Pink Floyd - Comfortably Numb ( original members )
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 7 ก.ย. 2024
- David Gilmour / Roger Waters/ Nick Mason / Richard Wright
July 2, 2005 at London's Hyde Park.
(" When I say original members, yes Syd was an original member, before David Gilmour. Comfortably Numb the song has all the original members that either sang , wrote or played are the original members for this song! ") Syd did not sing , play or write for this song.
David Gilmour . "Any squabbles Roger and the band have had in the past are so petty in this context, and if reforming for this concert will help focus attention, then it's going to be worthwhile."
See Full concert
• Pink Floyd - The Last ...
Question - Did Syd Barrett Sing, write or play guitar on Comfortably Numb ?
Short answer NO.
Pink Floyd - Comfortably Numb ( original members ) is correct !
Gilmour, Waters , Mason, and Richard Wright either Sang, Wrote , or Played on this track.
Had the title said Pink Floyd - Astronomy Domine with that track playing here it would have been wrong
David Gilmour was not the original member that played on that song.
Absolutely , Correct
Yeah i read a comment that said not original members, they DO NOT READ ,(Comfortably Numb ) they seem to know it all...read the info given, Your are Correct HDP
its those mr know it all s, duh it says original members , but if you could learn to read, it says Comfortably Numb , unless Barrett somehow sang , or played on this..
READ WHATS IT SAYS or go back to school, Thanks HDPinkFloyd, the best Floyd channel by FAR
Lol, Who's the dumb dumb that asked that question?
Richard Wright has not sang, wrote or played anything on this track. Correct me if I'm wrong.
Just some old guys in jeans playing some of the finest music you will ever hear. No flash, no bling just pure talent.
And that is the understatement of all time. I can't even talk about it....
Every time I watch this, I'm so sad this can never happen again. As you say, old guys in jeans with total control over their craft. Perfect.
Summed up perfectly
La creme de la creme!
I called David Gilmour as the one of the best guitarist ever
Gilmour's second solo is one of mankind's greatest achievements.
Agree. 100%
No doubt about it, the notes he hits, and more importantly holds, is brilliant.
Gilmore's voice takes me to a peaceful place 😌
Every note is perfect. It's just amazing.
Oh. I concur
glimours solo is enough to make a grown man cry. the absolute best there ever was. living legend
Yes sir he surely is the best ever in my book
@@janilane2599 we share the same book. 👌👌👌
Dude! I totally cry with that solo
@@martinperezvargas4814 everytime martin 👌 im crying alot more trying to learn it 😂
@@ocahan27 If you make it, you'll become in God haha
They came out, played a short set, and showed everyone why they're arguably the greatest band that has ever existed.
Golden god
Великих к счастью много,к сожелению раньше.щас уже всё хрень. Спасибо им что были и есть ещё.
Top 3 anyway
Something really matured musically together. This was their best show.
@@taylordwciao amico! 🙋♀️😍😘💘🌅
The solo is not something you hear , it's something you feel.
Absolutely spot on! The whole of Floyds music is feeling.
It's inarguably the most legendary solo of all time. Still gives me the chills
@@JoeStroup774 I would go one step further as it will always be the most legendary and best solo ever composed. I to this day still can't grasp how it gets overlooked time and again.
Its a perfect example of how 6 strings can move the soul and say things that have no words to express.
Love the way you put it. So true, I can feel it like it's so real!
Jorge Trelles So right. You said it perfectly!😎
Let’s be thankful that the 4 of them put their differences aside for this. This being their last live performance they simply hit it out of the park!
They didn't. Gilmour, smiles aside, did not want to do this in the first place and was very annoyed at being browbeaten by Waters and Geldoff to do it. The hostility never abated. I am glad that in the end Richard Wright got his chance to do this again.
@@Azabaxe80 Gilmour did the right thing by playing.
@@Azabaxe80 I’m glad they did it! I’m still not sure exactly why they broke up. I wasn’t a real big fan back then as I am of Gilmore now. Maybe you can help me out a bit! One thing I do know; sooner or later, this happens to every band. Sad!!
@@gregorycarlson6632 I would recommend that you read Mark Blake's excellent "Comfortably Numb: The Inside Story of Pink Floyd". It's really well written and documented, and it puts everything Floyd into proper context.
@@Azabaxe80 Thank you!! I will do that! Is it a book or an article?? I just read a pretty good story on Google. Pretty sad! No wonder Gilmour seemed hesitant to join the others with their arms around each other!! Have you seen David live in Pompeii Italy?? Comfortably Numb as the closing number . Best light show I’ve ever seen; in person or on tape. Check it out if you haven’t already!! Thanks again for the info!! 😊👍
One of the greatest moments in music history
I agree wish I could have been there. I am in awe.
Definitely.
Agree
@@Antares070 ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Уважаю и обожаю***
ВАС ВСЕХ😢
In the terra planet history
I am leaving this comment here so after a month or a year when someone likes it, I get reminded of this masterpiece 😍
Friendly reminder 😊
Truly a masterpiece!❤
Mesmo que você queira, jamais esquecerá dessa música. Come back!
