Unpopular Harry Potter Opinions | Cherry Wallis
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 14 ต.ค. 2024
- ♡ Watch my Love Potion DIY here: • Harry Potter Potions: ...
♡ Subscribe: bit.ly/2SVNVfv
♡ MORE INFO BELOW!
Harry Potter on Reddit: / harrypotter
Hello! Thank you so much for watching! Be sure to join in the discussion down below! Do you have any unpopular Harry Potter opinions?
♡ SOCIAL MEDIA ♡
Twitter: / cherrywallis
Instagram: / cherrywallis
Facebook: / officialcherrywallis
♡ CONTACT / WANT TO WORK WITH ME? ♡
Email: james@freefocus.co.uk (Business use only)
Edited by: Chris Pearless
♡ MUSIC ♡
All music is royalty free, and used with permission.
This video is not sponsored, and all opinions are my own.
Do you have an unpopular opinion regarding the Harry Potter books / films? Leave it down below!
Thanks for watching... also - whilst I have your attention, you're going to want to keep a look out for my next video (Saturday). I'll be announcing something VERY exciting!
Hi! Love you! First reply,
OMG I love your videos! I think its better to read the book first then watch the movie. In the movie they didnt include Winke and it made me mad
People think Ron is an absolute prick but I think he's just a hurting soul who needs a slap across the face and then a good hug
Cherry Wallis love you ❣️❣️
Love you cherry 🍒🥰
I would consider Arthur Weasley a father figure to Harry too. Along with James, Sirius, Remus, Hagrid, and Dumbledore.
Dumbledore sucked as a father figure
Damn. Harry had a lot of daddies.
Dumbledor is kinda cruel tho he use Harry as a weapon
YESSS FR
Definitely agree
Personally, I believe Harry's greatest father figure has always been Remus. He's the one who truly looked after him. Sirius was great, but sometimes viewed Harry as a replacement James and I can't say Sirius as a person is/would be a perfect father. Hagrid has always seemed to be the fun uncle to me, and I wouldn't ever consider Dumbledore to be a father figure for Harry. He's more of a loony and wise grandfather..
I agree!
definitely, but i don't think it was Sirius's fault. I don't think he was completely mentally stable cuz he did his waiting! Twelve years of it, in Azkaban!
Umm..noo it's def hagrid. Think about it
Jas L agreement
Dumbledoor is that grandmas aunt who is always sorta dancing
Sirius was definitely more of a father figure. Hagrid was more of the fun, but sometimes irresponsible, uncle (I mean, there was the whole dragon thing...).
That's So Landrum exactly! The ‘uncle’ analogy works very well with Hagrid 🙌🏻
Also I have the feeling he was a best friend. Harry never put Hagrid on a pedestal. They always were on the same level.
ya i agree but sometimes sirius could be a bit irresponsible and tend to treat harry more like james than he should've. sirius is still my fave character but molly weasley had a point in the 5th book.
He does remind me of my uncle a bit haha
However Sirius was loving and cherished Harry because he’s his dads son, he even treated him like James. Hagrid has ties to Harry and yet was nurturing to him.
I feel like Sirius' view of Harry as a James-figure was really more an invention of the *MOVIES* .
Sirius is far more fatherly in the books, continuing to send Harry letters using "tropical birds" to keep him amused when he is stuck with the Dursleys, living in a cave during 4th year to keep a close eye on Harry during the Triwizard Tournament, INSISTING that Harry leave the Department of Mysteries even though he wanted to fight. I think the film version of Gary Oldman calling Harry "James" by mistake really stuck in peoples' memories and made them forget book-Sirius, who tended to treat Harry like a child in need of protection and emotional support through adolescence. In contrast, the fact that Hagrid habitually places Harry in great harm (Aragog, Grawp, night visits, PLUS, being so personally insulted that Harry and Ron don't continue taking Care of Magical Creatures in 6th year that he actively ignores them for weeks.) makes Hagrid a lovable but ultimately immature figure.
Rather than the misplaced feelings for James shown in the movies, the biggest issue in Sirius and Harry's relationship in the *BOOK* is the former's battle with depression/cabin fever/residual Azkaban trauma while he is confined in Grimauld place. This causes Sirius to secretly hope for Harry's expulsion following the Dementor attack, which also makes him feel guilty and causes him to pull away from Harry. He becomes emotionally and physically distant. This issue stems from loneliness, rather than Sirius not appreciating the fact that Harry is a young adolescent.
Agreed, I always see Hagrid as Beign that Cool Uncle, But not as a Father
I'm too lazy to read everything so-
Ok
yours is the first most accurately summed up version of sirius i have ever read, kudos to u mate
Hagrid ignored children by disign to make them come and share their opinions and thoughts openly. He knew that Trio wouldn't attend his classes before the 1th of September.
Siri wasn't distant. Harry and he didn't have safe ways of communication before the mirror. And Harry immediately forgot about it, but not about code for entrance of MOM
"SPOILER ALERT Sirius died"
Like minutes after you talked about how sad Sirius' death was xD
hahjahah
@Angela Dan Even if a person hasn't, they really shouldn't be here watching this if they are worried about spoilers.
