They have probably turned on some loud music so they clap to it and do not hear the noise from the music instruments. But in this case actors that play musicians are deaf.
After hearing the "real" version I realize why everyone looks so happy, they are obviously laughing their heads off because of the "so bad it's funny" performance going on in front of them. Btw, Eddy dubbing the actual nonsense they are singing sent me every time. Like others have already written "What it should have sounded like" should be a series!
@@hoegender in this context, the tambourine is off tempo and not always consitent, the person playing the tambourine does that weird "flourish" in the beginning, and ends with weird dancing and busking (of all things) in a high end restaurant. I doubt that was SYF worthy. Besides, I'm not dumb enough to think that percussion is useless. I'm just pointing out that his bad percussion, specifically his, is useless. Lastly, I used the tambourine to identify the man because it was the unique thing about him.
Well what I heard was a classical guitar in the recording but on screen I see a normal acoustic guitar and they have different tones because the classical uses nylon strings.
I know, right? The guitar is completely silent for most of the time and when it does make a sound it doesn't match the movement. Just look at 8:32 where you can hear the guitar play a little melody while the actor keeps strumming chords.
Exactly! Toward the beginning there were other notes that you could hear from the guitar but his hand was totally still. He stopped playing like 3 seconds too early.
at the end of the beginning, apr. 01:20 you hear completely different notes, while the hand is actually moving away from the guitar and is close to the first string
Same, at the beginning it doesn't even look like his fingers are on the strings. There's only one that is.... but he's still moving them like he's supposed to be doing something. I died laughing.
To be honest they faked everything in this series, I remember there was a scene where they were in a party and they just edited some music in. There was a split second where the music awkwardly stops and the people were still dancing. That scene made me laugh my ass off I swear to god
Why would they fake dancing/music on the speakers? Like they must’ve had pretty low budget for that, but they got a violin? But then again, they faked the violin.
Bad post-production...:D Dancing scenes are generally shot with no music. They play the music for a few seconds for the actors to get a sense of the rhythm and then they shut the music off and you have to pretend you're vibing. :D Maybe they did the same with the music scene...and that's why the clapping was completely off....
0:57 The pianist is supposed to change his hand position from playing the initial chord. The initial chord was d minor and his right hand is supposed to be up on the C5 position, and his left hand should be in the C2 position, but they are both in the C3 position which makes it sacrilegious enough. Not to mention that he was not actually playing a d minor chord but pressing random keys there, I can actually see it. 1:01 His hands is not supposed to shift down, and his left hand should have stayed down there, and his right hand is supposed to move back to the initial C5 position to play the higher parts of the chord but we can see that he fakes it. 1:10 He is supposed to lift off the right foot from the pedal but he did not so that sounds like a sacrilegious echo. 5:11 He is not supposed to lift his arms that high especially in the middle of playing 5:13 He is supposed to lift his right foot and change the pedal, but he did not and he kept the buzzing sound there. I'm sure the noise pollution comes mostly from the piano, not the violin and guitar. 7:57 and 7:59 He should have changed his pedaling on those seconds but he did not 8:33 He was supposed to pedal but he did not, his hand position should have been shifted for a second to reach the low notes but he kept his arms at the same position 8:53 He was supposed to pedal but he kept his foot on the floor
ChibiDoggos ÒwÓ is it just me or were they only white people and like 3 Indians no black people!?!?!? (Actually I think their where no Indians just white people of course
Omg look at 12:06 where her smile fades into a straight face and back into a smile as she realizes “oh yeah I’m supposed to be pretending it sounds good” 💀🤣
the last part tho. glorious. I was laughing like an idiot. you should do that with every terrible music scene you react to. the entertainment factor is just over 9000.
I love that they actually went into the trouble of recording and arranging all these sounds for violin, piano, vocals and claps, just to show us what it would actually sound like 😂
when i was a kid i thought those actors were really playing and were talented since i don't pay attention to their hands and now i finally know the dark secrets behind those actors with good visuals. edit: OMG thanks for 1.6k likes omg thats the most likes I've ever had tysm🥺
lol.. exactly!.. was about to leave the same comment.. you can also hear the tambourine once or twice without him slapping it when he is about to start collecting
Haha, I was about comment that to, but yeah and did you know that the girl she was trying to impress was called "sun-shai", and the boy that was trying to impress her was not the one she ended up with in the end😂😂
When he was tapping the tambourine there was no tambourine sounds 😂😂😂 but when he was walking around taking money and not playing tambourine, there were tambourine sounds 😂 I'm dead 😂😂😂
What his girlfriend sees in that "violinist" eyes: LOOOOVEEEE what I see in his eyes: Do not drop the violin. Do not drop the violin. Do not drop the violin. Do not drop the violin.
like, i saw one video once named "the next Mozart?" where a 6 year old played with a piano and was just hitting random keys.. bitch please, Mozart wrote a song when he was 5!
