No it's not. Humanity shouldn't tolerate a terrorist organization that kidnaps babies, beheads innocent left wing people and rapes young girls. Learn some history and facts.
I suspect a large number of zionists are not survivors of parents who were holocaust survivors. They just use the holocaust as a twisted way to justify what they do.
It is amazing how the Palestinian tragedy has introduced me to too many great people and intellectuals like Gabor mate, LowKey and Norman Finkelstein, but also unveiled the mask of certain hypocrites, such as the western media. Thanks to you Piers, despite your double standards, for giving these people a platform.
When Isreal wasnt attacked ??? What are Semitic check the dictionary and history yourself its not Isreal first. Fact chcek WWII started in Poland Gdańsk Westerplatte 1 september 1939. Germany attacked Poland to clime Gdańsk as thier own at the time population registery Polish people was 34 millions. When war end 1945 Polish population was shrink to 21 millions!!! We have lost 13 millions at witch 6 milions International Jewis communities prescribe to themselves!!! When 2010 Isreal created state in Palestina had 5 milions 70 years after the war. Poland suffer attack by Germany follow by Ukraine mascara Polish millions on today Ukraine follow by Russia invasion and stay for decades. Poland was distroy by the same forces previously and participation after the Greate Kingdom of Poland Litvenia. Jewish Nation has no countries they take stool the suffer of Poland and made Poland in Isreal guilty for WWII. THEY ARE CHOSEN NATION DOUBLE STANDARDS TWO TRIANGLE IN THE FLAG. Its GOD allmighy tell us Masonic Pupets Masters use those parasites triving on pray in the flag they say to us who they are watch out. Nation without its own land what does it tell us really is it bleesing or curst ???
Agreed! And it is the least I saw Pierse interrupting someone he is interviewing. Apart from Douglas Murray right after the Finkelstein interview where Murray called Finkelstein a psychopath and Holocaust denier, Piers was quiet the whole time of Murray’s monologue but that is because he agrees with him. I wish he let the other guests he doesn’t agree with speak more, but I guess it is great he gives them the platform at least.
When Isreal wasnt attacked ??? What are Semitic check the dictionary and history yourself its not Isreal first. Fact chcek WWII started in Poland Gdańsk Westerplatte 1 september 1939. Germany attacked Poland to clime Gdańsk as thier own at the time population registery Polish people was 34 millions. When war end 1945 Polish population was shrink to 21 millions!!! We have lost 13 millions at witch 6 milions International Jewis communities prescribe to themselves!!! When 2010 Isreal created state in Palestina had 5 milions 70 years after the war. Poland suffer attack by Germany follow by Ukraine mascara Polish millions on today Ukraine follow by Russia invasion and stay for decades. Poland was distroy by the same forces previously and participation after the Greate Kingdom of Poland Litvenia. Jewish Nation has no countries they take stool the suffer of Poland and made Poland in Isreal guilty for WWII. THEY ARE CHOSEN NATION DOUBLE STANDARDS TWO TRIANGLE IN THE FLAG. Its GOD allmighy tell us Masonic Pupets Masters use those parasites triving on pray in the flag they say to us who they are watch out. Nation without its own land what does it tell us really is it bleesing or curst ???
Years ago, I discovered Dr. Gabor Matè’s book “Scattered”. I read it and became addicted to his work. He is absolutely brilliant. For years, I was afraid to look into his views on Palestinian rights. I was afraid that his view of Palestinians would crush me. I admired him and his work so very much..I am Palestinian. One day, I listened to an excellent talk that he gave to a group of teachers and school social workers. In the Q&A, someone asked him about Palestinian children and trauma. I felt a rush of adrenaline hearing this question. I inadvertently held my breath. Then he began to answer the question and I sobbed. I sobbed with my heart and soul. It was in that moment that I fully realized that Dr. Matè was more than just a brilliant doctor. He is an extraordinary empath. He is a man who views the world through the brilliant lens that he created through his work. I felt silly for avoiding looking into his views on the subject. He is Dr. Gabor Matè. Of course, he would understand the experience and traumas of Palestinian children. Thank you Dr. Matè. You are a living legend.
We , Jews and Palestinians, must find a middle ground compromise that future generations do not grow up with trauma. We also must acknowledge all the atrocities we committed against each other
I absolutely understand what u felt, ur post is riveting actually, u put so much in such a short text. In one message I feel very close to you. Anyway, thanks your for this bridging comment
Dr. Gabor Mate 's words " you have to go and see it for yourself. Then you would cry every day for two weeks." He is really an educated person. My respects ......
I doubt most white conservatives would cry. Heck even someone like Biden or Hillary might giggle a little. They only pay lip service to the legacy of the holocaust.
Piers has a way of asking inflammatory questions to incite defensive responses, but dr Mate addresses then in such a calm and rational manner that really elevates the integrity of the conversation. A true masterclass
Piers has only 1 good thing about him (also, not so good for him at the same time) that he brings people that are so smart, educated and miles ahead than him by humanity's perspective and then he opens his mouth and it's like he didn't hear anything nor that he cares about what has been said...
As a Muslim, watching every single interview for Piers on the subject.. this is the only one that burst me into tears! watching a kind-hearted jewish honest old man truly understand the main problem and facing all the heavy propaganda with such minimum logic simple wording! I really loved him from the bottom of my heart! I wish I had a grandfather like him.. I wish I grow old to be a kind grandfather like him.
People like you are the core of the problem because you always identify with the religion first and then with humanity. If people like you did not exist, if not identify with Islam first, and identified with being human first most of the problems today would go away. The problem is Muslim only stand with Muslim and not with other people when Muslims are the aggressors.
First interview I have seen Piers NOT interrupting and listening. And MASSIVE RESPECT for Gabor Mate for speaking words of wisdom and truth with such beautiful humanity! Peace for our planet! 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
*Whether you agree with him or not, Gabor's calm and collected way of presenting his point of view is an art that is quickly being forgotten in our modern age.*
A kind man not afraid to say the truth no matter how uncomfortable. 2005's most traumatized kids from Gaza are now young men fighting for their lives and freedom. Thank you Dr Mate
I.D.F is the terrorista group which started it all in 1948. And A Fact → H-M-S wasn't born then. The childrens whose parents where Massacréd by 🇮🇱 joined and took the oath for Vengeance !
Tsahal est le groupe terroriste qui a tout déclenché en 1948. Et un fait → Le Hamas n'était pas né à cette époque. Les enfants dont les parents ont été massacrés par 🇮🇱 se sont joints et ont prêté serment de vengeance
I’d like to see Ben Shapiro actually have a conversation with someone as intelligent and eloquent as Gabor Mate instead of ‘debating’ 20 year old students
Never have I seen a person mellow, with such efficiency and calm, the wandering soul of a chronically combative interrogator. This is a lesson on humanity and sympathetic communication, not just for Piers, but for the whole world.
This man is an example for people to take a step back and look at the overall picture before making a judgement through ignorance or through a cultural, political or religious bias.
hey im from israel. and i do also ant breath about whats happening to gaza children. but for every ongoing conflict there are 2 stupid sides. i really dont want to proove something. just remember that we here in israel also just humen beings that dont want to be burn alive. we live here in terror, we really afaid from hamas. and the only thing that enable him to do that is by hiding behind his children and shooting at me and my friends. i dont know whats the solution here
13:22 Amazing how it’s understandable except for when it applies to African Descendants of Slaves ! Palestine 80 years Blacks ::: 200 years plus ! But blacks are told to pull up their boot straps … while Zionists get 20 billion dollars a year from these same blacks ! Imagine Black taxpayers money going to Zionists to kill and forcefully sterilize other black people and Palestinians !
Piers Morgan works on Rupert Murdoch's TV shows, which funds the Jerusalem Foundation, which builds illegal Israeli settlements, which is why he frequently questions in support of the Israeli occupation. Israel controls the Western media
Ex Israeli Prime Minister and Minister of Defense Ehud Barak went on CNN and said the Tunnel below Al-Shifa Hospital was built by the Israelis 4 decades ago and the Israelis also have similar tunnels under their hospitals. Wake up people.
He actually said MY truth....I'd doesn't make it a truth if you claim it to be ... this guy has no basic knowledge on Israel Palestine conflict or history
@@grandekristianactually that's the whole truth. But again people like you wouldn't believe it even if you went back in time and watched it infront of your own eyes. It's alright we understand
I have two feelings after this interview - first, is admiration for Gabor and his ability to explain the feelings and humanity behind a complex situation that most are ill educated about - second - my embarrassment and shame as a UK citizen for Piers to mumble about October the 7th after Gabor has explained that the backstory of Palestine needs to be understood and taken into account to truly understand the situation.
@@omarzaitoun4270he only asks that racist loaded question to brown people. As an imperialist he assumes we are all OK with the killing of civilians. He also clearly values white coloniser lives more than indigenous Palestinian lives. Keeps going on about Oct 7th. How many hundreds of Oct 7ths did the zionist entity inflict on the Palestinians before then. And how many times more after then?
So you are occupying the land of Australia. When are you vacating and move back to the land of your forefathers? Why only land, why not Revert to the religion of your forefathers?
What an outstanding interview. This man should come on for longer. Such sincerity from every word he said. These are the guys whose voices should be highlighted to the world. Such honesty is commendable. Loved this.
How precisely he explained it…he is the only one that actually made Piers speechless otherwise this man will always be stuck on October 7 and talking about Israel defending itself A very great answer given by Gabor, “Israel has a right to defend itself against whom? People who are being massacred since 80 years?”
Agree, Piers always gets stuck on 7 0ktober with the same question, do you condemn Hamas? he couldn't accept the reality of the root of the problem. it was 80 years of suffering
@@yersifefebrina6068 Actually it is an important question to ask. The war caused an extreme level of propaganda, reaching many people who - as Máté explained - have limited knowledge. Hence even the most rational, knowledgeable and compassionate like Mate are constantly attacked by extreme accusations. On social media and on edited platforms too. Asking this questions is a way to rule out these accusations very early, so the person watching the screen get a "Hey, this guy is okay, he won't verify any inhumane actions, he is okay" message. It is bad that we need it but we need it. That's how war works.
Very correct argument for Mr. P Morgan, because he is sailing out on the ocean much of the time. But even though this jewsh man, who is a living history himself as survival of the holocaust, is telling him the historical context behind the real true of Palastine conflict Mr P Morgan still doesn't seem to understand what the hell the this whole conflict is about and then he goes and miss judging the situation, which is nothing less than lacking of historical knowledge.
Piers Morgan works on Rupert Murdoch's TV shows, which funds the Jerusalem Foundation, which builds illegal Israeli settlements, which is why he frequently questions in support of the Israeli occupation. Israel controls the Western media
Ex Israeli Prime Minister and Minister of Defense Ehud Barak went on CNN and said the Tunnel below Al-Shifa Hospital was built by the Israelis 4 decades ago and the Israelis also have similar tunnels under their hospitals. Wake up people.
Jesus christ, finally pierce let's a person TALK. THANK YOU! THANK YOU FOR NOT INTERRUPTING HIM EVERY 2 SECONDS. Finally someone says everything we have been screaming these past few weeks
To be fair, Piers in no way ALWAYS interrupts a guest. Usually when he has a lot of respect for a guest, he lets them speak in full. His job takes patience and skill. Great interview!!!!
Piers doesn’t sincerely mean what he says about the plight of the Palestinians, otherwise he wouldn’t have been so fixated on Oct the 7th alone. But I do have to give him credit for allowing people like Dr. Mate to speak on his platform. This almost never happens in the US mainstream media.
He normally talks over people . Dominates them and shouts at them . Pushing his own vile beliefs . Gabor is an intelligent and gentle soul . I bet piers was pre warned not to be a c…t.
Simply put, Israel occupies a country that was independent. You claim standardization while you trample the United Nations Charter and classify terrorism according to agenda and ideology. The correct question is: Do you condemn Israel? Hamas acted in response to the rape, encroachment on Palestinian lands, and killing of children seventy years ago. From 47 to now
I feel at peace knowing there are people like Dr Gabor Mate out there in the world, unfailingly committing to humanity, to kindness, to truth and to justice.
