Questioning Sam Harris | Sam Harris | EP 224
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 6 มิ.ย. 2024
- This episode was recorded on November 25, 2021.
Sam Harris is a neuroscientist, philosopher, New York Times best-selling author, host of the Making Sense podcast, and creator of the "Waking up" app.
Dr. Harris and I discuss the is/ought problem, dreams, attention, evidence, consciousness, logic, psychedelics, religion, Waking Up, and much more.
Meditate with the Waking Up app:
wakingup.com
Listen to the Making Sense podcast:
open.spotify.com/show/5rgumWE...
Sam’s website:
SamHarris.org
_____________
Timestamps
_____________
[00:00] Intro
[02:48] Background
[06:04] The debates
[12:25] Waking Up
[16:18] The is/ought problem (1)
[23:42] (Breaking out of) everyday patterns
[24:22] Experience & Expectations
[32:26] Evidence & Logic
[33:10] The is/ought problem (2)
[34:56] The Ecological Approach to Visual Perception
[40:52] Attention
[42:38] Carl Rogers
[49:21] (Dis)satisfaction
[51:01] Discomfort
[51:17] Entering meditative states
[54:06] Being like a mirror
[55:58] Thoughts & The Self
[56:56] Suffering
[01:01:03] Dreaming
[01:09:15] The Self & Psychedelics
[01:14:29] Prayer
[01:18:24] Organized religion
[01:25:33] The postmodern predicament
[01:41:54] Sacred texts
#Philosophy #Ethics #Meditation #Mindfulness #SamHarris
// SUPPORT THIS CHANNEL //
Newsletter: linktr.ee/DrJordanBPeterson
Donations: jordanbpeterson.com/donate
// COURSES //
Discovering Personality: jordanbpeterson.com/personality
Self Authoring Suite: selfauthoring.com
Understand Myself (personality test): understandmyself.com
// BOOKS //
Beyond Order: 12 More Rules for Life:
jordanbpeterson.com/Beyond-Order
12 Rules for Life: An Antidote to Chaos:
jordanbpeterson.com/12-rules-...
Maps of Meaning: The Architecture of Belief:
jordanbpeterson.com/maps-of-m...
// LINKS //
Website: jordanbpeterson.com
Events: jordanbpeterson.com/events
Blog: jordanbpeterson.com/blog
Podcast: jordanbpeterson.com/podcast
// SOCIAL //
Twitter: / jordanbpeterson
Instagram: / jordan.b.peterson
Facebook: / drjordanpeterson
I'm a success story. You turned a 50 year old into a man. Homeless to success. I started by making my bed in the shelter. Thank you for caring.
Congratulations, Kevin.
Many congratulations Kevin sir!
Best wishes and lots of blessings to you! You are going to do great things!
Shit. That one hit hard
Kevin, you are the man! Keep you chin up and keep pushing forward!
The reason why these kinds of discussions resonate so well with so many is there are billions of us who are logical, thoughtful, and curious and we are starving to hear intelligent and interesting conversation instead of the mind numbing bullshit that is constantly fed to us on a daily basis.
Billions ? I disagree. That number is much less.
Very few of us are truly logical or thoughtful. All of us are driven by emotions which most pretend to be based on rational thought. Few truly employ real conceptual thinking to most issues.
However, people who effectively put across rational ideas on complex issues can be refreshing for many of us. Plus give us food for thought.
@@iain5615 Everyone is driven by emotions - even Zen Buddhists get angry sometimes. Some people are just better at restraining and regulating them long enough to employ rational thinking more often than not.
Based on observations made in the last 2 years I'd estimate that approximately 20% of the human population is at least INTERESTED in rational thought. So you're not far off - I'd say it's around 1.6 billion people.
@@igg3937 i can agree with that. However, emotions aren't always anger. Desire, greed, etc. play apart and these can lead people to want to believe something that they then try to unconsciously rationalise.
Listened to this a second time... After a 5 month break... This time round, I'm just blown away by SAM'S coolness, calmness, intellect and especially his effortlessness in conveying his perspective.
ABSOLUTELY SUPERB 👌👌👌👏👏
Well, the great ones make it look easy.
Sam Harris lives in bondage and emptiness
John 8:32 Then you will know the truth, and the truth will set you free
That’s 30 years of meditative practice paying off.
Sam is a living treasure
Yes. That’s what enlightened beings are like and it’s on steroids communication because of his intellect and studies. Great stuff.
I'm retiring next month. And I'm a
bit nervous about how to keep up
with my kids.
please what do you mean by trade?
I think I came across this name Val J
Smith on my way to work on the
billboards and as to his
effectiveness how can he be
contacted please?
@@abrashaadrain8485dont listen to this guy. crypto is a complete scam.
@@abrashaadrain8485 I would say, just accepting them where and at the point that they are. You’re never going to be the friend in the way that their peers might be. Deep down it is human nature for children, no matter the age, to enjoy and embrace their parents presence. No need to smother or teach especially if they are independent. Your goal should be to find bliss in your own company. Remember to stay curious and always view the world with an open mind.
@Joshua Lanchester lol let me guess, he should invest with you? HAHA
The best part of the whole conversation was the last 10 seconds when they sincerely thanked each other for taking the time to have a conversation. We need more of that and less divisiveness and hatred on social media.
So much this. The honest and authentic apretiation towards each other was emotionally pallapable. So much mutual respect there.
Well put
we need more rainbows and lollipops
For me, the fact that I heard a novel take on the is-ought problem where it's actually flipped and we seem to have an ought-is-ought that needs to be explored was the best part of the conversation. The last 10 seconds were boring. We should live in a world where that's the norm, and we shouldn't be in awe of that kind of display just because it happens rarely. We need to normalize it, not ascribe some idealistic value to it which makes us numb to situations where courtesy and politeness aren't present.
@@fbarnea Yeah that's a good point. But the fact is that it is rare so I can't help but become moved when I see it.
We have a saying in my culture - When two elephants fight it’s the grass that suffers. This ‘debate’ between two titans is having the opposite effect. I can feel myself growing. Thank You JBP and Sam Harris
Great saying. Thanks for giving it out.
👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽
Except that Harris isn't an elephant or titan.
@@Consciousnesstransformation Just so; he is the subject of a metaphor. I bow to your mastery of facticity.
when 2 elephants fight its FOR THE GLORY OF ELEPHANT KIND
This is probably one of the most wholly positive TH-cam comments sections I've ever seen. Just a lot of people seeming to appreciate these two getting together and having an extremely civil discussion on very difficult topics. Obvious kudos to Sam and Jordan, but for my experience, it's been uplifting and wholesome to read what a lot of people are saying here in the comments.
❤️
Couldn’t agree more. Both very enjoyable to listen to on topics they are discussing.
I agree. I did not get the feeling there was any competition or confrontation, just two minds sharing their perception of truth's.
💚
I live for the comments section!
Very rare to see a real conversation between 2 brilliant minds. Thank you for this Jordan & Sam. ❤
At least 1 of them is...the other 1 is Jordan petersen.
@anything704 I am no where close to a fan of Peterson. However, he is absolutely brilliant. Just because you disagree with what he says, doesn't make him ignorant by any means.