@@Light14Lilium The guy plays the guitar when the guitar is gone... He doesn't move his hands... Jesus Christ. I'm not even a guitarist and I can tell...
Everytime I watch one of your videos I get guilted into practicing the piano. Before you guys I had stagnated for a couple years but now I’m actually getting back into it! I didn’t think I was ever gonna get back to playing- thank you so much!
Me when I first watched that scene in Meteor Garden: *Ugh so cute and look how Shancai stares at him, especially him staring back at her while playing beautifully* Me now that I watch this video: *I never noticed, well damn*
Should have just watched the original Taiwanese one. The sound quality is pretty bad (the boom mic picked up all the traffic and background noise) but at least they didn't fake the whole thing. And at least the main song sounded good (original singer) rather than this cheap sounding knockoff.
I saw this on Netflix and kept questioning why his fingers never really moved and also how slow he would move his bow... best violinist (in the show) oh and I got so annoyed on how the audience was so off on clapping. It’s so simple to know when to clap on beat...
The best part about the guitarist is that he's holding the wrong guitar. You'll hear nylon strings in the beginning (classical guitar) but he's using an acoustic
*PLOT TWIST:* THE TAMBOURINE IS SINGING!!!! Edit: I don’t think the other comment had enough likes so I didn’t see it, but there’s a comment that says the exact same thing written 4 days before I did. 😅
yassfish fish The other comment didn’t have as my likes as it does now, so I would’ve had to keep scrolling to see it (I’m assuming) so I didn’t realize that there was another comment.
The guitarist there too. He was strumming down with a pick on a steel string acoustic when you could *clearly* hear that it is a fingerpicked nylon string.
This is sooo funny! I just noticed as well that on the final close-up to the "violin player" the guy in the piano is not the actual actor who was "playing" the piano before. I wonder if they had someone who actually played the piano; not sure why bother if his performance was not really going to save this debacle!
Guitarista's faking as well. He's strumming when the backing track calls for plucking, he's too tense, he's obviously avoiding the strings (probably to reduce noise pollution like eddy said), he also doesn't shift finger position (you can tell by the lack of muscle movement in his forearms), and he's holding the guitar too far away from his body (afraid he might drop it?). What's really uncomfortable though is how awkward his strumming is, my god. It's like he's stroking a cat but he's afraid it might bite.
0:58 As a member of the piano gang, I feel so confused with this part right here, like there's definitely something wrong with the pianist's hands there 😂😂
@@aesthetism9 Man the fingers aren't even playing to the sound. As the camera is starting to pan up, the music plays two notes but the dude doesn't even press the keys
I love how the first thing I see is everyone pretending to play an instrument and doing a terrible job at it, AND they use close up shots to make it more obvious!
Ahh yes HE AINT EVEN PLUCKING THE FRICKING GUITAR AND SHIFTING HIS FINGER POSITION but tbh its like guitar boi isnt even pressing any string like WOOOOOOOOOWW sOoOoOo TaLeNtEd that hes just holding it too far from his body like hes afraid to drop it when there is a literall strap......
And the acting didn't match anything with the sound too. The dude acting is "playing" guitar with a pick, picking down each string then coming up very slow (sweep picking), with the left hand probably in a position that forms one chord. While the sound you hear would require a faster picking (or fingerstyle play) of some notes from a scale/chord with would require changes on the left hand/fingers position, and it wouldn't require that very slow sweep picking the actor is doing to sound correctly.
I play violin and this is so funny because I can point out so many bad things. This is so annoying to watch people fake playing but these guys reactions are so funny and just make this whole fake video funnier. 😭😭
Dramas always struggle with
1. Musical instrument play
2. Wearing thick makeup to sleep
3. Medical logics
Make up??
Yes
Crazy Of that and that yeah they wear lots of makeup, even when pretending to go to sleep
@@lyaura6148 Yeah even the doctors wear a lot of make up.
@@towoawa5229 yeah they use a lot of make up when thet are goint to sleep or other things but they make it seem more natural
“If we hear vibrato, we wanna see some wiggle.”
I’m dead lmao.
Well, technically, you move your hand but not the placement of the finger to create vibrato.
Connie Ma either way it still wiggles
@@___meph___4547
Yeah, that's what I meant.
I haven't played violin in so long.
I am your thousandth like
@@connordoesexist1807 i thought you ment a vig-
the actor honestly looks like hes afraid of the violin lol
that’s his character. he’s and introvert, quiet and pretty shy.
@@maxzhi6035 but the character he played is good in violin?
@@maxzhi6035 lmao how did this dude end up in front of the church with people gawking at him?? I would've been shivering from the anxiety ngl.