The problem is with Muslim people because they always put religion before humanity Muslims never stand up against other Muslims when the aggressor is Muslim.
The Palestinian Muslims engaged in routine terrorism against Jews beginning around 1917, long before they became 1948 refugees, in a time when they had superior numbers and local political power. The most notorious acts include the 1920 Nebi Musa riot, 1921 Jaffa riot, 1929 Palestinian riot, 1935 Cement Incident, 1947 Aden riote, and 1930's Arab Revolts. Murdering, raping, beatings, and property destruction. What history does he think needs to be known?
This was a beautiful interview. Please bring him again! He healed a part of me that has been utterly hopeless after I started a deep research about the Palestinian issue. It was so horrifying, it made me nauseous.
When Dr Gabor spoke about Isreali’s being unaware of the history and what is actually going on in Palestine 🇵🇸. Gideon Levy said in a 2005 interview ‘Israeli society is too brainwashed and life is too good. Israel lives in denial totally disconnected from reality.’ It would be great if Piers gets Gideon Levy on the show.
Sarah, sorry to hear how difficult seeing this has been for you. If you are wondering how Palestinians are able to cope, it Islam. I invite you to read the Quran and learn more.
I started reading The Ethnic Cleansing of Palestine by Ilan Pappe', a Jewish historian. I got to the fifth page and burst into tears because I already knew the history of Palestine. I am going to read it but now one year later I am seeing these wonderful people being completely wiped out and it breaks my heart because no one is doing anything about it.
Im from Vancouver and this man is a true treasure. Hes done so much for the city and the lower downtown eastside. We need more of his kind in this world.
This is a perfect display of how to truly approach an interview. Shoutout to Gabor Mate for his calmness, elegance, and poise while speaking on such delicate topics as such.
I guess you missed the questions he didn't answer just moved to whatever he wanted to talk about. it is manipulative and dissapointing, to be honest. @@TjaTjaTja80177
Gabor is one of the most patient, articulate, knowledgeable and compassionate people I've ever come across. He's a great man and a real positive force in the world. Today, the online space is unfortunately full of toxic influences whom people are looking to for guidance. More people should know about Mate.
No he is not. I bought his books and studied. He is another fake ideologist who likes his high moral ground. And a closet Socialist. It is people like him who have created the division in our universities.
Such a sincere human. We need more people like him. People who are able to articulate calmly, without any fear of retaliation in such a sensitive subject. Truth is always noble ❤️
A wise man. acknowledging each side of an issue, the flawed nature of humanity and also that it is possible to build bridges towards a more loving and understanding relationship between opposing parties, whether within families or on the macro level between ethnic groups or nations. Humanity desperately needs to move beyond the 'war as a solution' principle.
If more people like Dr. Matè were in power the world wouldn’t be in the horrible state that it’s in 😔. He is the type of person that should be leading the world.
I’ve followed Dr. Maté for some time and his strength of character seems alien (most especially in media personalities). If more people had his compassion and willingness to speak their truth with grace this world would surely be a better place. Thank you Dr. Maté, just knowing that you exist gives me hope that I have not found elsewhere.
The humanity and love this man has in his heart and the knowledge he has in his head is what we should all aspire to. Well explained Dr. Maté. Be well and thank you.
Piers Morgan works on Rupert Murdoch's TV shows, which funds the Jerusalem Foundation, which builds illegal Israeli settlements, which is why he frequently questions in support of the Israeli occupation. Israel controls the Western media
In Ireland we know all about occupation. Our very independence was gained by an armed conflict in 1921 . The Good Friday Agreement is testament to what can be achieved. Many atrocities were committed in the 30 years of conflict in the North . Gabor Mate is a voice of reason, a voice of humanity. God bless Gabor 🇮🇪🇮🇪
Yeah, most occupations had to be ended by armed resistance. The occupiers would NEVER grant freedom to the occupied out of their own volition. They always have to be FORCED to free the people they occupy. I think this is why those that come from colonial countries find it so difficult to wrap their heads about how oppressive and suffocating and disheartening and depressing being under occupation is. The closest thing it can be compared to is slavery, you feel that you lose your freedom, your dignity, your aspirations and dreams, you feel crushed from the inside out.
I am so proud that he is a fellow Hungarian and shines as an example in this world as a professional in trauma healing but most importantly, an outstanding human being. Have him back on this show, please
Piers, if someone occupied me, my body, my home, my family, how long could I suppress my hostility? How long before the dam burst and I no longer had the ability to withstand the conscious killing of my spirit and physical being? How long could you? Under these conditions what happens to a person? They either die slowly of no hope, or die trying to gain freedom. Most of us are mere mortals without the tolerance and patience of people like Mandela, Gandhi, or King. The lashing out in October was brutal but could not have been unexpected. My heart goes out to both peoples who are at the mercy of history and unconscious living.
Give me wA different Mandela. It was racism within a country. As for Palestine, which is an occupation, give me a country that was liberated by offering flowers and chocolate to the occupier. The only way to freedom is to fight. Since when was the one who steals your land and house and lives in an innocent citizen?
I didn’t know Dr. Gabor Mate before this interview but after listening to his words I see that there is still some humanity left in this world. Thanks for such a profound explanation on how Palestinians are suffering for decades and no one is there to speak on their behalf. Also, thanks to Piers for letting him communicate his point of view.
hey im from israel. really amayzed what he says. he is decent. he really cares about falstinias. i can feel it. i hope i could understand his point of view. from my point of view as child in israel in israel. all i want is peace, be friend with them. but all i see is that they want to kill me. i dont blame them. their dads fight israel to kill my parents. and thank god my parents won and get them to gaza. i sure they hate me for this. i dont blame them wanting to kill me because their study in school that they should do so. they learn from parents that to duy with a bomb in order to kill me is the bravest holliest thing to do. they live very hard live. and i really cant find solution. this is my point of view. thank for reading
I've watched so many of Piers' interviews on this Hamas-Israeli flare-up. This one with Dr Mate is the only one that's moved me. The man oozes humility, compassion and honesty. Totally devoid of anger. It's not hard to take onboard his views. Piers is disarmed and docility personified.
We cannot continue to live like this way, always holding our breaths anticipating the next round of atrocities ---"two states" may be a solution, but in my opinion NOT a viable solution anymore, where everyone anticipates to lose something. For those of us who understand politics and administration should look for a solution in the United Kingdom's, Switzerland's and South Africa's system of governance, which are by far NOT perfect, but are unitary system that has devolved governance and EQUITY under the law(s)... If we give ourselves, 7 years of Truth, Justice and Reconciliation and another 7 years to find a lasting political and administrative system, culminating into a referendum we may just see peace in Israel and The Palestine's in our life times...
@@pk3778we must try for something. I imagine with all the killing and torture of children isreal has done that it may be possible. Best solution would be for isreal to leave palistinian and stop its illegal occupation. Let them heal from oppression and let isreal focus on its security as that is their priority I don't think they would be ok assimilating palistinians into there world. That was the impression I got when I vitiated. Lives cannot be abused or taken like they have been by hamas and isreal with its punishment of everyone.
Just the fact that Piers doesn’t interrupt or speak over Dr. Máté makes this interview so exceptional and it speaks volume how his calmness affects Piers too. Amazing interview ❤️
Being calm doesn't make a case. Mate is lying about historical facts and use himself as a jew to build his arguments. Who you are doesn't make the things you say solid. Facts makes your case solid.
Hamas They were starved* and drugged, thrown into damp tunnels and dark attics, coerced and beaten by their captors or by a raging crowd, their skin burned with fiery exhaust pipes so they can be identified and can't escape. They were forced to watch the horrifying videos of terrorist atrocities from which adults escaped in tears, weren't allowed to go to the bathroom for hours, were threatened with rifles and shouts of "quiet!" when they cried. Some came back only whispering, some had bruises and lice, they didn't shower for 50 days, did not see daylight, drank muddy or salty water, a few had severe injuries that were treated in terrifying isolation in hospitals in Gaza, and others who were wounded received no treatment at all. Their captors scared them - telling them that their parents forgot about them, that they don't want them, that they'll be in those tunnels forever, that no one is coming to take them back.
What a sense of relief, a human like Dr Mate is so needed on this planet. The comments make it clear that so many of us believe in peace for humanity, Dr Mate is a seriously wise soul and may insight, understanding and the end of this hellish suffering of innocent people come asap, may the blind, see.
As a Muslim Man I will Say, Hats off to This Jewish Man .. ❤ While Palestine Issues is All About Humanity, And Only Free People in This Wolrd Can Feel ..
Why the need to indicate whatever you identify as or identify with to show your respect to him? This is because you all consider your groups as opposites of whatever he identifies with hence you felt the need to say "As a bloody this and a stup!d that, hats off to this man".
He literally spent the whole time saying a whole lotta nothing lmao. He recycles old talking points to appeal to Western audiences that got no skin in the conflict. No solutions, no practicality, no context.
@@lexakellington123 it's really horrible to see everyone agreeing with him when they prolly couldn't even point to Israel on the map. Just wanna act like "in this world full of craziness, I AM on the side that is moderate and makes sense", white savior complex at its fullest. He spreads lies about an occupation that literally don't exist, it aint real, it's fabricated. I guess the Nazis indoctrinated him in the camps and turned him into one of them
He is not just when he repeats lies about the supposed oppression of the 'natives' in Canada. Yes he has a heart for the downtrodden and oppressed no doubt, but we may be sincere also but also sincerely wrong. We need to let our minds leads / think rationally with healthy circumspect mentality/scepticism and not let our feelings.... when we make a choice based on critical and rational thinking, we make much better choices that are concrete and endure, when we makes choices on feelings, well feelings can come and go and thus it is not wise to make choices based on feelings as prime reason. Consider this also: He is lying about the alleged oppression of the called 'natives' here in Canada ... i have studied such history consistently, critically, doing deep digging, and diligently keeping fairness and balance in view, and in hard truth, Gabor is right on Israel, but he's dead wrong about the so called "residential graves" due to supposed abuse etc and more. A site called "C2C JOURNAL" and others like the "Dorchester Review" here in Canada + wokewatchcanada substack article "manufacturing a genocide" and "no pride in genocide + "IRSIG the often ignored truth" + "Archaeologist's clams of genocide and neglect at residential schools easily debunked" by Frontier Centre for Public Policy and more...fully expose the depth of the so facinorous lies by Leftist mainstream media and the govt who controls them and so dishonest so called "natives", that supposedly there was this full scale oppression and supposed magna-homicide of the so called "natives." Please check these sources out that i provided so you may see that Gabor may be right on what has happened to Gazans and the West Bank people by Sionist Israel but NOT right on his claim of what Canada govt supposedly did to the "natives."
What an incredibly charismatic, well-educated and kind person this is. thank you Mr. Gabor Mate for being who you are and speaking out regarding this subject!!!
What an incredible human being. One of the best interviews with Piers and possibly the only person I've seen to leave Piers with absolutely nothing to argue with; no retort, deafening silence in the eyes of truth and pure morality.
No Piers as any rational person couldn't respond to such a delusional, lying psychopath. Just look at the insane stare of this Finkelstein and Soros clone--only difference this guy is or was a doctor--lot of crazy, sick, doctors under professional care.