So refreshing to hear two grown adults having a civil discussion nowadays.
😁indeedio
.... that isnt at its heart a political marketing exercise
👍🏽word
@@ajb7786 Wow, you're just a ray of sunshine aren't you?
@@ajb7786 You must be fun at parties.
These two are speaking from an incredible depth of context . Everytime I come back to these two trading ideas, the more I come to understand exactly how little I know about the world
Yes it's very exciting watching the heavyweight championship fight. Our participation would be useless though lol
Sam Harris is a fascist. He believes people should be forced to be vaccinated and he also has TDS.
@@madamluis2537 Im not a Sam Harris viewer or anything, but you made a claim and i did some periphery research, and it doesnt seem like Sam Harris is in favor of government mandates of vaccines at this point in the pandemic although he believes people SHOULD get the vaccine, but thats not really fascism. Maybe he was pro vaccine mandate in the past, but at least according to his podcast AMA #19, he doesn't sound nearly as radical as you claim him to be. If you want to hear what Sam has to say on the subject, I've provided at least a single resource.
@@madamluis2537 that’s not fascism, that’s political force and violation of human rights, which all political ideologies have. Is there anyone in the world left, that knows what fascism actually means? Curious.
Especially now, when so many people's default mode is of "intelligence bragging", I'm right & if you disagree you're dumb, moral superiority and virtue signaling etc. It's much more impressive & intellectually honest, I think, to practice patience, humility and confidently exclaim that I DO NOT KNOW. At least I MAY NOT UNDERSTAND AS MUCH AS I'D LIKE TO. How many times throughout life we look back and realize that we have grown & sharpened our perspective and personality from a previous point when at the time we thought we were at a peak of understanding and now see some error and hubris from that earlier self. It's an interesting exercise to attempt to curb this cycle and to "do ones future self a favor and embrace our inevitable current ignorance and find peace in a sense of wonder & humility, instead of the much easier unfortunate defensiveness, bitter resentment and pompous judgments. I am not at all an example of conquering this dilemma but it's a much more noble space I'd like to dwell in. The epic cliche but unavoidably accurate notion that THE MORE YOU KNOW, THE MORE YOU'RE AWARE OF HOW LITTLE YOU TRULY UNDERSTAND.
These two are so dazzlingly eloquent and can communicate these insanely abstract and nuanced ideas with so much delicacy.
"I remember why we kept talking now": Jordan to Sam (at the end). That made me smile because it was exactly the kind of thought I had about halfway into the discussion. Having watched previous slightly more uncomfortable/jarring conversations between the two, it's really gratifying and enthralling to hear them together now. Keep 'em coming JP x
??? Are you blind? "This" was J.P. having Sam Harris on to see if he (J. P.) could be recognized and acknowledged by betters. J.P. was very tentative throughout this "conversation" and at the end he was very relieved that he made it through the conversation without going completely Bat-Sh** crazy. You could see the relief on Jordan's face at the end.
This is the most positive comment section I’ve seen, the result of a meaningful discussion that transcended cynicism. This is an important formula, genuine thinking and genuine listening, all in good faith. It has produced thousands of comments expressing gratitude. Thank you both for breaking the mold of the internet.
the very lovely Sam Harris: "What will we do if an Islamist regime, which grows dewy-eyed at the mere mention of paradise, ever acquires long-range nuclear weaponry? If history is any guide, we will not be sure about where the offending warheads are or what their state of readiness is, and so we will be unable to rely on targeted, conventional weapons to destroy them. In such a situation, the only thing likely to ensure our survival may be a nuclear first strike of our own. Needless to say, this would be an unthinkable crime-as it would kill tens of millions of innocent civilians in a single day-but it may be the only course of action available to us, given what Islamists believe. How would such an unconscionable act of self-defense be perceived by the rest of the Muslim world? It would likely be seen as the first incursion of a genocidal crusade. The horrible irony here is that seeing could make it so: this very perception could plunge us into a state of hot war with any Muslim state that had the capacity to pose a nuclear threat of its own. All of this is perfectly insane, of course: I have just described a plausible scenario in which much of the world’s population could be annihilated on account of religious ideas that belong on the same shelf with Batman, the philosopher’s stone, and unicorns."
@@someguy5063 Don't worry religion won't be a reason for the world to plunge into another chaotic war. We'll do that just ourselves without religion. Infact it won't even make sense to use religion as an excuse for war in this day and Age.
@@sxucekey619 my worry isn't religion or war or whatever else he was talking about. my worry is the person whom I quoted. you might want to read what he said once again. this guy is insane!
@@someguy5063 it's pretty eminently reasonable; if a death cultist got hold of a nuke (and a muslim death cultist IS more likely, due at least in part to how modern geopolitics interacts with unique tenets of their historico-religious tradition, such as the concept of jihad and paradise), a first strike would be a necessity; sorry the world isn't unicorns and rainbows like you want it to be. Also to be fair, this was written around 9/11 when the perceived global threat of Islam was at its height- you could probably find many such quotes from the time.
If you like JP you'd be worth marrying LOL
Kindness can flow between two people who disagree, this is the watermark of our humanity. I appreciate that a friendship can be cultivated sincerely even when core ideas are not shared. May we all strive to radiate this same kindness towards one another.
@Tyrannicaltech What would it take for you to forgive Sam?
If only people were so charitable nowadays , it seems to have been forgotten
Mark Wilson that was beautifully said....thanks,lorra
@Tyrannicaltech Jordan Peterson would disagree with your view of Sam, emotional outrage towards someone you disagree with in the manner you described, shows how childish and ignorant your mind is. I disagree with Peterson, religion is as bad as nihilism but I don't think Peterson is anything other than a very intelligent man trying to piece together reality with his incredible mind. Even you name suggests you might either be a child, russian farm trying to divide, or very ignorant person.
@Tyrannicaltech i'm sorry that you are the way you are
The depth and decency of these two men is awesome. And how they hold each other’s intellectual feet to the fire, with such rigor and compassion is truly inspiring. I could listen to them talk for hours. We’ll done gentlemen 👏🏼
thank you for your kind comments young lady, we appreciate it:)
Im watching this for the second time now and the way that Sam talks here is such a 180 from how he has been talking for the last week or so. I mean saying out loud that any form of corruption from the current goverment is justified, as long as they take out the main potential candidate of the opposition. That just goes so hard against the things he has been saying for a very long time... it makes me think about when they talked about atheism and how he asked Jordan if he believed that being an "atheist" would make him into a tyrant eventually. Jordan replied to this by saying "it would be more likely". Given the fact that Sam thinks the ends justify the means in this situation because of rational calculation, makes me believe that Jordan was right about Sam being more likely to move towards tyranney.
Harris is truth that Peterson is valiant!
Eh i’d rethink that now after the shit Harris has been saying
@@glennvoncken495 hey nice thoughts on it. Thank God youre floating around here on the WWW's
This is a fabulous conversation, I'm getting so much out of listening to people who have spent a great deal of time groping around in the dark, with a lighter, helping the rest of us who haven't figured out what the lighter is for.
The understanding that you guys have and from different angles on these central topics, is giving me almost psychedelic like self reflection and healing and restoring akin to love.
