Video? Oh, he's got hundreds of videos, sadly. 🙄😒 Dapper has covered several of them, as have others on here. And he always gets at least an honorable mention at the Cambrian Bunny Awards (the natural next step to the Golden Crockoduck Awards), if not a decently high placement. 😊
Ammonite have their siphuncle around the edge of the shell (between the whorls) whereas nautilods have the siphuncle through the middle of the chambers. I have ammonite fossils with the siphuncle preseved.
That seems like a HUGE evolutionary change! It must have taken millions of years to happen and some big changes to its environment. Very interesting! Thx!
"It's important to show people why this man's claims are demonstrably wrong" - just play the video where he genuinely asserts the existence of a dragon as big as the entire Sahara desert and walk away
Amorite (with one “M”) “a member of a seminomadic people living in Mesopotamia, Palestine, and Syria in the 3rd millennium BC, founders of the ancient city of Mari on the Euphrates and the first dynasty of Babylon.”- Oxford languages Dictionary online. Off to a great start people! 😂
there's quite a number of channels dedicated to this sort of thing specifically because there's more channels dedicated to spreading pseudoscience. actually followed another channel a long time ago start off as an amateur debunker to full on credible physics teacher, though probably as a side thing while getting a degree
He had to switch to that method after messing up screens, and the last straw was him completely destroying a screen with his fingers, I have been told. The source is pretty reliable, so I'd give the claim some weight, for sure. 😊
Stupidity gets to a point where it's actually physically painful to listen to but if you go just a little bit further past that the absurdity just becomes funny and Rodger is absolutely amazing for this that is painful stupidity and hilarious absurdity
Words are just words until action actually starts, and actions speak louder than words, but at the same time words speak louder than actions because sometimes it’s the right thing to do.
36:29 He's not particularely interested in scale! I have stumbled over some of his videos before, and he's showing structures that suggest for example giant humans between maybe 30 feet scaled up to hundreds or even thousands of MILES when scaled up. His ONLY "research" criteria is his pareidolia!
My favorite mudfossil video was when he said a cave was a fossilized vagina and the rock on the side of cave was a fossilized baby stuck in the wall of her vagina. Then he went on to talk about how he knows a womans anatomy and he made sure to teach his son about a womans anatomy.
Regarding the fossils found in clay (Roger’s skin), are according to Roger, parasites. Including the sharks and Dinosaurs found in some of the big cliffs. I’m still waiting for him to explain how a Sauropod was adapted to an internal parasitic lifestyle.
Ah, yes, the feather-to-the-screen expert, himself - which he had to do because he kept wrecking and breaking screens, I hear. 😂 Yeah, Roger is definitely... erm, different. BTW, I was sent by Dapper Dinosaur! 🦕 I'm one of your newest subscribers, thanks to him. I didn't even watch anything before I hit that button, since a suggestion from Dapper is as good as it gets. 😊
Roger looks and sounds like a guy named Roger of around his age; exactly how I thought he’d look from only hearing his voice from people like SirSic or Planarwalk cover him. I originally thought he was just a talking feather at first, because well… seemed more likely than a person spouting that much
You know... I've been upset about LLMs posting nonsense online about things like ants and mushrooms... but, I suppose this video has helped me to remember that nonsense can be human generated too. At least his imaginary science is kinda cool and fun. Why can't he just write speculative fiction about his fake kaiju? I was most horrified when GeoDuck casually mentioned that he's not the only "mudfossil" guy on this nonsense. WHY? WHY? WHY?
Oh my, this Roger fellow seems to live in a little world of his own. I wonder of he came across the "balls" idea because someone tried to simplify an explanation of a knee problem of his.
WOW what's going on with youtube. Small 815 subscriber account, gets 248 likes on his video and 3k views. YT obvs pushed it to me since I've been interested in geology a lot of late, but still these are incredible numbers!!!
I’m subscribing to you in hopes that you start making videos about microscopy specifically focusing on microfossils. I do amateur microscopy and I want to see more TH-camrs doing that kind of stuff. Share your knowledge 😊
So, you watched a lot more than once it appears. Roger is right about his claims and you folks aren't doing anything but slamming the guy. You aren't involved in any "science" yourselves.
