Some similarities I could find between this great composition and some other works. 0:46 and 1:55 BWV 529 Largo, BWV 688, Capriccio BWV 826 2:06 Courante BWV 830 2:18 BWV 1080 Contrapunctus 8 2:30, 3:53 and more BWV 998, BWV 645, BWV 532 Prelude, BWV 539 Fugue, BWV 525 part 1 This applies to other parts of this composition where the same theme is heard. 2:47 found in quite a few of Bach's Fugues, Fugues of BWV 548 and BWV 542 for example. 3:24 BWV 988 Variation 18 4:37 BWV 864 Prelude. Also in the Fugue of BWV 542 but in minor and not major. 6:14 BuxWV 146 6:33 BWV 903 Fugue 7:26 BWV 927 This similarity is not explicit, but the length of notes and pattern is very similar those at the end of that piece.
Great meticulous work! I am impressed! We only have to consider that great masters also inspired and imitated each other. For example, Bach's work would not have been conceivable in this form without Buxtehude's influence and role model.
Bravissimo! More one “counterpoint lover” I have found at TH-cam, so I don’t feel so alone in this contemporary world! “Baroquepunk” way of life!✊🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
This may sound quite bold but to me, counterpoint writing is more enjoyable and fun than harmony writing because there are at the same time horizontal and vertical dimensions so I have the feeling to get more from the music. This is what I like most in counterpoint. Anyway i am happy you enjoyed the piece !
Much gives; gives me a happy Clementi vibe. I miss that the prelude doesn't revisit much of its lots of material. I especially wanted to hear measure 93-95 again (because of the left hand). :)
For a long time, I was convinced I would only hear good compositions with Bach. Where the value is in the notes itself, and not in how the notes are played; This is why Bach sounds good on any instrument from organ to voice, to guitar, to trumpet, to kazoo, to synth. I see the same here. I have not fully understood what "it" is, but it seems that you have understood whatever it was that Bach understood, that no one else understood, and I can hear it clearly in your music. If you are still active, please could you explain your method of composition, because it might be the closest thing to finding out Bach's method. If you are also willing to discuss, I would like to learn from you.
Tbh I can see your point here, I was thinking about similar things (which people find in Bach's music) before, it's a big topic, I mean, is it possible to write music with Bach's vibe but in contemporary style, melodies and harmonies, so many questions but not enough answers still
I am deeply moved by your comment. Thank you for taking the time to write; Regarding "it" I don't know clearly how to define it but maybe it is not something so musical. Maybe it is just something about knowing how to build musical sentences and lines that are coherent and flow well into one another. Maybe it is what makes Bach so good. Regarding my technique, I would say it is closest to "impromptu speech" than traditional basso continuo technique. I usually find a theme on the keyboard or sometimes it just pops in my head and I immediately write it down for safe keeping. Then I try to find and tape interesting melodies and episodes suitable for this theme. But usually it ends up bigger than expected as I like to integrate more elements than planned on the go, this is the reason most of my pieces are quite long, a bit like an overmodded game 😆.
It' certainly has a baroque feel, but there are a lot of little details that can be polished, which could change the piece from decent to great. I didn't count every example, but you have multiple parallel octaves (between alto and tenor in m. 213) or various voice-leading irregularities (the unprepared B suspension to A in the alto in m. 215). Or in the E major / C# minor areas where you have C-natural written instead of a "proper" B# (Left hand m. 63 and 71) .... Improvement on details like these can really make the piece shine more.
It's just constant sixteenth notes without barely any cadences. It's tiring to listen to you can barely hear any development of material. The difference between this and Bach is that every note Bach writes serves a purpose and has a point. This is just plugging notes wherever they fit, making like a musical spaghetti
![ILLSLICK - KILLSHOT REMIX [FULL VERSION]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/RIK8RrqIAzE/mqdefault.jpg)
![[#2024MAMA] G-DRAGON - 무제(Untitled, 2014)+POWER+HOME SWEET HOME+뱅뱅뱅+FANTASTIC BABY | Mnet 241123 방송](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Ox29z5Nf1Uk/mqdefault.jpg)
1:43 renembered me to the 3rd theme of the bachs fugue in c# minor
This is fantastic, because the vibe is extremely close to the actual vibe of Bach's works, and ornamentation is
Some similarities I could find between this great composition and some other works.
