I'd like a dlc myself focusing on him, either have it focus on what he was facing at the time, he was in hollow storm so you could play through that for a chapter and at the end he gets the news about Ben, have it play out the same for other members
I hope so, and they don't kill them off, so Clayton him can be reunited. And for his name, I'm hoping maybe Damian Carmine? You know to stick with the A B&C
I really, really wish that they’d stop killing off the Carmines, each one is an awesome and unique character in their own right. But I think the Carmine curse has been played out now, right? Because as soon as we hear the name, we know their fate
In the part when you said that will is either a Onyx Guard or commando. I believe that Will is an Onyx Guard because you brought up the letter for Clayton and not Will because the Onyx Guard are an elite secret special forces that do not allowed written letters or discussion of any details of their missions. Which supports this theory that Will is Onyx Guard.
Wait a minute I just realized something. As you said in the video, so far the Carmines have been named alphabetically. There’s the first one we see Anthony “A”, the second one Ben “B”, the third seen Clayton “C”, and the fourth unseen one who you predict that their name will start with a “D”. In 5 we see Elizabeth, which is “E” which is the fourth’s daughter but in 4 we see Gary who’s name starts with a “G”. Which could mean that there is a possible F. Carmine out there.
That would be Fredo Carmine. He was a reporter that interviewed Colonel Loomis in Judgment. It’s unknown about what happened to him throughout the war, but he could be Gary’s father
@@amach3639 Not exactly since info on him is found in Collectibles in GOW Judgment. And there’s not much known about him besides what I wrote in the previous comment
In gears of War 2 there is a collectable that also has a newspaper in the back ground and on the newspaper there is a gear in standard cog Armour and the gear is identified as Sgt.Madison Carmine who was killed in action.
I love all these lore videos especially when it comes to the Carmine brothers guessing that has to do with how my brothers show some similarities to them & how we try to stay close
I'd maybe like to see this mystery Carmine to sort of have the Carmine Curse, only it affects other people, whoever he serves with (squad or whatever) ends up dying and leaving him without a scratch, could even tie into that stone-cold killer vibe, if they go for that.
What about Detrick Carmine? The one from the gears ad campaign where he was buying life insurance. I know it's not cannon but it'd be funny if they used his name as a callback to that.
So happy they didn’t kill my boy Clayton off. And was excited to see him in gears 5. Got my Gears tattoo of him finally, to start my Gears of War sleeve!
im thinking to make a concept for D carmine what will he looks like. and this video might help me imagining how he looks like. and im kinda agree he's lone wolf now since he's nowhere spotted on the game or even comics/novel
I think he could have gone Outsider and just left the COG since it took a lot of his family, just wanting to be away from it all. Then if they find him in 6 he’s just a grumpy, cold old guy.
I’m pretty sure it was a collectible of a letter from Ben to d carmine confirming his letter of his name and tbh I think 6 will be your character (created) following c and d carmine
There is also a possibility of another unknown Carmine. Someone with F as the first letter, because: Anthony Benjamin Clayton D---------- Elizabeth--> Lizzy F---------- Gary
If I ever got names for D Carmine then I’ll call him Donovan Carmine, Dwayne Carmine, Dexter Carmine, Darby Carmine, Diego Carmine, Dylan Carmine, Deon Carmine, Dustin Carmine, Duncan Carmine, Drake Carmine, Dallas Carmine or Darwin Carmine. Which names that anyone can prefer for D Carmine?
I really hope 6 finally gives us the final brother, who i’ve been calling Drayton for the time being. And i swear if “Drayton” and Clayton don’t get some good scenes together and mention at least Lizzie so help me. I’m still hoping we get to vote on the fate of this next Carmine or at least they let him live for a good chunk of 6.
@@KingAbzTV hey abs I left a comment and was wondering if you've ever heard of SGT.Madison Carmine you see him mentioned in the background on a collectable you find in GOW2 it's on a newspaper clipping.
