She didn’t receive much love in the series and films, but I love how Professor McGonagall had her back and stood up to Umbridge towards the end of the book/film.
@Sridevi Venkat I agree with you. She is an excellent seer sometimes. Pity no one really realizes it. (also the 13 in the table thing in PoA. Ron had Scabbers in his pocket. and Dumbledore rose first and died first) (and Harry's bday. His horcrux's bday WAS mid-winter-) (Ok, I needa write a wattpad story about Trelawney's correct predicions now-)
When I read the Half Blood Prince book. The part where Trelawney predicts the death of dumbledore was bone chilling. Really wish that part was added in the movie. Would have changed the whole atmosphere in an instant.
I totally agree! I think the reason why Dumbledore doesn't appreciate her prophecy in the HBP is he plans his own death, and knows how his fate would end. He doesn't want anyone innocent to ruin his plan and cause more trouble.
Technically they did show it. It's the part where she came to the great hall and there was 13 at the table. Dumbledore was the first to rise from the table. Hence he was the first to die from the group who sat at the table.
@@theresaiwright7085 but specifically for Half blood prince, it's quite chilling when reading that portion because after his encounter with Trelawney then everything goes downhill (the cave, poison, dumbledore's death, fake locket etc). This was a very chilling prediction she made. Even though the movie never add this (wanted the movie to be more teen drama and added unnecessary scenes) it would have elevated the third act of the movie and set the entire mood for the ending portion of the movie. Nevertheless, I enjoyed the Half Blood Prince movie but the book was incredible, much more mystery than teen drama.
Professor Trelawney is "unusually" important in the HP series. Let's face it! She is much more than that messy-hair lady who yells "open your eyes, see the future" in Divination classes. Kind of amazed that she nearly has no teaching talents, and cannot hear her REAL prediction! I wonder if anyone tells her that she predicted the fate of Harry and Voldemort after the battle of Hogwarts, when “all is well”.
I think she always knew Harry's fate, that is she saw all the times that Harry was going to die or maybe should have died but didn't hence the confusion.
One of the true HP plotholes for me: if Sibyl was in such peril outside the school, why wasn't she taken out of the school and put in to hiding by the Order, when it fell under Voldmort's control? It would have been nice to know if Voldmort discovered or was led to belive that there was no point in trying to search for the contents of the profecy in her memories. Or, in alternative, early in Hallows we are told that she has disaperd, making us think that Voldemort got her, only to discover later in the story that Dumbledore had a plan to put her to safety and that she was alive and well.
Perhaps she wouldn’t have any memory of making the prophecy at all. Like for example in PoA when she made that one in front of Harry about Pettigrew rejoining Voldemort and he mentioned it she had no idea what he was talking about.
She was the one who basically started the whole Harry potter story from the start, Without her, The Potters prob wouldn't died, Voldemort took over and done
I’ve always thought it’s very odd that so many witches and wizards don’t believe in divination. It’s a magical ability just like so many others like legilimancy, the ability to read other people’s mind. It’s not a spell or potion but a gift. It’s especially curious that Hermione doesn’t believe in it…she is the one that knows about time traveling and uses a time turner…afterall what is a prediction of the future but time traveling in a sense but with the mind. I believe that this had to be that way for the sake of the story to continue in the books and movies Bc otherwise they could just use divination and such to find out more about the future ect and where is the excitement and action with that lol
I think most of them believe and accept seeing the future is possible in theory, they are just very skeptical of people who say they can since its a rare ability and easy to fake. But yea i agree ita probably mostly for plot because its an OP power.
I guess divination and time turners muddle each other out, so if you possess a time turner and use it constantly. The outcome is that any divination you make will be murky.
Trelawney : wait … wait , I see something dark . You are in great danger. Fans be like : this the moment we all have been waiting for 🤣🤣🤣 . This is one the best scenes Fun fact : my birthday is on March 9th same as trelawney.
Wasn't Lavender's death only movie canon? As I remembered it in the book, she fell off somewhere and landed on the ground, Greyback then came racing to bite her which led to Hermione blasting him and Trelawney smashing a crystal ball on his head. Afterwards, Lavender was said to be feebly stirring and nothing indicates that she died. Especially since it reads like Greyback didn't even have the chance to attack her.
