Critiquing MY OLD MAKEUP VIDEOS!!! | PRO MUA Reacts
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 25 ส.ค. 2024
- Hello everyone! Today I am reacting to two of my old tutorials from when I first started doing makeup on myself for social media!!
LET’S STAY CONNECTED! -
Instagram - @RobertWLSH
Twitter - @RWLSHmakeup
TikTok - RobertWelshMUA
TWITCH - Robert_welsh
🌙 Disclaimer: The links below are affiliate, meaning I will earn a small commission if you click through and make a purchase.
Shop more of my favorite products here |
shopmyshelf.us...
🌙
ILLAMASQUA | 25% OFF
CODE | ROBERT
bit.ly/2Pw6xX7
SIGMA BEAUTY | 10% OFF
CODE | Robert10
sigma-beauty.q...
COLOURPOP | 10% OFF
CODE | ROBERT
colourpop.sjv....
This eye look is from this video ! - th-cam.com/video/rxwnXeCK05k/w-d-xo.htmlsi=32Gb5tsuQFoG_W8_
I also want to add for the nude liner look - the eye needed more texture like a shimmer on the lid or something 👍🏼
Did your hand slip and add the thumbs up? Or like.. are you ok? 😂 I don’t think I’ve ever seen you use it instead of a 🖤 or 💜
Robert first I very much still appreciate and watch tutorials. Also a video idea: when to wear eye primer and when you can get away with not. I absolutely love the way you articulate the reason why things will work or not ❤
We need to protect baby Robert at all costs
😂😂😂
Ooh, can I join? Can we get jackets 😁
I knowww I love him
Will there be a handshake, passcode??
@@millicentspears how about snap and girl instead?
Hello from the Pacific Northwest. I so enjoy your programs, thank you. I'm 70, a different canvas to work on. Since the death of my oldest son to a heartattack. He was 43, worked himself to death. I have stopped caring how I look, I never use to leave the house with out my eyes done. But for 2 years I just rock in my chair. Then I discovered your videos, ghost stories, product critiquing and your how to do the looks. I'm twice washing my face now, use toner and moisturizers, and I purchased a new tinted moisturizer for foundation. You have helped me try to live again. Thank you. ❤
I'm glad to hear you've found value and joy in your life again. Wishing you luck going forward :)
May your son rest in peace 🤍 finding beauty in life is beautiful itself
Robert, my one year old is obsessed with you and James and she cackles and smiles through your videos ❤️ we look forward to your posts every week and we're here right on time for this new video!
So cuuuute thank you!! 🖤🖤
Awwww
Omg so funny my 6 yr old loves them too lol..I’ll be watching them & she’ll come over and say oh these guys? I wanna watch lol. Or she’ll say can we watch those two guys again? Lol..Robert doesn’t like kids but I’m sure he’s flattered by the love 😆🥰
I love that…how freaking adorable 🥰
I remember someone, maybe about more than a year ago, commenting that she was a nanny of a little mouse who had learnt to say "What chu finking, huuuun?" before the good night tuck & kiss. My selective memory makes me say it too some nights. I live alone🤦🏻♀️😆.
🧛🏻♀️🖤
“I don’t know what it is about being a makeup artist and not following your own advice”… I feel attacked. Made me laugh out loud. 😂
Great video!! You’re so talented!
It’s so true though isn’t it!!? 😂😂
I think that’s every career though. You go to the doctor and they tell you to get your blood work done once a year but they haven’t had their’s done in 20 lol
That's just a human trait, giving advice we don't (or can't) take! 😅
@@mirandawesley7466 dont get me started on personal trainers :DDD
What would’ve been 🔥 is if you re-created these looks Rob!
