I wish we could go inside some of the interiors from the first game. Kinda seems like New Austin was rushed…. For example you can’t enter: Ridge Wood Farm, Rathskeller Fork, the interiors in Fort Mercer, Tumbleweed Mansion, Choots Chapel, Manzanita Post, or the hotel in Blackwater.
Oh so you guys don't actually know this... Ok so yeah new austin wasn't rushed, new austin wasn't supposed to be in the game in the first place We were supposed instead to have a bigger guarma and free roam there freely without restrictions and ability to comeback For some reason Guarmas role became much smaller and they added new austin last minute and only has half of a story mission taking place there We were lucky it was there in the first place I just wished guarma stayed like originally was.
I ain't gonna lie, I was trying to make RDR1 to look as good as I could. I used cheat code to set the game to sunny weather. I think the reason why RDR2 looks dark is because of the auto brightness adjustment. Whenever it's around 12:00 to 13:00, which should be the brightest period during a day, the game turns down the brightness automatically. I think the adjustment is too much
Red Dead is so good graphically. I remember being blown away as a kid playing RDR1 then I remember being blown away again as an adult with RDR2. Just great games
Ngl RDR2 looks too good, almost like real life. However RDR1 had that typical western filter on it. RDR2 is like the world the cowboys actually lived in, no film filters and such.
RDR2 is one of the most beautiful games in the world. However, I think RDR1 graphics style looks more like real life with lower quality, while RDR2 has a much higher graphics quality but with artified filter.
@@flamingmonkey7712 I disagree. RDR1 looks brighter and less colorful than real life. RDR2 almost looks like real life, but more colorful and polished.
It sucks that you can’t play in New Austin as Arthur, let alone playing in New Austin as the real John Marston instead of the monstrosity that they make you play as.(Arthur Marston) Keep up the great work.
RDR1, for me, looks more western than RDR2. I dont know, but RDR1 i feel the the hot weather in West Elizabeth, New Austin and Mexico, but in RDR2, i dont know, but i feel more cold and less hot in those places haha 😅.
The original map in RDR2 feels like a filming room with great set up background to me. The special graphical effects are too exaggerating, even though I have to admit it's beautiful. But for a western game, I like RDR1 style more
I understand why some other comparison videos which might not be as accurate in the positions, views, weather and time. The recording process is a pain in the ass even that I used a trainer for RDR2 for time, weather changing and teleporting. Cuz you still need to move your camera and your character in similar speed as you can. Anyway thanks for the compliment : )
I think a port to pc is better than a remake. Firstly I fear that they will ruin John's og personality, secondly the gameplay in the first game is more smooth and the pace is not that slow, the shooting and cover system, the wanted system are better, and the atmosphere of the graphics is more natural. Even that RDR2 is still a better and improved game indeed, but I don't want them to change RDR1 into a simple RDR2 DLC because each of them has their own up and down sides.
Woooow bro so much has changed since then look at the graphics but at that time even that graphic was everything for us the music Makes it even more great
@@aiarxa its called true faith by ashley johnson. Its actually from the game the last of us :) I only realised yesterday after doing research since i sadly never played it before xD Edit : typo
In RDR1 the rest of West Elizabeth after Beechers Hope and Black Water is completely empty with a few trees and just land far away. The land near the lake that divides the RDR1 map and RDR2 is identical in both games and even Owanjila is in RDR1 kind of. You have to play RDR1 to see
Did the JMRP get rid of authors hairstyles, because rdr1 john would look great with maybe length 6 aurthor hair or maybe length 5 But I really think somebody should just make a shortened version of Johns npc hair, because that would look excellent
@@flamingmonkey7712 rdr1 is magical I like the music so much In rdr2 the only music i like is when i roam around Roanoke ridge and a harmonica plays And also in rdr2 new Austin has some rdr1 sounds so good
@@flamingmonkey7712 maybe that's it. Or I just don't like that new Austin Looks red instead of bright yellow. It had more of a spaghetti western vibe before
How come rdr2 doesn't have any big mods like GTA does, seems like rdr2 only has basic mods like model swapping, rescaling, texture swaps, and save editor options .?
Maybe the game is too complicated for the mod to work? Whenever I use a trainer I only use the basic functions because I don't want to have a crash and stuff. IDK man
I never played rdr1.But what happens if you head to the eastern part of the map where Saint Denis is located?I know the place is not in rdr1,but i guess in the first game there is some kind of boundary to limit the map,like you got in rdr2 for Mexico
The eastest part of the map is Blackwater. Other parts that are east to it didn't exist back then. It's all water and mountain models that you're not supposed to reach, exactly like the map boundaries in RDR2
@@theodorvalentinghita1779 I think it's more of a shame that there's almost no content in New Austin. Would be great if they gave us a lot of stranger missions and side activities to do.
