Alright it’s theory time: Seamus has never actually watched a Disney movie sequel, and and all of his reviews were written by Kanye West. The facts are right there in front of you, open your eyes sheeple.
I'm pretty sure the "Jafar was good!" Theory stems from the starkid musical "Twisted" which is a parody of Aladdin that frames Jafar as the main character and Aladdin as an insane, sex-crazed lunatic. Theres a lot more to the story, and it's obviously not...going to hold up based on the Disney movie, but I can get where the theory came from.
The Scar Eating Mufasa Theory isnt bad but it is debunkable: 1. The skull is more similar to a baboon's skull than a lion's. 2. Hyenas dont *prey* on lions but they do eat their dead bodies.
It is literally just the skull of a male baboon. I know that even without looking up references. It's so stupid that people are so blind to clear differences in the two skulls.
Also, the point that hyenas don’t eat lions is also bad, because in the movie (not saying anything about real life, since I don’t know about it in real life) it’s assumed they kill Scar and eat him afterward.
The theory on Jafar is literally just the plot of "Twisted: The Untold Story of a Royal Viser". Its a musical by Starkid here on youtube and that is just its direct plot.
For the “Jafar was the good guy” theory, there’s an awesome musical on TH-cam called Twisted: The Untold Story of a Royal Vizier where it retells Aladdin in a way where yes, Jafar is the good guy. It’s really good, 10/10 should go watch. (ps. It is not family friendly. Like at all. Just a warning if there are any kiddos reading this. It is very hilarious though)
@Victoria Saade they didn't make it for Disney lmao. It's harmless too it's just a parody musical and Aladdin isn't even owned by Disney the story is public domain.
Ok but the whole “Wendy is tinkerbells mom” theory is indeed bad but could easily be adapted to make (a little more) sense. It’s obviously not Wendy because we see her as a child at the end, but I mean it could be Michael (Wendy’s youngest brother). Going by the timeline of the never land series set out by Seamus in one of the pixie hollow movie videos, a few years passing would give Michael the chance to grow up a bit from the (presumably) newborn in tinker bell to the toddler/young child in Peter Pan. Plus he’s blonde like the baby too. But I guess “Michael is tinkerbells father” doesn’t have the same clickbait potential. (Omg why did I put even a minuscule amount of thought into a theory that the creator obviously didn’t lol)
Tbh it is a good theory well you fixing it up it would make sense if it was Micheal Wendy's younger brother but it doesn't as he is male and Tinkerbell and Periwinkle aren't male. If they was male then I could accept that theory but since they aren't male I can't as the child is female
@@johannadagny6237 nope, definitely not. at the moment there are like... 15 canon male fairies in the movies. if something, i think the gender of the fairy could have more to do with what the laugh hits; for example Tink's birth laugh hits a white flower, which turns into a dress... but that's not really a good theory either
We were learning about Shakespeare in English I said lion king 1 and 2 were based off Shakespeare plays,my teacher said she likes lion king 2 and the Disney sequels were quite bad As soon as i heard this I knew Seamus had to know
Here’s a theory: Wendy grows up to be Mrs. Banks from Mary Poppins. Mrs. Banks first name is Winifred so she must of had the nick name Wendy as a child. The time line between the two stories linearly would make her a little old to be Mrs. banks, but in the book Peter Pan, Peter regularly brings Wendy back to Neverland, allowing her to not age as many years as she should have on Earth They both have a daughter named Jane, but the biggest problem with this theory is that in the Peter Pan sequal, Wendy’s son is named Danny. In Mary Poppins the son is named Michael (which it wouldn’t surprise me is Wendy actually decided to name her son after one of her brothers). This theory was mostly based off the books and the staged musicals.
that is really well thought out. I give you a round of applause. Also, Mary Poppins was definitely a Slytherin. Deal with it but I claim her as one (I mean, either that or Ravenclaw. C'mon, "practically perfect in every way?")
Interesting theory, but doesn't seem possible. Mary Poppins takes place during the Suffragette movement, Mrs. Banks has her song all about it, placing the film around 1910 or thereabouts. The Peter Pan sequel, Return to Neverland, takes place during the German campaign against England in 1940, during WWII. Wendy's daughter Jane is about 12 years old, meaning Wendy would be around 30-40 years old. This places Wendy's trip to Neverland to be between 1912 and 1922, when she was in her early teens (assuming she was about 12-ish). Meaning that Mary Poppin takes place before Peter Pan, so Wendy would have to age backwards to become Mrs. Banks to fit your theory. This does potentially indicate that Peter Pan and Mary Poppins were both flying around London in roughly the same time. So here's alternate theory: What if Mary Poppins is Peter Pans mother?! A petulant boy rebelling against his "practically perfect" mom.
