Me too!! However, I have Palestinian Muslim friends who have given western sounding names to their kids like Jude, and apparently it's a genuine Arabic name, so I gave it the benefit of the doubt. Or maybe like some reverts, he's changed his birth name
It is definitely about religion, in the Middle East, life is completely different, mindsets are different! I lived there and saw it! Because your study is in the west, your mindset is not the same!
I am Palestinian. However, I am a descendant of Abdurrahman, the son of Zaid, the son of the second Kalif Omar (may Allah be pleased with him). So, I am basically a Quraishite. If we want to talk about ethnics, I couldn't be more of an Arab. These claims that Palestinians were not Arabs but they were Aramaic etc... This assumption is stupid. Of course you have people of Aramaic origins. But the people have been interacially mixed. Most of the Aramaic people became Muslims centuries ago. And even back then, several tribes in the levant were ethnically Arabs like the Nabataians and th Ghassanides. And nevertheless, the people of the whole region speak nearly exclusively Arabic. The ethnicity argument is extremely dumb.
Many Palestinians believe they are direct descendants of Arabian tribes from the time of Mohammed. I hate to poop your party , but this is very common in nations where the dominant religion shifts. The local people who have adopted the religion want to appear to be closer to the source, and so genealogical connections are made, family names are changed, etc. When Ireland (my own country) converted to Christianity a myth evolved that claimed the original Celtic tribe that colonised Ireland was connected to the lost tribes of Israel lol.
@@williambarylo brother we see only extremist views in the comments, the history is different, there were minority of Arabs in the 7th century , the indigenous population were present they were Christians" jews"then the khalif Oumar brought the jews in the land. After islam spread most christians and jews became muslims thats y we have more Muslims than Jews n Christians as religion the people's ethnicity remains the same so majorities people r the indigenous population were present present there already just there religion change from judaism n Christianity to islam . And we the muslims gave protection to the people whatever their religions were n they flourished under islam for minimum a millenia. I'm i correct my brother...?
@@williambarylo AND i agree with you this "imam" is an arm of the colonialists tool of propaganda . His name is 'imam tawhidi' he's a Shia and a so called islam reformist and twisting history like the Zionist colonialists entity. Look for his content you'll understand Bi izhnillah
You are welcome to come to Israel and meet Israeli Muslims love their country and serve in the Supreme Court, parliament, government, hospitals and of course as commanders in the IDF. There are so many Arab Muslims and Christians fighting right now in Gaza to protect the state of Israel. Many of them died during their military service. God bless their soul 🙏🏻
@@williambarylo ...as I'm sure you are not such an impartial scholar, sorry but you have "built" the whole video to demonstrate what you already think to know, and statistic or other "tools" are not so useful as the Italian poet Trilussa has told in poem, statistic is that science that gives a chicken even to whom doesn't have one. Understanding pro-Israel Muslim? The video is merely a "parade" of to cases and, as you surely know being a scholar, it's not correct to derive a law from some isolated case. Working with Israel I have know eminent Jews and Arabs having prominent job and social positions. Many pro-Palestine Arabs questioned about who have to manage Palestine if they win the war say obviously Jews, they have created a social security system, education, economic system everything, in the Arab countries we have just inequality and poverty, following your analytical scheme should I believe them? I'm a pro-Israel, yes, indeed.
We didnt know any Jewish or Israelis because we are geographically located in Asia & also after 1948, Malaysia boycotted Israel. But I had an opportunity to live overseas in China & for the first time ever, we met a family of Israelis. They were not friendly at first. I think they are afraid of us because we are Muslim. But I learned about how Prophet Muhammad s.a.w. treated his blind jewish neighbor good even though she always cursed the prophet (unbeknownst that he was the prophet)… hence I tried my best to put away the feelings of Israel vs Palestinians conflict.
The prophet peace be upon him did not forbid us to be nice with those who aren't a clear enemy of the muslims. Anyone who is an open zionist is an enemy of Muslims so we cannot have sympathy to them
You sound as a wise person. Jews are not afraid of Muslims , they just don’t trust them, especially the Arab Jews who lived for centuries in Arab countries , and was treated as slaves and inhuman, and suffer atrocities by Muslims . They were kicked out and everything they had was taken from them.
The way that the first individual says ameen gives him away as a non muslim. No Arab pronounces ameen the way this man does, he sounds jewish and not muslim. Listen to the inflection of his voice as it does not emphasize the "e's" in Ameen. He can't even say the word "Muslim" with an s, he says Muzlim. This guys is completely fake.
The problem is that he identifies as a Muslim - he uses the title "imam" - and many consider him as a Muslim. There's no way for the average outside person to know - just like Sajid Javid in the UK. Many UK Muslims still consider him Muslim
@@HappyBloke81 I'm a revert and I've been confused by these kind of guys in the past. Part of my intention is that other new Muslims don't fall into the same traps as me!
@@williambarylo ma sha Allah. Good on you!! You're trying your best. İf you come across such characters in the future, just type in for example "Imam tawheedi exposed" . Some of these people may not have been exposed yet but I only mentioned him and not the other guy because literally any search of the tawheedi guy brings up red flags. You keep doing you bro. Allah is the one who guides. ♥️
@@williambarylothe Turks have a saying "not everyone with a beard is a Hajji (someone who has performed hajj)." I know he gets propped up by the western media the same media that also works for the Zionist Israel. He is always talking to an empty room. You're doing the right thing, I apologize. Everyone is at a different point in their journey. I made through these types very quickly.
[Re-Upload as previous version had no sound] Hey Trolls! Every comment on this video makes the algorithm reshare this video to 10 more accounts, so thank you very much for helping more people watch it. For the others, 2 points: 1. Many of you say they are kuffars and sellouts belonging to some sect. The problem is that they identify as Muslims (or imam!) and many non Muslims see them as Muslims (as they are given huge platform in the media and governments) - which can be confusing to non-Muslims or new Reverts to Islam who don't know these details. 2. Analysing these discourses is torture for me, but it's my paid job at uni. The reason for that is that to find solutions, you first need to diagnose and understand the problems you want to solve. And part of it also to give clarity to all those who are confused by this kind of people
@@jackjack-sh7uy the problem is that they identify as Muslims and many non Muslims see them as Muslims, and call them as such - which can be confusing to people who don't know these details
Only God Almighty is to say who is a Muslim nobody has right to practice Takfirism. Not only in Ahmadiyya case in Neobandis Naqshbandis and other groups in Islam.
@@Johanna-Rogier-AwadShia are from Iran and Lebanon compared with Sunnis that follow Sunnah. Shias follow Ali a.s Fátima ra husband the son in law of the Prophet.
Yeah, we all know about the love Muslims have for Jews. There is not a single opportunity that they would miss to show their deep love, affection and understanding for the Jews. It is very obvious and we see it all the time.
What about Palestinian state? Well that’s a tricky question isn’t it, after losing three wars and rejecting at least 3 peace deals, what about a Palestinian state, you tell me
3:00 I can't take things like this seriously. These are blatant lies. The extremity of what he's saying is cringe to even suggest people thought like this. Keep in mind he said this is what they were taught in school. I mean really, who would believe this? Muslim haters with no ability to think critically. I mean at this point the video was a parody. What do I make of this? He's paid. They found some Arab or Arab looking person, paid him to paint a certain image for the audience. Quite simple. I am from Morocco and the sht I hear (like Rachid from the PBD podcast) are all lies. Talking about how they view Christians and prohibit them from exercising their religion, how they are hated on. All of that is propaganda that they are paid to spread. Everyone that visits or has been to these areas know this quite well, the issue is the people that haven't are quick to believe "the other side is quite barbaric".
This is your answer. Of course, ANYTHING, other than admitting that islam with all it's sick craziness, is the WRONG, path. I swear, you people take twisting and distorting truth and out and out lies to a damn, high art form. I don't trust a damn, thing to come out of your mouths anymore. You sicken me, all of you.
The east ankle of Jordan also bong to thr Hebrews (the rest 10 tribes of israel) all thr Rabs tLk about subjects yhT they do not have enough true informatiomTion about. The imam talk nonsenc. The countty need first a sivil moral and jusgic common law (not religion)
The best bet for anyone wishing to leave their religion be it Muslim, Judaism, or Christianity is to convert to secular humanism. Every time one of those mythical power brokers, be it Allah, Jehovah, or Jesus gets involved, nothing but war and mayhem.
What is the argument in favor of the muslim brotherhood? Hamas? Why is their version of islam preferable to other more liberal interpretations of islam?
They're not worse or better, they have a different approach. People are stuck with the initial brotherhood as designed by Qutb as a response to colonial rule, which was absolutely horrendous. Now, the movement has become pacifists and moved their priorities towards social justice and democracy as seen with the Tunisian and Egyptian elections as their main goal is to end dictatorships and install democracy. However, they were no match for the Egyptian army and because of their non violent approach, they were easily crushed. Since the coup, many think the movement has become irrelevant. Compared to other islamicate political movements which want a theocracy, they are fairly Liberal as many of the newer generations have a western education. Hamas is completely different in terms of goals and priorities. And they have an armed branch
Our islam should never be liberalised to look good for nobody nor should it be made extreme for anybody. Anyone who veers towards extremes in religion is an extremist abd innovator. If they insist on that path they aren't muslim anymore. Sick and tired of people attempting to pacify Islam or make it war like religion when it's not
I am an ardent supporter of Palestinians. But I don't hate the Jewish people as such because Rasulullah sallalahu alaihi wasallam has had friendly relationship with Jewish people who he came in contact with. His visiting a Jewish child who was sick and praying for his health is well known. Those Jewish people who became Muslims were not in any way considered different from other Muslims just because they were descendants of Israeel. Apart from this in today's world, my disagreement is only with the Zionists who are mostly atheists and who I think do not abide by the commandments of God as conveyed to them via Moses and other prophets all of who are Prophets of Islam also. So many Jewish people belonging to the Neturai Kerta sect and large number of anti Zionist Jewish people including intellectuals, authors and journalists who decry the injustice done to the Palestinian people are Jews I hugely respect for their humanity.
Israeli government does not recognise they exist. The other day they bombed a church and snipers shot three or two women, and their response was there is no Christians in Gaza. So their experience is worse than being hate, they simply don't even count.
He is right about Palestinians are not Arab. Palestinians were colonized by several empire like Greece, Ottoman (Turkey), Roman, etc just like Israel. Palestinian language was different. Palestinians now speak Arabic because of forced conversion to Islam by Ottoman empire. It is very sad that the Arab, Turkish, and Iranian leaders are using Palestinians for their own twisted agenda. These leaders are all competing to control the area of Jerusalem that has historical significance. Very sad how these leaders are making Palestine and Israel fight. The people of Palestine and Israel need to wake up and make peace with each other and kick out those greedy competing leaders.
Thank you for educating us!! we don't get those type of comments very often! I'm pro-peace and I want both sides to solve the conflict and I think that both sides will get great benefit if more people stay in the side of peace instead of adding more to the conflict.
Lolz . Palestinians now speak Arabic because of forced conversion to islam by ottoman empire? What about other countries that embraced islam like Pakistan, iran, Indonesia, Malaysia etc. how come they didn't start speaking Arabic after Islam but Palestinians did.
He can't even pronounce name Allah correctly as an arab muslim. When he say Muslim believe Jews came from outer space is completely lie. He even speak English fluently.🤔
I believe what he says. Nothing fake. This is what they say in the mosques after Friday prayer. May Allah curse the Jews and Christians. I always tell my sons to ignore that and don't say Ameen.
I would like the hear you views on the son of the hamas leader who now utterly rejects his former ideology. Surely his views since he was literally born into it (islamism) are a valuable resource for people who truly want peace?.
One of the many problems surrounding this situation is that a land dispute is being conflated with a religious one. I really see no end to it, there's extremes on both sides who will never compromise.
There's no such thing as a Muslim who's anti-Palestinian and/or pro-Israel. That's basically just a munafiq/murtad/phony. Muslims can have many disagreements about many matters, but certain matters are the difference between having a baseline of Iman and engaging in outright Kufr.
