Joel's phrasing on the verse is actually quite accurate to the original song lmao 😂 anyway, these are interesting takes on Anti-Hero, you guys should make this a series it's so fun ahaha
Loved all of your songs, everyone had something different which was executed brilliantly like Jonas’ chorus, Joel’s verse and August’s arrangement. Jonas’ song- 3:50 Joel’s song- 8:16 August’s song- 11:26
homie why was this so SICK???? All the versions were *chefs kiss* loved how they all came out. could esp feel the emotion from Joel’s and the vibezzzz from August. also felt the bond b/w Taylor and Jonas in the depths of my soul
I 100% agree, Jonas knocked this one out of the park. Love when Joel, Jonas and August are all in the video together. Always my favorites, their chemistry is so great, you can tell they are genuinely friends. ❤️
All three versions were excellent, but Joel’s gave me goosebumps. Would have loved to see all three of you react to Taylor’s version at the end. Great video!! Make this a series, please!
Loving all your versions! August's first verse was *chef kiss*, Joel's and Jonas' chorus was so goooood!!! All in all, I really love how you guys came up with this in 3 hours! So gooood!!!
I think it would have been great to see you guys react to the actual song at the end. All 3 songs had their own merits but I think Jonas’s is the most “Taylor-esque” version.
Yes 🤣 I laughed through this entire video. Plus just loved hearing the songwriting approaches with so much hilarity idk man best video I’ve seen in awhile. 🤣
The synchronized head bops were hilarious. But genuinely, i used to love your channel and i love seeing your videos show up on my recommended after probably years, they always make me smile :)
Hahaha joel was super close except that high pitch lol the song is mellow and slow so the opposite. Jonas was also close too!! His was really melodic! This was fun. You guys should listen to the song afterwards that way you can see who was the closest and then troll whoever lost 🤡 lol
So I just did a weird thing.. I loaded up T-Swifty's version in one tab and Joel's version in another. Aside from the pacing being off (which I fixed by pausing Joel's faster mix at the end of each line) they actually lined up really nicely! They even harmonized! I guess to make it official (Roomie.. official ) I would need to rip the audio from both tracks and actually match them up in Audition or Audacity or something.. Hmmmm.
Nice to see the writing-sessions again! My ranking for this round is as follows: 1: Jonas (stanky groove & catchy melody, instantly dug it.) 2: Joel (the ascending chord-progression is a vibe, but the melody felt too disjointed, especially throughout the chorus.) 3: August (a little too stuck in the background compared to the other 2, 10/10 for the presentation, though.) GG everyone, would still probably listen to all 3 versions, though. Looking forward to more of these!
Roomie! You should do a video on "Most underrated songs" and then let your fans submit tracks they think never got enough attention/deserve more recognition and then you can review/critique them and give your opinion on if you agree that the song deserved more exposure or not. I think it'd be a good way to not only promote smaller artists, but also a great way to do something interactive with your audience!
I like Joel's the best because it has the build from simple to dramatic, slowly pulling you into the chorus. It's easy to absorb and not trying too hard.
Yay my three favorite snarky songskilled swedes!! Honestly I got goosebumps from Augusts intro, Joel was pure smooth emotion and Jonas impressed as usual. I love the og song and I would also listen to all of yours. Great job!
I loved this challenge!🤩 I really liked August's voice with that rhythm, so pleasant 🤗. For me Jonas also won, as a whole, but the first half of Joel's song was my favorite.
Copyright. They can't add the Taylor Swift song because of that. Joel did a Senorita video a while ago like this, and he couldn't show the original song.