@@ianforte8128 yes
@@claude7381 exactly!lmao
Imagine being a real violin player in the audience 💀
You don't need to be a violin player you just need common sense
I'm your 1k likes
@@Magister195 tru but its worse if u are a violinist
@@taffles7498yep true
I truly hope the video editor just messed up in syncing
*no people. You dont get it. The bow is a paid actor*
someone r/wooosh pleassse
Light Rifler BUt BOws CAnT be PAID!
You’re welcome.
With low salary
Lmao
@@KariMusic0116 am I supposed to r/woosh u?
Imagine the audience while filmig....
They had to act awed at the performance while they created earrape
I am at awe in earrape by default
Wow! He looks so handsome as he's moving his arm so slowly...
It's so painful to watch. And this is already edited. Man I feel bad for the audience because they have to sit and watch and hear out of tune squeaks.
I bet some of them wish they were deaf just so they wouldn't have to hear it.
They have the smile that says that.
Imagine being an audience actor and you have to sit through the actual performance without laughing.
lol it's a TV show but you're absolutely right XD
They have probably turned on some loud music so they clap to it and do not hear the noise from the music instruments. But in this case actors that play musicians are deaf.
They’re laughing tho lol
If I was there I woul create so many bloopers
I was thinking the same thing 😆
After hearing the "real" version I realize why everyone looks so happy, they are obviously laughing their heads off because of the "so bad it's funny" performance going on in front of them.
Btw, Eddy dubbing the actual nonsense they are singing sent me every time. Like others have already written "What it should have sounded like" should be a series!
LMAO I died laughing at the end. *_'What it shouldve sounded like'_* could be w whole new series.
YESSS
10:38
Same!!
me too XD lol
i havent laughed so hard in years
The bow is just a prop. He's actually using his mind to control the strings.
sealand000 I never thought about that
😂😂😂
Mystery solved!
LOL 😂😂😂😂😂
OmG
That is painful acting. Also imagine the audience without editing
Oh god i don't wanna imagine
I was cringing so hard at his acting. Like he made the bow go so slow when it was getting faster, Zhjdksk
HAH
The re-imagining of the actual sound these guys did at the end probably sounded better than what those actors had to endure.
@Kyle Billie in fact, thats the most realistic part 😂
At this point you don’t even need to play violin to tell that something is wrong 💀💀
true💀
I don’t even play an instrument and I noticed how fake it was
"bruh"
-everyone who has ever played an instrument
*an
Oh god. So true. LOL
I play guitar and ukulele.
Still can tell something in this scene was not right.
@@ttwpsbd9456 same im a ukulele player
"Bruh"
-Everyone that has functioning eyes and can see that everything is out of sync
yeh
The tambourine guy is the one guy in the group project who does nothing but tries to take credit for everything
I-
Tambourine is generally something you use to give a place in the band to the chick you want to impress, so that works I guess?
Glacies.Yin lol
@@hoegender in this context, the tambourine is off tempo and not always consitent, the person playing the tambourine does that weird "flourish" in the beginning, and ends with weird dancing and busking (of all things) in a high end restaurant. I doubt that was SYF worthy.
Besides, I'm not dumb enough to think that percussion is useless. I'm just pointing out that his bad percussion, specifically his, is useless.
Lastly, I used the tambourine to identify the man because it was the unique thing about him.
@@GlaciesYin Tambourine man, AKA man from the streets, AKA Mr. Hi-yes-can-I-have-yo-money-thanks, AKA Sir Cheapskate, AKA Happy Feet
I’m pretty sure everyone forgot about the person playing the guitar.
ikr
@Gp2 Engine im pretty sure he couldnt play either
Yeah.... Being a guitarist that's the first thing I noticed lol
Lol he’s definitely not playing 💀 he’s strumming instead of finger picking
Jugo 69 I see it now, how didn’t I notice this even though I literally know guitar 👁👄👁
I miss twoset roast 😢
We will miss them in our hearts
@@mikehumphries8587 yes, I think, I’m so confused about what’s going on.
Me too😢
😭😭😭
WHY did everyone completely gloss over the guitar. which is NOT SOUNDING. AT ALL
Well what I heard was a classical guitar in the recording but on screen I see a normal acoustic guitar and they have different tones because the classical uses nylon strings.
I know, right? The guitar is completely silent for most of the time and when it does make a sound it doesn't match the movement. Just look at 8:32 where you can hear the guitar play a little melody while the actor keeps strumming chords.
Exactly! Toward the beginning there were other notes that you could hear from the guitar but his hand was totally still. He stopped playing like 3 seconds too early.
at the end of the beginning, apr. 01:20 you hear completely different notes, while the hand is actually moving away from the guitar and is close to the first string
Glad I'm not the only guitarist watching this going nuts! Especially at that beginning. How do you get a low note on the 1st string!?
Tears are actually streaming down my face at the "What It Actually Sounded Like" section, y'all. I. can't. breathe. You guys are freaking geniuses.
