@@iroki3480 I also thought "why did I make a comment like this even though this is my first time seeing this vid???" Had to check my name if the names were the same and only the last name was different.
@@Br1dLt Yeah some Dives are really lying to themselves about that. Liz is a very talented and stable vocalist, but she is not perfect, which no singer is.
Leeseo really slayed, especially the bridge, she shined so much People calm down, she slayed, she has the courage to be an idol and slay her "job" so don't compare with other, she did well
actually when i listen their live vocals i was like 🤨 because their voices different from their studio self, and it was as if they were shouting and singing at karaoke rather than giving a performance
it's actually hard to sing lower note than high note when you are dancing. Moreover idols don't really get enough sleep during comeback that's why you need backtrack. Plus why do some of you so bitter when Ive sings live. is it that bad?
Lmfao. Are you serious? It's harder to sing high notes even while staying still how does it make it easier when moving around? Because When IVE sings live, it's terroble. Watch NMIXX and ITZY's live shows where there's little to no cracks in vocals.
@@GojokeSatoru they never said singing high notes gets easier it's just singing in lower notes are harder moving or not You can sing high notes if you try but for lower notes you need to have a lot of control and you need lots of practice if you don't have a naturally deep voice
Despite the fact that I wouldn’t say IVE’s best live singers as of right now, it’s impressive that they’re actually doing live since that’s pretty new for them. Also, this still hit the high note in the end, so I think that that’s a win
One thing a found out this days (because it came out a few days ago) is that IVE sang haft of their stages last year. But probably this time they are singing all of them, that's really new like you sad. The high notes are really good too, even though they did to do that everyday and sometimes even more then ones. It's good that even though this is pretty new for them they are doing their best. Hope they have a good promotion and get even better in the future. 😊 Ps: sorry for any error in my english
50% of ive's performances, they sang live, the problem is that the videos where they criticized them for not singing live went viral, that's ive's problem, the videos where they point out the "bad" things about them always go viral 😂
u crazy? I would agree if you said one of the best live singers. BUT the best?? if its 4th gen artists we all know its nmixx. ( No hate or favoritism in the groups mentioned)
It's not new for them. Haters just keep spreading so much hate, saying that they always lip sync, when they've been performing live most of the time. And then the Strawberry Moon incident, which they did lip sync blew up.
@@ken-kun9770 you misunderstood the comment, the punctuation is kind of confusing but they meant "i wouldnt say ive is the best live singer, it's impressive that...." so they werent saying that ive is the best
It would depend on the choreo Ives choreo seems to be one of the easier ones but a hard one would be like Antifragile but yes lots of movement is hard to sing but it depends on the idols stamina and choreo and overall ability
Lesseo vocals are really stable, especially in the bridge pard. And Yunjin's high note, they are amazing. I was tired of lip syncing. This was great 🎉💙
She DRASTICALLY IMPROVED to PROVED THOSE BASTARDS up that she is good at singing but I guess she still gets hate for singing LIVE😢 because what she does will never be enough for those MOTHERFUCKER.
She sing in live during pd48 but just unconfidence with her vocal since she didnt supported her notes Wonyoung is true ,she is careful with her voice dince this is damaged of singing with bad healthy technique Liz is only member support, the others sgould being carefully with their vocals techniques
Wonyoung’s low register parts are actually part of if not the hardest parts to sing, take for instance lesserafim’s fearless chorus part which is with a low register and how hard it was for them to sing it live Sooo y’all should add a bit of respect when talking about Wonyoung
Yeah it’s pretty hard to sing in a low tone especially while moving so yeah they need to put some respect while talking about Wonyoung, BUT I’d still say the high notes were def harder. They all did amazing 👏
@@itsaviasdepends, especially for females who tend to have a naturally higher pitched voice Liz and yUjin’a high note tends to be easier then wony’s low register notes.
