Allah's exclusive name is al Wahab! by Abu Huraira! - **I have not ceased to love Bani Tamim (bin Abd. Wahab?) since I heard 3 qualities of them by Allah's Messenger (ﷺ peace & blessings be on him) who said: They, out of my umma, will be the strongest opponent of Ad-Dajjal;** `Aisha had a slave-girl from them, and the Prophet (ﷺ peace and blessings be upon him) told her to manumit her as she was from the descendants of (the Prophet) Ishmael; and, when their Zakat was brought, the Prophet (ﷺ peace and blessings be upon him) said, "This is the Zakat of my people." - Sahih al-Bukhari 4366, Book of Expeditions, Kitab Al-Maghaazi
Salaam brother, that image with the muslim lady was disturbing because of the appearance of that lady not because she is a muslim. Please have respect for her and don't show us her. We came here to wake us up not to see a temptation. Please brother/sister. Correct me if im wrong please.
If I didn’t know Sheikh Hamza before and listen to him for the first time, I would say that he is a native Arabic speaker. And this is only shows how much dedication he put into learning our great religion ❤️
Yes indeed. He got most acknowledge from scholars from Moritania. Also he calls himself an Arab because he studied "fiqh allugha" or science or depth of the Arabic language. He teaches Arabic in Santa Clara Mosque USA. MOSLEM ADVISER....
What I learnt from Shaykh Hamza is let us not be judgemental of others especially since we are layman and should look towards our weaknesses and shortcomings. We at the same time should supplicate to Allah SWT to show us the Truth as Truth and be guided by it and be shown Falsehood as Falsehood and be safeguarded from it
I believe that this is valid for those zealous for Dawah. A lot of Daees are damaging the cause of Islam due to their lack of wisdom, manners and superiority complexes.
Shaykh Hamza saved my aqeeda and imaan with his vast knowledge of different sciences of the Deen. So fortunate to have him amongst us. May Allah bless him with health so we can benefit from him, because he brought me closer to the habeeb and the beloved prophet Muhammad sallalaahu alayhiwasallam and may Allah give the Shaykh closeness to the prophet sallalaahu alayhiwasallam.
How did he save your aqeeda when he calls upon the prophet directly for help as the video the brother linked clearly shows. This is shirk. After watching the video its your right as a muslim to remove your comment
Alhamdulillah for traditional scholars who can explain the narrowness of Salafiyyah in English... Our scholars are mostly in our Muslim society languages and very few in English..
@DaBurger1411 The word "Salaf" ≠ Salafiyya. Also, "Just following the Salaf" without explaining further is meaningless since even the Shia say they are "following the Salaf".
@DaBurger1411 Sigh. Look, I do not have the urge or time to debate, especially someone who identifies himself with a burger. If you want to actually learn, do it yourself by looking up the difference. In brief, this the problem with Salafis: Unless you can distinguish an 18th-century phenomenon from a 7th to 21st century phenomenon, you cannot understand what path has always been followed by the vast masses of Muslims. Salam
@DaBurger1411 Dear brother: 1) Sincere advice: Please do not assume of others that which you do not know. This is a huge problem with the Salafiyya who slap a pejorative label of "Sufi" on everyone and anyone without a eye on the issue at stake. I'm not a Sufi but a Muslim, a traditional Muslim, as were the vast masses of Muslims through the past 14 centuries. Traditional or ordinary Muslims have always opposed going to graves for intercession and also opposed the historic destruction of Sahabas' houses, flattening them and turning them into public bathrooms or highways. The former are Barelwi movement, a 19th century phenomenon, and the latter comes from Salafiyya, also a 19th century phenomenon. Salafiyya is a modern concept that borrows from the actual Salaf and some well-known scholars, but is qualitatively different from the Islam that has been followed by the vast masses of Muslims through the past. Salafiyya-identifying groups are known as "Ahle Hadeeth" in some parts of the world, which I find far more apt than Salafi because "Salafi" by itself can describe all kinds of Muslims. 2) Learn to distinguish between the map and the territory. You seem to confuse the two. They are not the same thing. 3) I want to emphasize, please read and teach in the real world instead of debating online, even on this very issue. Online comment box debates are not a very good use of your or my time. Salam aleykum.
I love you shaykh for the sake of Allah! May Allah reward you and to those who made this video available with good dunya wal akhirah! Allahumma Ameen.. 🤲🏼🤲🏽🤲🏻🤲🏾❤️
Something to bare in mind....Majority of historical scholars were imprisoned,tortured or killed due to them not compromising the pure deen.We should also keep in the mind those who have been murdered not only by western governments but also by so called 'Muslim' govrnements for speaking out against their attrocities.Remember also the Prophet pbuh warned against the times when 'scholars visit palaces'..Pure Islamic teaching is becoming more difficult to spread publicly..Innovation is rife..
I use to mock the sharia loving zealots around me by saying according to sharia law, all classical scholars are criminals and then asking them, So which one are you?
How to know what prophet Muhammad ﷺ actually said ? How lucky the companions of Prophet Muhammad ﷺ were. How beautiful it was to sit next to him and listen what he said when Angel's were surrounding him ﷺ
Even the mutawatir ahadith have variations. The ahadith aren't designed to be preserved. What is preserved is the Qur'an and the living tradition. The secret of Islam is in the Sanad. We didn't learn salah from hadith, we learnt it by watching other people who watched other people who watched other people etc. Only now, the protestant movement, just like in Christianity, says that we should turn only to Sola Scriptura. But the Imams didn't teach this deen through ahadith; they lived the tradition and other people saw them and lived it too. Islam is a living organism.
@@DarioHaruni it's wrong, if my dad make some innovation in the religion, I follow the wrong way. Ahadit are important to stay attached to autentic Islam.
Masha'Allah! Shaykh Hamza Yusuf is profoundly outspoken. At present what this reminds me of what is going on in Pakistan, where every so-called "critic/moulvi" are on the verge of calling eachother "KAFIRS" for not following their "school of thoughts" though we have very highly intelligent Islamic Scholars that are very well versed with the Holy Qur'an and Hadiths.But unfortunately there is so much disappointment and misguidance that is damaging the present ongoing situation in our society. Sorry I forgot but I must mention that there are so many new comers in this profession/trade that have adopted the title of "moulvi" inherited through their grandfather who happened to be a true/faithful believer and running a madrassa/masajid left behind for their children/grandchildren to use it for their political benefits and illegal activities
it's not just Pakistan it's all over Islamic world sadly.this is the weapon of west to divide and rule so muslims can fight each other then to rule worlds.
JazakaAllah, for your words of wisdom Sheikh, i believe i learn something new everytime i listen to one of your speeches. May Allah (SWT) keep you with us for as long as it would be best, put barakah in your life and work, Aameen.
I don't know where I belong to this called group, and I don't mind as long as I follow qur'an and the teaching of prophet (pbuh) and what sahabah did..
Jazakum Allahu Khairan Shaikh. The Messenger of Allah SAS said: "I am the City of Knowledge and Ali is its Gate." How do we interpret that? Is it not obvious? "Rabbi zidni ilman wa fahman."
My uncle used to remind me about bidah and I need to be careful with it, he graduate from Madinah University. I made it a habit to investigate the source of news whenever I went to any Islamic talks.
And the prophet صلى الله عليه وسلم also said be careful where you take your knowledge from as it can be for us or against us May Allah protect us all He صلى الله عليه وسلم feared for us for misguidance scholars like sufis, shias ect... So be careful from this individual
@@namakubento9604 May Allah guide you to true salafiasm the salafs the first generation who followed the prophet صلى الله عليه وسلم the correct way while the other 72 sects went astray
The trouble is: first Saudis rejected Islam then steadily accepted it....Then started owning it like Private Property with no scope for intellectualism,for some became Black n White to the letter.Yet there is another crowd who got stuck coal in the eyes, henna colour beard , Hijab of tent so on n so forth. Islam emphasis on moral,social,economic ethics with deep respect for creation that includes Natural World......Thanks for the lecture Shaikh Humza.
I swear the only pieces of knowledge and information that strnghtens my Iman always comes from Asharis. Everything makes sense. The others will plainly tell you don't use your brain.
Muhammad AS said some kinds of knowledge or eloquence is sorcery in the hands of a man who lacks character (a Hadith from Kitaab Al Kalaam from the Muwatta)
Without taking a stance, it is well known that Ibn Sina drank wine in moderation to help with sleep. This is not a conspiracy, it is documented in several historical texts and he advocated for it in moderation. The point: stop blindly following any scholar-whether Salafi, Sufi or other. They are all humans. Many scholars continue to be exposed today-whether it’s their political views or social life. The misguided scholars and corrupt rulers are a clear sign of the end times.
True salafiyyah is being a true sunni. It has got to this stage of calling one salafi as everyone claims to be sunni. Salaffiyah is based upon strict adherence to the sunnah, based on too the quran. That is based upon the companions understanding and practice of the two latter components. True salafi its principles are too, Knowledge ie the quran and sunnah proceeds action and speech. This is salafiyyah my brothers and sisters. May Allah protect us from personalities who preach the opposite. And with Allah lies sucess.