That was exactly, what I wanted to say
😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢
First opinion made me cry. Cedric's really was just a cruel death😭
xXFrozen_ -DragonXx - Especially since one of the last things he heard before dying was “Kill the spare”
OMG that felt like it really was the second saddest moment in Wizarding World history! Cedric deserved a better life rather than dying immediately
Sirius: “Get your hands of my God son”
Mama Weasley/Mama bear: Not my daughter I b**ch
Best lines in the movie represents parents really well if their children are in danger ☺️
I was really surprised when she said that. She had just lost one of her sons and Bellatrix had the nerve to mock her.
emily madren yup
AND on top of that in the movies in the battle of the department of mysteries Sirius slips up and says to Harry “Nice one James!” It really shows how much Sirius loves James and Harry
ᑕєlєѕтє well, Harry’s middle name IS James, but I also find your detail profound.
Its actually "get away from my godson" just pointing that out
But also, regarding the no toilets thing, if there were no toilets there how did Salazar Slytherin build the Chamber of Secrets in the plumbing if there was no plumbing?
Honestly, good question...
wasn't it said in the books that the creature didn't always use the plumbing? The girls bathroom wasn't built to hide the chamber of secrets but was unknowingly built on top of it.
My guess is that Slytherin was a bit of a misogynist.
@@prigg88 I believe this as well....
Paige Makepeace ohhh yeeasssgg
Whiterun Guard you have a good point, however that doesn’t explain the entrance to the chamber being in the girls bathroom with a snake on the right sink? Sure, there might be another entrance, there probably is, but why would there also be an entrance in the girls bathroom where there is a snake on the correct sink to speak parseltounge to? Hope you are well! ☺️
To me, Sirius basically saw Harry as James incarnate. Hagrid cared about Harry just because he was Harry.
Hagrid was just an all-round nice guy, and cared for many people. One of my fav characters, and he is never mean to anyone.
Buffy Cary TOTALLY i totally agree but i still LOVE sirius no matter what
"But I'm Harry, just Harry"
"Well just Harry..." lol
AND to strengthen this point in the movies in the battle of the department of mysteries Sirius lets slip and accidently says “Nice one James!” To Harry
@@l5098 yashh actually, it really breaks my heart a little bit because it really dissapointing to hear it and i really like sirius him self (the character) because what he do to harry (carring,etc) 😿
Sorting hat quiz
How do you brush your teeth
Bravely
While making a sandwich
While reading a book
I'm a snake
I've seen that everywhere, you aren't original m8
Yea but he didn't say it was original, he just wanted to spread the joke to people who didn't hear it yet
@@ihateyoshi6469 I think everyone's heard it and they never gave the original creator credit so.
Yea, that's pretty true. Thanks for actually replying unlike half of this community
I do this to show the funny stuff i find to the world
I agree, Im also in a Magical Bubble. Who said its over? Its alive as long as theres a community, everytime you read the books, wear your shirts, wave your wands, watch the movies, etc. I feel like its basically timeless now!
Me 2
C'mon, Star Wars was decades ago and people still yammer on about it like it's the Holy Grail.
They are still making movies and have been making fresh in universe stories since then though
Yeah and more people are coming in
I havent watched all the movies but I've watched some of them and I've read up to partway through goblet of fire
Also if theres a fandom, theres a harry potter crossover fanfiction
About the brooms one...no one cared when Harry was mysteriously gifted an expensive broom because he was in Gryffindor, but the second Malfoy gifts the entire team the new Nimbus it's all of a sudden an unfair advantage?
That's only in movies though. In book when he got the Firebolt, Hermione told McGonagall and she confiscated the broom (even though Harry protested) and got it checked by several professors if it's not cursed or something.
@@callie3444 Exactly. There's also the fact that he otherwise wouldn't have one at all.
The thing is Malfoy bought brooms for the whole team to buy his way into the team, not cause he was the most talented seeker they could find. Harry was gifted the firebolt after he was already on the team and he certainly didnt need it to keep his spot on the team.
I agree with you 100% the "books" for "Fantastic Beasts" should be NOVELS not SCREENPLAYS they are so hard toe read !!!!
Lord Quinn well i like that they are scripts cuz i like acting
Should be both
I agree, though I don't find screenplays too hard to read. I think it just takes away from the magic of the books. I mean, part of the magic Is the descriptions and Harry's emotions.
consider that even godzilla king of monsters has a novel adaption.
I absolutely agree he was a better father figure, Sirius had strong love for him, but he saw Harry as James too much
Pamela Allen I think the films made it seem more like that. Imo Sirius knew well that Harry is not James, that he is his godson and his own person but Sirius knew that Harry is just as capable as James and wanted to treat Harry as suchvjh
Unpopular opinion: Saddest death was that of voldy.
'Cause after that the series ended.😂😂😂
(Not mine. Read somewhere else. But I think it's right.)
I love it!!! 😂
I totally agree with u
Omg yh gg voldy
Everyone is so rude to the actor who plays Umbridge.
People being rude to the actor is unacceptable.