He can't. This man saw the truth, lived there as a settler and could not live with it. He then asked Piers to go there and see for himself. What can Piers argue about 🤷🏽♂️
As a Palestinian I take my hat off to Gabor in deep respect & reverence. I’ve been saying for decades now why can’t the Palestinians & Jewish people live side by side in peace. It’s because of man’s inhumanity to man-greed, power, money, corruption, etc. It would be an honor to have Gabor as my neighbor. Growing up my mother’s best friend was Jewish as was my brother’s best friend. We are ancestral cousins. Gabor presented us with a wonderful interview without ever having to raise his voice. Much love to you Gabor and may GOD bless you and all the people who pray for Palestine. 🙏🇵🇸
*As a Muslim I am so thankful to Dr. Mate... The world really needs men like him who speak truth despite being himself jewish. Peace is only possible if there were more people like him as Christians, Muslims or Jews. We do not have to hate each other.*
i agree. still, i think he is lacking "accountability" and taking responsibility elements in his approach. Also i didn't hear him offer a solution except for empathy at best. It is not enough against terrorist organizations like Hamas.
as a Jew I agree with you, indeed we are commanded by our one creator to love each other, and I apologize for the failure of so many of my people to accomplish that basic thing
yeah he said end the occupation and the siege, that's the first step of the solution, then there's rebuilding and mutual co-operation towards a sustainable peace. @@עינבשםטוב-פ7צ
Just abandon your ancient religion and use common sense as guide through the world. Or at least make up a new religion that has no justification for massacres and slavery.
I was mesmerized throughout this interview. I couldn't blink. Each and every point was delivered with such poignancy. I have never quite seen anything like it.
I wasn’t … he’s passively excusing the terrorist attack. And leaving out the fact that Hamas wants to kill every Jew in existence (and swears to do so)… . And then talks about how the Jews should seek peace as if they’re the problem.
@@amark350 Instead of condemning Hamas, how we about we condemn the loss of civilian life on both sides? Unless you value one side's civilians' wellbeing over the other... up to you.
Dr Gabor Mate is one of the greatest gifts in our world. Been following him for a decade. Such an amazing human being. I am pleased to see him use his Jewish voice which carries more weight at this time to remind the world of the brutal oppression and occupation the Palestinians have endured for so long.
Dr.Mate shows great courage in telling it like it is even when the narrative goes against his own people, he hopes someday perhaps peace can be reached, the biggest obstacle is facing truth.
This is the only interview with no shouting and interruptions and “do u condemn Hamaz”. Dr Gabor is a very knowledgeable and humble human being. Loved it! There is hope for humanity after all ❤
@oren6978 The question is designed to smear defenders of Palestinian people as terror sympathizers. People like Corbyn who have been standing up for Jews his whole career and any serious journalist would know that beforehand. It’s also an ignorant question if he doesn’t ask others whether they condemn the ethnic cleansing by Israel.
Piers is a good listener if the other participant is articulate and respectful. He only interrupts "loudmouth but no substance" trash like mohammed hijab
The world is blind to the TRUTH. The Jewish people have enriched the world with 213 Nobel Prizes, 5 for Israelis, 15 million Jews in the world and one democratic, developed, modern and progressive country that rose up after the Holocaust. 2 million Arab citizens live in Israel, the only ones who live in democracy, - in the Middle East!! 50 Muslim countries, one and a half billion Muslims. Not a single country is democratic. What did they contribute to your world? 5 Yes, five Nobel Prizes. (And I am not allowed to write about 9-11 and October 7 and dozens of terrorist organizations and the immigration of millions to Europe. Because they will block me!!)
Please have him back on the show. This is a man that can heal the hate in the world right now. Matè, I am truly inspired by your knowledge, wisdom and heart🌷
I'm proud to say that i just saw Dr. Mate in a drugstore, and I had the guts to speak to him. He has the same humble, compassionate, healing way of speaking, in person as well.
DR. Gabor Mate explained the terrible situation in Palestine very well with a wise, calming, from the heart and soul voice. What a positive energy, Respect.
As a Palestinan I love this man. This has never been about hate for Jews, we actually care about our cousins but this is literally about humanity. Our children’s future. Our future. Freedom for our beloved Palestine 🇵🇸 Update: to the ones who are ok with the genocide has clearly not understood the entire interview. Message Was from a Jewish holocaust survivor that became a doctor. If you don’t like it don’t travel to Palestine or anywhere in the Middle East. It’s fine. Statement stands for freedom. This in no way means the destruction of anybody but to preserve freedom and justice for all. Don’t like it nobody cares.
Oh man what they are doing to you is just horrible, just know that the world is not sleeping, we know what they are doing to you, and we hope that some day you guys will be able to get your land, hopes and dreams back, we are all part of the human species/family and we all deserve to have a happy and peacefull life.
They're Not your cousins They're your half brothers. Same father (Abraham) different Mother's (Sara / Hagar) In essence Jews (Issac) and Arabs (Ishmael) are "brothers from another Mother " The book (Bible) teaches that both Isaac Ishmael would be the father of many nations However Ishmael will be Ike a WILD DONKEY and His hand will be againts Every man(infidels) especially His own brothers (family) Jews and Arabs alike. . Thus this conflict has been ongoing for millennia and unfortunately Wil continue indefinitely. The Holy Quran and the Hadith ( writings of the prophet Muhammad) teaches Jews and infidels are dogs and Pigs and shoukd submit convert to Islam or be slaughtered.
Immense respect to Dr. Gabor Mate for reminding Piers that the current situation cannot be looked in isolation without the historical context! A brutal history of occupation for the past 75 years.
And that can definently be a point, but if u think this at any point justifies oct 7 you are out of your mind and gravely morally confused. If they attacked soliders or military points, you have an argument, but because of what they did and how they did it, they lost all that moral high ground in an instant and in many ways proved Israel right in calling them barbarians and savages.
What a man Gabor Mate is. He breaks down the complex issues into clear understandable facts, referring to history to hopefully allow us all the ability to shape the future of the Middle East.
Holy shit. This interview has single-handedly shifted my perspective on this conflict. Not from Israel to Palestine but from vengeance to healing. It may sound crazy but this may be the greatest chance in our lifetimes for incredible global healing. Incredible unity and recognition of our power to heal together and individually. To heal you must accept the wound. Be with the wound. If you’re Israeli or right wing reading this, please for the sake of us all, accept that the Nakba opened up a wound and let’s begin to heal it from that place.
Doesn’t sound crazy at all. I can feel a shift as well. People are waking up. And it’s giving me tremendous hope, especially for the Palestinian people.
I discovered Gabor in 2007 via a book about "When the Body Says No" and I couldn't put it down, even travelling with it because even though it was a medical book, it spoke to my trauma. He is an amazing human, honest and authentic, and humble. I'm Canadian, and I've managed to find great comfort once again in his speaking to the suffering in Gaza.
Surprising? Gabor Maté is a well-respected public figure who's held this same discourse for decades. Your comment proves his point: Western media has silenced the Palestinian perspective. I'm glad Piers gave Doctor Maté a platform.
@@lbrtvlldr It was about time for Pierce Morgan It surprises me that Pierce had him on his show! I know Dr Maté because I follow his interviews since many years! As I said : he is a gem! I am disappointed he did not talk about " The Hannibal Directive" I saw Dr Gabor Maté lately on THE GRAYZONE! And in a Podcast with Dr Cornell West! They were so witty!
I lost basic humanity? To understand that there is NO excuse for rape, kidnapping and beheading babies? I was a fan of Dr Mate., teaching is work for my students. Yet he lost it. How can you excuse the barbaric behavior of fundamental Islam? @@itsoktolovechina
My one criticism of Mate’ is that he missed an opportunity to point the direction forward from colonialist genocide towards multiculturalism and equality. One reason that Mate’ can speak quickly and barely even begin to describe the 150 year genocide of the First Nations in Canada is because multiculturalism and fighting prejudice and laying down multiculturalism since the somewhat transformative government of Lester B Pearson 1963- 1968. Without Mate’, but with him as witness to what Canada is doing Canada is definitely leading the world in Reconciliation, casting a net to round up men responsible for missing and murdered indigenous women, holding public hearings regarding abuse, and establishing integration of First Nations story telling as legal evidence. These are just a few examples of progress beyond violence and experts talking. Mate’ often forgets to paint himself out of the picture which is necessary when experts weigh in.
Thank you Dr. Matè for saying the truth that many others are afraid to admit. This is a person who supports humanity and people’s rights. Glad to finally listen to someone who can express his fair opinions about this issue without much interruption.
Mind Begs the Question: - If USA/West Leadership - Defend policies of Starvation,Death Camps,Gas Chambers/White Phosphorus,Pogroms,Ethnic Cleansing,etc - Pro Democracy or Pro Nazi?
Don’t be fooled. Israel has tried and tried to make peace with the Palestinian people. Palestinian don’t won’t it. Go back to the charter. The likud party charter does not state to kill every Palestinian inhabitants. The Hamas charter does.
*what a mistake in the Qur'an!* Allah himself testifies that he has a son and he is the son as Christians understand it! Only the Koran writer was too ignorant to know what Son of God means! Allah's word which created everything is Allah himself too! *The Word Allahs which created everything is the Son of God according to Christianity!*
Son of God does not mean that God has a child in Christianity! *what a mistake in the Qur'an!* Son of God are 2 titles one referring to the Word of God = God himself and one referring to creation (humans, angels, demons)
I have never seen such a meaningful interview in my life, and I would never forget this. Thank you Dr. Mate, and thank you piers for inviting such a great man in your show
From a military perspective and as an Afghanistan combat veteran, I don’t think what Israel is doing militarily will work any better than the U.S.’s 20-year, $1 trillion dollar war in Afghanistan did.
Wow. I’m blown away by this interview. Dr. Mate is amazing and the insights he shared about the Occupation and family are full of wisdom and understanding.
@@joeyballs30What are you trying to say. Can you express your complete take on the situation between both sides I am absolutely interested in seeing a potential *prejudice troll* trolling it’s comical at this point
I love how piers avoids the question of what do you expect them to do. He just cannot get his head around the fact, the suppression leads people to unimaginable things.
Yes, yes, yes! I had asked you to invite Mr. Mate to your show... and you did! Thank you, Mr. Gabor Mate for your infinite wisdom, your honesty, your courage, your calm defiance, your presence!!! ❤
Speaking so calmly, with so much truth, humanity, compassion for people being traumatised for decades. He is trying to explain several times where the problem began but Pierce like so many in this world just dont want to see or hear the truth
I used to be a Zionist, I am as you mentioned a holocaust survivor, Zionism was very important to me as a salvation for the Jewish people, until i found out that the state was founded based on opresssion and multiple massacres of the local population. And that is not historically controversial. The present situation cannot be understood without looking at historical context nor can we move forward if the present occupation and supression of the Palestinians continue. Sharon your previous guest talks about co-existence, there is no co-existence, there is supression, periodic massacres, land occupation, continuous expulsion of the population from their homes. This cannot go on. I m not talking about 1948, I m talking about since 1967 and what is going on right now. Most Israelis are not aware of the history of what the Palestinian have suffered. They dont know that in 1948 there were multiple massacres of large number of people by Israeli forces. They dont know the history of the subjective experience of the Palestinians and in the absence of that knowledge, October 7th just strike them as another horrific anti Semitic event. If you ask me on how to move forward lets inform ourselves of the actual experience of both sides. On Every country has the right to defend itself but Israel has no right to impose an occupation on people. In 1956 there was a great Hungarian revolution against Russian occupation, did Russia has the right to defend itself against the Hungarian revolutionaries? When we are talking about Israel's right of defense, we are taking isolated Palestinian actions but we are not saying that this population also has the right to defend itself against the occupation. I m not justifying the event on Oct 7, I am talking in absence of historical awareness, it all just looks like Israel defending itself. But against whom? Against the population that has been massacring in the number of thousands for 80 YEARS, and taking their lands, destroying their homes, jailing their children and torturing them. That's the history. Unless we know that its all looks like this poor little country trying to defend itself. Yugoslavia has gone through horrific atrocities but the are living together now. There are issues to be worked out but the minimum is the ending of the occupation and inhumane siege of Gaza and International Law has to be respected. International Law is very clear that this occupation is illegal. That has to be the basis of any future agreement. If Israeli can live within the borders that are internationally recognized I believe peace is possible. We keep talking about Hamas Charter. Did you know that the Likud Charter the ruling party in Israel excludes a Palestinian entity west of the Jordan River? So lets get rid of both charters and lets start on the basis of recognition and peace and ending of this unspeakable brutal occupation . There is no possibility of that until the international community and particularly Israel's big brothers the UK and the US stop supporting its illegal brutal inhumane and rapacious occupation. It cant happen without some pressure. Most Israeli are simply not aware, i have been to Israel talk to people they have no idea whats happening a few miles away from where they are sitting in Tel Aviv or Jerusalem having coffee and they have no idea how those people under occupation are living. Its not that they are not capable of being aware but like most people, they just not. I m saying that unless we fully get the Palestinian experience historically and throughout the decades and into the present moment, we can't possibly understand what is going on here. In 2005 there was a study appeared on the Journal of World Psychiatry looking at traumatized populations under war conditions, the most traumatized children in 2005 this is before Hamas gained power in Palestine and in Gaza, the most traumatized kids were in Gaza. This population has been traumatized severely, of course they're full of rage, i m not justifying anything they did but I m saying what do we expect from this population that's been surpressed and tormented and crucified for decades.
