Hey guys! This video is a re-upload because the original version of this episode was no longer viewable. We’ll be posting these re-uploads every Saturday for the next few months. There are still NEW sins videos every Tuesday and Thursday!
Moana's dad: i need to keep my daughter away from the ocean Moana's dad: what should i name her Moana's dad: i'll name her moana Moana's dad: which means ocean
That line reminded me of this old book I had as a kid, in which an eel meets a human girl and they fall in love. Despite the rest of the village trying to prevent them from meeting, they keep meeting. The girl grows older (she was like 8 in the beginning) and is still in love with the eel. Eventually the rest of the village realises that the only thing to do is kill the eel and when the girl goes to save it, the eel tells her to let them kill it, that she should bury it's head and it'll turn into a coconut tree Similar story no? (How the characters look and wears would in my mind also place it in the Hawaii area) But do remember that this is a KIDS BOOK... That is a bit messed up...
Yeah, I’m kinda disappointed he didn’t take off more sins for the accurate portrayal of Polynesian mythology and tradition. My family is from New Zealand and we were all impressed by this.
That makes sense, because he tried to sail to the edge of the world to prove that the earth is flat only to blame the ocean for the death of his friend, which is completely stupid.
As someone from New Zealand I have heard a lot of these legends before. So sinning the part about Maui burying an eel to create coconut trees or that moana wouldn’t know what a cultural drum would look like was probably not a good idea. I love this channel but you probably should have done some research before
He sinned the eel part because it doesn't make sense and guess what, even if it's genuine mythology it still doesn't make sense. Also, what or where on earth should he research to find out if Moana have seen drums before?
@@adambalmer801 OC: "Sinning... that moana wouldn’t know what a cultural drum would look like was probably not a good idea. I love this channel but you probably should have done some research before" MC: "where on earth should he research to find out if Moana have seen drums before?" Perhaps you should learn to read before responding.
Islanders: *starving to death* Moana: Why don't we go past the reef for fish? Moana's Dad: No Moana: Why not? Moana's Dad: BEcAuSe tHen pEOpLE wiLl DiE!
I love how he sinned for the ocean not just taking Moana straight to Maui, but then also sinned the "too convenient" ocean storm that took her straight to Maui......you can't have it both ways lol
That happens a lot actually. In John Wick 2 he sinned the fact that John's attacker didn't check the wreckage for a body after blowing up his house, but then sinned the fact that John survived, because it was so impossible.
@@gagecameron5672 It's stupid according to the laws of physics for the character to survive an explosion that is supposed to kill them. It's stupid to the laws of logic for the bad guys not to make sure the hero is dead. Even though that's the only way movies build tension, it seems.
Don’t like that a lot of the sins are coming from differences in Western ideology and Polynesian/pacific islander ideology and mythology it’s just a difference in culture it’s not sin worthy ..its representation
The sins this channel gives out are 100% arbitrary and say NOTHING, neither about the actual quality of the movie nor about how much they personally like it.
I would have taken 1 sin off for the hair budget in this movie. Maui's hair, and especially Moana's, were given their own budget and R&D with the CGI department to make it look as realistic as possible. Anybody who has ever done work with 3D animation knows just how difficult it is to pull that off, you need top-of-the-line machines and processors to get particles and primitives to behave and animate in that way. I believe Brave and Rapunzel had to use similar software to make the hair happen for those characters as well.
LordEirikr Same. It shows his cocky attitude but also explains a lot of what he did and how we came to be. The only other song that can compete in this movie is Shiny.
Look just because THEY are cynical enough to have a problem with inanimate objects being inanimate objects, doesn't mean you should get offended too. In fact, being offended by such petty negativity makes you just as- . . . . . OH, you ,meant Dwayne Johnson, okay nevermind.
@Swag Monke You do realize that's an entire bit on the channel that's so prevalent that he literally calls himself an asshole repeatedly throughout everything in this channel... Also, how many people going to disney movies are going to do research on mythologies contained... IN A DISNEY MOVIE? Keep in mind that majority of people that have access to disney movies either aren't Polynesian enough to know the mythology or pedantic enough to check if a children's movie publisher known for coming up with bullshit mythologies actually use real mythos for the first time in company history? THIS IS DISNEY! The only people that watch this garbage are 12 years or under girls, their parents, and young adult women that haven't found the "serial killer documentary" channel on their cable yet. Once again, THIS. IS. DISNEY.
His job is to be FUNNY. Not to educate 12 year olds about mythos that they won't ever care about. He's great at his job, because his job is to be a nitpicky asshole who points out mistakes in logic or background setting that you wouldn't notice without looking for them... i.e. HIS JOB IS TO BE FUNNY. CinemaSins is a COMEDY CHANNEL. HAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA You realize that not everyone will watch things that they're the target audience for, right? Especially since Disney is a CHILDREN's movie producer. Parents aren't in the market that Disney aims for, and yet parents watch it. Also, it's a well-known movie, he's going to get requests for things. As an asex, if I did a similar idea for "adult films", that doesn't mean I'm into them. It means that people request certain ones, and I get ad revenue for what gets requested. Basic business 101, go where the demand is. HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA I'm sorry, do you really think that Disney has a diverse target market for children's movies? Spoiler alert, they don't. It's either children or children's parents. If you're not under the age of 12 with estrogen in your body, and you're not a parent to someone that fits that description... YOU"RE NOT DISNEY'S TARGET MARKET!
@Swag Monke and you know that Marvel is known for its blatant manipulation (and consequent destruction) of ancient mythos. Also, Marvel may be owned by Disney, but that doesn't make them the same thing. Also also, Marvel is worthless to this discussion, because we're talking about Moana, and similar movies that have been written by the Disney team... The Disney team that makes Disney princesses for little girls that wanna grow up to be princesses... Now... NEXT. Edit: Also also also hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha
@Swag Monke ...I never said that was the only group that watched this. In fact, if you actually worked on your literacy, you might realize that I admitted that A) he likely did it because of requests, B) parents have to watch the same movies as their little runts, and C) young adult women will also watch this garbage prior to them making a discovery of what cable channel they can go to for serial killer documentaries. Furthermore, if you worked on your reading comprehension, you'd realize that I said that Disney's TARGET DEMOGRAPHIC is 12 year old girls who wanna grow up to be princesses. As far as this video's viewing audience, you don't have to like, or care about, the movie in order to like the video... because it's a comedy video, about someone's nitpicking a children's movie by a company that's well known for their thinking route of "we like surprises more than consistency".
Things Cinema Sins Got Wrong. 6:53 This is actully a real constellation called scorpius There is an ocean god in maori mythology, Tangaroa With the thing where they plant the eel and it grows a coconut tree that is actully a real polonaisian myth The "upside down horse saddle looking thing" is actully a traditional maori drum
@@burningfish156 no, I haven't even seen Moana. I just saw commentary from some people who had seen it that the CinemaSins list has a lot of inaccuracies which invalidate it. A lot of CS' "sins" are outright wrong or contradict each other. Check out Shaun's video about CinemaSins for some good examples. And I didn't discover CS from Shaun, I already watched it in the past and found it lazy, if that matters.
