Janne Rasimus Hadith was invented to distract Muslims from the real religion and create a doctrine to make Muslims slave of their imamas and their ruler. Quran is complete and no need for Chinese whisper to fabricate a book to a point people started worshiping human being.
Recently I have been having a few doubts regarding some issues in Islam. After watching many debates between Non-muslims and muslims some disturbing thought weakening my Imaan lingered in my head. However, coming back to the Quran made me realize how beautiful and truthful Islam is and how Quran helps us eliminate those doubts we have and helps us to acquire Yaqeen (certainty) in our faith. Quran is truly a living miracle that everybody can benefit from and Indeed Quran is a timeless book and guidance and mercy for a mankind. Praise be to Allah and his messenger. Assalamu alaykum wa rahmatullahi wa barakatuh.
I'm glad I found ur comment. My idea was to speak to non-muslims and help myself get to teach Islam because their questions can open a wider concept and topics about things I may never learn and I have found many Christians with vast knowledge speaking things against Islam. It truly is affecting my brain and my intellect and I have a fear inbuilt in me of committing shirk. Deep down Ik this is the best religion no doubt but theirs a small part of me taking over this entire fact and is against my intellect. I am myself raising so many questions and unable to find the answers. How did you help yourself? I really do not want to get away from Islam or let Shayateen take over my belief.
@asshyy7580 I think what helped me a lot was to redirect my focus from constantly listening to debates and listening to the arguments of non muslims. What I did is that I directed most of my effort towards learning Quran and pondering over the words. Also, one of best things to strengthen Imaan is to pray Tahajjud and ask Allah to remove any doubts from my heart. Hope my answer will benefit. Assalamu aleykym
@@iamergashevshahzod Jazakallah Khair. It's my one desire to stand tall and be knowledgeable about Islam and deen so I can defend it. That is why I look up their questions to find answers to myself. Giving myself a hard time. But jazakallah, I will look up to your advice in shaa allah.
These are the verses of Allah which We recite to you in truth. Then in what „Hadith“ حَدِيثٍ after Allah and His verses will they believe? [Quran 45:06]
@Sukran C brother thank you for your response. I never felt more Iman until I turned my self to the Qur'an. There is so many books of hadiths that became a distraction from the Qur'an because Iblis misguided the ummah. No one feels and understands the true message of the Quran because our hearts had been sealed and our eyes don't see and our ears do not hear the ayat of this amazing book. The mountains can not stand still if the Qur'an was to be revealed to them so how come we don't feel it? The prophet ordered his companions never to write the hadiths and asked them to burn what they had written but you never hear this from the shaykhs because they hide it from you. Search it and see for yourself. How come the four caliphats also didn't allow anyone to write hadiths? Until 200 years later bukhari started writing them down.
@Sukran C In Sahih Muslim narrated on the authority of Abu Said Al Khudri, the prophet said “Don’t write about me and anything written about me other than in the Quran should be erased” and in the Sunnan of Al Tirmidhi also on the authority of Abu Said Al Khudri “We asked the Propher permission to write and he declined” and Ahmed Ibn Hanbal in his Musnad narrated from Abu Huraira said when the Prophet heard what they were writing he became angry and said “Books other than the book of God? Praise the book of God and be faithful to it”. Abu Huraira said we gathered everything we had written in one pile and set it on fire.
sacred609 that was just when the Quran was being revealed to avoid confusion...just like there was permission to drink alcohol which was then abrogated.
@@streetzboxa there is no abrogation in the book. This is a myth. If there was confusion in mixing hadiths with Qur'an in the beginning then how did that confusion stop before the revelation of the Qur'an was completed. What changed? This is another lie. This was an excuse to write books beside the Qur'an and divide the believers over these many hadith collections that try to compete with God's book.
Stop spreading confusion among muslims. Just go to a cave and dont share your twisted logic. People like you will held accountable for other astray muslims in the day of judgement.
I grew up listening to Hadiths, I would be left at the mosque as a kid on weekends and all we did was memorize it in Arabic never once being taught to understand what I am memorizing. I finally read it 4 years ago and every Hadith i heard growing up is not mentioned in Quran. I discovered the truth and that scholars use and interpret Quran by using hadiths. You don’t need a scholar to guide you, there is no compulsion in religion. Our messengers first word first verse he heard was, “READ, IN THE NAME OF YOUR LORD...” Allah is talking to YOU. So read Quran and discover the TRUTH.
You need hadith lmao. Without hadith you wouldn't know how to pray. Give me a verse where Allah teach us how to pray. Al quran is a book of signs. The teaching part is Prophet Muhammad's duty, the hadith, is his word
Raja Susana umayma you do not need Hadiths you think Muhammad was the first man to submit to Allah. You really believe that their is just one way to pray how did Abraham Moses Noah pray? They didn’t have Hadiths. Hadiths have divided this ummah you have sunní Shia Salafi Wahabbi muslims and why because one group believes in these Hadiths so they call Themselves Shia and the other group believes in these other Hadiths so they call themselves Salafi muslims but WE MUSLIMS all read Quran . Where do U see the word Shia Salafi or any of these sects of islam in the Quran. I don’t idolize Muhammad and I don’t follow what I hear or Hadiths that were written 300 years later after Muhammad and claim as the word of. God that is blasphemy And I don’t need a hadith to tell me how to bow down to my Creator and recite the words of Quran, people have been praying since the beginning of time. Keep believing your own lies. Keep assuming that Hadiths are true just cuz they tell you keep following what your parents follow and what you hear keep avoiding the Quran that’s all you do watch these videos and go tell someone what Islam is instead of reading Quran and applying it in your life
“Is it not enough for them that We have revealed to you the Book which is recited to them? Most surely there is mercy in this and a reminder for a people who believe” ( Al Quran # 29:51)
@@ridovercascade4551 we follow the Qur'an and believe in the sunnah* the Qur'an is the guide, the only hadiths we should consider are the sunnah hadiths, they give context to the Qur'an so we can understand
@c i think you are highlighting the point of IS IT NOT ENOUGH FOE THEM , in a sense that we dont need hadith bcs the is enough for us. I am not saying it was your intension, but it seems like. You know, bcs i have talked to some shia brothers early which uses only part of the quran in favor of thier argument but ignore other part of it.
thank you my brother for the knowledge! I'm so happy I found your videos my father/mother brought me here and told me I need to learn more about the Quran and Hadith I can't just pray and not know what I'm praying for so humdallah I'm learning a lot again thank you very much Ramadan Kareem.
Nouman Ali Khan, by just simply looking at the mankind history we can easily see that, people are changing prophets messages unless Allah protects them...And the only book Allah promised to protect is Quran, it really doesn't matter how trustworthy people they were who transmitted hadith. All the hadith we have now is a very good source for us to understand that era as a historical information. But we don't have to take them as a source of islam. Please consider this verse 43. Surah Az-Zukhruf ...44. And verily, this (the Qur'an) is indeed a Reminder for you (O Muhammad ) and your people (Quraish people, or your followers), and you will be questioned (about it)
+tolga yuksel I watched this and now i am even more sure that we should follow the Qur'an alone. This does not diminish the importance of the Prophet. Tolga it is also clear to me that people are people everywhere and everytime. They tend to corrupt systems. And Allah said he will protect Qur'an. Who is protecting hadith?
I think u have taken it as Nouman is saying "Ahadith are equally authentic as Quran is" . No. He has just tried to tell (with logical arguments) that Ahadith cannot be ignored. As God has not promised to protect Ahadith, u need to validate the authenticity and understand the context before acting upon it.
Usman Khan the hadiths are damaged goods. No amount of wondow dressing or sugar coating can remedy them. They are not even worth the effort. A real embarrassment is what they are!
@@TahmidMiah-ry6gs Science? How does Bukhari know the first person in the chain actually said those things. He was just told by the last person in the chain.
It's interesting that bukari was seventeen or so when his mother took him to travel in pursuit of narrations.He was born 194 A.H so this would make it approximately two hundred and twenty one or so years later to establish the "Sahih' hadith.The others such as Muslim came even later. Wouldn't God had mentioned it rather then to say he completed the religion or he has fully detailed everything.Perhaps God forgot to tell us that there would be someone in the future to come and explain what God "MEANT".God also mentions that we would see many contradictions in their narrations.Perhaps that's why there are so many mathabs each claiming being the rightly guided.
Kindly bear patience to read the whole message inshaAllah. Upon learning the Quran and learning from people with knowledge of the Arabic language, I have come across only 3 prayers mentioned by name in the whole Quran. They are: 1- Salat Al-Fajr (Dawn Prayer)24:58 2- Salat Al-Isha (Night Prayer)24:58 3- Al-Salat Al-Wusta (The Middle Prayer) 2:238. We don't see salat al-dhuhr, or salat al-asr or salat al-maghrib mentioned in the Quran. Salat Al-Dhuhr is actually Salat Al-Wusta (The middle prayer) where there prayer begins when the sun starts to decline from its highest point (at noon), and 2 falsely added salat practiced by people are Asr and Maghrib. The question is: If the prescribed prayers are indeed five per day, why does the Quran have only three named salat? The following explanations and their merits are put forward: 1- The names of the other salat are not in the Quran because the Quran does not contain all the details. This is a false claim because God tells us in the Quran, 6:114, "Then is it other than Allah I should seek as judge while it is He who has revealed to you the Book explained in detail?" & 17:12, “And everything we have explained in detail” & 41:44, “And if We had made it a non-Arabic Qur'an, they would have said, "Why are its verses not explained in detail?” & 6:38, “We have not neglected anything in the book” 2- God forgot to mention the other two names of salat! This option is also false, God does not forget: 20:52, "The knowledge thereof is with my Lord in a record. My Lord never errs, nor does He forget." 3- God did not mention the names of the other 2 prayers because God wants us to guess them! Once again this is false. The Quran is unambiguous and is not a book of puzzles: 12:1, "Alif.Lam.Raa. These are the signs of the clear book" 4- God does not mention the names of the other 2 salat because God they can be found in the hadith. This is a false claim since we are commanded not to uphold any source of law other than the Quran (6:114, 7:3 and 5:48). We are also commanded specifically not to believe any hadith other than the Quran: 45:6, “These are God's revelations which we recite to you truthfully. In which Hadith other than God and His revelations do they believe?” The fact that God (The All-Wise) used the words “in which hadith” is very significant. In Islam we don’t judge according to what we assume or what the majority follows. We judge according to what Allah has revealed. Even by obeying prophet Muhammad as Allah has decreed in 47:33, “O you who have believed, obey Allah and obey the Messenger and do not invalidate your deeds”, remember that prophet Muhammad has said in the Quran 10:15 and 46:9, “I only follow that which is revealed to me”. The sunnah of sahih bukhari and sahih muslim, even from how they read from the way they are structured, they are not from what Allah has revealed. “Someone said that they heard from someone else who heard from someone else that prophet Muhammad said……”………Really?.......How do you prove that what the people along that chain said is true without giving witnesses as proof? 24:13, “Why did they [who slandered] not produce for it four witnesses? And when they do not produce the witnesses, then it is they, in the sight of Allah , who are the liars.” Anything which contradicts the words of Allah in the Quran is not part of Islam. In hadith we’re told to kill the apostates, whereas in the Quran, Allah has revealed that there is no compulsion in religion in 2:256. Do you take hadith over the Quran? No, a Muslim does not do that. A Muslims only guide to live by Islam is the Quran from Allah. 6- God does not mention the names of all the salat since they came to us through inherited rituals, and because God wants us to follow what we inherited from our parents even if it is not found in the Quran! Once again a claim that violates the Quran. 2:170, “And when it is said to them, "Follow what Allah has revealed," they say, "Rather, we will follow that which we found our fathers doing." Even though their fathers understood nothing, nor were they guided” 7- God does not mention the names of the other 2 prayers because He did not reveal to us those two other prayers in the Quran. For positive change, we should start by engaging in peaceful talks about such matters and to not let ourselves be deceived into thinking that 'we can't have been wrong all this time, not with the over 1.5 billion Muslims in the world'. That is a wrong mentality for a Muslim, and we don't want to neglect centuries of doing a mistake to affect us eternally in the next life, so let us act to help change the situation now. Let us begin with sharing the word through Islamic events and even on social media and let us not allow for people to be shut off from voicing out such matters. Allowing them to voice out such matters helps us to process the information and identify where we have gone wrong so that we can then act to improve ourselves. I pray that Allah makes it easy for all of us and that He grants us all goodness in this life and in the next life, and are saved from the hellfire.
Yes there are five prayers in the Quran. Brother don’t lead people who are already in doubt astray. Here is proof. Quran 11:114 24:58 states fair Quran 17:78 and 30:18 states zuhr 2:238 states asr, asr is the prayer seen by god 11:114 is Maghrib And 24:50 says isha So please next time read the Quran more careful
Ya Boy The verses you provided doesn’t mention the prayers you’re defending. You don’t lead the people astray from their 3 daily prayers. May Allah be pleased with all whom follows he Quran.
zubair 99 The time for mahgrib according to any prayer times in any country, Mahgrib is not the end of the day. So that also proves you’re wrong. Again, The Quran only mentions 3 prayers, but because modern day Muslims have been following these traditions for so long everyone’s going to just do it and not research it for themselves. in the Quran when it clearly and obviously mentions 3!
zubair 99 Also to add, If it were 5 prayers they would be mentioned by name in the Quran, Fajr, Wutsa & isha are mentioned. Mahgrib Dhur & asr were added over time by so called Islamic scholars. I follow the word of Allah, not the word of man. Astagfirullah!
K B go through this ayah.. البتہ تمہارے لیے رسول الله میں اچھا نمونہ ہے جو الله اور قیامت کی امید رکھتا ہے اور الله کو بہت یاد کرتا ہ. Surah Al ahzab ayah no.73
It's not that people don't want to obey the Prophet, they just don't want to obey the books where every saying of the Prophet is "hearsay". If the Prophet talked to me face to face, I would obey him, but I just can't trust the books that were transmitted through tens of people. How many times do you think they would have changed the words or meaning? If Quran was transmitted the same way then you would see multiple versions of surahs, but that's not the case.
And We revealed to you [O Muhammad] the message [Qur’an] that YOU MAY MAKE CLEAR TO THE PEOPLE what was sent down to them and that they MIGHT GIVE THOUGHT. (Qur’an 16:44)
Your own sunni translation of The Quran: An-Nahl 16:43 وَمَآ أَرْسَلْنَا مِن قَبْلِكَ إِلَّا رِجَالًا نُّوحِىٓ إِلَيْهِمْۚ فَسْـَٔلُوٓا۟ أَهْلَ ٱلذِّكْرِ إِن كُنتُمْ لَا تَعْلَمُونَ And We sent not before you except men to whom We revealed [Our message]. So ask the people of the message [i.e., former scriptures] if you do not know. An-Nahl 16:89 وَيَوْمَ نَبْعَثُ فِى كُلِّ أُمَّةٍ شَهِيدًا عَلَيْهِم مِّنْ أَنفُسِهِمْۖ وَجِئْنَا بِكَ شَهِيدًا عَلَىٰ هَٰٓؤُلَآءِۚ وَنَزَّلْنَا عَلَيْكَ ٱلْكِتَٰبَ تِبْيَٰنًا لِّكُلِّ شَىْءٍ وَهُدًى وَرَحْمَةً وَبُشْرَىٰ لِلْمُسْلِمِينَ And [mention] the Day when We will resurrect among every nation a witness over them from themselves [i.e., their prophet]. And We will bring you, [O Muhammad], as a witness over these [i.e., your nation]. And We have sent down to you the Book as clarification for all things and as guidance and mercy and good tidings for the Muslims.
Make clear, is actually reveal in arabic. Be carful of translations. ANd yes, a prophet reveals Allahs message to the people. Why7 would Allah swt say he made the Quran clear and then contradict himself here?
The words in 4:65 are addressed to prophet Muhammad. These words have been misinterpreted to claim 3 matters: 1- That the prophet of God is a lawmaker besides God whose law must be obeyed. 2- Since the source of any laws authroised by the prophet are found in the hadith, then the words in 4:65 compel all believers to follow the hadith as a second source of law besides the Quran. Ultimately, those who do not accept and follow the hadith are in breach of the instructions in 4:65.3- The promoters of this line of thought also claim that the words "they are not believers" mean that those who do not accept the hadith as a source of law are in fact disbelievers. Before analysing the words in 4:65 it is necessary to be reminded of the definition given by God for a believer. The definition is given in 2:285: The messenger has believed in what was brought down to him from his Lord, and so did the believers. They all , His , His and His : "We do not distinguish between any of His messengers", and they said, "We hear and we obey. Forgive us, our Lord. To You is the ultimate destination." 2:285 A believer is the one who believes in God, the angels, the Scriptures and the messengers of God. Nowhere in the Quran is the belief in hadith a requirement for being a believer. In fact, the Quran prohibits the acceptance of any hadith other than the Quran which is described as the best hadith: These are God's revelations (Quran) that We recite to you with truth, so 45:6 God has brought down ; a Book containing similarities and pairs. 39:23 ? 7:185 So ? 77:50 Now we need to look at the words in 4:65 closely: The words "until they make you judge" clearly indicate that the instructions in 4:65 applied to the time of the prophet and not today, for how can we expect a dead man to judge our ? Let us say two men disputed among themselves with regards to some conditions or terms of a joint business arrangement, how can they go to the grave of the prophet to ask him to arbitrate between them? The message we derive from 4:65 is that the believers who lived at the time of the prophet were instructed to place their trust in the prophet to judge among them . The words continue to instruct the believers to accept the verdict of the prophet wholeheartedly. Their faith in his verdict is a reflection of their belief in him as the messenger of God. Most importantly, to fully understand the message in 4:65, we need to know how the prophet of God judged between the poeple. The Quran gives us the exact method by which God instructed prophet Muhammad to use to judge between his people: We brought down to you (O Muhammad) the Book with the truth in accordance with what God has shown you, and do not be an advocate for the betrayers. 4:105 The words in 4:105 confirm the clear instruction given to prophet Muhammad. He was commanded by God to that was brought down to him to judge between the people. The same command to use the Quran to judge between the people is repeated in Sura 5: And with truth, confirming what came before it of the Scripture and superseding it. , and do not follow their personal desires in place of what has come to you of the truth. 5:48 For the importance of this command, it is immediately repeated in the verse that follows: And . 5:49 In fact, using God's Book to judge between the people was the method God prescribed to and not just prophet Muhammad: The people used to be one nation, then God sent as bearers of news and as warners, and . 2:213 The above words define the exact method prophet Muhammad used to judge among his people in their differences. He used the Book of God as his sole guidance, just like God commanded him, to judge people's disputes. It follows that to know the Quran is to know how prophet Muhammad judged. To claim that we need the verdict of stories written more than 200 years after the prophet died (hadith), when it is clear that prophet Muhammad used the Quran as his sole guidance is not only unjustified, but is totally misleading.
As for those who harbour deviation in their hearts, they pursue the multiple-meaning verses seeking to cause discord and seeking to interpret it. 3:7 In 3:7 we read that the Quran contains two types of verses. The first type of verses are the clear-cut verses (muhkamaat). As long as no foreign words are added to the interpretations of the clear-cut verses, they support only one clear meaning. The clear-cut verses are all the law-giving Quranic verses in the Quran. We will be held accountable to obeying the law in such verses, and so God would not phrase such verses in any uncertain manner. The second type of verses are the verses which can support more than one meaning (mutashabihaat). There are a number of reasons as to why God placed such multiple-meaning verses in the Book. The reason that concerns us in this specific research is that in such verses, God instilled a test for the people. Will they adhere to the meaning that conforms to the message of the Quran, and which is derived from Quranic evidence, and which is in harmony with other Quranic verses? Or will they seek a manipulated meaning that serves the non-Quranic ideologies of the reader? We should remember at this point that God informed us that He guides some people with the Quran and at the same time, God misguides some people, also with the Quran: As for those who believe, they know that it (Quran) is the truth from their Lord. As for those who disbelieve, they say, "What did God intend with that example?" He misguides many with it (Quran), and guides many with it (Quran), but He does not misguide with it except the wicked. 2:26 In the majority of cases, the mis-interpretations were a result of the scholar's attempt to uphold non-Quranic sources (hadith, culture, innovations, etc) which are not in harmony with the Quranic verdict in those verses.
Assalamualaikum brother, just wanted to clarify something, so do you reject any rules/regulations that was set even by his companions outside of prophet muhammad's (pbuh)?
@@elangz9201 walaikom assalam dear brother. why i should follow books that are contradicting with the holy quran and that contains mostly false stories?? isn't quran perfect? Allah says Quran is fully detailed and it contains everything, nothing left out of it. then should we seek man made false hadiths other than Quran as our religious guidence??
@@DiscoverHealth ah i see. I saw the comments below, and its really an intresting argument tho. It makes me intrested to learn for myself the history of the hadith itself. So if i may ask brother, hows your routine as a muslim? If you dont mind me asking ofcourse. How do you pray, do zakat, iedl fitr, iedl adha, etc etc. Would like to hear much from you, thank you very much 🙏
I simply not interested to enter in this debate. But one thing I have noticed. Just because of Ahadees, we have so many fracture in Islam. Sunni, Shia, Berivlve, Doubandi, Dancing Islam, Musical Islam, Qabr Poja Islam. +++++, they always find some Hadees to back their claim. Had muslims only followed Quran as ordered by Allah swt and Rasool Allah saw, there would have no or few cracks in Muslims today. Also, now-a-days almost all Ahadees are created by Yajoj (British) if you know this.
What’s even more ironic without Hadiths, Seerah and scholarly traditions you wouldn’t have the Quran 🤦🏾♂️. So be quiet “Quranist” and go play in the sand with the other western liberals
Say, [O Muhammad], "If you should love Allah, then follow me, [so] Allah will love you and forgive you your sins. And Allah is Forgiving and Merciful." Al-Quran 3:31 Say, "Obey Allah and the Messenger." But if they turn away - then indeed, Allah does not like the disbelievers.Al-Quran 3:32
Mahmood Ashraf salaam good morning may I recommend quranite.com his name is Sam Gerrans wonderful man with very good knowledge of the arabic language and quran his videos are on TH-cam you will be enlightened and benifit a great deal his translation you can download for free or buy from amazon or his website the quran a complete revelation watch his video on muhammad was not from mecca amongst others that will clear up everything about hadith corruption and fabrication including his seerah biography. also search dan Gibson searchformecca.com to know the facts about muhammad being a messenger from petra city. the film the sacred city is a film I would also recommend you watch to find out the facts.
K Bob Shut the fck up. It is westernizers or non Muslims who come in the fold of Islam to destroy it or make it liberal, kinda like how the old people of the scripture did. No one cares about your Sunnah rejection, it was foretold by us by the messenger. So go away and quit trying to press these views that this deviated religion only came out 200 years ago.
Verse 20:90 says that Harun (brother of Moses) says to his people: fattabi'ooni (follow me) which is the SAME word which is used in verse 3:31! So, does that mean the children of Isreal had to follow the Sunnah of Harun???? You know, eat, drink, dress, and pee like me??
السلام علیکم یہ سیشن قرآن و حدیث کے علم، تحقیق، اور حقیقت کی تلاش کے لیے بنایا گیا ہے۔ یہاں پہ کچھ طلباء اکٹھے ہو کے قرآن کو پڑھنے، سیکھنے، سمجھنے، تفکر، تدبر، کرتے ہیں۔ اور صرف قرآن کو لاریب سمجھتے ہیں۔ اس کی پریکٹیکل حکمت عملی اور سٹریٹیجی ڈسکس کر کے نظام کو عمل میں لانے کی کوشش کرتے ہیں اور اپنی زندگیوں میں متروک ہو جانے سے بچانے کی کوشش کرتے ہیں۔ سیشن کا لنک گوگل میٹ پہ جنریٹ کر کے روز مغرب کے بعد سینڈ کر دیا جاتا ہے۔ جس کے بھی دل میں قرآن سیکھنے، سکھانے، تدبر، تفکر، عمل کی خواہش ہو وہ سیشن جوائین کر سکتا ہے۔ گروپ کا لنک بھی دیا گیا ہے اور سیشن کا لنک روز گروپ میں بھیج دیا جاتا ہے۔ اوقات: مغرب تا عشاء، مغرب کی ادائیگی کے بعد سیشن شروع ہو کے عشاء تک رہتا ہے۔ اس گروپ کا مقصد ہماری روزمرہ زندگی کے معاملات کو قرآن و حدیث کی روشنی حل کرنا ہے۔ کوئی ایک ایسا معاملہ نہیں ہے جس پر قرآن و حدیث میں توجہ نہ دی گئی ہو۔ یہاں آپ اپنی روزمرہ کی زندگی کے تمام مسائل شیئر کر سکتے ہیں اور قرآن و حدیث کی روشنی میں ان کے حل پہ بات بھی کر سکتے ہیں۔ ہم قرآن کو صرف سے سمجھنے کی کوشش کرتے ہیں یاد رکھیں کہ بحث کا مقصد سیکھنا اور بڑھنا ہے، دلیل جیتنا نہیں۔ chat.whatsapp.com/FA8H826pXHJ61qWfKnY28B
Nouman Ali Khan states that" to question hadith is to question the Quran" One must stop him right in his place. When we know for a fact that hadith have major clear contradictions, flaws and go against the Quran! In some instances blatantly. . If we see the Quran being clear on an issue that is contradicted by a hadith, which do we obey?? To people like Khan, anyone who rejects a hadith that contradicts the Quran is accused of attacking the Sunnah. Surah 25: Verse 4, Oh my lord, truly my people have abandoned this Quran”. Consequently to those who follow writing other than the Quran, the verses have become…a book of mysteries and Symbols. So much so that many Muslims have become fearful of misinterpreting the Quran, when Allah has told us that he has made it easy. 54:17- “we have certainly made the Quran easy for remembrance” .You can’t say things like well, yea, Allah said that it was easy BUT we don’t believe it, this is haram and even Blasphemy. We must approach this matter as students’ and not teachers. Most who teach the Quran approach it as if being teachers of the book instead of the book being their teachers. If reading a poem in school for example, we spend a month on it trying to figure it out and understand. And if we read the Quran we rush through it a few minutes and put it away. This is wrong! Allah has even commanded his prophet: (75: 16-17) “Do not move your tongue with it in haste, it is upon us to collect it and promulgate it” 47:24- “do they not reflect upon the Quran, or are there locks upon their hearts”. 2: 256-“there shall be no compulsion in religion. The right course has become clear from the wrong” The only Quranic penal codes in life are those regarding murder, corruption and aggression. Now, regarding the punishment for apostasy, it was included by the jurist because the authority wanted to treat ANY OPPOSITION AS APOSTATES! That’s how Ja’ad Dirham was killed as well as other reformers such as Jahm ibn Safwan in both the Umayyad and Abbassid era’s had people killed in name of heresy. We put the word of man who has been shown to have errors and contradiction in the hadiths over the Quran??? We must look at the hadiths matn( meaning) before it’s sanad( chain of narration) and WE MUST LOOK AT THE QURAN BEFORE THE HADITH. IT IS THE QURAN THAT GUIDES TO THE UPRIGHT PATH AND THE ABOSLUTE TEXT WHICH ALLAH HAS COMMANDED US TO PONDER, THEY DON’T PONDER! The hadithers will dismiss 50 verses in favor of a questionable hadith. Deviants who don’t even know. We’ve put the Quran at the bottom and glorified the Bukhar, Nawawi, and Ibn Hajjar, as they are angles. When in fact they are poor men, and with known whims, flaws, and didn’t always hit their mark. Who so ever wishes to strike us, we shall strike him by the Quran, and if they choice to be humble then we shall be humble. The followers of the Quran have not been given a chance, There are followers of the companies and the prophets family, ( Sunni & Shia) but the Quran has a minority of true followers who had not been given a chance across history to reveal the Quran and what Allah has truly revealed. Consequently to those who follow writing other than the Quran, the verses have become…a book of mysteries and Symbols. This is a misconception that to reject hadith you reject "Sunnah" and this is false. There's no proof of this for many reasons. The people of hadith and their supporters who exaggerate in protecting the Sunnah….The argument isn't in regard to the authenticated words of the prophet, but in regards to WHAT THEY CLAIMED TO BE AUTHENTIC. Why? Because the Quran says' " I only follow what is revealed to me" 7:203. On that very clear and straight forward point, the Quran advocates freedom of belief, while there is a hadith narrated by Ikrimah to kill the apostate. Also, Allah Mentions in 4:123 “Paradise is not obtained by your wishful thinking nor by the people of the scripture. Whoever does a wrong will be recompensed for it” However, in Sahih Muslim, the hadith narrated by Abi Baraddah says, “ that in the day of judgement each Muslim will be redeemed from hell by sacrificing a Jew or Christian” How does anyone in their right mind think this oppressive hadith is from Allah and compares to Quranic Justice?? It’s important to understand that the people of hadith have further complicated and matters and distorted the truth by neglecting the important central issue in the Quran, the spirit of Islam such as knowledge, justice and honesty to Allah. In all six books, not a single section about the intellect despite its prevalence in the Quran, nor are there any section about justice, knowledge use of sense or honesty to Allah, despite their prevalence in the Quran. They got preoccupied with made up details. I wouldn’t say ALL hadiths but MOST hadiths that are being circulated on people’s tongues. If you hear a preacher mention 100 hadith’s then know that 90 of them are falsely attributed to the prophet and 10 MAY by authentic. And if you hear 10, it’s also the same. Why? They don’t examine the hadith by the Quran and the authenticate hadiths’ that contradict the Quran, the mind, the freedom and the principles. If we see the Quran being clear on an issue that is contradicted by a hadith, which do we go by? To people like Khan, anyone who rejects a hadith that contradicts the Quran is accused of attacking the Sunnah. To the people of Hadith, the Quran as become marginal source. The Quran has become their lowest source. They claim that it’s not but it most certainly is. Allah ordered us with honesty, And Allah as commanded honest in saying “be with those who are truthful” 9:19 Therefore, the Quran is light and the light self-revealing and does not need someone to reveal it. All matters that are discussed in the Quran about human rights, justice, forgiveness, honesty to Allah, knowledge and its standards are not prevalent in the Hadiths and in some instances deserted. The narratives in the hadith were established under authorities most often, the biggest narrators have flourished amidst oppressive authorities. Matters have gotten so far out of touch that in the Fatiha, “ not of those who evoked your wrath or of those who are astray” 1:7 are Jews and Christians. This isn’t from allah, it’s the prejudice of those people who make those claims in the hadith. The people of Hadith have reduced the Quran to a secondary source despite boasting about it. Therefore we must restore the spirit of the Quran. Why did the Islamic Ummah become the weakest in intellect and the most obtuse and alienating human rights? Because the narration prevailed over the spirit of the Quran over the knowledge and intellect. Allah states in the Quran, “don’t you think” is mentioned far more in the Quran than “don’t you believe” Why is there not a single book about use of intellect across our entire history? Therefore, it’s up to us now to bring back knowledge of the Quran, the truth, and rid of these oppressive writings in hadith and open our minds to the science and the worship of Allah exclusively and to message of Allah in his Quran.
Movefasta Bro lol so tell me how do you know how to pray? How do you know whether isha is 4 and not 1? How do you know how to pay zakah or about ritual bathing (ghusl). For the record that verse that you so happened to pluck out, it’s actually not talking about what yall think, but you’d have to study Arabic to understand what I’m talking about. Not modern colloquial Arabic but fus-ha (Classical Arabic) as the same words mean different things dependent on the context. So first and foremost study the Quran and read it’s proper explanations (science of tafsir) and study them, not take translations off an app or google, and then actually study the science of Hadith. You’ll be amazed at how much of your religion is actually based off of ahadith as allah told us to follow the sunnah of the prophet. The Quran doesn’t go into detail in much like how do we know the prophets wives names etc. So my advice to all of you brothers n sisters is to actually study the sciences of the Quran and ahaadith and your queries will be answered
God CONDEMNED any other Hadith than the Quran for religious laws, and He called His Book, QURAN, the BEST Hadith. God called on the believers to follow only His Hadith, the Quran, and so did Prophet Muhammad, as he was prohibited from saying any other statement other than what God revealed to him in the Quran. Therefore, with respect to you Mr Nouman, I apologize that I couldn't agree with you when you said that "you cannot separate these two entities", that the Prophet's personal words and God's revelation are intertwined together. This encourages the propagation that Hadith books written by humans are valid. To me, they are from two different sources. Quran is from God and the Hadith books are fabricated by His creations. As you said it yourself, you can tell when someone is speaking for himself or copying others; just like when you read the Quran and when you read the Hadith books. If you analyze it carefully, you will definitely notice the distinct difference in content, since the substantive information is in contrast to its actual manner of presentation. God willing. I seek refuge in God from Satan the damned. In the name of God, the Gracious, the Merciful. Most of them follow nothing but assumptions; and assumptions avail nothing against the truth. God is fully aware of what they do. (Quran 10:36) Say, "I am not different from the other messengers; and I do not know what will be done with me, or with you. I only follow what is inspired in me, and I am only a clear warner." (Quran 46:9) And when Our clear revelations are recited to them, those who do not hope to meet Us say, "Bring a Quran other than this, or change it." Say, "It is not for me to change it of my own accord. I only follow what is revealed to me. I fear, if I disobeyed my Lord, the torment of a terrible Day." (Quran 10:15) Some verses examples: God has sent down the BEST of narrations: a Scripture consistent and paired. The skins of those who reverence their Lord shiver from it, then their skins and their hearts soften up to the remembrance of God. Such is God's guidance; He guides with it whomever He wills. But whomever God leaves astray, for him there is no guide. (Quran 39:23) Have they not observed the government of the heavens and the earth, and all the things that God created, and that their time may have drawn near? Which message, besides this, will they believe in? (Quran 7:185) Among the people is he who trades in distracting tales; intending, without knowledge, to lead away from God's way, and to make a mockery of it. These will have a humiliating punishment. (Quran 31:6) Most of them follow nothing but assumptions; and assumptions avail nothing against the truth. God is fully aware of what they do. (Quran 10:36) These are God's Verses which We recite to you in truth. In which message, after God and His revelations, will they believe? (Quran 45:6) So let them produce a discourse like it, if they are truthful. (Quran 52:34) So leave Me to those who reject this discourse; We will proceed against them gradually, from where they do not know. (Quran 68:44) And when Our Verses are recited to him, he turns away in pride, as though he did not hear them, as though there is deafness in his ears. So inform him of a painful punishment. (Quran 31:7) Or do you have a scripture in which you study. (Quran 68:37) In what message, beyond this, will they believe? (Quran 77:50) God cites the example of a man shared by partners at odds, and a man belonging exclusively to one man. Are they equal in status? Praise be to God, but most of them do not know. (Quran 39:29) Those who prohibit what God never did in the Quran, will be surprised on Resurrection Day when the messenger of God WILL complain to Him about them: And the Messenger will say, "My Lord, my people have abandoned this Quran." (Quran 25:30) And God has reminded those who are unsure on how to deal with polytheists and hypocrites who follow other laws not authorized by God: What is the matter with you, divided into two factions regarding the hypocrites, when God Himself has condemned them on account of what they did? Do you want to guide those whom God has led astray? Whomever God leads astray-you will never find for him a way. (Quran 4:88) It was not easy for Muslims to decide how to deal with such people who called themselves "Muslims" but they were actually mushriks and hypocrites. Some were of the opinion that since they professed Islam, performed prayers, fasted and recited the Quran, they could not be treated as unbelievers. Here God pronounces His judgement on this issue. I'm sorry that I need to let you know my take on this. I admire your wonderful efforts in promoting Islam, you're a kind intellectual who have such a beautiful personality and you're still on my top list of lecturers. ☝☕🍰 May the Almighty pardon us, bless us, and guide us all. Peace be to you.