Why you dont talk of the many peace talks israel had with palestiniens and was not accepted.. today they would have had a country … instead they attacked Israel .. sending thousands of missiles .. palestiniens are not guiltless .. this is not a war for land this a a constant plead to not recognize israel as a state .. you need a partner to make peace
@@soniacharleschocron9749 They don't talk of the many peace talks israel had with palestiniens and was not accepted it because this doesn't serve the Palestinian false narrative. Gabor is another biased anti-zionist that pretends to be neutral but is in fact a far leftist with one-sided views and "knowledge", plus lots of exaggerations and false "historical facts" in his statements. Israel had several leaderships that went above and beyond to have this conflict resolved. No leadership on the Palestinian side really wanted this resolved and some Arab and Muslim countries leaderships thrive from maintaining this conflict going on for ages.
@@rykson161 Same comment copy and paste all over..... Not tired of that?? What is your point? Trying to discredit Dr. MATE, simply because he is not repeating the official zinosr lies???
@@rykson161 Comparing the descendants of formerly enslaved Africans with the Israel-Palestine conflict doesn't make sense. They're completely different issues. You could compare Palestinians with Native Americans and that would make more sense. But I don't really understand what correlation slavery has with the current events.
All respect for Dr Gabor Mate. You make me believe again in humanity. I hope that more people will understand the atrocities and trauma that Palestinians went through for more than 70 years.
The calmed composure of Gabor Mate is mesmerizing. His ability to deconstruct the war as a "stock and flow" problem, and showcasing the ignorance of snapshot judgment into one event. You can't simply judge the proportionate response of retaliation in contrast to a singular event.
Because we were just supposed to roll over and get over the death of the killing of 1400 of our people, the beheading of our babies and the kidnapping of our women. You guys would’ve been on the sides of Nazis. Jewish life doesn’t matter to you guys.
One of the best, if not “The” best, interviews Morgan has made so far. Hat-off to Dr. Gabor Mate. When one listens to his words and idea’s, he realises that humanity is still good.
"It's not about being pro Israel or Palestine, this is about standing up for humanity"
13:22
Amazing how it’s understandable except for when it applies to African Descendants of Slaves !
Palestine 80 years
Blacks
200 years plus !
100% AGREE
No it's not. Humanity shouldn't tolerate a terrorist organization that kidnaps babies, beheads innocent left wing people and rapes young girls. Learn some history and facts.
Arabs are the most oppressed people of today.
@@TC-zf1jiArabs should mind their own business and stop rioting
All respect for Dr Gabor Mate. He started by teaching Piers that the present situation can not be understood without the historical context.
But Morgan don’t want know or believe history as is clear from his emphasis on oct 7
The God of Israel has given that land to them it’s written in the holy book you can’t argue that! The arabs in Palestine today need to go to Jordan.
That's common sense, don't need a degree to understand that unless you're western and a colonizer.
Piers starter always with 7/10. every time😢
@@williewill1237 the other god said go to Argentina
A Holocaust survivor cried everyday for the 2 weeks period he visited Palestine, when he saw the suffering of Palestinians. This speaks volumes…
I suspect a large number of zionists are not survivors of parents who were holocaust survivors. They just use the holocaust as a twisted way to justify what they do.
@@garyluciani1082sure thing? Have you seen the "Europa, the last battle" documentary?? Will tell you everything you need to know about the reality
@@garyluciani1082if you still think the h.o.l.o....c.a.u.s.t happened you are still enslaved.
me too LOL@@StopWhatsGoingOn
🇵🇸
Thank you doctor for speaking up what a wonderful human you are .
It is amazing how the Palestinian tragedy has introduced me to too many great people and intellectuals like Gabor mate, LowKey and Norman Finkelstein, but also unveiled the mask of certain hypocrites, such as the western media. Thanks to you Piers, despite your double standards, for giving these people a platform.
When Isreal wasnt attacked ??? What are Semitic check the dictionary and history yourself its not Isreal first.
Fact chcek WWII started in Poland Gdańsk Westerplatte 1 september 1939. Germany attacked Poland to clime Gdańsk as thier own at the time population registery Polish people was 34 millions.
When war end 1945 Polish population was shrink to 21 millions!!! We have lost 13 millions at witch 6 milions International Jewis communities prescribe to themselves!!! When 2010 Isreal created state in Palestina had 5 milions 70 years after the war.
Poland suffer attack by Germany follow by Ukraine mascara Polish millions on today Ukraine follow by Russia invasion and stay for decades.
Poland was distroy by the same forces previously and participation after the Greate Kingdom of Poland Litvenia.
Jewish Nation has no countries they take stool the suffer of Poland and made Poland in Isreal guilty for WWII. THEY ARE CHOSEN NATION DOUBLE STANDARDS TWO TRIANGLE IN THE FLAG.
Its GOD allmighy tell us Masonic Pupets Masters use those parasites triving on pray in the flag they say to us who they are watch out.
Nation without its own land what does it tell us really is it bleesing or curst ???
😂😂😂😂😂
Don't forget Ilan pape
Agreed! And it is the least I saw Pierse interrupting someone he is interviewing. Apart from Douglas Murray right after the Finkelstein interview where Murray called Finkelstein a psychopath and Holocaust denier, Piers was quiet the whole time of Murray’s monologue but that is because he agrees with him. I wish he let the other guests he doesn’t agree with speak more, but I guess it is great he gives them the platform at least.
Or Gideon Levy. I'd be interested to hear someone such as Gideon Levy who still lives in Israel about his views.
I am so glad Gabor Maté was invited on the show. He is the most emotive voice of calm reason and humanity on this issue.
you said my mind 🤍
Absolutely! ❤
He is the most emotive voice of calm reason on most issues
You’d be surprised to one a lot of people do , you just don’t hear them on the news .
When Isreal wasnt attacked ??? What are Semitic check the dictionary and history yourself its not Isreal first.
Fact chcek WWII started in Poland Gdańsk Westerplatte 1 september 1939. Germany attacked Poland to clime Gdańsk as thier own at the time population registery Polish people was 34 millions.
When war end 1945 Polish population was shrink to 21 millions!!! We have lost 13 millions at witch 6 milions International Jewis communities prescribe to themselves!!! When 2010 Isreal created state in Palestina had 5 milions 70 years after the war.
Poland suffer attack by Germany follow by Ukraine mascara Polish millions on today Ukraine follow by Russia invasion and stay for decades.
Poland was distroy by the same forces previously and participation after the Greate Kingdom of Poland Litvenia.
Jewish Nation has no countries they take stool the suffer of Poland and made Poland in Isreal guilty for WWII. THEY ARE CHOSEN NATION DOUBLE STANDARDS TWO TRIANGLE IN THE FLAG.
Its GOD allmighy tell us Masonic Pupets Masters use those parasites triving on pray in the flag they say to us who they are watch out.
Nation without its own land what does it tell us really is it bleesing or curst ???
Years ago, I discovered Dr. Gabor Matè’s book “Scattered”. I read it and became addicted to his work. He is absolutely brilliant. For years, I was afraid to look into his views on Palestinian rights. I was afraid that his view of Palestinians would crush me. I admired him and his work so very much..I am Palestinian. One day, I listened to an excellent talk that he gave to a group of teachers and school social workers. In the Q&A, someone asked him about Palestinian children and trauma. I felt a rush of adrenaline hearing this question. I inadvertently held my breath. Then he began to answer the question and I sobbed. I sobbed with my heart and soul. It was in that moment that I fully realized that Dr. Matè was more than just a brilliant doctor. He is an extraordinary empath. He is a man who views the world through the brilliant lens that he created through his work. I felt silly for avoiding looking into his views on the subject. He is Dr. Gabor Matè. Of course, he would understand the experience and traumas of Palestinian children.
Thank you Dr. Matè. You are a living legend.
❤🌹
me too mate
Well articulated.
We , Jews and Palestinians, must find a middle ground compromise that future generations do not grow up with trauma. We also must acknowledge all the atrocities we committed against each other
I absolutely understand what u felt, ur post is riveting actually, u put so much in such a short text. In one message I feel very close to you. Anyway, thanks your for this bridging comment
Dr. Gabor Mate 's words " you have to go and see it for yourself. Then you would cry every day for two weeks." He is really an educated person. My respects ......
I doubt most white conservatives would cry. Heck even someone like Biden or Hillary might giggle a little. They only pay lip service to the legacy of the holocaust.
Piers has a way of asking inflammatory questions to incite defensive responses, but dr Mate addresses then in such a calm and rational manner that really elevates the integrity of the conversation. A true masterclass
Piers has only 1 good thing about him (also, not so good for him at the same time) that he brings people that are so smart, educated and miles ahead than him by humanity's perspective and then he opens his mouth and it's like he didn't hear anything nor that he cares about what has been said...
@@awada87OMG! 👏You're absolutely right. Piers Morgan does that every time!
@@awada87well said man ,you are 100 % right
Yes it was like he didn’t give any power to the provocation
So True!!!!
As a Muslim, watching every single interview for Piers on the subject.. this is the only one that burst me into tears! watching a kind-hearted jewish honest old man truly understand the main problem and facing all the heavy propaganda with such minimum logic simple wording! I really loved him from the bottom of my heart! I wish I had a grandfather like him.. I wish I grow old to be a kind grandfather like him.
Read his book "the myth of normal". It's very good too. You'll like it
@@dtwtan
Thank you so much.. I will definitely start reading his books
Me too 😅
People like you are the core of the problem because you always identify with the religion first and then with humanity.
If people like you did not exist, if not identify with Islam first, and identified with being human first most of the problems today would go away.
The problem is Muslim only stand with Muslim and not with other people when Muslims are the aggressors.
Yes, he is truly a wonderful human.
It is so difficult for this man to have this opinion yet he opened his eyes and saw things objectively. So much respect.
Maybe Finkelstein had some impact by mentioning how he had a heart..
It really isn't he's made literally millions by peddling it. It's just a grift.
@@maxdamagusbroskisounds like every other politician
@@maxdamagusbroski Ignorance is bliss!....G.M has saved many addicts!!...Myself being one off past!
it took him WAY too long. not too long ago he was being rude as hell to owen jones when he said pretty much thing cut from the same cloth.
First interview I have seen Piers NOT interrupting and listening. And MASSIVE RESPECT for Gabor Mate for speaking words of wisdom and truth with such beautiful humanity! Peace for our planet! 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
Indeed.
Peirs was totally disarmed by Gabor
100% @@chazbayley
It was time Piers didn't interrupt... Chapeau Dr Gabor Maté ...
It's a rare interview that Piers is not disturbing the guest but listening calmly.......wow the energy of Dr. Mate
you are so right
Agree with you!
what energy? he's half dead!
Exactly, I got the same vibe, He is just like a Zen Master, authentic spiritual personality.
@@Micciqueenhis energy is calm thoughtful fair and loving, and that’s exactly the energy this world needs… ❤
*Whether you agree with him or not, Gabor's calm and collected way of presenting his point of view is an art that is quickly being forgotten in our modern age.*
💯
What's not to agree with him?
