Rank is : 10- Service Now ERP 09- Sorkday ERP 08- Infor ERP 07- Salesforce ERP 06- SAP 4 ERP 05- SAGE x3 ERP 04- IFS ERP 03- Oracle cloud ERP 02- Microsoft D365 ERP 01- Oracle NetSuite ERP but i'm confuse why ODOO ERP is not in the top 10 list ?!!
Let's keep it simple. Choose a ERP system that work for the size, complexity and needs of the business. A system that evolve to this new market and helps to reduce manual data entry. It's very important to have a good support. SAP and Accumatica are the two tops on my list. Affordable, customizable, easy to use and learn. We are in times that we work with less staff, having the right leading ERP would make a huge difference at the end
Consultants can sometimes get a bad name because the are aligned with a product; it is refreshing and valuable to see the truly independent, technology agnostic approach to 'what's best'. Thanks for the effort and investment from Third Stage in this list.
Great analysis. I am glad to hear you mention the "Do nothing" option, or rather "Stay with what you got". In other words, continue to get more value out of the ERP investment you have. This is usually not looked at equally as an option. We are running one of the ERP's in the top 5 list and will likely continue to squeeze more value out of it in the coming years. Great video!
It would be interesting to see the top twenty I am considering Enterprise Odoo, which does not have nearly the penetration of these, but lists a set of appealing features (e.g. Python is the programming language to customize) has good pricing, and a huge set of modules which can be obtained ala carte. There is likely not a super wide, THIRD PARTY set of VAR, but a networked in set of staffers who run through San Francisco to get people up to speed (typically you buy hours of these folks time, and they get your implemented. Most of these systems simply are too high priced to get our small company out of Quick Books hell and into a functional system.
Hi Eric First of all, this is really nice intro for the best ERP. However, from my 20 years experience with most of the international erp players, today i can see new good players they do ERP in different way such as Triosuite company. Focusing on new concept of co-relation between consulting, digital platform for flexible business adaptation that lead to trustworthy best practice process. Good luck 4 all....
FMS is a manufacturing and pharmaceutical industries generic application and generically process with each department in manufacturing industry and 100% competitive to SAP and other ERP systems in any sized manufacturing industry. The new version is a revolutionary step for a dynamic management and better planning application system.Whether you are busy with financial analysis and accounting, planning material management, or focusing on expiry details of rm, fg or observing work in process, proceeding to product costing, materials evaluation, profit & loss, production against orders, planning tax return at the end of each month and focusing on employees payroll and human resource management, these tools are provided and grouped together in one single application for ease of access to make your life more comfortable. In FMS you can now open multiple companies in a single instance of application and can log in to the desired company one can wish.Get rid off the confusing activities and make your company more transparent. Get FMS new version with 6-12 months or more free service warranty with full range services and reduce tension for ever. =================================== Munawar Shah Afridi 00923339176357 00923139176357
All businesses are not same and all business requirements are not same. Having said that, comparing SAP with other ERPs in the list is like comparing Apples to Oranges.
I am working in IFS for last 8 to 9 years. However its not popular as Oracle or SAP but the best product compared to others with IFS 10 they are best in user experience. Would like to contact you if you have any plans in canada.
I liked the video but I disagree with your picks at 1. & 2. Personally I would still put Dynamics ahead of Netsuite. The O365 intergration is incredible. Its still the case that the majority of businesses are still using some or all of the Office Programs. The most common probably being excel and outlook. Very interesting video and well thought out from a product perspective.
Service Now should be ranked much higher than #10. SN has been adopted for use by two extremely large organizations in the CA for a few years now: University of California (the largest employer in CA) and Behr, and the new features we are seeing with every iteration is well thought out and on point. In my humble opinion, Infor should be 10 while SN is #7, as we are seeing movement away from Infor, particularly LN, as their goals are not clear.
Michael, topic of this video was for an "ERP Tool" not a tool which helps tracking incidents or ticket so this SN is still at 10 that is surprising instead of out of list.
Hi Burhan, yes Odoo was considered. It's a great emerging product, so it was hard to rule this and a bunch of other systems out of the Top 10 - even though you could make a strong argument for it being closer to the top of the list!
yeah id want more reviews on odoo as well. i am using community version. looks like the enterprise might be a good platform for my manufacturing company. and very cheap compared to others.