@@irisamelia9787 i mean they definitely don't have to listen to the whole song. Usually a couple of seconds is fine and since they only used some of the lyrics (a section of the song) it might work
Anti-Hero remake without listening 👀 This'll be something & fun to watch. Looks like the guys had some pretty neat submissions. Nice job, Keep it up & Stay Safe 🎶 😎 👊
This is aurally such a fun exercise to strengthen your song writing and production skills! Loved watching you guys put it all together! My inner musician is so satisfied right now 🎵💚😁
You guys should do more of these! Having musical intuition with phrasing and cadence, feeling how the melody should compliment the lyrics and being able to put yourself into someone else’s mindset is so amazing to watch. I was very impressed with all 3 but was blown away with how Jonas decided to speak the word Not knowing that Taylor actually did it that way…For that he has my vote
I love August's and I totally thought you'd all react to listening to the actual song and now I'm sad. Edit: after listening to the first verse and chorus of the original song, Joel's verse and August's chorus are pretty spot on to the original song.
1st: Indie (the style somehow sounds a bit like Gnash and country feels) 2nd: Acoustic that progresses to EDM 3rd: Very good combo of delicate tones. Sounds so soothing in the ears.
What you all did nail were the Taylor Swift style lyric videos. Jonas' Version is my favorite for exactly what they all pointed out - that he embodied Taylor Swift's Red era, and his hilarious 'Hi!' & 'At teatime!' were reminiscent of Taylor's Lover era. August's Version embodied folklore era, which is fitting as the album has a song called august. Yacht rock and nauticore/yachtcore is definitely a future Taylor Swift era aesthetic. Joel's Version sounds most like the Midnights era (but not antihero lol), but the strong presence of guitars kinda puts it more on Lover era.
I've thought Jonas has won every one of these challenges...I think I am partial to his tone, but I really like the way August writes songs. They all do wonderful.
everyone did a really good job, but omg Jonas's version was majestic!!! I also loved August's version his voice was so deferent!! you should definitely do this again!!!
Jonas’s version sounds like a Red song Joel’s version sounds like a 1989 song August’s version sounds like something completely different and magical, but fits Midnight’s vibe
Dang this is such a cool concept for a video! I'd definitely watch more like this. I really want to see your reaction to the actual song though! It would be nice to see how you think yours compared to the original song.
Joel: uses expensive equipment
August: cries his way to the finish line
Jonas: summons Taylor Swift to become her
The resemblance was uncanny.
I would like them to make a song together, want listen to a song where they are combining their different styles!
"So, what had happened was..."
@* Brandt * That would be fun. Like making a 3-part boyband song.
so true
August won imo... but Joel's was really good too. What I really wanted was a reaction part where you ACTUALLY listen to Taylor's song!
This!! I was a little sad that they didn't.
Probably didn’t want to get copyrighted
Facts! I ran listening to the song now, I never heard it lol
He actually sounds like a-ha lol
I was thinking the same thing 😭
why didn't y'all post your reaction to the actual song at the end to see how close you were? that would've been fun
Yes
im guessing copyright
@@stefanib.4283 they react to songs all the time on this channel lol
@@thatgirl4652 but putting it in this video would get the video claimed. This way the team can keep the ad money.
I was expecting that
Joel's phrasing on the verse is actually quite accurate to the original song lmao 😂 anyway, these are interesting takes on Anti-Hero, you guys should make this a series it's so fun ahaha
It is a series
I love the fact that August used stereo harmonies and the chorus was just plain and simple with one vocal take
Jonas's version: 3:50
Joel's version: 08:15
August's version: 11:25
they sound so good omg 😩✨
Up
Thank you
Jonas's voice tho 🔥🔥🔥 Love that we get to hear it so much these days.
Loved all of your songs, everyone had something different which was executed brilliantly like Jonas’ chorus, Joel’s verse and August’s arrangement.
Jonas’ song- 3:50
Joel’s song- 8:16
August’s song- 11:26
I wanna know who can make the best Christmas song.