Imagine playing a character so well that people hate you for it. She was just doing her job so idk why people can’t just chill.
umbridge is better than snape. snape killed a person, probably quite a few seeing as how he’s a death eater. umbridge on the other hand did not. snape was also obsessive over a dead, married woman.
I watched a movie with her as an actor, and she’s amazing! Hate the character, love the actor!
i personally love the actor just HATE the character.
Unpopular opinion: Hated how they did Severus Snape's memories in the Deathly Hallows Part 2. In the book, she EMPHASIZES Severus' terrible choices he made-you emphasize with his loss, but you don't forget he's a gray character and how his actions lead to that loss.
In the movie they really paint him to be a tragic hero. He's NOT a hero-he's at most an amoral hero or anti hero.
I gotta wonder if Albus Severus met Severus Snape's portrait if all his insecurities would vanish or amplify tenfold.
13:05 Girl, you already have the hair just buy a gryffindor robe and cosplay Ginny
Yes, I totally agree! She should cosplay Molly Weasley too, and make videos about the cosplaying process. That would be so much fun!
@@melinap3284 yes I didn't think about Molly but she could totally nail that cosplay too
Yeah! I particularly love cosplays that use real hair!
I was thinking that as well
😀
I thought that too!!
book Sirius death and Freds death were definitely the saddest (I cried so much😥)
I beg to differ....what ‘bout Dobby
My original order of the phonix book still has tear stains on the page sirius got killed
@@niahoad omg same, some words aren't even visible anymore :')
The proof the time turners were a bad idea?
"Oops, they all broke. Can't use them anymore"
"Couldn't we make more?"
"Can't use them anymore."
"Couldn't we borrow one from another country?"
"CAN'T USE THEN ANYMORE!!"
Carl Rood I know- at least ONE would have survived.
@@veeasaurus Actually, it wouldn't have worked. The cursed child completely ruined the whole time turner plot and changed it completely. The main idea of the time turner was "what is done is done". Basically, when Harry and Hermione went back in time, they didn't change anything that hadn't already happened. They just made sure that it actually happens. For eg. In their time, they thought buckbeak was dead but he already escaped. They just heard the executer go there. And when Remus, as a werewolf was going to attack them, he heard a howl in the forest and went there. When, they went back in time, they freed Buckbeak so that he could escape. And then they made the noises in the forest to attract Remus towards them and leave their past selves alone. So, technically no matter what. They still would have died. The cursed child just wrote whatever they wanted to, I mean half the characters were so OOC.
@@anyabajaj07 geez thats an old comment, yeah i agree with you completely my comment was that in the order of the pheonix, the amount of time turners they described seemed like a lot. and if they were able to fit inside a necklace at least a couple wouldve made it . regardless the cursed child literally did whatever it wanted to like you daid
Your "post potter depression" face 🥰
Also, KILLING the ginger brow game 🤩😲
My brows say thank you 🧡
Cedric’s death is the only one i cried over in the films, for the same reason as Cherry 😭 I cried during the audiobooks a few times too (which i listened to at work 🤣 good thing it was a family business haha) and I also cried listening to Ginny’s commentary in the audiobook version of ‘Quiditch though the ages’ as she was talking about how great some beaters where and i made me think that she was thinking about Fred and George and i cried.
I’m an emotional wee bear.
I feel like hagrid is more of an uncle figure or a older brother figure to Harry then a father figure, he was always looking out for him but never super invested and always lived his own life but serious did everything for Harry and truly loved Harry like a dad but with hagrid it was a bit more chill
Thank you for listening to my ted talk
"Dumbledore stood everywhere... whaddaya want me to do, float?" XD
When watching the films, I was convinced the Dumbledore was going to be revealed as a bad guy because he kept hiring evil teachers.
If I'm gonna be completely honest, it's not that much of his own fault...
Mainly all the DADA teachers. Year 5 and Year 7 weren’t his fault though. But couldn’t he see that Gilderoy was a fraud? He saw past Riddle easily and Lockhart’s just full of himself.
@@not-so-happypappypatton But the thing is, NO ONE really applied for the job, most think the spot was cursed (which it is)
Lupin : 👁👄👁
@@not-so-happypappypatton probably the reason why Dumbledore hired Lockhart was because he wanted to show that he was a fraud.(my opinion tbh)
But was Sirius’ love for Harry or for James? He didn’t know Harry. Hagrid loved Harry for Harry and always tried his best to care for him and put his needs first. That sounds more fatherly to me 🤷🏻♀️
But Hagrid started caring for Harry because he liked his parents too
@@hermione3639 hmmm you can say the same thing about Ron, that thought sitting with Harry Potter on the train is cool and he kind of liked him for that, but Hagrid and Ron both liked Harry for who he is and were ever there for him at the end, after they knew him and loved him as a friend. With all of my love to Sirius (and that's a lot), he always saw Harry as "the second James".
