Shut Up Ya Kunal EP 28 || Acharya Prashant & Prof. Dilip Mandal
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 9 ก.พ. 2025
- In this captivating episode of the Shut Up Ya Kunal, guests Acharya Prashant and Professor Dilip Mandal engage in a thought-provoking debate. With their clear and insightful perspectives, they address four key questions, exploring the intricacies of religion in India, the nature of religious individuals, the allure of superstitions among Indians, and their vision for Bharat (India).
Acharya Prashant, a renowned Indian author, and Advaita teacher, returns to the podcast for the second time. As the founder of the PrashantAdvait Foundation and a passionate vegan activist, he brings a unique perspective to the discussion.
Joining the podcast for the first time, Professor Dilip Mandal, the former managing editor of India Today Hindi Magazine and an accomplished author in media and sociology, adds his expertise to the conversation. His fresh insights shed light on the complex relationship between religion and society. He also shines a light on the intertwined issue of caste discrimination that permeates Indian society.
Throughout the episode, the guests engage in a healthy and respectful debate, presenting their well-reasoned arguments to tackle these pressing questions. Their dynamic exchange demonstrates how open communication and robust discussions can serve as powerful tools to address human and social challenges.
Don't miss this enlightening episode where Acharya Prashant and Professor Dilip Mandal's engaging debate offers valuable insights into the diverse aspects of religion, superstitions, and their vision for Bharat. Get ready to expand your understanding and witness the transformative power of meaningful dialogue.
***************************************************
BIG THANKS TO:
Prof. Dilip Mandal
( / profdilipmandal )
and
Acharya Prashant
(acharyaprashan...)
*****************************************************
Creative Producer: Nidhi Shetty
Edit by Abhishek Bhutwani & Shubham Sardar
Audio Mixed by Srijeeth Menon
Special Thanks to Anshu and AP Team
****************************************************
This is How civilized people talk .
I wish we could see such kind of debate on mainstream news channels
news channels ...
Exactly that said in this show.. Mainstream is corrupted...
Hijacking your comment here, for visibility.
As a revert to Islam from Hinduism, I would like to state the following.
10:00
the Dharmic Tripti('Religious Satisfaction' if translated literally) Acharya Prashant is talking about is Reality. Which is true. Because things that take us away from reality are things which are most often bad. Drugs, Alcohol, Smoking, Premarital Sex(Which is most often driven on lust and not love), Hateful Politics, and even Music if we obey Islam. These are all sins. Sins that take us away from God and Heaven and towards Hell.
'Manushya ki Baichaini se Chain tak le jane vala hota hai Dharm. Iss Dharm ki Kitab ban nahi sakti'
Here I would like to point out that what is a more complete statement is,' hum Manushya uss Kitab ko bana nahi sakte.' because we have tried that and what we end up is the concept of Modern governance. Democracy and Communism always turn into Oligarchy and Dictatorship Tyrrany, because of human desires. Only the Creator of us Humans can guide us to what is best for us. That complete guidance is Islam. Which has been constant since the first man, and will be till the Last Day.
God has sent humanity chosen Messengers from Time to Time, and that Message has gotten corrupted. Religions of Vedas, Judaism, Christianity, Islam are not isolated and disconnected. It has the same principle that has gotten corrupted. Only Islam is the uncorrupted Truth. Else Jesus, Moses, Writers of Vedas were all inspired by God. (I cannot verify writer of Vedas was a Prophet obviously, I intend to convey the principle).
All contrary arguments welcome.
Isliye hume Reality ko banane vale ke paas jaana hota hai. Kyuki Unke sivay hume kahi aur Chain prapt nahi hoga. Vo Reality ko banane vale hai Bhagvanji. Jinki taraf hum sabka mann aakarshit hota hai.
'Haan itna ho sakta hai ki ishare kiye jaa sake'
This is the Fitrah. The innate disposition of humans towards believing in One God. Towards doing what is morally right at the cost of personal desire and pleasure. When we go against this natural human nature the causes of this are ego and social conditioning. Not our hearts.
'Baichaini ke saath judi hai Agyan'
Jo Ekmatr gyan hum manushyo ka faida kar sakta hai, Bhagvan ke Satyata ka gyan hai. Ki hum sabko jivit karne vale koi hai. Aur humari jaan ka ek maqsad hai. Maqsad yahi hai ki Bhagvan ke aadesh ka hum palan kare.
I will continue the rest in a comment below. sometimes long comments get removed.
As a revert to Islam from Hinduism I would like to state the following... (hijacking your comment for visibility)
'Antim uttar' I am pretty sure he means Ultimate Truth here so I will comment on this. The ultimate truth is accepting and obeying God. The cause of our existence. When Ach. Prashant talks about the Antim Uttar being maun i.e quiet and the fact that we cannot question God in religion, I will say that he is wrong. You can absolutely question Islam all you want. But at the end of the day there is nothing able to disprove it. I welcome any arguments to the contrary.
'Kuch karne ko Dharm nahi bolte'
Here I mildly disagree. What Ach. Prashant is talking about is pointless rituals. Doing what is moral and right and obeying God and the Fitrah is very much Dharm.
I recommend all to study comparative religion. I think it is the most important subject everyone must study for themselves. Staying true to one's heart is most important in finding the Truth.
Hijacking your comment here, for visibility.
As a revert to Islam from Hinduism, I would like to state the following.
10:00
the Dharmic Tripti('Religious Satisfaction' if translated literally) Acharya Prashant is talking about is Reality. Which is true. Because things that take us away from reality are things which are most often bad. Drugs, Alcohol, Smoking, Premarital Sex(Which is most often driven on lust and not love), Hateful Politics, and even Music if we obey Islam. These are all sins. Sins that take us away from God and Heaven and towards Hell.
'Manushya ki Baichaini se Chain tak le jane vala hota hai Dharm. Iss Dharm ki Kitab ban nahi sakti'
Here I would like to point out that what is a more complete statement is,' hum Manushya uss Kitab ko bana nahi sakte.' because we have tried that and what we end up is the concept of Modern governance. Democracy and Communism always turn into Oligarchy and Dictatorship Tyrrany, because of human desires. Only the Creator of us Humans can guide us to what is best for us. That complete guidance is Islam. Which has been constant since the first man, and will be till the Last Day.
