Beyoncé’s technique is just... whew it’s almost like she’s got a piano in her throat and she has fun taping on the notes. This agility + stamina ?? How does she do it seriously ? Vocal teachers are still in awe listening to her
What’s even more impressive about Beyoncè’s voice is that in some of those clips there are dance routines too...so not only is she hitting those notes...but she’s also supposed to be out of breath but isn’t. What a legend.
Dee Man Blah blah...im a fan of jhud too but besides her power she is not in the same lane; sometimes we need to be real and stop being in our feelings 🙄
Jen is great, don't get me wrong, she can definitely sing but Beyonce is a vocal technician she's SO insanely talented. There are very very few contemporary vocalists that can do what Beyonce does with her voice.
If you mean by all the runs she does then yeah! I dont need to denigrate one because I prefer the other! I'm biased because I'm from Chicago. JHud has come into her own! From Broadway to the Respect film the ladies is on a roll.
@@gesk Exactly and in my opinion this video to me seems very one sided because she used Jennifer Hudson performance from way back I wish she would've used updated performances not when Jennifer Hudson was still learning how to use the right key to her voice in my opinion. To me Jennifer Hudson is the better singer because she sings and never over do it with the riffs and runs. I can't stand when Beyonce sings with all the riffs and runs because it's not necessary at all.
@@sweetreny1155 Lol in this Vid Her runs isn't overdo it actually compliments the vocal delivery and in this vid it's not about Beyonce riffs and runs it's just that she's more technical vocalist than Jhud. If you're going to check every Vocal coaches reaction about Beyonce vs Jhud y'all can have the same result. Beyonce is a better vocalist.
To be honest looking at the quality of the clips used and duration I feel this vocal battle was biased towards Beyonce, did not feel they were very good Jennifer Hudson selections.
@@darkcadence938 Lol and? An amazing technique will always speak for itself, and hers is flawless. Her not being to belt a certain note doesn't take away from that, and that goes for anybody obviously. Are we gonna call Cher a bad vocalist because of her limited range too? 😂
These clips are from very early in Jennifer Hudson's professional career. Notice they are almost all from the Dream girls era. Whereas, by the time Beyonce reached these clips she had already been a world wide mega star for over a decade. Further, it was clear this TH-camr just prefers Beyonce's vocal styling. Beyonce and Jennifer are just different singers.
Jennifer Hudson is honestly really underrated. People make her out to be someone who screams instead of actually singing. Her voice is amazing and she killed it in dream girls!
I'm not a huge Beyonce fan, however, Jen oversings, and then fails. Beyoncé knows how to use her techniques just right. You can tell she's a perfectionist.
@Shakur Wright the clips used for beyonce are even from 2003, so i dont know why u mean by "current" but i see you copying and pasting the same comment over and over so youre clearly pressed 😂 None of these two ladies know you and theyre pretty amazing in their respective fields, dont take it too personal
Last year Jennifer came to Columbia University to sing amazing grace and omg you could hear her voice from all the way from outside . Her range and power are crazy amazing wow
The biggest Jennifer's issue is the need to prove herself all the time. On the other hand, Beyoncé seems to be more confident to 'play' with her voice and she acknowledges that.
To be fair, Beyonce can fall off the stage and her fans still love her. Jen has a tough crowd to please and it's hard for powerhouse vocalists like that, because people just expect more and more. Beyonce relies on her technique but because of Jen's environment, she relies on her pure power (and she has more power than Bey, lets not lie to ourselves).
@@minnietheestorm9298 and she has more power than Bey, lets not lie to ourselves. Disagree when they did that dreamgirls medley and beyonce hopped on stage and transitioned out from jennifers voice on the same note the difference was ridiculous. Jen has a naturally deeper darker voice which can give the impression of extra power compared to beyonce being a mezzo soprano and having a light kinda feathery but strong tone but on that note jen seemed like she was reaching down to the depths of her sole to try and belt that note while bey had a casual smile on her face and did a little flexible run on it to on the way out the door.
It's funny how in Dream Girls, Beyonce's character was made out to be an inferior singer to Jennifer's, just because Beyonce was physically prettier, whereas Jennifer had the larger voice that could belt higher. People seem to still assume that just because you have the looks, you must not be as talented. BS.
Lissandra Freljord ok but deena is meant to have a weaker voice, they casted the role poorly, they were even gonna cast whitney before they got beyonce. either way, beyonce was way too talented to play deena
@@lordvoldemort5725 they very much are. In the movie Bey had to purposely dim her voice down to emulate Diana Ross. In the live performance for the movie at an awards show, you can see how Bey's E5 completely drowned out Jhud's F5. That's power and resonance there
Bey unmatched technic, controlled power, versatile register ... flawless performances ... unbeatable and incomparable 🙌 plus all the work she puts on her talent, she just keeps improving. unproblematic legend 🙌
Beyoncé is on a whole different level technically. To this day I still remember when Beyonce came on stage with Hudson on the Oscars and the both belted the same F5 note, Beyonce completely drowned Hudson!
JHud was louder but Beyoncé’s technique pushed through and legit drowned her out, when you have good technique you can add as much volume with little strain
King Bey she definitely brought her A game that night. My theory is she needed to remind the world that she was a world class singer because everyone was so into JHUD’s big number. I’m not a fan of listen by Beyoncé but the night at the Oscars is the best I’ve heard it from her. She intimated the hell out of JHUD.