Oh man Roger is so funny, I love the 900 mile long Moroccan dragon. And the one where he was looking at a diagram of the GI tract of a bird and concluded that since this diagram didn't have kidneys, that birds don't have kidneys. I hadn't seen him on camera though and I'm disappointed he isn't all long hair and beardy with an outback hat Anyway now I have another thing about Roger that is funny. Hard to believe anyone believes anything he says Am-o-right? :D Thanks for the video
Roger's ramblings are typical creationist nonsense. He doesn't make sense because making sense isn't remotely the point. He's just saying things that make willfully ignorant people feel good about their ignorance. You are unlikely to ever convince him or any of his followers that anything he says is wrong. If you somehow do, they'll drop it like he never said it and move on to some other nonsense without missing a beat. If you're having fun mocking him then keep at it, but don't expect to change anybody's mind in any meaningful way.
That's an incredibly dangerous stand to take. Yes, we are absolutely talking about extremists here. But that's no reason not to fight them wherever and however we can! Especially if we can do it with actual science like it was brilliantly done in this video. If conspiracy believers use a platform for their claims, we have to get there too and put the correct information out. And even if one in thousands consumes it and changes their mind afterwards - it's a win.
So you reach 1,000 of his followers and one of them changes their mind, but in doing that you drive 1,000 new people to his videos. If 1% of those take him seriously, you've just increased his net following by 9 people. Engaging this kind of misinformation tends to just put in front of more people. A much better approach is to just post the science content and let the tiny percent of his followers with open minds find it (or have it pointed out to them by people they trust).
@@jhuger I seriously doubt that. I feel like the amount of people who listen to a professional debunk a crack head, and side with the incoherent crack head, would be more like 1 in a million, definitely not 9 in 1k, and definitely not more than those who’d be turned away In fact, let’s bring up “unbiased” people - learning about science by learning what isn’t possible is great. It gives people skepticism, teaches them not to trust anyone just because other people are, etc. Those same viewers very well could’ve been future believers of bad theories To think otherwise just seems very cynical and paranoid. Bad attention is only still attention to rich and famous entities who weren’t gonna fall anyways; when it comes to random nut cases like these guys, bad attention is absolutely bad for them
If so, then he's had it for a long time. He's been making these mud fossil videos for ages, and in every one I've ever encountered being debunked he's mangled at least one word, if not 3, 5, or a baker's dozen.
well taking almost to the sub-atomic size almost everything recycled carbon and water and hanging around natraualy in the state of water, even the as you are already aware still breaks down into h2o and co2, and so on, and as saying everything recycled something, apart a bit space dust, falling to earth and some escaping gasses that leak the same way out in to space? everything has always been here and just changes its form, from more complicated things in simpler things and simpler things into more complicated ones at every scale from the subatomic to big stuff your and I, hills into mountain's, so why not the hole earths to, it, just maximin state of the biggest scale, breaking back down into smaller items?
Roger might be cookoo for coco pops, but at least he uses Linux 😜 Also that little gold/bronze plaque on the monitor and rockery set dressing. Chef's kiss.
OMG Just when I thought the Charlatan Universe couldn't get anymore diverse. 🙄 What do we have here, a Living Rock guy? I'm no geologist or genealogist, but I do know ( at least I'm 99% sure. Correct me if I'm wrong ) that Silicon isn't found in any life form on Earth. He's gonna have to explain why almost 30% of the Earth's crust is made from it.
How would he explain the ammonite beds in southern France where their diameter reaches one meter. Google Dalle aux ammonites near Digne-les-bains in the french alps, IIRC a world heritage site.
Thanks for your work! I tried to take one of his arguments apart in a very bad short video but this is so much better. I started working on something about the "Typhon" in the desert claims but got stuck at the geology part...I study archaeology, so I can only confidently rebunk his identification of the Atlas mountains as a mythological creature based on ancient sources. But I feel pretty motivated to continue now! Keep fighting conspiracy myths!
Roger has a hearing issue. ‘Ammorites’ is wrong, but also a clue to where his ‘tendon balls’ come from. The collectors from Yorkshire call those round nodules ‘canon balls’. He is simply misinterpreting words and jumping to conclusions based on his apparent hearing problems.
I watch debunking channels and Roger is considered the king of pareidolia. I'm glad the TH-cam algorithms knew another "Roger is a ding-bat" video would interest me and I can now subscribe to your channel.
