*Timestamps:* 00:00 - Channel Intro 00:15 - Introduction 00:38 - Background of the Guest 01:01 - Discussion on Personal Experiences 01:48 - Insights into Story nights, training & Health 03:03 - Perspectives on the UK Islamic Scene 04:00 - Community Development Comparisons 04:48 - Cultural Identity vs. Faith Identity 06:15 - Understanding the European Muslim Experience 07:30 - National Identity vs. Racial Identity 08:16 - Shifts in Political Conversations 09:11 - Evolving Perspectives on I$rahell & Politics 10:59 - Purpose of Quranic Revelation 12:38 - Understanding the Divine Order of the Qur'an 13:25 - Historical Evidence for Revelation 14:29 - Discourse on Consensus 16:30 - Divine vs. Human Significance 17:10 - Linguistic Marvels in the Qur'an 18:46 - The Miraculous Nature of the Qur'an 20:14 - Personal Engagement with the Qur'an 21:09 - Initial Encounter with Philosophy & Faith 22:37 - Charity Appeal 23:18 - Exploring Oral Tradition in Quranic Transmission 27:16 - Shifts in Academic Perspectives on the Qur'an 27:59 - Interpretation: Literal vs. Metaphorical Understanding 28:52 - Importance of Pre-Islamic Literature 30:14 - Figurative Language in the Qur'an 31:27 - The Dual Nature of Salah 33:40 - Contextual Understanding of Quranic Verses 37:07 - The Nature of Scholars & Knowledge in Islam 41:39 - Seeking Knowledge in Modern Times 41:52 - Intellectual Revolution Brought by the Quran 44:06 - Understanding the Value of Islamic Sciences 44:41 - Romanticism and Self-Awareness 45:56 - The Role of Evidence in Tradition 46:46 - Respecting Evidence-Based Arguments 49:05 - Understanding Spirituality Beyond Materialism 50:22 - Exploring the Pursuit of Allah's Favor 51:24 - Updates on Bayyinah TV and Quranic Studies 53:12 - Closing Remarks
Everytime I watch a video of ustad, I learn something else whilst falling in love with the Qur'an over and over again and marvelling over its miracle. Alhamdulillah for being a Muslim. Alhamdulillah
meaning that you are ignorant, he is not even a muslim, didu not hear what he just said, he does not believe quran 2:106, you cannot be a muslim until you believe the whole quran.
@@hassandiallo5326 listen to his explanation of the aayat. You know he has explanation of entire Quran. "Quran hive" app has it as the native tafseer. Be careful for your own sake, branding some one kaafir. There are serious ramifications.....
This man has truly inspired me to learn the Quran in my heart and I am now truly reciting the Quran with translation everyday Alhamdulillah. Soon I will be able to recite the Quran without translation insha'Allah and then I will teach insha'Allah
If you read the comment section, you will find the answer why the Ummah is suffering. Brother Dilly gave us an opportunity to find some answers about the Holy book from someone who is engaged in exploring it on a regular basis. And we are talking about nonsensical things. We as Ummah are so far from the reality it seems nothing will stop us from focusing on the meaningless issues. May Allah guide us all.
This interview was about Culture, identity and the Quran. Culture and identity is an issue Muslims are facing. People and communities are judged by their racial and cultural identity no doubt. The world doesn’t come to the aid of certain communities but it helps other communities. I wish to learn more about what the Quran says about race and identity and I will inshaAllah.
Excellent interview Dilli. You ask the right questions to your guests without making it seem like a big mountain. I especially devoured the answer to the preservation of the Quran. Both of you are blessed in your own special ways. Please brothers join together, you all together are a wealth. Many people are working hard and being to make sure that we don’t unite. Please join hands and unite and create like think tanks and movements and advocates.
@@hassandiallo5326pretty sure you're the ignorant one here. You're replying to a dua with criticism. And regarding your point, the abrogation of verses is a scholarly opinion, not a matter a pillar of faith. His full-time job is studying Quran, he has an institute for teaching Quran, he is a student of the Quran. And then there's you, who is judging not only one but two people on TH-cam because you think you know better. If Noman Ali Khan believes something about the Quran, it's obviously because he studied about it in-depth. I'm sure if you said that to his face, you'd be humbled by the amount of proof he would give you for his argument. As I said before, you're the ignoarant one. Stop spreading hateful judgement and finding fault in everything and go gain some knowledge.
If we didn't have NAK, our generation would be so lost. Completely disconnected from the Quran, as we are such a distracted and fast paced generation. He is a blessing to humanity and has done the world and our generation and those to come a GREAAAT service!
Is there any major US scholar calling for Jihad against Israel or calling LGBTQ disgusting? We have plenty of those scholars in the UK notably Shaykh Asrar. American Muslims seem more far more tolerant of haram and kufr than the Muslims of the UK. The Islam in the UK more closely resemble traditional islam of the muslim lands.
this is random but a few months back, I saw NAK at my gym in South Wales, UK. I began watching him over a decade ago so it was such a surreal moment, wasn't even aware that he was in the UK at the time so I didn't approach at the time as I thought it was just a guy who looked really similar to him.
The US don't know what Islam is. They are still arguing amongst themselves about what's halal food and what's not. Everything is halal to them. Alhamdulliah in the UK the core Islamic views are stronger
@adamkhan9161 Haram and Halal are clear though. If something new comes along then Muslims need to see if that is Halal or Haram not just assume it is Halal and take the easy option.
Therefore, by default everything is haram unless it's slaughtered Islamically. That's why you have Zahibah halal. Stop trying to fulfill your desires and bend the rules.
