16,000 Miles in the 2023 Mini Cooper S | Long-Term Test Update | What’s It Like to Live With?
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 1 ก.ค. 2024
- After a year and more than 16,000 miles, our long-term 2023 Mini Cooper S is leaving the fleet. In this video, Edmunds’ Nick Yekikian looks back at our year living with the Mini, including what we liked, what we didn’t, how much we spent on maintenance, and more.
00:00 Intro
00:43 Pros
02:14 Cons
05:42 Maintenance
05:55 Edmunds' Take
Subscribe to Edmunds th-cam.com/users/edmundsv... for the latest car news, car reviews, car comparisons, car shopping and advice.
Visit us! www.edmunds.com - ยานยนต์และพาหนะ
After our year with the Mini, we still think the Civic Si and Golf GTI are more well-rounded machines. Would you take a Cooper S over any of its competition?
NO!! I would take the Honda over both.
I still drive my 2002 JCW MINI Cooper S. It hasn’t been daily driven for a decade. Still massively fun. It gets tracked a lot.
I would because I fit this car…
Always. Style counts!
@@danielwoodard680 Does it have a Turbo?
I’m sure glad this review didn’t come out BEFORE I bought my ‘23 two (3?) door! I’m loving mine. OK, I don’t have to wrangle car seats, but dude, if you need a bigger car get a bigger car. Why so much angst? My A/C worked great through the hottest Texas Summer I’ve ever experienced. The problem is the A/C controls are just plain weird, but once you figure it out . . . Oh, and definitely get the upgraded seats with lumbar-way better for longer trips.
People considering this car should realize that this is a recreational car and for most part is usually a 2nd or 3rd car in the household. Secondly, in my opinion it wasn't designed to traverse long distances like one does in the US (not that it can't) and hence the absence of creature comforts . Lastly, it's a single/dual passenger car and not meant for filling it up like a mini van with passengers and luggage. If you keep that in mind then it's an awesome car to blow steam off (if you can find some curvy roads) and a blast to drive making even the most mundane grocery runs to be fun. The Golf is a better option for folks leaning towards practicality but then it doesn't drive like a Mini...
I love my mini. 2023 Cooper s I bought it in Aug. of 2022. I’ve driven it from SoCal to Albuquerque NM and back with my dog (golden retriever) and it was a blast! Side note, do not crash this car. I did a few months ago, thank god for insurance, but the costs to fix are outrageous! Hit a curb nothing else. Over $8k to fix. Like I said, thank you insurance.
Love this dude!! Happy to see him in more Edmunds content :)
Also- this was a fantastic review of the mini! Was considering getting it, but this was excellent in helping me make the right decision!!
All you reviewers forget about ECO MODE…I have a 2014 Hardtop F56S putting out 280hp w 166xxx miles …in Eco mode @ 65-70 mph I’ve gotten 60mpg + on the highway with cruise set at 65mph…try it Peace
That review is pretty much spot on. I have a basically identical '23 MCS, but it came with Hankook Optimo run-flat tires. I think the Hankooks might ride a bit better than the Goodyear F1s. I find the Mini's suspension to be plenty comfortable for road trips and the cargo space (seats up or down) is more than adequate and there's also a large storage area under the rear cargo floor. There can be a good bit of road and/or wind noise depending on pavement surface and speed. I prefer using the iDrive controller and don't like using a touchscreen while driving. No android auto, but my android phone pairs up fine for music and calls and the integrated BMW navigation works better than android or Apple maps/nav anyway. The 7 speed dual clutch automated manual transmission is great. While I only use the paddles for a quick downshift now and again, pulling the shifter over into manual mode lets the car behave exactly like a manual transmission. That works great in traffic, through the curves, or in the hills. So it will drive exactly like a manual if you want it to. My MPG is similar, but I drive the car pretty hard pretty and have also seen greatly increased MPG on road trips. At 6'0 and on the large-build side, my wife and I both find the front seats and interior to be plenty spacious and very comfortable. Yes, the AC is kind of weak, but it worked well enough through our relatively mild MD summer. The heated seats and steering wheel work VERY well. I probably wouldn't make this my only car, but as a fun driving second car for commuting or weekends it works beautifully. I love the three door hatch style w/ frameless windows and the huge moonroof(s). Civic Si is a sedan/manual combo only with no heated seats. While the GTI may be a more rounded car for a single car household, I prefer the three door hatch style w/ the frameless windows. And I think I paid about the same for the Mini Cooper S as I would've ended up paying for a GTI or Civic Si. GTI prices have gone way up and Civic Si prices are still subject to dealer markup around here. I got $2k off the sticker of my well equipped Mini.
Excellent report
I'm looking to get a "personal" daily driver, something small but sporty, the Mini Cooper S as one of the choices, however my only concern is the ride on long highways and freeways, my daily commute is at least 30 to 40 miles, most of it on the freeway.
I'm used to sports cars, so i don't mind a little stiffness, but I don't know about the seats
That's exactly how I use my Mini. I have the base seats and I find them very supportive and comfortable. Freeway comfort is excellent. I'm 6' tall and about 240 pounds, and the seat are a nice snug fit w/ good lateral support and sufficient lumbar support (but no lumbar adjustment in the base seats) for me. There is a thigh extension on the base seats like the BMW sport seats, but I don't find that to be useful for me. The driving position is generally low and your legs will be extended more than you would expect in a typical sedan or SUV (reminds me of an old Toyota Tacoma pickup seating position - high floor and low seats). But I actually love that seating position in the MINI. I think there is an upgrade seat, but I find the base seats more than satisfactory. I've done 8 hour road trips and felt better at the end than I did w/ my Honda Odyssey or Nissan Rogue (and those both have comfortable seats too). No back ache or butt hurt. And I have some hamstring issues that typically show up on long trips, but not when driving the Mini. The Mini seating position seems to facilitate long term comfort. The synthetic seat material on the base seats is great and the seat heaters (optional, but typically equipped) kick ass. I don't find the suspension to be stiff, but my wife told me that she does. I'm also used to motorcycles and sporty cars, so I think it's relatively soft by those standards. But you'll want to dodge the big potholes!