Liz and Yujin have always had knock out live vocals thats no surprise. But, Wonyoung and Leesou have really improved. I'm totally pleasantly surprised by them. I really hope they keep utilizing Wonyoung's lower register. I still like her high pitched voice but I LOVE her low pitched one.
Wonyoung was singing insanely low note Even many singer who are well trained struggle to sing low notes, if u listen her singing the song on normal studio then she is mild, In this stage she was singing after dance Low notes + dance is insanely hard As a dancer and trained singing student myself ( for 9 years, maybe I'm more trained than wonyoung herself yet I find it hard when I sing low notes while dancing especially wonyoung voice is higher pitched ) If u think it's that easy them hear me out I was professionally trained by top singing schools from where many big singers came out Yet low notes right after dancing is hard especially if you have higher pitched voice!!
Honestly, I don't stan IVE that much but I really want to start to because they have an amazing discography and I absolutely loved their new comeback. I saw them get a lot of unreasonable hate but now I'm really happy to see them proving how talented they are
For the ppl wondering why they don't sing some parts, you need time to breathe so your voice doesn't lose stability, it's hard to control your abdomen and chest to sing while you are dancing but that doesn't make you bad at all, it's still a difficult skill that you have to learn, and I say this as someone that sings and dances for cover performances, it's hard.
I discovered this song recently becauce of the Street girl fighter when Team Hook dance to this, I didn't know the message of this back then but I feel emotional right away and so happy that it says "be a writer, genre is a fantasy" , cause I'm a writer for a living, my heart is so happy
@@reddesktop3533 doesn’t matter. They sing it well enough while dancing. They’re idols not vocal coaches. It’s okay to call out idols when it’s really not good but we can see that there’s not only improvement but they are actually pretty stable
What I always hear is that Gaeul and Wonyoung are usually silent during some low or high register but sound very clear during their comfortable range. Leeseo is very comfortable and confident with her notes so she always slays it out. Yujin is strong, confident, and comfortable as usual. Liz is very stable and proper; she makes sure every note is put in places instead of just ‘reachable’.
Atleast ive are singing live and not lip syncing. The unstable vocals could be because of the choreography. As someone who's done it before, it's really hard to sing and dance at the same time
![[SUB] IVE's LIZ Shows Off Her Strong Vocal Skills🌸 #IVE #LIZ](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/qgYeGT9t96U/mqdefault.jpg)
![[SUB] IVE's LIZ Shows Off Her Strong Vocal Skills🌸 #IVE #LIZ](/img/tr.png)
![[MPD직캠] 베이비몬스터 직캠 8K 'FOREVER' (BABYMONSTER FanCam) | @MCOUNTDOWN_2024.7.11](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/ylRx8QOuGXo/mqdefault.jpg)
![fellow fellow - Proud [OFFICIAL MV]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/9uZF7BlUQPE/mqdefault.jpg)
Yujin and Liz ate up this era.
Umm........👀
@@sashabrauss1712 wtf I didn't know that y'all were different ppl until I read ur surname 💀💀
@@iroki3480 I also thought "why did I make a comment like this even though this is my first time seeing this vid???" Had to check my name if the names were the same and only the last name was different.
@@sashabrauss1712Lmao- 💀✋
Yujin be slaying every era
Liz vocals sound so good that u can't even guess if its Studio or Live lol.
Edit- I wrote this as a compliment not hate leave me alone.
I realized her because her voice cracked
Her vocals are good but be so serious rn…you can literally hear the difference 😭
@@Br1dLt Yeah some Dives are really lying to themselves about that. Liz is a very talented and stable vocalist, but she is not perfect, which no singer is.
@@Br1dLt
Ofc but still you know it’s really good I’m sure they were just saying that as an exaggeration to compliment them!
@@BuyJiafeiyassifiedpr0ducts exactly, like the live version is never gonna sound like the studio version
so proud of the girls.... they got called out and they answered back... so much respect.
what's the call out ?