The one thing I immediately thought of when I saw the "Scar ate Mufasa bc hyenas don't eat lions" theory was that the hyenas literally ate Scar at the end. So even if they don't eat lions irl they did in the movie.
The problem with the 'cannibal Scar' theory is that the skull Scar is holding isn't actually that of a lion. Like at all. It's actually a Baboon skull. You can tell based off the bony brow ridge above the eye sockets, which is a typical characteristic of monkey/ape skulls. Lion, and cat skulls in general, lack these. So no, Scar isn't holding Mufasa's skull
@@Bookish_Irish_Dancer0728 Remember how he feel down the sewer with no chances of surviving? Well... my theory says that he might have chocked with the food he was eating at the moment while he was falling. CRAZY, RIGHT? :000
Actually, the scar skull thing it was a Hamlet reference, like the whole film. Hamlet once held the skull of his jester. This could’ve been Scar’s “jester” as it is much more like the skull of a baboon than lion, especially when based on size.
Because Disney takes older more grotesque stories and makes them family friendly, wouldn't the lion King be that of a family friendly rendition of hamlet? I believe I saw that somewhere, I could be wrong though
@@_sadfrog1870 it is well known that the lion king is a retelling of hamlet. Uncle kills father, son runs away, father’s ghost tells so to skill uncle, son comes back to kill the uncle, causes the uncle’s death. Also the uncle does what he does to take the throne.
@@ashhinman1919 I wasn't entirely sure if it was because even though I've heard it somewhere I wasn't sure on the whole story of hamlet as I've never been told the whole story, so that you for confirming it was :)
unrelated to this specific video but I wanted Seamus to know that every time a character falls off a cliff I hear his voice in my head saying "Disney sequel fake-out death"
The "IS Jafar actually the good guy" just gave me flashbacks to Twisted, the musical by starkid (The same people who did a very potter musical). So yeah, if you ever feel like sympathising with Jafar, watch that. Also lockdown's hard on everyone, so don't you dare beating yourself up over or apologizing for not posting in while, that's totally valid!
How I feel when I go to make a Starkid reference on a not Starkid of Starkid adjacent video but there are already lots of other comments: “BABY YOU’RE NOT ALONE!” Seriously though we need to introduce Seamus to Starkid especially AVPT and Twisted but all of them that would be amazing
The lion King one is debunkable on all points 1. Hyenas most definitely will eat a dead lion, they even eat Scar at the end of the movie. 2. It is extremely rare for lions to eat each other. 3. That skull is most definitely a baboon skull
I need seamus to watch the a very potter trilogy by starkid or twisted. Edit: Siriusly, if he did it would be TOTALLY AWESOME Also I'd put in a Twisted pun, but I'm having a hard time finding one.
The problem with the theory is that the skull Scar is holding isn't actually that of a lion. Like at all. It's actually a Baboon skull. You can tell based off the bony brow ridge above the eye sockets, which is a typical characteristic of monkey/ape skulls. Lion, and cat skulls in general, lack these. So no, Scar isn't holding Mufasa's skull and is instead playing with the body of an unfortunate baboon.
3:10 THE HOUSE OF MOUSE MOVIES WERE MY CHILDHOOD lmao kind of exagerating here but I liked them when they played them on halloween and christmas as a kid
Flashback made me nostalgic for a "hello, there - how ya doing?" intro. Then the pic made me miss the blue hair ... Take care of yourself! February sucks.
Since in Frozen II they’re shown to have cameras that can take photographs, but when Anna and Elsa’s parents were young and those soldiers and such got trapped in the forest they didn’t, it must take place around the 1830s or 1840s, like it said (photography was invented in the late 1810s / early 1820s but wasn’t widely available until a little bit later).
What would make more sense for the tinkebell theory is if it was Michael Wendy’s younger brother. 1-Wendy is brunette 2-Michael is blonde 3- Wendy has a pretty big age gap to Michael. 4- It never says the baby is a girl in the beginning of the film That would make sense in the Tinkerbell fairy timeline and would maintain a connection between Tinkerbell and the Darling Family
because of your videos i’ve started yelling DISNEY SEQUEL FAKEOUT DEATH every time i watch a marvel movie (usually referring to loki) and no one in my family understands but i still do it because it needs to be said
Most people find a theory but dont do their research or even rewatch the film to see if it works, instead they go based off of their memory of the movies ... Then Seamus finds these theories ... Seamus: okay, hold my drink
I'm always drawn to the "they were dead the whole time" ideas because I love the idea of reshaping the entire story and examining it from a new, much less literal, perspective. Then I remember it's a dumb cliche and definitely not true.
