Why put down a functional weapon to grab a different one off the ground? Especially one that is not nearly as effective as the one he's currently holding? That isn't efficient in any capacity.
"Ah yes, I have a big ass bone shattering colossus of a sword here, but there's a spear over here on the ground that's been there for god knows how long so... Eh, guess I won't be needing this here" *highsenders his sword away and picks up spear*
15:17 No mercy is kinda ironic for me, because if you got your arm cut off in the middle of a battlefield you'd probably bleed out before you could get help, so it would probably be a painful last few minutes but highlander quickly kills warden after cutting his arm of kinda like a mercy kill.
Great video Raven, as usual! The only thing I would say is that Scottish two-handed swords, (there's actually a lot of debate around the accuracy of the term 'claymore',) are not especially heavy swords, and in terms of size, they are typically somewhere between your average longsword and greatsword, probably somewhere in the much disputed 'warsword' catagory. Other than that, though, it was an excellent analysis!
I LITERALLY JUST LOOKED THIS UP AND FOUND THAT ITS PREMIERING LETS GOOOO. Also love your harsher criticisms rather than playing it safe to appease people ❤
8:52 for this execution, i always thought he was grabbing hold of the warden so he could jerk the sword upward, breaking the spine. for that reason i find it so much cooler, even though the spine break isnt really necessary. its just so HIGHLANDER, and BRUTAL, just goin the extra step because its fuckin awesome
Based on your description, I don't understand what you meant that this video would be controversial. I think you gave a fair score and a lot of the executions you didn't like I agreed with, there's a few score I wouldn't be so lenient on personally but I genuinely agree with Highlander's scores. I thought you implied he was gonna get a very low score and everyone was gonna dislike that fact. I'm genuinely surprised how high he got. Also, if your a bit tired of these videos Raven, I wouldn't mind you throwing in the Deadliest Warrior Idea anytime soon to mix your For Honor Content up. For those curious of the rankings, here's the current list from Warden to Highlander 1st - Hitokiri 2nd - Highlander 3rd - Lawbringer, Valkyrie 4th - Nuxia, Jiang Jun 5th - Warden, Peacekeeper, Tiandi 6th - Black Prior 7th - Centurion, Warmonger, Kensei 8th - Warlord 9th - Berserker 10th - Conqueror 11th - Gladiator 12th - Raider, Shaman, Shugoki 13th - Orochi 14th - Shinobi 15th - Jormungandr
Like you did for Nobushi, it might've been worth translating a few of Highlanders quotes. For example he sometimes says (in Gaelic ofc) "Chicken on a skewer!" During the deep cut execution.
This is another example of a character that I thought was Heavy class, not Hybrid class. But still, yet another great video from you, Raven! Keep up the great work!
I mean…to be fair, Highlander’s Claymore is a pretty heavy sword so I would think him taking so long to take the sword out or put his sword down in some of his executions would make sense. Still though, expected a bit higher though for his score.
Makes you wonder huh? Why they didn't use a Molotov exe when those 4th feat exe came out. Part of me thinks because they were lazy and didn't want to animate a person on fire or something...
Raven knight when highlander hits a dude in the head with the hilt of his sword: "Yeah, lethality 4/4" Raven knight when a dude with a giant hammer hits a dude right in the skull: "hmm, i give it a 3 because he could survive" No hate, love yoir videos, cant wait for nobushi 😊
in hilt it up, he plunges the blade with a horizontal swing, but when he drives it deeper the blade magically becomes horizontal so that the crossguard can be driven into the dude's face. Not sure it's super realistic. It is a very entertaining video to watch tho :)
For high sender it's a reference to the highland games and specifikly the logthrow. I agree with you that this level of accuratie is not gona happen for most people, but a log throwers can defenitly get rather accurate with there throws and a greatsword is still lighter then a log sow he might be able to pull it of, but I agree with you it's very unlikely. For hole lander I have to disagree with your realisme score for one simple reason, there is no doubt about it he can't break that shaft that way. People have tested this your not gona break a spearshaft over your knee, you can't even chop true in one single-handed swing from a sword let alone with your forarm. Highlander is a big guy, but still it's not gona happen. Apart from those points I agree with everything.
@@RavenKnightYT still a pretty good score none the less. Although technically he would be 7 points below her as looking back at the hitokiri video she's actually an 88% persent which is a very dominant spot for her.
