Is Minecraft Story Mode A Bad Game?
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 18 ต.ค. 2024
- Minecraft Story Mode was developed by Telltale Games with the idea of you choosing your own path, but almost every choice means nothing...
🟧 My Patreon: / mastermatthew 🟧
🟦 My Discord: / discord 🟦
🟣 My Twitch: / mastermatthew457 🟣
#minecraft #minecraftstorymode
![The Wall Song ร้องข้ามกำแพง | EP.215 | พาเวล นเรศ - พูห์ กฤติน | 17 ต.ค. 67 [1/5]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/IUzrjuf60P4/mqdefault.jpg)
A lot of people have gotten this video in their recommended recently (which is awesome!) so if you did enjoy please do check out my other videos. I do a bunch just like this one on other topics along with other videos too.
Just subbed my guy :)
I just feel very sad that nobody mentions about it anymore. Like the witherstorm, that witherstorm in season 1 GAVE ME CHILLS!! It was much better and menacing looking than the one in the actual game. It’d be great if they did add a little touch to the witherstorm in the actual game, and the choices really matter in this game. Even though it died out in 2019 I just want a few mini episodes of it like “Behind The Scenes” where you choose either Petra or Jack to save in season 2 (In the sea chamber). Even if I look back to it now it seems that its all fading, I remember when I was kid, I wanted to keep going with the story on my ipad but I needed a purchase to continue the game. This game will never go away from heart.
Yes i love this game to bits
try cracker's witherstorm !
If you have a computer, there is a mod by nonamecrackers that is about the wither storm! It has a mini-boss and even more!
the wither and witherstorm are different things
Minecraft story mode definitely wasn’t the best game but it brings back so many memories
At no I disagree I love it with a passion I am always yearn for a 3rd seaseon
@@lsdeez374 same
It was not a game it was a series
It gives me da chills
It gives me da memories
I still attribute MCSM 2's improvements to the change in writers. Eric Stirpe's got enough writing savvy to make competent children's literature, which shines throughout the game. There are a few clever tricks pulled to make even the annoying characters worth paying attention to, whereas MCSM 1 typically resorted to established friendships to sell players on its main cast. The main exception to this rule, Lukas, is probably the most liked character in the game because one- he's largely unassuming and helpful- and two- the player actually has to earn a positive relationship with him, and is rewarded for it.
In MCSM 2, there are several characters designed from the ground up to be unlikeable at first, but who players may still become friends with if they so choose. MCSM 1 went so far out of its way to make a point about trust (drawn from IRL experiences in a minecraft server, if I'm not mistaken) that it does so at the player's expense by largely denying them their autonomy, let alone their participation. In MCSM 2, there is a strong theme about friendship and how it can be affected in the long-term, but it actively queries the player more frequently on their feelings towards the subject and accounts for the player's responses, better qualifying the overall experience as a game than its predecessor.
I love this game. It’s not perfect and some say it was a cash grab, but I find it interesting and visually pleasing and VERY nostalgic. Some hate it and yeah it is a bit cringe, but it was a good idea and I like the concept.
I thought it seemed like a nice passion project that was limited due to it's time and budget. Tell Tale didn't have much money during its time. Which is a pity as there are animations that are in much better quality for free
They should stop the word cringe
Honestly the only problem i have with it is the writing, like i get its made for 12 year olds but like, could have been better. Other than that i love the story and the writing has some really good lines in there
@@caramelcandys yes true
I love it too u can be 2 Jesses boy or girl
When I was younger I was addicted to this game. Looking back now even though it is not as good, it will always be pure nostalgia.
same I really wish I can still play it
Season one turned me into a big fangirl and i'm still am
season two was unexpected to me I thought this game will be one of those games that won't have more seasons when I seen season two news my brain exploded.
I’m watching through the game now and honestly, so far, I legitimately DON’T GET what all these people are trash talking it for. The main thing I’ve heard people criticize is “cringy dialogue”, but besides only a few parts, I always take it as the writers being “cringy” on PURPOSE because that’s the joke. In fact, the writing almost kinda reminds me of a tamer version of Phineas and Ferb. I think it has to do with the way the characters are really sarcastic and get into bickering fights about the most random things.