American exceptionalism probably has more to do with it. Muslims in America are more likely to be isolated and without muslim community, generally less religous, and their offspring are more likley to apostate sadly, 1 in 4 according to one study if i recall correctly. I don't say this with any pride or partisanship but those are things that have been documented though researched. American muslims are usually used by right wing neoliberal types to criticise European Muslims for not "integrating" enough. My worry is that people absurdly start looking to the US as some sort of model for the rest of us. Sadly far from that, it is.
The US is only a few hundred years old, and any immigrant can lay claim to the title American as the Europeans are not natives. This makes assimilation and "acceptance" easier. Whereas in the UK, Muslims, who have contributed far more to the UK and the Muslim community than their US counterparts, are still clashing with the natives because they are seen as outsiders.
@@MadingoY-b2m The reason for the apostatacy rate being 1 in 4 is skewed due to the rate at which Iranians leaving Islam. When you look at other ethnic groups in the US the apostacy rates are similar to the UK. One thing I have noticed in the UK is that the majority of Muslims are poor and uneducated where in the US they are wealthy and educated
Many Muslims in the UK have a very good standard of living. They are upwardly mobile in all the professions and have very well established businesses. Muslims are also very active in government and politics, much more so than the US. Also the masaajid in the UK are very well established and very active in a host of educational and community development activities. I find it surprising that American Muslim scholars who regularly visit the UK can be so shortsighted about the Muslim community in Britain, which is so active and vibrant.
The fact that he puts forward the idea that the US community is years ahead of the UK is laughable… in the US are years agead of keeping only the symbols of Islam, but they lost it’s essence decades ago, while the UK keeps on being a stronghold of traditional Islam and Islamic values
I agree with him what he was saying though that in America everyone is American Iam from UK and in UK but my mum is from France I understand French an Imam who was in France he was saying as well that nationalism is haram and if your born and grew up in France you are just French really but Muslims in France will say that they are Moroccan or Algerian and in England as well people say they Pakistani or Tunisian or Algerian they just liars they just Europpean really and nothing else really
@@AdamKhan-f9i That’s because in the US, with the exception of Native Americans, everybody else is or descends from immigrants, who adopted this new “American” identity. In Europe every single country has their native people, and muslims refuse to identify themselves with their nee home, and in a lot of instances, the country they themselves were born in, but rather they still see themselves as from where their ancestors came from. I am a Spanish revert and I am extremely proud of my Islam, as I am of my heritage. Now, that’s one thing, but it’s a completely different story to derive from their societal cohesion that somehow Islam is better and stronger in the US, when the whole Islamic West looks in horror and disbelief at the statements that come from the US muslim leaders, which many a time border Kufr. The UK is the stronghold of Islam in the West, that’s why I moved from Spain to the UK. And anybody who implies that the US somehow is a better place for muslims lives in lalaland🤷🏻♂️
@@MuhammadVilchezEverybody is immigrants though even the native people of Europe and nationalism is not allowed in Islam if your born in Europe your just European really your not Algerian or Pakistan Algeria Pakistan is not your home its just somewhere where you go for holidays its hypocrisy nationalism
@@AdamKhan-f9i It’s this retarded idea that you can’t call yourself British or European because Europeans are white and not muslims🤦🏻♂️ Everybody is going to have a certain attachment to their ancestral homeland, but for Muslims born and raised in the west, identifying yourself with “backhome” wherever that is, only serves to alienate us from the general population. But that has nothing to do with how strong Islam is in a certain country.
I have a love hate relationship with noman Ali khan. I remember I used to train hard, and this guy did a lecture about making muscles? is that what you live for. Now he's training. He talks about American Muslims as if they are so advanced but I'm gonna be real the majority of them are American first Islam 2nd. Yes Americans have really good scholars but still he talks of America as this great place and when I go there the racial tension is on another level. And also sometimes he says Quranic interpretation that for a layman like me couldn't agree with but I thought ok he's knowledgeable then I see so many people correct him time and time again. I do like him but at the same time I don't take his views as the gold standard, also I expected more from the blood brother podcast. You guys literally gave him the bubble wrap treatment ask him the questions you are known for. Even you guys took the knee for him. Mashallah he's a great guy but I expect those questions which challenge his views. Dilly you sat there on the first question and just sat there man? This wasn't a blood brothers more like the healing brothers podcast.
@@fabs99 this guy did a lecture on gym bros dissing them. Saying people are wasting Thier time in the gym. This was when he wasn't in shape then he did a U turn and I used to train hard back then. I literally slowed because of his lecture then I see this guy all pumped up. I've been following him since his first videos in a cafe. I even have a bayinah subscription, I don't care what he does in his private life but he says so many things and does the opposite. Maybe you haven't been following him like I have the last 20 years but trust me I ain't gonna say stuff to goto jahanam for the sake of slandering the guy. I wish him all the best but this guy is pompous at times. He's the only guy I know who talks of this Muslim divide Europe and America and the rest of the world. Why would I hate my American brothers but this stuff where my love hate part kicks in.
Assalamualaikum This is the first time I have heard a scholar say he does not believe that certain verses were abrogated. I am trying to understand the meaning of the following verse #106 in Surah Al Baqarah; "Whatever a Verse (revelation) do We abrogate or cause to be forgotten, We bring a better one or similar to it. Know you not that Allâh is able to do all things?"
He's not a scholar, he's a self trained daeeh that does not care about aqeedah or the understanding of the Salaf. Aisha رضي الله عنها clearly stated in Sahih Bukhari that a certain verse was abrogated. If we follow the likes of nak, it would be as if we consider Aisha رضي الله عنها less knowledgeable and infact a liar. Astaghfirullah
I thought it was interesting about what he said about American Muslims. It could be because America is so vast everyone is spread out, everyone is an immigrant and there aren’t many indigenous Americans left. But here we are all like sardines all rubbing each other up the wrong way, lots of friction, depressing weather, people complaining all the time. And most importantly we live with the actual indigenous majority who often remind us we are not from here. Still the UK a great place to live for Muslims but we have our problems.