What is the horse breed that you are using in the video and where did you get it? Missouri fox trotter blue and white in black water I think is the best and the gold Turkoman,white Arabian.
I have a white Arabian, but honestly don't use it much with either Arthur or John. I personally prefer big horses (not that biggest type like the one Bill rides on tho), and I think horses like white Arabians are too small and they feel like my character is riding on a pony, even tho they are fast. The one I use in the video is a black American standardbred. And by the way since I play the game in Chinese language, I'm not sure if I know many of their English names, sorry lol
Yeah me too honestly the big ones are usually better I love bill's horse it is so good it would be awesome if you could use or borrow camp members horses like npc John's horse and bill,s horse
@Flaming Monkey I know RDR2 has better graphics than RDR1 but I prefer gameplay elements from RDR1 ability to choose Normal+Hardcore also free roam ing both USA+Mexico while RDR2 only limited on USA only.
I wanna know as well. Sounds like Ashley Johnson. Edit: Yup, found it. Just had to type in some of the lyrics. The title is True Faith. This version is a cover by Ashley Johnson. For the Last of Us I guess.
Yes, with John's restoration mod and RDR1 face mod. And I play it with rampage trainer, which I only use for filming videos like this, or when I want to mess around, never for playthrough
I don't think you've actually played the game if this is how you think. The first game actually feels a lot more old western than the second one in graphics style, atmosphere, dialogues and story.
I wish we could go inside some of the interiors from the first game. Kinda seems like New Austin was rushed…. For example you can’t enter: Ridge Wood Farm, Rathskeller Fork, the interiors in Fort Mercer, Tumbleweed Mansion, Choots Chapel, Manzanita Post, or the hotel in Blackwater.
Can’t enter the blackwater church either
Oh so you guys don't actually know this...
Ok so yeah new austin wasn't rushed, new austin wasn't supposed to be in the game in the first place
We were supposed instead to have a bigger guarma and free roam there freely without restrictions and ability to comeback
For some reason Guarmas role became much smaller and they added new austin last minute and only has half of a story mission taking place there
We were lucky it was there in the first place
I just wished guarma stayed like originally was.
Blackwater in rdr1 feels more open, and jeez I didn't realize how dark rdr2 was
I ain't gonna lie, I was trying to make RDR1 to look as good as I could. I used cheat code to set the game to sunny weather. I think the reason why RDR2 looks dark is because of the auto brightness adjustment. Whenever it's around 12:00 to 13:00, which should be the brightest period during a day, the game turns down the brightness automatically. I think the adjustment is too much
Rdr1 is kinda yellow and dry while rdr2 is really like life and green
I love how you made the horses same too
That's because in RDR1, it actually looked like a city.
In rdr2 blackwater it's still in development
Rdr2's graphics definitely fit the Eastern part of the map better, not that the west looks bad in rdr2, it just doesn't have the classic western feel.
Ikr
Rdr2 is to lifelike for a dessert
I assume you mean the southwest because the northwestern territories of Ambirno and north westelizbeth look really good.
Maybe it’s a different season idk
Agree
Red Dead is so good graphically. I remember being blown away as a kid playing RDR1 then I remember being blown away again as an adult with RDR2. Just great games
The first song is beautiful, Ashley Johnson's voice is awesome, great comparison too!
What is the song called? Cos I absolutely loved it
@@colderclock4480 True Faith-Ashley Johnson
@@mrtryhard9269 thank you
TLOU2 🤝 RDR2: Beautiful music
RDR1 has such a unique look
Ngl RDR2 looks too good, almost like real life. However RDR1 had that typical western filter on it. RDR2 is like the world the cowboys actually lived in, no film filters and such.
RDR2 is one of the most beautiful games in the world. However, I think RDR1 graphics style looks more like real life with lower quality, while RDR2 has a much higher graphics quality but with artified filter.
@@flamingmonkey7712 I agree.
Agree, rdr2 style is more like irl, at least Arthur's map part
@@flamingmonkey7712 I disagree. RDR1 looks brighter and less colorful than real life. RDR2 almost looks like real life, but more colorful and polished.
It sucks that you can’t play in New Austin as Arthur, let alone playing in New Austin as the real John Marston instead of the monstrosity that they make you play as.(Arthur Marston) Keep up the great work.
I mean you can go there and get the stuff you need along with being able to save your game with cheats.
There's a mod to make John like rdr1
@@Aureus_ yeah but consoles can’t have mods
@@360eradaryl7 I know
Another reason I refuse to update my game, still playing on the 1.00 version. That way I can go to New Austin with Arthur no problem 🤠
I suppose we now just need a mod that flips the rifle that's on his back
Yeah
That got made
@@Bithe_Get Yes
@@Jipjert hoooray!
there is a mod that does that, but it does that to Arthur too
This is bringing back all those good memories😆. Thankyou🙂
Thank you for your kind words!
