Voice Teacher Reacts to A Perfect Circle - Outsider (Live at Red Rocks)
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 3 เม.ย. 2019
- Voice teacher Sam Johnson analyzes and reacts to Maynard James Keenan of A Perfect Circle singing Outsider.
Social Media:
/ oksamjohnson
/ samjohnson
/ samjohnson
Product and book recommendations:
www.amazon.com/shop/samjohnson
I hope this observation on how he sings helps you figure out how the voice works better, so you can learn how to make smart choices in your own voice.
Go to www.vocalease.net to sign up for lessons with Sam through video chat! - เพลง
![[Live สด] การออกรางวัลสลากกินแบ่งรัฐบาล งวดวันที่ 1 กรกฎาคม 2567](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/o6JPYXalcXU/mqdefault.jpg)
![[Watch Party] APL 2024 ใครชนะเข้ารอบ Hydra 🆚 Flash Wolves Talon 🆚 GGLive](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/BvuSgyLy4hA/mqdefault.jpg)
I got into this voice teachers reacting thing only because I wanted to see artists that I appreciate being validated and talked about, but thing is, after some time I ended up enjoying the technical and analytical side of it quite a lot. And, to be honest, I think you're the only TH-cam voice teacher that actually gets into the things that should be discussed, while others just sit there and make videos reacting like a fan would. Thanks for actually putting in the time and effort, Sam, I think it really shows how dedicated and knowledgeable you are!
Well said indeed! I should have read what you wrote before writing my novel, haha. Thank goodness for channels like this to teach our new generation about some of the wonderful talent that came before and show what makes them great and why they are and always will be relevant to the current landscape of music.
Tara Simons channel is also really good
Very much this!
The same for me. I didn't watch for a long time because I assumed the coaches would be like "he's doing wrong."
@@jamesstuart4037 hahaha.. who would dare say that about MJK?
Sam AND Maynard: I'm clicking. 👍
I've seen Maynard live with Tool and A Perfect circle. hes so amazing
Jackie Lopez same. Saw him on the Lateralus tour and he was incredible
Same. Prefered APC but it could be that it was about a 1000 person show each time I saw them. then again I prefer APC in general.
I’ve seen a perfect circle live twice and hoping to see Tool 😩
@@kylerivers922 this is the year they are coming back. Tool is back
He was also great when I saw Puscifer in 2016.
That face at the very beginning is the same one I make every time I listen to them too. Especially if I've been listening to other stuff for a while. It's like diving into cool water.
Refreshing!
we dont see enough voice teachers talking about metal rock or alt. its wonderful. the most recommended voice teachers only view pop and whats 'social media cool". Im loving this.
because pop or rap is the easiest way to earn money... if you know one, you know all... and thats the big difference to metal... nowhere else you find more different voices and real feelings...
re: the last bit of the video, your opinion on artistic approach/expression/direction - Im damn glad to have subscribed to you. That was a very articulate, reasonable flow of logic/opinion. Refreshing to listen to and think about.
I could tell you were a fan right away
His reaction to that opening alone gave away how much he likes this song. Can't blame him A Perfect Circle is awesome.
I wanna see some Mike Patton on this channel!
FANTOMAS
MooseyFate YEEEEEESSSSSSSSSSSSS!!!!!!!!!!!!
Second!
Agreed!
th-cam.com/video/lhYdf-ux3gE/w-d-xo.html
How's about this? :) The best performance of, what is for me, their best track.
MJK is so seriously talented. I love seeing you react to him!
I could tell instantly that you were a fan boy. How could you not be! ♥
he is only a member in the maynard church too...^^
A Perfect Circle is one of my favorite bands. So glad you made this video. You manage to explain theory in a way that is understandable and relaxed. Thank you, Sam.
I will never cease being in awe of Maynard's voice every single time he screams live. goosebumps, without fail
APC is like when the stars aligned. Wonderful musicians with MJK pings almost on a extraterrestrial level
I think the thing that impresses me most about Maynard’s singing is how effortless it sounds. He has so much control over his voice it’s almost inhuman.
Are you a Deftones fanboy too? Would love to see some Deftones reactions/analysis :)
Goadiroth especially to discuss how chino continues after a partial vocal paralysis diagnosis need to know lol
Yeeeeeesss
it gotta be a 90s video;
its been a while since his moans and inhale screams turned really really cringe;
Deftones is killer....🤟
Do “the passenger”, Maynard did guest vocals on that song.