I liked jonas's song
obviously sidemen
@@fahimhasan22 wdym 💀
@@supercalifragilisticex the sidemen are a youtube group and made christmas songs
Yeah this could be a nice idea for a new video
@Aubrey Danielle Music Confirmed today
homie why was this so SICK???? All the versions were *chefs kiss*
loved how they all came out. could esp feel the emotion from Joel’s and the vibezzzz from August. also felt the bond b/w Taylor and Jonas in the depths of my soul
When Joel gives the critique that a sentence was broken up and then in his version he breaks up the same sentence but in a different place 😂
His point was that the sentence was broken in an odd place, not that it was broken at all.
Joel breaks up the sentence the exact way Taylor does
I love August's version, you guys should make this a series! 😂
I 100% agree, Jonas knocked this one out of the park. Love when Joel, Jonas and August are all in the video together. Always my favorites, their chemistry is so great, you can tell they are genuinely friends. ❤️
Seeing all of you trying to write a Christmas song would be so cool.
Definitely!
All three versions were excellent, but Joel’s gave me goosebumps. Would have loved to see all three of you react to Taylor’s version at the end. Great video!! Make this a series, please!
I need more videos like this!! But I wish they react to the actual song and kinda compare it to their perspectives of it
After hearing all these versions, I can now fully appreciate how tremendous the og song is!
RIGHT!?!?🤣
I am a swiftie but I like Joel's chorus better than the OG.
Loving all your versions! August's first verse was *chef kiss*, Joel's and Jonas' chorus was so goooood!!! All in all, I really love how you guys came up with this in 3 hours! So gooood!!!
I think it would have been great to see you guys react to the actual song at the end. All 3 songs had their own merits but I think Jonas’s is the most “Taylor-esque” version.
Wow I was really surprised by Jonas' beautiful voice! Really liked all the versions :) Would've been fun to see their reaction to the real song!
Because i loved everyones vocals
Jonas: 3:50
Joel: 8:15
August : 11:25
The power point presentations are really funny😂. Love the facts that you guys always keep trying new things.Lots of love.
I think that August's version is the one that fits more with the "Midnights" album sound, I mean, it gives me the album vibe.
I like August's version the most! Such a good video overall ❤️
Jonas did really great! Sounded the most like an actual Taylor song! ❤️ But I also really liked august Version!
I really want to see their reaction to the actual song
I love this 🤣🤣🤣 But do we get to see a reaction of you guys finally hearing the real song? 🙏 please please 🤣
Yesss, would really like that!!
Yes 🤣 I laughed through this entire video. Plus just loved hearing the songwriting approaches with so much hilarity idk man best video I’ve seen in awhile. 🤣
I'm gonna say it again, Jonas's "hi" is the BEST part of all the songs! SHEDGANG
Shedgang!
The synchronized head bops were hilarious.
But genuinely, i used to love your channel and i love seeing your videos show up on my recommended after probably years, they always make me smile :)
Hahaha joel was super close except that high pitch lol the song is mellow and slow so the opposite. Jonas was also close too!! His was really melodic! This was fun. You guys should listen to the song afterwards that way you can see who was the closest and then troll whoever lost 🤡 lol
So I just did a weird thing.. I loaded up T-Swifty's version in one tab and Joel's version in another. Aside from the pacing being off (which I fixed by pausing Joel's faster mix at the end of each line) they actually lined up really nicely! They even harmonized! I guess to make it official (Roomie.. official ) I would need to rip the audio from both tracks and actually match them up in Audition or Audacity or something.. Hmmmm.
Please do it then tag me wherever you post it. I'm invested.
NO THEY DIDN'T DO IT!!!!!!
I'm surprised you guys hadn't heard it already lol
They probably filmed it right when it came out
I haven't either.
@@INTODAN nah they filmed it quite recently i was in stream a few days ago maybe a week or two
They all avoided it so they could make this video.
I listened to it for the 1st time after this for comparison
Nice to see the writing-sessions again! My ranking for this round is as follows:
1: Jonas (stanky groove & catchy melody, instantly dug it.)
2: Joel (the ascending chord-progression is a vibe, but the melody felt too disjointed, especially throughout the chorus.)