Watch it again, its my next door neighbour favourite song lol
I was 28 when this song was released and here we are, 45 years later, still admiring Pink Floyd's genius.
2:05 Manson: "Fuck off headphones, here comes Dave's solo!"
Good every body 😍 can hear this
It’s Nick Mason, not Manson. Manson is dead.
I’ve come to appreciate that even more over the years
Yeah iI saw thst
"Fuck it ill do it live"
When the solo is almost as long as the rest of the song but “it’s still too short and everyone wants more of it”
Natog1 1 .' '
It is like drug which makes you addicted first three note.
It'e about three months to short.
For theres only 3 best solos...
1. Staiway to heaven madison square
2. Confortably numb PULSE
3. Hotel California Washington
Subhodoy Maitra The pulse version is mind blowing
Did every one else see Nick Mason throw his headphones off to listen to the solo???
michael fountain yes cause music is music
Yes. I noticed that one to 😂
Where’s the time stamp?
@@jaded9247 2:06
I did, epic....thats a musicians musician if ever.
The last 3 minutes of the song are the absolute finest 3 minutes in music history. I remember, way back in the day when people had REAL stereo systems, my father would go help our friends and family set up their systems and this was the song my dad would play to make certain that the system was absolutely perfect with the true test of speaker quality, and volume, being the last 3 minutes of this song. Some of the best memories i have of my dad is us laying on the living room floor in front of the stereo and literally melting into my mom's shag carpet 🤣 i miss you dad but I'll never forget those times ❤️
Beautiful memory to have Dad is watching over you .
@David Gilmour Official Honored to read your post, Sir. Best wishes and God’s blessings for you and your family.
At 83 my dad liked Floyd also. i think of him when i hear this song.. I really miss my dad a lot .Love you dad and i miss you! I'm going and cry for a while now.
Your dad was a giant! My dad was a major jazz player, and he despised rock music. I played for 40 years before I got to play Pink Floyd. Retired now, I listen to all the music I missed….over GREAT earphones at an absurd volume!
not literally.
43 years since it came out but this solo is still a timeless masterpiece in the history of mankind
no arguments here
Made more epic, I do believe, by the fact a guy wrote the lyrics and another guy then composed the song. Absolute musicianship.
Like
@@jspntr was
Them must Du Mund halten
At the hospital, when I'm suffering from a heart condition
I think playing this song in my brain gave me the power to live.
Thank you.
Hope you have recovered and are doing well friend! Many prayers and good vibes headed your way!
Thank you for your message.
Let's do our best without losing to COVID-19! (・ ∀ ・)
Good luck! How is it rn?
@@carlneoh5843
I thank you for your words.
Let's be careful about each other's lives!
How are you doing now?
The line “the child is grown, the dream is gone” is so profound.
And true. So many of us who were Flower Children in the 60s became 'successful' and comfortably numb in the late 70s. As Jackson Browne also opined, ".. in the end they traded their tired wings for the resignation that living brings."
every year is getting shorter never seem to find the time, plans that either come to naught or half a page of scribbled lines, hanging on in quiet desperation is the English way, the time is gone, the song is over....
The dream is GONE 😭!
Let thy heart fall back to its youth...
The story of too many of our lives.🤔
My dad was a big fan of PinkFloyd... i use to put his The Wall vinyl to play every single Sunday morning when i was in his house. He used to wake up and sit with me to hear the whole thing and only then we would have breakfast on a near by bakery.. i was only 9 or 10 yo. Miss you so much dad! ❤️
Siete voi i grandi della terra. ❤
🎉😢🎉
I was in my own band playing in bars...and I am ONLY seventy two, TOO!🎉
😂❤🎉❤😂
This was a "Mom and Dad finally talk to each other at Xmas" moment for most Pink Floyd fans.
Regrettably, it didn't last long. Damn shame.
@@mcoleman6834 What were they gonna do, drag it out like all those rockers who become naught but a self parody. This was just right. 😀
@@goodpeopleoftheworldunite whatever the problem, the legacy matters most.
@@goodpeopleoftheworldunite well they're not getting any younger and two members have already passed, it'd be nice for them to at least be on good terms before it's too late
@@ainiesta4858 dont think that they are on bad terms.. david and roger are not friends and never were.. it is sad but it is true. They both said it and there's nothing we can do about it :D their writing talents were friends, not them
02:05-02:07
Nick: "I want to listen to the "Comfortably Numb" solo."
"After all these years?"
Nick: "Always."
ele te respondeu??? caralho!!!
@@alessandracaliento4728 , I'm just joking. It's that moment from "Harry Potter" when Dambledore asks Severus Snape, "After all these years?" meaning if Severus still loves Lily. And he responds, "Always."
That makes two of us. I will never get tired of playing this song.
always
Undefeated_Romantic you copied the comment
Gilmour:The heart
Waters:The mind
Mason:The body
Wright:The soul
This 4 forces to make the greatest rock band of all time:Pink Floyd
Syd:the creation
Barrett: The Cells and The utero
Very beautiful comment my friend...
waters thecomunist
Well put!