What happens when we stop believing the fairy tales named "hadiths" ? The so called "scholars" lose their academic advantage. A Muslim only has to read the Quran. He does not need to read the thousand of insanities contained in the hadiths books.
***** Assalammualaikum. Thank you for your time responding to my comments. I appreciate it, but in accordance to verified facts, I have to disagree with you. First of all, how could you say that I'm rejecting the Quran when the Quran is my ONLY source of guidance? It doesn't make sense at all and it's a little too much to compare me to "an extremist beyond that of ISIS" don't you think? To me, that is totally uncalled for. Perhaps you have not thoroughly read the Quran to comprehensively get what is really in it. You mentioned that "Sunnah denialists would cut off the hands of children for stealing candy, beat their wives mercilessly and divide Islam into thousands if not millions of sects because no two people would agree to the same rituals in terms of performance, amount of Zakat and call of prayer... "? May I ask, where did you get those lies from? Please quote me the relevant verses in the Quran for your false claims. I'm confident that you will not find any. In fact the Quran forbids abuse, oppression, and divisions in Islam, and have specified clearly the meaning of zakat and how to perform the prayer WITHOUT the need of Hadith books. It's highly likely that you've read all those despicable instructions from the Hadith books, and NOT from the Quran. I could elaborate on all of these false claims that you've made but unfortunately it will take too much of my time. Anyway, may I ask you another question; If you claimed that there is such thing as "Sunnah of Prophet Muhammad", where are the Sunnahs for the rest of God's Prophets? God says that "We make NO DISTINCTION between any of them." Say, "We believe in God, and in what was revealed to us; and in what was revealed to Abraham, and Ishmael, and Isaac, and Jacob, and the Patriarchs; and in what was given to Moses, and Jesus, and the prophets from their Lord. We make no distinction between any of them, and to Him we submit." (Quran 3:84) Anyway, please understand this verse below since Prophet Muhammad had been warned not to include his own sayings, practice (Sunnah) in any of his teachings; "It (the Quran) is a revelation from the Lord of the universe. Had he (Muhammad) uttered any other teachings, We would have grabbed him by the right, and We would have severed his Wateen (Major artery of the heart), none of you could have helped him." (Quran 69:43-47) Those who insist that the prophet left us a second source of religious law (Hadith) are either accusing Prophet Muhammad of disobeying God's commands as in 69:43-47, or do not really understand the Quran. Everyone knows that all of God's Prophets were Muslims, so if there is such thing as "Sunnah", they should have their own Sunnahs as well don't you think? To make the issue indisputable, God asserts in the Quran that the only "Sunnah" is the Sunnah of God. Nowhere in the Quran is there any mention of the Sunnah of Prophet Muhammad. "You will find that the Sunnah of God is the only Sunnah". (Quran 33:62....35:43.....48:23) As in the case of DIVISION in Islam. God says; Do not be of the idolaters. Of those who divided their religion, and became sects; each faction pleased with what they have. (Quran 30:31-32) They broke up into sects only after knowledge came to them, out of resentment among themselves. Were it not for a predetermined decision from your Lord, judgment would have been pronounced between them. (Quran 42:14) As for those who divided their religion and became sects-you have nothing to do with them. Their case rests with God; then He will inform them of what they used to do. (Quran 6:159) And hold fast to the rope of God, altogether, and do not become divided. And remember God's blessings upon you; how you were enemies, and He reconciled your hearts, and by His grace you became brethren. And you were on the brink of a pit of fire, and He saved you from it. God thus clarifies His revelations for you, so that you may be guided. (Quran 3:103) As you can see, Quran condemns all sects. All sects in Islam, whether Sunni, Shias, Ahmaddis, Ismailli......etc have disagreements about Hadith and Sunnah attributed to Prophet Muhammad. However, these same sects have no disagreements about the Quran. It is the sources of religious laws, stories, conjectures, etc. outside the Quran which have created these sects. The different versions/conjectures of these Hadith books are the ones that gave rise to sects. Because the majority of the Muslims follow conjecture (Hadith and Sunnah) instead of Quran Alone (Quran 17:46) as our Creator has commanded, the "Muslims" are divided into sects. These sects are there because of differences and disagreements on Hadith rather than disagreements over the Quran. Wassalam
Assalammualikum dear brother. You said that "Sunnah is but a term, it means the way/method of someone in doing something. But do enlighten me as to what the following terms refer to: ALLAH says; "And do not take the verses of Allah in jest. And remember the favor of Allah upon you and what has been revealed to you of the Book and wisdom by which He instructs you. And fear Allah and know that Allah is Knowing of all things." [2:231] ALLAH mentioned two things being revealed here: 1) The book. 2) The wisdom. There are many verses that mention these two entities: The book and wisdom. So my question is, what does He mean by "Wisdom"? Any idea?" Here I'm going to answer that question for you, perhaps God willing, there'll be a little more understanding in regards to the meaning of the word "Wisdom" in (Quran verse 2:231) which you've inquired. As anyone would know, ALL Messengers of God are Blessed with WISDOM. All prophets have a high calling indeed as God’s Messengers, but with that comes an even higher responsibility. There is more to it than just speaking the word God has revealed to them. Here are some examples of wisdom given to them: (Prophet Muhammad) Our Lord, and raise up among them a messenger, of themselves, who will recite to them Your revelations, and teach them the Book and wisdom, and purify them. You are the Almighty, the Wise." (Quran 2:129) Just as We sent to you a messenger from among you, who recites Our revelations to you, and purifies you, and teaches you the Book and wisdom, and teaches you what you did not know. (Quran 2:151) And remember God's favor to you, and that He revealed to you the Scripture and wisdom to teach you. And fear God, and know that God is aware of everything. (Quran 2:231) (Prophet Jesus) When Jesus came with the clarifications, he said, "I have come to you with wisdom, and to clarify for you some of what you differ about. So fear God, and obey me. God is my Lord and your Lord, so worship Him-this is a straight path." (Quran 43:63-64) (Prophet Joseph) When he reached his maturity, We gave him wisdom and knowledge. We thus reward the righteous. (Quran 12:22) (Prophet Lot) And Lot-We gave him judgment and knowledge, and We delivered him from the town that practiced the abominations. They were wicked and perverted people. (Quran 21:74) (Prophet Moses) And when he reached his maturity, and became established, We gave him wisdom and knowledge. Thus do We reward the virtuous. (Quran 28:14) (Prophet David) And We strengthened his kingdom, and gave him wisdom and decisive speech. (Quran 38:20) God sent many prophets and messengers to different people and at different times. There are only a few whose names are mentioned in the Quran but they were all blessed with Wisdom. And a verse for all of us; God says, "He gives wisdom to whomever He wills. Whoever is given wisdom has been given much good. But none pays heed except those with insight." (Quran 2:269) Indeed, not only messengers and prophets of God are blessed with Wisdom, we are also given the chance to grab this wisdom if we seek for it sincerely, correctly and wholeheartedly. We can see this very principle by reading the facts clearly written in the Holy Al-Quran. Therefore Quran equates knowledge and wisdom with righteousness. A truly knowledgeable person cannot fail to be a believer and a True believer is led to be a wise person. A fundamental duty of all Muslims is that they strive for knowledge and they be examples of the faith they practice. A truly knowledgeable person is bound to be righteous and a righteous becomes knowledgeable by virtue of his/her purity. Knowledge and wisdom comes from God Alone. A human is given inherent knowledge that can be retrieved if the 'nature' remains purer. If it gets corrupted, it fails in its capacity to sense and receive God’s Guidance. Acquired information is not knowledge: how information is sorted and viewed depends on one’s wisdom that in turn comes from God. The purer this 'nature' remains, the more forceful the connection with God to receive His Guidance to acquire knowledge and wisdom. The Quran unequivocally asserts that there is nothing fundamentally new that is revealed to Prophet Muhammad that was not revealed to all other prophets before. Therefore there shouldn't be any "Sunnah of Prophet Muhammad" if there's no Sunnah for the rest of God's Prophets. God says; Nothing is said to you but was said to the Messengers before you: your Lord is Possessor of Forgiveness, and Possessor of Painful Repayment. (Quran 41:43) This is an extremely important proclamation. It essentially conveys that the fundamental ideas and teachings have remained the same throughout human history. Different religions, different dogmas, different sects, different schools of thoughts, etc. have all emerged because human beings have failed to stay with the main Message of God. The differences appeared because man has changed God’s words. The Book says all the prophets and their people (mankind) belong to one brotherhood. This nation of yours is one nation, and I am your Lord, so fear Me. But they tore themselves into sects; each party happy with what they have. (Quran 23:52-53) Therefore, Quran condemns human tendency to break up unity, create dissension and establish different sects out of the same religion sent to mankind through different prophets. For that reason, the Quran warns that the worst transgressors are those who change God’s words and give lies to His Message. Also serious warning that there are dreadful penalties for those who create divisions and cause dissension in humanity. And do not be like those who separated and disputed after the clear proofs came to them; for them is a great punishment. (Quran 3:105) God has given us the ability to reason, but too much mental reasoning blocks spiritual discernment and breeds plenty of confusion, don't you think? With that in mind, is it possible that we are reasoning ourselves out of prophetic wisdom that could be blocking our spiritual growth, our blessings, and even the full manifestation of our destiny? I’ll admit that I am analytical. I tend to reason through every possibility before making a decision. But I also pray after my thoughtful analysis and ultimately submit my plans to the written Words of God and I surrender to God's Guidance which always agree. Of course, I’m not perfect, there is still much to learn. When someone like you challenged me in regards to my own beliefs, it forced me to ponder, but am not saying that it's bad, it's actually great for the mind to question and seek answers. And I thank you for that, but my purpose is to lean not on my own understanding, even when my own understanding seems plentiful in my own eyes. Because the human heart is deceitful above all things. There is an ever-present danger of flowing in pride in all of us, instead of flowing in the wisdom that God has blessed us with. This is especially true when we consider ourselves well-versed, experts even, in any area. Knowledge will burst out like a balloon, after all pride comes before the fall. If we rely solely on our own reasoning, our own understanding, we could find ourselves shipwrecked. But if we rely on God’s Wisdom on His Reasoning, we may find ourselves with a haul of blessings so big we can’t contain them. Anyway, it's alright for you to agree to disagree. :) May God Almighty guide us all. Wassalam.
+Rey Shin Saburo Assalamualaikum again dear brother. As for the verse that you've inquired; With the clarifications and the scriptures. And We revealed to you the Reminder, that you may clarify to the people what was revealed to them, and that they may reflect. (Quran 16:44) This verse has been used to claim that since Prophet Muhammad is commissioned to explain and teach the Quran, thus we need the Hadith which explains the Quran. May I ask, do you think these verses authorize the Hadith as an additional source besides the Quran? Can the Messenger really guide people to the true meaning and message of the Quran? Do you really think that these verses authorize the Hadith as an additional source besides the Quran? Just to kindly remind you that Prophet Muhammad only had the Quran during that time when he was alive. And furthermore the words in 16:44 clearly state that the Messenger can only make things clear to the people by means of what is revealed to him (Quran). The common meaning is that the messenger delivered the Quran to the people and that he spent all his remaining days preaching the Quran and commanding people to follow it and showing them what the Quran requires them to do. However, the messenger cannot guide anyone or guarantee that all people will understand the true message of the Quran. It is God, and God Alone, who can guide the people and truly explain the message of the book to the ones who deserve the guidance. There are numerous verses in the Quran that confirm this; You cannot guide whom you love, but God guides whom He wills, and He knows best those who are guided. (Quran 28:56) Say, "It is not in my power to harm you, nor to bring you to right conduct." (Quran 72:21) Obey God and obey the Messenger, and be cautious. If you turn away-know that the duty of Our Messenger is clear communication. (Quran 5:92) This duty does not only apply to God's messengers, it applies to any Imam, ustaz or teacher or preacher. There are thousands of such teachers all over the world today giving lectures, lessons and sermons. They all try to explain the Quran, but do all their listeners understand the message of the book? Unfortunately, the answer is NO. God reminded us with a stern warning; These are God's Verses which We recite to you in truth. In which message (Hadith), after God and His revelations, will they believe? (Quran 45:6) God says, "Shall I seek a judge other than God, when He is the One who revealed to you the Book, explained in detail?" Those to whom We gave the Book know that it is the truth revealed from your Lord. So do not be of those who doubt. (Quran 6:114) This verse above is confirmed by God Himself that the only source of law is "the Book", meaning the Quran, and so for us not to be doubtful about that fact. In addition, the messenger is prohibited from adding his own teachings to the message he received from God. If he does, he would be committing a great error that would incur a severe punishment from God. See (Quran 69:44-46) from my earlier comment. What this means is that Prophet Muhammad is authorized only in delivering the message of the Quran and nothing else. All what he preaches and which is from the Quran must be obeyed, but not any other personal teachings that do not have reference or authorization in the Quran. To obey the messenger blindly in every word he ever uttered is the work of those who are intent on making an idol out of the Prophet, don't you think? God says, "We neglected nothing in the Scripture." (Quran 6:38) The Quran informs us that some enemies of the Prophet, described as"human and jinn devils," will fabricate lies and attribute them to the Prophet as in (Quran 6:12, 25:31). This is precisely what happened after Prophet Muhammad's death; Hadith (oral) and Sunnah (actions) were invented and attributed to the Prophet. Hadith and Sunnah are satanic innovations because they defy the Divine assertions that the Quran is complete, perfect, fully detailed, and shall be the only source of religious guidance (Quran 6:19, 38, 114 and 45:6-7). They've blasphemed against the Prophet and depicted him as a vicious tyrant who did not uphold the Quran, and created false doctrines based on superstition, ignorance, and indefensible nonsensical traditions. Prophet Muhammad was enjoined, in very strong words, from issuing any religious teachings. (Quran 69:38-48) Therefore, all these verses concluded that Prophet Muhammad is authorized to use the Quran Alone to preach to the people. The messenger of God will pass the message of the Book to all people and invite all to accept and follow the Quran, but he cannot guide anyone nor guarantee that anyone will attain the true message of the Book. And if the messenger cannot guide anyone (as in Quran 72:21 above), so much for the claim which states that the Hadith offers guidance! As you said it my dear brother, "but when it comes to teachings and worship, to each his own." It's sad that Islam has come to that stage in this century, but I have to reluctantly agree on that. Thank you for sharing your thoughts and for your time spent in replying, I appreciate it. May our Lord give us goodness in this world, and goodness in the Hereafter, show us our rites, accept our repentance and protect us from the torment of the Fire. Wassalam
[For] it was narrated from Shuraih that: He wrote to 'Umar, to ask him (a question), and 'Umar wrote back to him telling him: "Judge according to what is in the Book of Allah. If it is not (mentioned) in the Book of Allah, then (judge) according to the Sunnah of the Messenger of Allah [SAW]. - Sunan an-Nasa'i If you cant find answers in allah book that mean you can find it in man made alterations? Doesn’t quran told us to follow only quran god words alone? Why need to follow man made to make us satisfied?
@@bilalamarumosi8282 it is difficult to tell which Hadith are historically accurate. Some have multiple iterations from varied sources which are identical. The ulema consider the fact that they spend 9 years memorizing them while at the same time being brainwashed that certain positions are better than others. This is what they call Hadith science, it's a made up innovation that has no place in jurisprudence. Hadith can and should be used only for inspiration, historical interest, motivation. There are hints at worship but never direct commandments, or instruction manuals. If The Prophet of Allah wanted us to have a manual, be would have sat down and dictated it accurately, with direct instructions. This did not happen, he warned us and guided us towards oneness of Allah and superiority of the Quran over all other books. No peripheral documents were ever needed for hundreds of years. The Hadith were forbidden as a matter of fact. But to think that Muslims with firm conservative conviction and connection to hadith's would just let them go immediately is ridiculous. There would be mass revolt. Ulema need hadith's prove their and their fathers and forefathers schools of thoughts, their whole economy depends on ahadith, too much pride. It will never happen. A mufti literally told me he doesn't care about a ruling that the Quran and Hadith prove wrong, because his school of thought (deiband) has their own unproven view, and he doesn't need to show me proof.
@Rafael 1. The verses you gave from the Quran , about the people of Fire , these are the verses that explain the viewpoint of the jews and christians. They used to say that we will do sin and in its recompense we will only be in Hell for a while. After that we will be in heaven. To refute this idea of theirs , Allah sent this verse. Also , only the Kuffar will remain in Hell fire forver. 2. For the shahadah before death and going to paradise , it is only for Muslims. I repeat , only for Muslims. Those who belived in Allah , His messengers , His books , His angels etc. Only for Muslims. Now , was Pharaoh a Muslim? No , he was not. He was a disbiliver , he claimed to be God , used to kill babies etc. When he was about to die , that was when he realised everything that he was doing was wrong. But it was too late for him. That is why he is not going to go to heaven. He will be punished by Allah. There are no contradictions , no offense but only your limited knowlege of Islam , Quran and ahadis.
The source of the so called sunnah you're referring to is the hadith literature which was compiled, 200+ years after the death of Prophet Muhammad, by persian scholars (not the companions of the Prophet). In all hadiths, it's the various personalities telling you that someone has probably heard Prophet Muhammad saying such and such, whereas in the Quran it's the direct word of Allah. You can't compare the two at all. If they hadn't compiled the hadith literature, what sunnah would have been left to follow? Would you have still considered the Quran to be an insufficient source of guidance?
Here's proof that Allah is the best teacher and that even the best of scholars can go astray. No one questions obedience to the prophet, the question is drawing a parallel betweeb current day obedience and unverifiable claims that these are the prophets words.
@b king Lol. He was never iliterate my friend. Ummi has always meant someone who didn't know or follow any type of religious or spiritual guidance. Allah says he teaches by the pen. There is even a sura Qalam which means pen or pencil which are used to write. I think you should do more homework and not be so quick to follow what everyone else says or does. To think that the messenger would be given a book he couldn't even read is kinda ridiculous.
@@bilalamarumosi8282 are u stupid? You didn't even know how our beloved prophet's early life was not do u know anything about his education and here just to defend yourself make false claims.
Come on people! He never mentioned that the hadiths are equivalent to the Quran. He emphasized that you need hadiths to correctly interpret the Quran, in that sense the authentic hadiths are part and parcel with the Quran which is the truth. May Allah (SWT) grant br. Nouman jannatul ferdous and the companionship of our beloved Prophet (PBUH) for his service to Islam!
Yup thats what he mean..people say no hadith but verse in al quran say..follow al quran and hadith..seem they didnt read al quran properly..thats effect using too much translation and reject hadith.they doesnt know its sync each other.
@@br4885 thats why al quran use arabic allah swt doesnt care if you master in english i'm expertise in real debate in english as my second languange and native languange(won medal dude got certificate too)+plus also speak many languange my race usually recongize as"golden tongue"flexible..usually dominate international tilawah al quran each year..fyi even arabs learn from my race..bcs how precise we recite.About proper english currently we not in test or in school plus youtube doesnt care if using boombastic,rude,shortterm etc languange..it doesnt matter..also my habit when typing brain work faster than hand plus..simple word "what ever".Why dont you start learning what is al quran and hadith..fyi all ulama they never denied or reject hadith..unless you never met or learn from them.Ahh..try to ponder think deeply..dont you realize most of muslim who reject hadith actually they already "USE"hadith in their daily routine??try check..these people like to make a joke as always
And: "THESE ARE THE REVELATIONS OF God WHICH WE RECITE TO YOU CORRECTLY. IN WHAT OTHER "HADITH" THAN God AND HIS REVELATIONS WOULD THEY THEN BELIEVE?" (Sura 45:6).
What make me happy..more and more people who reject it with out realize they apply hadith..🤣how you pray,how take wuduk,how or what to eat,how to work,how to fasting,how to ge friends,treat parent,take care children all of their action is part hadeeth Whats irony they dont know that..😁since didnt learn.
@@yasamini6346 which verse?if yes why?to who that verse send to??why only that step..why you take wudu different than that step you apply in daily life😁??explain..hadith from prophet exist not after 200 years spread by orientalis..hadith exist during prophet alive..so does al quran side by side..both inherited until now through memorization..
2:57 The verse that he quoted is not about the believers. Maarif-Ul-Quran: The present verses and those appearing immediately earlier were revealed in the background of an incident relating to Bishr, the hypocrite. As we already know, he had first proposed Ka'b Ibn Ashraf, the Jew as the adjudicator of his dispute, but, later on, mutual discussions forced him to go to the Holy Prophet ﷺ for this purpose. Since the judgment of the Holy Prophet ﷺ was against him, he did not accept it and went to ` Umar رضي الله عنه for a totally fresh decision. والله أعلم We should definitely follow the Sunnah of the prophet, and accept Hadiths, but I just wanted to point that out.
Salaamualaikum NAK! Thank you for this video! Jazah Kallah Khair Akhi and may Allah (The Glorified, The most High) grant you the strength and ability to continue what you're doing but only better :D
Best and most detailed explanation ever heard on this topic. Although i listened from many references before, it tops , BaarakAllah feek . May Allah guide our hearts in times of pseudo arguments against our religion . Without Rasul Allah , there is no practical Islam.
It is very confusing! Quranists say they believe only in the Quran but reject all Hadiths. Well, how do you Quranists know, accept, believe that the Quran is from Allah? Who received the wahi (revelation) from Allah, then recited to companions and scribes written down - we got today's Quran. Angel Jebreel did not come to Quranists to reveal the Quran. So, Prophet Mohammad sa declared the Quran as God's revelation - you Quranists believe that but at the time you Quranists deny the sayings, works, advice, explanation of Quran by Prophet Muhammad sa. It is utter nonsense, illogical, ridiculous, self contradictory. Either you believe both the Quran and Saheeh Hadiths or don't believe both. There is no in-between, no middle way, believing in part, not believing in part. This is new fitna.
We have been lied that the hadiths that go against the Qur'an are not accepted, when in fact most of the hadiths being put to practice or believed in are totally contradictory to the Qur'an. I'm not a Quranist but when I read certain hadiths I get doubts about my religion and it's like reading the Old Testament or one of the anonymous Gospels. When I read the Qur'an my Iman increases by tenfold.
really pleased to see people on here also question the validity of Hadith. The really odd thing is this: If hadith were meant to be followed why was there not any compiled before Bukhari gathered his? - Some (if not the majority) of hadith are absolutely laughable and so contradictory to the Quranic verses that it's blasphemous. - In hadith itself it is claimed that Abu Hurairah (one of the main contributors to Bukhari) shared false hadith and was reprimanded by Aisha. Also, that he had a profound fondness for female cats and detested the feminine nickname that the Prophet saw (apparently) gave him. He also allegedly got into various bitter spats with Aisha r'a. Conseuqently, surprise surprise the most mysoginistic hadith were narrated by Abu Huraira. And a really weird one where he allegedly claimed that cats were higher in status to women. He was also apparently a former jew. It is possible (no disrespect to any of the Prophets companions) that Abu Huraira could have been of the hypocrites and narrated these hadith to defile Islam. Or that other people did on his behalf. He was also I believe a former jew and spent only two years of his company with the Prophet saw. Yet his narrations are considered absolutely Sahih. One of the hadith narrated by AH was that woman came from the rib of a man. This is widely narrated by hadith-mongers but the Quran clearly states that man and woman came from one soul. The former is a biblical belief found in genesis. Yet so many people believe it.
[69:51] “And indeed, this ˹Quran˺ is the absolute truth.” [77:50]So in which hadith after it (Quran) do they believe? [7:185] Which hadith after it (Quran) do they believe in? [6:112-113] And thus We have made for every prophet an enemy - devils from mankind and jinn, inspiring to one another decorative speech in deception. But if your Lord had willed, they would not have done it, so leave them and that which they invent. And [it is] so the hearts of those who disbelieve in the Hereafter will incline toward it and that they will be satisfied with it and that they will commit that which they are committing. [31:6] And of the people is he who buys the idle / frivolous tales (lahw al-hadith) to mislead [others] from the way of God without knowledge and who takes it in ridicule. Those will have a humiliating punishment. [45:6] These are the verses of Allah which We recite to you in truth. Then in what statement (hadith) after Allah and His verses will they believe? [68:37] Or do you have some book in which you are studying? [68:36-38] What is (the matter) with you? How do you judge? Or do you have a book in which you learn that indeed for you in it is whatever you choose? [6:155] And this is a blessed Book which We brought down, so follow it and be reverent so that you may attain mercy. [6:114 part] Then is it other than Allah I should seek as judge while it is He who has revealed to you the Book explained in detail? [5:44 part]… And whoever does not judge by what Allah has revealed - then it is they who are the disbelievers (kafirun). [39:23] Allah has sent down the best discourse, a book containing subjects resembling each other, mentioned again and again.... .This is the Guidance of Allah with which He brings to the right path whomsoever He wills. As for the one whom Allah lets go astray, for him there is no one to guide. [7:2-3] A Book has been brought down to you, so let there be no constraint in your chest because of it, and so that you may warn with it. It is a Reminder for the believers. [7:3] Follow what has been brought down to you from your Lord and do not follow any allies besides Him. Rarely do you remember! [46:9] Say (O Muhammad), "I am not a novelty among the messengers, nor do I know what will happen to me or to you. I follow nothing other than what is revealed to me (Quran). I am no more than a clear warner." [10:15] When Our clear revelations are recited to them, those who do not expect to meet Us say ˹to the Prophet˺, “Bring us a different Quran or make some changes in it.” Say ˹to them˺, “It is not for me to change it on my own. I only follow what is revealed to me. I fear, if I were to disobey my Lord, the punishment of a tremendous Day.” [6:38] And there is no creature on (or within) the earth or bird that flies with its wings except (that they are) communities like you. We have not neglected in the Book (Quran) a thing. Then unto their Lord they will be gathered. [39:25] Those who lived before them did [too] give the lie to the truth - whereupon suffering befell them without their having perceived whence it came.. [12:111] There was certainly in their stories a lesson for those of understanding. Never was the Qur’an a narration invented, but a confirmation of what was before it and a detailed explanation of all things and guidance and mercy for a people who believe. [25:33] And they do not come to you with an argument except that We bring you the truth and the best explanation (ahsan tafsir). [25:1] Blessed is He who sent down the Criterion upon His Servant that he may be to the worlds a warner -
@michaelleroi8615 calling prophet's words as false is something to be ashamed. Hadeeth has definitions and people who narrated the prophet's companions. Also the verses above doesn't apply hadeeth but hadeeth means خبر also which means News.
Hadith to me is useful but not absolutely important. If Hadith is 200 years later, questioning Hadith is natural but can you regard with doubts the Quran, NO.
@SYED Shakib no. They were written by the wives of the prophet or people who listened to him preach. They weren't written by muhammad or while he was alive. I'm sorry but this is the truth.
Point is we don’t : Myself and by the grace of GOD millions of Quran Alone have no problem understanding and implementing the message of the Quran without the Hadiths , which the ‘scholars ‘ know are condemned by the Quran
@@mohdazhar3768 If ur bringing these points up, how is it the case for the muslims who lived way before the completion of the hadiths? They just follow the Quran alone cus its very clear that God is not playing mental gymnastics when he said to follow Quran alone, as it is complete and detailed
@@Hugulubugulu People who lived 200 years before the Hadiths were compiled memorized the hadiths as well, and would test each other and correct each other just like they would recite quranic verses, also there are many books before Sahih Bukhari and Muslim in those 200 years which compiled hadiths, they only filtered the authentic and inauthentic ones.
@@osamabinladen4613 You do NOT know the ijma without hadith. Without hadiths (sunnah) there is no islam. Anyone who tries to live by the Quran only is misguided. May Allah c.c guide us all.
Salam alaikum, I found some good examples and I'm thankful for them. I also found some errors and would like to highlight them to make them right. Let me explain: 2:00 Ashab said sentences like this "Is that you saying it or is that Qur'an?" to prophet for example in Ghazwatul Badr a Sahaba (Hubbab bin Munzir) suggested to prophet to encamp to somewhere else after he asked to prophet this question. This Sahaba fought by Prophet Muhammed (saw). He wasn't a munafiq. He thought Prophet's decision of encampment was mistaken if that decision was belong to Prophet himself. So he asked to prophet "Is this your decision or a divine revelation?". Prophet said that it is his decision then this Sahaba suggested to encamp somewhere else then Prophet listened this Sahaba's decision and encamped as he suggested. 2:28 in Surah an-Nisa ayat 150 Nouman Ali Khan make a few mistakes. First he reads the ayat wrong. He says "يُفَرِّقُوا بَيْنَ اللّٰهِ وَراسوليه" (Yufarriqune beyne Allahi ve Rasulihi) but ayat is not like he read instead Allah says "يُفَرِّقُوا بَيْنَ اللّٰهِ وَرُسُلِه۪" (Yufarriqune beyne Allahi ve rusulihi). Nouman Ali Khan claims that Allah forbids to separate between Allah and Muhammad (saw) but in the ayat Allah forbids to accept some of his messengers and refuse some of them and separate some of prophets from Allah. Allah says (rusulihi) which is plural of prophet but Nouman Ali Khan says (Rasulihi) which means Prophet of Allah and Nouman says this is prophet Muhammad (saw) but he changed this ayat, Subhanallah! May Allah forgive him. And this ayat is not about accepting prophet Muhammed's (saw) hadiths this ayat is about accepting some of prophets and refusing some of other prophets. 3:54 Nouman Ali Khan mention Surah an-Nisa, ayat 65 and then he says "They have no faith. We haven't been told who these people are, yet." but he cut this ayat from context of a group of ayats, so if we start to read from ayat 59 we would see that some people say that they believe to Muhammad (saw) and then they obey to other authorities whom commands things opposite of Qur'an and these people come to prophet and say "We wanted good only." but bad things happened to them because they didn't obeyed to Allah but obeyed to other authorities. After all these context Allah says "They have to take you as an authority and obey you without doubt or they have no faith." In ayat 59 Allah commands muslims to obey to Allah, his Prophet and legal authorities who doesn't contradict with Allah. In the time of Muhammad (saw) the legal authority was Muhammed (saw) but now, in our time he passed away and we can not follow Muhammad (saw) as a living authority but we can follow legal authorities among us as mentioned in ayat 59. So ayat 65 was about that specific time of prophet Muhammad (saw) and that specific people who disobeyed to Allah and his prophet and legal authorities whom obeyed to illegal authorities. Ayat 65 doesn't command us to follow Hadiths. This ayat mentions about these specific people in those times not all people in all times. 9:14 He mentions Surah al-Qalem, ayat 4 and he tries to show this ayat as Prophet Muhammad's (saw) proof of his prophesying. But if you read the ayat before you will see that Allah says Muhammad (saw) will gain endless rewards because of his good character. And Allah doesn't say anything about Muhammad's (saw) character to prove his prophesying. So Allah doesn't say character of the Muhammad (saw) is the proof of the Qur'an. 11:55 He says ashab can't separate Qur'an and words of Muhammad (saw) then 4 minutes later he says 16:00 he says Muhammad's (saw) speech pattern was different than Qur'an. People would separate Qur'an and words of Muhammad (saw). He contradict with himself. 17:53 He says Qur'an and Sunnah narrated from the same people. But the difference is when enemies of Islam tried to add ayats to Qur'an they have failed because of Allah's protection but when enemies of Islam or even some Muslims tried to add sentences to Hadiths they have managed to do that. We can find a lot of contradictions between hadiths in the same book or between other hadith books. Qur'an has been memorized by a lot of companions but hadiths weren't memorized like Qur'an. You can't compare these two as equals. Qur'an was recited to everyone but some hadiths were only for some specific companions. Thank you for your time. All mistakes I've made are because of my imperfection and all correct things are from wisdom of Allah. May Allah forgive me and all of us inshallah.
Brother what you wrote "in our time he passed away and we can not follow Muhammad (saw) as a living authority but we can follow legal authorities among us as mentioned in ayat 59" Subhaan Allah, you should review. May by you miss understand the sprit of Quran which leads all the believers until the last day comes to follow the Prophet Muhammad (saw) in their daily life by practicing Sunnah.
@@zulfiqarmahmood8015 Living authority means government like authority. I can't find anything about waiting at the traffic lights. He would have say something if he could live in this century but he didn't. He said somethings 14 centuries ago and some of those are irrelevant for us. We don't have to wear Arabian cloths for example. We have to follow Prophet Muhammad from Qur'an. Muhammad's examples are important if Qur'an mentions them. Other sources are changed like Bible. Allah will question us from Qur'an.
@@cihanfatihi please just stay away from the computer, how did you form this jahil, Islam is for all time, your talking about traffic lights and clothes? read the story of the Jews who were asking about pollinating the dates, Traffic lights are not about religion, the clothes have to be modest but if people want to wear what the Phrophet sallah alahi wa selim there is a reward in this . O you who believe, obey Allah and His Messenger ... " [Al-Qur'an 8:20] "Say: obey Allah and obey the Messenger ... " [Al-Qur'an 24:54] He says, "Obey Allah and the Messenger and perhaps you will be shown mercy." [Al-Qur'an 3:132] "If you obey him, you will be guided ... " [Al-Qur'an 24:54] WHats Allah saying here ? Roll up your sleeves and learn about your religion before you are called to account.