So here’s the biggest issue I have with this ranking; the sword wouldn’t go through the armor the way it does, so realism for most of them should be low/zero
So here's the biggest issue I have with this comment; it proves that you didn't watch my grading rubric video where I made it clear I don't take the victims armor into account because we cannot control who the victim will be on the battlefield. Just because it's Warden here doesn't mean it won't be shaman or shinobi elsewhere. As a result, I do not take armor into consideration so that it remains fair. This comment should be a low/zero.
I most definitely believe that highlanders kicks would be able to kill alone with those massive thighs, he could probably decapitate with the amount of power those things generate and should have conquerers head kick execution
My thoughts exactly. He kept say monumental and other such adjectives, but most real life great swords were 5lbs topping out at 10. The in game monstrosity on the other hand. Wardens sword probably classifies as a great sword by weight though.
@@jjkrayenhagen I figured the weight was around 7 or so, guess I was right. Real life claymore use is actually quite stylish, it's smooth and flows really well. Highlander just swings a 40 pound piece of steel at his foes with little skill, he's very barbaric.
@@I_Love_Warden Really the vikings in general and to a smaller extent the knights are no where near as skilled as their real life counterparts. Ubi seems to just abhor thrusting and avoid it as much as possible.
@@jjkrayenhagen The only characters with skill is probably some of the Wu Lin and Samurai, maybe Lawbringer. That's about it. Everyone else just swings like an absolute barbarian. Ex. Highlander, Shugoki, Warlord, Raider, Jorm, Gryphon, Conquer, ect.
When looking at it from the perspective of a battlefield I can understand “you never let go of your weapon”, but from the perspective of a duel - just a straight up duel, like let’s say it’s a setup Judicial 1v1 or something along those lines - would the situation or rating differ? Like, if the warrior is doing a power play for example? 👀
Claymores aren't as heavy as you think, on average they're only about 5 and a half pounds, though the sword that Highlander has is much larger than a regular claymore so 🤷♂
Despite being a Vlandian main, I got to give respect to the Battanian with the 'big fuck off sword'. I always appreciate some brutality in execution animations.
I have one question about your grading for the Efficiency category. While I agree that letting go of your weapon should always be a low score, how does it not automatically guarantee you will get a ZERO in that category? Does it have to do with how quickly he/she picks up their weapon again, or are there other factors that determine this?
16:32 Ok ive got a dumb question. During executions where they grab the sword by the blade and hit their opponent with the handle, arent they at risk of cutting themselves with the blade? Or is there some sorta technique to prevent that. Ive seen Highlander do it, Warden to it, etc. Idk it just gives me fucking anxiety. I know their hands are fine cuz its a game but still.
It's called halfswording, and it was pretty common in it's time, to the point of, IIRC, being a very basic technique. I agree though, I had the same thought before I learned that.
Hey raven I saw your kotor gameplay that is my first and favorite game of all time I love Star Wars and lol I will be mentioning it once this video is live 🤣
My main problem with his executions is that he always grabs the end of the blade. Im not super familiar with claymores, but i do know that most European greatswords are only dull enough to grab at the bottom.
A few examples of good moments would be if your current weapon is damaged and you could still use it as a projectile while grabbing a secondary. Or perhaps if your opponent is attempting to gain distance from you and you have a throwable spear or item that you know can incapacitate.
@@RavenKnightYT okay I was just curious is all. I mean spears are meant for throwing and you would disarm yourself but skirmishers usually have a small bundle of them like Javaliners.
Uh, when you talk about his feat where it rains "stakes" on a targeted location, don't you mean "thrown spears" instead of "stakes"? Because those are spears being thrown in the feat. And also, it's a spear that gets used in the execution as well.
Already know he's going to give highlander's base decapitation, and deep cut executions 100% he spends every video reminding us how difficult a decaptitation actually is to pull off, well my boy highlander literally wields a two handed greatsword that can decapitate three men in one swing, (they did it on proxy dummies in deadliest warrior)
I myself own a great sword they are fucking monsters mine sighs in at around 15 pounds. So highlanders carrying around a sword that weighs around just as much as the average sledgehammer. So him taking a bit to actually pull it out makes complete sense.