Possibly the best song ever written and the solo is just from another world. These guys are living legends!
O it’s not. Pink Floyd is great . try Beethoven.
Listening to today for what would of been my husband's 70th Birthday- his all time favorite song. We saw them live several times many years ago Happy B-Day sweetheart!
Bless you both and may your reunion be a beautiful thing when the time is right - until then keep loving all the good things and they will love you back 🙂
God bless you Cheryl.
Happy belated birthday to your sweetheart ❤❤🤘
Love from Canada, Cheryl.
Happy birthday.
The second solo never fails to give me the chills, absolutely incredible.
Same here. The best solo ever. Spine tingling.
@@alibobsmarland9572 9t why ttt
@@vilegod3025 ??
@@alibobsmarland9572 Pot and walking up that stairs is one he'll of a combo
I always think about some kid hearing it for the first time back then.
Imagine 20 years later on a random day you hear this song from your kids room at full blast...
This is a reality for me already. My dad introduced me to great music and I’ve done the same with my sons.
@@dalvarez8166 cool I like this song do you
In that day I will sit in front of his door and wait for the song to finish , then I will get in there , tap replay and turn the music up even more while looking at him proudly
That day , my friend , I would know that he is no more a boy
He is a man.
@@mohammadrezaroohi4643 I like it man thx for commenting you the best and everyone els who commented
That will be example of good parenting
Gilmour’s voice is absolutely beautiful. His solo on this song is absolutely mesmerizing. First time I heard it I was in tears and I had chills all over.
His solos on this song are my all time favs. You feel the song and get it by the solo alone. You can feel the sorrow in it.
Parenting done right:
When your 22 year old daughter comes for a visit, and this song is blasting from her car speakers, and she closes her eyes and sings along after parking said car
The best moments in parenting is when you realize your kids feel the same thing when listening to pink floyd.
Excellent parenting!
That comment brought tears to my eyes
I wanna meet her xD
I envy you
In a perfect world, the guitar solo in “Comfortably Numb” would last an hour.
Even more
It can. If you’re a guitar player
😊
2 hours would not do it justice... Just keep playing on and on and on...
Actually that solo will last forever. Long after we are nothing but ‘mortal remains’
It would last forever you mean
Gilmour meant business with that last solo.
5:20 Waters and Wright in sync throwing their heads back. Goosebumps.
Within that performance I often wonder whether moments of regret cross any of their minds because they must have known they nailed it.
They were jamming the hell out of that solo
Only for Roger. The other three have no regrets
@@williamstevens4251 I wish Roger wasn't such a douch canoe.
5:18 you mean
@@mufflersponge8969
5:18 - 5:20 time reset itself.
Why dont we have such soulful deep music in 21st century? Ive been listening to Pink Floyd for a couple of decades and I can keep going till my life ends. Their music is timeless - hits your soul straight! I doubt we'll have anything close ever again! Blessed to be alive n watch em play!
This song came from a time when people did things they enjoyed because they enjoyed doing it, and shared it because they thought others would enjoy it. It was never about the fame and fortune like it is now.
We won't.......it certainly doesn't seem that way. They are mesmerizing. I wasn't born until 1969 and love them. Timeless!!!!
We gotta bring it back, people can be lead to appreciate art like this again. If it’s this good, you can’t help but appreciate it
Breaks my heart that there will never be any band this good again.
There doesn't need to be.
@@number1Don and that is all good.🤟
Me too. There will never be another group like Pink Floyd.
Fear not! We might get old, but humanity doesn't. There will always be great music, but you're lucky if this particular manifestation of human genius was the soundtrack to your youth.
my too🙁
“Comfortably Numb” was my late husband’s favourite - he died as a result of Parkinson’s disease also lung cancer.
A very talented man ,brilliant bricklayer, his trade . He also had a passion for Steam trains and built the cases and workings of 4 Grandfather clocks, which included a Tavern Clock (black & white) or also called an Act of Parliament Clock ❤️👍❤️
Missed so much
Shirle Girling R.I.P 💔
What a great song to have as a memory...!!!
Shirle Girling my grandmother passed away and this is a song I discovered when she was just a little sick, and god, the lyrics fitted my situation so well, I think I know how you feel when you listen to this... I loved her so much it still hurts...
Just a Swede wanting to thank you for sharing that, I love to read other people's stories, loss is mourning, you never truly move on, but you never truly lose either, memories and nostalgia, is all we have before we leave, peace and love friend
Bless you ❤
I've heard this song so many times and every time David Gilmour plays that solo I get chills. That's what true music is. Something that moves you in an unexplainable way. Such an amazing treat to see these guys together here. Wow it would have been awesome to experience in person
Totally agree. We can be thankful to walk the earth in the times they do.
That's my peculiarity with regards to The Beatles They never give me chills, thought I reckon their masterpieces.
Floyd always blew me away when in an altered state 50+ years ago
No tattoos, no crazy piercings or body modifications, no crazy hair...just 5 iconic rock legends. Anyone who didn’t know them would think they were just someone else’s average grandpa. 🤘
Very well said👍
And this was all created without ProTools and Autotune!