3: August (a little too stuck in the background compared to the other 2, 10/10 for the presentation, though.)
GG everyone, would still probably listen to all 3 versions, though. Looking forward to more of these!
I love how the intro parts are chaotic and full of rudeness and the actual songs are soft and genuine good.
I AM AMZED at how similar some aspects of each of their songs sounded to the original. Especially Joel's!
This should be a regular thing on this channel. So good!
August's was SO GOOD!!!!
Joel’s song has the ability to make me teary eyed just like Taylor’s!!✨
I was really hoping to see your reactions to the actual song after finishing your versions! You all did great tho!
Do more videos like thiss! It is my fave, I always come back to watch it!
I really liked Jonas' verse/pre-chorus. Definitely something I would listen to.
Roomie! You should do a video on "Most underrated songs" and then let your fans submit tracks they think never got enough attention/deserve more recognition and then you can review/critique them and give your opinion on if you agree that the song deserved more exposure or not. I think it'd be a good way to not only promote smaller artists, but also a great way to do something interactive with your audience!
This is a great idea
I like Joel's the best because it has the build from simple to dramatic, slowly pulling you into the chorus. It's easy to absorb and not trying too hard.
That was so cool, I could hear a little of the actual song in all 3. Well done! Would have liked to see your reactions of hearing the real song though
Yay my three favorite snarky songskilled swedes!! Honestly I got goosebumps from Augusts intro, Joel was pure smooth emotion and Jonas impressed as usual. I love the og song and I would also listen to all of yours. Great job!
I loved this challenge!🤩 I really liked August's voice with that rhythm, so pleasant 🤗. For me Jonas also won, as a whole, but the first half of Joel's song was my favorite.
This was a difficult song to re-make, a lot of lyrics. You all did great, but Jonas' old Taylor song vibes won it for me.
Please do more of this concept. How about having the real artist rating the song in the end
As a Swiftie™ my personal favorite was August's, but Joel's was really good, too.
Love this new video concept. Maybe next time after listening to all of the songs, add a reaction to that part of the original song you remade.
Copyright. They can't add the Taylor Swift song because of that.
Joel did a Senorita video a while ago like this, and he couldn't show the original song.
@@irisamelia9787 Couldn’t they just mute it and show some parts visually?
@@RoKer13 I guess they could!
@@irisamelia9787 i mean they definitely don't have to listen to the whole song. Usually a couple of seconds is fine and since they only used some of the lyrics (a section of the song) it might work
@@xapokalypse I don't think so. If they want to make money off the video, I'm pretty sure they can't play any of a song that is copyrighted.
Jonas' song is so good, I honestly really want a full version of it now
Look at Joel being all handsome saying "ooo, Taylor's so cool." This video was basically a love letter.
I would’ve loved if they reacted to the actual version afterwards!!
Very interesting idea
Anti-Hero remake without listening 👀 This'll be something & fun to watch. Looks like the guys had some pretty neat submissions. Nice job, Keep it up & Stay Safe 🎶 😎 👊
Joel's version was amazing, so interesting to listen to vocally
This is aurally such a fun exercise to strengthen your song writing and production skills! Loved watching you guys put it all together! My inner musician is so satisfied right now 🎵💚😁
Most enjoyable set of PowerPoint presentations I've ever sat through!
Joel’s reaction @4:31 was so cute. He looked like a puppet. Then he tried to control himself but really lost to the vibe of Jonas Chorus. ❤❤❤
Jonas' presentation is the MVP.
bruh i was hoping they would listen to it all together and then let us decide, would have loved their reactions to the actual song
You guys should do more of these! Having musical intuition with phrasing and cadence, feeling how the melody should compliment the lyrics and being able to put yourself into someone else’s mindset is so amazing to watch. I was very impressed with all 3 but was blown away with how Jonas decided to speak the word Not knowing that Taylor actually did it that way…For that he has my vote
Jonas my man, please make a full cover , I need it on spotify or at least my youtube playlist :O sick.