The problem is that they identify as Muslims and many non Muslims see them as Muslims, and call them as such - which can be confusing to people who don't know these details
You are welcome to come to Israel and meet Israeli Muslims love their country and serve in the Supreme Court, parliament, government, hospitals and of course commanders in the IDF. There are so many Arab Muslims and Christians are fighting now in Gaza to protect the state of Israel. Many of them died during their military service. God bless their soul 🙏🏻
This is true and it was a mistake. Jews lived such an amazing life in Egypt and all over the arab world for a long time. Loads of beloved Egyptians actors were jews. Then comes Jamal Abd El Naser then creation of Israel then the expulsion of all the jews and the seize of all their belongings, definitely not just. But that doesn't mean Isreal is just.
Jews are not gypsies . It is our ancient land. We are praying for 2500 years to come home. We were granted a small country. And scince then we are attacked time after time. Do let us be and leave us alone
False, not all of them were forced since many of them were incentivied by economic oppurtunities, also it was pretty much a plot by the zionists to make the Mizrahi and other middle eastern jews migrate to the zionist country in order to repopulate and resettle the ethnically cleansed land from the 1948 war.
@@JosefSegal-qk5rg Well how about you leave my people alone? My home town is in Nablus in Palestine and its not JEWISH LAND ITS ARAB PALESTINIAN LAND! I dont care if your ancestors lived there 2500 years ago for the past centuries or millenia it belonged to my ancestors you have no right to take that away from them.
Scince U do not care - we do not care about u too... We can not live with 14 kilometers between U and SEA. Not scince 7/10. U are VERY WELCOME to return to Arabia.🤞🏻
I have not heard any of the bad things that the first bamboozeled goat told here, and i live in a place full of mad angry muftees. he was telling lies.
Wow. Fascinating and detailed deconstruction of these two videos. These highlight how wilful ignorance takes over and becomes not only damaging to the integrity of the individual, but creates division and perpetuates dangerous stereotypes. These people become 'useful idiots' for those who benefit from divisions our societies.
So you are saying William that the Muslim Brotherhood is not extremist but is considered a terrorist organization in Bahrain, Egypt, Russia, Saudi Arabia, Syria and the UAE?
These are countries who consider any kind of criticism of their government as terrorist. They even kill journalists. I'm not sure one can rely on such governments to provide a thorough analysis.
The second individual doesn't know basic History. Abraham's first born son is Ishmael who is the father of the Arabs. Israel is the land of the semitic people which includes jews and Arabs. He is a phony or an idiot to say that the Palestinian Arabs are not indigenous to the Judea.
So why the heck, are you ruling out the Jewish claim then? Why all the damn, fuss if you people admit that Jews have as much right there as Arabs. And it is not even, Arabs per say, but Arab muslims. It's RELIGION, that is causing this damn, mess, not issues over land, at all. Not really.
@@ivanj.conway9919 The jewish claim that any Jew from any corner of the planet can come and live on land that was taken from Palestinians who lived there for generations and had their homes bulldozed? That is what you are arguing for?
This sounds a very extreme views as you mentioned, he is using the same way of narration, used by those "ex-muslim" why I became Christian. Especially those talks about Taqia from their extreme perspective as every Muslim is practicing Taqia in the west, without even referred to the true meaning of Taqia. I'm 99% convinced and 100% believe that this is church production, mostly those evangelical pro israel associations/ churches.
The problem is that they identify as Muslims and many non Muslims see them as Muslims, and call them as such - which can be confusing to people who don't know these details
You've been very selective in what you've shown here ! Imam Tawhidi explains earlier why the Jews have a right to the land of Judea - indeed modern day Israel is a fraction of the land that was deemed theirs (included northern Egypt). He explains the covenant given by God, which is countenanced in the Quran. You have edited - so as to not include this. Furthermore, you state that the 49 countries who are deemed Muslim are Muslim as Christian countries are Christian. This is a disingenuous argument. First Islam is a political ideology, Christianity and others (Buddhism) are not. Christ said Give to Caesar that is Caesar and God that is God's. Many so called Chrustian countries have democracy - A Western system, developed by the ancient Greeks - nothing to do with Christianity. Sharia, present in most of the 49 Muslim countries is the legal system - which is Islamic. As far as I remember countries such as Iran are known as the Islamic Republic of Iran. You are playing with semantics here - they are Muslim countries! And I think you know this - so please be honest. It also might be that some Muslims (secretly maybe) are not antisemitic and respect the first people of the book. Perhaps also some may respect that Israel gives equality to women, homosexuals, Muslims (20% of Israelis are muslim) - who have the same rights and opportunities as Jewish folk. Palestine laws are not quite as progressive here. Maybe some muslims respect that Israel has chosen to develop science, technology and agriculture in a way that Palestine and other neighbouring states has chosen not to. And let's be honest here, both Israel and Palestine have received phenomenal amounts of money, but both peoples have chosen to use that money differently. Palestinian leaders live very luxurious muliti-millionaire lifestyles in Qatar and the likes Lastly many Muslim neighbouring states have concerns about the extreme elements in the Palestine populous. There have historic issues in Jordan, Lebanon and Egypt and for some Muslims, I suspect they may actually have misgivings of l both Israel and Palestine, though they would be wary of ilexpressing such views for fear of repercussions. Imam Tawhidi has had numerous death threats for not "toeing the line". As with most pro Palestine videos, your information is not as brazen as some, but is biased and selects information and discriminates.
50% of Israeli Jews are refugees from Arab Muslim countries like Egypt, Syria, Iraq etc. Muslim countries ethnically cleansed their Jews and therefore out of millions Jews in Muslim countries now we have a few thousands and in some countries just few Jews or even zero. The land of Israel is the land of the Jewish people for thousands of years even before the establishment of Islam. In the Quran it states that the land of Israel belongs to the nation of Israel, so all the Modern Palestinian propaganda is basically against Islam, against history and of course against the Jewish people and the state of Israel. Antisemitism in disguise here in your channel. So sad, but not surprising.
The Jewish left for Israel after the creation of Israel and in the case of Iraq by false flag bombing by Israelis to scare the Iraqi jews out. If you think the reason for this was Antisemitism, why were these jews living in these regions in the first place for 1400 years ? If Muslims wanted to kill all Jews living among them don't you think 1400 year is long enough to do that? Was there any verse in Quran that only came to light after 1948 that made Muslims hate Jews?
Great grand father of Prophet and Messenger Muhammad (Sallallahu alaihi wasallam), Hashim (Raliyallahu Anhu) is from Gaza. He is buried in Gaza. Palastine is the ancestral land of our Beloved leader. Simply it cannot be defeated nor the people will surrender. Palestine is the land of Brave Hearts.
5:08 this guy reminds me so much of Yeomni Park, the North Korean defector, and known liar paid by the state department. She made the same similar claims that in North Korea they dont have love for children or have a word for it. .. whenever I hear over the top ridiculous claims like this, I always think there is a monetary , or other perks attached. This is why international organizations dont take the word of defector testimonies as evidence, because they are usually influenced by powerful interests or intelligence agencies for a political agenda.
@@el_chico1313 two things can be true at once ya know. She can be a pathological liar, who hangs around swamp creatures like Mike Pompeio, and also North Korea can be not a great place to live. Are you seriously telling me you believe all her stories, like when the train would break down, everyone would push it, instead of just getting out and walking to work??? Or they play with dead rats? If you do, maybe look in a mirror, and that tells me more about you not wanting to hear anything you don't. 😂
New subscriber here. Muslim American. Great content. The world is big enough for all of us. With in this century we will be in space. I hate that they are fighting over something so small. Do they not see how big HaShem has made the universe?
Universe is very big yes. Earth is very small compared to it. It also makes us think are we the centre of creation. If we were, why are there stars so many light years away whose light don't even reach us and they have no affect on us. If world was made for us why are those stars and planets made.
@abhinavsingh3228 Quran 42:29 And among His signs is the creation of the heavens and the earth, and all living beings He dispersed throughout both. And He is Most Capable of bringing all together whenever He wills. This Ayat is interpreted as possible being Aliens. When Allah says heavens, he's referring to space. If he wills, he can join us and space creatures together. According to the Quran we are the middle of creation, not the center. Meaning Allah created creatures higher and lower than us. And he is still creating.
@@trustmebrobro yes brother. It would be more acceptable to all people if he also told about Neanderthals and other hominids whose dna continues in modern human to this day as they were ancestors at some point of time..
@abhinavsingh3228 Quran 17:70 And We have certainly honored the children of Adam and carried them on the land and sea and provided for them of the good things and preferred them over much of what We have created, with [definite] preference. They say this means with intellect. Allah is saying he created creatures like us before but not with the same intellect. Those mammals are gone. Have you read the Quran?
I am no sociologist and i am writing this comment while still at the start of the video. Irrational, intellectually deficient people (yes this is harsh but it is true) will position themselves on such topics based on emotional preferences that predetermine the outcome. The (pseudo)logical path that is then built to reconcile the predetermined outcome with previously adopted/proclaimed values/beliefs is usually a clumsy rationalization attempt that cannot survive the scrutiny of real rational debate. This explains the aggressiveness towards any attempt to rationally challenge such positionnings. This unfortunate pattern that sadly applies to so many topics other than the one at hand is at play when it comes to being for or against israel. Muslims are not excluded from being irrational on that topic. While most muslims will be emotionally biased towards being pro palestinian part of those who do not strongly identify to identities such as muslim or arab will have a positionning that is determined by other factors. The main factors that I can identify as being major causes of a pro-israeli bias are: - being a bully and thus identifying more with bullies than victims - having an inferiority complex towards a western world that is perceived as more "civilized" and more advanced - having a strong drive towards self serving positions combined with a belief that western states such as israel are impossible to challenge leading to submission being perceived as being the best positionment Everything mentioned in this comment only applies to understanding the positioning of people that are being sincere. Those who out of self interest choose to defend ideas they do not really believe in are out of topic.
The presenter is a really spreading hate. By calling Israelis the oppressors. You say that you are sociologist and you are against hate towards people and yet you spread hate, by suspecting that Imam gains financial gains out of his support of the right of Israel to exist, the way it does. He speaks with a wide spread knowledge of Islam, far more than the presenter. He, the Imam is an honest person he acknowledges the harsh face of Islam knowing also the history of harsh faces of other Abrahamic religious. The fact that he speaks freely and criticize the Islamic world is based on his knowledge both of the religion and the society of the Islamic differences.
I don't know where you get information from but since Ariel Sharon, the government has increasingly been oppressing some of its own Jewish citizens. It is very well documented and studied. It was never about religion.
@@williambarylo I am an Israeli, and I am also a student. Throughout the years I read a lot, I am also a witness of some of the information I was talking about, so that is where I get my information from. Oppression comes from a male society wherever, in particularly in the Arab society. I met Muslim women from whom I learned about the domestic oppression they are facing. 1) One of them, saw how are Jewish girls are being treated at home and society, so she decided to be a woman of free choice. Alas her brother has decided to limit her, to say the least... Yet he was not the only one. Other members of her family not brothers, threatened her life. So, she had to run away to Norway for a while. Something else she also told stories of how women are being oppressed in the Muslim society. 2) Another Muslim woman that I studied with, told me about another Muslim guy wanted her to become his fiancé when he was already engaged to another woman. She refused and as a result he would spread some false rumors about her, in order to defame her reputation. 3)A third one I met at the University told me in a conversation that her mother was terrified from her choice of study, she was afraid of somebody will heart her daughter for that. To say that it is not about religion, well I don't buy it. What happened in the 7-th of October had nothing to do with the Palestinian cause, it was religiously motivated. According to what the captured terrorists they were getting the blessings of Imams.
@@ylev100 Just like for all religions, many people who claim belonging to a certain religion don't follow or even know about the religion. All the observations you mentioned come from cultural practices in certain families - which are opposed to Islamic behaviour. Some people who identity as Muslim in India and Pakistan still use a caste system for example - while Islam came to abolish such divisions. What Hamas did was instrumentalise the religion to justify their actions - while Islam forbids the killing of civilians (killing one innocent is as if they would have killed the whole of humanity says the Qur'an).
@@williambarylo Imam Tawhidi has studied under many of the greatest Marjas at great length. You appear to be misunderstanding him. Maybe ask him to tell you about Islam. There is much to learn from him.
The host is not what he said he was. They were offered a state and they rejected and swears Islam. He does not a promoting peace just hiding behind so called sociology. Tell hamas to lay down their arms and talk peace.