Jennifer Hudson can sing and there is clearly no doubt about it. Admittedly I’m not an avid follower of hers however, based on what I have seen it’s not for me. I’m not a singer, so I don’t know about techniques & ability but, as a listener, her voice is too loud, has too much vibrato or is too growly at times. I’m no more a fan of Beyoncé than I am of Jennifer Hudson, but Beyoncé’s voice just seems more melodic. By that, I mean her voice seems to float effortlessly from one note to the next. Combine this with the fact she can dance, is reported to be a nice person and is absolutely stunning, I can see why she gets called Queen Bey! Anyway, regardless of my opinion I’m actually jealous of them both...at least they can actually hold a tune, unlike myself!!
In Jennifer’s defense these are some of the worst clips to choose from when she has many amazing vocal moments. It’s funny when people make these videos with their biased opinion in the forefront of their minds!
I hope this video is from recent times; Jennifer has improved massively over the past few years i.e. A Change Is Gonna Come, For All We Know, Ain't No Way, etc.
Those clips are definitely not from recent time, as you said Jhud's vocals have grown so much she is one of the best vocalist in today's music. No wonder why Aretha Franklin chose her to portray her
Beyoncé is a mezzo soprano. Jennifer Hudson is a soprano, so they are naturally going to sound a lot different in comparisons on the same notes. Jen’s notes 📝 won’t sound as good in the low register and Beyoncé will sound better in the lows just naturally because of their voice types...same in high but the opposite...Surprised she didn’t mention voice type in this video?
I agree Jen is a soprano and Beyoncé is a mezzo but thay hardly has anything to do with how good they will sound on a note. Quality of sound and range is not tied to a voice type. It is affected waaaaaaaaaaaay more by the technique of the singer. Beyoncé sounded better pretty much on every note because she has a more well rounded and developed technique, she is clearly extremely trained.
Beyonce is better in low and high notes what are you talking about. You must not know beyonce the Technical goddess! Only Mariah carrey rivals Bey in technicality. She puts Sopranos to shame in the higher notes, that's how good beyonce is
@@kennetht7490 it might be “belting” but that is the only strong part of her voice. Beyoncé’s technique in songs like Otherside, Love on top and I care OBLITERATE jhud. it’s just the truth
There were old clips from Bey too...Jhud doesn’t have the versatility or control to be matched with bey tbh and I like jhud. Jhud is too dependent on belting and vibrato but if thats what she has in her bag then we cant be mad at her for using it.
Im a HUGE fan of Jennifer Hudson and i think the video is kind of outdated for Jennifer... her technique REALLY improved since the time this video has been uploaded! You should react to another vocal battle for Jennifer!
@@samueltremblaay Jennifer is literally 8 DAYS younger than Beyoncé. Reaching a "vocal prime" has everything to do with age and training... since they are both 38 years of age, their primes would peak around the same time. Jennifer Hudson just isn't in the same league.
I just LOVE these vocal battle videos!! Jhud and Beyonce are both so amazing! Beyonce has the effortless agility, dynamic control, and clearer tone. And Jhud has that unbelievable vocal power and stamina that will knock you off your seat. Their vocal talent is insane! :)
BOTHS ARE EXTREMELY TALENTED AND ONE OF THE BESTEST OF ALL TIME BUT I THINK BEYONCE TECHNIQUE IS BIT BITTER THAN JENNIFER BTW LOVE JENNIFER HIGH NOTES THOO.😍😍
That compilation seemed a little unfair because the Beyonce clips were way longer than Jen's and they used the same performances over and over for Jen. Both are great vocalists though.
@@averyjenkins2786Beyonce’s resonance has drowned out Jen’s power. Beyonce also has better technique, better vocal dynamics, better vibrato, better musicality, better pitch, much more versatile as well.
Jhud and Bey have the same range. Bey has agility and control matched with a smooth pop-friendly sound, while Jhud has power, emotion and rawness. Jhud's voice is a lot more gospel which is a more stylized type of singing - the strong vibrato and glottal attack critized in the video is simply something gospel singers preferably use as artistic choice. Bey is more harmonic and smooth - so more pop/r'n'b according to her girl group background. The two are simply very different styles of singing.
Beyoncé technique its just perfect. Yes she makes mistakes sometimes who doesn’t. But whoever says she overrated clearly have no idea about vocal technique
@@isiscollinssingingandbeaut3485 and this is a fact how there are other singers than Beyoncé that also have great technique so how is this person the best at that. if she could match Beyoncé why isn’t she where Beyoncé is at
I'm not denying Jennifer's talent but she does very little for me. While her tone isn't particularly pleasant (or unique among gospel singers), I don't "feel" her singing. She's an unbelievably skilled singer but a rather bland artist
it's because she has a *gospel* tone. When you have a *gospel* tone it's hard sometimes to crossover. A lot of *gospel* music are *ballads* and that's not always good in the field of *pop* music. She's trying to become more *theatrical* to give her voice a *different texture* and for me it's working. She even hit a *whistle* this year.
I’m sorry but when head voices came up we all knew Jen lost the only head voice that you can compare to Beyoncé is Whitney’s they have the best head voices in the game
CLEAR. Because While I do think Bey is the overall better technician, Jhud can reach heights of depth and power that Bey's does not, and Jhud practically lives in sustained G5 belt land.
I know, her singing often sounds like shouting to me. If she could learn control the power, she'd be great. I'd like hear her try sing softly sometimes, get those dynamics in their. Not sure she can.