Thank you guys! Amazing!
I've had this thought for a few years now. Imagine if netflix and all these companies commissioned a speech or lecture from people like Jordan or Sam. The same way they pay comedians for an hour long special.
They could do it with intellectuals and tell them: 2 hour lecture on any topic of your choosing. That would be the future as it seems everyone loves these long form discussions
Man, how do I get to a world were that would ever happen?
And actually help inform the masses rather than entertaining and propagandizing to them?? If any of the up-and-coming companies trying to compete with netflix have an ounce of sense, they will incorporate talks like this into their platform. Just look at the views and sold out stadiums from these kinds of talks... the public is asking for it.
Even if Netflix decided to commission something like this, viewership wouldn't hit the top 100. The intellectual community is smaller than you think.
@@dingviet4310 its also larger than you think.
I don't think that most humans are ready for such a lecture. I know in my own vicinity nobody would be interested in it. And for those who are ready, plenty of material is already available at your fingertip.
Currently watching you two from a rehabilitation clinic on the south coast on England. Without your talks that I've avidly followed for the last few years, especially the biblical series Jordan, and surrendering to the powerlessness of things I cannot change while finding the courage the change the things I can, I highly likely would not alive and awoken today. I'm out in less than 3 weeks, ready to take back my life and help others do the same. THANK YOU.
Congrats man, one day at a time you got this 💪🏻
Great job Peter, awesome work seriously man. Pay it forward.
@@phil-jo8px Thankyou Sir. That is my full intention.
@@PlantsForHire Thank you Neil. I finally got it. Took longer than expected!
Stick close to the rooms and your sponsor. if you fumble just stop. Call your companion in recovery, and do not feel ashamed. It took me a while, but I've nailed it, I am 67 now. It took what it took. Grateful every day.
Whether you agree with Sam or Jordan or both, I think what they're doing (as well as others like them) is showing the rest of us of how valuable it is to be able to talk with each other and discover where we agree on certain topics, and where we disagree on certain topics.
I went to the O2 event in London and had a blast. It's great to see Sam and Jordan engaging again and talking fondly of one another and remembering those big events.
Glad to see Ben Stiller is back chatting with Jordan Peterson.
Zoolander and Kermit
Timeless joke
underrated comment
I thought I was being blazed by Blue Steel... Ty. Lol
Walter Mitty
I can't even begin to explain how valuable I find the discussions that you and Sam Harris have with each other. It's astounding how much of what you discuss are things that I have tried to understand within my own life. Hearing many of the thoughts that I have had (both intentionally and unintentionally) spoken outloud is very refreshing and eye-opening.
100% agree, I can't believe the trivial crap out there so hugely outweighing this kind of needed intelligent conversations. Most people are totally plugged into the matrix(metaphorically speaking of the deep states ruling paradigm) and everyone who is aware can see that we could almost have heaven on earth, if we stand together and stop letting these phsycotic people divide us with racism and sexism and nationalism etc.
@@antonjoubert6980 just curious what have you learnt from Sam Harris?
@@mcrobsaccount I always disregarded concepts of meditation etc. As just the same voodoo I learned from religious indoctrination, but from listening to Sam I got enticed to give it a second look and realized there is so much wisdom in meditation and self study too gain from these ancient practises(although there still is a lot of woo in alot of these traditions related to these practices)
@@antonjoubert6980 interesting there's plenty of scienctific literature backing up the positive effects of meditation, even psychedelic effects in some cases. I also find it interesting that you dismiss religion as simply just indoctrination, I take it your not a fan, what religion were you indoctrinated into ?
@@antonjoubert6980 Mediation may control your internal strain with your internal voice, and it's opinion, but does that make abusive people vanish from your life? Does it really do anything if you are already rational, and stable internally? Meditation seems to only work if you are irrational in some type of way. Also, does meditation help you walk around with no internal voice? If so, then you just become more reactionary, and possibly animalistic without opinion. My option is to refine your rationale, and meditation is the opposite of what you should do, but is similar. You talk with yourself in many different arguments at once in your head in essence which seems opposite of the tone these 2 present here.
I could happily listen to these two discuss anything. Both show incredible depths of mind & mental agility & want the best for humanity. There's simply nothing to dislike regardless of one's own opinion. The level of respect they have for each other speaks volumes in how to move forwards healthily.
God, Harris is so genuine, honest and fair. He seems so calm and friendly and kind. Again, what I see here reaffirms that. I have always struggled to understand people who hate Harris. This has led me to hypothesize that people hate him because he doesn't fail in arguing against people. He makes so good points that people either have to accept them or do mental gymnastics to avoid them, and this leads SOME people to use a rather childish tactic of painting him as this bad guy.
Oh I don't hate him, I disagree with much of what he says about God, but I don't hate him :D
Well there is his acceptance of murderous Pedophelia as long as Trump is gone. His own words
@@Grandmaster_Dragonborn Harris said nothing about "God". He comments on the Theory / Belief / Idea of a God. Harris knows there is no god thing.
@@124xhappeleshows He says God doesn’t exist; I think the case that He does exist is much stronger.
Some of it is partly justified, in him using purposefully stilted language and overly relying on a soothing voice which can com across as almost manipulative.
I think most of the current blowback against Harris is from him falling into Trump Derangement Syndrome and losing all sense of logic around the topic. And now getting into spats about it with other thinkers. Unbelievable how badly Trump messed him up.
The love and admiration they showed each other at the end was beautiful.
Pp
I love how Peterson always goes out of his way to try to Steelman rather than strawman whoever he is having a discussion with. It is so refreshing.
Yes, he constantly tries to make the other parties argument stronger, even though it´s a point of view he disagrees with.
Both Sam and Jordan value intellectual honesty/exploration above debate victory optics.
@@snackentity5709 a wonderful thing and great example for all
Shame he doesn’t do that on Twitter
Yeah you know who doesn't do that... Sam Harris.
I was in the London event and I noticed that people around me were clapping for both Sam and Jordan, so eventhough the Sam and JOrdan disagreed they made points that were rewarded by same members of the audience that was exciting and how things should be. Very rarely big questions are black and white and even contradicting things can exist at the same time. This would be so important to introduce back into the conversations in social media to make the conversations more adult and reflecting more the complex reality.
How did the audience react when Sam asked Jordan if he believed christ was resurrected and Jordy sat there with his thumb up his butt?
Just brilliant. Never met these guys.. but just an honour to stand on the same ground as them. But a consistent insight on conversations we should be having love you guys
After watching this conversation it struck me just how amazing it is I have access to this calibre of content for free and accessible anywhere anytime.
I think about that too, the dark ages wouldn’t have been dark if people could pull up a video of Aristotle giving a lecture 😂
Yes .. it’s great if you can support him by going ad free on his podcast .. Small price to pay for such great content. Support what you believe in …
@@obergssin I have purchased his book, personality course and writing course and will likely purchase future releases. I also intend to see him live on tour when he comes to my city
This gives me so much happiness. Two of the most intelligent and articulate people having a great conversation. That's why I love the internet.
Agreed, its a joy to see these two talk again and the internet isnt all bad :)
interesting how Jordan was nearly in tears by the end... hes so happy to be back I think ...im glad to see him speaking and debating.
love both yall Jordan and sam
He tears up more often now.