Here is how I would rate "Spin the Bottle" Lethality: S for Stupid Realism: S for Stupid Efficiency: S for Stupid Cool Factor: S for Stupid Overall Rating: It may be Stupid but its also Dumb
Let’s go when I first start playing I ground out enough steel to purchase Highlander and played them for 18 reps straight. I can’t wait to see what score he gets for his executions #FemaleHighlanderSkin.
@@RavenKnightYTYou're right, i wasn't aware. After getting familiar with all of these i'm surprised i commented this. My bad. Altough i wanted to say, i don't think his throwing execution should be a 1 in realism based on the odds. This could happen, if the throw was accurate and landed then the manner in which warden died wasn't unrealistic. Just very unlikely. That's why i believe that should have a 0 in efficiency because of the odds not realism. You say it yourself "you could do this" and i thought that was what realism was all about
I did not say they were. The average great sword weighed around 10 to 15 pounds depending on the make and steel. Granted it’s not very heavy in terms of pounds, but the size and length of the weapon means the weapon is more cumbersome, and harder to maneuver properly.
I will never understand the concept of grabbing your own blade?? Seems really dumb, I understand the strength of highlander and hes prob a tough fellow who can handle holding a sword but that sword is definitely sharp and heavy, just hold the handle? Too much could go wrong by turning the blade on urself (im talking realism here not im game persay”
The default beheading animation is by far the best: smooth, quick, big swing, beheading... simply perfect.
7:45
"Efficiency 1, he put his sword down"
My brother in Scotland, he picked up another weapon, he is still armed
not to mention its still very much in reach and can be grabbed in a second if needed
Why put down a functional weapon to grab a different one off the ground? Especially one that is not nearly as effective as the one he's currently holding? That isn't efficient in any capacity.
@@RavenKnightYT I can't think of a valid counterargument to that, ergo, 👺
"Ah yes, I have a big ass bone shattering colossus of a sword here, but there's a spear over here on the ground that's been there for god knows how long so... Eh, guess I won't be needing this here" *highsenders his sword away and picks up spear*
@@RavenKnightYT a spear is at worst a sidegrade to something as big and cumbersome as highlander's sword
Heave Ho has got to be one of my favorites simply because there’s a kill just like this in Berserk
With the rock pastor guy right?
@@psychoseth1643 Yes, Father Mozgus!
I love being a sudo highlander main, the most technical character with the meatiest executions, perfection
Highlander is one of my most favorite heros, thank you for covering him!
15:17
No mercy is kinda ironic for me, because if you got your arm cut off in the middle of a battlefield you'd probably bleed out before you could get help, so it would probably be a painful last few minutes but highlander quickly kills warden after cutting his arm of kinda like a mercy kill.
So, I would like to say that it doesnt matter if he puts doen his weapons.He is a menace, he will break you in half with those muscles
I figured his lethality scores were gonna be high, but damn. This Scotsman is legit, %100 Lethal!
Great video Raven, as usual! The only thing I would say is that Scottish two-handed swords, (there's actually a lot of debate around the accuracy of the term 'claymore',) are not especially heavy swords, and in terms of size, they are typically somewhere between your average longsword and greatsword, probably somewhere in the much disputed 'warsword' catagory. Other than that, though, it was an excellent analysis!
Raven addresses this in his Highlander Heroes in History video. Don’t know if you’ve seen it or not, but I would recommend it.
As a Scot and a highlander this has definitely put a smile to my face I did he was gonna get a little lower but I'm satisfied with his score
I love when Highlander uses murder strike hood the sword backwards
I will never be able to stop calling Highlander, Homelander.
Make him White, Yellow and Blue and you got a nice Homerlander
It’s Hihglander to me
I never notice homer was also called homerlander
Sausage
I wish there was one where Highlander just cleaves his enemy in half
Like that forged in fire episode where the claymore cuts the pig carcass right in half. Absolutely insane
Finally we're at the highlanders executions arguably the most gory executions in the game❤
I LITERALLY JUST LOOKED THIS UP AND FOUND THAT ITS PREMIERING LETS GOOOO. Also love your harsher criticisms rather than playing it safe to appease people ❤
Highlander; The king of giggidy, the Gaelic brute, The great disarmer and one of the best hybrids and in my opinion the best of the Vikings so far
8:52 for this execution, i always thought he was grabbing hold of the warden so he could jerk the sword upward, breaking the spine. for that reason i find it so much cooler, even though the spine break isnt really necessary. its just so HIGHLANDER, and BRUTAL, just goin the extra step because its fuckin awesome
10:07 Raven Knight had some PTSD from the first time he ranked this.