God has sent humanity chosen Messengers from Time to Time, and that Message has gotten corrupted. Religions of Vedas, Judaism, Christianity, Islam are not isolated and disconnected. It has the same principle that has gotten corrupted. Only Islam is the uncorrupted Truth. Else Jesus, Moses, Writers of Vedas were all inspired by God. (I cannot verify writer of Vedas was a Prophet obviously, I intend to convey the principle).
All contrary arguments welcome.
to be continued.......
I think we need to document this discussion. I would encourage the participants to write a book or books based on these discussions, their thoughts, theories, etc. We need such knowledge as a country. I consider this essential for the survival of humans in this part of this 3D world.
🎉🎉 record
I think Acharya Prashant has a channel and writes on the topics he spoke on.
Acharya prashant has more than 30(+) books to offer already
And what our sir has said a major chunk of it is there as a sociological study named "Protestant ethics and spirit of Capatalism" By Max Weber.
It is amazing to see how much diverse studies they have used in this discussion.
@@abhinavanshu7298 Please give us more books names.
it is pleasure to see that दो ज्ञानी लोग कितनी सभ्यता के साथ अपने disagreement express कर सकते हैं
I have never ever seen such an intellectual discussion in my life. This is one of the most iconic videos ever. I urge you to invest 70 Mins with your family and change your life.
Lots of respect to Prof Dilip Mandal and Acharya Prashant. Kunal you are a hero man!
भारत को आप दोनों की ही जरूरत है। ऐसे विद्वानो को सुनना मेरा सौभाग्य है।❤
This is one of the best conversation regarding religion topic. Prof Dilip Mandal Sir is Pragmatic n covered almost all of these. We need such types of debate rather than murga murgi ladai on news channels.
On what basis dilip is pragmatic... He is just trying to divide hindus, by trying to differentiate Dalits, Brahmins, kshatriya... Today everyone is staying together, it's only peaceful religion who have become problem in this country...
@@Peace-vs9yi They are already divided.🙃
@@lightspot5505 not more than Shia,Sunni, wahabi,ahmadia, hazaras and 67 more castes 🙃🙃
@@sumila56 ohh you are a Hindu because you hate Muslims,,, got your point.
@@sumila56 Btw 300 + castes in our hindu dharma.
I'm usually on the fence with Acharya ji but this was such a fascinating interaction with Prof. Mandal!
We need more of this!!!
Haha. 😂 Mandal Bhandal hai
Are sunna unke page se bahot video hai❤❤
आचार्य जी और Prof दिलीप जी दोनों लोगों का संवाद बहुत ज्ञानवर्धक रहा ,
Speciallly आचार्य जी एक एक मुद्दे को बहुत बारीकी से एवम बहुत ही सूक्ष्म से सूक्ष्म बिंदुओं को इतनी स्पष्टता के साथ बतलाते हैं
आचार्य जी❤
Wow man...what a debate....aankhein taras gayi mutual respect dekhne ke liye....kaan taras gye sabhya tareeke se baat bolte hue aur sunte hue......ek baat samajh aayi....ki prashant ji ki soch aur baatein ideal human ki taraf le jaati hai......aur Prof. Dilip Mandal sir ki baatein most practical ideal human ki taraf le jaati hai....thanks Kamra bhai🇮🇳🙏
Acharya prashant ki soch nahi
Jo Satya hai aur jo sahi hai vahi bata rahe हैं
और उनका काम इतना महत्वपूर्ण है की आज वोह कृष्ण के रूप में हमारे यहां हैं लेकिन हमको अर्जुन होना होगा तभी कृष्ण दिखेंगे
@@love.offical bhai ek baari mein samajh gya tha...lekin na hi vo krishna hai aur na hi kisiko arjun banne ki jaroorat hai.
प्रोफेसर दिलीप मंडल साहब आपको मेरा सैल्यूट है....... आपने जितनी आसान भाषा में सभी question के answer दिए सुनकर बहुत कुछ सीखने को मिला......thank you sir❤
AACHARYA ji ko bhi sun Lena mere bhai..
Bro Aacharya ji bahut complicated hai...... Unke vichar ache ho skte hai pr mere samjh me nhi aate...... Unke vicharo me problems ka solution nhi dikhta mujhe..... M galat bhi ho skta hu....... But Dilip sahab ki bate real me jo hmare smaaj me gandgi bhari hai usko dur krne me kargar savit hoti hai
@@mr.rohitverma2466
Mere bhai ye thik vaisi baat h ki Apko 104 degree fever h or aap gile kapde se heat kam karo...lekin asli dawai paracetamol h Jo fever ke virus ko maregi... Mandal ji ki baten shi h lekin wo bahari ilaj h hame virus ko pakdne ke liye Aacharya ji ko samjhna or sun na padega dhyan se... 🙏... Wo burai ke Kendra tak le jana chahte hain.. kabhi samay nikal kar unke videos dekhiye gahrai ka pata chalega aapko bhi...isi video ko ho sake to nispakh hoke 2-4 bar gahrai se Shanti se suniye aapko clarity aayegi
@@adxmalad4675 bilkul bro...... I'll try
Acharya prasanat is great ❤❤❤
I am enlightened by Acharya Ji. I am not taking sides which I don't need to at the age of 40. What I have to do is to learn the inner self. Which I am trying to do. I am enlightened.!!
Prashant Aacharya is a gem. Always on Point. With due respect to Professor Sahab.