Brother Nouman, The Quranic argument is actually taken out of context. If we go back to ayah 60 we read: أَلَمْ تَرَ إِلَى الَّذِينَ يَزْعُمُونَ أَنَّهُمْ آمَنُوا بِمَا أُنزِلَ إِلَيْكَ وَمَا أُنزِلَ مِن قَبْلِكَ يُرِيدُونَ أَن يَتَحَاكَمُوا إِلَى الطَّاغُوتِ وَقَدْ أُمِرُوا أَن يَكْفُرُوا بِهِ Have you not seen those who claim to have believed in what was revealed to you, [O Muhammad], and what was revealed before you? They wish to refer legislation to Taghut, while they were commanded to reject it Here the verb يَتَحَاكَمُوا is used in this context حَتَّىٰ يُحَكِّمُوكَ فِيمَا شَجَرَ بَيْنَهُمْ is an address not to all believers ( who obey the Allah SWT and his Prophet SAW ) but to those that were taking legislation from taghut. Note: hadith is affirmed by the Quran. Hadith can never interpret or limit the understanding of the Quran which is perfect.
According to the verses (2: 38, 39 and 2:2) following of only Quran protects man from the fire of the hell and nothing else. But according to the verse (28:50) following other things except Quran Karim is seduction. And according to the last part of the verse 18: 26 no one should take any thing associated with orders of Quran Karim. And Hadith is not from Quran Karim. But this is Hadith which has blocked the promulgation of Quran Karim. and because of this many people do not want to learn Quran Karim and then to act according to Quran Karim. But even the majority of our clerics do not Know Quran Karim and they act based on Hadith. And those they block the promulgation of Quran they will go to Hell, verse (22: 51).
Quran is indeed complete and explains everything to everyone who Allah wants to guide but how many people are smart enough to understand Quran in it's only context for e.g Quran says Establish prayer and Do charity(Zakaat) how do you know how much Zakat will be enough? if you are an economics genius you will understand that if everyone pays 2.5% of zakat if would help the poor and won't be a burden to anyone A normal person won't know this until he reads the HADITHS Musnad Ahmad 711 It was narrated that ‘Ali (رضي الله عنه) said: The Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) said: `I have relieved you of zakah on horses and slaves, so give zakah on silver: for every forty dirhams, one dirham. There is no zakah on one hundred and ninety, but if it reaches two hundred, then five dirhams are due (in zakah).` MAY ALLAH BLESS YOU
@@hyperceptional Quran is indeed complete and explains everything to everyone who Allah wants to guide but how many people are smart enough to understand Quran in it's only context for e.g Quran says Establish prayer and Do charity(Zakaat) how do you know how much Zakat will be enough? if you are an economics genius you will understand that if everyone pays 2.5% of zakat if would help the poor and won't be a burden to anyone A normal person won't know this until he reads the HADITHS Musnad Ahmad 711 It was narrated that ‘Ali (رضي الله عنه) said: The Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) said: `I have relieved you of zakah on horses and slaves, so give zakah on silver: for every forty dirhams, one dirham. There is no zakah on one hundred and ninety, but if it reaches two hundred, then five dirhams are due (in zakah).` MAY ALLAH BLESS YOU
@@ADeeSHUPA Quran is indeed complete and explains everything to everyone who Allah wants to guide but how many people are smart enough to understand Quran in it's only context for e.g Quran says Establish prayer and Do charity(Zakaat) how do you know how much Zakat will be enough? if you are an economics genius you will understand that if everyone pays 2.5% of zakat if would help the poor and won't be a burden to anyone A normal person won't know this until he reads the HADITHS Musnad Ahmad 711 It was narrated that ‘Ali (رضي الله عنه) said: The Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) said: `I have relieved you of zakah on horses and slaves, so give zakah on silver: for every forty dirhams, one dirham. There is no zakah on one hundred and ninety, but if it reaches two hundred, then five dirhams are due (in zakah).` MAY ALLAH BLESS YOU
omg... did he just say hadith is inseperable from quran.... I am shook. Can't listen to scholars ever. Allhamdullilah we have our brain and can think for ourselves.
Of course they are inseparable. You need to know the seerah to understand the context of the aya. for example. Please explain the FIRST verse of surat Al mujadila without any reference to hadith.
Yes sister wht He said is the truth... the Glorious Qur'an and the Hadees complement each other... you cant just take the Glorious Qur'an and ignore the Hadees and vice versa.. plz dont go on spreading false conclusions...
@@yahya2925 Salam alaikum, I found some good examples and I'm thankful for them. I also found some errors and would like to highlight them to make them right. Let me explain: 2:00 Ashab said sentences like this "Is that you saying it or is that Qur'an?" to prophet for example in Ghazwatul Badr a Sahaba (Hubbab bin Munzir) suggested to prophet to encamp to somewhere else after he asked to prophet this question. This Sahaba fought by Prophet Muhammed (saw). He wasn't a munafiq. He thought Prophet's decision of encampment was mistaken if that decision was belong to Prophet himself. So he asked to prophet "Is this your decision or a divine revelation?". Prophet said that it is his decision then this Sahaba suggested to encamp somewhere else then Prophet listened this Sahaba's decision and encamped as he suggested. 2:28 in Surah an-Nisa ayat 150 Nouman Ali Khan make a few mistakes. First he reads the ayat wrong. He says "يُفَرِّقُوا بَيْنَ اللّٰهِ وَراسوليه" (Yufarriqune beyne Allahi ve Rasulihi) but ayat is not like he read instead Allah says "يُفَرِّقُوا بَيْنَ اللّٰهِ وَرُسُلِه۪" (Yufarriqune beyne Allahi ve rusulihi). Nouman Ali Khan claims that Allah forbids to separate between Allah and Muhammad (saw) but in the ayat Allah forbids to accept some of his messengers and refuse some of them and separate some of prophets from Allah. Allah says (rusulihi) which is plural of prophet but Nouman Ali Khan says (Rasulihi) which means Prophet of Allah and Nouman says this is prophet Muhammad (saw) but he changed this ayat, Subhanallah! May Allah forgive him. And this ayat is not about accepting prophet Muhammed's (saw) hadiths this ayat is about accepting some of prophets and refusing some of other prophets. 3:54 Nouman Ali Khan mention Surah an-Nisa, ayat 65 and then he says "They have no faith. We haven't been told who these people are, yet." but he cut this ayat from context of a group of ayats, so if we start to read from ayat 59 we would see that some people say that they believe to Muhammad (saw) and then they obey to other authorities whom commands things opposite of Qur'an and these people come to prophet and say "We wanted good only." but bad things happened to them because they didn't obeyed to Allah but obeyed to other authorities. After all these context Allah says "They have to take you as an authority and obey you without doubt or they have no faith." In ayat 59 Allah commands muslims to obey to Allah, his Prophet and legal authorities who doesn't contradict with Allah. In the time of Muhammad (saw) the legal authority was Muhammed (saw) but now, in our time he passed away and we can not follow Muhammad (saw) as a living authority but we can follow legal authorities among us as mentioned in ayat 59. So ayat 65 was about that specific time of prophet Muhammad (saw) and that specific people who disobeyed to Allah and his prophet and legal authorities whom obeyed to illegal authorities. Ayat 65 doesn't command us to follow Hadiths. This ayat mentions about these specific people in those times not all people in all times. 9:14 He mentions Surah al-Qalem, ayat 4 and he tries to show this ayat as Prophet Muhammad's (saw) proof of his prophesying. But if you read the ayat before you will see that Allah says Muhammad (saw) will gain endless rewards because of his good character. And Allah doesn't say anything about Muhammad's (saw) character to prove his prophesying. So Allah doesn't say character of the Muhammad (saw) is the proof of the Qur'an. 11:55 He says ashab can't separate Qur'an and words of Muhammad (saw) then 4 minutes later he says 16:00 he says Muhammad's (saw) speech pattern was different than Qur'an. People would separate Qur'an and words of Muhammad (saw). He contradict with himself. 17:53 He says Qur'an and Sunnah narrated from the same people. But the difference is when enemies of Islam tried to add ayats to Qur'an they have failed because of Allah's protection but when enemies of Islam or even some Muslims tried to add sentences to Hadiths they have managed to do that. We can find a lot of contradictions between hadiths in the same book or between other hadith books. Qur'an has been memorized by a lot of companions but hadiths weren't memorized like Qur'an. You can't compare these two as equals. Qur'an was recited to everyone but some hadiths were only for some specific companions. Thank you for your time. All mistakes I've made are because of my imperfection and all correct things are from wisdom of Allah. May Allah forgive me and all of us inshallah.
@@yahya2925 Sorry about my bad English. I criticised Nouman Ali Khan. Almost all of his arguments are false. I'm studying Islam for 14 years. Studied Islam for 5 years at Islamic University in Turkey. I've read more than 20 different Qur'an translations 11 Tafseers and finally I concluded that Hadiths are just history books. Hadiths can't force a muslim to do something. I wish you could talk Turkish so I could suggest you more capable scholars than me. I may try to explain the point that confused you in my writing if you wish. And I'm a male. Cihan mean world, pronounced as Jeehan and Fatih means conqueror. Conqueror of the world is nickname I made up since my childhood.
Main questions: do i believe in god? Yes. Do i believe in the quran? Yes. Do i believe in mohamed saw? Yes. Do i believe in the words of mohamed saw? Yes. Do i believe that none of his words has been written down incorrectly by other people about 200 years later? No.
Packo Abdulqader how do you understand this verse without Hadith Quran 5 38 [As for] the thief, the male and the female, amputate their hands in recompense for what they committed as a deterrent [punishment] from Allah . And Allah is Exalted in Might and Wise.
Packo Abdulqader this verse is telling us to cut of thieves hands, and without Hadith we cannot know which thieves are this rules apply to, is it the one who steals dollar or the one who robs bank 🤷🏽♂️
@Irfan Alddin are you stupid? There a lot of hadiths which aren't true and fabricated but just because of them you are trying to completely dimiss what our prophet said us(through his companions). In order to find what is right and what is wrong there is a complete science of hadiths.
@Irfan Alddin my dear friend the science of hadiths is quite complicated but in a simpler form it's the study of isnad. We look at the chain of transmitters and by that we understand whether a hadiths is fabricated or not. All most all the hadiths credibility depends upon the transmitters. If the transmitters are well known among our ummah to be among pious people along with being the people who studied under the companions and thier offsprings then they are credible if not then they aren't. Once the credibility of the person in the chain is determined the content is also of one the very important factor for hadiths bring true or not. After a detailed study on all these factors hadiths are given their ranks. Hope you understand that
@Irfan Alddin oh sorry I don't not read your entire comment it seems you consider isnads being useless. If that's the case plz tell my why do you think isnads are useless. Because great alims of past who dedicated their entire lives towards our religion consider the science of isnad the best way and even a modern day person with enough knowledge understand this method to be best. But you laymen consider it to be wrong and we are supposed to believe you. Plz state your reason why science of isnads is wrong. I am sure u cannot but still let me see how ignorant one can be. Plz state your reasons
@Irfan Alddin what kind of illogical argument are u putting? You are depending on people means what? Don't try to beat around the bush. State it clearly or just accept your ignorance
Especially when you see their writings matching up with the New Testament writings you can see that they both go hand-in-hand with each other they are working and playing off each other you can see it very clearly
Yeah... Quran is the most authentic book. Hadiths got Contradictions but that doesn't say don't follow hadith. Just follow you think best in case of contradiction. Refer to scholars.
As Muslims we all know the story in Quran about when some of the jin listened to Quran 46:29 "وَإِذْ صَرَفْنَآ إِلَيْكَ نَفَرًۭا مِّنَ ٱلْجِنِّ يَسْتَمِعُونَ ٱلْقُرْءَانَ فَلَمَّا حَضَرُوهُ قَالُوٓا۟ أَنصِتُوا۟ ۖ فَلَمَّا قُضِىَ وَلَّوْا۟ إِلَىٰ قَوْمِهِم مُّنذِرِينَ" "˹Remember, O Prophet,˺ when We sent a group of jinn your way to listen to the Quran. Then, upon hearing it, they said ˹to one another˺, “Listen quietly!” Then when it was over, they returned to their fellow jinn as warners." 46:30 "قَالُوا۟ يَـٰقَوْمَنَآ إِنَّا سَمِعْنَا كِتَـٰبًا أُنزِلَ مِنۢ بَعْدِ مُوسَىٰ مُصَدِّقًۭا لِّمَا بَيْنَ يَدَيْهِ يَهْدِىٓ إِلَى ٱلْحَقِّ وَإِلَىٰ طَرِيقٍۢ مُّسْتَقِيمٍۢ" "They declared, “O our fellow jinn! We have truly heard a scripture revealed after Moses, confirming what came before it. It guides to the truth and the Straight Way." 46:31 "يَـٰقَوْمَنَآ أَجِيبُوا۟ دَاعِىَ ٱللَّهِ وَءَامِنُوا۟ بِهِۦ يَغْفِرْ لَكُم مِّن ذُنُوبِكُمْ وَيُجِرْكُم مِّنْ عَذَابٍ أَلِيمٍۢ" "O our fellow jinn! Respond to the caller of Allah and believe in him, He will forgive your sins and protect you from a painful punishment" 46:32 "وَمَن لَّا يُجِبْ دَاعِىَ ٱللَّهِ فَلَيْسَ بِمُعْجِزٍۢ فِى ٱلْأَرْضِ وَلَيْسَ لَهُۥ مِن دُونِهِۦٓ أَوْلِيَآءُ ۚ أُو۟لَـٰٓئِكَ فِى ضَلَـٰلٍۢ مُّبِينٍ" "And whoever does not respond to the caller of Allah will have no escape on earth, nor will they have any protectors against Him. It is they who are clearly astray.”" Did they take to their kin other than Quran Quran is the truth
I personally have a problem with inconsistencies. I view The Quran as the book of Law. In law, you always refer back to the constitution when a by-law contradicts with it or says something that is not of the intention of the constitution. Lets not forget, by-laws are created by those who want to impose their own laws or add laws for their own purposes. When an inconsistency occurs between the two, the constitution prevails.
This is actually a principle within Islam. If a hadith contradicts the Quran, then the hadith is rejected. But that doesn't mean we don't take the authentic hadith that agree with/and elaborate verses of the Quran. Both are extremely important. The Quran is more important, but the latter is also extremely important.
@@DatShakeel God claims the Quran itself is a guidance, so when Muslims follow Hadith, the prayer they do daily (4 zakat), where is it in the Quran? God says the Quran is complete and is a guidance, why is this Islamic teaching not in the Quran? The second they go out of the Quran, their actions say that the Quran is incomplete...so how can a Muslim go to heaven if he is against God's own words?🔥
@@mdasim891 where does the Quran say you SHOULD ONLY PRAY 3 TIMES A DAY? ‘It is He who has sent down to you, [O Muḥammad], the Book; in it are verses [that are] precise - they are the foundation of the Book - and others unspecific. As for those in whose hearts is deviation [from truth], they will follow that of it which is unspecific, seeking discord and seeking an interpretation [suitable to them]. And no one knows its [true] interpretation except Allāh. But those firm in knowledge say, "We believe in it. All [of it] is from our Lord." And no one will be reminded except those of understanding.’ Quran 7:3
@@DatShakeel what's the messengers goal? To deliver God's words only, the messengers are dead today, so how do we follow them? All of the messengers SAYINGS are in the QURAN. So when you follow Quran, you follow both God and his messengers!💛 Also Hadith isn't written by The messenger, it's written by Sha sunni, they said Muhammed wanted Abu bakir, no he wanted Ali as his successor, so it's not reliable cause we don't know what Muhammad actually said.🔥 So dont you think following Quran is enough to get heaven?
59:7 | ... *Whatever the Messenger gives you, take it. And whatever he forbids you from, leave it* . And fear Allah. Surely Allah is severe in punishment.
Exactly. as he would relay the quran only. Anything said 100s of years later with a chain of narration longer than a phone book is absurd. If Allah swt wanted to protect the ahadith as he did the quran he could have done so. Funny how each sect has their own ahadith eh? as they were created to promote secular and political views. The muslims were rotten after the rasool pbuh died. Civil war, assassinations etc. I do not trust one word coming from them.
At least quote the whole ayah. "As for gains granted by Allah to His Messenger from the people of ˹other˺ lands, they are for Allah and the Messenger, his close relatives, orphans, the poor, and ˹needy˺ travellers so that wealth may not merely circulate among your rich. Whatever the Messenger gives you, take it. And whatever he forbids you from, leave it. And fear Allah. Surely Allah is severe in punishment."
I agree with this wholeheartidly. All of my questions were answered as they were raised in my mind, and i do believe this is a very difficult subject to talk about in a way such that people understand, but yet again you did it in an honestly awesomely manner. I can't even express it, it's just that good. One thing I have to stress of which you also said yourself, believing and following the character of the Prophet SAW is paramount to being a muslim, but followng hadiths blindly or applying them wrongly into situations by painting broad strokes or misunderstanding the moral behind the hadiths is in a sense only slightly less bad as disregarding them altogether. Also, there are writings that portray themselves as genuine hadiths, genuine accounts of the Prophet's character SAW, yet have been revealed to be very likely lies and/or conjectures. That's when we have to be critical as muslims too, and try to avert ourselves from putting into practice things which the Quran (and Islam) doesn't promote. The distinciton is this: If I know or have a strong indication that something genuinely comes from or is an account about the Prophet SAW and his character, that's when I abide by it wholeheartidly as a muslim, as Allah SWT himself described him, and he has been witnessed, as being the embodiment of the teachings of the Quran. Basically, a muslim wouldn't disagree with the Prophet SAW in his teachings and doings, given that they're from him. If I f.ex. stood in front of the Prophet SAW and he would tell me to do something, I would abide by it the same way I would abide by the things that are written in the Quran.
***** I agree with your sentiment. If a hadith doesn't make sense to me and, more importantly, if I find it to be from a bad source, I'll discard it. However I won't rule all of the hadiths out necassarily, source criticism is key and using common sense, thinking as the Quran bids us to do, is th key to have a balanced understanding with or without hadith. You're right though, I have to be wary of bad hadith that can constrict my understanding of the breadth of wonder that is Islam.
@@Junior-yt6cx The quran instructs to obey Allah and obey His final messenger Muhammad SAWS. Not follows what one think is OK to follow and what one thinks is not OK to follow. This mindset are the so called ( Quranists) But this title is not befitting on them.They are literalists. They have been debunked all the time. In every arena. Totaly lost people
@@Yous0147lol only consider what modern moral considers bad to be Weak or False. But everything Good is true and Authentic. Lol that is lying to yourself to me
It's very simple brothers. He quotes verse 4:65 which is one of the most abused verses of the Qur'an. If you start reading from verse 60, you can easily see that it's referring to the hypocrits who were still seeking judgement from their false dieties (Taghoot). And Allah obviously is responding by saying they (munafikeen) can have no faith until they make the prophet Muhammad (as) a judge in their disputes. The arabic word used in verse 65 is 'yuhakkimooka' which comes from the root 'Ha Kaf Meem' and has the following meanings in arabic: To refrain from, exercise authority, command, judge, give judgement, be wise. It's no coincidence that in the SAME chapter, Allah says in verse 105: Indeed, We have revealed to you, [O Muḥammad], the Book (Alkitaab) in truth so you may judge (litahkuma) between the people by that which Allah has shown you. And do not be for the deceitful an advocate. The word 'litahkuma' shares the SAME root as the word 'yuhakkimooka' in verse 65! Therefore, the prophet Muhammad (as) ONLY JUDGED by what was revealed to him from THE BOOK!! The Qur'an also says in verse 2:213: Mankind was [of] one religion [before their deviation]; then Allah sent the prophets (annabiyeena) as bringers of good tidings and warners and sent down with them the Scripture (alKitaab) in truth to judge (liyahkuma) between the people concerning that in which they differed. Is Muhammad (as) excluded from the above Verse?? I don't think so and the following verse seals the deal: [Say], "Then is it other than Allah I should seek as judge (hakaman) while it is He who has revealed to you the Book (alkitaab) [i.e., the Qur’ān] explained in detail?" And those to whom We [previously] gave the Scripture know that it is sent down from your Lord in truth, so never be among the doubters. {6:114} What more needs to be said brothers?? But if you want to continue following your Lawlal-Hadeeth then be my guest. I'll stick with Ahsanal-Hadeeth (Qur'an 39:23). Peace
All the arguments so far i have heard including yours, in support of Hadith are not as logical as the arguments in against of the Hadith. The most logical thing is that even if you pass on this message orally through a chain of 20 people, the 20th one will not be able to repeat the message as it is sure to get corrupted. Hadiths were passed over 200 years through a chain of numerous people. It was provenly corrupted as several hadiths were already removed.
Svobodniy Razum actually their are hundreds of manuscripts of Sunni books but I don’t believe in Sunni books as I’m a Shia and their is UNDENIABLE proof that the books like Bukhari and Muslim are distorted but let me just ask you this how exactly do you know that the Prophet didn’t know who the Munafikeen were in Medina? Of course God revealed it to him but when exactly? And my second question is where in the Quran does it tell us how to pray? PS. How in the hell do you think we know about The Munafiks in Medina and in The Ummah in general? People wrote biographies on them after their deviancy and evil was made public and they were condemned by The Prophet (S) but anyway those are my questions so answer them Mr Quranist
satoshi miyazaki it's not conjecture pal if one was to study Sunni sources he will QUICKLY realize that they are all distorted, violent and fabricated the only authentic sources are the narrations and Hadith of the AhlulBayt (AS) which are in Shia sources if you honestly think Sunni books are reliable then your just as lost as the idiotic quranists
The Quran says that we should believe in our prophet but it doesn't say anything about a hadith, a written account of what the prophet did by other men written 250 years after our prophets death. The hadiths validity is so much lower than the Quran and we should only listen to those that work well with the Quran. Otherwise we can't believe the hadith.
+salman I certainly won't use hadith. Because they will use hadith against me, in parts where Mohammad kisses the penis of Hussain and Hassan. Or the parts where mohammad allows rape (Nika with no dowry, just a scarf), and numerous vile things. The sira of mohammad was written much sooner, about 100 years after the prophet. This can be used to extrapolate info, but the Quran is all you need. You must agree that ISIS and other terrorist radicals are all learning from hadith.
31:6 Among the people, there are those who accept baseless hadiths to mislead from the path of God without knowledge, and they take it as entertainment. These will have a humiliating retribution. 45:6 These are God's signs that We recite to you with truth. So, in which hadith, after God and His signs, do they acknowledge? 45:7 Woe to every sinful fabricator. 45:8 He hears God's signs being recited to him, then he persists arrogantly, as if he never heard them. Give him news of a painful retribution. 77:47 Woes on that day to the deniers! 77:48 When they are told to kneel, they do not kneel. 77:49 Woes on that day to the deniers! 77:50 So in what hadith after it (the Quran) will they acknowledge?
+kbg astaghfaraalh. "Not the hadith of men" ??? god says about the prophet: ""Nor does he speak from [his own] inclination, It is not but a revelation revealed," 53:3-4 when was the quran written? AFTER THE PROPHETS DEATH. the hadiths went through the same phase as the quran, whatever the prophet told them to do, they did, and they didn't need to write it down because they memorized everything, but if the quran and the hadiths weren't written down they would have disappeared by now because of these modern technologies, people nowadays cant remember their own phone number and you expect them to remember everything the prophet said. "O you who have believed, obey Allah and obey the Messenger and those in authority among you. And if you disagree over anything, refer it to Allah and the Messenger, if you should believe in Allah and the Last Day. That is the best [way] and best in result" 4:59 we have to obey god first (quran) and the messenger second (hadiths) and those in authority (scholars) and we have to use what they say in our problems, first you go to the quran if you cant find what youre looking for you go to the hadiths and if you still cant find what youre looking for you ask a scholar.and god says that its the best way and it has the best results, but now you are saying "NO" there is a better way. if you read the quran, when ever it says "obey god" its accompanied by "and obey his messenger" bro believe, I know you don't read the quran not frequently, because a person who reads the quran cant say that hadiths are fake, just an advice, go read the quran. how do you pay zakat??? how do you pray??? do you just make things up or do you want to listen to the prophet
We don’t need Hadiths, nobody can force me to follow Hadiths, I will only follow Quran and Allah and not Hadiths written by man 250 years after the prophets death.
@@ashrafqarashi5596 by memorisation done by people over centuries, and the promise Allah made in the Qur'an that it'll be safeguarded by Him; did Allah mention something about hadith?
People have memories the quran from beginning to end ,that's the miracle and no contradiction, the hadith have ma y corrupted hadith and it cant be memorize like the Quran, its not from Allah
It is quite intriguing how both Quran-only followers and traditional Sunnis both use the same verses to prove each other wrong. Brother Nouman makes a compelling argument with 4:65 (until they make you oh Muhammad their judge/decision maker). Though I can see the Quranists countering this with 4:105, 5:48-49 and 2:213, where the Prophet/s (a.s.) are ordered to make judgement in accordince with the Book/what has been brought down to them.
@@mustafasadir3017 That is because some disbelievers in the time of the prophet peace be upon him were saying to him "Did you said that on your own or did Allah say that" they were trying to instill doubt by accusing that the prophet added things from himself and there is a verse about that : Surah An-Nisa (4:150-151): 150: إِنَّ ٱلَّذِينَ يَكْفُرُونَ بِٱللَّهِ وَرُسُلِهِۦ وَيُرِيدُونَ أَن يُفَرِّقُوا۟ بَيْنَ ٱللَّهِ وَرُسُلِهِۦ وَيَقُولُونَ نُؤْمِنُ بِبَعْضٍۢ وَنَكْفُرُ بِبَعْضٍۢ وَيُرِيدُونَ أَن يَتَّخِذُوا۟ بَيْنَ ذَٰلِكَ سَبِيلًا 151: أُو۟لَـٰٓئِكَ هُمُ ٱلْكَـٰفِرُونَ حَقًّۭا ۚ وَأَعْتَدْنَا لِلْكَـٰفِرِينَ عَذَابًۭا مُّهِينًۭا but the problem is that the prophet peace be upon him is not with us living so we can't really make if he really said some hadiths even tho they are graded authentic because still that grading is subjective , if hadiths in total from all the 6 sunni books were 10000 hadiths you can't really be 100% sure that all of them were true , I mean majority would be true wa Lahu aalam but still , about 100 to 200 which is like one percent could be fabricated and we will never know , and those few hadiths that were not true and graded sahih makes a lot of problems in muslim communities as some scholars have a hard way to explain them and lose their logic explaining some of them meaning they also lose their credibility in other things that they were true about regarding other matters , that is why I don't believe that all the ahadiths mentionned in the 6 sunni books are true (99% were true and Allah knows best)
*Al-Ankabut 51. Is it not enough for them that We have sent down to you the Book, ˹which is˺ recited to them. Surely in this ˹Quran˺ is a mercy and reminder for people who believe.*
You didn't say when the Hadith was written, It was written 200 years after death of our prophet If you couldn't remember what did you eat last month then the hadith is Nit reliable And albukhari gathered 600000 hadith in 25 years without fast transportation, without internet, without phone and he travelled thousands of kilometers to do that Please explain to me how he did that, and even his student Muslim removed a lot of hadith that don't make sense from albukhari book Is this hadith worth to believe in ? I don't think so
@Fans humanity lol they pretty much all contradict quran. Stoning people for zina Killing people for leaving the religion And i could name more nonsense attributes to our prophet in the filthy hadiths.
@Fans humanity you are the perfect example of whats so dangerous about hadiths. ALLAH gave you only 2 situations where the death penalty is allowed. Yet you go against his words and follow devils like bukhari. How dare you send someone to allah when its not his time yet, devil. You think Allah is dependent on you? There is no compulsion in religion, there is not a punishment for leaving islam in the Quran. For you to claim our honorable prophet would go against the word of allah makes you a blasphemer, fuckface.
@Fans humanity “I respect these laws” Laws coming from humans and not from Allah. I spit on lowlife honorless people like you who tarnish the name of our religion. You will get your punishment though .. one way or another. Shirk will not be forgiven, you are warned.
Reliable narrators ? Those who divided Islam. Those who narrated stories. Are narrations still the same 250 years after ? Why no Arabs collected so many thousands of narrations, but a persians and btw almost all hadiths collectors were from persia. Quran 6:141 ....Eat of its fruit when it yields and give its due [zakah] on the day of its harvest. Abu Dawood (1572) narrated from ‘Ali (may Allah be pleased with him) that the Prophet (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him) said: “If you have two hundred dirhams and one full year has passed, then five dirhams are due on them. You do not have to pay anything - i.e. on gold -- unless you have twenty dinars; if you have twenty dinars and one full year has passed, then half a dinar is due on them, and if the number increases then work it out on this basis.” The Quran asks the Muslims to give zakat ON THE DAY OF THE HARVEST ( the day one receives his income ), but the followers of Mr bukhari holds the Zakaat, holds it from the poor for a whole year, then gives the poor ONLY 2.5% of the income. This is how Islam is destroyed Mr Nouman. Think of difference that this makes between following Allah and following Mr bukhari. Could be I am wrong, BUT I prefer be someone who gives Zakaat every time I earn my income than hold it for a year. What if the narrator was wrong ? what would I tell Allah on Judgement DAY ? A trusted narration that bukhari qualified as SAHIH : Volume 5, Book 58, Number 188 : Narrated by 'Amr bin Maimun During the pre-lslamic period of ignorance I saw a she-monkey surrounded by a number of monkeys. They were all stoning it, because it had committed illegal sexual intercourse. I too, stoned it along with them. Was monkeys marrying at that time ? Did the hadith of stoning existed at that time ? Were the monkeys muslims or jews ? Is it allowed for a human to stone monkeys ? Was Mr 'Amr bin Maimun imitating monkeys or following their religion ? BUKHARI HADITH: Volume 1, Book 6, Number 298: Narrated 'Aisha: The Prophet and I used to take a bath from a single pot while we were Junub. During the menses, he used to order me to put on an Izar (dress worn below the waist) and used to fondle me. While in Itikaf, he used to bring his head near me and I would wash it while I used to be in my periods (menses).
Comment: Please compare this to the Quranic surah: 002:222 "And they ask you about menstruation. Say: It is a discomfort; therefore keep aloof from the women during the menstrual discharge and do not go near them until they have become clean; then when they have cleansed themselves, go in to them as Allah has commanded you; surely Allah loves those who turn much (to Him), and He loves those who purify themselves." Volume 7, Book 62, Number 31: Narrated Ibn 'Umar: Evil omen was mentioned before the Prophet: The Prophet said, "If there is evil omen in anything, it is in the house, the woman and the horse." Volume 7, Book 62, Number 32: Narrated Sahl bin Sad: Allah's Apostle said, "If at all there is bad omen, it is in the horse, the woman, and the house." Reliable narrators that will guide people to HELL. Are these words of the prophet ? 69:40 This is the speech of an honourable Messenger, not the speech of a poet. Little do you believe! Nor is this the speech of a soothsayer. Little do you reflect! It has been revealed by the Lord of the Universe. And if Muhammad had made up about Us some [false] sayings, We would have seized him by the right hand; Then We would have cut from him the aorta. Are these hadith complementary with the Holy Quran ? are these types of stories we need to understand the Quran ? Stop being biased by the saytan, be safe, follow the Quran. 77:50 In what discourse (Hadith ) after this (Qur'an) will they, then, believe? 43:43 So hold fast to what has been revealed to you. Surely you are on the Straight Way. 46:9 Tell them: “I am not the first of the Messengers; and I do not know what shall be done with me or with you. I follow only what is revealed to me, and I am nothing but a plain warner.”
Thank You i got all my answers again. cause whenever i read hadith again it gives me same shit which i got in past. and i am a-sectarian Muslim i.e i don't follow any sect, hadith and tafsir or explanation of Qur'an by traditionalist muslims.
Ali Ismael Nothing in those hadiths and acts of Prophet against Quran or degradation to Prophet's status!! "Stay Away from menstruating women" means "to abstain from sex" -- this is the understanding that we get when we learn Prophet's life and actions - if you take such literal meanings of the Quran yourself then take such meanings here too - 1) [The believers are] those who follow the Messenger, the unlettered Prophet, whom they find written down with them in the Torah and the Gospel, commanding them to do right and forbidding them to do wrong, making good things lawful for them and bad things forbidden for them, relieving them of their heavy loads and the chains that were around them. Those who believe in him, honor and help him, and follow the Light that has been sent down with him are successful. (Surat al-A`raf: 157) 2) Say: "If you love Allah, then follow me and Allah will love you and forgive your sins." (Surah Al `Imran: 31) . . . . Hehehehe.....those Quranites jump off the hills after reading these verses - REMEMBER YOU HAVE TO TAKE DIRECT MEANING OF QURAN , no "but" no "if" no "it actually means" and no rubbish at all!! Take one more :- 3) Say, "Obey Allah and the Messenger." But if they turn away - then indeed, Allah does not like the disbelievers. NOwhere did the Quran say here to follow the revelation or the Quranic verses - its a direct order to do whatever the Prophet is saying!! . . . . And you Quranites do not use other Ayats of the Quran to propagate your foolish agenda -- otherwise we will use your own methodoly of referring to different Quran ayats and then taking meaning and show you 100 contradictions in the Quran and make you accept that as Quran has contradiction its not a word of God and you will have to accept openly that u are not a muslim (while until now you are hypocrites)
Indeed, We have revealed to you, [O Muhammad], the Book in truth so you may judge between the people by that which Allah has shown you. And do not be for the deceitful an advocate. 4:105 The messenger must use only the book to judge between the people.
Dear Brother Nouman, please dont keep the picture of Allah and Mohammed sallallahu aliahiwassalam in the way you kept, (behind you in the shelf) which resemble similarity in position. Kindly keep Allah always above whatever object you have.
Surah: 45 | Ayat: 6 تِلۡکَ اٰیٰتُ اللّٰہِ نَتۡلُوۡہَا عَلَیۡکَ بِالۡحَقِّ ۚ فَبِاَیِّ حَدِیۡثٍ ۢ بَعۡدَ اللّٰہِ وَ اٰیٰتِہٖ یُؤۡمِنُوۡنَ ﴿۶﴾ TRANSLATION : These are the verses of Allah which We recite to you in truth. Then in what hadeeth after Allah and His verses will they believe?