And I’m an adult and an animation student who just found out the show exists about a year and a half ago, so I’m not biased by being someone who watched it as a little kid and couldn’t tell the difference between good and bad writing lol
I think my only problem with this game is its artstyle and sometimes beyond cringe dialogue
@@empty9926 I mean….half the time the silliest lines of dialogue in the game, you only get if you either stand there and say nothing when you’re supposed to say something, or pick silly choices on purpose. It’s almost like the game is getting back at you for making a stupid choice by giving you an equally snarky/stupid/cringy answer back:)
@@kaylasilverstein4137 thats why i said “dialogue”
Not awnsering creates funny moments but its not dialoge
Bruh if you can't point out the obvious flaws with the Minecraft Story Mode games, then you are obviously blinded by nostalgia. Literally the plot of the game is your generic children's movie with a Minecraft coat of paint. None of the characters are at all interesting. Literally replace all of them with different character tropes they are representing and nothing will change. And the dialog is cringey yes, but there is just so much of it where you can't pass it off as "intentional"...
@@Player-jh4ko no, it’s impossible for me to be blinded by nostalgia because I only first found out this game existed a couple years ago
In my opinion minecraft storymode was really fun and making your own adventure increases my imagination. I am fine if people dislike.
It didn't make your own adventure, there's only two endings to season 2 and season one had the same ending.
@@gamerstheater1187 he said "make your own adventure" not "your own ending".
@@gamerstheater1187 adventure not ending
@@DieselMonstar965 even then the story is the same, just with slight differences that play little in the story
@@gamerstheater1187like every game, you can only make so many alternatives, it isn’t real life, you don’t have thousands of different choices.
I remember staying up all night for the new episodes to drop and then watch other people’s perspectives the next day
When I first saw episodes 1-4 for season 1, I thought it was 'okay'... I didn't care for most of the characters.... but when episode 5 came along and focused on LUkas, Petra, and Ivor, I liked it more.... just preferred them over axel and olivia. Loved season 2, don't even need to explain why.
It’s the definition of dumb fun. It’s not the best but everything is entertaining and the cast are lovable dorks
best way to sum it up really
I recently had a lot of nostalgia for the game so I got the disc version of seasons 1 and 2 (cause the digital version is now unavailable) and aside from nostalgia, I really love the game. The soundtrack for both seasons is great, I especially love how the composers tweak the same few themes into different versions for emotional moments, not to mention the combat music or the calm ones. As for the dialogue, I always felt like its cringe in season 1 because the characters are awkward and cringe themselves, even with their friends (like in episode 1 where they have their awkward handshake). It slowly becomes better, especially in season 2, as the characters gain confidence and find their courage to be heroes. The plot for the first part of season 1 is a coming of age story mixed in with action-adventure and I really love that. The second half is very fun cause the portals plot line allows for the story to explore fun concepts that would not work as well on the main world, like skyblock or a murder mystery. And while the ending for the first is always mostly the same, I see that almost as destiny. The main plot hinges on the characters getting to a point of maturity, therefore defeating the Wither Storm and becoming heroes. In the second one they are more mature so some of the issues with season 1 are not there. I really resonate with the second season and Petra's dilema, as I've struggled with similar friendship issues in the past, and nowadays. The whole story draws parallels between Jesse and his friends with Romeo, like on the clip on the cabin, and it shows kind of the different possibilities that could come from missing your friends, even to the point of anger. So yeah, I see how the plot, writing and sometimes gameplay (the xbox season 1 game is very glitchy) have their issues, but I love the story and the themes behind it. :)
The only thing i dont like abt s2 is how axel's personality has been stripped down to "tee-en-tee"
He's now a Magnus bootleg
True and i prefer the old olivia voice and aspect
Yeah. Plus Axel and Olivia barley did anything that season. Also the old Olivia voice was a lot better in my opinion idk why they would ever change it.
@@MG1K I guess the old voice actor was busy or just didn't want to come back
@Mega_Gamer_1000 Axel and Olivia were barely relevant to the plot after the first four episodes because according to Eric Stirpe (head writer for MCSM), Axel and Olivia weren’t as liked with this test audience as Lukas and Petra were, and the execs wanted him to axe them. He didn’t want to because he knew they still had fans, but he couldn’t do anything about it. (In case you’re wondering, Lukas wasn’t in S2 because his voice actor was becoming a father.)
And about Olivia’s voice actor: Martha Plimpton was busy, I don’t remember with what, but something related to Hollywood I think? I reckon they should’ve maybe got a different voice actor more similar to Plimpton’s voice (no disrespect or offence to Natasha Loring ofc) but eh, I’m kinda used to it by now.
