ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 12 ก.ค. 2022
- MOMENT The Speaker, Lindsay Hoyle LOSES IT and orders MPs to be kicked out of the House of Commons.
Alba MPs Kenny MacAskill and Neale Hanvey were ordered to leave the House of Commons after they launched a protest at the start of Prime Minister’s Questions.
The Sun newspaper brings you the latest breaking news videos and explainers from the UK and around the world
Become a Sun Subscriber and hit the bell to be the first to know
Read The Sun: www.thesun.co.uk
Like The Sun on Facebook: / thesun
Follow The Sun on Twitter: / thesun
Subscribe to The Sun on Snapchat: / 1633225139
#PMQs #Speaker
![[ไฮไลต์] ฟุตบอลหญิง เยอรมนี vs ออสเตรเลีย รอบแบ่งกลุ่ม | โอลิมปิก 2024](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/i_8UO61YqO8/mqdefault.jpg)
British parliament reminds me of a discord server when the owner forgets to mute people and everyone is talking at once.
What’s that
😅😅😅😅😅
@@wanyekest6969 its like zoom for the younger population
@@bruuh- it's like Skype for younger-est generation
Facts bro xD
As a former high school teacher, this brings back memories.
😭😭☠️
war flashbacks LMAO
"I will not tolerate such behaviour! Both of you, go stand in the hallway!"
As a former student of a high school teacher, this brings back memories as well
A high school teacher, that can’t tell the difference between a SNL skit, and a real courtroom? Wow! Where did you graduate?
"I will not tolerate such behaviour"
He said calmly.
🤣 HARRY!!!
Dumbeldor said calmly..
@@noahpaquet8357 "DIDYAPUYANAMEINDEGOBLETOFYAHARRY" Dumbledore asked calmly
i guess he doesn't make a point out of it.
"the House of Commons is like our Congress with a two drink minimum, crazy place" - Robin Williams
Should b at least 5 hay
i fkn love robin
I miss him 😢
Pelosi : hold my bottle of vodka
So glad this isn’t the state which Congress is in…
we can all understan this mans anger, as dealing with all those childish clowns there isnt easy
Sergeant at Arms had apparently already forgotten why (s)he was sitting there all the time :D :D :)
The problem is that MP's are angry with Hoyle letting Boris get away with not answering questions and lying. It is his job to ensure questions are answered and when someone says something which is not true, that they correct the record which Boris never does no matter how many times it is proven he lied
@@stevec6427 Yeah, a lame duck of a Speaker suddenly "doing his job" when its someone not in government breaking the rules. He has all the integrity of a sock puppet and less spine.
that's why I loved bercow, always responded accordingly. he was a good man.
P. S. I'm not British nor I live in the UK, idk it's your country, but I might be there in afew years😂🇬🇧
Why did I read this in an Irish accent
He shouldn't need a microphone, that's probably why he doesn't have one. The national leaders in that room should be mature enough not to need to be drowned out to create some order.
Bro is the speaker
no thats how brits are in politics
They is microphone hanging from the ceiling (I went for parliament tour less than 2 months ago and you get to go to house of commons as well)
He is not the national leader
@@JM-dy4ty she said national leaders, there is government in that room
Needs to happen more often. The way MPs conduct themselves in parliament is disgusting and not befitting of grown adults responsible for running a country. Imagine being in a meeting at work and booing and jeering over whoever is speaking whenever you disagree with them.
That's how parliaments have been science the beginning of time, like the stories of writing the constitution and roman Senate meetings where wild.
On the other hand what other recourse do mp's have towards others in there, that eg. Lie, refuse to address a point or answer a question?
Honestly if they did boo in meeting that would be a lot funnier
@@rancid7182 no. That's not how it always is. In some countries yes, in some no. Look at a scandinavian parlament and be prepared to be bored.
@@rancid7182 not everything romans do is good. there's bad side too. and we should not take their bad side.
I truly wonder how they got so far in this world with that system in place haha
Are you American?
They conquered half the world in the past. So I guess their system works.
@@gaiusjcaesar09 hell no, I live in a free country where we respect women and they are free to chose if they want pregnancy or not, I also live in a country where the government acts grown up and don't have to scream their lungs out just to ask someone to be quiet.
@@daniels-mo9ol what country is it exactly? Nigeria?
@@bayraktarx1386 did you just ask me if I'm from Nigeria, a country on the exact opposite end of the scale from what I referenced? Lol
He is like a school teacher who is scolding rowdy children in a bus while on a school trip.
