The assassins creed set didn't have traditional "commons," as it was just uncommon, rare and mythic due to being a new type of booster "beyond boosters," basically the same as epilogue boosters which also didn't have commons.
@@minervadetauro7646 That card screams "We had this designed, could never fit it into a set, we need more cards for this set, let's throw it in here because it vaguely fits".
yeah but people felt bad at being "specifically hated", which means "that color in particular receives a laser-focused hate", for ... some reasons so they gradually removed it it's a pity, I too wish to have more emphasis on this old, forgotten side of Magic
Keep in mind that back when the game was new and "Protection from [color]" was reasonably common, a time when color changing actually had a clear (non-broken) purpose and was relatively common, most of the color changing cards only let you change cards into colors *you already had* . Best case scenario, you're a multi-color deck with key combat creatures in one color, but more likely useless. Except for Black being immune to certain Black removal, I can't think of another card from early sets that both interacts with the color of something already on the board and isn't terrible.
@@jonothanthrace1530 Over the years, the aspect of the game that relied on “ally” and “enemy” colors pairings have become basically nonexistent. This aspect of the game started waning in the early 00’s.
Glad to see the Three Kingdoms cards got grouped together. These seem to go from a top 10 to a top 7 with whatever 1-3 Three Kingdoms cards happened to be printed topping the list. I'd almost prefer a disclaimer before the video acknowledging them with pricing and then moving forward with the remaining top 10. Awesome video as always.
i also like worldly tutor. i got a spike feeder combo deck where around turn 5 or so or sooner maybe, i gain infinite life and have infinitely large spike feeder on the board. 4 birds of paradise, then the rest of the deck is 50 50, 50 percent spike feeder and creature tutors, and the other 50 percent is the cards that combo with spike feeder to gain infinite life and make infinitely large spike feeder.
As a person happy to see standard alive at my locals for the first time in over half a decade, my boros mice deck is brutally strong, and its in no small part to Sheltered by Ghosts.
Honestly, I would have expected some more expensive cards to top the list. But hey, I won't complain. Enlightened Tutor is a damn staple, good thing it's not a $500 card. Unfortunately, I have no doubt that most if not all of the cards on "Top 10 Vintage Cards (Minus Power 9)" will be $100+. Or maybe not. Only one way to find out!
Dust to Dust suffers in commander because white has no problem taking care of those things, even repeatedly for much less money and often on synergistic permanents that help your strategy in other ways. It being old also makes it so a lot of people just haven't heard of it, seen it in action or had any thought of it. If it's not EDH Rec-ommended, it's not going to make a lot of decks. Lol
How about making the videos Top 20, and split in 2 parts? It's more content for us, there are more cards to show, and you get in theory, double ads revenue.
Yeah watch out for prices on things like card kingdom; they game their algorithms. I once did a search for a Forest from all the early sets to test my jewel loupe on, and didn't even buy any. Just the act of looking at them caused their algorithm to raise prices, and in the next few days the youtubers who watch card pricing were reporting that the price of Forest was on the rise. ROFL True story.
I'm from germany and i really like your videos, but jesus these Card Kingdom prices arent for real! Im getting like the first card the "Templar Knight" for 0,05 Cents in Europe 😅in NM in english language! I guess you know the other website.
I have no idea where you are getting the knight that cheap. Less than in the video, sure. But 5 cents? I wonder if Commander is less popular in Europe.
Enlightened tutor feels like it won on a technicality. Its been printed as a rare, in premium sets only, after 1999, after going 15 years without even being printed. The price reflects that decision as if it was an uncommon in dom remaster or eternal masters, it wouldnt stand a chance over $10. Case of rhystic study type cards. Its price reflects moderm day rarity price. High demand common/uncommon from 90s sets might as well be considered rares now a days.
I don't feel like having a high price tag because it is scarce given the incredibly high demand is a "technicality." These are the exact reasons that all cards have the prices they do.
@NizzahonMagic your criteria is based on the lowest cost version obtainable. The lowest cost version obtainable of enlightened tutor is high because it's been reprinted as a rare since. If it was reprinted as a uncommon, consistently, it wouldnt be #1. Thats not objective, it's just true when you uplift a rarity in the way ET has been. Its price reflects rarity track printing, largely. Not uncommon, since it HAS been reprinted as rare. Im not even being closed to convinced that's not a technicality. Criteria should also be not being reprinted as rare lol. It's no longer uncommon throughout.