Best part by far 🤣
Indeed
Hahahahahaha
😀😆😅😂😂😂😂😂😂
It looked like they were trying to summon a demon
God, I don’t play violin, and those bow strokes are ridiculously unmatched to the sound.
Variety of Everything that’s like basically everyone
Lol
I agree
Same, at the beginning it doesn't even look like his fingers are on the strings. There's only one that is.... but he's still moving them like he's supposed to be doing something. I died laughing.
Teenage girls dont't care
The end of the video with realistic sounds got me 💀
that was legit though. they could fr make an entire musical chinese drama.
"What it should have sounded like" part is a chaotic masterpiece
It's a masterpiece on par with Rite of Spring
Probably better than what it might have actually sounded like 😂
Watch stevie t he has that series
*mario theme starts playing*
As a person who’s never seen a guitar. The guy who’s playing guitar wasn’t even plucking strings.
IkR hahahaha. Like what the heck bro? Move your finger!!
It's not even the same kind of guitar as the music
I THINK THE SAME
Not even he's posture was good. No one can play the guitar like that
there was barely any guitar in it as well like???
To be honest they faked everything in this series, I remember there was a scene where they were in a party and they just edited some music in. There was a split second where the music awkwardly stops and the people were still dancing. That scene made me laugh my ass off I swear to god
Why would they fake dancing/music on the speakers? Like they must’ve had pretty low budget for that, but they got a violin? But then again, they faked the violin.
Bad post-production...:D Dancing scenes are generally shot with no music. They play the music for a few seconds for the actors to get a sense of the rhythm and then they shut the music off and you have to pretend you're vibing. :D
Maybe they did the same with the music scene...and that's why the clapping was completely off....
pretty sure there was a voiceover too
The piano playing in the beginning also was fake 😭😭😭😭
@@sstingreii ironically this drama had a gigantic budget. It's just a thing that chinese drama tend to do. they dub everything in post production.
0:57 The pianist is supposed to change his hand position from playing the initial chord. The initial chord was d minor and his right hand is supposed to be up on the C5 position, and his left hand should be in the C2 position, but they are both in the C3 position which makes it sacrilegious enough. Not to mention that he was not actually playing a d minor chord but pressing random keys there, I can actually see it.
1:01 His hands is not supposed to shift down, and his left hand should have stayed down there, and his right hand is supposed to move back to the initial C5 position to play the higher parts of the chord but we can see that he fakes it.
1:10 He is supposed to lift off the right foot from the pedal but he did not so that sounds like a sacrilegious echo.
5:11 He is not supposed to lift his arms that high especially in the middle of playing
5:13 He is supposed to lift his right foot and change the pedal, but he did not and he kept the buzzing sound there. I'm sure the noise pollution comes mostly from the piano, not the violin and guitar.
7:57 and 7:59 He should have changed his pedaling on those seconds but he did not
8:33 He was supposed to pedal but he did not, his hand position should have been shifted for a second to reach the low notes but he kept his arms at the same position
8:53 He was supposed to pedal but he kept his foot on the floor
Woah, you must be a real musician! Cool! You're cool!
What the hell bro that hand is flying to Mars istg
Wow
Thank you 😭😭😭
🤓
the director: “just do whatever, doesn’t matter since we’ll just edit it”
"We'll fix it in post". lmao.
The editor: AAAAAAAAAAAAAA
Crackhead
When it’s vibrating his hand is not moving at all
2set violin I am a new fan nice violin playing
‘ why is the Guy in the front kneeling?’
Hè is giving the violin powers of God so it can play its self
lmao u made my day
Kinda like La Corda d'Oro
1000th like
Where?
Hi
At this point it’s just
“Everything wrong with this scene” 😂😂😂
ChibiDoggos ÒwÓ is it just me or were they only white people and like 3 Indians no black people!?!?!? (Actually I think their where no Indians just white people of course
@@azkone24 it's a Chinese drama what did you expect
@@azkone24 also that's way too many "?!"
@@azkone24 also x it's they're*
@@nate5051 so you are expecting all white people in the audience of a chinese drama. Please make it make sense
Omg look at 12:06 where her smile fades into a straight face and back into a smile as she realizes “oh yeah I’m supposed to be pretending it sounds good” 💀🤣
Pfft, just noticed that-
the last part tho. glorious. I was laughing like an idiot. you should do that with every terrible music scene you react to. the entertainment factor is just over 9000.
AGREED 100%
Lmao dragon ball reference
Xd
4:09 got me the most
It was honestly a dream come true ahahah
My mom who has no experience what so ever: Wow, he's such a good player, why can't you play like that?
Me: (struggling to not laugh)
I don't play violin but even I know that it's only for show 🤣 guess I've watched too much violinists' playing
Hahaha! Why?
ikr lmao
Lol 😂
Grammar.exe has stopped working...