So is Malikiyyah not adherence to Quran? 'Salafis' believe a lot of things that are against the Quran lol and they say 'The Quran said to follow the Rasoul' so they can bring some Hadith and explain why they can contradict the Quran
Or people who call themself Salafis. This Maliki Sheykh from Saudi gave lectures about why Don't we teach Hadiths by virtues that Allah praised in the Quran, first Justice, then Character then Perceiverence etc.. And Saudis put him in Jail for 12 years for 'extremism'... Because he said most Shouyoukh focus on Hadith to only push certain politics.. And at this time the 'Salafis' all praised the rulers in Saudi all the time
@@nadjiguemarful we are not blind followers of malaki is, handbali etc, we are followers of Muhammad (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) following him only. We sunnis take from all of the 4 imams, may Allah have mercy upon them all. It is haraam to restrictedly follow one imam except, prophet Muhammad (peace and blessings be upon him). Also, imam Malik may Allah have mercy upon him, did not even call the ummah to say you are or must restrictedly call yourself Maliki? So why are you promoting this. We are labelled Muslim, sunni/ahlul hadeeth, salafi. Not even Muhammadans. May Allah protect us from blind following of personalities. Moreover, regarding Saudi politics, is not part of our topic, and answer concerning being sunni truly, its people of knowledge, its definition and what its strict criteria it is to be a real follower of the sunnah, and then truly call yourself muslim sunni, salafi. Ie followers of nabi Muhammad (peace and blessings be upon him) based upon the pious companions understanding and practice of Islam. Because you are straying from the issue at hand. And with Allah lies guidance and sucess.
Its sad when, prophet Muhammad call everyone "A believer"or muslim, and nowadays people end up making themselves "sunni"or "shia"or "salafi"whatever....
The Prophet Muhammad pbuh said on Arafat in his last sermon 'today your deen is complete,nothing has been left out and nothing needs to be added'..'any innovation will lead to the fire'..The sufi's have added innivation after innovation to the pure deen of Islam.Their twirling,singing and chanting etc was NEVER performed by the Nabi pbuh or his Sahabah,neither was mawlid practiced by the Nabi pbuh or the Sahaba ( the best of the best and most closest to the Prophet pbuh).Yet sufis practice these strange behaviours and claim them to be from Islam.It is very similar to Christian practices of monks.This is also something the Prophet pbuh warned us against imitating..
Not every hanafi practices twirling or mawlid. I don't. And many like me don't. But didn't you read about Ibn taymiyah saying "with pure intentions, a person performing mawlid shall be rewarded?" I can give reference.
You clearly didn't listen to a word that Hamza Yusuf said , you're just regurgitating typical Salafi talking points , like you've been brainwashed . I doubt you actually know what that even means . And I doubt you even know how many types of bidah there are and what they are called
@@Directlite664 Just like any unfortunate muslim who does zina. He becomes a sinner, yet he is still a muslim but on the day of judgment, only Allah knows who has iman in his heart or who didn't have any. In this world we can only judge by actions. If he says he is a muslim and he utters the shahada he is treated as a muslim and if a sin like zina is proven by specific witnessing of penetration by 4 adult morally upright male witnesses then the punishment is carried out by a valid court not mobs as is unfortunately the case nowadays. Secondly, you have to prove that ibn sina did zina openly before you make it public here as then you will be questioned by Allah swt on the day of judgment. Would you like someone who hates you do the Same to you? Fear Allah and do not concern yourself with whatever does not concern you, it would be better for your heart.
@Khaliil bin Ammar , this is a joke right? No one is making takfir except the Salafis. Takfir is their hallmark. They're a never-ending fitna started by Ibn Abd al-Wahhab and strategically bolstered by the British, Israelis and Americans in order to dismantle the Ottoman Sultanate and serve as a mechanism of internal strife in Ummah in order to keep the Muslims perpetually divided.
May Allah grant Sheikh Hamza Yusuf good health and increase him in Knowledge.But let get something clear here,he is human and he can make mistakes.Those who are taking everything from him are the true ignorants of the deen.He is doing a great service to Islam in his own way but along the line he makes mistakes and l pray Allah guide him.I have for a very long time understand the diversity of Islam.From the time of our dear prophet(PBUH) the different of opinions among his companions was apparent and that gave me the understanding of how Muslims can have different opinions.Also from the Hadith about the division in Islam.As a sunni muslim,l get to know the different of opinions among our four imams so there is no need for all these unnecessary arguments and insults here.
Salamu alaykom 🌸 thank you for this video around minute 6 shaykh Hamza yusef mentionned an imam who was also a doctor. Can you please give us his complete name? I couldn't find him on the internet. Jazakum allah Alf khair
In the book ‘Muhtesaru mearidil-kabul’ (page. 234) Ibn Qayyim al-Jawziyya says about Abu Ali Sinai this;" He believed that the world has existed forever (that it was not created), he denied the akhira, knowledge and Allah swt might, and denied the creation of the world and resurrection of the dead". This would conclude the debate and expose the ignorance of Hamza Yusuf.
Salafi's reject the idea of Mazhab and claim to follow Quran and Sunnah directly. This contraditcts the very foundation of having a Hanbali (or the other 3 Mazhabs) Hanbali's like the other school of Fiqh accept Ijma' as a source of Jurisprudice (after Quran and Sunnah). Salafis seem (at least in practice) reject that idea. There are differences in Aqida. More signifcant is that many Salafis seem to reject other opinions and schools in Fiqh and Aqidah, which the Hanbalis don't. **That means even if Salafis would equal Hanbalis in Aqida and Fiqh (which they don't), when the Salafis reject other Madhabs and Aqidah schools, than they become clearly different form Hanbalis. ** Also Salafis reject Tassawuf completely, Hanbalis do not. And the most important Point: Salafis by their ideologoy do not like to be associated with a certain mazhab, aqeeda, manaj, etc. That means there might be Salafi Scholars that accept Mazhabs completely, while others call people who folloow Mazhabs Kufaar. Both are of course extreme cases. Because this ambiguity with Salafis, but not with Hanbalis, they become something completely different. Also Hanbalis are accepted and embraced by all Sunni scholars as part of Ahlus-sunnah-wal-jamaa'a. Salafis are not. Very often because of the fitnah they create, but also because of the ambiguity. (You can't accept that you don't know). In conclusion: Salafis and Hanbalis are completely different things and can actually not be compared (e.g. apple vs oranges). Some Salafis might be pretty much Hanbalis, others might have absolutely nothing to do with it. Hanbalis are definitly Sunni. Salafis very often not due to their differences in Fiqh and Aqidah, but mostly due to their rejection of other schools and the ambiguity of their own fiqh and aqidah. Salafis claim to follow Hanbali madhab because they know that they cannot pray, fast, give zakat without following the authority of any of the four imams as all other valid schools of Ahl us Sunnah Wal Jamah are extinct.
I'm not salafi but my local masjid is salafi. One of brother was giving a class in the masjid and he made a joke about Humza Yusuf. I thought to myself this person just backbited him. I find in salafis Arrogance and backbiting they.
An unbelievable level of self righteousness . They talk about Quran and Sunnah but you'll think the Quran doesn't pass their throats because none of it reflects In their actions towards other Muslims
@revivalist355 There is the salafi methodology, and then there are groups that call themself salafi . But also, I just confirmed this masjid is also madkhali salafis (political party). The Sheikh came up to mic during an event, and then he said, "There are no shiekhs in jail in Saudi Arabia." What audacity do you have to lie like that. I have other sources and instances as well.
Now send this to these tiktokers who post hadiths there and they haven't studied at reputable institutions or with shiekhs who have sanad. They are causing a fitnah amongst the youth.
* ABOUT ABDUL WAHAB NAJDI AL TAMIMI That does not mean to suggest that we shud hate all tamimis or all tamimis are bad. That means Rasul Sallallahu Alaiva Sallam gave us a clue and show us the right path and warning that Abdul Wahab Najdi was from that clan. How true was his saying. That also means this Najdi (with same evil theology as Zul Kuwaisirathul Tamimi) was the one whom Umarul Faruk (R) wanted to behead. That also means to help us identify and be careful about this later day Tamimi and his takfir and terrorism - wahabism in garb of salafi, jamate Islami, tabligi jamati etc etc
In international Ahlu Sunnah Wal Jamaah scholar world meeting in Grozny...they concluded that Wahabi wasn't categorized as Ahlu Sunnah Wal Jamaah anymore
I am amazed by the deference Shaykh Hamza shows to Ibn Taymiyyah and, yet, Ibn Taymiyyah is a highly divisive figure by the insistence of his most avid followers today. This is like trying to be moral royal than the king, frankly. When a nasty group of people disparage almost all Muslim traditions and deem them heretical innovations, and then loosen their tongues on the sterling reputations of our greatest lights current and past, and then they bandy about Ibn Taymiyyah as the man showing them the way what is the dire need to stand up for Ibn Taymiyyah instead of those being attacked? When someone tries to destroy the foundation of your house you don't worry about their psychological background BEFORE stopping them. Shaykh Hamza Yusuf admonishes Wahhabi/Salafi craziness too mildly. And hits regular Sunnis too harshly. I don't doubt his commitment to the Sawad al-Azam, but he tries too hard, frankly, to please everyone. Or at least used to try, as this is an older recording. I don't think he is giving many talks like this one anymore. The crazies don't give out brownie points. Right and wrong are not mysteries. And extremism is bad no matter how intelligent the scholar. These are uncomplicated matters that the esteemed shaykh, unfortunately, is making too much of.
