Yasir Qadhi 3:51 Hamza Yusuf 4:19 Nouman Ali Khan 7:37 Omar Suleiman 8:34 Ismail Menk 11:40 Suhaib Webb 13:33 The Prophet ﷺ said: “Do not tell lies about me, for whoever tells lies about me will enter Hell.” Narrated by al-Bukhaari, 106. “O you who believe! If a Faasiq (liar - evil person) comes to you with any news, verify it, lest you should harm people in ignorance, and afterwards you become regretful for what you have done” [al-Hujuraat 49:6] May Allah guide us and protect us
Shaykh Saalih al-Fawzaan was asked (mp3): أنوي أن أكتب عن بعض الجماعات الضالة، والتحذير منها، لكن هذه الجماعة لم تخرج من الملة، وقد مدحها البعض من العلماء وأخشى أن يدعو علي، فما توجيهكم لي علما بأن هذه الجماعة منحرفة؟ I intend to write about some of the astray groups and warn from them however, this group has not exited from the religion and one of the scholars has praised it, and I fear that he may supplicate against me. So what is your advice with the knowledge that this group is deviated? The Shaykh's answer: الواجب عليك بيان الحق، الواجب عليك بيان الحق، إذا كنت متأكدًا من الأخطاء التي عندهم، والضلالات التي عندهم، متأكد مائة بالمائة، وعندك مقدرة وعندك علم تستطيع البيان يجب عليك هذا. (وَإِذْ أَخَذَ اللَّهُ مِيثَاقَ الَّذِينَ أُوتُوا الْكِتَابَ لَتُبَيِّنُنَّهُ لِلنَّاسِ وَلَا تَكْتُمُونَهُ) (إِنَّ الَّذِينَ يَكْتُمُونَ مَا أَنْزَلْنَا مِنَ الْبَيِّنَاتِ وَالْهُدَى) ما يجوز كتمان العلم، إذا كان عندك علم ومتيقن من ضلالات بعض الطوائف فبينها للناس من أجل أن يحذروها وهذا من النصيحة. قال -صلى الله عليه وسلم- "الدِّينُ النَّصِيحَةُ. قُلْنَا: لِمَنْ؟ قَالَ لِلَّهِ، وَلِكِتَابِهِ، وَلِرَسُولِهِ، وَلِأَئِمَّةِ الْمُسْلِمِينَ وَعَامَّتِهِمْ" . رَوَاهُ مُسْلِمٌ [رقم: 55]. ولا تخش الناس، عليك أن تخش الله -سبحانه وتعالى- وبيّن الحق وترد الباطل، ولا تخش الناس . نعم. اهـ It is obligatory upon you to explain the truth, it is obligatory upon you to explain the truth. If you are sure about the errors that are with them and the misguidance(s) that are with them, sure one-hundred percent and you have the ability, you have knowledge by which you are able to clarify, then this is obligatory upon you, "And when Allaah took the covenant from those who were given the Book that you will explain, clarify it to the people and not conceal it" [and] "Verily, those who conceal what we have revealed of clear evidences and guidance", it is not permissible to conceal knowledge. If you have knowledge with you and you are certain about the misguidance(s) of certain factions, then explain them to the people so that they may beware of them, and this is from sincere advice. He (sallallaahu alayhi wasallam) said, "The religion comprises sincerity of purpose" and we (the Companions) said, "To whom?" and he said, "To Allaah, His Book, His Messenger, the leaders of the Muslims and the common folk" (reported by Muslim, no. 55). Do not fear the people, upon you is to fear Allaah, the Sublime and Exalted, and explain to the people, refute falsehoood, and do not fear the people. Yes. We can add here for further clarification the statement of Shaykh Rabee bin Hadee (Fataawa Ash-Shaykh Rabee' 1/246): ...Al-Jarh Wa At-Tadeel will remain until the day of judgement. The people want to benefit from this particular scholar and you inform them that this person is a noble scholar and upon the Sunnah so you praise him, and this scholar is Raafidee, this one is a Soofee who believes in Wahdatul Wujood (This is referring to the false belief that all in existence is a single reality and that everything we see is only aspects of the essence of Allah), this one is a secularist, this one is a communist who conceals his reality with Islam. This one is this and this one is that. It is obligatory upon you to clarify this; this is an obligation. This is a form of Jihaad and it will not cease and it is not specific to narrators. Also the Salaf wrote [books] refuting the people of innovation as we have stated and they did not declare Al-Jarh Wa At-Ta'deel to be specific to the narrators alone. He is an innovator and is not from the people of hadeeth, [he is] Mu'tazilee, [he is] Jahmee, [he is] Murjee and so and so forth. He has no connection to any narrations but he is an innovator therefore they criticized him (Al-Jarh). So how can these people claim that the door of Al-Jarh is closed? In another place the Shaykh said (Fataawa Ash-Shaykh Rabee' 1/249): ...The methodology of Al-Jarh Wa At-Ta'deel will not cease until the day of judgement as long as innovations are present. Refer also to this article with another fatwa of Shaykh Saalih al-Fawzaan on this subject: Shaykh Saalih al-Fawzaan: The True and Real Fitnah is Leaving Alone the People of Falsehood and Evil and Remaining Silent About Them ..
These Da'ee know its weak hadiths when studying them, bcuz they mention the hadiths, ppl take it as Sahih, and they dont mention it as weak or fabricated or broken chain ...while quoting it.
The problem is your's approach and theirs approaches to hadiths differs. you have to tell this too. In short Albani makes it daef doesn't mean daef For me, Any hadith written by muhadithins after they call it sahih to them as far as it doesn't contradict reason, Quran and established islamic principle, i have no problem to work on it. So if you ask me if i am sure the prophet said that? I will say no i am not sure 100% and in reality you can't also be 100% sure any ahad or mutawatir hadith is verbatim word of the prophet.
The main problem is the ummah blindly following hadiths and anything with Muhammad's name attached to it. The Qur'an is from God, it's complete and fully detailed. The hadith are from HUMANS, of course there is fabrication and falsehood.
@@ummzaynul370 *All hadiths from A to Z are Da'eef because no any Hadith was IN PERSON certified as SAHIH by Rasool and 4 Caliphs. For example, Bukhari fabricated his book 220 years after the death of Prophet, and his book is full of concocted blasphemous tales which insult great man 68:4 Mohammad, and mock Quran and Quranic Wahi, repeatedly. Those sectarians who follow this kind of extra-Quranic Books are misled by Iblis 38:82, 38:83, **14:22*
Don't believe this person blindly...... Fabricated and weak hadees are two separate things.... Maudu'aat were compiled by scholars long before Albani......... Albani himself is a controversial figure, he died few years ago....... And Maudu'aat were written 7-800 years ago. In Fadail-e-Amal and Hikmat weak hadis are always allowed.
I am not saying that this person is lying because i haven't cross checked him but please don't believe him blindly........ Maudooat were already compiled by our earlier scholars like ibn ul Jawzi in separate books Name Mau'dooAat.... You can read Mau'dooAat (Fabricated hadees) from there and cross check it..... Secondly those books were also not 100% correct scholars made criticism over few hadees, still for a beginner it's very good book to read and understand... Weak hadees and Fabricated hadees both are put in (Unauthentic category ) but rulings on implications is totally different because both are totally different things. One is weak because a scholar might have weak memory, or someone had doubted over his time period or existence. Etc etc... Secondly weak hadees were always allowed in matters pertaining to Hikmat and Fadail-e-Amal, go and read Ibn Salah, Imam Ibn Haraj Asqali, Imam Ahmad Ibn Hanbal, Imam Abu Hanfia etc etc on this matter. I am not saying that everything this person is saying is wrong... I am just warning you to don't believe unless u have cross checked. And please Don't Cross check from new generation like albani or uthayameen.... They themselves are controversial because Albani says even Sahih Bukhari has several weak Hadees. He omitted several Hadees from Adab-al-Mufrad, another book by Imam Bukhari...... Go to previous scholars who did great job 800-1000years ago.
@@arhamabdaal9205 firstly of sheikh al albaani is controversial then so is daraqutni and abu haatim ar razi and shubah ibn hajjaj. Secondly they aren't always allowed in fadail aamaal Thirdly you should only tell the weak hadith in this If the people understand the prophet didn't really say it. Fourthly, the benefit should already be established
Jazakallah brother. That's how you put forth the correct view without disrespecting any of the speakers. Even I believed in many of these ahadith. May Allah reward you.
