Jewish men singing Pink Floyd's "Wish You Were Here"
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 26 ก.ค. 2013
- Two guys playing music after midnight, in the wee hours of Sunday morning, on Jaffa Street in Jerusalem (July 2013). The guys are the talented Gat Brothers, Aryeh and Gil.
I'm a global photographer who flips on the video function of his camera only on rare occasions -- listening to these two musicians was one of those occasions.
I walk by these guys all the time when I go shopping. They are literally 3 blocks away from me.
Living in Jerusalem is very special indeed
Good to know they’re still there so many years later
I’ve been there …
I would like to visit one day.
@@marcinhaUK ..me also.
So lucky you can be.
Hug them from my, next time you see them.
Daniel from Sweden 🙏🇸🇪🇮🇱❤️❤️🙏
Never in my life did I expect to see 2 orthodox jews sitting down playing Wish You Were Here. The reach of Pink Floyd has no bounds it seems.
Bravo chaps, very nice.
We played this song at my husband's memorial. He was Jewish and a huge Pink Floyd fan.
The wife of my male cousin, played tribute to Elvis Presley during her mother’s funeral!
Freddie will be played at mine.. it' s in my will, page one .
Hello from Illinois!!! My husband died suddenly on December 20 2021. I have every bit of empathy for you. I understand hey you have a good holiday. Get back with me if u want 😎✌️❤️
@@tartaninka who is Freddy? My funeral will play Crazy Diamond!!! Actually shine on you crazy diamond will be engraved on headstone ❤️✌️😎
Sending all my love
just shows all they want to do is play pink floyd and live in peace
Very very well put I can’t understand why we just all get along
It doesn't matter who you are, we all love Pink Floyd
Or, at least smoked one while the record was spinning
🙂👏💫
Absolutely..
Ikr.. they're a gift from God.
Whole point of Pink Floyd
Pink Floyd breaks boundaries. It's just an amazing melody in our ears and brain.
Roger Waters is one of the biggest antisemites around.
They are so much better than the cover bands, I've seen over the years.
My favorite rock band
Indeed
@@tvdinner325 Come to St.Louis this summer and see El Monstero. You will love it I promise!
I remember watching and listening to these guys when I was in Jerusalem back in 2012. Great memories.
How true it's not the people it's the stupid government's I however prefer Music becauful some new rich some even old make a lot of money at are expence and kill our son's. This makes me feel better knowing your maybe family friend's and music and hell there's a lot more of us then them so maybe wise to 💘 thy neighbor.
I just don't understand that in 10 years there's only 15,200 views. It should, seriously, be a million. I mean, I sent this link to my siblings and asked one to show it to my mother (we live in different states) and ALL of us were blown away. It's a song I've long loved. Everyone in the family loves Pink Floyd. My late brother even had one of their posters on his wall.
There was something about this that made me want to cry. They just brought such emotion to it juxtaposed from what many usually expect from deeply religious Hasidic Jews.
11million views
Over 12m now. Wow you’re siblings have a lot of friends.
I have visited this video hundreds of times but don't always acknowledge the visit.
The universal language, MUSIC! That was Awesome!
❤
Music is the answer to bring people from every nation together .
Cant we all just get along
Here's Johnny Johnny why you gotta be so silly, we have Muslim, Jewish, Catholic, Christian , Hindu and many other extremists in the world, but they are just that, extremist! There are more nice Muslim,Jew,Christian, Catholic,hindu people in the world than bad ones. And God said... let there be music, and it was good. Nice job gentlemen.
The reggae singer Audrey Hall did a song called 8 Little Notes which basically gives this message. It was on the B side of her 1986 single One Dance Won't Do but I think it is better than the A side.
Damn straight! Instead of guns, bring out the six string and just jam.
Motorman 0057 that would be Jesus, but he is an offence to those not of God.
Music can heal… If we only take the time to listen. 😊❤
That’s simply wonderful, very moving in these troubled times
Respect from a Muslim :). We should make music not war.
❤️
Peace to you all❤
First, we must leave religions aside.
Thank you! Agreed
I couldn't agree more.
I clicked on this because it seemed too weird and surreal to ignore. Props to these guys, this was really good.
