Hindi Imposition Debate | Is A Linguistic Controversy Steaming-Up In India? | The NewsHour Agenda
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 7 เม.ย. 2022
- In this episode of The NewsHour Agenda with Padmaja Joshi, we will speak about the recent statement of Union Home Minister Amit Shah, which has sparked another controversy. In the latest developments, the Hindi imposition debate has once again ignited in the country after Home Minister Amit Shah considered it as an alternative to English. Meanwhile, the opposition parties have slammed the BJP government for imposing Hindi on the citizens. Speaking on this, DMK spokesperson Sarvanan Annadurai said “Any language other than my mother tongue is a foreign language to me. Be it Telugu, Kannada, Japanese, Hindi. I will treat them all in the same manner. This push for Hindi instead of English is an imposition.”
Watch to know more!
#HindiImpositionDebate #AmitShah #TheNewsHourAgenda
Times Now - Times Now News channel examines news with in-depth analysis. We provide much more than the latest news and breaking news of the day. Times Network houses the upscale television channels.
Times Network takes the lead with its ground-breaking innovation and disruption of a new content category. The Times Network channels, which have a global footprint in 100 countries, inform, entertain, and engage viewers of all ages with fascinating and intriguing content, news, and information.
Subscribe to our News channel - goo.gl/U9ibPb
Check out our website: www.timesnownews.com
Times Now News App : bit.ly/3AD5qqN
Connect with us on our social media handles:
Facebook: / timesnow
Twitter: / timesnow
Instagram: / timesnow
Subscribe to our other network channels:
Times Now Navbharat: th-cam.com/users/timesnownavbh...
Zoom: tiny.cc/u435nz
Mirror Now: bit.ly/32xyBMe
ET Now: goo.gl/5XreUq
TN+: bit.ly/2EEJaF4
Follow us on Google News for latest updates
Times Now : bit.ly/3CyrrYg
Times Now Navbharat: bit.ly/3zDaKJo
Zoom: bit.ly/3CEK0dv
This decision is a Hindi imperialistic decision ... All non-Hindi speaking Indians should protest against it ....
Yes, Hindi is not even spoken in all North India, we have Punjabi, bhojpuri, Marwari, hadoti etc
Hindi is not national language don’t think rather we accept English as our national language too.. we want a language that can connect us and thats definitely not Hindi…
Reasons
1 Hindi is nothing but Urdu largely spoken by Muslims so definitely South Indian culture and people don’t connect to any thing that’s foreign language, I know there’s difference between Hindi and Urdu but they are like brothers so it’s big no, Urdu is national language of Pakistan..
2 a language should fill confidence and should give freedom to our mind so that we can think freely and that s key too lot of inventions you want an eg lot Indian inventions are from South Indians not north people eg non other than APJ Abdul Kalam even though he’s Muslim he embraced Tamil culture,
3 even after lot of invasions in north and Independence no govt tried to bring culture back and restore it and our education was designed by communists and pro western intellectuals in a way that we hate our country and there was no sense of pride in our country resulted in Hindi speaking states and people became scapegoats of that false history and even South felt but remain resistance becoz of our culture and pride in it..
4 Tamil is much older then even Sanskrit so bit difficult to accept Sanskrit itself than how can we accept its offsprings, you got know like Hindi many other South Indian languages have grown on their own over thousands of years with history, culture and only way too unify India is tell your North Indians to give respect too South language and mainly people becoz the amount of arrogance and superiority complex in North Indian to south people is deplorable that s also one of the reason why hate Hindi language and people just becoz you are in northern part you don’t become superiors in fact you people are one of the biggest reason India got an image of rapists and filthy country and no respect for elders..
5 we don’t need a common language when we have no problem communicating with others, English is international language that’s a need for jobs and follow up with western world, if western world was not so developed or some other eastern part of world like Japanese or Korean was giving job opportunities and Centre of world then we would have learnt that language too, Hollywood played its role in spreading English too… what we have to do is oppose western culture…imposing hindi will abolish all Indian languages and thousands of years of history culture attached to it over the period…
6 solution is seek out and tell original history, let all Indians know the truth and don’t make or impose any language or make 2-3 language as national language including a south language and mainly when you show some gratitude and respect to our people and culture na then you don’t have to impose anything they ll accept with open arms..
Why only non hindi people really if all are 1st Indian citizens then hindi people who have at least this much of common sense must also come out and speak for rest of others !.. they are going too far misleading people and misusing their position in ministry seriously.. this time i will vote aam admi party or ysr jagan party if they rally for national party.. or just remove this national party let every party regionally work better
Central govt spending money for learning hindi but its wrong the non hindi state give more revenue to Central government, Central government people should give service in local language. Hindi is also local language, population can't be the criteria.
@@balajip6405absolutely ri8 bro these hindi imperialist say why we learn a foreign language oh so why you guys watch and play cricket 🏏 football ⚽ tennis 🎾 badminton 🏸 rugby 🏉 since it's a Britishers games who not kho kho kabbadi 😂😅 ???
Why you wear shirt pant jacket coat etc etc rather than wearing dhoti kurta lungi langot ??? 😅😂
If Amit shah says English is an alien language, then by same logic, why is his own son the chair person for BCCI cricket board? Well cricket is Britishers game and why is Jay Shah not part of Kabaddi games? Bloddy hypocrite bjp... I am a Tamil speaking proud 🇮🇳 Indian
This is the hypocrisy&lies of the Hindi/Sanskrit Supremacists, they claim that speaking English is shameful but for some reason everything else from Western World is not.
I strongly condemn the role of central government in imposing Hindi on non Hindi speaking states , it will destroy the richness of local languages like Tamil, kannada, Bengali, Telugu etc . Shame on Amit shah and BJP and whoever who impose Hindi on us
When jinnah tried to impose urdu on East Bengal you know the how the bengalis went rampant and opposed it tooth and nail.
That was the first nail in the coffin to create Bangladesh.
@@gangasewani3041 correct
@@venkateshnatarajan2941 👌👍
@@gangasewani3041 boss now , first nail has been hit by union india over south .........
They are not imposing hindi, they told to make hindi as linkage language.
’m 39 when I was kid I felt very bad for not learning hindi and I admired other states that they were able to speak hindi. So I decided to put my child hindi Tamil and English and his age is 9 now. But for the past few years nearly 5 years I’m getting calls from cardeko, HDFC, Icici and mobile service provider and few other CustomerCare in hindi first when I speak Tamil to them they speak English and after that I understood why our Tamil leaders oppose hindi because they create a situation to learn by enforcing us. Now I cancelled hindi for my kid and I put him in French and he felt happy and it is very easy proud to say HINDHI THERIYATHU PODA
Hindi supremacy should be abolished...thanks to DMK as its fight for linguistic rights in pluralistic society...
Don't know where you tamils get confidence from tamil not spoken by every one in tamilnadu forget rest of india you saying big word for that
you stupid!!
India have more then 1000 s of languages
It is not possible to learn every language
thats why we need 1 common language
1. you can speak hindi for whole india
2. you can have your regional language as well
तुम मूर्ख !!
भारत में 1000 से अधिक भाषाएं हैं
हर भाषा को सीखना संभव नहीं है।
यही कारण है कि हमें 1 सामान्य भाषा की आवश्यकता है
1. आप पूरे भारत के लिए हिंदी बोल सकते हैं
2. आप अपनी क्षेत्रीय भाषा के साथ-साथ दूसरी भाषा का भी उपयोग कर सकते हैं..
@@amit1657 but no one have right to discriminate a language by its amount of usage .. let it be superiority or inferiority you cannot take any of the sides.. if feels problematic then use translator google technology .. see how bjp spreading hate by religion and region biasing.. we need real indians who respect all languages equally not someone like those and you who don't know how to put things in equal terms irrespective of it's quantity lol.. the constitution fundamental laws are broken now die to these type of people.. i don't hate people its useless for me but i have right to defend for my existence and the language equally !