Very informative. The Imam was parroting mainstream media points. Most of them don't know a law dictionary exists, like i didn't til 2015. Life & mind changer>>Black's Law dictionary, and editions matter.
@@deIsraelithe children of Israel were led out of Egypt to Palestine/Israel but it doesn’t mean they didn’t convert to Christianity and Islam. So the Palestinians (Muslims and Christians) are the also the children of Israel, isn’t it.
Very few know who these closet homosexuals are. Are you one of those closet homosexuals? I know they’re just dying to come out of the closet. Let them make things intolerable enough and they will surely start getting popped. They can be tracked through their bloodlines and exclusive associations with those who have publicly provable Sabbatean bloodlines. They’re mentioned in the Encyclopedia Britannica which is the most academically credible encyclopedia in the history of the English language. Former US Supreme Court Justice Louis Brandeis openly admitted to being a Sabbatean and that he and his wife had an arranged marriage because only Sabbateans can marry each other. Karl Marx is related to the Brandeis clan on record. You can find that on any genealogy website. It’s all public record. Princess Diana is a direct descendant of Jacob Frank through her mother going back to his daughter Leah Golda. This is also public genealogy record. The Encyclopedia Britannica is not a conspiracy theory publication. And aliens don’t exist. And everyone in Pizzagate wound up on Epstein island and CBS did a segment years ago connecting all these people to Princess Diana who is on record a direct descendant of Jacob Frank. Meghan Markle on record is related to Prince Harry through his grandfather going back to the Sabbateans of Salonica, Greece. Socialism, communism, anarchism, right wing nationalism, atheistic movement, agnostic movement, all came out of the Jacobin Society which was started by Jacob Frank’s family members, on record, who include Moses Dobruska and François Chabot. The LGBTQ movement was also founded by Sabbateans on record. These bloodlines are public record fool !! The Encyclopedia Britannica on the Sabbateans: “Shabbetaianism, in Judaism, a 17th-century messianic movement that, in its extreme form, espoused the sacredness of sin. The leader of the movement was Shabbetai Tzevi, a self-proclaimed messiah and charismatic mystic. Coerced by the sultan of Constantinople to accept Islam, Shabbetai Tzevi shocked and disillusioned many of his followers by proclaiming himself a Muslim.” “Other followers, interpreting Shabbetai Tzevi’s apostasy as a step toward ultimate fulfillment of his messiahship, also proclaimed themselves Muslims. They argued that such outward acts were irrelevant as long as one remains inwardly a Jew. Those who embraced the theory of “sacred sin” believed that the Torah (“Law” or “Teaching”) could be fulfilled only by its seeming annulment. Others felt they could remain faithful Shabbetaians without having to apostatize.” “After Shabbetai Tzevi’s death in 1676, the sect continued to flourish. The nihilistic tendencies of Shabbetaianism reached a peak in the 18th century with the false messiah Jacob Frank, who claimed to be Shabbetai Tzevi’s reincarnation and whose followers reputedly sought redemption through orgies at mystical festivals.” “Jacob Frank (born 1726, in Berezanka or Korolowka, Galicia, Pol. [now in Ukraine]-died Dec. 10, 1791, Offenbach, Hessen [Germany]) Jewish false messiah who claimed to be the reincarnation of Shabbetai Tzevi (1626-76). The most notorious of the false messiahs, he was the founder of the antirabbinical Frankist, or Zoharist, sect.” “Frank often traveled in the Balkans and there met followers of Shabbetai. An uneducated visionary, he appealed to many who awaited the resurrection of Shabbetai. In about 1751 he proclaimed himself the messiah and four years later, in Poland, formed a sect that held that certain elect persons are exempt from the moral law. This sect abandoned Judaism for a “higher Torah” (Jewish Law) based on the Zohar, which was the most important work in the Kabbala, the Jewish mystical movement. Hence its members also called themselves Zoharists. Their practices, including orgiastic, sexually promiscuous rites, led the Jewish community to ban them as heretics in 1756. Protected by Roman Catholic authorities, who saw in them a means of converting the Jews, the Frankists debated with representatives of the rabbinate and claimed that the Talmud, the rabbinical compendium of law and commentary, should be discarded as blasphemous. They were also partly responsible for the revival of the canard that the Jews use Christian blood for Passover rituals.” “In the meantime, to preserve his following, Frank publicly committed his supporters to mass baptism and was himself baptized in Warsaw, with Augustus III, king of Poland, acting as his godfather. The Frankists, however, continued their sectarian ways. As a result, the Inquisition imprisoned Frank in the fortress of Częstochowa (1760).” “Freed by the conquering Russians in 1773, he eventually settled in Offenbach, dubbing himself baron. His many followers supported him in a manner befitting the nobility. Upon Frank’s death, he was succeeded by his daughter Eve… descendants of those members who were baptized merged with the Roman Catholic population.” www.britannica.com/topic/Shabbetaianism www.britannica.com/biography/Jacob-Frank They have been in the Gaza Strip for 400 years on record. The False Prophet of Gaza of the False Messiah Shabbatai Tzvi, Nathan of Gaza according to the Encyclopedia Brittanica: “With a retinue of believers and assured of financial backing, Shabbetai triumphantly returned to Jerusalem. There, a 20-year-old student known as Nathan of Gaza assumed the role of a modern Elijah, in his traditional role of forerunner of the messiah. Nathan ecstatically prophesied the imminent restoration of Israel and world salvation through the bloodless victory of Shabbetai, riding on a lion with a seven-headed dragon in his jaws. In accordance with millenarian belief, he cited 1666 as the apocalyptic year.” “Threatened with excommunication by the rabbis of Jerusalem, Shabbetai returned to Smyrna in the autumn of 1665, where he was wildly acclaimed. His movement spread to Venice, Amsterdam, Hamburg, London, and several other European and North African cities.” “At the beginning of 1666, Shabbetai went to Constantinople and was imprisoned on his arrival. After a few months, he was transferred to the castle at Abydos, which became known to his followers as Migdal Oz, the Tower of Strength. In September, however, he was brought before the sultan in Adrianople and, having been previously threatened with torture, became converted to Islam. The placated sultan renamed him Mehmed Efendi, appointed him his personal doorkeeper, and provided him with a generous allowance.” www.britannica.com/biography/Nathan-of-Gaza www.newsweek.com/qanon-followers-defend-donald-trump-jeffrey-epstein-plane-ghislaine-maxwell-trial-1654823 www.washingtontimes.com/news/2015/aug/25/donald-trump-hillary-clinton-are-related-genealogy/
On the one hand the Internet is a great place for ideas, (self)help and making connections, and on the other - what a waste of space and time with the trash like this.
Can you please invite the wise Imam Tawhidi to your channel and engage him directly in respectful dialogue? There are hundreds of millions of liberal good muslims and this perspective is also valid,
The foundation of Zionism is Lurianic Kabbalah. You’re a gaslighting liar hahaha. The dogs who feel threatened bark the loudest. Hamas is not an Arabic word. It is the Biblical Hebrew for “VIOLENCE” (2 Samuel 2:3) and Bin Laden’s Kinda tribe used to be a Jewish kingdom and when the Zionism State was established a number of them fled to the Zionist State to claim asylum and citizenship stating they had been living as Crypto-Jews for centuries and this is public record. The Muslim Brotherhood was created by Hassan Al-Banna who on record was from a Sabbatean Jewish family from Morocco who was financed according to his own testimony by the same British government that founded the Zionist State who are Sabbateans genealogically. This isn’t even a theory. These are all facts. 9/11 hijacker Ziad Al-Jarrah had a cousin who was an Israeli Mossad spy named Ali Al-Jarrah. Public record. www.britannica.com/biography/Isaac-ben-Solomon-Luria#ref163234
The Imam cannot become an Imam without studying and getting the license to become an Imam from recognized and authorized institution. So, the presenter should have a minimum decency in contradicting what he says.
@@williambarylo But you need some authorization. I have been listening and watching some of his conversations with non-Muslims in a mixed audience Muslims and non-Muslims.
@@ylev100 you might need an authorisation if you want to teach (in places like Egypt or Saudi); however anyone who once leads a prayer is an "imam", and any mosque can appoint anyone as an imam - which sadly makes lots of people claim the title for all sorts of purposes.
Disregarding everything, the concept of govt making peace with an entity as if it applies to the people, as in the Abrahamic accord, imagine if some govt made an act as to eliminate racism or abandon feminism or communistic people, how can the govt possibly enforce it on the people? The govt may do it on its own, but how can it force the people individually to play along? 5ake the racism thing. So let's abandon racism, okay but how can you make the people do it on their own, let alone by mere ink on paper? I'm not discussing the morality of the accord, but merely using it as a command to the public is so nonsensical, even if it were to a good cause.
First impressions in first two mins (not finished vid yet) just the way the presenter of the first video was talking makes the whole thing seem fake propaganda against Muslims and Palestinians, especially from the ‘pro-Israel Palestinian’ when he said he was taught ridiculous things about Jewish people in kuwaití school. I mean come on, seems hard to believe that this is real, but Allah knows best, may Allah grant the Palestinians victory soon, Amin
@@williambarylo i’ve noticed your subscribers increasing, which makes me really happy as it is well deserved for great content. And it would be great to see your discussion series come back with your spouse that was really great as well.
They might be attention seeker who gets paid for doing these stuff but the point here is that innocent people gets deceived by them and it's important to spread caution
@riab3591 you always have the responsibility to help others if possible, then you leave the rest on the hand of Allah (swt). The thing is that many people still fall for israeli media, so if one of them comes accross this video by any chance, that might serve the purpose of making the video in the first place.
As I mentioned in the video, when your job is to find solutions, you first need to diagnose the problem and understand how it works. And this is what pays my bills.
William, Did you say Muslims do not represent religion ? Although you have a doctor title, you are not fully educated about the Middle East . The imam of peace is one of a kind. And you don’t understand what he’s talking about.
Yeah you're right maybe ISIS represents Islam, Trump represents Christianity, Netanyahy represents Judaism and the military of Myanmar represent Buddhism
It's not me, the current analysis of the movement shows it has become unrecognisable from its extreme beginnings. They are angels compared to most Arab regimes the US is currently calling "friends" like Saudi Arabia
yeah/nah clear bias sorry good luck promoting Islamist propaganda, it always surprises me that reverts are always the craziest in the end. FYI I grew up exclusively with Muslims in Dagestan, and it is unrecognizable now because of Islamist ideology, I used to be idealistic, believed in the peaceful Muslim majority, and separated Islamists from Muslims, etc until I saw those same Muslims who would break bread with non-Muslims one day and then point out their house to Islamist the next day. All the real peace-loving Muslims get treated like infidels and have to cover their identity from their Ummah for safety reasons that's why there are so few left, instead of looking in the mirror you always look for someone to blame. The majority of you do not acknowledge crimes that are committed by Muslims on non-Muslims and on Muslims and you judge Muslims who want peace like the people in this video. And start claiming insane things like they are getting paid to stand for coexistence. The Jew hatred is inherent in Islam unfortunately and the hatred of non-Muslims in general. Even Islamic hospitality which I love comes from a very dark place historically speaking @@williambarylo
Dear Dr William, Assalamualaikum. Please don't waste your time on these people. Nobody takes them seriously except those who already support israel for other reasons. They are paid agents. DON'T GIVE THEM MORE PUBLICITY
Wa alaykum salaam It's possible they're paid a lot but not many non Muslims (or new Muslims) know about that. My job is to diagnose problems and find solutions and the first step is to analyse and understand these problems
I think dr. Barylo is giving us tools to handle these kind of Muslims and that is needed. Personally I think these people will not end well after having probably enjoyd some time with material benefits from this mumble jumble.