@@NizzahonMagic in business terms it's reprinted at rare to maintain the reprinted equity of the price it's reached. They reprinted it at rare, among others, specifically to maintain the price because it wouldnt maintain the equity as a uncommon track printing in modern reprints. So that completely spoils the concept of "ideally the cheapest version" available. They seen an old uncommon reach rare price and choose not to ruin that.n it's artificially holding that price at the mercy of wizards up shifting rarity. Its hardly "uncommon" pricing.
@ Ah, I get your point now. Your'e saying I shouldn't have included cards that haven't been Uncommon in every printing. Yeah, that's a reasonable enough argument. I still think it's fine to include cards that were originally printed at Uncommon and reprinted at higher rarities, but I can see where you're coming from.
It doesn't happen very often in my "most expensive" videos, usually there are just other cards that are more expensive. The only exception to this is usually cards that are seeing play in a zillion formats and ar mythic rare (like Sheoldred or Atraxa). So, I'm surprised based on experience.
what are these prices ? is cardkingdom so expensive ??? i dont know it as i am european and i use cardmarket but damn thats like so much more then i am used to the cheapest land tax is 8,50 € and the average is 13€ ... sheltered by ghost is cheapest 2,90 € with avergage 4,29 € (cheapest MINT 10/10 quality is 3€) card kingdom having double the prices is crazy
@MrDeeluv1996 uncommon Overview Similar words From Oxford Languages adjective unusual abnormal rare atypical uncustomary unconventional unexpected unfamiliar strange odd curious out of the ordinary extraordinary out of the way outlandish offbeat irregular novel singular peculiar weird oddball way out freaky something else off the wall scarce few and far between thin on the ground exceptional isolated occasional infrequent sporadic out of the common seldom
Putting a "deck can contain any number of" card at uncommon just feels needlessly greedy
The assassins creed set didn't have traditional "commons," as it was just uncommon, rare and mythic due to being a new type of booster "beyond boosters," basically the same as epilogue boosters which also didn't have commons.
luckily Hasbro hasn't already forced WotC of putting that line of text in Rare/mythics
.... yet
In a beyond set too, its idiotic.
Also worth noting those packs only had SEVEN CARDS like wtf 😂
@marcoottina654 yeah I gave up on magic. I feel like wotc hates it's player base.
Minor note: Painter's Servant doesn't give all cards all colors; it gives all cards the chosen color.
Just a quick note: Universes Beyond Assassin's Creed is Modern legal (... I know lmao)
I think a couple of people play Basim Ibn Ishaq]
@@bat9056also yggdrasil, rebirth engine sees modern play
At least it is not sponge bob universe... yet...
Some people play Tax Collector in Humans
@@minervadetauro7646 That card screams "We had this designed, could never fit it into a set, we need more cards for this set, let's throw it in here because it vaguely fits".
Uncommon is the third lowest rarity behind Common and Aftermath Rarity.
Aftermath is the highest rarity in the game.
A slight correction: I believe that land tax was banned in premodern a year or so ago.
Land Tax was banned in Premodern a few months ago x3
Old School is the price driver for the Legends version now.
I've always felt like color changing should've been a bigger deal in the game than it is.
yeah but people felt bad at being "specifically hated", which means "that color in particular receives a laser-focused hate", for ... some reasons
so they gradually removed it
it's a pity, I too wish to have more emphasis on this old, forgotten side of Magic
It used to be
Keep in mind that back when the game was new and "Protection from [color]" was reasonably common, a time when color changing actually had a clear (non-broken) purpose and was relatively common, most of the color changing cards only let you change cards into colors *you already had* . Best case scenario, you're a multi-color deck with key combat creatures in one color, but more likely useless. Except for Black being immune to certain Black removal, I can't think of another card from early sets that both interacts with the color of something already on the board and isn't terrible.
@@jonothanthrace1530 Over the years, the aspect of the game that relied on “ally” and “enemy” colors pairings have become basically nonexistent. This aspect of the game started waning in the early 00’s.
Glad to see the Three Kingdoms cards got grouped together. These seem to go from a top 10 to a top 7 with whatever 1-3 Three Kingdoms cards happened to be printed topping the list. I'd almost prefer a disclaimer before the video acknowledging them with pricing and then moving forward with the remaining top 10. Awesome video as always.