Sorry for the long comment lol
Originally I was not a fan of season two. Now that Im older tough, and had a lot of friend groups fall apart, I appreciate it a lot more. Especially the ending. It's great.
I recently played the Season 2, it was the best 3 days of my life, playing an adventure my younger self could only dream off. As a kid I kept my promise of not watching any episode before I played them because I didnt want to get spoilers.
Whoops, got a little too emotional.
I don’t think it’s bad but it does have its flaws. Season 1 has a pretty weak story, but it gets better later on. I think Season 2 has a much stronger story and has twists. Season 2 also has more choices that matter. Even though it isn’t perfect I liked it, and I have to appreciate that it started Minecraft’s spin-offs. I know it probably won’t happen, but I do wish a season 3 would happen to help wrap things up, season 2 left a few things open with no answers.
I really liked the first game and its deqr to my heart the 2nd game fixed alot of the problems but I still really like the 1st one the plot in the 1st one wasn't anything special but it still was enjoyable at times it wasn't really cringe but sometimes the jokes where just really childish the animations and fights where cool seeing how actual characters would fight using blocks and such and it had this really appealing survival aspect about it which made me like it cause minecraft the characters aren't as bad as people say they are stereotypes but meh i like Jesse well in my opinion the 2nd game was kinda chaotic and I found it boring it lacked the epic ness it once had but I still think the 2nd is better it had ACTUAL CHARACTER DEVELOPMENT well I think its a good game but it was really bad at times
I never talk about the game that much because Sometimes I feel like I’m the only one who remembers that game. Like everyone is so DEAD silent, I even struggle to find RECENT videos of it online. I wish the game never died, the way season 2 ended was perfect. I really think they could have FIT a season 3! If only mojang didn’t interfere with them. I’m actually depressed about that game. It died so quickly and unnecessarily.
Sometimes I wonder if another company would buy the title and gain rights back from mojang. But the opportunity seems as if it’s fading, since the game isn’t that appealing now in 2020.
The game has became so unrelevant I even hesitate to talk about it on my channel, because I feel like people are gonna make fun of me for liking a game that died out years ago, and is barely mentioned.
Yea
They didnt interfear with them, the company got shut down
@@mr.preston1632 they did. Mojang wasn't satisfied with the Minecraft Storymode sequel, so now they revoked Telltales rights to continue the Title "Minecraft", because Mojang owns it. This is what caused telltale to shutdown. their financial income was relying on this project but now their legally forced to discontinue it which caused them to go bankrupt.
The part about someone buying the title is what I think about sometimes
I was in your situation, until I found a decently active and chill mcsm server. Really glad I found it. That's the only place I can talk about mcsm to other people
Minecraft Story Mode wasn't perfect, but it had a good soundtrack and memorable characters. The thing I liked the most about it was the ability of making choices that influenced the storyline. It's a shame this game isn't available anymore. It's just pure nostalgia and memories.
I haven't played any of the games except for the first episode but I did watched TH-camrs like DanTDM playing the games up until around the middle of Season 2. I kind of lost interest of the series and even decline an option to get all the episodes for free during the shutdown of TallTale Games. I didn't forget the game entirely, I even remembered some of the music in Season 1. Then around the summer of 2020, I decided to go look for music and Minecraft Storymode came to mind. After looking up the OST of Season 1, I like the song used in it. Then later I listened to the Season 2 OST and I liked it too. It then revamped my interest to the series and I watched a certain TH-camr (may he rest) playing through the games, all of the memories of what I have seen before my disintrest came back. Then he started to play the rest of Season 2 and I was amazed by the music's usage and story. The ending did actually made me feel something, a sort of sorrow and glee. I like the games for what it is and especially I love the music used, the seasons have its own style of music and the season 2 OST sounds more exciting and that there is a more serious tone. The season 1 OST has more of a loose but charming beat (probably because of my past experience with the game), it sounded a bit quirky and (personally) a more closer attempt to repliacate Minecrafts OST at the time. Though one thing I did liked about both was their chase music; for some reason I like good chase music or fitting chase music, it is odd. The story, I can see why people dislike the S1's story for being a bit generic, predictable, and its "cash-grabiness," I and some of us here at least mind the game. I like it for being different and humorous especially if it is based off of Minecraft because I didn't have any expectations on the game for a grand story although I and many would appreciate it did. And the later episodes do act like afterstories (I don't know this term) of what are the characters up to now with more interesting ideas and scenarios. S2's story expands what S1 laid out with bigger stakes, a more powerful antagonist, lives on the line, tougher enemies, and fleshed out characters. The ideas were expanded from previous ones like the witherstorm with it's command block and apply possible modding or advanced commands. It would be interesting to interpret the different portal as a metaphor for different Minecraft servers. The music applied here is has a serious undertone compared to the more homey and upbeat tone of S1. It feels like the different OSTs show the themes and identity of the season.