@@evnalsaphir4198oh.... well they said the girls could not perform live and sing well live. 🤷 I think they did a great job.
@@stevensong8618 I agree, especially that it's must be so hard to do their choreo while singing 🥵
@@evnalsaphir4198 exactly....
I mean all the girls are working really hard. Definitely proud of all of them.
Thats why I stan IVE, so proud of them. They always get hate but they will always show us that they are talented. They always show, not tell
yujin slayed that high note so much
bro 5.5k likes
yall in the comments stop fighting plzzzzzzzz just plz don't
When you have low standards
@@fromis.9 when you're a obsessed jealous ass bit$h
@@fromis.9when your on the wrong channel
@@fromis.9 that's why u short
@@kitsuen.m doesn't make sense
Leeseo really slayed, especially the bridge, she shined so much
People calm down, she slayed, she has the courage to be an idol and slay her "job" so don't compare with other, she did well
not really. she just keep clinging to wony bcs of wony popularity
@@wony278shut up! She is literally young. You cannot expect her to be alone all the time. And why can't she cling on to her unnies?
@@wony278 solo stan
@@wony278 y'all wonyoung stans are getting annoying lol, not everything is about her 😂
actually when i listen their live vocals i was like 🤨 because their voices different from their studio self, and it was as if they were shouting and singing at karaoke rather than giving a performance
it's actually hard to sing lower note than high note when you are dancing. Moreover idols don't really get enough sleep during comeback that's why you need backtrack. Plus why do some of you so bitter when Ive sings live. is it that bad?
dont they film music shows like in the AM?
Well cause 99% kpop groups don’t sing live for nothing so when a group finally sings live they have to praise them for it
IVE got backlash for ‘Lip syncing’ so their response is to prove haters that they can sing live 😊
Lmfao. Are you serious? It's harder to sing high notes even while staying still how does it make it easier when moving around? Because When IVE sings live, it's terroble. Watch NMIXX and ITZY's live shows where there's little to no cracks in vocals.
@@GojokeSatoru they never said singing high notes gets easier it's just singing in lower notes are harder moving or not
You can sing high notes if you try but for lower notes you need to have a lot of control and you need lots of practice if you don't have a naturally deep voice
Liz and Yujin's Vocal are not joke
fr they're stable and angelic and strong all at once, they slayed so good
Leeseo and Gaeul definitely the most surprising here... But all of them deserved all the praise and support in this world ❤❤❤
How is gaeul the most surprising
Her and Liz were the only two to actually sing live
Probably bc they don’t have much lines
@@Marvelnoob154 Wonyoung definetly sounded live to me.
@@Liz-abeth before iam
@@Marvelnoob154 You think she hasn't sung live before I Am? If so you are terribly mistaken.
@@Liz-abeth no she’s not sang live much maybe a few times but most of the time she’s not it’s just gaeul and Liz who does
Yujin litterally said:
1,2,3 1,2,3 1,2,3 FLY UUUUUUP
Such a queen
Help my phone automatically translates comments and it translated Yujin to ‘Eugene’ 😂
@@CreamieBunnies my phone always does it 😂
@@CreamieBunnies what’s the difference it sounds the same ?
Sis slayed
@@CreamieBunniesmine too 😆
Despite the fact that I wouldn’t say IVE’s best live singers as of right now, it’s impressive that they’re actually doing live since that’s pretty new for them. Also, this still hit the high note in the end, so I think that that’s a win
One thing a found out this days (because it came out a few days ago) is that IVE sang haft of their stages last year. But probably this time they are singing all of them, that's really new like you sad. The high notes are really good too, even though they did to do that everyday and sometimes even more then ones. It's good that even though this is pretty new for them they are doing their best. Hope they have a good promotion and get even better in the future. 😊
Ps: sorry for any error in my english
50% of ive's performances, they sang live, the problem is that the videos where they criticized them for not singing live went viral, that's ive's problem, the videos where they point out the "bad" things about them always go viral 😂
u crazy? I would agree if you said one of the best live singers. BUT the best?? if its 4th gen artists we all know its nmixx. ( No hate or favoritism in the groups mentioned)
It's not new for them. Haters just keep spreading so much hate, saying that they always lip sync, when they've been performing live most of the time. And then the Strawberry Moon incident, which they did lip sync blew up.