*brett:*
if you can clap wrong you can clap right
*me:*
dies laughing
Clap off beat?
Im ur 1k like
As a violinist and an archer, that bow is absolutely MURDERING me.
Violinist archer. Omg I want to be your friend ♡
they probably started off with a completely different song, and changed it at the last minute in post
Yeah...
Pickanapple it makes us feel better, just let us have this
Yeah they definitely started off with the song at 9:47
Just say that they faked it
Sry but.....
*PIECEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE
The girl staring at him should be thinking, “why am I here? This dude sucks. I will sue him.”
She had a crush on him💀
why? he’s not Min Yoongi.
JT - 06CJ - Erin Centre MS (1319) a fan of his made a joke saying she’d sue him because he’s dangerous. that’s why they said that he’s not min yoongi
her name is shen Yue
She actually likes him
I love that they actually went into the trouble of recording and arranging all these sounds for violin, piano, vocals and claps, just to show us what it would actually sound like 😂
Elite
I died when the claps came in 😂
They've done a brilliant job🤣
I laughed so hard 🤣🤣🤣🤣
I started laughing a bit.
With the recent news, it's time to rewatch videos for good time's sake.
Good luck on your future endeavors you two!
I never touched a violin but I know that this guy never touched one either (edit: omg 3,5k likes??? sheeeeeesh)
😂😂😂
Either*
Well, if you look very closely, you can see him touching a violin.
@@TheUnderscore_ -_-
@@aylazzz7 oh ok, thx. I'm bad in english because I'm from Québec
when i was a kid i thought those actors were really playing and were talented since i don't pay attention to their hands and now i finally know the dark secrets behind those actors with good visuals.
edit: OMG thanks for 1.6k likes omg thats the most likes I've ever had tysm🥺
Haha i usually skip it lol
Depends tho some directors are actually willing to find an actor who can really play , but most of them nah
fluffybrine 666 likes :))
SAME LOL
@@Buzzzy-bee hahaha
Did nobody notice that the tambourine FINALLY came in when the dude was gather money and not even playing?
lol.. exactly!.. was about to leave the same comment.. you can also hear the tambourine once or twice without him slapping it when he is about to start collecting
Me
Haha, I was about comment that to, but yeah and did you know that the girl she was trying to impress was called "sun-shai", and the boy that was trying to impress her was not the one she ended up with in the end😂😂
Gonna be honest, I would watch an entire series of what these actually should have sounded like, it's too golden of an opportunity to pass up.
If you can fake it slowly
*You can fake it sacrilegiously*
That's a pretty underrated comment
It's getting old bro :v
Is nobody gonna mention the totally fake piano and guitar player?
LemonGamer yes omg I don’t even know why that guitarist guy was doing all those weird movements
Me: is nobody going to mention that the room somehow has the portraits of King George III, II, IV and Charles I?
I was cringing the first seconds because of that piano player and I don't even play
Actually, I'm just gonna to...
I mean obviously the guitarist was a god who can play an acoustic guitar and make it sound like a classical I’m in awe
I love how at 10:37 they made the pianist play the Super Mario Bros theme song xD
How did I not realise that 😂
I was looking for that comment 🤣
Not so MLG Person Lol nice catch 😂🤣🤣😂
Bah ba ba bah da bah du
Listen to what she played at 10:06 XD
It’s been nice watching the both of you, Brett and Eddy. Enjoy your retirement
Hard to clap on time if all you hear is a total mess of random violin and piano sounds
I can imagine all the cast like: what the fuck is the music playing actually because the actor did not play anything. Lol
Should’ve gotten actors who ACTUALLY have talent🙄
@@abbymonster6509 agreed. Or atleast give them basic lesson if they dead on want that actor/actress regardless they know or not.
Piano guy gets bored, starts playing the Mario theme
Anton Huynh that made me crack up so hard when I heard it haha!!
Anton Huynh where?
Moon Gaze 10:37
Dun dun dun dun dun dun DUN
DUN dun dun DUN dundundun
Aaaaaaaaaaaaai 😂😂😂😂
When he was tapping the tambourine there was no tambourine sounds 😂😂😂 but when he was walking around taking money and not playing tambourine, there were tambourine sounds 😂 I'm dead 😂😂😂
It's just funny to see something being played, but no sound, and not being played, but there is sound.
I know I wasn't hearing things XD
I noticed that too!
Actually if you look close is playing it on his leg, but it's not on time
it only works when it can sense it's getting paid for performing.
please please dont take this one down too
The tambourine sound did come in later, when he was getting money and not playing it.
He's moving faster than the sound is travelling.
Maybe the whole audience was deaf so they were just enjoying the perfomance...
