Mercedes G-Wagon vs Land Rover Defender V8!
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 26 ส.ค. 2023
- You can see more of Alexanders Prestige’s stock here:
www.alexandersprestige.co.uk/...
Check out my podcast, Behind The Glass (The UK’s Number 1 Automotive Podcast)
/ behindtheglass
For all things Seen Through Glass, visit my website:
seenthroughglass.online/
----
Looking for a way to make car ownership easier? Check out Custodian:
www.custodian.club/p/stg
Thinking of financing a car? Check out the Magnitude finance calculator: www.magnitudefinance.com/seen...
----
What I Use To Make My Videos:
Main Camera - amzn.to/3a7fNY6
Drone - click.dji.com/AHchpNVD5qC1Tbd...
Second Camera - amzn.to/36a7bOY
On Camera Mic - amzn.to/2YegysJ
Radio Mic - amzn.to/3qO9u27
In Car Camera - amzn.to/365fbkr
[Cheap In Car Camera - amzn.to/3sRlTUN]
Camera Bag - amzn.to/39f9D91
Laptop - amzn.to/2LTnZDf
Essential Camera Accessory For Filming Cars - amzn.to/3c9R8V5
----
Follow me on:
Instagram - / seenthroughglass
Twitter - / seenthruglass
Facebook - seenthroughglass
---
Intro Music - Holismo, Sheldrake by Seiscientosdoce
Channel Art & Intro Photography by Adam Shah [ / adam_shah_ ] & Chris Williams [ / munch997 ]
----
Thanks for watching SeenThroughGlass. If you liked this video you may also like videos by Shmee150, Salomondrin, Supercars Of London, Car Throttle, MrJWW and Petrolicious. - ยานยนต์และพาหนะ
The Defender is a fantastic car, but I think the Urban package is a complete miss. It makes the Defender feel like it's pretending to be a G-Wagon, which it isn't and shouldn't be. The Defender is a car that should look slightly out of place on the road, like it belongs more in some muddy field. Perhaps I'm desperately clinging to the spirit of the old Defender, but the new Defender only exists because of the old Defender's charm.
Totally agree
I’d argue that it shouldn’t even be called a defender. If anything ivv to is more of a discovery replacement. Im
@@ThrottleBody Very true, but the Disco brand is less marketable.
If you want a real Defender check out the Ineos Grenadier
Plenty of urban ones on the road. Those that buy aren’t interested in 1948-2016
Another top quality upload! I don't understand why Sam doesn't have 1mil+ subs, the quality of STG vids is on another level!
Uploaded 8 minutes ago, your comment 5 minutes ago.. You've watched 3 minutes out of a 17 min video
His viewers watch the full video so he still gets paid bank. Whereas other TH-camrs just post catchy thumbnails and people skim through
Agree he’s knocking out some amazing content.
@@matthewkobylinski510most of the money comes from brand deals. You need shit loads of views to make any ad sense
🤦🏾♂️ You simps ruin comment sections.
“I’d get a half price F space SVR” yes I agree absolutely. The F pace SVR is such an under rated car !
it sounds silly - it's trying too hard and sounds like a fart in a bucket - so I bought a Macan turbo
now that's a shitty lie, the f pace has one of the best sounding SUV engines ever, that v8 is superb @@pw8764
"Some mobster.. trying to sell drugs to the sheep" Thank you, Sam. That made my day!
…or “look, is that a sheep fight? I think those sheep are fighting!” 😆 hilarious
Cracked me up 😂
Kinda highlights that he knows no drug dealers 🤣😂 they’re all on clios and corsas.
😂😂
“Sell drugs to the sheep” 🤣🤣🤣 Great review!
the g350d / g400d I think is the perfect one to have, personally prefer the look and is more understated
I agree. I wish we got those in america. I'd take a lifted narrow body g400d over a g550 4x4 all day.
Couldn't agree more. G400d, green over tan, clear glass, silver wheels.
@@vincentkr3w literally exactly how i’d have it but with brown leather, maybe 2-3in lift kit and some beadlocks
Agree 100%. I took ownership of a new G400d four months ago. It's more practical and than the G63 and not so "in your face". I absolutely love it.
@@Vincetagram you guys can get the g550 professional edition in the US. Sure it's not diesel but it has the off-road kit and isn't as massive as the 4x4 version
Excellent video regarding video quality and commentary made about both cars! However, I recently rented a p300 base model Defender and noticed that the car was 'floaty' and not sitting on the floor when driving on highway with big turns. Would that just be an issue with the base model defender or is it the same for higher specs defender like the p400 and V8 editions as well? Thanks !