😂 always on point? Video dekho bhaiya dhang se. Asaan se sawaalo ka itna bakwaas jawaab diya hai. Kya keh rahe ho
@@exanodeek dam shai kaha
@@exanodebilkul sahi😂😂
Are bhai ye sab saale hinduo ko barbad krne aaye hai
Jawab toh acha hi diya hai aur sahi bhi par samajhne wale ki samajh samajh alag alag hai issliye koi baat kisi ko bakwas lagti hai ki ko anmol heera
@@exanodeAbhi u r young. When you will cross 30years and see and experience life and see the complexities created by society then u will change ur point of view. And u will say A. Prashant is right and on point. He is an ex civil servant. He knows society more than what we all know. ❤
Kunal bhai..one of the best episode..!!!!
सच मे माॅर्डन भारत देश के लिऐ इस तरह की डिबेट होना बहोत जरूरी है !
आपने उन तमाम बिकाऊ मिडीया को बतादीया डिबेट कैसे कराते है !
Keep it up..bhai..!!!🙏👍
Aacharya Prasant is great compare than any other...... Because of he is think about whole creatures not only humen being. And Earth is allow equal life for all.........
ऐसी वार्तालाप देखने के लिए पूरा भारत तरस रहा था
जो भी दोनों की वार्तालाप से कुछ भी सीखा हो उसने आज बहुत कुछ नया सीख लिया है।
मुझे साझा सुख,साझा दुख,और साझा सपने जो सकारात्मक दिशा में हो
ये वाला कॉन्सपेट बहुत अच्छा लगा जो देश को राष्ट्र बना देगा।❤❤❤❤
Acharya Prashant,what a great thinker and greatly delivered, all words are well measured, well scaled.. pranam aapko🙏
शानदार विश्लेषण एक बेहतर मानव जीवन की ओर
मंडल जी कि बातें कड़वी दवा की तरह है जो समाजिक बेहतरी के लिए सार्थक हैं
परन्तु आचार्य जी की बातें छननी कि तरह है जो उस कड़वी दवा को और बेहतर बनाने का काम करती हैं
🙏
The best conversation ever! Oh man, the depth in which Acharya Prashant goes, very rational, straight, lively; and Professor Dilip Mandal Ji also went into an structural analysis of the topic.
Blessed to hear the conversation. Thankyou Kunal for bringing them together.
I'm listening Acharya Prashant for more than a year and listening Dilip Mandala Sir for the very 1st time. This is so blissful conversation 🙏
2:21 yahi samajh aa gaya tha ki kitne bade wala hai ye professor 😂
Na to isko data se matlab hai
Na hi isko linching based on religion ke barey mein kuch pata hai
Isko bas BJP ko Target karna tha jo isne kar diya😂
Warna Nehru aur Indira kitne bade waley religion based politicians rahey hai
Pade likhe log behtar jantey hai 😂
@@VR.christianoophli bar aachary ki baate smj nhi aai sady samne professor ji hi ese bete h ki aachary parshant ko smj nhi aa rha ki ab is Bache ke samne Kya bolu
@@mohabbatsingh5644 par ek cheej notice kee tumne ye acharya ji dusri baar gaye hai uske paas
Ek aur prodcast hai in dono ka purana
Ye jaan boojh kar gaye hai bhai
Ye aadmi bhi kahi na kahi thoda teda hai
Bro really killed it . What a podcast . A lot of things i learned from this podcast and i can say this was one of the best podcast ever i had . Mind opening podcast . Thanks to Kunal Kamra, what a session . Really, i think every youth of India must watch this session .This session is the definition of past, present and future of dharma . What dharma is and what DHARMA should be.
दिलीप जी की बाते सीधी सरल, जेनुइन, समाजिक, वास्तविक है, well both are good, बहुत अच्छा लगा, आप दोनों के स्पीच सुनकर कुछ सीखने को मिला।🙏❤️🌹
आचार्य प्रशांत के पास समाधान है और धर्म का सच्चा अर्थला रहे हैं
Mandal ji is a very experienced person with nuance in his thought, while Acharya Prashant is an existentialist and offers insights that most people residing in our earthly plane do not often get to access. The former tells us how the world thinks and what they believe, but the latter observes with us them breaking down an idea thoroughly by nuanced examination, which i find so valuable
Acharya needs to learn about other religions before he can comment on them. He clearly only understands Hinduism because he clearly does not understand the fundamental concepts of the Abrahamic religions and tries to overlay Hinduism on their beliefs. The ignorance was laughable.
आचार्य जी को कोटि कोटि प्रणाम और धन्यवाद कुनाल आपको भी आप जो आज प्रकृति को बचाने में सबसे आवश्यक है उस आवाज को आप लोगों के मध्य पहुंचाने में भागीदार बन रहे है।
Acharya जी ने कहा वह बिलकुल ठीक है।
I like it
I am waiting for this conversation with Prof. Dilip Mandal sir, I am very happy to listen to him,😊😊
Thanks a lot Kunal bhai❤❤❤
प्रोफेसर साहब के तर्क बिल्कुल व्वहारिकता पर आधारित है और आचार्य जी के तर्क हमे अध्यात्म की ओर ले जाते है...
दोनों की बाते सुनकर बहुत कुछ सीखने को मिला
No-one raised their voice to be heard. No-one interrupted the other person in the middle to make a point. They listened to the other to understand another perspective rather to win the argument. And this turned out to be so poetic in the end. Thank you Kunal for giving us this discourse.
@42:10 what a reply to mondal by Acharya... Amazing
Because arguably both are on the same side.
❤❤❤
धर्म की सही परिभाषा आचार्य प्रशांत ने दी है। आचार्य जी और प्रोफेसर साहब में वही अंतर है जो ज्ञान और साक्षरता में है। साक्षरता हमें ओपन माइंडेड या ज्ञानी नहीं बनाती।
इसे हम एक आध्यात्मिक मन और शास्त्रीय मन भी कह सकते हैं। एक समर्पित और उदार, एक जट्ट और आबद्ध, आबद्ध रूढ़ि परम्परा और मान्यताओं में। एक खुद की फिक्र करने वाला नितांत वैयक्तिक, एक वैचारिक रूप से समुदाय और समाज की उपरी तौर पर चिंता करने वाला।
बहुत ही बेहतरीन आचार्य प्रशांत जी और प्रोफेसर दिलीप मंडल सर, आप लोग जैसे भारत में 100 लोग हो जाए और भारत में सक्रिय रूप से सामाजिक समस्याओं पर कार्य करें तो भारत पूरे दुनिया में शीर्ष स्थान पर होगा।
Prof. Mandal is right in saying that today’s India is definitely more prosperous than it has ever been…. But Acharyaji wants to ask why that prosperity has not lead to true happiness and bliss in lives of people…. Because that is what actually matters in the end…. Such discussions are worthy of hearing…. Thanks all of you…. Lets hope for the best in future…🙏🏻
Yeah peace joy love truth cannot be materialised
There will be less broken people if they're in tune with the true Creator. Nothing else !