Oh good idea! Maybe I’ll do that on Insta! 🖤
@@RobertWelshI’d love to see the 2023 versions of these looks 😍
Ooooohhhh such a great idea
I’m teaching my 16-year-old niece, how to apply make up, and yours are one of the few accounts I refer her to for really good techniques and applications. Love you looking back and having a giggle at yourself, and still always having fun and not taking it all too serious. This should be fun 😅
Thank you! 🖤🖤🖤
'This is my favourite blending brush' - not now! and 'That brow! It just made me burp' 🤣🤣🤣 Never change Robert 💜
😂😂😂🖤🖤🖤
Dear Robert, You're are very kind. Watching ourselves is one of the most sincere reaction one can have. You weren't too hard on yourself. This can be an uncomfortable thing for others to watch & you made it pleasant! The naked liner & half off lashes are relatable for all make-up enthusiast! Love You💖
Thank you! 😝🖤🖤
You be nice to our Robert, Robert! We luv him! 😁
😂😂😂😂🖤🖤🖤🖤🖤
Your "old" makeup is mine on a good day! You're so, so talented. Proud to be your fan.
So it's not just me then? You'd think I'd be at least half decent at putting on makeup at my age, but, no! ( I'm 51)! 😒😂
Right?! 😂😅 When he was roasting himself over that eyeliner towards the end of the video I started to feel real bad about my eyeliner skills as they’re no where near as good as this 🥲
Aww I love your older tutorial videos! We're always our own worst critics, though! 🖤🖤🖤
😂😂🖤🖤
I have watched all the old videos (that are still there) and have a lot of them saved for the times I need to remind myself of the basics. I also like the closeups of how the makeup looks when applied. The look you create when reviewing the Stacy Marie Tahiti palette is still my number one makeup goal (I still haven’t attempted)
Oh no way! Thank you so so much! 🖤🖤
I wish tutorial videos got more love, I really miss these! 😊
Me too!
Your reaction videos are always so entertaining & informative - But you, reacting to YOU?! Beyoooond entertaining & informative! 🙌🏼
I absolutely loved this 🤍 Such an interesting dive into how your makeup (& makeup overall) has changed
Thank you so so much! 🖤🖤🖤🖤
You are so brave to share commentary on your older videos. I’m so self conscious about my old pictures let alone videos!! 😅
Video idea - you critiquing yourself critiquing yourself in another 5 years… video in video in video 😂 - no but don’t 😂. It’s so nice to see how much more relaxed and confident you are in videos now ❤ but early Robert is so sweet
😂😂😂 consider it done!
@Laura_Lawson Delete your comment asap (now that Robert has seen it and answered) before Christopher Nolan steals you this glorious metametameta concept!😜
🧛🏻♀️🖤💜🖤
@@sebumpostmortem 🤣🤣🤣🤣 fair point
Your makeup looks always blow me away! The teal/green is soo pretty! 🩵
Thank you! 🖤🖤
I feel that we need more tutorials like these ❤️ I always loved learning on how to stack colors, cause I still have issues with it 😭
And Robert can explain so nice, it would be a great to have more of these, guides on how to do eyeshadows, doing it for different eye shapes, soing contour or blush depending on the face snape and actually doing each one .
Make up lessons with Robert 😎
So lovely to see how much he has evolved ❤️❤️
“Look at this, that subscribe permanently up in the corner, that’s aggressive” 🤭😅 haha I love your way with words! I salute you for going back over old videos, I can see how much you’re not liking it but it shows true growth and maturity 😊
I have been following you since the beginning it’s very nostalgic to watch this! Your evolved but still amazing either way. 🖤🖤
Thank you!! 🖤🖤🖤
I'm so glad I get to exist on this earth at the same time as Robert Welsh
Thank you!! 🥹🖤🖤
U sound just like James 😁
Please do makeup tutorials, I love them 😊
Robert, I never realized until now that I’ve been watching you for over 4 years :O that’s insane. So proud of you ❤
I think being a professional and not following your own advice goes for many professions. I'm a nurse and we honestly make *THE* worst patients! 😆I had major surgery in 2020. I was up going to the toilet by myself, walking down the hospital corridors searching for a snack, etc. When I wasn't even supposed to be getting up unassisted yet. 😂🤷🏻♀️
❤ Love this! Maybe could you try to recreate your old looks? It would be great to see how you would improve them!
Yea I will! 🖤🖤
Amazing! Its always fun to see how we improve our skills over time. And funny to laugh at the old trends like the brows 😁
HIIIIIIIIIIIII ITSSSSSSS MEEEEEEEEEEEEEE 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 I love you roasting yourself. Also THANK YOU for still posting and being here for us 🎉
Thank you!! 🖤🖤🖤
Loving the green eye makeup!
