I honestly believe that the B1s were, at the very least, Slightly smarter than what you’re describing because they were given more Menial tasks such as crewing ships, fighting fires, aiding civilians who asked for directions, & cleaning the wild animal cages…
So basically they decided NOT to give them more intelligent programming because they were greedy and fearful of an intergalactic terminator army???. Well that makes a lot of sense. The droid's ai would have eventually started to evolve on it's own and they would turn on their creators. Not the most beneficial thing to have your army's do to you during War on the battlefield.
There is a lot of examples of IA that doesn't mess with their creators in fiction, but they could make a super computer IA that control the entire army but doesn't have full liberty. She could just process the battles and organize the army following the orders of the separatists. Would be cool to watch a more efficient droid army acting united as one.
But sometimes it takes intelligence to get the job done yes you have a lot of battle choice but they can all be wiped out because of this stupidity if you're going to put someone in charge of intelligence have a super tactical battle droid be in charge of that but even they will make a mistake that they couldn't calculate
@@macwelch8599 some militaries don't want to retreat and that they'll use every last man to achieve victory which is suicide sometimes you need to retreat if you're running low on men ammo munitions or the plan backfired or something it gives you and your men a chance to live to fight another day I'm not in the military but I've seen a few things.
@johnnyrocket1685 Yes, I get that it was all a show, but the Trade Federation had those droid armies before they started working for Sidious. Why would the Trade Federation purposefully include *organic* flaws in a *robot* army?
@johnnyrocket1685 Okay, but the Trade Federation already has the Droid Army during _Phantom Menace,_ you know, before the Separatist movement, when they're seemingly just being introduced to the Sith. That means they've had the droid army for a while. They're just now learning in _The Phantom Menace_ that the central control station is a problem, and so they get rid of the droids' reliance on it. Why wouldn't they get rid of the droid army's reliance on speech too?
I'm not sure I entirely agree with you. Yes, the B1 stupidity and basic programming made it unable to handle complex tasks. Therefore, it couldn't think for itself (not very well, anyhow) and couldn't be convinced to turn on its enemies. At the programming stage, people might have a difficult time because there isn't much to reprogram, but that doesn't mean they'd have a hard time reprogramming what is there. Meanwhile, with more complex droids, yes u might be able to convince them to join u because they can think for themselves. However, more powerful AI mean more money and programming was put into it. Surely these smarter (and more expensive) droids would have programming defences in them, the separatists wouldn't want them being reprogrammed to turn against them. And the amount of time and effort it would take to go through ALL of the complex programming would, in my opinion be harder then just reprogramming a single b1 with basic programming (a droid that might not have any programming defenses). However, to be fair, one issue that might make reprogramming a b1 more difficult is if u want it to go beyond its capabilities. If u want the b1 to become a tactical genius, then you will have to add all that programming yourself, whereas a tactical droid will already have all that programming. Anyhow, that's my opinion
I honestly think the reason for the battle droids being such idiots was Feloni's giving us some comedy relief in an other wise very dark war even for animation standards
Their first apperance in Phantom Menace was pretty cool as i always saw them as mindless robots made for exterminating stuff since i was a kid. OOM-9 was a example of how a tactical droid had to look like in the Clone Wars show. But the writters decided to turn them stupid because they had to make Republic and Jedi full of plot armor because they think we all love good guys. It just feels the bad guys are the Republic and Jedi. Its boring to warch nonr of them get at least hurt. Anakin in the show is smart but in RoTS hes just dumb and falls under Palpatines influence. I dont even know why do writters suck at everything they do whit this franchise.
I get they are cheap and dumb. But why cowardly? That does not go along with 'Crush your enemies by numbers'. They get worse as the films go on, flailing around and running. In the first episode of the Bad batch we even see some surrender. Ordering droids to retreat, fine but why programme battle droids to run away without orders, especially when expendible?
“The b1 battle droid is a basic microwave, it heats up your food”
Honestly the droids are my favorite, how can you not like the " uh oh" 😂
Roger roger
Droid saying "Oh my God"
" I just got promoted!"
@@ericleef1319 😂😂😂
"Uh.... He's in command!"
*Blast*
*sigh* "I guess I'm in command."
*Blast*
I wish they didn’t change their voice from the voice they had in the phantom menace movie
They were smart enough to know when they messed up. Of course, their linguistic skill was designed by producers to entertain children.
Roger roger
@Bromance 500 rounds coming at you something is going to get thru.
@Bromance well yeah and something that'd shoot anything moving with out question.
I honestly believe that the B1s were, at the very least, Slightly smarter than what you’re describing because they were given more Menial tasks such as crewing ships, fighting fires, aiding civilians who asked for directions, & cleaning the wild animal cages…
This video will not age well. Sooner or later, someone will decide our microwaves need wifi and AI capability.
"Roger Roger"
Roger Roger
So basically they decided NOT to give them more intelligent programming because they were greedy and fearful of an intergalactic terminator army???.
Well that makes a lot of sense.