Think he was just talking about size, scale and the concentration of their community to one place. And also the financial power of their community to grow it.
Dont forget, everyone is an immigrant at some point in the US - the indigenous Indian American are no more. As for the Uk and other ex empires, they cant colonise countries for centuries, cause wars, sponsored genocide and expect nothing to hit them back. Sorry
Ok seriously people who are arguing in comments about UK and US , like seriously people this is what is dividing you "I am better thn u",noone wants you to prove, just focus on ur areas of improvement n work on them, instead of making argument winning the whole purpose of ur life. Focus on the purpose not the nationalities, make purpose ur identity not ur ethnicity ,let the deeds speak for u, not u speaking for ur deeds.
30 years ahead in what sense? American Muslims have 0 influence on the politics in America. They might have Muslim docs engineers but the UK also has a lot of docs lawyers, as well as mps councillors mayor's which the US doesn't have. They have some big very beautiful mosques and a lot less sectarianism but the UK has a lot more Muslim populated areas where one will find halal food masjids etc. As for walking into a coffee shop and no one caring what background you are. That's the case in UK urban areas too. In smaller less diverse areas it's more of an issue which is also the case in America. Living in nice areas in a bubble is similar to living in a ghetto in a bubble. One becomes too proud of their country because they're living the high life and the other becomes too proud of their nationality culture because they're living in a bubble in their country.
you said there have nice mosques in America I dont know I havent been there iam from UK but probably in America for Friday gatherings they probably have just one gathering per city probably whereas UK there is lots of mosques in small area so muslims do divide themselves in Uk
Uk is a small island as well and it is tiny compared to America and Muslims they always arguing with each other in the UK there is something called speakers corner as well all there people Muslims arguing with one another me as someone from UK and born in UK iam ashamed to see this
@ it’s pretty complicated subject you need a scholar to teach you that and show you the evidence from the Quran of the sunnah, but from what I know, naskh, or abrogation in the Quran primarily concerning commands and prohibitions applies only to legal rulings and moral guidance, not to miracles or signs (ayat) that affirm GOD existence. (2:106) Any revelation We cause to be superseded or forgotten, We replace with something better or similar. Do you [Prophet] not know that God has power over everything? (16:101) When We substitute one revelation for another- and God knows best what He reveals- they say, ‘You are just making it up,’ but most of them have no knowledge. And from the hadith (Sahih Muslim 1406) And an example from the sunnah O people, I had permitted you to contract temporary marriage with women, but Allah has forbidden it (now) until the Day of Resurrection. So he who has any (woman with this type of marriage contract) he should let her off, and do not take back anything you have given to them (as dower).
@18:05 I guess the deep of appreciation of the Quranic miracles depends on the depth of knowledge of the reader...of course, the appreciation a scientist will have for the scientific miracles of the Quran will be far more than that of a historian and vice versa...I think that's why it is important for Quran students to also study other subjects alongside as they help increase the appreciation of Quran miracles
Hi does someone have the discount code for the bayinnah subscription please? Awesome session by the way - NAK is in touch with context of society and his content connects people with the tradition through Qur’an. 53:35
So I’m from slough in uk but now live in USA. Nouman is right, as a Muslim here I’ve never had any issues whatsoever. Granted i do live in dc and it’s very diverse. The difficulties may come soon if there was mass Muslim migration here and the z1onist media use it against us, like they do with Mexicans But 99% of the time Muslims have no issue here in USA, he is correct
I've lived in d.c and the Muslim community there haven't a clue about the world. Virginia Fairfax etc literally dry place. Yes Slough is cultural but they have a connection with the home land. But d.c is so dead. On top of that all you do is work and that's about it.
Such an easy interview lol. No mention about his blunders including saying to sisters regarding husbands wealth "my money is mine, his my husband's money is mine as well". Smh
Stop spreading hate. Maybe you don't know what is Advised by Allah about Exposing and judging others on Their Sins. You are no one to Call him Anything based on his Sins.
even some the sisters nowadays they want an ex bad boy they say oh he got some tattoos but now he is repented mashallah and when the ex bad boy leaves her and goes back to his past she spends her nights crying
Brother Nouman Ali Khan inspired me to start with the morning azkar and evening azkar for the time. Before that i didn't even knew about morning and evening azkar. My love for Quran also increased because of him. May Allah swt reward him and protect him from the evil eye and the evils in the form of humans. Ameen.
Jzk for this. Quick comment though, nak usually gives linguistic definition, figuritive,etc But what about the verses that Rasulullah s and sahaba r endorsed, established, implemented- such as treaties, hudood, etc etc Quran cant be seperate from the ahadith, fiqh, usool, seerah, etc They all go hand in hand. Thats when we get to appreciate living islam rather then just theoretical appreciations. I'm definately sure that quran has given a law or system to be implemented to protect falistin,rohingya, uighuyr, kashmir,shaam, khurasan, etc Allah swt give this noble ummah to implement and establish every hukum of Allah and Rasulullah s. Allahumma ameen thumma ameen ya rabbil alameen
I Dore and Appreciated The Sincere Teachings of Ustadh Nouman Ali Khan...However I Disagree Many Of His Views...May ALLAH Almighty Guide Us All To The Solid Teuth and Realities🤲🏽❤️
But the solidarity of all our people here in the UK Muslim and non Muslim black white brown and in between it gives us heart even in this terror and one of the biggest things for me its the Palestinians that are teaching us our religion they got faith even amogst all this brutality they call on Allah alone because who else have they got left the Muslim leaders are asleep
I don't think a lot of British Muslims realize that white British culture and white American culture are very different. Generally speaking, white Americans are very curious and open minded. Of course there is racism everywhere and incidents do happen. But brother NAK is right in that America is actually a pretty amazing country. It's a really weird paradox that American foreign policy is the exact opposite of how minorities experience life within America.