You seem to enjoy A Perfect Circle as much as I do. In my opinion, he's one of the best vocalists of our time. I grew up listening to them too, I was just a few years older! Lol.
Omg i was at this concert!! Saw more of Maynard in this video than during the actual concert. Extraordinarily talent.
So I take it you got to hear By and down🤬 Lucky Bastard 👊💯🔥❤️
that reaction at 6:15 is my reaction every time i hear that scream.
Maynard slayed the vocals on this song.
Have you seen their performance of Orestes from this concert? It is really something great. MJK alters his vocals a bit in some parts compared to the studio version, but it is for the better every time. It's my favorite version of that song since hearing it.
@@CyanideGirl94 I haven't. I need to check it out then! Thanks.
@@CyanideGirl94 That end vocal harmony "Gotta cut away...from killing you" is just amazing...
@@Egoblivion Maynard was absolutely on fire during this concert. I find myself coming back to watch these performances from time to time, and they never get old.
@@CyanideGirl94 Actually that part in that performance is one of my favorites in any performance of any song ever.
This album will physically make you high. The moment The Package starts you are pulled in. A must listen from start to finish. One of the best ever
I’m so glad you are an MJK fan. He is a perfect example of using different vocal techniques.
I saw A Perfect Circle on their recent UK tour. They were incredible, Maynards voice is the instrument that completes the band. Flawless, so easy and hypnotic.
So glad to see another Maynard analysis Sam! He's such a great artist. It's so interesting to hear you put into words the techniques he uses
Ironic how when he sings "disconnected"...
His voice is so connected
MJKs articulation, rhythm, poetry and angst speak to me:) excellent reaction and analysis Sam! I saw APC last year and they’re still just as explosive and genuine. His sound is signature and beautiful and haunting in the best way
Ahhh more Maynard!! Please react to his band Puscifer performing Grand Canyon!! One of the most beautiful songs with the most haunting, gorgeous vocals.
I keep discovering bands thanks to Sam... God, i love this channel lol.
You're just discovering A Perfect Circle? Have fun!
@@kvaldez46 100%. Tool, APC, even Puscifer. All great music.
This entire concert is incredible and I highly recommend you watch the whole thing. Will give you a good taste of their range.
I LOVE how much of a fanboy you are, it's so cute watching you quietly sing along and smile at all the parts he's nailing, even at the end when you just had to mention he went lower than on the recording 🥺🖤✨
Undertow is in my top 5 albums of all time. Can you please react to Alice In Chains -Love Hate Love live at the Moore. It is jaw dropping. His voice is incredible in that. I also would like to make others aware who missed out on him. Pretty please.
Yes!!! Love Hate Love live at the Moore is one of the best performances by Layne.
I have been begging for this as well! This girl loves Layne! Hands down his best performance! Every reaction to that song blows peoples minds! I am interested to see what Sam thinks. R.I.P Layne. We miss your voice.
Yes! Please do this!
Hazzah I was hoping you would do another analysis of MJK, I love the way you present vocal teaching in an easily understandable manner. So glad to see you come so far from when I started watching, keep up your good work, and thanks for all the awesome content!
You pick things up I never would’ve noticed!
I love your tangents! They're one of the things that make you such a delight to watch. Thanks for another great video. I'm always a fan of the rock/metal slanted videos. Would love to see more of them :)
We saw APC, he had the no film rule, which I didn’t mind, it allowed us to really take in the show. Maynard is one of the best voices out there IMO. So unique and so talented, incredible. I was waiting for you to critic the “yell,” so so soooo good! Just goosebumps! Love your channel. ❤️
I’m glad you talked about his vowel choices. It’s something I never really noticed until all of these reaction videos coming out
I watched a couple of videos of yours. I love how much you appreciate the technique of each individual singer, and also how merciful you are with your critiques. I love finding people who feel, as I do, that music can be appreciated in so many different ways and that music isn't inherently "bad" as it is misunderstood. Loving it. You earned my subscription. Keep on rocking!
I love that you know all the words, you're the coolest! Yet another great video!
Maynard's singing and lyricism defined my perception of music around the same age. Thanks for reacting to AND analyzing this one.