I can't vouch for the percentage of Roger's audience that believe his nonsense, but the whole thing dragons the size of mountain ranges is fantastic entertainment. Plus the monitor abuse, I'm secretly here for that.
Roger is so crazy, he may think crabs & ammonites came from escaped tendon balls of giants..... or maybe regular sized people & grew after they escaped? I try not to spend too much time inside Roger's mind, it's a very scary place LOL
Oh, haha, Mudfossil "University"! It doesn't have enough information to accurately use the phrase 'misinformation.' Maybe 'misanthropically pathological contrarianism.' 🤣
He claims that ammonites, which we definitely know were cephalopods and actual organisms, were just a part of another organism, and therefore that the organisms we call ammonites didn't exist. That is basically saying that ammonites as we know them didn't exist. Nothing slimey about my framing
Roger is looney tunes but you're correct, it's a shame he has so many subs. He is grand master of pareidolia who impresses people with the way he wields a feather. Geez he can't even use the proper name.
We are all just "ammorights" living in Rodger's world.
Well I'm an ammoWRONG actually
25:12 even your laptop knows how draining Roger is.
Hahahahaha yesss! (I can't believe I forgot to edit that out 😭🤣)
I actually checked the power to my laptop
@@muskyoxes So did I!
I watched his video twice via Dapper Dino and I thought the first time he sounded crazy because I was on a bunch of cold meds. He still sounds crazy
Video? Oh, he's got hundreds of videos, sadly. 🙄😒 Dapper has covered several of them, as have others on here. And he always gets at least an honorable mention at the Cambrian Bunny Awards (the natural next step to the Golden Crockoduck Awards), if not a decently high placement. 😊
@@MaryAnnNytowl yeah it’s baffling 😂 don’t play the drinking game with him. You won’t make it!!
Dapper Dino sent me. 😊
Wow this is….something. 😬😬
32:52 the sculptor in me loved this part 🥲
Ammonite have their siphuncle around the edge of the shell (between the whorls) whereas nautilods have the siphuncle through the middle of the chambers. I have ammonite fossils with the siphuncle preseved.
That seems like a HUGE evolutionary change! It must have taken millions of years to happen and some big changes to its environment. Very interesting! Thx!
"Those are the securing points that anchor all of that fabric, so that you can do gooshy around like this!"
Such a way with words this man has.
Well they are all balls...because, balls. What more explanation do you need...balls
Genuine academic research is healing for my soul fuckin hell man
"It's important to show people why this man's claims are demonstrably wrong" - just play the video where he genuinely asserts the existence of a dragon as big as the entire Sahara desert and walk away
Or the video where some cave is a vagina from a very VERY large woman. 😂
😂 my word! Roger is clearly not the full quid
Not the sharpest tool in the box…
Amorite (with one “M”) “a member of a seminomadic people living in Mesopotamia, Palestine, and Syria in the 3rd millennium BC, founders of the ancient city of Mari on the Euphrates and the first dynasty of Babylon.”- Oxford languages Dictionary online.
Off to a great start people! 😂
I don't know how you have the patience to deal with this illiterate and incoherent conspiracy theorist.
there's quite a number of channels dedicated to this sort of thing specifically because there's more channels dedicated to spreading pseudoscience. actually followed another channel a long time ago start off as an amateur debunker to full on credible physics teacher, though probably as a side thing while getting a degree
You can guess at someone's intelligence based on their mistreatment of monitors via feather.
He had to switch to that method after messing up screens, and the last straw was him completely destroying a screen with his fingers, I have been told. The source is pretty reliable, so I'd give the claim some weight, for sure. 😊
Can i blame my headache for how much the word "balls" is making my inner 12- year-old giggle
His foot rock is fascinating to me. Surely he could have found a rock that looked even more similar to a foot .....?
Stupidity gets to a point where it's actually physically painful to listen to but if you go just a little bit further past that the absurdity just becomes funny and Rodger is absolutely amazing for this that is painful stupidity and hilarious absurdity
All of the balls talk had the 1976 song by AC/DC coming into my head.
Now that's a quality earworm, right there!
Words are just words until action actually starts, and actions speak louder than words, but at the same time words speak louder than actions because sometimes it’s the right thing to do.
He said ammonite! 24minutes in
36:29 He's not particularely interested in scale!