Thanks to you, at the age of 55, I'm trying makeup for the first time. I can't do it like you, but at least I'm getting better!
There's no better way to finish the week than listening to Robert roasting himself 🤣 Also love the whole look today! 💚
😂😂😂😂!! Thank you! 🖤🖤
hahaha
Love you Robert! Seeing your dedication to your followers and how you take the time to like and comment on all of these wonderful statements warms my heart. Thanks for your kindness and professionalism always 🥰
Thank you! 🖤🖤
@@RobertWelsh AHH I did not expect such a quick response! I'm going to send this screenshot to my mom (who I got hooked on your twin channel), she's gonna freak out!
I like how close the camera was to your eye. Much easier to isolate what you're doing.
You're such a perfectionist and so hard on yourself. Treat yourself as you would a friend or client. Show yourself some love.😍
Yea absolutely!
Robert: I'm going to react to my old videos!
Robert: I really sucked at this.
😂😂🖤🖤🖤
omg this is the earliest i've been to roberts video ahhh
Thank you for being here!! 🖤🖤
Robert, anytime the day looks bleak--watching you changes everything. I wanted to tell you how much I loved one of your short clips where you talk about scars. And people's inquiries about them and their (sometimes) lack of proper understanding when asking. Your comment about some of us owning our scars was spot on. I've had one across part of my forehead since I was 5, had numerous offers to have it fixed, but said "No. I like my scar, I'd miss it." 💜🖤💜🖤
I love that you can look back at your early vids and critique them with good humor. 😂 You’re very brave. 💜🖤💜
And btw, some of us still enjoy tutorials. 😜
So happy to watch a video from you, specially now that I feel so sad #chandlerbingforever
🖤🖤🖤🖤
I used to thrive on these makeup tutorial videos back in, like, 2010. They were my favorites when I was starting to learn about makeup. I still go back and occasionally watch ones like this because they're relaxing to me, lol!
i love you robert! you’ve taught me so much about makeup and i couldn’t thank you enough 🖤
Thank you so so much! 🖤🖤🖤
@@RobertWelshomg you’re so welcome!! 🖤
Beauty trends are constantly changing so don't be so hard on your past videos. I learn from your older tutorials too. Robert, you always look fantastic and flawless in any makeup you choose!
17:14 I'M DYINGGGG NOT THE LASHES
I appreciate you like I never have before. Anyone who can giggle at themselves is the best type of person imaginable.💜🏆💜 But they weren't that bad Robert really they weren't...💜👻💜
Thank you! 😝🖤🖤🖤
Can we talk about today's Beetlejuice-esque look 🖤🤍💚 Your cut crease and blending are chef's kiss!! 😍😍
Robert 😂 staaahp! lol… “look at that suscribe just permanently up in the corner, that’s aggressive” your humor, love 👏 it 👏
This is so interesting, to see how much you've improved when it comes to putting make up on yourself. I sometimes come cross selfies from 3-4 years ago and I can't believe that I used to do some things so horribly... 🤦♀😂
Also, on the note of tutorials. I wish they would come back as a trend. I understand that it makes no sense for you to do them, because people don't watch them as much. But I hope that it will kind of come around as we move away from this kind of spending culture and hauls/reviews all the time. Nothing wrong with that per se, but maybe there's just too much content like that in the beauty community.
I agree I really hope people start to watch tutorials again!
ugh yes as a makeup noob, im in dire need of tutorials 😭😭😭
Completely agree, there's hardly any trustworthy guidance especially on newer techniques. I love Alexandra Anele for them but she's the only one that comes to mind.
My gawd, absolutely stunning look today! 💚💚💚
Thank you! 🖤🖤
@@RobertWelsh you are welcome! 💚
I wish tutorials still got views! Even though these weren't as evolved as you have become, I have no doubt that they helped a lot of people. Fourteen y/o me would have been obsessed.
You really sound like James in the first video!
😂😂 that’s my uncomfortable voice
@@RobertWelsh 🤣 I'm here for it
The timing of this is so funny because I actually watched your old smoky eye tutorial yesterday to do my makeup 😂
Oh no way! 😂😂🖤🖤
I'd love if you could do a video about hooded eyelids for mature women. Or possibly provide makeup guidelines for those of us who are older. Thank you!