What Dua did the Prophet teach Fatima? The Prophet (p.b.u.h) taught this supplication to Fatima (SA) to recite it when she wanted to go into the mosque: “O Allah, forgive me my sins and open to me the doors of Your favor.” Notes : [1] It is said, as in traditions, that al-Sahira is a land in other where than this earth where people shall be resurrected.
The comments that some people does make is as if they just can't understand. What is salafi ,number one the salaf our ancestors never use to demolish grave and cemetery and churches they preserve. Allah said in surah Al khaf to build a place of worship over them shrines , subhanallah.
I warned people about taking and reading hadiths with out context. Like for example reading a hadith about the prophet who supposed to have said burn people's house if they do not come to fijar. I warned people even in context you got to be very very careful about them becasue one you do not know if there are other hadiths, two you do not know the historical context. What does it mean by the latter, it means you do not know the political, soical, enviromental, geographical, demographical and lingustical context of the hadith. One needs speicalist training to understnad it. So no hadith can be taken singulary, and in isolation. Another example about a guy who said had dinnner with the prophet and the prophet when away and the guy followed him, it was then as he followed him he said he saw the seal of the prophet between his shoulder blades. Muslim 60. so what is the problem with the hadith? answer: how did the guy saw the seal on the prophet's back ? Was he in the house of the prophet, did the prophet take his upper garment off, or did the guy thought he saw it? Is there other hadiths about this hadith? Again the other warnings i given about hadiths also apply to this, ie when was it said, how was it said, why was it, etc, etc. in the video hamaza said if person believe in the one god with truth and from his heart will go to heaven but this contridict the otherr about a hadith being extremely sound that its impossible for it be not said, and person says i do not believe in it, will not be a muslim even if he believe in truth and with his hear their is one god and muhammad is his messenger. I think the problem here is a failure to understand historical methodology, even if 10 people heard something said, it does not mean it was said, all could be mistaken, if if 50 heard a saying, they could alll be wrong. Of course the more people hear something the more likely it would be said,, but say it was 100% correct, cannot be be said ever without massive amount of evidence. My view would be it would be there would a strong case for a saying to be related but based on the number of people who heard it, the context, and the rest, read start of the paragraph. So hamaza is not showing a true understaind of historical methodology here as both sayings of belief and not accepting a very strong hadith contridict. The point about being careful about hadith is very true via the fly hadith. It is medical fact flies carry infections, there is no evidence that part of the part fly carries cure and other part carries the diesease. So one puts that fly in your fea or food you are indangering yourself, that fly could been on a piece of dung, a dead animal etc and you are eating it bease on the hadith. Now does it mean the prophet said it no, but equally it could mean he did. So if i said you i do not accept the hadith true meaing the prophet is wrong if said. Some one would say i am not muslim even though they would not do what the prophet advised. Please note even if the prophet DID say it, it does not mean he is a prophet of god, it just means he is not perfect and made a mistake. In other words he is being human. "Narrated Abu Huraira: The Prophet (ﷺ) said "If a house fly falls in the drink of anyone of you, he should dip it (in the drink) and take it out, for one of its wings has a disease and the other has the cure for the disease." sunnah.com/bukhari:3320
Salafee I know in west are hard as rock to fellow muslims in petty differences and soft as candle to non-muslims and find hundreds of ayat of commonalities with non-muslims but million and one reason to discredit muslims on aqeeda like they are given prophecy .
@@alhassangangu4357 anthropomorphist not anthropologist. Typo error. You get what I'm saying good you don't get it what can I say. At that point your a donkey
@@ReturningRuh Salafi is a not a new movement. Salafi refers to the true followers of the sunnah. Salafi, ahlul sunnah wal jammah, ahlul hadith they are all the same.
Nobody Allow me to correct your misconceptions and assumptions of the Salafi methodology. What does the term Salafi mean?based on the hadeeth of the messenger saws, who praised his generation as the best of people. This generation are regarded as the Salaf (predecessors )There is no doubt that they were the guided predecessors of this ummah.This included the 4 imaams of mathaaieb,so the reason Salafies reject the idea of blind following a mathaaieb is because it's in opposition to following the messenger saws.No order came from Allah or the prophet saws that ordered this ummah to follow a particular individual in order to understand the Deen.This is absolutely baseless and is nowhere to be found in the Deen. Allah made it clear through out the Quran for us to obey Allah and his messenger saws.Not even one companion made mention about following a particular individual after the messenger saws.The Egyptian scholar Yusuf Qardawi said,"IF you Shaafi'e in mathaaieb, then you Ash'ari in Aqida, and if you Ganafie in mathaaieb, then you Mathoereedi in Aqida. Sadly most Muslims don't know the Aqida of these Imaams. The verse in Surah 4v59.is clear,Obey Allah and his messenger and those in authority over you,but if they DIFFER then refer the matter back to Allah and his messenger saws.Are the ummah taught to do this,or are they told to hang onto their differences of opinions. Did the Imaams of maathieb encourage people to blind follow them?The answer is NO.In fact they cleared themselves from being blind followed.Sayings of them. Imam Maaliek rag. "We are fallible, we mite hold n opinion today,and tomorrow we change our mind,but not so the messenger of Allah. " As Shaafi'e rag. "IF it is reported from the messenger saws in a statement or n order,then that becomes my maathieb even if you don't hear it from me." Abu Ghaneefa rag. "It is not allowed for anyone to take from my verdicts,if he doesn't know where I got it from. " Imam Aghmad rag. "Do not take from Abu Ghaneefa,Shafee'e,,AL Awzaaie,but take where they took from. " So clearly the ummah doesn't know the Aqida of these four Imaams.They were definitely united upon the same Aqida,methodology and against innovation and shirk.Yes,they were Salafi in Aqida and they followed the Deen based on the understanding of the companions. The Salafi methodology is based on what the messenger saws and his companions were upon. People were called Ahlul Hadeeth,Ahlul Sunnah, Ahlul Athaar,Ahlul Sunnah Wal Jamaa'a, so on what basis are you labeling who Ahlul Sunnah is or calling only those who follow a particular mathaaieb as Sunni,this is another Fallacy. Innovation, desire. Salafies don't need a maathieb or to be partially Hambali to practice their Deen, another Fallacy. Algamdoelilaa they follow whatever the companions were upon.Their Fiqh, Aqida, Manhaj (methodology) are all based upon the Quran and Sunnah. Saying of Imam AL Awzaa'ie (157) to the youth of his time."Stick to the words of the Salaf, even if the people are against you, beware of scholars with eloquent speech,say what they said,(companions)stop where they stopped, refrain from what they refrained from,what was sufficient for them is sufficient for you." All Imaams of maathieb followed the Salaf, thus they can be called Salafies.Saying of Imam AL Barbahaarie, "Islam is the Sunnah and the Sunnah is Islam." As for Tassawuf, they are one of those deviant sects who strayed off from the Quran and Sunnah. Their practices consist of Shirk and Innovation. Worshipping of Graves of Awlia. Allah says in Surah Waqi'a v.13,14 Speaking about those who are nearest to him,A multitude of the foremost will be from the first generation, and a few of those will be from the later generation who will follow the correct way."
being a scholar doesnt mean being a real islamic scholar, what is the contribution of this guy to islamic scholarship except spreading dalal and batil? If you believe he deserves any title then it is you that have no manners towards your Lord and his deen
When you sacrifice as much as our salafi brothers do then you can talk until then just be quite because in this times words doesn’t do anything it’s only actions and sacrifice. And that is to all of you
Your right actions are much higher than empty words. That's why shaykh Hamza Yusuf built a whole educational institution to empower our youth and build the foundations of Islam in this country. Meanwhile these "brothers" your talking about are busy making youtube videos calling Muslims innovators, finding their faults and "warning others of their mistakes and misguidance"... right those sacrifices
@Khaliil bin Ammar This video you are sharing around is the greatest deception and dishonesty in translation I have ever seen. They will have to answer infront of Allah for hiding knowledge from the Muslims, for slander against Imam Al Busayri, against the scholars of the Muslims that recited his poem out of love for the Messenger of Allah ﷺ. I wrote a comment there explaining their mistranslation, if you change the comments filter to "newest" you should see it. Anyone that even knows the basics of arabic could see the gross mistranslation. I advise you to stop sharing this link, even go back to all your previous comments and delete it. You don't want to be a part of this, you don't want to answer infront of Allah for a video of deception by mistranslating and hiding knowledge from the ummah. Even if you don't like Hamza Yusuf, I'm not asking you to love him, but for your own sake don't take the risk and be apart of slander against the scholars.