I have stumbled over some of his videos before, and he's showing structures that suggest for example giant humans between maybe 30 feet scaled up to hundreds or even thousands of MILES when scaled up.
His ONLY "research" criteria is his pareidolia!
My favorite mudfossil video was when he said a cave was a fossilized vagina and the rock on the side of cave was a fossilized baby stuck in the wall of her vagina. Then he went on to talk about how he knows a womans anatomy and he made sure to teach his son about a womans anatomy.
Oh my gosh his poor son!!!
If I recall correctly, he completely ignored that there's evidence that the cave was massively changed from man made carvings.
@@NinjaMonkeyPrime Okay, I might make this a topic for a future video
what now
Exactly! @@tysonwastaken
I'm glad you have the courage to take them on! Good for you.
Regarding the fossils found in clay (Roger’s skin), are according to Roger, parasites. Including the sharks and Dinosaurs found in some of the big cliffs.
I’m still waiting for him to explain how a Sauropod was adapted to an internal parasitic lifestyle.
Oh my gosh that is absurd! Thanks for clarifying!
I look forward to his analysis of the rocks on Mars.
I think, or at least hope, that most people responding on Roger's channel are humoring him because they find him funny.
Ah, yes, the feather-to-the-screen expert, himself - which he had to do because he kept wrecking and breaking screens, I hear. 😂 Yeah, Roger is definitely... erm, different.
BTW, I was sent by Dapper Dinosaur! 🦕 I'm one of your newest subscribers, thanks to him. I didn't even watch anything before I hit that button, since a suggestion from Dapper is as good as it gets. 😊
I've never heard balls mentioned so many times in a single video. I've seen channels demonetized for far less🤦♂️
Im on the unrecognized channel side of youtube and im not sad.
I gotta hand it to you dude, this is great! I don't even have the patience. Cheers.
Roger looks and sounds like a guy named Roger of around his age; exactly how I thought he’d look from only hearing his voice from people like SirSic or Planarwalk cover him.
I originally thought he was just a talking feather at first, because well… seemed more likely than a person spouting that much
You know... I've been upset about LLMs posting nonsense online about things like ants and mushrooms... but, I suppose this video has helped me to remember that nonsense can be human generated too. At least his imaginary science is kinda cool and fun. Why can't he just write speculative fiction about his fake kaiju? I was most horrified when GeoDuck casually mentioned that he's not the only "mudfossil" guy on this nonsense.
WHY? WHY? WHY?
Waiter: soup or salad?
Roger: balls and straps
So, spaghetti and meatballs then?
🤣 🤣
You deserve a big hug after watching his video. People like him are emotionally and mentally draining.
I have always loved the way Roger lies about the illustrations he uses while showing the legends correcting him on screen.
Amazing video, thanks!
Glad you liked it, you're welcome:)
Oh my, this Roger fellow seems to live in a little world of his own. I wonder of he came across the "balls" idea because someone tried to simplify an explanation of a knee problem of his.
Watching some besides me have their brain melt is awesome. Well done.
Hahaha thanks :D
@@geoduckgeoscience4300 you're welcome!
You have to admit, he makes a ballsy claim!
WOW what's going on with youtube. Small 815 subscriber account, gets 248 likes on his video and 3k views. YT obvs pushed it to me since I've been interested in geology a lot of late, but still these are incredible numbers!!!
Option 3: Roger reads but does not understand, and relies on his _extreme_ pareidolia.
Was a little confused "ammorites"? Thanks for clarifying early on.
Do another video on Roger! I get a kick out of this!
Balls balls balls balls balls balls balls balls
Thanks, Roger!
Roger is absolutely obsessed with balls and straps. He's a very very silly man. 😁
I’m subscribing to you in hopes that you start making videos about microscopy specifically focusing on microfossils. I do amateur microscopy and I want to see more TH-camrs doing that kind of stuff. Share your knowledge 😊
Don't worry; I will!
Animal rights? Am i right? Ammo type.
Subbed via a shout out from Planarwalk 👍
Dapper sent me, subbed 😊
Hailing from Dapper Dino's squad. Great video. Sometimes, I truly worry about Mudd fossil 😅
He's talking balls alright. Not sure where tendons come in though.