I wonder if the Jonathan and Ben in the patrons section are J and Ben from supercarlinbrothers because if not that’s a funny coincidence lmao Also I’m really sorry you’re going through mental health stuff Seamus, I really hope you know you make so many peoples days better and that there is always help out there if you aren’t getting it already :))
@@joshuasgameplays9850 well technically I wasn’t proving it since I even said the original didn’t have it I was just referencing a work/ musical that actually has that
I hate the whole "this theory will ruin your childhood" trope because I feel like it fundamentally misunderstands the joy of theories. The opportunity to piece together evidence and expand a story you love is not childhood ruining, even if it is in service to a slightly morbid theory.
Did the "good jafar theory" just rip off starkid's Twisted just like that? Lmao Also, l really needed that "headcanon vs theory" mini rant. Like, there is no reason to be ashamed to call what it is. I myself have my own share of stupid headcanons that go against all stablished canon, but thats the fun of it. Embrace the headcanon!
Didn't Matilda's powers work from fear and anger so I think she'd be a Sith. I do subscribe to the headcanon that Matilda later becomes Carrie from the 1976 thriller.
I’ve been waiting for a Seamus Gorman video all week. After WandaVision is over you should do a reacting to the worst WandaVision theories. That ought to be interesting
Thanks for teaching me something new, I had no idea what a sultana was and thanks to you I got to hear about it and look it up! For those who don't know it's a raisin but made with green grapes, usually seedless, instead of purple or red ones, usually with seeds, which I always was curious about if you could make raisins from green grapes
13:45 it’s popular because people like angst and dark twists. Making a movie “darker” with a theory/headcannon makes people think it’s more mature, even though those theories/headcannons suck. Sometimes they have an interesting food for thought though.
Alright it’s theory time:
Seamus has never actually watched a Disney movie sequel, and and all of his reviews were written by Kanye West.
The facts are right there in front of you, open your eyes sheeple.
This is canon
sheeple may be my new favorite word
I feel so betrayed.
Kanye West isn’t real and Seamus Gorman is actually the CEO of Disney
All the scripts are written by kanye and brad bird's son
There are 3 things certain in life.
1.Death
2.Taxes
3.Seamus having a great intro
Taxes aren’t certain if you die before you do them
And that Bethesda's next game will be glitchy.
and this all being jafars fault
@@RealogOnlyBrodie yee
@@RealogOnlyBrodie slightly dark..... but ok
“Jafar is a full on grape”
-Seamus Gorman 2021
this made sense in my head i swear
@@SeamusGorman4 I get you 😂
@@RiptidePen the not brain world
Idk if you guys have it in English too, but in Portuguese it would mean that jafar is real pretty
@@luizasabbaga592 Not here, but Imma use that now lol. Whenever I flirt or just compliment someone Imma say they're a grape
"Does this make this a top ten video?"
Does this make you become the thing you swore to destroy?
you either die a hero or live long enough to see yourself become the villain
@@SeamusGorman4 it’s ok I’d rather watch you then them anyway 😂
Seamus Gorman I'M POSITIVE THAT'S A QUOTE BUT I CAN'T REMEMBER FROM WHAT!!!!
@@techtor6928 It’s from Star Wars I think
@@techtor6928 It's from The Dark Knight. Harvey Dent says it.
The Jafar was the good guy theory is pretty much just Starkids "Twisted"
Yes! Exactly!
Damn, now I want him to make a video reviewing Twisted.
I said the same thing lol, I bet that’s where that theory comes from
@@unicornburgers302 that would be amazing
Glad someone brought this up.
"how is Wendy getting from a baby to a child in a few weeks?"
*Billy and Tommy have left the chat*
😂😂😭
*What if I told you that Wendy from Peter Pan is an Avenger?!?!?!*
I understood that reference
@@RealogOnlyBrodie I understood THAT reference
The baby wasn't Wendy it was her baby brother Michael
theory: in the movie Soul, Joe Gardener is actually dead for almost the whole film!
The movie directors: *YESN’T*
But Joe never even died?
I dont know seems like a stretch, proof?
WHAT REALLY
THAT’S IMPOSSIBLE
can we all agree that most disney theories were thought of when people were high on cocaine?