Ben Solera they must have never met any Hasidic Jewish people before, those dudes love to jam
I know those guys. Used to see them in Jerusalem all the time. It’s actually not very common to see Hassidic people playing secular songs. They are unique because they were born and raised secular and become hassidic later in life. They are born again hassids :)
Ben Solera go to any Dave Matthews band or phish show and you would know this haha
DeMarc DeGasol
First I would have to kick my own ass for going to see a Dave Matthews concert.
There is no possible reality where I would ever be a willing attendee at a Phish concert, I’m not a big enough douchebag.
Peter Anon This is in my top 5 favorite songs, and I’m picky and weird. Glenn Miller is in there, and these guys nailed it. Very beautiful voices.
I am born in Muslim family but love JUWISH people... ❤❤❤
If there is one thing that can bring us together, it’s the appreciation of good music!
I'm here in 2021, absolutely brilliant. Peace be with everyone.
I say i wish we could just get back to normal. Im not sure what normal is anymore. Kinda confused i guess. Music always makes it better in the end though. Stay safe everyone.
@@oldguy7144 you be safe and well brother.
@@chillinOkie I feel music goes hand in hand with love and peace, can't remember ever being hateful at music.
Well said friend ❤️❤️
And you,kind sir
One of my favourite pink floyd's songs was in re-hab when this came out. Eventually i got the message 29 years clean and sober. Thank-you pink floyd and this version goes to show we can all live together 💎
Paul Potyka: Isn’t that boring?
Congratulations. 💛
@@kthekeeper5117 Literally one of the most obtuse and ignorant comments I've seen on youtube, congrats.
@@FrenchDanceParty: And I still don’t give a fuck about your opinion.
Xxxx
G'day from Melbourne Australia..love your music...music is universal...it brings everyone together..regards Karolyn Melbourne
I've been listening to Pink Floyd for 40yrs....one of the best bands in history and I've gotta say these 2 nailed it...Fantastic 🕶👍
Got ya beat. 53 years here.
Absolutely, think these might have been in Ashdod in 2014 brilliant rendition...
For 40 years and you still don't know their frontman is a antisemite? 🤔
Well I certainly didn’t expect to be watching this
You and me both my friend. They do way better than me and my buddy
🔵 Well...I certainly didn't expect to
see your comment here.
@@joshhayl7459 who is this. Do I know you
Same
I almost cried, I got so emotional watching this
Now these Jews rock 😀 god bless and protect ❤️
'Never judge a book by its cover'.....They are freakin AWESOME
jim dartouzos Uhm, aint that what bookcovers are for?
@@awesomewelles9174Hi Awesome. ... uh.....I guess that you're correct...l Love that name Awesome. ....that is Awesome
@@awesomewelles9174 to make you curious what's inside😏
@@awesomewelles9174 No, they ain't. As Tom wrote, they're there to arouse curiosity and interest.
Deep down we're all the same. The rest is just window dressing.
Music is magic! It has no race, color or judgement. Just beautiful.
Definitely. Listen to Johnny rebel's Coontown. Most inspiration non-judgemental song.
Penguin Penguin Penguin Penguin Penguin Penguin Ahaha.
Rap🧐
256101120 music can also indoctrinate people to vote Democratic
Joe Rodriguez ok
This is a great cover of a wonderful song by Pink Floyd. A damn good job men!!!!! Well done!!!! ........... Thank YOU two!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Awesome! This was a delight to watch!
Nothing short of spectacular.... beautiful sound
Music has no boundaries, only endless possibilities for love and peace. ✌
Copyright theft.
Oh absolutely excellent !! ❤✌This is what TH-cam and the internet is really for . Thank you gentlemen and Joel C.
Ikr, not like the sh t I upload! th-cam.com/video/3Bu3kudf8As/w-d-xo.html
AMEN and AMEN
Guys, HERE is Our Savior
YaH The Heavenly FATHER HIMSELF was Who they Crucified/Pierced for our sins and “HERE IS THE PROOF”
From the Ancient Semitic:
"Yad He Vav He" is what Moshe (Moses) wrote, when Moses asked YaH His Name (Exodus 3)
Ancient Semitic Direct Translation
Yad - "Behold The Hand"
He - "Behold the Breath"
Vav - "Behold The NAIL"
Bravo! I love Pink Floyd, have been a fan for over 40 years these men did this proud!