@@erickimberling Odoo should be #1. It will be the talk of the town in the near future. It's doing the one thing the bigger ERP's are not and that's making an affordable scalable option. I think that's why Shopify has done well. Rather than be like Magento and price everyone out of the market, they made a solution that was for all. I'm all-in on Odoo and loving it!
Oracle sucks for small to mid sized businesses. Don't even consider NetSuite unless your sales are $10M with at least a 50% margin. NetSuite is clunky, slow or buggy servers and damn near impossible to customize without massive investments. NetSuite is also $100-$200 per user per month and can go up if they feel like it. I heard a company doing $20M was paying $90k yr and they raised it to $150k per year just for licensing. That cost doesn't even include the Shopify connector or other apps that you'll need to make that HUNK OF JUNK work. It's also not well designed from an interface perspective. Almost no intuitive aspects about it. I tried to change our company logo on the profile and could not. I have a degree in digital marketing. Unless you have a huge budget and like blowing your money on an expensive vehicle that will literally bleed you dry when it breaks, RUN!!! I highly recommend Odoo.com, for the price and the number of apps they have developed you will have all the pieces you need to manage a small to mid sized business. That doesn't mean you can't be a world-wide company and use Odoo. There's just some things Odoo doesn't do and there is not such a thing as one size fits all for ERPs. We are also building our website on Odoo Ecommerce which has shown to be far more robust than Shopify. If not Odoo then look at Microsoft. If you have a complex model then go back to Odoo ;)
What about small margin economy Russia isn't so big in terms of finance, economy in Russia stagnating , most business done by the Russian government or his representatives, good luck getting those contracts if any you are friend of russian goverment well , maybe you can hit Abramovich or Raldugin, but i dont think that they interested in buying a ERP.....
Im surprised that you didn't mention Acumatica especially since they have been ranked highest by SIIA CODiEs, industry-insider awards from techies to techies , PCMag Editors’ choice four years in a row, G2 Crowd, & Gartner
Hi Erika, Acumatica does appear in our ranking for manufacturing systems, as well as the top ERP systems for 2022, which you can find here: www.thirdstage-consulting.com/top-10-erp-systems-2022-top-software-vendors/.
I applaud the effort to simplify this into top 10, but really it's impossible. There's too many variables. We focus on smaller business, where we would declare ourselves #1, but not for mid-sized business. Then there's value, trade offs, it's enough to make you dizzy (salesforce is not big on ERP, but ok).
You’re right that there are a ton of variables to consider! I’ve compiled a few other top 10 lists since then, one specific to small business, another for manufacturers, etc.
Eric, thank you. Which ERP system would you really recommend for an educational organization with branches in different countries? I would clarify here, that still it is a startup.
Hey Eric, Thanks for this video - and all the others. It's a valuable source of information for all and contributes to more transparency and open discussions in the industry. At 16:55, you said that Oracle ERP Cloud had not figured out how to address manufacturing. Could you please expand on that point?
Thank you for your feedback, Stephane. We have had some large manufacturing clients try to implement Oracle Cloud, which has exposed gaps in capabilities - especially when compared to legacy EBS. It isn’t yet as robust in its manufacturing workflows.
ERP is a gray area - HCM, CRM, financials systems, and other functional systems are slowly expanding their functionality to be more like ERP systems. ServiceNow is not as broad as a "real" ERP system, but it can act as a core system for service and ticketing based companies.
Hi Eric, What ERP system do you suggest for a real estate company ? Company is more than 10 years old. Already finished and delivered 5 projects with 5 more on going. Employees in the company are not tech savvy Things are still managed via calls and processes are more towards analog than digital Looking forward to your recommendation
To be the ERP implementing consultant for 20 years I agreed most your comments on your different TH-cam topics, however this time is that more clear and appropriate if with the topic "Ranking of cloud-based ERP systems" ?
@@harveylynn6530 Evening Harvey, True Cloud Software is simply software which is Hosted/Published from an offsite computer, just like a web site. If you have a Windows10 Pro computer, this can also be used as a web server thus hosting your software in house. So as long as the Software is truly cloud based, yes you can host it from an onsite PC.
Have you ever used or come across Ecount ERP? I am thinking of getting into the ERP implementation space for small businesses and I think this might be a good solution especially the price?