S1 OST shows an upbeat type of mood with dramatic parts being more on the serious tone, sometimes the tracks can be a bit chaotic in-game but it presents itself as a rollercoaster of fun and challenge; in my eyes a story that can be made up in a Minecraft world, makes sense that we have nostalgia for the game.
S2 OST has a serious take with how the music is presented. The locations have more depth in their themes and dramatic moments are more serious and a bit freighting in some cases. Showing that the game is more mature and fleshed out on everything that was set up from S1. Though it still has its S1 charm, it seems to me to have a serious undertone. By around 2017, Minecraft was starting to "fall," we moved on.
Now this comment (if anyone cared to read it) is to informally (at mid-night) express my personal thoughts of the games. I enjoy them and I hope that you all found something worth while in this video, comment, and the games. If I didn't, I am sorry. Maybe I may make a video about it or a better "essay" analyzing the good and the bad of Minecraft Story Mode S1&2 but for now this is all that I will publically state. See ya everyone and Minecrafters... I still don't know why I like good chase music- anyways byeee.
I was so obsessed with this game as a kid when the game released. It's super nostalgic for me. I enjoy it as dumb fun basically. I don't take it as seriously as I used to when I was younger. I just laugh out loud at many scenes because the game's so corny sometimes it cracks me up. It's so awkward yet so charming. Its story is nothing amazing but it's fun to poke around the different choices, and seeing how characters act in this minecraft world. It has its ups and downs but I personally don't think it's really as bad as people think. It's a children's game that is fondly remembered by mostly teens nowadays who have grown up with it. I admit I'd love to see a comeback some day with a new season, but it's just dumb casual fun to sit and replay this game every once in a while and laugh at its cheesy-ness. I have to say visually it's super charming, and the animations, though sometimes buggy, are super fluid and smooth for minecraft characters. It's hard to take them seriously sometimes but I like being immersed in their dumb world while playing. It's a mixed bag but it can be a charming good time if you just want to chill and get nostalgic over it or just enjoy some quirky awkward minecraft inspired fun. I always loved those quick time events though haha.
Sorry for how messy this comment was, it's 3 in the morning and I'm very tired but I just felt like saying a few words on this dumb mess I'm so passionate about😭
Season 1 was good but I do agree season 2 was superior in almost every way
Season 2 kinda was bad, it was shorter and the characters end up going back to square one
@@gamerstheater1187 yeah season two also had a worse story it was like they had twenty ideas for the antagonist and they implemented them to their lowest potential and you barely know what's happening until episode 4 and the episode quality is just worse than season one so here's an episode ranking
Season 1
E1: Good
E2: Good
E3: Great
E4: Ok
E5: Good
E6: Best
E7: Great (Best Great)
E8: Great (Worst Great)
Season 2
E1: Bad
E2: Worst
E3: Ok
E4: Good
E5: Ok
Season 1 Average: Good
Season 2 Average: Mediocre
This is just my opinion but it proves that season 2 is worse (in my opinion)
@@gamerstheater1187 true
@@filipfilip1507 i strongly agree
but hay at least Season two is good and impressive, it's quite darker and a bit sadder than season one.
I am shocked by the amount of sheer hatred for this game and most negative reviews are illogical in my opinion, but i can understand were the rest are coming from. I think the game is fine. The entire story can be separated into two parts: the witherstrom saga and the old builders saga. The witherstorm saga is legendary but the old builders saga is just a repeat of the previous with a rather underwhelming ending. But overall, its a good game and the bad dialogue that people are complaining about so much is honestly pretty forgettable once you get into the story. It has good graphics, likeable characters and topnotch music.
I loved both seasons.
Then I got common sense and realized the first game was a burning pig in a dragon costume
and the second game is actually now in my top 20 favorite games
Minecraft Story Mode is one of the best games I ever played. It's a game about friendship and working together to achieve a common goal and being there for one another.
I like how MSM takes characters in the minecraft world and uses the elements from the original game... like night time having the monsters come out.... building with blocks even if it isn't possible in our world, it's possible in theirs...... If they continue MSM it'd be nice to see more adventures.