@@ken-kun9770 you misunderstood the comment, the punctuation is kind of confusing but they meant "i wouldnt say ive is the best live singer, it's impressive that...." so they werent saying that ive is the best
Leeseo's vocals is improving a lot! it sounds a lot like the studio version,Her vocals are so underrated
Leesoo's live vocals are impressive at her young age
Yujin is really very talented in singing . But I think it is hard to sing while dancing. What do you think ?
Yeah
It would depend on the choreo Ives choreo seems to be one of the easier ones but a hard one would be like Antifragile but yes lots of movement is hard to sing but it depends on the idols stamina and choreo and overall ability
Usually it is yeah, depends on the intensity of the choreo, their voices are gonna sound shaky
that's why i don't understand haters complaining about lip sync ... They want to hear singers panting on the mic while dancing or something ?
And the fact that this song is also hard to sing due to high notes,,, I don't think those haters can't do the same thing like them girlies❤😂
I am impressed with Wony . She really improved alot
Yes she did :)
Yasss
Queen
@@anacristof1118 she is shining
@@lolipopberryy she is perfect !!!
leeseo’s key change was 🤌
Yujin’s highly notes gives me goosebumps
Leeseo’s vocals are so good!!
I liked it when leeseo changed the "oh my god" part tone
they really prove their vocals here, I'm so amazed😭❤️
Liz is so amazing and Leeseo has improved so muchhhhh
How can every girl in this group be so beautiful? Good Lord!
Leeseo is the most obvious singing live.
Lesseo vocals are really stable, especially in the bridge pard. And Yunjin's high note, they are amazing. I was tired of lip syncing. This was great 🎉💙
lets talk about wonyoung???
She DRASTICALLY IMPROVED to PROVED THOSE BASTARDS up that she is good at singing but I guess she still gets hate for singing LIVE😢 because what she does will never be enough for those MOTHERFUCKER.
Yeah she is so talented I love her😊❤😊❤😊❤
She improved a lot💜
first time she’s ever sang live in her life
@@EzraHawkThat’s really exaggerated.
That high note at last ♥
Im happy wonyoung is finally singing live she has amazing vocals its just those toxic fans who are bringing her down, and they all did amazing
She sing in live during pd48 but just unconfidence with her vocal since she didnt supported her notes
Wonyoung is true ,she is careful with her voice dince this is damaged of singing with bad healthy technique
Liz is only member support, the others sgould being carefully with their vocals techniques
@@lavienrosewon8811 i think during iz*one days wonyoungs voice got damage or something. She probably never had good vocal training
yeah she is the best vocalist, she live so good
Ive proving haters wrong for lip sync criticism . They are really good singers ❤❤
lmfao they really were lip syncing before 😭 idk what made them change up but i’m not complaining
@@johnavanuchiha7898 exactly 😂
After so many accusation they did live lol 😂
@@avaca3353 No, they’ve always been singing live in festivals and concerts
@@venus7499 in your dream that was lip syncing
@@venus7499 in your dreams actually they did sing live
Leeseo is so stable
That a good thing or a bad thing? 💀
@@avadea2023 good
and other not
@@universe_08 I’m thinking she’s just saying that Leeseo is stable and they are surprised about it
@@lanaingaround does she not stable before
Wonyoung’s low register parts are actually part of if not the hardest parts to sing, take for instance lesserafim’s fearless chorus part which is with a low register and how hard it was for them to sing it live
Sooo y’all should add a bit of respect when talking about Wonyoung
exactly. Anyway she doesn't need validation from haters who hate her just because she is popular and pretty.