Salaam, After the thorough study of the Quran, and the critical analysis of Nouman Ali Khan's arguments in favour of the Hadith literature, in the video, I must say that Nouman is playing a game with the Aqeedah of people either intentionally or in ignorance, but Anyway. Let's analyse his baseless Arguments in favour of the Hadith literature. I say these are baseless Arguments because Nouman tries to prove his own beliefs using Quran by quoting the verses of the Quran out of the context completely. Let's see. Nouman Quoted Chapter 4, Verse 65 of the Quran, which says "But No, By your Lord, they have no Faith untill they make you ( O Messenger) judge, concerning that over which they dispute among themselves and then find within themselves no discomfort from what you ( O Messenger) have Judged and Submit in total Submission" Now Nouman cleverly tried to fit the verse with his beliefs, in favour of Hadith literature, by saying that the verse doesn't tell us about whom Allah is saying that they have no faith, untill according to Nouman, we read further into the verse and thus claiming that the verse is about those who don't make the messenger the Judge between their disputes and be comfortable with it with full submission, which he says is to follow the Hadith literature. See the 4:55 moment of the video. I am astonished to see how Nouman plays with people because the verse has it's clear context starting from Verse 60, which says, "Have you not seen those who claim that they have believed in what was revealed to you and what was revealed before you? They wish to go for Judgement ( in their disputes) to Taghut ( The false God or Deity), when they have been ordered to reject it ; but Satan wishes to lead them far Astray". Note: The Arabic word for "Judgement" in verse 60 of Chapter 4, is exactly the same word in Verse 65 of Chapter 4 where Allah Points out to the Messenger or the message he receives being the Judge, which comes from the same root word Haa-Kaaf-Meem. So as you can see while reading from Verse 60 and afterwards, that Allah is talking about the Hypocrites who wished to go for their judgement in their disputes to a false God Taghut about whom Allah later, after 4 verses says that, they have no faith untill they make you ( which in the context refers to messenger) Judge, meaning untill they make The message of the prophet as a Judge which is Signified in the word "Rasul" in the context of previous verse and Confirmed in the Quran in many places, that the messenger judges between people by the Quran or revelation and it's even defied by the Quran to assume the judge other than God or his revelation through messenger. See Chapter 21, Verse 112, Chapter 2, Verse 213, Chapter 5, Verse 45, Chapter 4, Verse 105, Chapter 5, verse 48, Chapter 5, verse 45 etc. There is just no way that one one argue the other way. Now if one is to say that the judge is the prophet himself, meaning that his sayings other than the Quran, then I see the same shirk and Kufr in those people as was in those Hypocrites who wished to make Taghut as their judge, which in the former case would be replacing Taghut by Prophet Himself. ( May Allah protect us from such a grave sin). I also Noticed how Nouman confused alot in the video without realising what he was talking about. From 11:27 moment of the video, Nouman Talked about How Hadith and Quran were inseparable, in a sense that there was no book called Quran and Books of Hadiths to Differentiate between the two in the Early times, referring to the time when Quran was not compiled in a Book Form. And thus arguing that Quran and Hadiths were actually the same things to people of that time cause they couldn't separate the two as the source was the one i.e The voice of Prophet. But Notice a Contradiction is his own speech at 16:01 moment of the Video where he says, that Quran and Hadith were being completely different to people who listened to the prophet reciting Quran and saying other than the Quran, because of their different style, vocabulary etc. He even Admits that the whole stuff of Hadith literature doesn't even come close to Quran in it's linguistics. "So High is Allah, the Sovereign, the Truth, and (O Muhammad), do not hasten with the Quran before it's revelation is completed to you, and say, "My Lord, Increase me in Knowledge"". ____ Quran 20: 114
Athar S. Baba Then if we follow you, all the predecessors of Muhammad sws doesn't have to follow the messengers of God, because there wasn't a protected book??? If you agree with the assumption that the only book who is flawless is qu'ran, that we are the only community who can actually follow God because we have an untouched book, so why is God talking about our predecessors who followed his words without a book??? Ppl who where following words of others messengers, wich passed trough the centuries?? Before the Holly book there wasn't any protected book!! Just texts compiled as Ahadith!! There is nothing more accurate in the historical compilation than Ahadith!! Go study it before talking nonsense!!! The Bible isn't at all compiled the same way. Rejecting mutawatir???? Foolish! It is even more accurate than the story of Napoleon Waterloo Battle. This people are defending the supreme incoherence. The Book AND the path of the messenger are the revelation. They are indivisible. If you can't trust in the Ahadith, you can't trust in qu'ran. It was the same ppl who passed it. Moreover Without the Sunnah, you are in fact applying your own ijtihad on the Qu'ran. There is NO Qu'ran only. It is either your brain or the perfect exemple of Muhammad sws You prefer your understanding than the one that the prophet gives us. Even if there is a minor chance to get something wrong from reading Qu'ran and Ahadith, you multiply it by reading it just with your reason. The Qur'an as the only source is a lure. The Koranists do not take into consideration one factor: the fact that the analysis of the Quran rests on our reason, which is itself fallible. Why then accept this margin of error in understanding the Qur'an and not in the Sunnah? In rejecting the Ahadiths, logic would have them reject the Qur'an as well. The Quran is immediately disqualified, if the criterion is infallibility in the application of the precepts of God. By rejecting the Sunnah, they are just multiplying the margin of error by trying to apply religion only with their reason. This margin exists WITH or WITHOUT the Ahadiths. All that we risk in applying the Sunna, while remaining critical, is to be closer to what Allah enjoins us to do. not to mention that the predecessors of Mohammed sws, the "ahl al-kitab" and "nasara", have not benefited from a protected word. Does this mean that they were all lost in following an oral tradition subject to error? Use your logic.
Can we establish contact? We have a foundation that is working to unite and reveal the truths of Qur'an and debunk Hadith. We would like to contact you.
Athar S. Which school did you train to be a sheikh at my friend? You’ve basically just confirmed everything Nouman said except you tried to distort the truth with your own opinion. Whether the hypocrites were going to idols or they’re mothers as judges....it really doesn’t matter because the point is Allah (SWT) said that they should be coming to him (The Prophet SAW) as he is the rasool of Allah (SAW) to judge between they’re disputes as he is the one the revelation was given to. Thus my point is, Nouman was fully correct in what he said.
Facts First debunk hadith?? What an arrogant position. What are your knowledge?? Did you know that this crazy position is the result of modernity? Before colonialism, no one argued something so foolish.
Athar S. Baba 'after the study of the Qu'ran and the critic of Nouman' What an arrogant position! Why do you think that traditionalist where following Sunnah? They ALL misunderstood the Din?? Show humility. And study.
Shall I seek other than God as a 'hakaman' (lawmaker) when it is He who has brought down to you the Book fully detailed? 6:114 In some translations the word 'hakaman' is translated as judge. That is also correct, for the role of a judge is to issue judgments that are as binding as laws. The Arabic word 'hakaman'is the one who issues 'ahkam' (laws). The words in 6:114 contain a command not to accept any source of (religious) law other than God. We also know that one of the Quranic commands that is repeated in a number of verses is to obey God and obey the messenger: O you who believe, obey God and obey the messenger, and do not nullify your work. 47:33 And in other verses it is told that the believers are those who believe in God and His messenger: Rather, the believers are those who believe in God and His messenger, then have no doubt, and strive with their money and themselves in the cause of God. Those are the truthful ones. 49:15
Wait, you're telling me God's words can't be understood without an explainer? Did we read the same Qur'an? God is clear as a bell whenever He wants to be and left some ambiguous intentionally. You weren't supposed to know how many were in the cave.
The Quran isn’t just a book dropped down. The Quran are the words of Allah, the hadeeth is the actions of the prophet. They’re inseparable because Allah says to us follow Allah and his last prophet (hadeeth). This doesn’t mean we don’t believe in the other prophets we believe in all prophets. And yes I agree Allah (God) is clear as a bell for those who understand and take the time to gain the knowledge.
@@artakrasniqi6351 there inseparable? Are you seriously placing hadith as the word of God it reminds me so much of Christianity cuz it sounds to me that your idolizing Muhammad. Why are there so many different secs in Islam? Why Sufi, Shia wahabbi Salafi all these different types of Muslims when we all read the same Quran? Why? If hadiths are really from Muhammad why didn’t he write it down? Following his sunnah is not believing in hadiths its Muhammad applying Quran in his life it’s his character actions based on Quran. He was a role model a model of Quran coming to life through him. You believe in hadiths cuz that’s what we been condition to believe following what are parents followed.
Quran is protected clearly by God. But who protects the Hadith? Man? So now we worship what man says the messenger did? Make it make sense. Quran alone has been sufficient enough to change my life for the better. Clear and concise. Memorized by millions around the world.
This question was really bothering me for a while and I got a very satisfying answer. How wonderfully you have understood the pros and cons of Qur'an! May Allah bless you.
Move not your tongue with it, [O Muhammad], to hasten with recitation of the Qur'an. 75 16 Indeed, upon Us is its [Quran] collection [in your heart] and [to make possible] its recitation. 75:17
shovon100 The absurdity of “Quran-only” Muslims. If they had been living with the Prophet (s), would they have told him, “Tell us what the Quran says, but we don’t care to know your way, your example. It is irrelevant. Only the Quran matters”? Yet, strangely, this is the attitude of some foolish people in our time.
@@HK-USA well please dont attribute anyone with anything. You can have different opinion. But the judgement on Allah. we are not denying here the practice our prophet [pbuh] that came through Fiqh. how do we pray, do rukuh these are part of Sunnah as example and this was transmitted from prophet to Muslims and then generations. Hadith books discusses about what is said in Quran, Sunnah and many other things. many things are irrelevant, full of errors. But Many people considering Sahih bukhari or other books as equivalent to Quran. not verbally but through actions. many core concepts they are taking from Hadith where Quran has opposite statements. Teaching of Quran is hardly there and most of the people give lectures based on hadith. just they bring ad-hoc verse from Quran.
shovon100 I didn't judge you. It was just a reminder that I posted to several comments. I'm not saying either that we have to sacralize the Ahadith. They should of course be criticised with wisdom and knowledge. Things that's lacking to the vast majority of people. That's why the following of school's or 'ulamah is relevant. I'm against both extremism : rejection of Sunnah without the tools and her sacralization.
Ustadh, no one denies how invaluable Prophet Muhammad SAWW is or how remarkable his character was. HE IS the one who brought the Qur'an to us, then isn't it paying him the greatest reverence by obliging hum by putting full faith in the Book he gave us on Allah's authority?
The "Sahih" hadith contradiction with Quran Quran 2:256 tells us that there is no compulsions in religions but... "Sahih" bukhari 8:387 Narated By Anas bin Malik : Allah’s Apostle said, “I have been ordered to fight the people till they say: ‘None has the right to be worshipped but Allah.’ And if they say so, pray like our prayers, face our Qibla and slaughter as we slaughter, then their blood and property will be sacred to us and we will not interfere with them except legally and their reckoning will be with Allah.” Narrated Maimun ibn Siyah that he asked Anas bin Malik, “O Abu Hamza! What makes the life and property of a person sacred?” He replied, “Whoever says, ‘None has the right to be worshipped but Allah’, faces our Qibla during the prayers, prays like us and eats our slaughtered animal, then he is a Muslim, and has got the same rights and obligations as other Muslims have
Sayed Ibrahim Abuelmagd Thats nonsense! Who else than Muhammad sws could perfectly understood the God's message?!? Even if the compilation isn't flawless, that doesn't legitimate her abandon! We should in the contrary examine it meticulously!! You are full of passion. As many of Qu'raniyun, you're a reaction. You can't bear the outside critics (Wich are nonsense since without religion, there isn't absulte morality), so you're rejecting it. That's weakness. The Qur'an as the only source is a lure. The Koranists do not take into consideration one factor: the fact that the analysis of the Quran rests on our reason, which is itself fallible. Why then accept this margin of error in understanding the Qur'an and not in the Sunnah? In rejecting the Ahadiths, logic would have them reject the Qur'an as well. The Quran is immediately disqualified, if the criterion is infallibility in the application of the precepts of God. By rejecting the Sunnah, they are just multiplying the margin of error by trying to apply religion only with their reason. This margin exists WITH or WITHOUT the Ahadiths. All that we risk in applying the Sunna, while remaining critical, is to be closer to what Allah enjoins us to do. not to mention that the predecessors of Mohammed sws, the "ahl al-kitab" and "nasara", have not benefited from a protected word. Does this mean that they were all lost in following an oral tradition subject to error? Even if everything wasn't compiled (there IS compilation from the beginning!) , the sahabas were verry attached to his exemple. There is the revelations AND the exemple of the Prophets. They were memorizing all of his behavior. Like the contemporary of other Prophets. That's how the revelations were working before Muhammad sws. If the only revelation that could legislate is THE Holly book, what about all the predecessor of prophet Muhammad sws?? What about them, following handsmade scripture ?? God is not discrediting them. They are the people of book as well!!! Is God sw wrong??? No! They follow the path of prophecy with possibility of errors!!! And God permitted it!! Because there is NO "perfect" understanding! Even by reading solely qu'ran, you're putting on it your OWN view, with all our defective senses. Between your own interpretation and the prophets one (with possibility of error), the choice is easily made! It is way more rationale to follow his path with criticism on the source. Also, the thing that you're missing is the fact that The Sunnah is also protecting Islam. Without it, you'll probably fall into the lost of religion as the Christian's experienced with it's schism between Catholicism and Protestantism and all the horror that followed the reform. What's left to Christianity?? Sunnah is the shield of Islam. Without it, you can reject the salat as we're doing it. You can defend fornication,... There is two extremes : sacralize the Ahadiths or rejecting all of them. And you're part of one sect. Being critical about our scripture should not lead us to abandon all of it. It is hardly possible to avoid all sunnah and thus hadith. Too many cases would prevent us. The hadith is essential in the interpretation of the Koranic text and in the practical understanding of worship, even if "too many hadiths harm the hadith". We need to question the Sunnah and reject everything that contradict Qu'ran (that's the work of 'ulamah since centuries).
@KebenaranBukanMilikAndaAtaupunSaya Of course it is. But it doesnt mean you reject the Sunnah. Look ag the last sermon of the Prophet (SAW). He asked us to hold onto Quran AND Sunnah so we will be guided. Of course there are fabrications but it never meant that hadith are entirely false. For example, Hadiths tell us that the heavens are squeaking. NASA confirmed it. Hadiths tell us almost everything like how to pray and how to do hajj etc. I believe the Quran is better than Hadith. But without Hadith we cant understand our beloved book.
Salam, I actually really disagree with this interpretation. In fact, here are direct quotes from the Quran which I believe directly disavow the validity of any “hadith” coming after it. أَفَغَيْرَ اللَّهِ أَبْتَغِي حَكَمًا وَهُوَ الَّذِي أَنزَلَ إِلَيْكُمُ الْكِتَابَ مُفَصَّلًا Then is it other than Allah I should seek as judge while it is He who has revealed to you the Book explained in detail? … (6:114 part) تِلْكَ آيَاتُ اللَّهِ نَتْلُوهَا عَلَيْكَ بِالْحَقِّ ۖ فَبِأَيِّ حَدِيثٍ بَعْدَ اللَّهِ وَآيَاتِهِ يُؤْمِنُونَ These are the verses of Allah which We recite to you in truth. Then in what statement (hadith) after Allah and His verses will they believe? (45:6) فَبِأَيِّ حَدِيثٍ بَعْدَهُ يُؤْمِنُونَ Then in what statement after it (the Qur’an) will they believe? (77:50) مَا لَكُمْ كَيْفَ تَحْكُمُونَ أَمْ لَكُمْ كِتَابٌ فِيهِ تَدْرُسُونَ إِنَّ لَكُمْ فِيهِ لَمَا تَخَيَّرُونَ What is [the matter] with you? How do you judge? Or do you have a book / scripture in which you learn that indeed for you in it is whatever you choose? (68:36-38) اللَّهُ نَزَّلَ أَحْسَنَ الْحَدِيثِ كِتَابًا مُّتَشَابِهًا مَّثَانِيَ … Allah has sent down the best statement (ahsan hadith): a consistent Book wherein is reiteration. … (39:23 part) وَتَمَّتْ كَلِمَتُ رَبِّكَ صِدْقًا وَعَدْلًا ۚ لَّا مُبَدِّلَ لِكَلِمَاتِهِ ۚ وَهُوَ السَّمِيعُ الْعَلِيمُ And the word of your Lord has been fulfilled / completed in truth and in justice. None can alter His words, and He is the Hearing, the Knowing. (6:115) وَمَا مِن دَابَّةٍ فِي الْأَرْضِ وَلَا طَائِرٍ يَطِيرُ بِجَنَاحَيْهِ إِلَّا أُمَمٌ أَمْثَالُكُم ۚ مَّا فَرَّطْنَا فِي الْكِتَابِ مِن شَيْءٍ ۚ ثُمَّ إِلَىٰ رَبِّهِمْ يُحْشَرُونَ And there is no creature on [or within] the earth or bird that flies with its wings except [that they are] communities like you. We have not neglected in the Book (Quran) a thing. Then unto their Lord they will be gathered. (6:38) … وَمَن لَّمْ يَحْكُم بِمَا أَنزَلَ اللَّهُ فَأُولَٰئِكَ هُمُ الْكَافِرُونَ … And whoever does not judge by what Allah has revealed - then it is they who are the disbelievers (kafirun). (5:44 part) To imply that we need the hadith to understand the Quran is to imply that the Quran itself is either incomplete, imperfect, or requiring further supplementation, which is the most anti-muslim sentiment one can have. It is clear that the Quran contains everything within it for one to be a Muslim, and to obtain the blessing of Allah in this life and in the next. The simple fact that there are “weak hadith” and “strong hadith” should be evidence enough that the entire concept is weak. There are no “weak” Surah or Ayah in the Quran. The Quran is completely strong. By dogmatically adhering to the hadith and claiming it as a holy text with religious authority, we are falling into the same traps that the pre-islamic religions fell into, such as idol worship, or intentionally disregarding the true message of God. For this reason, the prophet Mohammed (pbuh) was given the message of God, to give the people the uncorrupted truth. Anything after his revelations is deviating from this. If Allah, who is all wise, all knowing, and all powerful, had wanted us to do any of the things instructed in the hadith, he would have revealed them to the prophet and it would be in the Quran. The Quran is PERFECT and complete, and to suggest anything other than that by implying that hadith is necessary to understand the Quran or to be a Muslim, is actually a very anti-islamic sentiment, and goes directly against what is given to us in the Quran. This is just my humble opinion that I have reached after reading the Quran.
This (Quran) is not a fabricated hadith, but an authentication of what came before it, a detailed account of all things, and guidance and mercy for people who believe.12:111
...you tell us WHAT HADITH SAYS HOW TO PREY ??? ...I learned how to prey before I even knew how to read (before reading Quran or hadiths)... I learned it from my parents,...they did the same,...they learned from they parents,...and, it went like that through years back to Prophet,...
No doubt the Hadith is a great source of information. However, if any part of the Hadith is in contradiction with Holy Quran then the Quran takes the precedence. Thanks.
@@PabloChacon213 if its not contradict the Quran, thats means is from Allah s.w.t.and is WAHI to Rasool Allah thats also mean every single words in it is from Allah Which Allah contradict that in surah in this ayat Allah is only referring to Quran and challenging every one with their BOOKS ,To brinhs Quran like this if it is not from Allah they will find full and majority of contradictions in those BOOKS. See Surah An-Nisa 4 :82. Do they not consider / ponder Al-Quran / The Reading if it had been from other than Allah, they would surely have found in it much discrepancies / contradictions.
@Izdihar Ali if its not contradict the Quran, thats means is from Allah s.w.t.and is WAHI to Rasool Allah thats also mean every single words in it is from Allah Which Allah contradict that in surah in this ayat Allah is only referring to Quran and challenging every one with their BOOKS ,To brinhs Quran like this if it is not from Allah they will find full and majority of contradictions in those BOOKS. See Surah An-Nisa 4 :82. Do they not consider / ponder Al-Quran / The Reading if it had been from other than Allah, they would surely have found in it much discrepancies / contradictions.
A Book has been brought down to you, so let there be no constraint in your chest because of it, and so that you may warn with it. It is a Reminder for the believers. Follow what has been brought down to you from your Lord and do not follow any allies besides Him. Rarely do you remember! 7:2-3 And this is a blessed Book which We brought down, so follow it and be reverent so that you may attain mercy. 6:155 This (Quran) is not a fabricated hadith, but an authentication of what came before it, a detailed account of all things, and guidance and mercy for people who believe. 12:111 We brought the Book down to you providing explanations of all things. 16:89
Sunni: you can't follow Quran alone Sunni: following Quran alone misleads Sunni: Hadith explains Quran Yet we need Quran to prove it But we need Hadith to understand😅 So we can't understand Quran that way Cuz we can't prove Hadith, it's a paradox, "Sunnism" Hadith: Umar was a Quraniy (Bukhari 7366) 😅
@@atraonlycowardsmuteme3285omar narrated hadeeths leave sunni and shias all sects, but hadeeth are saying of the prophet in surah star, Allah mentioned prophet Muhammad doesn't talk in his own but it's revelation. Dajjal is mentioned in the hadeeth also, rakahs of salah are in the hadeeth, also reading al-tahiyah is in the hadeeth. Hadeeth is how you do what's command you to do. The people narrated are prophet's companions. Keep that in your mind. Even aisha narrated hadeeths.
I only accept authentic Hadith with a strong Isnad(chain of narration), but to disregard all Hadith is something no one should do. What about all the end time predictions? We get that from the Hadith and it's all happening right now. Also, it's in the Quran that the Prophets doesn't speak of his own desires. No prophet did.
25:30 The messenger said, "My Lord, my people have deserted this Quran. Please explain how this verse is applied. How I see it, its talking about you, correct me if I'm wrong.
@@ibrahim-qk7ii there is a difference although its unimportant to the fact that you must obey the messanger in "whatever he forbids you" as quran states, hashr verse 7 Nonetheless, Muhammed pbuh is both a messanger and a prophet (33:40) "O believers, (know) that Muhammad is not the father of any man among you, but he is the Messenger of God and the Seal of the Prophets. God has full knowledge of everything."
@@chailouai3084 Its clear to me that you do not read Quran to understand. If the difference is not important why then use different words? You make no sense sorry. Read the conext in the vers you are talking about. Dont take couple of words out of the middle of the vers. Thx.
@@mahamedjmal2536 explaining was not his primary job. His main job was to deliver the message. The Quran is easy to u understand. The hadith stories don't even explain anything. SMH
@Karishma firstly i don't consider him jsut stupid, i consider him a worst human being and a liar and womenizer , and he3 used verse of quran for his advatange and he was murderer and pedopheliac
This is the way/ sunnah of Allah swt Quran4: 64 , All the messengers We sent were meant to be obeyed by God’s leave. If they had come to you and sought forgiveness from God whenever they wronged themselves, and the Messenger had prayed for forgiveness for them, they would have found that God is ever-forgiving and merciful. 4:65 By your Lord, they will not be true believers until they seek your arbitration in their disputes and find within themselves no doubt about what you decide and accept it wholeheartedly.c”
The Koran says in Surah 4:100 He who forsakes his home in the cause of Allah, finds in the earth many a refuge, wide and spacious. Should he die as a refugee far from home for Allah and his messenger , his reward becomes due and sure with Allah. Or verse 95 which states, "Not equal are those believers who sit at home and receive no hurt." You say Allah never commanded believer to leave their home but the Koran says differently.
It sounds like a man trying to explain why you should come to him as an authority instead of telling the truth. There is no reason whatsoever for Hadiths. This is an archaic system holding on to power in a new world.
O believers! Obey Allah and *obey the Messenger* and those in authority among you. Should you disagree on anything, then *refer it to Allah and His Messenger* , if you ˹truly˺ believe in Allah and the Last Day. This is the best and fairest resolution. Surah al-nisa -59
Quran says Prophet Muhammad is the Explainer of Quran Now if you don't belive in hadiths can People who reject HADITHS explain to me where are the Explanations of Quran By Prophet Muhammad?? They are the HADITHS that have been preserved by the Sahaba of PROPHET Muhammad although some hadiths are weak and fabricated but most of them are the Best way to understand the Quran
Quran says dogs r man's friend(kitmir)was respected by Almighty and in hadith prophet said that dogs r impure now God is giving respect and God's best creation is disrespecting so this proves that hadiths r fabricated
Hadith is made by bukhari and muslim after our prophet already dead long time ago, i mean these two didnt even live in muhammad's era how could you trust them.. You cant 100% trust human word if you did then youre no better than christian and their stupid gospel
All my family believes in hadith even my wife but I don't because since I was a child my heart always declined the hadith .. some hadith may have been true but there is no proof of hadith. Allah is great and his quran is complete ....
@Revelation … there is tremendous proof of hadeeth. It is the only science that is backed by what is called “ilm ar-rijaal” - literally, the knowledge of men - which is an exhaustive encyclopedic reference of the biographies of the people who transmitted hadeeth: including the eras and places in which they lived and travelled, the strength of their memory and their reputations. It’s an incredible proof for the veracity of hadeeth by which the deen of Islaam was preserved and passed on.
@@mikaalwaters2172 that's incredible and all and I do think there are hadiths that are authentic and that we can believe in and follow such as sunnah hadiths, but it should never be the primary source, it should be used to explain and give context to the Qur'an, remember the Qur'an is the only book of Allah SWT that Allah himself promises to safeguard, this is why regardless of which sects of Islam, we all have the same Qur'an, while the reason why we have different sects is due to the hadiths
Sheik, you are pretty fluent and well learned. JUST AGREE TO A DEBATE ALREADY... stop this singular videos that ANYONE can use to PROOF ANYTHING.... Atheist do single videos and raise arguments to support the notion that God does not exist, which will get an unlearned mind convinced, theist also do same. TRUTH or rather POINTS ARE CLEARER, when both sides of the argument MEET... it gives the audience VERY GOOD idea of the subject matter... Stop the single videos, and stage A DEBATE.... just like our christian brothers do with atheist or other factions of theist and atheist. SIMPLE! Your video all the way half way is TRUE... Yes, the prophet was a judge, a leader, a father, a counsel, a friend etc... but all this ended when he died and his message (Quran), remained. WHAT YOU FAIL TO DO.. is successfully link the prophet to the hadiths... The Quran makes it clear that OBEYING THE PROPHET is conditioned, Only the prophets righteous orders are to be obeyed.. how did the people know or judge which of the prophets orders where righteous? obviously the QURAN. "O prophet, if the believing women come to you and pledge that they will not idolize anything beside God, nor steal, nor commit adultery, nor kill their children, nor produce any falsehood, nor disobey you WHEN YOU ARE RIGHT, you shall accept their pledge, and ask God to forgive them." (60:12). He was Given the Quran to JUDGE with it... teaching the Quran never means adding extra-non existing details as people frequently suggest. When i teach my students about atoms, I can use models to make my students understand what i really mean by an atom, at the end of the day... i don't CHANGE the meaning of what an atom is and introduce extra particles and disfigure what an atom is... the proponents of the argument that the hadith explain the Quran is so absurd that, 80percent of what they practice is not found IN THE QURAN... How? its like completely distorting the message or introducing entirely NEW concept non existent in the Quran. regardless of the historicity of the influence of dynasties and politicians on which hadith is fabricated and promoted, NO SANE MIND WILL ACCEPT THE TESTIMONY OF BUKHARI AS AUTHENTICALLY COMING FROM THE PROPHET... unless the person is DELUDED as the risk of sounding immodest.
But brother u need to understand he is telling to the US Muslim people coz someone has asked him something similar like that so that's why he wants it to explain it.... for people to not confuse ur self .....
K B Yes anyone has full rights to judge which Hadith is authentic and which one is fabricated but to judge between this one must have to follow all the rules and regulations to do so (i.e) one must have complete knowledge of Hadith and quran only then he can be a mujaddid
Subhan Allah ..Nouman Ali Khan May Allah elevate your station here and hereafter...May he protect you from the evil eye .. Late Dr.Israr Ahmed and you are our great guidance and inspiration
"We have surely set forth in this Quran every kind of lesson for people, but humankind is the most argumentative of all beings." [18:54]
Dawud red , Who made you God ?
Dawud red you argued 🤦♂️
Janne Rasimus Hadith was invented to distract Muslims from the real religion and create a doctrine to make Muslims slave of their imamas and their ruler. Quran is complete and no need for Chinese whisper to fabricate a book to a point people started worshiping human being.
Who is addressing to whome?
@@stevehas1861 🚫 quran is also a hadith
Recently I have been having a few doubts regarding some issues in Islam. After watching many debates between Non-muslims and muslims some disturbing thought weakening my Imaan lingered in my head. However, coming back to the Quran made me realize how beautiful and truthful Islam is and how Quran helps us eliminate those doubts we have and helps us to acquire Yaqeen (certainty) in our faith. Quran is truly a living miracle that everybody can benefit from and Indeed Quran is a timeless book and guidance and mercy for a mankind.
Praise be to Allah and his messenger.
Assalamu alaykum wa rahmatullahi wa barakatuh.
I'm glad I found ur comment. My idea was to speak to non-muslims and help myself get to teach Islam because their questions can open a wider concept and topics about things I may never learn and I have found many Christians with vast knowledge speaking things against Islam. It truly is affecting my brain and my intellect and I have a fear inbuilt in me of committing shirk. Deep down Ik this is the best religion no doubt but theirs a small part of me taking over this entire fact and is against my intellect. I am myself raising so many questions and unable to find the answers. How did you help yourself? I really do not want to get away from Islam or let Shayateen take over my belief.
@asshyy7580 I think what helped me a lot was to redirect my focus from constantly listening to debates and listening to the arguments of non muslims. What I did is that I directed most of my effort towards learning Quran and pondering over the words. Also, one of best things to strengthen Imaan is to pray Tahajjud and ask Allah to remove any doubts from my heart. Hope my answer will benefit. Assalamu aleykym
@@iamergashevshahzod Jazakallah Khair. It's my one desire to stand tall and be knowledgeable about Islam and deen so I can defend it. That is why I look up their questions to find answers to myself. Giving myself a hard time. But jazakallah, I will look up to your advice in shaa allah.
These are the verses of Allah which We recite to you in truth. Then in what „Hadith“ حَدِيثٍ after Allah and His verses will they believe? [Quran 45:06]
@Sukran C brother thank you for your response. I never felt more Iman until I turned my self to the Qur'an. There is so many books of hadiths that became a distraction from the Qur'an because Iblis misguided the ummah. No one feels and understands the true message of the Quran because our hearts had been sealed and our eyes don't see and our ears do not hear the ayat of this amazing book. The mountains can not stand still if the Qur'an was to be revealed to them so how come we don't feel it? The prophet ordered his companions never to write the hadiths and asked them to burn what they had written but you never hear this from the shaykhs because they hide it from you. Search it and see for yourself. How come the four caliphats also didn't allow anyone to write hadiths? Until 200 years later bukhari started writing them down.
@Sukran C In Sahih Muslim narrated on the authority of Abu Said Al Khudri, the prophet said “Don’t write about me and anything written about me other than in the Quran should be erased” and in the Sunnan of Al Tirmidhi also on the authority of Abu Said Al Khudri “We asked the Propher permission to write and he declined” and Ahmed Ibn Hanbal in his Musnad narrated from Abu Huraira said when the Prophet heard what they were writing he became angry and said “Books other than the book of God? Praise the book of God and be faithful to it”. Abu Huraira said we gathered everything we had written in one pile and set it on fire.
sacred609 that was just when the Quran was being revealed to avoid confusion...just like there was permission to drink alcohol which was then abrogated.
@@streetzboxa there is no abrogation in the book. This is a myth. If there was confusion in mixing hadiths with Qur'an in the beginning then how did that confusion stop before the revelation of the Qur'an was completed. What changed? This is another lie. This was an excuse to write books beside the Qur'an and divide the believers over these many hadith collections that try to compete with God's book.
Stop spreading confusion among muslims. Just go to a cave and dont share your twisted logic. People like you will held accountable for other astray muslims in the day of judgement.
I grew up listening to Hadiths, I would be left at the mosque as a kid on weekends and all we did was memorize it in Arabic never once being taught to understand what I am memorizing. I finally read it 4 years ago and every Hadith i heard growing up is not mentioned in Quran. I discovered the truth and that scholars use and interpret Quran by using hadiths. You don’t need a scholar to guide you, there is no compulsion in religion. Our messengers first word first verse he heard was, “READ, IN THE NAME OF YOUR LORD...” Allah is talking to YOU. So read Quran and discover the TRUTH.
Check out (Sam gerrans ) and you will be able to relate. I was also like you once.
Reeha so what was the result? Do you only read Quran... and what helps you understand the verses more?
You need hadith lmao. Without hadith you wouldn't know how to pray. Give me a verse where Allah teach us how to pray. Al quran is a book of signs. The teaching part is Prophet Muhammad's duty, the hadith, is his word
Raja Susana umayma you do not need Hadiths you think Muhammad was the first man to submit to Allah. You really believe that their is just one way to pray how did Abraham Moses Noah pray? They didn’t have Hadiths. Hadiths have divided this ummah you have sunní Shia Salafi Wahabbi muslims and why because one group believes in these Hadiths so they call
Themselves Shia and the other group believes in these other Hadiths so they call themselves Salafi muslims but WE MUSLIMS all read Quran . Where do U see the word Shia Salafi or any of these sects of islam in the Quran. I don’t idolize Muhammad and I don’t follow what I hear or Hadiths that were written 300 years later after Muhammad and claim as the word of. God that is blasphemy And I don’t need a hadith to tell me how to bow down to my Creator and recite the words of Quran, people have been praying since the beginning of time.
Keep believing your own lies. Keep assuming that Hadiths are true just cuz they tell you keep following what your parents follow and what you hear keep avoiding the Quran that’s all you do watch these videos and go tell someone what Islam is instead of reading Quran and applying it in your life
@@wakeup5943 excellent
“Is it not enough for them that We have revealed to you the Book which is recited to them? Most surely there is mercy in this and a reminder for a people who believe” ( Al Quran # 29:51)
We believe in Qur'ān and Sunnah, the Sunnah has the explanation of the prophet ﷺ do you know better than him?
@@ridovercascade4551 we follow the Qur'an and believe in the sunnah* the Qur'an is the guide, the only hadiths we should consider are the sunnah hadiths, they give context to the Qur'an so we can understand
HAVE YOU BY YOURSELF EVER READ THE WHOLE QURAN WITH TRANSLATION ?
@c i think you are highlighting the point of IS IT NOT ENOUGH FOE THEM , in a sense that we dont need hadith bcs the is enough for us. I am not saying it was your intension, but it seems like. You know, bcs i have talked to some shia brothers early which uses only part of the quran in favor of thier argument but ignore other part of it.
@c yeah you are right, but maybe he had a misunderstanding and he is trying to clarify it
thank you my brother for the knowledge! I'm so happy I found your videos my father/mother brought me here and told me I need to learn more about the Quran and Hadith I can't just pray and not know what I'm praying for so humdallah I'm learning a lot again thank you very much Ramadan Kareem.