Why is no one talking about the woman walking at 6:45, where is she going? There's no civilization in a 50 mile radius
A great review. Exactly my take on the G Wagon. I have a current Defender and love it. Reliability is the main issue however..
I have a new Defender as well. 2.5 years in … no problems. My 2012 LR4 had no problems whatsoever. What is your concern about reliability?
I see that statement made in a vacuum often on the internet, but it leaves out the fact that all of my buddies with G wagons, other high end Benzes, Bentleys, BMWs... they all have issues too.
Yes, expensive cars are generally expensive to maintain and when they do break they are also expensive to repair. But…some do break more than others😊
I’m not sure the G wagon is that reliable either. It’s durable, but idk about reliable
Awesome video, love this kind of content… keep it coming!
As Sebastian Vettel said, even if not cheering for Ferrari, everybody is a Ferrari fan. I’d say same applies in road car wold for the G wagon!
FUGLY vehicle... i used to have MATCHBOX cars that looked like that - hated them, give me Hot Wheels anytime
I kind of agree. The g wagon isn’t my style, but it’s still an amazing vehicle. I’d take the jag svr off that defender v8 over one as well. They are a bit more understated, still look aggressive enough and are $85k+ cheaper new. The g63 amg is a status suv. The jag and defender are for people who don’t care about getting the head nods. You want a comfortable ride, stunning interior and enough power to get in trouble with. And I believe you could even get the svr with a blower in older models if I’m not mistaken.
No!! I dont like of the G Wagon as i dont like almost anything from Mercedes
G wagon is a legacy car, people can moan as much as they want but it is good at what it was built to do, its unapologetically itself. it sells in droves and holds it value like nothing else in its sector, apart from maybe the first URUS's. Its just such a solid cool car. There isnt anything like a G wagon, theres no other car in that sector that has that level of luxury and performance and then can go off-roading with the best of the best and keep up. Carwow has done numerous G wagon off road tests and the proof is in the pudding.... its fine if people dont personally like G wagons but to act like its an "objectively" inferior car to JLR products is crazy😂
@@CITRUS-- yea it was good as a Nazi military vehicle sure
Great video! You earned a subscriber from Ghana🇬🇭. G-wagon is everything! I think the Germans did a great job by maintaining the old military body but focusing on the inside. The new Defender however, has changed in looks and doesn’t feel like the old one at all. I can also understand why Sam prefers Rover over Benz lol.. Brits always prefers what’s theirs even if the other is better 😅. Kudos
you will never drive G-wagen because is too expensive😅😅😅😅
@@casamia995your reply has nothing to do with anything he says, fool🙄Just because it's too expensive for you, doesn't mean it's too expensive for other people.
You’re right that an F-Pace SVR makes far more sense as an on road SUV! But also it’s another fantastic video with wonderful cinematic quality 👌
I love seeing the white defenders at the ski lodge. Especially the two doors!
Can I ask, insurance-wise how are you able to drive these cars ? Is there a type of insurance you have or is it covered under the garage/showroom policy ?
Amazing camera work mate!
Two of my dream cars…Powerful Machines ❤
From the beginning you could already hear the bias. Cool review but I wonder if you could have one where you genuinely tested the vehicles on their merits and less on your bias against the one. Maybe if you reviewed each car alone without the link we'd get something smooth. But hella hilarious watching. Loved it
I think the difference in feel/handling is the Gwagon being body on frame, which is a huge plus if you offroad it. Of course, 99.9% of SUV owners never do, so the Defender is probably a better choice for almost everyone.
The Defender is great offroad.
….body stiffness on the new Defender is higher than the G Wagon’s… and due to Defenders chassis construction, axle articulation is greater than the G Wagon ones too… funny, but facts! Still, my heart beats most for the G!😊
@@wuchengranschiiet9992 Not as good as the G
G wag on top
The G Wagon has been my fav vehicle for years and years. There is just something about the style, the off-road prowess and the sound (of the AMG version) that clicks all the boxes for me
I don't care for the fact that it's hard to differentiate looks-wise between a 2005 and a 2023 G
@@Christoph-sd3zi Why? Is it a status thing? To go against that point - G-wagons hold their value very well. So, a 2005 is still a status symbol.