There is more that unites us than divides us in this beautiful world. Let’s all focus on what unites and grow with love
This is fantastic! Underscores the reason why you should never judge someone by their looks, color, religion, race, etc. We are all human and music is the universal language. Peace to all from Toronto, Canada
You are so Right 🙏❤️❤️❤️❤️🙏
And the same to you!!☮️♥️✨
1000% accurate....
But it just isn’t really it kind of is but your culture has a huge effect on your musical taste and how u have learned music what music theory’s your most likely to prescribe too how u notate music
I feel like saying music is a universal language leaves out a huge amount of nuanced
As a black guy from Columbus,Ohio who loves Floyd I wish I was there👏👍
...try "Someone Of Great Renown". Robin Trower. Guitarz Master.
No no jewish you were here lol
I am also from cbus, and love floyd....although I'm a white girl....respect
O-H!!!!! COLUMBUS IN THE HOUSE!! 😎
Whats race have to do with it 😆 keep separating urself and blaming the white man
Gotta love this...deep rock and soul from the most religious people on Earth.
I love your comment. Have a wonderful day have a wonderful week have a wonderful life.😊❤
Not sure that "the most religious people on Earth" is any kind of compliment, given what religious people do.
My biggest surprise today! After everything's going on in the world I loved to see something good.
How beautiful is this ❤️
Spread love not hate
Music not war
From Tunisia
More of this! Less hate!
Then everyone needs to stop being religious.
Spread true not lies, spread Jesus life not hate Jesus, like Jews do
@@paintingholidayitaly
I wish..
@@paintingholidayitaly most people only know a few tropes about the Jewish people. They don't want people to know who they really are like a vampire getting him with the sun. They are wolves in sheeps clothing
The Floyd is bigger than all of us.
...May the Floyd be with you...
Paulabella And also with you.
Mr Floyd😂😂😂👹
No truer words.
Your comment made me smile!
for me it is just fascinating, i live in Oklahoma U.S. im quite poor and have never really been very far from here. i do not now how i picture modern Jerusalem in my head but this was probably not it, it is after midnight and the street is bustling with all sorts of people and life. it would be very interesting to experience.
Never tire of this music, classic, will still be played in a hundred years and more
Pink Floyd.
It's for everyone.
Peace not war, happiness not sadness. Love not hate. Pink floyd, these 2 men out did themselves. Beautiful.
And the lord said unto them, “play this tasty jam”
James Gearring better pull out your dictionary this man can’t spell revelations
LOL, thanks for the laugh.
😂
Amen brother....
Ah yes. Traditional jewish folk music.
Great music brings us together..(c)rap tears us apart. Good job guys ✌
This video just came up on my feed, and all I can say is WOW!!! What a awesome performance by these men!!
Respect from Lebanon
😀😀😀from israel
he said respect from Lebanon he didn't say that its from Lebanon
+Anas Mouakkil and the other guy meant "respect from israel" he didn't meant to say this video is from israel.
יובל לאידוע ahhhh got it sorry about that :)
Blessings bro 😎
This is so cool and unexpected.
I was in a bar in Florida and a Russian Guy walked in and seen the piano and said can I play . Sure. He started to play show tunes and then asked me what I like. I said Pink Floyd , really meaning Not show tunes. He then proceeded to play Pink Floyd on the piano for about 2 hours . It blew me away, he was fabulous. I never would believe that Pink Floyd could sound so good on just a piano.
I never seen him again .
tackless: I love encounters like that. Thanks for sharing!
tackless I just want to let you know that it was me.yes it's me. see u in Florida again my friend
No he did not SEEN the piano he SAW it. Education past the 3rd grade is a great thing. Also he did not SAY 'can I play' he ASKED.
That is the f#@@ing problem with these a$#holes, grammar makes them more suitable to comment on music and life experiences is the expectation it seems!!
arrogant dick is far too high praise
Excellent! Thank you for the listen (lesson).
Wow what a great performance!
I can remember seeing someone on the street who looked like this and thinking that we must have nothing in common. Shows how wrong I can be!