I've seen a lit of debate over this. And people always say Jhud is better becasue she belts and sings loudly😑I love Jhud and she is an amazing singer no doubt. But not compared to Beyonce. Beyonce can sing while dacing and still sound amazingly, she growls, she can hit high and low notes effortlessly and uses her voice like an instrument. She has more techniques than Jhud🤷♂️It's not me being a fan, it's just facts and you can't argue with facts And I don't like the videos you used of them singing. There are so much better ones of them😕why'd you chose these. They are both phenomenal singers and Jennifer can DEFINITELY SANG! These clips didn't fully showcase that
In my opinion, these videos also test how consistent an artist is. If one thinks that clips are biased to another artist, that artist is the better singer.
Jen has amazing power but sometimes she over does it to me.. Beyoncé all the way around to me is a more skilled and flexible singer with her vocal agility and range.
Beyoncé is my idol and she is definitely my favorite singer of all time ❤️ I'm a huge fan of her, I have been a fan of Beyoncé from the beginning, when she was with Destiny's Child and I still am, of course. I saw her in concert 6 times and I know I'm extremely lucky for that, It was easily the best moments of my life part I'll never forget that. Her vocal performances in live was purely incredible, Queen B is clearly the best singer, the best artist, she's the best performer and she has the best vocal technique of all. Now, I cannot wait to see this Battle but Beyoncé is obviously the BEST, she is the greatest singer. Hudson is ok but she is absolutely not at Beyoncé level, she is nothing compared to her, sorry for her fans but Jen Hudson has already lost against Queen B Lol... Beyoncé is the best of the two at every level, she is the most talented , she's the best vocalist, she has the most beautiful and most powerfull voice, she is 100 times better than her and she is the best at every level !Beyoncé is the one and only Queen, she won this battle, that's all.
This sounds like the *stan* that may have made this video. Delusional and all. Bey can't sing everything and as a performer she does not *always* sing live. You let them *trick* you if you want. Don't forget she *lipped* the National Anthem, remember? There was NO performance necessary and she still lipped it. Anyways, you sound *consumed* and *very biased* in your comment but that's usually how stans are.
I feel like most videos done are bias. The competitor is on for a three second clip while the person they clearly like better is on longer. They seem to use videos when the person first started their career like Jennifer Hudson on like American idol versus a fully recognize Beyoncé’s after destiny’s child. No question Beyoncé is super amazing and Jennifer Hudson is in her own right as well. However Jennifer Hudson seems to have a more husky voice and it’s completely different than Beyoncé’s. However there’s a reason why Aretha Franklin chose Jennifer Hudson to play her. I’m not particularly a Jennifer Hudson fan. I mean I like her but I find Beyoncé’s voice more beautiful.
It might help if they did some J Hud from the last 20 years, her game has picked up tremendously. The growth seems to be mostly confidence, maybe getting hand picked by Aretha has set her free.
Zeek Street Beyoncè can suppot up to an belted F#5 goes down to G#2. Perfect technique, excellent melisma user and equipped with an operatic delevoped head-voice. SceamHudson can‘t relate
They r winning in their own rights.... its more like a preference like U SAID. Jhud is more on belting while beyonce is more on agility n vocal versatility. Yes Beyonce wins in this video.
Let’s make an extra note than most of Bey’s examples here we’re at 2hr shows while JHUD was just singing one song. Not that the clarification is needed but it adds to her magnificence. There’s not other like her, period.
They are fundamentally different types of singers. Jennifer is a ballade girl; big, brassy, power, are the operative word. Beyoncé is more subtle, possibly because she has to be being that she doesn’t have Jennifer’s raw power. I love them both but I think Beyoncé is the more versatile singer. I think that’s why her career is continuing in such an upward trajectory. People are fickle, and artists have to evolve. Unfortunately, the type of stuff that Jennifer did that isn’t ballades is just kind of weak. It’s the quality of her voice, she can’t really do anything about it, and the fans can only listen to so many ballads.
The ear tends to lean towards Beyonce because her voice is "cleaner". Note by note, Beyonce will usually win because she is more accurate and clear. Jennifer totally relies on that "churchy" sound and you'll just rarely hear her sing with an open throat. She will clench every bit of air out of a tight space to hit the notes rather than relax to it and pull more from the lungs, but that's her style. Jennifer's voice is about the context.
am actually a fan of both of'em but it was an unfair battle cuz they literally show the clip of JEN only with the note that is mentioned but with BE they show in her clips more runs so i think it sounds more catchy
Beyonce has a classical trained voice with amazing technique and range and she can do alot with her voice. As for Jen it's only so much she can do with her voice.
Love your videos. I like watching them to see how I can improve my singing so when I perform I can have the best techniques. Sending love from North Carolina.❤️🎼
![SAFEPLANET - ดาวเคราะห์ [ THE PLANET ]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/4X1XL3I_k3c/mqdefault.jpg)
Beyoncé’s technique is just... whew it’s almost like she’s got a piano in her throat and she has fun taping on the notes. This agility + stamina ?? How does she do it seriously ? Vocal teachers are still in awe listening to her
What’s even more impressive about Beyoncè’s voice is that in some of those clips there are dance routines too...so not only is she hitting those notes...but she’s also supposed to be out of breath but isn’t. What a legend.
They picked bad videos of Jhud. Notice the obvious spin...you people are so gullible.
Dee Man Blah blah...im a fan of jhud too but besides her power she is not in the same lane; sometimes we need to be real and stop being in our feelings 🙄
@@Wordalways oh god stfu! You’re delusional
Bcs they’re not live. They’re lip synced.
@@Badgalriri2.0 Lmaoo just let them be delusional...