Very surprisingly but quite pleasant SAP is no more #1. I think you should break down Oracle ERP’s - EBS, JDE, Peoplesoft, Cloud Same SAP ECC, SAP Cloud. I couldn’t understand and digest you are comparing tier 1 ERP’s with tier 10 ERP’s. General comparison is never correct. It means this analysis has no practical use
Hi Erick, I have been struggling to find an ERP that is focused in project management: planning schedule, material management. If you can please picture yourself as a procurement manager, what ERP system would you prefer to implement in your company? Thank you.
This video iwas released in 2019...but is for 2021? Also Netsuite is terrible have seen more midsize companies (20-100M) move away from it than keep it.
What a great Analysis, However I dont think right now SF coul be considered as an ERP provider, they have potential of course, but it is not their core business
Yeah that would be a big help for the left out small business owner! I’ve been looking and researching these for a while now and so far these are the best ones I’ve seen that are affordable. I’d throw in one more to check out called epromise thx I’ll look forward to the video!
@@jayv2447 You may start to investigate with ERPNext. ERPNext is in the ERP FrontRunners List by Gartner for 4 consecutive years. www.softwareadvice.com/erp/#top-products
Hi Eric, Nice work with the video. Its really hard to find independent opinions in ERPs as the vendors are always involved. Only thing I would add in cosideration about Netsuit is that Oracle's big bet for the future seems to be Oracle Cloud so this look bad for Netsuit in the middle/long term. What's your opinion on this? Also, if I'm an analyst of an old Oracle suit (JD Edwards), where do you think I should aim my career? I'm thinking on learning and getting expirience in one of the new ERPs with more future but I don't want to bet in the wrong horse. Do you have any video of what's best from an analst perspective?
Hi Manuel, I see your point about Oracle and Netsuite. However, I really don’t think Netsuite customers are at risk, simply because the install base is so big and because they target such different companies then oracle cloud. I don’t have any videos specific to analysts as you suggest, but the top 10 videos are a good place to start. I think it’s always a good idea to broaden your knowledge of different systems, especially given the uncertainty of JDE’s future.
Hi Eric, I am working on oracle ebs r12 as a techno functional role in finance module but I want to move current ERP application which has good future in long run. Which application should I choose to learn in 2020. Any suggestions
SAP S/4 HANA would have been placed higher on top as there seems to be lot of complexities in Microsoft and Oracle even they also finding it difficult to land in a better when it comes to maturity and Product development
Hey Eric, where would you stick SAS? Haven't had bunch of experience with those, but know they've been around for so long and especially care about analytics and data insights long time before it became a hype. Are they used anywhere outside risk management and customer marketing for banks and insurance companies?
I don’t understand one thing: you have mentioned D365 as No.2 ERP in your list. Then why does Microsoft use SAP S/4 HANA for all of its core ERP related processes? Why don’t they use D365 for it.
Service Now isn't an ERP system and really doesn't belong on this list. Workday is a bit a of stretch as well because it's not a complete package. It could be a piece of a best of breed solution. I can concede Salesforce because depending on your industry, it could be the primary component of your ERP solution, but most people have Salesforce integrated to another big 5 ERP system for the supply chain and operations pieces. I think the others belong in the top ten because they are the packages that everyone should look at if you are switching systems. Depending on your industry there maybe a couple others added to this list and a few that should drop out.
Can you publish the scoring details for the solutions? Your commentary seems to be inconsistent with the placement decisions that I am sure would be easier to understand if the scoring were available. Also, I noticed this was a PURE SaaS comparison only but that was not made clear. Thanks in advance.
@@erickimberling Not sure I understand, is that a "no?" you won't provide the underlying scoring? How can anyone assess the claims? There are several inconsistencies in your commentary about why various vendors got different rankings. Without the data it is impossible to reconcile the claims. My assumption is you would provide the underlying support and the inconsistent commentary is just opinion.
That is correct, we do not share the detailed data for free on public forums. Our clients pay us to do this analysis, so we don’t share detailed data outside our paying client base. You are more than welcome to debate any part of the video you wish - many vendors and system integrators do!
Yes, it was. It didn’t make the top 10 for all industries, but it likely would be toward the top for certain industries such as government contracting.
Hi, seeking career advice, can i switch to oracle erp from workday? I have 5yrs exp in workday but those are support and testing. Not able to study integration or func config. Please advice.
So im trying to wrap my head around this. Your saying due to the shift in management, the market share always shrinks or becomes less unstable, the service then also takes a hit, ranks lower on maturity? Why does it matter really if people step down from a software agency?
It’s a minor factor, but could signal a sign of instability or uncertainty at the software company. It’s one minor consideration in the grand scheme of things.