Did you know that Sybil in Greek means a prophetess and also There was an oracle of Apollo named herophile though we know that her last name is trelawney
Hold on. I have a theory for the fact Trelawney said Harry was born in the middle of winter. Actually Voldemort killed Harry's parents in the middle of winter 80 or 81 and Harry just became an Horcruxe so in a certain way he was born, as an Horcruxe, in mid-winter. Maybe she saw that. Sorry for my english btw i'm french and i hope it's understandable.
it happened on halloween not mid winter. If anything it's possible that her believing he was born mid winter could have been her seeing the horcrux, of Voldemort , who was in fact born on December 31st, which is indeed mid winter.
16:25 Trelawney might have been right, as she could have sensed the horcrux that "lived" with Harry, wich was created on chrismas eve; Mid winter so to speak.
I've long thought of Trelawney as a troubled and misunderstood genius character, since she made at least one correct prediction with the lightning struck tower. But reading these comments I'm realizing it goes even deeper than that. She made a lot of correct predictions, but just like her ancestor's namesake, no one ever took her seriously. Not even she herself.
Just a idea you made this video so why not a video about the different oracle and prophecy in Rick Riordan book. Ps:I don't really like her but cool video.
I’ve seen this trope before. The goofy, bohemian mage that is self taught and has raw talent but no expertise in any particular field. Yet when things get tough, they Blast off a series of actions that are integral to the plot. She’s basically that Psyduck from Pokémon. (I don’t remember that girl’s name the one that goes with Ash)
She was actually correct with the 13 persons sitting at a dining table. since peter pettigrew was with ron, they were already 13 when trewlaney came. Dumbledore stud up to welcome Sibil and he died first.
Emma Thompson - most incredible English actress, screenwriter, author comedian, producer, director and activist. Oh ya and she did a bit in this Harry Potter thing. My favorite of her movies is of course Since and Sensibility. Also you youngsters, look up Footlights. She started out with Hugh Laurie and Stephen Fry. Amazing.
i love how she is a direct reference to greek mythology Cassandra (the prophet cursed by Apollo to always predict truthfully, yet never be taken seriously) cause even if she is literally grasping, she still manages to perfectly predict the future (even if often dismissed as ramblings of an insane person ;) ) She is even a descendant of an ancient seer by the name of Cassandra.. coincidence? ... i think not... she is the great-great granddaughter of THE Cassandra! look it up! xD
That 13 people at the table bit is interesting because there were 13 people at the last supper, and the first to rise was Jesus, and he died the next day. Just an interesting bit of lore there
Actually, the 13 people dining together prediction was correct. 13 people were already dining together before she arrived because scabbers/Peter Pettigrew was in Ron’s pocket, and dumbledore, who died first, rose to greet her.
9:31 the fact that McGonagall had this kind of impression of Trelawney from the very start (which never really changed ever), but yet stood up for Trelawney when Umbridge threatened to have her fired, shows how much everyone really hated Umbridge. *EDIT* : oh he covered this later in the video. :D
she was right with her predictions most of the time, surprisingly Ron DID had a gift of a see-er with his predictions in the movie. We need to re-watch to spot that
She is quite an underrated character, it’s like Ron being in the shadow of his brothers. She was in the shadow of her great-grandmother but she may be under the pressure of her heritage.
She made more correct predictions than many assume. 1) Hermione did leave the class around Easter. 2) Harry did meet a giant black dog, only it wasn’t a grim, she just misinterpreted the sign. 3) umbridge was indeed in grave danger, meeting centaurs later that year. 4) that prediction when she described Harry’s fate and assumed he was born in winter. Don’t forget harry had a piece of Voldy’s soul inside him. And Voldy was indeed born 31st December. She actually looked into that other soul and made her prediction about Voldemort. Who knows, maybe it’s not the only time she mixed 2 souls. And that’s why she found Harry to be an interesting object. 5) in HBP Trelawney saw many signs. I don’t remember the exact cards, but definitely she predicted Malfoy’s role, Dumblodore’s death. To conclude, I believe that all her true predictions were involuntary and she never realized they came true. And most of time it was wondering in the dark. But she has some gift and is not completely a fraud
Not related to trelawney but Don’t forget the sneaky thing in sorcerers stone with the centaurs arguing that harry needed to die in the forest because of the planets alignment. It was 6 years too early but very clever by Rowling.