@@mika-kv6tz u are right but my point was that those people(including Ron)started liking harry because of his parents or his fame but eventually came to care for the real harry . I think that at f
Irst sirius did view Harry as the second james but that changed overtime . Surely Sirius musnt have thought he was the second James when harry was disgusted by James behaviour in Snapes memories. And lets not forget that Sirius was there for Harry too and warned him against doing dangerous stuff . Oof sorry this was long lol
e m So? Hagrid still viewed Harry as an individual instead of an extension of James. Our family members care for us because we’re born to our parents too. So I’m missing your point here.,
Dobbys death is in my opinion the saddest
It easily is and Snapes too 💔❤️
I don't think I cried more than when Dobby died.
@@ca1.1um Yeah, his death was really sad...😥
Dobby’s death is devastating but I think that Fred’s death is the worst. Molly and Arthur losing a son and George losing his TWIN.. brb I’ll go cry in the corner
@@shaunOG91 Oh yes I forgot about that... I was crying so long when I found out that he dies..😥
Cherry "vanish-poop-o"
Me (dyeing on the floor laughing)
When you said „stabby stab stab stab“ yeah I really felt that😂
Ravenclaw, here! My issue with merchandise is: blue and silver effing raven.
I want a bronze eagle.
So I am between ravenclaw and Gryffindor, so I but mainly Gryffindor Merch when it comes to licensed. Etsy and fan made stuff I go with the book style ravenclaw
I’m between ravenclaw and slytherin
Yeah it's not that hard to get the colors and animal right. Geez. I think even the movies got it wrong.
Idk how this mistake just spread like a wildfire.
@@blueandbronzeravenclaw1961 Slytherclaw FTW
Right there with you
That Snape joke though
"How dare you stand where he stood?
🤣🤣 that one made me chuckle 🤣🤣🤣🤣
YES THOUGH 😂😂😂 And the meme where his answer was along the lines of "you want me to fly?"
@@31iz4.5 Snape:Dumbledore stood everywhere in this castle.What do you want me to do?
fLoAt??
But he could float! I mean he can literally fly..
In America in schools the school provides the sports equipment so at a school like Hogworts all 4 teams would have the same brooms
Well hogwarts is in Scotland and the story takes place in the 90’s in an old fashioned wizard society
Dawn Long Basically sames in australia
Yes, but certain districts are wealthier than other districts here in the US. Some of the high schools’ athletic facilities here in the south are ridiculous, while other schools are using the same equipment from 10 yrs ago.
Thays not true for all American schools. Mine you had to buy your own stuff.
I remember our soccer team didn't have matching jerseys
Hello Cherry 🍒 you are helping me with lots of stress and anxiety at the moment I love you so much ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️💖💖💖💖💖
Say what you like about the films but Imelda Staunton was perfect as Umbridge.
I feel Albus didn't care about Harry.
And used him as he knew about prophecy.
I mean it was Severus who send his charm to protect Harry.
QueenOfObscurePairings I agree
How can you say that!!!!
Tell me one thing what profit he would gain by using Harry
What he did was for the welfare of whole wizarding world
Dumbledore loved harrry so much
(And sorry for my english)
Varda Kazmi yes yes definitely a good point but... Dumbledore always knew in the end Harry had to die for the welfare of the wizarding world/ Voldemort to die. The one turning point where he had hope for Harry was where Voldemort came back to life and used Harry’s blood to resurrect himself, so the love protection lived in Voldemort. (this is just a theory that I think is a good one) don’t attack me
@@jas5117 by the way I love your account name😂
Varda Kazmi thanks lol also I just realized that my explaining was horrible when I was talking about the love protection. So I was saying how Harry would have the protection as long as he called 4 Privet Drive his home (until 17 or 18 I’m not completely sure). Dumbledore knew he would have to die when Voldemort was at his weakest point. But in goblet of fire, when Peter Pettigrew resurrected Voldemort, they used Harry’s blood as part of the potion thing. So then Voldemort could touch Harry but it also meant that the protection lived in Voldemort even if Harry didn’t call the Dursley’s house his home. This is where the ultimate plan changed, Dumbledore knew Harry had to die but since one of them had to kill each other, he knew that when Harry sacrificed himself, he wouldn’t fully “die” because of the love protection in Voldemort’s blood. So what I’m trying to say is that Dumbledore was less of a father figure but more of a guardian/mentor as he always knew what fate Harry had to face in the end. So yea quoting Snape: “You’ve been raising him like a pig for slaughter” But that’s not 100% true as I explained above.
I really like the canon ships and they really work
Ron and hermione kind of started to actually have feelings for eachother back in their 3rd year
And harry and ginny are just great together and both relationships developed really well
It's not as out of the blue as it seems
The bit about the toilets had me like 😂😂 your reaction was priceless
Mine: Voldemort having a kid with Bellatrix actually makes complete sense. Siring an heir in order for them to bring him back to life in case the horcruxes fail is a pretty ”Voldemort” thing to do.
You do realize voldermort was conceived under a LOVE POTION AND HE CAN’T FELL LOVE AT ALL!