Based on your description, I don't understand what you meant that this video would be controversial. I think you gave a fair score and a lot of the executions you didn't like I agreed with, there's a few score I wouldn't be so lenient on personally but I genuinely agree with Highlander's scores. I thought you implied he was gonna get a very low score and everyone was gonna dislike that fact. I'm genuinely surprised how high he got. Also, if your a bit tired of these videos Raven, I wouldn't mind you throwing in the Deadliest Warrior Idea anytime soon to mix your For Honor Content up.
For those curious of the rankings, here's the current list from Warden to Highlander
1st - Hitokiri
2nd - Highlander
3rd - Lawbringer, Valkyrie
4th - Nuxia, Jiang Jun
5th - Warden, Peacekeeper, Tiandi
6th - Black Prior
7th - Centurion, Warmonger, Kensei
8th - Warlord
9th - Berserker
10th - Conqueror
11th - Gladiator
12th - Raider, Shaman, Shugoki
13th - Orochi
14th - Shinobi
15th - Jormungandr
You do great vids, dont let folks and their buthurt get you down.
Like you did for Nobushi, it might've been worth translating a few of Highlanders quotes. For example he sometimes says (in Gaelic ofc) "Chicken on a skewer!" During the deep cut execution.
Nobody is talking about the giggity. That caught me off guard and made me choke on my drink😭
Time?😭
@Davina Robertson at 5:02. But he does it a few more times and in other videos too
High Sender is one of my favorites, if not the favorite, execution in the game. With 360 take down and Pathetic as close seconds.
Highlander seems to have an unhealthy obsession with Mordhau considering his bare hands
This is another example of a character that I thought was Heavy class, not Hybrid class. But still, yet another great video from you, Raven! Keep up the great work!
Cool thing about Deep Cut that I didn't know, if you kill from behind the target then the execution will be different which is an amazing detail.
I mean…to be fair, Highlander’s Claymore is a pretty heavy sword so I would think him taking so long to take the sword out or put his sword down in some of his executions would make sense. Still though, expected a bit higher though for his score.
Combine Highlander with Gryphon and you have Guts from Berserk. I love the Highlander!
As a Highlander main myself, I say that Hole Lander SHOULD'VE been the spear call down execution but have it be for Highlander only tbh.
Makes you wonder huh? Why they didn't use a Molotov exe when those 4th feat exe came out. Part of me thinks because they were lazy and didn't want to animate a person on fire or something...
@@psychoseth1643 I mean they did that with the Aramusha execution where they lit someone on fire with the oil pot and a match.
@@The-Black-Death yeah, but it was done in a very weeb fashion=lame.
@@psychoseth1643 ye
Raven knight when highlander hits a dude in the head with the hilt of his sword: "Yeah, lethality 4/4"
Raven knight when a dude with a giant hammer hits a dude right in the skull: "hmm, i give it a 3 because he could survive"
No hate, love yoir videos, cant wait for nobushi 😊
1:38
"Infact there were tests that were done to see if a sword that big could take off the head"
I'd fuckin' hate to be the test subject. Goddamn
in hilt it up, he plunges the blade with a horizontal swing, but when he drives it deeper the blade magically becomes horizontal so that the crossguard can be driven into the dude's face. Not sure it's super realistic. It is a very entertaining video to watch tho :)
I'd honestly give that fourth execution a 1.5 (in realism) on the grounds that the claymore didn't go that high before descending.
Love the vid js surprised he never talks abt how Highlander swings the sword by the blade
For high sender it's a reference to the highland games and specifikly the logthrow. I agree with you that this level of accuratie is not gona happen for most people, but a log throwers can defenitly get rather accurate with there throws and a greatsword is still lighter then a log sow he might be able to pull it of, but I agree with you it's very unlikely. For hole lander I have to disagree with your realisme score for one simple reason, there is no doubt about it he can't break that shaft that way. People have tested this your not gona break a spearshaft over your knee, you can't even chop true in one single-handed swing from a sword let alone with your forarm. Highlander is a big guy, but still it's not gona happen. Apart from those points I agree with everything.