If you don't agree with Gabor, you need some serious introspection...
the information he is saying is not correct. @@matjazkarlovcec924
I agree some of what he said, but some sounds like liberal gobbledygook
I have almost lost all hope in humanity but when I listen to people like Dr Gabor I get a little hope that it's not all lost yet.
Me too
Lost hope why?
@@hindude4572i hope you'll get there someday child 👶
@@MemorieEU you are part of the problem, rather than providing an explanation you’d resort to personal attacks and childish wit
Not just bright but kind hearted and a good soul. That’s pretty rare
This brought me tears…Dr Mate is an angel to this world! He made of his traumas a treasure to give to humanity.
I love him so much.
He is definitely angelic. His voice is so calming
This is the best guest Piers has invited on his show. Pure humanity, compassion and not turning a blind eye to genocide. Respect Dr. Maté.
pure demagogery
What genocide. Pure bullshit. Since 2005 when the last Jew was expelled from Gaza the Arab population of Gaza has boomed.
@@architecture_logs that is laughable. You can't have contempt for a man who doesn't have contempt for others. Demegogue is so off the mark
@@architecture_logs completely off the mark.
@@architecture_logsThis is not a good look. You are coming off as either misinformed, uninformed or just downright cruel. I wish you well
A kind man not afraid to say the truth no matter how uncomfortable. 2005's most traumatized kids from Gaza are now young men fighting for their lives and freedom. Thank you Dr Mate
And commiting war atrocities, you forgot about that part.
@@thedevilluiswat about idf cruelty,lies,....
@@thedevilluiswhich is what they've been suffering for 80 years.
Why did my comment get deleted? I didn't say anything provocative
@@thedevilluisto get your answer, please watch the video again 🤦
I couldn't hold back my tears listening to this man. Thank you, Mr. Gabor Maté, for standing up for humanity. You have all my respect
Please explain the ( Hannibal Directive Protocol)!
They did use it on the 7th and afterwards (A helicopter pilot, a female soldier, and a hostage testimonies )!
I.D.F is the terrorista group which started it all in 1948.
And A Fact → H-M-S wasn't born then.
The childrens whose parents where Massacréd by 🇮🇱 joined and took the oath for Vengeance !
I.D.F is the terrorista org. which started it all in 1948.
And A Fact → H-M-S wasn't born then.
Tsahal est le groupe terroriste qui a tout déclenché en 1948.
Et un fait → Le Hamas n'était pas né à cette époque.
Les enfants dont les parents ont été massacrés par 🇮🇱 se sont joints et ont prêté serment de vengeance
I’d like to see Ben Shapiro actually have a conversation with someone as intelligent and eloquent as Gabor Mate instead of ‘debating’ 20 year old students
Yes!
you know that will never happen
Ain’t going to happen! People like Shapiro and AIPAC are the problem. You can’t argue with anyone who has to be right.
Never have I seen a person mellow, with such efficiency and calm, the wandering soul of a chronically combative interrogator. This is a lesson on humanity and sympathetic communication, not just for Piers, but for the whole world.
Agreed. You said that do well. You’re good with words.
Quite!
damn insane sentence bro. deadass thought this was gibberish until the second read
Its the DEVILS DECEPTION U FOOL. HE LOOKS LIKE A DEVIL.
Thank you, Dr. Gabor
This man is an example for people to take a step back and look at the overall picture before making a judgement through ignorance or through a cultural, political or religious bias.
He is a useful idiot protecting his career.
hey im from israel. and i do also ant breath about whats happening to gaza children. but for every ongoing conflict there are 2 stupid sides. i really dont want to proove something. just remember that we here in israel also just humen beings that dont want to be burn alive. we live here in terror, we really afaid from hamas. and the only thing that enable him to do that is by hiding behind his children and shooting at me and my friends. i dont know whats the solution here
Facts
10000%
He has never bn Pro Zionist, God bless Israel.🇮🇱
Immense respect to Dr. Maté. What a genuine and wise human being he is! Touched my heart and enriched my mind at the same time.
13:22
Amazing how it’s understandable except for when it applies to African Descendants of Slaves !
Palestine 80 years
Blacks :::
200 years plus !
But blacks are told to pull up their boot straps … while Zionists get 20 billion dollars a year from these same blacks !
Imagine Black taxpayers money going to Zionists to kill and forcefully sterilize other black people and Palestinians !
Piers Morgan works on Rupert Murdoch's TV shows, which funds the Jerusalem Foundation, which builds illegal Israeli settlements, which is why he frequently questions in support of the Israeli occupation.
Israel controls the Western media
Ex Israeli Prime Minister and Minister of Defense Ehud Barak went on CNN and said the Tunnel below Al-Shifa Hospital was built by the Israelis 4 decades ago and the Israelis also have similar tunnels under their hospitals. Wake up people.
He made me vomit. Disgusting. Shame on you both
Go watch his content and interviews one of the best to talk about psychology specifically anxiey and trauma and adhd
“SPEAKING THE TRUTH IS MORE IMPORTANT TO ME THAN WHO LIKES ME OR DOESN’T LIKE ME. “Dr. Gabor Mate
He actually said MY truth....I'd doesn't make it a truth if you claim it to be ... this guy has no basic knowledge on Israel Palestine conflict or history
@@grandekristian😅😅😅
Do you have any?
Why don't you go on the show or spread information regarding this argument?
@@grandekristianactually that's the whole truth. But again people like you wouldn't believe it even if you went back in time and watched it infront of your own eyes. It's alright we understand
@@fersikhawla570 learn history is my advice 👍
I have two feelings after this interview - first, is admiration for Gabor and his ability to explain the feelings and humanity behind a complex situation that most are ill educated about - second - my embarrassment and shame as a UK citizen for Piers to mumble about October the 7th after Gabor has explained that the backstory of Palestine needs to be understood and taken into account to truly understand the situation.
At least he didn't start by asking him if he condemns Hamas.😄
Agree
Exactly
Absolutely agree... I guess some people just see the trains, and others see the tracks that the trains are on...
@@omarzaitoun4270he only asks that racist loaded question to brown people. As an imperialist he assumes we are all OK with the killing of civilians.
He also clearly values white coloniser lives more than indigenous Palestinian lives. Keeps going on about Oct 7th. How many hundreds of Oct 7ths did the zionist entity inflict on the Palestinians before then. And how many times more after then?
I live in Australia , I am not in Palestine but I can feel the sufferings and now I am crying 😢again after listening his so truthful speech.
🇵🇸🇵🇸🐱👍
So you are occupying the land of Australia. When are you vacating and move back to the land of your forefathers? Why only land, why not Revert to the religion of your forefathers?
You live in an occupied land . Give the land back to the aboriginals and get out
❤️🫶🏼🇵🇸🫒🇸🇩🕊️✌🏼🌍☮️
Me too😭😭
What an outstanding interview. This man should come on for longer. Such sincerity from every word he said. These are the guys whose voices should be highlighted to the world. Such honesty is commendable. Loved this.
He has many great interviews on the topic that I would recommend watching
Unfortunately such people do not bring profit and do not help making money…
13:22
Amazing how it’s understandable except for when it applies to African Descendants of Slaves !
Palestine 80 years
Blacks
200 years plus !
Brilliant.
No shouting no agenda.
Just pure facts and calmness.
If that would happen Piers would be fired.
Here in Canada, he is a national treasure. I am so proud to be living in the same city as him.
How precisely he explained it…he is the only one that actually made Piers speechless otherwise this man will always be stuck on October 7 and talking about Israel defending itself
A very great answer given by Gabor, “Israel has a right to defend itself against whom? People who are being massacred since 80 years?”
Agree, Piers always gets stuck on 7 0ktober with the same question, do you condemn Hamas? he couldn't accept the reality of the root of the problem. it was 80 years of suffering
@@yersifefebrina6068 He knows the actual truth. See his 2014 tweets.
@@yersifefebrina6068 he has some bosses to please, some people r shameless 🤷🏻♂️
@@yersifefebrina6068 Actually it is an important question to ask. The war caused an extreme level of propaganda, reaching many people who - as Máté explained - have limited knowledge. Hence even the most rational, knowledgeable and compassionate like Mate are constantly attacked by extreme accusations. On social media and on edited platforms too.
Asking this questions is a way to rule out these accusations very early, so the person watching the screen get a "Hey, this guy is okay, he won't verify any inhumane actions, he is okay" message.
It is bad that we need it but we need it. That's how war works.
Very correct argument for Mr. P Morgan, because he is sailing out on the ocean much of the time. But even though this jewsh man, who is a living history himself as survival of the holocaust, is telling him the historical context behind the real true of Palastine conflict Mr P Morgan still doesn't seem to understand what the hell the this whole conflict is about and then he goes and miss judging the situation, which is nothing less than lacking of historical knowledge.
Piers please bring Dr. Mate back again for a full 1 hour special! He is the therapy that the world needs!
Piers Morgan works on Rupert Murdoch's TV shows, which funds the Jerusalem Foundation, which builds illegal Israeli settlements, which is why he frequently questions in support of the Israeli occupation.
Israel controls the Western media
his son is aradical marxist that was in prsion in germany....
Ex Israeli Prime Minister and Minister of Defense Ehud Barak went on CNN and said the Tunnel below Al-Shifa Hospital was built by the Israelis 4 decades ago and the Israelis also have similar tunnels under their hospitals. Wake up people.
Seriously. A great, educated voice on the topic and he had to change the topic over to prince Harry 😵💫
@@SSMindsI noticed that too. Piers is still a those CNN propagandist
Jesus christ, finally pierce let's a person TALK. THANK YOU! THANK YOU FOR NOT INTERRUPTING HIM EVERY 2 SECONDS. Finally someone says everything we have been screaming these past few weeks
I think it's the calm nature of Dr Gabor Maté lol. You just enjoy listening to him forever. 😂
To be fair, Piers in no way ALWAYS interrupts a guest. Usually when he has a lot of respect for a guest, he lets them speak in full. His job takes patience and skill. Great interview!!!!
it's not Piers allowing, but Dr Mate mesmerizing talks and voice and experience. He is undebatable
He want but he can't.. what he can told😂
I second you in thanking him for not asking his ever infamous QUESTION :"do you condmen Hamas?"
Piers doesn’t sincerely mean what he says about the plight of the Palestinians, otherwise he wouldn’t have been so fixated on Oct the 7th alone. But I do have to give him credit for allowing people like Dr. Mate to speak on his platform. This almost never happens in the US mainstream media.
He normally talks over people . Dominates them and shouts at them . Pushing his own vile beliefs . Gabor is an intelligent and gentle soul . I bet piers was pre warned not to be a c…t.
If Gabor Maté, a Holocaust survivor, doesn’t get Piers Morgan to condemn Israel’s genocide & apartheid, I don’t know what will… Free Palestine 🇵🇸🕊️
Piers is taking orders from his masters. No backbone to accept what's right. Free palestine ❤
Genocide? You’re so ignorant! Name a country in the history of the world who limits more civilian casualties than Israel? You are just a racist!
He himself said that his brain can’t comprehend what isreal should do that’s he keeps interviewing people to find out who can fit his brains.
Piers has ties to the Zionist lobby, he will never condemn Israel.
Simply put, Israel occupies a country that was independent. You claim standardization while you trample the United Nations Charter and classify terrorism according to agenda and ideology. The correct question is: Do you condemn Israel? Hamas acted in response to the rape, encroachment on Palestinian lands, and killing of children seventy years ago. From 47 to now
I feel at peace knowing there are people like Dr Gabor Mate out there in the world, unfailingly committing to humanity, to kindness, to truth and to justice.
The problem is with Muslim people because they always put religion before humanity
Muslims never stand up against other Muslims when the aggressor is Muslim.
I completely agree. Kindness, truth and justice is the only way for people to live together in peace.
So true❤
Why don't you look into this yourself instead of listening to what others have to say? Then you'll see what the truth is..