DMK only do brain wash of your brain.if they really love their language then they provide higher education in Tamil language and also they sent their children's in tamil medium school
Can somebody explain the rationale why all Indians should learn hindi language when majority of Indians are quite comfortable using English as a formal and professional language???
Due to south languages English flourished as a link language in the south. Because of this people can find good paying jobs abroad and be updated with the world. Tell me who’s offering jobs in the Hindi belt? Rather the North Indians should learn south languages when they are looking for jobs in places like Bangalore, Hyderabad, Chennai, Trivandrum and Goa. As simple.
There are various factors why people from Hindi speaking states move to Southern states for jobs. Look at that Northern states, Punjab Haryana, are in the borders of Pak, Himachal, Sikkim do not have the geographical advantages of constructing IT companies. Same goes for Bihar as it is earthquake prone region. So companies choose Chennai, Bangalore, Hyderabad, etc. People from Hindi speaking states who wish to work in IT companies, move to Southern states. People who have interest in journalism, central government jobs, banking , etc easily find jobs in North. Again , when an outsider moves to Southern states, if he wishes to learn the local language, well and good, if not then u can't say NORTH INDIANS SHOULD LEARN THE LOCAL LANGUAGES. They moved there, because they deserved the jobs and qualified for the role. The only thing u can expect is these outsiders not imposing their language on the localites and respecting the norms of the society.
@@divyabharti8479 we will say you bloody northie, don't cry it's my choice, if it is your choice of not learning the language of state then dont cry that we are getting illtreated in south becoz you yourself asked for it so enjoy the ill-treatment northie and IT companies came not becoz of you said geographical reasons or becoz of central government it is becoz of our leaders like Chandrababu Naidu, sm krishna who went to foriegn countries and brought the companies to their places but you northies don't want to give us credit so giving the credit for south indians and think that becoz of you only we developed and if they are so much qualified for the job ask them to do the qualified job in their bimaru states only nobody is begging them to come here
EU language policy is based on respect for linguistic diversity in all Member States. The EU has 24 official languages and the European Parliament accepts all official languages as working languages. India is a similar union of states, If the government fail to respect or unable to represent every Indian state and its language, it is not qualified to rule the country.
@@ayushnair3587 again India is not a single country before British invasion. Even they didn't force English as one language policy. Indian Union. Unity in diversity. Think globally so make English as national language and respective regional languages as state's own official language. Or let's treat equal. Let's have one of the Indian languages as national language in yearly or parliamentary period basis. Come on. This is simply a diversion politics by present govt to deviate us from other issues.
@@ayushnair3587 India is a UNION of states
@@ayushnair3587 If the union government continues with this Hindi hegemonic attitude, the day is not far
@@ayushnair3587 Not just for giving importance to Hindi..there are many other factors where South is short changed...tax returns higher for north and lower for south...next up they are building a new Parliament to seat 1000 MPs...if that is based on current census...South states will lose even more seats...As of now whoever wins UP, Bihar Hindi heartland states wins India and becomes PM and dictates orders from Delhi...going forward with a 1000 MP Parliament will only make matters worse ...all this will lead to only one destination...another freedom struggle !
Hindi is not national language don’t think rather we accept English as our national language too.. we want a language that can connect us and thats definitely not Hindi…
Reasons
1 Hindi is nothing but Urdu largely spoken by Muslims so definitely South Indian culture and people don’t connect to any thing that’s foreign language, I know there’s difference between Hindi and Urdu but they are like brothers so it’s big no, Urdu is national language of Pakistan..
2 a language should fill confidence and should give freedom to our mind so that we can think freely and that s key too lot of inventions you want an eg lot Indian inventions are from South Indians not north people eg non other than APJ Abdul Kalam even though he’s Muslim he embraced Tamil culture,
3 even after lot of invasions in north and Independence no govt tried to bring culture back and restore it and our education was designed by communists and pro western intellectuals in a way that we hate our country and there was no sense of pride in our country resulted in Hindi speaking states and people became scapegoats of that false history and even South felt but remain resistance becoz of our culture and pride in it..
4 Tamil is much older then even Sanskrit so bit difficult to accept Sanskrit itself than how can we accept its offsprings, you got know like Hindi many other South Indian languages have grown on their own over thousands of years with history, culture and only way too unify India is tell your North Indians to give respect too South language and mainly people becoz the amount of arrogance and superiority complex in North Indian to south people is deplorable that s also one of the reason why hate Hindi language and people just becoz you are in northern part you don’t become superiors in fact you people are one of the biggest reason India got an image of rapists and filthy country and no respect for elders..
5 we don’t need a common language when we have no problem communicating with others, English is international language that’s a need for jobs and follow up with western world, if western world was not so developed or some other eastern part of world like Japanese or Korean was giving job opportunities and Centre of world then we would have learnt that language too, Hollywood played its role in spreading English too… what we have to do is oppose western culture…imposing hindi will abolish all Indian languages and thousands of years of history culture attached to it over the period…
6 solution is seek out and tell original history, let all Indians know the truth and don’t make or impose any language or make 2-3 language as national language including a south language and mainly when you show some gratitude and respect to our people and culture na then you don’t have to impose anything they ll accept with open arms..
Gentleman it's "Kannada" do not pronounce it as 'Kannad'
They know, but they don't want to correct it. Things like this is enough to ruin this country.
They also say TamilNad and Keral 😂
They pronounce like that only telugu as teelugu, tamil as taamil etc.
You don't know how to speak hindi
Hindi is not national language don’t think rather we accept English as our national language too.. we want a language that can connect us and thats definitely not Hindi…
Reasons
1 Hindi is nothing but Urdu largely spoken by Muslims so definitely South Indian culture and people don’t connect to any thing that’s foreign language, I know there’s difference between Hindi and Urdu but they are like brothers so it’s big no, Urdu is national language of Pakistan..
2 a language should fill confidence and should give freedom to our mind so that we can think freely and that s key too lot of inventions you want an eg lot Indian inventions are from South Indians not north people eg non other than APJ Abdul Kalam even though he’s Muslim he embraced Tamil culture,
3 even after lot of invasions in north and Independence no govt tried to bring culture back and restore it and our education was designed by communists and pro western intellectuals in a way that we hate our country and there was no sense of pride in our country resulted in Hindi speaking states and people became scapegoats of that false history and even South felt but remain resistance becoz of our culture and pride in it..
4 Tamil is much older then even Sanskrit so bit difficult to accept Sanskrit itself than how can we accept its offsprings, you got know like Hindi many other South Indian languages have grown on their own over thousands of years with history, culture and only way too unify India is tell your North Indians to give respect too South language and mainly people becoz the amount of arrogance and superiority complex in North Indian to south people is deplorable that s also one of the reason why hate Hindi language and people just becoz you are in northern part you don’t become superiors in fact you people are one of the biggest reason India got an image of rapists and filthy country and no respect for elders..
5 we don’t need a common language when we have no problem communicating with others, English is international language that’s a need for jobs and follow up with western world, if western world was not so developed or some other eastern part of world like Japanese or Korean was giving job opportunities and Centre of world then we would have learnt that language too, Hollywood played its role in spreading English too… what we have to do is oppose western culture…imposing hindi will abolish all Indian languages and thousands of years of history culture attached to it over the period…
6 solution is seek out and tell original history, let all Indians know the truth and don’t make or impose any language or make 2-3 language as national language including a south language and mainly when you show some gratitude and respect to our people and culture na then you don’t have to impose anything they ll accept with open arms….
Due to Hindi and my state langauge i can't even speak my mother tongue clearly. Why should we follow it. As a northeast indian hindi being me 3rd language it's already a great Hassel and English is my forth langaug
We South indians also expect North indians to start learning atleast one South indian language.