@@Marcedonia not love
Voldemort used bellatrix and never valued her as "love". He used her to create delphini so that if anything goes wrong they could have a second chanace
But he doesn't expect the horcruxes to fail, he's got so many. He's powerful and commands an army. He doesn't understand love, he doesn't feel love. He would never do such an act with Bellatrix
@@brelonwy he could’ve deviced this ”plan b” once he learned Harry was after the horcruxes and was capable to destroy a few. And as said before, you don’t need to feel love to concieve a child. He could’ve well just looked at it as a ”something to get over with” rather than an expression of love. There could also well be love potion envolved since the books do describe Voldemort and Bellatrix as having somekind of feelings toward each other
@@TRtherocknroller He didn't recognize that Harry was hunting for horcruxes until they got to the Hufflepuff cup (I think) and there is no way for them to have a child before the Battle of Hogwarts if that's the case. Plus, a child goes against everything, he would never commit such an act, whether for love or not, it's not who he is. Voldemort believes he's immortal, he is not about to conceive a child. Also the Cursed Child isn't considered canon by fans sooo
Here’s one: I ship Hermione Granger and Viktor Krum. If you do, reply. I also agree with that one person, Harry should’ve became the DADA teacher.
Omg yessss!!! I was recently rereading the series and I couldn't help but swoon every time Victor tried to catch Hermione's attention. Sadly she wasn't ever interested 😥
I'm also a huge Fremione and Runa shipper 😍
I'm the opposite. I ship Viktor and Ron.
I agree with the second point but not the first, but you do you!
yes, he was so cute and treated her so well 😍😍
I for one think Augusta Longbottom should've become the DADA teacher. She has loads of experience, being a veteran of TWO magical wars and an accomplished duelist. Harry would've been a great choice too, but he's got his hands full with the whole "being an Auror" thing.
Hagrid tends to drink too much and think too little and Sirius sees Harry as a James number 2, neither of them's a good father figure. Maybe Lupin?
ysBecca Lupin is underrated.
Lupin and Arthur are better in my opinion 😌
Personally I do not like how Dumbledore’s personality ended up in the last few books and it kind of made me hate him for it. I loved him and his character seemed so amazing to me just to have him make Harry into a pig to slaughter 🤷🏼♀️
Harry WASN'T a pig for slaughter, that's what Snape said because he didn't know Dumbledore's full plan. Dumbledore said that to make Harry believe that he was going to sacrifice his life for all the people fighting against Voldermot. Dumbledore couldn't tell Harry that he wouldn't really die(he didn't) only that he would have to let Voldermot kill him so that it kills the last horcrux attached to Harry.
The main reason for Dumbledore to not tell Harry because was because the protection charm couldn't work if Harry knew. After Harry walked to Voldermot and allowed him to kill him without fighting(like Lily did), it placed a protection charm on all those fighting against Voldermot (you may have noticed no one died after that, even Neville whose head was put on fire) also they could break through Voldermot's silence charm that Harry noted.
Sorry for the long paragraph 😅 but I had to make sure you didn't think Harry was a pig for slaughter.
Also J.K Rowling showed through Dumbledore's character how your past mistakes don't define you. Dumbledore may have been power driven in his teen years but he did a lot of great stuff to rectify it later, for example help stop two of the darkest wizards.
That really clears things up I didn’t think of it in the light before. Thank you for redeeming Dumbledore in my eyes
@@finleymelvin7556 yayyy glad to help 😊
@@shezcreative dude. This cleared up so much for me. Thank you.
I was watching Tessa Netting one day and came along to you and have been watching you ever since. Love your channel ❤️
Don't know if necessarily unpopular.. But I don't like Dumbledore!
I think he is controlling, manipulating and puts way too much pressure on children, especially Harry. Of course he is a mastermind and genius, but I really don't like him and his way to solve things 🤷🏼♀️
Totally agree with you!
I have to partly agree with you because Dumbledore is a very problematic and flawed character.
But he does it to save humanity, so...
@@RunaaSteinamrk yes! Thats why I think he is very intelligent. But I still don't LIKE him and put him on a pedestal like other fans do... :)
I'd love to have a friendly debate over that because I really like Dumbledore's character.
Please do elaborate how he was manipulating and controlling.
I think Hagrid was more like the cool (but cute!!!) uncle.😂
A beep beep
Edit: thanks for the heart cherry 🍒 💙💚💛❤️
That was my giggle moment! A *beep* *beep*
Yes, I have post Potter depression.. and you and your channel is my therapy.. keep up the good work. Love you 💮🌹🌸❤️❤️❤️
really liked this relaxed style video! and Harry Potter memes are always good
Sophie we have same name
But the Hagrid thing, in the battle, how they hugged after and him carrying his body was so sad
I saw all of them as father figures but after Sirius dies is when you truly notice it
Sirius was more of a father figure! He loved Harry so much and died trying to protect him. Hagrid was Harry’s friend/ lovable uncle. To this day I will never forgive Rowling for killing Sirius.
but killing sirius means that he gets to be with james. sirius obviously was in so much pain because of his best friend's death and it just makes sense for the marauders to be together again.
Here is some characters I think should have been in different houses
Harry- Slytherin
Hermione- Ravenclaw
Ginny- Slytherin
Neville- Hufflepuff
McGonagall- Ravenclaw
Hagrid- Hufflepuff
Wormtail- Slytherin
lol I just realized they are all Gryffindors😅
Okay but Ludo Bagman deserved a cameo 😂💁🏽♀️
Aisha 1 and teddy lupin
And Peeves. Winky, too.