RDR1, for me, looks more western than RDR2. I dont know, but RDR1 i feel the the hot weather in West Elizabeth, New Austin and Mexico, but in RDR2, i dont know, but i feel more cold and less hot in those places haha 😅.
The original map in RDR2 feels like a filming room with great set up background to me. The special graphical effects are too exaggerating, even though I have to admit it's beautiful. But for a western game, I like RDR1 style more
@@flamingmonkey7712 Exactly!!! That's i try to say haha 😁
Great video, keep up the great content mate!
I understand why some other comparison videos which might not be as accurate in the positions, views, weather and time. The recording process is a pain in the ass even that I used a trainer for RDR2 for time, weather changing and teleporting. Cuz you still need to move your camera and your character in similar speed as you can. Anyway thanks for the compliment : )
I really miss the bleached look New Austin had in RDR1
This was really well made. I was curious about these comparisons.
Thank you sir for using JMRP
are there any mods for rdr2 that puts that taco-holster on johns back. Btw nice vid
I don't think so, and since both games work differently, I doubt that the mod will work well even if there is one.
@@flamingmonkey7712 ok
There's one now
@@jakopay yup
We need a Red Dead Redemption remake
I think a port to pc is better than a remake. Firstly I fear that they will ruin John's og personality, secondly the gameplay in the first game is more smooth and the pace is not that slow, the shooting and cover system, the wanted system are better, and the atmosphere of the graphics is more natural. Even that RDR2 is still a better and improved game indeed, but I don't want them to change RDR1 into a simple RDR2 DLC because each of them has their own up and down sides.
@@flamingmonkey7712 I believe Rockstar are planning a remake depending on the success of the GTA remakes
@@joey2020 I'm sure the GTAs are remasters. A remake is a new game with an old title, it'll take years to develop. I hope so though
@@flamingmonkey7712 Yeah sorry I mean remaster
@@joey2020 Nothing to be sorry man, hope we get decent remasters
Oh yeah they made some new austin areas with that red sand and rock......i preffer the yellow from rdr1
I like the grayish look in rdr1
Woooow bro so much has changed since then look at the graphics but at that time even that graphic was everything for us the music Makes it even more great
Both graphics are amazing in their own time I think. And thank you for the nice words : )
dope video man, love the music as well
What is the first song tho its beautiful
that’s what i was waiting for to lol hopefully he tells us
@@aiarxa its called true faith by ashley johnson. Its actually from the game the last of us :)
I only realised yesterday after doing research since i sadly never played it before xD
Edit : typo
@@nlrenzo9432 thank you and yeah i knew her voice sound familiar lol just didn’t know which song
I like both of them a Lot everyone has their best graphics & mechanical
I recommend everyone to check strange man's channel because he just shows how much great this game is
@Redspire nah he's the guy that steals other people's discoveries
I think the epilogue still has 1899 new Austin
And here I thought they basically just copied the map over but there are actually some noticable differences
Can someone tell me, what is at the RDR1 map border where the RDR2 Border starts? So, up from Beechers Hope.
The border is along the Upper Montana River, so it starts on the shore of Flat Iron Lake and goes all the way to the Owanjila dam.
In RDR1 the rest of West Elizabeth after Beechers Hope and Black Water is completely empty with a few trees and just land far away. The land near the lake that divides the RDR1 map and RDR2 is identical in both games and even Owanjila is in RDR1 kind of. You have to play RDR1 to see
Did the JMRP get rid of authors hairstyles, because rdr1 john would look great with maybe length 6 aurthor hair or maybe length 5
But I really think somebody should just make a shortened version of Johns npc hair, because that would look excellent
Only a few that's been replaced, most of the hairs are still there
Music at 14:50
What's the name?
It's from rdr1 right?
Yes, I fotgot the name sorry. I got it from TH-cam by searching "RDR1 soundtrack" there's an album and you'll find it in there.
@@flamingmonkey7712 rdr1 is magical
I like the music so much
In rdr2 the only music i like is when i roam around Roanoke ridge and a harmonica plays
And also in rdr2 new Austin has some rdr1 sounds so good
The colors of the first one seem better somehow
I think RDR1 has a more realistic graphics style while RDR2 has that beautiful artified filtering graphics
@@flamingmonkey7712 maybe that's it. Or I just don't like that new Austin Looks red instead of bright yellow. It had more of a spaghetti western vibe before
@@MisteryDMOR33 I agree. Actually I like the old one better on this too
Nice video bro! Subbed!
thank you!
How come rdr2 doesn't have any big mods like GTA does, seems like rdr2 only has basic mods like model swapping, rescaling, texture swaps, and save editor options .?