If you’re a suffi stop dancing around in circles calling it ibadah and going to the graves asking the dead to intercede for you, if you’re a shia stop cutting yourselves with machetes and cursing the companions. If you’re salafi continue to tread the path of the messenger of Allah and his companions and those who came after them
😂😂 brother if you are salafi please start criticising evil of Saudi govt and MBS. It’s open truth the most salafi scholar are not criticising the evil and shirk, hallowe’en , dance and alcohol friendly policies of Saudi govt how they they criticise other Muslims and their sins . Suddenly their tone became soft towards their master and even hardcore salaf became tolerant towards their shirk.
@@tuwaylubul_3ilm Assalam, I know the Hadith , as far what I understand and the general meaning , Hadith prohibit from rebellion against Muslim ruler and to try to overthrow his rule. And this Hadith apply to all Muslim ruler and country including Egypt, Libia , Syria, Iran, Turkey and not just Saudi . Second Imp thing is I’m not saying to rebel against Al Saud regime , I’m saying amrbil maroof and condemning evil and haram in the Saudi , Muslim or Arab society . ulema who do takfir of Sufi and Shia on something wrong they are involved , are quite on Halloween and alcohol. Do know Saudi govt give money on interest to other countries? Will you still defend their sins? If you are Muslim you should know how sever ribaa (interest) is? My point is do not defend other people/ Saudi govt dunya in exchange of your akhira. Salam
@@tuwaylubul_3ilm brother if same Muslim ruler of Saudi or any other country ask you/us to give up our Islam then will you obey them by giving this Hadith as a proof of your evidence.
@@End_Occupation it is from the Sunnah to advise your Muslim brothers and sisters privately, you and I don’t know know what goes on behind the scenes of politics, we don’t know if the scholars are advising them or not and don’t lie as if you do.
Yeah!!! You better not follow the sahaba and their students(literal meaning of the word salaf)DONT YOU DARE!! Follow people who made their own whims and become ahlul bidah today!! No need to follow authentic tradition rather lets hold hands with the munafiqun and jews,
"Sheikh" Hamza Yusuf. Lol. If the asharis consider this guy to be a legitimate sheikh then I can only feel sorry for them. Alhamdulillah proud to be a Muslim upon salafiyyah.
@@alhaqiquhOfficial Assalamualaikum! My English is not very good so I couldn’t understand all words… I consider my self a salafi because I learned from salafi Shaikhs and I trust them… but can someone tell me why salafis are wrong?
@@seattle_1974 they’re not wrong my brother, but just remember, just because you have the Hadith and the reference doesn’t mean you can interpret things and take rulings from them, someone needs to explain when the Hadith was sent down, who the prophet (saw) was talking to, if it was madani or makkani, if it applies to you in your situation, and many others questions in which you will need to get knowledge from a scholar you trust, don’t open the Quran or the Hadith and take ruling from them (fiqh) if you are not a learned person, and if you do that you can follow whoever you want my bro
I would like to make the admin aware that Salafis are not Takfeeris, in fact the barelvis/sufis do more takfeer of salafis even though Sufis are on Shirk.
Idk why Salafees need to listen to this, cause I can assure u that Salafees would never call someone kafir. Cause they typically have more knowledge than the average believer, and they know the magnitude of that sin. Salafee literally means follower. Follower of who? In this context is the followers of the hadith and Quran.
Salafi comes from root word “salaf” which means previous in a time frame like ancestors so salafi refers to followers of the salaf alsaleh (sahaba). In short, salafi is a person who takes fron the quran and sunna upon the salafs understanding
They (Sufis, shias, asharies and ect) do not understand the difference between making takfir of certain beliefs/actions that deviate from the Qur'an and sunnah and the understanding of the salaf, and making direct takfir on someone i.e calling them a kafir. A person upon a innovated/deviant belief may be forgiven due to ignorance, wrong interpretation, blind following their forefathers and ect so therefore we cannot make takfir on them but we can refute them and warn against it and leave their affairs upto Allah. To make direct takfir, it is recommended to leave that to the scholars and people of knowledge but they have refute the deviant belief, advice the person and be patient with them. If they refuse to let go of their innovation out of stubbornness despite knowing that what their following is batil, they can then be made takfir of.
@@muhammadabdulmateen8473 I mean that should be the case, but unfortunately as the world progress the ummah just becomes more and more ignorant and illiterate.
For some context to such excerpts as this clip, you’ll need to spend a bit of time on basic literacy around this subject. A solid convenient summary here: th-cam.com/video/RcDPwhpIb7w/w-d-xo.html
Pls Like And Subscribe l JazakAllahu Khair And May Allah Bless You And Your Family, Ameen
Allah's exclusive name is al Wahab! by Abu Huraira!
- **I have not ceased to love Bani Tamim (bin Abd. Wahab?) since I heard 3 qualities of them by Allah's Messenger (ﷺ peace & blessings be on him) who said: They, out of my umma, will be the strongest opponent of Ad-Dajjal;** `Aisha had a slave-girl from them, and the Prophet (ﷺ peace and blessings be upon him) told her to manumit her as she was from the descendants of (the Prophet) Ishmael; and, when their Zakat was brought, the Prophet (ﷺ peace and blessings be upon him) said, "This is the Zakat of my people."
- Sahih al-Bukhari 4366, Book of Expeditions, Kitab Al-Maghaazi
Salaam brother, that image with the muslim lady was disturbing because of the appearance of that lady not because she is a muslim. Please have respect for her and don't show us her. We came here to wake us up not to see a temptation. Please brother/sister. Correct me if im wrong please.
Why you can not on English Caption !
As-salamulikum bro please don’t use the pictures of woman tomorrow Allah will ask you why
Could please respect our right that Islam gives by not posting the pictures of woman
If I didn’t know Sheikh Hamza before and listen to him for the first time, I would say that he is a native Arabic speaker. And this is only shows how much dedication he put into learning our great religion ❤️
Yes indeed. He got most acknowledge from scholars from Moritania. Also he calls himself an Arab because he studied "fiqh allugha" or science or depth of the Arabic language. He teaches Arabic in Santa Clara Mosque USA. MOSLEM ADVISER....
Ur mad religion u mean 😂
Sheikh Hamza is a real inspiration . May Allah bless you . Salaam and love from Kashmir
اسلام علیکم
From Delhi
What I learnt from Shaykh Hamza is let us not be judgemental of others especially since we are layman and should look towards our weaknesses and shortcomings. We at the same time should supplicate to Allah SWT to show us the Truth as Truth and be guided by it and be shown Falsehood as Falsehood and be safeguarded from it
I believe that this is valid for those zealous for Dawah. A lot of Daees are damaging the cause of Islam due to their lack of wisdom, manners and superiority complexes.
Yes, 100%
Whatch hamza Yusuf
th-cam.com/video/npKWJfLnXmQ/w-d-xo.html
Whatch hamza Yusuf
th-cam.com/video/npKWJfLnXmQ/w-d-xo.html
@@tuwaylubul_3ilm wonderful , Jazak Allahu Khayr!
@@FranzVonGaart tycik
Salaam only one God and it's Allah SWT love here from South Africa Johannesburg pray 5 times a day
Peace be upon you brother in belief
@Aziz Rahman I think it's a reminder, not a boast
@@shouneezedries4689 q
I love Hamza Yusuf for the sake of Allah
you will not love him when you watch this:
th-cam.com/video/MVtZ9CoVhek/w-d-xo.html
Shaykh Hamza saved my aqeeda and imaan with his vast knowledge of different sciences of the Deen.
So fortunate to have him amongst us.
May Allah bless him with health so we can benefit from him, because he brought me closer to the habeeb and the beloved prophet Muhammad sallalaahu alayhiwasallam and may Allah give the Shaykh closeness to the prophet sallalaahu alayhiwasallam.
isnt he liberal
@@AC-mp7cx nahhhh
He said and I quote "Our Deen is conservative."
How did he save your aqeeda when he calls upon the prophet directly for help as the video the brother linked clearly shows. This is shirk. After watching the video its your right as a muslim to remove your comment
th-cam.com/video/npKWJfLnXmQ/w-d-xo.html
@@mihawk6780 th-cam.com/video/RasU3N4LN_0/w-d-xo.html
Alhamdulillah for traditional scholars who can explain the narrowness of Salafiyyah in English... Our scholars are mostly in our Muslim society languages and very few in English..
@DaBurger1411 The word "Salaf" ≠ Salafiyya.
Also, "Just following the Salaf" without explaining further is meaningless since even the Shia say they are "following the Salaf".