Rest all are worthless
well here prod.mandal is factually wrong then , india is nowhere close to how prosperous it was in earlier centuries where it shared almost 40% of world's wealth , around gupta period
बहुत शालीन और सभ्य वार्ता,काश भारतीय TV channel पर देखने को मिलती है ✍️
कुनाल भाई का धन्यवाद 🙏🙏
Mainstream media is a national shame.
To saale, TH-cam pe to mil raha jo National TV se zyada dekha jaata hai.
Bas rote rehna jeevan bhar.
मैं केवल इतना सुन सकता हूं कि आचार्य प्रशांत भारतीय पीढ़ी के भविष्य को लेकर चिंतित हैं और उनकी चिंता मुझे चिंतित कर रही है, लेकिन दूसरी ओर, जब मैं प्रोफेसर दिलीप मंडल को सुनता हूं, तो मुझे केवल एक प्रचार सुनाई देता है। जो एक हठधर्मिता में सीमित है. इस चर्चा ने मुझे अपनी समस्याओं और उन सुधारों के बारे में सोचने पर मजबूर किया जिन्हें मेरे जीवन को सार्थक बनाने के लिए किया जा सकता है।
Correct
जिनके साथ असमान व्यवहार नहीं होता है, उन्हें ये बातें हठधर्मिता ही लगती है।
गांधी जी को भी बाबा साहेब हठधर्मी लगते थे।
और वेदांत जब खुद ही कहता है कि संसार में रहने के लिए विद्या अविद्या दोनो चाहिए तो आप सिर्फ आचार्य
प्रशांत को ही क्यों महत्व दे रही हैं।
मुझे तो ये दोनों विद्या अविद्या के प्रतीक प्रतीत हुए चर्चा में।🙏
काश मेरे देश में हर tv चैनल पर ऐसी वार्ता सुनने को मिलती। This video is for the open-minded people by the open-minded people.
Mai bhi yahi soch raha hun abhi
Same
To sab chodumal ban jaenge.
Sab bate hi cho*enge
Because kisi ko sach nhi sunna
Exactly. Nothing else can be said other than this.
This is one of the most Brilliant interview, Dilip Mandal ji coming on Kunal show. 🙏🙏🙏🙏
Common sorrow, common happiness and common dream , commonness in people of a country will be called a nation. What a thought by Prof. Mandal. Thanks you Mr Kunal to bring this discussion here.
This is definition of nation is also mentioned by Dr Babasaheb Ambedkar in one of his book's or his speech... This is logically very sound...
Common Happiness? Happiness is and individual pursuit. Common Goal is just an excuse to capture power by Politicians
@@smeshnoymatvey2054 commonness or uniformity always used to manipulate masses
ऐसे ही लोग भारत में होने चाहिए,ये दोनो एक ही संस्कृति से आते है,और उसी संस्कृति के सुधार में अपना योगदान दे रहे हैं,ये केवल और केवल इसी सस्कृति में पॉसिबल है,वरना आजतक हमने नहीं देखा किसी और मजहब के 3 लोग बैठकर अपने ही किताबों के कुछ लाइनों पर भी चर्चा कर सकें,इसीलिए इसे सुधारों की संस्कृति कहते हैं।🙏
Don't compare the legends. I followed proffessor Mandal since long. He is really a fighter on the social ground and I truely admire Acharya ji he is a worrior and fighting from the darkness of society. Their grounds are different, their battles are different but their love for truth is common. Thier vision for humanity is common.
Kunal is always a good and calm listner with curious questions.
Loved this.❤
All intellectual can stop convertion of society towards Christian religion or sleeping or ignore critical issues towads society need them stop convertion
Lol a Dwivedi supporting mandal 😂.
mondal fighting on ground? america rahta h vo 😂😂, or ek number ka sutiya hai kuch ka kuch bakta hai
@@sanjaybhatt60 he is fighting there to have reservation in America he is a Brahmin hater and their target will be baniya community basically an ambedkar follower who hate everyone because of their success and these dimwits dindu Brahmins are supporting such hate mongers. Heck they wish for your genocide and ambedkar followers are no different than Islamists terrorist
@sanjaybhatt60 अमेरिका बहुत से भारतीय रहते हैं, यदि मण्डल जी रहते हैं वहाँ तो ये उनकी चॉइस है. वैसे आपकी जानकारी ग़लत है, वो नोएडा में रहते हैं, दो वर्ष पहले तक रिसर्च स्कॉलर के तौर पर जेएनयू में एनरोल थे. मिडिया और समाजशास्त्र के विद्वान हैं. मिडिया पर उनकी किताबें बड़े पब्लिकेशन हॉउस ने छापी हैं. रही बात कुछ भी बोलने की तो आजादी है किसी को कुछ भी बोलने की, हाँ गैरकानूनी, हिंसक वक्तव्य बोलने की आजादी नहीं है. दो दशकों से ज़्यादा के पत्रकारिता के करियर में अगर मण्डल साहब गिरफ्तार होकर सजायाफ्ता नहीं हैं तो ज़ाहिर है कुछ गैरकानूनी नहीं ही कहा है. हाँ आपकी संकीर्णताओं को चोट लगी हो और आप कुछ भी बोल रहे हों तो आज़ादी आपको भी है. 👍🏻
Best quote of Ambedkar 53:30
If the Hindu social order was based on inequality, it would have been over-thrown long ago. But it is based on graded inequality so that the Shudra while he is anxious to pull down the Brahmin, he is not prepared to see the Untouchable raised to his level. : B.R Ambedkar
Source : Volume 5 page 116
So true. His book and the speech is a gem.