Not even a bevy of syncopated backup dancers. They just played music. Imagine that!
The magical chemistry between Roger and David is perfectly complemented by Richard and Nick. I love how intense Roger is when the camera pans to him during David’s parts. Who know what happened between these gentlemen, but there’s no mistaking the beautiful art they were capable of expressing through the music. I get choked up every time I see this. They are LEGENDS in every sense of the word. Right up on the Mt Rushmore of greatest bands ever!!
I sometimes wonder how the band's albums after The Wall would have been if the band never fell apart. They made like 4 great albums back to back. They had the perfect chemistry.
@@endergamer.mp4 In truth, both are still present in The Final Cut. But their greatness was given by a perfect mix of balance between Waters' authorial skills and Gilmour's perfect technique. As well as the skill of keyboardist Richard Wright. When Waters took over the group by chasing away Richard Wright and reducing Gilmour's spaces and his fabulous solos the balance was broken and, in fact, already in The final cut they were dead.
@@alessandrosibona4554 And yet, an old man now, he fails to recognize the fact that he fu@ked things up.🤔
Ying and Yang....
"The child is grown, the dream is gone". - One of the most iconic lines to any song in rock and roll.
Those words resonate with 99.9% of the worlds population...
@@secondchance6603 if this is relevant or not im going to say im 14 and i love pinkfloyd and i see what u mean from a teenagers perspective so that means it must be getting preety bad
@@mediumrare2715 To me it's more about your hopes and dreams as a child and growing up to the reality that it doesn't always turn out how you want it to.
I was sixteen when this album came out and I had always wanted to join the navy which didn't end up happening so that's how I read that line. In other words it's open to interpretation. All the best from New Zealand...
@@secondchance6603 thanks for the response and well said. all the best from australia
@@Coffeetime110 What makes you think I'm worried about something?
If you are reading this, I hope something amazing happens to you. You deserve it. All the best, Always.
I love you too my friend
Thie is unbelieve musicus
Listening to this is amazing me enough
Thank you, random person in the internet. I hope something amazing will happen to you too.
Thanks friend! All the best!
This is the like of which we will never see again. No current or future band will command gigs like this with genuine raw talent.
Память в наших сердцах
It takes me back. Love the feeling.
Dave Mustaine: 'David Gilmour Could Do More With One Note Than Today's Shredders Can Do With a Dozen'
Great insight mate,👌
You take a mortal man
And put him in control
Watch him become a god
---------------Dave Mustaine
legend praising another legend, legendary.
Who cares lol
PERFECTLY explained Sir David's magical touch
Everyone's talking about Nick taking off his headphones before the solo but Rick and Roger throwing their heads back in unison at 5:18 is just phenomenal
It is one of the most memorable parts. The more you watch it you can see they wanted to experience the whole ambience as much as the audience. A fantastic piece of musical history. I wish I'd been there.
I'd missed this...wonderful.
But Nick leads the movement with the cymbal smash, the shot captures their heads and Nick's cymbals all in unison. I wonder how many times the three of them had done that all together over the years while Dave's solo just sears on and on. Thanks for pointing that out :)
Everyone engage with this comment so more people can see. Such an awesome moment I almost missed out on
Beautiful
4:32 Gilmour blows Hyde Park off the map... 6:10 Camera goes to Waters, he looks at Gilmour and just shakes his head... Gilmour in the zone, plays not a solo, but a piece of history through that guitar, he hits every note a human soul craves... every time he plucks one of those strings... An immortal rock God... right there... get your kids on it now and save their souls... what a legacy. Privileged. One of the best things our mortal ears will ever hear...
Pure legends that stand alone .....
wHAT a great description man!!!
The big bang exploded to answer What Can Be? This was an answer.
There is little talent like that in today's music. If it can be considered music.
I can proudly say when my son started driving and got his 1st truck, 1/2 of my cds disappeared! The Wall was one of them!
Man if you take into account how sour the relationship between David and Roger was and still is, it's short of a miracle to see them together one last time.
So sad to realise it can now never happen again, since Richard's passing as well.
I just hope they can amend things one day. For their own peace.
I totally agree with all your words 👌
Love it when, at 5:18, Roger and Rick both throw their heads backwards. All antagonism between them was, at least in that moment, forgotten as they worked as hard as they could to support one of the most emotional solos ever performed on a stage
Wow I didn’t even notice that...that was amazing!
For that brief second, they were a full 40 years younger.
True! From the interviews I have seen, Roger is as they say, kind of difficult. Sad, all those years lost.
I noticed that moment too! So friggin epic!!
@@solano8725 Yeah, looks like he is wearing a Rolex here?....that is usually a tip off
Still has one of the best guitar solos of all time. The emotion going through that guitar, it’s more than just a set of notes being played, it’s someone’s mind being expressed
well said! That's why I love it so much. It's not just showing off virtuosity. It's actually the emotional climax.
Ashra - midnight on mars solo is better.
The best solo ever. Still gives me goosebumps after all this time. Majestic.
There is no best with music, but it sure is my favorite.