Thank you for your insights about both vehicles. Everybody has their own take and their own preferences. I appreciate the comparison of them on-road, which is what most people will be doing the vast majority of the time. But I think you missed a very big point of the G-wagon, and that is its off-road ability and durability. That soft suspension that makes it not so great going down twisty roads, makes it excel off-road, which wasn't tested. I think if you would take them both off-road in various conditions for a few hours, you would have realized where the G-Wagon really shines. The new Defender is beautiful and I'm sure does handle better on the road, but that's the problem, for somebody like me who does take their vehicles off road and overlanding, the defender wouldn't cut it. Sadly, the basis for its coolness factor, as a great off-roader, doesn't apply so much anymore. Whereas the G wagon's still 100% does.
i have never seen anyone take the G63 overlanding
Put some KO2’s on a defender you’ll be impressed
The g63 is really undistructable. Whistlindiesel proved it well.
Beautiful video and some stunning backdrops. Great work and a fab (if unintended) advert for Yorkshire!
Epic Sam!! You need to shout out more matey... You deserve way more followers!
Love your content
Nice to see the Durham Dales (M2 review) and now the North York Moors featuring in your videos Sam. It’s brilliant up here in the North East 👍🏻
mate I loved your description of what it was like driving a G wagon, cracked me up😂
Love you're videos keep it coming Sam Want to see you're Porsche GT3 back on the channel soon.
Nice one Sam. I thoroughly appreciate your Sunday video drops. Kindest regards, Richard U.K
Brilliant video as always sam BUT.....There's absolutely no way you just compared the monolithic and unbreakable off-roading land yacht legend that is the G wagon.... to a car thats trim pieces fall off just from being outside for too long, let alone off-roading. Iv seen so many new defenders with hanging off panels and irresponsive front and rear lights its actually not funny. These 2 cars just arent rivals and its weird that you thought they could be.
Urban have really fallen off recently. Their cars look so tacky
This was a twin test that I've been waiting to see!! .. 'Give me a brick wall and I'll drive through it!' ... Loved the test and your energy and enthusiasm, Sam!! .. Keep up the great work!!👍🙂
My mistake, I thought he was a gurning buffoon.
Can you send me that image of the G wagon in the beginning of the video..i tlooks so dope.. or tell me from where yu got pls
Let's be real here. The only narrow "roads" a modern G-wagon is at home at. Is the driveway to your mansion and the drive through at a Starbucks. 😁
😂
Same with the Defender too lol
12:40 it's the other way around here in Germany. I drive a nicely gondwana stone satin (ppf) full black packed Defender and everyone is turning their head. The Defender in general is really rare over here - you see a well specced one maybe once a month. But you see a dozen G-Wagons every day.
Sam - your videos are the best by any auto TH-camr - it’s not because you’re most technically sound or drive the best, but because you come across as the best human, relatable, down to earth, humorous. Excellent overall rounded package. Good Luck. Oh and btw - I completely disagree with you on this one. G63 will blow the Defender or nothing else away. There’s nothing like it on the road. When all everyone cares about is being politically correct the G63 doesn’t care about popular opinions and delivers the best unapologetic driving experience imho.
The G400 diesel is the coolest G Wagon. But even that one being the cheapest in the lineup is like twice the price of a Defender with an equivalent engine
Before I watching this I will always go for that defender 😍
Which one is more reliable the G wagon or defender.
Well, one thing sure about the G63 is its engine won't explode with 7k km on the clock.
Shame it looks like shit tho
How do these compare to the INEOS Grenadier?
In the Netherlands you see the new Defender (V8 or not) far less often than a G wagon. But maybe that’s because the gap between a G and a Defender is not that big compared to the UK. It’s both ridiculously expensive, so I understand that if you’re spending ridiculous amounts of money, you’d also want something that is actually ridiculous.
Defender outsells G Wagon by 3 - 1.
I know this is completely off subject. BUT, Who makes that green jacket?
I think the point was missed here. The G wagon is more of a dedicated offroader, it's not meant for backroad blasts on twisty country lanes. With it's body on frame construction, three locking diffs, it's the one that is better suited for off road trails and muddy terrain. It does lose some of that in the G63 version, but the DNA is still there. No it's not going to be doing that, but neither are you going to be diving with your Rolex Submariner either
Apart from in Dubai, hardly any owner takes their G-Wagon off-road. In terms of off-road capability, Land Rover cars are the best.
I will take the G wagon AMG. It turns heads like no other and it just looks and feels beautiful.
G Wagons are the Ultimate Mall Crawlers
Brilliant! Loved your comparison. I agree with you totally!
I feel you, but Panamera is life 😍
If only I had one. I'll stick to my ford focus 😭
Personally I think it’s too heavy feeling
Both cars are great. I spent a long time deciding which one to buy, and still chose a G-class, despite the fact that it turned out to be 2 times more expensive
Aways a great day when Sam uploads! I am keen to see what you replaced your X3 with 👀
Gotta be a G-wagon Sam. LR/RR will always have problems. Electrics usually. My cousin rewired his old V8 defender with his own wiring loom, no more problems!! He stopped issues from his garage yet they couldn't in a mahoosive factory !