The droid's ai would have eventually started to evolve on it's own and they would turn on their creators.
Not the most beneficial thing to have your army's do to you during War on the battlefield.
the battle droids for idiots for one reason... comedy relief...
There is a lot of examples of IA that doesn't mess with their creators in fiction, but they could make a super computer IA that control the entire army but doesn't have full liberty. She could just process the battles and organize the army following the orders of the separatists. Would be cool to watch a more efficient droid army acting united as one.
Roger roger
These droids are hilarious. Deserve a union to protect them.
Roger roger.
I love those droids. They're hilarious.
What the droids and the clones have in common? Both sides are expendable to the governments they were fighting for.
And the droids were sentient
@@obamabincoco7436 That too.
That actually makes sense.
Sometimes numbers are more important than intelligence
But sometimes it takes intelligence to get the job done yes you have a lot of battle choice but they can all be wiped out because of this stupidity if you're going to put someone in charge of intelligence have a super tactical battle droid be in charge of that but even they will make a mistake that they couldn't calculate
@@noahdean9685 true, there’s a delicate balance that military leaders need to achieve
@@macwelch8599 some militaries don't want to retreat and that they'll use every last man to achieve victory which is suicide sometimes you need to retreat if you're running low on men ammo munitions or the plan backfired or something it gives you and your men a chance to live to fight another day I'm not in the military but I've seen a few things.
@@noahdean9685 like, seriously? Just retreat already lol
ORDER 66
" Dew...it "
It will be done....my lord
*Blaster Noise and Jedi dying voice*
Awesome Vid
I always wonder what other different types of droids in the separatist army ever thought about the b1 battle droids
Okay, but why did the droids have to give each other orders? Shouldn't they be able to communicate at light speed through EM waves?
@johnnyrocket1685 Yes, I get that it was all a show, but the Trade Federation had those droid armies before they started working for Sidious. Why would the Trade Federation purposefully include *organic* flaws in a *robot* army?
@johnnyrocket1685 Okay, but the Trade Federation already has the Droid Army during _Phantom Menace,_ you know, before the Separatist movement, when they're seemingly just being introduced to the Sith. That means they've had the droid army for a while. They're just now learning in _The Phantom Menace_ that the central control station is a problem, and so they get rid of the droids' reliance on it. Why wouldn't they get rid of the droid army's reliance on speech too?
roger roger
Okay but why is the thumbnail pic fire
I'm not sure I entirely agree with you. Yes, the B1 stupidity and basic programming made it unable to handle complex tasks. Therefore, it couldn't think for itself (not very well, anyhow) and couldn't be convinced to turn on its enemies. At the programming stage, people might have a difficult time because there isn't much to reprogram, but that doesn't mean they'd have a hard time reprogramming what is there. Meanwhile, with more complex droids, yes u might be able to convince them to join u because they can think for themselves. However, more powerful AI mean more money and programming was put into it. Surely these smarter (and more expensive) droids would have programming defences in them, the separatists wouldn't want them being reprogrammed to turn against them. And the amount of time and effort it would take to go through ALL of the complex programming would, in my opinion be harder then just reprogramming a single b1 with basic programming (a droid that might not have any programming defenses). However, to be fair, one issue that might make reprogramming a b1 more difficult is if u want it to go beyond its capabilities. If u want the b1 to become a tactical genius, then you will have to add all that programming yourself, whereas a tactical droid will already have all that programming.
Anyhow, that's my opinion
I honestly think the reason for the battle droids being such idiots was Feloni's giving us some comedy relief in an other wise very dark war even for animation standards
I'm pretty sure they were just written that way for entertainment purposes in a theater.
What dat? Dat. nottin….. ughhh
In Legends the Droids were designed to be obedient killing machines while in Canon they were literal jokes with no brain
Wow
Not only B1 droids but almost all droids of CIS.
NNNNNNOOOOOOO
🤗
Has George Lucas ever commented on Darth Jar Jar? That needs to be canon
Thought you'd already covered this. Must be wrong.
Their first apperance in Phantom Menace was pretty cool as i always saw them as mindless robots made for exterminating stuff since i was a kid. OOM-9 was a example of how a tactical droid had to look like in the Clone Wars show. But the writters decided to turn them stupid because they had to make Republic and Jedi full of plot armor because they think we all love good guys. It just feels the bad guys are the Republic and Jedi. Its boring to warch nonr of them get at least hurt. Anakin in the show is smart but in RoTS hes just dumb and falls under Palpatines influence. I dont even know why do writters suck at everything they do whit this franchise.
Just. Make. Drones.
I get they are cheap and dumb.
But why cowardly? That does not go along with 'Crush your enemies by numbers'. They get worse as the films go on, flailing around and running.
In the first episode of the Bad batch we even see some surrender. Ordering droids to retreat, fine but why programme battle droids to run away without orders, especially when expendible?
the droids where the best😂
Nice
Hype
It’s horrible filmmaking, not the droids
1
Roger Roger