inch Allah they may change the course of the future with Allah permission next Nov election by breaking the 2 party system that will transform the country
Not sure I agree with his take on Muslims in the UK having a harder time than Muslims in the US and I don't think the Muslims in the US are 30 years ahead. The dynamics in each country are different. But the Muslims in the US have felt marginalised, especially after Trump's comments regarding stopping Muslim immigration. No politician in the UK has ever made such a direct comment about Muslim immigration. The Muslims in the US also have a very heavy weight on their conscience regarding the US's unwavering support for Israel and the Billions of dollars it gives Israel in military aid and hardware, making the US complicit in the ongoing genocide in Gaza. As well as the US's role in the so called, 'War on Terror' and the destruction of Iraq, Afghanistan and Syria. And what about the US's disgusting and inhumane treatment of Muslim prisoners in Guantanamo, which is still ongoing. So American Muslims have all this to grapple with. Have American Muslims done enough to speak up against their country's foreign policy? Frankly, I don't think they have. If I were Dilly, I would have put these questions to Nouman.
I think you forget how the so called war on terror impacted the Uk from the anti terror laws to the Prevent program and so on - the past year all the Zionist assets were activated in the UK parliament and started uttering racist things I would have never imagined. So in a way he is right and for Trump a good chunk of the people admit he is a fool and no one take him seriously. But I found the rhetoric of the like of Farage and the Conservative party much more dangerous.
I am quite disappointed with 5pillars on this. I've been a long time subscriber and recently signed up to regularly support the organisation. I was expecting Dilly with this ethics to question NAK on his past behaviour with women and clear up the controversy. Instead this was like a promotion for NAK.
*Timestamps:*
00:00 - Channel Intro
00:15 - Introduction
00:38 - Background of the Guest
01:01 - Discussion on Personal Experiences
01:48 - Insights into Story nights, training & Health
03:03 - Perspectives on the UK Islamic Scene
04:00 - Community Development Comparisons
04:48 - Cultural Identity vs. Faith Identity
06:15 - Understanding the European Muslim Experience
07:30 - National Identity vs. Racial Identity
08:16 - Shifts in Political Conversations
09:11 - Evolving Perspectives on I$rahell & Politics
10:59 - Purpose of Quranic Revelation
12:38 - Understanding the Divine Order of the Qur'an
13:25 - Historical Evidence for Revelation
14:29 - Discourse on Consensus
16:30 - Divine vs. Human Significance
17:10 - Linguistic Marvels in the Qur'an
18:46 - The Miraculous Nature of the Qur'an
20:14 - Personal Engagement with the Qur'an
21:09 - Initial Encounter with Philosophy & Faith
22:37 - Charity Appeal
23:18 - Exploring Oral Tradition in Quranic Transmission
27:16 - Shifts in Academic Perspectives on the Qur'an
27:59 - Interpretation: Literal vs. Metaphorical Understanding
28:52 - Importance of Pre-Islamic Literature
30:14 - Figurative Language in the Qur'an
31:27 - The Dual Nature of Salah
33:40 - Contextual Understanding of Quranic Verses
37:07 - The Nature of Scholars & Knowledge in Islam
41:39 - Seeking Knowledge in Modern Times
41:52 - Intellectual Revolution Brought by the Quran
44:06 - Understanding the Value of Islamic Sciences
44:41 - Romanticism and Self-Awareness
45:56 - The Role of Evidence in Tradition
46:46 - Respecting Evidence-Based Arguments
49:05 - Understanding Spirituality Beyond Materialism
50:22 - Exploring the Pursuit of Allah's Favor
51:24 - Updates on Bayyinah TV and Quranic Studies
53:12 - Closing Remarks
Jazakallah khayran!
If you put this in the description, TH-cam will create chapters automatically:) @@5Pillars
Ustad Nouman my reason for learning Arabic and loving Quran. May Allah Bless him
Everytime I watch a video of ustad, I learn something else whilst falling in love with the Qur'an over and over again and marvelling over its miracle. Alhamdulillah for being a Muslim. Alhamdulillah
This man has enriched my life for over ten years with his teachings of our divine book. Jazakallah Khair
Naaa
@@muhammadomer4674braaa
Me too! Alhumdulillah
The way some of you put these imams on pedestals....m and he's not a scholar he has no ijaaza from what I know
@@ajam-n3s some scholars.do evil things to children
So... eff them
Could listen to Ustadh Nouman all day. May Allah SWT preserve him.
meaning that you are ignorant, he is not even a muslim, didu not hear what he just said, he does not believe quran 2:106, you cannot be a muslim until you believe the whole quran.
@@hassandiallo5326 listen to his explanation of the aayat. You know he has explanation of entire Quran. "Quran hive" app has it as the native tafseer.
Be careful for your own sake, branding some one kaafir. There are serious ramifications.....
Ameen..
Same here❤
A collab we did not expect.
Excited for this episode 🤍
In Shaa Allah
he is not a muslim because he does not believe in quran 2:106, listen again
@@hassandiallo5326 what do you mean?
May Allah increase brother Dilly and brother Nouman in knowledge and all of the believers and bless us and guide us and purify us ameen!
Ameen ya Rab
This man has truly inspired me to learn the Quran in my heart and I am now truly reciting the Quran with translation everyday Alhamdulillah. Soon I will be able to recite the Quran without translation insha'Allah and then I will teach insha'Allah
The way he enriches my relationship with the quran and Allah! May Allah bless him protect him and reward him!
One of the bests!!! One episode! A summary of all the very fundamentals about Islam and the Quran. Jazakallahu Khair...