I only realized it was a re-upload when he mentioned sinning it for the pop cover in the credits. Still going to finish it though it's not like i haven't binge watched all of these multiple times.
BUILD THAT CINEMA SINS SUB COUNT! BUILD THAT CINEMA SINS SUB COUNT! BUILD THAT CINEMA SINS SUB COUNT! BUILD THAT CINEMA SINS SUB COUNT! BUILD THAT CINEMA SINS SUB COUNT! BUILD THAT CINEMA SINS SUB COUNT! BUILD THAT CINEMA SINS SUB COUNT! BUILD THAT CINEMA SINS SUB COUNT! BUILD THAT CINEMA SINS SUB COUNT! BUILD THAT CINEMA SINS SUB COUNT! BUILD THAT CINEMA SINS SUB COUNT! BUILD THAT CINEMA SINS SUB COUNT! BUILD THAT CINEMA SINS SUB COUNT! BUILD THAT CINEMA SINS SUB COUNT! BUILD THAT CINEMA SINS SUB COUNT! BUILD THAT CINEMA SINS SUB COUNT! BUILD THAT CINEMA SINS SUB COUNT! BUILD THAT CINEMA SINS SUB COUNT! BUILD THAT CINEMA SINS SUB COUNT! BUILD THAT CINEMA SINS SUB COUNT! BUILD THAT CINEMA SINS SUB COUNT! BUILD THAT CINEMA SINS SUB COUNT! BUILD THAT CINEMA SINS SUB COUNT! BUILD THAT CINEMA SINS SUB COUNT! BUILD THAT CINEMA SINS SUB COUNT! BUILD THAT CINEMA SINS SUB COUNT! BUILD THAT CINEMA SINS SUB COUNT! BUILD THAT CINEMA SINS SUB COUNT! BUILD THAT CINEMA SINS SUB COUNT! BUILD THAT CINEMA SINS SUB COUNT! BUILD THAT CINEMA SINS SUB COUNT! BUILD THAT CINEMA SINS SUB COUNT! BUILD THAT CINEMA SINS SUB COUNT! BUILD THAT CINEMA SINS SUB COUNT! BUILD THAT CINEMA SINS SUB COUNT! BUILD THAT CINEMA SINS SUB COUNT! BUILD THAT CINEMA SINS SUB COUNT!
I like how moana's grandmother said "you've been told all of the villages story but one" how did moana not know that her father's best friend drowned and at the same time didn't know that her people were voyagers?
@@kellieirvin4644 That's how it was while it was forming, yes. However, they're saying that at some point a little later down the line it was probably an ocean planet. Science does, in fact, support this.
@Swag Monke uh yes? this channel doesn't actually do legit reviews for movies. its a joke. besides, most of the time they sin movies they like. you can tell when he actually hates a movie.
@Cockjuggling Thundercunt It kindof does because this movie is about Moari's and that is a Moari drum so the sin is incorrect, because to Moana, that would be exactly what a drum looks like. So Granny didnt need to be specific for Moana like he says she should
@@filmeditstudios3182 This movie isn’t Maori, it’s a mix of Samoan, Fijian and Tahitian culture. You would have known that if you watched the making of the film…
Actually I believe that when he first saw the heart he did seem scared of the heart, his character’s eyes widened and stuff, but at the time he didn’t want anything to do with Moana and thought he could get rid of her. At first he only saw the glimpse of it too.
Fun fact: with sin 3 science is actually giving the finger cause it’s fact that early earth was covered with water(I’m not trying to sound like those douches who think they know how everything works)
I only know that it rained like hell, but I never thought about that there could have been a moment where there was ALL water. Thinking about that stuff makes me feel so small :o
Fun fact: according to current theory, even then, we still had the same amount of landmass that we do now, it was just a singular continent called Pangea.
@@lucidfangirl1030 I mean, the bible also says that the all-powerful, all-knowing entity in the sky can't/won't deal with an evil entity that's actively killing/causing pain to the defenseless creatures it claims to love and protect and yet is still all-powerful and/or kind. So I wouldn't really say that the bible is the best source for information.
0:23 44 billion years ago, the earth was almost completely covered in ocean, with a few islands. +1 sin for CinemaSins 8:17 that is referring to (Polynesian?) mythology +1 sin for CinemaSins
In terms of why the Crab was fooled (I can't think of his name right away), I think it's that the Kakamura detected the prescence of the heart rather than knew it's exact down to the second location. So the crab could be fooled by the algee since, for all he knew, that WAS the heart. Moana had the heart on her, so the algee would presumably be thought to be the Heart
Does he not realize that this movie is almost entirely drawn from Hawaiian mythology and the movie/ writers aren’t responsible at all for the illogical stuff.
To quote the Cinema Sins: "Cinema Sins.." "Were American. (AMMMERICA, F*CK YEAH!) Which means we don't have any desire to learn about other people's cultures."
The bad part is I've been watching their videos for years and now my wife hates watching movies with me.... we have a rule now, first time seeing the movie I'm not allowed to, After that it's free game
Of course it also have a backstory to it. Maui actually lost his fishhook while he was using it for fishing but instead, he accidentally created an island. He told his brothers to pull up but dont to look back until one of his brothers disobeyed which led the rope breaks and flying up to the sky which then created a constellation. There's probably many stories of how Maui's fishhook become a constellation but to me this is the only version of the story that I'm very familiar with.
9:38 Moana quite _literally_ yelled out loud that this was the current location of the heart. Fairly certain it doesn’t take a genius to figure out that it’s there when you have a -princess- daughter of the chief shout “COME AND GET IT!” after loudly talking about the heart.
TidalShores It’s vegetarian but not vegan. Vegetarians still use animal products and things that were produced with the help of animal products, thy just won’t eat meat. Pescatarians are like vegetarians but they still eat fish and shellfish. Vegans don’t eat/use anything that came into contact with an animal (no leather chairs, no wool socks, no eggs, no honey, etc.)
@@presidentialcampaignmusic1018 theory still isnt capable of being 100% accurate with no potential dispute like scientists and archaeoligists thought a plant fossil was an ancient lizard spine and that plant didnt date back nearly 4 billion years ago while he did probably mean theory the reason i am unwilling to touch any theories is scientists believe a flood happened on mars but not earth even though as of the current day mars has been frozen an insanely long time and most of earths water still exists
Something that always bugged me was Maui being rewarded for bringing back what he stole. If you steal a priceless gem from a museum and break your tools along the way I doubt you'll be refunded and thanked for returning the gem.
Gods and Goddesses are sometimes far more forgiving than normal people would be (though other times they can be far less forgiving, such as in Greek Mythology).
rmsgrey Cinema sins, sins like a picky movie goer, who the fuck researchs shit before watching a movie. Cuz if he did research it he'd be a bigger asshole pointing out all the inaccuracies to the point people would still hate on.
There should definitely be a sin off for the scene where Moana restores the heart to Te Ka and she becomes Te Fiti again. It's so beautiful it makes me cry just thinking about it.