Your last bit of the video was really nice to hear coming from a professional in the business, I am a developing singer for a small rock band and I am in the process of really figuring out who I want to be on that stage. Your video reacting to Sober actually put my onto Tool, and Maynard as a singer. He was the first performer I actually saw that showed his pain through a total body performance that coincided with the themes of the songs he was singing. He is also probably my favorite singer, and your reactions to his performances and the critiques/analysis of his work give me more to look out for in my own development. Not saying I compare haha have you heard Opiate? But just that he is an idol and a source of inspiration. But thank you for your advice, I'm definitely going to take what you said to heart. I would love to see you react to Tool perform "Bottom" from Oakland in 1995, probably his most melodic version of that song I've heard. The scream at the end if heartbreaking, a lot of pain. Thanks again Sam.
Seeing you enjoy a song I enjoy so much made me very happy
man, you're awesome. the speech about the moment in the end is really nice!
Love his reaction when the song starts
Discovered your channel through the Jinjer reaction a little while back, and I've enjoyed watching basically every single video you've been putting out since, even if the artists aren't ones I would normally enjoy or listen to. You give such awesome, unbiased analyses and never actively put down someone who's putting their all out there (regardless of whether or not you enjoy the music in question), it's such a refreshing change from everything.
Also It was great to see the look on your face when this song started, and mouthed along to the words as it went on, clearly this is a song that you REALLY enjoy.
A: you demonstrating that fry with so much ease made my day. B: I'd love to see you react to a vocalist that performs in a way you don't like. I'm not sure that I've seen any video of yours where you have less than positive commentary.
Maybe drake or Katy perry?
I've been watching these reaction videos for some time now and this dude is the best and moist technical sounding that I have seen. Very well done and you have a new subscriber! And if I had any singing voice at all I would want you as my teacher! Keep up the good work!
They are AMAZING LIVE! So happy you did this video 🙏🏼🙏🏼💜💜🔥🔥✌🏼
Reactions like this is why i kept listening to these types of videos. Much respect, keep it up!
I love how you said that he’s very conscious of every sound he puts into it. I notice it a lot with his vocals in Puscifer. There’s an unbelievable control to his voice that I am in insane awe of. Soft, controlled, perfection.
:08 Seeing his reaction to just those first notes being played put my mind at ease that I wasn't gonna have to go on defense automatically because of someone never having heard the magic that is Tool, APC and Puscifer and as ALWAYS, MJK's voice!!
My God, man...you are on point with your commentary, especially with the artist allowing themselves to experiment during live performances! 💖
It only took me one video of yours to subscribe! You're input is very sweet and informative and helpful! Keep up the great work!
I love the way you explain your points, and that you can tell how much you enjoy listening to them :)
Had notification for this earlier, but waited until now to watch because I've been a huge fan of Maynard James Keenan for so long. Sam, you make me appreciate your critiques even more. No I don't sing, wish I could, lover of music forever, and curious on hows and whys to techniques. Gotta say Thanks, Sam.
Love the tangent at the end. It’s what I needed to hear today.
When you mentioned getting into music at such a young age, and that sticking with you- same! MJK is a legend, and I’ve been a fan since my young teens! 🖤 I enjoyed hearing your analysis of his vowel choice and distortion in the voice. I also enjoyed you telling singers to be themselves!!!! 🖤🖤🖤
Your explanations of what is going on actually make sense to me, someone who doesn't know how to sing, and to see you as a fan, is awesome.
Two things- 1) as a person whose home state is Colorado (though I no longer live there) - it’s nice to see Red Rocks. 2) Thank you for your hard work on these videos you produce. I am learning a lot.
Loved your take on every performance being a separate piece of art. Never thought of it that way but it makes so much sense.
We need more of these videos. I love watching you analyze video of artists you can tell you actually love and are very into... seems to be the rock videos... give us more rock!!!!
awesome. awesome. awesome. another fan here...
as always, super clear... kind words... you are always cheering people up.
thank you.
Sam, you are such an awesome dude. I too discovered APC when I was 12 and they blew my tiny little mind. Love ya x
Ugh..i love that you love a perfect circle. Its so nice to see reactions to this.
I just adooore how you enjoyed this one omfg, this is one of my favorite vids ever now.
The last two minutes you were just handing out pearls of wisdom. You are always succint,enlightning and ever the teacher.
finally Outsider! amazing pick, Sam, and super interesting as always
Love your analyzis as a professional . I'm a big fan of Maynard and you are spot on to notice the way he uses his voice to express himself in different ways, in different bands and in different situations, live or on record. That's what makes him and his bands so great.
thank you! more mjk! you are very knowledgeable, great videos 😁
I LOVE that you're singing along to this!