Nouman Ali Khan, by just simply looking at the mankind history we can easily see that, people are changing prophets messages unless Allah protects them...And the only book Allah promised to protect is Quran, it really doesn't matter how trustworthy people they were who transmitted hadith. All the hadith we have now is a very good source for us to understand that era as a historical information. But we don't have to take them as a source of islam. Please consider this verse
43. Surah Az-Zukhruf ...44. And verily, this (the Qur'an) is indeed a Reminder for you (O Muhammad ) and your people (Quraish people, or your followers), and you will be questioned (about it)
+tolga yuksel I watched this and now i am even more sure that we should follow the Qur'an alone. This does not diminish the importance of the Prophet. Tolga it is also clear to me that people are people everywhere and everytime. They tend to corrupt systems. And Allah said he will protect Qur'an. Who is protecting hadith?
+adikill Maybe you should try doing further research on Hadith, maybe taking a course on sciences of Hadith to come with a more solid conclusion.
I think u have taken it as Nouman is saying "Ahadith are equally authentic as Quran is" . No. He has just tried to tell (with logical arguments) that Ahadith cannot be ignored. As God has not promised to protect Ahadith, u need to validate the authenticity and understand the context before acting upon it.
tolga yuksel hello, actually I agree with your point of view! We need to interpret hadith in a historical context .
Usman Khan the hadiths are damaged goods. No amount of wondow dressing or sugar coating can remedy them. They are not even worth the effort. A real embarrassment is what they are!
what makes anyone extremely confident that no generation changed the message of the hadiths??
The chains of narrations and the complex sciences of the men who narrated them and how those men lived as to accept their narration
@@TahmidMiah-ry6gs Science? How does Bukhari know the first person in the chain actually said those things. He was just told by the last person in the chain.
It's interesting that bukari was seventeen or so when his mother took him to travel in pursuit of narrations.He was born 194 A.H so this would make it approximately two hundred and twenty one or so years later to establish the "Sahih' hadith.The others such as Muslim came even later. Wouldn't God had mentioned it rather then to say he completed the religion or he has fully detailed everything.Perhaps God forgot to tell us that there would be someone in the future to come and explain what God "MEANT".God also mentions that we would see many contradictions in their narrations.Perhaps that's why there are so many mathabs each claiming being the rightly guided.
Kindly bear patience to read the whole message inshaAllah.
Upon learning the Quran and learning from people with knowledge of the Arabic language, I have come across only 3 prayers mentioned by name in the whole Quran. They are:
1- Salat Al-Fajr (Dawn Prayer)24:58
2- Salat Al-Isha (Night Prayer)24:58
3- Al-Salat Al-Wusta (The Middle Prayer) 2:238.
We don't see salat al-dhuhr, or salat al-asr or salat al-maghrib mentioned in the Quran.
Salat Al-Dhuhr is actually Salat Al-Wusta (The middle prayer) where there prayer begins when the sun starts to decline from its highest point (at noon), and 2 falsely added salat practiced by people are Asr and Maghrib. The question is: If the prescribed prayers are indeed five per day, why does the Quran have only three named salat?
The following explanations and their merits are put forward:
1- The names of the other salat are not in the Quran because the Quran does not contain all the details.
This is a false claim because God tells us in the Quran,
6:114,
"Then is it other than Allah I should seek as judge while it is He who has revealed to you the Book explained in detail?"
&
17:12,
“And everything we have explained in detail”
&
41:44,
“And if We had made it a non-Arabic Qur'an, they would have said, "Why are its verses not explained in detail?”
&
6:38,
“We have not neglected anything in the book”
2- God forgot to mention the other two names of salat!
This option is also false, God does not forget:
20:52,
"The knowledge thereof is with my Lord in a record. My Lord never errs, nor does He forget."
3- God did not mention the names of the other 2 prayers because God wants us to guess them! Once again this is false. The Quran is unambiguous and is not a book of puzzles:
12:1,
"Alif.Lam.Raa. These are the signs of the clear book"
4- God does not mention the names of the other 2 salat because God they can be found in the hadith. This is a false claim since we are commanded not to uphold any source of law other than the Quran (6:114, 7:3 and 5:48).
We are also commanded specifically not to believe any hadith other than the Quran:
45:6,
“These are God's revelations which we recite to you truthfully. In which Hadith other than God and His revelations do they believe?”
The fact that God (The All-Wise) used the words “in which hadith” is very significant.
In Islam we don’t judge according to what we assume or what the majority follows. We judge according to what Allah has revealed. Even by obeying prophet Muhammad as Allah has decreed in 47:33, “O you who have believed, obey Allah and obey the Messenger and do not invalidate your deeds”, remember that prophet Muhammad has said in the Quran 10:15 and 46:9, “I only follow that which is revealed to me”.
The sunnah of sahih bukhari and sahih muslim, even from how they read from the way they are structured, they are not from what Allah has revealed. “Someone said that they heard from someone else who heard from someone else that prophet Muhammad said……”………Really?.......How do you prove that what the people along that chain said is true without giving witnesses as proof?
24:13,
“Why did they [who slandered] not produce for it four witnesses? And when they do not produce the witnesses, then it is they, in the sight of Allah , who are the liars.”
Anything which contradicts the words of Allah in the Quran is not part of Islam. In hadith we’re told to kill the apostates, whereas in the Quran, Allah has revealed that there is no compulsion in religion in 2:256. Do you take hadith over the Quran? No, a Muslim does not do that. A Muslims only guide to live by Islam is the Quran from Allah.
6- God does not mention the names of all the salat since they came to us through inherited rituals, and because God wants us to follow what we inherited from our parents even if it is not found in the Quran!
Once again a claim that violates the Quran.
2:170,
“And when it is said to them, "Follow what Allah has revealed," they say, "Rather, we will follow that which we found our fathers doing." Even though their fathers understood nothing, nor were they guided”
7- God does not mention the names of the other 2 prayers because He did not reveal to us those two other prayers in the Quran.
For positive change, we should start by engaging in peaceful talks about such matters and to not let ourselves be deceived into thinking that 'we can't have been wrong all this time, not with the over 1.5 billion Muslims in the world'. That is a wrong mentality for a Muslim, and we don't want to neglect centuries of doing a mistake to affect us eternally in the next life, so let us act to help change the situation now.
Let us begin with sharing the word through Islamic events and even on social media and let us not allow for people to be shut off from voicing out such matters. Allowing them to voice out such matters helps us to process the information and identify where we have gone wrong so that we can then act to improve ourselves.
I pray that Allah makes it easy for all of us and that He grants us all goodness in this life and in the next life, and are saved from the hellfire.
Yes there are five prayers in the Quran. Brother don’t lead people who are already in doubt astray. Here is proof.
Quran 11:114 24:58 states fair
Quran 17:78 and 30:18 states zuhr
2:238 states asr, asr is the prayer seen by god
11:114 is Maghrib
And 24:50 says isha
So please next time read the Quran more careful
Ya Boy The verses you provided doesn’t mention the prayers you’re defending. You don’t lead the people astray from their 3 daily prayers. May Allah be pleased with all whom follows he Quran.
@@malkia5572 yes he is right , establish prayers at two ends of the DAY , clearly says about fajr and maghribh prayers
zubair 99 The time for mahgrib according to any prayer times in any country, Mahgrib is not the end of the day. So that also proves you’re wrong. Again, The Quran only mentions 3 prayers, but because modern day Muslims have been following these traditions for so long everyone’s going to just do it and not research it for themselves. in the Quran when it clearly and obviously mentions 3!
zubair 99 Also to add, If it were 5 prayers they would be mentioned by name in the Quran, Fajr, Wutsa & isha are mentioned. Mahgrib Dhur & asr were added over time by so called Islamic scholars. I follow the word of Allah, not the word of man. Astagfirullah!
These are the verses of Allah which we recite to you in truth. In what Hadith after Allah and His verses will they believe? [45:6]
I am feeling like he is reading my mind😰.He answered all the questions I have without asking😱.
No. Allah answered your questions…sorry, the tone of that sounded cheesy 😅
MashaAllah,well explained by Ustad Nouman Ali khan.each time I listen you,I got motivated and energetic jazakallahukhair..
K B go through this ayah..
البتہ تمہارے لیے رسول الله میں اچھا نمونہ ہے جو الله اور قیامت کی امید رکھتا ہے اور الله کو بہت یاد کرتا ہ. Surah Al ahzab ayah no.73
Quran 4:82] Why do they not study the Quran carefully? If it were from other than God, they would have found in it numerous contradictions.*
@@wakeup5943 it's you deviant leteralists who needs to study quran. By the way u still haven't answered my question on the verse u put in ur comment.
It's not that people don't want to obey the Prophet, they just don't want to obey the books where every saying of the Prophet is "hearsay".
If the Prophet talked to me face to face, I would obey him, but I just can't trust the books that were transmitted through tens of people. How many times do you think they would have changed the words or meaning?
If Quran was transmitted the same way then you would see multiple versions of surahs, but that's not the case.
And We revealed to you [O Muhammad] the message [Qur’an] that YOU MAY MAKE CLEAR TO THE PEOPLE what was sent down to them and that they MIGHT GIVE THOUGHT. (Qur’an 16:44)
Your own sunni translation of The Quran:
An-Nahl 16:43
وَمَآ أَرْسَلْنَا مِن قَبْلِكَ إِلَّا رِجَالًا نُّوحِىٓ إِلَيْهِمْۚ فَسْـَٔلُوٓا۟ أَهْلَ ٱلذِّكْرِ إِن كُنتُمْ لَا تَعْلَمُونَ
And We sent not before you except men to whom We revealed [Our message]. So ask the people of the message [i.e., former scriptures] if you do not know.
An-Nahl 16:89
وَيَوْمَ نَبْعَثُ فِى كُلِّ أُمَّةٍ شَهِيدًا عَلَيْهِم مِّنْ أَنفُسِهِمْۖ وَجِئْنَا بِكَ شَهِيدًا عَلَىٰ هَٰٓؤُلَآءِۚ وَنَزَّلْنَا عَلَيْكَ ٱلْكِتَٰبَ تِبْيَٰنًا لِّكُلِّ شَىْءٍ وَهُدًى وَرَحْمَةً وَبُشْرَىٰ لِلْمُسْلِمِينَ
And [mention] the Day when We will resurrect among every nation a witness over them from themselves [i.e., their prophet]. And We will bring you, [O Muhammad], as a witness over these [i.e., your nation]. And We have sent down to you the Book as clarification for all things and as guidance and mercy and good tidings for the Muslims.
@@atraonlycowardsmuteme3285And which book is that? It is Quran. There is no other hadith. Quran is the best Hadith.
Make clear, is actually reveal in arabic. Be carful of translations. ANd yes, a prophet reveals Allahs message to the people. Why7 would Allah swt say he made the Quran clear and then contradict himself here?
The words in 4:65 are addressed to prophet Muhammad. These words have been misinterpreted to claim 3 matters:
1- That the prophet of God is a lawmaker besides God whose law must be obeyed.
2- Since the source of any laws authroised by the prophet are found in the hadith, then the words in 4:65 compel all believers to follow the hadith as a second source of law besides the Quran. Ultimately, those who do not accept and follow the hadith are in breach of the instructions in 4:65.3- The promoters of this line of thought also claim that the words "they are not believers" mean that those who do not accept the hadith as a source of law are in fact disbelievers.
Before analysing the words in 4:65 it is necessary to be reminded of the definition given by God for a believer. The definition is given in 2:285:
The messenger has believed in what was brought down to him from his Lord, and so did the believers. They all , His , His and His : "We do not distinguish between any of His messengers", and they said, "We hear and we obey. Forgive us, our Lord. To You is the ultimate destination." 2:285
A believer is the one who believes in God, the angels, the Scriptures and the messengers of God.
Nowhere in the Quran is the belief in hadith a requirement for being a believer. In fact, the Quran prohibits the acceptance of any hadith other than the Quran which is described as the best hadith:
These are God's revelations (Quran) that We recite to you with truth, so 45:6
God has brought down ; a Book containing similarities and pairs. 39:23
? 7:185
So ? 77:50
Now we need to look at the words in 4:65 closely:
The words "until they make you judge" clearly indicate that the instructions in 4:65 applied to the time of the prophet and not today, for how can we expect a dead man to judge our ? Let us say two men disputed among themselves with regards to some conditions or terms of a joint business arrangement, how can they go to the grave of the prophet to ask him to arbitrate between them?
The message we derive from 4:65 is that the believers who lived at the time of the prophet were instructed to place their trust in the prophet to judge among them . The words continue to instruct the believers to accept the verdict of the prophet wholeheartedly. Their faith in his verdict is a reflection of their belief in him as the messenger of God.
Most importantly, to fully understand the message in 4:65, we need to know how the prophet of God judged between the poeple.
The Quran gives us the exact method by which God instructed prophet Muhammad to use to judge between his people:
We brought down to you (O Muhammad) the Book with the truth in accordance with what God has shown you, and do not be an advocate for the betrayers. 4:105
The words in 4:105 confirm the clear instruction given to prophet Muhammad. He was commanded by God to that was brought down to him to judge between the people.
The same command to use the Quran to judge between the people is repeated in Sura 5:
And with truth, confirming what came before it of the Scripture and superseding it. , and do not follow their personal desires in place of what has come to you of the truth. 5:48
For the importance of this command, it is immediately repeated in the verse that follows:
And . 5:49
In fact, using God's Book to judge between the people was the method God prescribed to and not just prophet Muhammad:
The people used to be one nation, then God sent as bearers of news and as warners, and . 2:213
The above words define the exact method prophet Muhammad used to judge among his people in their differences. He used the Book of God as his sole guidance, just like God commanded him, to judge people's disputes.
It follows that to know the Quran is to know how prophet Muhammad judged. To claim that we need the verdict of stories written more than 200 years after the prophet died (hadith), when it is clear that prophet Muhammad used the Quran as his sole guidance is not only unjustified, but is totally misleading.
As for those who harbour deviation in their hearts, they pursue
the multiple-meaning verses seeking to cause discord
and seeking to interpret it.
3:7
In 3:7 we read that the Quran contains two types of verses. The first type of verses are the clear-cut verses (muhkamaat). As long as no foreign words are added to the interpretations of the clear-cut verses, they support only one clear meaning. The clear-cut verses are all the law-giving Quranic verses in the Quran. We will be held accountable to obeying the law in such verses, and so God would not phrase such verses in any uncertain manner.
The second type of verses are the verses which can support more than one meaning (mutashabihaat). There are a number of reasons as to why God placed such multiple-meaning verses in the Book.
The reason that concerns us in this specific research is that in such verses, God instilled a test for the people. Will they adhere to the meaning that conforms to the message of the Quran, and which is derived from Quranic evidence, and which is in harmony with other Quranic verses? Or will they seek a manipulated meaning that serves the non-Quranic ideologies of the reader?
We should remember at this point that God informed us that He guides some people with the Quran and at the same time, God misguides some people, also with the Quran:
As for those who believe, they know that it (Quran) is the truth from their Lord. As for those who disbelieve, they say, "What did God intend with that example?" He misguides many with it (Quran), and guides many with it (Quran), but He does not misguide with it except the wicked. 2:26
In the majority of cases, the mis-interpretations were a result of the scholar's attempt to uphold non-Quranic sources (hadith, culture, innovations, etc) which are not in harmony with the Quranic verdict in those verses.
Assalamualaikum brother, just wanted to clarify something, so do you reject any rules/regulations that was set even by his companions outside of prophet muhammad's (pbuh)?
@@elangz9201 walaikom assalam dear brother. why i should follow books that are contradicting with the holy quran and that contains mostly false stories?? isn't quran perfect? Allah says Quran is fully detailed and it contains everything, nothing left out of it. then should we seek man made false hadiths other than Quran as our religious guidence??
@@DiscoverHealth ah i see. I saw the comments below, and its really an intresting argument tho. It makes me intrested to learn for myself the history of the hadith itself. So if i may ask brother, hows your routine as a muslim? If you dont mind me asking ofcourse. How do you pray, do zakat, iedl fitr, iedl adha, etc etc. Would like to hear much from you, thank you very much 🙏
I simply not interested to enter in this debate. But one thing I have noticed. Just because of Ahadees, we have so many fracture in Islam. Sunni, Shia, Berivlve, Doubandi, Dancing Islam, Musical Islam, Qabr Poja Islam. +++++, they always find some Hadees to back their claim. Had muslims only followed Quran as ordered by Allah swt and Rasool Allah saw, there would have no or few cracks in Muslims today.
Also, now-a-days almost all Ahadees are created by Yajoj (British) if you know this.
What’s even more ironic without Hadiths, Seerah and scholarly traditions you wouldn’t have the Quran 🤦🏾♂️. So be quiet “Quranist” and go play in the sand with the other western liberals
Say, [O Muhammad], "If you should love Allah, then follow me, [so] Allah will love you and forgive you your sins. And Allah is Forgiving and Merciful." Al-Quran 3:31
Say, "Obey Allah and the Messenger." But if they turn away - then indeed, Allah does not like the disbelievers.Al-Quran 3:32
Mahmood Ashraf salaam good morning may I recommend quranite.com his name is Sam Gerrans wonderful man with very good knowledge of the arabic language and quran his videos are on TH-cam you will be enlightened and benifit a great deal his translation you can download for free or buy from amazon or his website the quran a complete revelation watch his video on muhammad was not from mecca amongst others that will clear up everything about hadith corruption and fabrication including his seerah biography. also search dan Gibson searchformecca.com to know the facts about muhammad being a messenger from petra city. the film the sacred city is a film I would also recommend you watch to find out the facts.
K Bob Shut the fck up. It is westernizers or non Muslims who come in the fold of Islam to destroy it or make it liberal, kinda like how the old people of the scripture did. No one cares about your Sunnah rejection, it was foretold by us by the messenger. So go away and quit trying to press these views that this deviated religion only came out 200 years ago.
david mitchell all u can do is copy and paste we will see how brave you are when I find you
@@pmpm1841 lol have u found him
Verse 20:90 says that Harun (brother of Moses) says to his people: fattabi'ooni (follow me) which is the SAME word which is used in verse 3:31! So, does that mean the children of Isreal had to follow the Sunnah of Harun???? You know, eat, drink, dress, and pee like me??
فَوَيْلٌ لِلَّذِينَ يَكْتُبُونَ الْكِتَابَ بِأَيْدِيهِمْ ثُمَّ يَقُولُونَ هَٰذَا مِنْ عِنْدِ اللَّهِ لِيَشْتَرُوا بِهِ ثَمَنًا قَلِيلًا ۖ فَوَيْلٌ لَهُمْ مِمَّا كَتَبَتْ أَيْدِيهِمْ وَوَيْلٌ لَهُمْ مِمَّا يَكْسِبُونَ
Read your Quran and Quran alone!! Follow Quran and Quran alone!!!!!!!!
السلام علیکم یہ سیشن قرآن و حدیث کے علم، تحقیق، اور حقیقت کی تلاش کے لیے بنایا گیا ہے۔
یہاں پہ کچھ طلباء اکٹھے ہو کے قرآن کو پڑھنے، سیکھنے، سمجھنے، تفکر، تدبر، کرتے ہیں۔ اور صرف قرآن کو لاریب سمجھتے ہیں۔ اس کی پریکٹیکل حکمت عملی اور سٹریٹیجی ڈسکس کر کے نظام کو عمل میں لانے کی کوشش کرتے ہیں اور اپنی زندگیوں میں متروک ہو جانے سے بچانے کی کوشش کرتے ہیں۔
سیشن کا لنک گوگل میٹ پہ جنریٹ کر کے روز مغرب کے بعد سینڈ کر دیا جاتا ہے۔
جس کے بھی دل میں قرآن سیکھنے، سکھانے، تدبر، تفکر، عمل کی خواہش ہو وہ سیشن جوائین کر سکتا ہے۔
گروپ کا لنک بھی دیا گیا ہے
اور سیشن کا لنک روز گروپ میں بھیج دیا جاتا ہے۔
اوقات:
مغرب تا عشاء، مغرب کی ادائیگی کے بعد سیشن شروع ہو کے عشاء تک رہتا ہے۔
اس گروپ کا مقصد ہماری روزمرہ زندگی کے معاملات کو قرآن و حدیث کی روشنی حل کرنا ہے۔ کوئی ایک ایسا معاملہ نہیں ہے جس پر قرآن و حدیث میں توجہ نہ دی گئی ہو۔ یہاں آپ اپنی روزمرہ کی زندگی کے تمام مسائل شیئر کر سکتے ہیں اور قرآن و حدیث کی روشنی میں ان کے حل پہ بات بھی کر سکتے ہیں۔ ہم قرآن کو صرف سے سمجھنے کی کوشش کرتے ہیں
یاد رکھیں کہ بحث کا مقصد سیکھنا اور بڑھنا ہے، دلیل جیتنا نہیں۔
chat.whatsapp.com/FA8H826pXHJ61qWfKnY28B
Thanks Ustaz Nouman. Those were some good arguments against quran-only people. Alhamdu lillah.
Nouman Ali Khan states that" to question hadith is to question the Quran" One must stop him right in his place. When we know for a fact that hadith have major clear contradictions, flaws and go against the Quran! In some instances blatantly. . If we see the Quran being clear on an issue that is contradicted by a hadith, which do we obey?? To people like Khan, anyone who rejects a hadith that contradicts the Quran is accused of attacking the Sunnah. Surah 25: Verse 4, Oh my lord, truly my people have abandoned this Quran”. Consequently to those who follow writing other than the Quran, the verses have become…a book of mysteries and Symbols. So much so that many Muslims have become fearful of misinterpreting the Quran, when Allah has told us that he has made it easy. 54:17- “we have certainly made the Quran easy for remembrance” .You can’t say things like well, yea, Allah said that it was easy BUT we don’t believe it, this is haram and even Blasphemy. We must approach this matter as students’ and not teachers. Most who teach the Quran approach it as if being teachers of the book instead of the book being their teachers. If reading a poem in school for example, we spend a month on it trying to figure it out and understand. And if we read the Quran we rush through it a few minutes and put it away. This is wrong!
Allah has even commanded his prophet: (75: 16-17) “Do not move your tongue with it in haste, it is upon us to collect it and promulgate it”
47:24- “do they not reflect upon the Quran, or are there locks upon their hearts”. 2: 256-“there shall be no compulsion in religion. The right course has become clear from the wrong” The only Quranic penal codes in life are those regarding murder, corruption and aggression.
Now, regarding the punishment for apostasy, it was included by the jurist because the authority wanted to treat ANY OPPOSITION AS APOSTATES! That’s how Ja’ad Dirham was killed as well as other reformers such as Jahm ibn Safwan in both the Umayyad and Abbassid era’s had people killed in name of heresy.
We put the word of man who has been shown to have errors and contradiction in the hadiths over the Quran??? We must look at the hadiths matn( meaning) before it’s sanad( chain of narration) and WE MUST LOOK AT THE QURAN BEFORE THE HADITH. IT IS THE QURAN THAT GUIDES TO THE UPRIGHT PATH AND THE ABOSLUTE TEXT WHICH ALLAH HAS COMMANDED US TO PONDER, THEY DON’T PONDER! The hadithers will dismiss 50 verses in favor of a questionable hadith. Deviants who don’t even know. We’ve put the Quran at the bottom and glorified the Bukhar, Nawawi, and Ibn Hajjar, as they are angles. When in fact they are poor men, and with known whims, flaws, and didn’t always hit their mark. Who so ever wishes to strike us, we shall strike him by the Quran, and if they choice to be humble then we shall be humble.
The followers of the Quran have not been given a chance, There are followers of the companies and the prophets family, ( Sunni & Shia) but the Quran has a minority of true followers who had not been given a chance across history to reveal the Quran and what Allah has truly revealed. Consequently to those who follow writing other than the Quran, the verses have become…a book of mysteries and Symbols.
This is a misconception that to reject hadith you reject "Sunnah" and this is false. There's no proof of this for many reasons. The people of hadith and their supporters who exaggerate in protecting the Sunnah….The argument isn't in regard to the authenticated words of the prophet, but in regards to WHAT THEY CLAIMED TO BE AUTHENTIC. Why? Because the Quran says' " I only follow what is revealed to me" 7:203. On that very clear and straight forward point, the Quran advocates freedom of belief, while there is a hadith narrated by Ikrimah to kill the apostate. Also, Allah Mentions in 4:123 “Paradise is not obtained by your wishful thinking nor by the people of the scripture. Whoever does a wrong will be recompensed for it” However, in Sahih Muslim, the hadith narrated by Abi Baraddah says, “ that in the day of judgement each Muslim will be redeemed from hell by sacrificing a Jew or Christian” How does anyone in their right mind think this oppressive hadith is from Allah and compares to Quranic Justice??
It’s important to understand that the people of hadith have further complicated and matters and distorted the truth by neglecting the important central issue in the Quran, the spirit of Islam such as knowledge, justice and honesty to Allah. In all six books, not a single section about the intellect despite its prevalence in the Quran, nor are there any section about justice, knowledge use of sense or honesty to Allah, despite their prevalence in the Quran. They got preoccupied with made up details. I wouldn’t say ALL hadiths but MOST hadiths that are being circulated on people’s tongues.
If you hear a preacher mention 100 hadith’s then know that 90 of them are falsely attributed to the prophet and 10 MAY by authentic. And if you hear 10, it’s also the same. Why? They don’t examine the hadith by the Quran and the authenticate hadiths’ that contradict the Quran, the mind, the freedom and the principles. If we see the Quran being clear on an issue that is contradicted by a hadith, which do we go by? To people like Khan, anyone who rejects a hadith that contradicts the Quran is accused of attacking the Sunnah. To the people of Hadith, the Quran as become marginal source. The Quran has become their lowest source. They claim that it’s not but it most certainly is. Allah ordered us with honesty, And Allah as commanded honest in saying “be with those who are truthful” 9:19
Therefore, the Quran is light and the light self-revealing and does not need someone to reveal it. All matters that are discussed in the Quran about human rights, justice, forgiveness, honesty to Allah, knowledge and its standards are not prevalent in the Hadiths and in some instances deserted. The narratives in the hadith were established under authorities most often, the biggest narrators have flourished amidst oppressive authorities. Matters have gotten so far out of touch that in the Fatiha, “ not of those who evoked your wrath or of those who are astray” 1:7 are Jews and Christians. This isn’t from allah, it’s the prejudice of those people who make those claims in the hadith. The people of Hadith have reduced the Quran to a secondary source despite boasting about it.
Therefore we must restore the spirit of the Quran. Why did the Islamic Ummah become the weakest in intellect and the most obtuse and alienating human rights? Because the narration prevailed over the spirit of the Quran over the knowledge and intellect. Allah states in the Quran, “don’t you think” is mentioned far more in the Quran than “don’t you believe” Why is there not a single book about use of intellect across our entire history?
Therefore, it’s up to us now to bring back knowledge of the Quran, the truth, and rid of these oppressive writings in hadith and open our minds to the science and the worship of Allah exclusively and to message of Allah in his Quran.
Which hadith after it (Quran) do they believe in? 7:185
Facts , this is an eye opener for anyone
Movefasta Bro lol so tell me how do you know how to pray? How do you know whether isha is 4 and not 1? How do you know how to pay zakah or about ritual bathing (ghusl). For the record that verse that you so happened to pluck out, it’s actually not talking about what yall think, but you’d have to study Arabic to understand what I’m talking about. Not modern colloquial Arabic but fus-ha (Classical Arabic) as the same words mean different things dependent on the context. So first and foremost study the Quran and read it’s proper explanations (science of tafsir) and study them, not take translations off an app or google, and then actually study the science of Hadith. You’ll be amazed at how much of your religion is actually based off of ahadith as allah told us to follow the sunnah of the prophet. The Quran doesn’t go into detail in much like how do we know the prophets wives names etc. So my advice to all of you brothers n sisters is to actually study the sciences of the Quran and ahaadith and your queries will be answered
@@nabilyasin2088 mashallah you have so many questions. Please go search uncorrupted Islam on Google, you'll find all your answers.
@@nabilyasin2088
Answer is the way Prophet Ibrahim pay Zakah, prayed Salah and did Hazz.
@@wonder_007 oh tell me then, was he instructed to pray 5 times a day?
God CONDEMNED any other Hadith than the Quran for religious laws, and He called His Book, QURAN, the BEST Hadith. God called on the believers to follow only His Hadith, the Quran, and so did Prophet Muhammad, as he was prohibited from saying any other statement other than what God revealed to him in the Quran. Therefore, with respect to you Mr Nouman, I apologize that I couldn't agree with you when you said that "you cannot separate these two entities", that the Prophet's personal words and God's revelation are intertwined together. This encourages the propagation that Hadith books written by humans are valid. To me, they are from two different sources. Quran is from God and the Hadith books are fabricated by His creations. As you said it yourself, you can tell when someone is speaking for himself or copying others; just like when you read the Quran and when you read the Hadith books. If you analyze it carefully, you will definitely notice the distinct difference in content, since the substantive information is in contrast to its actual manner of presentation. God willing.
I seek refuge in God from Satan the damned.
In the name of God, the Gracious, the Merciful.
Most of them follow nothing but assumptions; and assumptions avail nothing against the truth. God is fully aware of what they do. (Quran 10:36)
Say, "I am not different from the other messengers; and I do not know what will be done with me, or with you. I only follow what is inspired in me, and I am only a clear warner." (Quran 46:9)
And when Our clear revelations are recited to them, those who do not hope to meet Us say, "Bring a Quran other than this, or change it." Say, "It is not for me to change it of my own accord. I only follow what is revealed to me. I fear, if I disobeyed my Lord, the torment of a terrible Day." (Quran 10:15)
Some verses examples:
God has sent down the BEST of narrations: a Scripture consistent and paired. The skins of those who reverence their Lord shiver from it, then their skins and their hearts soften up to the remembrance of God. Such is God's guidance; He guides with it whomever He wills. But whomever God leaves astray, for him there is no guide. (Quran 39:23)
Have they not observed the government of the heavens and the earth, and all the things that God created, and that their time may have drawn near? Which message, besides this, will they believe in? (Quran 7:185)
Among the people is he who trades in distracting tales; intending, without knowledge, to lead away from God's way, and to make a mockery of it. These will have a humiliating punishment. (Quran 31:6)
Most of them follow nothing but assumptions; and assumptions avail nothing against the truth. God is fully aware of what they do. (Quran 10:36)
These are God's Verses which We recite to you in truth. In which message, after God and His revelations, will they believe? (Quran 45:6)
So let them produce a discourse like it, if they are truthful. (Quran 52:34)
So leave Me to those who reject this discourse; We will proceed against them gradually, from where they do not know. (Quran 68:44)
And when Our Verses are recited to him, he turns away in pride, as though he did not hear them, as though there is deafness in his ears. So inform him of a painful punishment. (Quran 31:7)
Or do you have a scripture in which you study. (Quran 68:37)
In what message, beyond this, will they believe? (Quran 77:50)
God cites the example of a man shared by partners at odds, and a man belonging exclusively to one man. Are they equal in status? Praise be to God, but most of them do not know. (Quran 39:29)
Those who prohibit what God never did in the Quran, will be surprised on Resurrection Day when the messenger of God WILL complain to Him about them:
And the Messenger will say, "My Lord, my people have abandoned this Quran." (Quran 25:30)
And God has reminded those who are unsure on how to deal with polytheists and hypocrites who follow other laws not authorized by God:
What is the matter with you, divided into two factions regarding the hypocrites, when God Himself has condemned them on account of what they did? Do you want to guide those whom God has led astray? Whomever God leads astray-you will never find for him a way. (Quran 4:88)
It was not easy for Muslims to decide how to deal with such people who called themselves "Muslims" but they were actually mushriks and hypocrites. Some were of the opinion that since they professed Islam, performed prayers, fasted and recited the Quran, they could not be treated as unbelievers. Here God pronounces His judgement on this issue.
I'm sorry that I need to let you know my take on this. I admire your wonderful efforts in promoting Islam, you're a kind intellectual who have such a beautiful personality and you're still on my top list of lecturers. ☝☕🍰 May the Almighty pardon us, bless us, and guide us all. Peace be to you.
What happens when we stop believing the fairy tales named "hadiths" ? The so called "scholars" lose their academic advantage. A Muslim only has to read the Quran. He does not need to read the thousand of insanities contained in the hadiths books.
You're on so point, i wish i was having such potential to write a comment like an article to clear this Nouman scholar.
***** Assalammualaikum.
Thank you for your time responding to my comments. I appreciate it, but in accordance to verified facts, I have to disagree with you.
First of all, how could you say that I'm rejecting the Quran when the Quran is my ONLY source of guidance? It doesn't make sense at all and it's a little too much to compare me to "an extremist beyond that of ISIS" don't you think? To me, that is totally uncalled for. Perhaps you have not thoroughly read the Quran to comprehensively get what is really in it.
You mentioned that "Sunnah denialists would cut off the hands of children for stealing candy, beat their wives mercilessly and divide Islam into thousands if not millions of sects because no two people would agree to the same rituals in terms of performance, amount of Zakat and call of prayer... "? May I ask, where did you get those lies from? Please quote me the relevant verses in the Quran for your false claims. I'm confident that you will not find any. In fact the Quran forbids abuse, oppression, and divisions in Islam, and have specified clearly the meaning of zakat and how to perform the prayer WITHOUT the need of Hadith books. It's highly likely that you've read all those despicable instructions from the Hadith books, and NOT from the Quran. I could elaborate on all of these false claims that you've made but unfortunately it will take too much of my time.
Anyway, may I ask you another question; If you claimed that there is such thing as "Sunnah of Prophet Muhammad", where are the Sunnahs for the rest of God's Prophets? God says that "We make NO DISTINCTION between any of them."
Say, "We believe in God, and in what was revealed to us; and in what was revealed to Abraham, and Ishmael, and Isaac, and Jacob, and the Patriarchs; and in what was given to Moses, and Jesus, and the prophets from their Lord. We make no distinction between any of them, and to Him we submit." (Quran 3:84)
Anyway, please understand this verse below since Prophet Muhammad had been warned not to include his own sayings, practice (Sunnah) in any of his teachings;
"It (the Quran) is a revelation from the Lord of the universe. Had he (Muhammad) uttered any other teachings, We would have grabbed him by the right, and We would have severed his Wateen (Major artery of the heart), none of you could have helped him." (Quran 69:43-47)
Those who insist that the prophet left us a second source of religious law (Hadith) are either accusing Prophet Muhammad of disobeying God's commands as in 69:43-47, or do not really understand the Quran.