Is your cousin an engineer or something?
@@bohlalenchabeleng1370 When he was in the military he used to strip down, fix, then rebuild Challenger tanks. Now he does I.T. maintaining business networks.
This has to be the most underrated automotive channel on TH-cam.
Another strong vid. Appreciate the content.
I have owned a 2015 Brabus G63 and now a current model 400d, and I think that the Alexander guy sums it up when he talks about personality. Most new cars are pretty damned good these days, but very few actually talk to you. I owned a 2022 911GTS and couldn’t fault it…it was amazing….but it was, well, dull! Sometimes a car that’s flawed but has personality will outscore something that’s perfect.
I concur! I’d buy a Defender in a heartbeat, but I’d never buy a G-Wagon. …basically for the exact reason stated in this video!
I drove a g wagon 4x4 conversion on my channel awhile back as well as a brabus 4x4 and a 'regular' g63 off camera. They're incredible machines for off roading but aren't all that great as a daily imo. It's literally a military truck with a modern mercedes reskin and luxury interior. You could make teh interior rolls royce level but you can't change the fact that it still is a heavy duty truck unless you completely redesign the chassis and suspension as a unibody luxury SUV, not to mention it has the aerodynamics of a cinderblock and will never be as useable or as comfortable as a GLE. Those are the same reasons why the jeep wrangler will never be as comfortable as a grand cherokee, a defender will never be as comfortable as a RR sport, and a bronco will never be as comfortable as a ford explorer.
Love my new Defender! So far she performs great on and off road/construction sites here in Florida…It is definitely a house on wheels😎
Another fantastic video. You are great at this. Thank you
Some more technical comparison would have been appreciated, with the suspension layouts for example.
I will help you . The G-wagon drives like shit compared to Defender -Thank you
@@anthonytromp6265 Opposite off road.
Great segway for the F-pace SVR
What a beautiful review, thoroughly enjoyed it.
The craziest part is, the defender dashboard is more g-wagon than the new g-wagon, it kinda similar to the old one..
Personally would go for the defender or the new XM
My brother swapped his g400d for the new XM and what a difference 😍
Haven’t driven the v8 defender but I think my P400 defender is more than enough
XM 😂😂😂😂😂😂 not even the same level on a g wagon
@@Nnn30055g wagons are trash you are right
@@-LK34- bmw fan boy
@@Nnn30055 Mercedes’ are shit
@ssh3005 ah yes, the BMW Xm that has a higher starting price than the g wagon 'Is not on the same level as a g wagon' makes sense.
Not a fan of either but the Defender would have the edge if I was.
I think a sheep fight is called a Shight. Pretty fitting that you was sitting in the G-Wagon!
Small screen on v8 Def?? How it could be?
Great content. It’s not a fair comparison though. I can’t think of a situation where I would prefer the defender, one of the main issues is a d250 s can look exactly like a v8. The g class manages to get away with this though due to its iconic Shape. I think Range Rover could have an even bigger hit on their hands if they stick closer to the original design.
The fact that a base model D250 with cloth seats and steel wheels exists and a G-Wagon equivalent doesn’t should tell you all you need to know about these vehicles.
G-Wagons are now exclusively owned by the absolute worst people. They aren’t cool any more.
@@kwekuadoboli38 speak for yourself
First thing I noticed is the road noise in the Defender. It is a lot louder inside than the G wagon.
Martin Luther King: I had a dream
STG: I had a dream
Hi Sam, great video. Are you able to please share the name of the piece of music playing between 3:01 and 3:35? It’s awesome and I’d love to follow the artist. Thanks! 🙏🏼
Both are my favourite want both infront of my house, in same colour. Can you provide a picture of both together. Please !!! I can't find it anywhere on internet
You could tell what Sam would say without even watching the video
Does the UK get Lexus vehicles? You appreciate trucks. I’ll be curious to hear your take of the new GX 550.
Shocking and different style of editing at the start,but very fitting given the vehicles featured i think
Everyone knows the G in G-Wagon stands for Gangsta!
Sam, surely a G Wagen is twice the price of a Defender, not really in the same class is it !!!
What else would a g wagon compare to then. Ofc they are competitors
10:46 Are "after market" those "air vents" on the bonnet on the Defender V8?. Also very strange to see small touch-screen in the V8.