🇮🇳INDIA FIRST🇮🇳
That won't happen mate. Because as they say in English 'Necessity is the mother of all invention'. There is no necessity of learning southern Indian languages in Northern, Western or Eastern parts of India. But according to Amit Shah it is necessary to learn Hindi and use it as a link language between different provinces instead of English which is our colonial rulers language.
can u shut ur mouth y those &***8 has to learn our language and destroy it ..... its enough if our people learned it properly pls dont bring this issue again
@@RaviKumar-ii6cb how bogus is that argument by amit shah
@@Raveendhana Aaamam. Makkal odu virrupat ku edhir a oru vishayat a kazhuthu puduchu thinnikardhu adaavaditanam arajagam.
@@RaviKumar-ii6cb yes right
Am from AP... i love to speak in Telugu, No chuthiya can impose any language on me which is in my blood. Jai Hind I respect other languages as well
you can spreak as a second language
@@Ishant007 that should be our own choice man what we speak it shouldn't be told by people who think of themselves as superior groups.
South Indians be United to gether it's time to defend our mother dravidian family from fu..... hindi imposition
This is just to make some noise. In reality they can't even pluck our dravidian hair.
Learning English is useful for studies and job if I learn hindi what can I do with ? Sell panipuri? As a south indian I don’t travel to north India often !!!! so I’m good with my Tamil and English !!!! I’m against Hindi imposition !!!!
No one asked our pm to speak in Hindi. He can speak in his mother tongue or in any other language. He will communicate in a language that’s comfortable and serves his political agenda! Let people decide and no need to trash any language
@therealsumeet then you speak tamil learn it.. we fellow Tamils (Who joined with north to form India) speaks it
😂😂🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
We need leaders like bharath ratna EX-PM SHRI P V NARSIMHA RAO GARU THE ARCHITECT OF MODERN INDIAN ECONOMY WHO CAN SPEAK UPTO 18 INDIAN LANGUAGES.
Don’t know why language is such a big debate. Let’s all unite by learning English at least. No one seems to have a problem with that, and hopefully we can speak English and any other language we’d like.
I don't know why this Amit Shah had to speak on this subject. In fact the matter is already sorted out in Sec 343 of the Indian constitution. Hindi and English are working languages (link Language) It is ideal to know both but not compulsory. Either one of the language should be known to communicate between different states. SO Northern & Western India prefers Hindi as the link language and Southern India prefers English. End of the story.
@@RaviKumar-ii6cb they want to divert from the core issue , he is thinking south dravidian states like hindi belt , which if union gives sugar coated shit saying this is sweet tat belt will eat it ....lol
BJP ideology
Hindi is not national language don’t think rather we accept English as our national language too.. we want a language that can connect us and thats definitely not Hindi…
Reasons
1 Hindi is nothing but Urdu largely spoken by Muslims so definitely South Indian culture and people don’t connect to any thing that’s foreign language, I know there’s difference between Hindi and Urdu but they are like brothers so it’s big no, Urdu is national language of Pakistan..
2 a language should fill confidence and should give freedom to our mind so that we can think freely and that s key too lot of inventions you want an eg lot Indian inventions are from South Indians not north people eg non other than APJ Abdul Kalam even though he’s Muslim he embraced Tamil culture,
3 even after lot of invasions in north and Independence no govt tried to bring culture back and restore it and our education was designed by communists and pro western intellectuals in a way that we hate our country and there was no sense of pride in our country resulted in Hindi speaking states and people became scapegoats of that false history and even South felt but remain resistance becoz of our culture and pride in it..
4 Tamil is much older then even Sanskrit so bit difficult to accept Sanskrit itself than how can we accept its offsprings, you got know like Hindi many other South Indian languages have grown on their own over thousands of years with history, culture and only way too unify India is tell your North Indians to give respect too South language and mainly people becoz the amount of arrogance and superiority complex in North Indian to south people is deplorable that s also one of the reason why hate Hindi language and people just becoz you are in northern part you don’t become superiors in fact you people are one of the biggest reason India got an image of rapists and filthy country and no respect for elders..
5 we don’t need a common language when we have no problem communicating with others, English is international language that’s a need for jobs and follow up with western world, if western world was not so developed or some other eastern part of world like Japanese or Korean was giving job opportunities and Centre of world then we would have learnt that language too, Hollywood played its role in spreading English too… what we have to do is oppose western culture…imposing hindi will abolish all Indian languages and thousands of years of history culture attached to it over the period…
6 solution is seek out and tell original history, let all Indians know the truth and don’t make or impose any language or make 2-3 language as national language including a south language and mainly when you show some gratitude and respect to our people and culture na then you don’t have to impose anything they ll accept with open arms..
@yitzhak shekkelsteingoldmanberg it's not about ego, if Tomo Muslims becomes majority and demand Urdu as National launguage, you want us to support that too, hell no, you first learn India s oldest launguages Tamil, kannada, Telugu and Malayalam...
An avoidable controversy. People in nonl speaking states resist it.English is the link langusge .This language issue will divide Hindus,
exactly! Amit Shah is sabotaging the BJP momentum with such a stupid move. They lose the south and keep that criminal Mamata Banerjee in power with idyotic moves like this.
Hindus in south are okay with Urdu but not Hindi, south indian Hindus already divided. South muslims are 100% with Urdu. And thanks god, Hindi has made a way into south because of muslims.
@@1n1lymk Hindi has nothing to do with Hinduism .... Hindi is an illegitimate brother of Urdu ....
All south Indian politics are ok with Arabic and urdu cause its appeasement of minorities but have problem with hindi
Today nobody speaks hindi or any other indian language properly. These very leaders can't speak a straight sentence without throwing English words.
I watched this video as I am starting to learn Tamil for my Tamil Partner. I am european, more precisely from Germany. In Europe we usually learn several european languages to communicate with eachother. Mostly We speak english with people from other european countries, in the eastern Parts of Europe it is russian. Why? Because These nations invaded parts of our continent at one time and became predominant in larger regions, and because English is THE world language. Do we try to impose German to the other countries as we now have no english speaking country in the EU anymore? German is the mostly spoken language in the EU, but other nations would definitely rebel against our language as they already feel (and rightly so) that Germans have too much influence in the EU. In the contrary Geans so often speak several european languages. So I can't really See any Points for imposing Hindu (as it would seem Like Just another colonizers language to Many Indians). Looking forward to be able to speak some Tamil at some Point in time 🤩
India have more then 1000 s of languages
It is not possible to learn every language
thats why we need 1 common language
1. you can speak hindi for whole india
2. you can have your regional language as well
भारत में 1000 से अधिक भाषाएं हैं
हर भाषा को सीखना संभव नहीं है।
यही कारण है कि हमें 1 सामान्य भाषा की आवश्यकता है
1. आप पूरे भारत के लिए हिंदी बोल सकते हैं
2. आप अपनी क्षेत्रीय भाषा के साथ-साथ दूसरी भाषा का भी उपयोग कर सकते हैं..
@@Ishant007 why should we have only your hindi for whole India just keep your hindi in your states no need to bring it here.
@@Attitudezero884 hindi is not my native
Why can't Hindi belt people learn other language, why special status to them?
we use hindi as a second language u can use
When Krishank Anna told that signboard point that BJP candidate Guru Prakash has no words.
Guru prakash must realise people down south also donot need lessons on what language to speak with our fellow Indian
PEOPLE OF UP, BIHAR SHOULD RATHER LERN BANGLA...AS THEY ARE COMMING TO BENGAL TO EXPLOITE HEAR
Not against Hindi - however DO NOT IMPOSE IT. Being a Bengali am proud of Bengali as my FIRST language. Back in ‘80’s had leaned English and Bengali in school. Speaking of which I speak Kannada, eager to learn Tamil (the oldest in India) and some EU’s. NO ONE HAS RIGHT TO IMPOSE Hindi on me - my choice.