Faith Bismillahiir ArRahmaanhir ArRahiim May Allah help us rid ourselves of the hypocrites and the arrogant. May we act in only those ways that please Him so that those people are never allowed to return to power in this world even as they will be removed from power in the next. 9. التوبة: 9. at-Taubah: Repentance 32 يُرِيدُونَ أَن يُطْفِـُٔوا۟ نُورَ ٱللَّهِ بِأَفْوَهِهِمْ وَيَأْبَى ٱللَّهُ إِلَّآ أَن يُتِمَّ نُورَهُۥ وَلَوْ كَرِهَ ٱلْكَفِرُونَ 32 Fain would they put out the light of Allah with their mouths, but Allah disdaineth (aught) save that He shall perfect His light, however much the disbelievers are averse. 33 هُوَ ٱلَّذِىٓ أَرْسَلَ رَسُولَهُۥ بِٱلْهُدَىٰ وَدِينِ ٱلْحَقِّ لِيُظْهِرَهُۥ عَلَى ٱلدِّينِ كُلِّهِۦ وَلَوْ كَرِهَ ٱلْمُشْرِكُونَ 33 He it is Who hath sent His messenger with the guidance and the Religion of Truth, that He may cause it to prevail over all religion, however much the idolaters may be averse. 41 ٱنفِرُوا۟ خِفَافًۭا وَثِقَالًۭا وَجَهِدُوا۟ بِأَمْوَلِكُمْ وَأَنفُسِكُمْ فِى سَبِيلِ ٱللَّهِ ۚ ذَلِكُمْ خَيْرٌۭ لَّكُمْ إِن كُنتُمْ تَعْلَمُونَ 41 Go forth, light-armed and heavy-armed, and strive with your wealth and your lives in the way of Allah! That is best for you if ye but knew. 42 لَوْ كَانَ عَرَضًۭا قَرِيبًۭا وَسَفَرًۭا قَاصِدًۭا لَّٱتَّبَعُوكَ وَلَكِنۢ بَعُدَتْ عَلَيْهِمُ ٱلشُّقَّةُ ۚ وَسَيَحْلِفُونَ بِٱللَّهِ لَوِ ٱسْتَطَعْنَا لَخَرَجْنَا مَعَكُمْ يُهْلِكُونَ أَنفُسَهُمْ وَٱللَّهُ يَعْلَمُ إِنَّهُمْ لَكَذِبُونَ 42 Had it been a near adventure and an easy journey they had followed thee, but the distance seemed too far for them. Yet they will swear by Allah (saying): If we had been able we would surely have set out with you. They destroy their souls, and Allah knoweth that they verily are liars. 45 إِنَّمَا يَسْتَـْٔذِنُكَ ٱلَّذِينَ لَا يُؤْمِنُونَ بِٱللَّهِ وَٱلْيَوْمِ ٱلْءَاخِرِ وَٱرْتَابَتْ قُلُوبُهُمْ فَهُمْ فِى رَيْبِهِمْ يَتَرَدَّدُونَ 45 They alone ask leave of thee who believe not in Allah and the Last Day, and whose hearts feel doubt, so in their doubt they waver. 49 وَمِنْهُم مَّن يَقُولُ ٱئْذَن لِّى وَلَا تَفْتِنِّىٓ ۚ أَلَا فِى ٱلْفِتْنَةِ سَقَطُوا۟ ۗ وَإِنَّ جَهَنَّمَ لَمُحِيطَةٌۢ بِٱلْكَفِرِينَ 49 Of them is he who saith: Grant me leave (to stay at home) and tempt me not. Surely it is into temptation that they (thus) have fallen. Lo! hell verily is all around the disbelievers. 50 إِن تُصِبْكَ حَسَنَةٌۭ تَسُؤْهُمْ ۖ وَإِن تُصِبْكَ مُصِيبَةٌۭ يَقُولُوا۟ قَدْ أَخَذْنَآ أَمْرَنَا مِن قَبْلُ وَيَتَوَلَّوا۟ وَّهُمْ فَرِحُونَ 50 If good befalleth thee (O Muhammad) it afflicteth them, and if calamity befalleth thee, they say: We took precaution, and they turn away well pleased. 51 قُل لَّن يُصِيبَنَآ إِلَّا مَا كَتَبَ ٱللَّهُ لَنَا هُوَ مَوْلَىٰنَا ۚ وَعَلَى ٱللَّهِ فَلْيَتَوَكَّلِ ٱلْمُؤْمِنُونَ 51 Say: Naught befalleth us save that which Allah hath decreed for us. He is our Protecting Friend. In Allah let believers put their trust! 52 قُلْ هَلْ تَرَبَّصُونَ بِنَآ إِلَّآ إِحْدَى ٱلْحُسْنَيَيْنِ ۖ وَنَحْنُ نَتَرَبَّصُ بِكُمْ أَن يُصِيبَكُمُ ٱللَّهُ بِعَذَابٍۢ مِّنْ عِندِهِۦٓ أَوْ بِأَيْدِينَا ۖ فَتَرَبَّصُوٓا۟ إِنَّا مَعَكُم مُّتَرَبِّصُونَ 52 Say: Can ye await for us aught save one of two good things (death or victory in Allah's way) ? while we await for you that Allah will afflict you with a doom from Him or at our hands. Await then! Lo! We are awaiting with you.
It is so clear that he is lying, acting, look how they make video , it is like a movie, he get paid some how, Muslim in Kuwait don’t teach their children, what he is saying, those guys get paid to say this things,
@@williambarylo i understand, but i have never heard any Muslim from any part of the world saying "i am a moslim" . And after watching many IDF's propaganda videos, i find it impossible to give them benefit of the doubt.
I did not understand what you are or who you are...but Israel did not conquer anything...the Israelites returned to the Holy Land as written in the Bible
Btw this guy I believe is not an Arab or I could be wrong, he’s either iraqi or Iranian or maybe Iraqi born in Iran some thing like this I forgot it been very long ago I’m frm Afghanistan our community is not big in the west
@@williambarylo Ho, and there is not even a slight chance that his arguments are valid? The bottom line of this video, If you don't see things the way Mark do, something must be wrong with you.
@@iditbes6962 Mark's approach is really good because it draws from a personal story. The imam uses irrelevant arguments and incorrect theological points. It's good if he wants to befriend supporters of Israel but without a good command of theology he's not gonna convince any Muslim, that's maybe why he's not very popular in Muslim circles. If he can't convince his target audience, he's not being a good ally to Israel.
I don't believe this guy is not Palestinian and definitely not Muslim that's why I'm not to continue watching the video , I don't understand why you give a voice to these imposters
Dear Dr. William, you are delusional. Of course this conflict has a huge religious component! It is about reconquering dar al Islam considered a Waqf to the Muslims which can't be governed by infidels. If you ignore that you ignore the core of the conflict. It makes little difference if you create the 23rd or the 24th Arabs state, but it makes a huge difference if you destroy the only Jewish state because it is on Muslim land
In 1982, a prominent Israeli strategic analyst, Avner Yaniv, coined the term “Palestinian peace offensive” to describe the risk that Palestinians would become too moderate politically and Israel would be forced to make concessions. He urged using the "fiercest military pressures" against the PLO in Lebanon to undermine Palestinian moderates and make the PLO more hardline in order "to halt its rise to political respectability". How do you explain this statement? If it was about religion than why moderate Palestinians were a problem for Israel?
First time I see the "muslim" named Mark.
Me too!! However, I have Palestinian Muslim friends who have given western sounding names to their kids like Jude, and apparently it's a genuine Arabic name, so I gave it the benefit of the doubt. Or maybe like some reverts, he's changed his birth name
@@ayudroid3568Hude or Jude i canfused
@@williambarylo Jude is an Arabic word
It's a form of generosity!!
He probably changed it after converting to judaism.
@@ayudroid3568Mark is a christian Jews..
lol. What Muslim thinks that Jews came from space. Claiming to be Muslim, with this premise, alone, is bad enough.
The guy was obviously paid to say that, nothing about him seem genuine
It's completely possible. Some make huge money out of it
i heard they paid 5 grands just to change side
Imam Tawhidi is a clown and not a real Imam. He is a Zionist lap dog disguised as a an Imam.
It is definitely about religion, in the Middle East, life is completely different, mindsets are different! I lived there and saw it! Because your study is in the west, your mindset is not the same!
If war was a religious commandment, everyone on Earth would be dead already
@@williambaryloThis not religious. The Palestinians aren't even Muslim. Anyone who has hate for someone enough to kill them is not Muslim.
Who else is Muslim and supports Israel like me?
The genie in Aladdin
You must be intelligent enough to under Stand Israel.
I am Palestinian. However, I am a descendant of Abdurrahman, the son of Zaid, the son of the second Kalif Omar (may Allah be pleased with him). So, I am basically a Quraishite. If we want to talk about ethnics, I couldn't be more of an Arab. These claims that Palestinians were not Arabs but they were Aramaic etc... This assumption is stupid. Of course you have people of Aramaic origins. But the people have been interacially mixed. Most of the Aramaic people became Muslims centuries ago. And even back then, several tribes in the levant were ethnically Arabs like the Nabataians and th Ghassanides. And nevertheless, the people of the whole region speak nearly exclusively Arabic. The ethnicity argument is extremely dumb.
Completely agree. He doesn't know what he's talking about
Many Palestinians believe they are direct descendants of Arabian tribes from the time of Mohammed. I hate to poop your party , but this is very common in nations where the dominant religion shifts. The local people who have adopted the religion want to appear to be closer to the source, and so genealogical connections are made, family names are changed, etc. When Ireland (my own country) converted to Christianity a myth evolved that claimed the original Celtic tribe that colonised Ireland was connected to the lost tribes of Israel lol.
Can I please ask what country you were born in and if you were also raised there?
@@williambarylo brother we see only extremist views in the comments, the history is different, there were minority of Arabs in the 7th century , the indigenous population were present they were Christians" jews"then the khalif Oumar brought the jews in the land. After islam spread most christians and jews became muslims thats y we have more Muslims than Jews n Christians as religion the people's ethnicity remains the same so majorities people r the indigenous population were present present there already just there religion change from judaism n Christianity to islam . And we the muslims gave protection to the people whatever their religions were n they flourished under islam for minimum a millenia.
I'm i correct my brother...?
@@williambarylo AND i agree with you this "imam" is an arm of the colonialists tool of propaganda . His name is 'imam tawhidi' he's a Shia and a so called islam reformist and twisting history like the Zionist colonialists entity. Look for his content you'll understand Bi izhnillah
You are welcome to come to Israel and meet Israeli Muslims love their country and serve in the Supreme Court, parliament, government, hospitals and of course as commanders in the IDF. There are so many Arab Muslims and Christians fighting right now in Gaza to protect the state of Israel. Many of them died during their military service. God bless their soul 🙏🏻
😂
All the Arab Israelis would leave Israel once given the chance. I met dozens of them in Germany.
I'm sure they don't agree with the IDF targeting and neglecting Israeli hostages
@@williambarylo ...as I'm sure you are not such an impartial scholar, sorry but you have "built" the whole video to demonstrate what you already think to know, and statistic or other "tools" are not so useful as the Italian poet Trilussa has told in poem, statistic is that science that gives a chicken even to whom doesn't have one. Understanding pro-Israel Muslim? The video is merely a "parade" of to cases and, as you surely know being a scholar, it's not correct to derive a law from some isolated case. Working with Israel I have know eminent Jews and Arabs having prominent job and social positions. Many pro-Palestine Arabs questioned about who have to manage Palestine if they win the war say obviously Jews, they have created a social security system, education, economic system everything, in the Arab countries we have just inequality and poverty, following your analytical scheme should I believe them? I'm a pro-Israel, yes, indeed.
@@MJMilano7 No you are completely wrong.
@@reuterromain1054 I met at least a dozen in Germany. They are all seeking the German passport and would never go back.
We didnt know any Jewish or Israelis because we are geographically located in Asia & also after 1948, Malaysia boycotted Israel. But I had an opportunity to live overseas in China & for the first time ever, we met a family of Israelis. They were not friendly at first. I think they are afraid of us because we are Muslim. But I learned about how Prophet Muhammad s.a.w. treated his blind jewish neighbor good even though she always cursed the prophet (unbeknownst that he was the prophet)… hence I tried my best to put away the feelings of Israel vs Palestinians conflict.
My son Muhammad & their son Yuval was so close that the boy stopped eating pork because Muhammad told him he doesnt eat pork
The prophet peace be upon him did not forbid us to be nice with those who aren't a clear enemy of the muslims. Anyone who is an open zionist is an enemy of Muslims so we cannot have sympathy to them
Jews don't eat pork@@aidomuah
You sound as a wise person. Jews are not afraid of Muslims , they just don’t trust them, especially the Arab Jews who lived for centuries in Arab countries , and was treated as slaves and inhuman, and suffer atrocities by Muslims . They were kicked out and everything they had was taken from them.