I think they both have perform a truly genuine conversation, and sam has touch peterson's heart in some way, that's why he's crying
@@PoetlaureateNFDL i think his journey to sober up has cracked open his heart and connected him directly to source.
@@bendietreeswhat do you mean “sober up”?
I could listen to this conversation they come down to at the end every single time for days. And I'm sure it could continue for days. There's almost never a satisfying conclusion made for me. So crazy.
Best way to live, always thinking, just don’t stress about you’ll work it out eventually ❤
This is a fascinating conversation. You can totally see how Sam’s neuroscience background and Jordan’s psychology background shape each of their perspectives and overlap.
Ever looked into Carl jung and Sigmund freud?
Into the sky my friend
Remember when we used value different perspectives?? Jordan and Sam are extraordinary showing us how to have a conversation respectfully when perspectives are different. We should all take a lesson from this.
To See Clearly Without the Need to Zoom in because of the quality of the lens or the software embedded in Your Brain while the mindset has actually evolved from the heart.... ❕
@Windows XP go watch the conversations they referenced at the beginning
As someone who suffers from intrusive thoughts (OCD) and was diagnosed with Asperger’s at 5 years old, this entire discussion spoke to me on such a deep level. Intellectually and psychologically stimulating would be the best way I can describe the experience of listening to these two.
Thanks to Dr. Peterson and Dr. Harris for providing such enlightenment and thought-provoking analysis over the years (and hopefully for many more to come).
@plushdogg124 I have been on a similar journey seven years ago. Good luck my friend! Work on it like your life depends on it.
Same boat over here
Truly fascinating and revelatory. It is indeed especially satisfying to listen to you both discuss the issues addressed here. Clarity and insight can be found amidst so much vapid and effete discourse nowadays.
You blokes are legends. Thanks 🙏🏼💯👌🏼
I absolutely love & savor the coming together of these guys minds in so many ways. Of course they've had some contentious meetings--theyre both brilliant geniuses in their own right; they're not going to have identical takes on everything. The fact they can have such fundamental disagreement, & still come together and work & share ideas together to create such a beautifully rich, nuanced, fantastically brilliant and original product....well it's no surprise that'd eventually be the outcome w/ these two. I could listen to them conversing all damn day.
Two important giants in the world trying to do the 'highest good'. Two different approaches entirely but with mutual respect on both sides. Let's keep this conversation going.....a weekly chat on a Netflix series would be amazing.
Agreed! It seems like it ended just as it was getting started.
Sorry, but there was only one giant & a fool in this conversation! Jordan was the giant btw!
Imagine a documentary style where the two of them travel the world visiting sacred sites and dissecting the ideology. Then at the end of the whole thing being in lab explaining the science behind neuro pathways.
Neither of these "giants" can give anyone eternal life. Jesus Christ can and will. The entire human race is on "death row" not just those in prison. The most important problem every man has is death. For all of their "wisdom" neither of these men can provide what men need most. They cannot even save themselves from death.
John 3:16 "For God so loved the world, that he gave his only begotten Son, that whosoever believeth in him should not perish, but have everlasting life."
John 5:24 "Verily, verily, I say unto you, He that heareth my word, and believeth on him that sent me, hath everlasting life, and shall not come into condemnation; but is passed from DEATH unto LIFE."
John 10:28 "And I give unto them ETERNAL LIFE; and they shall never perish, neither shall any man pluck them out of my hand."
John 5:40 "And ye will not come to me, that ye might have life."
That would be too good to be true
Yes Jordan! More events with Sam. I could listen to you two talk all day. Absolutely captivating content.
Add Douglas Murray in as well
@@ChillAssTurtle You're thinking of Stefan Molyneux, dude. Douglas Murray is a totally different guy..
@@ChillAssTurtle I think you are confusing him with Charles Murray.
Honestly I like their private conversations more than the public ones. Their public events seemed more competitive while the podcasts seem more productive with finding common ground. Also I didn’t like the interruptions of the cheering that much. Still enjoy all of their conversations deeply!
@Andy Mann such nonsense!
Two brilliant minds discussing important things, not always agreeing, but getting along. Love this.
No dear 😂 one brilliant honest mind and one brilliant pseudo intellectual whos skill is word salad .
San Harris is a mindless sheep who NEVER looks at facts
@@scottblack7182 nice description of yourself, a pseudo intelectual who thinks himself above valuable minds and conversations
Sam isn't brilliant in the least. Your LSD zonked 20 something thinks like he does as a matter of course. And his politics are comically bad. Like holy shit, bad.
@@scottblack7182 who will be who?
My mind has no business being this expanded, but here we are. Who am I , and then what do I DO with that?! Food for thought indeed. I feel such a deep love for both of you, thank you so much
I wonder if even the Universities in todays time actually go through such deep content or conversations. An episode like this really takes you on a ride and teaches you to think pretty critically. So great to see Jordan and Sam discuss.
I don't think these conversations can happen in the class. After class...yes.
Just graduated. It's disgusting that most of my teachers weren't themselves supporters of being critical except when it comes to criticising the intellect of the student.
For once I risked it all and went loose on one of them. Truly something I would recommend everyone to do (IF YOU KNOW WHAT YOURE TALKING ABOUT). They humbled themselves from then on. Never had the guts to do that.
They don’t
@@zakariab9591 You are very brave for that and I admire you for standing up against authoritative figures who try to suppress free speech and critical thinking. It truly is disgusting how the society we live in in the west tries to superimpose their ideology and discourages contemplation and finding our own truth, not that which has been forced upon us.
You can bet it starts and ends with how much does it cost
Great discussion as always, The only problem i have about this Podcast is that it has an end. While all the stupidity around me is endless.
Everyone is in their own realm of reality. Peterson & Harris are Phd. ‘S. The majority of people are blue collar workers & proletariat. Those sectors require people to be repeat pattern - operators. In order to fit in - there are other aspects of the person that have to be sacrificed ( ie not developed & nurtured ) .
> Patience will help you navigate the not as intelligent among us.
> And know - that we each have value/ regardless.
the very lovely Sam Harris: "What will we do if an Islamist regime, which grows dewy-eyed at the mere mention of paradise, ever acquires long-range nuclear weaponry? If history is any guide, we will not be sure about where the offending warheads are or what their state of readiness is, and so we will be unable to rely on targeted, conventional weapons to destroy them. In such a situation, the only thing likely to ensure our survival may be a nuclear first strike of our own. Needless to say, this would be an unthinkable crime-as it would kill tens of millions of innocent civilians in a single day-but it may be the only course of action available to us, given what Islamists believe. How would such an unconscionable act of self-defense be perceived by the rest of the Muslim world? It would likely be seen as the first incursion of a genocidal crusade. The horrible irony here is that seeing could make it so: this very perception could plunge us into a state of hot war with any Muslim state that had the capacity to pose a nuclear threat of its own. All of this is perfectly insane, of course: I have just described a plausible scenario in which much of the world’s population could be annihilated on account of religious ideas that belong on the same shelf with Batman, the philosopher’s stone, and unicorns."