The game was flawed. Very much so. But there’s something special about it. Yeah the writing isn’t amazing and the story isn’t revolutionary, but it’s charming. The game is charming. A little box of beauty and ugly that I always find myself coming back to. It’s something you go return to for comfort and nostalgia.
I think season 2 had less annoying characters was because they weren't defined by a single personality trait, like many in season 1 were.
Petra is obviously the most complex
Jack is admittedly not as interesting and never really changes(huge missed potential for him to change a lot after Vos was revealed to be the Admin, but it was hardly touched on)
Nerm is just there, but he's not annoying.
Radar, as annoying as he is, is likeable. He's just trying to prove himself and help others, even if he's horrible at it.
Xara felt like an actual human being
The villain is so much more complex and interesting than the Witherstorm
Admittedly Stella is completely dead weight as she stays shallow the whole time(she literally turns good if you make a single choice lol), and Axel and Olivia are still bad. But it's clear that improvements were made all across the board in season 2.
Also am I the only one who considers season 1 to be the first 4 episodes, and episodes 5-8 to be a season 1.5 of sorts? A lot of people lump them together as a way to say season 2 was bad for being shorter, but 1-4 and 5-8 are so irrelevant to each other.
To be fair Stella at least has a little bit more charm in her personality, and she "somewhat" develops based off your choice whenether you truly trust her or not. Shes pretty funny to assist aswell (at least to me)
Axel and Olivia in the other hand only counterpart two of the Order of the stone with their personalities deep as two sheets of paper. Staying static for an entire season and cut off for most of the second.
I did see development in Jack; I think the problem was with him not really getting much screen time to revolve around the arc.
@@randomality77 valid
@@MCA_Critic Thanks! And apart from that, and what you said about Stella (I like her for the reasons the person above said), I agree with everything else you said.
And yes I know this is a month late lol
Season 1 and 2.
One of the best game i have ever played, legit fire almost all the time
those times were gold times when Minecraft Story Mode was released, I liked both games a lot
I dont know why but whenever I revisit the armory in episode 4 in season 1 i dont know why but it just feels awesome, your given the chance to have the power single handedly destroy the wither storm without any gimick and the score matches perfectly with the scene it just invokes the sense of you are going to be the strongest man ever alive it just really sticked with me
It's with sure a treasure, especially Episode 3
I really love season two, season 1 is awkward but still super epic and memorable, one of my favourite nostalgic games
I love the game. It may not be perfect and it has a few quirks here and there, but in a few moments and scenes, it still conveys what it's trying to convey.
It's a real shame we will never get any more Seasons.
I find making other games based on Minecraft kinda pointless since you can already do anything there. There is an adventure map recreating Story Mode in vanilla Minecraft.
it's for the lore I guess
Hard disagree for multiple reasons...
@@Player-jh4ko Could you explain the reasons?
@@jeromevaleska2014 My reasoning for my disagreement is because while yes mods are very open with what you can do, you can never fully recreate a game 1 to 1 with a mod.
@@jeromevaleska2014 Also there are many advantages of creating an entirely new game using a different engine rather than using the engine that most mods uses.
I did not know there was a lesson in Minecraft story mode 2!
Don't forget that Jack and Nurm are the first canonical couple in Minecraft Story Mode
Man I love this game so much. The whole idea of the wither storm really got me intrigued. The fact that a pig can make grown men cry is amazing
9:35 So in my opinion, I like season 1 better BUT your words really changed my opinion and now I agree it is a mess. But despite this, I still like it more. It's probably my emotions coming in but I don't think it's all that bad tbh. I think Petra and Jessie's relationship was really touched on. Not as much as in season 2 ofc but I enjoy shipping male Jessie and Petra (dont ask) Minecraft Story Mode s1 helped me get through a rough time in my life. It was something I could turn on and laugh, cry (yes Reuben's death was surprising and sad to me.... still is dont judge me), and I was entertained. I was offended at first but as I watch the video I agreed. Mostly. Nostalgia and how it helped me personally might be blinding me but I think the wither storm, that one TH-camr episode, and the references to Minecraft really made it fun and gave that "I- I understood that reference". Especially with episode 8 that's my second favorite episode. Season 2 I didn't care for but I played it and I really enjoyed it. Yet still I thought it was ok. But watching this video, I think that season is nearly perfect. Like you said, characters, dialogue, and the freaking ENDING was f#cking amazing! Not to mention how relatable Petra was. When she confessed to Jessie it was lowkey the best scene. So emotional I could tell the writers were actually trying. This story also actually had a message unlike the first one. The choices felt like actual choices... but anyway thanks for this video. And thanks for reading if you see this...