STOP FOLLOWING ME, i see you at almost every video, WHO ARE YOU?
@@718jef i am vengeance
jef718 I think I've seen the two of you on another video I watched
Omg it’s spooederman! I’ve seen you all over the place!
@@spooderman6312 wrong hero buddy
I'm pretty sure the "Jafar was good!" Theory stems from the starkid musical "Twisted" which is a parody of Aladdin that frames Jafar as the main character and Aladdin as an insane, sex-crazed lunatic. Theres a lot more to the story, and it's obviously not...going to hold up based on the Disney movie, but I can get where the theory came from.
the theory should've given starkid credit lmao
jasmine is also a spoiled brat which lines up with what they say about the sultan in this theory
YESSS
THIS IS ALL YOUR FAULT JAFAR!
thanks hermione
The Scar Eating Mufasa Theory isnt bad but it is debunkable:
1. The skull is more similar to a baboon's skull than a lion's.
2. Hyenas dont *prey* on lions but they do eat their dead bodies.
*He ate Rafiki’s mom confirmed*
@@RealogOnlyBrodie OMG RLLY?? My mind is blown!
It is literally just the skull of a male baboon. I know that even without looking up references. It's so stupid that people are so blind to clear differences in the two skulls.
@ICIEYT mr stark I don’t feel so good
Also, the point that hyenas don’t eat lions is also bad, because in the movie (not saying anything about real life, since I don’t know about it in real life) it’s assumed they kill Scar and eat him afterward.
The theory on Jafar is literally just the plot of "Twisted: The Untold Story of a Royal Viser". Its a musical by Starkid here on youtube and that is just its direct plot.
Yeah, but the theory is like, the Disney sequel/ ripoff that no one except some kids in the audience likes-
Guys Seamus has actually been dead this whole time and the table is his guardian angel guiding him to the afterlife 🤯🤯🤯
Perfect
Crazy 🤯
Reviewing all of the Barbie movies will be his purgatory.
it all makes sense now...
OMG IT'S ALL COMING TOGETHER🤯🤯
For the “Jafar was the good guy” theory, there’s an awesome musical on TH-cam called Twisted: The Untold Story of a Royal Vizier where it retells Aladdin in a way where yes, Jafar is the good guy. It’s really good, 10/10 should go watch.
(ps. It is not family friendly. Like at all. Just a warning if there are any kiddos reading this. It is very hilarious though)
@Victoria Saade they didn't make it for Disney lmao. It's harmless too it's just a parody musical and Aladdin isn't even owned by Disney the story is public domain.
did my comment get deleted.. sad
Ok but the whole “Wendy is tinkerbells mom” theory is indeed bad but could easily be adapted to make (a little more) sense. It’s obviously not Wendy because we see her as a child at the end, but I mean it could be Michael (Wendy’s youngest brother). Going by the timeline of the never land series set out by Seamus in one of the pixie hollow movie videos, a few years passing would give Michael the chance to grow up a bit from the (presumably) newborn in tinker bell to the toddler/young child in Peter Pan. Plus he’s blonde like the baby too.
But I guess “Michael is tinkerbells father” doesn’t have the same clickbait potential.
(Omg why did I put even a minuscule amount of thought into a theory that the creator obviously didn’t lol)
Tbh it is a good theory well you fixing it up it would make sense if it was Micheal Wendy's younger brother but it doesn't as he is male and Tinkerbell and Periwinkle
aren't male. If they was male then I could accept that theory but since they aren't male I can't as the child is female
@@Angryginger2421 wait is that a fact a male fairy can only be born by a male baby fairy and vice versa ?
@@johannadagny6237 nope, definitely not. at the moment there are like... 15 canon male fairies in the movies. if something, i think the gender of the fairy could have more to do with what the laugh hits; for example Tink's birth laugh hits a white flower, which turns into a dress... but that's not really a good theory either
Day 1 of asking Seamus to make a video about the political climate in Pixie Hollow.
DON’T START THIS
@@SeamusGorman4 I already did, Seamus. I already did.
I second this motion
I hereby join this movement
“Climate” good one
the Jafar one is just a worse version of Starkid’s Twisted
Yep
it’s all jafars fault
We were learning about Shakespeare in English I said lion king 1 and 2 were based off Shakespeare plays,my teacher said she likes lion king 2 and the Disney sequels were quite bad
As soon as i heard this I knew Seamus had to know
So I'm pretty sure the 2nd theory was based off the musical "twisted" that pretty much makes Jafar the good guy
I love how this comment section is just full of Starkid fans talking about Twisted
NEXT YEAR I’LL BE TRANSFERRED TO PIGFARTS!