That's essentially what's happening here
@@RetroPlus yup hahaha
There ain’t much difference when it comes to most of the parliament clowns 🤡
@@DoktrDub "Parliament clowns" is such an ironic term. Actual circus clowns are better behaved.
Yeah he’s even asking the teaching assistant for names 😅😂
Feels like a Pirates of The Carribean, parlay treaty scene with all the other pirates. Except it’s modern day in a Parliament
"This is madness!"
"This is politics"
Parlayment
Exactly on my mind
I think it's great that people are allowed to express freely and argue, that's what makes a good system. This was a bit chaotic tho ngl lol
@@brbrdeng9122 Dam gotten beaten to it.
If the Speaker gets to this stage, you know it's bad.
Hes like a headmaster dealing with a bunch of school kids. How the UK still stands amazes me
This is what politicians are like in all countries.
how the UK still stands...?? 😂 are you special needs? do you think THIS is it? oh dear kiddy keyboard warrior bye bye back to the lobby
It really doesn't. The UK is basically a failed democracy at this point
Now if he was a headmaster he woulda use Crucio on those mps for interrupting lol
@@thatlonelygiraffeinc.6989 Any country that still uses the archaic first past the post electoral system is a pseudo democracy. The election results is not even remotely an accurate representation of the will of the people, and they are basically reduced to select the lesser of only two evils. Unless one party has dominant regional support, but even so, there is now way such a party can unseat the dominant two parties simply becausecof the math of the system.
British politics look and sound like a bunch of people in a room arguing about how to build a desk from walmart.
Bro British people built different 💀
How do you think we feel! we have to build the desk and they're not giving us the plans and their just arguing to themselves ABOUT the plans. so we have to just sit there and wait. 😭😩
Here I thought American politics were crazy to watch 0.o......i mean they are.... but it's true the UK is built different.
@@muffinstuff6195 Same bs in Canada, different circus, same clowns.
AMERICAN SCHOOLS LOOK LIKE SHOOTING FARMS
"Oh dear, it appears as if this distinguished gentleman has been interrupted by these scallywags, Blimey! I shall not stand for it."
*sips tea with malicious intent*
Couldnt have said it better m8
@@helton3425 Cheerio!
Shenanigans I tells ya, shenanigans.
Your talkin utter tripe.
*Eats scone with malcontent*
what americans hear when they watch this video
If a teacher walked in to this classroom, everyone would get detention.
This is why we need new mps in who know our economy, our struggles and much more, kick these childish pigs out and get the new ones in as this is getting out of hand, good on the speaker.
Unfortunately the naughty pigs won't listen to us😒 goes and sulks in the corner grumpily.
No, just suffer
Group of screaming kids trying to run the country 🤣 🤷♂️
Kids?
Clowns more like.
This guy needs a 20000 watt sound system to speak to those clowns
Or a gun.
calling MPs 'clowns' is such boomer humour.
Bloody typical for this behaviour to happen in parliament I’m not even surprised at this point
This is such an outdated system. The House of Commons needs to change. Nothing gets solved by shouting a load of crap to each other
sometimes it's a really good still better than North Korea😂
@@Owen714 "it's a really good"
This just shows absolutely absurd our political system has become. Parliament no longer functions the way it was intended, it's become undermined by those who lack any degree of moral decency, or respect for rules and laws. It's time the system was re-engineered to account for this sickness amongst our political parties, there need to be new mechanisms in place to avoid this current situation!
Parliament has always been like this.
@@paulk3681 John needs a history lesson.
You too huh? Signed - an American 🇺🇸
@@JoeyRhubarb When in modern history has parliament ever become so manipulated by rouge actors as it has today? There's never been a time with such unapologetic corruption and deceit as now, MP's today don't even try to look honourable, and they certainly don't act as if they are! If the likes of Johnson had anything like the decency of past prime ministers he would have stepped down a long time ago, same goes for most of his cabinet!
@@Altair885 Sorry but you don't get to just confine yourself to "modern history" becuase it suits your narrative better and you can't be bothered to learn anything outside your adult lifetime. When you restrict your sample size you restrict your accuracy.
It's like watching babies at kindergarden fighting over the best toys
They drink at lunch. That's why.
John Bercow would have handled this with much alacrity.
John Bercow is a 2 foot tall shrew, bullying serial liar pretty much like all lefties.
Bercow was entertaining, used to just smile at them and make small verbal jabs at folk
Miss him already bruv
Bercow was cool and powerful at the same time.