Brit floyd is much better
At some point, all these guys are going to pass away. I cry like a baby every time I think of that. Giants. We live in a time when the giants of rock are dying out.
Giants like Justin Bieber are replacing them
@@BarriosGroupie meh he is no giant
The next generation is coming, that's for sure!
They'll live forever brother - in their music. It will never age.......
That's so melancholy.
One of the greatest songs ever, ever. No matter what kind of music you’re in if this guitar solo doesn’t deeply touch your soul you’re not alive go see a doctor
Even though Rogers and Gilmour don’t get along, like at all, you can’t deny that the chemistry that the two have when they play together is undeniably beautiful and superb.
What an awkward hug between Gilmour and Waters, you can see it in Dave's face.
Who gets along with Waters?
@@t-bagbagwell1327 Nick Mason for a starter.
@@anycolouryoulike8567 Nick Mason get along with everyone.
Roger and David have met up several times since this concert, David even played at Rogers solo "The Wall" concert and performed this song and they both did a charity gig together just a few years ago, the wounds are healing from all those years ago.
2020 . And still there is no words how to describe how good this is .
2021
And its the same in 2021, and will be the same in 2022, and 2023, and ............. forever!!
True perfection.
Rock God's.
The child has grown, the dream is gone. One of the saddest yet most often felt experiences for many. But keep the child alive damnit!!
You are so right x
The child ,was,in time.
So very true. For all of us.
Syd Barrett !
Amazing lyrics
The child is grown and hopefully stays in touch with 👪 family, so important, as my Mom taught me !
This is music that will forever transcend through the generations long after these guys have left this earth
I'm very confident that this music will be recognized in more than 200-300 years to be the best written lyrics by humans by a long shot
So sad to think l will leave this world and won’t have the privilege to see them playing alive!! These guys created something beyond generations.
These guys and Led Zeppelin are two that we as a generation of fans will never get the privilege of seeing live in all their glory, but their legacies will live on for years to come
Yes I agree. Does miss this band live. They are amazing. Absolutely amazing.
@@Mark-tu5yl in the 70s you guys had music at its best, there was a good scene in the 90s but the 70s had so much going on and there didn't seem to be so much of a 'scene' where you had to fit in it was about the music and nothing else.
Also one of my greatest disappointments in life
VC FALOU TUDO eu também tenho essa frustação de não ter assistido o PINK FLOYD me refiro ao grupo completo e não apenas 1 solo
I'm an old man. I've heard guitarists in an era when guitarist were rock stars and in all honesty none of the could make a guitar cry like Gilmour, not even Hendrix.
Absolutely right; let it be known that the rarest and most precious of guitarists is he or she who sings through the instrument. Dave, Knopfler, and Lifeson, not sure there's anyone else...
MustangPianist yeh your just ignoring everyone else for some reason
Mark Tremonti
@@illusionfiveofficial Mark tremonti will laugh at you for that comment !
Not sure about that
2021, and I"m still listenting...
me too :(
Word!
SO DO I...
Same here at the age of almost 63!
Classical music has no expiration date
Guitars were created to play this masterpiece. Whenever i listen this solo i get goosebumps. Greatest guitar solo in rock history. Period🐐!
As a drummer, Nick Mason did everything right. No flash, just a solid beat on perfect timing 👌
The fact that he removes his headphones before the first solo
@@robertbanys I know you can tell he was so into it
Right! Und einen Ferrari 250 GTO in seiner Garage. Alles Richtig gemacht!
I'm late to the party, but I noticed this a few years ago and never commented... I love how Nick Mason rips his headphones off right before the first solo, it's so great to see true talent enjoying what they were born to do!
I love how he took his headphones off right as David Gilmour started the first half of the solo. He wanted to hear all of it. Not just the track on his in ear monitor.
Never tire of this. One of the best guitar solos ever.
Vence McAdams check the pulse live concert 1994 for me its the best version
The delicate sound of thunder tour circa 1990 version is by far the best and the longest,ive listened to them all,pulse,Pompeii etc.. and none of them come close. But of course ill happily listen or watch any version!
Vence McAdams probably the best one ever
goosebumps every time
This song is an anthem to my generation (the end of the baby boomers). But all generations love it also. David Gilmore is the epitome of guitar gods!!!
David Gilmour / Roger Waters/ Nick Mason / Richard Wright when all four were playing its exceptional ! Pink Floyd died the day Richard left the planet ...., Richard, Richard, Richard ! Rest in Peace, you will never be forgotten !
Don't forget about Syd Barret, the man behind it all, who led the group in their infant years.
You mean Sid?
Michelle Reifsteck no Syd
Michelle Reifsteck its actually Syd
Pinky Floyd who is richard
This song is one the greatest compromise of talent, skill and creativity in the history of music. Pink Floyd takes you on an acoustic journey with every song as it bleeds from the previous and into the next. Like no other.