Exactly
Which book are you talking about?(riddles in Hinduism?)
@@honeyogeeks7558writing and speeches
exactly
You need a great sense of wisdom to understand Acharya Prashant..... More power to you sir... Dilip Ji's point is also important in the reformation of society
I don't know if it's wisdom...but surely curiosity and dare and will to not give up
@@hchghgffyfexposed for what exactly?
@@KS-xp1odthey got his old pics of having fun with his friends, girls, smoking, dancing. Which in their opinion very unethical thing to do LMAO. This is what they call being exposed.
@@Scikit27 everyone has done those in their life. Nobody is perfect. The change matters
AP's opinions appeal a lot to the collective ego of Hindus by glorifying vedant, Upanishads and Gita as the highest and most authentic source of knowledge in sanatan dharm, he is whitewashing Hinduism while pushing his atheist, woke agenda in the name of Vedant ..
Acharya prashant wisdom is beyond time ❤
Professor Mandal primarily focuses on social change and Acharya ji primarily focuses on individual change ❤
Social change is the reflection of individual change.
@@aditya-xe2og exactly 💯
Prashant stuck in illusion
Social change starts only if individual change happens
Social change can only happen by changing the poeple
And acharya prashant very hardly trying to change the common people mindset so that our country becomes true Bharat and so on automatically world becomes a great place for all living beings
What an amazing level of intellectualism..maza aa gya ..finding ur self if true religion.. amazing things .both archya ji and prof hats off
What an insightful conversation! Nobody addresses these aspects like Acharya ji does, and I am forever grateful for that. We need more such discussions.
आचार्य प्रशांत जी और प्रो. Dilip ji me इतना ही फर्क कर पाया हूं, की आचार्य जी अंदर की तरफ देख रहे है और dilip जी बाहर की तरफ देख रहे है।
🎉🎉
😮😮🙏
प्रशांत ने जो बोला है वो ओशो काफी पहले बोल गये हैं बल्कि उससे भी गहरे तल पर जाकर। और प्रोफेसर ने प्रैक्टिकल बातें कहीं हैं।
@@Anick-xi2rgabe chutiye Jin practical baton ki tu baat kar raha hai vah to normal chij hai Kaun si bahut badi baat ho gai jahil baat deepness ki hai Jo Ho Raha hai use dekhna vah sahi hai ya galat ki bus ho raha hai aap practical ho raha hai sahi hai jahil hai kya be tere niji jindagi tere Naam jindagi mein Jo vigyan Jo tu dekh raha hai vah normal chij hai because you are capable of samjha chutiye.
करोड़ों साल से इंतजार था
Me too
@@saurav3719 are mane ramji ki oolad randi chote bhim chota bhim ko kuch bola hi nahi
@@saurav3719 bhai tere pe 295 lag jayega cmnt delete kar, Hamare Ram ke baare me esa Mt bol.
@SCIENTISTMEN1312😂😂😂
Sir en sabhi ko ek bar science Journey sir se divet karni chahiye 😊❤❤❤ good work Dilip sir
Acharya Ji,
You've given me so Much Hope!!! I say that with tears in my eyes. Hope not only in the Adhyatm but in worldly life too. I started listening to you on TH-cam 1.5 years ago. You are the one mentor I never had. Your teaching here on TH-cam and course of yours in website have given me such crystal clear clarity. I believe you've literally led me to gold. It's up to me now to chisel it out and bag it :). I accept the responsibility and am excited at the prospects. Thank you, Acharya ji💕!!! :)
u sound like his PR team member
@@123xyzabccba i wish i was in any team. Still waiting for that destined moment🙏
I am new but i like Acharya Uncle
Ek Acharya + Ek Comedian + Ek Professor = Tons of Wisdom !! 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
Can you see the contribution of the comedian for the country...❤ for ACHARYA PRASHANT 😊
Humours intellect educated comedian
@@shreshthaprakash3745 Exposing the lies of a political leader in a sarcastic way when millions are paying homage. That's what a comedian does..
fake professor hai mandal
2 mahine setting se padha ke nakli professor ban gya
@@shreshthaprakash3745 भाई आचार्य प्रशांत अच्छा काम कर रहे हैं लेकिन अगर कामेडियन लोगों की मानसिक अंधभगतई को थोड़ी सी भी चोट पहुंचा पा रहा है कि लोग बिलबिला के उसके शो बंद कराके ही अपने को ताकतवर समझ रहे तो वो भी अपनी जगह कामयाब है
Acharyji Aapne 100% sach kaha.
we are proud of you. Thank you sir. ⚘️🙏
To me both are explaining physics , Mandal sir in school physics language and Acharya sir in master degree physics language.
Like ,what is momentum ?
Prof Mandal : mass * velocity
Acharya sir : Momentum wave function is Fourier transform of position wave function.
Such a great level of discussion
Nope, Not at all. Prf. Mandal is too soft for these kind of discussions and I can prove in just one question’s answer given by Prof Mandal. In Q3 Kunal asks about Superstition and why Indians are attracted to it, Prof. Mandal’s reply is not related at all to the question. Instead of answering WHY he is just answering HOW. Acharya Prashant on the other hand gave a clear reason on WHY.
🙏🙄🤭🤔Adam Seekar Urdu
99.99% of people can't understand what Acharya Prashant is saying. It's Sad.
Thanks, Kunal for bringing these people and letting them speak.
The telegram account is a fake scammer.
Yes. 01% BRILLIANT people like you only understood.
@@toufiqueahmed7sarcasm huh. But joke aside Acharya was spot on , and mondol was practical.