Bercow was faster when speaking so he could deal with it.
This is a genuine comedy show.
Sister: Dad, he took my doll!
Brother: That's because you took my action figure
Sister: Did not!
Brother: DID TOO!
Sister: DID NOT!
Brother: DID TOO-
Dad: *I am now naming you and your sister to leave this living room and go to your ROOMS!*
I'll set this up as my alarm tone.
It's like my high school teacher. Waiting for him to scream, "SECURITY!".
Imagine if a private company was run this way. Why is it okay for governments to be so ludicrously inefficient?
Can you imagine the pressure that man is feeling, he’s like 1-2 steps away from a angry mob carrying him outside
LOL, he was two steps from some people's representatives speaking the minds of the people they represent. The horror! How dare someone confront the Prime Minister on his lies and the repercussions of those lies on the livelihoods of the the citizens.
Imagine the possibilities if they would all get along and put all there combined knowledge together, instead we get a nonsensical government from both sides, and there only goal is to discredited the opposition and make the uk look like a episode of Jerry springer, you all say your for the people but can't put your egos aside for one minute to actually prove it and get jobs done
Having an effective opposition is one of the most important parts of Parliament. "Getting along" is not the job of Parliament, quite the opposite. You have no idea what you are talking about.
@@JoeyRhubarb I don't know what I'm talking about, do you even know who I am, it's this one dimension thinking I'm talking about, it goes beyond competition when the people have to deal with the mess, and off couse you need competition, and new ideas I'm not saying we don't, but it's how you go about it that matters
@@matterb6049 Well this system has done its job reasonably well, albeit not without fault for hundreds of years and our Parliamentary system is the envy of many nations around the world but I'm all ears as to how you think it could be made better. Scrutiny is the role of the House of Commons and well established traditions ensure that whilst it can get fiery at times it does not get out of hand.
@@JoeyRhubarb I don't know half of the details to give an option how the contery should be run, but I have lots of Ideas on how they could stop acting like children and do some good for this contry, and I'm sure many other people do too
@@matterb6049 Ok, lets hear those ideas then?
I don't know how many times I went back to 0:28 and laughed my ass tf off
The British accent makes it funnier
Sir Hoyle looks so tired. Years in the chair haven't been kind to his constitution but I fully respect his Speakership.
Put a camera in my house and senate so we can make our minds up for our selves. These people see this, and make their mind up.
I knew about British hooliganism from Football.. Now I see it in parliament lol
A face in a frame between 0:19 and 0:21 by speaker hoyle is surely meme-able haha
Send this man to deal with Putin
Speaker: I will not tolerate such behavior. The Kremlin is mine now you go out.
Putin: Guess war is over then.
@Augusto Pinochet ok
Scotland so just leave the UK because of this is going to be the attitude of Westminster we get no respect in the House of Commons at all we get no respect under Westminster if they’re literally willing to take us out of Parliament and hope we just walk out the UK with no warning. It’s not like they would actually care they might even be happy.
“Give me the Bloody Name!”……”Barty Crouch…..Junior”
I grew up with people yelling screaming School children even to this day I still deal with it I wish I can do what he does Because I would be angry this is a government place this needs to be professional not like children
This kind of loud heckling has always been a part of British Parliament- especially Prime Ministers Question time.However, this level of vitriol combined with Boris Johnson's shenanigans and the Conservative Party govt. leadership mess seems to have taken things to a new dimension 😵💫😵💫😵💫
I hate to be that person (I don’t really) but it’s Prime Ministers Questions.
Question Time is the TV show where people say things for claps.
Honourable member surely he jests!😌😁
I can't take this 😫 seriously, I hear this guy talk and I see the squirrel from open season, lmfao 😆 😂 🤣 😄
I’m waiting on someone to shout “he’s behind you”… it’s just cringeworthy otherwise.
This is like Showtime at the Apollo. Waiting for Sandman Sims to come out. 😂
I wish when I went to court for traffic ticket this is how it looked and sounded
Just think how many would be sacked if this kind of carry on happened in a business meeting! ... and this lot run our country! Politicians and the way they conduct business is a sham and a total embarrassment.
0:28 He was possessed by Betty Boothroyd there for a minute! 😂
Thought I was the only one who caught that lmmfao
I can't understand why some people say he's not doing a good job.
He's crap, just got an inflated ego matched by a lack of ability
Me neither...
Lol Bolsonaro shill shoring up the right wing in other countries too
The speaker having to scream at people to assert his authority...........not a good look
Ha.