@@fathergascoigne6104 When the first drops of water came with the comets the earth was nothing but a big ball of rock and fire. It rained comets with little drops of water for several hunderd years. At one point there was so much water that no land was visible from space.
You should’ve added a sin for the ending. Father is just like “oh yay my daughter came back after she abandoned my rules and the island, and I’m not even slightly pissed” Why? Because.. Disney.
I can’t believe he missed the fact that the people have been living there in a small village for 1000 years yet have developed several distinct accents... 🤷🏼♀️
Arent all of the voice actors (except the voice for the chicken) Polynesian though? That's got to be worth something. I honestly give them props for accurate representation. 🤷♀️
@@coolbeans6312 of the main cast from what I could find: Dwayne Johnson is technically only half polynesian. He was born in california to a samoan kiwi mother and a black canadian man from NS, but lived his early life in kiwi-land before coming to the states. Jemaine Clement who played the crab only has a mother who is maori but other than his blood connection he doesn't know much of culture or have any connections outside he's a kiwi as most of the cast. Auli'i Carvalho who plays moana is chinese-hawaii'an and moana's mother is philipino-hawaii'an making an small lil connection funnily enough Rachel House who played grandma is Maori-scotish making her the third kiwi alongside Dwayne and Jemaine. Temuera Morrison who plays the chief is Maori as well making the cast nearly completely polynesian so you are indeed correct
Or that it says that all of the world was just ocean except the one island with the stone- but there are many other islands that it later says was destroyed or something????
The whole, “Maui killing an eel and burying it’s body” thing is a REAL Polynesian legend. If it wasn’t, why would Disney put such a stupid and random line in such a good and memorable song?
I myself have not seen Moana but I dont think it should have so many sins for the specific things you criticize. I mean it deserved most of them but you need to keep in mind that a lot of Moana is based on Māori culture and traditional stories. It kinda bothered me everytime you criticized things that were pulled right from the culture like Māui planting an eel and growing a tree. I dunno just my opinion
Faeron Dewart Thank you, I support your guys view. Being Hawaiian I am a little insulted making jokes not only to my ancestors but the fellow ancestors of the other Polynesians people
Faeron Dewart Maori are the Polynesian people of Aotearoa sure. Your comments not far off but this mythology isn’t Maori mythology it’s sort of proto-Maori. Just imagine the sequel to this movie being Moana and friends discovering Aotearoa (New Zealand) then over time the Polynesian mythology transforms in to what the Maori myths are.
I usually love your videos but some of these “sins” were you disregarding actual Polynesian culture and mythology as Disney doing too much fantasy which comes off as lazy and not researched
Okay, then just transfer the sins to the Polynesian culture and mythology. Even if it was originally Polynesian mythology, that doesn't remove the logical problems with the story in some instances.
I feel like this video should just be called Everything Wrong with CinemaSins Comprehension of Polynesian Culture, Mythology and the Concept of Fantasy in General.
@@wealljammin eating shit is not good for your health, ergo what you just said is "eat shit so you can get incredibly sick" and lazy content is the funniest thing in the fucking universe, dont tell me you didnt laugh at The Hangover.
@@tey_zah r u calling a major motion picture with a huge budget lazy content??? do u think they just slapped a wolf tshirt on zach galifianakis n started filming?? yr comment makes no sense, rethink n try again later
Ethan Smith Infinity War was over rated. I’m not even kidding, the only things I remember from it were “You should have aimed for the head.” and “Mr. Stark, I don’t feel so good.” It was so forgettable and boring.
@Just a Lil Artist if this guy is trying to be funny, he fails. Even if he was being sarcastic, sinning a movie for having mythology that "isn't scientifically correct" is stupid. It's even more stupid because of the fact that the world was a big ocean at one point. Just had to get that off my chest. Carry on.
Oddball Kitten does it even matter? he’s said that the sins hold no value and should be taken **very** lightly like iron man 2 got more sins than The Wall so calm down about this video on an ONLINE PLATFORM bud
Hey guys! This video is a re-upload because the original version of this episode was no longer viewable. We’ll be posting these re-uploads every Saturday for the next few months. There are still NEW sins videos every Tuesday and Thursday!
Sinner
CinemaSins hey
Praise be the CinemaSins
Infinity War plz my dude
Please do infinity war please
Moana's dad: i need to keep my daughter away from the ocean
Moana's dad: what should i name her
Moana's dad: i'll name her moana
Moana's dad: which means ocean
XD
Parent of the year (current year)
I think hes on to something...
Perhaps I should name my daughter Prison.
....pfft....parent of all enernety oh god XD
In Hawaiian mythology, Maui actually kills an eel and buries it, then a coconut tree grows from it. Sin off for animation being accurate with it
That line reminded me of this old book I had as a kid, in which an eel meets a human girl and they fall in love. Despite the rest of the village trying to prevent them from meeting, they keep meeting.
The girl grows older (she was like 8 in the beginning) and is still in love with the eel. Eventually the rest of the village realises that the only thing to do is kill the eel and when the girl goes to save it, the eel tells her to let them kill it, that she should bury it's head and it'll turn into a coconut tree
Similar story no? (How the characters look and wears would in my mind also place it in the Hawaii area)
But do remember that this is a KIDS BOOK... That is a bit messed up...
Yeah, I’m kinda disappointed he didn’t take off more sins for the accurate portrayal of Polynesian mythology and tradition. My family is from New Zealand and we were all impressed by this.
@@olorin_i_maia is new Zealand polynesian? Sry I'm stupid
@@olorin_i_maia nvm I just saw that it is a pacific island
@@annamirosh2085 i dont think technically its a part of Polynesia but they are close so I could see how there would be cultural overlaps.
Plot twist:
Moana’s dad didn’t want her to go beyond the reef because he is a flat earther
That makes sense, because he tried to sail to the edge of the world to prove that the earth is flat only to blame the ocean for the death of his friend, which is completely stupid.
Yep
*Noone goes beyond the reef.*
I know but if there are no fish in the lagoon...
Ye
As someone from New Zealand I have heard a lot of these legends before. So sinning the part about Maui burying an eel to create coconut trees or that moana wouldn’t know what a cultural drum would look like was probably not a good idea. I love this channel but you probably should have done some research before
He sinned the eel part because it doesn't make sense and guess what, even if it's genuine mythology it still doesn't make sense. Also, what or where on earth should he research to find out if Moana have seen drums before?
@@Ackalan One of the first images that comes up when you Google Polynesian drum is a very similar one.
@@adambalmer801 And you think Moana used google often?
@@Ackalan The world of Moana is adapted from Polynesian mythology. She wouldn't need to Google anything, she would recognise it as a drum.
@@adambalmer801 OC: "Sinning... that moana wouldn’t know what a cultural drum would look like was probably not a good idea. I love this channel but you probably should have done some research before"
MC: "where on earth should he research to find out if Moana have seen drums before?"
Perhaps you should learn to read before responding.
Islanders: *starving to death*
Moana: Why don't we go past the reef for fish?
Moana's Dad: No
Moana: Why not?