EINSTEIN STORY 💯
One day Einstein Makes the large hole in door for mother cat 😺
In few days, next to the large hole, he makes small hole for kitten 🐈
Then only he realised, large hole itself enough for both kitten and cat
That small hole is Hindi
That large hole is English
English is enough to connect peoples in All over world🌍 assuming North India part of world
Is 67% non Hindi mother tongue population in India should study 33% Hindi mother tongue population language. What happened to mighty USSR would happen to India on language basis. Western countries intellectuals have already predicted that India would disintegrate on language basis. I think BJP is inducing the seperation by imposing Hindi on non Hindi states.
If 100% non english mother tongue population can learn it then for national communication we can choose 1 native language of india and hindi because of sheer numbers now if sanskrit or tamil or assamese gain popularity we can shift to it whats the problem.
@@RahulRaj-sn8rg isase accha hai hum alag ho jaye 😛
Sorry meh gay nahi hoon apne galli me kisi ko doondh le bhe.
@@RahulRaj-sn8rg so you are saying that Tamilnadu should increase the population.
@@HariKrishnan-pe3ft increase the proficiency of your language make great poets stories music and artists and economy so others will want to learn it instead of complaining and whining and playing divisive politics.
We don't want hindi in our telugu states 🔥🔥🔥
We should have some common things like National Flag... National Anthem.... So National language.....
No need for some of them
You have it for your North indian country, our South India don't need a national langauge. And don't buy any properties in South. we are going to get separated any way if this cunning acts continue in northern belt.
Just tell me how to write ✍
The following python code in hindi ( national language by default and propoganda )
Def add(a,b)
Add=a+b
Add(a,b)
While i
There is no national language....
National anthem was written in Bengali by Rabindranath Thakur..
Very nicely conducted debate and the way both the sides have articulated the points is great.
The percentage of people who speak Telugu has reduced from 9.24% (according to the 1951 census) to 6.7% (according to the 2011 census), which might have gone further down in the last decade. However, the percentage of people who speak Hindi has gone up at the same time. So, the imposition of Hindi definitely will destroy other languages' existence in India.
Very true friend
Bro you are very wrong. Let's not talk percentage ok. Because 1% of India's population means 1.3 crore people. 6.7% means 8.7 crore people. In 1951 our India's population is only 36 crore. Now it's 130+ crores. So don't speak percentage bullshit please. Also if you add population of all South Indian states like tamilnadu, kerala, Andhra ,Telangana and Karnataka then it's about 25+ crores.on comparing it with 1951 population it's nearly 75% okay. Don't bring rubbish stats please.
@@pandiguru4283 We are not talking about the population increase but the decrease in the percentage of people who speak regional languages has reduced due to Hindi imposition. In 1951, 1 in every 10 Indians used to speak Telugu whereas now only 1 in 14 speak Telugu, which indicates a reduction in the number of people who speak Telugu.
@@pandiguru4283 looks like you are a myopic guy.. Who just starts farting the moment you hear something that is not clear to you.. deliver into the details.. South Indians and very smart and the same cannot be said for all the northis.. you have very short temper and have less ability to discuss a subject..
So understand the other person's view and then put your comment
Sorry to say this but the decrease in % speaking Telugu is because of people themselves and you should blame the people for not taking pride in speaking or initiative in protecting their mother tongue (TELUGU)
Telugu is sweet language everyone learn it
yes it is: I am Northern Indian, but then again I speak Mandarin too, and many others.
so is kannada but you idiots come to karnataka and speak your language why you looted the lands of kannadiga and today your reddys have become bosses telgu is sweet language rape is sweet which you use frequently
@@repealsection230forbigtech4 I respect you for learning multiple languages. But that happened out of your own will. Like wise , we ll learn hindi if needed. But Compulsive attitude will break this country which will benifit many nations.
Hindi is not national language don’t think rather we accept English as our national language too.. we want a language that can connect us and thats definitely not Hindi…
Reasons
1 Hindi is nothing but Urdu largely spoken by Muslims so definitely South Indian culture and people don’t connect to any thing that’s foreign language, I know there’s difference between Hindi and Urdu but they are like brothers so it’s big no, Urdu is national language of Pakistan..
2 a language should fill confidence and should give freedom to our mind so that we can think freely and that s key too lot of inventions you want an eg lot Indian inventions are from South Indians not north people eg non other than APJ Abdul Kalam even though he’s Muslim he embraced Tamil culture,
3 even after lot of invasions in north and Independence no govt tried to bring culture back and restore it and our education was designed by communists and pro western intellectuals in a way that we hate our country and there was no sense of pride in our country resulted in Hindi speaking states and people became scapegoats of that false history and even South felt but remain resistance becoz of our culture and pride in it..
4 Tamil is much older then even Sanskrit so bit difficult to accept Sanskrit itself than how can we accept its offsprings, you got know like Hindi many other South Indian languages have grown on their own over thousands of years with history, culture and only way too unify India is tell your North Indians to give respect too South language and mainly people becoz the amount of arrogance and superiority complex in North Indian to south people is deplorable that s also one of the reason why hate Hindi language and people just becoz you are in northern part you don’t become superiors in fact you people are one of the biggest reason India got an image of rapists and filthy country and no respect for elders..
5 we don’t need a common language when we have no problem communicating with others, English is international language that’s a need for jobs and follow up with western world, if western world was not so developed or some other eastern part of world like Japanese or Korean was giving job opportunities and Centre of world then we would have learnt that language too, Hollywood played its role in spreading English too… what we have to do is oppose western culture…imposing hindi will abolish all Indian languages and thousands of years of history culture attached to it over the period…
6 solution is seek out and tell original history, let all Indians know the truth and don’t make or impose any language or make 2-3 language as national language including a south language and mainly when you show some gratitude and respect to our people and culture na then you don’t have to impose anything they ll accept with open arms….
United dravidian states or United States of south India?
Indha Tamilnaat le dhaan Dravida per le makkal a yemathardhu. Dravida Aryan philosophy already debunked and dismantled. Say Southern Indian states.
🤧
If you still wants to do it on non Hindi speaking states,we will call for new country
Because of the British rule, today non Hindi mother tongue Indians facing all this language problem.
Let kannada grow and we promote kannada but not at the cost of any other language .
Dear BJP kindly give recognition to bhojpuri Language if you really respect diversity of India, My Language is dying due to Hindi imposition, Awadhi, bundeli and braj etc died from normal communication due to hindi imposition, Bhojpuri is One of the most spoken language of India, Mother tongue of East UP and Bihar is not hindi
English is and was the international link language.. Not there language formula. Hindi could be an optional. That's all
Hindi should be banned in every non hindi speaking states.
உங்களுக்கு என்னடா பிரச்சனை நாட்டுல ஆயிரம் பிரச்சனை இருக்கு இதெல்லாம் அடா உங்களுக்கு பிரச்சனை,புடிச்சவங்க படிக்க போறேன் உங்களுக்கு என்னடா எங்க மேல அக்கறை🧐
The anchor says English is a colonisers language by that logic Hindi also derived from Persian language. The debate in your channel going in English language comprising a Telugu speaker, Tamil Nadu, Bengali Then why we need to put an extra effort to learn Hindi language to interact with you.
Number or percentage can not be only criterion to select a language as national language. If number is only criterion then crows should be national birds and dogs should be national animals.
Speaking in regional language is very very important. Because when we speak our regional language automatically we are following our culture . There is a word called “Dating in english. There is no such word dating in our regional languages. Because we do not live together before our marriage. Regional languages represents our culture. One more benefit of speaking in our regional languages, our regional languages has tongue twisting nature, we live in canada, we were teaching our language Tamil to other kids. We found out that the kids those who speak indian regional languages first are able to pronounce any language with great clarity. But if kids start speaking english first , then they cannot pronounce any language . The kids those who speaking english alone , then their tongue is flat , is not ready for other languages. Even in tamilnadu, those days everyone learned both Tamil and sanskrit , so tamilans good in learning any language and they spoke English with great clarity. But most of the tamilans are learning only english, so even they cannot say the word tamil properly.