If he does show up in gears of war 6 hopefully he's a badass like clayton and hopefully they keep him alive,id hate to see another carmine go down in the battlefield.imagine his name is Deacon carmine or Dalton carmine something cool like that I presume
I already have a made-up conversation between D. And Clayton: - D: show up at recruite base. - Clayton: the hell are you doing here D. - D: I'm here to re-join the COG Clayton, and don't you dare stop me. - Clayton: I can let you do that D. , you are all I got left. - D. : they took her from me Clayton, and I'll kill every last one of those god-damn grubs even if it kills me.
Still one of the biggest mysteries for me. Where the FUCK is the fourth brother at? There has been ZERO mention of him ever sense Benjamin said their was four. That was 3 games ago now.
Isn't the 4th Carmine dead? Didn't he die in GoW 4 in COG attack on the outsiders camp right at beggining of the game (guy that was operating turrent) ?
Have you ever did halo content because if you did I haven't seen it can you do the covenant species along with there home planet, there role in the military and what they think of humans
To finally end the saga i hope that carmine officially takes off his mask to reveal what he looks like underneath. I dont wanna see the same repetitive story happen againa and again , no more carmine curse shit, just show us who he really is and have him command the COG army or something. It would show carmines evolution from clumsy rookie in g1 and g2 to a experienced badass general or something, it would be so satisfying and really better the flow of the story.
Kinda irks me that he’s the second oldest yet he’s named with a d. You’d think Clayton would be second oldest considering the chronological order of their names
Feel like gears 6 will kill a Carmine and I've got this feeling that D. Carmine will be it its not a gears game without a Carmine death 😅 I feel like D Carmine just a normal civilian after the locust war and settled down had a bunch of kids cause I don't think Gary and lizzie are his only kids
If the 6 game does come out, can we all agree? We don't want to see any more of these Clayton deaths and stop treating him and his family like a joke. They wasted lizzie Clayton she had potential
In the new Gears you get to play as D Carmine, an RH Agent, Deep Red 40, ha ha I spoiled it, :) and yes he has no locust blood, let me know on my channel,
"D Carmine settled down with an unknown wife, and together they conceived a child."
A hundred bucks says the helmet stays on during sex.
💀💀💀💀
Always wear protection.
you think bro went down on her with the helmet too? bro was like “GOT SOME ON ME!” 😂
@@_GeRAHHH Oh absolutely. The helmet *never* comes off.
A hundred bucks say the helmet is a part of he body. Like a robot/cyborg.
I want an act where the main character is Clayton carmine and we get to play as him for a bit
Highly agree with this
I'd like a dlc myself focusing on him, either have it focus on what he was facing at the time, he was in hollow storm so you could play through that for a chapter and at the end he gets the news about Ben, have it play out the same for other members
im even wanting Carmine spinoff when we mainly play as Clayton Carmine.
I want a game where the main character isn’t Kait better yet she isn’t a character
I wanna see Clayton’s perspective during operation Hollow Storm
I hope so, and they don't kill them off, so Clayton him can be reunited. And for his name, I'm hoping maybe Damian Carmine? You know to stick with the A B&C
Yea abcdefghiki
Gary on. Gear 4 carmine no remember him
I hope so. That would be the first time we see the brothers actually interacting with eachother outside of multiplayer.
Nah Damian is Bairds name
@@trick9037 Baird's name is Damon, But you do have a point.
I really, really wish that they’d stop killing off the Carmines, each one is an awesome and unique character in their own right. But I think the Carmine curse has been played out now, right? Because as soon as we hear the name, we know their fate
I think the carmine curse is funny, but there's a old thing about a joke not being repeated more than thrice.
In the part when you said that will is either a Onyx Guard or commando. I believe that Will is an Onyx Guard because you brought up the letter for Clayton and not Will because the Onyx Guard are an elite secret special forces that do not allowed written letters or discussion of any details of their missions. Which supports this theory that Will is Onyx Guard.