Moana's Dad: BEcAuSe tHen pEOpLE wiLl DiE!
no1 gos beeyond da reef
Make this comment 666 likes.
It went past sorry
@@s-b9ifjry7732 I love this reply
They'll die without food too-
I love how he sinned for the ocean not just taking Moana straight to Maui, but then also sinned the "too convenient" ocean storm that took her straight to Maui......you can't have it both ways lol
That happens a lot actually. In John Wick 2 he sinned the fact that John's attacker didn't check the wreckage for a body after blowing up his house, but then sinned the fact that John survived, because it was so impossible.
He does that a lot
Well, that IS true, but then again CinemaSins is, to say the least, unforgiving. Also, screw this movie.
@@alb.rhoades What do you have against this movie?
@@gagecameron5672 It's stupid according to the laws of physics for the character to survive an explosion that is supposed to kill them.
It's stupid to the laws of logic for the bad guys not to make sure the hero is dead. Even though that's the only way movies build tension, it seems.
You didn't sin the fact that Maui's back story was literally a *back* story. *DING*
@Help Find Picasso you will be good in cinemasins! *DING*
😂😂😂
BurgerInParadice34 HARDY HAR HAR
😂
@@RealZone_King so are you *DING*
You forgot that Pua and Hey Hey never grew up / old or die as Moana grew up from a toddler to a teenager.
I actually thought the tattoo being his consciousness was clever
Of course you did
I thought it was pretty cool 😗😗
And you can think it's cool. Don't change your opinion.
It is clever
Conscience. Not consciousness.
little did they know it, but the heart of tafiti was a infinity stone
NOW THIS IS AN AVENGERS LEVEL THREAT.
@@chaboxcloud Behold! A recent comment !
@@chaboxcloud Ya like jazz memes?
@@sarahsmiles4155 nOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
@@b1._.x457 Yᴏᴜʀ ʙʟᴜᴇ ᴅᴀ ʙᴀʙʏ Dᴇᴇ ᴅᴀ ʙᴀ ᴅɪᴇ
“I’m the village crazy lady that’s my job”
My life in one sentence 😂
That has got to be the coolest job EVER!
Tigergirl06 AJ saaaame
@Digital Gamer Again bruh get out of here it was a joke chill
@Digital Gamer Again haha, no. That is not the point of this comment., this comment is a joke.
Man, seeing all these people with WoF pfp’s watching cinemasins, it’s great XD
Don’t like that a lot of the sins are coming from differences in Western ideology and Polynesian/pacific islander ideology and mythology it’s just a difference in culture it’s not sin worthy ..its representation
I noticed that too 😒
Like what
"What can I say, it's exposition" - nice voice
I KNOWWWW
Honestly tho
lol
I want to like it but it's on 420.
@@jellykitty9618 ok
Nuh-uh.
I absolutely REFUSE to believe that this has more sins than the goddamn emoji movie
And it has L E S S than joker
bruh joker was better than both of them ;-;
More sins doesn't mean it's bad. It's just it had more plotholes and took more risks. And the Emoji movie took none so it's just a sin itself.
Plus, sins.. as CinemaSins has said themselves, "doesn't really have a value" so I don't know why ppl care about the sins
th-cam.com/video/VYslZytdOWg/w-d-xo.html
The Emoji movie has 279 sins, while Moano only has 107.
You're wrong
The sins this channel gives out are 100% arbitrary and say NOTHING, neither about the actual quality of the movie nor about how much they personally like it.
8:17 that’s actually based on a real Polynesian tale of coconuts coming from the buried carcass of an eel
This is why I watch film theory
@@artacrosstheuniverse hahaha samee tho
Art Across the Universe lol same
Now I want to see them do this in the Animal Crossing games.
Lady Onikara lol
I would have taken 1 sin off for the hair budget in this movie. Maui's hair, and especially Moana's, were given their own budget and R&D with the CGI department to make it look as realistic as possible. Anybody who has ever done work with 3D animation knows just how difficult it is to pull that off, you need top-of-the-line machines and processors to get particles and primitives to behave and animate in that way. I believe Brave and Rapunzel had to use similar software to make the hair happen for those characters as well.
“Let’s name my daughter after the ocean even though I hate the ocean”
Her grandma gave her that name
@@CranberrySauce-gh3fj And the dad was just cool with letting the grandma name his child after something she knows he has bad memories with?
@@CranberrySauce-gh3fj And the dad accepted that
@Pecan *illuminati music intensifies*
I know right? Like, bruh.
"Maui's mother tossed him into the water"
No wonder he did the same to moana
Oof
Genes
wow
when you put it like that it becomes a really big off
@@kemenonon2154 when you don't want to deal with something, you toss it into the water. makes sense.
And then he turned into a worm and went into his mother's vagina and died
“Annnd that’s how grandma got fired as the daycare teacher”
-CinemaSins
LMAOOOOOO
why does this have so many likes
Cinema sins: the world was never just ocean
The Cambrian era: am i a joke to you
Yeah he probably doesn’t know how land is made....
Seeing how he sinned Polynesian mythology and culture I didn’t expect much research to be done for this movie
It's the *Cambrian Explosionn*
@@respawn_9 look there’s a worm, and a fish, and other water bug like creatures...
there was land in the Cambrian era, it wasn't JUST ocean so what's the point of this comment?
Honestly I think that the Rock did an insanely good job with his voice, I’m sinning CinemaSins for sinning the Rock
Definitely. It's actually my favorite song in the movie.
LordEirikr
Same. It shows his cocky attitude but also explains a lot of what he did and how we came to be. The only other song that can compete in this movie is Shiny.
Supposedly he took a few shots of tequila before singing in the studio.
Look just because THEY are cynical enough to have a problem with inanimate objects being inanimate objects, doesn't mean you should get offended too. In fact, being offended by such petty negativity makes you just as- . . . . .
OH, you ,meant Dwayne Johnson, okay nevermind.
DING!!!
The grandma dying thing is because the heart of te fiti was keeping her alive and by giving it to moana she started to die, that's all I know
WOWWWWWW
Oooohhhhhhhh
OoOooOooh this makes more sense 😁 NO WONDER SHE WAS SO FRICKING OLD
OK Jimmy nuetron said gotta blast
*WOAH*
The whole coconut eel thing is actually a Polynesian legend.
Cooooool
yeh and Moana is Maui's daughter according to that same myth
@@thembaninkomo7910 so is the pig
And he didn't need his hook to shapeshift
@@thembaninkomo7910
No, because Moana isn’t a demigoddess…
In fact she’s not mythical…
plot twist:
Moana's dad doesn't let anybody eat anymore because somebody died after eating 50 ghost peppers at once
I don't think this channel has ever made me laugh quite as hard as I did about Grandma getting fired from the daycare center.
Tzisorey Tigerwuf no was one of the best part
Lmao 😂😂
You do realize that quite a few of these sins are *actual* Polynesian mythology, right?
@Swag Monke You do realize that's an entire bit on the channel that's so prevalent that he literally calls himself an asshole repeatedly throughout everything in this channel...