@@wademorefield3797 thanks for sharing, my concern of getting the Mini are the seats, I don't mind the stiff suspension that much since I myself come from sports cars, but the seats are what matters (I'm 6'1 , 240 too)
Understood. I think you will find them very comfortable and supportive. They also have great adjustability, but no lumbar adjustment on the base seats.
I mean...if you need to complain about space then get a Mini countryman or clubman...Kinda weird to complain about that a two-door hatch.
Odd... I live in Florida and have never felt the a/c in my '23 Mini Cooper S couldn't keep up. Also couldn't help but feel there was a unfair amount of griping in this review. It's a Mini! I guarantee no one looking to buy this car expects to get a baby seat in the back. I consistently get 32 mpg with the manual transmission with fairly spirited driving.
I also live in FL, idk what this dude was talking about, my AC is SOLID
Two-door hardtop is definitely not a family car, more a 2+2. A 4-door hardtop or Countryman/Clubman are the more logical choices for families. As for the stiff ride on 17-inch wheels, I switched from 18-inch rims to 16-inch rims and got regular tires, instead of the runflats. Totally different ride, still fun to drive and race through corners without taking a beating.
I love my 2023 Mini Cooper S. Bought mine on Dec 2022. It's fun to drive and the space inside is just right for me. I must admit that the ride is quite stiff. Makes me want to cry everytime I hit a pothole. 😫 Not sure if I should change tires.
This guy is great. Give him more screen time.
Good point about Mini no longer being "mini". Someone fit an old mini inside a new one - literally. Practicality shouldn't be this compromised.
Did any interior rattles develop during your time with it?
Mini is perfect in ev form. I've had ice version and it was so bad at road tripping and great at short stuff at cities, that small range is no issue.
Idk why someone would try to put a car seat in the back of a 2-door mini
True. As far as I know, in the US manufacturers do that so that insurance and imports can be cheaper for the consumer.
The whole reason why so many 2 doors have tiny back seats, insurance
Exactly.
For their child 🤷♂️
Has more leg room then frs brz 86
Hertz gave me a mini countryman for rental....i'm just 5'3" and it was hard getting into the driver seat...the side support was way too huge....but the ride was great though
I'm sorry I disagree, the suspension is not that stiff, and the 17inc wheels are fine, if you really wanted to complain, try the JCW with the 18's. Mine has NO AC problems, and I live in FL, mines EXTREMELY GOOD. Next thing, MPG, I've gotten 38 mpg while doing 75 MPH in my manual, and filling up my tank if like 30 bucks and that with gas being $4 a gallon. And yes the trunk is small, but not "Jenga" bad, I've been shopping for a family of 5 to Walmart and no seats were folded. Oh yeah, and my 12 Y/O brother fits amazingly in the back seats, so they are not that small. Cope harder, and try again
I have. the S convertible and the only negative for me is the blind spot is huge. You turn your head and you see nothing but the soft top. The side window is not big enough. I have resigned to driving in the right lanes on highways because the blind spot makes changing lanes frightening.
I have the 2023 4 door (2nd MINI). Bought last year after owning a 2018 VW Golf TSI (Hated the handling).
I love my MINI but it's DEFINITELY lacking in tech.
-No android auto (I had to buy and iphone 🤢😂)
-Still push button entry... I was spoiled on the toughless entry.
-Still scooting the seats forward like a savage, no automatic.
-Even the back up cam is exposed so it gets dirty all the time and is useless in the rain. (VW's flips out of the rear logo emblem)
I was expecting so much more for a $38k car.
But I'm a MINI lover for life so I'm sucking it up. 🫶🏿
I have a 4 done mini, no problem
I need it for Dubái. AC 😢
Um, it's a Mini COOPER, not a Mini-VAN!
I know car seat regulations have changed but when I was a kid in the 90’s we had this old Chrysler minivan that had little fold out car seats in the middle row. They were genius and I loved them. I wonder why cars that are clearly not made for adults to fit in the back don’t bring back the fold out child seat or just make them obviously child sized seat belts with 5 point restraints? Just commit and make the back seat of a (insert sports car here) a toddler only zone.
I was behind a Mini the other day. He had his left signal on but it was a big right arrow. How confusing!
basically it is a two seater fun sporty enjoy driving car,,, enjoy it for exactly what is and meant to be. stop complaining and drive.... lose weight.
They want a MINI Cooper I repeat a MINI with the size of a Van, this is a nonsense video.
This dude talks way too slow. I had to run the video at double speed just to stay awake. 😉
Sorry dawg im just hyper haha
Host talks to fast. As a hearing impaired person you need new host. Sorry…..😢
Closed captions bayBEE--personally I'm glad I didn't have to go 1.25x speed on this one 😩
They made this so ugly. Can’t escape the horrible BMW design. Then there is the crazy high price tag for a non premium car. The car seat issue isn’t surprising considering car seats are now larger than most adults.
It's a clown car. No full size spare tire for long trips. Head gaskets leak due to engine mount bolted to head.