Trelawney, to me, is what most people would call a "sleeper". Though overlooked, brings more to the table. She made very crucial prophecies, even though she couldn't remember them.
The first to die prediction actually was ironically right, yes there were the twelve sitting but unknown to them all there were actually 13, the thirteenth you ask? Peter Pettigrew. And who stood up first? Dumbledore. Also the Harry was born in mid winter one is also right, she saw the TROUBLED SOUL WITHIN, Harry was a horcrux at this time, and when was Voldemort born? Mid-Winter aka December.
Yes haha! Very true! The future is SO easily changeable. Her predictions could be a whole mix of future timelines stacked in one, and that’s why she seems like she doesn’t know what she’s talking about… but I trust her, she deserved more credit smh
It is interesting how Neville and Harry's lives were still so paralleled. They both lost their parents because of that prophecy neither growing up with a healthy parental figure and their first real place of acceptance came from Hogwarts.
Either one of them would've fulfilled the prophecy and it is Voldemort that makes the ultimate choice. Ironically, he would've avoided his death by not choosing either Harry or Neville.
@@BHuang92 Prophecies by their very nature are self fulfilling. How many depended on the person trying to avoid the prediction, in order for it to come True?
@@pranavp7502 also Harry predicted / “foreshadowed” all his task. He’d be burned (dragon) drowned (task2) loose a treasured (Ron) betrayed be a friend (fake moody)
In Greek mythology, Cassandra was given the gift of foresight. Cassandra was cursed with no one believing her predictions because she refused to sleep with the person who gave her the power. Maybe that’s why their powers slowly weened down.
I loved Sybil's character and her gift as a seer and wish she would have gotten the justice she surely deserves ❤❤. I absolutely loved how Emma Thompson portayed her in the films ❤❤
13:03 She was probably right because as Peter Pettigrew, disguised as Scabbers, was in Ron's pocket there were already 13 people at the table and Dumbledore was the first one standing up in order to greet Trelawney.
Currently re listening to the Harry Potter audio books read by Stephen fry, he did an amazing job with all the voices and I get chills down my spine when I hear the prophecy
Am I the only ne who noticed this: In the divination exam, Harry told that he saw a hippogriff flying away with a man, which disappointed sybill as she had expected him to see a beheaded hippogriff with Hagrid crying. But what Harry said came true: Buckbeak flew away with Sirius!
The "when 13 dine together the first to rise will be the first to die" statement was true. Though in an unexpected way. Without trelawney, there were already 13 people there (counting Pettigrewas scabbard.) Dumbledore stood up first to greet trelawney and he was the first to put of the others
You know I always felt Trelawny did not get the respect she deserves, I mean she did predict important events 1) Harrys birth and having the power to destroy Voldemort, 2) Pettigrew being freed from his rat forum and returning to Voldemort. 3) The Battle of the Astronomy Tower. Plus I hate it away Hermione treated her because she can be narrow-minded sometimes. Bottom line Trelawny is proof that divination isn't rubbish. Plus I love the design of her wand and most importantly she is portrayed by Emma Thompson it doesn't get any better than that
Idk, but I think she's not underrated, but rather having both something to look up to and a really big downside to overshadow all of it. Like how Snape is a man to admire and he does most of the heavy lifting spying stuff, he's also an annoying, grumpy, mean spirited individual and even quite a salty teenager if you look close enough into the daily life aspect of it.
I didn't like how Hermione acted so snooty during Divination classes. She can really be insensitive to other's feelings, especially that one time when Lavender's rabbit died.
I actually cringed when I saw how insensitive she was towards Lavender’s rabbit’s death. Like, “I mean, Lavender only received the news today, so it may have not happened on the same day”, like what?
@@So_Indecisive yes well , but characters need negative traits too or they would all be mary sues. But yeah hermione was rude in divination, even if she was voicing what most of the class was thinking, she could have gone better about it ..she seemed to really have it against that particular subject tho, maybe some family member had a bad experience with a fraud fortune teller?
@@nessyness5447for the first part, that’s what I’m saying, she’s not flawless . For the second part,it doesn’t excuse the insensitive when lavender’s pet dead (even tho, I agree with Hermione).last part,well,if that was the case it should been stated
Hogwarts may have been her home but McGonagal really stepped up to make her feel loved. Tralawneys' story is such a heartbreaking one and she really did need to be told that just as a person without the innereye was enough.