Its a pretty fun game for me, even if its writing is messy but thats what makes it fun in my opinion. i usually play story-type games like undertale and ofcorse minecraft storymode so i was hooked to the game even if its storyline wasnt that good.
When this game first came out I was amazed then s2 I loved it I played through the games at least 3 times but after playing other games like Detroit become human I realized that I was 7 and I liked anything minecraft
The only reason someone would like this game despite how bad it is is the music I must say they really went above and beyond with music score, some of the tracks I still remember even after 8 years like the title screen music and many others from both s1 and s2
Also I do agree that s2 is much better than s1 even though it still has many flaws and writing issues it's still an actually decent game that tried to do something creative not the lazy cash grab that is s1
S2 should have been the actual minecraft story mode, s1 should have never existed
This game is amazing. I'd constantly replay the game on my XBOX, PC, Phone.. Borderline obsessed with Jesse and the gang. This game is criminally underrated, the biggest event with this game I can think of is the Chapter 6 cameos blowing up.
I love this game, the (sometimes) cheesy writing cracks me up and.. well I have no other words, this game's story is very long but hooks you in to bring you into the next episode.
I wouldn't say that it's the best game ever, but it is quite far from being a bad game. Maybe it's nostalgia talking, but I think MCSM just has a certain charm to it. The music, the characters, the sets, the writing... It's something of a simpler time. I'm sad it had to go out the way it did. I'd just like for Minecraft: Story Mode to be sold again, even if we never get a third season or anything.
When I was 12 I really like Minecraft story mode but looking back at it it was kinda a mess, i can see why some people like it and some people don’t, and kinda wanna play it from beginning to end.
I used to like it back in like 2016 - early to mid 2017, then in like later in 2017 not like it, now I’m mixed.
I feel like MineCraft Story Mode could’ve been much better, allowing the player’s choice have more affect, better character’s.
I have nostaglia for Season 1, but Season 2 is better I feel, for reason’s you explained.
Basically the only reason I like Season 1 is because it created one of my favourite boss mobs.
The Wither Storm
1:05
I feel like I just got flash banged. My body had the biggest physical reaction.
Yes, definitely a bit of the nostalgia talking, but I loved the game. I bought it when it game out on my IPAD in 2015! That's right, I didn't even have a console. I was a broke 8 year old. I absolutely loved it. I played episode 1 about a million times, and made about all the choices you could. Then the 2nd episode came out, and I played that one about a million times. Then I got a ps3 and played it on that, which was a million times better. Then I replayed the entire game about a million times. Then I took a break. Then the famed episode 5 'Order Up' came out, and I played that. I loved it. Then the rest of the episodes, and I loved those too. It was just sort of missing something, and I didn't know what it was. The ending of season 1 was just unfulfilling.
Then season 2 came out. I was so fucking exited. I couldn't wait for it to come out on ps4, so I spent birthday money to get it on my laptop, and I played it on that. I was 11 at the time. I opened the game, saw the opening logo, listened to the theme, and fell in love. The theme alone gave a newer vibe. I basically exploded when you got 3 new character options. I played the first episode and I already knew that it was going to be a better game. I absolutely loved it. My favorite episode to this day is S2E4 'Below the Bedrock' because of the weekend when I played it. It was Veteran's Day weekend 2017, and I was with my dad. He served in the Navy in the 80s. I had a 4 day weekend. I played it while watching a movie with him. We'd seen the move a million times, so I could concentrate on the game a bit more. Hands down one of the best games I've ever played. Season 1, I agree, is not as good. Lazier writing, and sort of a cash grab, but loads of nostalgia, and I loved episode 5. They clearly put more effort in Season 2 with the choices that actually change the game, and just the overall story and animation. I think that MCSM is a great game, and I hope they make a season 3.
Honestly this game was one where the episodes that were good I could play over and over again
I could replay season 1 so much I could practically play it blindfolded. It certainly is a massive nostalgia trip to remember, and yeah season 1 ended the same a lot of the time but I could still feel the stuff happening
Example: apparently if your a jerk to Lukas through the first 4 episodes, he kinda acts like a jerk at the end of episode 4
Season 2, I could replace any of those episodes so much and never feel bored, but this game overall was some of my favorite childhood memories
Even if it’s a long shot, with telltale technically back.. part of me does really hope for a season 3 of Minecraft story mode, it’s a long shot, but I can hope
I like the game, not even for nostalgia sake, I genuinely like the story and the whole aspect of the game. Surprised so many people hate it. I also really love season 2.