He does this for every set, and often alpha. This was just one of the few times Alpha/Arabian Knights didn't dominate a list like this.
Enlightened Tutor costs less than $20 on sites you’re not sponsored by
Mother of runes is so good. I won a commander game by protecting my Herald of Eternal Dawn and going down to -41 life.
I love my mother of runes. I have old cards, so keeping that around since the old days is a treat 😂
Premodern mentioned
Enlightened Tutor looks to me like it'd be pretty nice in an Amanitou commander deck
It'd good in any White deck because it fetches Smothering Tithe
Funnily enough i never see land tax anymore... like at all even in mono white decks
White has good card draw now. No need to load up on lands every turn.
Which cards?
i also like worldly tutor. i got a spike feeder combo deck where around turn 5 or so or sooner maybe, i gain infinite life and have infinitely large spike feeder on the board. 4 birds of paradise, then the rest of the deck is 50 50, 50 percent spike feeder and creature tutors, and the other 50 percent is the cards that combo with spike feeder to gain infinite life and make infinitely large spike feeder.
Love lists like this. Didn't realize the three Starnheim Aspirants I have are kind of beefy.
Ive never understood why they print uncommon cards that are only available in a commander decks. Its as rare as any rare printed for that deck.
I agree, but I think it something like shorthand for telling a player (especially a new player) the general power level of a card
As a person happy to see standard alive at my locals for the first time in over half a decade, my boros mice deck is brutally strong, and its in no small part to Sheltered by Ghosts.
land tax and fastbond in a kudo deck feels so cheesy but nice. use that ayrula card to discard spare lands for free bears and take right off.
Should the Warhammer card really count as an Uncommon if players were never able to pull it out of a booster pack?
AC set is legal on Modern.
Honestly, I would have expected some more expensive cards to top the list. But hey, I won't complain. Enlightened Tutor is a damn staple, good thing it's not a $500 card. Unfortunately, I have no doubt that most if not all of the cards on "Top 10 Vintage Cards (Minus Power 9)" will be $100+. Or maybe not. Only one way to find out!
Please do top 10 Basic Lands.
What do you hope to accomplish by making this pointless comment on every video?
@@JasonOshinko I answered you already or is reading as hard as critical thinking for you?
Edit: He has asked me this before in another video.
Dust to Dust suffers in commander because white has no problem taking care of those things, even repeatedly for much less money and often on synergistic permanents that help your strategy in other ways. It being old also makes it so a lot of people just haven't heard of it, seen it in action or had any thought of it. If it's not EDH Rec-ommended, it's not going to make a lot of decks. Lol
and when you shelter by ghost their sheltered by ghost it gets wild !! I love putting 2 x shelterd by ghost on the same creature : ward 4 !!!
You mean, "10 Secret Lair Reprint Cards Used To Inflate Value"
force of will? Top?
lol, thought it was just uncommons
Would a top 10 mana values be too wild of an idea?
White Painter is a very very narrow subsect of Painter decks in legacy
note that these are based on the inflated card kingdom prices
Isnt empty city ruse just a worse fog?
No.
Keeping creatures from attacking at all is a pretty big difference from preventing damage.
I mean i guess there are some creatures that get valu3 just for attacking (prime time ect)
@@natenathan2654 Yep, turns off "beginning of combat" triggers too.
Remember when Fatal Push was expensive?
Pretty good cards all around. And those whack Portal 3 that always have stupid value.
How about making the videos Top 20, and split in 2 parts? It's more content for us, there are more cards to show, and you get in theory, double ads revenue.
Why isn’t Wasteland in this video?
It's not White
If I play casually, I just proxy everything.
Boooo
@@kkelsey8811 Magic is too expensive, bro.
Yeah watch out for prices on things like card kingdom; they game their algorithms. I once did a search for a Forest from all the early sets to test my jewel loupe on, and didn't even buy any. Just the act of looking at them caused their algorithm to raise prices, and in the next few days the youtubers who watch card pricing were reporting that the price of Forest was on the rise. ROFL True story.