@@aidomuahPor que vocês copiaram os judeus que não come carne de porco
The way that the first individual says ameen gives him away as a non muslim. No Arab pronounces ameen the way this man does, he sounds jewish and not muslim. Listen to the inflection of his voice as it does not emphasize the "e's" in Ameen. He can't even say the word "Muslim" with an s, he says Muzlim. This guys is completely fake.
It's highly possible
His father had Jordanian citizenship . Jordon was the western part of the "Palestinian Territory" until 1946 , Why didn't they stay in Jordon . ?
Because my land is in Nablus west bank not Jordan, we wont relocate because Jews said so.
That Imam for peace is not a Muslim he has been exposed previously. So please do better research when putting someone as Muslim .
The problem is that he identifies as a Muslim - he uses the title "imam" - and many consider him as a Muslim. There's no way for the average outside person to know - just like Sajid Javid in the UK. Many UK Muslims still consider him Muslim
@@williambarylo true but it's very very very easy to see that he's not Muslim when you take a quick look at who is this guy.
@@HappyBloke81 I'm a revert and I've been confused by these kind of guys in the past. Part of my intention is that other new Muslims don't fall into the same traps as me!
@@williambarylo ma sha Allah. Good on you!! You're trying your best.
İf you come across such characters in the future, just type in for example "Imam tawheedi exposed" . Some of these people may not have been exposed yet but I only mentioned him and not the other guy because literally any search of the tawheedi guy brings up red flags.
You keep doing you bro. Allah is the one who guides. ♥️
@@williambarylothe Turks have a saying "not everyone with a beard is a Hajji (someone who has performed hajj)."
I know he gets propped up by the western media the same media that also works for the Zionist Israel. He is always talking to an empty room.
You're doing the right thing, I apologize. Everyone is at a different point in their journey. I made through these types very quickly.
[Re-Upload as previous version had no sound]
Hey Trolls! Every comment on this video makes the algorithm reshare this video to 10 more accounts, so thank you very much for helping more people watch it.
For the others, 2 points:
1. Many of you say they are kuffars and sellouts belonging to some sect. The problem is that they identify as Muslims (or imam!) and many non Muslims see them as Muslims (as they are given huge platform in the media and governments) - which can be confusing to non-Muslims or new Reverts to Islam who don't know these details.
2. Analysing these discourses is torture for me, but it's my paid job at uni. The reason for that is that to find solutions, you first need to diagnose and understand the problems you want to solve. And part of it also to give clarity to all those who are confused by this kind of people
Brother, i think most of them are from Qadiani kafir and shia kafir background and not from Muslim backgorund
@@jackjack-sh7uy the problem is that they identify as Muslims and many non Muslims see them as Muslims, and call them as such - which can be confusing to people who don't know these details
What do you mean with Shia Kafir background ?
Only God Almighty is to say who is a Muslim nobody has right to practice Takfirism. Not only in Ahmadiyya case in Neobandis Naqshbandis and other groups in Islam.
@@Johanna-Rogier-AwadShia are from Iran and Lebanon compared with Sunnis that follow Sunnah. Shias follow Ali a.s Fátima ra husband the son in law of the Prophet.
Yeah, we all know about the love Muslims have for Jews. There is not a single opportunity that they would miss to show their deep love, affection and understanding for the Jews. It is very obvious and we see it all the time.
lul
Lol😅
LOL and we know how peace is an invention of Hamas, Iran and Qatar and their supporters like the UN.
@@williambarylo The word "Peace" in Arabic, roughly translates as : G-had....;-)
@@liviuconstantin9960 No idiot it means Salam, if you dont speak arabic then dont embarras yourself and show yourself to be the r*tard that you are.
What about Palestinian state? Well that’s a tricky question isn’t it, after losing three wars and rejecting at least 3 peace deals, what about a Palestinian state, you tell me
Anyone Who leaves Islam Is a Hero.
Leaving or accepting any religion is not heroic, it's a personal journey
3:00 I can't take things like this seriously. These are blatant lies. The extremity of what he's saying is cringe to even suggest people thought like this. Keep in mind he said this is what they were taught in school. I mean really, who would believe this? Muslim haters with no ability to think critically. I mean at this point the video was a parody.
What do I make of this? He's paid. They found some Arab or Arab looking person, paid him to paint a certain image for the audience. Quite simple. I am from Morocco and the sht I hear (like Rachid from the PBD podcast) are all lies. Talking about how they view Christians and prohibit them from exercising their religion, how they are hated on. All of that is propaganda that they are paid to spread. Everyone that visits or has been to these areas know this quite well, the issue is the people that haven't are quick to believe "the other side is quite barbaric".
It's very similar to what these "ex Muslims" are saying when they're invited everywhere by the media
This is your answer. Of course, ANYTHING, other than admitting that islam with all it's sick craziness, is the WRONG, path. I swear, you people take twisting and distorting truth and out and out lies to a damn, high art form. I don't trust a damn, thing to come out of your mouths anymore. You sicken me, all of you.
Another bogus Hollywood production
Can you show me a thriving Jewish, Christian, Yazidi or Zoroastrian population in any Muslim nation?.
I understand that UNRWA teaches that to the little ones in Gaza and the teaching materials endorsing has been exposed.
The east ankle of Jordan also bong to thr Hebrews (the rest 10 tribes of israel) all thr Rabs tLk about subjects yhT they do not have enough true informatiomTion about.
The imam talk nonsenc. The countty need first a sivil moral and jusgic common law (not religion)
They don't look like a Muslims. Israel has their people, probably one of them
We never know. But I'm sure they enjoy a good career and lots of money
The best bet for anyone wishing to leave their religion be it Muslim, Judaism, or Christianity is to convert to secular humanism. Every time one of those mythical power brokers, be it Allah, Jehovah, or Jesus gets involved, nothing but war and mayhem.
Same with any ideology and philosophy. It's about how people interpret them
What is the argument in favor of the muslim brotherhood? Hamas? Why is their version of islam preferable to other more liberal interpretations of islam?
They're not worse or better, they have a different approach. People are stuck with the initial brotherhood as designed by Qutb as a response to colonial rule, which was absolutely horrendous. Now, the movement has become pacifists and moved their priorities towards social justice and democracy as seen with the Tunisian and Egyptian elections as their main goal is to end dictatorships and install democracy. However, they were no match for the Egyptian army and because of their non violent approach, they were easily crushed. Since the coup, many think the movement has become irrelevant. Compared to other islamicate political movements which want a theocracy, they are fairly Liberal as many of the newer generations have a western education. Hamas is completely different in terms of goals and priorities. And they have an armed branch
There are no liberal islam , the text is clear and can't be interpreted like the bible .
The west put some scum as leaders and the ppl don't want them
Our islam should never be liberalised to look good for nobody nor should it be made extreme for anybody. Anyone who veers towards extremes in religion is an extremist abd innovator. If they insist on that path they aren't muslim anymore. Sick and tired of people attempting to pacify Islam or make it war like religion when it's not
@@frozone1973True the Palestinians aren't Muslims since many of them have hate.
I am an ardent supporter of Palestinians. But I don't hate the Jewish people as such because Rasulullah sallalahu alaihi wasallam has had friendly relationship with Jewish people who he came in contact with. His visiting a Jewish child who was sick and praying for his health is well known. Those Jewish people who became Muslims were not in any way considered different from other Muslims just because they were descendants of Israeel. Apart from this in today's world, my disagreement is only with the Zionists who are mostly atheists and who I think do not abide by the commandments of God as conveyed to them via Moses and other prophets all of who are Prophets of Islam also. So many Jewish people belonging to the Neturai Kerta sect and large number of anti Zionist Jewish people including intellectuals, authors and journalists who decry the injustice done to the Palestinian people are Jews I hugely respect for their humanity.
What is the experience of Christians in Gaza?
Israeli government does not recognise they exist. The other day they bombed a church and snipers shot three or two women, and their response was there is no Christians in Gaza. So their experience is worse than being hate, they simply don't even count.
There are only 1000 of them
@@jimmyalloul Why is that?
Go watch tucker
Not a good one
May Allah guide Imam Tawhidi. It appears that he has a political agenda. We as Muslims accept all prophets so his argument is extremely weak.
Well observed!!
He is right about Palestinians are not Arab. Palestinians were colonized by several empire like Greece, Ottoman (Turkey), Roman, etc just like Israel. Palestinian language was different. Palestinians now speak Arabic because of forced conversion to Islam by Ottoman empire. It is very sad that the Arab, Turkish, and Iranian leaders are using Palestinians for their own twisted agenda. These leaders are all competing to control the area of Jerusalem that has historical significance. Very sad how these leaders are making Palestine and Israel fight. The people of Palestine and Israel need to wake up and make peace with each other and kick out those greedy competing leaders.
Thank you for educating us!! we don't get those type of comments very often! I'm pro-peace and I want both sides to solve the conflict and I think that both sides will get great benefit if more people stay in the side of peace instead of adding more to the conflict.
Lolz . Palestinians now speak Arabic because of forced conversion to islam by ottoman empire? What about other countries that embraced islam like Pakistan, iran, Indonesia, Malaysia etc. how come they didn't start speaking Arabic after Islam but Palestinians did.
He can't even pronounce name Allah correctly as an arab muslim. When he say Muslim believe Jews came from outer space is completely lie. He even speak English fluently.🤔
Many red flags indeed
Why shouldn't muslims be pro israel?
Many of them are, and even serving in the IDF
Did he reflect on why he was refugee in Kuwait?
Im very sceptical of his sincerity, I suspect he's an Israeli actor.
It could be!
It’s always good to hear from another Sociologist viewpoint.
its great to see not all muslims have lost their common sense, slava🇮🇱
I believe what he says. Nothing fake. This is what they say in the mosques after Friday prayer. May Allah curse the Jews and Christians. I always tell my sons to ignore that and don't say Ameen.
This is crazy!
That is sooo not anything an Imam would say in a masjid 🤦♀️ this is beyond fake.
But he got people to listen to him. and probably offer him a huge salary
your options are not BIAS if you were really a "Professor"
Even scientists in physics and maths have bias and subjectivities. And I'm not a professor.
I would like the hear you views on the son of the hamas leader who now utterly rejects his former ideology.
Surely his views since he was literally born into it (islamism) are a valuable resource for people who truly want peace?.
It sounds like the first person in the video. People brought up in very rigorous or constraining environments often end up rejecting them
One of the many problems surrounding this situation is that a land dispute is being conflated with a religious one.
I really see no end to it, there's extremes on both sides who will never compromise.
There's no such thing as a Muslim who's anti-Palestinian and/or pro-Israel. That's basically just a munafiq/murtad/phony.
Muslims can have many disagreements about many matters, but certain matters are the difference between having a baseline of Iman and engaging in outright Kufr.
The problem is that they identify as Muslims and many non Muslims see them as Muslims, and call them as such - which can be confusing to people who don't know these details
You are welcome to come to Israel and meet Israeli Muslims love their country and serve in the Supreme Court, parliament, government, hospitals and of course commanders in the IDF. There are so many Arab Muslims and Christians are fighting now in Gaza to protect the state of Israel. Many of them died during their military service. God bless their soul 🙏🏻
@@leab2039he prefers to live with the stories he tells himself instead.
Hello Doc, I encourage you to study some history and go to the land of Israel, both Jewish and Arab parts before you form an opinion.
At some point I'll maybe visit
U forgot 1 million jews were forced to live Arab and muslim countries!
U ALWAYS ignore this point
This is true and it was a mistake. Jews lived such an amazing life in Egypt and all over the arab world for a long time. Loads of beloved Egyptians actors were jews. Then comes Jamal Abd El Naser then creation of Israel then the expulsion of all the jews and the seize of all their belongings, definitely not just. But that doesn't mean Isreal is just.
Jews are not gypsies .
It is our ancient land. We are praying for 2500 years to come home.
We were granted a small country. And scince then we are attacked time after time.
Do let us be and leave us alone
False, not all of them were forced since many of them were incentivied by economic oppurtunities, also it was pretty much a plot by the zionists to make the Mizrahi and other middle eastern jews migrate to the zionist country in order to repopulate and resettle the ethnically cleansed land from the 1948 war.