Everyone knows that all of God's Prophets were Muslims, so if there is such thing as "Sunnah", they should have their own Sunnahs as well don't you think?
To make the issue indisputable, God asserts in the Quran that the only "Sunnah" is the Sunnah of God. Nowhere in the Quran is there any mention of the Sunnah of Prophet Muhammad. "You will find that the Sunnah of God is the only Sunnah". (Quran 33:62....35:43.....48:23)
As in the case of DIVISION in Islam. God says;
Do not be of the idolaters. Of those who divided their religion, and became sects; each faction pleased with what they have. (Quran 30:31-32)
They broke up into sects only after knowledge came to them, out of resentment among themselves. Were it not for a predetermined decision from your Lord, judgment would have been pronounced between them. (Quran 42:14)
As for those who divided their religion and became sects-you have nothing to do with them. Their case rests with God; then He will inform them of what they used to do. (Quran 6:159)
And hold fast to the rope of God, altogether, and do not become divided. And remember God's blessings upon you; how you were enemies, and He reconciled your hearts, and by His grace you became brethren. And you were on the brink of a pit of fire, and He saved you from it. God thus clarifies His revelations for you, so that you may be guided. (Quran 3:103)
As you can see, Quran condemns all sects. All sects in Islam, whether Sunni, Shias, Ahmaddis, Ismailli......etc have disagreements about Hadith and Sunnah attributed to Prophet Muhammad. However, these same sects have no disagreements about the Quran. It is the sources of religious laws, stories, conjectures, etc. outside the Quran which have created these sects. The different versions/conjectures of these Hadith books are the ones that gave rise to sects. Because the majority of the Muslims follow conjecture (Hadith and Sunnah) instead of Quran Alone (Quran 17:46) as our Creator has commanded, the "Muslims" are divided into sects. These sects are there because of differences and disagreements on Hadith rather than disagreements over the Quran.
Wassalam
Assalammualikum dear brother.
You said that "Sunnah is but a term, it means the way/method of someone in doing something. But do enlighten me as to what the following terms refer to: ALLAH says; "And do not take the verses of Allah in jest. And remember the favor of Allah upon you and what has been revealed to you of the Book and wisdom by which He instructs you. And fear Allah and know that Allah is Knowing of all things." [2:231] ALLAH mentioned two things being revealed here: 1) The book.
2) The wisdom. There are many verses that mention these two entities: The book and wisdom. So my question is, what does He mean by "Wisdom"? Any idea?"
Here I'm going to answer that question for you, perhaps God willing, there'll be a little more understanding in regards to the meaning of the word "Wisdom" in (Quran verse 2:231) which you've inquired.
As anyone would know, ALL Messengers of God are Blessed with WISDOM. All prophets have a high calling indeed as God’s Messengers, but with that comes an even higher responsibility. There is more to it than just speaking the word God has revealed to them. Here are some examples of wisdom given to them:
(Prophet Muhammad)
Our Lord, and raise up among them a messenger, of themselves, who will recite to them Your revelations, and teach them the Book and wisdom, and purify them. You are the Almighty, the Wise." (Quran 2:129)
Just as We sent to you a messenger from among you, who recites Our revelations to you, and purifies you, and teaches you the Book and wisdom, and teaches you what you did not know. (Quran 2:151)
And remember God's favor to you, and that He revealed to you the Scripture and wisdom to teach you. And fear God, and know that God is aware of everything. (Quran 2:231)
(Prophet Jesus)
When Jesus came with the clarifications, he said, "I have come to you with wisdom, and to clarify for you some of what you differ about. So fear God, and obey me. God is my Lord and your Lord, so worship Him-this is a straight path." (Quran 43:63-64)
(Prophet Joseph)
When he reached his maturity, We gave him wisdom and knowledge. We thus reward the righteous. (Quran 12:22)
(Prophet Lot)
And Lot-We gave him judgment and knowledge, and We delivered him from the town that practiced the abominations. They were wicked and perverted people. (Quran 21:74)
(Prophet Moses)
And when he reached his maturity, and became established, We gave him wisdom and knowledge. Thus do We reward the virtuous. (Quran 28:14)
(Prophet David)
And We strengthened his kingdom, and gave him wisdom and decisive speech. (Quran 38:20)
God sent many prophets and messengers to different people and at different times. There are only a few whose names are mentioned in the Quran but they were all blessed with Wisdom.
And a verse for all of us;
God says, "He gives wisdom to whomever He wills. Whoever is given wisdom has been given much good. But none pays heed except those with insight." (Quran 2:269)
Indeed, not only messengers and prophets of God are blessed with Wisdom, we are also given the chance to grab this wisdom if we seek for it sincerely, correctly and wholeheartedly. We can see this very principle by reading the facts clearly written in the Holy Al-Quran.
Therefore Quran equates knowledge and wisdom with righteousness. A truly knowledgeable person cannot fail to be a believer and a True believer is led to be a wise person. A fundamental duty of all Muslims is that they strive for knowledge and they be examples of the faith they practice. A truly knowledgeable person is bound to be righteous and a righteous becomes knowledgeable by virtue of his/her purity. Knowledge and wisdom comes from God Alone. A human is given inherent knowledge that can be retrieved if the 'nature' remains purer. If it gets corrupted, it fails in its capacity to sense and receive God’s Guidance. Acquired information is not knowledge: how information is sorted and viewed depends on one’s wisdom that in turn comes from God. The purer this 'nature' remains, the more forceful the connection with God to receive His Guidance to acquire knowledge and wisdom.
The Quran unequivocally asserts that there is nothing fundamentally new that is revealed to Prophet Muhammad that was not revealed to all other prophets before. Therefore there shouldn't be any "Sunnah of Prophet Muhammad" if there's no Sunnah for the rest of God's Prophets.
God says; Nothing is said to you but was said to the Messengers before you: your Lord is Possessor of Forgiveness, and Possessor of Painful Repayment. (Quran 41:43)
This is an extremely important proclamation. It essentially conveys that the fundamental ideas and teachings have remained the same throughout human history. Different religions, different dogmas, different sects, different schools of thoughts, etc. have all emerged because human beings have failed to stay with the main Message of God. The differences appeared because man has changed God’s words. The Book says all the prophets and their people (mankind) belong to one brotherhood.
This nation of yours is one nation, and I am your Lord, so fear Me. But they tore themselves into sects; each party happy with what they have. (Quran 23:52-53)
Therefore, Quran condemns human tendency to break up unity, create dissension and establish different sects out of the same religion sent to mankind through different prophets. For that reason, the Quran warns that the worst transgressors are those who change God’s words and give lies to His Message. Also serious warning that there are dreadful penalties for those who create divisions and cause dissension in humanity.
And do not be like those who separated and disputed after the clear proofs came to them; for them is a great punishment. (Quran 3:105)
God has given us the ability to reason, but too much mental reasoning blocks spiritual discernment and breeds plenty of confusion, don't you think? With that in mind, is it possible that we are reasoning ourselves out of prophetic wisdom that could be blocking our spiritual growth, our blessings, and even the full manifestation of our destiny? I’ll admit that I am analytical. I tend to reason through every possibility before making a decision. But I also pray after my thoughtful analysis and ultimately submit my plans to the written Words of God and I surrender to God's Guidance which always agree. Of course, I’m not perfect, there is still much to learn. When someone like you challenged me in regards to my own beliefs, it forced me to ponder, but am not saying that it's bad, it's actually great for the mind to question and seek answers. And I thank you for that, but my purpose is to lean not on my own understanding, even when my own understanding seems plentiful in my own eyes. Because the human heart is deceitful above all things. There is an ever-present danger of flowing in pride in all of us, instead of flowing in the wisdom that God has blessed us with. This is especially true when we consider ourselves well-versed, experts even, in any area. Knowledge will burst out like a balloon, after all pride comes before the fall. If we rely solely on our own reasoning, our own understanding, we could find ourselves shipwrecked. But if we rely on God’s Wisdom on His Reasoning, we may find ourselves with a haul of blessings so big we can’t contain them. Anyway, it's alright for you to agree to disagree. :)
May God Almighty guide us all. Wassalam.
+Rey Shin Saburo Assalamualaikum again dear brother.
As for the verse that you've inquired;
With the clarifications and the scriptures. And We revealed to you the Reminder, that you may clarify to the people what was revealed to them, and that they may reflect. (Quran 16:44)
This verse has been used to claim that since Prophet Muhammad is commissioned to explain and teach the Quran, thus we need the Hadith which explains the Quran. May I ask, do you think these verses authorize the Hadith as an additional source besides the Quran? Can the Messenger really guide people to the true meaning and message of the Quran? Do you really think that these verses authorize the Hadith as an additional source besides the Quran? Just to kindly remind you that Prophet Muhammad only had the Quran during that time when he was alive. And furthermore the words in 16:44 clearly state that the Messenger can only make things clear to the people by means of what is revealed to him (Quran). The common meaning is that the messenger delivered the Quran to the people and that he spent all his remaining days preaching the Quran and commanding people to follow it and showing them what the Quran requires them to do.
However, the messenger cannot guide anyone or guarantee that all people will understand the true message of the Quran. It is God, and God Alone, who can guide the people and truly explain the message of the book to the ones who deserve the guidance. There are numerous verses in the Quran that confirm this;
You cannot guide whom you love, but God guides whom He wills, and He knows best those who are guided. (Quran 28:56)
Say, "It is not in my power to harm you, nor to bring you to right conduct." (Quran 72:21)
Obey God and obey the Messenger, and be cautious. If you turn away-know that the duty of Our Messenger is clear communication. (Quran 5:92)
This duty does not only apply to God's messengers, it applies to any Imam, ustaz or teacher or preacher. There are thousands of such teachers all over the world today giving lectures, lessons and sermons. They all try to explain the Quran, but do all their listeners understand the message of the book? Unfortunately, the answer is NO.
God reminded us with a stern warning;
These are God's Verses which We recite to you in truth. In which message (Hadith), after God and His revelations, will they believe? (Quran 45:6)
God says, "Shall I seek a judge other than God, when He is the One who revealed to you the Book, explained in detail?" Those to whom We gave the Book know that it is the truth revealed from your Lord. So do not be of those who doubt. (Quran 6:114)
This verse above is confirmed by God Himself that the only source of law is "the Book", meaning the Quran, and so for us not to be doubtful about that fact. In addition, the messenger is prohibited from adding his own teachings to the message he received from God. If he does, he would be committing a great error that would incur a severe punishment from God. See (Quran 69:44-46) from my earlier comment. What this means is that Prophet Muhammad is authorized only in delivering the message of the Quran and nothing else. All what he preaches and which is from the Quran must be obeyed, but not any other personal teachings that do not have reference or authorization in the Quran. To obey the messenger blindly in every word he ever uttered is the work of those who are intent on making an idol out of the Prophet, don't you think?
God says, "We neglected nothing in the Scripture." (Quran 6:38) The Quran informs us that some enemies of the Prophet, described as"human and jinn devils," will fabricate lies and attribute them to the Prophet as in (Quran 6:12, 25:31). This is precisely what happened after Prophet Muhammad's death; Hadith (oral) and Sunnah (actions) were invented and attributed to the Prophet. Hadith and Sunnah are satanic innovations because they defy the Divine assertions that the Quran is complete, perfect, fully detailed, and shall be the only source of religious guidance (Quran 6:19, 38, 114 and 45:6-7). They've blasphemed against the Prophet and depicted him as a vicious tyrant who did not uphold the Quran, and created false doctrines based on superstition, ignorance, and indefensible nonsensical traditions. Prophet Muhammad was enjoined, in very strong words, from issuing any religious teachings. (Quran 69:38-48)
Therefore, all these verses concluded that Prophet Muhammad is authorized to use the Quran Alone to preach to the people. The messenger of God will pass the message of the Book to all people and invite all to accept and follow the Quran, but he cannot guide anyone nor guarantee that anyone will attain the true message of the Book. And if the messenger cannot guide anyone (as in Quran 72:21 above), so much for the claim which states that the Hadith offers guidance!
As you said it my dear brother, "but when it comes to teachings and worship, to each his own." It's sad that Islam has come to that stage in this century, but I have to reluctantly agree on that. Thank you for sharing your thoughts and for your time spent in replying, I appreciate it.
May our Lord give us goodness in this world, and goodness in the Hereafter, show us our rites, accept our repentance and protect us from the torment of the Fire. Wassalam
SubhanAllah 🥺 May Allah bless you Ustad!
[For] it was narrated from Shuraih that: He wrote to 'Umar, to ask him (a question), and 'Umar wrote back to him telling him: "Judge according to what is in the Book of Allah. If it is not (mentioned) in the Book of Allah, then (judge) according to the Sunnah of the Messenger of Allah [SAW]. - Sunan an-Nasa'i
If you cant find answers in allah book that mean you can find it in man made alterations? Doesn’t quran told us to follow only quran god words alone? Why need to follow man made to make us satisfied?
nasa'i is not sahih. typical to fall back on weak hadith to reinforce your baseless traditionalism
@@c5quared626 none of them are sahih.
@@bilalamarumosi8282 it is difficult to tell which Hadith are historically accurate. Some have multiple iterations from varied sources which are identical. The ulema consider the fact that they spend 9 years memorizing them while at the same time being brainwashed that certain positions are better than others. This is what they call Hadith science, it's a made up innovation that has no place in jurisprudence. Hadith can and should be used only for inspiration, historical interest, motivation. There are hints at worship but never direct commandments, or instruction manuals. If The Prophet of Allah wanted us to have a manual, be would have sat down and dictated it accurately, with direct instructions. This did not happen, he warned us and guided us towards oneness of Allah and superiority of the Quran over all other books. No peripheral documents were ever needed for hundreds of years. The Hadith were forbidden as a matter of fact. But to think that Muslims with firm conservative conviction and connection to hadith's would just let them go immediately is ridiculous. There would be mass revolt. Ulema need hadith's prove their and their fathers and forefathers schools of thoughts, their whole economy depends on ahadith, too much pride. It will never happen. A mufti literally told me he doesn't care about a ruling that the Quran and Hadith prove wrong, because his school of thought (deiband) has their own unproven view, and he doesn't need to show me proof.
@Rafael which ahadis of Bukhari contradict with the Quran?
@Rafael 1. The verses you gave from the Quran , about the people of Fire , these are the verses that explain the viewpoint of the jews and christians. They used to say that we will do sin and in its recompense we will only be in Hell for a while. After that we will be in heaven. To refute this idea of theirs , Allah sent this verse. Also , only the Kuffar will remain in Hell fire forver.
2. For the shahadah before death and going to paradise , it is only for Muslims. I repeat , only for Muslims. Those who belived in Allah , His messengers , His books , His angels etc. Only for Muslims.
Now , was Pharaoh a Muslim? No , he was not. He was a disbiliver , he claimed to be God , used to kill babies etc. When he was about to die , that was when he realised everything that he was doing was wrong. But it was too late for him. That is why he is not going to go to heaven. He will be punished by Allah.
There are no contradictions , no offense but only your limited knowlege of Islam , Quran and ahadis.
The source of the so called sunnah you're referring to is the hadith literature which was compiled, 200+ years after the death of Prophet Muhammad, by persian scholars (not the companions of the Prophet). In all hadiths, it's the various personalities telling you that someone has probably heard Prophet Muhammad saying such and such, whereas in the Quran it's the direct word of Allah. You can't compare the two at all.
If they hadn't compiled the hadith literature, what sunnah would have been left to follow? Would you have still considered the Quran to be an insufficient source of guidance?
quran is also hadith. theyre also product of x said y said that z said that prophet said that
Here's proof that Allah is the best teacher and that even the best of scholars can go astray.
No one questions obedience to the prophet, the question is drawing a parallel betweeb current day obedience and unverifiable claims that these are the prophets words.
@b king the prophet...
@b king Lol. He was never iliterate my friend. Ummi has always meant someone who didn't know or follow any type of religious or spiritual guidance. Allah says he teaches by the pen. There is even a sura Qalam which means pen or pencil which are used to write. I think you should do more homework and not be so quick to follow what everyone else says or does. To think that the messenger would be given a book he couldn't even read is kinda ridiculous.
@@bilalamarumosi8282 are u stupid? You didn't even know how our beloved prophet's early life was not do u know anything about his education and here just to defend yourself make false claims.
@b king Allah taught him how to read... Also the companions did write it, but it was the prophet's words(from Allah).
b king Ummi doesn’t mean illiterate.
Come on people! He never mentioned that the hadiths are equivalent to the Quran. He emphasized that you need hadiths to correctly interpret the Quran, in that sense the authentic hadiths are part and parcel with the Quran which is the truth. May Allah (SWT) grant br. Nouman jannatul ferdous and the companionship of our beloved Prophet (PBUH) for his service to Islam!
Sohan ahmed.Ameen...brother very said..JazakAllah khair
Yup thats what he mean..people say no hadith but verse in al quran say..follow al quran and hadith..seem they didnt read al quran properly..thats effect using too much translation and reject hadith.they doesnt know its sync each other.
@@br4885 thats why al quran use arabic allah swt doesnt care if you master in english i'm expertise in real debate in english as my second languange and native languange(won medal dude got certificate too)+plus also speak many languange my race usually recongize as"golden tongue"flexible..usually dominate international tilawah al quran each year..fyi even arabs learn from my race..bcs how precise we recite.About proper english currently we not in test or in school plus youtube doesnt care if using boombastic,rude,shortterm etc languange..it doesnt matter..also my habit when typing brain work faster than hand plus..simple word "what ever".Why dont you start learning what is al quran and hadith..fyi all ulama they never denied or reject hadith..unless you never met or learn from them.Ahh..try to ponder think deeply..dont you realize most of muslim who reject hadith actually they already "USE"hadith in their daily routine??try check..these people like to make a joke as always
The Quran does not external sources to be interpreted !
*not NEED external sources to be interpreted
As the Lord of the worlds Allah has said this book is enough for any disputive conversation regarding Islam
Exactly ✨
th-cam.com/video/jOT7686kj1Y/w-d-xo.htmlsi=hPbEYnN-gG9N6d59
Surah al Baqarah verse 42: And do not mix the truth with falsehood or conceal the truth while you know [it].
And: "THESE ARE THE REVELATIONS OF God WHICH WE RECITE TO YOU CORRECTLY. IN WHAT OTHER "HADITH" THAN God AND HIS REVELATIONS WOULD THEY THEN BELIEVE?" (Sura 45:6).
makes me happy to see more and more people rejecting hadiths
What make me happy..more and more people who reject it with out realize they apply hadith..🤣how you pray,how take wuduk,how or what to eat,how to work,how to fasting,how to ge friends,treat parent,take care children all of their action is part hadeeth
Whats irony they dont know that..😁since didnt learn.
alhamdullah
@@GardeniaInc you have not read quran i'm sure because if you have read quran you shoul know that wudue un the quran
@@yasamini6346 which verse?if yes why?to who that verse send to??why only that step..why you take wudu different than that step you apply in daily life😁??explain..hadith from prophet exist not after 200 years spread by orientalis..hadith exist during prophet alive..so does al quran side by side..both inherited until now through memorization..
2:57
The verse that he quoted is not about the believers.
Maarif-Ul-Quran:
The present verses and those appearing immediately earlier were revealed in the background of an incident relating to Bishr, the hypocrite. As we already know, he had first proposed Ka'b Ibn Ashraf, the Jew as the adjudicator of his dispute, but, later on, mutual discussions forced him to go to the Holy Prophet ﷺ for this purpose.
Since the judgment of the Holy Prophet ﷺ was against him, he did not accept it and went to ` Umar رضي الله عنه for a totally fresh decision.
والله أعلم
We should definitely follow the Sunnah of the prophet, and accept Hadiths, but I just wanted to point that out.
Salaamualaikum NAK! Thank you for this video! Jazah Kallah Khair Akhi and may Allah (The Glorified, The most High) grant you the strength and ability to continue what you're doing but only better :D
Ameen
Best and most detailed explanation ever heard on this topic. Although i listened from many references before, it tops , BaarakAllah feek . May Allah guide our hearts in times of pseudo arguments against our religion . Without Rasul Allah , there is no practical Islam.
is this guy serious he has muhameds name next to Allah swt like they are equal
It is very confusing!
Quranists say they believe only in the Quran but reject all Hadiths.
Well, how do you Quranists know, accept, believe that the Quran is from Allah? Who received the wahi (revelation) from Allah, then recited to companions and scribes written down - we got today's Quran.
Angel Jebreel did not come to Quranists to reveal the Quran.
So, Prophet Mohammad sa declared the Quran as God's revelation - you Quranists believe that but at the time you Quranists deny the sayings, works, advice, explanation of Quran by Prophet Muhammad sa. It is utter nonsense, illogical, ridiculous, self contradictory.
Either you believe both the Quran and Saheeh Hadiths or don't believe both.
There is no in-between, no middle way, believing in part, not believing in part.
This is new fitna.
@@HunTer-ki1gi so what. Its clearly written Allah is god and Muhammad pbuh is his messenger.
Quran is all you Need! Allah knows best.
How to we pray salah
@@knowledgeofimportantissues2364 If Quran doesn't explain about the Salah we do right now, then we are doing it wrong
@theraven900
Allah has thought us how to pray
@theraven900
You tell me
How do we pray and where you get your instraction
@theraven900
Where other muslim learn from
We have been lied that the hadiths that go against the Qur'an are not accepted, when in fact most of the hadiths being put to practice or believed in are totally contradictory to the Qur'an. I'm not a Quranist but when I read certain hadiths I get doubts about my religion and it's like reading the Old Testament or one of the anonymous Gospels. When I read the Qur'an my Iman increases by tenfold.
What? Comparing the Quran & Prophet's Sunnah to the Old & New Testaments? What's wrong with you?
@@defenderofdecency7218They didnt though
really pleased to see people on here also question the validity of Hadith. The really odd thing is this:
If hadith were meant to be followed why was there not any compiled before Bukhari gathered his?
- Some (if not the majority) of hadith are absolutely laughable and so contradictory to the Quranic verses that it's blasphemous.
- In hadith itself it is claimed that Abu Hurairah (one of the main contributors to Bukhari) shared false hadith and was reprimanded by Aisha. Also, that he had a profound fondness for female cats and detested the feminine nickname that the Prophet saw (apparently) gave him. He also allegedly got into various bitter spats with Aisha r'a. Conseuqently, surprise surprise the most mysoginistic hadith were narrated by Abu Huraira. And a really weird one where he allegedly claimed that cats were higher in status to women. He was also apparently a former jew. It is possible (no disrespect to any of the Prophets companions) that Abu Huraira could have been of the hypocrites and narrated these hadith to defile Islam. Or that other people did on his behalf. He was also I believe a former jew and spent only two years of his company with the Prophet saw. Yet his narrations are considered absolutely Sahih.
One of the hadith narrated by AH was that woman came from the rib of a man. This is widely narrated by hadith-mongers but the Quran clearly states that man and woman came from one soul. The former is a biblical belief found in genesis. Yet so many people believe it.
bob dylan God bless you my brother!
Make proper research. Hadith recording has been taking place since the time of the prophet
Muhammed Sonko you have no evidence of that be a man n don't try to lie about it
I just did completed a research about it. Read about the shaheefah of abdullah ibn amr. Imam Malick muwatta etc
Some hadith were written during the lifetime of the prophet. Take your time and research
[69:51] “And indeed, this ˹Quran˺ is the absolute truth.”
[77:50]So in which hadith after it (Quran) do they believe?
[7:185] Which hadith after it (Quran) do they believe in?
[6:112-113] And thus We have made for every prophet an enemy - devils from mankind and jinn, inspiring to one another decorative speech in deception. But if your Lord had willed, they would not have done it, so leave them and that which they invent. And [it is] so the hearts of those who disbelieve in the Hereafter will incline toward it and that they will be satisfied with it and that they will commit that which they are committing.
[31:6] And of the people is he who buys the idle / frivolous tales (lahw al-hadith) to mislead [others] from the way of God without knowledge and who takes it in ridicule. Those will have a humiliating punishment.
[45:6] These are the verses of Allah which We recite to you in truth. Then in what statement (hadith) after Allah and His verses will they believe?
[68:37] Or do you have some book in which you are studying?
[68:36-38] What is (the matter) with you? How do you judge? Or do you have a book in which you learn that indeed for you in it is whatever you choose?
[6:155] And this is a blessed Book which We brought down, so follow it and be reverent so that you may attain mercy.
[6:114 part] Then is it other than Allah I should seek as judge while it is He who has revealed to you the Book explained in detail?
[5:44 part]… And whoever does not judge by what Allah has revealed - then it is they who are the disbelievers (kafirun).
[39:23] Allah has sent down the best discourse, a book containing subjects resembling each other, mentioned again and again....
.This is the Guidance of Allah with which He brings to the right path whomsoever He wills. As for the one whom Allah lets go astray, for him there is no one to guide.
[7:2-3] A Book has been brought down to you, so let there be no constraint in your chest because of it, and so that you may warn with it. It is a Reminder for the believers.
[7:3] Follow what has been brought down to you from your Lord and do not follow any allies besides Him. Rarely do you remember!
[46:9] Say (O Muhammad), "I am not a novelty among the messengers, nor do I know what will happen to me or to you. I follow nothing other than what is revealed to me (Quran). I am no more than a clear warner."
[10:15] When Our clear revelations are recited to them, those who do not expect to meet Us say ˹to the Prophet˺, “Bring us a different Quran or make some changes in it.” Say ˹to them˺, “It is not for me to change it on my own. I only follow what is revealed to me. I fear, if I were to disobey my Lord, the punishment of a tremendous Day.”
[6:38] And there is no creature on (or within) the earth or bird that flies with its wings except (that they are) communities like you. We have not neglected in the Book (Quran) a thing. Then unto their Lord they will be gathered.
[39:25] Those who lived before them did [too] give the lie to the truth - whereupon suffering befell them without their having perceived whence it came..
[12:111] There was certainly in their stories a lesson for those of understanding. Never was the Qur’an a narration invented, but a confirmation of what was before it and a detailed explanation of all things and guidance and mercy for a people who believe.
[25:33] And they do not come to you with an argument except that We bring you the truth and the best explanation (ahsan tafsir).
[25:1] Blessed is He who sent down the Criterion upon His Servant that he may be to the worlds a warner -
And do not mix the truth with falsehood or conceal the truth while you know [it]. (2:42)
Aren't sahih hadiths mixed with weak/strong narrations?
FIRST QUESTION FOR HADITH REJECTORS.
th-cam.com/video/jJqi-pT2Cas/w-d-xo.html
@@michaelleroi8615 The strong narrations are the saheeh and hassan ones. The weak ones are not to be classified among saheeh, which means authentic.
@stormistormi1902 do you believe Muhammad is the last messenger of Allah?
@michaelleroi8615 calling prophet's words as false is something to be ashamed. Hadeeth has definitions and people who narrated the prophet's companions. Also the verses above doesn't apply hadeeth but hadeeth means خبر also which means News.
Hadith to me is useful but not absolutely important. If Hadith is 200 years later, questioning Hadith is natural but can you regard with doubts the Quran, NO.
@S h a k i b no they weren't they tried to document them 200 years after he died
@S h a k i b They were written hundreds of years after Mohammed Death
@S h a k i b Hamzah from EFDawah and historians
@S h a k i b Hadith was written centeries after muhammads death
@SYED Shakib no. They were written by the wives of the prophet or people who listened to him preach. They weren't written by muhammad or while he was alive. I'm sorry but this is the truth.
This is the best answer for this question. Ma Sha Allah❤❤❤
Point is we don’t :
Myself and by the grace of GOD millions of Quran Alone have no problem understanding and implementing the message of the Quran without the Hadiths , which the ‘scholars ‘ know are condemned by the Quran
@@mohdazhar3768 If ur bringing these points up, how is it the case for the muslims who lived way before the completion of the hadiths?
They just follow the Quran alone cus its very clear that God is not playing mental gymnastics when he said to follow Quran alone, as it is complete and detailed
@@Hugulubugulu People who lived 200 years before the Hadiths were compiled memorized the hadiths as well, and would test each other and correct each other just like they would recite quranic verses, also there are many books before Sahih Bukhari and Muslim in those 200 years which compiled hadiths, they only filtered the authentic and inauthentic ones.
How many rekats?????? Where i can find it in the quran bro
through ijma and tawatur. no need of hadith@@Mr.Fonkake
@@osamabinladen4613 You do NOT know the ijma without hadith. Without hadiths (sunnah) there is no islam. Anyone who tries to live by the Quran only is misguided. May Allah c.c guide us all.
Salam alaikum, I found some good examples and I'm thankful for them. I also found some errors and would like to highlight them to make them right.
Let me explain: 2:00 Ashab said sentences like this "Is that you saying it or is that Qur'an?" to prophet for example in Ghazwatul Badr a Sahaba (Hubbab bin Munzir) suggested to prophet to encamp to somewhere else after he asked to prophet this question. This Sahaba fought by Prophet Muhammed (saw). He wasn't a munafiq. He thought Prophet's decision of encampment was mistaken if that decision was belong to Prophet himself. So he asked to prophet "Is this your decision or a divine revelation?". Prophet said that it is his decision then this Sahaba suggested to encamp somewhere else then Prophet listened this Sahaba's decision and encamped as he suggested.
2:28 in Surah an-Nisa ayat 150 Nouman Ali Khan make a few mistakes. First he reads the ayat wrong. He says "يُفَرِّقُوا بَيْنَ اللّٰهِ وَراسوليه" (Yufarriqune beyne Allahi ve Rasulihi) but ayat is not like he read instead Allah says "يُفَرِّقُوا بَيْنَ اللّٰهِ وَرُسُلِه۪" (Yufarriqune beyne Allahi ve rusulihi). Nouman Ali Khan claims that Allah forbids to separate between Allah and Muhammad (saw) but in the ayat Allah forbids to accept some of his messengers and refuse some of them and separate some of prophets from Allah. Allah says (rusulihi) which is plural of prophet but Nouman Ali Khan says (Rasulihi) which means Prophet of Allah and Nouman says this is prophet Muhammad (saw) but he changed this ayat, Subhanallah! May Allah forgive him. And this ayat is not about accepting prophet Muhammed's (saw) hadiths this ayat is about accepting some of prophets and refusing some of other prophets.
3:54 Nouman Ali Khan mention Surah an-Nisa, ayat 65 and then he says "They have no faith. We haven't been told who these people are, yet." but he cut this ayat from context of a group of ayats, so if we start to read from ayat 59 we would see that some people say that they believe to Muhammad (saw) and then they obey to other authorities whom commands things opposite of Qur'an and these people come to prophet and say "We wanted good only." but bad things happened to them because they didn't obeyed to Allah but obeyed to other authorities. After all these context Allah says "They have to take you as an authority and obey you without doubt or they have no faith." In ayat 59 Allah commands muslims to obey to Allah, his Prophet and legal authorities who doesn't contradict with Allah. In the time of Muhammad (saw) the legal authority was Muhammed (saw) but now, in our time he passed away and we can not follow Muhammad (saw) as a living authority but we can follow legal authorities among us as mentioned in ayat 59. So ayat 65 was about that specific time of prophet Muhammad (saw) and that specific people who disobeyed to Allah and his prophet and legal authorities whom obeyed to illegal authorities. Ayat 65 doesn't command us to follow Hadiths. This ayat mentions about these specific people in those times not all people in all times.
9:14 He mentions Surah al-Qalem, ayat 4 and he tries to show this ayat as Prophet Muhammad's (saw) proof of his prophesying. But if you read the ayat before you will see that Allah says Muhammad (saw) will gain endless rewards because of his good character. And Allah doesn't say anything about Muhammad's (saw) character to prove his prophesying. So Allah doesn't say character of the Muhammad (saw) is the proof of the Qur'an.
11:55 He says ashab can't separate Qur'an and words of Muhammad (saw) then 4 minutes later he says 16:00 he says Muhammad's (saw) speech pattern was different than Qur'an. People would separate Qur'an and words of Muhammad (saw). He contradict with himself.
17:53 He says Qur'an and Sunnah narrated from the same people. But the difference is when enemies of Islam tried to add ayats to Qur'an they have failed because of Allah's protection but when enemies of Islam or even some Muslims tried to add sentences to Hadiths they have managed to do that. We can find a lot of contradictions between hadiths in the same book or between other hadith books. Qur'an has been memorized by a lot of companions but hadiths weren't memorized like Qur'an. You can't compare these two as equals. Qur'an was recited to everyone but some hadiths were only for some specific companions.
Thank you for your time. All mistakes I've made are because of my imperfection and all correct things are from wisdom of Allah. May Allah forgive me and all of us inshallah.
Brother what you wrote "in our time he passed away and we can not follow Muhammad (saw) as a living authority but we can follow legal authorities among us as mentioned in ayat 59" Subhaan Allah, you should review. May by you miss understand the sprit of Quran which leads all the believers until the last day comes to follow the Prophet Muhammad (saw) in their daily life by practicing Sunnah.
@@zulfiqarmahmood8015 Living authority means government like authority. I can't find anything about waiting at the traffic lights. He would have say something if he could live in this century but he didn't. He said somethings 14 centuries ago and some of those are irrelevant for us. We don't have to wear Arabian cloths for example. We have to follow Prophet Muhammad from Qur'an. Muhammad's examples are important if Qur'an mentions them. Other sources are changed like Bible. Allah will question us from Qur'an.
@@cihanfatihi please just stay away from the computer, how did you form this jahil, Islam is for all time, your talking about traffic lights and clothes? read the story of the Jews who were asking about pollinating the dates, Traffic lights are not about religion, the clothes have to be modest but if people want to wear what the Phrophet sallah alahi wa selim there is a reward in this . O you who believe, obey Allah and His Messenger ... " [Al-Qur'an 8:20] "Say: obey Allah and obey the Messenger ... " [Al-Qur'an 24:54] He says, "Obey Allah and the Messenger and perhaps you will be shown mercy." [Al-Qur'an 3:132] "If you obey him, you will be guided ... " [Al-Qur'an 24:54] WHats Allah saying here ? Roll up your sleeves and learn about your religion before you are called to account.
Brother Nouman, The Quranic argument is actually taken out of context. If we go back to ayah 60 we read:
أَلَمْ تَرَ إِلَى الَّذِينَ يَزْعُمُونَ أَنَّهُمْ آمَنُوا بِمَا أُنزِلَ إِلَيْكَ وَمَا أُنزِلَ مِن قَبْلِكَ يُرِيدُونَ أَن يَتَحَاكَمُوا إِلَى الطَّاغُوتِ وَقَدْ أُمِرُوا أَن يَكْفُرُوا بِهِ
Have you not seen those who claim to have believed in what was revealed to you, [O Muhammad], and what was revealed before you? They wish to refer legislation to Taghut, while they were commanded to reject it
Here the verb يَتَحَاكَمُوا is used
in this context حَتَّىٰ يُحَكِّمُوكَ فِيمَا شَجَرَ بَيْنَهُمْ is an address not to all believers ( who obey the Allah SWT and his Prophet SAW ) but to those that were taking legislation from taghut.