Trelawny was also sort of right when she talked about Harry being born in midwinter. Voldemort was born then and she was "seeing" the part of his soul in Harry.
@@Lapislazuli_36 Really? You have copies of all my comments on every site? The reason Trelawny was right was she was picking up on the horcrux of Tom Riddle. Remember she also suffered the curse of her ancestor, of being right but not believed. I am not the only one to make such observations.
She didn’t receive much love in the series and films, but I love how Professor McGonagall had her back and stood up to Umbridge towards the end of the book/film.
ya
And Dumbledore, even he stood up for her
@@animeweeb1201 that’s right, I forgot about Dumbledore. He’s the best there ever was.
Commented before u could finish the video lol
Dark times often unite people through our shared humanity.
It's funny how much an fortune telling, enlarged mosquito can change the plot of a series so much.
And you profile pic is my favourite
@@myrajain5445 Classic michael grimace face, you can get it yourself if you want!
To True
@Sridevi Venkat I agree with you. She is an excellent seer sometimes. Pity no one really realizes it. (also the 13 in the table thing in PoA. Ron had Scabbers in his pocket. and Dumbledore rose first and died first)
(and Harry's bday. His horcrux's bday WAS mid-winter-)
(Ok, I needa write a wattpad story about Trelawney's correct predicions now-)
*a
I had never thought of Trelawney witnessing Lavender getting bitten. That must've been hard man. Great video btw
“That miserable old bat”
Ron weasley, the goblet of fire
When I read the Half Blood Prince book. The part where Trelawney predicts the death of dumbledore was bone chilling. Really wish that part was added in the movie. Would have changed the whole atmosphere in an instant.
I totally agree! I think the reason why Dumbledore doesn't appreciate her prophecy in the HBP is he plans his own death, and knows how his fate would end. He doesn't want anyone innocent to ruin his plan and cause more trouble.
Technically they did show it. It's the part where she came to the great hall and there was 13 at the table. Dumbledore was the first to rise from the table. Hence he was the first to die from the group who sat at the table.
agreed.
@@theresaiwright7085 that Was in prisoner of askaban and only in the books
@@theresaiwright7085 but specifically for Half blood prince, it's quite chilling when reading that portion because after his encounter with Trelawney then everything goes downhill (the cave, poison, dumbledore's death, fake locket etc). This was a very chilling prediction she made. Even though the movie never add this (wanted the movie to be more teen drama and added unnecessary scenes) it would have elevated the third act of the movie and set the entire mood for the ending portion of the movie. Nevertheless, I enjoyed the Half Blood Prince movie but the book was incredible, much more mystery than teen drama.
Sybil Trewlany is one of my favourite characters. You might think that it is weird. But no, I even cried when The Pink Human Toad tried to fire her.
Pink human toad 😂😂😂
I loved the art you used for the ancestor, using art from an actual ancient fortuneteller is great.
That bit about Rowlings own marriage is actually really cool and i never knew that before
Her relationship with Minerva was one of my favourites
We should appreciate Morgan more, he spends so much time to bring us content
WHAT THE? HE HAS 1.54M SUBSCRIBERS, THAT’S NOT ENOUGH FOR YOU!!!!!????
@@haxozr bruh compared to views per video that is really low
He deserves 10 m
Professor Trelawney is "unusually" important in the HP series. Let's face it! She is much more than that messy-hair lady who yells "open your eyes, see the future" in Divination classes. Kind of amazed that she nearly has no teaching talents, and cannot hear her REAL prediction!
I wonder if anyone tells her that she predicted the fate of Harry and Voldemort after the battle of Hogwarts, when “all is well”.
@Lt.Dangle I hope he will tell her, so that she’ll know the true reason why she’s employed in Hogwarts.
I think she always knew Harry's fate, that is she saw all the times that Harry was going to die or maybe should have died but didn't hence the confusion.
One of the true HP plotholes for me: if Sibyl was in such peril outside the school, why wasn't she taken out of the school and put in to hiding by the Order, when it fell under Voldmort's control? It would have been nice to know if Voldmort discovered or was led to belive that there was no point in trying to search for the contents of the profecy in her memories. Or, in alternative, early in Hallows we are told that she has disaperd, making us think that Voldemort got her, only to discover later in the story that Dumbledore had a plan to put her to safety and that she was alive and well.