As soon as I saw her about to compare “head voices” I knew it was over for J-HUD lol.
Lol same, I don't see many within mainstream competing with Beys head voice.
Xtina can
Khee Sian that's falsetto that Xtina mainly uses. Xtina's tone up there is one of the prettiest but in terms of HEAD VOICE, Bey has it in the bag.
@@kheesianteng2993 go watch the Xtina vs Perrie video because I-
@@kheesianteng2993 She can do only in falsetto. Her head voice is not strong enough to compete with Beyonce.
Jen is great, don't get me wrong, she can definitely sing but Beyonce is a vocal technician she's SO insanely talented. There are very very few contemporary vocalists that can do what Beyonce does with her voice.
If you mean by all the runs she does then yeah! I dont need to denigrate one because I prefer the other! I'm biased because I'm from Chicago. JHud has come into her own! From Broadway to the Respect film the ladies is on a roll.
@@gesk Exactly and in my opinion this video to me seems very one sided because she used Jennifer Hudson performance from way back I wish she would've used updated performances not when Jennifer Hudson was still learning how to use the right key to her voice in my opinion. To me Jennifer Hudson is the better singer because she sings and never over do it with the riffs and runs. I can't stand when Beyonce sings with all the riffs and runs because it's not necessary at all.
@@sweetreny1155 Lol in this Vid Her runs isn't overdo it actually compliments the vocal delivery and in this vid it's not about Beyonce riffs and runs it's just that she's more technical vocalist than Jhud. If you're going to check every Vocal coaches reaction about Beyonce vs Jhud y'all can have the same result. Beyonce is a better vocalist.
To be honest looking at the quality of the clips used and duration I feel this vocal battle was biased towards Beyonce, did not feel they were very good Jennifer Hudson selections.
exactly lol
I agree. Jennifer is phenomenal.
Even if you picked the best clips from Jennifer, she still wouldn’t beat Beyoncé lmao
10000% agree!
Thank you! I even prefer Bey myself but I know Jen has amazing moments that were definitely avoided in whoever made the video!
Beyoncé is a star rated vocalist, with the complete vocal package.
Yet she can't sustain no belt notes above g5
What the vocal package
@@roostaworld1325 great vocal, great performance, great stage, great sale, great achievement and carreer i think
@@darkcadence938 Lol and? An amazing technique will always speak for itself, and hers is flawless. Her not being to belt a certain note doesn't take away from that, and that goes for anybody obviously. Are we gonna call Cher a bad vocalist because of her limited range too? 😂
No lies told
Beyonce for me, her tone is just more pleasant on the ears.
I agree.
Tone is completely subjective....But Beyonce still wins on technique and control
Disgusting
@@gamarrathvalentino4027 what’s disgusting?
The thing is, Jennifer Hudsons voice has changed a lot as she got older, she got way better. These clips are of when she was still young.
So were beyonce's
Mmm actually lots of these Beyoncé clips are from 2013 and before, and they’re only a year apart in age. So it’s not too big of an discrepancy.
true but Beyoncé still reigns supreme
These clips are from very early in Jennifer Hudson's professional career. Notice they are almost all from the Dream girls era.
Whereas, by the time Beyonce reached these clips she had already been a world wide mega star for over a decade.
Further, it was clear this TH-camr just prefers Beyonce's vocal styling. Beyonce and Jennifer are just different singers.
@@greenguy369 bey was better back then too lol
Jennifer Hudson is honestly really underrated. People make her out to be someone who screams instead of actually singing. Her voice is amazing and she killed it in dream girls!
Also in Cats- she was amazing! I love Jennifer!
But she did screams lol
She definitely screams alot
She sings better these days, she used to scream though (she was bringing church style in pop music).
I'm not a huge Beyonce fan, however, Jen oversings, and then fails. Beyoncé knows how to use her techniques just right. You can tell she's a perfectionist.
Shakur Wright fact
@Shakur Wright the clips used for beyonce are even from 2003, so i dont know why u mean by "current" but i see you copying and pasting the same comment over and over so youre clearly pressed 😂
None of these two ladies know you and theyre pretty amazing in their respective fields, dont take it too personal
distorted lmaoooooooo imagine thinking jhud oversings more than bey and claiming you’re not in the beyhive
Not a huge beyawnce fan huh? 😒...
@@atolm1 🙄She dosent have to be a huge fan to pick her. Don't get triggered
Last year Jennifer came to Columbia University to sing amazing grace and omg you could hear her voice from all the way from outside . Her range and power are crazy amazing wow
You dont know what you talking about Jenis the best all time
The biggest Jennifer's issue is the need to prove herself all the time. On the other hand, Beyoncé seems to be more confident to 'play' with her voice and she acknowledges that.
Jhud suffers from the Effie White syndrome.
Shakur Wright it could be current and Jennifer would still lose. These weren’t even Beyoncé’s best clips lol
Shakur Wright if that were true they would’ve put if I were I boy from the Grammys in 2011 for Bey
To be fair, Beyonce can fall off the stage and her fans still love her. Jen has a tough crowd to please and it's hard for powerhouse vocalists like that, because people just expect more and more. Beyonce relies on her technique but because of Jen's environment, she relies on her pure power (and she has more power than Bey, lets not lie to ourselves).
@@minnietheestorm9298 and she has more power than Bey, lets not lie to ourselves. Disagree when they did that dreamgirls medley and beyonce hopped on stage and transitioned out from jennifers voice on the same note the difference was ridiculous. Jen has a naturally deeper darker voice which can give the impression of extra power compared to beyonce being a mezzo soprano and having a light kinda feathery but strong tone but on that note jen seemed like she was reaching down to the depths of her sole to try and belt that note while bey had a casual smile on her face and did a little flexible run on it to on the way out the door.