0:46 and 1:55 BWV 529 Largo, BWV 688, Capriccio BWV 826
2:06 Courante BWV 830
2:18 BWV 1080 Contrapunctus 8
2:30, 3:53 and more BWV 998, BWV 645, BWV 532 Prelude, BWV 539 Fugue, BWV 525 part 1
This applies to other parts of this composition where the same theme is heard.
2:47 found in quite a few of Bach's Fugues, Fugues of BWV 548 and BWV 542 for example.
3:24 BWV 988 Variation 18
4:37 BWV 864 Prelude. Also in the Fugue of BWV 542 but in minor and not major.
6:14 BuxWV 146
6:33 BWV 903 Fugue
7:26 BWV 927 This similarity is not explicit, but the length of notes and pattern is very similar those at the end of that piece.
yes
@@Tizohip
👍.
Wow
Great meticulous work! I am impressed! We only have to consider that great masters also inspired and imitated each other. For example, Bach's work would not have been conceivable in this form without Buxtehude's influence and role model.
it is an Frankenstein which was stolen by Barocco-era, that autore this channel can have gloriuos.
Bravissimo! More one “counterpoint lover” I have found at TH-cam, so I don’t feel so alone in this contemporary world! “Baroquepunk” way of life!✊🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
This may sound quite bold but to me, counterpoint writing is more enjoyable and fun than harmony writing because there are at the same time horizontal and vertical dimensions so I have the feeling to get more from the music. This is what I like most in counterpoint. Anyway i am happy you enjoyed the piece !
@@studentofcounterpoint once has you played this concerto D-major on piano/clavier?
This guy really understood what counterpoint
BRAVISSIMO!!!!!!!!!!
Really a very, very nice composition, BRAVO!!!! 👏👏👏👏
I made some romantic works with high counterpoint ratio
Nice work. Some parts are not playable unless you have rachmaninoff hands
Much gives; gives me a happy Clementi vibe. I miss that the prelude doesn't revisit much of its lots of material. I especially wanted to hear measure 93-95 again (because of the left hand). :)
Clementi was a bit later, more Bach.
@@SusanneStechow-r6n Yes, but it's Clementi vibes I get (especially at the beginning). Fun regardless.
yo I fuckin love this piece, especially the playful prelude
I am happy you enjoyed. Thank you for sharing your thoughts
Magnifique prélude et fugue !! A la Bach
I can’t believe how baroque it is! Bravissimo!
I am happy you enjoyed it. Thanks for sharing your thoughts
For a long time, I was convinced I would only hear good compositions with Bach. Where the value is in the notes itself, and not in how the notes are played; This is why Bach sounds good on any instrument from organ to voice, to guitar, to trumpet, to kazoo, to synth.
I see the same here.
I have not fully understood what "it" is, but it seems that you have understood whatever it was that Bach understood, that no one else understood, and I can hear it clearly in your music.
If you are still active, please could you explain your method of composition, because it might be the closest thing to finding out Bach's method.
If you are also willing to discuss, I would like to learn from you.
Tbh I can see your point here, I was thinking about similar things (which people find in Bach's music) before, it's a big topic, I mean, is it possible to write music with Bach's vibe but in contemporary style, melodies and harmonies, so many questions but not enough answers still
@@alexanderbayramov2626
I was thinking the same thing. I have the same question about whether it's possible.
I am deeply moved by your comment. Thank you for taking the time to write;
Regarding "it" I don't know clearly how to define it but maybe it is not something so musical.