Micellar water was invented in 1913. Bioderma (probably most popular) were the first company to produce it commercially in 1995... 😎✌🏼💜
Robert I love this so much! And as a newer TH-camr with 200ish subs it really inspires me seeing videos like this 🥹
Also, you and James both had similar beginner TH-camr voices. I literally thought it was James talking!
You dragging yourself made me laugh so hard omg. You were amazing then and still are ❤
That eyebrow giving me 2016 lifeeeeee 💕 that ABH dip brow 😅 I’m glad we don’t do that anymore.
What’s amazing is I remember your videos when you started on TH-cam. Absolutely have loved watching Robert throughout the years 🩷🧡🖤
Thank you so so much!
@@RobertWelsh You’re welcome!
I personally love, love closeup eye makeup tutorials. You have come a long way baby 🖤💜🖤💜🖤💜
When old you said about the Kiko brush I was like oh no, new Robert doesn't like those brushes so much now! So interesting seeing your older stuff. I loved seeing the eye close up especially, cos I'm really not great at eyeshadow! was really helpful
I totally forgot about that brush! I don’t even own them anymore 😂 it was good brush though!
I'm an OG to your channel! Love you so! ❤
Thank you so so much!! 🖤🖤🖤
Baby Robert sounds a lot like James does today. Kudos for staying humble and showing the learning curve of your YT career
That was fun - and, honestly, I think we ALL feel that way looking at old pictures/content.
This is such a fun idea 😂 love your hair like this, and with the green eye look - absolutely stunning! Tbh - the biggest problem so far is the awful sound quality, but I think your vibe etc was really good for just starting!
Thank you! Omg yea that would have been the built in camera on a cheap camera!
Omg your entire looooooook 😍 spent my evening so far searching for makeup and fashion inspo and you’ve given me the missing piece I needed 😍🔥
Oh amazing!!
Hi robert. Your eye make up is arttt. Could you maybe do a video for hooded eyes with small space between the eye and the brows? A lot of tutorials are for big hooded eyes
I found your videos on Facebook during lockdown. Three years later and I still love you and your content.
This was so enlightening because you were just as harsh with yourself if not more as you are with MUAs doing questionable things today. Sometimes seeing someone as flawless as you can be intimidating but I’m tremendously thankful you showed us a bit of how where you started and how far you’ve come along. Great body of work!
The spit take killed me lmao, that's ALL of us looking at our old brows 😂😂
Almost fell on the floor after seeing that eye look! 😍 Excited for this video as a new subscriber!
Thank you so so much! 🖤🖤🖤
I still love this look and actually miss real closeup tutorials! Off to do this tomorrow 😁
Sir you need a spider for that spot between your collar! 😜🖤
Yessss 😂😂
I found your channel around this time in 2019, I think after watching Wayne Goss. I still don't do my makeup very often unless it's for a special occasion, or even just because. Liquid and winged eyeliner are still the bane of my existence.
There are people like myself who still enjoy watching tutorials and I'd love to see you reenact some of your old ones!
Something about the liner in the second one reminds me of James's Tiana makeover on you 😭 it's nice to see how you've become more confident on camera and I'm glad you stuck with youtube 💜🖤
Take a shot every time 2016 Robert says socket ‼️🤭
😂😂😂!!!!!!
Love this!! The growth omg! Not in makeup technique (I know nothing about makeup) but in video/audio quality! I love seeing your whole face lol 🖤🖤
This is such a wonderful concept for a video, @RobertWelsh. When I first found you and @JamesWelsh (maybe a year ago), after I inhaled all of your then-recent videos, I went back to the earliest things you've allowed to survive on TH-cam. You were both so shy and awkward. I love seeing the growth in both you and James, as you've honed your professional skills, but also your TH-camr (i.e. "influencer" -- I hate that word) skills. Also though, any time you want to bring back tutorials, I will watch every second, like, share on TH-cam, and share on other platforms.
Robert roasts his past self 😂 I about died when you stopped on the photo with the lash hanging off. 😂😂 all in good fun, and you’re an exceptional MUA & content creator!