Perhaps she wouldn’t have any memory of making the prophecy at all. Like for example in PoA when she made that one in front of Harry about Pettigrew rejoining Voldemort and he mentioned it she had no idea what he was talking about.
She was the one who basically started the whole Harry potter story from the start, Without her, The Potters prob wouldn't died, Voldemort took over and done
I’ve always thought it’s very odd that so many witches and wizards don’t believe in divination. It’s a magical ability just like so many others like legilimancy, the ability to read other people’s mind. It’s not a spell or potion but a gift.
It’s especially curious that Hermione doesn’t believe in it…she is the one that knows about time traveling and uses a time turner…afterall what is a prediction of the future but time traveling in a sense but with the mind.
I believe that this had to be that way for the sake of the story to continue in the books and movies Bc otherwise they could just use divination and such to find out more about the future ect and where is the excitement and action with that lol
I think most of them believe and accept seeing the future is possible in theory, they are just very skeptical of people who say they can since its a rare ability and easy to fake. But yea i agree ita probably mostly for plot because its an OP power.
I guess divination and time turners muddle each other out, so if you possess a time turner and use it constantly. The outcome is that any divination you make will be murky.
Trelawney : wait … wait , I see something dark . You are in great danger.
Fans be like : this the moment we all have been waiting for 🤣🤣🤣 .
This is one the best scenes
Fun fact : my birthday is on March 9th same as trelawney.
Cool
Wasn't Lavender's death only movie canon? As I remembered it in the book, she fell off somewhere and landed on the ground, Greyback then came racing to bite her which led to Hermione blasting him and Trelawney smashing a crystal ball on his head. Afterwards, Lavender was said to be feebly stirring and nothing indicates that she died. Especially since it reads like Greyback didn't even have the chance to attack her.
That was my favourite part of the third book mcgonnigal saying that
She so sweet and underated and very mistreted
Let's appreciate how generous the actor playing the character was with her talent.
A new video suggestion Life of Aberforth/Albus Dumbledore
Did you know that Sybil in Greek means a prophetess and also There was an oracle of Apollo named herophile though we know that her last name is trelawney
Hold on. I have a theory for the fact Trelawney said Harry was born in the middle of winter. Actually Voldemort killed Harry's parents in the middle of winter 80 or 81 and Harry just became an Horcruxe so in a certain way he was born, as an Horcruxe, in mid-winter. Maybe she saw that.
Sorry for my english btw i'm french and i hope it's understandable.
it happened on halloween not mid winter.
If anything it's possible that her believing he was born mid winter could have been her seeing the horcrux, of Voldemort , who was in fact born on December 31st, which is indeed mid winter.
Again a very good video my friend you really do these videos justice I mean that
Great video MovieFlame!
The books were better tralauny was ignored by the movies and my potterheads finally someone appreciated her
16:25 Trelawney might have been right, as she could have sensed the horcrux that "lived" with Harry, wich was created on chrismas eve; Mid winter so to speak.
I've long thought of Trelawney as a troubled and misunderstood genius character, since she made at least one correct prediction with the lightning struck tower. But reading these comments I'm realizing it goes even deeper than that. She made a lot of correct predictions, but just like her ancestor's namesake, no one ever took her seriously. Not even she herself.
probably my favorite character in the hp series
They did a great job with casting sybil
16:43 that one ain't fake. Yes, harry wasn't born in midwinter, but Voldemort is. Trelawney saw Voldemort in harry.
Professor trelawny is the last character I expected movieflame make a video on. I wasn’t expecting this.
Can you make a video on the life of Rolanda Hooch
Just a idea you made this video so why not a video about the different oracle and prophecy in Rick Riordan book.
Ps:I don't really like her but cool video.
Loved the character but she's under-rated
severely underrated
This is why I like Professor Trelawney. There’s something mysterious about her.