Dennis
So true, who would have thought they would be enlightened by Pink Floyd
No judgement here
And to think about sleeping with them in college!
@@lisaschuster9187 both of them?
@@lisaschuster9187 Why specifically in college?
Kudos! It takes a lot of humility to write something like this.
Some can okay music, but few can replay the feeling perfectly! These gentlemen are amazing, the way the younger one uses his vocals with guitar just like Gilmour!! 🖤👊🏼🤘🏼✌🏼🇺🇸🇮🇱
Awsome, shows we can all something great reguardless of our religion, nationality, political beliefs or any other label.
This is magnificent, i wish I could see them. I love it. Much respect from Greece Macedonia Thessaloniki. ❤️🐬🦋🐳❤️
Once thee were many Jews in Salonica.
A real eye opener.
They're Awesome!
Love the lead guitar!
This is the power of music. Watching in the Holy month of Ramadan and praying that we all come out of this storm as one nothing but human beings.
Love from Pakistan!
Haseeb Khan that's not the will of God.
Kaelon Gorke true that's not the will of the Ibrahimic God of Islam Allah and all his ideology. Islam strictly differentiates between KAFIR the non Islamic infidel unbelievers and MUSLIMS the believers. Hence there is absolutley no scope in these religions to be purely Human Beings. So stop dreaming Mr. Haseeb Khan.
Haseeb Khan I hear you my brother from Pakistan. I'm a Christian from Austin TX! What difference does it make right. We all breath the same air. Want the same thing. Clear air and water peace for our kids. Watch them grow up in a world that is not killing itself and each other. Keep the faith brother and sisters out there. What ever faith that might be.....
Peace! Love!
Haseeb Khan - Amen.
GalacticPenguinTV You mean the Holomdor? Perpetrated by the Jews? You know there's a reason Waters won't go to Israel. And the Talmud is as bad as the Quran.
Good music knows no barriers fantastic guys play on.
Well said
I'm not even sure what barrier you're even talking about 🤔
Ok thanks for your permission
A beautiful rendition of a song that I first heard 38 years ago and still haunts me every time I hear it to this day,
As David Crosby wisely stated, "Music is love." No matter the ethnicity or creed, truth and love overcomes.
ERIKA!!!
Lol some songs honestly don’t preech love at all I’m sorry your really giving a big slap to common sense and ethnomusicology
@@leachlurker3569 AHH!!, but are they 'songs'? Or are they melodramatic rapping / screaming?
This song gives me a mental breakdown no matter how often I've heard it. We all have loved ones we wish still were here
No truer statement has ever been said... I miss my Mom and Dad. Id give anything just to hear their voices again
@@scottgoad6459 They are with you NOW.....I promise....just on a different plane... promise...🐌💜☮️
Same here😩
O' the beautiful fragrance of those distant memories. So true my friend.
Much Acho - Yes we all do have loved ones that are gone, but they are not gone forever... They are very close by, and know about us. They are exactly the same they were before they left... And We will be reunited with them someday, for Eternity...
God Bless you and yours !
Fran Danco
One of the coolest things Ive ever seen ! Goes to show we may have our differences but we arent really that different . 🇺🇸
@Atheos B. Sapien if using the same 2 words a hate group used makes me a bigot so be it 🤣. You have to be a 🤡 liberal
And some people think we’re so very different. I like this a lot.
We are very different.
TH-cam have been recommending I watch this for months, tonight I finally got round to it. Glad I did, far better than I was expecting
Very cool. They're on a Hasid trip.
Haaaaaa! 👍🏾
This should be top comment
LOL and then again and again! Righteous!
Looks like they should be playing ZZTop.
Easy now Mr. Currie.
As of last August, they're still playing on the streets of Jerusalem. They're pretty amazing to see live!
Gonna have to head out to the holy land to visit the lord and these fellas
Ive seen the older one busking on his own. Very good
Is that in Mamila?
Shaw Tael the description says Jaffa street
@@matthewzarris9177 wat other songs do they cover?
Beautiful song. Great to see the guys singing a Pink Floyd song dressed in that way
My favorite song from Pink Floyd..It's beautiful
Saw a guy from indonesia, thailand, even from africa and now this. Just proved to me one thing...music transcends all boundaries!!!❤️🤟✌️
Christian Jewish or Muslim, we all need to sing together more often...