@@zeeshanahmad4161 that was a Sam Harris quote
@@someguy5063 Apologies!
@@someguy5063 I personally believe that their isn't going to be a nuclear war in the near future in the ist place. But if it happened its would be from a non Muslim country, probably from US or Israel against a probable non Muslim country I.e China or Russia or possibly muslim country Iran.
They have such an interesting dynamic to watch. I wish the conversation went forever.
No one who does it like you two. Please never stop having these kinds of conversation with each other. Do not be shy about your greatness, the two of you are speer-heading contemporary philosophical and socio-cultural discourse.
If you think those two are "speer-heading contemporary philosophical and socio-cultural discourse" you most likely are not very up-to-date on those matters and only know those two thinkers, whose purely circumstantial and lucky mediatic success makes them more easily known than others who have done more, quantitatively and qualitatively.
For real .
For real .
For real .
@@bazingacurta2567would you mind recommending some people then? i am very eager to learn
I've always wondered what it would be like to be a fly on the wall when the philosophers and religious titans of old met and had their discussions. Thank you for the pleasure and blessing to be a part of it now
I'd describe Harris as more of a Sophist
It would be pretty similar to being a fly on the wall when two dudes fuck. You just be sitting there vomiting your stomach contents onto the wall. Except with the dudes theres more food available on the walls
I am actually somewhat of a intellectual titan my self. Please mr. Peterson debate me
Probably like this: Acts 17:16-32 🙂
This is the Dr. Peterson I love hearing. Two great minds having a heady discussion with us in the room. Heath and peace to both of you...and to all kindred spirits really. As long as you harbor no hate in your heart, the seat is open. Welcome.
Sam seems to be not willing to step out of his "the analyst"/ "detachment" mode.
What is this mode? While in this mode, it shows us that we can experience/ spend time in the realization that we as spiritual beings can be very separated from our embodiment/ action-realm, while in that mode.
The analyst mode is something that deep meditation tends to introduce to a person (personal experience). It is a great "perception tool" in "the toolset".
But being in that mode is not where most of Sam's/ ours "daily embodied actions" take place. It's not where our social life/ organization of our society takes place. It's not where our experience with "material reality" takes place.
What I mean is, the analyst mode is not dealing with the problems of how to act in this world. That mode is pure perception. It is inherently without agency, inherently without the motivation to act.
Jordan is talking about how to determine how to make ever-better embodied actions. Sam seems to not even be interested in diving into the process of how humans did/ do that, in practice. Is it just me?
@@elektrotehnik94 Perhaps I've misunderstood you, but I believe you've committed an error in delineating Sam's position, and in understanding the "selflessness" (or "anatta") that he is describing, by characterizing it as "actionless" detachment, and disassociated from ethical action in the world; I've also heard it described as a "refusal to face the danger of actual life". I think in Sam's view, these "dangers of everyday social life" are precisely the "I" (the wrongheaded way in which people identify themselves, and the suffering which is almost entirely reducible to it), and that meditation is therefore *precisely* to face the dangers of everyday life- which on a more fundamental level are not sociological, but phenomenological: errors in how human beings interpret perception, which lead to suffering & unethical behavior.
I think also, an advanced meditator and those familiar know that a "selfless" person- in Harris' sense- is almost always in fact a person of tremendous energy and activity (Buddhism actually has strong criticisms of the kind of "becoming like a stone, sitting inactively" that I think you're describing), not just a person who perceives without agency. Think of your phrase, "embodied action", and think of what Sam is describing, how most people erroneously identify themselves AS thought which HAS a body. Sam is describing actually becoming MORE embodied. Harris is suggesting that agency is actually IMPEDED or even illusory in the mode that 99.9 people live their lives; sitting and meditating actually reveals a power for real agency.
Lastly, I think the idea that meditation/mindful awareness is akin to "a mode of pure perception without agency" is... I think it comes from the erroneous and hyper-rationalist view that we somehow THINK our way into action, which thence constitutes agency: I think this is a common-sensical view which is quite at odds with the reality of how things work; what Harris is describing is much more akin to SKILL in action, not actionlessness.
@@julianmarx2002 Thanks for letting me clarify.
@@elektrotehnik94 Well then its I who misunderstood you... I do agree with you that Harris can come off as somewhat pompous or defensive at times. But, I don't necessarily agree that everyone HAS to be outwardly playful and light all the time either. Some people are ferocious in temperament, or rather cold (like Spock) but if their heart is in the right place I think its fine. And Sam is actually quite playful (he has a whole series with Ricky Gervais for instance, which is hilarious).
@@julianmarx2002 Maybe you are right... maybe Sam has a good reason to be as he is... But I still feel Sam would benefit from meditating more :D
I'm fairly confident he has yet plenty to gain from meditation
I love listening to these gentlemen.
The level of intellect is of such nature that I have to listen to them more than once to make sense of it some times. English is not my mother tongue and some times their discussion sounds as if they are talking in a language completely unknown to me.
I love listening to you, because the subjects you discuss matter. It has substance and makes me think.
Love you guys.
this is one of my favorite conversations for sure. i am not religious, and have not been since i was 16, but hearing different perspectives is always interesting to me.
perspective '
all sam did is lie about religion brother.
he can lie to peterson but not to wel informed inetelectuals about this topic.
this is so stupid ...he spoke for an hour i did not learn much from him
Saw this. Had to stop what I was doing and allocate the next 1:45:32 of my life to something that I'm sure will be useful and important. Time well spent. Thanks for all you do and say JP. Stay well!
Note : Complexity in the above comment is that it uses timestamp 1:45:32 for completing the sentence.
What did you learn from it? Any actionable changes made from this info?
@@zblus Yes, he’s going to send Peterson a ‘stay well’ card. 😳
same
Man . . . it is so damned good to see these two discussing things again . . . and how exciting and invigorating their conversations are! I will be seeing Jordan Peterson speak live here in Southern California in a couple of months or so (my sister bought the tickets and invited me . . . both of my sisters are awesome!) . . . What an absolute treasure these two are.
Hoping with everything that is in me that Jordan Peterson gets plenty of rest and stays healthy . . .
Iam going to a lecture too, in June. Finally got tickets. Peterson is back and got himself a big tour in 2022. Just need to see a live show and Peterson is almost 60. Maybe he quits or ritire after this year. Enjoy your show 👍
You can tell they've both grown from the past discussions.... from spending two hours at an impasse on the definition of the word "truth" to this
Iove that idea about this moment being potentially fresh and meditation leading to this. Breaking on through to the other side - transcending our ideas and labels and artificial concepts.
Once I effectively learned to meditate I would do it at any time, it became a mobile state in which I was rejuvenated and empowered at the same time. Such a great, great ability in usefulness and self care. I love you guys, beautiful minds openly sharing. I respect you both so much.
The first step is the hardest step. I encourage you to start doing it again. Take that first step.
I am a survivor of a serious Brain injury, And all of the words you use have a very deep and explanatory meaning to me. Bravo Keep it up!
I have noticed a gradual increase in suffering from the moment my meditation habit started crumbling a couple of months ago.
In some sense you could say I am waking up to the fact that the waking up app has drastically reduced my suffering in times of consistent practice.