@@aaliyaaafreen firstly even in fadail aamaal they must already b established as well as the benefit. And it's not allowed to say the prophet pbuh said it rather it was reported that the prophet pbuh said. And is a people don't understand the diff then you shouldn't say it Secondly ad daraqutni and ibn hajar al asqallani also criticized few few few ahadith in sahih bukhari. Thirdly, no body ever said adab al mufrad was completely authentic
@@Bulayla1426 wait, bukhari was critized only for some negligible ahadith. And he won the argument mostly. Please word your sentences right BaarakAllahu feek, just saying cause some laymen will overturn Bukhari cause there's supposedly some minor mistakes
I am devistated. I used to listen to Nouman and Menk a sister told me to be careful and I checked on YT and came across this video I am confused now and so sad. May Allah guide these sheikhs and help us to gain true knowledge amin
Don’t be devastated, as they are humans who aren’t infallible. Stick to learning your deen from credible scholars, and verify everything you hear before accepting it. Baaraka Allahu feekum!
You cannot say that these men intentionally lied and they are not reliable... It is just a mistake (although needs to be corrected) and you will find no scholar without any mistakes... So do not multiply them by zero
Just a suggestion, when you make these videos, please show some references, quations and maybe go a bit in detail why the certain hadith is weak or fabricated. As people who are new to the channel or just very unaware would think "who are you to say these are weak!".
Baaraka Allahu feekum akhi, I did mention references where applicable. The reality is that the burden of proof is upon the one who is claiming that a Hadith has a reference to provide it and if he’s claiming that it’s authentic to provide an authentic chain of narration.
@@ryansn3600 Apologising to Allah is their personal matter. If they have said it in public then they should apologize for it in public. The least they can do is make an apology clip and upload it from their respective channels.
It is not the business of laymen to check the authenitcy of hadith. This field is based on ijtihaad, independent reasoning, its not clear cut. Its possible all of the hadith here are not considered to be fabricated by many muhadditheen.
@@The-servant-of-ALLAH1 Then tell me what are the conditions for determining the authenticity of hadith? Scholars vary on what they consider to be authentic or not and what conditions they use to determine this. Hafiz Ibnus Salah (rahimahullah) writes the following after defining the basic conditions for a Hadith to be classified as Sahih (authentic): “Sometimes the scholars differ on the authenticity of some Hadiths. This could be the result of their disagreement on whether the above conditions are met. It could even be the consequence of their disagreement on the relevance of some of these conditions.” (Muqaddimah Ibnus Salah, pg. 13) Hafiz Ibn Taymiyyah (rahimahullah) writes in his book: “Raf’ul Malam”: “The field of grading the narrators is vast, and the scholars may sometimes disagree on the credibility of the narrators just as the scholars of other branches of knowledge differ with each other.” (Qawa’id fi ‘Ulumil Hadith, pg.49)
16:15 - 'I'd rather have them and anyone else be my opponent on the day of judgment, rather than have the Prophet Muhammad (pbuh) be my opponent because I did not protect and defend his sunnah and point out these lies that are being attributed to him'. Barakallahu feek for highlighting this point. May Allah swt accept your deeds, keep you sincere and makes us from the 70,000.
I've been wanting to write a blog post/article about the same topic. Jazak'allah for the video brother. I really appreciate it. May Allah guide us all in the right path, Ameen
Really, write a blog? what about you write a blog on your own mistakes. Send an email to them reminding them about the hadith with the reasons its weak or whatever, Arrogance is not a nice trait.
SubhanAllaah. I didn't realise lying upon the messenger of Allaah was this widespread. May Allaah guide us and them nad their followers. May Allaah destroy the misguiders and the liars May Allaah save us from lying upon Allaah and His prophet May Allaah save us all from speaking without knowledge regarding His religion May Allaah make us give the science of the authenticity of hadeeth its due importance جزاك الله خيرا
As'salamu aleikum ya Omar, hayakallah. I think you need to make some videos regarding what fabricated ahadith are, and also explain what weak ahadith are, and why the content in a weak hadith can be true even though the chain is weak. So in sha Allah, my naseehah clarify these matters more, I see many confused in the comment section.
First buy books on mustalah al hadith and then get a teacher of sunnah. Learn Arabic to hear videos of some modern muhaditheen like wasiullah abbas, mashhoor ibn hasan and others Start reading small books and build up. Be with friends that study it well
It’s a long journey but to become an expert one definitely needs to know Arabic well enough as the vast majority of resources and books in the field are in Arabic. That being said while you are learning Arabic you can also begin by learning the basics about the science of Hadith such as the terminology and just familiarizing yourself with the field, it’s books, etc.
It would be even better if you name the sources mentioning the status of these narrations with book title and number of narration or page/chapter depending on published version.
Many of them are baseless fabrications as I stated which aren’t mentioned in any of the books of Hadith. So such a reference doesn’t even exist for them.
@@omarchatila85 Can you please specify which ones are weak and which ones are fabricated or fake because I can not follow a scholar who quotes fabricated Ahadith. JazakAllah
The usual suspects! May Allah guide us all. These speakers should be very careful about this matter, they know that their videos are watched by millions of people, extra care should be taken in the matter of Deen.
youre right these people in fact all of them are always doing something very weird NAK with the quran and his enterpritaion menk behind the scenes yaqeen nd evolution yasir qadhi being the "SçhOLar"of the world quoting shia books more fabricated hadith and talking about holes in narratives mind u this yasir clown graduated from madinah was a "salafi"and still quotes from abu mighnaf quotes more fabricated hadith about the prophetﷺ and his companions wife and who knows what else.hamza yusuf is sufi. And the other neverheard of him
Unfortunately many muslims trust the celebrity speakers more than scholars. If you tell them to list down the names of scholars they would probably know a few while if you ask them the names of famous speakers they wouldn't have enough fingers to count. May Allah guide us and keep us steadfast
Assalamualaikum, how are you my brother, you call him an Usthad,he looks more like a jew to me,no signs of any Sunnah on him,even his moustache is over his lips,please verify his authenticity before accepting what he says is fabricated, if he is a man of integrity then he should personally approach all these scholars before refuting them,maaf if I have said anything to harm anyone ALLAH KNOWS BEST
@@khalidpadia9561 Seriously? "All these scholars"?? I would call them scholars for dollars, misguided deviant, celebrity speakers, people of whims and desires ... Who misguide and mislead the mosses... How dear you call a Muslim brother a Jew? Rather, you're a person who's infected by the ignorance and falsehood of those heretics mentioned in this video... These whimsical speakers cast aspersions upon Islam, they ridicule Islam and spread diseases of deviation to the Ummah ... So, theses deviants are NOT scholars, rather, they're comedians and stage performers...
Plz try to contact them and inform them about their mistakes intentionally or unintentionally, so that they repent and ask forgiveness, May Allah guide us all and forgive us all, Ameen!!!
The biggest questions, is why do these speakers not fact check they're speeches and narrations they are using? And why when they speak out these narrations, they do not quote the sources and chains? Is it so hard to take a few minutes of your time to cite the source and chains?
Way to evade the question! I actually do understand Arabic Alhamdulillah as it is my mother tongue. But I also don’t rely on my own limited knowledge, rather I learn from the actual scholars of Islam past and present.
Bukhari collected around 600,000 hadiths and only accepted around 7000 of them. Have some common sense. Scholars are normal people and they are in no way authorized to grease hadiths. Some weak hadiths are considered hasan today.
It doesn’t matter if I know Arabic as a language or not. What matters is that I have common sense to know that Allah never authorized these so-called scholars to grade Hadiths. The grading system of Hadiths is man-made.
Akhi amazing video. After finding out many things I was doing was not from the sunnah and that they were weak ahadiths I started looking into this topic deeper to understand my religion better and like you said the severity and importance of this topic. With that being said can you recommend a book or scholar who has spoken about this topic so that I may gain knowledge. Jazakumuallahu khayran
In Arabic there are a lot more resources akhi. In English unfortunately the resources are limited on this topic, but insha Allah I’m working on some things. In the mean time, feel free to check out the following series: th-cam.com/play/PLr7GBSozm2hKmMybECg_xfk0zpcw4ON79.html
Subhan Allah!!!! A yound girl in the comments shared that fabricated story 11:46 that Mufit Menk shared about the old lady. I asked her if the hadith was authentic, and she said I dont know. I wanted to find out if the hadith was authentic or not because I doubted its authenticity. And Subhan Allah, today I found out! 💕 May Allah reward you
السلام عليكم Perhaps in another video you could clarify how weak hadith can be used for virtues and also how strong the weak hadith has to be in order to be used. I feel like the people of desires always pull this excuse when they get caught using weak hadith. Please clarify if you can. بارك الله فيك
Asalām-Alaykum. However, these mentioned Ahadīth are Mawdū (fabricated), not weak. The narrator has a defect and is known to lie, these are unacceptable. The weak Ahadīth has a different matter.