My supervisors always would say!!!
U ye you challenge my
Or-thoratay.
Yep. The same idiots the world over.
And what is he supposed to do, sit and wait 10 minutes till they shut up on their own?
As an American, I wish we could see political theater like this more it's pure entertainment
That is the speakers job idk if you saw the last guy in this position but this is how this job is to keep the animals who are in charge of us all in order
@@ValhemasaurusRex Bercow was much more effective. If he didn't get order he'd publicly shame the MP responsible. Worked a treat
Am I the only one who absolutely loves this guy
and they thought the other guy was a bully lol
Imagine if the queen was just sitting in the background watching these fools 😅
She would immediately dissolve Commons!
A great Speaker.
This speaker is total rubbish. Bercow would never have let things get to that point. Pathetic crowd management. The usual English shouting down of the SNP or ALBA when they rise to make a point. We are divorcing you England and nothing you do or say will stop the people who live in Scotland for England is a failed state of Brexit and 'we' in 'our country' are not having any of it.
@@tomwaller6893 You should write comedy. Berkow was a vile bully and loudmouth with a short fuse.
He lacked a sense of neutrality and at the end of his time as speaker, he was denied a peerage in the house of Lords because he was so well widespread disliked for his behaviour in the Brexit issue.
As for the SNP and that tiny Albe party, they are the worst thing to happen to England's province of Scotland.
Your better off in the union, where we English can look after your fellow Scotsmen and women, and protect you from yourselves. Fried Mars bars indeed. LOL
On what planet
@@ddaavviiddttaaaaffee I spotted the imperialist.
I love watching House of commons, its really like watching debate in pub after like 3 - 4 beers
My friend from London: "that escalate quickly!!" *drinks barley beer*
Normie
Omg, this reminds me of the time my teacher went complete ape and kicked everyone out of the classroom XD, great memoires
Lmao
Same lmfao I’m having. Flashbacks
Working there must be a living headache
"Shut up a minute!"😃😃😃
I kinda wish that the debates in our Bundestag in Germany were as lively lol.
I never liked John Bercow, however he had a way of dealing with MP’s with his sophisticated put down. I believe he had better control of the house than Lindsay does.
I agree. Yelling "shut up!!" doesn't seem like it is much better than what he complaining about having to deal with.
He didn't "LOOSE IT" its his job ffs
Hahahaha every one in that room has lost it, completely 🤣🤣🤣
No sympathy for the speaker. He threw Ian Blackford out after Blackford called Boris a liar. Even when it was evident Boris had clearly lied to the house
It's a Saturday Night Live sketch. 🤣🤣🤣
So comforting to know that our parliament is in such good hands with serious politicians dealing with serious issues in such an adult way. Time to get rid of the lot of them.
I couldn't agree more with you, this is just embarrassing to watch.
You completely misunderstand the role of our parliament..Seats are arranged close and near to opposition..This is to encourage fierce debate..When you get a horseshoe style setting,it becomes just a sedate talking shop..There is nowhere to hide in our parliament..We do not want polite,bland discussion in our country.
@@davidglow3 That explains the *U WOT M8* energy.
@@davidglow3 I LIKE this. :D
@@MoiraWillenov 650 MPs but only 450 seats in HofC..This is deliberate,to stop MPs getting comfortable and languid..When parliament were thinking of moving temporarily to the old H and SS building in Whitehall,the first thing discussed was having the same proportion of seats to MPs as being essential.
British "Democracy" in action. You're not allowed to call a spade a spade in Parliament.
Why can't we Malaysians have a speaker like him to deal with the likes of Bung-hole and Teriyaki.
Someone get this man some waterrr lmao
Terrible this 🤮
Technicality question: who enforces the order to remove the MPs from the House? The King and his officers (or Queen and hers) are prohibited from Parliament, correct? So who has the legal authority to use force to compel the MPs to comply with the removal order?
I don't know (American) but I know who does, TH-cam TLDR. Check them out if you haven't already.
I believe it's the Serjeant-At-Arms
No wrong, Queen is not prohibited from parlament, but she doesn't go to house of commons, she only goes to House of Lords chamber (and have her own way to get there which is different from the rest) and she is opening of parliament, but both house of lords and house of commons members are in house of lords and she has special place where she sits in House of Lords (when you visit London go for the tour of parliament, its super nice)
First, the Serjeant at Arms, who will formally confront the offender and require him/her to leave the chamber.
If things really get violent, the Speaker will announce to the House that recourse to force is necessary and will call in the police officers stationed just outside.