Das im Mittelstand sehr beliebte Standard ERP System Microsoft Dynamics 365 Business Central (vormals: Navision, ERP System Dynamics NAV) bietet einen vollen Funktionsumfang der beliebig um firmenspezifische Funktionen mit sogenannten Business Central Extensions, zertifizierten Add-On´s, vollintegrierten Zusatzanwendungen erweitert und komplett in Microsoft Dynamics 365 integriert und so optimal an Ihre unternehmensspezifischen Bedürfnisse angepasst werden kann: navision-partnerwechsel.jetzt/erp-software/erp-system-dynamics-nav-module-und-funktionen-im-ueberblick/
![How Do ERP Systems Work? [The Mechanics of ERP Software]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/zI2eCVrUTvU/mqdefault.jpg)
![Top 10 Food and Beverage ERP Systems [Independent Ranking for Food and Bev Manufacturers]](/img/n.gif)
Download the 2021 Digital Transformation Report here: resource.thirdstage-consulting.com/2021-digital-transformation-report.
Rank is :
10- Service Now
ERP
09- Sorkday
ERP
08- Infor
ERP
07- Salesforce ERP
06- SAP 4
ERP
05- SAGE x3
ERP
04- IFS
ERP
03- Oracle cloud
ERP
02- Microsoft D365
ERP
01- Oracle NetSuite ERP
but i'm confuse why ODOO ERP is not in the top 10 list ?!!
Let's keep it simple. Choose a ERP system that work for the size, complexity and needs of the business. A system that evolve to this new market and helps to reduce manual data entry. It's very important to have a good support.
SAP and Accumatica are the two tops on my list.
Affordable, customizable, easy to use and learn.
We are in times that we work with less staff, having the right leading ERP would make a huge difference at the end
Consultants can sometimes get a bad name because the are aligned with a product; it is refreshing and valuable to see the truly independent, technology agnostic approach to 'what's best'. Thanks for the effort and investment from Third Stage in this list.
Thanks, David...glad to help!
Order
10.Service now
9.workday
8.infor
7.sales force
6.SAP 4 Hana
5.SAGE
4.IFS
3.Oracle
2.Microsoft D365
1.Oracle Netsuite
I really thought i would see Odoo ERP on the TOP 10 List
Great analysis. I am glad to hear you mention the "Do nothing" option, or rather "Stay with what you got". In other words, continue to get more value out of the ERP investment you have. This is usually not looked at equally as an option. We are running one of the ERP's in the top 5 list and will likely continue to squeeze more value out of it in the coming years. Great video!
And then switch to blockchain? ERP seems old school nowadays
But as a vendor, which ERP is more profitable to sell? Also, if you were developing custom products for ERPs, which would be more profitable?
Good concise summary of the trends in ERP space. Being an average finance person I find your videos interesting and informative! 👍
Thank you, Anna. I’m glad you enjoy the videos!
Well it really work good. I really enjoy using ERP portal on daily basis. Making different orders.
It would be interesting to see the top twenty I am considering Enterprise Odoo, which does not have nearly the penetration of these, but lists a set of appealing features (e.g. Python is the programming language to customize) has good pricing, and a huge set of modules which can be obtained ala carte. There is likely not a super wide, THIRD PARTY set of VAR, but a networked in set of staffers who run through San Francisco to get people up to speed (typically you buy hours of these folks time, and they get your implemented. Most of these systems simply are too high priced to get our small company out of Quick Books hell and into a functional system.
Nice whiteboard! I actually have two of those exact same models!
Here you go!
1. Oracle Netsuite
2. Microsoft D365
3. Oracle ERP cloud
4. IFS
5. SAGE
6. SAP S4/HANA
7. Salesforce
8 . Infor
9. Workday
10. Service Now
10. Service Now
09. Workday
08. Infor
07. Salesforce
06. SAP
05. SAGE
04. IFS
03. Oracle
02. Microsoft dynamic 365
01. Oracle Netsuite
Thanks Eric! Perfect like usually.
Hi Eric
First of all, this is really nice intro for the best ERP.
However, from my 20 years experience with most of the international erp players, today i can see new good players they do ERP in different way such as Triosuite company. Focusing on new concept of co-relation between consulting, digital platform for flexible business adaptation that lead to trustworthy best practice process.
