In case anyone doesn't know, Jay Chou's opponent in this movie scene is his real-life junior, both of whom are music majors. Their playing is legit. They two even played the last piano repertoire at concerts or award ceremonies more than once.
Oh my goodness, I didn't realise until the end that this wasn't Twoset's channel..! It's too bad they took this down, I thought it was quite funny. I think everyone needs to lighten up a bit! I mean, if the pianist was unhappy about it, he could've just made a response video to counter them, like Davie 504, and who knows, an interesting collab could've come from this, who knows? Thanks for the re-upload!
Jay Chou's status in asia is like Michael Jackson's in west - a true pop music KING. So probably would never collab with them🤷 About piano, he learned since 4 and majored in it. Don’t know if he’s professional level or not but definitely good So basically this video is like two professional dancers rating MJ's moves, then sigh&🙄 while he’s literally JUST starting to dance. I mean you can criticize but not be prejudice before it
I don't know why fans got so offended that they needed to delete the videos. As a fan of Jay Chou, I think it's fun to see the reaction of someone who has never heard of Jay Chou (or didn't recognize it's him). I mean Twoset already acknowledged that they are real musicians. Yes they laughed the entire time but it's because of how "piano battle" is unrealistic in real life and because of that Mr. Ice, who is meant for people to make fun of. It's too sad that Twoset had to delete this.
Don't know if they can see this, but if you play piano in China, you can certainly get the girls' attention haha and can become the "Prince of Piano". However, you need to play something hard and fancy or something that looks hard and fancy, which is what this piano battle has shown lol.
Not that impressive since a lot of transposed pieces are just the piece but well… transposed. May be impressive but the piece somewhat is still the exact same
They didn't know the fact that Jay Chou (The main actor) Is the one who composed almost the whole OST of the movie ( Secret) And his the director too 💀💀 P.S: no hate, I love Twoset
As a big fan of this movie and Jay Chou, I felt quite uncomfortable with their attitude. I enjoyed twoset’s other roast videos because many of the performances are terrible or fake. I wished two set could have been more cautious with this one. Or they were. It seems they did not put this to their channels on bilibili in the first place.
@@sophiebi5798 not furious but I also got uncomfortable. What makes twoset roasts funny are because they are coming from professional violin players, but piano is not their main instrument. So it's just throwing criticisms on something they do not know well enough.
@@mariannec2322 They do have less experience with piano but that doesn't mean that their comments in this video are total nonsense or less funny. I mean, most of the comments are about how classical music is represented in general, only very few are actually about piano techniques.
I got a faint memory that some Jay Chou's fans felt annoyed of Twoset for having doubts about his piano playing because he in fact is really good at it. Unlike other Twoset's roasting videos of Chinese dramas movies because of their sacrilegeous representation the violin/instrument playing, in this one most of the time they couldn't tell the playing was legit or not, so neither they gave criticites nor compliments (actually they did applaud but it's likely for the acting skills, not playing). Maybe Twoset didn't want to pick a fight with those fans for nothing so they deleted the video. Don't mind correcting me if I'm wrong.
@@shinsei2135 they actually dissed the playing, and in the end said 'Jay Chou: not the best piano technique, but at least he can play" in other video where they revisited this movie (I think its the movie scenes tier list). because jay chou isnt a classical píanist, but a pop pianist that plays some classical pieces and improvise over them.
@@irinakarlova8921 Who are the two sets? I have absolutely no idea what you're on about. However, I am confident that those who do not know Jay Chou aka 'king of mandapop', particularly asians, are not truly Asian.Since his debut in 2000, he has received 15 awards from 49 nominations. His net worth is 95 million dollars and how much did the two sets earn? Internet celebrities nowadays especially ytber likes to critic someone without knowing the person background to earn flows while Jay Chou is a well-known global star as he earns his respect by producing quality music.
@@irinakarlova8921 How do you feel when I compare your favorite singers to some TH-cam clowns who earns money by criticizing people? Everyone can have their own opinion about their favorite musicians/singers, but they cannot criticize someone on the Internet simply by abusing the freedom of speech.
i kinda get why they deleted the video, they were definetly being a bit nitpicking and overcritical, even going into this video their initial attitudes were a bit pompous/snobbish...