Very good analysis.
Thankyou brother Gautam Ghosh. Please encourage our kids to speak regional languages at home. If you can encourage our kids to enroll in RSS to follow nationalism and culture.
all central govt offices worker all north Indian in Karnataka no kannadigas were not given job.this govt impose by them it is kannadigas restored
kanaadicka
@@Ishant007 hindi benchod
Hindi our national language we have learn to know national issues , parliament sessions, politics but states opposing because they want to keep away their people from all those to keep their Power
Hindi is not a national language, it is just a love child of urdu and sanskrit dreaming to become a queen of all ancient langauges in South which is not possible even in next life.
Coming to national politicals knowledge, we have better and clear cut idea than you guys, and also, our state media translate every thing for us to let us know how shitty and under developed the northen belt is.
So please stop this lame narrative s.
Lol you guys speak as if south indians are loosing something and are in worst condition due to not learning of hindi. But the reality potrays a complete different thing.
Dear Hindi is not a national language it's just a regional like all other languages in India. And by the way most of the people from South India didn't speak Hindi. India is not a single state , it's a union of states, so to discuss any national issue you need to speak in the language which all people can understand.
Hindi is not national language don’t think rather we accept English as our national language too.. we want a language that can connect us and thats definitely not Hindi…
Reasons
1 Hindi is nothing but Urdu largely spoken by Muslims so definitely South Indian culture and people don’t connect to any thing that’s foreign language, I know there’s difference between Hindi and Urdu but they are like brothers so it’s big no, Urdu is national language of Pakistan..
2 a language should fill confidence and should give freedom to our mind so that we can think freely and that s key too lot of inventions you want an eg lot Indian inventions are from South Indians not north people eg non other than APJ Abdul Kalam even though he’s Muslim he embraced Tamil culture,
3 even after lot of invasions in north and Independence no govt tried to bring culture back and restore it and our education was designed by communists and pro western intellectuals in a way that we hate our country and there was no sense of pride in our country resulted in Hindi speaking states and people became scapegoats of that false history and even South felt but remain resistance becoz of our culture and pride in it..
4 Tamil is much older then even Sanskrit so bit difficult to accept Sanskrit itself than how can we accept its offsprings, you got know like Hindi many other South Indian languages have grown on their own over thousands of years with history, culture and only way too unify India is tell your North Indians to give respect too South language and mainly people becoz the amount of arrogance and superiority complex in North Indian to south people is deplorable that s also one of the reason why hate Hindi language and people just becoz you are in northern part you don’t become superiors in fact you people are one of the biggest reason India got an image of rapists and filthy country and no respect for elders..
5 we don’t need a common language when we have no problem communicating with others, English is international language that’s a need for jobs and follow up with western world, if western world was not so developed or some other eastern part of world like Japanese or Korean was giving job opportunities and Centre of world then we would have learnt that language too, Hollywood played its role in spreading English too… what we have to do is oppose western culture…imposing hindi will abolish all Indian languages and thousands of years of history culture attached to it over the period…
6 solution is seek out and tell original history, let all Indians know the truth and don’t make or impose any language or make 2-3 language as national language including a south language and mainly when you show some gratitude and respect to our people and culture na then you don’t have to impose anything they ll accept with open arms….
There is no national language....
All bengalis(labours) coming to kerala speaks in hindi not in malayalam my native tongue
We the northeast strongly opposed this. Even some students may commit suicide if it comes compulsory because they would fail. We r not Hindi speaking people. India is a diverse country. We include to India after independence we r princely independent states but we accept as Indian but imposing without concern is like a dictatorship. Day by day India is becoming dictator under bjp. So sad.
We tamils never let it happen.
True agree with you. For us northeastern Hindi is 3rd language and for me i cant read Hindi and Assamese clearly because of the languages my mother tongue, state language, hindi, English.
Won't worry brother entire South India with you.. Don't take such steps
Most of South states throw away hindi as 3rd language .. As a South Indian 2 language enough.. One is mother's and english..
Bro nothing will happen, amit Shah is just trying to divert some issues.
@@Attitudezero884 can't trust the bjp gov. They are crazy when comes to their north indian mindsets
I totally with Garga sir 💚
ha ha he is a big joker
Why? Because he appeases Muslims?
He is a joker
We need a common language.
If required historians should research on the origins of Tamil.
If it's the oldest one everyone can learn that.
@@seemyaboutsection8168 Certainly not Hindi. Modern day Hindi is full of Urdu words, and Punjabi / Khariboli origin expletives.
PS: People from Hindi belt should be forced to go multilingual. And there should be activie (positive) discrimination against them to compensate for, their "relative white privilege".
Hindi is not the mother tongue of many north Indians, we have Mythili, Bhojpuri, Marwari, Mewari, Avadh, Brij, Santhali. Totally different languages. Hindi supremacists have been suppressing the north Indian languages for a long a time by calling them dialects. Now, trying to suppress other old Indian languages of south India. This is a ridiculous thought to have one language to unite. We are already united as a union of India. We are a pluralistic country, where all cultures, languages have equal rights. English is equi distant from all language speakers of India. And also, English as an international language , when I as a Kannadiga , English opens an international gate for me economically, why would I need to forcibly learn another language within India, when I already know my mother tongue , that is Kannada.
How two persons will communicate each other is bilateral issue. How a third person Amit Shah dictate terms in between them ?
I can see the anchor is also supporting one side Hindi as national language. Please note that Hindi is not completely native to india. Its a mixture of Urdu, Persian, Pali and many other languages some are foreign. Name Hindi itself is Persian
One Nation One Roti ( Wheat Food) No Respect To Rice Food.
One Nation One Food ( Veg Only)
No Respect For Non Vegetarians.
One Nation One Language. (Hindi)
No Respect For Malayalam Tamil Telugu Kannada Etc.
One Nation One Agriculture. Only Wheat Cultivation No Rice Cultivation.
One India One Dress No Lungi Panja Mundu Etc Only Jeans And Shirt.
One India One Vote Only For BJP
use can use hindi as a second language
like us
@@Ishant007 Hindi is not our second language. English is our second language
12:53 The golden moment when the anchor and BJP spokesperson got rod at the same time.
But nobody is watching Hindi movies but watching regional language movies
Stop saying regional movies. Hindi too is a regional movie which is located in Mumbai, made by copywood. Every movie is regional and nothing is main or national.
That sign board matter LMAO 😂 😂 😂
Everyone should travel to different States in India too understand the uniqueness of each area. Unity in diversity not even Western Countries have achieved in that area of diversity. Diversity defines a Country than just one langauge etc. 565 Princely States were merged to form Union of India under currently 28 States and 8 Union Territories in Country named India / Bharath/ Bharatham. 🙏👍🎊🎉👏. I have travelled to many States and their no other Country in the World blessed with everything on Earth with snow capped Mountains, deserts, rivers, tributeries, animal's, flora, fauna etc.
The other day when Mr. Jayashankar spoke about India's neutral stand and abstention in UN meetings, his speech was so clear, I understood every word he spoke. I didn't know that he hails from Tamilnadu. He was fluent in English and was able to communicate the content so well. Everyone in the Parliament listened so attentively.
Suppose, Mr. Jayashankar should not speak in English, as per Amit Shah's logic, because it is a foreign language. Then in Parliament Jayashankar would have communicated only in Tamil, because he doesn't know Hindi. How many Parliamentarians, attending the session, would have been able to understand the content of his speech, let alone the general public all over India?
We need not denounce English, because it is a foreign language. In fact, it is English that unites the people in the whole of India, as experiene shows. Almost every State in India has its own official language. It is important to understand the content. A particular language, for that matter any language, is only a means of communication.