Good luck 4 all....
simplicity is the highest level of complication
FMS is a manufacturing and pharmaceutical industries generic application and generically process with each department in manufacturing industry and 100% competitive to SAP and other ERP systems in any sized manufacturing industry. The new version is a revolutionary step for a dynamic management and better planning application system.Whether you are busy with financial analysis and accounting, planning material management, or focusing on expiry details of rm, fg or observing work in process, proceeding to product costing, materials evaluation, profit & loss, production against orders, planning tax return at the end of each month and focusing on employees payroll and human resource management, these tools are provided and grouped together in one single application for ease of access to make your life more comfortable. In FMS you can now open multiple companies in a single instance of application and can log in to the desired company one can wish.Get rid off the confusing activities and make your company more transparent. Get FMS new version with 6-12 months or more free service warranty with full range services and reduce tension for ever.
===================================
Munawar Shah Afridi
00923339176357
00923139176357
Great analysis
All businesses are not same and all business requirements are not same. Having said that, comparing SAP with other ERPs in the list is like comparing Apples to Oranges.
Sap s/4 Hana has lot of hype but also have big questions in future. Too much investment against result
I am working in IFS for last 8 to 9 years. However its not popular as Oracle or SAP but the best product compared to others with IFS 10 they are best in user experience. Would like to contact you if you have any plans in canada.
Great summary Eric, I'd love to see your updated 2022 list!
Agreed! It should be out by now..
I liked the video but I disagree with your picks at 1. & 2. Personally I would still put Dynamics ahead of Netsuite. The O365 intergration is incredible. Its still the case that the majority of businesses are still using some or all of the Office Programs. The most common probably being excel and outlook. Very interesting video and well thought out from a product perspective.
Service Now should be ranked much higher than #10. SN has been adopted for use by two extremely large organizations in the CA for a few years now: University of California (the largest employer in CA) and Behr, and the new features we are seeing with every iteration is well thought out and on point. In my humble opinion, Infor should be 10 while SN is #7, as we are seeing movement away from Infor, particularly LN, as their goals are not clear.
Michael, topic of this video was for an "ERP Tool" not a tool which helps tracking incidents or ticket so this SN is still at 10 that is surprising instead of out of list.
Much better audio than 2018!
Devin Valencia agreed!
Thanks for sharing the information
Hi Eric. Great Video. It was very instructive. You really seem to be on top of the topic. Congrats
Thank you!
Hello Eric, Thanks for sharing the rankings and information.
What do you think about Odoo ERP? I wonder if it was considered in this list?
Hi Burhan, yes Odoo was considered. It's a great emerging product, so it was hard to rule this and a bunch of other systems out of the Top 10 - even though you could make a strong argument for it being closer to the top of the list!
yeah id want more reviews on odoo as well. i am using community version. looks like the enterprise might be a good platform for my manufacturing company. and very cheap compared to others.
@@erickimberling Odoo should be #1. It will be the talk of the town in the near future. It's doing the one thing the bigger ERP's are not and that's making an affordable scalable option. I think that's why Shopify has done well. Rather than be like Magento and price everyone out of the market, they made a solution that was for all. I'm all-in on Odoo and loving it!
Oracle sucks for small to mid sized businesses. Don't even consider NetSuite unless your sales are $10M with at least a 50% margin. NetSuite is clunky, slow or buggy servers and damn near impossible to customize without massive investments. NetSuite is also $100-$200 per user per month and can go up if they feel like it. I heard a company doing $20M was paying $90k yr and they raised it to $150k per year just for licensing. That cost doesn't even include the Shopify connector or other apps that you'll need to make that HUNK OF JUNK work. It's also not well designed from an interface perspective. Almost no intuitive aspects about it. I tried to change our company logo on the profile and could not. I have a degree in digital marketing. Unless you have a huge budget and like blowing your money on an expensive vehicle that will literally bleed you dry when it breaks, RUN!!! I highly recommend Odoo.com, for the price and the number of apps they have developed you will have all the pieces you need to manage a small to mid sized business. That doesn't mean you can't be a world-wide company and use Odoo. There's just some things Odoo doesn't do and there is not such a thing as one size fits all for ERPs. We are also building our website on Odoo Ecommerce which has shown to be far more robust than Shopify. If not Odoo then look at Microsoft. If you have a complex model then go back to Odoo ;)
superb video. Really professional. I am now feeling more confident in my ERP project implementation business.
Thank you...and that's great to hear!
Which erp you are in?
Hi Eric, this is great and wondering analysis.
Keep up the great work, very valuable indeed!.