Ammonoid by watching Roger poke his monitor.. Hahahaha a pun! Get it? Get it? Hahahaha.. ammannoyed! 🤣🤣 /runs away..
the creator of mudfossil university has tiny balls in him
@DapperDinosaur sent me.
Roger makes me sad. Guy's got so many problems it's absurd
I'm shocked he didn't call them vaginas. Has anyone made a supercut of all the times he's called rocks vaginas?
So, you watched a lot more than once it appears. Roger is right about his claims and you folks aren't doing anything but slamming the guy. You aren't involved in any "science" yourselves.
You should cover some of those “meltology” people. They misinterpret weathered outcroppings of rock as being melted remains of buildings.
Love me some Rodger and insanity.
Oh man Roger is so funny, I love the 900 mile long Moroccan dragon. And the one where he was looking at a diagram of the GI tract of a bird and concluded that since this diagram didn't have kidneys, that birds don't have kidneys. I hadn't seen him on camera though and I'm disappointed he isn't all long hair and beardy with an outback hat
Anyway now I have another thing about Roger that is funny. Hard to believe anyone believes anything he says Am-o-right? :D
Thanks for the video
Yes, I always got a 'stoned hippy' vibe from him - am I right?
Man failed Orb Pondering Class smh... its supposed to be orbs, not balls.
Roger's ramblings are typical creationist nonsense. He doesn't make sense because making sense isn't remotely the point. He's just saying things that make willfully ignorant people feel good about their ignorance. You are unlikely to ever convince him or any of his followers that anything he says is wrong. If you somehow do, they'll drop it like he never said it and move on to some other nonsense without missing a beat. If you're having fun mocking him then keep at it, but don't expect to change anybody's mind in any meaningful way.
Idk if I'd call his ramblings typical lol, his fascination with balls seems pretty unique to me
@@geoduckgeoscience4300he is a very unique individual
That's an incredibly dangerous stand to take. Yes, we are absolutely talking about extremists here. But that's no reason not to fight them wherever and however we can! Especially if we can do it with actual science like it was brilliantly done in this video. If conspiracy believers use a platform for their claims, we have to get there too and put the correct information out. And even if one in thousands consumes it and changes their mind afterwards - it's a win.
So you reach 1,000 of his followers and one of them changes their mind, but in doing that you drive 1,000 new people to his videos. If 1% of those take him seriously, you've just increased his net following by 9 people. Engaging this kind of misinformation tends to just put in front of more people. A much better approach is to just post the science content and let the tiny percent of his followers with open minds find it (or have it pointed out to them by people they trust).
@@jhuger I seriously doubt that. I feel like the amount of people who listen to a professional debunk a crack head, and side with the incoherent crack head, would be more like 1 in a million, definitely not 9 in 1k, and definitely not more than those who’d be turned away
In fact, let’s bring up “unbiased” people - learning about science by learning what isn’t possible is great. It gives people skepticism, teaches them not to trust anyone just because other people are, etc. Those same viewers very well could’ve been future believers of bad theories
To think otherwise just seems very cynical and paranoid. Bad attention is only still attention to rich and famous entities who weren’t gonna fall anyways; when it comes to random nut cases like these guys, bad attention is absolutely bad for them
I'm 6 mins in and I already know this is going to be excellent 😂
Omg, it's ammorite inception!
Good job ❤
The nonsense coming out of this guy's channel is staggering, LOL. Holy cow. Thank you for being so patient going over all the silliness.
Amorites?! He has dementia.
If so, then he's had it for a long time. He's been making these mud fossil videos for ages, and in every one I've ever encountered being debunked he's mangled at least one word, if not 3, 5, or a baker's dozen.
@@MaryAnnNytowl And it still has "Amorites"
Dapper dinosaur sent me and roger is actually quite a trip. Like how does he come up with this?
I kinda feel like he makes it up as he goes along, to be honest
Wait until you see his claim that a whole island chain is the remains of a dead dragon. I think it was the Aleutians.
Yep, just found my third favorite evolution youtuber, right after Forrest and Aron
Amorrites??? LOL. Grandpa need to be put back in the "old fools home."
The "mudflood" conspiracy people.
lol
Ammorites. Is he drunk?