@DaBurger1411 Sigh. Look, I do not have the urge or time to debate, especially someone who identifies himself with a burger. If you want to actually learn, do it yourself by looking up the difference. In brief, this the problem with Salafis: Unless you can distinguish an 18th-century phenomenon from a 7th to 21st century phenomenon, you cannot understand what path has always been followed by the vast masses of Muslims. Salam
@DaBurger1411 Dear brother:
1) Sincere advice: Please do not assume of others that which you do not know. This is a huge problem with the Salafiyya who slap a pejorative label of "Sufi" on everyone and anyone without a eye on the issue at stake. I'm not a Sufi but a Muslim, a traditional Muslim, as were the vast masses of Muslims through the past 14 centuries. Traditional or ordinary Muslims have always opposed going to graves for intercession and also opposed the historic destruction of Sahabas' houses, flattening them and turning them into public bathrooms or highways. The former are Barelwi movement, a 19th century phenomenon, and the latter comes from Salafiyya, also a 19th century phenomenon. Salafiyya is a modern concept that borrows from the actual Salaf and some well-known scholars, but is qualitatively different from the Islam that has been followed by the vast masses of Muslims through the past. Salafiyya-identifying groups are known as "Ahle Hadeeth" in some parts of the world, which I find far more apt than Salafi because "Salafi" by itself can describe all kinds of Muslims.
2) Learn to distinguish between the map and the territory. You seem to confuse the two. They are not the same thing.
3) I want to emphasize, please read and teach in the real world instead of debating online, even on this very issue. Online comment box debates are not a very good use of your or my time.
Salam aleykum.
@DaBurger1411 Aqeedah Tahawwiyya
I love you shaykh for the sake of Allah! May Allah reward you and to those who made this video available with good dunya wal akhirah! Allahumma Ameen.. 🤲🏼🤲🏽🤲🏻🤲🏾❤️
Alhamdulillah I'm a sunni 😇
Imam Hamza, shukran. May Allah The Guide help our ummah to benefit from your knowledge.
Something to bare in mind....Majority of historical scholars were imprisoned,tortured or killed due to them not compromising the pure deen.We should also keep in the mind those who have been murdered not only by western governments but also by so called 'Muslim' govrnements for speaking out against their attrocities.Remember also the Prophet pbuh warned against the times when 'scholars visit palaces'..Pure Islamic teaching is becoming more difficult to spread publicly..Innovation is rife..
I use to mock the sharia loving zealots around me by saying according to sharia law, all classical scholars are criminals and then asking them, So which one are you?
@@noblemann4898 Im glad Im not you. .
This topic is way beyond me... I don't understand anything. May Allah guide me and give me knowledge Ameen.
Humans are humans, scholars or not. Take the best of AFKAR and leave the rest!
So beautiful ❤ Shaykh Hamza my Allah bless
How to know what prophet Muhammad ﷺ actually said ? How lucky the companions of Prophet Muhammad ﷺ were. How beautiful it was to sit next to him and listen what he said when Angel's were surrounding him ﷺ
Even the mutawatir ahadith have variations. The ahadith aren't designed to be preserved. What is preserved is the Qur'an and the living tradition. The secret of Islam is in the Sanad. We didn't learn salah from hadith, we learnt it by watching other people who watched other people who watched other people etc. Only now, the protestant movement, just like in Christianity, says that we should turn only to Sola Scriptura. But the Imams didn't teach this deen through ahadith; they lived the tradition and other people saw them and lived it too. Islam is a living organism.
Salam, we do not believe in luck
@@عليريسؤينا Salam! It's an expression in English "how lucky were they".
@@DarioHaruni it's wrong, if my dad make some innovation in the religion, I follow the wrong way. Ahadit are important to stay attached to autentic Islam.
@@DarioHaruni are you qurani???
I love you sheikh Hamza for the sake of Allah
Masha'Allah! Shaykh Hamza Yusuf is profoundly outspoken.
At present what this reminds me of what is going on in Pakistan, where every so-called "critic/moulvi" are on the verge of calling eachother "KAFIRS" for not following their "school of thoughts" though we have very highly intelligent Islamic Scholars that are very well versed with the Holy Qur'an and Hadiths.But unfortunately there is so much disappointment and misguidance that is damaging the present ongoing situation in our society.
Sorry I forgot but I must mention that there are so many new comers in this profession/trade that have adopted the title of "moulvi" inherited through their grandfather who happened to be a true/faithful believer and running a madrassa/masajid left behind for their children/grandchildren to use it for their political benefits and illegal activities
it's not just Pakistan it's all over Islamic world sadly.this is the weapon of west to divide and rule so muslims can fight each other then to rule worlds.
@@maheenrabbani356 And surprisingly people who are reverting back to ISLAM are teaching/spreading the true spirit of the Holy Qur'an and Hadith
@@arabianseagull yes in my eyes they r ture and best muslims.
Sad
@@maheenrabbani356 It is not for Muslims to unite upon falsehood.
Salaam to everyone may Allah paak bless brother hamza yousuf with long life and good health ameen sum ameen
This man is a Miracle in the aspect of his Arabic influence and the understanding of Muslims traditions and creed.
There are many like him, but don't get the chance or are being ignored
اللهم صل وسلم على سيدنا ومولانا محمد عبدك ورسولك النبي الأمي وعلى آله
What a scholar. My God. SubhanAllah
JazakaAllah, for your words of wisdom Sheikh, i believe i learn something new everytime i listen to one of your speeches. May Allah (SWT) keep you with us for as long as it would be best, put barakah in your life and work, Aameen.
We should be concerned with our state of faith before going after people's.
Muhammad (ﷺ) said "Part of the excellence of a man's Islam is that he looks only to what concerns his own soul", from the Muwatta Book of Character
I don't know where I belong to this called group, and I don't mind as long as I follow qur'an and the teaching of prophet (pbuh) and what sahabah did..
Whatch hamza Yusuf
th-cam.com/video/npKWJfLnXmQ/w-d-xo.html
Ma Sha Allah - May Allah make you firm upon his religion
You nailed bro. Let us be Muslims ❤
Jazakum Allahu Khairan Shaikh. The Messenger of Allah SAS said: "I am the City of Knowledge and Ali is its Gate." How do we interpret that? Is it not obvious? "Rabbi zidni ilman wa fahman."
Source please. From The Qur'an or Hadith that all the major mazhab can accept.
Nderek (follow) ta'zim Syaikh Hamza Yusuf
تبارك الله يا شبخ حمزة ❤
My uncle used to remind me about bidah and I need to be careful with it, he graduate from Madinah University. I made it a habit to investigate the source of news whenever I went to any Islamic talks.
May Allah bless save cure protect you all ameen
And the prophet صلى الله عليه وسلم also said be careful where you take your knowledge from as it can be for us or against us May Allah protect us all
He صلى الله عليه وسلم feared for us for misguidance scholars like sufis, shias ect...
So be careful from this individual
thanks for your advice.
May Allah protect me from misgidance of pseudo salafi- nashibi, and shia-rafidhi
@@namakubento9604
May Allah guide you to true salafiasm the salafs the first generation who followed the prophet صلى الله عليه وسلم the correct way while the other 72 sects went astray
@@stepstojannah8173
May Allah guide me to true salafism , ameen
May Allah protect me from pseudo salfism
@@namakubento9604
Ameen all.of us ya rab
Beautiful and informative at all he same time
He's not critic of salafism but the jammiyah nowadays the takfeer and all the readers of books not acquired through any scholar
بارك الله فيكم آمين يارب العالمين
MASHA Allah. Very good explanation.
The trouble is: first Saudis rejected Islam then steadily accepted it....Then started owning it like Private Property with no scope for intellectualism,for some became Black n White to the letter.Yet there is another crowd who got stuck coal in the eyes, henna colour beard , Hijab of tent so on n so forth. Islam emphasis on moral,social,economic ethics with deep respect for creation that includes Natural World......Thanks for the lecture Shaikh Humza.
*8:43* Beautiful! 🔥
_15:34_ 💡
MashaAllah
That shamshi guy from speaker's corner needs to listen to this.
13:00 mins plus is extremely important.
I swear the only pieces of knowledge and information that strnghtens my Iman always comes from Asharis. Everything makes sense. The others will plainly tell you don't use your brain.
Ilm and sincerity are linked, Algamdullilah
No they're not always linked the Prophet AS warned against confusing knowledge with character
Muhammad AS said some kinds of knowledge or eloquence is sorcery in the hands of a man who lacks character (a Hadith from Kitaab Al Kalaam from the Muwatta)
Without taking a stance, it is well known that Ibn Sina drank wine in moderation to help with sleep. This is not a conspiracy, it is documented in several historical texts and he advocated for it in moderation. The point: stop blindly following any scholar-whether Salafi, Sufi or other. They are all humans. Many scholars continue to be exposed today-whether it’s their political views or social life. The misguided scholars and corrupt rulers are a clear sign of the end times.
Ibn Sina was neither misguided nor corrupt.
Alhamdulilah
This is not just a salafee problem, Allahu mustaan.
Agree..
True salafiyyah is being a true sunni. It has got to this stage of calling one salafi as everyone claims to be sunni. Salaffiyah is based upon strict adherence to the sunnah, based on too the quran. That is based upon the companions understanding and practice of the two latter components. True salafi its principles are too, Knowledge ie the quran and sunnah proceeds action and speech. This is salafiyyah my brothers and sisters. May Allah protect us from personalities who preach the opposite. And with Allah lies sucess.