Their thoughts about piano skills were positive in the end, but at first they were so impatient and prejudiced...like5:06while he's literally JUST starting to play So I totally get why some people are mad about it, especially this movie and Jay Chou are REALLY popular in asia
yeah twoset probably unlisted/got private/deleted the video because they were harshly roasting the performers. after all they arent to blame for the cringy script, theyre just actors not the writers or directors
How come they did not realized that those actors are actually pianist? Like Jay Chou obviously can play, he is a very skillful musician. Did they assumed all actors can't play? How could they missed I don't get it
@@samuelmike3843 the movie was made back in 2005-6, what do you expect? the point of this video is they dont know who jay chou is, and humiliated themselves bcs they are too naive and judgemental
@@nickywong905 if a movie is from 2005 its expected to be cringe? And adding a name to an actor in a cringe movie somehow makes it good? It doesn't matter if hes martin luther king junior lol. Im sure hes a cool guy just saying within his acting in this specific movie its not very good. You don't need outside context of every actor's life and status to judge a movie XD. Maybe I should start checking each actor's fanbase before criticizing a movie instead of actually forming an opinion on the movie itself
@@samuelmike3843 it is a good movie, just that you don't understand the context since you are not an Asian, or from Asia. The acting might be cringe, but the movie has some interesting plot, overall good storyline, too bad I can't find an English analysis video for this movie.
@@nickywong905h I can't imagine how will they recover from this HumiLiAtiOn 🙄🙄🙄 of not knowing this one particular actor/musician!! Dude they obviously don't care enough lol and neither should you cuz not everybody will know your blorbos, especially since they don't listen to that much pop music to begin with They even said the playing is good so what else do you want
In case anyone doesn't know, Jay Chou's opponent in this movie scene is his real-life junior, both of whom are music majors. Their playing is legit. They two even played the last piano repertoire at concerts or award ceremonies more than once.
Oh my goodness, I didn't realise until the end that this wasn't Twoset's channel..! It's too bad they took this down, I thought it was quite funny. I think everyone needs to lighten up a bit! I mean, if the pianist was unhappy about it, he could've just made a response video to counter them, like Davie 504, and who knows, an interesting collab could've come from this, who knows?
Thanks for the re-upload!
Jay Chou's status in asia is like Michael Jackson's in west - a true pop music KING. So probably would never collab with them🤷
About piano, he learned since 4 and majored in it. Don’t know if he’s professional level or not but definitely good
So basically this video is like two professional dancers rating MJ's moves, then sigh&🙄 while he’s literally JUST starting to dance. I mean you can criticize but not be prejudice before it
@@朝索yet they pretended like they are just reviewing a super talented singer from Asian country, like classical musician is pop music blind zzzzz
7:16 Oh no, not the clapping off beat.
Just like my rhythm 😭
I don't know why fans got so offended that they needed to delete the videos. As a fan of Jay Chou, I think it's fun to see the reaction of someone who has never heard of Jay Chou (or didn't recognize it's him). I mean Twoset already acknowledged that they are real musicians. Yes they laughed the entire time but it's because of how "piano battle" is unrealistic in real life and because of that Mr. Ice, who is meant for people to make fun of. It's too sad that Twoset had to delete this.
Don't know if they can see this, but if you play piano in China, you can certainly get the girls' attention haha and can become the "Prince of Piano". However, you need to play something hard and fancy or something that looks hard and fancy, which is what this piano battle has shown lol.
i think they didn't understand that that piece was more difficult when transposed to white keys than on black keys
Not that impressive since a lot of transposed pieces are just the piece but well… transposed. May be impressive but the piece somewhat is still the exact same
@@justanoob1839 i think you didn't get it just like the violinists
@@lucyfiniarel2347 yes I did get it. The piece is more difficult but just like they said there’s zero point since the piece sounds the exact same
@@justanoob1839 r u stupid , of course it’s different . It’s just that U can’t hear the difference .
It doesn't really matter but why do you think it's more difficult transposed.On white keys it's basically easier than on black keys in my opinion..
They didn't know the fact that Jay Chou (The main actor) Is the one who composed almost the whole OST of the movie ( Secret)
And his the director too 💀💀
P.S: no hate, I love Twoset
For sure they know, they are from Taiwan !! They were just faking come On
That's like... a mix between the japanese series Kakegurui and the Prince of tennis.
11:29 I just died 😂😂😂
Horowitz kinda plays black keys with flat fingers like that
i loved this video, why did they take it down? It was a lighthearted review
As a big fan of this movie and Jay Chou, I felt quite uncomfortable with their attitude. I enjoyed twoset’s other roast videos because many of the performances are terrible or fake. I wished two set could have been more cautious with this one. Or they were. It seems they did not put this to their channels on bilibili in the first place.
They’re high nosed that time, peak of their channel/ career.
That's their attitude always, and that's what makes it funny! And they did mention the playing was legit. I don't get why people are furious about it.