Totally agree with you Justin.
Music brings us all together and brings joy
Yep.....take a break from killing each other and rock some Pink Floyd!!
Tribalism will, likely, always win out in the end. It is human nature, imbedded for millions of years. When push-comes-to-shove, we will always revert to the basic instincts of our animal brain. It's how we have survived for millions of years. When someone attacks your family, are you going to stop and sing a song with them or are you going to fight for survival?
@@tonyheaton4941 well I disagree with your worldview of millions of years and animal evolution.. scripture is clear we all have a fallen sin nature and are alienated from our Our Creator and God and He has provided a way of reconciliation through the cross of Christ . He who knew no sin became sin that we might become the righteousness of God through Him .
Grace and Peace ✌🏼
Don't forget atheist
2023 here Awesome guy's. Loved to have been there singing along.
Lovely ! These guys talented and what a gift of a voice , the crowd clearly loved it as well. Thank You
They killed it! Loved it!! Everyone knows how difficult it is to cover Pink Floyd but they did, in my opinion, a great job! Kudos!
this is the easiest floyd song to play lol
I've seen many people butcher this song over the years. Great cover
i cannot think of a better way to spend the wee hours of a sunday morning than in that crowd, on that street, with these two blokes providing the tunes. thanks for posting.
That was so much better than I expected when I clicked on the video! Brought a smile to my face and a warm feeling in my heart.
Beautiful, thank you.
"Just 2 lost souls swimming in a gefiltefish bowl, year after year!" Kudos to you gentlemen, fantastic rendition!
haha i saw what you did! good one.
Cannot stop laughing!
I like what you did there!
Ian Redmond - well done Ian, well done.
Haha goddamn
Wow! I think world peace happened in a few minutes... chillbumps ... peace to all who watch. So beautiful.
Chill bumps 😂
Absolutely amazing!!! thank you so much, really enjoying it!
Wow and Awesome. I LOVE Pink Floyd. Music transcends all things.
The musicianship is incredible and this gentleman has a beautiful voice. Very heartfelt and 😊 lovely.
I didn’t expect this at all. Life is truly an amazing journey.
This is a favorite song of my lifetime! Your performance of it was exceptional! I will enjoy listening to this again and again. You gentlemen are wonderful❣
In peace and love
Jewish people are beautiful people and beautiful voices thank you for gracing us with your amazing talent GodBless you forever amen
What an oddity, yet maybe not, purity and reverence towards "a song". What a pleasant surprise, even a joy! Thanks for sharing the performance with us.
Another reminder, music bridges the divides.
Amen
Ramen
If only forever✌️
that's a nice thing coming from a "GAS Man"
Stuart Houselander you racist sack of shit.
I keep coming back to this. So unique! So good
Haunting, beautiful, we are all one. What matters is what's in our heart.
A song that cuts across time and speaks to everyone
Life and humanity cuts across and speaks volumes to everyone.
This was wonderful. So unexpected and so good. I wish it didn’t stop so abruptly.
Exceptional ! Outstanding!
im a floyd fan and was blown away when i saw these guys do shine on you crazy diamond, while the ad is playing i thought i come here and predict wish you were here will be outragously great as well.
EDIT: its like im psyhcic
Music goes beyond anything bad in this world, This video made my day !
Peace and music to everybody on this planet !
I love this, its so beautiful and these guys are talented. It's really hard to cover a Pink Floyd song.
With all my heart, thanks for this.
Wow! This is amazing. Sounds like Pink Floyd.
respect from Holland
respect uit België :') rechtreekse concurrentie! haha. nee grapje
Why not? Music is music. Brings the world together!
Amen my friend
Military band.
Human People makes good music 👍👍👍
Music is healing and unites people! Great performance! Thank you! 👏👏👏
Peace everyone, this was lovely, thank you.
MUSIC!!!!.... The sound of the soul. Cuts through all cultures. God Bless Music.
My heart is full of joy at the musiccoming from these two lovely humans
Wow they sound great
Two wonderful Jewish men , talented as Jewish are and beyond ! Thanku from Australia ♥️