If you read the comment section, you will find the answer why the Ummah is suffering. Brother Dilly gave us an opportunity to find some answers about the Holy book from someone who is engaged in exploring it on a regular basis. And we are talking about nonsensical things. We as Ummah are so far from the reality it seems nothing will stop us from focusing on the meaningless issues. May Allah guide us all.
This interview was about Culture, identity and the Quran. Culture and identity is an issue Muslims are facing. People and communities are judged by their racial and cultural identity no doubt. The world doesn’t come to the aid of certain communities but it helps other communities. I wish to learn more about what the Quran says about race and identity and I will inshaAllah.
Excellent interview Dilli. You ask the right questions to your guests without making it seem like a big mountain. I especially devoured the answer to the preservation of the Quran. Both of you are blessed in your own special ways. Please brothers join together, you all together are a wealth. Many people are working hard and being to make sure that we don’t unite. Please join hands and unite and create like think tanks and movements and advocates.
I didn't knew about surah Muzammil part. So thank you for that. I really needed that.
I am from germany and ustadh is got the muslim situation here absolute on point ❤
How can it change??
There nothing we can do @@MaxPayne-fi1mz
NAK is a treasure! Jazak Allah
@@bigjoegoesnowhere he is getting paid treas9
Amazing discussion! May Allah grant both of you all the best of both worlds!
because you r ignorant, did you not hear him say that he does not believe in quran 2:106? abrogation.
@@hassandiallo5326pretty sure you're the ignorant one here. You're replying to a dua with criticism. And regarding your point, the abrogation of verses is a scholarly opinion, not a matter a pillar of faith. His full-time job is studying Quran, he has an institute for teaching Quran, he is a student of the Quran. And then there's you, who is judging not only one but two people on TH-cam because you think you know better. If Noman Ali Khan believes something about the Quran, it's obviously because he studied about it in-depth. I'm sure if you said that to his face, you'd be humbled by the amount of proof he would give you for his argument. As I said before, you're the ignoarant one. Stop spreading hateful judgement and finding fault in everything and go gain some knowledge.
If we didn't have NAK, our generation would be so lost. Completely disconnected from the Quran, as we are such a distracted and fast paced generation.
He is a blessing to humanity and has done the world and our generation and those to come a GREAAAT service!
❤❤❤❤ you so much.
What nonsense.
Congratulations on this podcast, we need more. The host was spot on...GREAT JOB TO EVERYONE INVOLVED. Allah Almighty reward and bless you all, Ameen!
Thank you for connecting this generation to the Quran. Thank you for doing the work we didnt do
My first favorite teacher. He's lecture change my life. I love and pray him...
Excellent interview. Brother Nouman inspire me to read and learn the Quran. Thank you and may you both be blessed by the Almighty
Is there any major US scholar calling for Jihad against Israel or calling LGBTQ disgusting? We have plenty of those scholars in the UK notably Shaykh Asrar. American Muslims seem more far more tolerant of haram and kufr than the Muslims of the UK. The Islam in the UK more closely resemble traditional islam of the muslim lands.
And what person has gone from UK and done Jihad in Palestine though its good to talk though
Much tunnel vision there, that final line.
Uthman bin Farooq
Your masjids are just one demographic....our masjids and communities are diverse
Shiekh Asrar the sufi 😆
Ustad is amazing and MashaaAllah He is so so knowledgeable so many duas for this beautiful person ❤
Jazakallah khair to these brother who are helping us to understand Quran more and more..May ALLAH swt reward you guys and forgives your mistakes
Finally... The man of knowledge.
JazakAllah Khair
Another great interview guys, thanks again.
Thank you brother Nouman, because of your earlier lectures I have benefitted greatly. I’m a member of Bayyi ah and benefiting immensely.😊
this is random but a few months back, I saw NAK at my gym in South Wales, UK. I began watching him over a decade ago so it was such a surreal moment, wasn't even aware that he was in the UK at the time so I didn't approach at the time as I thought it was just a guy who looked really similar to him.
Good journalistic skills. He listens questions, and waits. Good convo. Some I understood some I didn't
This was great, thank you
The US don't know what Islam is. They are still arguing amongst themselves about what's halal food and what's not. Everything is halal to them. Alhamdulliah in the UK the core Islamic views are stronger
Everything is Halal by default though
@adamkhan9161 Haram and Halal are clear though.
If something new comes along then Muslims need to see if that is Halal or Haram not just assume it is Halal and take the easy option.
@@KhadijahbintAslambut food everything is Halal by default though your allowed to eat the meat and slaughtering of Christians and Jews as well
@@AdamKhan-f9i please do your research, it's not halal by default. America is a secular country, not a Christian country.
Therefore, by default everything is haram unless it's slaughtered Islamically. That's why you have Zahibah halal. Stop trying to fulfill your desires and bend the rules.
He can easily be categorised as Arabic linguist, he has deep knowledge of words and the connotation associated with them in the Quran.
Worth using the time listening to the discussion. Very informative.
Thank you both of you
Enjoyed this conversation. Was informative and relaxed.
Americans are generally proud to be American, probably due to their standard of living far better than average UK. Also they do have amazing mosques.
American exceptionalism probably has more to do with it. Muslims in America are more likely to be isolated and without muslim community, generally less religous, and their offspring are more likley to apostate sadly, 1 in 4 according to one study if i recall correctly.
I don't say this with any pride or partisanship but those are things that have been documented though researched. American muslims are usually used by right wing neoliberal types to criticise European Muslims for not "integrating" enough.
My worry is that people absurdly start looking to the US as some sort of model for the rest of us. Sadly far from that, it is.
That's now we all started somwwhere
The US is only a few hundred years old, and any immigrant can lay claim to the title American as the Europeans are not natives. This makes assimilation and "acceptance" easier. Whereas in the UK, Muslims, who have contributed far more to the UK and the Muslim community than their US counterparts, are still clashing with the natives because they are seen as outsiders.