Wait a minute I just realized something. As you said in the video, so far the Carmines have been named alphabetically. There’s the first one we see Anthony “A”, the second one Ben “B”, the third seen Clayton “C”, and the fourth unseen one who you predict that their name will start with a “D”. In 5 we see Elizabeth, which is “E” which is the fourth’s daughter but in 4 we see Gary who’s name starts with a “G”. Which could mean that there is a possible F. Carmine out there.
That would be Fredo Carmine. He was a reporter that interviewed Colonel Loomis in Judgment. It’s unknown about what happened to him throughout the war, but he could be Gary’s father
@@z-man1237 I’m not gonna lie I never heard of Fredo before, he someone you I have to look deep into the lore for?
@@amach3639
Not exactly since info on him is found in Collectibles in GOW Judgment. And there’s not much known about him besides what I wrote in the previous comment
Yo… felix carmine
In gears of War 2 there is a collectable that also has a newspaper in the back ground and on the newspaper there is a gear in standard cog Armour and the gear is identified as Sgt.Madison Carmine who was killed in action.
I’ll have to look into that! Must be an act 1 collectible that I’ve not seen
I looked at the collectible and it’s hard to read but I believe it says SGT Hudson Connors not Carmine 🤷♂️
I love all these lore videos especially when it comes to the Carmine brothers guessing that has to do with how my brothers show some similarities to them & how we try to stay close
Glad you enjoy the lore videos! & yeah definitely, I have a lot of brothers too so it’s cool how every brother is so different to one another
Holy COG a like & comment from the man himself I can die happy now & oh yeah absolutely
Abz I'm so amazed how much stuff you keep coming up with to talk about for gears
When I think I’ve ran out of stuff to talk about…I find more! 😆
@@KingAbzTVwell I'm glad about that
Gary Carmine is like a cousin something like that
Your like one of the few people besides shadows who is this dedicated I appreciate it
I'd maybe like to see this mystery Carmine to sort of have the Carmine Curse, only it affects other people, whoever he serves with (squad or whatever) ends up dying and leaving him without a scratch, could even tie into that stone-cold killer vibe, if they go for that.
I always had a theory of my own that the 4th carmine bro was onyx
I hope he's a gear commando even more badass. Great video.
YES make D Carmine an Onyx Guard
Exactly, one of the most badass Onyx guards.
Geez... How many babies did Carmines' parents make?
Just four
Possible names for D Carmine:
David, Dillan, Dante, Dareth, Daniel, Dennis.
David, Dillan, Dareth, Daniel and Dennis definitely sound like the kind of men who gets killed easily. Dante sounds bad@ss.
I think David too or maybe Derek?
Or Donnie?
damian maybe
I agree with the last name
i like these little jokes you crack. "D.. for Doomslayer aheheh.."
great hosting as always man
Thanks haha glad you enjoyed!
Gary is the other one he died on 4
bet if D, Carmine appears you'll hear Psychosocial playing in the background
What about Detrick Carmine? The one from the gears ad campaign where he was buying life insurance. I know it's not cannon but it'd be funny if they used his name as a callback to that.
The will of “D”
So happy they didn’t kill my boy Clayton off. And was excited to see him in gears 5. Got my Gears tattoo of him finally, to start my Gears of War sleeve!
Daddy Carmine
im thinking to make a concept for D carmine what will he looks like. and this video might help me imagining how he looks like. and im kinda agree he's lone wolf now since he's nowhere spotted on the game or even comics/novel
Anthony, Benjamin, Clayton, perhaps we see a David Carmine and the Grubkiller fighting alongside each other to purge the swarm
Ten bucks on David or Derek Carmine, he has to be at least half as badass as Clayton though forsure.
Damian Carmine , Daric Carmine, Desmond Carmine I just putting names on here of what it could be.