Thank you Jordan and Sam for the lovely conversation. 🙏
Meditation (or other similar spiritual practice) has that "grounding effect" on a person
Do you know what meditating cutting firewood taking care of animals taken care of your children taking care of your home and doing your work whatever that is you won’t have time to be needing to meditate your work is your meditation your humbling yourself
Could you explain shortly how this app is a help, as opposed to for instance just meditating old school? What does it do and how does it help? Gives you reminders for example?
I was a fan of Sam Harris before Dr. Peterson's ascencion into the spotlight. I'm still a fan of both men and enjoy listening to both of them share their ideas. Very enriching stuff.
A true intellectual doesn't denounce either side of an argument. The best thing to do is seek the Truth from both sides. Even as an Atheist I am a huge fan of Jordan Peterson because he is far more than just a believer, he's a Humanist and that's just fine by me. Society needs more of that on top of reason and logic which cannot stand on its own without the wisdom of the other.
Same here, I've always been a fan of both of them.
@@proudatheist2042 Indeed and well said. I will ponder what you said today. Kind regards.
@@proudatheist2042 - Well stated. I have a lot of respect for both Sam Harris and Jordan Peterson. I used to be an atheist but I still have all my Sam Harris books.
Man, I love how much these two respect and admire each other, even when encountering areas of deep disagreement. I wish more people in the public eye had the maturity and obvious good intention these men show. SO grateful for these conversations ❤
YOU are an amazing person Jordan! I love you & am very proud of you. I strive to be a better father, husband, and friend every day. Your messages & teachings are beyond inspiring.
Love when these two link up. If you haven't seen their debate videos, you can find them on TH-cam and they are MASTERFUL
Sam Harris is a colossal fraud.
It's sad that Jordan is still talking to him 👎🏼
It would be better if Sam was programmed to have a personality
@@john_g_henderson a
@@john_g_henderson aside from his tds Sam is pretty brilliant
my favorite conversations... these 2...we need free-thinkers like this; agreeing/disagreeing... but learning and evolving stances through acquiring and parsing what they've learned.
This is the type of dialogue that gives me hope for the future. Thank you!
I'm an educator and I suggest these podcasts to all my students. Thank you for your work Dr Peterson.
Really? You cannot recommend something better to them?
J. Peterson all I can continue to say is thank you for all you do for all of us. While my life is pretty difficult at the moment, your talks have given me the ability to keep going and see the light in all the darkness. Finding meaning in everything I do and why I do it. It’s help me stay in a positive state through my difficult sickness that I’m going through. Thank you !
surrender surrender surrender surrender surrender surrender to god
@@mikelisteral7863 it’s the most difficult thing because it means to lose control and have solely have faith in Gods will… to the point of death and or believe that your sickness will end you …. Its been difficult. Raised in the Catholic faith and Jordan has help me understand my faith and truly appreciate my faith.
You have to hang on and get out of social conditioning. You have to create your own way of thinking
Surrender to God as in he came with his army and ripped the village apart killed all the men raped the women and took the children that God
Ynwa mate
Harris really does bring the best out of Peterson, I think. What I would give to have this monthly! Thanks to the both of you.
imagination is greater than knowledge. an artists will always be able to debunk an logician.
These conversations are so important. I believe they're critical, and become more so over time. Thanks to you and Sam for doing this essential work.
Id like to see debate installed as a credited course in junior or high school
This wasn't so much of a conversation as it was Sam Harris lending some attention and support to J.P. in hopes that J. P. makes a recovery from his mental issues and doesn't jump off a cliff. ( Which is what happened after their previous stage appearances.)
I appreciate this discussion, and for me I think this is the conversation that sealed the deal that Sam Harris ultimately won the war throughout these two's series of arguments.
I love seeing you two having a relationship and these ongoing conversations. Thank you both for all the work you have put into your lives and your work, and for having this conversation.
Jordan really has an amazing ability to state his case in such an enlightened way. He makes the confused come to grips with facts. Sam on the other hand is so confused on facts and makes you want change the channel in frustration.
@@heynow01 enjoy them both. Don't take them for granted.
The amount of truth and ideas packed into the ongoing dialogue between these two has been hugely edifying and orienting for me, especially since recently starting a family. *THANKS DR. PETERSON* 🙏🏽
fancy seeing you here
Love your channel sir. Good to see you here.
173880 proves when the Christ would come. Chuck Missler saved me.
Can you find the hidden cross in numbers chapter 2?
What do the names mean in Genesis chapter 5?
Electric resistivity scans proves Noah’s ark in Turkey!
Sam Harris is an effete trust fund baby who has contributed nothing of lasting value to science, philosophy, or politics. He's a fraud.
congratulations on your new baby!
The consistency in the comments to this video makes it so clear how true the words are that were spoken. It touches places in my mind that were starving for recognition.
the biggest joy one can only achieve having gone through very rough adversity. Like ReUniting with loved ones you were seemingly forever separated from. That is a joy you only can feel having felt / endured the opposite.
So lucky that we can watch great minds like Jordan and Sam engage, debate and question all things, Thank you.
I agree about Jordan being a great mind, but Sam...not so much.
No kidding S.H. is FULL OF HIMSELF!
^^^ examples of dogmatic ideology and bias are center stage above me
And We demand more Good Sirs!
Sam Harris is a legitimate intellectual , Jordan Peterson is frankly the Canadian version of Deepak Chopra .
It's a privilege to witness this discussion between two people I respect so much. Each of these people are making immense effort to sincerely and honestly find solutions to the biggest questions and most intractable issues of our time. I recommend anyone not already familiar with either of their work to dig deep and explore their work sooner than later.
Thank you to both of you for taking the time to share so much with us.
@@faridguelmi7123 Thank you for sharing your perspective Farid. I also can't agree with everything either Peterson or Harris say. What impresses me the most is that the things they teach that are the most impactful, I agree with entirely. That's a hard combination to find these days. As far as who's behind Harris, keep in mind he has constructed an incentive structure for himself and his organization that is immune at best and resistant at worst to undue interference from the outside. We are all fallible, but Harris seems to be on the correct track.
Their first conversation was my introduction to this whole thing. Thanks guys!
Wow. This is my introduction to Sam Harris. I’ve heard JP speak of him often, but I’d never listened to any of their conversations. This was fantastic. I look forward to the next one.
Them saying goodbye to each other just about had me in tears. Touching.
bit awkward eh?
Me too! Genuine love and admiration for each other. So refreshing.
@@mr.goldfish7473 not at all, it is just your projection anyway two beautiful souls looking to make good in this earth
@@mr.goldfish7473 just the regular stuff that comes with communicating on zoom
what always stuck me was the obvious synergy between Sam's premise of being able to derive morality via Science and Jordan's work to scientifically understand the importance of mythology
sam makes an age old mistake of confusing morality with utilitarianism. morality does not come from good, it comes from our sense of fairness which comes from the fact we are all equal on the human level.
@@mikelisteral7863 biology says otherwise.
@@mikelisteral7863 What do you mean "we're all equal on the human level"? And why only on the human level? Identifying with the species? Morality stems from a sense of belonging, i.e. tribalism? It's interesting to note here that that's almost entirely a mammalian thing, as far as I'm aware amphibians and reptilians don't have that thing (ingroup vs outgroup, herd mentality, abstraction about belonging in a collective). Just saying.
