a s/m semi detached 3bed was £5000 including the substacy. Also my forecasted savings is only £10 a month so best case in 25yrs id only saved £3000 that dosent add up to me. And soon as you put the yearly service cost onto it witch on average is twice as expensive as gas puts this as more expensive than my combi. Let alone all the other issues or costs. The only way it makes any sense if you have a decent solar array with decent battry backup. But that’s 10s of thousands ££££££. Personally im not made of money plus factor in we are looking like we may be going into a recession / crash economy personally id consider taking out debt wouldn’t be wise especially if the return is in the - range.

  • @datoon83
    @datoon83 4 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    Let's stop talking about HP's as a investment.
    Gas boilers don't get talked about as an investment.

    • @PinkDuckUK
      @PinkDuckUK 3 หลายเดือนก่อน

      Let’s talk about Spark Gap instead.

  • @robwoodphotos
    @robwoodphotos 4 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    Good or not I applied octopus for a quote and was told they don’t do it in my area … tempt me and then let me down

    • @thomasjohnbirks132
      @thomasjohnbirks132 4 หลายเดือนก่อน

      Same here, they don't install in Scotland.

  • @EileenKemp-y9d
    @EileenKemp-y9d 4 หลายเดือนก่อน

    No good for OAPS, like myself ,no heating allowance for me ,I have Stenosis of my back ,most days I am house bound, just get taken to get weekly shop once each week so I need Heating allowance badly, "what do I do".freeze to death.)??.

  • @cyngaethlestan8859
    @cyngaethlestan8859 4 หลายเดือนก่อน +2

    Some major errors and omissions in this video.
    1. The grant is only available for a whole house system. People that have to use multiple heating sources can't apply.
    2. If you are one of those, like me, in the countryside without gas or oil you will not have radiators so can not use, (this kind of,) heat pump as they use your rad's even if a few need replacing with larger ones.
    3.Those who have the most expensive heating - storage heaters - can't use this system as it requires radiators.
    4. Heat pumps are very bad in deep winter, but good at other times. (see below) I speak from experience, not figures that show 'average over a year'
    5. The more practical form of heat pump, other than for new builds, is to install air to air heat pumps otherwise know as air conditioners. I find they work very well in all but deep winter when I do have to use the storage heaters but that is normally only a few weeks a year and I still put one air con unit on if the temp' pops up a little midday. The only bad things about air conditioners are that there is no grant at all for them - they are thought of as a luxury rather than what they are - very good heaters, even if they do need a backup heater. and the installation will cost the same as the units themselves. 2 years ago I paid £3,200 for 2 x 4kw (heating) units and slightly over half of that was installation which took two men one day. I do recommend these especially if you have PV, you get free heating for a good part of the year and even taking into account needing a secondary heater, (in my case a few mobile oil filled electric rad's and a wood burner) are well worth buying
    PV + Air con is an excellent match.

  • @johnbruce9698
    @johnbruce9698 4 หลายเดือนก่อน +2

    What he doesn’t mention is that at temperatures of 5 degrees or less the heat pumps efficiency drops and it uses more electricity. This will means there will be no cost advantage and as the pump has to work harder the noise levels increase. All the space that will be required to house all the cylinders and tanks will cause problems in modern homes that took the cylinders out when they were encouraged to install condensing boilers that don’t need storage. The particular design of the Octopus heat pump might have a problem if there is heavy snow as the fan faces up.

    • @Biggest-dh1vr
      @Biggest-dh1vr 4 หลายเดือนก่อน

      The 4x efficiency he quotes is for energy use over the whole year, factoring in both drops and rises as the temperature changes outside.

    • @waynebeal1152
      @waynebeal1152 3 หลายเดือนก่อน

      Also electricity is around 4 times more expensive than gas , and I can pretty much guarantee all radiators will need changing to accommodate the lower working temps.
      I am a heating engineer and I have recently installed a heat pump to my own property so I can be a guinea pig for my customers.

    • @Biggest-dh1vr
      @Biggest-dh1vr 3 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

      ​@@waynebeal1152we needed to replace about half our radiators to obtain a decent flow temperature. We could have replaced fewer by using a higher flow temperature.
      People may like Nicholas Raimo's video on his Octopus pump install.

    • @wobby1516
      @wobby1516 3 หลายเดือนก่อน +2

      I have an Octopus energy heatpump so unlike a lot of people who haven’t got one yet are experts on heatpumps I can tell you my experience. Heatpumps that are installed correctly are not noisy in fact a boiler flue makes more noise and the do heat the house even when the temp is below zero. However the need to be on most of the time but having said that they still are cheaper to run than gas and much cheaper than oil.

    • @russcraig1216
      @russcraig1216 3 หลายเดือนก่อน

      @@waynebeal1152 The electricity runs a heat pump, it isn't "burned" to make heat.

  • @iareid8255
    @iareid8255 4 หลายเดือนก่อน +5

    Octopus Energy,
    no, heat pumps are not four times as efficient as a gas boiler, that is a common but basic error. You cannot use the electricity used to power it as a basis for efficiency calculation, you must use the amount of fuel used to make that electricity. And from that they do not emit 80% less CO2.
    The achilles heel of an air source heat pumop is that output declines with a fall in ambient outside air tempertaure, i.e. the colder the weather the less heat the heat pump gives out.

    • @rtfazeberdee3519
      @rtfazeberdee3519 4 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

      ROFL. Other sources confirm the COP of 4

    • @iareid8255
      @iareid8255 4 หลายเดือนก่อน

      @@rtfazeberdee3519
      I suggest you go back and read what I wrote regarding how efficiency should be calculated.
      An air source heat pump with a CoP of four is at what outside ambient temperature as the normal accepted level is three at seven degees C ambient?

    • @rtfazeberdee3519
      @rtfazeberdee3519 4 หลายเดือนก่อน

      @@iareid8255 i'd suggest you ring the experts who wrote the book on these things and explain to them how wrong they are.

    • @ThePrawlin
      @ThePrawlin 4 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

      Whatever the efficiency it doesn’t seem to mention that Lecky costs 4x what gas costs!

    • @iareid8255
      @iareid8255 4 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

      @@rtfazeberdee3519
      I'm no expert but do have a solid background in electrical power engineering.
      Self style experts on the other hand?

  • @thetroopersk
    @thetroopersk 3 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    dont firget to insulate your house....

  • @alexanderevanska4274
    @alexanderevanska4274 2 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Most people can't afford the cost even with a grant. It's a scam.

  • @EileenKemp-y9d
    @EileenKemp-y9d 4 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Very confused.

    • @PinkDuckUK
      @PinkDuckUK 3 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

      I thought Ben explained it all rather clearly and concisely.

    • @terryT-r5o
      @terryT-r5o 3 หลายเดือนก่อน

      Yes, but do say why you are confused.

  • @caractacus22
    @caractacus22 4 หลายเดือนก่อน

    I do t believe you…..