You are on point sir, well done! Congrats on 500k, saw a video of yours once before... now I'm subbing and belling ya. Keep at it!
You deserve more subs man. Love your content.
Loved your analysis. It’s always amazing to see bands play here in Colorado (thats where red rocks is located),because we lack oxygen here.
love the fact that u re a fan and appreciate this amazing frontman
I'd love to see you do more tool or APC videos.. grew up listening to them, love em still after decades lol Maynard is a genius with melodies, lyrics, and of course his beautiful Voice 😍😍
I’ve seen him live so many times and he always blows me away. He has such a unique sound. I love you more for being a fanboy.
Love that you're such a Maynard fan. That's how I got here! He was awesome in a show I saw recently here in Amsterdam. Looking forward to Tool's show here in june! Mainly a metal and rock fan here but love the reactions! Keep it up!
lol I completely relate to what you said about this album defining everything you like. I had thirteenth step on my old iPod and it was one of the first albums I'd gotten into on my own, without my parent's influence. Definitely started me down a path of discovering music I wouldn't have otherwise come across. Great video!
2:25 is killer advice! best vocal deconstruction I've heard yet, thank you!
Oh, it so glad to see like you really love this music :) It's in your eyes, in your movements. Love it!
haha so I know I am a bit behind the game here :) but that was great fun watching this with you. I had not seen that clip before, so thanks for getting it to me :) Fuck I miss live music! 2021. Sydney. Lockdown.
peace.
Omg I love you for this❤️
This is the first time I ever hear them. Thanks to Sam, my playlist keeps increasing.
Gah I just am forever amazed by MJK. Love seeing Sam do a video on this!
I love your videos man!
Oh yeah. Totally love this!
I WAS AT THIS SHOW! Gosh, what a combination... Listening to your wonderful analysis while basking in an amazing memory.
I would really love to see you react to Orestes from this same concert. It is so beautiful.
I ADORE this song! Sam you are wonderfully insightful and very educating, Thank you for what you do and please do keep it up ^_^
Maynard has such a great unique voice. His ability to change the sound of his voice sincerely amazes me. I love when you critique tool and apc!
Would love to see you react to more MJK. Seeing you rock out to it while still analyzing is so entertaining 😆 Your speech at the end really helps put things more into perspective for me personally as I am trying to learn to sing.
Your tangent was sage advice in every area of life. Better to simply be yourself. Always enjoy your videos. Great analysis of interesting vocalists.
What I like most about the video is that you enjoy the song. Then you declare yourself a fan and it's like YAY!
I love when bands do songs slightly different live. Theres a live version of tool H. When he says "connected to you", its hard to explain but he puts the emphasis on it differently and goes higher. Even though i cant find the song(cus how do you put that in yt) i still to this day after 12 yrs sing it like that.
th-cam.com/video/b6CFaMh3rys/w-d-xo.html maybe this one?
Sam, thank you for your closing idea of this video. Love you.
Sam Sam Sam! I think this is my favorite video of yours so far! I appreciate the emotion you visually express in this vid, like you felt that shit for real. Seeing you in your earlier videos with your long hair I took you for more of a metal head \m/, too and you ended up mentioning you got this album when younger so maybe I was right.
Anyway, I usually find that the people that like heavier music judge you if you listen to music outside of the genre. I know I've gone through that myself, but meh. I like to think I'm balanced.
Anyway just want to say I appreciate your universal love of all music and vocals!
Much love from Las Vegas!
His voice is awesome, and man do I LOVE how Red Rocks makes music sound. Going to that place live is something else. This song is my teenager years for sure though.
One of my fave songs ♥️
At 6:20 . . . Wow dude, that didn't sound the same as Maynard, but it was amazing! And then you go on to talk about being yourself instead of trying to be someone else. I've been trying to sing that note like Maynard for about a year now, and it's only just now that I can hit that note, because I tried to find out the way that works best for my voice, and now I can do it with distortion and quality, within FIFTEEN MINUTES of having seen this video! Thanks so much for doing this channel man! It's awesome! And most importantly, it's useful, valuable, and educational.
I have to give it up to you. I have seen other videos of so claim "vocal teachers" and even I can tell they are just making stuff up or just can't explain certain vocals or notes. But I can definitely tell you know your stuff! *Awesome work!* I love Maynard James Keenan work, since he was in the band TooL.
aaaaaaaaa... this is such a good song in every possible level. Thank you.
Congratulations on your silver button! You earned it!
Great advice at the end!