I like how you guys went back to showing the process of your song writing. I've missed that in some of your previous videos.
I love August's and I totally thought you'd all react to listening to the actual song and now I'm sad.
Edit: after listening to the first verse and chorus of the original song, Joel's verse and August's chorus are pretty spot on to the original song.
1st: Indie (the style somehow sounds a bit like Gnash and country feels)
2nd: Acoustic that progresses to EDM
3rd: Very good combo of delicate tones. Sounds so soothing in the ears.
What you all did nail were the Taylor Swift style lyric videos.
Jonas' Version is my favorite for exactly what they all pointed out - that he embodied Taylor Swift's Red era, and his hilarious 'Hi!' & 'At teatime!' were reminiscent of Taylor's Lover era.
August's Version embodied folklore era, which is fitting as the album has a song called august. Yacht rock and nauticore/yachtcore is definitely a future Taylor Swift era aesthetic.
Joel's Version sounds most like the Midnights era (but not antihero lol), but the strong presence of guitars kinda puts it more on Lover era.
3:07 why was this Jack producing the album lmao
Also, Joel and August definitely had Mine vibes for their verses
I've thought Jonas has won every one of these challenges...I think I am partial to his tone, but I really like the way August writes songs. They all do wonderful.
Augusts was closest in Chorus.
everyone did a really good job, but omg Jonas's version was majestic!!!
I also loved August's version his voice was so deferent!!
you should definitely do this again!!!
Jonas is quickly becoming my favourite. He's just so funny. And his singing voice is amazing.
Was really excited to see you compare it to the original and finding out how close you were...
More of this! Buuut end it with listening to the real song as well, would be fun to see your reactions
How y’all not hear anti-hero yet?!
ikr it's been like more than a month already
I’m pretty sure they filmed it a while ago and it’s been in editing
I hope they listened to the actual song afterwards! It wouæd be fun to see them compare it
The only thing that would make this video complete would be reacting to the actual song at the end
August’s was amazing! Definitely my favorite!😊
This video competition is sooo much fun! I hope we get to see more of this in the future!
August won imo! But they were all awesome! Such a cool concept gentleman, looking forward to more in the future!
i kinda wish we could see them listen to it after too, nice vid idea tho! nice 3 different versions
As soon as Joel said “let’s hear my song” I got the whopper whopper add lol
I need full versions of all of these
Now remake “This is me” without hearing it.
Or if you have heard of it, just remake it how you’d make it.
Omg this was great! I really want to see your reactions to hearing the official version of Anti-Hero now
August can win because Taylor Swift wrote a song about him.
August & Jonas: performing and regularly presenting it
Joel: flexing
Those were all fun & really interesting takes. Got pretty close there in a few parts.
August's version is just great!
Jonas’s version sounds like a Red song
Joel’s version sounds like a 1989 song
August’s version sounds like something completely different and magical, but fits Midnight’s vibe
5:04 I liked where he said Stand as a stand-alone word! Get it? Metaphors are fun
Dang this is such a cool concept for a video! I'd definitely watch more like this. I really want to see your reaction to the actual song though! It would be nice to see how you think yours compared to the original song.
The first one was SO GOOD! I just want this song but with different lyrics.
the guitar, embarrassing vocal take, high notes - straight to my🫀
interesting that Joel brought up Fall Out Boy as Taylor has said that Pete Wentz is a massive lyrical inspiration of hers
and now Electric Touch exists
This is so much fun to watch 😀
This is such an experience when you haven't heard the song yourself yet and only listened to it now lol
Joel, that "hi" is channeling soo much fallout boy but I am here for it! love it all, good work guys!
Blind remixes are epic! I love this
joel experimenting with the guitar sounds EXACTLY LIKE HITS DIFFERENT OMG
i loved augusts version it kind of reminds me of drew monson, very indie and nice vibes :)