I think he's using the most trusted source there is: crack
well taking almost to the sub-atomic size almost everything recycled carbon and water and hanging around natraualy in the state of water, even the as you are already aware still breaks down into h2o and co2, and so on, and as saying everything recycled something, apart a bit space dust, falling to earth and some escaping gasses that leak the same way out in to space? everything has always been here and just changes its form, from more complicated things in simpler things and simpler things into more complicated ones at every scale from the subatomic to big stuff your and I, hills into mountain's, so why not the hole earths to, it, just maximin state of the biggest scale, breaking back down into smaller items?
It's actually very sad that Roger's obvious imagination and curiosity have been wasted and now he is misinforming others too.
Roger might be cookoo for coco pops, but at least he uses Linux 😜 Also that little gold/bronze plaque on the monitor and rockery set dressing. Chef's kiss.
OMG Just when I thought the Charlatan Universe couldn't get anymore diverse. 🙄 What do we have here, a Living Rock guy? I'm no geologist or genealogist, but I do know ( at least I'm 99% sure. Correct me if I'm wrong ) that Silicon isn't found in any life form on Earth. He's gonna have to explain why almost 30% of the Earth's crust is made from it.
Hello. DD sent me
its clearly amorite season doc 🤣😂
How would he explain the ammonite beds in southern France where their diameter reaches one meter. Google Dalle aux ammonites near Digne-les-bains in the french alps, IIRC a world heritage site.
I mean, this guy thinks some of the "tendon balls" he's talking about are 1.5 metres plus across, so that isn't going to deter him lol.
Thanks for your work! I tried to take one of his arguments apart in a very bad short video but this is so much better.
I started working on something about the "Typhon" in the desert claims but got stuck at the geology part...I study archaeology, so I can only confidently rebunk his identification of the Atlas mountains as a mythological creature based on ancient sources. But I feel pretty motivated to continue now! Keep fighting conspiracy myths!
Roger has a hearing issue. ‘Ammorites’ is wrong, but also a clue to where his ‘tendon balls’ come from. The collectors from Yorkshire call those round nodules ‘canon balls’. He is simply misinterpreting words and jumping to conclusions based on his apparent hearing problems.
Just for your tenacity in chasing down this BS artist you got a sub from me.
I pity his coworkers.
I watch debunking channels and Roger is considered the king of pareidolia. I'm glad the TH-cam algorithms knew another "Roger is a ding-bat" video would interest me and I can now subscribe to your channel.
thanks for the sub :)
@@geoduckgeoscience4300 You're welcome.
And I will be honest… I clicked because of the Pokémon… stayed once you said microfossils.
I suspect nearly all Mudfossil's subs are youtube content creators lining up to watch the Village Idiots Convention.
I can't vouch for the percentage of Roger's audience that believe his nonsense, but the whole thing dragons the size of mountain ranges is fantastic entertainment. Plus the monitor abuse, I'm secretly here for that.
36:46 (or so) they be thicc bro 🙃😜
Human ankle with a 100m thigh..dudes be droolin!
Roger is so crazy, he may think crabs & ammonites came from escaped tendon balls of giants..... or maybe regular sized people & grew after they escaped? I try not to spend too much time inside Roger's mind, it's a very scary place LOL
Your voice sounds so lovely
Oh, haha, Mudfossil "University"! It doesn't have enough information to accurately use the phrase 'misinformation.'
Maybe 'misanthropically pathological contrarianism.' 🤣
Ouch!
Clam?
Amirights?
Is Roger high?
Ball ball anchor anchor ball ball anchor ball ball!
you know when someone says "My claim is not what they claim they are" is not the same as saying "they aren't real".
Pretty Sliney of you.
He claims that ammonites, which we definitely know were cephalopods and actual organisms, were just a part of another organism, and therefore that the organisms we call ammonites didn't exist. That is basically saying that ammonites as we know them didn't exist. Nothing slimey about my framing
He's busting my bawls
Balls
Balls
Balls
Balls
Roger is looney tunes but you're correct, it's a shame he has so many subs. He is grand master of pareidolia who impresses people with the way he wields a feather. Geez he can't even use the proper name.
Roger reminds me of Terry Davis but not based :(
ahh yes the "found world wide and still not understood for ____ years until now" title.
another one for the pseudoscience bingo card
Do, ammonites are _not_ dragon hairballs?
Roger is obsessed with talking balls about balls. This should be a surprise to no one who has seen any of his content before.