Honestly Barak Allahu fikum to brothers like you, Sajid, Wajdi etc. I was ultra antagonist some months ago (you [rightfully] blocked me on twitter lol) and I was studying at bayyinah institute for about 10 years & listening to all these individuals... Allahu akbar. I left the institute and unfollowed everyone. Thank you honestly, your efforts mean a LOT, they are currently having a major impact on my life. I am currently adhering to and studying the athari creed. May Allah grant you the highest reward and to your family. Salam aleykum
Wa feekum baaraka Allah! Thank you for your kind words. Alhamdulillah, all good is from Allah. May Allah keep you and us all steadfast upon the sunnah. I’m glad that you have started to learn the correct Aqeedah, but my advice to you is be mindful of who you learn your deen from as not everyone who claims to be following the correct methodology of understanding the Quran and sunnah is truly abiding by what they claim. So stick to well known and credible scholars such as sheikh Albani, Bin Baz, and Ibn Uthaymeen rahimahum Allah. May Allah bless you and keep you firm upon the truth. Wa alaykum alsalam wa rahmatullah!
Ameen. Thank you very much for the advice @@omarchatila85 . I noticed that, some have ikhwani and others khariji tendencies. In shaa Allah I will, I started listening to their fatawa and bought their books (I purchased yours too). I started kitab at tawheed too. Barak Allahu fik. Last question. Can I learn from Abdurahman Hassan and Tim Humble ? Because I just joined amau academy
I don’t know too much about them to be honest, but based on what I have seen from them, both seem to be credible duat calling to the sunnah. Keep in mind though that they aren’t scholars, and that they aren’t infallible and might make mistakes as we all do. The best thing to do would be to learn Arabic, and seek knowledge from actual scholars, especially those who spent their entire lives calling to the sunnah, and died upon that. In the mean time, learn from the du’at who are calling to the sunnah in the English language, while keeping in mind what was mentioned above. Hope this helps insha Allah. Baaraka Allahu feekum!
Very very helpful. I started arabic and I am making progress alhamdulillah. Then I'll learn from actual scholars like Ibn Uthaymeen, etc. I even changed my view about criticizing/rebelling against rulers, I was so ignorant subhan Allah, now I am called madkhali but it doesn't matter. I also showed your video to my husband (he listens to YQ) I pray Allah guides him, amin. Jazak Allah khair for everything!!!! @@omarchatila85 .
I need to watch more of your videos and also set a study routine to understand about hadiths further. Do you have a recommendation on how I can become more knowledge in this area? I’d like to know what is fabricated and what is sahih. It’s hard for the average layman like myself to point out these issues.
@@abz7800 brother I’d advise you to stay away from shabir aly and not take knowledge from him. He’s a Hadith rejector and doesn’t follow the guidelines set by scholars of Hadith since the time of the early scholars until today.
@@omarchatila85 idk because alot of islam comes from hadith but at the same time hadiths are not from god or preserved by god so may have false things or be fabricated . such example is the ruling for if you apostacise . yet the quran says theres no compulsion in religion its very hard to reconcile these verses without rejecting the hadith .
In the Quran, Allah commands us to follow what the Prophet ﷺ commands us. The authentic sunnah is part of Islam and has been preserved by Allah. Just because some ahadith are fabricated doesn’t negate the authentic ones which have been preserved.
@@omarchatila85 im not saying it negates and im not a hadith rejecter but i acknowledge when hadith contradicts quran ,then quran is to be followed like the example with the d penalty for leaving islam. furthermore allah commands us to follow the prophet but who is this us ? we have to distinguish who is the us because clearly some parts of the quran are addressed to only the people at the time of the prophet and not the rest of humanity but are just stories to learn ,from our perspective . also authentic doesnt mean its true for example if someone at the time of the prophet said the earth if flat it would be recorded as authentic narration but that doesnt mean its true all it means is someone said it humans may make mistakes in their knowledge as its the words of man not allah
How you are determining whether a Hadith contradicts the Quran or not? Is it based on your own personal understanding of what each is saying? With all due respect, using one’s own limited understanding of the Arabic language and of the texts from the Quran and sunnah to make such a determination isn’t appropriate. The example you gave highlights that as there isn’t a true conflict between the two, only a perceived contradiction on your end.
I heard the hadith about abu Bakr and that old blind lady from a trustworthy student of knowledge a salafi from Holland. Real bummer i love it. Are you sure ter is not one hadiht similar avout abu Bakr helping out this old blind lady?. Baraak Allah oe fik.
Yes akhi unfortunately this story isn’t authentic at all. Alhamdulillah the authentic stories that we do have about their biographies are much better. Wa feekum baaraka Allah!
Can you tell us the origins of the Hadith of the shaytan was sent to speak to rasul saaws which I’m told is also fabricated thank you brother as salami alaikkum
Brother it will be better if u explain these things with reference ....as these are the things which we used to hear since childhood.. And how we can find out which speaker is on truth as any person can make mistake somewhere or the other .
Maudooat, Fabricated hadees were already compiled by the scholars long back... Cross check it from there don't believe this person blindly....... Weak hadees were always allowed......
@@Hashim_Naysapuri All the scholars from the past HAD CONCENSUS DAIF HADITHS ARE ALLOWED. Please don't come with these lies. Only the new scholars like ALBANI said it wasn't allowed but this is clearly a new statement. Dive in to history please.
Alhamdulillaah. As soon as i saw the thumbnail, i knew it was gonna be bad. I do not listen to a single person from that. Alhamdulillaah, Allaah has guided me to see the truth. May Allaah keep our hearts firm
My brother, all of them are normal human beings who make mistakes, only allah knows what their true intention, it could be that they didnt know the hadith was fabricated or have forgot it was fabricated, jazakallah khayrun for this video
Wa iyyakum akhi! As I stated in the video, the purpose was to highlight how widespread this problem is and to emphasize the importance of verifying Hadith authenticity before attributing something to the Prophet ﷺ. Baaraka Allahu feek!
This is so scary. Makes me wanna give dawah with whatever little knowledege I have but now after seeing your video I'm thinking to not do it or limit the amount of incidents I mention about the prophet PBUH since I may enter hell fire unkowingly despite all the good I do
Give dawah only about what you’re certain of. If you’re unsure about something, verify it and seek more knowledge about it first, then give dawah. Knowledge comes first before speech and action. Baaraka Allahu feekum!
Scholars of Hadith study and evaluate the chain(s) of narration to determine whether a Hadith is authentic or not. There’s a whole field of studying Hadith, it’s terminology, it’s authenticity, etc.
It’s sign of end of times, I stop listening those mentioned long ago, specially YQ. Jazak Allahu khair brother Omar… Kindly give is insight, aren’t they know that Hadiths are weak let alone fabricated ? On what basis that have narrate that?
Wa iyyakum! It would be difficult to tell whether they knew these ahadith weren’t authentic and still went ahead and attributed them to the Prophet ﷺ. Allah knows best about their intentions, but even if we assume the best and that they weren’t aware, that still doesn’t excuse the fact that they’re callers to Islam and are falling into something this severe by attributing lies to the Prophet ﷺ which he never said. Baaraka Allahu feekum!
I can't find the hadith about Eid Ed'ha, I found a (weak/fabricated) hadith that talks about good deads in the amount of the hair of the animal and not about forgiving sins.
Ma Sha Allah, barakallah feek, I've heard some of these before and didn't even know they were fabricated. Interesting that the ones quoting the fabrications are people known to be on batil... Allahul musta'an, may Allah dispose of the lies attributed to Rasulullahﷺ - ameen
@@arhamabdaal9205 ya akhi, you know the difference between weak/daif and fabricated ahadith? He said none of them are from the known books of hadith like bukhari, muslim, ibn majah, tirmidhi etc. Prove him wrong if you're truthful instead of sending essays you don't know.
@@arhamabdaal9205 yes, do you blame Shaykh Albani for pointing out the hadith in Bukhari saying that Rasulullahﷺ thought of comitting suicide after Jibreel aleihi salam appeared in the cave? My advice to you akhi, learn the usool regarding ahadith before criticizing the ulema for their efforts. We should respect the classical ulema for their efforts, but what you're advocating would leave you out from Allah's blessing of ulema. Abu Hurayrah (may Allah be pleased with him) from the Messenger of Allah (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him), that he said: “At the beginning of every century Allah will send to this ummah someone who will revive its religious understanding.” Narrated by Abu Dawood (4291); classed as saheeh by as-Sakhkhaawi in al-Maqaasid al-Hasanah (149) and by al-Albaani in as-Silsilah as-Saheehah (no. 599).