Maybe the game is too complicated for the mod to work? Whenever I use a trainer I only use the basic functions because I don't want to have a crash and stuff. IDK man
No cause they haven't found a way to add stuff without replacing pretty sure.
Because Take Two dont like modders in RDR2.
gta v has been out longer and has a larger modding community
its just so pretty!
Thank you!
What’s the first song In This video? Sounds like Ellie from the last of us
Because it is😂
Song name is "True Faith"
Can anyone help me out,I have rdr and play on Xbox one and when I do dead eye I can't mark enemies with the x marks...
You need to proceed your game. Your dead eye level will get higher with the game's process.
Cool music.
I never played rdr1.But what happens if you head to the eastern part of the map where Saint Denis is located?I know the place is not in rdr1,but i guess in the first game there is some kind of boundary to limit the map,like you got in rdr2 for Mexico
The eastest part of the map is Blackwater. Other parts that are east to it didn't exist back then. It's all water and mountain models that you're not supposed to reach, exactly like the map boundaries in RDR2
@@flamingmonkey7712 So there are just mountains that block the parts of rdr2 map
@@theodorvalentinghita1779 And other models too. Was just using that point to let you understand how it is in the first game
@@flamingmonkey7712 Shame they didn't add Mexico in rdr2. But i can see why. The map is already too big and traveling by horse takes a lot of time
@@theodorvalentinghita1779 I think it's more of a shame that there's almost no content in New Austin. Would be great if they gave us a lot of stranger missions and side activities to do.
Where can I listen to this version of the first song on the video?
I found it on TH-cam. Just search "Truth Faith by Ashley Johnson" and you'll find it
@@flamingmonkey7712 thanks
What is the horse breed that you are using in the video and where did you get it? Missouri fox trotter blue and white in black water I think is the best and the gold Turkoman,white Arabian.
I have a white Arabian, but honestly don't use it much with either Arthur or John. I personally prefer big horses (not that biggest type like the one Bill rides on tho), and I think horses like white Arabians are too small and they feel like my character is riding on a pony, even tho they are fast. The one I use in the video is a black American standardbred. And by the way since I play the game in Chinese language, I'm not sure if I know many of their English names, sorry lol
Yeah me too honestly the big ones are usually better I love bill's horse it is so good it would be awesome if you could use or borrow camp members horses like npc John's horse and bill,s horse
The black American Standardbred is really cool and it is like solid black
@@samuraigames4125 Yeah man
Did anybody know the song name this video used?
Seeing Arthur in Beechers Hope looks sad. It seemed like it would of been a nice home for him.
Its John in Arthur's outfit after spoiler!
Arthur's death you be able to wear any of Arthur's standart outfits.
Which’s ur horse?
American's standarbred is what I used in this video for RDR2
@Flaming Monkey I know RDR2 has better graphics than RDR1 but I prefer gameplay elements from RDR1 ability to choose Normal+Hardcore also free roam ing both USA+Mexico while RDR2 only limited on USA only.
Yeah, and once I enter Mexico I really feel like I traveling in a foreign country. Even though I'm not American and English isn't my first language😂
Sounds like Ellie from TLOU.... Is it?
Yeah it’s her singing True Faith 😂
Wtf 😐 . ellie ?
Awesome video! What’s the first song that plays?
I wanna know as well. Sounds like Ashley Johnson.
Edit: Yup, found it. Just had to type in some of the lyrics. The title is True Faith. This version is a cover by Ashley Johnson. For the Last of Us I guess.
@@drutarthesavage5156 yea I found it right after commenting this lmao
You play rdr2 with mods?
Yes, with John's restoration mod and RDR1 face mod. And I play it with rampage trainer, which I only use for filming videos like this, or when I want to mess around, never for playthrough
Best way to play is with mods, vanilla game isnt bad, but mods make it better
0:32 RDR1 graphic looks better, LOL
It doesn't, LOL
@@Wikkid124it do
@@MSC-556 it dont
Are you blind?
you should check your eyes
Sure new austin was rushed and all but at least we have it
Howdy frendo
Howdy meeeaster
I thought this was rdr2 why are we hearing Ellie from the last of us 2
Why not lol
And Mexico...?
Ain’t in RDR2
I don't like it. There's too much civilization in the first RDR
I don't think you've actually played the game if this is how you think. The first game actually feels a lot more old western than the second one in graphics style, atmosphere, dialogues and story.
Tell me you haven’t played RDR without telling me you haven’t played RDR
@@edwardsmith9260 why is the map smaller where’s Nothern West Elizabeth
Rdr1 is more western than rdr2
@@Cheez_Doodlezz Because that part wasn't designed and didn't exist back then
RDR 2 graphics are freaking ridiculous. Its like comparing real life to a video game
I just started playing RDR2. Its the best game Ive ever played. It is insanely good. I will replay RDR1 afterwards for sure.