Bey is one of the best singers of all time! Her hv lows runs belts are just much better then jhud( i really like both of them)
Saggi Abitbol her belts are not better than Jennifer..
It's funny how in Dream Girls, Beyonce's character was made out to be an inferior singer to Jennifer's, just because Beyonce was physically prettier, whereas Jennifer had the larger voice that could belt higher. People seem to still assume that just because you have the looks, you must not be as talented. BS.
Lissandra Freljord ok but deena is meant to have a weaker voice, they casted the role poorly, they were even gonna cast whitney before they got beyonce. either way, beyonce was way too talented to play deena
@@will4698 I think you're just jealous of beyonce's looks and using it as an excuse to discredit het
@@lordvoldemort5725 they very much are. In the movie Bey had to purposely dim her voice down to emulate Diana Ross. In the live performance for the movie at an awards show, you can see how Bey's E5 completely drowned out Jhud's F5. That's power and resonance there
Lmao it's clear that Beyoncè has better technique
And more train
ondy andra andra girl tf is a train
@ondy andra andra omg yassss she so rich she bought 100 trains 😌😍👏👏💅💅💖💖
@@Ariana-nw2oh Lmao
Bey unmatched technic, controlled power, versatile register ... flawless performances ... unbeatable and incomparable 🙌 plus all the work she puts on her talent, she just keeps improving. unproblematic legend 🙌
Jen's clips don't really show her amazing vocal range, they were even shorter than Bey's
Thank you
Beyoncé is on a whole different level technically. To this day I still remember when Beyonce came on stage with Hudson on the Oscars and the both belted the same F5 note, Beyonce completely drowned Hudson!
JHud was louder but Beyoncé’s technique pushed through and legit drowned her out, when you have good technique you can add as much volume with little strain
qa3bool no she didn’t that’s impossible seeing as Jennifer’s voice is naturally bigger stop lying
@@loganl7725 having a naturally big voice does not necessarily mean having full control over it. Big voices are hard to control.
King Bey she definitely brought her A game that night. My theory is she needed to remind the world that she was a world class singer because everyone was so into JHUD’s big number. I’m not a fan of listen by Beyoncé but the night at the Oscars is the best I’ve heard it from her. She intimated the hell out of JHUD.
This had more to do with the mic level lol. Beyonce was totally overshadowed during that perf by both JHud and Anika Noni Rose.
Jennifer Hudson can sing and there is clearly no doubt about it. Admittedly I’m not an avid follower of hers however, based on what I have seen it’s not for me.
I’m not a singer, so I don’t know about techniques & ability but, as a listener, her voice is too loud, has too much vibrato or is too growly at times.
I’m no more a fan of Beyoncé than I am of Jennifer Hudson, but Beyoncé’s voice just seems more melodic. By that, I mean her voice seems to float effortlessly from one note to the next. Combine this with the fact she can dance, is reported to be a nice person and is absolutely stunning, I can see why she gets called Queen Bey!
Anyway, regardless of my opinion I’m actually jealous of them both...at least they can actually hold a tune, unlike myself!!
You should listen to Jennifer *now* she's a whole different machine.
Zeek Street 😂😂😂
@@ZeekStreet true!
@@ZeekStreet True
In Jennifer’s defense these are some of the worst clips to choose from when she has many amazing vocal moments. It’s funny when people make these videos with their biased opinion in the forefront of their minds!
Honestly, I think these two singers are world apart in their way of singing. For me, these two cannot compare
I hope this video is from recent times; Jennifer has improved massively over the past few years i.e. A Change Is Gonna Come, For All We Know, Ain't No Way, etc.
Those clips are definitely not from recent time, as you said Jhud's vocals have grown so much she is one of the best vocalist in today's music. No wonder why Aretha Franklin chose her to portray her
Thank you 🙌🏾🙌🏾
Jen still doesnt have the octave to go against beyonce. It's a lose-lose situation for her
Russel Stephan you know that’s a lie...
JHud’s Ain’t no way performance changed things, she went next level!
Beyoncé is a mezzo soprano. Jennifer Hudson is a soprano, so they are naturally going to sound a lot different in comparisons on the same notes. Jen’s notes 📝 won’t sound as good in the low register and Beyoncé will sound better in the lows just naturally because of their voice types...same in high but the opposite...Surprised she didn’t mention voice type in this video?
Beyonce seemed to perform better in both low notes and high notes
I agree Jen is a soprano and Beyoncé is a mezzo but thay hardly has anything to do with how good they will sound on a note.
Quality of sound and range is not tied to a voice type. It is affected waaaaaaaaaaaay more by the technique of the singer.
Beyoncé sounded better pretty much on every note because she has a more well rounded and developed technique, she is clearly extremely trained.
but beyoncé did better in both high and low notes
Beyonce is better in low and high notes what are you talking about. You must not know beyonce the Technical goddess! Only Mariah carrey rivals Bey in technicality. She puts Sopranos to shame in the higher notes, that's how good beyonce is
Russel Stephan the reason Beyonce is well in both is simple, her technique is better and she mastered her voice.
Most of these Jennifer clips are old. She has brushed up on her technique a lot. She is also singing if the same song in most clips.
There are clips for Bey from 2003 lmfao Screamfer Hud is not on her level
W V it’s called belting but ok...