I'm just imagining someone who's never watched any Starkid reading through all these comment threads and being so confused
Meh, I may as well contribute. DUCK IS LOOOOORD...
Is it ok that I’ve only ever watched Avpm by them?
Here’s a theory:
Wendy grows up to be Mrs. Banks from Mary Poppins.
Mrs. Banks first name is Winifred so she must of had the nick name Wendy as a child.
The time line between the two stories linearly would make her a little old to be Mrs. banks, but in the book Peter Pan, Peter regularly brings Wendy back to Neverland, allowing her to not age as many years as she should have on Earth
They both have a daughter named Jane, but the biggest problem with this theory is that in the Peter Pan sequal, Wendy’s son is named Danny. In Mary Poppins the son is named Michael (which it wouldn’t surprise me is Wendy actually decided to name her son after one of her brothers).
This theory was mostly based off the books and the staged musicals.
that is really well thought out. I give you a round of applause. Also, Mary Poppins was definitely a Slytherin. Deal with it but I claim her as one (I mean, either that or Ravenclaw. C'mon, "practically perfect in every way?")
Actually, Winifried's nickname would be Winnie.
Winnie is definitely more common of a nick name for Winifred, but I think Wendy could work:)
@@sarahclark2042 Wendy is actually a popular nickname for Gwendolyn!
Interesting theory, but doesn't seem possible.
Mary Poppins takes place during the Suffragette movement, Mrs. Banks has her song all about it, placing the film around 1910 or thereabouts.
The Peter Pan sequel, Return to Neverland, takes place during the German campaign against England in 1940, during WWII. Wendy's daughter Jane is about 12 years old, meaning Wendy would be around 30-40 years old. This places Wendy's trip to Neverland to be between 1912 and 1922, when she was in her early teens (assuming she was about 12-ish).
Meaning that Mary Poppin takes place before Peter Pan, so Wendy would have to age backwards to become Mrs. Banks to fit your theory. This does potentially indicate that Peter Pan and Mary Poppins were both flying around London in roughly the same time. So here's alternate theory:
What if Mary Poppins is Peter Pans mother?! A petulant boy rebelling against his "practically perfect" mom.
I was just thinking "I want to watch TH-cam" and immediately got the notification for this video
OMG same
Sameee
ME TOO
It's fate
“What if Jafar was actually the good guy?” *THIS IS ALL YOUR FAULT JAFAR*
thanks hermione
@@sillygoosetaur DID SOMEONE SAY DRACO MALFOY
@@sillygoosetaur I'm going to Pigfarts this year
10 points to Dumbledoor
I WANT A NEW QUALITY WAGON WITH WHEELS THAT ARE CIRCLES
Apparently the skull Scar has fits closer to a baboon than a lion
Day two of asking Seamus to spend his mid-twenties watching and reviewing Barbie movies. (Sorry Seamus, but it had to be done)
I hereby join this movement
I'm in!! please make it happen
I've been looking for this
yes
YES
I'm so happy that everyone is mentioning Twisted, Seamus should definitely watch and review it!
dhjsjdjdk yes
The one thing I immediately thought of when I saw the "Scar ate Mufasa bc hyenas don't eat lions" theory was that the hyenas literally ate Scar at the end. So even if they don't eat lions irl they did in the movie.
Seamus should absolutely do a tier list of ALL the barbie movies..
I know I’d at least like to see him watch Barbie and the Diamond Castle
@@savannahwestover2538 YES! THAT WAS MY CHILDHOOD!
@@philiprivers669 Same!!! I’ve loved it ever since
@@savannahwestover2538 and philp rivers SAMEEE he needs to review that one!
Title: 10 of the WORST Disney theories
Seamus: This theory is actually pretty decent!
Ah yes, the first theory.
Cannibalism, my favourite.