I imagine that a lot of his efficiency and realism ratings will be pretty low, but he will be taking no hits to lethality or cool factor.
Intend to behead is probably my favorite
Actually you are right they are very heavy being 5 lbs which realistically is actually very heavy especially for such a large sword
An 81%? Y'know what- I'll take it! I expected that score to look like sunbaked shyte with the efficiency and realism scores, but I guess not!
One of my favorite heroes!🎉🎉
Is half swording a claymore realistic? It just seems too heavy to effectively grip by the blade and swing around, especially bare handed
Highlander is now tied woth Hitokiri
Actually he’s just one point below her. Hitokiri was 82%
@@RavenKnightYT still a pretty good score none the less. Although technically he would be 7 points below her as looking back at the hitokiri video she's actually an 88% persent which is a very dominant spot for her.
So here’s the biggest issue I have with this ranking; the sword wouldn’t go through the armor the way it does, so realism for most of them should be low/zero
So here's the biggest issue I have with this comment; it proves that you didn't watch my grading rubric video where I made it clear I don't take the victims armor into account because we cannot control who the victim will be on the battlefield. Just because it's Warden here doesn't mean it won't be shaman or shinobi elsewhere. As a result, I do not take armor into consideration so that it remains fair. This comment should be a low/zero.
Your first mistake was assuming the sword was his weapon. HAVE YOU SEEN THOSE GUNS. Lol good video!
I most definitely believe that highlanders kicks would be able to kill alone with those massive thighs, he could probably decapitate with the amount of power those things generate and should have conquerers head kick execution
Were you going by the weight the game portrays, or the weight of a real life Claymore?
My thoughts exactly. He kept say monumental and other such adjectives, but most real life great swords were 5lbs topping out at 10. The in game monstrosity on the other hand. Wardens sword probably classifies as a great sword by weight though.
@@jjkrayenhagen I figured the weight was around 7 or so, guess I was right. Real life claymore use is actually quite stylish, it's smooth and flows really well. Highlander just swings a 40 pound piece of steel at his foes with little skill, he's very barbaric.
@@I_Love_Warden Really the vikings in general and to a smaller extent the knights are no where near as skilled as their real life counterparts. Ubi seems to just abhor thrusting and avoid it as much as possible.
@@jjkrayenhagen The only characters with skill is probably some of the Wu Lin and Samurai, maybe Lawbringer. That's about it. Everyone else just swings like an absolute barbarian. Ex. Highlander, Shugoki, Warlord, Raider, Jorm, Gryphon, Conquer, ect.
When looking at it from the perspective of a battlefield I can understand “you never let go of your weapon”, but from the perspective of a duel - just a straight up duel, like let’s say it’s a setup Judicial 1v1 or something along those lines - would the situation or rating differ? Like, if the warrior is doing a power play for example? 👀
I’m a duel scenario, yes it’s not as big a deal. But I do only look at these from a battlefield scenario as For Honors context is a war scenario.
I really don't like when he grabs the blade just seems like a good way to lose your fingers. Same thing when warden does it.
Claymores aren't as heavy as you think, on average they're only about 5 and a half pounds, though the sword that Highlander has is much larger than a regular claymore so 🤷♂
Going to guess almost all will be leathality four
Despite being a Vlandian main, I got to give respect to the Battanian with the 'big fuck off sword'.
I always appreciate some brutality in execution animations.
I have one question about your grading for the Efficiency category. While I agree that letting go of your weapon should always be a low score, how does it not automatically guarantee you will get a ZERO in that category? Does it have to do with how quickly he/she picks up their weapon again, or are there other factors that determine this?
16:32 Ok ive got a dumb question. During executions where they grab the sword by the blade and hit their opponent with the handle, arent they at risk of cutting themselves with the blade? Or is there some sorta technique to prevent that. Ive seen Highlander do it, Warden to it, etc. Idk it just gives me fucking anxiety. I know their hands are fine cuz its a game but still.
It's called halfswording, and it was pretty common in it's time, to the point of, IIRC, being a very basic technique. I agree though, I had the same thought before I learned that.