I haven't critized him.... And what i said is 100% true, u r also accepting that Albani did those things..... Modern Salafis/Ahle Hadees believes in Albani but others school of thought have criticised him so i have just asked to go for much reliable source from previous generation......... And secondly i Have already said in first line that i am not saying this person is lying because I haven't checked, I have just asked to be aware and more cautious....... No were I said Albani did wrong or this scholar is doing wrong.... This video is available on Internet so people of Every Madhab will come and watch and they will take it otherwise also. And it will create more fitnah.
@@arhamabdaal9205 no you haven't spoken 100% true, you said weak ahadith are put with fabricated in the unauthenticated category. That's not true, a weak hadith only mentions its chain for those reasons you said but content of a saheeh and weak hadith can be same or similar however the chain of narration is weak, the narration can still be true. Weak and fabricated ahadith are miles apart akhi
And tell me one thing is Albani Infallible...???? Only he has all the knowledge...??? What he said is right and Imam ibn Hajar who defend Sahih Bukhari was wrong Nauzbillah.??? And the hadees which u quoted about A Mujadid, tell who can say that this particular person of this generation is Mujadid, every Maslaq treats their Head Scholar as Mujadid of this century.... And lastly is it written in any hadees to only believe in Albani and close eyes on other scholars.......... It us often said by almost all the scholars to go to earlier scholars for authenticity.... When we already have huge collection of earlier scholars i would choose to go to their book instead of reading Albani.
@Omar Chatila if one is not a scholar , you should follow a mathhab. As far as I know all Ahlus sunna Wal jama ulama follow a matthab. The four Imams trace their knowledge to the Prophet PBUH without an unbroken chain of transmission. We have been give a golden spoon as far as Islam.
That is not true at all brother. What madhab did the people follow before these 4 madhabs? If all 4 imams trace their entire knowledge back to the prophet ﷺ with an unbroken chain of transmission, then why did they differ on so many issues? And why did some of their students differ with them? And why did they change their opinion on a matter sometimes? This issue isn’t as over simplified as some would like to present it. Not to mention that there is no proof in the Quran or sunnah making it obligatory on someone to follow one of the 4 madhabs.
Jazak Allahu khayra brother Omar. May Allah bring about change in speakers’ attitude to only narrate authentic Hadith, aameen. I seriously doubt though many will heed to you advise, because: 1. To most of them despite the seriousness of the issue it’s not a concern. 2. If and when you confront them they will blame it on the one they heart it from. Nauman Ali khan for example used this defense when he was refuted about the pokiman Hadith. But. he was undeterred, he continues to do that as you pointed out in this clip. 3. Their blind follower will always be there to cheer them on and will rather condemn the messenger such as yourself then to ever challenge them. 4. Using fabricated and daeef stories adds juice to their speech without which they think they will not be effective. 5. To ensure authenticity, they will need to spend more time in preparation which they are not prepared to afford. 6. Some speakers malign muhadditheen for causing confusion about classification of Hadith. Due to which they cast doubt over the science of Hadith. I ask Allah to give tawfeeq to all speakers to do their due diligence and ensure status of the Hadith is authentic before referring to them in their speeches.
No it means you should only learn your deen from credible scholars rather than from duat who might not be verifying the authenticity of the ahadith they quote. Reading books of Hadiths is good, but you can’t learn the deen independently on your own as you need to get the proper understanding of them from credible scholars.
While Imam Bukhari and Imam Muslim set criteria to only include Authentic ahadith when compiling those two books/Sahihs, but the same thing applies regarding learning the proper understanding of those authentic ahadith from credible scholars rather than independently relying on one’s own understanding of them.
Yasir Qadhi 3:51
Hamza Yusuf 4:19
Nouman Ali Khan 7:37
Omar Suleiman 8:34
Ismail Menk 11:40
Suhaib Webb 13:33
The Prophet ﷺ said:
“Do not tell lies about me,
for whoever tells lies about me will enter Hell.”
Narrated by al-Bukhaari, 106.
“O you who believe! If a Faasiq (liar - evil person) comes to you with any news, verify it, lest you should harm people in ignorance, and afterwards you become regretful for what you have done”
[al-Hujuraat 49:6]
May Allah guide us
and protect us
thanks 4 this!
Ameen
Shaykh Saalih al-Fawzaan was asked (mp3):
أنوي أن أكتب عن بعض الجماعات الضالة، والتحذير منها، لكن هذه الجماعة لم تخرج من الملة، وقد مدحها البعض من العلماء وأخشى أن يدعو علي، فما توجيهكم لي علما بأن هذه الجماعة منحرفة؟
I intend to write about some of the astray groups and warn from them however, this group has not exited from the religion and one of the scholars has praised it, and I fear that he may supplicate against me. So what is your advice with the knowledge that this group is deviated?
The Shaykh's answer:
الواجب عليك بيان الحق، الواجب عليك بيان الحق، إذا كنت متأكدًا من الأخطاء التي عندهم، والضلالات التي عندهم، متأكد مائة بالمائة، وعندك مقدرة وعندك علم تستطيع البيان يجب عليك هذا. (وَإِذْ أَخَذَ اللَّهُ مِيثَاقَ الَّذِينَ أُوتُوا الْكِتَابَ لَتُبَيِّنُنَّهُ لِلنَّاسِ وَلَا تَكْتُمُونَهُ) (إِنَّ الَّذِينَ يَكْتُمُونَ مَا أَنْزَلْنَا مِنَ الْبَيِّنَاتِ وَالْهُدَى) ما يجوز كتمان العلم، إذا كان عندك علم ومتيقن من ضلالات بعض الطوائف فبينها للناس من أجل أن يحذروها وهذا من النصيحة. قال -صلى الله عليه وسلم- "الدِّينُ النَّصِيحَةُ. قُلْنَا: لِمَنْ؟ قَالَ لِلَّهِ، وَلِكِتَابِهِ، وَلِرَسُولِهِ، وَلِأَئِمَّةِ الْمُسْلِمِينَ وَعَامَّتِهِمْ" . رَوَاهُ مُسْلِمٌ [رقم: 55]. ولا تخش الناس، عليك أن تخش الله -سبحانه وتعالى- وبيّن الحق وترد الباطل، ولا تخش الناس . نعم. اهـ
It is obligatory upon you to explain the truth, it is obligatory upon you to explain the truth. If you are sure about the errors that are with them and the misguidance(s) that are with them, sure one-hundred percent and you have the ability, you have knowledge by which you are able to clarify, then this is obligatory upon you, "And when Allaah took the covenant from those who were given the Book that you will explain, clarify it to the people and not conceal it" [and] "Verily, those who conceal what we have revealed of clear evidences and guidance", it is not permissible to conceal knowledge. If you have knowledge with you and you are certain about the misguidance(s) of certain factions, then explain them to the people so that they may beware of them, and this is from sincere advice. He (sallallaahu alayhi wasallam) said, "The religion comprises sincerity of purpose" and we (the Companions) said, "To whom?" and he said, "To Allaah, His Book, His Messenger, the leaders of the Muslims and the common folk" (reported by Muslim, no. 55). Do not fear the people, upon you is to fear Allaah, the Sublime and Exalted, and explain to the people, refute falsehoood, and do not fear the people. Yes.
We can add here for further clarification the statement of Shaykh Rabee bin Hadee (Fataawa Ash-Shaykh Rabee' 1/246):
...Al-Jarh Wa At-Tadeel will remain until the day of judgement. The people want to benefit from this particular scholar and you inform them that this person is a noble scholar and upon the Sunnah so you praise him, and this scholar is Raafidee, this one is a Soofee who believes in Wahdatul Wujood (This is referring to the false belief that all in existence is a single reality and that everything we see is only aspects of the essence of Allah), this one is a secularist, this one is a communist who conceals his reality with Islam. This one is this and this one is that. It is obligatory upon you to clarify this; this is an obligation. This is a form of Jihaad and it will not cease and it is not specific to narrators.
Also the Salaf wrote [books] refuting the people of innovation as we have stated and they did not declare Al-Jarh Wa At-Ta'deel to be specific to the narrators alone. He is an innovator and is not from the people of hadeeth, [he is] Mu'tazilee, [he is] Jahmee, [he is] Murjee and so and so forth. He has no connection to any narrations but he is an innovator therefore they criticized him (Al-Jarh). So how can these people claim that the door of Al-Jarh is closed?