They were deaf after hearing them
Xisuma Sounds lol
I wonder how it really sounded like in real without edit
Watch the drama Meteor Garden. I promise you wont regret watching it
@َ oop-
@Angeline De Ocampo no
don‘t watch it, its really bad and has some weird ass scenes that give off rapey vibes
kronya it’s not as bad as you’re interpreting but
i need other roast videos uploaded again😭😭😭😭😭
I'm not even a violinist, I'm a flute player, but this still hurts my eyes
Wtf how did this reach 1k likes? Ty anyways ppl
Me too lul
Yeah
I'm a guitar player, but it still hurts my eyes
I’m a clarinet player
Ima flute boi as well
Anyone realize that the guy puts his hat back on with the money in it
I do. LOL
Seems reasonable to me
Wow thanks for this many likes
And sub to pewdiepie 👏👏
Only bills, no coins :-D
He's a street performer and a thief; he knows that no one will make a grab for the hat when it's upside down, on his head.
I play the piano and when they started clapping I felt my eyes burn
Me too, my friend. Me too. 😞
Jessica Sims me three
If that’s a thing😂
You don't get it, they are clapping at 69/420
I don’t even play the piano but my eyes burned on the behalf of my pianist friends
supermouse73 it's like they purposefully clapped on the wrong beats
Don’t leave us
Ling Ling is so good they don't even need to move the bow to play the violin.
Can I just say I love your profile picture
Kerianne Tennis I know it’s wrong of me to ask this but...
who is ling ling?
Jack Asparagus a made up character who is the best violinist in the world, they reference it as a joke
Matthew Simpson oh
Kerianne Tennis , Well, he can do left hand pizzicatos.
What his girlfriend sees in that "violinist" eyes: LOOOOVEEEE
what I see in his eyes: Do not drop the violin. Do not drop the violin. Do not drop the violin. Do not drop the violin.
Looks like someone didn't watch/get meteor shower
@No Bubbles• yess lets explain
@No Bubbles• its been a long time since i watched it lol sorry
Oooohhhhh so I see a non Meteor Garden fan...
That dude is ENGAGED
@@yourfavoriteoliveoil766 yeahh
Never touched a violin in my life but c’mon this is an actual insult to musicians and music lovers
That's an insult to dramas
come on their just pointing things out, at least we got to learn from each other's mistake
No they are not they are pointing out that they lied to everyone
At this point any drama with instrument English or none English is hard to watch cause of the mistakes
I don't play the violin but I played the alto saxophone
Litterly what happened this is like the only original video they have left!??
The thing is that I watched this whole series and never noticed.....
Same
How did you not notice? xD
what series is this?
oh it’s meteor garden
Um how 😐😐do u not play an instrument? Like no offense but that’s the only I think I wouldn’t notice if if I never played an instrument😶
10:35 the pianist litrally played the Mario theme song in the middle of the performance I'm dead😂😂😂
Omggggg lmao
I can’t get over it
Yea
XD
My god that’s brilliant😂
I personally like Meteor Garden but I gotta agree this scene was actual shit and made me wanna tear my eyeballs out lmao.
YEEESSS IVE WATCHED IT TWICE (I THINK) AND THIS SCENE IS T R A S H but i like the show either way
ohhh that's why I recognized him(lol I'm 20 episodes in)
SAMEEE
LMAO SAME AKDHSKAHH
I love Meteor Garden Japanese version and Taiwan’s...but China’s...Oh ..they are broking my childhood and youth！😂
The guitarist jamming soulfully when there isn't even a guitar playing in the score.
They were hoping we would be distracted by his cuteness that we wouldnt notice the terrible playing
me
Not even he's cute enough for that...
Though he's cute enough to not hold it against him.
story of every child "prodigy"
like, i saw one video once named "the next Mozart?" where a 6 year old played with a piano and was just hitting random keys.. bitch please, Mozart wrote a song when he was 5!
kpop in a nutshell.
They're so fake they become instantly believable.
You're better than this, Justin.
Justin you’re not supposed to be this early
*ʟᴇ ɢᴀsᴘᴇᴜ* ᴛʜᴇ ᴊᴜsᴛɪɴ ʏ?!?!
You’re better than this
Wow it’s my first Justin Y comment
10:37 just listen the piano...
IT'S MARIO 🎶
LET'S A GO!
Omg. I'm dead 😂
LOLLL
Lmao WHAHAHAH
oh nO
The audience not clapping on time is actually 100% accurate to nearly every audience in any occasion, lol
The last part is killing me LOL 😂😂😂
Same.
That super mario killed me
@@elementsenpai Same LOL
same
Now we know how all those extras must have felt at the scene
He's not even moving his fingers and you're complaining about them not vibrating 😂😂
Google is Stealing my Data like this mans is still in first position yall talking about vibrato 😭😭
I don't get it, they both said something about vibrato, shifting, and fingers not moving... not really complaining in my opinion
You forgot about the guitar player more than the producers did
Ikr
I think they dont know how to play guitar so they left it out...