FORREAL it's even easier for me to hit liz's pre chorus highnote than wonyoung low register 😭
Hard but not hardest as Yujin and Liz's Belting was definitely hardest
Yeah it’s pretty hard to sing in a low tone especially while moving so yeah they need to put some respect while talking about Wonyoung, BUT I’d still say the high notes were def harder. They all did amazing 👏
@@itsaviasdepends, especially for females who tend to have a naturally higher pitched voice Liz and yUjin’a high note tends to be easier then wony’s low register notes.
I must say wonyoung has great vocals damn she just slayed
Yes
Well you can't spell LIVE without IVE 🤷♂️
This one's good 👍🏻
REAL
THIS ONE IS HEAVENLY
You can't spell skydive without IVE either.
Girlys can do anything!
@@coollittlebinch4689i swear i saw these same comments on another video, hmmm 🤔
Leeseo literally singing ✨live✨
So proud of leeseo!❤
They sing better than lesserafim fact
Liz and Yujin have always had knock out live vocals thats no surprise. But, Wonyoung and Leesou have really improved. I'm totally pleasantly surprised by them. I really hope they keep utilizing Wonyoung's lower register. I still like her high pitched voice but I LOVE her low pitched one.
I really love Wony's voice and her low voice at the begging it's so good
My baby leeseo so goodaaa even all pf them love it!!!
An Yujin my girl!!! also Leeseo is doing so so well... all of them are doing so well... so proud of you Ive
Leeseo has such a unique voice...❤❤❤
I'm not their fan but i'm really impress for their vocal for this comeback. They are also human no need to be perfect.
Leeseo is such an underrated maknae ppl need to show her more support honestly. She sang Rei’s lines perfectly show her some love plssss 🗣️🗣️
I notice most of 4gen youngest being ignored, even though they're talent. I think it depends on they're too young.
Liz and Yujin are doing very well but since the beginning Leeseo is also doing great. I love how each of them are doing in this comeback.
Ohw Leeseo 😳👏🏽 good Job my girl !!
Why Is no one praising wonyoung now when she is singing live she also did a great job and slapped the haters all girls slayed❤️🔥
leeseo is getting better day by day omg
leeseo needs more recognition of her vocals
It's called I am for a reason ofc yujin slayed sm
i might stan ive like their vocals are so good
Leeso is so cute pls I’m giggling her voice is so strong but so cute? Lol I love her wony ate yunji ate Liz ate
Idk why y’all think wonyoung’s vocal is bad, it’s not like crazy or anything but it’s balanced and pretty. Why does she get so much hate?
Wonyoung was singing insanely low note
Even many singer who are well trained struggle to sing low notes, if u listen her singing the song on normal studio then she is mild, In this stage she was singing after dance
Low notes + dance is insanely hard
As a dancer and trained singing student myself ( for 9 years, maybe I'm more trained than wonyoung herself yet I find it hard when I sing low notes while dancing especially wonyoung voice is higher pitched )
If u think it's that easy them hear me out
I was professionally trained by top singing schools from where many big singers came out
Yet low notes right after dancing is hard especially if you have higher pitched voice!!
This comeback is a slap to all the haters
Not me imagining the meme in my head when the “big big stage” part came 💀
yujin slayed the high notes fr
I'm glad Ive are singing live especially wonyoung BC of all the hate. They sing live well idk why starship does this to their idols
IVE have always sing live, there's only a few times they've lip synced
they sing live all the time just one performance were they didn't got viral thanks to kbs
Tbh I started to RELUCTANTLY doubt Wony's skills (hate me if you want 🙇🏼♀️) but my faith regained.