What a episode
@@toufiqueahmed7😂😂
💯
Acharya ji aur dilip sir both are amazing , I have learned alot from listening these 2 , we need more such interviews . Also Kudos to Kunal for being them both to same stage
*वाह! मुझे बहुत ही आनन्द मिला दोनों के संवाद से।मैं नतमस्तक हूँ दोनों के सरल और सहज स्वभाव से। और एक बात से खुश हूँ कि दोनों ने एक दूसरे को सुना और स्वीकार भी किया और मेरी मुर्गी की एक टांग वाला संवाद नहीं बन पाया।
साधुवाद 🙏🏻🥰👌🏻❤️
Prof. Mandal is too rational and superb clarity … imagining what if he becomes CM of any state. Acharya prashant is also representing a true meaning of religion and humanity. India can be vishwaguru if person like mandal and prashant ji start coming and representing india.
आचार्य जी को इतना सुन चुका हूं कि जब कुणाल ने प्रश्न पूछा ही था तभी मैने सोच लिया था कि आचार्य जी शुरुआत ही ऐसे करेंगे - "पहले जान लेते हैं कि धर्म क्या है, किसे धर्म कहते हैं"
❤💯🙏
bhai ye es era k swami vivekanand hai
धन्यवाद आप को आप ऐसे ही आचार्य जी के साथ आगे बढ़ते रहिए।
में भी यही सोचा था सच्ची
Me also ❤
Professor Dilip mandal is a brilliant personality who raise the questions about casteist society and political hagimony
*Dilip's intellect is hijacked by abrahamic framework of religious identification*
This kind of shallow intellect can gain some traction among people with low level inquisitiveness and charvaks , but real seekers know this very well that acharya prashant is on right tract ...
@@SAY-jf3hy sare devta prakriti ke anthropomorphic gunvachak nam hai... devta prakriti hi hai... indra koi bharat ka devta nahi.. the word Indra is rooted to indriya..Or sense organs...The ruler of senses... baat wohi hai ki aap devta ko bas mandir me jante ho.. sashtro se nahi jante... prakriti aur purush (chetna) universal hai... koi ek boundary ka baat nahi hai.. khudko boundary me bandhneka saukh sabse zyada religious adharmiko ko hota hai...😁😋
Dilip Sir target caste system not
Focus on dharma debate
Insan ke andar ke Janwar ko khatam Karo caste system apne aap khatm ho jaega
Can you see the contribution of the comedian for the country...❤ for ACHARYA PRASHANT 😊
@@adwaitvedant3297 bro stop this bakwas, whatever you are saying is based on Vedic and Vedanta scripture, but brahminvaad already replaced vedic culture long time back, aaj ke time mein koi bhi India mein Indra ki pooja nhi karta hai, can you name a single popular Indra temple in India, Veda believe in advaita one God but that concept is not good preached by most brahmin, jydataar brahmin kayi tarah ki pooja kara ke yhi bolkar paisa lete hai ki iss pooja se aapki manokamana poori ho jaye gi, brahmin Satyanarayan pooja karate hai, jagratha karate hai, santhoshi mata ke vrat bhi karate hai,Ram katha karate hai but you can even find one brahmin jo vedic scripture padhaye ya Indra ki pooja kare, you literally have zero knowledge about history of Hinduism, Rig Veda culture was different from Later culture, Adwaita Vedanta is completely different from current brahminvaad based on casteism and temple culture, Indra was most powerful God in Rig Veda and he is controller of all nature force, but in most brahmin scripture he's shown as coward who easily defeated by Rawan Or his son and any other normal Rakhsa and Asur, and then he go to Narayan and Shiva for asking help,its impossible as per Rig Veda because he's most powerful force of Nature,all this happen because current day brahmin developed as different sect from vedic Miminasha philosophy, nowadays brahmin are using Vedanta to proof their superiority, but the fact is that you can't find a single brahmin who preach Veda or worship Indra in your locality except in some part of South India or self learned person like Acharya Prashant
The way Acharyaji envisions Bharat is just my kind of dream . For me it is my wonderland it is my swarg
Dilip sir on this platform with acharyaji was unexpected...great one bhai❤
Professor Dilip Mandal sir describes root cause of the problems very clearly and deeply.
😂😂😂blind watch this again he only tell which satisfies human mind but acharya prashant is telling us the roots on the basis of philosophy he is saying which is deep
@@rishabhyadav6705 Buddhism ka chor aur bhrastachari adi shankarcharya ka chela he anacharya ashaant.
Prof. Dilip Mandal sir is a true genius and visionary.
Love this talk full of wisdom.
😂😂😂
Abe gandu hai vo ..dyan se suno uski baat
😂
भीमटा ☕☕ 😹😹
Sirf atheists ko promote karke or Brahmans ko gaali dene se koi full of wisdom ni hojata
आचार्य जी ने धर्म के वास्तविक स्वरूप का परिचय दिया।।❤❤❤🎉🎉🎉
First time listening to professor Dilip mandal. Highly impressed! His simplistic approach towards the lucid explanation of complicated aspects of our society just made my day. Looking forward to seeing him more in future. Good job Kunal. You deserve thanks and appreciation big time here.
I witnessed my brother in intelligence who passed away long back.
Thank you ACHARYA ji & Mandal ji
Prof Dillip mandal is intellectual with courage.he never afraid of raising questions against govt and issue of caste, tribals and women's, education and has deep knowledge about society and good command on journalism 🙏🙏🙏🙏
😂😂😂😂
@@Indium6480what is laughable in his comment ?
@@Indium6480 What was funny in this comment? (Note that I'm not the same person as the author)
I have seen on twitter that Prof. Dilip Mandal Mostly Focus on Annihilation of Caste, Always raise the issue of caste because it decides a lot in India.
@@Indium6480tu kaya rat ko muta ha..bed meh chup chup ke😂😂😂
Enlightening debate. Acharya Prashant’s grasp and learning is unparalleled. His goal is to progress and liberate everyone. He is an asset in today’s twisted times. Brutal truth and nothing else.
How beautifully described, common dream, common happiness and common sadness. And most importantly common sadness. That's how we can create a true nation. Prof Dilip Mandal kudos sir 🙏❤️
Just one problem he cannot show a way to achieve this commoness...bcz you cannot achieve it without something like vedant
@@mrigendrajha2690 it's not a problem just an addition. There can be various ways, like Acharya himself explained to attain a goal. Just a right spirit is needed. Both gave beautiful answers.