This character is actually my favourite one since I read the books and when I read she died in the war on a trash website I cryed
Fun fact Sybill actually had an (temporary) addiction to sherry after all the pressure she was put under to be just like her great grandma
It's weird how a ring, a crack-head fortune teller and a bug stuck in tree sap can change a flim series
I thought her death omen for harry was for when he would choose to sacrifice himself and die at the hands of voldemort (and bring himself back)
I’ve seen this trope before. The goofy, bohemian mage that is self taught and has raw talent but no expertise in any particular field. Yet when things get tough, they Blast off a series of actions that are integral to the plot.
She’s basically that Psyduck from Pokémon. (I don’t remember that girl’s name the one that goes with Ash)
She was actually correct with the 13 persons sitting at a dining table. since peter pettigrew was with ron, they were already 13 when trewlaney came. Dumbledore stud up to welcome Sibil and he died first.
Emma Thompson - most incredible English actress, screenwriter, author comedian, producer, director and activist. Oh ya and she did a bit in this Harry Potter thing. My favorite of her movies is of course Since and Sensibility. Also you youngsters, look up Footlights. She started out with Hugh Laurie and Stephen Fry. Amazing.
You are so underrated
I've been binging these videos, great content and adds even more to a great series
draco just chillin right there while trelawney was making a weird fake prediction to umbridge was i-
Her story has me in tears.
Please do the hunger games every single difference between book and movies
1:51 The wand of Sybill Trelawney was 9½" long, made of Hazel wood with a Unicorn hair core.
Id of like to have sceen in the Battle of Hogwarts, Trelawney throwing crystal balls at death eaters like in the Deathly Hallows book.
I love these videos, I learn so much about so many characters!
I swear your talking about me through talking about her lol.
I would love to see you do Lord of the Rings videos
I really loved Professor Trelawney.
i love how she is a direct reference to greek mythology Cassandra
(the prophet cursed by Apollo to always predict truthfully, yet never be taken seriously)
cause even if she is literally grasping, she still manages to perfectly predict the future
(even if often dismissed as ramblings of an insane person ;) )
She is even a descendant of an ancient seer by the name of Cassandra.. coincidence? ... i think not...
she is the great-great granddaughter of THE Cassandra! look it up! xD
I love your videos #notisquad
you deserve more subscribers your content is so good. but obviously its their choice
Omg Yes a video about her life!!
I can’t she’s just so adorable
well done ross
Your next series could be Percy Jackson Book vs Comic
That 13 people at the table bit is interesting because there were 13 people at the last supper, and the first to rise was Jesus, and he died the next day. Just an interesting bit of lore there
One of my favorite side characters
From that picture alone I COULD'VE told rowling that her marriage is going to fail
Satisfied
youtube had a stroke again
trelawney predicted you'd do this video
16:25 Trelawney was correct as Voldemort was born in mid-winter and a part of Voldemort's soul lies with in harry
lol, crazy fact
She was always right, you know.
Still got it
Can you do in your next video the history of the order of the Phoenix first and second war
Actually, the 13 people dining together prediction was correct. 13 people were already dining together before she arrived because scabbers/Peter Pettigrew was in Ron’s pocket, and dumbledore, who died first, rose to greet her.
Do an Annabeth timeline, the original series and heroes of olympus!
9:31 the fact that McGonagall had this kind of impression of Trelawney from the very start (which never really changed ever), but yet stood up for Trelawney when Umbridge threatened to have her fired, shows how much everyone really hated Umbridge.
*EDIT* : oh he covered this later in the video. :D
Ikr umbridge is a bad mean bitch
Was Trelawny right when she said that Umbridge was in grave danger. Because later in the film the centaurs almost killed her...
she was right with her predictions most of the time, surprisingly Ron DID had a gift of a see-er with his predictions in the movie. We need to re-watch to spot that
She was right, but i do feel that was more a passive agressive threat than a prophecy XD
She is quite an underrated character, it’s like Ron being in the shadow of his brothers. She was in the shadow of her great-grandmother but she may be under the pressure of her heritage.
Exactly, and also that most lines from the books Ron had but Hermione mainly took in the movies just cause of the director or whoever
She made more correct predictions than many assume. 1) Hermione did leave the class around Easter. 2) Harry did meet a giant black dog, only it wasn’t a grim, she just misinterpreted the sign. 3) umbridge was indeed in grave danger, meeting centaurs later that year. 4) that prediction when she described Harry’s fate and assumed he was born in winter. Don’t forget harry had a piece of Voldy’s soul inside him. And Voldy was indeed born 31st December. She actually looked into that other soul and made her prediction about Voldemort. Who knows, maybe it’s not the only time she mixed 2 souls. And that’s why she found Harry to be an interesting object. 5) in HBP Trelawney saw many signs. I don’t remember the exact cards, but definitely she predicted Malfoy’s role, Dumblodore’s death.