Liz and yujin killed it😭😭❤❤❤❤
IVE live vocal is the BEST❤😭
Honestly, I don't stan IVE that much but I really want to start to because they have an amazing discography and I absolutely loved their new comeback. I saw them get a lot of unreasonable hate but now I'm really happy to see them proving how talented they are
For the ppl wondering why they don't sing some parts, you need time to breathe so your voice doesn't lose stability, it's hard to control your abdomen and chest to sing while you are dancing but that doesn't make you bad at all, it's still a difficult skill that you have to learn, and I say this as someone that sings and dances for cover performances, it's hard.
To be honest... I'm surprised with Leeseo's stable and clean vocals... Maknae on top❤❤❤❤❤😮😮😮😮🎉
Their live singing is so damn good✨
Yunjin and leeseo are on fire
"SO THAT IS WHO I AM!" in love with this part 💗
Yujin so pretty pretty pretty❤
its so hard to dance and singing but staying in a perfect level especially their dancing is so UGHHHHH but still we're proud of iVE
This is the type of videos which should go viral
YUJIN ATE UP AND LEFT NO CRUMBS❤
I discovered this song recently becauce of the Street girl fighter when Team Hook dance to this, I didn't know the message of this back then but I feel emotional right away and so happy that it says "be a writer, genre is a fantasy" , cause I'm a writer for a living, my heart is so happy
Yujin and Liz are so good
Yujin's voice is so stable...bless her god
Yujin’s part got me 😮😮😮😮
Amazing song the vocals from soyeon, liz and ive are no joke what a mashup of talent 😊
I love this performance in all others coz this one was very powerful and the fact that it was live....😭
Netizen: this song has many high notes. can IVE peform it
IVE:
only liz can perform high notes well. rest of yujin parts are flat and strain lol
@@reddesktop3533 fr but at least she's trying
@@reddesktop3533 okay and they still sound good💀
@@reddesktop3533sound better than you probably💀
@@reddesktop3533 doesn’t matter. They sing it well enough while dancing. They’re idols not vocal coaches. It’s okay to call out idols when it’s really not good but we can see that there’s not only improvement but they are actually pretty stable
Wonyoung charisma and aura really suit all concepts. I just can not :'')
나는 Zhang Yuanying을 매우 좋아하고 그녀는 나를 깊이 매료시킵니다! ! ! ♥️번역기를 사용하고 있습니다
can we just stop and appreciate HOW GOOD AND AMAZING leeseos vocals are🤩🤩
I think Ive has really improved and have been amazing lately
It’s the only time when the mic is actually louder than the backing track! ❤
Yujin sounds so mad while doing the chorus lol 😂
The high note was omg! Congrats to IVE they did amazing 👏
What I always hear is that Gaeul and Wonyoung are usually silent during some low or high register but sound very clear during their comfortable range.
Leeseo is very comfortable and confident with her notes so she always slays it out.
Yujin is strong, confident, and comfortable as usual.
Liz is very stable and proper; she makes sure every note is put in places instead of just ‘reachable’.
The chorus part is real, we can hear lesseo's vocals, she proved it❤❤
I cried at Yujin’s high note!!😭 She is so amazinggg
I Am is IVE's best title track of all time. I already memorized the lyrics and sing it by heart
They actually said "IAM singing lIVE
Atleast ive are singing live and not lip syncing. The unstable vocals could be because of the choreography. As someone who's done it before, it's really hard to sing and dance at the same time
Where are those wonyoung haters now
The plane sound lmao😂
Don’t wanna hear people saying IVE ALWAYS lip syncs after this.
Yujin slay!!
I screamed at midnight hearing the last girl's high not! Ateee!
Yujin is FR a vocal queen
They never fail to disappoint or deliver with their vocals
Why did yujins high note sound better here than the encore 😭
They slapped the haters hard with a Asian mom spatula right in the face😂😂
Yujin slayyed the "FIRE" part
um it's "fly up"
Yujin's highnote just💅🪄
Yujin just slayed😮😮
I'm glad that they're standing up and clearing their name, other group should take notes
SLAYYY I
VEEE
YUJIN'S 123 123 OMG
Leeseo really stepped it up after the strawberry moon hate😭