The Palestinian Muslims engaged in routine terrorism against Jews beginning around 1917, long before they became 1948 refugees, in a time when they had superior numbers and local political power. The most notorious acts include the 1920 Nebi Musa riot, 1921 Jaffa riot, 1929 Palestinian riot, 1935 Cement Incident, 1947 Aden riote, and 1930's Arab Revolts. Murdering, raping, beatings, and property destruction.
What history does he think needs to be known?
This was a beautiful interview. Please bring him again! He healed a part of me that has been utterly hopeless after I started a deep research about the Palestinian issue. It was so horrifying, it made me nauseous.
When Dr Gabor spoke about Isreali’s being unaware of the history and what is actually going on in Palestine 🇵🇸.
Gideon Levy said in a 2005 interview ‘Israeli society is too brainwashed and life is too good. Israel lives in denial totally disconnected from reality.’
It would be great if Piers gets Gideon Levy on the show.
Sarah, sorry to hear how difficult seeing this has been for you. If you are wondering how Palestinians are able to cope, it Islam. I invite you to read the Quran and learn more.
I started reading The Ethnic Cleansing of Palestine by Ilan Pappe', a Jewish historian. I got to the fifth page and burst into tears because I already knew the history of Palestine. I am going to read it but now one year later I am seeing these wonderful people being completely wiped out and it breaks my heart because no one is doing anything about it.
Im from Vancouver and this man is a true treasure. Hes done so much for the city and the lower downtown eastside. We need more of his kind in this world.
This is a perfect display of how to truly approach an interview. Shoutout to Gabor Mate for his calmness, elegance, and poise while speaking on such delicate topics as such.
I love how Dr Gabor was calm and collected enough to juggle both questions about the war and then mental health and trauma. A true doctor indeed.
a great doctor. yet i was disappointed, in many cases, he didn't answer the question yet answered unrelated answer?! a bit confusing
His "empathy" is based on self-pity and is chronically self-referring - this is a common narcissistic trait.
@@עינבשםטוב-פ7צHe provided context and he did that very well. Nothing confusing about to be honest.
He never answered the questions and his opinions on 1948 are simply WRONG.
I guess you missed the questions he didn't answer just moved to whatever he wanted to talk about. it is manipulative and dissapointing, to be honest. @@TjaTjaTja80177
People like Dr Gabor give us hope for this world. Love and respect for him for telling the truth.
In the absence of historical awareness. Exactly. Gabor Mate for president.
Give Piers a medal, he didn't ask "Do you condemn Hamas?" for the first time
😅
haha, he maybe realised this Guy is too intelligent to be asked these pointless questions
that's a travesty!!!
Interesting that, he chooses when to get uppity so should avoid it like this talk. He needs Aaron Mate on or Max Blumenthal vs Schmooly guy.
He asked but with another way 😂😂😂😂😂
Gabor is one of the most patient, articulate, knowledgeable and compassionate people I've ever come across. He's a great man and a real positive force in the world. Today, the online space is unfortunately full of toxic influences whom people are looking to for guidance. More people should know about Mate.
No he is not. I bought his books and studied. He is another fake ideologist who likes his high moral ground. And a closet Socialist. It is people like him who have created the division in our universities.
I WOULD LOVE TO COME ON YOUR SHOW
So true! Mad respect for this amazing human being!
and his son
Gabor Mate is what it means to be human. I appreciate Piers Morgan for having him on, but he has a serious blind spot he needs to come to grips with.
Such a sincere human. We need more people like him. People who are able to articulate calmly, without any fear of retaliation in such a sensitive subject.
Truth is always noble ❤️
A wise man. acknowledging each side of an issue, the flawed nature of humanity and also that it is possible to build bridges towards a more loving and understanding relationship between opposing parties, whether within families or on the macro level between ethnic groups or nations. Humanity desperately needs to move beyond the 'war as a solution' principle.
If more people like Dr. Matè were in power the world wouldn’t be in the horrible state that it’s in 😔. He is the type of person that should be leading the world.
I’ve followed Dr. Maté for some time and his strength of character seems alien (most especially in media personalities). If more people had his compassion and willingness to speak their truth with grace this world would surely be a better place. Thank you Dr. Maté, just knowing that you exist gives me hope that I have not found elsewhere.
The humanity and love this man has in his heart and the knowledge he has in his head is what we should all aspire to. Well explained Dr. Maté. Be well and thank you.
Piers Morgan works on Rupert Murdoch's TV shows, which funds the Jerusalem Foundation, which builds illegal Israeli settlements, which is why he frequently questions in support of the Israeli occupation.
Israel controls the Western media
In Ireland we know all about occupation. Our very independence was gained by an armed conflict in 1921 . The Good Friday Agreement is testament to what can be achieved. Many atrocities were committed in the 30 years of conflict in the North . Gabor Mate is a voice of reason, a voice of humanity. God bless Gabor 🇮🇪🇮🇪
God bless your country Ireland as well. A beacon of light in the west.
Yeah, most occupations had to be ended by armed resistance.
The occupiers would NEVER grant freedom to the occupied out of their own volition.
They always have to be FORCED to free the people they occupy.
I think this is why those that come from colonial countries find it so difficult to wrap their heads about how oppressive and suffocating and disheartening and depressing being under occupation is.
The closest thing it can be compared to is slavery, you feel that you lose your freedom, your dignity, your aspirations and dreams, you feel crushed from the inside out.
Respect for you and of course for Dr MATE .
ireland was and is one of this bright light in these dark times where the western constantly betray palestinians and piss on human rights.
What you know about "occupation" is in big opposition what you have now.
So what took you so long ?
I am so proud that he is a fellow Hungarian and shines as an example in this world as a professional in trauma healing but most importantly, an outstanding human being. Have him back on this show, please
That guy is so corrupted by Chaos Gods that his face melts down and you cannot deny he's a devil worshipper xD
@@wlaba272you better put that crack pipe down
@@wlaba272Big man this isn't 40k
Piers, if someone occupied me, my body, my home, my family, how long could I suppress my hostility? How long before the dam burst and I no longer had the ability to withstand the conscious killing of my spirit and physical being? How long could you?
Under these conditions what happens to a person? They either die slowly of no hope, or die trying to gain freedom.
Most of us are mere mortals without the tolerance and patience of people like Mandela, Gandhi, or King.
The lashing out in October was brutal but could not have been unexpected.
My heart goes out to both peoples who are at the mercy of history and unconscious living.
Give me wA different Mandela. It was racism within a country. As for Palestine, which is an occupation, give me a country that was liberated by offering flowers and chocolate to the occupier. The only way to freedom is to fight. Since when was the one who steals your land and house and lives in an innocent citizen?
I didn’t know Dr. Gabor Mate before this interview but after listening to his words I see that there is still some humanity left in this world. Thanks for such a profound explanation on how Palestinians are suffering for decades and no one is there to speak on their behalf. Also, thanks to Piers for letting him communicate his point of view.
Hes such an amazing bookwriter, ive been following him for a long long time, amazing man.
Truly a great guy, I watched some of his videos and lectures on mental health during COVID and it really helped me and many others out
Dr Gabor, Respectively you are incorrect.
hey im from israel. really amayzed what he says. he is decent. he really cares about falstinias. i can feel it. i hope i could understand his point of view. from my point of view as child in israel in israel. all i want is peace, be friend with them. but all i see is that they want to kill me. i dont blame them. their dads fight israel to kill my parents. and thank god my parents won and get them to gaza. i sure they hate me for this. i dont blame them wanting to kill me because their study in school that they should do so. they learn from parents that to duy with a bomb in order to kill me is the bravest holliest thing to do. they live very hard live. and i really cant find solution. this is my point of view. thank for reading
Please learn the history.
Why didn’t Hamas help the Palestinians by going to the UN and discussing the atrocities that Israel was supposedly doing ?
I've watched so many of Piers' interviews on this Hamas-Israeli flare-up.
This one with Dr Mate is the only one that's moved me. The man oozes humility, compassion and honesty. Totally devoid of anger. It's not hard to take onboard his views. Piers is disarmed and docility personified.
We cannot continue to live like this way, always holding our breaths anticipating the next round of atrocities ---"two states" may be a solution, but in my opinion NOT a viable solution anymore, where everyone anticipates to lose something. For those of us who understand politics and administration should look for a solution in the United Kingdom's, Switzerland's and South Africa's system of governance, which are by far NOT perfect, but are unitary system that has devolved governance and EQUITY under the law(s)...
If we give ourselves, 7 years of Truth, Justice and Reconciliation and another 7 years to find a lasting political and administrative system, culminating into a referendum we may just see peace in Israel and The Palestine's in our life times...
@@pk3778I love your idea very much. Practically, there are too many people on both sides of the conflict to ruin it. See how 1993 Oslo accord worked
I love him a lot. I’d suggest you watch his talks on trauma and all types of addiction.
@@pk3778we must try for something. I imagine with all the killing and torture of children isreal has done that it may be possible. Best solution would be for isreal to leave palistinian and stop its illegal occupation. Let them heal from oppression and let isreal focus on its security as that is their priority I don't think they would be ok assimilating palistinians into there world. That was the impression I got when I vitiated. Lives cannot be abused or taken like they have been by hamas and isreal with its punishment of everyone.
Dr. Gabor mate us a true human
Just the fact that Piers doesn’t interrupt or speak over Dr. Máté makes this interview so exceptional and it speaks volume how his calmness affects Piers too. Amazing interview ❤️
Everyone respects Gabor Mate ❤. He’s pure love and compassion. His son Aron Mate is amazing also.
I only wish that Piers had been as calm with Dr. Finkelstein. Much love and respect for both Drs. ❤
@@tcm8804Agree!
Being calm doesn't make a case. Mate is lying about historical facts and use himself as a jew to build his arguments. Who you are doesn't make the things you say solid. Facts makes your case solid.
Hamas
They were starved* and drugged, thrown into damp tunnels and dark attics, coerced and beaten by their captors or by a raging crowd, their skin burned with fiery exhaust pipes so they can be identified and can't escape. They were forced to watch the horrifying videos of terrorist atrocities from which adults escaped in tears, weren't allowed to go to the bathroom for hours, were threatened with rifles and shouts of "quiet!" when they cried. Some came back only whispering, some had bruises and lice, they didn't shower for 50 days, did not see daylight, drank muddy or salty water, a few had severe injuries that were treated in terrifying isolation in hospitals in Gaza, and others who were wounded received no treatment at all. Their captors scared them - telling them that their parents forgot about them, that they don't want them, that they'll be in those tunnels forever, that no one is coming to take them back.
What a sense of relief, a human like Dr Mate is so needed on this planet. The comments make it clear that so many of us believe in peace for humanity, Dr Mate is a seriously wise soul and may insight, understanding and the end of this hellish suffering of innocent people come asap, may the blind, see.
As a Muslim Man I will Say, Hats off to This Jewish Man .. ❤
While Palestine Issues is All About Humanity, And Only Free People in This Wolrd Can Feel ..
Hunger becomes angry if food water is not allowed
As a Buddhist Man, I will Say, Hats off to This Man.. His son, Aaron Mate, is a pretty good guy, too.
As a jew I second that emotion and pray the occupation and terrorism ends and eventually there are no need for borders, armies and division.
Seems like Piers was told in the commercial break to change the topic because the guest was speaking to much facts!
Why the need to indicate whatever you identify as or identify with to show your respect to him? This is because you all consider your groups as opposites of whatever he identifies with hence you felt the need to say "As a bloody this and a stup!d that, hats off to this man".
Dr. Gabor is so humane and just. I have no words. He is a hero a voice for peace. I am moved to tears just listening to him.
He literally spent the whole time saying a whole lotta nothing lmao. He recycles old talking points to appeal to Western audiences that got no skin in the conflict. No solutions, no practicality, no context.