So is Malikiyyah not adherence to Quran? 'Salafis' believe a lot of things that are against the Quran lol and they say 'The Quran said to follow the Rasoul' so they can bring some Hadith and explain why they can contradict the Quran
Or people who call themself Salafis. This Maliki Sheykh from Saudi gave lectures about why Don't we teach Hadiths by virtues that Allah praised in the Quran, first Justice, then Character then Perceiverence etc.. And Saudis put him in Jail for 12 years for 'extremism'... Because he said most Shouyoukh focus on Hadith to only push certain politics.. And at this time the 'Salafis' all praised the rulers in Saudi all the time
@@nadjiguemarful we are not blind followers of malaki is, handbali etc, we are followers of Muhammad (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) following him only. We sunnis take from all of the 4 imams, may Allah have mercy upon them all. It is haraam to restrictedly follow one imam except, prophet Muhammad (peace and blessings be upon him). Also, imam Malik may Allah have mercy upon him, did not even call the ummah to say you are or must restrictedly call yourself Maliki? So why are you promoting this. We are labelled Muslim, sunni/ahlul hadeeth, salafi. Not even Muhammadans. May Allah protect us from blind following of personalities. Moreover, regarding Saudi politics, is not part of our topic, and answer concerning being sunni truly, its people of knowledge, its definition and what its strict criteria it is to be a real follower of the sunnah, and then truly call yourself muslim sunni, salafi. Ie followers of nabi Muhammad (peace and blessings be upon him) based upon the pious companions understanding and practice of Islam. Because you are straying from the issue at hand. And with Allah lies guidance and sucess.
Its sad when, prophet Muhammad call everyone "A believer"or muslim, and nowadays people end up making themselves "sunni"or "shia"or "salafi"whatever....
Sahih, Salafi is in essence ahlul sunnah
The Prophet Muhammad pbuh said on Arafat in his last sermon 'today your deen is complete,nothing has been left out and nothing needs to be added'..'any innovation will lead to the fire'..The sufi's have added innivation after innovation to the pure deen of Islam.Their twirling,singing and chanting etc was NEVER performed by the Nabi pbuh or his Sahabah,neither was mawlid practiced by the Nabi pbuh or the Sahaba ( the best of the best and most closest to the Prophet pbuh).Yet sufis practice these strange behaviours and claim them to be from Islam.It is very similar to Christian practices of monks.This is also something the Prophet pbuh warned us against imitating..
Not every hanafi practices twirling or mawlid. I don't. And many like me don't.
But didn't you read about Ibn taymiyah saying "with pure intentions, a person performing mawlid shall be rewarded?"
I can give reference.
You clearly didn't listen to a word that Hamza Yusuf said , you're just regurgitating typical Salafi talking points , like you've been brainwashed . I doubt you actually know what that even means . And I doubt you even know how many types of bidah there are and what they are called
@@TheeMrAbz Then can you please explain how what he said isn't bid'ah? I honestly would really like to know.
Can we have a link to the full talk please, or if possible without the background sounds?
Ibn sina never missed his five daily prayers and this is known from his life.
Have some integrity.
Why are you sufis just like people of the book.?
Don't you feel ashamed?
@@Directlite664
I didn't praise him in terms of religiosity, I only mentioned it because he was accused by some later scholars as being non muslim
@@Directlite664
I am not a sufi but I know for sure you have plastic brains, ie doesn't have the quality of brain cell to retain knowledge.
@@Directlite664
Just like any unfortunate muslim who does zina. He becomes a sinner, yet he is still a muslim but on the day of judgment, only Allah knows who has iman in his heart or who didn't have any. In this world we can only judge by actions. If he says he is a muslim and he utters the shahada he is treated as a muslim and if a sin like zina is proven by specific witnessing of penetration by 4 adult morally upright male witnesses then the punishment is carried out by a valid court not mobs as is unfortunately the case nowadays.
Secondly, you have to prove that ibn sina did zina openly before you make it public here as then you will be questioned by Allah swt on the day of judgment. Would you like someone who hates you do the Same to you?
Fear Allah and do not concern yourself with whatever does not concern you, it would be better for your heart.
@@kurdistanijunior
I mean, before doing extensive search on where ibn taymiyyah did a slight error, read your own imams AUTOBIOGRAPHY.
Love this talk...however, not all salafis are takfiris
Not all Salafis are Takfiris but all Takfiris are Salafis / Wahhabis.
@Khaliil bin Ammar , this is a joke right? No one is making takfir except the Salafis. Takfir is their hallmark. They're a never-ending fitna started by Ibn Abd al-Wahhab and strategically bolstered by the British, Israelis and Americans in order to dismantle the Ottoman Sultanate and serve as a mechanism of internal strife in Ummah in order to keep the Muslims perpetually divided.
@@majorpremise ever heard of ibadis and asharis?
@@majorpremise exactly
@@majorpremise That's a bold claim. Not saying it's smart nor stupid. Just bold
وعليكم السلام ورحمة الله وبركاته
Absolutely
thank you brother.
May Allah grant Sheikh Hamza Yusuf good health and increase him in Knowledge.But let get something clear here,he is human and he can make mistakes.Those who are taking everything from him are the true ignorants of the deen.He is doing a great service to Islam in his own way but along the line he makes mistakes and l pray Allah guide him.I have for a very long time understand the diversity of Islam.From the time of our dear prophet(PBUH) the different of opinions among his companions was apparent and that gave me the understanding of how Muslims can have different opinions.Also from the Hadith about the division in Islam.As a sunni muslim,l get to know the different of opinions among our four imams so there is no need for all these unnecessary arguments and insults here.
Salamu alaykom 🌸 thank you for this video around minute 6 shaykh Hamza yusef mentionned an imam who was also a doctor. Can you please give us his complete name? I couldn't find him on the internet.
Jazakum allah Alf khair
If Islamic scholars of nowadays had understood ahadiths in your way !!!!
In the book ‘Muhtesaru mearidil-kabul’ (page. 234) Ibn Qayyim al-Jawziyya says about Abu Ali Sinai this;" He believed that the world has existed forever (that it was not created), he denied the akhira, knowledge and Allah swt might, and denied the creation of the world and resurrection of the dead".
This would conclude the debate and expose the ignorance of Hamza Yusuf.
Are you not just providing what he said.
Who were they his teachers? Scholars are studied from other scholars. So I wonder how he gained knowledge!
Is there anything original from Ibn Sina to that effect? That will shed real light on the claims.
@@Ismailmsheikh Ibn Sina was an Esmailly.
@@Razzaqabuali False. Why lie? You know that's a sin
MaShaa ALLAAAH. SUCH AN IMPORTANT TOPIC EXPLAINED SO VERY NICELY AND WTH SO MUCH ZEAL. SUBHAANALLAAH.
السلام عليكم ! انا مسلم ! THATS IT, MUSLIM !!!
Salafi's reject the idea of Mazhab and claim to follow Quran and Sunnah directly. This contraditcts the very foundation of having a Hanbali (or the other 3 Mazhabs)
Hanbali's like the other school of Fiqh accept Ijma' as a source of Jurisprudice (after Quran and Sunnah). Salafis seem (at least in practice) reject that idea.
There are differences in Aqida.
More signifcant is that many Salafis seem to reject other opinions and schools in Fiqh and Aqidah, which the Hanbalis don't. **That means even if Salafis would equal Hanbalis in Aqida and Fiqh (which they don't), when the Salafis reject other Madhabs and Aqidah schools, than they become clearly different form Hanbalis. **
Also Salafis reject Tassawuf completely, Hanbalis do not.
And the most important Point: Salafis by their ideologoy do not like to be associated with a certain mazhab, aqeeda, manaj, etc. That means there might be Salafi Scholars that accept Mazhabs completely, while others call people who folloow Mazhabs Kufaar. Both are of course extreme cases. Because this ambiguity with Salafis, but not with Hanbalis, they become something completely different.
Also Hanbalis are accepted and embraced by all Sunni scholars as part of Ahlus-sunnah-wal-jamaa'a. Salafis are not. Very often because of the fitnah they create, but also because of the ambiguity. (You can't accept that you don't know).
In conclusion: Salafis and Hanbalis are completely different things and can actually not be compared (e.g. apple vs oranges). Some Salafis might be pretty much Hanbalis, others might have absolutely nothing to do with it. Hanbalis are definitly Sunni. Salafis very often not due to their differences in Fiqh and Aqidah, but mostly due to their rejection of other schools and the ambiguity of their own fiqh and aqidah.
Salafis claim to follow Hanbali madhab because they know that they cannot pray, fast, give zakat without following the authority of any of the four imams as all other valid schools of Ahl us Sunnah Wal Jamah are extinct.
We follow Ahmad bin hambal and Malik and all the 4. We SAY don’t!! Follow blindly that’s all we say even albani will say this.
Wrong
MashaAllah love the way U teach. Djazaakillahoe ghairan
I'm not salafi but my local masjid is salafi. One of brother was giving a class in the masjid and he made a joke about Humza Yusuf. I thought to myself this person just backbited him. I find in salafis Arrogance and backbiting they.