Dubledore one did represent the character of Dumbledore portrayed in the books better than two. But one wouldn't have done such a good job in the later films but he was a great fit for the first two
Yes. I always wonder why the ministry didnt just use oclumancy on Harry during all the instances they didnt believe him. But, everyone says there wouldnt be much of a story without the ministry backlash.
I think it was more about being in denial then not believing him. They didn't want to hear the truth so they didn't bother to find it out.
that would've gone badly for harry. many of them thought he was lying, but there were just as many that thought he was psychotic. rita skeeter published an article suggesting that the curse that failed to kill him may have caused some prolonged brain damage. so if they used occlumency or truth potion, fudge would think this would just be memories of some psychotic episode and mental delusion, so he would've had harry committed. he was looking for any opportunity to expel harry (Umbridge made that attempt with the dementors) so he would've jumped at any opportunity to twist things and have harry declared legally insane and locked up
Legelimensy*
i have post-potter depression.
i think cherry’s bubble of magicalness
would literally be heaven.
cHeRRy i’M wAiTiNg fOr aN iNviTe!!
I just LOVE the hufflepuff flag in the backgroung !
I agree with the Remus comment and Arthur too. Remus and Arthur loved him for who he was, not because he was James's son. Hagrid is an amazing uncle. I like Sirius but he wasn't Harry's last family member or adult figure.
When she does her voice it sounds like Miranda sings
If I’m being completely honest I didn’t cry a ton when most of the characters died within the series I did still cry but I balled when Dobby died. Something about Dobby just felt so different and unique I couldn’t stand it when he passed.😔
You could cosplay Ginny! Your hair is perfect!
I think that she has brown eyes as well
..I wanna be a Ravenclaw..
**uses pottermore**
Omg I'm Ravenclaw :D
I feel like Arthur and Remus are/were the best father figures in Harry’s life. They can be fun and sweet but also get strict at certain times. All dads should be a mix.
Umbridge is a great antagonist but not a villain. She isn’t evil. She’s just extremely cruel.
I guess you could say that about Umbridge but I personally do think that she was evil. Many Death Eaters can’t produce Patronuses and that’s bc they don’t have enough happy memories (sad ik) and Snape is one of the only ones that can actually produce one.
In the last book, Umbridge is wearing the Horcrux locket which actually prevented Harry from producing his Patronus and she is also surrounded by Dementors and she produced her Patronus Charm. She was interrogating a half blood woman and about to take her wand (bc at the time the Ministry had a thing against non pure bloods) and she was able to produce her charm. This means that seeing someone suffer, even though she was wearing the locket and was surrounded by Dementors, made her so happy that she could produce her Patronus charm. Pretty evil.
I agree about the Auror thing. No doubt, Harry is a fantastic Auror. But, I would have been happier if he'd come to be the Defense Against the Dark Arts professor. I mean, who would be better to teach these kids than The Boy Who Lived?! Also, I always knew I was a Gryffindor *my whole family are Gryffindors* and I got sorted by Pottermore several years ago into Gryffindor. My roommate is a Slytherin.
A few of my unpopular opinions:
The whole Rita Skeeter thing
Regulus Black’s story. It is so incredibly moving and anyone who has only seen the films will see regulus as a bad character when he is such an incredible person!
The St Mungo’s scene in OOTP. When Neville is meeting his parents and he keeps his mum’s gum wrapper. IT IS SO MOVING AND BEAUTIFUL!
This is a common opinion but Ginny in the films. Bruh. I think Bonnie did an incredible job but in the books she is so savage and is so strong, whereas in the films she just says ‘shoelace’ and is Harry’s awkward girlfriend.
HEDWIG’S DEATH. Harry literally doesn’t care. It broke my heart
Harmione had way more chemistry than Romione
In the films, I shipped Luna and Harry more than Harry and Ginny
Neville should’ve killed Bella
Cursed child is just.. no
Philosophers stone just isn’t it
Draco had a choice. I’m sorry, it’s just that Sirius’ family were all Slytherin and supported Voldemort so why should Draco be excused?
Gary Oldman looked fricking incredible for his age. I lowkey have a crush on Sirius black and I’m a 13 year old girl
Nymphadora is so underrated
Wolfstar was real no one can tell me otherwise
Harry is kinda scary
Voldy is a nose-less, bald, pathetic villain
Ravenclaw and hufflepuff are overlooked so much
Lavender Brown and Cho Chang get way too much hate. They were young girls who were genuinely in love
Michael Gambon was awful
Harry and Ginny’s kids have horrendous names
Percy should’ve died
Harmione’s hugs were way more passionate than Harry and ginnys kisses
KREACHER!