@@Realivangarcia i did not say we are identical. i said we are all equal on the human level. you are human and i am human and therefore fairness is objectively correct.
@@EyeOfTheTiger777 morality has nothing to do with belonging. our emotions are programmed to keep us in a tribe. but morality is rooted in our sense of fairness not sams utility or hedonism root.
It's been a whole year since another live show was teased on this podcast. Please make it happen! You two have the best conversations ❤
The "Smart money" is on it not happening. (anytime soon anyway) Petty went bat-sh** crazy after their previous conversations. He worsened his benzedrine addiction and had to resort to treatments (which are illegal/prohibited here in the West) in the USSR. Now- He has recovered to some degree but for the most part the noted and respectable voices in the Pshyc field(s) do avoid him so as not to contribute to his problems. Sam appeared, as a guest here, out of professional and personal courtesy.
@@BobSTK I just see an addict who got the help they need and is now fully in recovery. Not sure why anyone feels the need to bring up that the help he got wasn't licensed in the US. All countries have their own policies on health care - most important is that it seems to have worked for him. The question in that case really ought to be, why isn't it licensed in the US?
He's clearly got mental health and addiction problems but that shouldn't rule out someone compassionate like Sam having a conversation with him. It's not like they ever agreed to begin with, they still managed to get along courteously and have interesting chats. Peterson may have become more grandiose and evangelical in his style (as has Sam, on some subjects!) but his basic positions haven't changed. I don't see why his health issues would really matter on this topic.
@@JoshWiniberg I can appreciate your thoughts. However I was simply stating and briefly explaining my reasoning. Of course this is just my opinion but when I watch this video I strongly see (sense) a lot of tension / apprehension in J.P. facial expressions. And a sense of relief in J. P.’s facial expressions at the end. As if to say to him-self, “Wow I made it!!!” And I also “sense” that Sam H. did this interview out of an obligation he possibly feels to show /lend J. P. some personal support in his recovery and of course as a professional courtesy.
@@BobSTK I think at that time JP was happy just to make it to the end of an interview without keeling over and dying. If you watch any of his discussions from that time you can tell he's struggling to get through it. Regarding why Sam came on, I don't think it's so much a matter of courtesy - their discussions have been mutually beneficial if you look at the fact they sold out four arenas to have discussions that are celebrated to this day. You could be right that he feels like helping out a friend but I don't think Sam would prostitute himself out exclusively for friendship or professional courtesy - he's extremely intellectually proud and I don't think he'd do anything that he didn't think was really meaningful, even for close friends. You may be right of course, it's impossible to say one way or the other, and we don't know them personally or what their relationship is really like. But it doesn't sound like Sam to me, and I don't see anything unusual in Peterson's body language either that would lead me to the same conclusions as you.
Such a deep conversation. Sometimes it's over my head, but I still love to listen to Mr. Peterson talk.
so does Jordan Peterson.
Dr. ;)
@@HomelessHomeowner617 lame
Peterson and Harris, I would like to thank you from the bottom of my heart. Thank you !!. You two have brought me such a tremendous amount of joy, intellectual stimulans and most of all personal improvement. I really hope there will be more conversations like these. And I Wish you both all the best in the future.
That experimmmetnal dddrug called the bcovvid druggg is causing the hearttt atttackks of young athelllets on the fieeld. Wakke up.
JACK FROSTY We can only hope Mr Frosty
@@jackfrosty4674 what on earth are you talking about and what does that have to do with what I just said?? 😆🤔
My wife and I are Heroin addicts living in our car. We are currently in the parking lot of a psychward/Detox facility. We are sleeping in the parking lot, so tomorrow morning at 8:30am when they allow people to check in we won’t miss our chance by getting here to late. We are so excited to start living a happier and healthier life together. Both Sam and Jordan have helped us in so many ways!!! Thank you gentlemen, seriously you two are amazing people!
How you doin?
Since that post we did 30 days in rehab and have now been just over 120 days off heroin. My wife has an amazing job, and we’ve been staying in a motel, but in just under two weeks will be in a a house with good sober friends of ours who we are moving 6 hours away from Chicago to be as far away from knowing where to possibly even get heroin. So my wife will be able to do her job remote, we are doing so much better than we ever thought. We are still doing intensive outpatient three days a week as well on Skype.
@@courtneysettepani9782 Wow, that's impressive. I am very glad.
Damnit. Never give up. PLEASE TAKE KRATOM. TRY IT. ITS THE ONLY REASON IM STILL HERE......
@@jessemontano762 hey Jesse thank you so much. We’re still completely off opioids. We moved 6 1/2 hours from Chicago, so we have no clue where to even get it now. Now being in Wisconsin so far from the IL boarder we can’t get kratom., it’s illegal here, which is fucking bullshit!! We’re going back that way for a night in about a week n will 100% get like 100 ounces or something to last. Anyway I’m ranting, thank you again for your kind words and caring!
I could write out all the questions born out of my own personal need for, well it doesn’t matter. This was a treat. Thank you to both of you.
One of his finest interviews up to this day.
I don't know if you'd both be able to find the time, but there is HUGE potential for a regular Peterson/Harris podcast, separate from your own individual ones. You two seem to have a unique relationship where you approach things from completely different angles, yet often seem to reach similar conclusions with an odd blend of conversation, debate, agreement, argument. And it's all with 100% good faith. It's compelling viewing 👍
A conversation combining viewpoints from neuroscience, ethics, (17-20th century) psychology and philosophy always makes for a compelling listen especially from the minds of JP and SH.
@Andy Mann
Stop projecting.
@Andy Mann
Just because you can’t remember or understand something does not mean others can’t follow along.
Again stop projecting your inadequacies onto everyone else.
@Andy Mann In just 1 hour 45 minutes they give us enough content to keep coming back. It's like reading a complex book. You can't just understand all of it in one sitting.
Harris called humans Apes. Doesn’t seem to be the sharpest tool in the shed.
Listening to these chaps I actually feel somewhat more optimistic for the future than i did. The fact i can listen to people like this for free is actually a great and encouraging thing. There is much fear about the soft power mafia of the technocracy, arts media and culture (and rightly so) but they’ve always been a shady bunch who’ve choked free narratives- at least now we have access to people and ideas like this. Thanks to TH-cam and The Drs
Why? Sam Harris openly and proudly supports the parties of censorship and mandates.
Just as an aside this isn’t always the easiest conversation to follow. Sams propensity to thread a very complex epistemological strand through the eye of a hard to imagine, abstract needle is impressive :) … maybe my IQ and cognitive RAM is just not up to the job though
@@MrAhuraMazda I don’t know about that sir. But I suppose i meant more generally as a phenomenon. That people are able to connect with a larger sea of ideas. In my youth there was 4 TV channels and 6 newspapers in the UK. That was a very easy landscape for the ‘Metro elite’ to seize and control. I think we’re far more aware of how a small group is doing that now and platforms like these (TH-cam) are helping us.
JP and Sam Harris have the same audience.
Most of their audience is the typical Joe Rogan crowd. Majority Right wing frustrated men.