I like to share the following without intending to offend anyone.
Transport is a means of moving from one place to other. People are free to choose their mode of travel depending on the availability of financial resource, time, purpose and priority. People will make their choice.
Now, Amit Shah wants to raise the status of Hindi to that of an aeroplane, and insists that everyone should travel only by that mode. Reaching the destiny is more important. Let people choose the mode of travel. Amit Shah may have his logic, but how practical it is for the whole of India, which is multicultural, multi-linguistic, pluralistic, and with so much diversity?
Then Jaishankar must learn Hindi.
Funny thing to note the debate is carried out using English! Try this debate in Hindi with the same speakers from different states!!
We vehemently oppose the imposition.
If i am forced to speak in Hindi i will never..if I am I wish i will..Hindi can never be national language if so then all state language should be national language..Why Shah wants Gujarati which has rich culture and tradition to go extint to appease Hindi belt..If this happens BJP will surely lose all non Hindi speaking states
Muslim has become ricky mulla
@@explorerfoxy your cheap mindset guttar
I agree as a gujarati,hindi people who are working and staying here do not make any learn Gujarati,particularly all central gov jobs which are occupied by noth indians...Hindi should be abolished from all non hindi states
We don't take Nirmal sitharaman as tamilian we treate her as high caste religious hindu women
Shouldn't that be the case with Sundar Pichai, Subramaniam Bharatiyar, Actor Ajith, Cho Ramaswamy, Kamal Hasan, Indra Nooyi, MS Subbulakshmi and so many names I probably missed out? Why are you singling out just the Finance Minister? When it comes to Sundar Pichai, Kamal Hasan, Indra Nooyi etcetera why do you so proudly thump your chest, highlighting their Tamil roots. The hypocrisy of Tamil Nadu right now is actually funny
@@ashokseshadri8331 You forgot Chandra gupta mauriya and his bald head guru and all his followers.
@@ashokseshadri8331 it depends on behavior and attitude.
@@ashokseshadri8331 British government and Indian government's decision to teach hindi was stalled by protesters in 1937 after only English and Tamil... You motioned names above all well educated in English medium neither hindi not sanskriti.. English helped these people not you pani poori Hindi
@@moorthit6964 Who's supporting hindi? I am talking about Tamil Brahmin demonization and ostracization in Tamil Nadu. The people of tamilnadu are not consistent with their opinions. He pointed out the Finance Minister's caste. Not me.
Well resisted. Amit shah must learn a lesson.
Polarization by govt either by religion or by language!!
One Language one Nation
One religion one Nation
No!! The country is multicultural yet one Nation.
বাঙালিদের ভাষা শিক্ষা অন্বেষণে সবচেয়ে বেশি গুরুত্ব দেওয়া উচিত প্রাথমিক ভাবে মাতৃভাষা বাংলায় এবং তারপরে ইংরেজী ' তে..........
TRS made its point rock solid and BJP guy repeating the same thing
Is India is constituted oonly by UP.state. millions of money spend to propagate Hindi. Most of the Indians were able to work in foregin countries because of the English language knowledge.
If you come karnataka only kannada 🇮🇳
Bengaluru is full of hindi. 🤦
@@HariKrishnan-pe3ft some people talk but don't force to talk hindi 😒
Garga sir 💚💚
English is in India for nearly 300 years. More than 10% of India can easily converse in English. English should be considered very much as an Indian language.
Let us not get swayed away by random emotions but rather have the discussion or debate based on 'facts' and 'ethics':
(1) Based on discrimination:
The attempt from any Indian national Government of the day to declare Hindi as the 'national language' will make non-Hindi speaking people be treated by the Hindi-speaking people as 'second-class citizens in their own country. Hindi is NOT the mother tongue of the majority of Indians. Although English is a foreign language to Indians it acts as a good leveler in the sense that it is a foreign language to all Indians - it is foreign both to Hindi-speaking people as well as to non-Hindi-speaking people and so, everyone gets an equal opportunity to compete at anything. Replacing English with Hindi will give a massive advantage to Hindi-speaking people and this will be unfair to non-Hindi-speaking people. English is a neutral language and avoids caste/race discrimination that happens in Indian languages.
(2) Based on practicality:
Hindi practically has NO use in science or technology. Nobody can become a doctor/engineer/technician etc by just knowing Hindi. Hindi is just for entertainment through the overrated Bollywood insanity. English on the other hand is widely accepted on the global level and has more value to science, technology, communication, etc than any other language. English works as a link language practically. I have typed this comment on TH-cam entirely in English and people all over the world on social media communicate mostly in English.
(3) Based on uniqueness:
If the number of speakers is the main criterion for the greatness of a language then the 'crow' should be designated as the national bird of India and not the peacock or the 'dog' should be made the national animal of India and not the tiger. It is the uniqueness of a language that makes it great and not some population factor. If someone says that many people speak in Hindi in terms of some 40% of speakers then he/she fails to look the other way the majority of Indians (60%) don't communicate in Hindi. Hindi can mostly be read and understood only in North India, and probably in Nepal. But Tamil, on the other hand, is already official in Tamil Nadu, Sri Lanka, Malaysia, Singapore, and to some extent in South Africa. Also, Tamil, Telegu, Malayalam, Kannada, Marathi, Gujarati, Punjabi, Odiya, Bangla, Aasami, Urdu, etc. are classical languages and have been in existence in history way before Hindi.
(4) Based on imposition:
After independence, the states in India were formed on a linguistic basis. We have a Maharashtra for Marathi-speaking people, a Gujarat for Gujarati-speaking, a Tamil Nadu for Tamil-speaking people, and so on. Then why does the Hindi belt have many states even when they say that they have Hindi as one language? That is because the influence of Rajasthani, Awadhi, Maithili, Marwadi, Bhojpuri, Santhali, etc. languages was mowed down because of Hindi imposition and they were designated to the level of just 'dialects' of Hindi. Marathi used to be written in Mudy lipi (script) in the past but because of the Devnagri script imposition back in the 1950s for a set of languages like Hindi, Marathi, Konkani, Nepali, Sanskrit, etc. Marathi, Konkani, Nepali lost their influences. The only vague defense BJP gives is the mudy script of Marathi was continuous in nature and would have been difficult to get that type-written on the press - which is an irrational argument because the same press could typewrite all the other languages like Punjabi, Urdu, Gujarati, Kannada, Malayalam, Tamil, Telegu, Odiya, Bangla, Aasami, etc. and somehow just could not do the same thing for Marathi? Marathi people are facing the crisis for the reason that they are struggling to have a script for their own official use and the average Hindi person thinks that Marathi is some kind of a 'dialect' of Hindi. How ridiculous! Marathi historically came into existence way before Hindi was 'formed'.
(5) Based on the two v/s three language formula:
The two-language formula 'Mother tongue language + English' is sufficient. Three language formula doesn't make sense. What the 3-language formula does is that it wants the non-Hindi speaking states to have three languages -> mother tongue for within the state communication + English for communication outside the state to the rest of the world + Hindi for communication within India with others who don't understand English. This makes the Hindi belt to be selfish to just have one language Hindi as they will not bother to study English. Why should someone from Tamil Nadu or Bengal or Maharashtra have English to communicate with the rest of the world and Hindi to communicate in India when the same Indians can try to understand basic English? English is sufficiently practical as a secondary language.
(6) Based on the existing concept of India:
Hindi imposition will destroy the unity in diversity of India. There had been riots over this controversy since 1937, the 1950s, and the 1960s, and might happen now or later in the future. The idea of one nation, one election, one party, one uniform, one language, etc. all this oneness stems from the BJP's RSS ideology which was inspired in turn by Nazi Germany. It is harmful, racist, religiously intolerant, linguistically chauvinistic, and detrimental in nature. Tamil Nadu will be the first state in India to secede from the Union of India if Hindi imposition ever becomes a reality.