Yea season two had a much better story season 1 story was kinda weak but there was good parts in it liked season 2 better tho
I loved and still love this game.Maybe it isn't the best but for me this game was perfect.
One last comment, the minecraft story mode is about jesse as a character, you basically go from living in a tree to sort of owning a city and having an armory. Might not be 10/10 like i think for everyone but its def not bad. Ofc i wanted jesse to end up F@#% petra getting a child and also keeping his powers for the great of good.
In my opinion both of the seasons are good. I absolutely love this game, although you can't choose your ending in the first one doesn't mean it's horrible. It has an original plot line and it has its weird parts but it makes the game funny. I don't understand why the first season is getting alot of hate-
Also your making your own adventures not making your own endings (besides season 2) -🤓
**Cries in never getting Season 3**
I personally loved it, it was so fun to watch and the either storm was incredible. I don’t see how it’s bad. Like there doesn’t seem to be anything i see wrong. Maybe I can see some flaws, but for the most part it was a amazing experience. Especially for nostalgia purposes
2:58 that caught me off guard
I was worth it
The memories
It was not perfect game
But still holds many memories
Fix ur grammar . Your comment was so damn cringe to read
True
Season 1 isn’t that great, but hey it’s a part of my childhood. It’s a very enjoyable game. Season 2 however, Holy shoot that’s an actual pretty decent 7/10.
I gotta say it mn, Minecraft story mode was definitely one of the games of all time
Please tell me I wasn’t the only kid that was obsessed with Ivor-
I wish I played Season 2 when I had the chance
You know you can get a cracked version
@@charlescalvin1186How? From where?
You can still order physical copies of both seasons on amazon
@@jennyfisher3765 but I would still have to find someway to download the episodes that's the problem
you can still play it i just downloaded all the episodes a few weeks ago for free
I love minecraft story mode it is one of the best games in history and of my favorite it deserves more love and it needs to come back
I can totally relate to Petra foe her complaints about loneliness and faded friendships.
In my opinion I loved both games
Music: ✔
Visuals: ✔
Characters: 😕
Gameplay: ✔
7/10
it's just that fun
Finally someone talking good about story mode and I think too that the first season was a really bit bad but the final moments of the season was awesome, I cried wen eligard died and the pig too I Just really sad that I couldn't play the full game on the computer because I Just watched the first season on netflix so moments that were different on the game itself I couldn't feel than. I hope someday minecraft story mode come back because is not Just nostalgia is a different angle from a minecraft world that we all see
I am a coder and I want to make my own season 3 but I do not have the time and I have limited knowledge in animation. Plus, dialogue would be very limited unless I make an AI model for all the characters (which I'm too lazy to do), but if I had enough commitment I could very well change it to reality.
I love this game forever to bits i just finished it last week and i feel sad😢 i want a s3. I'll never be bored with this game, this is my favourite telltale game right next to tales from the borderlands
Same
Keep up the great work Matthew!
Also new patron 🎉
I actually really liked it! I'm fine if other people think it's bad, but I liked it and had a fun time with it
First bit with the wither storm was good IMO, the rest of it kind of descended into madness
To clarify, i mean the episodes with the wither storm as the antagonist
To be completely honest, I don't know why people think the game is bad at all, to me every aspect of it is really good and it's genuinely an amazing game
this is so late but i'v gotten into mcsm again recently and i will admit it has.... MANY flaws. especially season1; the animation, minecraft logic, some of the characters were cringe af, but the story was pretty good, it took minecraft to another level by taking elements already there and changing them like the witherstorm and portal system. its not meant to be the best game ever but its simple enough and enjoyable. it got ALLOT better in season 2 as you said and i'll admit that i like it allot more than season 1. it gets too much hate tbh, idc if people dont like it but RELAX FFS its just a silly minecraft game 😭
it was made in a different time though, you can't really call the characters cringe because it was based off of 2015 standards.