What about 1C?
What about small margin economy Russia isn't so big in terms of finance, economy in Russia stagnating , most business done by the Russian government or his representatives, good luck getting those contracts if any you are friend of russian goverment well , maybe you can hit Abramovich or Raldugin, but i dont think that they interested in buying a ERP.....
Eric,
Good Video, thank you for the info. Which software do you recommend for learning in the role of controller/CFO position?
Hello Eric, Can you make an independent review for TCS iON digital manufacturing ERP.
Great suggestion!
What do you think about odoo13? Please give your thought
1+
Its a great video as usual , very helpful information for evaluation
Thank you for the kind words!
Man...spot on at least on the few ERPs I'm familiar with. Thanks Eric.
hello....what are you doing here
Great analysis Eric i want to know your opinion about TEMENOS T24 transact ERP the core banking ERP.
Sometimes , listen to other option is good
And Eric , you are doing 👍
Ur videos are so informative.. anything better than Siemens ERP in manufacturing companies.. what's the feature tat lacks in Siemens?
Im surprised that you didn't mention Acumatica especially since they have been ranked highest by SIIA CODiEs, industry-insider awards from techies to techies
, PCMag Editors’ choice four years in a row, G2 Crowd, & Gartner
Hi Erika, Acumatica does appear in our ranking for manufacturing systems, as well as the top ERP systems for 2022, which you can find here: www.thirdstage-consulting.com/top-10-erp-systems-2022-top-software-vendors/.
Why no one knows Russian 1c erp. 1c -The best.
Yes. ERP 1C is great
١ j 1
Qaa
ooooo
lol
I applaud the effort to simplify this into top 10, but really it's impossible. There's too many variables. We focus on smaller business, where we would declare ourselves #1, but not for mid-sized business. Then there's value, trade offs, it's enough to make you dizzy (salesforce is not big on ERP, but ok).
You’re right that there are a ton of variables to consider! I’ve compiled a few other top 10 lists since then, one specific to small business, another for manufacturers, etc.
Thanks Eric, very good unbiased analysis
Hi Eric, have you reviewed Proshop ERP?
The top 5 are the most expensive ERP as well
They certainly can be!
Thank you for the thorough insight into Erp systems and their performance; I definitely will share presentation with my friends.
Eric, thank you. Which ERP system would you really recommend for an educational organization with branches in different countries? I would clarify here, that still it is a startup.
Hey Eric,
Thanks for this video - and all the others. It's a valuable source of information for all and contributes to more transparency and open discussions in the industry.
At 16:55, you said that Oracle ERP Cloud had not figured out how to address manufacturing. Could you please expand on that point?
Thank you for your feedback, Stephane. We have had some large manufacturing clients try to implement Oracle Cloud, which has exposed gaps in capabilities - especially when compared to legacy EBS. It isn’t yet as robust in its manufacturing workflows.
Hi Eric. But ServiceNow is an ERP? I think it is just a Ticketing tool like JIRA. Does it have modules like Service Order/Quotation/Warehousing etc?
ERP is a gray area - HCM, CRM, financials systems, and other functional systems are slowly expanding their functionality to be more like ERP systems. ServiceNow is not as broad as a "real" ERP system, but it can act as a core system for service and ticketing based companies.
Service Now definitely does not belong on this list. It's not an ERP
Hi Eric, What ERP system do you suggest for a real estate company ?
Company is more than 10 years old.
Already finished and delivered 5 projects with 5 more on going.
Employees in the company are not tech savvy
Things are still managed via calls and processes are more towards analog than digital
Looking forward to your recommendation
To be the ERP implementing consultant for 20 years I agreed most your comments on your different TH-cam topics, however this time is that more clear and appropriate if with the topic "Ranking of cloud-based ERP systems" ?
Thanks Eric, very informative but do you also do reviews on the smaller ERP systems for small independent Businesses 1 to 50 operators ?
Thank you Eric, very informative. Clean & precise. I had the same question.
1-50 operators. Is there such a thing as hybrid.. on premise/ cloud?
@@harveylynn6530 Evening Harvey, True Cloud Software is simply software which is Hosted/Published from an offsite computer, just like a web site. If you have a Windows10 Pro computer, this can also be used as a web server thus hosting your software in house. So as long as the Software is truly cloud based, yes you can host it from an onsite PC.
Thank you so much Eric!!!
This ERP list is for small to medium size companies that are not overly complex.