@@MadingoY-b2m The reason for the apostatacy rate being 1 in 4 is skewed due to the rate at which Iranians leaving Islam. When you look at other ethnic groups in the US the apostacy rates are similar to the UK. One thing I have noticed in the UK is that the majority of Muslims are poor and uneducated where in the US they are wealthy and educated
Many Muslims in the UK have a very good standard of living. They are upwardly mobile in all the professions and have very well established businesses. Muslims are also very active in government and politics, much more so than the US. Also the masaajid in the UK are very well established and very active in a host of educational and community development activities. I find it surprising that American Muslim scholars who regularly visit the UK can be so shortsighted about the Muslim community in Britain, which is so active and vibrant.
We love brother Nouman ali khan!!
The fact that he puts forward the idea that the US community is years ahead of the UK is laughable… in the US are years agead of keeping only the symbols of Islam, but they lost it’s essence decades ago, while the UK keeps on being a stronghold of traditional Islam and Islamic values
I agree with him what he was saying though that in America everyone is American Iam from UK and in UK but my mum is from France I understand French an Imam who was in France he was saying as well that nationalism is haram and if your born and grew up in France you are just French really but Muslims in France will say that they are Moroccan or Algerian and in England as well people say they Pakistani or Tunisian or Algerian they just liars they just Europpean really and nothing else really
Because the blood of a muslim on american hands is decades old n the Europeans is centuries@@AdamKhan-f9i
@@AdamKhan-f9i That’s because in the US, with the exception of Native Americans, everybody else is or descends from immigrants, who adopted this new “American” identity.
In Europe every single country has their native people, and muslims refuse to identify themselves with their nee home, and in a lot of instances, the country they themselves were born in, but rather they still see themselves as from where their ancestors came from.
I am a Spanish revert and I am extremely proud of my Islam, as I am of my heritage.
Now, that’s one thing, but it’s a completely different story to derive from their societal cohesion that somehow Islam is better and stronger in the US, when the whole Islamic West looks in horror and disbelief at the statements that come from the US muslim leaders, which many a time border Kufr.
The UK is the stronghold of Islam in the West, that’s why I moved from Spain to the UK. And anybody who implies that the US somehow is a better place for muslims lives in lalaland🤷🏻♂️
@@MuhammadVilchezEverybody is immigrants though even the native people of Europe and nationalism is not allowed in Islam if your born in Europe your just European really your not Algerian or Pakistan Algeria Pakistan is not your home its just somewhere where you go for holidays its hypocrisy nationalism
@@AdamKhan-f9i It’s this retarded idea that you can’t call yourself British or European because Europeans are white and not muslims🤦🏻♂️ Everybody is going to have a certain attachment to their ancestral homeland, but for Muslims born and raised in the west, identifying yourself with “backhome” wherever that is, only serves to alienate us from the general population. But that has nothing to do with how strong Islam is in a certain country.
I have a love hate relationship with noman Ali khan. I remember I used to train hard, and this guy did a lecture about making muscles? is that what you live for. Now he's training. He talks about American Muslims as if they are so advanced but I'm gonna be real the majority of them are American first Islam 2nd. Yes Americans have really good scholars but still he talks of America as this great place and when I go there the racial tension is on another level. And also sometimes he says Quranic interpretation that for a layman like me couldn't agree with but I thought ok he's knowledgeable then I see so many people correct him time and time again. I do like him but at the same time I don't take his views as the gold standard, also I expected more from the blood brother podcast. You guys literally gave him the bubble wrap treatment ask him the questions you are known for. Even you guys took the knee for him. Mashallah he's a great guy but I expect those questions which challenge his views. Dilly you sat there on the first question and just sat there man? This wasn't a blood brothers more like the healing brothers podcast.
Yeah, expected more Devil's advocate role from Dilly. But I guess it's the shortage of time.
So true! Couldn't have said it better!
If he likes going to the gym and keeping his body in shape, what's wrong with that?
Seems like a nonsensical criticism.
@@fabs99 this guy did a lecture on gym bros dissing them. Saying people are wasting Thier time in the gym. This was when he wasn't in shape then he did a U turn and I used to train hard back then. I literally slowed because of his lecture then I see this guy all pumped up. I've been following him since his first videos in a cafe. I even have a bayinah subscription, I don't care what he does in his private life but he says so many things and does the opposite. Maybe you haven't been following him like I have the last 20 years but trust me I ain't gonna say stuff to goto jahanam for the sake of slandering the guy. I wish him all the best but this guy is pompous at times. He's the only guy I know who talks of this Muslim divide Europe and America and the rest of the world. Why would I hate my American brothers but this stuff where my love hate part kicks in.
@atrociousnonsense no he literally said don't waste your time in the gym. I know your a fanboy but find it and check it out yourself
Another amazing episode! جَزَاکَ اللَّهُ خَيْرً
Assalamualaikum This is the first time I have heard a scholar say he does not believe that certain verses were abrogated. I am trying to understand the meaning of the following verse #106 in Surah Al Baqarah; "Whatever a Verse (revelation) do We abrogate or cause to be forgotten, We bring a better one or similar to it. Know you not that Allâh is able to do all things?"
He's not a scholar, he's a self trained daeeh that does not care about aqeedah or the understanding of the Salaf.
Aisha رضي الله عنها clearly stated in Sahih Bukhari that a certain verse was abrogated. If we follow the likes of nak, it would be as if we consider Aisha رضي الله عنها less knowledgeable and infact a liar. Astaghfirullah
He is an ideal person❤Mashaallah
Didn't expect ustadh. Ma sha Allah
Ma Sha Allah ❤
Ustadh Nauman ❤
I thought it was interesting about what he said about American Muslims. It could be because America is so vast everyone is spread out, everyone is an immigrant and there aren’t many indigenous Americans left. But here we are all like sardines all rubbing each other up the wrong way, lots of friction, depressing weather, people complaining all the time. And most importantly we live with the actual indigenous majority who often remind us we are not from here. Still the UK a great place to live for Muslims but we have our problems.