Also, how many people going to disney movies are going to do research on mythologies contained... IN A DISNEY MOVIE? Keep in mind that majority of people that have access to disney movies either aren't Polynesian enough to know the mythology or pedantic enough to check if a children's movie publisher known for coming up with bullshit mythologies actually use real mythos for the first time in company history? THIS IS DISNEY! The only people that watch this garbage are 12 years or under girls, their parents, and young adult women that haven't found the "serial killer documentary" channel on their cable yet. Once again, THIS. IS. DISNEY.
His job is to be FUNNY. Not to educate 12 year olds about mythos that they won't ever care about. He's great at his job, because his job is to be a nitpicky asshole who points out mistakes in logic or background setting that you wouldn't notice without looking for them... i.e. HIS JOB IS TO BE FUNNY. CinemaSins is a COMEDY CHANNEL.
HAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA
You realize that not everyone will watch things that they're the target audience for, right? Especially since Disney is a CHILDREN's movie producer. Parents aren't in the market that Disney aims for, and yet parents watch it. Also, it's a well-known movie, he's going to get requests for things. As an asex, if I did a similar idea for "adult films", that doesn't mean I'm into them. It means that people request certain ones, and I get ad revenue for what gets requested. Basic business 101, go where the demand is.
HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA I'm sorry, do you really think that Disney has a diverse target market for children's movies? Spoiler alert, they don't. It's either children or children's parents. If you're not under the age of 12 with estrogen in your body, and you're not a parent to someone that fits that description... YOU"RE NOT DISNEY'S TARGET MARKET!
@Swag Monke and you know that Marvel is known for its blatant manipulation (and consequent destruction) of ancient mythos.
Also, Marvel may be owned by Disney, but that doesn't make them the same thing.
Also also, Marvel is worthless to this discussion, because we're talking about Moana, and similar movies that have been written by the Disney team... The Disney team that makes Disney princesses for little girls that wanna grow up to be princesses... Now... NEXT.
Edit: Also also also hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha
@Swag Monke ...I never said that was the only group that watched this. In fact, if you actually worked on your literacy, you might realize that I admitted that A) he likely did it because of requests, B) parents have to watch the same movies as their little runts, and C) young adult women will also watch this garbage prior to them making a discovery of what cable channel they can go to for serial killer documentaries.
Furthermore, if you worked on your reading comprehension, you'd realize that I said that Disney's TARGET DEMOGRAPHIC is 12 year old girls who wanna grow up to be princesses.
As far as this video's viewing audience, you don't have to like, or care about, the movie in order to like the video... because it's a comedy video, about someone's nitpicking a children's movie by a company that's well known for their thinking route of "we like surprises more than consistency".
Mythology for a reason
Things Cinema Sins Got Wrong.
6:53
This is actully a real constellation called scorpius
There is an ocean god in maori mythology, Tangaroa
With the thing where they plant the eel and it grows a coconut tree that is actully a real polonaisian myth
The "upside down horse saddle looking thing" is actully a traditional maori drum
cause they're lazy and their channel sucks
You should check out Th3BirdMan
@@treehann Just cause they sinned your favorite movie?
@@burningfish156 no, I haven't even seen Moana. I just saw commentary from some people who had seen it that the CinemaSins list has a lot of inaccuracies which invalidate it. A lot of CS' "sins" are outright wrong or contradict each other. Check out Shaun's video about CinemaSins for some good examples. And I didn't discover CS from Shaun, I already watched it in the past and found it lazy, if that matters.
@@treehann Well okay then.
Is nobody gonna talk about how he didnt take a sin off for shiny? SHINY?!??! S H I N Y?!?!?
At least one of Miranda's songs needed a sin off that guy is a freaking legend
Maybe if you say it a few more times it'll make sense
@@GyeongmiBaeb *SHINY*
Anyone else still watch it even if it is a re-upload?
I only realized it was a re-upload when he mentioned sinning it for the pop cover in the credits. Still going to finish it though it's not like i haven't binge watched all of these multiple times.
Wait, why is he re-uploading the eww episodes?
It's hard to tell with Disney Movies. could have been any of them.
Yup
Yeah
Movie: Has narration
Cinemasins:Sin
Movie:No narration
Cinemasins: Sin
Me:**Confused as fukk** What?
That's racist
yeah that's the point
@@johns5638 Narrationist.
Then We Are Decided hypocritical
You: makes this comment
Me:*SIN*
First upload: mediocre
Reupload: NUMBER 1 ON TRENDING
BUILD THAT CINEMA SINS SUB COUNT! BUILD THAT CINEMA SINS SUB COUNT! BUILD THAT CINEMA SINS SUB COUNT! BUILD THAT CINEMA SINS SUB COUNT! BUILD THAT CINEMA SINS SUB COUNT! BUILD THAT CINEMA SINS SUB COUNT! BUILD THAT CINEMA SINS SUB COUNT! BUILD THAT CINEMA SINS SUB COUNT! BUILD THAT CINEMA SINS SUB COUNT! BUILD THAT CINEMA SINS SUB COUNT! BUILD THAT CINEMA SINS SUB COUNT! BUILD THAT CINEMA SINS SUB COUNT! BUILD THAT CINEMA SINS SUB COUNT! BUILD THAT CINEMA SINS SUB COUNT! BUILD THAT CINEMA SINS SUB COUNT! BUILD THAT CINEMA SINS SUB COUNT! BUILD THAT CINEMA SINS SUB COUNT! BUILD THAT CINEMA SINS SUB COUNT! BUILD THAT CINEMA SINS SUB COUNT! BUILD THAT CINEMA SINS SUB COUNT! BUILD THAT CINEMA SINS SUB COUNT! BUILD THAT CINEMA SINS SUB COUNT! BUILD THAT CINEMA SINS SUB COUNT! BUILD THAT CINEMA SINS SUB COUNT! BUILD THAT CINEMA SINS SUB COUNT! BUILD THAT CINEMA SINS SUB COUNT! BUILD THAT CINEMA SINS SUB COUNT! BUILD THAT CINEMA SINS SUB COUNT! BUILD THAT CINEMA SINS SUB COUNT! BUILD THAT CINEMA SINS SUB COUNT! BUILD THAT CINEMA SINS SUB COUNT! BUILD THAT CINEMA SINS SUB COUNT! BUILD THAT CINEMA SINS SUB COUNT! BUILD THAT CINEMA SINS SUB COUNT! BUILD THAT CINEMA SINS SUB COUNT! BUILD THAT CINEMA SINS SUB COUNT! BUILD THAT CINEMA SINS SUB COUNT!
I like how moana's grandmother said "you've been told all of the villages story but one" how did moana not know that her father's best friend drowned and at the same time didn't know that her people were voyagers?
Maybe it's an incident that the father doesn't want to talk about, y'know.
Holy shit, this might be the first reupload to be #1 Trending
HUNGER GAMES Is nope pewds is treading
Dropped from #1 to #3 in four hours. Lol
ö
Ikr
HUNGER GAMES exactly
One sin for questioning mythology with science
Also, pretty sure the Earth was a giant water ball at one early point.