@@JosefSegal-qk5rg Well how about you leave my people alone? My home town is in Nablus in Palestine and its not JEWISH LAND ITS ARAB PALESTINIAN LAND! I dont care if your ancestors lived there 2500 years ago for the past centuries or millenia it belonged to my ancestors you have no right to take that away from them.
Scince U do not care - we do not care about u too...
We can not live with 14 kilometers between U and SEA. Not scince 7/10.
U are VERY WELCOME to return to Arabia.🤞🏻
I have not heard any of the bad things that the first bamboozeled goat told here, and i live in a place full of mad angry muftees. he was telling lies.
Me neither!
3rd video i've watched in a row. Fantastic content, sir.
Thank you!
love your content, keep it up you can easily become very successful.
Thank you
Wow. Fascinating and detailed deconstruction of these two videos. These highlight how wilful ignorance takes over and becomes not only damaging to the integrity of the individual, but creates division and perpetuates dangerous stereotypes. These people become 'useful idiots' for those who benefit from divisions our societies.
Exactly. And when governments pay them salaries they can't refuse...
The first person is Zionist pretending to be an ex Muslims the second person pretend self claim Imam
So you are saying William that the Muslim Brotherhood is not extremist but is considered a terrorist organization in Bahrain, Egypt, Russia, Saudi Arabia, Syria and the UAE?
These are countries who consider any kind of criticism of their government as terrorist. They even kill journalists. I'm not sure one can rely on such governments to provide a thorough analysis.
And since when you consider these type of govs something to believe a word from them
The second individual doesn't know basic History. Abraham's first born son is Ishmael who is the father of the Arabs. Israel is the land of the semitic people which includes jews and Arabs. He is a phony or an idiot to say that the Palestinian Arabs are not indigenous to the Judea.
Maybe he's paid to be confused on purpose!
@@williambarylo I believe you are correct! Thank you for your work Dr. Barylo and peace be upon you.
So why the heck, are you ruling out the Jewish claim then? Why all the damn, fuss if you people admit that Jews have as much right there as Arabs. And it is not even, Arabs per say, but Arab muslims. It's RELIGION, that is causing this damn, mess, not issues over land, at all. Not really.
@@ivanj.conway9919 The jewish claim that any Jew from any corner of the planet can come and live on land that was taken from Palestinians who lived there for generations and had their homes bulldozed? That is what you are arguing for?
Palestinian christians are suffering under zionism as well, and the palestinian jews fought against the zionist jews.
Money can make hypocracy easy - but the Angel of Death will make a barrier of no return with the money and then regrets begin eternally.
Am Yisrael Chai
Le maître de Chai
Tawhidi is a clown. Not an Imam. No certification from any reputable institution.
Indeed
They aren't Muslim.
Nowadays anyone can "identify" as Muslim
Why Airquotes bro?
@@mri8517 because it's the big trend right now
@williambarylo again spot on. May allah bless your Efforts. Your Commentary and Analysis are needed.
This sounds a very extreme views as you mentioned, he is using the same way of narration, used by those "ex-muslim" why I became Christian. Especially those talks about Taqia from their extreme perspective as every Muslim is practicing Taqia in the west, without even referred to the true meaning of Taqia.
I'm 99% convinced and 100% believe that this is church production, mostly those evangelical pro israel associations/ churches.
Exactly! These ex-Muslims sound similar
Some of them are Qadyani aka Ahmediya not real Muslims they follow some guy called Mirza as a prophet
The problem is that they identify as Muslims and many non Muslims see them as Muslims, and call them as such - which can be confusing to people who don't know these details
You've been very selective in what you've shown here ! Imam Tawhidi explains earlier why the Jews have a right to the land of Judea - indeed modern day Israel is a fraction of the land that was deemed theirs (included northern Egypt). He explains the covenant given by God, which is countenanced in the Quran. You have edited - so as to not include this. Furthermore, you state that the 49 countries who are deemed Muslim are Muslim as Christian countries are Christian. This is a disingenuous argument. First Islam is a political ideology, Christianity and others (Buddhism) are not. Christ said Give to Caesar that is Caesar and God that is God's. Many so called Chrustian countries have democracy - A Western system, developed by the ancient Greeks - nothing to do with Christianity. Sharia, present in most of the 49 Muslim countries is the legal system - which is Islamic. As far as I remember countries such as Iran are known as the Islamic Republic of Iran. You are playing with semantics here - they are Muslim countries! And I think you know this - so please be honest. It also might be that some Muslims (secretly maybe) are not antisemitic and respect the first people of the book. Perhaps also some may respect that Israel gives equality to women, homosexuals, Muslims (20% of Israelis are muslim) - who have the same rights and opportunities as Jewish folk. Palestine laws are not quite as progressive here. Maybe some muslims respect that Israel has chosen to develop science, technology and agriculture in a way that Palestine and other neighbouring states has chosen not to. And let's be honest here, both Israel and Palestine have received phenomenal amounts of money, but both peoples have chosen to use that money differently. Palestinian leaders live very luxurious muliti-millionaire lifestyles in Qatar and the likes Lastly many Muslim neighbouring states have concerns about the extreme elements in the Palestine populous. There have historic issues in Jordan, Lebanon and Egypt and for some Muslims, I suspect they may actually have misgivings of l both Israel and Palestine, though they would be wary of ilexpressing such views for fear of repercussions. Imam Tawhidi has had numerous death threats for not "toeing the line". As with most pro Palestine videos, your information is not as brazen as some, but is biased and selects information and discriminates.
I find Mark much more convincing than Tawhidi
imam Tawhidi is right
No he's Left
50% of Israeli Jews are refugees from Arab Muslim countries like Egypt, Syria, Iraq etc. Muslim countries ethnically cleansed their Jews and therefore out of millions Jews in Muslim countries now we have a few thousands and in some countries just few Jews or even zero. The land of Israel is the land of the Jewish people for thousands of years even before the establishment of Islam. In the Quran it states that the land of Israel belongs to the nation of Israel, so all the Modern Palestinian propaganda is basically against Islam, against history and of course against the Jewish people and the state of Israel. Antisemitism in disguise here in your channel. So sad, but not surprising.
sadly, many sefaradic Jews return to countries like Morocco or Tunisia because they're not treated fairly in the Israeli society
The Jewish left for Israel after the creation of Israel and in the case of Iraq by false flag bombing by Israelis to scare the Iraqi jews out.
If you think the reason for this was Antisemitism, why were these jews living in these regions in the first place for 1400 years ? If Muslims wanted to kill all Jews living among them don't you think 1400 year is long enough to do that? Was there any verse in Quran that only came to light after 1948 that made Muslims hate Jews?
Ayaan Hirsi Ali said some similar things in her book 'Nomad.' I can't say if she was lying.
Great grand father of Prophet and Messenger Muhammad (Sallallahu alaihi wasallam), Hashim (Raliyallahu Anhu) is from Gaza. He is buried in Gaza. Palastine is the ancestral land of our Beloved leader. Simply it cannot be defeated nor the people will surrender. Palestine is the land of Brave Hearts.
shitait tauhidi was bamboozoled by the shitaits.
Some people say he's not even shi'a
5:08 this guy reminds me so much of Yeomni Park, the North Korean defector, and known liar paid by the state department. She made the same similar claims that in North Korea they dont have love for children or have a word for it. .. whenever I hear over the top ridiculous claims like this, I always think there is a monetary , or other perks attached. This is why international organizations dont take the word of defector testimonies as evidence, because they are usually influenced by powerful interests or intelligence agencies for a political agenda.
the fact that u call yeonmi a liar says everything about you, u dont wanna hear what u dont like
@@el_chico1313 two things can be true at once ya know. She can be a pathological liar, who hangs around swamp creatures like Mike Pompeio, and also North Korea can be not a great place to live. Are you seriously telling me you believe all her stories, like when the train would break down, everyone would push it, instead of just getting out and walking to work??? Or they play with dead rats?
If you do, maybe look in a mirror, and that tells me more about you not wanting to hear anything you don't. 😂
New subscriber here. Muslim American. Great content. The world is big enough for all of us. With in this century we will be in space. I hate that they are fighting over something so small. Do they not see how big HaShem has made the universe?
thank you!
Universe is very big yes. Earth is very small compared to it. It also makes us think are we the centre of creation. If we were, why are there stars so many light years away whose light don't even reach us and they have no affect on us. If world was made for us why are those stars and planets made.
@abhinavsingh3228 Quran 42:29 And among His signs is the creation of the heavens and the earth, and all living beings He dispersed throughout both. And He is Most Capable of bringing all together whenever He wills.
This Ayat is interpreted as possible being Aliens. When Allah says heavens, he's referring to space. If he wills, he can join us and space creatures together. According to the Quran we are the middle of creation, not the center. Meaning Allah created creatures higher and lower than us. And he is still creating.
@@trustmebrobro yes brother. It would be more acceptable to all people if he also told about Neanderthals and other hominids whose dna continues in modern human to this day as they were ancestors at some point of time..
@abhinavsingh3228 Quran 17:70 And We have certainly honored the children of Adam and carried them on the land and sea and provided for them of the good things and preferred them over much of what We have created, with [definite] preference. They say this means with intellect. Allah is saying he created creatures like us before but not with the same intellect. Those mammals are gone. Have you read the Quran?
I am no sociologist and i am writing this comment while still at the start of the video. Irrational, intellectually deficient people (yes this is harsh but it is true) will position themselves on such topics based on emotional preferences that predetermine the outcome. The (pseudo)logical path that is then built to reconcile the predetermined outcome with previously adopted/proclaimed values/beliefs is usually a clumsy rationalization attempt that cannot survive the scrutiny of real rational debate. This explains the aggressiveness towards any attempt to rationally challenge such positionnings. This unfortunate pattern that sadly applies to so many topics other than the one at hand is at play when it comes to being for or against israel. Muslims are not excluded from being irrational on that topic. While most muslims will be emotionally biased towards being pro palestinian part of those who do not strongly identify to identities such as muslim or arab will have a positionning that is determined by other factors. The main factors that I can identify as being major causes of a pro-israeli bias are:
- being a bully and thus identifying more with bullies than victims
- having an inferiority complex towards a western world that is perceived as more "civilized" and more advanced
- having a strong drive towards self serving positions combined with a belief that western states such as israel are impossible to challenge leading to submission being perceived as being the best positionment
Everything mentioned in this comment only applies to understanding the positioning of people that are being sincere. Those who out of self interest choose to defend ideas they do not really believe in are out of topic.
And this person pro-israel somehow he speaks English better than English speakers in the west!!.😁
if only muslims prefer dialogues, there will be more peace. In reality and obviously beginning from 7th Century, islam is not about dialogues!!!!
That can be said about followers of all religions.
The presenter is a really spreading hate. By calling Israelis the oppressors. You say that you are sociologist and you are against hate towards people and yet you spread hate, by suspecting that Imam gains financial gains out of his support of the right of Israel to exist, the way it does. He speaks with a wide spread knowledge of Islam, far more than the presenter. He, the Imam is an honest person he acknowledges the harsh face of Islam knowing also the history of harsh faces of other Abrahamic religious. The fact that he speaks freely and criticize the Islamic world is based on his knowledge both of the religion and the society of the Islamic differences.
I don't know where you get information from but since Ariel Sharon, the government has increasingly been oppressing some of its own Jewish citizens. It is very well documented and studied. It was never about religion.
@@williambarylo I am an Israeli, and I am also a student. Throughout the years I read a lot, I am also a witness of some of the information I was talking about, so that is where I get my information from. Oppression comes from a male society wherever, in particularly in the Arab society. I met Muslim women from whom I learned about the domestic oppression they are facing.
1) One of them, saw how are Jewish girls are being treated at home and society, so she decided to be a woman of free choice. Alas her brother has decided to limit her, to say the least... Yet he was not the only one. Other members of her family not brothers, threatened her life. So, she had to run away to Norway for a while.
Something else she also told stories of how women are being oppressed in the Muslim society.
2) Another Muslim woman that I studied with, told me about another Muslim guy wanted her to become his fiancé when he was already engaged to another woman. She refused and as a result he would spread some false rumors about her, in order to defame her reputation.
3)A third one I met at the University told me in a conversation that her mother was terrified from her choice of study, she was afraid of somebody will heart her daughter for that.