@@kennetht7490 it might be “belting” but that is the only strong part of her voice. Beyoncé’s technique in songs like Otherside, Love on top and I care OBLITERATE jhud. it’s just the truth
There were old clips from
Bey too...Jhud doesn’t have the versatility or control to be matched with bey tbh and I like jhud. Jhud is too dependent on belting and vibrato but if thats what she has in her bag then we cant be mad at her for using it.
Jennifer is a Soprano. Not a Mezzo. Beyonce is a Mezzo, however lighter tone. Jennifer voice shines in the F5 - Bb5 area. She's a high soprano.
Im a HUGE fan of Jennifer Hudson and i think the video is kind of outdated for Jennifer... her technique REALLY improved since the time this video has been uploaded! You should react to another vocal battle for Jennifer!
The clips of Beyoncé are also dated so I’d say it’s fair
Jenifer is no where near beyonce vocally. Hahah🤣🙆♀️
Jaz Room yeah, but Beyonce was in her prime while Jennifer is now in her prime and the clips show her debut where her technique was poor.
@@samueltremblaay I mean they use beyonce clips from even 2003, and she was still winning. Some of the clips of beyonce are more than 10 yrs old
@@samueltremblaay Jennifer is literally 8 DAYS younger than Beyoncé. Reaching a "vocal prime" has everything to do with age and training... since they are both 38 years of age, their primes would peak around the same time. Jennifer Hudson just isn't in the same league.
I just LOVE these vocal battle videos!! Jhud and Beyonce are both so amazing! Beyonce has the effortless agility, dynamic control, and clearer tone. And Jhud has that unbelievable vocal power and stamina that will knock you off your seat. Their vocal talent is insane! :)
Jennifer ofter screams too much for my opinion 🤔
Beyonce is perfection!
It’s called high notes not screaming
@@flipperbigg8943 Nah she over screams sometimes
Flipper BIG G it‘s called screaming and shooting
She is belting not screaming. But she has a issue where her belts thin out inconsistently, especially above e5
SJ it’s also called belting..
I love them both but let’s be honest. Bey’s a better singer technically and all as well.
I agree, but also the clips they chose for Jen were not even close to her best lmao.
@@whitneyhoustonstan2472
but these weren’t Beyoncé’s best either.
BOTHS ARE EXTREMELY TALENTED AND ONE OF THE BESTEST OF ALL TIME BUT I THINK BEYONCE TECHNIQUE IS BIT BITTER THAN JENNIFER BTW LOVE JENNIFER HIGH NOTES THOO.😍😍
Before the video, Beyoncé better win.
Edit: honestly Jennifer has a more powerful voice type but she isn’t vocally comparable to Beyoncé.
agree. i think about that, jen have very high quality in her voice. but beyonce voice quality is more than anything. she had amazing technic.
That compilation seemed a little unfair because the Beyonce clips were way longer than Jen's and they used the same performances over and over for Jen. Both are great vocalists though.
Beyoncé has breath control and agility but Jen has power and range they both are equally good love queens
Beyoncé has range as well💪
Beyoncé has range too. What Bey lacks in Power she has agility and what Jhud lacks in Agility she has in power
@@averyjenkins2786Beyonce’s resonance has drowned out Jen’s power. Beyonce also has better technique, better vocal dynamics, better vibrato, better musicality, better pitch, much more versatile as well.
Jhud and Bey have the same range. Bey has agility and control matched with a smooth pop-friendly sound, while Jhud has power, emotion and rawness. Jhud's voice is a lot more gospel which is a more stylized type of singing - the strong vibrato and glottal attack critized in the video is simply something gospel singers preferably use as artistic choice. Bey is more harmonic and smooth - so more pop/r'n'b according to her girl group background. The two are simply very different styles of singing.
@@averyjenkins2786bey has power too
How can you say on the first note that Jennifer super quick soft airy note was better than Beyonce's resonant and more powerful one?
Jennifer was good... for a warming up
And can we talk about that run on beyonce ? 😍@8:00
Brilliant! I’m glad your finally realising that Bey is the real deal!!!
Just because you *think* so doesn't mean it's always true
It’s a fact Zeek
Yass me too ! Finally
Jennifer crushes beyonce vocally and blows her out of her ivy park so I dont know what you talking about she is the real deal . 🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@kemariemaragh-campbell6721 you honestly don’t have a clue what your talking about if you think that’s the case
Queen B ✨✨
Why are Jen's clips shorter ...i mean before i know it its already Queen Bee hitting those notes
Beyoncé technique its just perfect. Yes she makes mistakes sometimes who doesn’t. But whoever says she overrated clearly have no idea about vocal technique
A love these vocal battles. It's technical and at the same time respectful.
Have you looked at recent jenn performances? Changed quite a bit.
Jennifer Hudson’s voice is incredibly powerful, but Bey is as well, as well as incredible agility, precision, and technique. Love em both.
B is the best of course
Beyoncé's resonance is unmatched!
If by resonance you mean use of artificial reverberation usually reserved to karaoke singers, then yes.
Technically Soyhang has the best technique ever. She can match Beyoncé
@@isiscollinssingingandbeaut3485 lies
@@isiscollinssingingandbeaut3485 and this is a fact how there are other singers than Beyoncé that also have great technique so how is this person the best at that. if she could match Beyoncé why isn’t she where Beyoncé is at
@@theoneandonly2503 even without reverb her resonance is astounding. She just uses it as an artistic tool.