Согласен. Здесь очень зыбкая граница между старой классикой и струнно-клавишной музыкой конца ХХ века. По гармонии, по мелодике и ритмике, по бережному отношению к звуку это одно из лучших музыкальных произведений последних 100-150 лет. А по эмоциональному заряду - в первой пятерке точно. Какое счастье, что ребята 60-70-х оставили нам такое сокровище, как Pink Floyd, King Crimson, Chick Corea, Camel, Genesis, Focus или MM Earth Band. И какие помои пишут после 1990-го года!
Fifty one years old.
Northeast Pennsylvania.
Still crying my eyes out in joy for this song and this band.
The best band ever. Helps me every time I'm down.
Absolutely!!!
AMEN .
And helps me when I’m up
Always there in a time of need
And me
No matter how you turn it around, Pink Floyd is and remains the greatest band of all time and Comfortably Numb has the most epic, heartbreaking and gorgeous solo of all universes.
They are indeed one of the greatest
It’s not even close
@@wonderman65 I mean there’s the Beatles…
The Beatles are no competition !! Pink Floyd is 100x better 🎇🎆
@@Former_Pastor neither of them are any slouches but, you gotta give credit where credit is due.
i come back to this performance every once in a while just to remind myself that even despite the inner band drama, these men loved performing the songs they created together. i love that moment at 2:05 where nick mason takes off his headphones just before the first solo starts. their music means as much to the members as it does to us.
Dave Gilmore NEVER plays a bad solo. Pure quality.
I was twenty metres from the stage. Second solo brought me to to tears. Amazing day all round. I'm a lucky man.
I love the drums on this. The whole thing is perfection. Pink Floyd is perfection!
the drums and keyboards elevate this version over most of the others
Melhor banda do mundo. Essa época foi a melhor da música na história da humanidade! 👍👍😁🌷❤️❤️
Nick Mason flicking his headset off to hear Gilmour solo one last time is pretty epic!!
@@anaestrela820 yes indeed the best musica AND era
@@anaestrela820 soy de Puerto Rico y viví en u.s.a. en la época de los 60 y 70 y la música y época era extraordinario tremenda experiencia
I get chills every time with Gilmour's 2nd solo... absolute master piece!
The best piece of recorded music ever heard. The solo is just what every guitar player in the world wishes he created.
Its not that its terribly hard, its the emotion with which he plays it. A true masterpiece.
The emotion!!! Absolutely! This is what every guitarist strives for. Something that has feeling and meaning.
Watching in 2018. Will watch this repeatedly until I die.
same here watching since 80s
Same for me, I actually lost count how many times I watched 'Comfortably Numb" on this video, goosebumps and happy tears.
Me too
There are songs and then there is Comfortably Numb. Rare one that resonates with my soul
Me too
I was raised on Pink Floyd. My dad is the biggest Floyd fan EVER.. he’s seen them live twice. I remember as a child, listening to Pink Floyd with him. Not asking questions. Not interrupting the music. Just listening. Soaking in every word. Every chord. Getting lost in my own mind. Now, as an adult and having a son of my own, i am teaching him the ways of Pink Floyd. Even now, 30 years later, i still get lost in my own mind. Their music is not just music, its a story. Its a tale of 4 guys that came together to make the best songs there ever will be. Pink Floyd paved the way for musicians today. Best band ever, i cant emphasize that. Best band ever.
I experienced the same with my dad. I'm 42 and Floyds his all time favorite. This was my 1st concert ever when I was 16. He piled me and my friends in his van and we rolled to the stadium. Its 2020 and my 8 year old rocks out floyd and of course Papaw bought him a Pink Floyd shirt! Pink Floyd will always be a massive staple in our family. It's in our soul
@JAMES DURHAM U.E. typical liberal
@@zs9265 why u have to be political? Music has nothing to do with it, so keep it out of it! Music is the one thing that truely frees our mind and soul from it! So Why r u even on here, making weird comments?
@@ginaclemons2558 last time I checked, this is America. We have the freedom to do and say what we want. The freedoms I fought for. I'm not politically correct. If what I say offends you, then, that's on you.
@@zs9265 yes you are entitled to say whatever, I can careless, I'm comfortably numb!😉 but I'm on here talking about rocking out, making the soul feel good, not stupid ass politics, if I wanted to talk politics I'd go to another youtube channel🙄 I swear always one ass in the bunch no matter where u go!
makes me very sad that performances of this magnitude will never ever happen again. Greatest guitar solo ever!
There is not anything on Earth as great as good classic rock in my opinion. It can make you happy, sad, laugh, cry, excited, nostalgic, and a whole lot more. Pink Floyd is up there on the British rock and roll Mount Rushmore.
Sem palavras ❤❤❤❤❤💐💐💐💐💐❤❤❤❤❤❤
Tudo de bom❤❤❤❤
English rock.
This is not a solo. This is the absolute written in a rock for eternity.
It was all planned by God to have David Gilmour with us
kids....this is what greatness looks like...
gavin suhan remember we are the reason you get to watch this whenever you please! lol
gavin suhan so sad they will never know those days. You didn't need talent shows. The bands back then we're naturally talented.
Esmee de Grijs glad to know you found out about talented artist as so many kids don't
gavin suhan
I know. Best band in the world. I always get goosebumps when I listen to them. They're just fucking great. BTW I'm just 14 years old 😂
This is what Perfection sounds
like
“There is no pain you are receding…” Lifts my soul every single listen.