@@empressofvibes yes it was
People correcting other people cliché.
*ding*
@@kellieirvin4644 That's how it was while it was forming, yes. However, they're saying that at some point a little later down the line it was probably an ocean planet. Science does, in fact, support this.
*WEATHER ALERT*
The world is now an ocean.
I'm surprised he didn't remove a sin every time Moana was YEETED off the boat.
I loved that
Grandma Tala: There was only ocean
Subtitles: There was only oh sh*t
I became sad when no sins were taken off for the accuracy to polynesian mythologies ://
HONESTLY
@Swag Monke maybe because these videos are satire and he's not actually critiquing the movies?
@Swag Monke uh yes? this channel doesn't actually do legit reviews for movies. its a joke. besides, most of the time they sin movies they like. you can tell when he actually hates a movie.
@@Blu_Berry_Jam he will critique a building archetecture but not myths 😂
GNID
5:14 this is a drum. for the Maori
Maori, typo I guess
@@snoovian7951 i might be wrong, but isn't Moari and Maori two different words that exist?
I’m not actually sure, you’re probably right though that is a Maori drum as well.
@Cockjuggling Thundercunt It kindof does because this movie is about Moari's and that is a Moari drum so the sin is incorrect, because to Moana, that would be exactly what a drum looks like. So Granny didnt need to be specific for Moana like he says she should
@@filmeditstudios3182
This movie isn’t Maori, it’s a mix of Samoan, Fijian and Tahitian culture.
You would have known that if you watched the making of the film…
4:29 "Pigs hate water"
Tell that to those swimming pigs in the Bahamas.
Then again, if those pigs are exceptional and noteworthy enough to be famous like that, it only proves his point.
And those people in Florida.
Micah Philson lip
TYPE AN ARTIST BETTER THAN BOOM ⁉️ still waiting 😴💀💤
And also that one guy i saw at the water park.
Actually I believe that when he first saw the heart he did seem scared of the heart, his character’s eyes widened and stuff, but at the time he didn’t want anything to do with Moana and thought he could get rid of her. At first he only saw the glimpse of it too.
12:25 Its an actual back story. His backstory on his back. Story. HOW HAVE YOU MISSED THIS
Ryan Holt 😭😂😭😂😭
plz view and like: th-cam.com/video/Q6zW7G2lPS8/w-d-xo.html
Hahahhahahahah😭😭😫😭😭😭😫
Because it's an actually clever pun. Sin should be removed for it.
“It’s Ocean god...I think”
Me:” *OcEAn MAn TAkE mE bY thE HaNd* “
Lead me to the land.
Tony Little
_THAT YOU UNDERSTAND-_
@@phoenixsnilloc995 Oop
There is actully an ocean god in maori mythology, tangaroa
WeSt ViRGiniA!!!
When a re upload gets #1 on trending
SirGamesALot lol
yass
Fun fact: with sin 3 science is actually giving the finger cause it’s fact that early earth was covered with water(I’m not trying to sound like those douches who think they know how everything works)
well we don't know for sure. Also when it was covered entirely with water humans couldn't breath so there's that
I only know that it rained like hell, but I never thought about that there could have been a moment where there was ALL water. Thinking about that stuff makes me feel so small :o
Fun fact: according to current theory, even then, we still had the same amount of landmass that we do now, it was just a singular continent called Pangea.
I mean, in the Bible creation story, it's also said that the earth was all water before land
@@lucidfangirl1030 I mean, the bible also says that the all-powerful, all-knowing entity in the sky can't/won't deal with an evil entity that's actively killing/causing pain to the defenseless creatures it claims to love and protect and yet is still all-powerful and/or kind. So I wouldn't really say that the bible is the best source for information.
Moana: “I AM MOANA!!”
Me: “oh I’m sorry. I thought you were John.”
Who's John?
L05T_ 50U1 i was minted in the year 1985
Lol
Anonymous Anonymous WHAT?
No, this is Patrick
The world was just ocean at one point.
Man you need to watch some bill wurtz
LuckyDiamond Diamond great minds
LuckyDiamond Diamond he
lol
I thought the exact same thing as he said that😂👏
*the sun is a deadly laser*
0:23 44 billion years ago, the earth was almost completely covered in ocean, with a few islands.
+1 sin for CinemaSins
8:17 that is referring to (Polynesian?) mythology
+1 sin for CinemaSins
1: he said Completly covered in ocean so no sin there
2:Polynesian he must not like the mythology
no, there was actually time where there was only ocean, and nothing else
The earth is only 4.5 billion years old
He said all ocean. Not mostly ocean with just a few islands.
@@camacaroni_2284 yeah, which is why we all were fishes once.. until that fecking fish decided to get out of the water!! Goshdarnit
In terms of why the Crab was fooled (I can't think of his name right away), I think it's that the Kakamura detected the prescence of the heart rather than knew it's exact down to the second location. So the crab could be fooled by the algee since, for all he knew, that WAS the heart. Moana had the heart on her, so the algee would presumably be thought to be the Heart
Does he not realize that this movie is almost entirely drawn from Hawaiian mythology and the movie/ writers aren’t responsible at all for the illogical stuff.
Probably not. Also mytology is really something interesting!
Alot of it is maori aswell
I suppose you could still sin the myths for making no sense but then again a sensible myth is probably an oxymoron
James Dessent i feel like you still shouldn’t sin it bc it’s culture \:
To quote the Cinema Sins: "Cinema Sins.."
"Were American. (AMMMERICA, F*CK YEAH!) Which means we don't have any desire to learn about other people's cultures."
Your wife must love watching movies with you.
The bad part is I've been watching their videos for years and now my wife hates watching movies with me.... we have a rule now, first time seeing the movie I'm not allowed to, After that it's free game
Jobs TV go fuck yourself
He has a wife?
WIFe???
Jeremy is married?! o_0
can we add a sin or two for the movie suggesting that Moana's hair could go from soaking wet to dry as f*ck in a matter of seconds in some scenes ?
That's just movie physics. It happens all the time in movies & TV too. And clothes! insta-dry!
She is the sea god in polynesian culture. Her name means ocean.
Still a sin ^^
@@raptorjesus5870 Not the sea god. I mean I'm named after the ocean sooo
Sin guy decides to sin a geological fallacy despite the fact that not 10 seconds later this story adds in a goddess.
"Non-existent Fishhook Constellation" is actually Scorpio. A very bright and prominent Constellation here in Hawai'i, known as "Maui's Fishhook".
Michael Suzuki - - 111
I just learned about this too. It was very important to voyagers back then
Of course it also have a backstory to it. Maui actually lost his fishhook while he was using it for fishing but instead, he accidentally created an island. He told his brothers to pull up but dont to look back until one of his brothers disobeyed which led the rope breaks and flying up to the sky which then created a constellation. There's probably many stories of how Maui's fishhook become a constellation but to me this is the only version of the story that I'm very familiar with.
haha
@CogitoErgoCogitoSum the fishhook is the tail of Scorpio. Different cultures have different consolations.
Bad Influence Grandma was disappointed to later be reincarnated as the Wise Old Oak tree in Pocahontas.