Love me some cardkingdom
Land tax is banned in premodern now
I'm from germany and i really like your videos, but jesus these Card Kingdom prices arent for real! Im getting like the first card the "Templar Knight" for 0,05 Cents in Europe 😅in NM in english language! I guess you know the other website.
I have no idea where you are getting the knight that cheap. Less than in the video, sure. But 5 cents?
I wonder if Commander is less popular in Europe.
@@NizzahonMagic no not less popular! On cardmarket its like eBay but kinda better for buying cards 😶🌫.
Enlightened tutor feels like it won on a technicality. Its been printed as a rare, in premium sets only, after 1999, after going 15 years without even being printed. The price reflects that decision as if it was an uncommon in dom remaster or eternal masters, it wouldnt stand a chance over $10.
Case of rhystic study type cards. Its price reflects moderm day rarity price. High demand common/uncommon from 90s sets might as well be considered rares now a days.
I don't feel like having a high price tag because it is scarce given the incredibly high demand is a "technicality." These are the exact reasons that all cards have the prices they do.
@NizzahonMagic your criteria is based on the lowest cost version obtainable. The lowest cost version obtainable of enlightened tutor is high because it's been reprinted as a rare since. If it was reprinted as a uncommon, consistently, it wouldnt be #1. Thats not objective, it's just true when you uplift a rarity in the way ET has been. Its price reflects rarity track printing, largely. Not uncommon, since it HAS been reprinted as rare.
Im not even being closed to convinced that's not a technicality. Criteria should also be not being reprinted as rare lol. It's no longer uncommon throughout.
@@NizzahonMagic in business terms it's reprinted at rare to maintain the reprinted equity of the price it's reached. They reprinted it at rare, among others, specifically to maintain the price because it wouldnt maintain the equity as a uncommon track printing in modern reprints. So that completely spoils the concept of "ideally the cheapest version" available. They seen an old uncommon reach rare price and choose not to ruin that.n it's artificially holding that price at the mercy of wizards up shifting rarity. Its hardly "uncommon" pricing.
@NizzahonMagic still love the channel, just calling shenanigans on this one. First one I've called out in like 700+ so you're fine
@ Ah, I get your point now. Your'e saying I shouldn't have included cards that haven't been Uncommon in every printing.
Yeah, that's a reasonable enough argument.
I still think it's fine to include cards that were originally printed at Uncommon and reprinted at higher rarities, but I can see where you're coming from.
I'm not nearly as surprised as you that a standard card made the list. That's simply the economy of standard.
It doesn't happen very often in my "most expensive" videos, usually there are just other cards that are more expensive. The only exception to this is usually cards that are seeing play in a zillion formats and ar mythic rare (like Sheoldred or Atraxa). So, I'm surprised based on experience.
Swords to Plowshares and Path to Exile came close to making this list.
White removal can make lists of Uncommons more easily than other colors.
Man, I love TRIBAL decks 👀
Land tax banned in pm. But was good before it was
Templar knight is okay but crusade is banned lol
true
what are these prices ? is cardkingdom so expensive ??? i dont know it as i am european and i use cardmarket but damn thats like so much more then i am used to
the cheapest land tax is 8,50 € and the average is 13€ ...
sheltered by ghost is cheapest 2,90 € with avergage 4,29 € (cheapest MINT 10/10 quality is 3€)
card kingdom having double the prices is crazy
TCGPlayer has cheaper Enlightened Tutor and Land Tax in USD too.
Cardkingdom is just wrong.
Let's go
H
This just sounds like basic economics? If something is uncommon (ie rare) it's going to be more expensive than something that's common (ie plentiful).
The rarities are Mythic, rare, uncommon, common.
@@RibusPQR rare and uncommon are synonyms...
@@GigaBoostthey aren’t synonymous tho….. a simple internet search could’ve helped you
@MrDeeluv1996 uncommon
Overview
Similar words
From Oxford Languages
adjective
unusual
abnormal
rare
atypical
uncustomary
unconventional
unexpected
unfamiliar
strange
odd
curious
out of the ordinary
extraordinary
out of the way
outlandish
offbeat
irregular
novel
singular
peculiar
weird
oddball
way out
freaky
something else
off the wall
scarce
few and far between
thin on the ground
exceptional
isolated
occasional
infrequent
sporadic
out of the common
seldom
Rare and Uncommon are definitely synonyms in most ways. But...not in Magic. They are two very different things.