An unbelievable level of self righteousness . They talk about Quran and Sunnah but you'll think the Quran doesn't pass their throats because none of it reflects In their actions towards other Muslims
@revivalist355 There is the salafi methodology, and then there are groups that call themself salafi . But also, I just confirmed this masjid is also madkhali salafis (political party). The Sheikh came up to mic during an event, and then he said, "There are no shiekhs in jail in Saudi Arabia." What audacity do you have to lie like that. I have other sources and instances as well.
Now send this to these tiktokers who post hadiths there and they haven't studied at reputable institutions or with shiekhs who have sanad. They are causing a fitnah amongst the youth.
* ABOUT ABDUL WAHAB NAJDI AL TAMIMI That does not mean to suggest that we shud hate all tamimis or all tamimis are bad. That means Rasul Sallallahu Alaiva Sallam gave us a clue and show us the right path and warning that Abdul Wahab Najdi was from that clan. How true was his saying. That also means this Najdi (with same evil theology as Zul Kuwaisirathul Tamimi) was the one whom Umarul Faruk (R) wanted to behead. That also means to help us identify and be careful about this later day Tamimi and his takfir and terrorism - wahabism in garb of salafi, jamate Islami, tabligi jamati etc etc
In international Ahlu Sunnah Wal Jamaah scholar world meeting in Grozny...they concluded that Wahabi wasn't categorized as Ahlu Sunnah Wal Jamaah anymore
Great reminder MashAllah
Does anyone know the full lecture?
Who are Salafis by definition? Those who believe in Quran and Sunnah??
Plz can I translate this to Arabic ?
People worship ahadith more than The Quran. And they are truly lost
Beautiful.
Please share the original link
alhamedullilah I am salafiy !
You a Zionist Najdi qarnus shaytan
I am amazed by the deference Shaykh Hamza shows to Ibn Taymiyyah and, yet, Ibn Taymiyyah is a highly divisive figure by the insistence of his most avid followers today. This is like trying to be moral royal than the king, frankly. When a nasty group of people disparage almost all Muslim traditions and deem them heretical innovations, and then loosen their tongues on the sterling reputations of our greatest lights current and past, and then they bandy about Ibn Taymiyyah as the man showing them the way what is the dire need to stand up for Ibn Taymiyyah instead of those being attacked? When someone tries to destroy the foundation of your house you don't worry about their psychological background BEFORE stopping them.
Shaykh Hamza Yusuf admonishes Wahhabi/Salafi craziness too mildly. And hits regular Sunnis too harshly. I don't doubt his commitment to the Sawad al-Azam, but he tries too hard, frankly, to please everyone. Or at least used to try, as this is an older recording. I don't think he is giving many talks like this one anymore. The crazies don't give out brownie points.
Right and wrong are not mysteries. And extremism is bad no matter how intelligent the scholar. These are uncomplicated matters that the esteemed shaykh, unfortunately, is making too much of.
What Dua did the Prophet teach Fatima?
The Prophet (p.b.u.h) taught this supplication to Fatima (SA) to recite it when she wanted to go into the mosque: “O Allah, forgive me my sins and open to me the doors of Your favor.” Notes : [1] It is said, as in traditions, that al-Sahira is a land in other where than this earth where people shall be resurrected.
The comments that some people does make is as if they just can't understand. What is salafi ,number one the salaf our ancestors never use to demolish grave and cemetery and churches they preserve. Allah said in surah Al khaf to build a place of worship over them shrines , subhanallah.
The Religion's name is islam. We are Muslims. Allah swt wont ask you which sheikh are you following.
Iben tyymiya is sheikh El Islam whether he likes it or not.
I warned people about taking and reading hadiths with out context. Like for example reading a hadith about the prophet who supposed to have said burn people's house if they do not come to fijar. I warned people even in context you got to be very very careful about them becasue one you do not know if there are other hadiths, two you do not know the historical context. What does it mean by the latter, it means you do not know the political, soical, enviromental, geographical, demographical and lingustical context of the hadith. One needs speicalist training to understnad it. So no hadith can be taken singulary, and in isolation. Another example about a guy who said had dinnner with the prophet and the prophet when away and the guy followed him, it was then as he followed him he said he saw the seal of the prophet between his shoulder blades. Muslim 60. so what is the problem with the hadith? answer: how did the guy saw the seal on the prophet's back ? Was he in the house of the prophet, did the prophet take his upper garment off, or did the guy thought he saw it? Is there other hadiths about this hadith? Again the other warnings i given about hadiths also apply to this, ie when was it said, how was it said, why was it, etc, etc.
in the video hamaza said if person believe in the one god with truth and from his heart will go to heaven but this contridict the otherr about a hadith being extremely sound that its impossible for it be not said, and person says i do not believe in it, will not be a muslim even if he believe in truth and with his hear their is one god and muhammad is his messenger. I think the problem here is a failure to understand historical methodology, even if 10 people heard something said, it does not mean it was said, all could be mistaken, if if 50 heard a saying, they could alll be wrong. Of course the more people hear something the more likely it would be said,, but say it was 100% correct, cannot be be said ever without massive amount of evidence. My view would be it would be there would a strong case for a saying to be related but based on the number of people who heard it, the context, and the rest, read start of the paragraph. So hamaza is not showing a true understaind of historical methodology here as both sayings of belief and not accepting a very strong hadith contridict.
The point about being careful about hadith is very true via the fly hadith. It is medical fact flies carry infections, there is no evidence that part of the part fly carries cure and other part carries the diesease. So one puts that fly in your fea or food you are indangering yourself, that fly could been on a piece of dung, a dead animal etc and you are eating it bease on the hadith. Now does it mean the prophet said it no, but equally it could mean he did. So if i said you i do not accept the hadith true meaing the prophet is wrong if said. Some one would say i am not muslim even though they would not do what the prophet advised. Please note even if the prophet DID say it, it does not mean he is a prophet of god, it just means he is not perfect and made a mistake. In other words he is being human.
"Narrated Abu Huraira:
The Prophet (ﷺ) said "If a house fly falls in the drink of anyone of you, he should dip it (in the drink) and take it out, for one of its wings has a disease and the other has the cure for the disease." sunnah.com/bukhari:3320
Salafee I know in west are hard as rock to fellow muslims in petty differences and soft as candle to non-muslims and find hundreds of ayat of commonalities with non-muslims but million and one reason to discredit muslims on aqeeda like they are given prophecy .
You are right ya sheikh
Coz most of the isis people from salafi
The true path is ahlu sunna wal jamaha
No Isis are khawarej, not salafi, a salafi follow prophet and the companions, the first generation
Salam
الحمد لله الذي جعل العلم يؤخذ من أفواه العلماء وليس من مثل هؤلاء
"Some people read Ibn Taymiyah and say 'He is a Kafir'". Well certainly not a Salafi. more likely an an extreme Ashari.
Ibn tamiyyah was a hanbali in fiqh
But he was not ashari maturidi or athari zahiri. He was of the karammiya school
He was an anthropologist
In Taymiyyah was anthropologist? Never heard that before
@@alhassangangu4357 anthropomorphist not anthropologist. Typo error. You get what I'm saying good you don't get it what can I say. At that point your a donkey
🌹
Alhamdulilah for the truth. Alhamdulliah for Salafiyyah. Bidah will never be succesful.
Salafisim has been HIJACKED by Wahabsim
ElhamduliLah to Allah. To no else
But the salafi movement is a new found movement with their own interpretations
@@ReturningRuh Salafi is a not a new movement. Salafi refers to the true followers of the sunnah. Salafi, ahlul sunnah wal jammah, ahlul hadith they are all the same.
الحمدالله
Nobody
Allow me to correct your misconceptions and assumptions of the Salafi methodology. What does the term Salafi mean?based on the hadeeth of the messenger saws, who praised his generation as the best of people. This generation are regarded as the Salaf (predecessors )There is no doubt that they were the guided predecessors of this ummah.This included the 4 imaams of mathaaieb,so the reason Salafies reject the idea of blind following a mathaaieb is because it's in opposition to following the messenger saws.No order came from Allah or the prophet saws that ordered this ummah to follow a particular individual in order to understand the Deen.This is absolutely baseless and is nowhere to be found in the Deen. Allah made it clear through out the Quran for us to obey Allah and his messenger saws.Not even one companion made mention about following a particular individual after the messenger saws.The Egyptian scholar Yusuf Qardawi said,"IF you Shaafi'e in mathaaieb, then you Ash'ari in Aqida, and if you Ganafie in mathaaieb, then you Mathoereedi in Aqida. Sadly most Muslims don't know the Aqida of these Imaams. The verse in Surah 4v59.is clear,Obey Allah and his messenger and those in authority over you,but if they DIFFER then refer the matter back to Allah and his messenger saws.Are the ummah taught to do this,or are they told to hang onto their differences of opinions. Did the Imaams of maathieb encourage people to blind follow them?The answer is NO.In fact they cleared themselves from being blind followed.Sayings of them.