That we'll be sick that Clayton Carmine have DLC In Gears6 I think D Carmine well show up in game just like Gears Judgment
I think he could have gone Outsider and just left the COG since it took a lot of his family, just wanting to be away from it all. Then if they find him in 6 he’s just a grumpy, cold old guy.
I’m pretty sure it was a collectible of a letter from Ben to d carmine confirming his letter of his name and tbh I think 6 will be your character (created) following c and d carmine
Love you’re videos bro!!!❤
Stay positive!!!
Thank you 💙
There is also a possibility of another unknown Carmine. Someone with F as the first letter, because:
Anthony
Benjamin
Clayton
D----------
Elizabeth--> Lizzy
F----------
Gary
If I ever got names for D Carmine then I’ll call him Donovan Carmine, Dwayne Carmine, Dexter Carmine, Darby Carmine, Diego Carmine, Dylan Carmine, Deon Carmine, Dustin Carmine, Duncan Carmine, Drake Carmine, Dallas Carmine or Darwin Carmine. Which names that anyone can prefer for D Carmine?
I really hope 6 finally gives us the final brother, who i’ve been calling Drayton for the time being. And i swear if “Drayton” and Clayton don’t get some good scenes together and mention at least Lizzie so help me. I’m still hoping we get to vote on the fate of this next Carmine or at least they let him live for a good chunk of 6.
Drayton & Clayton would be awesome
@@KingAbzTV hey abs I left a comment and was wondering if you've ever heard of SGT.Madison Carmine you see him mentioned in the background on a collectable you find in GOW2 it's on a newspaper clipping.
Maybe they're twins?
Daniel Carmine for sure
Since people say the newest Carmine brother's name starts with "D," I'll predict his name will be either "Daryll", "Donnie", or "Duane". Or "Danny."
I feel like he would have the last cog helmet design in which is the cog marine helmet that we see on random gear soldiers
Derek Carmine
I think there will be an arc when d finds out that lizzie is dead and jd was at the time she died, he would blame jd for not saving her on time
Admittedly since they'll probably have collaberation characters in multiplayer, Doom Slayer would be a good pick for a gears game.
It will be a full circle of the four Carmine brothers.
Oh yes my friend. He will be Gears 6.
Hopefully TC Did Right the Games .
If he does show up in gears of war 6 hopefully he's a badass like clayton and hopefully they keep him alive,id hate to see another carmine go down in the battlefield.imagine his name is Deacon carmine or Dalton carmine something cool like that I presume
I already have a made-up conversation between D. And Clayton:
- D: show up at recruite base.
- Clayton: the hell are you doing here D.
- D: I'm here to re-join the COG Clayton, and don't you dare stop me.
- Clayton: I can let you do that D. , you are all I got left.
- D. : they took her from me Clayton, and I'll kill every last one of those god-damn grubs even if it kills me.
They should have and be the main character of a spin-off game
Wasn’t the 4th brother killed in Gears 4? It was the Act where you enter the village and Jin blames you for the disappearances
That's Gary Carmine, I think he's the cousin
That was Gary Carmine, the black sheep of the family who was born after the locust war had ended
Oh okay, thanks for clearing that up (:
I swear Dizzy hasn't been in Gears of War since gow3, what happened to him?
@@lukemoore2 prolly died due to old age
For some strange reason I've always heard his name was Michael carmine
Before any of y’all ask about Gary just know that Gary is a cousin
I wonder he is one of the cog soldiers in gears of war 2 he is wearing the third unique helmet
Wait Is There 4 Of Them?
Still one of the biggest mysteries for me. Where the FUCK is the fourth brother at? There has been ZERO mention of him ever sense Benjamin said their was four. That was 3 games ago now.
Im pretty shore the 4th carmine died in the beginning of 4 when Rana village rated by DBs
You forgot to mention the Carmine that appear in Gears of War 4
2:02
Either
Daniel Carmine
Derrick Carmine
Dickson Carmine
Dr. Dre Carmine, rapper of the COG
I don’t know why but I always thought D Carmine was a Onyx Guard
I mean, I'll take a carmine spin off game at this point! haha.