The early videos are still so good quality. I have no idea how I could set it up so that I can see what I’m doing, and stay in focus or on the damn frame at least. I move around apparently a lot and I end up slouching to the bottom of the frame 😅
Can't wait to see you react to you 😁 🖤
Happy Sunday, Robert.
🖤🖤🖤🖤
I really enjoy you looking back at older videos and laugh at yourself. I want to start a channel but am so scared too. Love you and James
Love this look today ❤️
Thank you! 🖤🖤
This eye look is SO FAB but SO IS THIS HAIRRRRR 😍💖
Ooh is that the Made By Mitchell Colour Case Cosmetic Paint Palette you have on Robert? It just pops 🤩
Yea!!!
What a great video. ❤ I think it shows all of us we always have room to grow. You were still great, though! I wish people still watched tutorials. I love them.
I have been watching you for a few years now, and my makeup has gotten much better. If we had portable video cameras in the early 80’s when I first really started wearing makeup, it would be good for a laugh!! I didn’t blend anything!! It would be a stripe of blue and a stripe of pink. We would take a lighter to our Maybelline eyeliner and melt it and line everything in black. Bright pink blush and a bright lipstick and out the door, with half a can of Aqua Net on my hair!!😂😂
Your hair 🖤🖤, and your eye makeup!?!? 🖤🖤🖤🖤 I love so much! It’s always so funny looking back at our “former self” 🤣🥰
Omg Robert, I'm obsessed with your eyes today! I really got into greens this year 😊
Thank you! 🖤🖤
Be kind to you!!! We all start somewhere and the brow was on point for the time!
Robert, you are so humble and secure in yourself. Being able to laugh at yourself and point out your mistakes - and how to correct them - is the sign of a very confident person. You don't pretend you've always been the genius you are, and that's rare. I just love you ❤❤!
honestly...I love these eye looks!😂 and the close up are very usefull for us poor mortals who are helpless in makeup...
Love u lots!!!!❤
I get tutorials aren't a thing anymore but I would really love a basic techniques tutorial. I'm picking up bits from different videos.
"Lustre is a finish not a tone 😜" is the same energy as Niles and Frasier reminiscing about how carefree and naive they were at Yale 😂😂
the green looks so good omfg!!
Thank you! 🖤
"Oh that's aggressive" 😂😂 "That's disgusting" Just killing me with the comments!! 😂😂
OMDog, i didn't know about cut creases, eye shadow primer, false eyelashes, basically i knew nothing about anything beyond a very "no make-up" looking make-up until Robert taught me!! 😂 Thank you Robert!! 🩷🩷🩷
I looove the striped shirt and eye look & wavy hair combo!! 🤩
Baby Robert is adorable!!! And the skill 💯
😆 brows with an extension pack. For real, tho I miss the tutorial days 😅
❤❤❤ I still go back and watch these 😊 u knew sooo much then and now❤
Oh, be kind to young Robert😂 please to more of these - it was so funny!
Your are definitely harder on yourself than anyone else you critique. That may be one of the reasons you are so successful and admired now.
I absolutley loved the detached eyelash! 😂😅❤
Robert, you’re so hard on yourself love….i think for 2016 and being new to TH-cam you did a fabulous job! I loved the second look & I think you’re just so sweet, kind and so adorable. I gotta be honest here I live with several chronic pain conditions that started from a spinal surgery gone wrong and I have several chronic illnesses. So for a month or so as the weather is changing I’ve been really struggling because I’ve been sick for over a month, and my painful condition and chronic illnesses have flared up and I’ve just been stuck in bed and honestly depressed because I’m missing out on so much and this pain while being sick can be a bit overwhelming. But the positive here is that I have an amazing husband, young adult kids who really take care of me and I get to catch up on James and your videos, which have made me laugh until I’ve cried. Just thank you so much for bringing me such joy. Oh and thank you to Ashton and Marcus for all you do to make the videos come together 💜
Its always interesting looking back at your old makeup looks. Seeing how your technique, product choices, color/style choices have changed and evolved.
This was so fun and informative! It'd be fun for you to re-create the looks, given your growth -- like, do your left side following your original video, and then do your right side showing how you'd change it and/or improve it.