I love the game. Season 1 Rating: 6.5/10
Season 2 Rating: 9/10 (season 2 is so much better)
looks like we have a jetra shipper here :3
I think it had some great ideas and was very heartfelt but wasn’t executed the best. There’s some inconsistencies(Petra supposedly fighting a wither to get a wither star for Lukas in ep 1 but not knowing the recipe for a wither later in that same episode being one of them) and it was always kind of annoying how the second half of season 1 was basically season 1.5 with very little tying it together.
ivor having a completely different personality in the portal arc was quite jarring. Still love him though, inconsistent little rat of a man.
I look at it and see endless possibilities for fans to swoop in and make it better. I’m honestly surprised there’s not more Mcsm re-writes in the fandom
I love the game plus the beacontown credit's can be my morning alarm
I liked the game (season 1 that is, never bought season 2 but did watch a playthrough) when I was a kid, but I can appreciate the validity of the complaints. Honestly, it was more funny than everything - I’d highly recommend watching RTgame’s playthrough if you haven’t already
It's kinda funny how there are literal Minecraft animations on TH-cam that have better quality and writing than Story Mode
Yeah but animations on TH-cam aren’t as complex as a choose your adventure game.
that's like saying the cutscenes in video games are better than the game play, of course it's gonna be higher quality because its just an animation.
This is probably one of the dumbest complaints on MCSM I've seen 😂
Ain’t no way you said those TH-cam MC animations are better than story mode…
I honestly think mcsm was amazing I loved it
The nostalgia is real
I still really like the game, both seasons. Tho I do agree the second season was a lot better in a lot of ways
I loved minecraft story mode honestly it had a good amount intresting villains some of course weren't but who cares plus it left me with a lot of questions which could be answered in a sequel kind of thing
Minecraft story mode Will never be Forgotten.
It was the best spin off Minecraft game, other like dungeons or legends will never take its place
There's two type of a person who love the game or hate the game but i don't care
for me, i only played the first chapter, until the end of the wither storm, back in 2015. i never really played past that point, but regardless of the quality of the writing or the story, the chapter one struggle against the wither storm will always be great for me.
For me, minecraft story mode is so bad it's good and I love to play it and laugh at the dialoge, but I'll admit the characters are fun to draw. Also the prison episode in season 2 unironically slaps.
I used to play this game when i was a kid and im just now hearing about the drama. It actually gives me the chills
MCSM is my most favorite game on earth ever, I play it single everyday, way better than the original minecraft and I never get tired of it. The only reason I disagree with MCSM is some of the choices like for an example - either Magnus armor or Ellegards armor, I was so hard me to choose and I wish it was a was were you could save them both. Also Rubens death was so very sad😭/hilarious🤣 and I wish there was a way to save him😔. It's a great game and season 2 is pretty good too but however I barely play it because it was so sad at the end and I cried so hard when it ended😢😔. However I heared that season 3 might be coming out in 2026 or something like that I read on the internet🤔
s1 had its gripes but s2 is wayy better
Well... I have nothing to say about the video, because i dont know English so much... But i will say about MSM.
I just love this two seasons... All heart and... I just don't know... They always feels like with soul... Yes MSM isn't great and he have some very stupid and dumb things that i don't like, but it's a simple story with... Some magic.
And i can't say that sort of magic is that... Maybe it's magic of original Minecraft or something else. And yet i can say one thing.
Thank you Telltale for amazing two seasons. Will pass much years, but i will always remember this games and love them!
Maybe it’s nostalgia, but I found the game extremely fun
I can totally agree that minecraft story mode season 2 was better than the first one. I would get insanely bored with the first season after the first 4 episodes, but I never got bored with the second season, since it was always keeping me on my toes when I fought a boss and had to try my hardest to not die, the movement mechanics were cleaner, it felt like a real adventure rather than an apocalyptic world with pain in the ass characters, and it actually almost made me cry at one point. One thing is that, I know this will never happen, but what if the endings came along just like in undertale/deltarune, where your actions (villain or hero) would lead to your consequence at the ending for either the pacifist, genocide, or neutral endings. The story ending would be prepared throughout the entire story and not just choosing ending at the end, unless it is a certain occasion where choosing endings made more sense.
Yes another person who made a Minecraft Story Mode video... im not crazy... also suggestion add "Minecraft story mode season 3" as a tag. It worked for me to get nearly 10k views
So much nostalgia 😭
I hated the maze in season 1
lmao I remember being like 8 and sitting there for like 2 hours trying to figure out where to go.
I haven't been able to get my hands on the second season yet, but I remember the first season being good but at the same time I barely remember it except for the last 3 episodes.
I grew up playing this game I will always like it no matter what anyone says