To conclude, I believe that all her true predictions were involuntary and she never realized they came true. And most of time it was wondering in the dark. But she has some gift and is not completely a fraud
also about one of the patil sisters and the orange haired boy as one of them would go with ron to the yule ball and it wouldnt end well
Not related to trelawney but Don’t forget the sneaky thing in sorcerers stone with the centaurs arguing that harry needed to die in the forest because of the planets alignment. It was 6 years too early but very clever by Rowling.
I think the alcohol may have played a role in why she couldn't interpret the different visions and signs very well.
For the recored the card was the lighting-struck tower, which suposoly always means something or someone is going to die soon
Harry did die. Much later and came back in I’m not mistaken. I think she’s legit.
Trelawney, to me, is what most people would call a "sleeper". Though overlooked, brings more to the table. She made very crucial prophecies, even though she couldn't remember them.
The first to die prediction actually was ironically right, yes there were the twelve sitting but unknown to them all there were actually 13, the thirteenth you ask? Peter Pettigrew. And who stood up first? Dumbledore. Also the Harry was born in mid winter one is also right, she saw the TROUBLED SOUL WITHIN, Harry was a horcrux at this time, and when was Voldemort born? Mid-Winter aka December.
I think those are the accidentally right ones. It’s made really clear when she’s really telling the future and when she’s guessing
I am very proud of Lavender and Pervati because they were so kind and loving toward Sybill. Epic legends.
❤❤❤
Fun Fact: Actually, If y'all pay attention to Trelawney's predictions, you would notice/understand that some of them came true.
Yes haha! Very true! The future is SO easily changeable. Her predictions could be a whole mix of future timelines stacked in one, and that’s why she seems like she doesn’t know what she’s talking about… but I trust her, she deserved more credit smh
It is interesting how Neville and Harry's lives were still so paralleled. They both lost their parents because of that prophecy neither growing up with a healthy parental figure and their first real place of acceptance came from Hogwarts.
Either one of them would've fulfilled the prophecy and it is Voldemort that makes the ultimate choice. Ironically, he would've avoided his death by not choosing either Harry or Neville.
Such good writing.
@@BHuang92 Prophecies by their very nature are self fulfilling. How many depended on the person trying to avoid the prediction, in order for it to come True?
Honestly one of my favourite characters. I lover how she was comedic but if you paid attention, almost all her predictions were correct.
Fun fact: Harry accidentally made a true prediction of buckbeak escaping
@@pranavp7502 also Harry predicted / “foreshadowed” all his task. He’d be burned (dragon) drowned (task2) loose a treasured (Ron) betrayed be a friend (fake moody)
@@mapa0012 harry is the true seer in hogwarts
Don't forget she told the truth about the tortured soul born in winter - she was reading the Tom Riddle soul living in Harry.
@@katherinkeegan8601 I mean even if not many knew about Tom's soul in Harry's
his soul is anyway tortured
Anyone could have guessed
In Greek mythology, Cassandra was given the gift of foresight. Cassandra was cursed with no one believing her predictions because she refused to sleep with the person who gave her the power. Maybe that’s why their powers slowly weened down.
Apollo was the one who gave her the power btw
PJO FANS!!! YAAA!!!!
Cassandra was my birth-name.
I go by Cas now, but I love the story behind the name Cassandra.
@@swymmrjkar7852 Not necessarily, but hopefully.
@@duonggialinh5724
Thanks. Forgot the name.
I loved Sybil's character and her gift as a seer and wish she would have gotten the justice she surely deserves ❤❤. I absolutely loved how Emma Thompson portayed her in the films ❤❤
I’m reading through the 3rd book again and she already tells the future in many lines
That is true
13:03 She was probably right because as Peter Pettigrew, disguised as Scabbers, was in Ron's pocket there were already 13 people at the table and Dumbledore was the first one standing up in order to greet Trelawney.
oh my god
“The one with the power to vanquish the dark lord approaches…”
Born to those who have thrice defied him...