In another place the Shaykh said (Fataawa Ash-Shaykh Rabee' 1/249):
...The methodology of Al-Jarh Wa At-Ta'deel will not cease until the day of judgement as long as innovations are present.
Refer also to this article with another fatwa of Shaykh Saalih al-Fawzaan on this subject: Shaykh Saalih al-Fawzaan: The True and Real Fitnah is Leaving Alone the People of Falsehood and Evil and Remaining Silent About Them ..
Incredible!!
Barakallahu feeki
The main problem is most of the people are ignorant, and too much emotional too believe that their celeb Sheikh's can make mistakes
These Da'ee know its weak hadiths when studying them, bcuz they mention the hadiths, ppl take it as Sahih, and they dont mention it as weak or fabricated or broken chain ...while quoting it.
The problem is your's approach and theirs approaches to hadiths differs. you have to tell this too.
In short Albani makes it daef doesn't mean daef
For me, Any hadith written by muhadithins after they call it sahih to them as far as it doesn't contradict reason, Quran and established islamic principle, i have no problem to work on it.
So if you ask me if i am sure the prophet said that? I will say no i am not sure 100% and in reality you can't also be 100% sure any ahad or mutawatir hadith is verbatim word of the prophet.
The main problem is the ummah blindly following hadiths and anything with Muhammad's name attached to it.
The Qur'an is from God, it's complete and fully detailed. The hadith are from HUMANS, of course there is fabrication and falsehood.
@@ummzaynul370
*All hadiths from A to Z are Da'eef because no any Hadith was IN PERSON certified as SAHIH by Rasool and 4 Caliphs. For example, Bukhari fabricated his book 220 years after the death of Prophet, and his book is full of concocted blasphemous tales which insult great man 68:4 Mohammad, and mock Quran and Quranic Wahi, repeatedly. Those sectarians who follow this kind of extra-Quranic Books are misled by Iblis 38:82, 38:83, **14:22*
Subhanallah @@zayder-0406
Subhan Allah, some of these Hadith were narrated to me since childhood. May Allah guide us to the Truth.
Same! Ameen!
You are blessed with knowledge mashallah
Don't believe this person blindly...... Fabricated and weak hadees are two separate things.... Maudu'aat were compiled by scholars long before Albani......... Albani himself is a controversial figure, he died few years ago....... And Maudu'aat were written 7-800 years ago. In Fadail-e-Amal and Hikmat weak hadis are always allowed.
I am not saying that this person is lying because i haven't cross checked him but please don't believe him blindly........ Maudooat were already compiled by our earlier scholars like ibn ul Jawzi in separate books Name Mau'dooAat.... You can read Mau'dooAat (Fabricated hadees) from there and cross check it..... Secondly those books were also not 100% correct scholars made criticism over few hadees, still for a beginner it's very good book to read and understand...
Weak hadees and Fabricated hadees both are put in (Unauthentic category ) but rulings on implications is totally different because both are totally different things. One is weak because a scholar might have weak memory, or someone had doubted over his time period or existence. Etc etc...
Secondly weak hadees were always allowed in matters pertaining to Hikmat and Fadail-e-Amal, go and read Ibn Salah, Imam Ibn Haraj Asqali, Imam Ahmad Ibn Hanbal, Imam Abu Hanfia etc etc on this matter.
I am not saying that everything this person is saying is wrong... I am just warning you to don't believe unless u have cross checked. And please Don't Cross check from new generation like albani or uthayameen.... They themselves are controversial because Albani says even Sahih Bukhari has several weak Hadees. He omitted several Hadees from Adab-al-Mufrad, another book by Imam Bukhari...... Go to previous scholars who did great job 800-1000years ago.
@@arhamabdaal9205 firstly of sheikh al albaani is controversial then so is daraqutni and abu haatim ar razi and shubah ibn hajjaj.
Secondly they aren't always allowed in fadail aamaal
Thirdly you should only tell the weak hadith in this If the people understand the prophet didn't really say it.
Fourthly, the benefit should already be established
Jazakallah brother. That's how you put forth the correct view without disrespecting any of the speakers. Even I believed in many of these ahadith. May Allah reward you.
Glad i got this in my recommendations. Alhamdulillah. Jazakallahu khayr brother Omar
Jazak'Allah Khair brother Omar for this video on this very very important topic. May Allah SWT bless you and protect us from falling in this fitnah.
May Allah bless you.
I legit was expecting you to comment here mashallah
Ameen
aameen
Happy that I saw this video. This Attahiyatu hadith I didn't know it's fabricated! Jazak Allahu Khairan!
Wa iyyakum!
Thank you for bringing up such importent matter
I believed in most of those stories subhanAllah, May Allah reward you
This video is very important. Many young muslims blindly follow celeb shiekhs.
Not just young, old too but they watch the celeb sheikhs of their backhome countries
@@aaliyaaafreen firstly even in fadail aamaal they must already b established as well as the benefit. And it's not allowed to say the prophet pbuh said it rather it was reported that the prophet pbuh said. And is a people don't understand the diff then you shouldn't say it
Secondly ad daraqutni and ibn hajar al asqallani also criticized few few few ahadith in sahih bukhari.
Thirdly, no body ever said adab al mufrad was completely authentic
@@Bulayla1426 wait, bukhari was critized only for some negligible ahadith. And he won the argument mostly. Please word your sentences right
BaarakAllahu feek, just saying cause some laymen will overturn Bukhari cause there's supposedly some minor mistakes
@@mewzi yup you right I should
@@Bulayla1426 JazakAllahu khairan akhi. Fitan has risen these days. May Allah protect us
I am devistated. I used to listen to Nouman and Menk a sister told me to be careful and I checked on YT and came across this video I am confused now and so sad. May Allah guide these sheikhs and help us to gain true knowledge amin
Don’t be devastated, as they are humans who aren’t infallible. Stick to learning your deen from credible scholars, and verify everything you hear before accepting it. Baaraka Allahu feekum!
You cannot say that these men intentionally lied and they are not reliable... It is just a mistake (although needs to be corrected) and you will find no scholar without any mistakes... So do not multiply them by zero
@@mohdfaisal7990They are deviant liars who sugarcoat islam
@@mohdfaisal7990Jazakumullahukhayron
Just a suggestion, when you make these videos, please show some references, quations and maybe go a bit in detail why the certain hadith is weak or fabricated. As people who are new to the channel or just very unaware would think "who are you to say these are weak!".
Baaraka Allahu feekum akhi, I did mention references where applicable. The reality is that the burden of proof is upon the one who is claiming that a Hadith has a reference to provide it and if he’s claiming that it’s authentic to provide an authentic chain of narration.
@@omarchatila85 why have these shekihs who have large no. of followers haven't yet apologized for this yet. Is it not necessary for them to apologise.
@@aamirakhtar3911 who should they apologize to? If anyone, it is none other than Allah and then inform people what is right.
@@ryansn3600 Apologising to Allah is their personal matter. If they have said it in public then they should apologize for it in public. The least they can do is make an apology clip and upload it from their respective channels.
@@omarchatila85 You should share their Hadith no. so that even people can say which Hadiths are these or at least list the video o links.
Jazakallahkhair for the most important Dawah you are doing
Wa iyyakum!
I urge the scholars and people of knowledge of the hadiths to create an application where we can check the authenticity of a Hadith easily.
There are many
Islam 360
It is not the business of laymen to check the authenitcy of hadith. This field is based on ijtihaad, independent reasoning, its not clear cut. Its possible all of the hadith here are not considered to be fabricated by many muhadditheen.
@@youngomniverse35 what are you saying, may ALLAH have mercy on you. It is upon us to make sure what we share as laymen and say, is authentic.
@@The-servant-of-ALLAH1 Then tell me what are the conditions for determining the authenticity of hadith?
Scholars vary on what they consider to be authentic or not and what conditions they use to determine this.
Hafiz Ibnus Salah (rahimahullah) writes the following after defining the basic conditions for a Hadith to be classified as Sahih (authentic):
“Sometimes the scholars differ on the authenticity of some Hadiths. This could be the result of their disagreement on whether the above conditions are met. It could even be the consequence of their disagreement on the relevance of some of these conditions.”
(Muqaddimah Ibnus Salah, pg. 13)
Hafiz Ibn Taymiyyah (rahimahullah) writes in his book: “Raf’ul Malam”:
“The field of grading the narrators is vast, and the scholars may sometimes disagree on the credibility of the narrators just as the scholars of other branches of knowledge differ with each other.”