To say that it is not about religion, well I don't buy it. What happened in the 7-th of October had nothing to do with the Palestinian cause, it was religiously motivated. According to what the captured terrorists they were getting the blessings of Imams.
@@ylev100 Just like for all religions, many people who claim belonging to a certain religion don't follow or even know about the religion. All the observations you mentioned come from cultural practices in certain families - which are opposed to Islamic behaviour. Some people who identity as Muslim in India and Pakistan still use a caste system for example - while Islam came to abolish such divisions. What Hamas did was instrumentalise the religion to justify their actions - while Islam forbids the killing of civilians (killing one innocent is as if they would have killed the whole of humanity says the Qur'an).
@@williambarylo Imam Tawhidi has studied under many of the greatest Marjas at great length. You appear to be misunderstanding him. Maybe ask him to tell you about Islam. There is much to learn from him.
The host is not what he said he was. They were offered a state and they rejected and swears Islam. He does not a promoting peace just hiding behind so called sociology. Tell hamas to lay down their arms and talk peace.
Discussion thread archived
Islam is a hateful ideology and even if a good person embraces that ideology his brain becomes fucked up.
Very informative. The Imam was parroting mainstream media points. Most of them don't know a law dictionary exists, like i didn't til 2015. Life & mind changer>>Black's Law dictionary, and editions matter.
The Jewish people are connected to Israel, by history and by religion.
And By LIES
@@mohammedhoussani1899 Not only the Old Testament says the land was given to the people of Israel (the Jews), but also the Quran
@@deIsraelithe children of Israel were led out of Egypt to Palestine/Israel but it doesn’t mean they didn’t convert to Christianity and Islam. So the Palestinians (Muslims and Christians) are the also the children of Israel, isn’t it.
so you are connected by the old testament not by history or relegion
@@deIsraeli
They used to be called Sabbateans. Descendants of Shabbatai Tzvi and his followers.
the Annunaki
Very few know who these closet homosexuals are. Are you one of those closet homosexuals? I know they’re just dying to come out of the closet. Let them make things intolerable enough and they will surely start getting popped. They can be tracked through their bloodlines and exclusive associations with those who have publicly provable Sabbatean bloodlines. They’re mentioned in the Encyclopedia Britannica which is the most academically credible encyclopedia in the history of the English language. Former US Supreme Court Justice Louis Brandeis openly admitted to being a Sabbatean and that he and his wife had an arranged marriage because only Sabbateans can marry each other. Karl Marx is related to the Brandeis clan on record. You can find that on any genealogy website. It’s all public record. Princess Diana is a direct descendant of Jacob Frank through her mother going back to his daughter Leah Golda. This is also public genealogy record. The Encyclopedia Britannica is not a conspiracy theory publication. And aliens don’t exist. And everyone in Pizzagate wound up on Epstein island and CBS did a segment years ago connecting all these people to Princess Diana who is on record a direct descendant of Jacob Frank. Meghan Markle on record is related to Prince Harry through his grandfather going back to the Sabbateans of Salonica, Greece. Socialism, communism, anarchism, right wing nationalism, atheistic movement, agnostic movement, all came out of the Jacobin Society which was started by Jacob Frank’s family members, on record, who include Moses Dobruska and François Chabot. The LGBTQ movement was also founded by Sabbateans on record. These bloodlines are public record fool !!
The Encyclopedia Britannica on the Sabbateans:
“Shabbetaianism, in Judaism, a 17th-century messianic movement that, in its extreme form, espoused the sacredness of sin. The leader of the movement was Shabbetai Tzevi, a self-proclaimed messiah and charismatic mystic. Coerced by the sultan of Constantinople to accept Islam, Shabbetai Tzevi shocked and disillusioned many of his followers by proclaiming himself a Muslim.”
“Other followers, interpreting Shabbetai Tzevi’s apostasy as a step toward ultimate fulfillment of his messiahship, also proclaimed themselves Muslims. They argued that such outward acts were irrelevant as long as one remains inwardly a Jew. Those who embraced the theory of “sacred sin” believed that the Torah (“Law” or “Teaching”) could be fulfilled only by its seeming annulment. Others felt they could remain faithful Shabbetaians without having to apostatize.”
“After Shabbetai Tzevi’s death in 1676, the sect continued to flourish. The nihilistic tendencies of Shabbetaianism reached a peak in the 18th century with the false messiah Jacob Frank, who claimed to be Shabbetai Tzevi’s reincarnation and whose followers reputedly sought redemption through orgies at mystical festivals.”
“Jacob Frank (born 1726, in Berezanka or Korolowka, Galicia, Pol. [now in Ukraine]-died Dec. 10, 1791, Offenbach, Hessen [Germany]) Jewish false messiah who claimed to be the reincarnation of Shabbetai Tzevi (1626-76). The most notorious of the false messiahs, he was the founder of the antirabbinical Frankist, or Zoharist, sect.”
“Frank often traveled in the Balkans and there met followers of Shabbetai. An uneducated visionary, he appealed to many who awaited the resurrection of Shabbetai. In about 1751 he proclaimed himself the messiah and four years later, in Poland, formed a sect that held that certain elect persons are exempt from the moral law. This sect abandoned Judaism for a “higher Torah” (Jewish Law) based on the Zohar, which was the most important work in the Kabbala, the Jewish mystical movement. Hence its members also called themselves Zoharists. Their practices, including orgiastic, sexually promiscuous rites, led the Jewish community to ban them as heretics in 1756. Protected by Roman Catholic authorities, who saw in them a means of converting the Jews, the Frankists debated with representatives of the rabbinate and claimed that the Talmud, the rabbinical compendium of law and commentary, should be discarded as blasphemous. They were also partly responsible for the revival of the canard that the Jews use Christian blood for Passover rituals.”
“In the meantime, to preserve his following, Frank publicly committed his supporters to mass baptism and was himself baptized in Warsaw, with Augustus III, king of Poland, acting as his godfather. The Frankists, however, continued their sectarian ways. As a result, the Inquisition imprisoned Frank in the fortress of Częstochowa (1760).”
“Freed by the conquering Russians in 1773, he eventually settled in Offenbach, dubbing himself baron. His many followers supported him in a manner befitting the nobility. Upon Frank’s death, he was succeeded by his daughter Eve… descendants of those members who were baptized merged with the Roman Catholic population.”
www.britannica.com/topic/Shabbetaianism
www.britannica.com/biography/Jacob-Frank
They have been in the Gaza Strip for 400 years on record. The False Prophet of Gaza of the False Messiah Shabbatai Tzvi, Nathan of Gaza according to the Encyclopedia Brittanica:
“With a retinue of believers and assured of financial backing, Shabbetai triumphantly returned to Jerusalem. There, a 20-year-old student known as Nathan of Gaza assumed the role of a modern Elijah, in his traditional role of forerunner of the messiah. Nathan ecstatically prophesied the imminent restoration of Israel and world salvation through the bloodless victory of Shabbetai, riding on a lion with a seven-headed dragon in his jaws. In accordance with millenarian belief, he cited 1666 as the apocalyptic year.”
“Threatened with excommunication by the rabbis of Jerusalem, Shabbetai returned to Smyrna in the autumn of 1665, where he was wildly acclaimed. His movement spread to Venice, Amsterdam, Hamburg, London, and several other European and North African cities.”
“At the beginning of 1666, Shabbetai went to Constantinople and was imprisoned on his arrival. After a few months, he was transferred to the castle at Abydos, which became known to his followers as Migdal Oz, the Tower of Strength. In September, however, he was brought before the sultan in Adrianople and, having been previously threatened with torture, became converted to Islam. The placated sultan renamed him Mehmed Efendi, appointed him his personal doorkeeper, and provided him with a generous allowance.”
www.britannica.com/biography/Nathan-of-Gaza
www.newsweek.com/qanon-followers-defend-donald-trump-jeffrey-epstein-plane-ghislaine-maxwell-trial-1654823
www.washingtontimes.com/news/2015/aug/25/donald-trump-hillary-clinton-are-related-genealogy/
On the one hand the Internet is a great place for ideas, (self)help and making connections, and on the other - what a waste of space and time with the trash like this.
Can you please invite the wise Imam Tawhidi to your channel and engage him directly in respectful dialogue?
There are hundreds of millions of liberal good muslims and this perspective is also valid,
Not imam! It is the Most Venerable Ayatollah Tawhidi
@@williambarylo Thanks for the correction. Please ask him tough questions when you interview him.
Please also ask him about irfan muraqabah sufism.
@@williambarylo
Rafidi Mushrik actually
Now that its been over 10 months, i wonder if the Iman still holds these views??
He's been in business for more than 10 years
Ahh so he's been bought off a long time ago then. JAK for your video now I know to avoid this "Imam" like the plague
It is a religious conflict based on Lurian Kabbalah.
the epic of Gilgamesh!
The foundation of Zionism is Lurianic Kabbalah. You’re a gaslighting liar hahaha. The dogs who feel threatened bark the loudest. Hamas is not an Arabic word. It is the Biblical Hebrew for “VIOLENCE” (2 Samuel 2:3) and Bin Laden’s Kinda tribe used to be a Jewish kingdom and when the Zionism State was established a number of them fled to the Zionist State to claim asylum and citizenship stating they had been living as Crypto-Jews for centuries and this is public record. The Muslim Brotherhood was created by Hassan Al-Banna who on record was from a Sabbatean Jewish family from Morocco who was financed according to his own testimony by the same British government that founded the Zionist State who are Sabbateans genealogically. This isn’t even a theory. These are all facts.
9/11 hijacker Ziad Al-Jarrah had a cousin who was an Israeli Mossad spy named Ali Al-Jarrah. Public record.
www.britannica.com/biography/Isaac-ben-Solomon-Luria#ref163234
Salam brother, the last guy who makes you confused don’t look like a proper Muslim except the clothes. Have you checked who he was really ? Salam. 😊
Yeah, these people can be very confusing for new Muslims
He’s Shia
This is Islam. In all your years of studies never have you looked into Muhammad
Comment moved to the "Theology" discussion thread
Well, no one will mistake you for one of them.
Lol lots of people don't even consider me Muslim anyway
@@williambarylo I love you for the sake of Allah , brother!
The Imam cannot become an Imam without studying and getting the license to become an Imam from recognized and authorized institution. So, the presenter should have a minimum decency in contradicting what he says.
Factually incorrect. No one needs a license to become imam
@@williambarylo But you need some authorization. I have been listening and watching some of his conversations with non-Muslims in a mixed audience Muslims and non-Muslims.
@@ylev100 you might need an authorisation if you want to teach (in places like Egypt or Saudi); however anyone who once leads a prayer is an "imam", and any mosque can appoint anyone as an imam - which sadly makes lots of people claim the title for all sorts of purposes.
Israeli Palestinians have a median income higher than any other arab country and they have more rights than anyone else. That could be why.
Because Israel guarantees it
It’s a secular Jewish state
Comment moved to the "Arab Israelis are First Class Citizens" discussion thread
Disregarding everything, the concept of govt making peace with an entity as if it applies to the people, as in the Abrahamic accord, imagine if some govt made an act as to eliminate racism or abandon feminism or communistic people, how can the govt possibly enforce it on the people? The govt may do it on its own, but how can it force the people individually to play along? 5ake the racism thing. So let's abandon racism, okay but how can you make the people do it on their own, let alone by mere ink on paper?
I'm not discussing the morality of the accord, but merely using it as a command to the public is so nonsensical, even if it were to a good cause.
Governments are sadly very disconnected from real people
First impressions in first two mins (not finished vid yet) just the way the presenter of the first video was talking makes the whole thing seem fake propaganda against Muslims and Palestinians, especially from the ‘pro-Israel Palestinian’ when he said he was taught ridiculous things about Jewish people in kuwaití school. I mean come on, seems hard to believe that this is real, but Allah knows best, may Allah grant the Palestinians victory soon, Amin
Yes, it has a clear purpose!
@@williambarylo i’ve noticed your subscribers increasing, which makes me really happy as it is well deserved for great content. And it would be great to see your discussion series come back with your spouse that was really great as well.
@@ahm2213 thank you! inshaAllah there is a whole new discussion series coming with some very interesting people
@@williambarylo I am very much looking forward to it. Thank you. JazakumAllahu khairan
Don’t you feel it was a waste of your time to cover attention seekers?