Isn't the 4th Carmine dead? Didn't he die in GoW 4 in COG attack on the outsiders camp right at beggining of the game (guy that was operating turrent) ?
That was Gary Carmine, the black sheep of the family that was born after the locust war had ended :)
I knew his name is Gary, but I always thought that he's the 4th Carmine brother. Good to know that Clay isn't the last brother alive. Thanks
"Damien Carmine"
Make him an onyx but the main antagonist to Clayton
It's Daniel Carmine. Both Clay & Dan are going to die together in 6; forever ending the curse...
maybe could be Dalton Carmine? Anthony, Benjamin, Clayton, Dalton.
Mmmmhmmmm
D carmine.....D Carmine.....hes on my check list
Have you ever did halo content because if you did I haven't seen it can you do the covenant species along with there home planet, there role in the military and what they think of humans
I made a couple of halo lore videos but not much, I'll probably touch on them more in the near future hopefully!
He could be Gary Carmine.
To finally end the saga i hope that carmine officially takes off his mask to reveal what he looks like underneath. I dont wanna see the same repetitive story happen againa and again , no more carmine curse shit, just show us who he really is and have him command the COG army or something. It would show carmines evolution from clumsy rookie in g1 and g2 to a experienced badass general or something, it would be so satisfying and really better the flow of the story.
D.Carmine could be Damon Carmine...(I work with the Gears team)
Kinda irks me that he’s the second oldest yet he’s named with a d. You’d think Clayton would be second oldest considering the chronological order of their names
Will D. Carmine.
Dillon Carmine? David Carmine? Danny Carmine? DJ Carmine?
Just to think about a few names
What about Gary Carmine, was he the nephew or son to Clayton?
That would be cool I heard he is only in the comics right?
Feel like gears 6 will kill a Carmine and I've got this feeling that D. Carmine will be it its not a gears game without a Carmine death 😅 I feel like D Carmine just a normal civilian after the locust war and settled down had a bunch of kids cause I don't think Gary and lizzie are his only kids
We see him in gears 4
We need a carmine dlc!
If the 6 game does come out, can we all agree? We don't want to see any more of these Clayton deaths and stop treating him and his family like a joke. They wasted lizzie Clayton she had potential
here are all the names that could be the name for d carmine Darin daric damion
Oldest to Youngest: C, D, A, B. CDAB, C-DAB. See Dab **dabs**
(Sorry but not sorry)
Isn't there a carmine in gears 4 when they get back from the raid in the beginning of the game
That was Gary Carmine, the black sheep of the family that was born after the locust war had ended :)
Damian carmine sounds good
In the new Gears you get to play as D Carmine, an RH Agent, Deep Red 40, ha ha I spoiled it, :) and yes he has no locust blood, let me know on my channel,
I hope he’s in gears of war e day
Isn’t the 4th brother Gary
I want a dlc of the r8se and fall of the carm8nes
Daryl Carmine
I dont know why but i feel like Clayton carmine is gonna die in gears of war 6 hes my favorite character to
ABCD carmine
He appears in gears 4 or 5
Probably Derick Carmine
Damian carmine and he’s still a little kid that’s why we never saw him or heard about him he’s the youngest one 🤦♂️
maybe his name is david?
honestly bently carmine
I thought the 4th was gary????
didnt will die from ram in E Day from the comic book
That was Will Carmine! 😪
@@KingAbzTV are the comics Canon?
@@fdkrill8049 yeah of course, they’re great!
@@KingAbzTV then it can't be will carmine then so 🤷 we don't know who it's gona be but I can't wait to gears 6 comes out
David carmine
Damian Carmine
dequarius carmine
Dante Carmine
David Carmine
I swear he must be a electrician then. Cus I know like 20 electricians called Dave