(7) Based on statistics:
Migration for work happens largely from the Hindi belt to the non-Hindi speaking states and not vice versa. So, now you see how grave the problem is in the Hindi backward belt. Non-Hindi speakers' tax money is taken to promote Hindi and a less or negligible amount is spent on other languages. Also, why is the taxpayer's money spent more on the promotion of Hindi and less or negligible for other non-Hindi languages? 60% of the budget is spent on Hindi, 20% on Urdu; for Tamil, it is 0, Bangla it is 0, for other languages it is 0; why? This is an utter disgrace!
(8) Based on pride and politics:
Pride goes before a fall and the average Indian is somehow blind to this and ironically remains to be. It makes Indians not only hypocrites but also narcissistic to its own neighbors. This is because the current BJP government is systematically trying to keep brainwashing the mass illiterate Indians on the internet through the IT cell and in the open rallies. The current BJP government is heavily influenced by the RSS. Before World War II, the RSS leaders admired Adolf Hitler and Benito Mussolini. Golwalkar took inspiration from Hitler's ideology of racial purity. The RSS since its formation opposed joining the independence movement against the British rule of India. Excessive pride will cause India's downfall. No wonder the RSS had its roots in Nagpur within Maharashtra (Golwalkar, Savarkar, Godse, Hegdewar, etc. were Marathis) and is now making the average Maharashtrian behave diplomatically two-faced as some kind of an illogical balance in the policy of appeasement for vote bank politics. Donald Trump in the USA, Scott Morrison in Australia, and Boris Johnson in the UK caused a lot of problems due to right-winged politics. People over there realized the mistake of voting for them and then overthrew the governments and brought center-left progressive governments back to power. In India, it is a big shame that people here are still mostly illiterate, blindly religious, and emotional.
(9) Based on nationalism:
India as a nation is different in concept compared to European nationalism. Nations in Europe have their own national languages because the influence of other languages in their own countries was moved down by a single language when the boundaries were drawn. In the European Parliament, they still have English as a practical link language. Some people state that China, Russia, Japan, etc. take pride in having their own national languages and not English and rely on translations all the time in dealing with other countries and not using English. But the communist crazy countries or the workaholic nations treat their own people in their own countries in un-democratic ways just to somehow economically prosper by degrading human rights. One-China policy is degrading Tibet, Taiwan, Xinjiang, and Hong Kong. Japan's workaholic culture is straining the working-class people in the name of pride. Germany was the victim of Nazi ideology in the past. People all the time cannot rely on memory or machine translations/translators and waste time when the same would come naturally in simple communication by knowing basic English. Even the Chinese have started to aggressively teach their citizens English. India had prospered before on global level only because of English and now we are going back.
(10) Based on globalization:
Once upon a time, there was a colonial power but it's all in the past. The English people are called 'gentlemen' for a reason - although colonial they were not as racist as Germans. The British Empire in the 1920s was the largest empire in the world at any point in history. Whether you like it or not like it - it happened and people all over the world were either directly or indirectly influenced by it. The UK, the USA, Canada, Australia, and New Zealand have the English Anglosphere with more geographical areas for economic opportunities. The USA is still the major global power and the internet in the 1990s popularized English even more leading to an increase in the demand for globalization. Nationalism has become useless in the sense that no country can be self-dependent now and the 'Athmanirbhar Bharat' strategy of the BJP government is notorious in the sense that being self-dependent will first hypocritically rely on Russia, USA, etc. for defense from China OR it will replenish the resources of the non-Hindi states to feed the needs of the impoverished Hindi states.
Majority of Indians are not linguistic experts so them learning other regional languages when in other regions is out of the question. Hindi and English are more familiar; If it ain't broke don't try an fix it!
The point is that why non hindi speaking people of India should tolerate the hateful spells and mockery done against them.
Why should we continue to be proud of a colonist language.
Cause it rocks.
Dumb view......Hindi is also a alien language....
Because Hindi is also a colonist language for us... non Hindi people...
@@bk9848 well in one breath you gave equated Indians with Mongols , Portuguese ,and British. I guess you are a list cause.
P.S. I am happy if Tamil or Sanskrit in made national language but your regionalistic mindset possibly cannot understand this. It’s was likes of you who sided with foreigners against Indians .
@@user-barnala as alien as English.
1st language -state language
2nd language - Hindi
3rd language - English
Clear view of HM
Fuck 2nd language English, hindi pani poori language
No need for 3rd language. Mother tongue and English is enough.
I am from delhi. And there are thousands of people from bengali here it is as worse as UP and Bihar. It is only state where still inhumane hand moderate rickshaw are used please check data of bengal and immigrant from them then talk about anything else.
may be they are from bangladesh. Now in west bengal over 15 of population is north indian, so clearly one can figure out which side is migrating more. By the way cuz of U Delhi walas india, with it's capital is known as rape capital of the world by many.
Should add sanskrit too..
Opp all r fools utter fools making dirty politics of language do not see so many importance it’s just an alternative to English they never stopped any regional languages
Did you not listen to the news reporter saying Amit Shah want HIndi to be spoken as the link language and not English'. What does that mean?? Obliterate English.
Hindi is not national language don’t think rather we accept English as our national language too.. we want a language that can connect us and thats definitely not Hindi…
Reasons
1 Hindi is nothing but Urdu largely spoken by Muslims so definitely South Indian culture and people don’t connect to any thing that’s foreign language, I know there’s difference between Hindi and Urdu but they are like brothers so it’s big no, Urdu is national language of Pakistan..
2 a language should fill confidence and should give freedom to our mind so that we can think freely and that s key too lot of inventions you want an eg lot Indian inventions are from South Indians not north people eg non other than APJ Abdul Kalam even though he’s Muslim he embraced Tamil culture,
3 even after lot of invasions in north and Independence no govt tried to bring culture back and restore it and our education was designed by communists and pro western intellectuals in a way that we hate our country and there was no sense of pride in our country resulted in Hindi speaking states and people became scapegoats of that false history and even South felt but remain resistance becoz of our culture and pride in it..
4 Tamil is much older then even Sanskrit so bit difficult to accept Sanskrit itself than how can we accept its offsprings, you got know like Hindi many other South Indian languages have grown on their own over thousands of years with history, culture and only way too unify India is tell your North Indians to give respect too South language and mainly people becoz the amount of arrogance and superiority complex in North Indian to south people is deplorable that s also one of the reason why hate Hindi language and people just becoz you are in northern part you don’t become superiors in fact you people are one of the biggest reason India got an image of rapists and filthy country and no respect for elders..
5 we don’t need a common language when we have no problem communicating with others, English is international language that’s a need for jobs and follow up with western world, if western world was not so developed or some other eastern part of world like Japanese or Korean was giving job opportunities and Centre of world then we would have learnt that language too, Hollywood played its role in spreading English too… what we have to do is oppose western culture…imposing hindi will abolish all Indian languages and thousands of years of history culture attached to it over the period…
6 solution is seek out and tell original history, let all Indians know the truth and don’t make or impose any language or make 2-3 language as national language including a south language and mainly when you show some gratitude and respect to our people and culture na then you don’t have to impose anything they ll accept with open arms….
I remember one panel discussion in which Chithra Mudgal, a writer stubbornly talks in Hindi eventhough she is well versed in English. What I want to add is that, Hindi as a language have its origin within 300 years. In that way, her forefathers could have been speaking some other native language. Isnt that true that, she lost her heritage on the way, a person without address?, an orphan?. Another gimmick is that, all regional languages more or less similar to Hindi is counted as a dialect of Hindi, thereby boosting the percentage of Hindi speakers. Isnt it a language terrorism and treason towards that languages which are much older and richer than Hindi culturally?. If thats so, add all south Indian languages together, because southerners can understand each other with little effort than hindi, for which only sign language can help them. Moreover, people of any language have to understand an important thing, that each language is an archeological and anthropological treasure, that preserved your identity for generations and will preserve it for generations to come. For eg., the 'Sangam' classical literature in Tamil describes the western border similar to Thar desert and Northern borders with white snow Yak ruminating under its favourite tree. Even many place names in Tamil Nadu exists in Pakistan, Afghanistan and Central Asia where native people do not know the meaning, but the Tamil literature has.(Ref: Talks of Balakrishnan IAS, Orissa)
Why only Hindi, make kannada or Telugu or Tamil or malyalam etc as link language.