(Qawa’id fi ‘Ulumil Hadith, pg.49)
جزاك الله خيرًا كثيرًا يا عمر، رحم الله والديّ و والديك، ءامين
آمين! و إيّاكم أخي
BarakAllahu feek. May Allah make and keep your intentions pure, the work you do is valuable brother!
Ameen! Wa feekum baaraka Allahu akhi!
16:15 - 'I'd rather have them and anyone else be my opponent on the day of judgment, rather than have the Prophet Muhammad (pbuh) be my opponent because I did not protect and defend his sunnah and point out these lies that are being attributed to him'. Barakallahu feek for highlighting this point. May Allah swt accept your deeds, keep you sincere and makes us from the 70,000.
Wa feekum baaraka Allahu akhi! Ameen!
🗣
Dang. I was one of the people who was moved by the story of Abu Bakr and the old lady. I don't even know what to say now.
I second that
Alhamdulillah ALLAH guided us to show this narration was fabricated.
Subhanallah
I stopped trusting any of these celebrity scholars.. most of them lie on plain sight.. unbelievable
scholars of taghut
The Term of "Famous Speaker" fits perfect to this group of innovater!
May Allah(s.w.t.) bless for your efforts on this matter.
Jazak Allah khayr
2 dislikes? They prefer lies over truth or what?
Subhaanallaah, May Allah guide us to the right path. Aameen
I've been wanting to write a blog post/article about the same topic. Jazak'allah for the video brother. I really appreciate it. May Allah guide us all in the right path, Ameen
Can I see this?
Really, write a blog? what about you write a blog on your own mistakes. Send an email to them reminding them about the hadith with the reasons its weak or whatever, Arrogance is not a nice trait.
Brother Omar, may Allah bless you and keep you and us firm upon the truth, Aameen.
Thank you!!! This video deserves more views
It really was an eye opener for me, thank you for making this beautiful video, please keep on making such videos
Alhamdulillah. Baaraka Allahu feekum akhi!
A very needed video
Jazak ALLAH Khair ,very important topic
The Qur'an is the Most Truthful Hadith.
Yes indeed. And the most truthful Hadith, the Quran, commands us to follow what the Prophet ﷺ has instructed us to do.
SubhanAllaah. I didn't realise lying upon the messenger of Allaah was this widespread.
May Allaah guide us and them nad their followers.
May Allaah destroy the misguiders and the liars
May Allaah save us from lying upon Allaah and His prophet
May Allaah save us all from speaking without knowledge regarding His religion
May Allaah make us give the science of the authenticity of hadeeth its due importance
جزاك الله خيرا
As'salamu aleikum ya Omar, hayakallah. I think you need to make some videos regarding what fabricated ahadith are, and also explain what weak ahadith are, and why the content in a weak hadith can be true even though the chain is weak. So in sha Allah, my naseehah clarify these matters more, I see many confused in the comment section.
Hayak Allah, brother Omar! An extremely important video.
Baaraka Allahu feekum akhi!
May Allāh bless you brother Omar
Jazak Allahu Khairan Brother for pointing it out, It was much needed in the times of Celeb Sheikhs❤️
Defeating the purpose f these celebs ...
Jazaakallaahu khayran for continuing to raise awareness about the seriousness of sharing weak and fabricated ahadith.
How can I become an expert in Hadith Science?
First buy books on mustalah al hadith and then get a teacher of sunnah.
Learn Arabic to hear videos of some modern muhaditheen like wasiullah abbas, mashhoor ibn hasan and others
Start reading small books and build up. Be with friends that study it well
@@Bulayla1426 ok, jazak Allah khair. I will stert with Arabic in shaa Allah
It’s a long journey but to become an expert one definitely needs to know Arabic well enough as the vast majority of resources and books in the field are in Arabic.
That being said while you are learning Arabic you can also begin by learning the basics about the science of Hadith such as the terminology and just familiarizing yourself with the field, it’s books, etc.
@@ibnamanot
Mashallah
May Allah make you from the muhaditheen of this Ummah
جدك الله خيرا very important video
السلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته
*May Almighty Allah guide us to right path and knowledge*
subhanAllah, not expected from those scholars, Jazzak Allah khairen for making this video.
Wa iyyakum akhi!
It would be even better if you name the sources mentioning the status of these narrations with book title and number of narration or page/chapter depending on published version.
Many of them are baseless fabrications as I stated which aren’t mentioned in any of the books of Hadith. So such a reference doesn’t even exist for them.
@@omarchatila85 Can you please specify which ones are weak and which ones are fabricated or fake because I can not follow a scholar who quotes fabricated Ahadith. JazakAllah
The usual suspects! May Allah guide us all. These speakers should be very careful about this matter, they know that their videos are watched by millions of people, extra care should be taken in the matter of Deen.
Hahaha the usual suspects , that was epic 🤣🤣🤣
youre right these people in fact all of them are always doing something very weird NAK with the quran and his enterpritaion menk behind the scenes yaqeen nd evolution yasir qadhi being the "SçhOLar"of the world quoting shia books more fabricated hadith and talking about holes in narratives mind u this yasir clown graduated from madinah was a "salafi"and still quotes from abu mighnaf quotes more fabricated hadith about the prophetﷺ and his companions wife and who knows what else.hamza yusuf is sufi. And the other neverheard of him
Unfortunately many muslims trust the celebrity speakers more than scholars. If you tell them to list down the names of scholars they would probably know a few while if you ask them the names of famous speakers they wouldn't have enough fingers to count. May Allah guide us and keep us steadfast
what scarier is many also believe on random guy on youtube saying a hadith is fabricated
SubhanAllah, i remember how that umar suleman story made me cry 🤦🏼♂️
I remember watching this multiple times. It would motivate me. May Allah guide him or diminish his da'wah
Wait I just noticed. Did he just quote a maudu' hadith showing Umar was spying on Abu Bakr?
أعوذ بالله
Jazaka Allahu khairan, may Allah bless you and your family for spreading the truth... And keep up the beautiful work dear Usthad!
Assalamualaikum, how are you my brother, you call him an Usthad,he looks more like a jew to me,no signs of any Sunnah on him,even his moustache is over his lips,please verify his authenticity before accepting what he says is fabricated, if he is a man of integrity then he should personally approach all these scholars before refuting them,maaf if I have said anything to harm anyone ALLAH KNOWS BEST
@@khalidpadia9561 Seriously? "All these scholars"?? I would call them scholars for dollars, misguided deviant, celebrity speakers, people of whims and desires ... Who misguide and mislead the mosses...
How dear you call a Muslim brother a Jew? Rather, you're a person who's infected by the ignorance and falsehood of those heretics mentioned in this video... These whimsical speakers cast aspersions upon Islam, they ridicule Islam and spread diseases of deviation to the Ummah ... So, theses deviants are NOT scholars, rather, they're comedians and stage performers...
The condition in the Asian subcontinent is much worse!
May Allah reward you for your efforts in this life and hereafter. Aameen
جزاك الله خيرا
May Allah reward you for these beneficial videos
Good work.
Subhan Allah, Your work is commendable, Jazak Allah Khair Brother ❤
Plz try to contact them and inform them about their mistakes intentionally or unintentionally, so that they repent and ask forgiveness, May Allah guide us all and forgive us all, Ameen!!!
The biggest questions, is why do these speakers not fact check they're speeches and narrations they are using? And why when they speak out these narrations, they do not quote the sources and chains? Is it so hard to take a few minutes of your time to cite the source and chains?
Barak Allah feek for this video
May Allah Reward You Brother Chatilla
The Qur’an is fully detailed (mufassala) - Qur’an 6:114. It also contains the explanation for all things - Qur’an 16:89.
Do you understand Arabic?
@@omarchatila85you clearly don't
Way to evade the question! I actually do understand Arabic Alhamdulillah as it is my mother tongue. But I also don’t rely on my own limited knowledge, rather I learn from the actual scholars of Islam past and present.
Bukhari collected around 600,000 hadiths and only accepted around 7000 of them. Have some common sense. Scholars are normal people and they are in no way authorized to grease hadiths. Some weak hadiths are considered hasan today.
It doesn’t matter if I know Arabic as a language or not. What matters is that I have common sense to know that Allah never authorized these so-called scholars to grade Hadiths. The grading system of Hadiths is man-made.
In my opinion you guys are the people from whom we learn. Reach up to them and discuss will be more beneficial to us.