About Kreacher and Regulus' story, IT SHOULD'VE BEEN IN THE MOVIES. Like did you remember in Deathly Hallows pt 1 the scene where Harry and Hermione danced? It was lovely and all, but it took up a lot of time that could be enough to tell Kreacher's tale! And I definetely agree with the St. Mungo's scene about Neville and his mother, it's VERY touching
Eliza S absolutely! I mean, I’m a huge Harmione shipper so I loved the dance but they really could’ve told kreacher’s story
A LOT of people agree with the Cursed Child being a bit bad and Ravenclaw and Hufflepuff being overlooked, so I wouldnt day those 2 were unpopular, but the others are! (This is just my opinoin)
Omg yes the St.Mungos scene and everything you mentioned. Also I hate how Peeves and Winky the House elf were left out of the movies
*some things..some i disagree with but that’s just my opinion sorry..not everything you mentioned*
Do you know how Harry bought the whole trolley remember he was in the last carriage so everybody must have got what they wanted and if they didn’t then too bad lol
Can we just talk about how flawless Cherry's hair always is?! It's so smooth and straight and like too unproblematic for this world. K, that's the end of my rant, thanks for your time.
She looks great with curls, too.
I this Sirius’s death was one of the saddest! I always well up! I do have abit of post potter depression but your channel and my collecting still keeps the channel alive! Xx
I need you doing cosplays right now!! You should do Ginny you have the hair already xx
Yessssssss
Yasss
I was thinking that instead of a 12 hour Harry Potter movie with every detail from the books, why not just make a Harry Potter episode series WITH EVERY DETAIL FROM THE BOOKS???? WOULDN THAT BE SO COOL!
Yeeessss I need to see a cosplay by you!! I really want to get into Harry Potter cosplay!
Hagrid brought harry to his uncles
Introduced him to what he was
Took him away when needed
Was their protecting him in DHP1 linking to taking him away when it was time
And literally saw him grow up ( with Ron and Hermione ) all through the years and stood by him.
I'd say he had a big part to play.
I’m a young witch but I never was in Gryffindor or Slytherin! I was in Ravenclaw since the beginning! I couldn’t be happier with it!
I'm Ravenclaw. Hi🦅🦅🦅
The vanishing poop thing really kind of freaked me out. Like where does it all go!
Dumbledore did not care about Harry, only his ability to take out Lord Voldemort. He emotionally manipulated him since the beginning of the books.
Julia Marie yes yes and YES
Julia Marie yes I’ve been saying this for years!! People hate on Snape constantly for being mean, but praise Dumbledore even though he was 10x worse
Lari Adams well Snape is shitty as well... i mean I feel like 90% of adult figure in that books were shitty person ahahah
Yes yes a thousand times yes
Julia Marie agreeeeeeed
Yessss!!!! Please please please do a detailed Luna cosplay!!!
Also.... my sons 10 months, do we think it's time to put down the gruffulo and start reading Harry Potter to him at bedtime? I have the Jim Kay ones if that helps 🤷♀️😂
Every time you skip a post i have to go back and pause to read it😂
OMG! You could totally pull off Ginny if you cosplayed her.I say go for it!
I have also just realised if you put a wig on you could so be Luna too.
saying "Malfoy voice" three times fast, might be harder then saying "toy boat" three times fast. Yes, would love to see you do some cosplay.
Ravenclaw here. You absolutely can "choose" your house on Pottermore, the sorting hat quiz is so easy to game and most of the answers are clear what house they represent. But maybe that is the reason why I'm in ravenclaw.
i still makes me sad thinking about how harry completely left out hagrid when naming his sons
I so wasn't going to follow you but you genuinely made me laugh with this video. I'll be honest, I really wanted to be a Gryffindor but then I did the pottermore quiz and was sorted into Hufflepuff. I was gutted then read many of the qualities and traits of the house and I thought, you know what. I am totally a Hufflepuff... Haven't looked back once. I try and get my hands on as much Hufflepuff merch as I can!
I think snape's death was actually the most devastating🤷🏻♀️
beth upton that’s.....interesting 😂
Same!!
Nah, Snape sucks. And he didn’t have anything to live for after Voldemort was defeated anyway. He wasted his life pining for Lily, which is immature, creepy, and ridiculous, and then only helped fight Voldemort because he was attempting to avenger her.
For me it was sirius. He's my favourite character, i hoped for a redemption arc for him, and after i figured out harry could use the mirror shard to see he's okay, i litteraly cried for an hour (after i read the book)
his death was the most interesting
I’m glad draco didn’t get a redemption arch , he never showed interest on being on the “good side “ , he never attempted it , yes he got cold feet when Voldemort returned cuz he was scared , the malfoys in general didn’t wanted to be a part of death eaters anymore but that doesn’t mean they wanted to switch sides and join Harry , they just wanted to be left alone , that’s not a redemption arch nor a tease at one
liquid luck is nothing more than a placebo - See Super Carlin Brothers video (makes so much sense)
You went past my post on the top Harry Potter posts on Reddit!! You were so close and I got excited 😭
Wow! Your hair is so vibrant! It's beautiful! I hope I can go ginger one day too!
Really nice!
Surely you can’t lock your future children in their bedrooms to read HP, that’s OUTRAGEOUS! You have to lock them in the cupboard under the stairs.