Beyonce’s head voice 😭😭😭
I'm not denying Jennifer's talent but she does very little for me. While her tone isn't particularly pleasant (or unique among gospel singers), I don't "feel" her singing. She's an unbelievably skilled singer but a rather bland artist
it's because she has a *gospel* tone. When you have a *gospel* tone it's hard sometimes to crossover. A lot of *gospel* music are *ballads* and that's not always good in the field of *pop* music. She's trying to become more *theatrical* to give her voice a *different texture* and for me it's working. She even hit a *whistle* this year.
Charles what is not pleasant about her tone.
@@joelprince4170 It lacks texture, dynamics and to be frank it is not particularly pretty. Just my opinion though
Her tone is so unpleasant sksksks even when she’s singing softly 🤢
Beyoncé is technically a better singer and one of the best of the industry ✨
The best currently
Underrated
The Best*
Russel Stephan I feel like Ariana in Beyoncé running the industry right now but the voice would always be Whitney Mariah in Celine
Yes bey is so underrated vocally
beyoncé all the way
I’m sorry but when head voices came up we all knew Jen lost the only head voice that you can compare to Beyoncé is Whitney’s they have the best head voices in the game
It comes down to versatility, control and technique. Bey has all of that, Jennifer does not.
Ugh, I need updated videos from Jennifer Hudson in these videos
6:50 Jennifer has countless G5s sustained with vibrato. Whoever made the video had a clear bias
CLEAR. Because While I do think Bey is the overall better technician, Jhud can reach heights of depth and power that Bey's does not, and Jhud practically lives in sustained G5 belt land.
The quality is just better on Beyonce, LoL.
Queen B hands down....wowww
I love Jennifer but feel like she over sings
I know, her singing often sounds like shouting to me. If she could learn control the power, she'd be great. I'd like hear her try sing softly sometimes, get those dynamics in their. Not sure she can.
Funny, Beyonce's tone annoys me. I prefer Jennifer.
Jennifer has Soul in her singing I personally love how she sings .
@@prestonwilliams9531 bad taste
@@prestonwilliams9531 for me it feels like beyonce tries to much.
I've seen a lit of debate over this. And people always say Jhud is better becasue she belts and sings loudly😑I love Jhud and she is an amazing singer no doubt. But not compared to Beyonce. Beyonce can sing while dacing and still sound amazingly, she growls, she can hit high and low notes effortlessly and uses her voice like an instrument. She has more techniques than Jhud🤷♂️It's not me being a fan, it's just facts and you can't argue with facts
And I don't like the videos you used of them singing. There are so much better ones of them😕why'd you chose these. They are both phenomenal singers and Jennifer can DEFINITELY SANG! These clips didn't fully showcase that
Beyoncé is amazing as is Jennifer fact remain Beyoncé is a wonderful technical singer however Jennifer will always give my goosebumps!!!!
Loving that your doing more Beyoncé here a step now we need more Beyoncé reactions etc.
Not really. Beyonce hasn't done much vocally *lately*
Zeek Street talking about her videos in General she don’t always react to the newest videos
I am a part of beyhive, but jenifer has improved so much nowadays which means this clip is kind of outdated
your avi-
leandro silva nope
@@Rsilva-nv4vp based on technique yes based on raw vocals probably not
Bradley Diale raw vocals are still vocals wtf are u talking about😂😂
In my opinion, these videos also test how consistent an artist is. If one thinks that clips are biased to another artist, that artist is the better singer.
Jen has amazing power but sometimes she over does it to me.. Beyoncé all the way around to me is a more skilled and flexible singer with her vocal agility and range.
Both amazing singers, but Jennifer parts were so quick! That was impossible to win Beyoncé with this selection of clips 😪
leandro silva so they didn’t use the right clips, cause Jennifer has proven many times she can hit any of those notes perfectly
The videos aren’t fair at all!! The clips of Jennifer aren’t as good
Beyoncé is my idol and she is definitely my favorite singer of all time ❤️ I'm a huge fan of her, I have been a fan of Beyoncé from the beginning, when she was with Destiny's Child and I still am, of course. I saw her in concert 6 times and I know I'm extremely lucky for that, It was easily the best moments of my life part I'll never forget that. Her vocal performances in live was purely incredible, Queen B is clearly the best singer, the best artist, she's the best performer and she has the best vocal technique of all. Now, I cannot wait to see this Battle but Beyoncé is obviously the BEST, she is the greatest singer. Hudson is ok but she is absolutely not at Beyoncé level, she is nothing compared to her, sorry for her fans but Jen Hudson has already lost against Queen B Lol... Beyoncé is the best of the two at every level, she is the most talented , she's the best vocalist, she has the most beautiful and most powerfull voice, she is 100 times better than her and she is the best at every level !Beyoncé is the one and only Queen, she won this battle, that's all.
So you never heard JHud
Jhud has more soul tho and there are singers who can out shine Beyoncé so she isn’t the best there’s always some one better
@@flipperbigg8943 So' yang is better than Beyonce and can hit *higher* notes than Beyonce. Ariana Grande can as well.
This sounds like the *stan* that may have made this video. Delusional and all. Bey can't sing everything and as a performer she does not *always* sing live. You let them *trick* you if you want. Don't forget she *lipped* the National Anthem, remember? There was NO performance necessary and she still lipped it. Anyways, you sound *consumed* and *very biased* in your comment but that's usually how stans are.
@@ZeekStreet " So' yang is better than Beyonce" Yes, in you'r head, of course..
"Beyoncé came out on top...love on top...eehhhhh...." 😂 you’re the cutest georgina!