HA
plz view and like:th-cam.com/video/Q6zW7G2lPS8/w-d-xo.html
@Burnetta McDonaldYou will understand....😅😅😅😅
no shes a seahorse in infinity war
9:38
Moana quite _literally_ yelled out loud that this was the current location of the heart. Fairly certain it doesn’t take a genius to figure out that it’s there when you have a -princess- daughter of the chief shout “COME AND GET IT!” after loudly talking about the heart.
Incredible..... a chiken make him take more sins that he ever took in his intire life
The last “a” in Moana in the thumbnail is covered by the time stamp so it just says
Everything wrong with MOAN in 10 minutes or less lmao
Who's Moan?
lmao nice
I was searching for that
moan sound like the low budget porn parody of moana XD
6:55 that is a real constellation
Fishermen
No fucking shit?
8:26 but the guts thing was in mythology it should be a sin off for being accurate
A lot of these should be a sin off for accuracy. Disney brought in a ton of people to make sure the mythology was accurate
@Just a Lil Artist hey did you know google is a thing
Just a Lil Artist ITS CINEMA SINS. WHY WOULD THE SINS NOT BE TRUE? G O P L E A S E.
So then, does eating coconut technically go against vegetarianism, since they originated from eel guts? Or does eel count as a vegetarian dish?
TidalShores It’s vegetarian but not vegan. Vegetarians still use animal products and things that were produced with the help of animal products, thy just won’t eat meat. Pescatarians are like vegetarians but they still eat fish and shellfish. Vegans don’t eat/use anything that came into contact with an animal (no leather chairs, no wool socks, no eggs, no honey, etc.)
I love how every time Alan Tudyk is involved, CinemaSins immediately chooses to remove a sin
Also Moana putting a shell on the stack so no future leaders could carry out this tradition
*Ding*
Simon Green i didn’t even think of that, thank you
They left that island, so there's no need to continue
@@TheGoldenDunsparce Doesn't mean that future generations might inhabit the island later.
@@KhanMann66 Would they have that same tradition though? Even if they did, they'd prob start a new stack, right? :P
@@TheGoldenDunsparce True
0:19 according to history of the entire world, I guess, “severe flooding alert, the entire world is now an ocean. Volcano alert, that’s land!”
Well, dont take that video as truth. Those are predictions, and I disagree with all of them
@@presidentialcampaignmusic1018 theory still isnt capable of being 100% accurate with no potential dispute like scientists and archaeoligists thought a plant fossil was an ancient lizard spine and that plant didnt date back nearly 4 billion years ago while he did probably mean theory the reason i am unwilling to touch any theories is scientists believe a flood happened on mars but not earth even though as of the current day mars has been frozen an insanely long time and most of earths water still exists
mars water sorry?
@@themagicalonionfairy7455 th-cam.com/video/xuCn8ux2gbs/w-d-xo.html
Pretty sure it's just a reference to a very popular youtube video
Something that always bugged me was Maui being rewarded for bringing back what he stole. If you steal a priceless gem from a museum and break your tools along the way I doubt you'll be refunded and thanked for returning the gem.
Gods and Goddesses are sometimes far more forgiving than normal people would be (though other times they can be far less forgiving, such as in Greek Mythology).
*insert British Museum joke*
8:52 it’s funny hearing cinemasins laugh
I know, I think his laugh is adorable
The origin of coconut trees is a real Polynesian myth. Disney was showing they did their research
It bugs me that he keeps calling the boats "bamboo rafts"
He was just as annoying in the coco thing >:(
...unlike CinemaSins, who can't be bothered with research... or facts.
It's a Samoan myth to be exact
rmsgrey
Cinema sins, sins like a picky movie goer, who the fuck researchs shit before watching a movie.
Cuz if he did research it he'd be a bigger asshole pointing out all the inaccuracies to the point people would still hate on.
*insert a ‘you’re welcome’ joke*
🎶'You look gay and you're welcome for telling you the truth..jjjjjk my boi you're welcome so stop crying like a fool.🎶
Ur welcome?
Vsauce Puppet I don't get it.
It's the song Dwayne Johnson sang when Moana met him, just google Dwayne Johnson - You're Welcome
A 'you're welcome' joke
My favorite part of any of these is always when he laughs genuinely at the jokes in the midst of this absolute onslaught of teardowns
10:30"i don't understand how an all-knowing ocean knows the concept of a high five" is the most contradictory sentence i've heard
ikr the sins on these videos are terrible
hey hey! @8:30 all those things he did in that song were based on actual myths from the pacific islands, bro. they did their homework
Yea but mowie or whatever didnt do all those things him self
Their were different gods for each of those th ings
true, and if the sin was for misrepresenting the legend, that's be fair, but he was just sinning the eel guts = coconut tree
He has a history of sinning culturally significant movie moments soley because he didn't do his homework
There should definitely be a sin off for the scene where Moana restores the heart to Te Ka and she becomes Te Fiti again. It's so beautiful it makes me cry just thinking about it.
Tomatoa: Did you like the song?
Jeremy: Not particularly.
Schaffrillas would like to know your location
"Pretty sure at no time in Earth's history was it ONLY ocean."
Ahem.... about 4 billion years ago.
How?
@@fathergascoigne6104 When the first drops of water came with the comets the earth was nothing but a big ball of rock and fire. It rained comets with little drops of water for several hunderd years. At one point there was so much water that no land was visible from space.
@@ombeod just cause you cant see something from space doesnt mean it doesnt exist
@@fathergascoigne6104 i recommend you watch a documentary about the creation of earth. Could be really helpful
@@ombeod because we could only see things from space 4 billion years ago
I watch this channel in place of actually watching the movies.
Meracore That’s really dumb
Meracore Not the greatest idea. Watch the movie yourself and make your own judgements. Cinemasins is often wrong about things.
And that's why they keep sueing Cinemasins
It’s free movies
That’s a really bad idea, Jeremy is often extremely disingenuous with his “sins“.
6:54 fun fact that is actually the constellation Scorpio
Cool! Thats my zodiac!
@@Marvelfanatic3658 stupid
Steven how
@@dalebarrow5014 if you believe that stuff you're stupid
Yep
shit that "what can I sayyy, it's exposition" really got me.
You should’ve added a sin for the ending.
Father is just like “oh yay my daughter came back after she abandoned my rules and the island, and I’m not even slightly pissed”
Why? Because.. Disney.
Well she also saved their island
An actual Polynesian parent would still be pissed😂😂
I thought he was okay with her leaving..
Ceara Bostick her dad didn’t want to her to leave at all, remember she left without him knowing
Donit mjh ch
Can we talk about how Fkin blue the water is? Really, it just looks like someone poured a gigantic bucket of off brand food coloring into the ocean
@RadioactiveRoses trueeeeee that
It's actually pretty normal you could find it in a simple Google click. But hey
It’s beautiful
I've been to the beach. The water is blue if there's enough of it!