You just said everyone keeps complaining (in UK) while making a whole comment... complaining. Maybe look at how you look at the world first.
Think he was just talking about size, scale and the concentration of their community to one place. And also the financial power of their community to grow it.
Dont forget, everyone is an immigrant at some point in the US - the indigenous Indian American are no more. As for the Uk and other ex empires, they cant colonise countries for centuries, cause wars, sponsored genocide and expect nothing to hit them back. Sorry
Ok seriously people who are arguing in comments about UK and US , like seriously people this is what is dividing you "I am better thn u",noone wants you to prove, just focus on ur areas of improvement n work on them, instead of making argument winning the whole purpose of ur life. Focus on the purpose not the nationalities, make purpose ur identity not ur ethnicity ,let the deeds speak for u, not u speaking for ur deeds.
Genius, may Allah grant him good health
Thank you so much 🤍🤍🤍
30 years ahead in what sense? American Muslims have 0 influence on the politics in America. They might have Muslim docs engineers but the UK also has a lot of docs lawyers, as well as mps councillors mayor's which the US doesn't have. They have some big very beautiful mosques and a lot less sectarianism but the UK has a lot more Muslim populated areas where one will find halal food masjids etc. As for walking into a coffee shop and no one caring what background you are. That's the case in UK urban areas too. In smaller less diverse areas it's more of an issue which is also the case in America. Living in nice areas in a bubble is similar to living in a ghetto in a bubble. One becomes too proud of their country because they're living the high life and the other becomes too proud of their nationality culture because they're living in a bubble in their country.
you said there have nice mosques in America I dont know I havent been there iam from UK but probably in America for Friday gatherings they probably have just one gathering per city probably whereas UK there is lots of mosques in small area so muslims do divide themselves in Uk
Uk is a small island as well and it is tiny compared to America and Muslims they always arguing with each other in the UK there is something called speakers corner as well all there people Muslims arguing with one another me as someone from UK and born in UK iam ashamed to see this
I doubt there is any place like Saville Town, Dewsbury in the US.
@@AdamKhan-f9i so what if they argue. muslim dominate the uk in the dawah scene what does american do liberalise it. hahaha
@@lokidedbeat1878What does UK do for Islam though really don't forget that UK created Israel also
May bless you Ustadh..
Why is he saying I don’t believe in naskh? (نسخ) it’s literally mentioned in the Quran and there are many ahadith about it
give reference then please if there is, it would be better for others too
@ it’s pretty complicated subject you need a scholar to teach you that and show you the evidence from the Quran of the sunnah, but from what I know, naskh, or abrogation in the Quran primarily concerning commands and prohibitions applies only to legal rulings and moral guidance, not to miracles or signs (ayat) that affirm GOD existence.
(2:106)
Any revelation We cause to be superseded or forgotten, We replace with something better or similar. Do you [Prophet] not know that God has power over everything?
(16:101)
When We substitute one revelation for another- and God knows best what He reveals- they say, ‘You are just making it up,’ but most of them have no knowledge.
And from the hadith
(Sahih Muslim 1406)
And an example from the sunnah
O people, I had permitted you to contract temporary marriage with women, but Allah has forbidden it (now) until the Day of Resurrection. So he who has any (woman with this type of marriage contract) he should let her off, and do not take back anything you have given to them (as dower).
Very good questions asked!
I’m happy about the south east asia story night 🎉 May allah preserve you ustad
Excellent discussion. He makes you want to explore the quran even more.
Im not sure i agree with his UK vs US observation though.
Nice one❤❤❤
Sad that it was only 53 mins. Make it 6 hours next time please.
listen again, he is not a muslim, he does not believe in quran 2:106
@@hassandiallo5326 who?nouman? or the other one?
@18:05 I guess the deep of appreciation of the Quranic miracles depends on the depth of knowledge of the reader...of course, the appreciation a scientist will have for the scientific miracles of the Quran will be far more than that of a historian and vice versa...I think that's why it is important for Quran students to also study other subjects alongside as they help increase the appreciation of Quran miracles
و عليكم السلام و رحمة الله و بركاته
What is he referring to about the comments of the ongoing things related to the Catholic Church? 19:14
Hi does someone have the discount code for the bayinnah subscription please? Awesome session by the way - NAK is in touch with context of society and his content connects people with the tradition through Qur’an. 53:35
Ma Sha Allah
Luv the format. Just a chat on key fundamental topics. Reminds me of ROGAN!!!
So I’m from slough in uk but now live in USA. Nouman is right, as a Muslim here I’ve never had any issues whatsoever. Granted i do live in dc and it’s very diverse. The difficulties may come soon if there was mass Muslim migration here and the z1onist media use it against us, like they do with Mexicans
But 99% of the time Muslims have no issue here in USA, he is correct
Yeah so you guys should stay in the Uk
I've lived in d.c and the Muslim community there haven't a clue about the world. Virginia Fairfax etc literally dry place. Yes Slough is cultural but they have a connection with the home land. But d.c is so dead. On top of that all you do is work and that's about it.
moving from one place of kufr to another, great
@@farleymarly2575 lol I'm from this area and yeah the Maryland community is thriving. Most of you Brits come here for money anyway so go back...
@@farleymarly2575 home land 😆
Such an easy interview lol. No mention about his blunders including saying to sisters regarding husbands wealth "my money is mine, his my husband's money is mine as well". Smh
Did he is said this?😮
Not to mention his insults on the prophet pbuh.
@@thepathofguidance5684elaborate
@@thepathofguidance5684which one?
Stop spreading hate.