@@mrigendrajha2690 And kindly don't say can't. No offense 🙏 Hope you have a good time.
Professor Deelip Mandal sir, you are great 👍
Bhai deelip ji ka mindset ek taraf hai
Prof. Mandal knows the society and Acharya Parshant knows the individual living in that society.
Great combination of what is and what should be.
What is society?even if you know it?what are you really knowing about? individual?
Isn't that looks like a loop?
I think AP is questioning the source society>individual>Mind(thoughts)>connects withego(the root cause of all problems)
And ego is a illusion it is not real but looks like real(Mithya)
And you don't know both😂
Oh wow ,, you described them perfectly with your first statement ,,
@@TheoSophiihaan tu to bhagwaan h saale
"Just watched the interview with Acharya Prashant and Dilip Mandal on Kunal Kamra's channel, and I must say, it was an enlightening experience. Kunal's knack for engaging with thought-provoking personalities brings out conversations that are not only intellectually stimulating but also deeply inspiring. This interview was no exception. It offered a wealth of insights and perspectives that challenge us to think deeper and broader. Thank you for providing a platform that enriches our understanding and encourages meaningful dialogues. Keep up the fantastic work!"
Why this type of conversation didn't occurs everywhere ..
How much of a healthy conversation this is..I am just thankful to respected sir Acharya ji and mandal ji.
I am huge fan of Prof. Deelip Mandal.🎉
I am following Acharya Prashant for few months ,but today I meet first time with Dilip Mondal ,you can't ignore Dillip mondal
20june ko theprint me accha article bhi likha hai sir ne
💯% right 🇮🇳
The sociological approach to study has many advantages as evident from Prof. Mondal Ji's argument and I too respect that. But sociological approach by itself isn't enough to guide the social change as social change starts from the individual and Acharya Ji is addressing the individual and the individual's weaknesses.
Sahi baat
One who gets the knowledge of real Vedanta, it is not only difficult to win but it is impossible. Repeated salutations to Acharya Prashant
Wow! People like Acharya ji are born in generations. Hats off to Acharya ji 🙏🙏🙏
What a great closing statement by Acharya Prashant. Both of them had brilliant points. Satisfaction level: 100%
Ye to bole only BJP's and hindus hi dharam ke naam pe violence karte hai!
muslims aur congress nai?
@@killer7495 ek bhi Hindu mob lynched karke mara Gaya ya force Kara Gaya bandhke kahi ki Allah hu akbar bolo?
Ek incident ginade maanjaunga ek baap. Ki aulaad hai
Is takle ke pas entina hai kya
Ye dono logo ko chutiya bana rahe keval adarsh baate kar rahe hai,jo ground level par hai uski baat nahi kar rahe, ye ved ko manta hai ved me itni ghatiya baate likhi hai ye padha nahi hoga 😂😂😂😂
@@killer7495nhi aap samjhe nhi fir se unbiased hokar dekhiye
Prof. Dilip Mandal - intelligent well read professor = practical answers 👍
Acharya Prashant = Great philosopher, great thinker and very visionary person and he understands the core of the problem 🙏.
My personal favourite ( since I am a thinker ) = Acharya Prashant showed more clear and visionary picture 🙏🙏
im not agree with prof dilip mandal at 52:29 that one seventh of population of world didnt produced or invented anything in last 2000 years starting from aryabhatas zero to Chess, snakes and ladders,yoga, Sanskrit, Ayurveda, water on the moon, plastic surgery, binary system, ink, Fibonacci numbers by acharya pingala in 2nd bce, fiber optics, USB, and boson named after satyender nath bose many more inventions the recipe was already there in indian minds west just stolen it from vedas and nalanda libraries and just made a good dish and at 1:10:13 he is saying u cant show a single apartment built on vedas i can say that new parliament of india is built according to vastu from atharva veda and mostly i disagree with dilip mandals points and as he mentioned specifically the points of suppresion of dalits and muslims at 1:08:56 we can guess his deep rooted leftist ideology and why he is on kunal lamras channel
Right
Acharya visualises a world with humanity love rationality without any political social economic boundaries.
An anarchy with humanity. A civilization with rationality.
Best discussion on religion , nation and on humanity
Good job Kunal brother ♥️
Probably the best discussion on religion and India that I have come across. Compelling from both Acharya and Prof. Mandal. May such programs proliferate.
what does mandal have to say about, saudi's using robots to distrubute the quran?? cz islam ti progressive hai sanatan se??
@bhagatkibhakti949 aap bataa do.....hate monger
@bhagatkibhakti949 KYO SUNNA HE TUMHE USKE BAARE ME ???.. PADLO KHAREED KAR ..
प्रोफेसर दिलीप मंडल जी वास्तविकता पर बात कर रहें हैं जबकि आचार्य जी डिबेट को आध्यात्मिकता की ओर ले जा रहे हैं...
बाकी दोनों अपने अपने क्षेत्र में लीजेंड हैं....👍
Rong
नहीं दिलीप मंडल की सोच समझ संकुचित और किताबी है और वे ऐसे ही बात कर रहे हैं
Aachary Jee only gyan pel rhe h farji admi h bs gyan pelne vale person ku6 change nhi kr pa rhe h gyan pelenge abhi 10 -20 sal jb tk jiyenge inki dharmikata kb adharmik bn jayega pta nhi chlega practical bat kro jo samaj follow kr rha h aap gyan pelo bs 😢😢😢😢😢
@@sanchardarshan Kyu ki hindu sankuchit hai
@@sanchardarshan More realistic
मनुष्य जाति की सारी समस्या का अंतिम समाधान आत्मज्ञान है पूज्य आचार्य जी अंतिम समाधान दे रहें हैं हमारी पात्रता कैसी है ये हम पर हमारी नियत पर निर्भर है !!