@@Light14Lilium yeah, but the guitar man was literally just balancing himself... He didn't even play notes...
@@Light14Lilium The guy plays the guitar when the guitar is gone... He doesn't move his hands... Jesus Christ. I'm not even a guitarist and I can tell...
Everytime I watch one of your videos I get guilted into practicing the piano. Before you guys I had stagnated for a couple years but now I’m actually getting back into it! I didn’t think I was ever gonna get back to playing- thank you so much!
Hope you're still at it!
Me when I first watched that scene in Meteor Garden: *Ugh so cute and look how Shancai stares at him, especially him staring back at her while playing beautifully*
Me now that I watch this video: *I never noticed, well damn*
Same 😂
Jazmin yessssssssss
I wasn’t even paying attention to that🥵🥵🥵all I focused on was “stop oh god please sToP tHe ViOlIn aCtInG”
Should have just watched the original Taiwanese one. The sound quality is pretty bad (the boom mic picked up all the traffic and background noise) but at least they didn't fake the whole thing. And at least the main song sounded good (original singer) rather than this cheap sounding knockoff.
Lmao mood
I saw this on Netflix and kept questioning why his fingers never really moved and also how slow he would move his bow... best violinist (in the show) oh and I got so annoyed on how the audience was so off on clapping. It’s so simple to know when to clap on beat...
Abby what show is this?
@@neoculture4215 Meteor Garden
Anastasija i was going to watch that but nopeee
@@kelseyleeves8514 the show isnt that bad besides the music factor
Oof Nation it’s just the music parts that are bad, the story overall is good
I like how the guitarist isn't even strumming half the time
The best part about the guitarist is that he's holding the wrong guitar. You'll hear nylon strings in the beginning (classical guitar) but he's using an acoustic
Also, there is no guitar in the music.
1:10 Guitar plucking in the BGM, but actor is strumming it.
Slamalamadingdangdong THANK YOU! I was thinking the same thing!!
Also, I like your name 😊
Also right hand planting is not correct either for classical player
if i was an extra in there i would've probably laughed my ass off seeing the rest of them just awkwardly "playing" the instruments
It was the tambourine that was singing, obviously.
Are you dumb? It was the piano, duh.
No way it was definitely the guy with the guitar
I thought I was also guitar guy. He was the only one moving his lips, but you only see it at the end.
Piano beat: On time
Audience beat: off time
Girl beat: off time with the audience beat
Oof
Girl beat: off time with the audience beat and the piano beat
the piano was also fake btw lol
pOlYrHyThM
@@op-ve6hm But it looked kinda believable at least.
Why does it feel more like a funeral than a party...
Because their orchestra is sounded dead😂😂😂
well lol that's not party
@@airadenisseandreicumabig1691 It is supposed to be a party. A ridiculous party I must say, but still a "party".
Because the guy is trying to speedrun the violin’s funeral
Love how he magically changed the notes at 2:43-
*PLOT TWIST:* THE TAMBOURINE IS SINGING!!!!
Edit: I don’t think the other comment had enough likes so I didn’t see it, but there’s a comment that says the exact same thing written 4 days before I did. 😅
I love your dog
just saw another person (makesh) make the same comment as you but a week earlier, but I'm just gonna assume it was a coincidence
yassfish fish The other comment didn’t have as my likes as it does now, so I would’ve had to keep scrolling to see it (I’m assuming) so I didn’t realize that there was another comment.
@@dhanyasharma4817 ahh I see, don't worry. like I said, I assumed it was a coincidence
Um, it's obviously the piano
The guitarist there too. He was strumming down with a pick on a steel string acoustic when you could *clearly* hear that it is a fingerpicked nylon string.
Thank you.
@@micahlovesjesus3437 everyone in that room is a fraud
@@tomatotom984 Including the pianist
Yep, his right hand movements don’t make any sense. He would also probably be muting the strings he’s playing.
"That bow looks like an archery bow"
People with baroque violin bow: surprised pikachu face
AnotherRandomUselessTH-camChannel Was looking for this exact comment and you delivered, thank you 😂
This is sooo funny! I just noticed as well that on the final close-up to the "violin player" the guy in the piano is not the actual actor who was "playing" the piano before. I wonder if they had someone who actually played the piano; not sure why bother if his performance was not really going to save this debacle!
one could call it...an Attack On Tighten lol
Attack on tighten 😂😂😂 oh gosh
ROFL
i can't believe you've done this
That was the best pun I think I've ever heard
SKSJJSJSJSJSJ HOW COULD YOU
"If we hear vibrato, we wanna see some wiggle" xD
I really need to practice on the weekends and not just orchestra class ;-;
skskskks same
Catzilla X Challenge: thumb position harmonic vibrato
Whoa
Guitarista's faking as well. He's strumming when the backing track calls for plucking, he's too tense, he's obviously avoiding the strings (probably to reduce noise pollution like eddy said), he also doesn't shift finger position (you can tell by the lack of muscle movement in his forearms), and he's holding the guitar too far away from his body (afraid he might drop it?).