The problem with the 'cannibal Scar' theory is that the skull Scar is holding isn't actually that of a lion. Like at all. It's actually a Baboon skull. You can tell based off the bony brow ridge above the eye sockets, which is a typical characteristic of monkey/ape skulls. Lion, and cat skulls in general, lack these. So no, Scar isn't holding Mufasa's skull
welp circle of life
@@Joakim1400 r/ape
Clearly someone hasn’t seen “Twisted: The Untold Story of a Royal Vizier” by Starkid
Clearly everyone in the comment section has watched it
Ok, but her me out. WHAT IF JOE GARNERD FROM SOUL ACTUALLY DIED AT THE BEGGING OF THE MOVIE AND THE AFTERLIFE IS ACTUALLY THE AFTERLIFE
WHAT? HOW🤔🤔
@@Bookish_Irish_Dancer0728 Remember how he feel down the sewer with no chances of surviving? Well... my theory says that he might have chocked with the food he was eating at the moment while he was falling. CRAZY, RIGHT? :000
‘Jafar was the good guy’
that’s just the whole plot of Twisted right there
THIS IS ALL YOUR FAULT JAFAR
THIS IS ALL YOUR FAULT JAFAR
THIS IS ALL YOUR FAULT JAFAR
THIS IS ALL YOUR FAULT JAFAR
THIS IS ALL YOUR FAULT JAFAR
Actually, the scar skull thing it was a Hamlet reference, like the whole film. Hamlet once held the skull of his jester. This could’ve been Scar’s “jester” as it is much more like the skull of a baboon than lion, especially when based on size.
Because Disney takes older more grotesque stories and makes them family friendly, wouldn't the lion King be that of a family friendly rendition of hamlet? I believe I saw that somewhere, I could be wrong though
@@_sadfrog1870 it is well known that the lion king is a retelling of hamlet. Uncle kills father, son runs away, father’s ghost tells so to skill uncle, son comes back to kill the uncle, causes the uncle’s death. Also the uncle does what he does to take the throne.
@@ashhinman1919 I wasn't entirely sure if it was because even though I've heard it somewhere I wasn't sure on the whole story of hamlet as I've never been told the whole story, so that you for confirming it was :)
I never thought there would be a theory about the political climate of Aladdin.
unrelated to this specific video but I wanted Seamus to know that every time a character falls off a cliff I hear his voice in my head saying "Disney sequel fake-out death"
I watched Rise of Skywalker and that's all I could think of...cause it's full of those bad boys
I love how Twisted was turned into a full blown theory XD
aka they ripped off twisted and claimed it as their own
this is all your fault jafar
Seamus : is this a top 10 video?
Me: Seamus you have broken your own rules
The "IS Jafar actually the good guy" just gave me flashbacks to Twisted, the musical by starkid (The same people who did a very potter musical). So yeah, if you ever feel like sympathising with Jafar, watch that.
Also lockdown's hard on everyone, so don't you dare beating yourself up over or apologizing for not posting in while, that's totally valid!
this is all your fault jafar
penelope rat-storm I‘m at work rn and it kinda sucks. Getting this notification lowkey made my day.
How I feel when I go to make a Starkid reference on a not Starkid of Starkid adjacent video but there are already lots of other comments: “BABY YOU’RE NOT ALONE!” Seriously though we need to introduce Seamus to Starkid especially AVPT and Twisted but all of them that would be amazing
Couldn't agree more. Just lots of Starkids wandering around in the internet and trying to convert everyone in their new exciting religion.
Seamus you should watch twisted from Starkid which is the parody that everyone’s talking about, and starship which is the little mermaid in space
And A Very Potter Trilogy, of course!
In fact, Seamus just review all Starkid musicals.
Theory: Seamus is actuallly a storm trooper who got tired of his job
Underrated comment
I think the whole Jafar being good thing comes from the Twisted parody musical, since his goal in that was to make his country better
he didn’t fix the socioenomic inequality
Clearly everything was his fault, he was a sorcerer! Smh my head, he really tried to tell us that it was "sCieNce"
This is a joke-
@@sillygoosetaur But if he believed he could...
@@sillygoosetaur I mean he wasn’t Sultan for very long
@@Al_-cf1dj it wasn’t lol
if you don’t want it to be a top ten you could call them bottom ten since they’re the worst
The lion King one is debunkable on all points
1. Hyenas most definitely will eat a dead lion, they even eat Scar at the end of the movie.
2. It is extremely rare for lions to eat each other.
3. That skull is most definitely a baboon skull
The "they were dead the whole time" and the "it was just a dream" theorys infuriate me for some reason.
Re: Jafar is good, You need to watch Starkid's Twisted on youtube. Its obviously not canon but it explores it
he can’t be good, it’s all his fault! he didn’t fix the socioeconomic inequality
Can we take a moment and talk how much seamus has improved in terms from editing every video gets better and better keep it Up❤️
My mom showed me the “did scar eat mufasa?” One
the only "good" jafar story is twisted by team starkid and its incredible
MY THOUGHTS EXACTLY
3:19 Twisted by Starkid on TH-cam 😳 (not making fun of the musical, I rly enjoy it)
this is all your fault jafar
The skull Scar holds is WAY too small to be a lion skull though.