Very helpful. Thank you!
Thank you very much Eric, for providing your professional insights. I wonder your opinion on Acumatica ERP
Thank you, Shia! I'm glad you enjoy. Here are my thoughts on Accumatica ERP: th-cam.com/video/U_VlBXFnAlM/w-d-xo.html...
And what about ODOO?
Have you ever used or come across Ecount ERP? I am thinking of getting into the ERP implementation space for small businesses and I think this might be a good solution especially the price?
Very surprisingly but quite pleasant SAP is no more #1.
I think you should break down Oracle ERP’s - EBS, JDE, Peoplesoft, Cloud
Same SAP ECC, SAP Cloud.
I couldn’t understand and digest you are comparing tier 1 ERP’s with tier 10 ERP’s.
General comparison is never correct.
It means this analysis has no practical use
Hi Eric, Great Video.
Can you please make video on open source ERP which one is best :D
That’s a great idea - I will add to my list. Thank you!
Hi Erick, I have been struggling to find an ERP that is focused in project management: planning schedule, material management.
If you can please picture yourself as a procurement manager, what ERP system would you prefer to implement in your company?
Thank you.
This video iwas released in 2019...but is for 2021? Also Netsuite is terrible have seen more midsize companies (20-100M) move away from it than keep it.
What a great Analysis, However I dont think right now SF coul be considered as an ERP provider, they have potential of course, but it is not their core business
I have the same feeling. SF is just a CRM solution.
Hi Eric, how about open source ERP such as iDempiere or Adempiere ? they came from oracle
Thanks for your valuable information ...
hello....that nice
Hey Eric. What do you think of ERPNext? Was it considered?
Hey Eric do you have a video on cloud ERP for small business? Such as Versaccounts, K9erp BizAutomation?
Hi Jay, I haven’t yet, but that’s a great idea for a future video. Thank you for your feedback!
Yeah that would be a big help for the left out small business owner! I’ve been looking and researching these for a while now and so far these are the best ones I’ve seen that are affordable. I’d throw in one more to check out called epromise thx I’ll look forward to the video!
@@jayv2447 You may start to investigate with ERPNext. ERPNext is in the ERP FrontRunners List by Gartner for 4 consecutive years. www.softwareadvice.com/erp/#top-products
Hi Eric,
Nice work with the video.
Its really hard to find independent opinions in ERPs as the vendors are always involved.
Only thing I would add in cosideration about Netsuit is that Oracle's big bet for the future seems to be Oracle Cloud so this look bad for Netsuit in the middle/long term. What's your opinion on this?
Also, if I'm an analyst of an old Oracle suit (JD Edwards), where do you think I should aim my career?
I'm thinking on learning and getting expirience in one of the new ERPs with more future but I don't want to bet in the wrong horse.
Do you have any video of what's best from an analst perspective?
Hi Manuel, I see your point about Oracle and Netsuite. However, I really don’t think Netsuite customers are at risk, simply because the install base is so big and because they target such different companies then oracle cloud. I don’t have any videos specific to analysts as you suggest, but the top 10 videos are a good place to start. I think it’s always a good idea to broaden your knowledge of different systems, especially given the uncertainty of JDE’s future.
Eric Kimberling, Independent ERP Consultant thanks a lot!
1C Enterprise - russian ERP system
Workday started by PeopleSoft employees who are recreating PeopleSoft in a different imagine.
Do you think that's a good thing or a bad thing?
Hi Eric, I am working on oracle ebs r12 as a techno functional role in finance module but I want to move current ERP application which has good future in long run. Which application should I choose to learn in 2020. Any suggestions
SAP S/4 HANA would have been placed higher on top as there seems to be lot of complexities in Microsoft and Oracle even they also finding it difficult to land in a better when it comes to maturity and Product development
Just starting to explore ERP systems. Sage Intacct not in the top 10.... where does it come out in all this?
Hey Eric, where would you stick SAS? Haven't had bunch of experience with those, but know they've been around for so long and especially care about analytics and data insights long time before it became a hype. Are they used anywhere outside risk management and customer marketing for banks and insurance companies?
fair enough review, thanks for sharing
I don’t understand one thing: you have mentioned D365 as No.2 ERP in your list. Then why does Microsoft use SAP S/4 HANA for all of its core ERP related processes? Why don’t they use D365 for it.
A quick question, where would you place SharePoint Online?
Thank you Eric for this great vidéo
@Francis, you’re welcome - thank you for watching!