Well even if it was true, he is merely analysing how they come to have certain ideas about the world.
They might be attention seeker who gets paid for doing these stuff but the point here is that innocent people gets deceived by them and it's important to spread caution
@@ASH-dj8mv I would not give the the minute to expand their fame. I would let their Creator deal with them
@riab3591 you always have the responsibility to help others if possible, then you leave the rest on the hand of Allah (swt). The thing is that many people still fall for israeli media, so if one of them comes accross this video by any chance, that might serve the purpose of making the video in the first place.
As I mentioned in the video, when your job is to find solutions, you first need to diagnose the problem and understand how it works. And this is what pays my bills.
William, Did you say Muslims do not represent religion ? Although you have a doctor title, you are not fully educated about the Middle East . The imam of peace is one of a kind. And you don’t understand what he’s talking about.
Yeah you're right maybe ISIS represents Islam, Trump represents Christianity, Netanyahy represents Judaism and the military of Myanmar represent Buddhism
🇮🇱💙🤍🇮🇱💙🤍🇮🇱💙🤍🇮🇱💙🤍🇮🇱🤍🇮🇱💙🤍🇮🇱💙🙏
thanks for trolling. You help increasing the visibility of this channel. Here is a present from Finland: th-cam.com/video/dudPOUWOuKI/w-d-xo.html
Did you just say the "Muslim Brotherhood" is not extremist?
It's not me, the current analysis of the movement shows it has become unrecognisable from its extreme beginnings. They are angels compared to most Arab regimes the US is currently calling "friends" like Saudi Arabia
yeah/nah clear bias sorry good luck promoting Islamist propaganda, it always surprises me that reverts are always the craziest in the end. FYI I grew up exclusively with Muslims in Dagestan, and it is unrecognizable now because of Islamist ideology, I used to be idealistic, believed in the peaceful Muslim majority, and separated Islamists from Muslims, etc until I saw those same Muslims who would break bread with non-Muslims one day and then point out their house to Islamist the next day. All the real peace-loving Muslims get treated like infidels and have to cover their identity from their Ummah for safety reasons that's why there are so few left, instead of looking in the mirror you always look for someone to blame. The majority of you do not acknowledge crimes that are committed by Muslims on non-Muslims and on Muslims and you judge Muslims who want peace like the people in this video. And start claiming insane things like they are getting paid to stand for coexistence. The Jew hatred is inherent in Islam unfortunately and the hatred of non-Muslims in general. Even Islamic hospitality which I love comes from a very dark place historically speaking @@williambarylo
Olorun agbaye ooo you are mighty
Pappapisshu!
Cute liberal Muslim(!) highlighted by RAND Corporation
Dear Dr William, Assalamualaikum.
Please don't waste your time on these people. Nobody takes them seriously except those who already support israel for other reasons. They are paid agents.
DON'T GIVE THEM MORE PUBLICITY
Wa alaykum salaam
It's possible they're paid a lot but not many non Muslims (or new Muslims) know about that. My job is to diagnose problems and find solutions and the first step is to analyse and understand these problems
@@williambarylo Yes indeed. You are right. May Allah bless you. Ameen.
I think dr. Barylo is giving us tools to handle these kind of Muslims and that is needed. Personally I think these people will not end well after having probably enjoyd some time with material benefits from this mumble jumble.
@@pellesvansl thank you!
@@pellesvansl yes, I agree. Thanks
Prophet never went to Jerusalem. That is a lie.
Discussion thread archived
Faith
Bismillahiir ArRahmaanhir ArRahiim
May Allah help us rid ourselves of the hypocrites and the arrogant. May we act in only those ways that please Him so that those people are never allowed to return to power in this world even as they will be removed from power in the next.
9. التوبة: 9. at-Taubah: Repentance
32 يُرِيدُونَ أَن يُطْفِـُٔوا۟ نُورَ ٱللَّهِ بِأَفْوَهِهِمْ وَيَأْبَى ٱللَّهُ إِلَّآ أَن يُتِمَّ نُورَهُۥ وَلَوْ كَرِهَ ٱلْكَفِرُونَ
32 Fain would they put out the light of Allah with their mouths, but Allah disdaineth (aught) save that He shall perfect His light, however much the disbelievers are averse.
33 هُوَ ٱلَّذِىٓ أَرْسَلَ رَسُولَهُۥ بِٱلْهُدَىٰ وَدِينِ ٱلْحَقِّ لِيُظْهِرَهُۥ عَلَى ٱلدِّينِ كُلِّهِۦ وَلَوْ كَرِهَ ٱلْمُشْرِكُونَ
33 He it is Who hath sent His messenger with the guidance and the Religion of Truth, that He may cause it to prevail over all religion, however much the idolaters may be averse.
41 ٱنفِرُوا۟ خِفَافًۭا وَثِقَالًۭا وَجَهِدُوا۟ بِأَمْوَلِكُمْ وَأَنفُسِكُمْ فِى سَبِيلِ ٱللَّهِ ۚ ذَلِكُمْ خَيْرٌۭ لَّكُمْ إِن كُنتُمْ تَعْلَمُونَ
41 Go forth, light-armed and heavy-armed, and strive with your wealth and your lives in the way of Allah! That is best for you if ye but knew.
42 لَوْ كَانَ عَرَضًۭا قَرِيبًۭا وَسَفَرًۭا قَاصِدًۭا لَّٱتَّبَعُوكَ وَلَكِنۢ بَعُدَتْ عَلَيْهِمُ ٱلشُّقَّةُ ۚ وَسَيَحْلِفُونَ بِٱللَّهِ لَوِ ٱسْتَطَعْنَا لَخَرَجْنَا مَعَكُمْ يُهْلِكُونَ أَنفُسَهُمْ وَٱللَّهُ يَعْلَمُ إِنَّهُمْ لَكَذِبُونَ
42 Had it been a near adventure and an easy journey they had followed thee, but the distance seemed too far for them. Yet they will swear by Allah (saying): If we had been able we would surely have set out with you. They destroy their souls, and Allah knoweth that they verily are liars.
45 إِنَّمَا يَسْتَـْٔذِنُكَ ٱلَّذِينَ لَا يُؤْمِنُونَ بِٱللَّهِ وَٱلْيَوْمِ ٱلْءَاخِرِ وَٱرْتَابَتْ قُلُوبُهُمْ فَهُمْ فِى رَيْبِهِمْ يَتَرَدَّدُونَ
45 They alone ask leave of thee who believe not in Allah and the Last Day, and whose hearts feel doubt, so in their doubt they waver.
49 وَمِنْهُم مَّن يَقُولُ ٱئْذَن لِّى وَلَا تَفْتِنِّىٓ ۚ أَلَا فِى ٱلْفِتْنَةِ سَقَطُوا۟ ۗ وَإِنَّ جَهَنَّمَ لَمُحِيطَةٌۢ بِٱلْكَفِرِينَ
49 Of them is he who saith: Grant me leave (to stay at home) and tempt me not. Surely it is into temptation that they (thus) have fallen. Lo! hell verily is all around the disbelievers.
50 إِن تُصِبْكَ حَسَنَةٌۭ تَسُؤْهُمْ ۖ وَإِن تُصِبْكَ مُصِيبَةٌۭ يَقُولُوا۟ قَدْ أَخَذْنَآ أَمْرَنَا مِن قَبْلُ وَيَتَوَلَّوا۟ وَّهُمْ فَرِحُونَ
50 If good befalleth thee (O Muhammad) it afflicteth them, and if calamity befalleth thee, they say: We took precaution, and they turn away well pleased.
51 قُل لَّن يُصِيبَنَآ إِلَّا مَا كَتَبَ ٱللَّهُ لَنَا هُوَ مَوْلَىٰنَا ۚ وَعَلَى ٱللَّهِ فَلْيَتَوَكَّلِ ٱلْمُؤْمِنُونَ
51 Say: Naught befalleth us save that which Allah hath decreed for us. He is our Protecting Friend. In Allah let believers put their trust!
52 قُلْ هَلْ تَرَبَّصُونَ بِنَآ إِلَّآ إِحْدَى ٱلْحُسْنَيَيْنِ ۖ وَنَحْنُ نَتَرَبَّصُ بِكُمْ أَن يُصِيبَكُمُ ٱللَّهُ بِعَذَابٍۢ مِّنْ عِندِهِۦٓ أَوْ بِأَيْدِينَا ۖ فَتَرَبَّصُوٓا۟ إِنَّا مَعَكُم مُّتَرَبِّصُونَ
52 Say: Can ye await for us aught save one of two good things (death or victory in Allah's way) ? while we await for you that Allah will afflict you with a doom from Him or at our hands. Await then! Lo! We are awaiting with you.
It is so clear that he is lying, acting, look how they make video , it is like a movie, he get paid some how, Muslim in Kuwait don’t teach their children, what he is saying, those guys get paid to say this things,
Definitely lots of money involved!
the first guy was a jewish/christian troll. he was not even pronouncing "Muslim" properly 😂😂he was saying "moslim".
I'm really trying hard to give them the benefit of the doubt
@@williambarylo i understand, but i have never heard any Muslim from any part of the world saying "i am a moslim" . And after watching many IDF's propaganda videos, i find it impossible to give them benefit of the doubt.
Without lies, islam dies
Discussion thread archived
I did not understand what you are or who you are...but Israel did not conquer anything...the Israelites returned to the Holy Land as written in the Bible
Only because the British colonised it first
I’m hoping this bloke isn’t a lefty woke bloke and not bullshiting
The imam in the video is left of left, pro-LGBTQ, etc
He is not muslim neither jew he is relaps
That's a possibility
He’s a dog of the west I know this dude he always been extra soft and weird then became like this later down the line
Btw this guy I believe is not an Arab or I could be wrong, he’s either iraqi or Iranian or maybe Iraqi born in Iran some thing like this I forgot it been very long ago I’m frm Afghanistan our community is not big in the west
There are many like him, and the media love them!
This guy I don't believe him. He is just propaganda. But I like the way explain
Thank you!
I guess you never heard about sharia law.
It is also religion.
They want this type of law in the entire world
Sharia is law
Trump supporters have tried to implement White Sharia, it didn't go down well
This is religion don't lier yourself why all Muslims countries saying just religion
Mark?
They auto debunked their fabrication 😅
I know! But, he may have changed his birth name like some Muslim converts do
You don’t try to understand them but to counter them and dismiss their views. Too bad because this people can be a part of the solution.
I think Mark is alright. The imam is trying to hard to be accepted
@@williambarylo For me he make perfect sense.
@@williambarylo Ho, and there is not even a slight chance that his arguments are valid? The bottom line of this video, If you don't see things the way Mark do, something must be wrong with you.
@@iditbes6962 Mark's approach is really good because it draws from a personal story. The imam uses irrelevant arguments and incorrect theological points. It's good if he wants to befriend supporters of Israel but without a good command of theology he's not gonna convince any Muslim, that's maybe why he's not very popular in Muslim circles. If he can't convince his target audience, he's not being a good ally to Israel.
I don't believe this guy is not Palestinian and definitely not Muslim that's why I'm not to continue watching the video , I don't understand why you give a voice to these imposters
Because when I was new to Islam and didn't know about Palestine, these guys would confuse me.
Free Palestine 🇪🇭🇪🇭🇪🇭🇪🇭🇪🇭🇪🇭🇪🇭
Dear Dr. William, you are delusional. Of course this conflict has a huge religious component! It is about reconquering dar al Islam considered a Waqf to the Muslims which can't be governed by infidels. If you ignore that you ignore the core of the conflict. It makes little difference if you create the 23rd or the 24th Arabs state, but it makes a huge difference if you destroy the only Jewish state because it is on Muslim land
If it was about religion, you wouldn't have Muslims serving in the IDF and Christians in Gaza would not be bombed
In 1982, a prominent Israeli strategic analyst, Avner Yaniv, coined the term “Palestinian peace offensive” to describe the risk that Palestinians would become too moderate politically and Israel would be forced to make concessions.
He urged using the "fiercest military pressures" against the PLO in Lebanon to undermine Palestinian moderates and make the PLO more hardline in order "to halt its rise to political respectability".
How do you explain this statement? If it was about religion than why moderate Palestinians were a problem for Israel?