These videos always make me smile! Thanks, Georgina!
You picked when Jennifer was really young
Omg I was just literally watching Dreamgirls!!!! Bahahahaha coincidenceee
I feel like most videos done are bias. The competitor is on for a three second clip while the person they clearly like better is on longer. They seem to use videos when the person first started their career like Jennifer Hudson on like American idol versus a fully recognize Beyoncé’s after destiny’s child. No question Beyoncé is super amazing and Jennifer Hudson is in her own right as well. However Jennifer Hudson seems to have a more husky voice and it’s completely different than Beyoncé’s. However there’s a reason why Aretha Franklin chose Jennifer Hudson to play her. I’m not particularly a Jennifer Hudson fan. I mean I like her but I find Beyoncé’s voice more beautiful.
It might help if they did some J Hud from the last 20 years, her game has picked up tremendously. The growth seems to be mostly confidence, maybe getting hand picked by Aretha has set her free.
From the last 20 years? This ones are from 30 years ago?
the fact that all these jen clips are all from the same performance....
They could use her best ones lmao. Even DC era Beyoncé is better than her vocally
it's *unfair* whoever made the video is a *Bey stan* it's always like that when it comes to Jennifer Hudson
Zeek Street Beyoncè can suppot up to an belted F#5 goes down to G#2. Perfect technique, excellent melisma user and equipped with an operatic delevoped head-voice. SceamHudson can‘t relate
Look I’m in the hive but I’m not drinking the kool aid 🤷🏾♂️
@@kevinhmj08 Now this is a member of the hive I can support. P.s. that ain't honey in that Kool aid...
And she dances and, and she is one of the best performers of all time, once in a lifetime talent indeed
Two divas are awesome... The only people that should be critiquing them should be on there level or at least close to it... Love them both
Beyonce has better technique, that is so obvious.
Jennifer Hudson is something else 🔥🔥
I’m waiting for this
Jenhud clip selection should updated
Both are too good. but Beyonce is just another level
Might have to deduct a few points from B, she was caught Lip Syncing at the Inauguration and on another one of those clips I think.
BEYONCÉ IS SO AMAZING. THE BEST VOCALIST OF HER GENERATION
Both fantastic singers, I prefer Beyonce. This was really interesting. I could watch you for hours 👍
Some prefer b. Some prefer j. Some hate both. Some love both. I think it's a matter of personal taste.
They r winning in their own rights.... its more like a preference like U SAID. Jhud is more on belting while beyonce is more on agility n vocal versatility. Yes Beyonce wins in this video.
The person that made that video didn’t chose the best performances for Jennifer/ old ones unless that whole video is a few years old.
They r individually great singers but I stan for Queen B......
Bey always will be the supreme queen
I watched Tara Simons's reactions about these ladies. Technique wise, both of them got it.
Beyoncé flips through all her registers, effortlessly.
Let’s make an extra note than most of Bey’s examples here we’re at 2hr shows while JHUD was just singing one song. Not that the clarification is needed but it adds to her magnificence. There’s not other like her, period.
I’m a huge fan of Bey but I feel Jen’s videos in this compilation was outdated while Bey has more recently videos so it kinda unfair for Jen.
Exactly, I smell a Bey Stan
Right
The majority of both of their videos were from before 2010.
But most of Beyoncé videos are older than Jen's, so...
Both videos were older. I saw a clip from 2003 on the side of beyonce. The Dangerously inlove performance. That's when shes like 20 or so.
They are fundamentally different types of singers. Jennifer is a ballade girl; big, brassy, power, are the operative word. Beyoncé is more subtle, possibly because she has to be being that she doesn’t have Jennifer’s raw power. I love them both but I think Beyoncé is the more versatile singer. I think that’s why her career is continuing in such an upward trajectory. People are fickle, and artists have to evolve. Unfortunately, the type of stuff that Jennifer did that isn’t ballades is just kind of weak. It’s the quality of her voice, she can’t really do anything about it, and the fans can only listen to so many ballads.
The ear tends to lean towards Beyonce because her voice is "cleaner".
Note by note, Beyonce will usually win because she is more accurate and clear.
Jennifer totally relies on that "churchy" sound and you'll just rarely hear her sing with an open throat. She will clench every bit of air out of a tight space to hit the notes rather than relax to it and pull more from the lungs, but that's her style. Jennifer's voice is about the context.
That shows that technically, Beyonce’s the better singer. Beyonce also has more vocal abilities than Jhud.
I’m glad she said “Bee” and not “Bay”. Cheers to proper pronunciation.
I can tell that the owner that video is beyonce's fan ;)
am actually a fan of both of'em but it was an unfair battle cuz they literally show the clip of JEN only with the note that is mentioned but with BE they show in her clips more runs so i think it sounds more catchy
Beyoncé wins of course. Jennifer Hudson have to improve her technique but she's powerful and soulful, that's undeniable.
Damn. Bey destroyed her😭
😂
BEING WAS ALWAYS UGLY, THAT'S WHY SHE'S ALWAYS BLEACHING AND RETOUCHING HER FACE FROM DAY ONE. ENOUGH SAID, PERIOD.
@@jessicabuntz8668 she’s still the better singer lol
😂
Beyonce has a classical trained voice with amazing technique and range and she can do alot with her voice. As for Jen it's only so much she can do with her voice.
Love your videos. I like watching them to see how I can improve my singing so when I perform I can have the best techniques. Sending love from North Carolina.❤️🎼
Can we just talk about how much that intro snapped?
Beyoncé is better singer