@@sophiebi5798 not furious but I also got uncomfortable. What makes twoset roasts funny are because they are coming from professional violin players, but piano is not their main instrument. So it's just throwing criticisms on something they do not know well enough.
@@mariannec2322 They do have less experience with piano but that doesn't mean that their comments in this video are total nonsense or less funny. I mean, most of the comments are about how classical music is represented in general, only very few are actually about piano techniques.
Any idea why the video can't be found on their channel?
I got a faint memory that some Jay Chou's fans felt annoyed of Twoset for having doubts about his piano playing because he in fact is really good at it. Unlike other Twoset's roasting videos of Chinese dramas movies because of their sacrilegeous representation the violin/instrument playing, in this one most of the time they couldn't tell the playing was legit or not, so neither they gave criticites nor compliments (actually they did applaud but it's likely for the acting skills, not playing).
Maybe Twoset didn't want to pick a fight with those fans for nothing so they deleted the video.
Don't mind correcting me if I'm wrong.
@@shinsei2135 they actually dissed the playing, and in the end said 'Jay Chou: not the best piano technique, but at least he can play" in other video where they revisited this movie (I think its the movie scenes tier list). because jay chou isnt a classical píanist, but a pop pianist that plays some classical pieces and improvise over them.
@@shinsei2135 ...now I'm panicking whether I should download every single twoset video bacuase of crazy fans and their complains
@@irinakarlova8921 Who are the two sets? I have absolutely no idea what you're on about. However, I am confident that those who do not know Jay Chou aka 'king of mandapop', particularly asians, are not truly Asian.Since his debut in 2000, he has received 15 awards from 49 nominations. His net worth is 95 million dollars and how much did the two sets earn? Internet celebrities nowadays especially ytber likes to critic someone without knowing the person background to earn flows while Jay Chou is a well-known global star as he earns his respect by producing quality music.
@@irinakarlova8921 How do you feel when I compare your favorite singers to some TH-cam clowns who earns money by criticizing people? Everyone can have their own opinion about their favorite musicians/singers, but they cannot criticize someone on the Internet simply by abusing the freedom of speech.
i kinda get why they deleted the video, they were definetly being a bit nitpicking and overcritical, even going into this video their initial attitudes were a bit pompous/snobbish...
Their thoughts about piano skills were positive in the end, but at first they were so impatient and prejudiced...like5:06while he's literally JUST starting to play
So I totally get why some people are mad about it, especially this movie and Jay Chou are REALLY popular in asia
Oh, they deleted the original video?
They are from Taiwan, they definitely who is Jaychou, but they pretended they didn’t for the reaction lol
eh i thought it was pretty lighthearted, they acknowledge a lot that they are legit musicians (jay chou and the other guy)
@@朝索 Not really, there are too many movements and their questions are pretty legit.
Obviously, Brett and Eddy don't know Jay Chou.
Actually the best piano battle was in "Who Framed Roger Rabbit".
yeah twoset probably unlisted/got private/deleted the video because they were harshly roasting the performers. after all they arent to blame for the cringy script, theyre just actors not the writers or directors
9:19 If you can make friends slowly, you can make friends quickly
Thanks Dipper
9:24 if u can play fast slowly, you can play fast quickly and find friends quickly
People get offended too easily smh
How come they did not realized that those actors are actually pianist? Like Jay Chou obviously can play, he is a very skillful musician. Did they assumed all actors can't play? How could they missed I don't get it
The movie and acting is cringe af
@@samuelmike3843 the movie was made back in 2005-6, what do you expect? the point of this video is they dont know who jay chou is, and humiliated themselves bcs they are too naive and judgemental
@@nickywong905 if a movie is from 2005 its expected to be cringe? And adding a name to an actor in a cringe movie somehow makes it good? It doesn't matter if hes martin luther king junior lol. Im sure hes a cool guy just saying within his acting in this specific movie its not very good. You don't need outside context of every actor's life and status to judge a movie XD. Maybe I should start checking each actor's fanbase before criticizing a movie instead of actually forming an opinion on the movie itself
@@samuelmike3843 it is a good movie, just that you don't understand the context since you are not an Asian, or from Asia. The acting might be cringe, but the movie has some interesting plot, overall good storyline, too bad I can't find an English analysis video for this movie.
@@nickywong905h I can't imagine how will they recover from this HumiLiAtiOn 🙄🙄🙄 of not knowing this one particular actor/musician!! Dude they obviously don't care enough lol and neither should you cuz not everybody will know your blorbos, especially since they don't listen to that much pop music to begin with
They even said the playing is good so what else do you want