Jazakullah khair
Akhi amazing video. After finding out many things I was doing was not from the sunnah and that they were weak ahadiths I started looking into this topic deeper to understand my religion better and like you said the severity and importance of this topic. With that being said can you recommend a book or scholar who has spoken about this topic so that I may gain knowledge. Jazakumuallahu khayran
In Arabic there are a lot more resources akhi. In English unfortunately the resources are limited on this topic, but insha Allah I’m working on some things. In the mean time, feel free to check out the following series:
th-cam.com/play/PLr7GBSozm2hKmMybECg_xfk0zpcw4ON79.html
@@omarchatila85may Allah reward you and may Allah increase in knowledge and understanding in our religion. Thank you akhi
I can understand why people believe these because they’re nice stories but that’s what makes them the most dangerous
Subhan Allah!!!!
A yound girl in the comments shared that fabricated story 11:46 that Mufit Menk shared about the old lady.
I asked her if the hadith was authentic, and she said I dont know.
I wanted to find out if the hadith was authentic or not because I doubted its authenticity.
And Subhan Allah, today I found out! 💕
May Allah reward you
Thank you
MashaAllah. Brother, do you have the PDF of Al Bani's book?
السلام عليكم
Perhaps in another video you could clarify how weak hadith can be used for virtues and also how strong the weak hadith has to be in order to be used. I feel like the people of desires always pull this excuse when they get caught using weak hadith. Please clarify if you can. بارك الله فيك
Asalām-Alaykum. However, these mentioned Ahadīth are Mawdū (fabricated), not weak. The narrator has a defect and is known to lie, these are unacceptable. The weak Ahadīth has a different matter.
Jazakallah khairun sheikh
جزاك ألله خيرا يا اخى الكريم
Honestly Barak Allahu fikum to brothers like you, Sajid, Wajdi etc. I was ultra antagonist some months ago (you [rightfully] blocked me on twitter lol) and I was studying at bayyinah institute for about 10 years & listening to all these individuals... Allahu akbar.
I left the institute and unfollowed everyone. Thank you honestly, your efforts mean a LOT, they are currently having a major impact on my life. I am currently adhering to and studying the athari creed. May Allah grant you the highest reward and to your family. Salam aleykum
Wa feekum baaraka Allah! Thank you for your kind words. Alhamdulillah, all good is from Allah. May Allah keep you and us all steadfast upon the sunnah. I’m glad that you have started to learn the correct Aqeedah, but my advice to you is be mindful of who you learn your deen from as not everyone who claims to be following the correct methodology of understanding the Quran and sunnah is truly abiding by what they claim. So stick to well known and credible scholars such as sheikh Albani, Bin Baz, and Ibn Uthaymeen rahimahum Allah.
May Allah bless you and keep you firm upon the truth. Wa alaykum alsalam wa rahmatullah!
Ameen. Thank you very much for the advice @@omarchatila85 . I noticed that, some have ikhwani and others khariji tendencies. In shaa Allah I will, I started listening to their fatawa and bought their books (I purchased yours too). I started kitab at tawheed too. Barak Allahu fik.
Last question. Can I learn from Abdurahman Hassan and Tim Humble ? Because I just joined amau academy
I don’t know too much about them to be honest, but based on what I have seen from them, both seem to be credible duat calling to the sunnah. Keep in mind though that they aren’t scholars, and that they aren’t infallible and might make mistakes as we all do.
The best thing to do would be to learn Arabic, and seek knowledge from actual scholars, especially those who spent their entire lives calling to the sunnah, and died upon that. In the mean time, learn from the du’at who are calling to the sunnah in the English language, while keeping in mind what was mentioned above.
Hope this helps insha Allah. Baaraka Allahu feekum!
Very very helpful. I started arabic and I am making progress alhamdulillah. Then I'll learn from actual scholars like Ibn Uthaymeen, etc. I even changed my view about criticizing/rebelling against rulers, I was so ignorant subhan Allah, now I am called madkhali but it doesn't matter. I also showed your video to my husband (he listens to YQ) I pray Allah guides him, amin. Jazak Allah khair for everything!!!! @@omarchatila85 .
Alhamdulillah. Wa iyyakum!
Jazakallahu Khayran. I hope you make more of this in the near future.
Wa iyyakum!
The mufti menk story i’ve heard of it since i was 7
I need to watch more of your videos and also set a study routine to understand about hadiths further. Do you have a recommendation on how I can become more knowledge in this area? I’d like to know what is fabricated and what is sahih. It’s hard for the average layman like myself to point out these issues.
I can advise you to read Usūl Al-Hadīth. It is advanced but it explains many things and Allāh Knows Best.
Not our job
intresting that you are exposing them, i made a similar video...
just watched dr shabir ally talk about this video and came here
@@abz7800 brother I’d advise you to stay away from shabir aly and not take knowledge from him. He’s a Hadith rejector and doesn’t follow the guidelines set by scholars of Hadith since the time of the early scholars until today.
@@omarchatila85 idk because alot of islam comes from hadith but at the same time hadiths are not from god or preserved by god so may have false things or be fabricated . such example is the ruling for if you apostacise . yet the quran says theres no compulsion in religion its very hard to reconcile these verses without rejecting the hadith .
In the Quran, Allah commands us to follow what the Prophet ﷺ commands us. The authentic sunnah is part of Islam and has been preserved by Allah. Just because some ahadith are fabricated doesn’t negate the authentic ones which have been preserved.
@@omarchatila85 im not saying it negates and im not a hadith rejecter but i acknowledge when hadith contradicts quran ,then quran is to be followed like the example with the d penalty for leaving islam. furthermore allah commands us to follow the prophet but who is this us ? we have to distinguish who is the us because clearly some parts of the quran are addressed to only the people at the time of the prophet and not the rest of humanity but are just stories to learn ,from our perspective . also authentic doesnt mean its true for example if someone at the time of the prophet said the earth if flat it would be recorded as authentic narration but that doesnt mean its true all it means is someone said it humans may make mistakes in their knowledge as its the words of man not allah
How you are determining whether a Hadith contradicts the Quran or not? Is it based on your own personal understanding of what each is saying? With all due respect, using one’s own limited understanding of the Arabic language and of the texts from the Quran and sunnah to make such a determination isn’t appropriate.
The example you gave highlights that as there isn’t a true conflict between the two, only a perceived contradiction on your end.
The story mufti menk told, i actually know it since i was a child, heard it from a bunch of places.
Yes unfortunately that’s how wide spread some of these fabricated stories are.
I heard the hadith about abu Bakr and that old blind lady from a trustworthy student of knowledge a salafi from Holland. Real bummer i love it.
Are you sure ter is not one hadiht similar avout abu Bakr helping out this old blind lady?. Baraak Allah oe fik.
Yes akhi unfortunately this story isn’t authentic at all.
Alhamdulillah the authentic stories that we do have about their biographies are much better.
Wa feekum baaraka Allah!
Can you tell us the origins of the Hadith of the shaytan was sent to speak to rasul saaws which I’m told is also fabricated thank you brother as salami alaikkum
Wa alaykum alsalam wa rahmatullah akhi! Are you referring to this one?
hadithcheck.blogspot.com/2010/11/fabricated-interview-with-shaytaan.html?m=1
May Allah bless you Ameen. Pls put english subtitles or english auto generated subtitles
Brother it will be better if u explain these things with reference ....as these are the things which we used to hear since childhood..
And how we can find out which speaker is on truth as any person can make mistake somewhere or the other .
@Abeera Khawaja Reality of Mufti Menk
th-cam.com/video/enHawv4UIJE/w-d-xo.html
Maudooat, Fabricated hadees were already compiled by the scholars long back... Cross check it from there don't believe this person blindly....... Weak hadees were always allowed......
@@arhamabdaal9205 Please bring the reference for weak hadith being allowed.
Sister try to check for there aqidah as they will be fearful of ALLAH to narrate Unacceptable hadiths
@@Hashim_Naysapuri All the scholars from the past HAD CONCENSUS DAIF HADITHS ARE ALLOWED. Please don't come with these lies. Only the new scholars like ALBANI said it wasn't allowed but this is clearly a new statement. Dive in to history please.
Alhamdulillaah. As soon as i saw the thumbnail, i knew it was gonna be bad. I do not listen to a single person from that. Alhamdulillaah, Allaah has guided me to see the truth. May Allaah keep our hearts firm
Is there any specific book where can i get all fabricated hadiths??
@Fawaz Shaikh thats what iam asking a book where all lies and fabricated hadith are trashed , so that we can be aware of that and warn people
Mawdooaat of ibn al jawzi
Silsillah al ahadeeth ad daeefa wal mawdou of al albaani
Can you please add the references so that we can verify ourselves also?