Acharya ji ko khud atmagyan nahi hi.kewal hawa Hawaii baaten krta hi.recent social problems se koi Matlab nahi.cast system ko defend krta hi.
अरे भाई तेरे को कितना ज्ञान है तू देने लग जा फिर सब समस्या एक ही आदमी की ठेकेदारी थोड़ी है तू करने लग जा समाजिक परेशानियों का निवारण@@Tnt-x9t
This is how any conversation or discussion should be..calmly..open minded, and not getting offended by every passing minute.... This is the kind of content we need .🔥🔥🙏🙏🤝🤝
This is how debates should be.
Civilized way.
This single video can take our country (all countries) (whole earth) on the right humanitarian path eradicating all the problems like climate change, wars, communalism, greed, food shortage, population. Its an ideal approach but even 10% of wisdom from this video is implemented by everyone, we are good to go.
Agreed if people choose to invest their time in getting to know more whats inside and your inside reflects the world that we live in😇
This statement 🤝🤝🤝🤝
What an enlightening conversation. Thank you to Acharya Prashant ji, Prof. Dilip Mandal ji for this talk and kunal for this video and expecting more in future.
52:17 here prof sir is wrong. He use so many thing in todays life given by ancient and medieval hindus, which is:- 10 digits(hindu numerals) , algebra, trigonometry, rhinoplasty and other forms of surgery, natyashastra, grammar(by panini), economics(by arthshastra), philosophy etc. and contributions in many other fields.
*The main reason that india is left behind, which these professors will never say is the destruction of hundreds of universities by islamic invaders who invaded india and never built a single university in 500-600 years of muslim rule in india.* so if there is no universities then from where does the innovation will come* . Meanwhile the west during this era was building a lot of universities and thats why they succeeded.
We have to accept the harsh truth!
Professor Dilip mandal is a great speaker. Very sensative speaker & very knowledgeable
😂😂😂😂
Prof Dilip Mondal logic is very good. He is the man of intelligence
Sachaii sunne me jalan to hogi hi...mastan
Kya thoda chudu hai Bhai tu sab religion ke liye he bol rahe he dona sab religion me burai nai hai unke jo thekedar he vo bure
@@tupacshakur4929 exmuslim search karo
@@tupacshakur4929 Religion me hi burai hai murkh kafi religious text padh lena
Professor Dilip Mandal is one of the Fantastic Rational Minds in India at Present.❣
Its Always Soothing, Informative and Enlighting to listen Professor Dilip Mandal. Do Share it with Friends and Family.
Jai Bhim, Jai Bharat.
Gajputunni Gaandput Bhimta spotted 😂😂😂
True❤
And what about AP?
I have seen on twitter that Prof. Dilip Mandal Mostly Focus on Annihilation of Caste, Always raise the issue of caste because it decides a lot in India.
😂😂👌👌 once more once more
If u really want change on concious level of indian just promote this guy Mr. आचार्य प्रशांत
As Acharya ji is vedanti, He is looking at the origin of any problem and the solution accordingly.
And D.C Mandal ji is a rationalist who is looking towards social reform desperately.
Correctly said… totally same i feel for both
@@jyotsanayadav4733 sure, and we should say thanx to Kunal Kamra that he invites such combination of personalities who can teach us great sense.
Well conclued
A vedanti is also a rationalist
But Acharya Prashant is talking from a very individualist prospective that's why it is easier for him to ignore caste , becuz u don't need to deal in caste in ur relationship in God .
But Dilip Mondol is talking about the social relations where the caste exists , also spirituality will never be able to disloge the caste system , becuz majority of the population in the country will remain social people with Little spiritual knowledge no matter how much we try .
All words fall short if I want to eulogise Kunal Kamra. Equally Acharya Prashamt and Dilip Mandal who have studied so much about religion to guide lakhs of people who listen to you patiently. Your contribution to our nation is most valuable and highly appreciable. God bless you all.
A philosophical and pragmatic discourse at the same time! Beautifully conducted! Awesome work Kunal!
R u Athiest
@@theeternalloser6885 only when everything is going alright in life
I liked the criteria that Acharya mentioned:
1) curious mind
2) mind that seeks truth
3) mind that does not accept shackles, especially if they are illogical and irrational
Excellent!
First time watching this show because of prof.dilip Mandal sir.
Dilip Mandal showed us who we are, and Acharya Prashant showed who we could be. The journey from 'what is' to 'what to become' is through complete understanding of 'what is' and not chasing an ideal. The 'what could be' is the by-product of unbiased observation of 'what is'
Krishnamurty?
"osho" the legend
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
After so many years, I have heard such a long conversation. It's highly intellectual and interesting.
Hope this conversation fruitful to most of the Indians. 🙏✌️
Acharye Prashant is true visionary human of modern time that humanity needs to tackle all problem that human has created... True real teacher ... Hats off his effort, spirit and knowledge.. 🙏
wow, from this video i bow to achaarya's understanding of Dharma and i got to know that why Acharaya is great person from whom we learn Dhrma...and it's really wonderful to meet Mr. Professor, he gave more sociological view point of religion, i love him explaining the topic as a wise persons perspective,
i would like to listen prof. more to get diff. perspective and understanding....
Dilip Mandal sir's knowledge and confidence is very high👍👍
Professor Dr Dilip Mandal a well matured philosopher. He shared his views in a very rational and logical way. Thanks sir nice to hear you and enlightening us by your knowledge.
Hahaha ...wo keh rahe hai ki Science me humne kuch nhi kia....jake Apne Sir se bolo bhai ki Jake Ved Prd le
@@Tubeshubhammishraved padke sirf teer kaman he bana sakte the....😂😂
ye professor ek no. illiterate h
@@Seeker3101 wo to dikh rha h kon h 😂😂
@@_utkarsh_6770 read about all quantum scientist what they have said about upnishad.
Because of upnisahd they think to deeper and open up many things.
Germans are not stupid who studying Sanskrit so they can able to read our scripture and kmow what is hidden with them.
The conceptual clarity of Acharya Prashant ji is just soo brilliant 👍