Note: hadith is affirmed by the Quran. Hadith can never interpret or limit the understanding of the Quran which is perfect.
why you lie , he is talking about those who claim to have believed, like you claim you are belivers
@@kkhalid4328 brother got back to the ayaat and read it for yourself . The context is very important.
this guy makes money off of this he not in it for the Truth he is in it for the Loot lol
FIRST QUESTION FOR HADITH REJECTORS.
th-cam.com/video/jJqi-pT2Cas/w-d-xo.html
JazakAllah khair brother nouman..May Allah give everyone hidayat and understanding of the quran and hadith. Ameen
According to the verses (2: 38, 39 and 2:2) following of only Quran protects man from the fire of the hell and nothing else. But according to the verse (28:50) following other things except Quran Karim is seduction. And according to the last part of the verse 18: 26 no one should take any thing associated with orders of Quran Karim. And Hadith is not from Quran Karim. But this is Hadith which has blocked the promulgation of Quran Karim. and because of this many people do not want to learn Quran Karim and then to act according to Quran Karim. But even the majority of our clerics do not Know Quran Karim and they act based on Hadith. And those they block the promulgation of Quran they will go to Hell, verse (22: 51).
promulgation
Yes brother
Quran is indeed complete and explains everything to everyone who Allah wants to guide but how many people are smart enough to understand Quran in it's only context for e.g Quran says Establish prayer and Do charity(Zakaat)
how do you know how much Zakat will be enough?
if you are an economics genius you will understand that if everyone pays 2.5% of zakat if would help the poor and won't be a burden to anyone
A normal person won't know this until he reads the HADITHS
Musnad Ahmad 711
It was narrated that ‘Ali (رضي الله عنه) said:
The Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) said: `I have relieved you of zakah on horses and slaves, so give zakah on silver: for every forty dirhams, one dirham. There is no zakah on one hundred and ninety, but if it reaches two hundred, then five dirhams are due (in zakah).`
MAY ALLAH BLESS YOU
@@hyperceptional Quran is indeed complete and explains everything to everyone who Allah wants to guide but how many people are smart enough to understand Quran in it's only context for e.g Quran says Establish prayer and Do charity(Zakaat)
how do you know how much Zakat will be enough?
if you are an economics genius you will understand that if everyone pays 2.5% of zakat if would help the poor and won't be a burden to anyone
A normal person won't know this until he reads the HADITHS
Musnad Ahmad 711
It was narrated that ‘Ali (رضي الله عنه) said:
The Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) said: `I have relieved you of zakah on horses and slaves, so give zakah on silver: for every forty dirhams, one dirham. There is no zakah on one hundred and ninety, but if it reaches two hundred, then five dirhams are due (in zakah).`
MAY ALLAH BLESS YOU
@@ADeeSHUPA Quran is indeed complete and explains everything to everyone who Allah wants to guide but how many people are smart enough to understand Quran in it's only context for e.g Quran says Establish prayer and Do charity(Zakaat)
how do you know how much Zakat will be enough?
if you are an economics genius you will understand that if everyone pays 2.5% of zakat if would help the poor and won't be a burden to anyone
A normal person won't know this until he reads the HADITHS
Musnad Ahmad 711
It was narrated that ‘Ali (رضي الله عنه) said:
The Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) said: `I have relieved you of zakah on horses and slaves, so give zakah on silver: for every forty dirhams, one dirham. There is no zakah on one hundred and ninety, but if it reaches two hundred, then five dirhams are due (in zakah).`
MAY ALLAH BLESS YOU
omg... did he just say hadith is inseperable from quran.... I am shook. Can't listen to scholars ever. Allhamdullilah we have our brain and can think for ourselves.
As soon as I heard "inseperable entities" I stopped this video..
Haeun S.
I thought all Muslims read the Hadith?
Of course they are inseparable. You need to know the seerah to understand the context of the aya.
for example. Please explain the FIRST verse of surat Al mujadila without any reference to hadith.
so if the doctor tells you that you're sick but you don't fell sick he's wrong?
Yes sister wht He said is the truth... the Glorious Qur'an and the Hadees complement each other... you cant just take the Glorious Qur'an and ignore the Hadees and vice versa.. plz dont go on spreading false conclusions...
True Islam is from the Quran ALONE.
To reject sunna is rejecting the prophet pbuhm
@@yahya2925 Salam alaikum, I found some good examples and I'm thankful for them. I also found some errors and would like to highlight them to make them right.
Let me explain: 2:00 Ashab said sentences like this "Is that you saying it or is that Qur'an?" to prophet for example in Ghazwatul Badr a Sahaba (Hubbab bin Munzir) suggested to prophet to encamp to somewhere else after he asked to prophet this question. This Sahaba fought by Prophet Muhammed (saw). He wasn't a munafiq. He thought Prophet's decision of encampment was mistaken if that decision was belong to Prophet himself. So he asked to prophet "Is this your decision or a divine revelation?". Prophet said that it is his decision then this Sahaba suggested to encamp somewhere else then Prophet listened this Sahaba's decision and encamped as he suggested.
2:28 in Surah an-Nisa ayat 150 Nouman Ali Khan make a few mistakes. First he reads the ayat wrong. He says "يُفَرِّقُوا بَيْنَ اللّٰهِ وَراسوليه" (Yufarriqune beyne Allahi ve Rasulihi) but ayat is not like he read instead Allah says "يُفَرِّقُوا بَيْنَ اللّٰهِ وَرُسُلِه۪" (Yufarriqune beyne Allahi ve rusulihi). Nouman Ali Khan claims that Allah forbids to separate between Allah and Muhammad (saw) but in the ayat Allah forbids to accept some of his messengers and refuse some of them and separate some of prophets from Allah. Allah says (rusulihi) which is plural of prophet but Nouman Ali Khan says (Rasulihi) which means Prophet of Allah and Nouman says this is prophet Muhammad (saw) but he changed this ayat, Subhanallah! May Allah forgive him. And this ayat is not about accepting prophet Muhammed's (saw) hadiths this ayat is about accepting some of prophets and refusing some of other prophets.
3:54 Nouman Ali Khan mention Surah an-Nisa, ayat 65 and then he says "They have no faith. We haven't been told who these people are, yet." but he cut this ayat from context of a group of ayats, so if we start to read from ayat 59 we would see that some people say that they believe to Muhammad (saw) and then they obey to other authorities whom commands things opposite of Qur'an and these people come to prophet and say "We wanted good only." but bad things happened to them because they didn't obeyed to Allah but obeyed to other authorities. After all these context Allah says "They have to take you as an authority and obey you without doubt or they have no faith." In ayat 59 Allah commands muslims to obey to Allah, his Prophet and legal authorities who doesn't contradict with Allah. In the time of Muhammad (saw) the legal authority was Muhammed (saw) but now, in our time he passed away and we can not follow Muhammad (saw) as a living authority but we can follow legal authorities among us as mentioned in ayat 59. So ayat 65 was about that specific time of prophet Muhammad (saw) and that specific people who disobeyed to Allah and his prophet and legal authorities whom obeyed to illegal authorities. Ayat 65 doesn't command us to follow Hadiths. This ayat mentions about these specific people in those times not all people in all times.
9:14 He mentions Surah al-Qalem, ayat 4 and he tries to show this ayat as Prophet Muhammad's (saw) proof of his prophesying. But if you read the ayat before you will see that Allah says Muhammad (saw) will gain endless rewards because of his good character. And Allah doesn't say anything about Muhammad's (saw) character to prove his prophesying. So Allah doesn't say character of the Muhammad (saw) is the proof of the Qur'an.
11:55 He says ashab can't separate Qur'an and words of Muhammad (saw) then 4 minutes later he says 16:00 he says Muhammad's (saw) speech pattern was different than Qur'an. People would separate Qur'an and words of Muhammad (saw). He contradict with himself.
17:53 He says Qur'an and Sunnah narrated from the same people. But the difference is when enemies of Islam tried to add ayats to Qur'an they have failed because of Allah's protection but when enemies of Islam or even some Muslims tried to add sentences to Hadiths they have managed to do that. We can find a lot of contradictions between hadiths in the same book or between other hadith books. Qur'an has been memorized by a lot of companions but hadiths weren't memorized like Qur'an. You can't compare these two as equals. Qur'an was recited to everyone but some hadiths were only for some specific companions.
Thank you for your time. All mistakes I've made are because of my imperfection and all correct things are from wisdom of Allah. May Allah forgive me and all of us inshallah.
@@cihanfatihi I was a bit confused of about half of what you said because I'm a new Muslim and your english wasn't too great. Apologies sister
@@yahya2925 Sorry about my bad English. I criticised Nouman Ali Khan. Almost all of his arguments are false. I'm studying Islam for 14 years. Studied Islam for 5 years at Islamic University in Turkey. I've read more than 20 different Qur'an translations 11 Tafseers and finally I concluded that Hadiths are just history books. Hadiths can't force a muslim to do something. I wish you could talk Turkish so I could suggest you more capable scholars than me. I may try to explain the point that confused you in my writing if you wish. And I'm a male. Cihan mean world, pronounced as Jeehan and Fatih means conqueror. Conqueror of the world is nickname I made up since my childhood.
@@cihanfatihi Summarize why hadiths are invalid for practice? What about the hadith that says all sects will go to hell except 1?
Main questions: do i believe in god? Yes. Do i believe in the quran? Yes. Do i believe in mohamed saw? Yes. Do i believe in the words of mohamed saw? Yes. Do i believe that none of his words has been written down incorrectly by other people about 200 years later? No.
God is All-Knowing
@Packo Abdulqader pitty. You think this new movement is the truth. Si we been deceived all along and gi to hell huh? Brother I am sorry for you.
Packo Abdulqader how do you understand this verse without Hadith Quran 5 38 [As for] the thief, the male and the female, amputate their hands in recompense for what they committed as a deterrent [punishment] from Allah . And Allah is Exalted in Might and Wise.
Packo Abdulqader this verse is telling us to cut of thieves hands, and without Hadith we cannot know which thieves are this rules apply to, is it the one who steals dollar or the one who robs bank 🤷🏽♂️
Packo Abdulqader i just asked you a question why you mad? Just answer my question from the Quran alone, give me verses that explain this verse?
It's so sad to hear that he's not only insulting Quran, misinterpreting the verse., which isn't about Hadith books.
@Haaris Toor these people just say something without evidence
@Irfan Alddin are you stupid? There a lot of hadiths which aren't true and fabricated but just because of them you are trying to completely dimiss what our prophet said us(through his companions). In order to find what is right and what is wrong there is a complete science of hadiths.
@Irfan Alddin my dear friend the science of hadiths is quite complicated but in a simpler form it's the study of isnad. We look at the chain of transmitters and by that we understand whether a hadiths is fabricated or not. All most all the hadiths credibility depends upon the transmitters. If the transmitters are well known among our ummah to be among pious people along with being the people who studied under the companions and thier offsprings then they are credible if not then they aren't. Once the credibility of the person in the chain is determined the content is also of one the very important factor for hadiths bring true or not. After a detailed study on all these factors hadiths are given their ranks. Hope you understand that
@Irfan Alddin oh sorry I don't not read your entire comment it seems you consider isnads being useless. If that's the case plz tell my why do you think isnads are useless. Because great alims of past who dedicated their entire lives towards our religion consider the science of isnad the best way and even a modern day person with enough knowledge understand this method to be best. But you laymen consider it to be wrong and we are supposed to believe you. Plz state your reason why science of isnads is wrong. I am sure u cannot but still let me see how ignorant one can be. Plz state your reasons
@Irfan Alddin what kind of illogical argument are u putting? You are depending on people means what? Don't try to beat around the bush. State it clearly or just accept your ignorance
Especially when you see their writings matching up with the New Testament writings you can see that they both go hand-in-hand with each other they are working and playing off each other you can see it very clearly
But the hadith was complied 200 year after the Prophet. And in the hadith there are lots of contradictions.
They got this thing called isnad. Authentication of hearsay. It's still hearsay.
Yeah... Quran is the most authentic book. Hadiths got Contradictions but that doesn't say don't follow hadith. Just follow you think best in case of contradiction. Refer to scholars.
As Muslims we all know the story in Quran about when some of the jin listened to Quran
46:29
"وَإِذْ صَرَفْنَآ إِلَيْكَ نَفَرًۭا مِّنَ ٱلْجِنِّ يَسْتَمِعُونَ ٱلْقُرْءَانَ فَلَمَّا حَضَرُوهُ قَالُوٓا۟ أَنصِتُوا۟ ۖ فَلَمَّا قُضِىَ وَلَّوْا۟ إِلَىٰ قَوْمِهِم مُّنذِرِينَ"
"˹Remember, O Prophet,˺ when We sent a group of jinn your way to listen to the Quran. Then, upon hearing it, they said ˹to one another˺, “Listen quietly!” Then when it was over, they returned to their fellow jinn as warners."
46:30
"قَالُوا۟ يَـٰقَوْمَنَآ إِنَّا سَمِعْنَا كِتَـٰبًا أُنزِلَ مِنۢ بَعْدِ مُوسَىٰ مُصَدِّقًۭا لِّمَا بَيْنَ يَدَيْهِ يَهْدِىٓ إِلَى ٱلْحَقِّ وَإِلَىٰ طَرِيقٍۢ مُّسْتَقِيمٍۢ"
"They declared, “O our fellow jinn! We have truly heard a scripture revealed after Moses, confirming what came before it. It guides to the truth and the Straight Way."
46:31
"يَـٰقَوْمَنَآ أَجِيبُوا۟ دَاعِىَ ٱللَّهِ وَءَامِنُوا۟ بِهِۦ يَغْفِرْ لَكُم مِّن ذُنُوبِكُمْ وَيُجِرْكُم مِّنْ عَذَابٍ أَلِيمٍۢ"
"O our fellow jinn! Respond to the caller of Allah and believe in him, He will forgive your sins and protect you from a painful punishment"
46:32
"وَمَن لَّا يُجِبْ دَاعِىَ ٱللَّهِ فَلَيْسَ بِمُعْجِزٍۢ فِى ٱلْأَرْضِ وَلَيْسَ لَهُۥ مِن دُونِهِۦٓ أَوْلِيَآءُ ۚ أُو۟لَـٰٓئِكَ فِى ضَلَـٰلٍۢ مُّبِينٍ"
"And whoever does not respond to the caller of Allah will have no escape on earth, nor will they have any protectors against Him. It is they who are clearly astray.”"
Did they take to their kin other than Quran
Quran is the truth
Jinns are not invisible creatures that you have been told by sectarians.
Jinns are humans with some specific characteristics.
I personally have a problem with inconsistencies. I view The Quran as the book of Law. In law, you always refer back to the constitution when a by-law contradicts with it or says something that is not of the intention of the constitution. Lets not forget, by-laws are created by those who want to impose their own laws or add laws for their own purposes. When an inconsistency occurs between the two, the constitution prevails.
This is actually a principle within Islam. If a hadith contradicts the Quran, then the hadith is rejected. But that doesn't mean we don't take the authentic hadith that agree with/and elaborate verses of the Quran. Both are extremely important. The Quran is more important, but the latter is also extremely important.
@@DatShakeel God claims the Quran itself is a guidance, so when Muslims follow Hadith, the prayer they do daily (4 zakat), where is it in the Quran? God says the Quran is complete and is a guidance, why is this Islamic teaching not in the Quran? The second they go out of the Quran, their actions say that the Quran is incomplete...so how can a Muslim go to heaven if he is against God's own words?🔥
@@wolfblockstrike2924 Allah says in the Quran to obey the messenger. How are you going to obey the messenger without the hadith?
@@mdasim891 where does the Quran say you SHOULD ONLY PRAY 3 TIMES A DAY?
‘It is He who has sent down to you, [O Muḥammad], the Book; in it are verses [that are] precise - they are the foundation of the Book - and others unspecific. As for those in whose hearts is deviation [from truth], they will follow that of it which is unspecific, seeking discord and seeking an interpretation [suitable to them]. And no one knows its [true] interpretation except Allāh. But those firm in knowledge say, "We believe in it. All [of it] is from our Lord." And no one will be reminded except those of understanding.’ Quran 7:3
@@DatShakeel what's the messengers goal? To deliver God's words only, the messengers are dead today, so how do we follow them? All of the messengers SAYINGS are in the QURAN. So when you follow Quran, you follow both God and his messengers!💛 Also Hadith isn't written by The messenger, it's written by Sha sunni, they said Muhammed wanted Abu bakir, no he wanted Ali as his successor, so it's not reliable cause we don't know what Muhammad actually said.🔥 So dont you think following Quran is enough to get heaven?
59:7 | ... *Whatever the Messenger gives you, take it. And whatever he forbids you from, leave it* . And fear Allah. Surely Allah is severe in punishment.
Exactly. as he would relay the quran only. Anything said 100s of years later with a chain of narration longer than a phone book is absurd. If Allah swt wanted to protect the ahadith as he did the quran he could have done so. Funny how each sect has their own ahadith eh? as they were created to promote secular and political views. The muslims were rotten after the rasool pbuh died. Civil war, assassinations etc. I do not trust one word coming from them.
I wonder why you quoted that without context.
At least quote the whole ayah.
"As for gains granted by Allah to His Messenger from the people of ˹other˺ lands, they are for Allah and the Messenger, his close relatives, orphans, the poor, and ˹needy˺ travellers so that wealth may not merely circulate among your rich. Whatever the Messenger gives you, take it. And whatever he forbids you from, leave it. And fear Allah. Surely Allah is severe in punishment."
I agree with this wholeheartidly. All of my questions were answered as they were raised in my mind, and i do believe this is a very difficult subject to talk about in a way such that people understand, but yet again you did it in an honestly awesomely manner. I can't even express it, it's just that good. One thing I have to stress of which you also said yourself, believing and following the character of the Prophet SAW is paramount to being a muslim, but followng hadiths blindly or applying them wrongly into situations by painting broad strokes or misunderstanding the moral behind the hadiths is in a sense only slightly less bad as disregarding them altogether. Also, there are writings that portray themselves as genuine hadiths, genuine accounts of the Prophet's character SAW, yet have been revealed to be very likely lies and/or conjectures. That's when we have to be critical as muslims too, and try to avert ourselves from putting into practice things which the Quran (and Islam) doesn't promote.
The distinciton is this: If I know or have a strong indication that something genuinely comes from or is an account about the Prophet SAW and his character, that's when I abide by it wholeheartidly as a muslim, as Allah SWT himself described him, and he has been witnessed, as being the embodiment of the teachings of the Quran. Basically, a muslim wouldn't disagree with the Prophet SAW in his teachings and doings, given that they're from him. If I f.ex. stood in front of the Prophet SAW and he would tell me to do something, I would abide by it the same way I would abide by the things that are written in the Quran.
***** I agree with your sentiment. If a hadith doesn't make sense to me and, more importantly, if I find it to be from a bad source, I'll discard it. However I won't rule all of the hadiths out necassarily, source criticism is key and using common sense, thinking as the Quran bids us to do, is th key to have a balanced understanding with or without hadith. You're right though, I have to be wary of bad hadith that can constrict my understanding of the breadth of wonder that is Islam.
@@Yous0147 If that's the case then I'll just learn and follow the Qur'an which is guaranteed from Allaah.
@@Junior-yt6cx The quran instructs to obey Allah and obey His final messenger Muhammad SAWS. Not follows what one think is OK to follow and what one thinks is not OK to follow. This mindset are the so called ( Quranists) But this title is not befitting on them.They are literalists. They have been debunked all the time. In every arena. Totaly lost people
@@Yous0147lol only consider what modern moral considers bad to be Weak or False. But everything Good is true and Authentic.
Lol that is lying to yourself to me
It's very simple brothers. He quotes verse 4:65 which is one of the most abused verses of the Qur'an.
If you start reading from verse 60, you can easily see that it's referring to the hypocrits who were still seeking judgement from their false dieties (Taghoot). And Allah obviously is responding by saying they (munafikeen) can have no faith until they make the prophet Muhammad (as) a judge in their disputes. The arabic word used in verse 65 is 'yuhakkimooka' which comes from the root 'Ha Kaf Meem' and has the following meanings in arabic:
To refrain from, exercise authority, command, judge, give judgement, be wise.
It's no coincidence that in the SAME chapter, Allah says in verse 105:
Indeed, We have revealed to you, [O Muḥammad], the Book (Alkitaab) in truth so you may judge (litahkuma) between the people by that which Allah has shown you. And do not be for the deceitful an advocate.
The word 'litahkuma' shares the SAME root as the word 'yuhakkimooka' in verse 65! Therefore, the prophet Muhammad (as) ONLY JUDGED by what was revealed to him from THE BOOK!! The Qur'an also says in verse 2:213:
Mankind was [of] one religion [before their deviation]; then Allah sent the prophets (annabiyeena) as bringers of good tidings and warners and sent down with them the Scripture (alKitaab) in truth to judge (liyahkuma) between the people concerning that in which they differed.
Is Muhammad (as) excluded from the above Verse?? I don't think so and the following verse seals the deal:
[Say], "Then is it other than Allah I should seek as judge (hakaman) while it is He who has revealed to you the Book (alkitaab) [i.e., the Qur’ān] explained in detail?" And those to whom We [previously] gave the Scripture know that it is sent down from your Lord in truth, so never be among the doubters. {6:114}
What more needs to be said brothers?? But if you want to continue following your Lawlal-Hadeeth then be my guest. I'll stick with Ahsanal-Hadeeth (Qur'an 39:23).
Peace
All the arguments so far i have heard including yours, in support of Hadith are not as logical as the arguments in against of the Hadith. The most logical thing is that even if you pass on this message orally through a chain of 20 people, the 20th one will not be able to repeat the message as it is sure to get corrupted. Hadiths were passed over 200 years through a chain of numerous people. It was provenly corrupted as several hadiths were already removed.
Faizan Ansari that's where ill are rajjal comes in it separates the weak Hadith from the authentic ones
That shows you don’t have a clue in hadith field since chains rarely goes beyond 5 persons in Sahih books and have multiple path anyway.
@@Wouda_fr who needs to go thru all that when the Qur'an is sufficient?
Svobodniy Razum actually their are hundreds of manuscripts of Sunni books but I don’t believe in Sunni books as I’m a Shia and their is UNDENIABLE proof that the books like Bukhari and Muslim are distorted but let me just ask you this how exactly do you know that the Prophet didn’t know who the Munafikeen were in Medina? Of course God revealed it to him but when exactly? And my second question is where in the Quran does it tell us how to pray? PS. How in the hell do you think we know about The Munafiks in Medina and in The Ummah in general? People wrote biographies on them after their deviancy and evil was made public and they were condemned by The Prophet (S) but anyway those are my questions so answer them Mr Quranist
satoshi miyazaki it's not conjecture pal if one was to study Sunni sources he will QUICKLY realize that they are all distorted, violent and fabricated the only authentic sources are the narrations and Hadith of the AhlulBayt (AS) which are in Shia sources if you honestly think Sunni books are reliable then your just as lost as the idiotic quranists
The Quran says that we should believe in our prophet but it doesn't say anything about a hadith, a written account of what the prophet did by other men written 250 years after our prophets death. The hadiths validity is so much lower than the Quran and we should only listen to those that work well with the Quran. Otherwise we can't believe the hadith.
Quran does mention hadith! The hadith of Allah! "And what hadith will you accept after this one?"
MustBe TheMost That's true. The quran is the hadith of Allah. We won't except any other hadith. Not the hadith of men.
+salman I certainly won't use hadith.
Because they will use hadith against me, in parts where Mohammad kisses the penis of Hussain and Hassan. Or the parts where mohammad allows rape (Nika with no dowry, just a scarf), and numerous vile things.
The sira of mohammad was written much sooner, about 100 years after the prophet. This can be used to extrapolate info, but the Quran is all you need.
You must agree that ISIS and other terrorist radicals are all learning from hadith.
31:6 Among the people, there are those who
accept baseless hadiths to mislead from
the path of God without knowledge, and
they take it as entertainment. These will
have a humiliating retribution.
45:6 These are God's signs that We recite to
you with truth. So, in which hadith, after
God and His signs, do they
acknowledge?
45:7 Woe to every sinful fabricator.
45:8 He hears God's signs being recited to
him, then he persists arrogantly, as if he
never heard them. Give him news of a
painful retribution.
77:47 Woes on that day to the deniers!
77:48 When they are told to kneel, they do not
kneel.
77:49 Woes on that day to the deniers!
77:50 So in what hadith after it (the Quran) will they
acknowledge?
+kbg astaghfaraalh.
"Not the hadith of men" ???
god says about the prophet:
""Nor does he speak from [his own] inclination, It is not but a revelation revealed," 53:3-4
when was the quran written? AFTER THE PROPHETS DEATH.
the hadiths went through the same phase as the quran, whatever the prophet told them to do, they did, and they didn't need to write it down because they memorized everything, but if the quran and the hadiths weren't written down they would have disappeared by now because of these modern technologies, people nowadays cant remember their own phone number and you expect them to remember everything the prophet said.
"O you who have believed, obey Allah and obey the Messenger and those in authority among you. And if you disagree over anything, refer it to Allah and the Messenger, if you should believe in Allah and the Last Day. That is the best [way] and best in result" 4:59 we have to obey god first (quran) and the messenger second (hadiths) and those in authority (scholars) and we have to use what they say in our problems, first you go to the quran if you cant find what youre looking for you go to the hadiths and if you still cant find what youre looking for you ask a scholar.and god says that its the best way and it has the best results, but now you are saying "NO" there is a better way.
if you read the quran, when ever it says "obey god" its accompanied by "and obey his messenger"
bro believe, I know you don't read the quran not frequently, because a person who reads the quran cant say that hadiths are fake, just an advice, go read the quran.
how do you pay zakat??? how do you pray??? do you just make things up or do you want to listen to the prophet
We don’t need Hadiths, nobody can force me to follow Hadiths, I will only follow Quran and Allah and not Hadiths written by man 250 years after the prophets death.
So how did the quran come to you?
@@ashrafqarashi5596 by memorisation done by people over centuries, and the promise Allah made in the Qur'an that it'll be safeguarded by Him; did Allah mention something about hadith?
People have memories the quran from beginning to end ,that's the miracle and no contradiction, the hadith have ma y corrupted hadith and it cant be memorize like the Quran, its not from Allah
i wonder how u pray through. because AL Quran dont specify the specific things to do and say during solah.
@@tirmizikhamsani9137 its you that don’t believe/trust in the Words of Allah.
It is quite intriguing how both Quran-only followers and traditional Sunnis both use the same verses to prove each other wrong. Brother Nouman makes a compelling argument with 4:65 (until they make you oh Muhammad their judge/decision maker). Though I can see the Quranists countering this with 4:105, 5:48-49 and 2:213, where the Prophet/s (a.s.) are ordered to make judgement in accordince with the Book/what has been brought down to them.
I thought the same, im confusef. Because both sound convincing.
@@mustafasadir3017 That is because some disbelievers in the time of the prophet peace be upon him were saying to him "Did you said that on your own or did Allah say that" they were trying to instill doubt by accusing that the prophet added things from himself and there is a verse about that : Surah An-Nisa (4:150-151):
150: إِنَّ ٱلَّذِينَ يَكْفُرُونَ بِٱللَّهِ وَرُسُلِهِۦ وَيُرِيدُونَ أَن يُفَرِّقُوا۟ بَيْنَ ٱللَّهِ وَرُسُلِهِۦ وَيَقُولُونَ نُؤْمِنُ بِبَعْضٍۢ وَنَكْفُرُ بِبَعْضٍۢ وَيُرِيدُونَ أَن يَتَّخِذُوا۟ بَيْنَ ذَٰلِكَ سَبِيلًا
151: أُو۟لَـٰٓئِكَ هُمُ ٱلْكَـٰفِرُونَ حَقًّۭا ۚ وَأَعْتَدْنَا لِلْكَـٰفِرِينَ عَذَابًۭا مُّهِينًۭا
but the problem is that the prophet peace be upon him is not with us living so we can't really make if he really said some hadiths even tho they are graded authentic because still that grading is subjective , if hadiths in total from all the 6 sunni books were 10000 hadiths you can't really be 100% sure that all of them were true , I mean majority would be true wa Lahu aalam but still , about 100 to 200 which is like one percent could be fabricated and we will never know , and those few hadiths that were not true and graded sahih makes a lot of problems in muslim communities as some scholars have a hard way to explain them and lose their logic explaining some of them meaning they also lose their credibility in other things that they were true about regarding other matters , that is why I don't believe that all the ahadiths mentionned in the 6 sunni books are true (99% were true and Allah knows best)
*Al-Ankabut 51. Is it not enough for them that We have sent down to you the Book, ˹which is˺ recited to them. Surely in this ˹Quran˺ is a mercy and reminder for people who believe.*
Yes he went through that and explained the meaning of it. Does not go against the sunnah of the prophet.
hahahahahahaha@@ThePurplizer
You didn't say when the Hadith was written,
It was written 200 years after death of our prophet
If you couldn't remember what did you eat last month then the hadith is
Nit reliable
And albukhari gathered 600000 hadith in 25 years without fast transportation, without internet, without phone and he travelled thousands of kilometers to do that
Please explain to me how he did that, and even his student Muslim removed a lot of hadith that don't make sense from albukhari book
Is this hadith worth to believe in ?
I don't think so
Excellent brother well done for pointing this out. Allah has given you wisdom that’s why you can understand right from wrong.
@Fans humanity lol they pretty much all contradict quran.
Stoning people for zina
Killing people for leaving the religion
And i could name more nonsense attributes to our prophet in the filthy hadiths.
brother you should read hadith terminology to know how Ulma accept or reject the hadith.
@Fans humanity you are the perfect example of whats so dangerous about hadiths.
ALLAH gave you only 2 situations where the death penalty is allowed. Yet you go against his words and follow devils like bukhari. How dare you send someone to allah when its not his time yet, devil. You think Allah is dependent on you?
There is no compulsion in religion, there is not a punishment for leaving islam in the Quran. For you to claim our honorable prophet would go against the word of allah makes you a blasphemer, fuckface.
@Fans humanity “I respect these laws”
Laws coming from humans and not from Allah.
I spit on lowlife honorless people like you who tarnish the name of our religion. You will get your punishment though .. one way or another. Shirk will not be forgiven, you are warned.
Reliable narrators ? Those who divided Islam. Those who narrated stories. Are narrations still the same 250 years after ? Why no Arabs collected so many thousands of narrations, but a persians and btw almost all hadiths collectors were from persia.
Quran 6:141 ....Eat of its fruit when it yields and give its due [zakah] on the day of its harvest.
Abu Dawood (1572) narrated from ‘Ali (may Allah be pleased with him) that the Prophet (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him) said: “If you have two hundred dirhams and one full year has passed, then five dirhams are due on them. You do not have to pay anything - i.e. on gold -- unless you have twenty dinars; if you have twenty dinars and one full year has passed, then half a dinar is due on them, and if the number increases then work it out on this basis.”
The Quran asks the Muslims to give zakat ON THE DAY OF THE HARVEST ( the day one receives his income ), but the followers of Mr bukhari holds the Zakaat, holds it from the poor for a whole year, then gives the poor ONLY 2.5% of the income.
This is how Islam is destroyed Mr Nouman. Think of difference that this makes between following Allah and following Mr bukhari. Could be I am wrong, BUT I prefer be someone who gives Zakaat every time I earn my income than hold it for a year. What if the narrator was wrong ? what would I tell Allah on Judgement DAY ?
A trusted narration that bukhari qualified as SAHIH : Volume 5, Book 58, Number 188 :
Narrated by 'Amr bin Maimun
During the pre-lslamic period of ignorance I saw a she-monkey surrounded by a number of monkeys. They were all stoning it, because it had committed illegal sexual intercourse. I too, stoned it along with them.
Was monkeys marrying at that time ?
Did the hadith of stoning existed at that time ?
Were the monkeys muslims or jews ?
Is it allowed for a human to stone monkeys ?
Was Mr 'Amr bin Maimun imitating monkeys or following their religion ?
BUKHARI HADITH: Volume 1, Book 6, Number 298:
Narrated 'Aisha:
The Prophet and I used to take a bath from a single pot while we were Junub. During the menses, he used to order me to put on an Izar (dress worn below the waist) and used to fondle me. While in Itikaf, he used to bring his head near me and I would wash it while I used to be in my periods (menses).
Comment: Please compare this to the Quranic surah:
002:222
"And they ask you about menstruation. Say: It is a discomfort; therefore keep aloof from the women during the menstrual discharge and do not go near them until they have become clean; then when they have cleansed themselves, go in to them as Allah has commanded you; surely Allah loves those who turn much (to Him), and He loves those who purify themselves."
Volume 7, Book 62, Number 31:
Narrated Ibn 'Umar:
Evil omen was mentioned before the Prophet: The Prophet said, "If there is evil omen in anything, it is in the house, the woman and the horse."
Volume 7, Book 62, Number 32:
Narrated Sahl bin Sad:
Allah's Apostle said, "If at all there is bad omen, it is in the horse, the woman, and the house."
Reliable narrators that will guide people to HELL. Are these words of the prophet ?
69:40 This is the speech of an honourable Messenger,
not the speech of a poet. Little do you believe!
Nor is this the speech of a soothsayer. Little do you reflect!
It has been revealed by the Lord of the Universe.
And if Muhammad had made up about Us some [false] sayings,
We would have seized him by the right hand;
Then We would have cut from him the aorta.
Are these hadith complementary with the Holy Quran ? are these types of stories we need to understand the Quran ?
Stop being biased by the saytan, be safe, follow the Quran.
77:50 In what discourse (Hadith ) after this (Qur'an) will they, then, believe?
43:43 So hold fast to what has been revealed to you. Surely you are on the Straight Way.
46:9 Tell them: “I am not the first of the Messengers; and I do not know what shall be done with me or with you. I follow only what is revealed to me, and I am nothing but a plain warner.”
Thank You i got all my answers again. cause whenever i read hadith again it gives me same shit which i got in past. and i am a-sectarian Muslim i.e i don't follow any sect, hadith and tafsir or explanation of Qur'an by traditionalist muslims.
Salaam
Ali Ismael
Nothing in those hadiths and acts of Prophet against Quran or degradation to Prophet's status!!