It's actually a baboon skull
@@Joakim1400 Ohhhhh.
But I do believe that Scar ate Mufasa sounds hella accurate
@@ribottostudio Along with Nala is Simbas half-sister and if Scar had any cubs when Simba came back he'd have gone around killing them.
@@Cliffdog01 Why are you like this?
The jafar is the good guy theory is obviously wrong but there’s a great musical called twisted by starkid that is amazing and has great songs
The musical is about if jafar was good btw
yeah they just ripped it off and claimed it as their own
this is all your fault jafar
I need seamus to watch the a very potter trilogy by starkid or twisted.
Edit: Siriusly, if he did it would be TOTALLY AWESOME
Also I'd put in a Twisted pun, but I'm having a hard time finding one.
YES
YESSSS
YAAAS
I don't understand how the "Scar ate Mufasa" theory went so viral. It doesn't make sense at all.
The problem with the theory is that the skull Scar is holding isn't actually that of a lion. Like at all. It's actually a Baboon skull. You can tell based off the bony brow ridge above the eye sockets, which is a typical characteristic of monkey/ape skulls. Lion, and cat skulls in general, lack these. So no, Scar isn't holding Mufasa's skull and is instead playing with the body of an unfortunate baboon.
@@Joakim1400 and in the end scar gets eaten by hyenas and for some reason people don’t think about that
100% thought the Jafar one was going to describe the plot of Starkid's Twisted lmaoo
this is all your fault jafar
3:10 THE HOUSE OF MOUSE MOVIES WERE MY CHILDHOOD lmao kind of exagerating here but I liked them when they played them on halloween and christmas as a kid
When I tell u I was waiting
I mean I was dying this week
i’m sorry i hope the wait was worth it!!
@@SeamusGorman4 it always is 😁
I am getting flashbacks to Seamus reacting to Watchmojo. The nostalgia is kicking in.
Flashback made me nostalgic for a "hello, there - how ya doing?" intro. Then the pic made me miss the blue hair ...
Take care of yourself! February sucks.
Since in Frozen II they’re shown to have cameras that can take photographs, but when Anna and Elsa’s parents were young and those soldiers and such got trapped in the forest they didn’t, it must take place around the 1830s or 1840s, like it said (photography was invented in the late 1810s / early 1820s but wasn’t widely available until a little bit later).
“He might as well eat his brother”
-Seamus Gorman 2021
I wonder if Seamus has ever seen Twisted
this is all your fault jafar
Y'all if you want a 'What if Jafaar was the good guy' thing, there's a musical by Starkid called Twisted. Its hella good go watch it
What would make more sense for the tinkebell theory is if it was Michael Wendy’s younger brother.
1-Wendy is brunette
2-Michael is blonde
3- Wendy has a pretty big age gap to Michael.
4- It never says the baby is a girl in the beginning of the film
That would make sense in the Tinkerbell fairy timeline and would maintain a connection between Tinkerbell and the Darling Family
*Hyenas don’t eat Lions*
Scars Death by being eaten by Hyaenas: *Am I a joke to You?*
because of your videos i’ve started yelling DISNEY SEQUEL FAKEOUT DEATH every time i watch a marvel movie (usually referring to loki) and no one in my family understands but i still do it because it needs to be said
Most people find a theory but dont do their research or even rewatch the film to see if it works, instead they go based off of their memory of the movies ...
Then Seamus finds these theories ...
Seamus: okay, hold my drink
Love how people just grabed twisted and said it was a theory, lmaoooo i love that
*this is all your fault jafar*
The Disney Princess Combined Universe is real if you watched Sofia The First.
Disney theory: you know the sultan, guess what he’s old, guess who else is old , Triton from the little mermaid. The sultan is triton confirmed
I'm always drawn to the "they were dead the whole time" ideas because I love the idea of reshaping the entire story and examining it from a new, much less literal, perspective. Then I remember it's a dumb cliche and definitely not true.