@@zionboutboul👏 🙌 👌
@@lexakellington123 it's really horrible to see everyone agreeing with him when they prolly couldn't even point to Israel on the map. Just wanna act like "in this world full of craziness, I AM on the side that is moderate and makes sense", white savior complex at its fullest. He spreads lies about an occupation that literally don't exist, it aint real, it's fabricated. I guess the Nazis indoctrinated him in the camps and turned him into one of them
He is not just when he repeats lies about the supposed oppression of the 'natives' in Canada. Yes he has a heart for the downtrodden and oppressed no doubt, but we may be sincere also but also sincerely wrong. We need to let our minds leads / think rationally with healthy circumspect mentality/scepticism and not let our feelings.... when we make a choice based on critical and rational thinking, we make much better choices that are concrete and endure, when we makes choices on feelings, well feelings can come and go and thus it is not wise to make choices based on feelings as prime reason. Consider this also: He is lying about the alleged oppression of the called 'natives' here in Canada ... i have studied such history consistently, critically, doing deep digging, and diligently keeping fairness and balance in view, and in hard truth, Gabor is right on Israel, but he's dead wrong about the so called "residential graves" due to supposed abuse etc and more. A site called "C2C JOURNAL" and others like the "Dorchester Review" here in Canada + wokewatchcanada substack article "manufacturing a genocide" and "no pride in genocide + "IRSIG the often ignored truth" + "Archaeologist's clams of genocide and neglect at residential schools easily debunked" by Frontier Centre for Public Policy and more...fully expose the depth of the so facinorous lies by Leftist mainstream media and the govt who controls them and so dishonest so called "natives", that supposedly there was this full scale oppression and supposed magna-homicide of the so called "natives." Please check these sources out that i provided so you may see that Gabor may be right on what has happened to Gazans and the West Bank people by Sionist Israel but NOT right on his claim of what Canada govt supposedly did to the "natives."
World needs more people like Dr. Mate
Actually, I'd argue we need less liars
The world needs people who know what they are talking about and don't have self-interested. This is something that the doctor is very far from.
What's the difference between how we think of Nazi sympathisers and Israeli sympathisers? 10 years!
@@13thcentury pls too rich for you pro i s r@£l to talk.
@@yafitsolomon4428stop being anti semetic to a hcaust survivor.
What an incredibly charismatic, well-educated and kind person this is. thank you Mr. Gabor Mate for being who you are and speaking out regarding this subject!!!
What an incredible human being. One of the best interviews with Piers and possibly the only person I've seen to leave Piers with absolutely nothing to argue with; no retort, deafening silence in the eyes of truth and pure morality.
I totally agree with you...one of the few interviews where Piers behaves himself and as you say he had nothing to argue
No Piers as any rational person couldn't respond to such a delusional, lying psychopath. Just look at the insane stare of this Finkelstein and Soros clone--only difference this guy is or was a doctor--lot of crazy, sick, doctors under professional care.
Check out him with Baseem.
He can't. This man saw the truth, lived there as a settler and could not live with it. He then asked Piers to go there and see for himself. What can Piers argue about 🤷🏽♂️
I mean, he didn't interrupt Jordan Peterson either but that's because he's a fan.
I just got chills. Gabor spoke with such grace and sincerity. I wish we could have more civil conversations like this
As a Palestinian I take my hat off to Gabor in deep respect & reverence. I’ve been saying for decades now why can’t the Palestinians & Jewish people live side by side in peace. It’s because of man’s inhumanity to man-greed, power, money, corruption, etc. It would be an honor to have Gabor as my neighbor. Growing up my mother’s best friend was Jewish as was my brother’s best friend. We are ancestral cousins. Gabor presented us with a wonderful interview without ever having to raise his voice. Much love to you Gabor and may GOD bless you and all the people who pray for Palestine. 🙏🇵🇸
Only under Palestinian authority, NOT under ANY israeli occupation. There was never an israel and there will NEVER be an israel. It's ONLY Palestine.
Historically under muslim rule Muslims Christians jews always lived together peacefully.
They shouldn’t be there
You have a hat? I thought hats were banned by Hamas
@@hmq9052when a donkey speaks
Thanks to Gabor for bringing much needed clarity!
*As a Muslim I am so thankful to Dr. Mate... The world really needs men like him who speak truth despite being himself jewish. Peace is only possible if there were more people like him as Christians, Muslims or Jews. We do not have to hate each other.*
i agree. still, i think he is lacking "accountability" and taking responsibility elements in his approach. Also i didn't hear him offer a solution except for empathy at best. It is not enough against terrorist organizations like Hamas.
as a Jew I agree with you, indeed we are commanded by our one creator to love each other, and I apologize for the failure of so many of my people to accomplish that basic thing
yeah he said end the occupation and the siege, that's the first step of the solution, then there's rebuilding and mutual co-operation towards a sustainable peace. @@עינבשםטוב-פ7צ
He speaks no truth, just cheap propaganda, no connection to reality
Just abandon your ancient religion and use common sense as guide through the world. Or at least make up a new religion that has no justification for massacres and slavery.
I was mesmerized throughout this interview. I couldn't blink. Each and every point was delivered with such poignancy. I have never quite seen anything like it.
Agreed. You perfectly put into words what I and I am sure many others felt too.
I wasn’t … he’s passively excusing the terrorist attack. And leaving out the fact that Hamas wants to kill every Jew in existence (and swears to do so)…
.
And then talks about how the Jews should seek peace as if they’re the problem.
@@amark350 *Zionists, and he's correct in his assessment.
@@amark350 Instead of condemning Hamas, how we about we condemn the loss of civilian life on both sides? Unless you value one side's civilians' wellbeing over the other... up to you.
Coz he speaks from the heart and he is honest and genuine about his views.
Dr Gabor Mate is one of the greatest gifts in our world. Been following him for a decade. Such an amazing human being. I am pleased to see him use his Jewish voice which carries more weight at this time to remind the world of the brutal oppression and occupation the Palestinians have endured for so long.
How old is he?
🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱✌️✌️✌️♥️♥️♥️👍👍💪💪💪✡️✡️✡️
the occupation is not real
@@billmoretz8718 77 years
Sorry he is 80 years old
Dr.Mate shows great courage in telling it like it is even when the narrative goes against his own people, he hopes someday perhaps peace can be reached, the biggest obstacle is facing truth.
Well said.
This is the only interview with no shouting and interruptions and “do u condemn Hamaz”. Dr Gabor is a very knowledgeable and humble human being. Loved it! There is hope for humanity after all ❤
Piers is to embarrassed to ask that, he knows it’s gaslighting
What's wrong with that question? you can condemn Hamas and at the same time criticize Israel.
@oren6978 The question is designed to smear defenders of Palestinian people as terror sympathizers. People like Corbyn who have been standing up for Jews his whole career and any serious journalist would know that beforehand. It’s also an ignorant question if he doesn’t ask others whether they condemn the ethnic cleansing by Israel.
@@Owen7768obviously you cant.. it's antisemitics to even mention israel :(
Imagine him asking a holocaust survivor that
One of the best interviews i have seen in relation to the war on Gaza. Thank you Piers for bringing him, and for being a good listener this time.
Did pathetic Piers actually shut his mouth and open his brain?
Piers is a good listener if the other participant is articulate and respectful. He only interrupts "loudmouth but no substance" trash like mohammed hijab
This interview with such a true humanitarian like Gabe Mate was wonderful.This sad situation should deepen our humanity,not numb it.😢
The world is blind to the TRUTH.
The Jewish people have enriched the world with 213 Nobel Prizes, 5 for Israelis, 15 million Jews in the world and one democratic, developed, modern and progressive country that rose up after the Holocaust. 2 million Arab citizens live in Israel, the only ones who live in democracy, - in the Middle East!!
50 Muslim countries, one and a half billion Muslims. Not a single country is democratic.
What did they contribute to your world? 5 Yes, five Nobel Prizes.
(And I am not allowed to write about 9-11 and October 7 and dozens of terrorist organizations and the immigration of millions to Europe. Because they will block me!!)
What a fantastic, deep human being!Thank you for bringing him on!
Please have him back on the show. This is a man that can heal the hate in the world right now.
Matè, I am truly inspired by your knowledge, wisdom and heart🌷
I'm proud to say that i just saw Dr. Mate in a drugstore, and I had the guts to speak to him. He has the same humble, compassionate, healing way of speaking, in person as well.
wow
Mr Piers Morgan, do you condemn the Israeli government and the IDF for every other day that isn't October the 7th? 😊
No, he doesn't because he keeps repeating Israeli lies e.g. beheaded babies.
Exactly 💯
bit reserved but it seems he does.
It's my show, I won't answer your question 😂
He can’t answer that. His job is in jeopardy.
DR. Gabor Mate explained the terrible situation in Palestine very well with a wise, calming, from the heart and soul voice. What a positive energy, Respect.
As a Palestinan I love this man. This has never been about hate for Jews, we actually care about our cousins but this is literally about humanity. Our children’s future. Our future. Freedom for our beloved Palestine 🇵🇸
Update: to the ones who are ok with the genocide has clearly not understood the entire interview. Message Was from a Jewish holocaust survivor that became a doctor. If you don’t like it don’t travel to Palestine or anywhere in the Middle East. It’s fine. Statement stands for freedom. This in no way means the destruction of anybody but to preserve freedom and justice for all. Don’t like it nobody cares.
So do you want a Palestinian state on pre-67 lines or pre-48?
But it is clearly about arab hate of the Jews. How can you look at history (both pre and post WWI) and not come away with that?
Oh man what they are doing to you is just horrible, just know that the world is not sleeping, we know what they are doing to you, and we hope that some day you guys will be able to get your land, hopes and dreams back, we are all part of the human species/family and we all deserve to have a happy and peacefull life.
They're Not your cousins They're your half brothers.
Same father (Abraham) different Mother's (Sara / Hagar)
In essence Jews (Issac) and Arabs (Ishmael) are "brothers from another Mother "
The book (Bible) teaches that both Isaac Ishmael would be the father of many nations However Ishmael will be Ike a WILD DONKEY and His hand will be againts Every man(infidels) especially His own brothers (family) Jews and Arabs alike. .
Thus this conflict has been ongoing for millennia and unfortunately Wil continue indefinitely.
The Holy Quran and the Hadith ( writings of the prophet Muhammad) teaches Jews and infidels are dogs and Pigs and shoukd submit convert to Islam or be slaughtered.
@@vzwodb1748 ، All Muslims, Christians and Jews live in peace in Palestine ( 1948 )
Immense respect to Dr. Gabor Mate for reminding Piers that the current situation cannot be looked in isolation without the historical context! A brutal history of occupation for the past 75 years.
He is incapable of looking at the big picture
@@dwiz146😂
@@dwiz146 complete distortion of history
@@dwiz146😂😂😂😂
And that can definently be a point, but if u think this at any point justifies oct 7 you are out of your mind and gravely morally confused. If they attacked soliders or military points, you have an argument, but because of what they did and how they did it, they lost all that moral high ground in an instant and in many ways proved Israel right in calling them barbarians and savages.
As a human being, I respect this man for standing with the people of truth, and history will never forget him. History will always remember him.
What a man Gabor Mate is. He breaks down the complex issues into clear understandable facts, referring to history to hopefully allow us all the ability to shape the future of the Middle East.
Holy shit. This interview has single-handedly shifted my perspective on this conflict.
Not from Israel to Palestine but from vengeance to healing.
It may sound crazy but this may be the greatest chance in our lifetimes for incredible global healing. Incredible unity and recognition of our power to heal together and individually.
To heal you must accept the wound. Be with the wound.
If you’re Israeli or right wing reading this, please for the sake of us all, accept that the Nakba opened up a wound and let’s begin to heal it from that place.
Are you a left wing?
You are so naive
So powerful
Doesn’t sound crazy at all. I can feel a shift as well. People are waking up. And it’s giving me tremendous hope, especially for the Palestinian people.
@@__Sobrinotf u laughing at loser
I discovered Gabor in 2007 via a book about "When the Body Says No" and I couldn't put it down, even travelling with it because even though it was a medical book, it spoke to my trauma. He is an amazing human, honest and authentic, and humble. I'm Canadian, and I've managed to find great comfort once again in his speaking to the suffering in Gaza.
He's a fantastic mind and communicator.