They themselves have acknowledged this, they personally say that their audiences overlap on about 80% of the issue besides religion and some political issues.
Just watched the 4 discussions in Vancouver, Dublin, and London. Very excited to see where this conversation goes.
Two intellectual titans. Pushing the absolute limit of human understanding. The most complex and demanding conversations in history. I love the way they respect each other and I bow down to both of them. Thanks for this gents.
Wait till you see a conversation about phisics lol
You have articulated my thoughts on both this interaction between the two persons and my views on them as individuals.
these kind of conversations give me so much hope, less arguing to argue and more of this ❤ everytime JP said something like "I'm not trying to corner you" it made me smile. How can we ever talk through and learn if everything is a fight and we can never misspeak or change our mind. As a religious person I usually struggle with Sam Harris and feel he is condescending to what I believe but found him fascinating here :)
sam is a materialist who is trying to squeeze spirituality into his materialism
@@mikelisteral7863 spot on. nothing can explain or sum him up better than the manner you succinctly put here.
@@Arafat-my6fe sam gets alot of happiness from intellectualizing about his material reality. and therefore is not ready to give it up and jump off the deep end in meditation.
@@mikelisteral7863 Sam speaks about spirituality all the time, as well as the significance, relevance, and doubtlessness of spiritual experiences..... you clearly are unfamiliar with Sam's work.
Tyte life
Why do you think he is being condescending? Don't you think he understands why you believe what you believe?
I am always relieved when I can listen to Jordan and he isn't constantly talking over his guest. These two are more pleasant to listen to in this conversation than in past recordings I have heard.
Oh good he doesnt in this? Im just starting and was hoping JP didnt over talk and Sam isnt claiming vaccine necessity is as obvious as necessity of oxygen. Im not seeing any comment on Sams unwillingness to discuss pandemic.. maybe that is not discussed..
hmmm
@@Think-dont-believe That's just not the topic of this podcast and it doesn't have to be. Covid will pass, the topic of this podcast will not.
Extremelt satisfying... Very odd yet complimenting coupling... And yes! Please do this again...
Actually Dr Harris talked about things against religion that I thought for a long time and nobody else talk about that so I'm so happy for this stuff thanks Dr Harris.
I love to listen to the discussions you have with Sam, I find them so engaging that I can't even get distracted for like more than 1 hour and that's saying something to me.
I rarely listen to podcasts as long as this one. But with them two, no way I could skip to other podcasts. Love them both!
Jordan talks about the roots of anything or anyone's issues with a very fine tooth and comb. I love the topics he speaks on. Usually the ones that matter to humanity's well being, and communicating with every different ways of thinking 🤔. I love his podcast!
This conversation really warmed my heart.
This is probably the single most valuable and educational podcast episode, I have ever come across.
Well that's really saying something lol
Wow - that was quite something. Sometimes I find these intellectual discussions a little difficult to connect with, but this one felt grounded in experience I could relate to. Thank you to both speakers!
Agreed.
I saw and met them both when they toured to Dublin. It was the most boring conversation ever. You can watch that entire tour on TH-cam I think.
I'm a big fan of both. But I nearly fell asleep...
This conversation was incredible. 2 intellectual heavyweights. I would pay to see them speak again.
Please listen again, Peterson uses sophist tools.
@@frederickvandenheuvel479 Can you be more specific?
@@ClanMacqueen Before his explosive popularity, Peterson was a talking head in Ontario for a decade or more, weighing in on various topics. Heard him many times. His debating skill was evident and convincing. But, if you paid attention, you could tell he’d adjust the underlying argument or obfuscate the discussion. Listen to him - he’s good - but listen again with a critical ear. Admittedly, Peterson is mostly acquiescent in this discussion. I recommend you go back and listen to his past arguments.
Nevertheless, at 55:55 and 1:11:50 he pushes a bit (not sure my times are exactly right). Beginning at 1:14 things get odd. Criticism of the sacred, of something that cannot be questioned, sets him off… Curious, considering the 55:55 point regarding totalitarianism.
JP, you are spoiling us with all this free knowledge lately! Top notch conversations, almost every day.
It’s hard to focus on college course material with all this content dropping, watch Jordan recent appearance on PBD podcast, it’s good
Sam seems to be not willing to step out of his "the analyst"/ "detachment" mode.
What is this mode? While in this mode, it shows us that we can experience/ spend time in the realization that we as spiritual beings can be very separated from our embodiment/ action-realm, while in that mode.
The analyst mode is something that deep meditation tends to introduce to a person (personal experience). It is a great "perception tool" in "the toolset".
But being in that mode is not where most of Sam's/ ours "daily embodied actions" take place. It's not where our social life/ organization of our society takes place. It's not where our experience with "material reality" takes place.
What I mean is, the analyst mode is not dealing with the problems of how to act in this world. That mode is pure perception. It is inherently without agency, inherently without the motivation to act.
Jordan is talking about how to determine how to make ever-better embodied actions. Sam seems to not even be interested in diving into the process of how humans did/ do that, in practice. Is it just me?
@@elektrotehnik94, it's not just you. The way you said it was very eloquent, though. I was not going to be so charitable. But since you were, I will be.
I really appreciate how thought-provoking JP's questions are. I admire how JP, who seems to have nearly endless knowledge about so many things--even things he claims he has not much knowledge of (he's truly humble), can understand the other person's point of view so well that he even helps make the other person's point, even when that other person doesn't realize he is not making a point or that he, himself, is sabotaging his own point (the times when he seems to have one--a point, I mean).
@@davidbeaumont244 Demonizing a blind man (Sam Harris) for not seeing is not helping.
It might feel good, but it's not helping.
You help convince him to get the operation making him see again. That actually helps, helps both of you
You get a like just for your name . LOL!
Sam accidentally (or maybe not) described a great part of the Buddhist worldview. I'm so glad to see this rising to people's awareness lately.
Like Jordan, Sam is genuinely and continuously searching for truth, this is why these discussions are so deep, interesting and seems endless. I noticed that at many levels they seem to agree until they arrive to practically bottom level. This is the level from which their own world view emerges.
I would suggest that every discussion between Jordan and Sam starts by phrasing and reminding the major point of disagreement, first. Its useful for the listener.
Wow, I've followed you both for years and to see this discussion is so powerful. Thank you both. Watching you agree and discuss your versions of was more powerful than the battles of the past.
Thank you, that is all I can say. Your conversations are so incredibly honest, thoughtful, thought-provoking, and important. I love that you invite us all in to join you. These conversations are a kind of meditation in and of themselves, a filet mignon with fine wine for my mind. Again, thank you.
Or bread and water, to the starved.
I really appreciate how these men engage in a deep, difficult discussion without trying to talk over the other to make a point. Voice volume remains constant even when disagreement is obviously present. They are both skilled listeners. TV personalities could learn a lot from these two men.
Good luck trying that with a laydee, haha 😄
Appreciate your intellect and thoughtfulness in making this important observation. Nicely stated.
ehh, i actually felt jordan kept interrupting sam’s line of thinking one too many times in this… got kinda annoying
WHERE is it that Sam Harris does the BIG REVEAL... on his Anti-Trump Delusions?
They are entertainers