Maybe you don't know what is Advised by Allah about Exposing and judging others on Their Sins. You are no one to Call him Anything based on his Sins.
Would love his thoughts about the Australian Muslim experience. He has been here a few times.
I havent been to Australia but Iam in the UK but the Australian talker Mohammad Hoblos was talking about the Muslim gangsters in Australia
even some the sisters nowadays they want an ex bad boy they say oh he got some tattoos but now he is repented mashallah and when the ex bad boy leaves her and goes back to his past she spends her nights crying
subhanallah some of the brothers there with egos the size of mountains
Glad to see Ustad on the pod 💯
Ustaad❤
Brother Nouman Ali Khan inspired me to start with the morning azkar and evening azkar for the time. Before that i didn't even knew about morning and evening azkar. My love for Quran also increased because of him. May Allah swt reward him and protect him from the evil eye and the evils in the form of humans. Ameen.
Excellent.
assalammualaikum sir, glad to se you here..❤😁
Absolutely brilliant and beautiful!
Usthad Nouman Ali Khan is without a doubt is an آية الله without a shadow of doubt
Didnt get the chance to meet him at thr GPU event. The event was so missorganised with lectures either cancelled or location changed.
السلام عليكم و رحمة الله و بركاته
اخوان
Yes always start from Al Baqarah, it's easier to learn, trust me, insyaa Allah
The man, The myth, The legend ❤
❤ you. Can you listen to me?
Is your health okay sir?
May Allah grant you amazing health, and to your child.
I wish I could see them happily play 🏀 basketball. Ameen
Jzk for this. Quick comment though, nak usually gives linguistic definition, figuritive,etc
But what about the verses that Rasulullah s and sahaba r endorsed, established, implemented- such as treaties, hudood, etc etc
Quran cant be seperate from the ahadith, fiqh, usool, seerah, etc
They all go hand in hand.
Thats when we get to appreciate living islam rather then just theoretical appreciations. I'm definately sure that quran has given a law or system to be implemented to protect falistin,rohingya, uighuyr, kashmir,shaam, khurasan, etc
Allah swt give this noble ummah to implement and establish every hukum of Allah and Rasulullah s.
Allahumma ameen thumma ameen ya rabbil alameen
The reason it doesn't suffer chinise whispers is because of the redundant databases, i.e. many hafiz/memorizers.
Bless you son
I’m surprised Dilly didn’t bring up the scandal - he was allowed to integrate without any repercussions.
Did he really said there is no naskh and mansukh in the quran? No abrogation in the quran? So wine is allowed now?
No verse in the Quran tells us to drink wine
@@younesalkhaddari69before wine was not prohibited
Agree usa is much better for muslims than anywhere in world ... i was surprosed when i moved here..
Forget 3D become 5D! Greater depth, greater understanding
43:39 basically, it was bitcoin before bitcoin…decentralization
I Dore and Appreciated The Sincere Teachings of Ustadh Nouman Ali Khan...However I Disagree Many Of His Views...May ALLAH Almighty Guide Us All To The Solid Teuth and Realities🤲🏽❤️
A true Gem 💎 .
No thoughts about palestine?
But the solidarity of all our people here in the UK Muslim and non Muslim black white brown and in between it gives us heart even in this terror and one of the biggest things for me its the Palestinians that are teaching us our religion they got faith even amogst all this brutality they call on Allah alone because who else have they got left the Muslim leaders are asleep
Bro i thought he introduced himself as Diddy Hussain
Bring shrill adeem and nouman together
I don't think a lot of British Muslims realize that white British culture and white American culture are very different. Generally speaking, white Americans are very curious and open minded. Of course there is racism everywhere and incidents do happen. But brother NAK is right in that America is actually a pretty amazing country. It's a really weird paradox that American foreign policy is the exact opposite of how minorities experience life within America.
inch Allah they may change the course of the future with Allah permission next Nov election by breaking the 2 party system that will transform the country
Legend
One important Qur'anic resource: Project lIIumine Tafsir.
Nouman is the GOAT
Astagfirullah! Allahu akbar. No mortal is the greatest of all time.
Very good chat
Not sure I agree with his take on Muslims in the UK having a harder time than Muslims in the US and I don't think the Muslims in the US are 30 years ahead. The dynamics in each country are different. But the Muslims in the US have felt marginalised, especially after Trump's comments regarding stopping Muslim immigration. No politician in the UK has ever made such a direct comment about Muslim immigration. The Muslims in the US also have a very heavy weight on their conscience regarding the US's unwavering support for Israel and the Billions of dollars it gives Israel in military aid and hardware, making the US complicit in the ongoing genocide in Gaza. As well as the US's role in the so called, 'War on Terror' and the destruction of Iraq, Afghanistan and Syria. And what about the US's disgusting and inhumane treatment of Muslim prisoners in Guantanamo, which is still ongoing. So American Muslims have all this to grapple with. Have American Muslims done enough to speak up against their country's foreign policy? Frankly, I don't think they have. If I were Dilly, I would have put these questions to Nouman.
and you believe UK is better
I think you forget how the so called war on terror impacted the Uk from the anti terror laws to the Prevent program and so on - the past year all the Zionist assets were activated in the UK parliament and started uttering racist things I would have never imagined. So in a way he is right and for Trump a good chunk of the people admit he is a fool and no one take him seriously. But I found the rhetoric of the like of Farage and the Conservative party much more dangerous.
Dilly bayta be aware of him some time he talks like a totally liberal
❤
Needed two hours minimum.
❤❤❤
My honey brother if you have subtitles with your video
Please invite saahil adeem sir again
I am quite disappointed with 5pillars on this. I've been a long time subscriber and recently signed up to regularly support the organisation. I was expecting Dilly with this ethics to question NAK on his past behaviour with women and clear up the controversy. Instead this was like a promotion for NAK.