@@TheDapperDragon I just looked up 'Half-Swording' yeah you're right. That's pretty cool actually. Thanks man
Hey raven I saw your kotor gameplay that is my first and favorite game of all time I love Star Wars and lol I will be mentioning it once this video is live 🤣
My main problem with his executions is that he always grabs the end of the blade. Im not super familiar with claymores, but i do know that most European greatswords are only dull enough to grab at the bottom.
Highlander? More like Giggity-lander on all the 69%s
I'm curious, what would be a good reason to disarm yourself in combat then? You said a good reason, what would be one
A few examples of good moments would be if your current weapon is damaged and you could still use it as a projectile while grabbing a secondary.
Or perhaps if your opponent is attempting to gain distance from you and you have a throwable spear or item that you know can incapacitate.
@@RavenKnightYT okay I was just curious is all. I mean spears are meant for throwing and you would disarm yourself but skirmishers usually have a small bundle of them like Javaliners.
6:55 Hole Lander could have ended with a beheading and it would be so much cooler (And it would make sense).
Actually, I think it would've been better if he snapped off a third piece and shoved it into the eye socket.
@@psychoseth1643 Coolio
Let's goo finally. Hl is my main!
Uh, when you talk about his feat where it rains "stakes" on a targeted location, don't you mean "thrown spears" instead of "stakes"? Because those are spears being thrown in the feat. And also, it's a spear that gets used in the execution as well.
would have rated him higher but after all im rep 70 highlander and kind of biased. But i think the score was fairly reasonable
Already know he's going to give highlander's base decapitation, and deep cut executions 100% he spends every video reminding us how difficult a decaptitation actually is to pull off, well my boy highlander literally wields a two handed greatsword that can decapitate three men in one swing, (they did it on proxy dummies in deadliest warrior)
I myself own a great sword they are fucking monsters mine sighs in at around 15 pounds. So highlanders carrying around a sword that weighs around just as much as the average sledgehammer. So him taking a bit to actually pull it out makes complete sense.
Here is how I would rate "Spin the Bottle"
Lethality: S for Stupid
Realism: S for Stupid
Efficiency: S for Stupid
Cool Factor: S for Stupid
Overall Rating: It may be Stupid but its also Dumb
Fyi if you are reading this, this rating is (Mostly) Meant to be a joke
Why would HL need a weapon if he has those THICC THIGHS
What’s his longest execution
22:57 it’s just cruel
Can you do Aramusha next pllllllsssss
Your efficiency and cool factor are contradicting themselves
In what way?
I joined the stream as it ended.
Let’s go when I first start playing I ground out enough steel to purchase Highlander and played them for 18 reps straight. I can’t wait to see what score he gets for his executions #FemaleHighlanderSkin.
I’m personally not a fan of highlander
Right know
Right
Giggity
real
waited for this!
You are aware that blades are useless against armor right?
you are aware I don't take armor into consideration in these videos, right?
@@RavenKnightYTYou're right, i wasn't aware. After getting familiar with all of these i'm surprised i commented this. My bad. Altough i wanted to say, i don't think his throwing execution should be a 1 in realism based on the odds. This could happen, if the throw was accurate and landed then the manner in which warden died wasn't unrealistic. Just very unlikely. That's why i believe that should have a 0 in efficiency because of the odds not realism. You say it yourself "you could do this" and i thought that was what realism was all about
Adimblast blast adanamier
I mean… if you are as yoked as this man most of these are super realistic.. most..
Once again Raven I am first hahaha 🥇🥇🥇I absolutely love your content btw
Thank you. :)
@@RavenKnightYT the legend actually responded thank you so much
"Greatswords are heavy"
Please do some research, greatswords were not heavy slabs of steel.
I did not say they were. The average great sword weighed around 10 to 15 pounds depending on the make and steel. Granted it’s not very heavy in terms of pounds, but the size and length of the weapon means the weapon is more cumbersome, and harder to maneuver properly.
I dont what f this is. I'm trying to find out what happens to a Scott highlander from the lore happens when he cuts his own head off
female highlander gang ↓
I will never understand the concept of grabbing your own blade?? Seems really dumb, I understand the strength of highlander and hes prob a tough fellow who can handle holding a sword but that sword is definitely sharp and heavy, just hold the handle? Too much could go wrong by turning the blade on urself (im talking realism here not im game persay”
holding the blade isn't unheard of, but I've never liked it myself. Still, from a historical context, it has been done.
8th I guess
4th to comment! Please pin