Imagine being a backup singer and having Pink Floyd on your resume.
I fully realised that joke, but sorry musicians doesn't really need a resume
Pink Floyd , no fancy rock n roll outfits , no tattoos, just good music and fine songwriting , and that solo I can listen to it even if it would last 12 hours!!
Our British understatement make it for me. No fuss.
I agree that solo is euphoric, amazing
Wea!!!!!!!!! Me too!!!
seeing on TH-cam at METAL GIRLS REACT TO PINK FLOYD
One of the most beautiful things ever to have been heard on this planet
точно.
This dudes in jeans and t-shirts are the best team in this world to create and express every emotion that I've had buried deep in my ❤️ and this song and solo are truly the greatest masterpiece ever created bc it is a GOLDEN MASTERPIECE. Thanks for the joy and magical feeling it brings to my soul.
I love to see these guys together. I’ve raised my kids on this music. Music today is not even close to the same level as this. I love you guys. Keep doing what you do. Thank you for reaching my life in so many ways.
If that's not the greatest guitar solo of all time, then it's in the top one.
Stairway to heaven its the Best solo of all time
@@mauroyza100 they both are amazing in their own way in my opinion
mauroyza100 STH is my favourite song too but that solo can’t beat comfortably numb’s solo,
Page and Plant tribute tour of "Thank you" from 1994 was it? and This
Sudip Thapa Rolling Stones and Total Guitar voted “Stairway to heaven” the best solo of all time... i think David Gilmour is a great Guitar player but come on... Jimmy Page is a God!!
Imagine not talking for 20+ years and being able to get up there and do that?
Imagine having "No Excuses" above the stage and still refusing to give up on a 30+ year fued.
Who didnt talk for 20 years??
@@shreyashshrestha6085 David Gilmour and Roger Waters had a bit of a fall out
@@liammullan6931 ah i see, wonder why this happens to ever band ever huh
@@shreyashshrestha6085 British bands notorious for terrible breakups
Amazing. It's wonderful that they can occasionally put aside their differences and just put on stellar performance after stellar performance. These guys are incredible and I cherish every day that most of them are still with us and still able to perform at such a high level. I ❤ Pink Floyd.
I'm not sure "most" applies when nearly half the main members are dead and Waters and Gilmour wish that for each other.
Lassolo di David... Brividi, solo brividi... 🙄😊😍😘🎶🎸🎶💘💞💔💋💯💯💯💯💯
It is wonderful !
Absolute magic with these four musicians together! Hard to believe it's been 12 years already. RIP Richard you are sorely missed. 💔
Leavebutdontleaveme Roger waters is touring next year which means in less than 20 hours
Leavebutdontleaveme and Syd barret
2008 for rick
10 years 2008
i love hendrix, page, clapton and all the others, but when gilmour strikes his guitar it is as god strikes his hammer of lightning. best ever!
I FEEL Gilmour more on an emotional level not a showy one. No disrespect at all to those legends.
@@missdee4927 , Clapton brings the emotion too to be fair but I agree Gilmour is the GOAT from that point of view
Phil Keaggy.
David Gilmore has been underrated his entire career. On Rolling Stones too 100 greatest guitarists he places 14. Which is an absolute crime. Top 5 for sure. My list would be (5)Prince, (4)Clapton, (3)Gilmore, (2) Van Halen (1) Hendricks.
AMAZING. Brilliant
45 years old that I'm a fan of pink floyd and it will never stop
best old for 2018
Happy New Year
Awsmome
Awsome thank you and God bless you
Would like to sing it with you before I die
Sme ges with me
I am 49 grew up with all the best bands what a life I've had so luck
I was blessed to see them twice. I didnt realize at the time but it was a life changing moment. The first time my wife couldn't go because of work. I called her from a pay phone from 3 rivers stadium (before cell phones) and held the phone out towards the stage next show she went too. Best guitar solo ever.
This performance will go down in the history books and will always be admired as one of the best in Pink Floyd’s history.
Was this the reunion with roger? What year?
Same Passion..
Same committment..
Same Energy .....
as it used to be long ago.
psychedelic , intoxicating
simply no words how to praise such deep music.
Simply the greatest rock song ever by the greatest band.
No its not.
Its fucking good, but neither music neither band are the greastest. Solo is top 5 in history for sure.
Free Bird
Stairway to Heaven
Highway Star
Different moods, also Majestic
Subjective, to say the least; and generally not even considered close.
@@juliomartins7467 Your opinion is not fact
@@michaelmikeykellymikeydama5405 fuck off. Neither yours. But i am sure i can get a thousands of reviews that goes against the original comment (also an opinion) and disagree about Pink Floyd being the greastest band and this solo being the greastest ever. Chill out!
My dad is addicted to this song, he used to listen without missing a single day, now that he's no more I'm now addicted, I can't start my day without this song. The lyrics, guitar leads and the surrounding instrumental tunes are phenomenal
Thank you England for giving us epic transforming music..