My brother, all of them are normal human beings who make mistakes, only allah knows what their true intention, it could be that they didnt know the hadith was fabricated or have forgot it was fabricated, jazakallah khayrun for this video
Wa iyyakum akhi! As I stated in the video, the purpose was to highlight how widespread this problem is and to emphasize the importance of verifying Hadith authenticity before attributing something to the Prophet ﷺ. Baaraka Allahu feek!
@@omarchatila85 👍🏻
May Allah protect us from this Fitna.
This is so scary. Makes me wanna give dawah with whatever little knowledege I have but now after seeing your video I'm thinking to not do it or limit the amount of incidents I mention about the prophet PBUH since I may enter hell fire unkowingly despite all the good I do
Give dawah only about what you’re certain of. If you’re unsure about something, verify it and seek more knowledge about it first, then give dawah. Knowledge comes first before speech and action. Baaraka Allahu feekum!
@@omarchatila85 Jzkh for clearing it up sheikh. Makes more sense now
Brother how about bid3a can you plz answer Me
What about bid’a?
@@omarchatila85 is someone doin bid3a bad can we do a hassana bidaa like taraweeh
Subhanallah this is a dangerous disease which is widespreading among the ummah..
May Allah Protect Us from this and Guide us..
Whaaaat? I'm kinda shook but thank you for pointing out which are false!!
Can you please mention the name of the 5th speaker?
Assalamu Alaikum Warahmathullahi Wabarakathuhu
Wa alaykum alsalam wa rahmatullahi wa barakatuhu!
How do you know which one is authentic and which isn't? who gets to decide it?
Scholars of Hadith study and evaluate the chain(s) of narration to determine whether a Hadith is authentic or not. There’s a whole field of studying Hadith, it’s terminology, it’s authenticity, etc.
I will score this video 50.1%
It’s sign of end of times, I stop listening those mentioned long ago, specially YQ. Jazak Allahu khair brother Omar…
Kindly give is insight, aren’t they know that Hadiths are weak let alone fabricated ? On what basis that have narrate that?
Wa iyyakum!
It would be difficult to tell whether they knew these ahadith weren’t authentic and still went ahead and attributed them to the Prophet ﷺ. Allah knows best about their intentions, but even if we assume the best and that they weren’t aware, that still doesn’t excuse the fact that they’re callers to Islam and are falling into something this severe by attributing lies to the Prophet ﷺ which he never said.
Baaraka Allahu feekum!
@@omarchatila85 on point brother, that is my thoughts. As public speakers they should research more.
Wa feekum baaraka Allahu akhi!
That’s exactly why u should take from the big scholars I.e shaykh saleh al fawzan,al albani,taymiyyah,uthaymeen and so on.
I can't find the hadith about Eid Ed'ha, I found a (weak/fabricated) hadith that talks about good deads in the amount of the hair of the animal and not about forgiving sins.
That’s the one akhi. He even misquoted the fabricated Hadith.
@@omarchatila85
LOL
Ma Sha Allah, barakallah feek, I've heard some of these before and didn't even know they were fabricated. Interesting that the ones quoting the fabrications are people known to be on batil... Allahul musta'an, may Allah dispose of the lies attributed to Rasulullahﷺ - ameen
@@arhamabdaal9205 ya akhi, you know the difference between weak/daif and fabricated ahadith? He said none of them are from the known books of hadith like bukhari, muslim, ibn majah, tirmidhi etc.
Prove him wrong if you're truthful instead of sending essays you don't know.
@@arhamabdaal9205 yes, do you blame Shaykh Albani for pointing out the hadith in Bukhari saying that Rasulullahﷺ thought of comitting suicide after Jibreel aleihi salam appeared in the cave?
My advice to you akhi, learn the usool regarding ahadith before criticizing the ulema for their efforts.
We should respect the classical ulema for their efforts, but what you're advocating would leave you out from Allah's blessing of ulema.
Abu Hurayrah (may Allah be pleased with him) from the Messenger of Allah (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him), that he said:
“At the beginning of every century Allah will send to this ummah someone who will revive its religious understanding.”
Narrated by Abu Dawood (4291); classed as saheeh by as-Sakhkhaawi in al-Maqaasid al-Hasanah (149) and by al-Albaani in as-Silsilah as-Saheehah (no. 599).
I haven't critized him.... And what i said is 100% true, u r also accepting that Albani did those things..... Modern Salafis/Ahle Hadees believes in Albani but others school of thought have criticised him so i have just asked to go for much reliable source from previous generation......... And secondly i Have already said in first line that i am not saying this person is lying because I haven't checked, I have just asked to be aware and more cautious....... No were I said Albani did wrong or this scholar is doing wrong.... This video is available on Internet so people of Every Madhab will come and watch and they will take it otherwise also. And it will create more fitnah.
@@arhamabdaal9205 no you haven't spoken 100% true, you said weak ahadith are put with fabricated in the unauthenticated category. That's not true, a weak hadith only mentions its chain for those reasons you said but content of a saheeh and weak hadith can be same or similar however the chain of narration is weak, the narration can still be true. Weak and fabricated ahadith are miles apart akhi
And tell me one thing is Albani Infallible...???? Only he has all the knowledge...??? What he said is right and Imam ibn Hajar who defend Sahih Bukhari was wrong Nauzbillah.??? And the hadees which u quoted about A Mujadid, tell who can say that this particular person of this generation is Mujadid, every Maslaq treats their Head Scholar as Mujadid of this century.... And lastly is it written in any hadees to only believe in Albani and close eyes on other scholars.......... It us often said by almost all the scholars to go to earlier scholars for authenticity.... When we already have huge collection of earlier scholars i would choose to go to their book instead of reading Albani.
Omar ,what mathhab do you follow ?
are you a hadith scholor or a scholar ?
I do not follow one particular madhab akhi.
No I am not a scholar.
@Omar Chatila if one is not a scholar , you should follow a mathhab. As far as I know all Ahlus sunna Wal jama ulama follow a matthab. The four Imams trace their knowledge to the Prophet PBUH without an unbroken chain of transmission.
We have been give a golden spoon as far as Islam.
That is not true at all brother.
What madhab did the people follow before these 4 madhabs?
If all 4 imams trace their entire knowledge back to the prophet ﷺ with an unbroken chain of transmission, then why did they differ on so many issues? And why did some of their students differ with them? And why did they change their opinion on a matter sometimes?
This issue isn’t as over simplified as some would like to present it. Not to mention that there is no proof in the Quran or sunnah making it obligatory on someone to follow one of the 4 madhabs.
@Omar Chatila your argument is not accurate
Wahhabis talk exactly like this no offense
@Omar Chatila you cannot have Quran and sunna without the ulama
As a Sunni Muslim I do not follow the works of Abdillah ibn Wahhab or Ibn Taymiyya
Jazak Allahu khayra brother Omar. May Allah bring about change in speakers’ attitude to only narrate authentic Hadith, aameen. I seriously doubt though many will heed to you advise, because:
1. To most of them despite the seriousness of the issue it’s not a concern.
2. If and when you confront them they will blame it on the one they heart it from. Nauman Ali khan for example used this defense when he was refuted about the pokiman Hadith. But. he was undeterred, he continues to do that as you pointed out in this clip.
3. Their blind follower will always be there to cheer them on and will rather condemn the messenger such as yourself then to ever challenge them.
4. Using fabricated and daeef stories adds juice to their speech without which they think they will not be effective.
5. To ensure authenticity, they will need to spend more time in preparation which they are not prepared to afford.
6. Some speakers malign muhadditheen for causing confusion about classification of Hadith. Due to which they cast doubt over the science of Hadith.
I ask Allah to give tawfeeq to all speakers to do their due diligence and ensure status of the Hadith is authentic before referring to them in their speeches.
Does this fall under speaking about Allah without any knowledge
Does this means that one should rely on the sahih hadiths from the books and avoid listening ?
No it means you should only learn your deen from credible scholars rather than from duat who might not be verifying the authenticity of the ahadith they quote.
Reading books of Hadiths is good, but you can’t learn the deen independently on your own as you need to get the proper understanding of them from credible scholars.
@@omarchatila85
Thanks for your response and appreciated.
@@omarchatila85
What about Sahih al-Bukhari Hadith and Sahih Muslims ?
While Imam Bukhari and Imam Muslim set criteria to only include Authentic ahadith when compiling those two books/Sahihs, but the same thing applies regarding learning the proper understanding of those authentic ahadith from credible scholars rather than independently relying on one’s own understanding of them.
@@omarchatila85
Thanks for your response.