What's really uncomfortable though is how awkward his strumming is, my god. It's like he's stroking a cat but he's afraid it might bite.
The worst thing is he's using a steel string acoustic while the track actually uses a classical guitar.
There is a worst problem. There isn't guitar in the audio! I hear only a violin and some piano notes! O.O
@@giuliag.6174 guitar at 1:00
Dude, if pay attention to the very beggining, there are some arpeggios going on but his right hand isn't even touching the strings
Same for the pianist. Man's not in sync with the music
Jenna learned cello in 2 months for her movie but I think that actor hasn’t even touched a violin before.
edit: 109 likes?!
Are you talking about Jenna Ortega in Wednesday?
Yah
why is Jenna/Wednesday always dragged into EVERY topic?
Cuz she is great? Or do you hate her?
Yeah but the cello scene is fake
*sees first 10 seconds of the video* I already hate this.
On another note, happy birthday, Ling Li-- I mean Brett!
_Who's Brett?_
On another *"note?"* See what ya did there 😎
@@haferbrei7759 Oh my god😂
Can I just tell you how much I love your profile picture?
@@asdf14051 haha thank you!
I didn't expect you guys make the real scene 😂😂😂 I bursting into laugh 😂😂😂 great 👍👍👍👍
Dari indonesia?
@@priscillakatherine9815 ya dr Indonesia 😊
Wiih..sama!! aku juga :)
Ooohh me too
I bursting into many laugh.
0:58 As a member of the piano gang, I feel so confused with this part right here, like there's definitely something wrong with the pianist's hands there 😂😂
You definitely aren't seeing things my dude.
And yet I'm from the cello gang.
Piano gang member here. I see it too.
@@divyap4357 same
I have been cringed to death
I'm a new pianist-- what's wrong-😭
@@aesthetism9 Man the fingers aren't even playing to the sound. As the camera is starting to pan up, the music plays two notes but the dude doesn't even press the keys
I love how the first thing I see is everyone pretending to play an instrument and doing a terrible job at it, AND they use close up shots to make it more obvious!
Yes! Make these ”how it would have sounded” renditions more! :D
*PERFECTION!*
YEEESSS
Jajaja can't stop laughing at that part
It was very amusing. I think they should do this whenever they react to movies or shows.
I laughed so hard at this part when i realized what was happening. 😀
I think I peed a little 😂🤣🤣🤣
Sure, the violin acting was bad, and I’m no musician but that guitar acting: ABSOLUTELY TERRIBLE
Also the pianist has no idea what he's doing xD
As a pianist, the piano hurt me
@@souvlaki._ same-
bread god
Me too since I’ve played it since childhood-
@@souvlaki._ as a guitarist... I hope i can also play the guitar without my fingers touching the strings :>
The guitarist is so talented, he can make the noise without even touching the strings
Do you play guitar?
@@ortulaalyxlorianna Yes, I do.
@@aalayareddy4809 sameee 🤗🤗🤗
Ahh yes HE AINT EVEN PLUCKING THE FRICKING GUITAR AND SHIFTING HIS FINGER POSITION but tbh its like guitar boi isnt even pressing any string like WOOOOOOOOOWW sOoOoOo TaLeNtEd that hes just holding it too far from his body like hes afraid to drop it when there is a literall strap......
@@ortulaalyxlorianna oh same
The guy playing the violin giving the vibes of my first violin class lol🤣
😂😂🤣🤣 true
He's darren chen btw🤣 he's a famous actor in china
#HireRealMusicians
God knows musicians need more money and jobs.
*artists in general
though it can be said there is a rise in jobs needing art
If you can fake playing slowly, you can fake playing quickly.
Autumnpiano YES
Interesting
Clever boi ;) lmbo
I also love how the guitar player has an steel stringed (acoustic) guitar but the sounds are from a nylon stringued (clasical) guitar...
Yes it does afect greatly, try listening to the diference in youtube and you'll see how much it actually changes
And the acting didn't match anything with the sound too. The dude acting is "playing" guitar with a pick, picking down each string then coming up very slow (sweep picking), with the left hand probably in a position that forms one chord. While the sound you hear would require a faster picking (or fingerstyle play) of some notes from a scale/chord with would require changes on the left hand/fingers position, and it wouldn't require that very slow sweep picking the actor is doing to sound correctly.
Woo guitar expert here!
Was looking for this comment, now I don't have to say anything about it anymore hehe..
@@vitoraldan totally agreed honestly I was trying to listening for strumming, all I could hear is plucking...
I play violin and this is so funny because I can point out so many bad things. This is so annoying to watch people fake playing but these guys reactions are so funny and just make this whole fake video funnier. 😭😭