हर किसी को 3 भाषा सीखने की जरूरत है
पूरे भारत के लिए पहली भाषा हिंदी
पूरे राज्य के लिए दूसरी भाषा क्षेत्रीय
तीसरी भाषा अंग्रेजी पूरी दुनिया के लिए
Hindi is also a regional language only like all other regional languages of india or official language like all other official languages of india thats it..
Why should we learn hindi as alternate to English.
Why not Tamil, malayalam, telegu, kannada, Rajasthani, Konkani????
Why is Garga's title Political Analyst. He seems to have no logical argument at all.
Why hindi?????? Why not Tamil Or Punjabi or Kannada or Marathi???????
When u bihari and UP wala....come to south india, learn the south indian languages....we are not the ones coming in throng to north india...it is these poor people from the so called hindi belt are coming to our lands...so technically learn the regional language.
Good reply .
Linguistic Controversy is not streaming in India. It is being created.
But why
DMK parent party DK's Periyar was fond of adopting English instead of Tamil. DMK purely taking the issue for political brownies. Mr Dhayanidhi Maran was made as union minister in UPA just because he was fluent in Hindi. They are trying to emotionally trigger people.. Nothing wrong in learning more languages.
I think there should be 2 Indias ..south India and Hindustan
Times now promoting pro Hindi conversation. Screen shows 44% of total population but the question is how many states? The states who speak Hindi has a huge population but that doesn't make their language superior or more important. The fact is except English India cannot have a single language to communicate..
Bjp divert topic bcos of petrol price hike
Poor fella....He is not aware of Jaishankar and seetharaman don't know tamil
People need phone, computer, business, dignity, level, enjoyment, education, job, on-site job, H1B visa, IoT, machine learning, cloud computing, robotics, drone... Uh... Many things... That is possible only in English... It's better to you to work honestly to improve education system, stop corruption... Show your true desh-Prem by these essential works... Stop Hindi imposition work... Stop providing freebie on Hindi languages... Many regional languages are almost in dying state... If possible call people to protect them..
Hello Guys... Respecting any language is nothing but wherever you go try to learn and speak in their local language... Otherwise you don't have any moral right to stay in that state ( South/North/East/ West State)....
Just 3 yrs after that they will be thrown out from there state
For the past 70+ years South Indians were imposed to learn Hindi in schools. This is the reason 40% speaks Hindi now.
Learn English since technology is more in English and it is evolving everyday and go globally. So it a must language. We don't need two languages for communication.we don't like a third person pushing down our throat something we dont want.
What advantage hindi will give to a south indian? How many languages a South Indians want to learn ? How may North Indians learn a south language apart from just saying "we are ready to learn". The North Indians comes to South India for job, but they are expecting south Indians to speak in their language apart from learning a south languages. If someone want to learn Hindi by own interest let him learn as the same way the north indians learns a south language.
North Indian's can learn Hindi very fast because there are similarities. Similarly south Indian's can learn other south langauges very fast. On the other hand it is difficult to learn Hindi by a South Indian and a south indians language by a North Indian
Many hindi wala r coming to tamilnadu. For job after learning hindi
Why India people are not accepting Tamil as indian national languages?
only tamil speak
Make sanskrit the national language, no problem...
not even 2% of people know Samaskrutam (Sanskrit). What the hell are you yapping about.
Dear, don't oppose just for the sake of opposing, 1st let's understand the issue here in north east.
Kodagu is a language doesn't have its own alphabet, they use kannada script. Tulu script has disappeared with time, they use Malayalam script in Kerala, kannada script in Karnataka. Santali lnguage doesn't have ots own script, they use Devanagari script in Jharkhand, Odia script in Odisha. Koshali language doesn't have its own script, they use Odia alphabets.
In North east each state have 3-4 languages. Many of them doesn't have separate alphabets for notation except a few. During British rule they imposed english alphabets to write those languages. But many pronunciation doesn't real match with english making a very difficult notation with english alphabets. Now either they have to use Bengali/Assamese alphabate (both are same except 1 or 2 letters), which they mostly won't like or they have to use Devanagari script. As devanagari script has distinct alphabate for each pronunciation, so it is more preferable than english. So they preferred devanagari script. They could've used Odia alphabets if the they were inhabitants of Odisha, they would've used Tamizh alphabets if they were in Tamilnadu.
Even Marathi language is written with devanagari script. Does that mean they are all Hindi. Hindi is just another child language, which adopted Devanagari script for its writing.
Hope you understood the point.
Dmk is doomed..
Everywhere in the World Counties are United because of their one Language Identity and of course Language is a parameter of Unity. We always have been fighting among each other because of Culture differences and more importantly different Languages that we speak. Todays Bharat needs only one Language to remain United or else we would again fight and get divided I am sure of that. Different Languages means different cultures, different opinion and different histories which would surely become a reason of Conflict in years to come and then fight for Independence from Bharat. Why Hindi? Well because Hindi is a direct Descendant from Sanskrit. Pure Hindi is a basic evolution of Sanskrit and that it keeps Sanskrit alive. Other languages might be also children of Sanskrit but they are difficult to be spoken and represent a culture sect. While Hindi doesn't represent a culture sect but represent the Philosophy of Bharat Varsh and is like the eldest Child of Sanskrit. Pure Hindi should surely become the National Language of Bharat because it would help to keep Bharat United for years to come and stop the unstoppable division of this country again due to so many languages and culture divisions
That’s entirely your opinion. I don’t see Hindi as language which would beneficial to next generation. English has already been deeply rooted in our education and professional life’s. We don’t need to impose Hindi or any other language on anyone. If there is a need, then it will be adopted. Does not matter whether it’s Indian originated language or not, imposition would never work!! We should move on from one nation one language idea, we aren’t 🇨🇳..
@@praneethpuligundla - For better communication, we all have to accept one language that is hindi as an official language. Many peoples feel uncomfort in expressing their views and ideas in english or other language as they express better in hindi. As we all know that different countries have different official languages and they feel proud to speak their own language but why can't we?
@@praneethpuligundla - The Indian Constitution states that Hindi should be the official language of India. It should be in Devanagari script. Still, many regions are not ready to accept this fact.
Though India has 22 languages, Hindi is the most widely spoken amongst all. Hindi is the 5th most widely spoken language in the world.
Even before independence, Hindi was considered to be the official language. Today, English is a global language but it does not mean that we should adopt it. We should try to promote our own identity.
Around 75% of the country resides in villages where people are aware of Hindi mostly. It would be tough for these people to accept English as their official language.
Hindi is your identity not mine, my identity comes from telugu i don't need to adopt some scriptless shit as my identity to prove my nationality.
@@WorkWizdom if they cannot accept english then ask them to stay in their bimaru places only no need to come to south.
I OPPOSE THE IDEA THAT HINDI DID FREEDOM FIGHT WHY SO MANY BENGALI FOUGHT FREEDOM AND DIED ALSO.WHO WERE NETAJI ? WHO WAS KHUDIRAM ETC.?
Albeit being a great supporter of BJP - this is sad - time and again this Hindi Push - Just because the Home Minister is not fluent in English and many of the Northern state leaders also struggle - they are looking to push an agenda to cover their short comings😂😂
All indian languages are national languages and Hindu can't claim to be the sole national language because it is spoken by a majority.