Currently re listening to the Harry Potter audio books read by Stephen fry, he did an amazing job with all the voices and I get chills down my spine when I hear the prophecy
Born as the seventh month dies...
•_•
@@keatonmorgan4883 And the Dark Lord will mark him as his equal...
Could do you a series where you check out each and every hunger games book and their movie counterpart the same way you did for Harry Potter?
I really want him to do the series for percy Jackson but those would be some long videos. Very long.
@@DarthAxolotl too long
@@gamerstheater1187 it may not even fit on TH-cam it would be that long.
It might be faster to list te similarities
@@DarthAxolotl #shorts for the similarities
Am I the only ne who noticed this:
In the divination exam, Harry told that he saw a hippogriff flying away with a man, which disappointed sybill as she had expected him to see a beheaded hippogriff with Hagrid crying. But what Harry said came true: Buckbeak flew away with Sirius!
No i noticed it too
Also the headless hippogriff in the first round before they went back in time
The "when 13 dine together the first to rise will be the first to die" statement was true. Though in an unexpected way. Without trelawney, there were already 13 people there (counting Pettigrewas scabbard.) Dumbledore stood up first to greet trelawney and he was the first to put of the others
Can you explain what happened to Kreacher after the books/movies please? i've been wondering about this for so long
Didn’t he work in hogwarts kitchens?
I think he became the house elf for the Potters.
I imagine him fretting over Albus Severus forgetting his books. 😂
You know I always felt Trelawny did not get the respect she deserves, I mean she did predict important events
1) Harrys birth and having the power to destroy Voldemort,
2) Pettigrew being freed from his rat forum and returning to Voldemort.
3) The Battle of the Astronomy Tower.
Plus I hate it away Hermione treated her because she can be narrow-minded sometimes. Bottom line Trelawny is proof that divination isn't rubbish. Plus I love the design of her wand and most importantly she is portrayed by Emma Thompson it doesn't get any better than that
Exactly
I think you mean form
Idk, but I think she's not underrated, but rather having both something to look up to and a really big downside to overshadow all of it. Like how Snape is a man to admire and he does most of the heavy lifting spying stuff, he's also an annoying, grumpy, mean spirited individual and even quite a salty teenager if you look close enough into the daily life aspect of it.
I loved her character despite how odd she could be at times.
I thought Sybill was annoying in the movies. Now i just think shes very spiritual and cool and kinda sad
Oh she was spiritual allright XD
best potter content maker ever
yes he is
Sometimes people who reach for something so desperately deserve to feel it on their fingertips.
I didn't like how Hermione acted so snooty during Divination classes. She can really be insensitive to other's feelings, especially that one time when Lavender's rabbit died.
That’s one of her negative character traits,she always has to be right
I actually cringed when I saw how insensitive she was towards Lavender’s rabbit’s death. Like, “I mean, Lavender only received the news today, so it may have not happened on the same day”, like what?
@@adenosinetriphosphate2494 "Don't Listen to her Matthew, she doesn't care about other people's pets"
@@So_Indecisive yes well , but characters need negative traits too or they would all be mary sues. But yeah hermione was rude in divination, even if she was voicing what most of the class was thinking, she could have gone better about it ..she seemed to really have it against that particular subject tho, maybe some family member had a bad experience with a fraud fortune teller?
@@nessyness5447for the first part, that’s what I’m saying, she’s not flawless . For the second part,it doesn’t excuse the insensitive when lavender’s pet dead (even tho, I agree with Hermione).last part,well,if that was the case it should been stated
Hogwarts may have been her home but McGonagal really stepped up to make her feel loved. Tralawneys' story is such a heartbreaking one and she really did need to be told that just as a person without the innereye was enough.
Trelawny was also sort of right when she talked about Harry being born in midwinter. Voldemort was born then and she was "seeing" the part of his soul in Harry.
Lmao, trelawny there, almost spoiling the plotwist.
I have made this remark in several comments.
@@katherinkeegan8601no you haven't
@@Lapislazuli_36 Really? You have copies of all my comments on every site? The reason Trelawny was right was she was picking up on the horcrux of Tom Riddle. Remember she also suffered the curse of her ancestor, of being right but not believed. I am not the only one to make such observations.
@@katherinkeegan8601 lmao you're psychotic 😂