Maybe it is just something about knowing how to build musical sentences and lines that are coherent and flow well into one another.
Maybe it is what makes Bach so good.
Regarding my technique, I would say it is closest to "impromptu speech" than traditional basso continuo technique.
I usually find a theme on the keyboard or sometimes it just pops in my head and I immediately write it down for safe keeping.
Then I try to find and tape interesting melodies and episodes suitable for this theme.
But usually it ends up bigger than expected as I like to integrate more elements than planned on the go,
this is the reason most of my pieces are quite long, a bit like an overmodded game 😆.
@@studentofcounterpoint
Thank you so much for responding!
This approach makes sense and I am now using this information.
@@christianindividual4550 May it serve you well. Good luck on the Path
Well done.
this piece fills me with so much joy! i feel very blessed to stumble upon a piece as beautiful as this! immediately subscribing!
This is wonderful!
Also it sounds a bit like Bach, Scarlatti and Beethoven combined
Well done, late student of Bach. What would he say? Maybe:"Fine, people write fugues again. And not bad ones. I can calmly do other things."
Impressed.
truly a masterpiece
Thanks a lot for your comment
This is great!
It’s so beautiful
Bravo, wonderful and inspiring. Thank you for this.
If people like the piece, I am happy. But I am even more when they find it inspiring. Thank you for commenting.
Wow, very nice! Very well done! 👍🏼😀
Thanks for sharing your thoughts. Happy you enjoyed
Really quite nice. ....and L O N G !
Sometimes I get carried away.. and I don't know how to stop 😅 Happy you liked it !
very good
Wow I love this!
Hello Elia, I am happy you enjoyed it. Thank you for your comment
i want hear that on a harpsichord!!!
Here you go ! th-cam.com/video/NNqJo0m1LKc/w-d-xo.html
I'm happy you liked it.
Can you make a fugue explanation video iam a piano student but i love organ polyphonic, fugues i love Bach
based
Great work. 👌👌
Thank you. I am happy you enjoyed.
I would love to play this. Could you give me the sheet
You inspired me to compose something on my own. I just uploaded it. Thanks man
Who has made this masterpiece?
Hi , amazing piece! What program did you use?
Hi, happy you enjoyed. I use Musescore 3
Bravo
Bravo ❤️🇵🇹
Hello Alexandre, I am happy you enjoyed the piece. Thank you for your comment
can you give me notes of this musical piece??? Bravo!!!
Please turn this into a cantata sinfonia or a concerto, or I''ll have to do it myself haha
Really ? please feel free to try, i ve got my hands pretty full at the moment.
For a moment It becomes Rameau
Si alguien me dijera que estoy escuchando una pieza de Bach no lo dudaría ni un segundo
Nice, fugue is not easy to write
It' certainly has a baroque feel, but there are a lot of little details that can be polished, which could change the piece from decent to great. I didn't count every example, but you have multiple parallel octaves (between alto and tenor in m. 213) or various voice-leading irregularities (the unprepared B suspension to A in the alto in m. 215). Or in the E major / C# minor areas where you have C-natural written instead of a "proper" B# (Left hand m. 63 and 71) .... Improvement on details like these can really make the piece shine more.
there needs to be quite a bit more improvement than you mentioned in order for this piece to start being "decent"
👍
😋😁☺️
Not quite a fugue tho
Seems AI composed to me...
agreed. it doesn't sound human
AI wouldn’t make nearly this many mistakes
@@therealtruetwelfth798one of these guys again. Bachs compositions aren’t flawless either
@@konst1887that’s not an excuse?
It's just constant sixteenth notes without barely any cadences. It's tiring to listen to you can barely hear any development of material. The difference between this and Bach is that every note Bach writes serves a purpose and has a point. This is just plugging notes wherever they fit, making like a musical spaghetti
Shut up, you don't know what art is.
This piece is beautiful.
@@siniestgolde547 whatever 👍