From the Beatles to present day musicians
@@mark-fu9fe Actually "music" sucks today.
321gates I wouldn’t say it sucks but it lacks innovation and character. Last celebrity with any character or substance was eminem. People care too much these days it stops the magic of creation
We are proud that they're English. Glad you enjoy what we produce over here.
It almost hurts to watch and listen to this masterpiece. It is a painful reminder of what could be and should be again.
👌❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
Remember watching this live, crying like fuck, knew we would never see them again...
I was a spectator during their final tour. I invited my neighbor to the Division Bell gig at giants stadium. I told my dad he was too old to rock. I regret it. I had a feeling, it was gone. How do u live with the decision to be with someone your own age and not your dad? He is afflicted with Parkinsonism now. Sighs.
I was 20 years old. He is 78.
JT Smith sorry to hear about your father. We all make mistakes we regret, some worse than others, but at the end of the day, all we can do is learn from them and strive to be better.
The way Waters calls to Gilmour for a salute to the audience really shows how much he misses being a part of the band. Gilmour said Waters wanted to still have a say in what songs they would rehearse and play live together. After all these years he still wanted to be in command. Gilmour said Waters was a "guest" and would play what Rick, Nick and himself would like (Pink Floyd post Final Cut). You can see how much Waters enjoyed playing with them. It's crazy to see because he still has that feeling of superiority as he mouths the lyrics with Gilmour. Its just amazing to see that he has the same mentality after all these years yet truly wants to be a part of the band. The tension is phenomenal and without that mentality of Waters, we never would truly appreciate Floyd. Its that egotistical side that really created The Wall. Just sad to see it still prominent in his disposition. What a band. What a pleasure to live in this exact time of incredible music. Im 31 and wish I could have experienced this live. The emotion and passion is on another level. Roger and Dave really accentuated each other! Respect to Nick and Rick as well, Im sure it wouldnt be the same without any of them. Thanks guys for evoking such emotion in myself and many others! Just my pov 😎
I'm sitting here crying. To think how important Pink Floyd have been in my life throughout my teenage years to now. And to see them again reunited on stage and to have all of them finish with Comfortably Numb. And knowing that this will never happen again due to Rick's passing.
So epic.
Couldn’t say it better. To think how instrumental Pink Floyd have been in my life. I thank my dad for introducing me to them when I was young to taking me to two of their concerts. I’ve aged with them and what a journey it has been. There will never be another band like them.
I have been listening to that solo since I was a very young boy and it still gives me chills. This is 1 of the best pieces of music to ever be written anywhere by anyone. It is perfection.
September 2022 and the world is a mess but this masterpiece cuts right through all of it. The 4 men have given us all the proof that behind all the ugliness' there is this beauty that we have to dream of better times. Sadly we lost Richard but his contribution was immense. Thank you gents.
Just makes me so proud to be British and knowing my country have given this finest music to the world ❤️
Reminds me of when I was a teenager after losing my entire family and having no one. Wandering the streets looking for my next meal or a warm place to lay my head. Worked hard and had children and became a multi millionaire but always stayed grounded.
I'm and old man now and my children and my generation of music keeps me going.
This is when real music was made!
Thank you for this wonderful video and amazing song....
Glad you made it! I grew up with this great band. I have lost most of my family now but still have my music which got me through a lot that happened in my life.. They are definitely an original
@@seaairaraine13 Happy New Year 2022 to you! Be strong and enjoy each day to the fullest. Proud of you!
...became a multi millionaire..?
@@l.pietrobon3925 i got confused with that too
We were there for this. We were stood 30feet from the stage with me totally lost in tears, as I thought they wouldn't play together in my lifetime. That's twice I was wrong, as I didn't think the Berlin Wall would come down either. Happy to be wrong on both counts. I took a photo that will be buried with me, of all Pink Floyd arm in arm bowing to the crowd. Oh fine fine memories ❤❤❤ 🍻🍻🍻 🎉🎉🎉
Hey, can I come to your funeral? I want to see that picture.
There will never be anything like Pink Floyd again in my lifetime. Darkside of the Moon and The Wall will go down as two of the most influential albums in Rock history, if not music history. And The Pulse album has it's place as one of the most incredible live albums. Gilmour's guitar playing reaches to the deepest parts of your soul and lets it free. Waters, somehow knew what to say to us with his words(yes, I know that Gilmour wrote a lot of the music, but for me Waters lyrically touched my soul more). Richard Wright to me was the heart of the group.his smile from behind the keyboards was all you needed to see to know life was good. Nick Mason is never given enough credit for what he brought to the group and as a drummer. Last, but not least, their late and great leader Syd Barret. How wish he had been well enough to give us more of what was in his incredible mind.
You have said it all my friend!
never was a huge fan of early floyd work but syd def deserves credit
Very true, his death made a huge impact on the band.
Don't forget "Wish you were here" great one.
Chris Britton Not Rock Just Music Period.
Pink floyd 🙏.
I grew up on Pink Floyd. Brings me to tears seeing them on stage together for the final time like that. I know this was a while ago but I watch this often. Greatest band ever.