I personally love that Harry became an Auror. I felt it was fitting lol
Personally think the Pottermore sorting quiz is a load of BS. What pet do I want? Do I prefer night or day? I think you can really determine your house for yourself, depending on what you value. Chances are if you want to be in a certain house, it’s probably your house because you value it or whatever 🤷♂️
The heads or tails question was even worse. Or left or right. Or black or white. I didn't like the patronus test either. Self-typing is always the best way of typing for me, the info is there. I took the sorting test several times (with multiple accounts and deleting it). In the end I took it like 30 times and always got another result. Also the set of questions is always different too- the one set sends you to one house, the other set to another. And even when you think the black or white question made sense (black for Slytherin)- look at the breakdown someone published. As far as I know white sent you into Slytherin. Most of the breakdown is just like- what? Anyway, I totally agree with you. Almost any other inofficial test is even better.
Marianne The pottermore tests I took sadly never had these questions ):
Marianne Sounds much better, the way it was before /:
And the wand test👎👎👎👎
Agreed. I'm surprised it didn't ask for your favorite color.
The pet question is really dumb.
I got Gryffindor one time and was really confused because that's the house I identify with the least. In general, I think these types of quizzes shouldn't focus on likes and should focus on values.
The time turner should have really been used to go back to Slughorn and Tom Riddle's conversation about horcruxes.... IMO
The time turned couldn’t go back in time more then a couple hours😉
I sort of feel like Hagrid was like a nurturing older brother to Harry. He clearly loved him and didn't want to see him hurt, but he could also be reckless and was guided through many of his decisions by Dumbledore (who was the one who planned how Harry would be looked after).
About the Hogwarts plumbing thing, the first thing that came to my mind was that tiny, wholly unimportant plot point *the* *Chamber* *of* *Secrets.* Where was the entrance before? Why did nobody find it when they were tearing up the school to put the plumbing in? Was the plumber an heir of Slytherin? I can't imagine why else they'd put a sink with a carved snake that opens to the Chamber there. Or maybe there was another entrance which the previous heir blocked off then tore up the girls' bathroom to put this new entrance there without attracting any attention at all? I honestly can't think of any answer to these questions that isn't stupidly convoluted, and for what? To justify a silly tweet?
Also, what *is* your accent? I couldn't pin that down at all.
draco when the Candy's gone
draco - POTTER!!!!!!!!
I love the t-shirt. Where did you get it?
No, I loved Hagrid from first sight. He loved the three of them so much and I didn’t see the same smile from Harry when he was with Sirius that he had when he was with Hagrid. Oh and it’s so cute when Hagrid cries when he’s been released from Azkaban. And they hug him. I see Harry having tea with Hagrid in his hut everyday and just talking about the world of magic, where’s Hagrid says “I shouldn’t have said that..”
I definitely agree with the cedric one. It was so sad.
I never understood why they had top notch Potions masters, yet never made Liquid Luck more than once that whole time, so they could sort out the issue with Voldemort early on. It's odd they would only offer 1 as a gift to a child randomly, with everything that was going on in that world. If Harry hadn't won it, ironically only due to another Potions Master at the school who was so good he re-wrote the text book, it would've sat idle. That's bonkers! They didn't give him any rules for using it and some of the kids even thought he'd given it to Ron to win a simple ordinary Quidditch match. The fact that Harry used it to just get some info from Slughorn blows my mind lol He didn't even keep some for when they went to get the Horcrux after. I know he gave some to his friends which saved them (in the books) but it was so underused and wasted. Albus had already figured out Tom had learnt about Horcruxes, doesn't matter that whole convo he had with Slughorn. Same as the time-turners, I know they all allegedly broke but someone could make another and go back and fix all the wrongs Voldermort did. I know they are just fictional books and not everything makes sense or is tidy, but they were gaping holes. With Hermione's skills she could've made some while they were hiding and used it on every trip to find more Horcruxes. Only one person would've needed to take it to protect everyone around them also. Nothing bad can happen while someone is feeling the effects! Voldemort also would've prized Felix Felicis above anything else, even the Elder Wand. Nothing would be more powerful than guaranteed success!
I thought I was a Slytherin for so long but it was just one of my other personalities pushing their thoughts on to me. I am a Ravenclaw!😁
Sirius indeed was a great god father and also a very good and cool replacement of james.. Harry liked him more than anything after he met him.. and it really made me cry while reading the book when Sirius died.. and whenever Harry remembers him he was really missing him and hoping if he comes back..
Personally I love Sirius more than any one in Harry Potter series...
Oh hey! I'm the Hermione cosplayer! (:
Really?
@@jemima8118 Yep!!!
You did such a good job!!! 🌻
@@okeannos5449 Thank you!
@@kariellex Wait are you that person on Reddit?
Hagrid's the only father figure that didnt have any ulterior motives in regards to his relationship with Harry. Dumbledore had the whole greater good plan for defeating Voldemort, and Sirius was projecting James Potter onto Harry. not saying they didnt care for him, just that Hagrid wasnt sending Harry invites to his hut for tea justso Harry would have mail for some underlying personal gain. He just cared about Harry's emotional wellbeing
THIS
Did not cedric father yell.
MY PRESIUS !!!