Your videos make me smile...just a guy sharing his passion. Op topic. The G looks agient compares to the Defender ( was not a fan in the beginning).....I prefer the Defender.
Out of the two, I would (and did) pick the Wrangler 392
One thing to note about Mercedes AMG vs the Defender is, Mercedes will boost the sound of the exhaust through the speakers while that is not the case with the defender. If you stand behind booth of them, I think the defender has a better sound. And you get true interior sound of your revs in the defender vs Mercedes. Although the Mercedes is really nice, I just can’t justify paying $250k for a vehicle when I can get something just as nice or close for $130k less.
If you have to justify paying more, your not the target customer
Sam can you do a review on the Land Cruiser 300, btw love the uploads man keep it up!
You were on good form for this film, don't know if you scripted this, but either way… fine work.
There’s no comparison about the 2 cars. I love the defender, I m even in love with the defender however the g wagon is by far no comparison with the defender.
Lmao with the rap music
Love both vehicles, but would prefer either from the 90s instead of these new models!
This test isn't fair. You have compare standard g63 to urban something defender which I see has different suspension and maybe even distances which make ride completely different to standard defender v8. You should take brabus g63 and then compare it.
I currently have a 2020 Lexus GX 460 Just ordered a 2024 Defender I had to order it because I had a few things added. I wish I could have picked red leather seating like I have in my GX But Land Rover does offer that color option. If anyone has had both a Lexus GX and Defender can you tell me which one you prefer. Thanks
I've just been reading about how problematic recovering a Defender is, if it's in a truly offroad situation. Its owner's manual is very enlightening.
"The vehicle should not be towed on all four wheels and should not be recovered with the front or rear wheels suspended. Doing so can result in serious transmission damage. The method for recovery and/or transportation of the vehicle is on a transporter or trailer designed for that purpose."
"The recovery agent must activate the transmission park release before recovery commences. The procedure for activating the transmission park release is covered in a separate publication for service personnel."
If you don't, the following happens:
"If Neutral (N) is selected and the engine is then switched off, the transmission automatically selects Park (P) after 10 minutes has elapsed. If the transmission park release mechanism has not been activated and the vehicle is being towed, serious damage to the transmission will result."
"If the vehicle cannot be recovered via the correct method, the vehicle can be towed on all four wheels for a short distance."
" Do not tow the vehicle for more than 50 km (30 miles). Do not exceed 50 km/h (30 mph). Towing for a greater distance or at a higher speed may result in serious damage to the transmission."
So you can only go offroad to places that are within 50-ish km of access to a flatbed truck. ... but you can't even go that far unless you've learnt how to activate the transmission park release.
" Only tow the vehicle in a forward direction with all four wheels on the ground. Towing in a reverse direction, or with only two wheels on the ground, will cause serious damage to the transmission."
What if pulling it out backwards is the only access to where it's stuck?
" Do not tow the vehicle if the transmission cannot be set in Neutral (N)."
"Do not tow the vehicle if the rear electronic differential has failed in the locked position."
Crikey. With electrics that shut down the whole vehicle at the drop off a hat, how on earth does all THAT make it a good choice for serious offroading? Australia? Any continent except Europe? Hmm...
Realy good comparison on two lux suv
Q Would a Landrover Defender 'fit in' along side a G Wagon in Monaco?
Definitely not embarrassing to be in a G-Wagon where I live.
I see them around.
One house has about 4 of them!
& what’s your point ….
Interior of the g wagon is the same you get in a 5 year old c class, wouldn’t call it luxurious🤣
You don't buy a g wagon to be a luxurious car you buy a g wagon cause its a g wagon
Sam, it truly is OK to just like the car let it go take a breath and enjoy the ride.
Wish you had added a 3rd and drive the rsq8 best all rounder for the price
They say Land Rovers not that great. My daughter owned one did not last her long too many mechanical problems. My dream car is a G wagon. Yes I saw a red one I fell in love ❤. I dream all the time of owning one. Never lose hope. I visualize it and smell the new car scent,the wonderful sensation inside it and driving it. 😍
The G Wagon has the most comfortable seat that i've ever sat in for a short period. Apparently they're not that great over long distances or on the motorway though....
I take the Defender any day!! Great content as always!
The G wagon has such a military look to it that I love
I also had a dream of owning one, one day a G-wagon
Downside of defender: build quality, noise isolation, speaker
❤ it’s the complete opposite in Australia, there’s more g dragon’s then defenders.
I see a defender and go “ooooooh yeh baby”❤
Sam at Alexanders prestige to try and sell off their stock of Land Rovers
Nah - most of Sams audience aren’t old enough to insure anything more than a Fiesta