Imam Maaliek rag.
"We are fallible, we mite hold n opinion today,and tomorrow we change our mind,but not so the messenger of Allah. "
As Shaafi'e rag.
"IF it is reported from the messenger saws in a statement or n order,then that becomes my maathieb even if you don't hear it from me."
Abu Ghaneefa rag.
"It is not allowed for anyone to take from my verdicts,if he doesn't know where I got it from. "
Imam Aghmad rag.
"Do not take from Abu Ghaneefa,Shafee'e,,AL Awzaaie,but take where they took from. "
So clearly the ummah doesn't know the Aqida of these four Imaams.They were definitely united upon the same Aqida,methodology and against innovation and shirk.Yes,they were Salafi in Aqida and they followed the Deen based on the understanding of the companions. The Salafi methodology is based on what the messenger saws and his companions were upon. People were called Ahlul Hadeeth,Ahlul Sunnah, Ahlul Athaar,Ahlul Sunnah Wal Jamaa'a, so on what basis are you labeling who Ahlul Sunnah is or calling only those who follow a particular mathaaieb as Sunni,this is another Fallacy. Innovation, desire.
Salafies don't need a maathieb or to be partially Hambali to practice their Deen, another Fallacy. Algamdoelilaa they follow whatever the companions were upon.Their Fiqh, Aqida, Manhaj (methodology) are all based upon the Quran and Sunnah.
Saying of Imam AL Awzaa'ie (157) to the youth of his time."Stick to the words of the Salaf, even if the people are against you, beware of scholars with eloquent speech,say what they said,(companions)stop where they stopped, refrain from what they refrained from,what was sufficient for them is sufficient for you." All Imaams of maathieb followed the Salaf, thus they can be called Salafies.Saying of Imam AL Barbahaarie, "Islam is the Sunnah and the Sunnah is Islam."
As for Tassawuf, they are one of those deviant sects who strayed off from the Quran and Sunnah. Their practices consist of Shirk and Innovation. Worshipping of Graves of Awlia.
Allah says in Surah Waqi'a v.13,14
Speaking about those who are nearest to him,A multitude of the foremost will be from the first generation, and a few of those will be from the later generation who will follow the correct way."
HaiyakAllaah
This guy is amazing! I could listen to him for hours and hours without learning anything beneficial
You should keep adab when commenting, especially if it's a scholar talking.
being a scholar doesnt mean being
a real islamic scholar, what is the contribution of this guy to islamic scholarship except spreading dalal and batil?
If you believe he deserves any title then it is you that have no manners towards your Lord and his deen
@@manuelcardinali5340 let each of us meet God with their claim.
@@yus3158 amin
I feel like he just jumps from topic to topic, I can never grasp what he says. I feel like its randoms sentences.
When you sacrifice as much as our salafi brothers do then you can talk until then just be quite because in this times words doesn’t do anything it’s only actions and sacrifice. And that is to all of you
Your right actions are much higher than empty words. That's why shaykh Hamza Yusuf built a whole educational institution to empower our youth and build the foundations of Islam in this country. Meanwhile these "brothers" your talking about are busy making youtube videos calling Muslims innovators, finding their faults and "warning others of their mistakes and misguidance"... right those sacrifices
@Khaliil bin Ammar This video you are sharing around is the greatest deception and dishonesty in translation I have ever seen. They will have to answer infront of Allah for hiding knowledge from the Muslims, for slander against Imam Al Busayri, against the scholars of the Muslims that recited his poem out of love for the Messenger of Allah ﷺ. I wrote a comment there explaining their mistranslation, if you change the comments filter to "newest" you should see it. Anyone that even knows the basics of arabic could see the gross mistranslation. I advise you to stop sharing this link, even go back to all your previous comments and delete it. You don't want to be a part of this, you don't want to answer infront of Allah for a video of deception by mistranslating and hiding knowledge from the ummah. Even if you don't like Hamza Yusuf, I'm not asking you to love him, but for your own sake don't take the risk and be apart of slander against the scholars.
Lol! Takfiri murder & treason gang!
Plz unmute as there's no sound in video
And then they you with calling themselves the righteous ones. I dont want to mention but speak corners debates are full of this
If you’re a suffi stop dancing around in circles calling it ibadah and going to the graves asking the dead to intercede for you, if you’re a shia stop cutting yourselves with machetes and cursing the companions. If you’re salafi continue to tread the path of the messenger of Allah and his companions and those who came after them
😂😂 brother if you are salafi please start criticising evil of Saudi govt and MBS. It’s open truth the most salafi scholar are not criticising the evil and shirk, hallowe’en , dance and alcohol friendly policies of Saudi govt how they they criticise other Muslims and their sins . Suddenly their tone became soft towards their master and even hardcore salaf became tolerant towards their shirk.
@@End_Occupation brother if you’re Muslim remember what the messenger said about speaking against Muslim rulers 🤫
@@tuwaylubul_3ilm Assalam, I know the Hadith , as far what I understand and the general meaning , Hadith prohibit from rebellion against Muslim ruler and to try to overthrow his rule. And this Hadith apply to all Muslim ruler and country including Egypt, Libia , Syria, Iran, Turkey and not just Saudi .
Second Imp thing is I’m not saying to rebel against Al Saud regime , I’m saying amrbil maroof and condemning evil and haram in the Saudi , Muslim or Arab society . ulema who do takfir of Sufi and Shia on something wrong they are involved , are quite on Halloween and alcohol. Do know Saudi govt give money on interest to other countries? Will you still defend their sins? If you are Muslim you should know how sever ribaa (interest) is?
My point is do not defend other people/ Saudi govt dunya in exchange of your akhira.
Salam
@@tuwaylubul_3ilm brother if same Muslim ruler of Saudi or any other country ask you/us to give up our Islam then will you obey them by giving this Hadith as a proof of your evidence.
@@End_Occupation it is from the Sunnah to advise your Muslim brothers and sisters privately, you and I don’t know know what goes on behind the scenes of politics, we don’t know if the scholars are advising them or not and don’t lie as if you do.
Yeah!!! You better not follow the sahaba and their students(literal meaning of the word salaf)DONT YOU DARE!! Follow people who made their own whims and become ahlul bidah today!! No need to follow authentic tradition rather lets hold hands with the munafiqun and jews,
"Sheikh" Hamza Yusuf. Lol. If the asharis consider this guy to be a legitimate sheikh then I can only feel sorry for them.
Alhamdulillah proud to be a Muslim upon salafiyyah.
Your profile picture is The Joker, that pretty much sums you up
@@alhaqiquhOfficial 👏
@@alhaqiquhOfficial Assalamualaikum! My English is not very good so I couldn’t understand all words… I consider my self a salafi because I learned from salafi Shaikhs and I trust them… but can someone tell me why salafis are wrong?
@@seattle_1974 they’re not wrong my brother, but just remember, just because you have the Hadith and the reference doesn’t mean you can interpret things and take rulings from them, someone needs to explain when the Hadith was sent down, who the prophet (saw) was talking to, if it was madani or makkani, if it applies to you in your situation, and many others questions in which you will need to get knowledge from a scholar you trust, don’t open the Quran or the Hadith and take ruling from them (fiqh) if you are not a learned person, and if you do that you can follow whoever you want my bro
I would like to make the admin aware that Salafis are not Takfeeris, in fact the barelvis/sufis do more takfeer of salafis even though Sufis are on Shirk.
Idk why Salafees need to listen to this, cause I can assure u that Salafees would never call someone kafir. Cause they typically have more knowledge than the average believer, and they know the magnitude of that sin.
Salafee literally means follower. Follower of who? In this context is the followers of the hadith and Quran.
Salafi comes from root word “salaf” which means previous in a time frame like ancestors so salafi refers to followers of the salaf alsaleh (sahaba). In short, salafi is a person who takes fron the quran and sunna upon the salafs understanding
@@Asce3109 which is the best way to take the Quran and the sunna.
They (Sufis, shias, asharies and ect) do not understand the difference between making takfir of certain beliefs/actions that deviate from the Qur'an and sunnah and the understanding of the salaf, and making direct takfir on someone i.e calling them a kafir. A person upon a innovated/deviant belief may be forgiven due to ignorance, wrong interpretation, blind following their forefathers and ect so therefore we cannot make takfir on them but we can refute them and warn against it and leave their affairs upto Allah. To make direct takfir, it is recommended to leave that to the scholars and people of knowledge but they have refute the deviant belief, advice the person and be patient with them. If they refuse to let go of their innovation out of stubbornness despite knowing that what their following is batil, they can then be made takfir of.
Every muslim is a salafi then. Im a salafi hanafi 😂
@@muhammadabdulmateen8473 I mean that should be the case, but unfortunately as the world progress the ummah just becomes more and more ignorant and illiterate.
Where is the Hadith he quotes?
For some context to such excerpts as this clip, you’ll need to spend a bit of time on basic literacy around this subject. A solid convenient summary here:
th-cam.com/video/RcDPwhpIb7w/w-d-xo.html
13:25