#ERPNext.... the best one..!!!
What do you think about odoo?
hi Eric, what do you think about SYSPRO?
It’s a good system...we see it a lot with our midsize and smaller manufacturing companies.
Thankyou Eric, do u think it can enter the rank if it is a top15 or top 20 ranking？ Or it specialize in manufacturing which should not included？
What about microsoft business central 356 and sap business by design all fit in same category as netsuit by oracle
How about Epicor? I heard it can be compared to SAP A1
Service Now isn't an ERP system and really doesn't belong on this list. Workday is a bit a of stretch as well because it's not a complete package. It could be a piece of a best of breed solution. I can concede Salesforce because depending on your industry, it could be the primary component of your ERP solution, but most people have Salesforce integrated to another big 5 ERP system for the supply chain and operations pieces. I think the others belong in the top ten because they are the packages that everyone should look at if you are switching systems. Depending on your industry there maybe a couple others added to this list and a few that should drop out.
Thank you for the feedback, Jim. There is definitely a blurring line between ERP and other types of enterprise software!
What ERP system would be best for Manufacturing company that is trying to integrate over to JobBoss?
Top ERP system is 1C:ERP
:-)
Can you publish the scoring details for the solutions? Your commentary seems to be inconsistent with the placement decisions that I am sure would be easier to understand if the scoring were available. Also, I noticed this was a PURE SaaS comparison only but that was not made clear. Thanks in advance.
We use that data in our consulting services, but may publish a summary of some of it at some point. Thank you for the feedback!
@@erickimberling
Not sure I understand, is that a "no?" you won't provide the underlying scoring?
How can anyone assess the claims? There are several inconsistencies in your commentary about why various vendors got different rankings. Without the data it is impossible to reconcile the claims. My assumption is you would provide the underlying support and the inconsistent commentary is just opinion.
That is correct, we do not share the detailed data for free on public forums. Our clients pay us to do this analysis, so we don’t share detailed data outside our paying client base. You are more than welcome to debate any part of the video you wish - many vendors and system integrators do!
@@erickimberling I love this reply
@@erickimberling That was a very British no, even though you are American ;)
Could you also check and analyze Priority ERP Software
I'm wondering if Deltek Costpoint was considered for this list?
Yes, it was. It didn’t make the top 10 for all industries, but it likely would be toward the top for certain industries such as government contracting.
Have you heard anything about Process Pro for cosmetic contract manufacturers?
What do you think about T.FAT ERP? I wonder if it was considered in this list?
Hi Geeta, I am not familiar with that one and haven’t seen any of our clients use it, but am curious to learn more about it...
Microsoft Dynamics 365 is beating Oracle since two years so I would put Oracle Net-suite at Rank #2 and Dynamics 365 #1.
What's the best ERP for real estate company or Alan developer ?
It is somewhat misleading to say Charles Phillips resigned as Infor CEO. He became Chairman of the Board.
But still being replaced as CEO, correct?
@@erickimberling Yes I believe so.
What do you think about Odoo?
What about Epicor iScala...where does it stand..there is not much information about it
Hi, seeking career advice, can i switch to oracle erp from workday? I have 5yrs exp in workday but those are support and testing. Not able to study integration or func config. Please advice.
Yes, you can do that. It may give you a broader experience since Oracle extends beyond HCM.
@@erickimberling also Oracle is in top 3 - OTM
Hi eric thanks for video. What do u think about vienna advantage erp? Tq
So im trying to wrap my head around this. Your saying due to the shift in management, the market share always shrinks or becomes less unstable, the service then also takes a hit, ranks lower on maturity?
Why does it matter really if people step down from a software agency?
It’s a minor factor, but could signal a sign of instability or uncertainty at the software company. It’s one minor consideration in the grand scheme of things.
Das im Mittelstand sehr beliebte Standard ERP System Microsoft Dynamics 365 Business Central (vormals: Navision, ERP System Dynamics NAV) bietet einen vollen Funktionsumfang der beliebig um firmenspezifische Funktionen mit sogenannten Business Central Extensions, zertifizierten Add-On´s, vollintegrierten Zusatzanwendungen erweitert und komplett in Microsoft Dynamics 365 integriert und so optimal an Ihre unternehmensspezifischen Bedürfnisse angepasst werden kann: navision-partnerwechsel.jetzt/erp-software/erp-system-dynamics-nav-module-und-funktionen-im-ueberblick/