Thanks for the book 👍
Suffering can be stopped by simply accepting Israeli peace terms
@@maximr6576BOT
@@maximr6576please 🙏 what are the isrealis peace terms?
Surprising interview! Dr Gabor Maté is a gem! Thank you for having him on your show!
Surprising? Gabor Maté is a well-respected public figure who's held this same discourse for decades. Your comment proves his point: Western media has silenced the Palestinian perspective. I'm glad Piers gave Doctor Maté a platform.
@@lbrtvlldr It was about time for Pierce Morgan It surprises me that Pierce had him on his show!
I know Dr Maté because I follow his interviews since many years! As I said : he is a gem! I am disappointed he did not talk about " The Hannibal Directive" I saw Dr Gabor Maté lately on THE GRAYZONE! And in a Podcast with Dr Cornell West! They were so witty!
Dr Gabor Mate was a gem and then lost the basic humanity of knowing good vs evil.
@doronben-dov5658
No, you lost the basic humanity of good vs evil. You obviously are super biased. You should try to listen better
I lost basic humanity? To understand that there is NO excuse for rape, kidnapping and beheading babies? I was a fan of Dr Mate., teaching is work for my students. Yet he lost it. How can you excuse the barbaric behavior of fundamental Islam? @@itsoktolovechina
👍For Gabor Mate!
👎🏿For Piers.
No words can express how we are blessed to have an intelligent and truthful person like Dr. Gabor Mate in our planet.❤
My one criticism of Mate’ is that he missed an opportunity to point the direction forward from colonialist genocide towards multiculturalism and equality. One reason that Mate’ can speak quickly and barely even begin to describe the 150 year genocide of the First Nations in Canada is because multiculturalism and fighting prejudice and laying down multiculturalism since the somewhat transformative government of Lester B Pearson 1963- 1968. Without Mate’, but with him as witness to what Canada is doing Canada is definitely leading the world in Reconciliation, casting a net to round up men responsible for missing and murdered indigenous women, holding public hearings regarding abuse, and establishing integration of First Nations story telling as legal evidence. These are just a few examples of progress beyond violence and experts talking. Mate’ often forgets to paint himself out of the picture which is necessary when experts weigh in.
Thank you Dr. Matè for saying the truth that many others are afraid to admit. This is a person who supports humanity and people’s rights. Glad to finally listen to someone who can express his fair opinions about this issue without much interruption.
Yes!!! I was so surprised he barely interrupted. A way better experience than his constant interruptance.
Mind Begs the Question:
- If USA/West Leadership
- Defend policies of Starvation,Death Camps,Gas Chambers/White Phosphorus,Pogroms,Ethnic Cleansing,etc
- Pro Democracy or Pro Nazi?
Don’t be fooled. Israel has tried and tried to make peace with the Palestinian people. Palestinian don’t won’t it. Go back to the charter. The likud party charter does not state to kill every Palestinian inhabitants. The Hamas charter does.
*what a mistake in the Qur'an!*
Allah himself testifies that he has a son and he is the son as Christians understand it! Only the Koran writer was too ignorant to know what Son of God means! Allah's word which created everything is Allah himself too! *The Word Allahs which created everything is the Son of God according to Christianity!*
Son of God does not mean that God has a child in Christianity!
*what a mistake in the Qur'an!*
Son of God are 2 titles one referring to the Word of God = God himself and one referring to creation (humans, angels, demons)
I have never seen such a meaningful interview in my life, and I would never forget this.
Thank you Dr. Mate, and thank you piers for inviting such a great man in your show
From a military perspective and as an Afghanistan combat veteran, I don’t think what Israel is doing militarily will work any better than the U.S.’s 20-year, $1 trillion dollar war in Afghanistan did.
Wow. I’m blown away by this interview. Dr. Mate is amazing and the insights he shared about the Occupation and family are full of wisdom and understanding.
The Occupation started when the muslims kicked the jews from their land
Piers to the Israeli: I have a moral conundrum. Piers to the Palestinian: DO YOU CONDEMN HAMAS!!!!!
Well does he??????
@@joeyballs30Do you have any evidence? He's an alcoholic? And even if he was, what does that matter in?
I'm not sure if Pears realizes that he is still completely biased in this matter.
@@SheshiBesh He's in his paymaster's pocket.
@@joeyballs30What are you trying to say. Can you express your complete take on the situation between both sides I am absolutely interested in seeing a potential *prejudice troll* trolling it’s comical at this point
Wow. This guy should be aired on every news channel. He is the real deal.
There is a reason they don't
Yeah, sure
Please explain the ( Hannibal Directive Protocol)!
They did use it on the 7th and afterwards (A helicopter pilot, a female soldier, and a hostage testimonies )!
That won’t happen because the media is controlled by the same people that’s doing the killing
Dr Mate has a beautiful soul and a person with tremendous integrity.
I’m glad Piers gave this wonderful man the opportunity to speak. This needs to be heard worldwide.
I agree, for ONCE Morgan let anyone speak freely. Dr Mate is so True and right about the situation
I love how piers avoids the question of what do you expect them to do. He just cannot get his head around the fact, the suppression leads people to unimaginable things.
He would understand it if they were white.
I love how none of you seem to care what Pal's are actually fighting for and the price they are willing to pay. You think they can be satisfied.
Morgan is like a broken record.
Yeah like how the jews butchered all those german civilians, oh wait...doesnt work with your dumb theory.
You mean the soft bigotry of low expectations?
Yes, yes, yes! I had asked you to invite Mr. Mate to your show... and you did! Thank you, Mr. Gabor Mate for your infinite wisdom, your honesty, your courage, your calm defiance, your presence!!! ❤
@@UFCalltimegreatsShould be Illan Pappé
I'd love to see Rabbi Yaakov Shapiro on here.
@@UFCalltimegreatsAlso Rabbi Yisroel Dovid Weiss.
Speaking so calmly, with so much truth, humanity, compassion for people being traumatised for decades. He is trying to explain several times where the problem began but Pierce like so many in this world just dont want to see or hear the truth
This is the best interview he has conducted. It’s important for the world to see people like him and to hear what he has to offer to the conflict
I used to be a Zionist, I am as you mentioned a holocaust survivor, Zionism was very important to me as a salvation for the Jewish people, until i found out that the state was founded based on opresssion and multiple massacres of the local population. And that is not historically controversial.
The present situation cannot be understood without looking at historical context nor can we move forward if the present occupation and supression of the Palestinians continue.
Sharon your previous guest talks about co-existence, there is no co-existence, there is supression, periodic massacres, land occupation, continuous expulsion of the population from their homes.
This cannot go on. I m not talking about 1948, I m talking about since 1967 and what is going on right now.
Most Israelis are not aware of the history of what the Palestinian have suffered. They dont know that in 1948 there were multiple massacres of large number of people by Israeli forces. They dont know the history of the subjective experience of the Palestinians and in the absence of that knowledge, October 7th just strike them as another horrific anti Semitic event.
If you ask me on how to move forward lets inform ourselves of the actual experience of both sides.
On Every country has the right to defend itself but Israel has no right to impose an occupation on people. In 1956 there was a great Hungarian revolution against Russian occupation, did Russia has the right to defend itself against the Hungarian revolutionaries?
When we are talking about Israel's right of defense, we are taking isolated Palestinian actions but we are not saying that this population also has the right to defend itself against the occupation. I m not justifying the event on Oct 7, I am talking in absence of historical awareness, it all just looks like Israel defending itself.
But against whom? Against the population that has been massacring in the number of thousands for 80 YEARS, and taking their lands, destroying their homes, jailing their children and torturing them.
That's the history. Unless we know that its all looks like this poor little country trying to defend itself.
Yugoslavia has gone through horrific atrocities but the are living together now. There are issues to be worked out but the minimum is the ending of the occupation and inhumane siege of Gaza and International Law has to be respected. International Law is very clear that this occupation is illegal. That has to be the basis of any future agreement. If Israeli can live within the borders that are internationally recognized I believe peace is possible.
We keep talking about Hamas Charter. Did you know that the Likud Charter the ruling party in Israel excludes a Palestinian entity west of the Jordan River? So lets get rid of both charters and lets start on the basis of recognition and peace and ending of this unspeakable brutal occupation .
There is no possibility of that until the international community and particularly Israel's big brothers the UK and the US stop supporting its illegal brutal inhumane and rapacious occupation. It cant happen without some pressure.
Most Israeli are simply not aware, i have been to Israel talk to people they have no idea whats happening a few miles away from where they are sitting in Tel Aviv or Jerusalem having coffee and they have no idea how those people under occupation are living. Its not that they are not capable of being aware but like most people, they just not. I m saying that unless we fully get the Palestinian experience historically and throughout the decades and into the present moment, we can't possibly understand what is going on here.
In 2005 there was a study appeared on the Journal of World Psychiatry looking at traumatized populations under war conditions, the most traumatized children in 2005 this is before Hamas gained power in Palestine and in Gaza, the most traumatized kids were in Gaza. This population has been traumatized severely, of course they're full of rage, i m not justifying anything they did but I m saying what do we expect from this population that's been surpressed and tormented and crucified for decades.
Why you dont talk of the many peace talks israel had with palestiniens and was not accepted.. today they would have had a country … instead they attacked Israel .. sending thousands of missiles .. palestiniens are not guiltless .. this is not a war for land this a a constant plead to not recognize israel as a state .. you need a partner to make peace
@@soniacharleschocron9749 They don't talk of the many peace talks israel had with palestiniens and was not accepted it because this doesn't serve the Palestinian false narrative.
Gabor is another biased anti-zionist that pretends to be neutral but is in fact a far leftist with one-sided views and "knowledge", plus lots of exaggerations and false "historical facts" in his statements.
Israel had several leaderships that went above and beyond to have this conflict resolved. No leadership on the Palestinian side really wanted this resolved and some Arab and Muslim countries leaderships thrive from maintaining this conflict going on for ages.
To use a fashionable quote: Palestinian suffering didn't happen in a vacuum. They worked very hard on being horrible neighbors.
So many lies in this text by Gabor
@@maximr6576where do you live?
This man's wisdom and compassion is what the world needs right now.
Gabor Mate never fails to amaze and impress me.
Speaking compassinately but 100% bullshit. He is just another kapo. It's a genre now...
Israel should leave . They can’t defend themselves because they are the occupying party end of story
Mate represents the WISDOM we desperately need. It's not that hard to understand, but listen! He speaks the truth!
I could listen to this guy talk all day, the way he speaks gently and with understanding
13:22
Amazing how it’s understandable except for when it applies to African Descendants of Slaves !
Palestine 80 years
Blacks
200 years plus !
@@rykson161 Same comment copy and paste all over..... Not tired of that??
What is your point? Trying to discredit Dr. MATE, simply because he is not repeating the official zinosr lies???
@@rykson161 Comparing the descendants of formerly enslaved Africans with the Israel-Palestine conflict doesn't make sense. They're completely different issues. You could compare Palestinians with Native Americans and that would make more sense. But I don't really understand what correlation slavery has with the current events.
All respect for Dr Gabor Mate. You make me believe again in humanity. I hope that more people will understand the atrocities and trauma that Palestinians went through for more than 70 years.
The calmed composure of Gabor Mate is mesmerizing. His ability to deconstruct the war as a "stock and flow" problem, and showcasing the ignorance of snapshot judgment into one event. You can't simply judge the proportionate response of retaliation in contrast to a singular event.
The way Piers keeps repeating "how about Oct 7th" makes me suspect that he's part of the Israeli propaganda machines and rewarded for doing so.
Because we were just supposed to roll over and get over the death of the killing of 1400 of our people, the beheading of our babies and the kidnapping of our women. You guys would’ve been on the sides of Nazis. Jewish life doesn’t matter to you guys.
You can if you have cognitive dissonance, that’s when it becomes “too complex”
So true. Well said!
One of the best, if not “The” best, interviews Morgan has made so far. Hat-off to Dr. Gabor Mate. When one listens to his words and idea’s, he realises that humanity is still good.