@RadioactiveRoses yep, im also from a tropical island place and the water be lookin like blue kool-aid
I can’t believe he missed the fact that the people have been living there in a small village for 1000 years yet have developed several distinct accents... 🤷🏼♀️
Arent all of the voice actors (except the voice for the chicken) Polynesian though? That's got to be worth something. I honestly give them props for accurate representation. 🤷♀️
@@coolbeans6312 of the main cast from what I could find:
Dwayne Johnson is technically only half polynesian. He was born in california to a samoan kiwi mother and a black canadian man from NS, but lived his early life in kiwi-land before coming to the states.
Jemaine Clement who played the crab only has a mother who is maori but other than his blood connection he doesn't know much of culture or have any connections outside he's a kiwi as most of the cast.
Auli'i Carvalho who plays moana is chinese-hawaii'an and moana's mother is philipino-hawaii'an making an small lil connection funnily enough
Rachel House who played grandma is Maori-scotish making her the third kiwi alongside Dwayne and Jemaine.
Temuera Morrison who plays the chief is Maori as well making the cast nearly completely polynesian so you are indeed correct
He also missed the fact that genetic doesn't really enjoy when a small group breed together for 1000 years...
Or that it says that all of the world was just ocean except the one island with the stone- but there are many other islands that it later says was destroyed or something????
What's your point. This happens on England every few miles
The whole, “Maui killing an eel and burying it’s body” thing is a REAL Polynesian legend. If it wasn’t, why would Disney put such a stupid and random line in such a good and memorable song?
Chief: "I should have burned those antique boats a long time ago."
The chief would be really good at Cinema Sins
Anyone else love how Jeremy sins movies for narration and exposition but then also sins movies for not having enough context
MemesAreCancer it’s almost like the sins aren’t to be taken literally...
*movie opens up with text*
Cinema sins: "reading" *ding*
*movie opens up with narration*
Cinema sins: "narration" *ding*
Me: "which is it asshole?"
Jacobi Paulerson Then the channel shouldn't be taken seriously
*everything wrong with The Croods*
Surprisingly good movie
Forgot about it
That would be funny.
Everything lmao
I forgot that movie was even a thing.
"Everything Wrong With Moana"
Schaffrillas: nothing, it's perfect
*tamatoa intensifies*
The soundtrack for this movie is absolutely incredible
indeed it is
SnakeBake24
I have TWO Korean room mates and they DO smell like rancid garlic, they HAVE eaten dog before, and Kimchi smells like the very bowels of SATAN!
I guess we're just gonna ignore the fact that the crab guy ate his grandma.
Yep
Ye kefe
I myself have not seen Moana but I dont think it should have so many sins for the specific things you criticize. I mean it deserved most of them but you need to keep in mind that a lot of Moana is based on Māori culture and traditional stories. It kinda bothered me everytime you criticized things that were pulled right from the culture like Māui planting an eel and growing a tree. I dunno just my opinion
Moana is not based on Maori culture its base on polynesian culture, whose the ignorant one now.
@@joelcraig-sauer6637 The Maori people live in Polynesia
Faeron Dewart Thank you, I support your guys view. Being Hawaiian I am a little insulted making jokes not only to my ancestors but the fellow ancestors of the other Polynesians people
CinemaSins isn't meant to be taken seriously. In their own words, they're assholes.
Faeron Dewart Maori are the Polynesian people of Aotearoa sure. Your comments not far off but this mythology isn’t Maori mythology it’s sort of proto-Maori. Just imagine the sequel to this movie being Moana and friends discovering Aotearoa (New Zealand) then over time the Polynesian mythology transforms in to what the Maori myths are.
I usually love your videos but some of these “sins” were you disregarding actual Polynesian culture and mythology as Disney doing too much fantasy which comes off as lazy and not researched
Okay, then just transfer the sins to the Polynesian culture and mythology. Even if it was originally Polynesian mythology, that doesn't remove the logical problems with the story in some instances.
What can I say except *_NO MOVIE IS WITHOUT SIN_*
0 p , v
Star Wars the clone wars is without sin
What can I say except *SHREK 2 HAS NO SIN*
Pornhub thou 😏
not black panther ask anyone..
"What can I say, it's exposition!" Had me *dead* 😂
I get the feeling that he didn’t talk about shiny because he’d have to remove 50 sins for its absolute craziness.
(Or, you know... copyright)
I liked it
Shiny is an amazing song so I thought he woulda taken some sins off
“I ATE my grandma”
This video just reveals how little the writers of CinemaSins know about astronomy, history, and Polynesian mythology and culture
He called a musical scene of a man flambeing food in Princess and the Frog, "arson". So really, they don't know much about anything.
0:20 it actually was 100% ocean at one point though. Land was later formed by underwater volcanoes
The underwater volcanoes were made of rock - so not 100% water
Kevin The Bold where did he say it's 100% water? He said 100% ocean, not 100% water
Unless you count lava oceans, then Im 99% sure this is BS.
@Kevin The Bold That's not what he meant and you know it.
wildmadafaka Ocean = water
You should've added person that everyone thinks is crazy is actually right cliche
At least the actress pronounced canoe properly for her regionally dialect
I always find it funny how his Disney movies are always bangers😭
Not anymore.....
I feel like this video should just be called Everything Wrong with CinemaSins Comprehension of Polynesian Culture, Mythology and the Concept of Fantasy in General.
I feel like maybe this comment should be called Everything Wrong With OP’s Ability to Understand What a Joke Is
@@backchanneling eat shit bitch, nothing funny about lazy content
Literally dude, literally
@@wealljammin eating shit is not good for your health, ergo what you just said is "eat shit so you can get incredibly sick" and lazy content is the funniest thing in the fucking universe, dont tell me you didnt laugh at The Hangover.
@@tey_zah r u calling a major motion picture with a huge budget lazy content??? do u think they just slapped a wolf tshirt on zach galifianakis n started filming?? yr comment makes no sense, rethink n try again later
Where is everything wrong with avengers infinity war? Pls make one soon. I'm begging.
There’s nothing wrong with it.
Ethan Smith Infinity War was over rated. I’m not even kidding, the only things I remember from it were “You should have aimed for the head.” and “Mr. Stark, I don’t feel so good.” It was so forgettable and boring.
Dino blu ...
Dino blu are you sure you were actually paying attention? I remember a lot from infinity war, and I’m not even into marvel that much.
H3its I saw it twice in theaters. Once by myself and again with a friend. I also watched it at my cousin’s house once.
*Takes Polynesian LEGEND*
*tries to use science against it*
And gets some of it wrong anyway
@@equalssign44 exactly
@Just a Lil Artist if this guy is trying to be funny, he fails. Even if he was being sarcastic, sinning a movie for having mythology that "isn't scientifically correct" is stupid. It's even more stupid because of the fact that the world was a big ocean at one point. Just had to get that off my chest. Carry on.
Oddball Kitten does it even matter? he’s said that the sins hold no value and should be taken **very** lightly like iron man 2 got more sins than The Wall so calm down about this video on an ONLINE PLATFORM bud
@@djskellex5608 why don't you calm down? It's just a video on an online platform.
1:12 each time she does this she needs to replace the cloth.