I wonder if the Jonathan and Ben in the patrons section are J and Ben from supercarlinbrothers because if not that’s a funny coincidence lmao
Also I’m really sorry you’re going through mental health stuff Seamus, I really hope you know you make so many peoples days better and that there is always help out there if you aren’t getting it already :))
Hey for the jafar good theory just watch the musical twisted that is literally about that unlike the original Aladdin movie
this is all your fault jafar
@@penelopestonee a fellow starkid fan
@@lillychrysanthemums6951 why hello
Do you know how to prove a theory? You can't just cite non-cannon fam works as evidence
@@joshuasgameplays9850 well technically I wasn’t proving it since I even said the original didn’t have it I was just referencing a work/ musical that actually has that
Bless anybody who points out Tarzan isn't Elsa and Anna's brother. That should be really obvious,but you know
i especially hate the up theories that claim carl died at the beginning of the movie or went crazy, like no❤️
Seamus saying that Scar should've ate Mufasa is kind of concerning. Does anyone know if he has siblings by any chance?
Not that it’s different, but as a kid, I loved the idea that Mary Poppins was a time lord a la Dr. Who rather than a wizard
I hate the whole "this theory will ruin your childhood" trope because I feel like it fundamentally misunderstands the joy of theories. The opportunity to piece together evidence and expand a story you love is not childhood ruining, even if it is in service to a slightly morbid theory.
SEAMUS HAS RETURNED ALL HAIL KING SEAMUS
Of course jafar was the good guy! Have you never watched “twisted” by starkid?!? Sounds like a new video in the future!!
We must convert Seamus into a starkid
@abigail wails
we must
Do you know how to prove a theory? You can't just cite non-cannon fan works as evidence
@@joshuasgameplays9850 i hope the duck curses you- or heck even wiggly could curse you
@@penelopestonee A DUCK IS LOOOOORD A DUCK IS LORD LORD LORD A DUCK IS LOOOORD
Why was I just thinking about wanting another reacting to bad Disney theories from Seamus- WOW he’s a mind reader!!
Maybe you are the mind reader 🤯
btw a female Sultan is called Sultana, so when Jasmine starts ruling she is literally a Sultana
When you said “Is Timon a cult leader?” I spit out my drink
I love how the second theory makes it seem like Jafar would be so much better than the Sultan- LIKE N O
100% with you on this one, let’s remember how jafar died: obsesión for power
Wait, Seamus has blue motifs and brings magic into our lives... Seamus is Genie confirmed?
Did the "good jafar theory" just rip off starkid's Twisted just like that? Lmao
Also, l really needed that "headcanon vs theory" mini rant. Like, there is no reason to be ashamed to call what it is. I myself have my own share of stupid headcanons that go against all stablished canon, but thats the fun of it. Embrace the headcanon!
yes. they did. and they didn’t even mention achmed.. wait who’s achmed again?
this is all your fault jafar
I really want Seamus to react to Twisted by Starkids, I honestly think he’d love it and it’d be really funny to see his overall opinions on it
+1
"Was Jafar the good guy?"
*cries in Twisted*
(But seriously I want Seamus to review Twisted now.)
NEW THEORY: MATILDA IS ACTUALLY A SECRET JEDI?!?!?!?!?
YES
Dang, you must be a Toydarian because my mind trick to get you to ignore the facts did not work.
Didn't Matilda's powers work from fear and anger so I think she'd be a Sith.
I do subscribe to the headcanon that Matilda later becomes Carrie from the 1976 thriller.
Makes sense to me
Ye, Scar ate Mufasa isn't a bad theory but I remember casual geographic debunking it
Day 4 of asking Seamus to review the Disney live action remakes
I’ve been waiting for a Seamus Gorman video all week.
After WandaVision is over you should do a reacting to the worst WandaVision theories. That ought to be interesting
i was watching famiily for my rewatch of failboat’s miitopia but then i saw seamus posted
I love how I now get notifications right when he posts now!
Pleaseee do a tier list ranking the Disney live action remakes
Thanks for teaching me something new, I had no idea what a sultana was and thanks to you I got to hear about it and look it up! For those who don't know it's a raisin but made with green grapes, usually seedless, instead of purple or red ones, usually with seeds, which I always was curious about if you could make raisins from green grapes
Seamus: “Does this make this a top ten video?”
Me: “No, cause they’re the wor-
Seamus, basically every time: “It’s not that bad”
Me: “...maybe.”
The sound at 0:28 terrified me and I spent five minutes trying to figure out where it was from
I _love_ how everyone is talking about "Twisted" By Starkid! Seamus PLEASE make a video on it
this is all your fault jafar
@@penelopestonee he didn't fix the socio-economic inequality like he promised
13:45 it’s popular because people like angst and dark twists. Making a movie “darker” with a theory/headcannon makes people think it’s more mature, even though those theories/headcannons suck. Sometimes they have an interesting food for thought though.