Any officer of the Crown can come into the chamber IF invited to do so, like Black Rod...they just can't come in without the permission of the House or the Speaker representing the House.
This isn't the first time it's been rowdy in the house of commons. UK needs to make some changes.
Let me say as someone in teacher training this is worse than some primary school classrooms I’ve been in.
More context: Kenny MacAskill and Neale Hanvey are the only House of Commons MPs of the Alba Party (pro-Scottish independence/pro-Scottish republicanism) which formed in 2021. Before this clip started, Kenny was raising a point of order to Boris by shouting "We need a referendum" before he was drained out by the Tories. Then Neale tried to stand up for Kenny and it was here where Hoyle kicked them out. They did this because of Boris' refusal to let Scotland have another referendum. They were arguing that now is the best time more than ever to let the Scottish people decide their path in this complicated climate. The First Minister of Scotland Nicola Sturgeon of the SNP has made clear that Scotland would have a referendum in 2023, and that they would take legal action if the British government refused.
I'm personally not in favor of independence because that would mean the new republic would have a unicorn as their national animal, and as we all know I discovered unicorns in a cave within our country back in 2012
Their parties should be embarrassed...
They're both members of the Alba Party, and are the only two representatives in the House of Commons. No way they'll be embarrassed, they'll both feel justified in their behaviour.
While these shoutings might seem unorderly and chaos, it is quite better than being afraid to open one's mouth.
Why is this so entertaining!? 🤣🤣🤣
No disrespect to the current Speaker, but John Bercow would have handled this with more aplomb.
Amen my brother
sigh just watched my countrys parliament show, yes its an entertainment show for me rn tbh and seeing this clip made me realise we have lots of similarities in terms of how these clowns politicians in the parliament behaved..
Reminds me of Hitchhikers guide to the galaxy lol
He looks like harry potter casting new spells
If only the speaker would have been that loud when it came to demanding MPs to correct the record. But no, lying is apparently fine.
Since uk voted for Brexit the British parlement has been a great show.
This is how its always been...
@@EthanfromEngland- I only started watching after Brexit because i knew the British would be fun to watch now
@@tomminsart1205 so, you admit having nothing to compare it to and yet you state "since voting for brexit"...odd.
@@EthanfromEngland- no need to i find it a good show.
Man sounded like was about to cast a spell 🤣
Its like in that song "if I lose myself tonight it would be nananana"
Finally the man grows some balls.
Right at 28 sec
Looks like what teachers have to put up with everyday ...
0:28 When puberty kicks in.
They claim to be wise, they became fools. 🙏🏻❤️🕊️🌎
dont think they are fools, they're saying their opinions, which is what politics is about. It's the ones shouting over them and laughing that are being childish and made fools
British citizens: "Americans are so backwards"
British parliament: *Monty Python noises intensify*
When JD Rockefeller invested in the American education system he did so to produce workers and not thinkers.
While it’s true some of the brightest brains are from the US, many are truly backward conspiracists with little idea of the world as it is.
Every lower-set classroom in every British secondary school 😂
Thx 4 sharing
Lol!!! They will all laugh about it over a beer later . No system is perfect.
And let’s face it, there is a new generation coming in to parliaments that thinks it’s better then the rest of the world .
Agreed that "no system is perfect", but a system which causes a country to have no say in its own leadership is so far from perfect that it need to be disrupted. Do you know how many MPs representing Scotland have a vote in this leadership? None. Zero. Scotland is watching a group of English MP choosing Scotland’s next Prime Minister.
@@SpeckleKen well are you going to demand to dissolve the United Kingdom or just push to actually have that instated
Absolutely frightened knowing that these people are in charge of anything.
Best Jerry Springer episode ever! I bet Steve got them two out.
The muppet show 😭😭😭😭 lol
This is so embarrassing I’ve never understood this .. at school you were taught to not talk over one another and let someone speak, these “grown adults” cannot even do the simple fundamentals taught in primary school... and to top it off they are the ones who are responsible for running this country how embarrassing .
I'm actually laughing at the utter ridiculousness. Also, remembering how bad off my country(USA) is right now. So then it makes me frustrated. Why can't people just listen to each other?
These are childish politicians, they throw the rattle out of the pram.These were actually the bigots of Scotland getting pushed out.
Whatever happened to civility, diplomacy, respect and decency. This is clearly disgusting to watch.
It's like Grandpa yelling at kids skateboarding on the sidewalk.
The World is falling apart