"Stay Away from menstruating women" means "to abstain from sex" -- this is the understanding that we get when we learn Prophet's life and actions - if you take such literal meanings of the Quran yourself then take such meanings here too -
1) [The believers are] those who follow the Messenger, the unlettered Prophet, whom they find written down with them in the Torah and the Gospel, commanding them to do right and forbidding them to do wrong, making good things lawful for them and bad things forbidden for them, relieving them of their heavy loads and the chains that were around them. Those who believe in him, honor and help him, and follow the Light that has been sent down with him are successful. (Surat al-A`raf: 157)
2) Say: "If you love Allah, then follow me and Allah will love you and forgive your sins." (Surah Al `Imran: 31)
.
.
.
.
Hehehehe.....those Quranites jump off the hills after reading these verses - REMEMBER YOU HAVE TO TAKE DIRECT MEANING OF QURAN , no "but" no "if" no "it actually means" and no rubbish at all!!
Take one more :-
3) Say, "Obey Allah and the Messenger." But if they turn away - then indeed, Allah does not like the disbelievers.
NOwhere did the Quran say here to follow the revelation or the Quranic verses - its a direct order to do whatever the Prophet is saying!! .
.
.
.
And you Quranites do not use other Ayats of the Quran to propagate your foolish agenda -- otherwise we will use your own methodoly of referring to different Quran ayats and then taking meaning and show you 100 contradictions in the Quran and make you accept that as Quran has contradiction its not a word of God and you will have to accept openly that u are not a muslim (while until now you are hypocrites)
Indeed, We have revealed to you, [O Muhammad], the Book in truth so you may judge between the people by that which Allah has shown you. And do not be for the deceitful an advocate. 4:105
The messenger must use only the book to judge between the people.
Dear Brother Nouman, please dont keep the picture of Allah and Mohammed sallallahu aliahiwassalam in the way you kept, (behind you in the shelf) which resemble similarity in position. Kindly keep Allah always above whatever object you have.
izra for jews , isa for christains.......
Obedience to Allah and obedience to prophet is same ...WORSHIPPInG is ONLY for Allah..u can refer to NAK lectures on bayyinah tv
Surah: 45 | Ayat: 6
تِلۡکَ اٰیٰتُ اللّٰہِ نَتۡلُوۡہَا عَلَیۡکَ بِالۡحَقِّ ۚ فَبِاَیِّ حَدِیۡثٍ ۢ بَعۡدَ اللّٰہِ وَ اٰیٰتِہٖ یُؤۡمِنُوۡنَ ﴿۶﴾
TRANSLATION :
These are the verses of Allah which We recite to you in truth. Then in what hadeeth after Allah and His verses will they believe?
It's not hadith what this guy meant, if you read it carefully you will understand
Salaam,
After the thorough study of the Quran, and the critical analysis of Nouman Ali Khan's arguments in favour of the Hadith literature, in the video, I must say that Nouman is playing a game with the Aqeedah of people either intentionally or in ignorance, but Anyway.
Let's analyse his baseless Arguments in favour of the Hadith literature.
I say these are baseless Arguments because Nouman tries to prove his own beliefs using Quran by quoting the verses of the Quran out of the context completely. Let's see.
Nouman Quoted Chapter 4, Verse 65 of the Quran, which says
"But No, By your Lord, they have no Faith untill they make you ( O Messenger) judge, concerning that over which they dispute among themselves and then find within themselves no discomfort from what you ( O Messenger) have Judged and Submit in total Submission"
Now Nouman cleverly tried to fit the verse with his beliefs, in favour of Hadith literature, by saying that the verse doesn't tell us about whom Allah is saying that they have no faith, untill according to Nouman, we read further into the verse and thus claiming that the verse is about those who don't make the messenger the Judge between their disputes and be comfortable with it with full submission, which he says is to follow the Hadith literature. See the 4:55 moment of the video.
I am astonished to see how Nouman plays with people because the verse has it's clear context starting from Verse 60, which says,
"Have you not seen those who claim that they have believed in what was revealed to you and what was revealed before you? They wish to go for Judgement ( in their disputes) to Taghut ( The false God or Deity), when they have been ordered to reject it ; but Satan wishes to lead them far Astray".
Note: The Arabic word for "Judgement" in verse 60 of Chapter 4, is exactly the same word in Verse 65 of Chapter 4 where Allah Points out to the Messenger or the message he receives being the Judge, which comes from the same root word Haa-Kaaf-Meem.
So as you can see while reading from Verse 60 and afterwards, that Allah is talking about the Hypocrites who wished to go for their judgement in their disputes to a false God Taghut about whom Allah later, after 4 verses says that, they have no faith untill they make you ( which in the context refers to messenger) Judge, meaning untill they make The message of the prophet as a Judge which is Signified in the word "Rasul" in the context of previous verse and Confirmed in the Quran in many places, that the messenger judges between people by the Quran or revelation and it's even defied by the Quran to assume the judge other than God or his revelation through messenger. See Chapter 21, Verse 112, Chapter 2, Verse 213, Chapter 5, Verse 45, Chapter 4, Verse 105, Chapter 5, verse 48, Chapter 5, verse 45 etc. There is just no way that one one argue the other way.
Now if one is to say that the judge is the prophet himself, meaning that his sayings other than the Quran, then I see the same shirk and Kufr in those people as was in those Hypocrites who wished to make Taghut as their judge, which in the former case would be replacing Taghut by Prophet Himself. ( May Allah protect us from such a grave sin).
I also Noticed how Nouman confused alot in the video without realising what he was talking about. From 11:27 moment of the video, Nouman Talked about How Hadith and Quran were inseparable, in a sense that there was no book called Quran and Books of Hadiths to Differentiate between the two in the Early times, referring to the time when Quran was not compiled in a Book Form. And thus arguing that Quran and Hadiths were actually the same things to people of that time cause they couldn't separate the two as the source was the one i.e The voice of Prophet. But Notice a Contradiction is his own speech at 16:01 moment of the Video where he says, that Quran and Hadith were being completely different to people who listened to the prophet reciting Quran and saying other than the Quran, because of their different style, vocabulary etc. He even Admits that the whole stuff of Hadith literature doesn't even come close to Quran in it's linguistics.
"So High is Allah, the Sovereign, the Truth, and (O Muhammad), do not hasten with the Quran before it's revelation is completed to you, and say, "My Lord, Increase me in Knowledge"". ____ Quran 20: 114
Athar S. Baba Then if we follow you, all the predecessors of Muhammad sws doesn't have to follow the messengers of God, because there wasn't a protected book???
If you agree with the assumption that the only book who is flawless is qu'ran, that
we are the only community who can actually follow God because we have an untouched book,
so why is God talking about our predecessors who followed his words without a book??? Ppl who where following words of others messengers, wich passed trough the centuries??
Before the Holly book there wasn't any protected book!!
Just texts compiled as Ahadith!!
There is nothing more accurate in the historical compilation than Ahadith!!
Go study it before talking nonsense!!!
The Bible isn't at all compiled the same way.
Rejecting mutawatir???? Foolish!
It is even more accurate than the story of Napoleon Waterloo Battle.
This people are defending the supreme incoherence.
The Book AND the path of the messenger are the revelation. They are indivisible.
If you can't trust in the Ahadith, you can't trust in qu'ran. It was the same ppl who passed it.
Moreover Without the Sunnah, you are in fact applying your own ijtihad on the Qu'ran.
There is NO Qu'ran only.
It is either your brain or the perfect exemple of Muhammad sws
You prefer your understanding than the one that the prophet gives us.
Even if there is a minor chance to get something wrong from reading Qu'ran and Ahadith, you multiply it by reading it just with your reason.
The Qur'an as the only source is a lure.
The Koranists do not take into consideration one factor: the fact that the analysis of the Quran rests on our reason, which is itself fallible.
Why then accept this margin of error in understanding the Qur'an and not in the Sunnah?
In rejecting the Ahadiths, logic would have them reject the Qur'an as well.
The Quran is immediately disqualified, if the criterion is infallibility in the application of the precepts of God.
By rejecting the Sunnah, they are just multiplying the margin of error by trying to apply religion only with their reason.
This margin exists WITH or WITHOUT the Ahadiths.
All that we risk in applying the Sunna, while remaining critical, is to be closer to what Allah enjoins us to do.
not to mention that the predecessors of Mohammed sws, the "ahl al-kitab" and "nasara", have not benefited from a protected word.
Does this mean that they were all lost in following an oral tradition subject to error?
Use your logic.
Can we establish contact? We have a foundation that is working to unite and reveal the truths of Qur'an and debunk Hadith. We would like to contact you.
Athar S. Which school did you train to be a sheikh at my friend? You’ve basically just confirmed everything Nouman said except you tried to distort the truth with your own opinion. Whether the hypocrites were going to idols or they’re mothers as judges....it really doesn’t matter because the point is Allah (SWT) said that they should be coming to him (The Prophet SAW) as he is the rasool of Allah (SAW) to judge between they’re disputes as he is the one the revelation was given to. Thus my point is, Nouman was fully correct in what he said.
Facts First debunk hadith?? What an arrogant position.
What are your knowledge??
Did you know that this crazy position is the result of modernity? Before colonialism, no one argued something so foolish.
Athar S. Baba 'after the study of the Qu'ran and the critic of Nouman'
What an arrogant position! Why do you think that traditionalist where following Sunnah? They ALL misunderstood the Din??
Show humility. And study.
Shall I seek other than God as a 'hakaman' (lawmaker) when it is He who has brought down to you the Book fully detailed? 6:114
In some translations the word 'hakaman' is translated as judge. That is also correct, for the role of a judge is to issue judgments that are as binding as laws. The Arabic word 'hakaman'is the one who issues 'ahkam' (laws). The words in 6:114 contain a command not to accept any source of (religious) law other than God.
We also know that one of the Quranic commands that is repeated in a number of verses is to obey God and obey the messenger:
O you who believe, obey God and obey the messenger, and do not nullify your work. 47:33
And in other verses it is told that the believers are those who believe in God and His messenger:
Rather, the believers are those who believe in God and His messenger, then have no doubt, and strive with their money and themselves in the cause of God. Those are the truthful ones. 49:15
May Allah reward u with jannatul firdaus, brother nouaman
Wait, you're telling me God's words can't be understood without an explainer? Did we read the same Qur'an? God is clear as a bell whenever He wants to be and left some ambiguous intentionally. You weren't supposed to know how many were in the cave.
The book is send from that time till now, i can interpret something different to someone years ago or years.
The Quran isn’t just a book dropped down. The Quran are the words of Allah, the hadeeth is the actions of the prophet. They’re inseparable because Allah says to us follow Allah and his last prophet (hadeeth). This doesn’t mean we don’t believe in the other prophets we believe in all prophets. And yes I agree Allah (God) is clear as a bell for those who understand and take the time to gain the knowledge.
Yes sir, thank you.
@@artakrasniqi6351 there inseparable? Are you seriously placing hadith as the word of God it reminds me so much of Christianity cuz it sounds to me that your idolizing Muhammad.
Why are there so many different secs in Islam? Why Sufi, Shia wahabbi Salafi all these different types of Muslims when we all read the same Quran? Why?
If hadiths are really from Muhammad why didn’t he write it down?
Following his sunnah is not believing in hadiths its Muhammad applying Quran in his life it’s his character actions based on Quran. He was a role model a model of Quran coming to life through him. You believe in hadiths cuz that’s what we been condition to believe following what are parents followed.
Amazing I agree We have revealed to you the Book, an exposition of everything, and guidance, and mercy, and glad tidings for the Muslims.
Quran is protected clearly by God.
But who protects the Hadith? Man?
So now we worship what man says the messenger did? Make it make sense.
Quran alone has been sufficient enough to change my life for the better. Clear and concise. Memorized by millions around the world.
Great lecture! May Allah grant you Jannat Ul Firdous.
This question was really bothering me for a while and I got a very satisfying answer. How wonderfully you have understood the pros and cons of Qur'an! May Allah bless you.
+Abrar Hasan I AM HINDU BUT I AM READING SHAI AL BHUKHARI
@@ratnaghosh9349 That's very pleasing to know. May Allah guide you.
@@abrarhasan6446 are you from india
@@ratnaghosh9349 No.
@@abrarhasan6446 then?
Move not your tongue with it, [O Muhammad], to hasten with recitation of the Qur'an. 75 16
Indeed, upon Us is its [Quran] collection [in your heart] and [to make possible] its recitation. 75:17
and they still don't get it. do they?
@@KamranKhan-xf6gr That is because they are deaf dumb and blind. Their hearts are sealed, they would surely follow it if a person or mullah wrote it
shovon100 The absurdity of “Quran-only” Muslims. If they had been living with the Prophet (s), would they have told him, “Tell us what the Quran says, but we don’t care to know your way, your example. It is irrelevant. Only the Quran matters”? Yet, strangely, this is the attitude of some foolish people in our time.
@@HK-USA well please dont attribute anyone with anything. You can have different opinion. But the judgement on Allah.
we are not denying here the practice our prophet [pbuh] that came through Fiqh.
how do we pray, do rukuh these are part of Sunnah as example and this was transmitted from prophet to Muslims and then generations.
Hadith books discusses about what is said in Quran, Sunnah and many other things.
many things are irrelevant, full of errors. But Many people considering Sahih bukhari or other books as equivalent to Quran. not verbally but through actions. many core concepts they are taking from Hadith where Quran has opposite statements. Teaching of Quran is hardly there and most of the people give lectures based on hadith. just they bring ad-hoc verse from Quran.
shovon100
I didn't judge you.
It was just a reminder that I posted to several comments.
I'm not saying either that we have to sacralize the Ahadith. They should of course be criticised with wisdom and knowledge.
Things that's lacking to the vast majority of people.
That's why the following of school's or 'ulamah is relevant.
I'm against both extremism : rejection of Sunnah without the tools and her sacralization.
Ustadh, no one denies how invaluable Prophet Muhammad SAWW is or how remarkable his character was. HE IS the one who brought the Qur'an to us, then isn't it paying him the greatest reverence by obliging hum by putting full faith in the Book he gave us on Allah's authority?
The "Sahih" hadith contradiction with Quran
Quran 2:256 tells us that there is no compulsions in religions but...
"Sahih" bukhari 8:387
Narated By Anas bin Malik : Allah’s Apostle said, “I have been ordered to fight the people till they say: ‘None has the right to be worshipped but Allah.’ And if they say so, pray like our prayers, face our Qibla and slaughter as we slaughter, then their blood and property will be sacred to us and we will not interfere with them except legally and their reckoning will be with Allah.” Narrated Maimun ibn Siyah that he asked Anas bin Malik, “O Abu Hamza! What makes the life and property of a person sacred?” He replied, “Whoever says, ‘None has the right to be worshipped but Allah’, faces our Qibla during the prayers, prays like us and eats our slaughtered animal, then he is a Muslim, and has got the same rights and obligations as other Muslims have
You challenge Allah! Allah Himself said that the Quran is enough, fully detailed and complete. Go repent.
Sayed Ibrahim Abuelmagd
Thats nonsense! Who else than Muhammad sws could perfectly understood the God's message?!?
Even if the compilation isn't flawless, that doesn't legitimate her abandon!
We should in the contrary examine it meticulously!!
You are full of passion.
As many of Qu'raniyun, you're a reaction.
You can't bear the outside critics (Wich are nonsense since without religion, there isn't absulte morality), so you're rejecting it.
That's weakness.
The Qur'an as the only source is a lure.
The Koranists do not take into consideration one factor: the fact that the analysis of the Quran rests on our reason, which is itself fallible.
Why then accept this margin of error in understanding the Qur'an and not in the Sunnah?
In rejecting the Ahadiths, logic would have them reject the Qur'an as well.
The Quran is immediately disqualified, if the criterion is infallibility in the application of the precepts of God.
By rejecting the Sunnah, they are just multiplying the margin of error by trying to apply religion only with their reason.
This margin exists WITH or WITHOUT the Ahadiths.
All that we risk in applying the Sunna, while remaining critical, is to be closer to what Allah enjoins us to do.
not to mention that the predecessors of Mohammed sws, the "ahl al-kitab" and "nasara", have not benefited from a protected word.
Does this mean that they were all lost in following an oral tradition subject to error?
Even if everything wasn't compiled (there IS compilation from the beginning!) , the sahabas were verry attached to his exemple.
There is the revelations AND the exemple of the Prophets.
They were memorizing all of his behavior.
Like the contemporary of other Prophets.
That's how the revelations were working before Muhammad sws.
If the only revelation that could legislate is THE Holly book, what about all the predecessor of prophet Muhammad sws??
What about them, following handsmade scripture ??
God is not discrediting them.
They are the people of book as well!!!
Is God sw wrong???
No! They follow the path of prophecy with possibility of errors!!! And God permitted it!!
Because there is NO "perfect" understanding!
Even by reading solely qu'ran, you're putting on it your OWN view, with all our defective senses.
Between your own interpretation and the prophets one (with possibility of error), the choice is easily made!
It is way more rationale to follow his path with criticism on the source.
Also, the thing that you're missing is the fact that
The Sunnah is also protecting Islam.
Without it, you'll probably fall into the lost of religion as the Christian's experienced with it's schism between Catholicism and Protestantism and all the horror that followed the reform.
What's left to Christianity??
Sunnah is the shield of Islam.
Without it, you can reject the salat as we're doing it.
You can defend fornication,...
There is two extremes : sacralize the Ahadiths or rejecting all of them.
And you're part of one sect.
Being critical about our scripture should not lead us to abandon all of it.
It is hardly possible to avoid all sunnah and thus hadith. Too many cases would prevent us.
The hadith is essential in the interpretation of the Koranic text and in the practical understanding of worship, even if "too many hadiths harm the hadith".
We need to question the Sunnah and reject everything that contradict Qu'ran (that's the work of 'ulamah since centuries).
Yes. Sunnah is a fluke and must be ignored. Circumcision is mutilation.
@KebenaranBukanMilikAndaAtaupunSaya Your not Muhhamad either that you'd be talking. Bukhari was at least better than you
@KebenaranBukanMilikAndaAtaupunSaya Of course it is. But it doesnt mean you reject the Sunnah. Look ag the last sermon of the Prophet (SAW). He asked us to hold onto Quran AND Sunnah so we will be guided. Of course there are fabrications but it never meant that hadith are entirely false. For example, Hadiths tell us that the heavens are squeaking. NASA confirmed it. Hadiths tell us almost everything like how to pray and how to do hajj etc. I believe the Quran is better than Hadith. But without Hadith we cant understand our beloved book.
Salam, I actually really disagree with this interpretation. In fact, here are direct quotes from the Quran which I believe directly disavow the validity of any “hadith” coming after it.
أَفَغَيْرَ اللَّهِ أَبْتَغِي حَكَمًا وَهُوَ الَّذِي أَنزَلَ إِلَيْكُمُ الْكِتَابَ مُفَصَّلًا
Then is it other than Allah I should seek as judge while it is He who has revealed to you the Book explained in detail? … (6:114 part)
تِلْكَ آيَاتُ اللَّهِ نَتْلُوهَا عَلَيْكَ بِالْحَقِّ ۖ فَبِأَيِّ حَدِيثٍ بَعْدَ اللَّهِ وَآيَاتِهِ يُؤْمِنُونَ
These are the verses of Allah which We recite to you in truth. Then in what statement (hadith) after Allah and His verses will they believe? (45:6)
فَبِأَيِّ حَدِيثٍ بَعْدَهُ يُؤْمِنُونَ
Then in what statement after it (the Qur’an) will they believe? (77:50)
مَا لَكُمْ كَيْفَ تَحْكُمُونَ أَمْ لَكُمْ كِتَابٌ فِيهِ تَدْرُسُونَ إِنَّ لَكُمْ فِيهِ لَمَا تَخَيَّرُونَ
What is [the matter] with you? How do you judge? Or do you have a book / scripture in which you learn that indeed for you in it is whatever you choose? (68:36-38)
اللَّهُ نَزَّلَ أَحْسَنَ الْحَدِيثِ كِتَابًا مُّتَشَابِهًا مَّثَانِيَ …
Allah has sent down the best statement (ahsan hadith): a consistent Book wherein is reiteration. … (39:23 part)
وَتَمَّتْ كَلِمَتُ رَبِّكَ صِدْقًا وَعَدْلًا ۚ لَّا مُبَدِّلَ لِكَلِمَاتِهِ ۚ وَهُوَ السَّمِيعُ الْعَلِيمُ
And the word of your Lord has been fulfilled / completed in truth and in justice. None can alter His words, and He is the Hearing, the Knowing. (6:115)
وَمَا مِن دَابَّةٍ فِي الْأَرْضِ وَلَا طَائِرٍ يَطِيرُ بِجَنَاحَيْهِ إِلَّا أُمَمٌ أَمْثَالُكُم ۚ مَّا فَرَّطْنَا فِي الْكِتَابِ مِن شَيْءٍ ۚ ثُمَّ إِلَىٰ رَبِّهِمْ يُحْشَرُونَ
And there is no creature on [or within] the earth or bird that flies with its wings except [that they are] communities like you. We have not neglected in the Book (Quran) a thing. Then unto their Lord they will be gathered. (6:38) …
وَمَن لَّمْ يَحْكُم بِمَا أَنزَلَ اللَّهُ فَأُولَٰئِكَ هُمُ الْكَافِرُونَ …
And whoever does not judge by what Allah has revealed - then it is they who are the disbelievers (kafirun). (5:44 part)
To imply that we need the hadith to understand the Quran is to imply that the Quran itself is either incomplete, imperfect, or requiring further supplementation, which is the most anti-muslim sentiment one can have. It is clear that the Quran contains everything within it for one to be a Muslim, and to obtain the blessing of Allah in this life and in the next. The simple fact that there are “weak hadith” and “strong hadith” should be evidence enough that the entire concept is weak. There are no “weak” Surah or Ayah in the Quran. The Quran is completely strong. By dogmatically adhering to the hadith and claiming it as a holy text with religious authority, we are falling into the same traps that the pre-islamic religions fell into, such as idol worship, or intentionally disregarding the true message of God. For this reason, the prophet Mohammed (pbuh) was given the message of God, to give the people the uncorrupted truth. Anything after his revelations is deviating from this. If Allah, who is all wise, all knowing, and all powerful, had wanted us to do any of the things instructed in the hadith, he would have revealed them to the prophet and it would be in the Quran. The Quran is PERFECT and complete, and to suggest anything other than that by implying that hadith is necessary to understand the Quran or to be a Muslim, is actually a very anti-islamic sentiment, and goes directly against what is given to us in the Quran. This is just my humble opinion that I have reached after reading the Quran.
Not against the Hadiths, but if a Hadith contradicts with the Quran.. I just reject it.
If there are Hadiths that contradict the Quran then surely that casts doubt on all Hadiths in general?
This (Quran) is not a fabricated hadith, but an authentication of what came before it, a detailed account of all things, and guidance and mercy for people who believe.12:111
...you tell us WHAT HADITH SAYS HOW TO PREY ??? ...I learned how to prey before I even knew how to read (before reading Quran or hadiths)... I learned it from my parents,...they did the same,...they learned from they parents,...and, it went like that through years back to Prophet,...
No doubt the Hadith is a great source of information. However, if any part of the Hadith is in contradiction with Holy Quran then the Quran takes the precedence. Thanks.
A hadith which contradicts the Quran is automatically rejected
Can we do the same with the bible?
Shaheeh hadith can never contradicts the qur'an. There will an explanation to the appear contradiction
@@PabloChacon213 if its not contradict the Quran, thats means is from Allah s.w.t.and is WAHI to Rasool Allah thats also mean every single words in it is from Allah Which Allah contradict that in surah in this ayat Allah is only referring to Quran and challenging every one with their BOOKS ,To brinhs Quran like this if it is not from Allah they will find full and majority of contradictions in those BOOKS.
See Surah An-Nisa 4 :82.
Do they not consider / ponder
Al-Quran / The Reading if it
had been from other than Allah,
they would surely have found
in it much discrepancies
/ contradictions.
@Izdihar Ali if its not contradict the Quran, thats means is from Allah s.w.t.and is WAHI to Rasool Allah thats also mean every single words in it is from Allah Which Allah contradict that in surah in this ayat Allah is only referring to Quran and challenging every one with their BOOKS ,To brinhs Quran like this if it is not from Allah they will find full and majority of contradictions in those BOOKS.
See Surah An-Nisa 4 :82.
Do they not consider / ponder
Al-Quran / The Reading if it
had been from other than Allah,
they would surely have found
in it much discrepancies
/ contradictions.
A Book has been brought down to you, so let there be no constraint in your chest because of it, and so that you may warn with it. It is a Reminder for the believers.
Follow what has been brought down to you from your Lord and do not follow any allies besides Him. Rarely do you remember! 7:2-3
And this is a blessed Book which We brought down, so follow it and be reverent so that you may attain mercy. 6:155
This (Quran) is not a fabricated hadith, but an authentication of what came before it, a detailed account of all things, and guidance and mercy for people who believe. 12:111
We brought the Book down to you providing explanations of all things. 16:89
Une magnifique vidéo ! Merci beaucoup. J'en ai beaucoup appris et ça fait vraiment du bien au cœur. Qu'Allah vous bénisse !
With all due respect this “scholar” and others like him would not have a job without Adith.
well said.
Quran = al you will ever need.
Hadith = this is how you will need it
Sunni: you can't follow Quran alone
Sunni: following Quran alone misleads
Sunni: Hadith explains Quran
Yet we need Quran to prove it
But we need Hadith to understand😅
So we can't understand Quran that way
Cuz we can't prove Hadith, it's a paradox,
"Sunnism"
Hadith: Umar was a Quraniy (Bukhari 7366) 😅
@@atraonlycowardsmuteme3285omar narrated hadeeths leave sunni and shias all sects, but hadeeth are saying of the prophet in surah star, Allah mentioned prophet Muhammad doesn't talk in his own but it's revelation. Dajjal is mentioned in the hadeeth also, rakahs of salah are in the hadeeth, also reading al-tahiyah is in the hadeeth. Hadeeth is how you do what's command you to do. The people narrated are prophet's companions. Keep that in your mind. Even aisha narrated hadeeths.
I only accept authentic Hadith with a strong Isnad(chain of narration), but to disregard all Hadith is something no one should do. What about all the end time predictions? We get that from the Hadith and it's all happening right now. Also, it's in the Quran that the Prophets doesn't speak of his own desires. No prophet did.
Revolutionary speech! I wish you give talks in the Arab world !
25:30 The messenger said, "My Lord, my people have deserted this Quran.
Please explain how this verse is applied. How I see it, its talking about you, correct me if I'm wrong.
Iam pretty sure he wasnt born in the the 7th century and he is following the quran as the quran orders obedience to the messanger
@@chailouai3084 Why does God use the word Messenger and Prophet? Clearly there is a difference.
@@chailouai3084 The vers 25:30 is talking on Judgement day. Not the time of the prophet.
@@ibrahim-qk7ii there is a difference although its unimportant to the fact that you must obey the messanger in "whatever he forbids you" as quran states, hashr verse 7
Nonetheless, Muhammed pbuh is both a messanger and a prophet
(33:40) "O believers, (know) that Muhammad is not the father of any man among you, but he is the Messenger of God and the Seal of the Prophets. God has full knowledge of everything."
@@chailouai3084 Its clear to me that you do not read Quran to understand. If the difference is not important why then use different words? You make no sense sorry.
Read the conext in the vers you are talking about. Dont take couple of words out of the middle of the vers. Thx.
13:25 That's why we should say NO to Asmani Kitab. You made 4 Asmani Kitab. Allah has revealed only one book for Guidance of Humanity
and for the prophet peace and blessings be upon him to explain it.
@@mahamedjmal2536 explaining was not his primary job. His main job was to deliver the message. The Quran is easy to u understand. The hadith stories don't even explain anything. SMH
Umair Javaid Mashallah
Umair Javaid you are right hadith have many stupid things
@Karishma firstly i don't consider him jsut stupid, i consider him a worst human being and a liar and womenizer , and he3 used verse of quran for his advatange and he was murderer and pedopheliac
This is the way/ sunnah of Allah swt
Quran4: 64 , All the messengers We sent were meant to be obeyed by God’s leave. If they had come to you and sought forgiveness from God whenever they wronged themselves, and the Messenger had prayed for forgiveness for them, they would have found that God is ever-forgiving and merciful.
4:65 By your Lord, they will not be true believers until they seek your arbitration in their disputes and find within themselves no doubt about what you decide and accept it wholeheartedly.c”
The way you presented... Was very good.
The Koran says in Surah 4:100 He who forsakes his home in the cause of Allah, finds in the earth many a refuge, wide and spacious. Should he die as a refugee far from home for Allah and his messenger , his reward becomes due and sure with Allah. Or verse 95 which states, "Not equal are those believers who sit at home and receive no hurt." You say Allah never commanded believer to leave their home but the Koran says differently.
+peakpower13 I'm still waiting for a response. How can you say the Quran never says to leave your home in the cause of Allah, when it clearly does.
It sounds like a man trying to explain why you should come to him as an authority instead of telling the truth. There is no reason whatsoever for Hadiths. This is an archaic system holding on to power in a new world.
Brother, I think you should review your argument regarding the preservation of the Quran and the collection of Hadith. Seriously!
O believers! Obey Allah and *obey the Messenger* and those in authority among you. Should you disagree on anything, then *refer it to Allah and His Messenger* , if you ˹truly˺ believe in Allah and the Last Day. This is the best and fairest resolution.
Surah al-nisa -59
That was for people alive at the time the rasool pbuh was alive. That was not for us, since we dont have the rasool anymore.
Quran says Prophet Muhammad is the Explainer of Quran
Now if you don't belive in hadiths can People who reject HADITHS explain to me where are the Explanations of Quran By Prophet Muhammad??
They are the HADITHS
that have been preserved by the Sahaba of PROPHET Muhammad
although some hadiths are weak and fabricated but most of them are the Best way to understand the Quran
Quran says dogs r man's friend(kitmir)was respected by Almighty and in hadith prophet said that dogs r impure now God is giving respect and God's best creation is disrespecting so this proves that hadiths r fabricated
Sunni “authentic” Hadith books have very few narrations explaining the Quran (tafsir). You cannot get a tafsir of the Quran from Hadith.
Hadith is made by bukhari and muslim after our prophet already dead long time ago, i mean these two didnt even live in muhammad's era how could you trust them.. You cant 100% trust human word if you did then youre no better than christian and their stupid gospel
All my family believes in hadith even my wife but I don't because since I was a child my heart always declined the hadith ..
some hadith may have been true but there is no proof of hadith.
Allah is great and his quran is complete ....
Quran rejects hadiths. Scroll through the comment section, maybe people give example. Your heart was inclined to truth.
@@sba374 th-cam.com/video/EloWrUEzapA/w-d-xo.html this will clear your confusion, thank me later. Please see the whole thibg. Allah may guide us all
Desert Eagle 45 oh yeah I know, no worries
Edit: can’t remember why I wrote that reply lol
Edit 2: I think you meant to reply to him?
@Revelation … there is tremendous proof of hadeeth. It is the only science that is backed by what is called “ilm ar-rijaal” - literally, the knowledge of men - which is an exhaustive encyclopedic reference of the biographies of the people who transmitted hadeeth: including the eras and places in which they lived and travelled, the strength of their memory and their reputations. It’s an incredible proof for the veracity of hadeeth by which the deen of Islaam was preserved and passed on.
@@mikaalwaters2172 that's incredible and all and I do think there are hadiths that are authentic and that we can believe in and follow such as sunnah hadiths, but it should never be the primary source, it should be used to explain and give context to the Qur'an, remember the Qur'an is the only book of Allah SWT that Allah himself promises to safeguard, this is why regardless of which sects of Islam, we all have the same Qur'an, while the reason why we have different sects is due to the hadiths
Sheik, you are pretty fluent and well learned. JUST AGREE TO A DEBATE ALREADY... stop this singular videos that ANYONE can use to PROOF ANYTHING....
Atheist do single videos and raise arguments to support the notion that God does not exist, which will get an unlearned mind convinced, theist also do same. TRUTH or rather POINTS ARE CLEARER, when both sides of the argument MEET... it gives the audience VERY GOOD idea of the subject matter...
Stop the single videos, and stage A DEBATE.... just like our christian brothers do with atheist or other factions of theist and atheist. SIMPLE!
Your video all the way half way is TRUE... Yes, the prophet was a judge, a leader, a father, a counsel, a friend etc... but all this ended when he died and his message (Quran), remained. WHAT YOU FAIL TO DO.. is successfully link the prophet to the hadiths...
The Quran makes it clear that OBEYING THE PROPHET is conditioned, Only the prophets righteous orders are to be obeyed.. how did the people know or judge which of the prophets orders where righteous? obviously the QURAN.
"O prophet, if the believing women come to you and pledge that they will not idolize anything beside God, nor steal, nor commit adultery, nor kill their children, nor produce any falsehood, nor disobey you WHEN YOU ARE RIGHT, you shall accept their pledge, and ask God to forgive them." (60:12).
He was Given the Quran to JUDGE with it... teaching the Quran never means adding extra-non existing details as people frequently suggest. When i teach my students about atoms, I can use models to make my students understand what i really mean by an atom, at the end of the day... i don't CHANGE the meaning of what an atom is and introduce extra particles and disfigure what an atom is... the proponents of the argument that the hadith explain the Quran is so absurd that, 80percent of what they practice is not found IN THE QURAN... How? its like completely distorting the message or introducing entirely NEW concept non existent in the Quran. regardless of the historicity of the influence of dynasties and politicians on which hadith is fabricated and promoted, NO SANE MIND WILL ACCEPT THE TESTIMONY OF BUKHARI AS AUTHENTICALLY COMING FROM THE PROPHET... unless the person is DELUDED as the risk of sounding immodest.
But brother u need to understand he is telling to the US Muslim people coz someone has asked him something similar like that so that's why he wants it to explain it.... for people to not confuse ur self .....
If you don't believe in Hadith, then how do you pray?
Raga Bintang
What age did your parents give you the hadith yo learn to pray? And which one from start to finish?
who are you to judge the prophet's saying?
K B Yes anyone has full rights to judge which Hadith is authentic and which one is fabricated but to judge between this one must have to follow all the rules and regulations to do so (i.e) one must have complete knowledge of Hadith and quran only then he can be a mujaddid
Subhan Allah ..Nouman Ali Khan May Allah elevate your station here and hereafter...May he protect you from the evil eye .. Late Dr.Israr Ahmed and you are our great guidance and inspiration